Latest / Interfaiths / Re-Covering a Mutual Language: Bukharan Jews in Austria
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine sitting in a like a brightly lit room
- 0:03in Vienna. It's June 2022. And gathered around
- 0:08this table are eight people who, you know, on
- 0:13paper, they have absolutely nothing to do with
- 0:14one another. Right. On one side of the table,
- 0:16you have four Bukharin Jews and on the other
- 0:18side, four Muslims from Afghanistan. A fascinating
- 0:22setup. Right. And the air in the room is probably,
- 0:25I don't know, a little tentative. Maybe a little
- 0:28polite. Because they are there to participate
- 0:31in a reading group organized by a researcher
- 0:34specifically to read classical Persian poetry.
- 0:37Yeah, like the beautiful, intricate works of
- 0:39Omar Khayyam. Exactly. So as the reading begins,
- 0:43a Bukharan Jewish woman named Karen, she sits
- 0:45back and she's listening to the Afghan strangers
- 0:47across the table read aloud. Yeah. And suddenly
- 0:49she just freezes. Oh, yeah. Because the words
- 0:51that are washing over the table, they're entirely
- 0:53familiar to her. She realizes they're speaking
- 0:55her language. Yes. She realizes these strangers,
- 1:00these Afghans, are speaking the exact same mother
- 1:03tongue she grew up with. I mean, for her entire
- 1:05life, she thought the language her grandmother
- 1:08spoke was, you know, exclusively a Jewish dialect.
- 1:12Right. She called it Bukhari. Exactly. Bukhari.
- 1:14Yeah. She had absolutely no idea that it was
- 1:17essentially the same Persian language spoken
- 1:19by the Muslims sitting just a few feet away from
- 1:22her. It is an. incredibly powerful, I mean, almost
- 1:25cinematic image. Yeah, totally. And the emotional
- 1:28weight of that realization, it doesn't just stop
- 1:31with Karen. Oh, really? No. By the end of that
- 1:34very session, an Afghan woman named Shirin looks
- 1:36across the table at the Jewish participants and
- 1:38she says something that honestly reads like a,
- 1:40well, a small miracle of recognition. Wait, what
- 1:43did she say? She says, you understand that you
- 1:46are not alone with your story. Oh, wow. Right.
- 1:49That right there, that profound moment of a shattered
- 1:52boundary, that is the beating heart of the research
- 1:54we are diving into today. I love that. Yeah.
- 1:57Anthropologist Arianne Sajid captured this in
- 1:59her incredible work. It was published in History
- 2:01and Anthropology, and it's titled Recovering
- 2:04a Mutual Language. The idea that two groups of
- 2:07people could sit down, assuming they're total
- 2:10strangers, only to realize they share a mother
- 2:12tongue. It's just staggering to me. It really
- 2:17is. And Sajid's research, it uses this specific
- 2:20encounter in Vienna to like. pry open a much
- 2:23larger global conversation. Yes. Because today,
- 2:26our mission for this Deep Dive is to look at
- 2:29how memory, language, and shared culture between
- 2:32Jews and Muslims have been forgotten. Forgotten
- 2:34and actively rewritten. Right. Actively and sometimes
- 2:37aggressively rewritten. Yeah. And how, against
- 2:40all odds, recovering that shared history might
- 2:43actually be the secret key to rebuilding trust
- 2:45today. The central thread we're pulling on here
- 2:48is that the intense estrangement between Jews
- 2:50and Muslims. Right. This rigid boundary that
- 2:53feels so permanent and so ancient to us right
- 2:55now. It's actually not the natural state of history.
- 2:58Which is wild to think about. It really is. It
- 3:00is in many ways a recently manufactured reality.
- 3:03Yeah. By tracing the epic multi -generational
- 3:06journey of Bukharan Jews, right, from the Emirate
- 3:09of Bukhara in Central Asia all the way to modern
- 3:12day Austria, we get a front row seat to the mechanics
- 3:16of human identity. To see how it's built. Exactly.
- 3:19We see exactly how identities shift, how they
- 3:22harden, and how they mutate under extreme political
- 3:25and social pressure. It kind of makes you wonder
- 3:28about your own family history, doesn't it? Oh,
- 3:29absolutely. I mean, for you listening right now,
- 3:31think about it. How many of the deeply held traditions
- 3:34that you consider your core identity, the things
- 3:38that make you you, how many of them are actually
- 3:41just recent survival tactics? That's a great
- 3:44question. Right. Things your grandparents or
- 3:46great -grandparents invented or maybe adapted
- 3:48just to survive in a brand new environment. It's
- 3:50a slightly unsettling thought, honestly. It is,
- 3:53but it's crucial for understanding Karen and
- 3:55Shirin in that room. Definitely. So, okay, let's
- 3:58unpack this. I want to pull apart this poetry
- 3:59room experiment a little more. Because the implications
- 4:02of Karen not recognizing the origins of her own
- 4:05language are just fascinating to me. Yeah, let's
- 4:08get into it. Like, how does an entire community...
- 4:11Just forget where its mother tongue comes from.
- 4:13It sounds impossible. Right. Because Karen literally
- 4:16had never heard Tajik or Afghan Persian spoken
- 4:19in a way that connected the dots for her. No,
- 4:22she hadn't. She just thought, you know, this
- 4:25is Bukhari. This is what my Jewish family speaks.
- 4:27End of story. To understand the mechanics of
- 4:30that kind of cultural amnesia and honestly, the
- 4:32sheer speed at which it happens. Because it was
- 4:35fast. Extremely fast. We have to look at the
- 4:39massive disruptions these communities faced over
- 4:42just two generations. You have to remember, these
- 4:44are two communities that shared a homeland, a
- 4:47rich literature, and a language for centuries
- 4:50in Central Asia. Centuries of shared history.
- 4:52Exactly. But then you introduce the Soviet era.
- 4:56Oh, right. Yeah, during the 20th century, the
- 4:59indigenous languages of Central Asian Jews were
- 5:02systematically displaced by Russian. Okay, so
- 5:04the state steps in. Right. The Soviet machine
- 5:07aggressively promoted Russian as the language
- 5:09of upward mobility. It was the language of the
- 5:12intelligentsia, the language of education and
- 5:15of public life. Right. So the mother tongue gets
- 5:18basically Pushed out of the public square and
- 5:20retreats into the home. Exactly. Bukhari was
- 5:23relegated entirely to the private sphere. Wow.
- 5:25It became the language spoken by the grandmothers
- 5:28in the kitchen. Yeah. It was no longer the language
- 5:30of commerce or literature or the streets. That
- 5:33makes so much sense. And then the second massive
- 5:36disruption hits. Which is? Migration. When these
- 5:40Bukharan Jewish families eventually migrated
- 5:43out of the Soviet Union to places like Austria
- 5:45or Israel, that dominant Russian language was
- 5:48replaced yet again. Like German or Hebrew, I'm
- 5:51guessing. Exactly. This time by German or Hebrew.
- 5:53So within a very short, volatile time frame,
- 5:57the linguistic bridge to their Muslim neighbors
- 5:59was utterly dismantled. Like it was just bulldozed
- 6:02over. Pretty much. The language became an isolated
- 6:05relic. The broader context of its shared nature
- 6:08simply vanished from the community's collective
- 6:10memory. Man, I'm trying to picture what that
- 6:12feels like on an individual level. It's hard
- 6:15to grasp. It's almost like finding a locked,
- 6:19dusty trunk in your attic. Okay, I like this.
- 6:22You know it belonged to your great -grandparents,
- 6:24right? But you assume the key was lost forever.
- 6:27Right. So you just accept that whatever's inside
- 6:30is entirely private, maybe a little mysterious.
- 6:33but ultimately yours alone. Yeah. And then a
- 6:36complete stranger walks into your house holding
- 6:39the exact spare key. on their keychain oh that's
- 6:43a brilliant way to look at it and the key fits
- 6:44perfectly yes and the shock isn't just that the
- 6:48key fits it's the sudden realization that the
- 6:50trunk didn't just contain isolated jewish artifacts
- 6:52wait what did it contain the trunk contained
- 6:55a shared world oh wow it fundamentally rewrites
- 6:59your understanding of what belongs to you and
- 7:01who you were actually connected to that gives
- 7:03me chills and to really grasp the magnitude of
- 7:05what was locked inside that trunk we have to
- 7:07travel back to the world where that language
- 7:09was originally spoken Okay, where are we going?
- 7:12Back to where that shared culture was forged.
- 7:14We need to go back to the Emirate of Bukhara.
- 7:17Yes. I love diving into this part of the history
- 7:20because it completely shatters the assumptions
- 7:22a lot of people hold today. We're traveling back
- 7:25roughly between 1785 and 1920. And the Bukharan
- 7:30Emirate... was a place where Jews held real standing
- 7:34and cultural influence. Very true. Saged's research
- 7:38brings up a fascinating historical figure. Levi
- 7:41Babakhanov. Yes, Babakhanov. He was a highly
- 7:44celebrated Jewish court musician who performed
- 7:47for the last emir of Bukhara. He was incredibly
- 7:50famous in that region. And to give you listening
- 7:53a real sense of the historical reality of this
- 7:55time, there's this incredible artifact from the
- 7:5819th century. Oh, the letter. The letter. It's
- 8:00written by Rabbi Pinches, who is actually an
- 8:02ancestor of that same famous... musician Babakhanov.
- 8:05The context of this letter is so telling. It's
- 8:08at the stage for us. So Rabbi Pinchas is writing
- 8:10to Maurice de Hirsch. Okay. De Hirsch was a very
- 8:13wealthy, very famous European Ashkenazi Jewish
- 8:18philanthropist. Like mega wealthy. Oh, absolutely.
- 8:21And de Hirsch had essentially heard about these,
- 8:25quote unquote, exotic Jews living out in Central
- 8:28Asia. Right, out in the East. And he offered
- 8:30them a massive sum of money. We are talking 20
- 8:34million rubles to support their community. 20
- 8:38million rubles. A fortune. Which, I mean, on
- 8:41the surface, that sounds incredibly generous.
- 8:43Right. But it was entirely based on a projection.
- 8:46Completely. DeHersch and the European Jewish
- 8:48establishment, they basically assumed that because
- 8:51the Bukharan Jews were living in a Muslim -majority
- 8:54land, they must be destitute. Ah, I see. They
- 8:56assumed they were oppressed and in desperate
- 8:58need of European salvation. They were projecting
- 9:01their own narrative. Exactly. They were projecting
- 9:03a very European narrative of Jewish persecution
- 9:06onto a Central Asian reality. And that's what
- 9:09makes Rabbi Pinch's response so amazing. It's
- 9:12iconic. He writes back and essentially says,
- 9:14thank you, but absolutely not. We don't need
- 9:17your money. Yeah, he turns down 20 million rubles.
- 9:20But the phrasing he uses is what really stops
- 9:22you in your tracks. Oh, read the quote. He writes
- 9:25that the Jewish community in Bukhara lives peacefully,
- 9:28quote, under the wings of the kingdom of Ishmael.
- 9:32the kings of grace and mercy, lovers of Israel.
- 9:34It's just so powerful. He explicitly states that
- 9:38they are loyal servants to their king, living
- 9:40in tranquility. He flat out refuses the European
- 9:43money because they simply do not fit the narrative
- 9:46of the oppressed victim that Dahersh is trying
- 9:49to cast them in. That letter is a historical
- 9:51sledgehammer. Seriously. It shatters the retroactive
- 9:54modern assumption that Jews in Muslim majority
- 9:57lands were constantly living in a state of terrified
- 10:00subjugation. Right. The historical reality of
- 10:04coexistence in the Emirate was deeply, inextricably
- 10:07intertwined. Give me an example of that. Well,
- 10:09take the music, for example. OK. Jewish and Muslim
- 10:12musicians like Bob Akunov, they didn't just perform
- 10:15in separate spheres. Right. They weren't segregated.
- 10:18No, they performed together at the court. They
- 10:20actively developed the classical. music tradition
- 10:23of the entire region, which is known as Shashmakam,
- 10:26together. Together. It was a joint cultural enterprise.
- 10:29And it went beyond just art, right? It was woven
- 10:32into the fabric of daily life. Absolutely. The
- 10:35boundary between communities in the Emirate,
- 10:37it ran along lines of profession or, you know,
- 10:40which specific town you were from. Or your family
- 10:43lineage, maybe. Exactly. Family lineage. It did
- 10:45not run along an absolute hardline religious
- 10:48divide. Wow. Even their visual identity was shared.
- 10:51Really? Their clothes? Yeah. Their traditional
- 10:54garments were nearly identical. That's fascinating.
- 10:57A Jewish rabbi's white velvet coat with... Like
- 11:00intricate silk embroidery looked almost exactly
- 11:04like a Bukharin Muslim's traditional dress. No
- 11:06way. Yes. They occupied the same aesthetic and
- 11:10cultural universe. But OK, this is where the
- 11:12narrative takes a really sharp, almost jarring
- 11:15turn. Here comes the twist. Right. Because Sajed
- 11:17doesn't just look at the historical archives.
- 11:19You know, she interviews people today. Yeah.
- 11:21And the graphic work. She speaks with a modern
- 11:23day Bukharin rabbi living in Vienna. She gives
- 11:26him the pseudonym Rabbi Aaron. OK. And Rabbi
- 11:29Aaron. Aharon tells the story of Levi Babakhanov,
- 11:32that famous court musician we just talked about.
- 11:35But he tells it completely differently than the
- 11:38historical and record suggests. Yes. The reiteration
- 11:41is stark. Here's where it gets really interesting.
- 11:43Go for it. Rabbi Aharon layers on this heavy
- 11:47narrative of coercion. Coercion. Yeah. He claims
- 11:51the emir forced the musician to come play for
- 11:53him on Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish high holiday.
- 11:57Wow. He emphasizes that the Jews were totally
- 12:00separate from the Muslims, explicitly stating
- 12:02to the interviewer, of course, there was no assimilation.
- 12:06Shader very carefully points out that this idea
- 12:08of coercion, framing the act of playing for the
- 12:11emir on a holiday as a forced oppressive demand
- 12:15rather than, you know, a massive cultural honor.
- 12:17Yeah. That is a distinctly modern interpretation
- 12:20layered onto the past. He's rewriting it. Yes.
- 12:22The modern rabbi is taking a documented history
- 12:24of deep integration, shared music and mutual
- 12:27respect, and he is actively tweaking it. Well,
- 12:29why? He is retrofitting the story to align with
- 12:32the contemporary framework where Jewish. and
- 12:35Muslim identities must always be fundamentally
- 12:37opposed and antagonistic. I am just, I'm trying
- 12:41to wrap my head around the motivation there.
- 12:42It's complex. Because if the historical record,
- 12:45like Rabbi Pinch's own letter refusing millions
- 12:48of rubles because life was so peaceful, if that
- 12:51shows this beautiful integration, why is a modern
- 12:56rabbi tweaking the story to make it sound oppressive?
- 12:59Wow. It feels like... Taking a beautifully blended
- 13:03watercolor painting, right, where all the colors
- 13:06bleed into one another. I like this analogy.
- 13:08And taking a thick black Sharpie to draw hard
- 13:11lines between the colors. Yes. Why ruin the watercolor?
- 13:14Why does Rabbi Aaron feel such an urgent need
- 13:17for those hard Sharpie lines today? Because the
- 13:20gallery he is trying to hang that painting in
- 13:22today only accepts line art. Oh, wow. The audience
- 13:26has changed and the rules of survival have changed.
- 13:28Okay, unpack that for me. To understand why Rabbi
- 13:31Aaron feels the need to draw their sharpie lines,
- 13:33to enforce a retroactive narrative of strict
- 13:36separation, we have to look at the massive trauma
- 13:39of migration. We have to look at what happened
- 13:42to these Central Asian Jews when they left that
- 13:44integrated watercolor world of Gukhara, navigated
- 13:48the Soviet system, and eventually arrived in
- 13:51Europe. This brings us squarely into the 1970s.
- 13:54Exactly. The 1970s. This is such a crucial pivot
- 13:57point. It really is. Because the Soviet Union
- 13:59had become an increasingly difficult and restrictive
- 14:02place to be Jewish. Very much so. So many Bukharin
- 14:05Jews managed to secure exit visas, mostly with
- 14:08the stated intention of going to Israel. Right.
- 14:10But the geopolitics of migration are messy. Always.
- 14:14Their route takes them through Vienna, Austria.
- 14:17A major transit hub. Vienna was this transit
- 14:19hub run by the Hebrew Immigration Aid Society,
- 14:22or HIAS. Right, HIAS. But for many families,
- 14:25the plan kind of derails. Yeah, they hit a wall.
- 14:29They arrive in Vienna. Take stock of the situation
- 14:31and decide that Israel isn't the right fit for
- 14:34them, maybe due to fear of the ongoing conflicts
- 14:37there or just economic uncertainty. Right. It
- 14:40was a very tense time. But the Soviet authorities
- 14:42obviously won't let them return. No, going back.
- 14:44So they become stuck. They are stranded in Vienna.
- 14:48Stranded. And this is where a profound. agonizing
- 14:52identity crisis begins. And it's an identity
- 14:54crisis forged in the fires of double discrimination.
- 14:57Double discrimination, right. Because they arrive
- 14:59in Vienna and are immediately hit from two sides.
- 15:02The first side being the host country. Yes. First,
- 15:05you have the Austrian Majority Society. We have
- 15:08to look at the labor dynamics of Austria in the
- 15:101970s. The country had brought in many Turkish
- 15:14guest workers to handle low wage manual labor.
- 15:19Right. because Bukharan Jews looked Middle Eastern
- 15:22or Central Asian and they didn't speak German.
- 15:25Oh, I see where this is going. Austrians on the
- 15:27street often mistook them for Turkish laborers.
- 15:30That is just awful. As a result, they were subjected
- 15:32to the exact same xenophobia, racism and social
- 15:35exclusion that the Turkish Muslim immigrants
- 15:37faced. So they are receiving hostility from the
- 15:40host nation based on a visual misidentification.
- 15:43Yes. But the deeper, much more intimate wound
- 15:46came from within the Jewish community itself.
- 15:49This part is just heartbreaking. It really is.
- 15:51The established Ashkenazi. Jewish community in
- 15:55Vienna, the European Jews who had their own long,
- 15:59complex history in the city, they completely
- 16:03rejected. Completely. They look at these Central
- 16:05Asian families arriving with their different
- 16:07customs, their different language, their different
- 16:09style of dress, and they simply didn't see them
- 16:12as real Jews. Wow. The prejudice was visceral.
- 16:16Some Ashkenazim even mock them with terrible
- 16:19racial slurs. Oh, God. The research notes that
- 16:22Bukharan women were sometimes called Schwarzer.
- 16:25Yeah. Which is a derogatory German term that
- 16:28essentially translates to blackie. It's devastating.
- 16:32You have to imagine the intense psychological
- 16:34toll this takes. I can't even imagine. You flee
- 16:37the oppressive regime of the Soviet Union. You
- 16:39end up stranded in a cold foreign city where
- 16:42the local population resents you because they
- 16:45think you are a Muslim immigrant. And the local
- 16:47Jewish community, the people who are supposed
- 16:49to be your safety net. Your brothers and sisters.
- 16:51Exactly. They reject you because you don't fit
- 16:53their European template of what a Jew looks and
- 16:56acts like. It's a complete isolation. They were
- 16:58marginalized in community meetings, their voices
- 17:00were ignored, and they were cut off from the
- 17:02social capital of the established community.
- 17:04I'm trying to put myself in their shoes in 1970s
- 17:07Vienna. Yeah, put yourself there. You're rejected
- 17:09by the locals. You're mocked by the established
- 17:12Jewish community. You must feel entirely adrift.
- 17:16Desperate, even. You'd probably grasp at any
- 17:18institution that offered you a life raft. Exactly.
- 17:21Even if it meant changing how you practiced your
- 17:23own faith just to prove you belonged. Exactly.
- 17:27Survival in a diaspora community often requires
- 17:30adapting to the dominant culture's metrics of
- 17:33authenticity. Wow. Metrics of authenticity. Yeah.
- 17:36Now let's look at what that European template
- 17:38actually was. Okay. In Vienna, Jewish identity
- 17:42was largely defined by European institutional
- 17:44frameworks. And increasingly for those seeking
- 17:47validation from the establishment, by strict
- 17:50adherence to religious law, or halakha, Which
- 17:53was a massive culture clash because that was
- 17:56totally different from how Bukharan Jews experienced
- 17:59their Jewishness back in the Soviet Union. Radically
- 18:02different. Back in Central Asia, being Jewish
- 18:05was almost an ethnicity, a deeply ingrained cultural
- 18:08rhythm. Right. It was tied to local traditions.
- 18:10Yeah. It was the specific foods your grandmother
- 18:12cooked. The smells, the tastes. Exactly. It was
- 18:15the familial warmth of gathering for Shabbat.
- 18:18It was even celebrating secular holidays like
- 18:20Novi Gad, the Soviet New Year, with your community.
- 18:23Yeah. It wasn't about sitting in a yeshiva studying
- 18:26strict legalistic religious texts or debating
- 18:31the minutia of rabbinic law. And there's historical
- 18:33reason for that. Tell me. Under decades of Soviet
- 18:36rule. formal religious education and the training
- 18:40of rabbis had been largely suppressed. Ah, of
- 18:42course. So their Jewishness had to become deeply
- 18:46cultural, deeply local, and implicitly understood
- 18:49within the family unit just to survive the Soviet
- 18:52era. It was lived, not studied. Beautifully put.
- 18:55But when they got to Vienna, that beautiful cultural
- 18:58Jewishness wasn't recognized as valid. It wasn't
- 19:01enough. It wasn't enough. The pressure to be
- 19:04accepted as real Jews by the European Ashkenazi
- 19:07establishment forced Bukharans to adapt. Because
- 19:10they had to. Right. Sociologists have long noted
- 19:13that marginalized groups will often adopt the
- 19:15dominant group's metrics of authenticity in order
- 19:18to survive. Survive and, like, gain access to
- 19:21vital resources. Precisely. Like kosher food,
- 19:24religious schooling for their children. Basic
- 19:27community support. Yeah. For the Bukharans, survival
- 19:30meant adopting a more legalistic, bounded, and
- 19:34strictly orthodox version of Judaism that the
- 19:36Europeans would finally recognize and respect.
- 19:39But wait, that adaptation doesn't happen in a
- 19:41vacuum. No, it doesn't. You don't just wake up
- 19:44one morning in Vienna, realize the Ashkenazim
- 19:46are judging you, and suddenly know an entirely
- 19:48different framework of strict religious law.
- 19:50You need teachers. Someone has to teach you.
- 19:53Someone has to build the infrastructure for that
- 19:55new identity. That is exactly where the institutional
- 19:57forces step in. Enter the institutions. Nature
- 20:01abhors a vacuum and identity in diaspora is no
- 20:05different. Into this void of rejection, confusion
- 20:08and longing for belonging stepped powerful, globally
- 20:11organized religious movements. OK, who are we
- 20:14talking about? These institutions fundamentally
- 20:17reshaped Mizrahi and Sephardic identity. Meaning
- 20:21Jews from the Middle East, North Africa and Central
- 20:23Asia. Correct. And not just in Vienna, but worldwide.
- 20:26So Sajid's research points to two major players
- 20:29in this transformation. Yes. The first is an
- 20:32Israeli political and religious movement called
- 20:34SAS. SAS, right. Now, to understand their impact
- 20:39in Vienna, we have to look at what they were
- 20:41doing in Israel. A quick detour. SAS was founded
- 20:44in 1984 by a very famous, very charismatic rabbi
- 20:48named Ovadia Yosef. And SAS did something incredibly
- 20:51strategic. What did they do? In Israel at the
- 20:53time, Jews from the Middle East and North Africa
- 20:55were facing terrible ethnic, economic, and class
- 20:58discrimination from the European Ashkenazi elite
- 21:01who had essentially founded the state. Right.
- 21:03Similar discrimination to what we saw in Vienna.
- 21:05Exactly. So H .A .O. came along and offered a
- 21:07political and spiritual home that united all
- 21:10these diverse Middle Eastern and North African
- 21:12communities under a single unified Sephardic
- 21:15umbrella. The strategic genius of S .H .A. was
- 21:19how they reframed the narrative of discrimination.
- 21:21How so? They told these marginalized communities,
- 21:25you are failing to assimilate into Israeli society
- 21:28because you are backward or uneducated, as the
- 21:32Ashkenazim claim. You are being discriminated
- 21:34against because the secular Ashkenazi establishment
- 21:37has lost its way. They've lost their religion
- 21:40while you have maintained your holy tradition.
- 21:42Oh, wow. That flips the script. It was an incredibly
- 21:45empowering message. It gave them pride. But that
- 21:48empowerment came with a catch. A significant
- 21:49one. Yeah. By reframing ethnic discrimination
- 21:52as a matter of religious superiority, SHAS began
- 21:56to standardize what it meant to be a Sephardic
- 21:59Jew. To create unity. Exactly. They had to create
- 22:01a unified voting bloc and a unified religious
- 22:04practice. Okay. In doing so, they began replacing
- 22:06the incredibly diverse, rich, local traditions
- 22:10of Yemen, Iraq, Morocco. Yeah. With a unified,
- 22:15strictly orthodox religious identity that mirrored
- 22:18the stringency of the Ashkenazim, but with Sephardic
- 22:22legal rulings. So they basically built a massive
- 22:25standardized umbrella. Right. But to fit under
- 22:28it, you had to leave your unique local customs
- 22:30out in the rain. That's a great way to put it.
- 22:33And in Vienna, this process of standardization
- 22:35was accelerated even further. By the arrival
- 22:38of Shabbat. Yes, Shabbat. Which is a highly influential,
- 22:42globally organized, orthodox, Hasidic movement.
- 22:47Saad actually interviews the head of a Shabbat
- 22:49center in Vienna, a man she calls Raphael, who
- 22:52caters to many of the Bukharan youth today. Yes,
- 22:55I remember this interview. And Raphael's quote
- 22:57in the research is just, it's a gut punch when
- 23:00you think about Karen in the poetry room. Read
- 23:02the quote. He says, quote, there are no Bukharan
- 23:05traditions that one could teach. Many Bukharan
- 23:08traditions are Muslim things that we adopted.
- 23:10The religious don't do that anymore. Wow. That
- 23:13quote is the absolute crux of the cultural transformation.
- 23:16That's just, wow, it's so dismissive. It is breathtaking
- 23:19in its erasure. Rafael is actively engaged in
- 23:22a process that the renowned anthropologist Talal
- 23:25Asad describes perfectly. What does Asad say?
- 23:28Assad argues that religion is not a static, timeless
- 23:32category. It is a shifting set of disciplines
- 23:35defined by power structures. So whoever has the
- 23:38power defines the religion. Exactly. Rafael is
- 23:41engaged in purifying the religion. Purify. He
- 23:45is taking the vast, rich, deeply intertwined
- 23:49cultural inheritance of Central Asia, right?
- 23:51The Shashmakam music, the specific traditions
- 23:54of hospitality, the shared aesthetics, the local.
- 23:57ways of celebrating life milestones. All that
- 23:59beautiful watercolor stuff. Yes. And he is casually
- 24:02discarding them as mere Muslim things. He's drawing
- 24:05the Sharpie line. Exactly. He is declaring that
- 24:08if a practice doesn't exist in the strict codified
- 24:10legal texts of European style orthodoxy, it isn't
- 24:14authentically Jewish. It's a contaminant. It
- 24:16is a foreign contaminant. And by discarding the
- 24:19culture as a contaminant, they effectively sever
- 24:21the historical bridge between the Jewish and
- 24:23Muslim communities. The tragedy of losing the.
- 24:26you know, the grandmother's traditions, is just
- 24:29palpable here. It really is. It's like a family
- 24:32that owns a custom -built, quirky, centuries
- 24:36-old home. Okay, I'm listening. It's got weird
- 24:39hallways, colors that clash, but it holds all
- 24:41their memories. Then an inspector comes along
- 24:43and says, it's not up to the new municipal code.
- 24:45Oh, man. So they tear down the quirky family
- 24:48home and replace it with a standardized concrete
- 24:52franchise model. That's entirely what happened.
- 24:55Right. I mean, yes, you gain global recognition.
- 24:57Everyone recognizes the franchise. You get the
- 24:59safety and the funding of the institution. But
- 25:02you lose the local flavor. You lose the soul
- 25:04of the home. You lose the soul. I have to imagine
- 25:07not everyone was on board with this. Was there
- 25:09any pushback against this franchise model of
- 25:12Judaism? Yes, absolutely. You see a deep generational
- 25:15divide. I would assume so. Some of the older
- 25:18generation in Vienna. deeply resent this standardization.
- 25:22They must hate it. They see their grandchildren
- 25:24adopting this strict, rigid orthodoxy and they
- 25:28feel it's actually a step backward. To them,
- 25:31it feels like an alien form of Judaism that they
- 25:34simply don't recognize from their lives in Bukhara.
- 25:37Because it is alien to them. Right. Sajid notes
- 25:40that one elder in the community literally went
- 25:42out and built his own independent synagogue.
- 25:45Oh, really? Yes, just to maintain a sense of
- 25:47Bukharan family. music and community outside
- 25:51of this new rigid institutional framework. A
- 25:55sanctuary for the quirky family home. Precisely.
- 25:57But the tragedy is that the younger generation
- 26:00is navigating a completely different world. Yeah,
- 26:03they don't know the old home. They don't have
- 26:04the lived memories of the Emirate. They don't
- 26:06remember the watercolor painting. Right. And
- 26:08more importantly, they are navigating a new,
- 26:11highly polarized political reality in modern
- 26:14Austria. Politics. We're adopting a strict, legally
- 26:17bounded and Separate identity isn't just an internal
- 26:20community debate. What is it then? It is heavily
- 26:23encouraged by the state itself. Which brings
- 26:25us to the political climate and how this internal
- 26:28identity shift is weaponized by outside forces.
- 26:31Yes, the weaponization of identity. Now, I want
- 26:34to pause here just so you listening know, we
- 26:37are strictly looking at the academic findings
- 26:39from Ariane Sajid and Ruth Wodak here. Yes, very
- 26:42important context. We're not like... endorsing
- 26:45a political stance or picking sides on Austrian
- 26:47politics. We're strictly analyzing the sociological
- 26:51dynamic that they reported in attacks. Exactly.
- 26:53We are just reporting their analysis. Right.
- 26:55So to understand how this separation hardened
- 26:58into something political. Seyed and political
- 27:01scientist Ruth Wodak point to the political climate
- 27:04in Austria over the last decade. Specifically
- 27:07under former Chancellor Sebastian Kurz. Yes,
- 27:10Chancellor Kurz of the UVP party, who governed
- 27:12at times in coalition with the right -wing FPO.
- 27:15Wodak's research documented how the government
- 27:18utilized very specific, highly visible messaging.
- 27:21Like what? They actively paired highly demonstrative
- 27:24pro -Israel symbolism. Oh, like flying the flag.
- 27:28Literally flying the Israeli flag over the Austrian
- 27:31chancellery and parliament buildings. Wow. And
- 27:33they paired that with aggressive systemic anti
- 27:36-Muslim policies. Sociologically, this creates
- 27:39a fascinating and incredibly tense dynamic for
- 27:42minorities on the ground. Yeah, I bet. The state
- 27:44was simultaneously elevating one minority symbolically
- 27:47while actively targeting another. And the policies
- 27:51Wodak outlines were not subtle. Give me an example.
- 27:54For example, the government published an online
- 27:56Islam map. An Islam map? Yeah. This was a digital
- 27:59map that identified the locations and details
- 28:01of hundreds of Muslim organizations, mosques,
- 28:05and cultural centers across Austria. That sounds
- 28:08dangerous. Well, the stated goal was transparency,
- 28:10but unfortunately it led to right -wing groups
- 28:12putting up warning signs and some mosques being
- 28:15targeted and vandalized. Of course it did. They
- 28:18also introduced requirements for refugees, largely
- 28:20from Muslim countries, to sign formal declarations
- 28:23against anti -Semitism in order to receive asylum.
- 28:26And the political logic here, as Sajid points
- 28:29out, is incredibly calculated. How so? It's designed
- 28:32to reframe anti -Semitism purely as an imported
- 28:36problem, a disease brought into pure Austria
- 28:39by Muslim immigrants. The sheer political utility
- 28:42of this framing cannot be overstated. Right.
- 28:44Serves a purpose. By casting Muslims as the inherent
- 28:47imported threat. Yeah. And passing the Austrian
- 28:50state as the valiant protector of the Jews. I
- 28:54see where this is going. The host society conveniently
- 28:56manages to absolve itself of its own long, deep
- 29:00-seated and horrific history of European anti
- 29:03-Semitism. Oh, wow. It's a sleight of hand. It's
- 29:05a massive sleight of hand. It turns minority
- 29:08groups into opposing chess pieces. Yeah. It forces
- 29:11a public narrative where minorities are played
- 29:13against each other. And the real historical danger
- 29:16of anti -Semitism becomes a convenient political
- 29:18instrument. An instrument to justify harsh anti
- 29:22-immigration policies. Exactly. And what's so
- 29:25vital about Syed's ethnographic research is that
- 29:28she doesn't just analyze this from a bird's eye
- 29:30view. No, she gets on the ground. She shows us
- 29:33exactly how this top -down political discourse
- 29:35takes up residence inside the mind of a human
- 29:38being. The story of Layla. Yes. She introduces
- 29:41us to a woman named Leila. Leila is a Bukharan
- 29:44woman in her late 50s living in Vienna. And in
- 29:47her interviews, Leila has absorbed this political
- 29:50frame perfectly. Totally internalized it. When
- 29:52the interviewer asks her about Syrian refugees
- 29:55coming into Austria, Leila physically recoils.
- 29:58She expresses deep fear. Right. She specifically
- 30:02mentions fearing the black that they would wear,
- 30:05referring to traditional Islamic clothing. Buys
- 30:08into the fear entirely. Yeah, entirely. And simultaneously,
- 30:12she fiercely praises Chancellor Sebastian Kurz.
- 30:15Of course. She says he loves Israel. He loves
- 30:18the Jews. She has completely internalized the
- 30:21state's narrative. Muslims are the terrifying
- 30:24threat. The Austrian strongman is the protector.
- 30:27But this is where Sajid's research delivers a
- 30:29profound, almost unbelievable twist. It's so
- 30:32good. It challenges everything we think we know
- 30:35about prejudice. Yeah. In the exact same interview,
- 30:38literally minutes after expressing this deep
- 30:40fear of serial refugees, Leila tells a completely
- 30:43different story. Wait for it. She casually mentions
- 30:46that she recently bought a pet bird on an online
- 30:48marketplace. Right, just a normal everyday errand.
- 30:50Wait, she literally just went to buy a bird.
- 30:52Yes. She goes to the seller's apartment to pick
- 30:55up the bird and discovers that the sellers are
- 30:58an Afghan family. Oh, wow. Now, according to
- 31:02the political frame she just espoused, she should
- 31:04be terrified. She should run away. Right. But
- 31:07what actually happens? What happens? She hears
- 31:10them speaking and she starts speaking to them
- 31:12in Bukhari. Oh, my gosh. She tells the interviewer
- 31:15with a sense of wonder, it's almost the same
- 31:18language. The trunk unlocks. The trunk unlocks.
- 31:21The Afghan family doesn't treat her as a political
- 31:24enemy. Right. They welcome her into their home.
- 31:26They set a table for her. They serve her tea.
- 31:29Because that's the culture. Exactly. They treat
- 31:31her with immense honor and hospitality, exactly
- 31:33as you would treat a respected elder in Central
- 31:36Asian culture. That is beautiful. They even call
- 31:39her weeks later just to check on how the bird
- 31:41is doing. No way. Yes. And Layla, sitting there
- 31:45reflecting on this, tells the interviewer, we
- 31:47have a lot to learn from them. They are not all
- 31:50bad. Right. Yeah. It is amazing how Layla can
- 31:54hold these two entirely contradictory thoughts
- 31:56in her head at the exact same time. Cognitive
- 31:59dissonance at its finest. I mean, the Syrian
- 32:02refugee is a terrifying, faceless abstraction
- 32:05that makes her fear for her safety. But the Afghan
- 32:08bird seller is a brother who serves her tea.
- 32:11It perfectly illustrates the psychology of prejudice
- 32:14and the power of proximity. Proximity is key.
- 32:16The abstraction, you know, Arabs, Islam, the
- 32:19refugees. that produces fear. Right. And abstraction
- 32:23is essentially a blank canvas onto which top
- 32:26-down political rhetoric can paint monsters.
- 32:29That's a great way to say it. But the encounter,
- 32:31the face -to -face reality, especially an encounter
- 32:34conducted in a shared mother tongue, produces
- 32:37kinship. Yeah, you can't hate someone you're
- 32:40sharing tea in a language with. Exactly. Layla
- 32:43simply could not hold on to the rigid political
- 32:45frame of the Muslim enemy while sitting at a
- 32:48physical table being served tea by people speaking
- 32:51her grandmother's language. The shared tongue
- 32:53literally cracked the political frame open. It
- 32:56dismantled the Sharpie lines in real time. So
- 32:59what does this all mean? I mean, I love the mechanics
- 33:01of that, the language short circuits, the political
- 33:03conditioning. But Layla's fleeting moment with
- 33:05the bird seller begs a massive question. What's
- 33:08the question? If a shared language can crack
- 33:10that political frame for a few minutes, is there
- 33:13anyone actually trying to keep that door wedged
- 33:15open permanently? Ah, scaling the experience.
- 33:18Right. Because, let's be honest, the encounter
- 33:20is fragile. Sajid is very clear about that. But
- 33:23very fragile. After the bird story, Layla still
- 33:25generally fears the Syrians. The political conditioning
- 33:28often snaps right back into place because the
- 33:31institutions pushing it are so powerful. The
- 33:33rubber band snaps back. Exactly. So how do we
- 33:36scale Layla's experience? Is anyone actively
- 33:39using this shared history as a tool for actual
- 33:42lasting resistance? That brings us to one of
- 33:45the most compelling figures in Sajid's research.
- 33:48Like who is it? A man who provides a roadmap
- 33:50for what that resistance actually looks like
- 33:52in practice. Sajid introduces us to another Bukharan
- 33:56living in Vienna, a shop owner named Ruben. Ruben
- 33:59is fascinating because he subverts every expectation.
- 34:02He really does. He is a deeply spiritual man.
- 34:04He studies Kabbalah, Jewish mysticism intensely,
- 34:08but he keeps his Jewishness very private in his
- 34:11public life. He runs a shop that gets a lot of
- 34:13foot traffic from Muslim immigrants from Central
- 34:16Asia and the Middle East. Okay. When they come
- 34:18into his shop, he doesn't announce his religion.
- 34:22He doesn't put up boundaries. What does he do?
- 34:24He treats them, in his own words, like a brother.
- 34:28Wow. He speaks their language, whether it's a
- 34:32dialect of Persian or Russian. He engages with
- 34:35them on the level of shared culture. What Ruben
- 34:38is doing is... Quietly revolutionary. Quietly
- 34:41revolutionary. I love that. He actively refuses
- 34:43to buy into the political victim narrative that
- 34:46the state is pushing. Right. He explicitly rejects
- 34:49the instrumentalization of European anti -Semitism
- 34:51and particularly the Holocaust as a tool to make
- 34:55Jews fear modern Muslim immigrants. He sees right
- 34:58through the slide at hand. Exactly. He recognizes
- 35:00the political game being played and he opts out
- 35:02of it entirely. He operates on a completely different
- 35:05geometry of relationship. Yes. And this is the
- 35:08core argument that researchers drawing on Sajjad's
- 35:10work are making today about interfaith dialogue.
- 35:14If we connect this to the bigger picture. Yeah,
- 35:16let's connect it. Most interfaith dialogue in
- 35:18the West, whether it's in Vienna, London or New
- 35:21York, relies entirely on an Ashkenazi European
- 35:24template. OK. The historical reference points
- 35:27brought to the table are the Holocaust and the
- 35:30Israeli -Palestinian conflict. Which is completely
- 35:33understandable given the immense moral weight
- 35:35and historical trauma of those events. Absolutely.
- 35:38No one is denying that. Right. But structurally,
- 35:41when you use that specific European template
- 35:44as the starting point for interfaith work. What
- 35:46happens? It forces Jews and Muslims into the
- 35:49roles of complete strangers. It sets them up
- 35:52as opposing sides who have to laboriously build
- 35:54trust from scratch. Right. Reaching across a
- 35:57massive, terrifying chasm of historical grievance,
- 36:00genocide, and modern geopolitical tension. That
- 36:02is incredibly heavy, difficult work. It is exhausting
- 36:06work. But the Mizrahi and Sephardic experience,
- 36:08the specific experience of Jews from the Muslim
- 36:11world, like Karen, like Ruben. Yeah. It completely
- 36:14shifts that geometry. It changes the entire foundation
- 36:17of the conversation. How so? These are Jews whose
- 36:21ancestors prayed in Arabic and Persian. Yeah.
- 36:24Their poetry, their music, their cuisine, the
- 36:27very cut of their clothing were continuous with
- 36:30their Muslim neighbors. The watercolor painting.
- 36:32Yes. The Muslim world, for the vast majority
- 36:35of its history, wasn't primarily a site of European
- 36:39-style persecution. Right. For centuries, it
- 36:42was home. It was home. Coexistence was the absolute
- 36:45norm, not the exception. Wow. So when you center
- 36:50the Bukharan or Mizrahi experience in interfaith
- 36:52work, Jews and Muslims are no longer strangers
- 36:55trying to negotiate a fraught peace treaty. What
- 36:58are they then? They are estranged family members
- 37:00recovering a forgotten shared household. Ah,
- 37:02I love that. The difference between construction
- 37:05and recovery is everything. It is everything.
- 37:08Think about it in your own life, you know, for
- 37:10the listener. Think about how much easier it
- 37:12is to reconnect with an old childhood friend
- 37:14you had a falling out with compared to cold calling
- 37:16a total stranger. trying to convince them to
- 37:18become your best friend. Such a good comparison.
- 37:21With a childhood friend, you already have the
- 37:24shared language, the shared inside jokes, the
- 37:27muscle memory of the relationship. That's what
- 37:30this shared culture does. Exactly. And the analysts
- 37:34looking at Sajid's work lay out four incredibly
- 37:36practical lessons for anyone trying to actually
- 37:40build bridges today. Okay, let's hear the four
- 37:41lessons. First, center the Jews of the Muslim
- 37:44world. Right. Bring Bukharin, Yemeni, Iraqi,
- 37:48Moroccan Jews to the forefront of the conversation.
- 37:51Because of that muscle memory? Yes. Their very
- 37:54existence, their lived history, disrupts the
- 37:57political lie that Jewish and Muslim are inherent
- 38:00ancient opposites. Okay, second lesson. Second.
- 38:03Use shared culture as the doorway, not theology.
- 38:06Yes. Don't start with heavy debates over scripture
- 38:08or geopolitical sovereignty. That never works
- 38:11anyway. Start with the food. Start with the Shashmako
- 38:13music. Start with the Persian poetry. The Omar
- 38:15Khayyam. Exactly. The text refers to these as
- 38:19the low wide doors. Think about it like this.
- 38:22Theology and politics are high, narrow doors
- 38:25with strict bouncers checking IDs. Oh, totally.
- 38:28You get defensive just approaching them. But
- 38:30poetry and food are low, wide doors. Everyone
- 38:34can walk through them together without feeling
- 38:36threatened. That's a beautiful metaphor, and
- 38:38it works perfectly. Okay, what's lesson three?
- 38:40Third. Name the political manipulation out loud.
- 38:44Say it to their faces. We have to be honest and
- 38:46vocal when political majorities are trying to
- 38:49set minorities against each other for their own
- 38:51electoral gain. Yeah. You have to expose the
- 38:54sharpie lines for what they are. And finally,
- 38:56the fourth lesson, which I think is the most
- 38:58poignant. What's your take on it? Expect the
- 39:00encounter to be temporary and fragile and do
- 39:03it anyway. Yes, do it anyway. Layla's moment
- 39:05of kinship over the bird was temporary. It didn't
- 39:09cure her of all her prejudices instantly. Right.
- 39:12She still feared the Syrians. But for an afternoon,
- 39:14it widened the space in her mind. It made a different
- 39:18kind of relationship suddenly thinkable. Thinkable
- 39:21is the first step. If you accumulate enough of
- 39:23those temporary fragile moments, you eventually
- 39:26wear down the cognitive isolation. You slowly
- 39:29rebuild the muscle memory of coexistence. We
- 39:32have covered an incredible amount of ground today.
- 39:35We really have. We started with Karen in a room
- 39:37in Vienna. entirely shocked to hear Afghan refugees
- 39:40speaking her grandmother's supposedly exclusive
- 39:44Jewish language, Bukhari. A truly cinematic start.
- 39:48We traveled back to the Emirate Bukhara, where
- 39:50Jewish musicians played for the emir, and rabbis
- 39:53proudly lived under the wings of Ishmael. The
- 39:56watercolor days. Exactly. We watched as that
- 39:59beautifully blended shared culture was dismantled
- 40:01by the racism of 1970s Vienna, which forced stranded
- 40:05Bukharan Jews to adopt European religious metrics.
- 40:09just to survive. Force them into the mold. We
- 40:11saw how institutions standardized that identity,
- 40:14labeling centuries of shared culture as Muslim
- 40:16things to be discarded. And we navigated the
- 40:19dark waters of modern political weaponization,
- 40:21where the state actively pits minorities against
- 40:24each other. And finally, we found a roadmap in
- 40:27Rubin and the low, wide doors of shared cultural
- 40:30memory. The recovery of the household. The profound
- 40:32realization that we aren't building peace from
- 40:35scratch, we are just remembering a forgotten
- 40:37friendship. It is a remarkable, sobering, yet
- 40:41ultimately hopeful trajectory. It really is.
- 40:44And as we wrap up this deep dive, I want to leave
- 40:46you listening with a final thought to Mullover.
- 40:48Let's hear it. We've seen today how immense geopolitical
- 40:53and social pressures, you know, migration, racism,
- 40:56institutional standardization and political rhetoric.
- 40:59How all of that can cause an entire community
- 41:02to literally forget its own mother tongue and
- 41:05actively rewrite its own history of peaceful
- 41:08coexistence all in the staggering span of just
- 41:12two generations. Two generations. It's nothing.
- 41:15If human memory is truly that malleable, if our
- 41:18deepest identities can be reshaped that quickly
- 41:21to serve the needs of the present. What's the
- 41:23question? What other ancient unbreakable animosities
- 41:26in our world today are actually just recent inventions?
- 41:28Oh, wow. What shared languages, what shared histories
- 41:31are you right now being conditioned to forget?
- 41:34A profound question to end on. Thank you for
- 41:36joining us on this deep dive. Thanks for listening.
- 41:38Keep questioning the narratives you are handed.
- 41:40Keep looking for those low, wide doors. And maybe,
- 41:44just maybe you'll find out that the stranger
- 41:47across the table has been speaking your mother
- 41:49tongue all along.