Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Did Diocletian Save Rome… or Break It?
Transcript
- 0:00We think Diocletian saved Rome. That's the story.
- 0:04A soldier rises from nothing, grabs the empire by the throat
- 0:07and pulls it back together from the edge.
- 0:10But here's what the history books skipped By the time he
- 0:12took power, Rome wasn't losing battles.
- 0:15It was losing its architecture. The structure underneath
- 0:18everything, the money, the borders, the chain of command
- 0:22was already hollow. Coins that carry the emperor's
- 0:25face wouldn't buy a loaf of bread.
- 0:27Forts along the Danube built Harrison and staff, and still
- 0:31the frontier dissolved. Laws carved into stone, prices
- 0:35fixed by imperial decree, death penalty for violations, and
- 0:39merchants simply stopped selling.
- 0:41Diocletian didn't lack intelligence.
- 0:43He didn't lack power. He built the most sophisticated
- 0:46administrative machine the ancient world had ever seen, and
- 0:50it wasn't enough because you cannot engineer your way out of
- 0:53economic collapse. But you can delay it.
- 0:56Today, Doctor Colin and I are going to perform the autopsy.
- 0:59And I'll warn you now. The pattern he built to save
- 1:02Rome, you're going to recognize it because somebody is running
- 1:06it right now. Welcome back to the Roman
- 1:27Pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO
- 1:30and Co founder of Command Your Brand.
- 1:32We help our clients to appear on some of the top podcasts on the
- 1:35planet. Check us out via the link in the
- 1:37description. And today I'm excited to have
- 1:41one of the few interviews we've had on this channel.
- 1:43We had Adrian Goldsworthy on about a year ago to talk about
- 1:45the life of Caesar, which was awesome.
- 1:48Dean Kinzer. We talked about coins, which was
- 1:51really cool. But today we have Doctor Collins
- 1:55Elliott with us today, and we're going to be taking a look at the
- 1:59man who turned Rome into a machine.
- 2:01And that man is Diocletian. So, Doctor Elliott, thanks for
- 2:06hanging out with me today, Sir. Jeremy, thank you so much for
- 2:08inviting me. So for people that may not know
- 2:11who you are and what you do, could you just tell us a little
- 2:13bit about your background, Sir? Sure.
- 2:16So from my day job, the things that kind of thing that kind of
- 2:19brings in the money is I'm a professor.
- 2:21I'm a historian over at Indiana University in the Midwest of the
- 2:24United States. And as kind of part of my role
- 2:28as a historian, I've written a few books.
- 2:30So I'm an author as well. Most recent book was called Pox
- 2:34Romana, The Plague that Shook the Roman World that just came
- 2:36out in 2024. I also host a podcast called the
- 2:42Pax Romana podcast PAX. And that's just a kind of
- 2:46chronological survey that goes from the death of Julius Caesar
- 2:51all the way till we're all done talking about Roman history.
- 2:55So right now, I think we're just past Dio cliche.
- 2:58We're kind of wrapping up the 4th century AD.
- 3:01But that has been a lot of fun too, because, you know, I
- 3:04enjoyed teaching in the classroom, but it's also been
- 3:07really fun to engage with kind of a wider audience as you of
- 3:10course know the joy of that as well.
- 3:12Well I'll have to pick up the book and I I have to ask since I
- 3:15haven't looked it up, was it Antonine plague or Cyprian
- 3:19plague? Which were you covering?
- 3:20Yeah, Antonine Plague. So this is looking at which for
- 3:23your listeners if they want to know about this very briefly.
- 3:27So this is, in my opinion, a true pandemic.
- 3:30It strikes the Roman Empire during the reign of Marcus
- 3:33Aurelius. We don't know what the disease
- 3:35was. We don't know how many people
- 3:37had killed. But it was really interesting to
- 3:39write this book during COVID because it makes you think a lot
- 3:42more broadly about what a disease can do, like how it can
- 3:45freak people out, how it can cause persecution, how it can
- 3:49cause religious changes. So it's sort of a book that's
- 3:53less about a disease and it's more about what it was like in
- 3:58the Roman Empire to deal with the first pandemic that anybody
- 4:03at the time, and indeed anybody in sort of living, living memory
- 4:06had ever experienced. Well, we'll definitely link that
- 4:08up in the description and for the audio listeners, we'll link
- 4:10it in the show notes for you as well.
- 4:12And I'll have to give it a read too, because I'm I see the
- 4:16Antonine Plague is actually very pivotal in the fall of Rome
- 4:19because of just the number of men that are missing and the
- 4:22number of, you know, non Romans they have to replace those
- 4:24soldiers with. So just kind of an interesting
- 4:26concept to look at. But anyway, we're here to talk
- 4:29about Diocletian today and the tetrarchy.
- 4:32So, so Doctor Elliot, the thing I wanted to start with is for
- 4:36people that may not be familiar, who is Diocletian or or as he's
- 4:40known earlier, Dioclet. Yeah, I'm glad that you start
- 4:43out with his his his name before he was Diocletian.
- 4:48We don't know a lot about his background, but even his name
- 4:51tells a little bit of a story. So Dioclees is not a Latinized
- 4:57name, it's a Greek name and it's a pretty common name in kind of
- 5:02the lower echelons of Roman provincial society.
- 5:07So the suspicion is that this guy diocese is just kind of a
- 5:11regular guy who had joined the military, probably came from one
- 5:16of those Balkan provinces, maybe Dalmatia, may have been the son
- 5:24of a former slave himself. Again, diocese would be a pretty
- 5:29normal name for for even a a slave.
- 5:32So his rise to power goes along with the military.
- 5:37The time in which he is born is a period in which the Roman
- 5:41Empire is in the midst of a transition between rule by their
- 5:46emperors that are always in charge.
- 5:47But the the aristocracy, the Senate under the emperor is sort
- 5:52of shifting towards being pretty weak and effective and and
- 5:57really lacking even the ceremonial prestige that it had
- 6:00had before. And increasingly the military
- 6:03like not not just not like the Praetorian Guard, the household
- 6:07guard of the Emperor, but like the, the rank and file soldiers
- 6:11are finding themselves with an increasing amount of power and
- 6:15money. And diocese is just one of these
- 6:19soldiers who's very competent as a soldier and also eventually as
- 6:25a commander. So he experiences upward
- 6:27mobility in the military during this period when the military is
- 6:32like he rides the wave of the military.
- 6:34So by the time he's kind of in his 30s, in his mid 30s, late
- 6:4040s, he is a commander in the Imperial Bodyguard and that's
- 6:45where we sort of meet him for the first time in the literary
- 6:49sources. And I guess when we look at
- 6:51diocese, you know, not long before him, we have the Restitur
- 6:56Orbis or Aurelian that actually puts everything back together.
- 7:00And I think had he not been assassinated, he might have been
- 7:03the guy that kind of put Rome back in a, in a lot of ways of
- 7:06how it should been. Did he have any connection to
- 7:09Aurelian or, or kind of earlier emperors or kind of how did he
- 7:13find his way to power? Yeah.
- 7:15So at least to my knowledge, I can't think of like an obvious
- 7:19familial connection, his connection to previous emperors.
- 7:23The only one that I know of is the emperor that immediately
- 7:26preceded him, who was a guy named Chorus.
- 7:29He was just another of these emperors in the 3rd century
- 7:32that's ruling for like months rather than years.
- 7:35And Chorus was one of many emperors that's ruling the Roman
- 7:39Empire after you. You're right after Oralian, who
- 7:43had briefly got the band back together and united the Empire,
- 7:47well, Arealians assassinated and then they're all these again.
- 7:51There's like 10 year period of a bunch of usurpers and and would
- 7:55be emperors. And so Diocletian is in the
- 7:57imperial bodyguard of Chorus of of one of these many emperors.
- 8:04And for for our listeners, the video right before this, we kind
- 8:08of did our climax of the third set of the crisis of the 3rd
- 8:11century after breaking down piece by piece.
- 8:13But the 3rd century crisis, you have a lot of things going on.
- 8:17You have emperor's declaring themselves challenging each
- 8:20other. You have the Cyprian plague, you
- 8:22have the Roman climate optimum is is suddenly changing.
- 8:26You have Barbarians coming across the border.
- 8:28So it's a very strange time for not just regular people, but
- 8:33also the wheels of power. And I guess how would this have
- 8:36affected dioques and kind of the way he looked at not just his
- 8:39world, but also power? Yeah, I mean, there's a there's
- 8:43a ton of stuff that and all of this is sort of contextual.
- 8:46We are kind of making some conjectures, but I think it's
- 8:49reasonable to say, OK, first of all, you, you do have the the
- 8:53military situation, which I already mentioned.
- 8:55You have increasing power and influence and wealth among
- 8:59soldiers. You have regionalization.
- 9:01So even though the Empire has been reunited nominally under
- 9:07Oralian, the armies are regional armies, like they are loyal to
- 9:14particular commanders. They tend to come from
- 9:17particular regions. So we have less of an idea of a
- 9:21Roman army or a Roman soldier, and we really have soldiers that
- 9:26are attached to particular legions, particular commanders,
- 9:30particular provinces, particular nationalities, if we can use
- 9:34that term. The climate and plague stuff is
- 9:37of course really interesting too.
- 9:38And I certainly recommend my friend Kyle Harper's book The
- 9:41Fate of Rome, if folks want to read that.
- 9:43So what we see with with that element is you have widespread
- 9:48disease, which who knows how many people the plague of
- 9:52Cyprian has killed. But it's even if it killed a few
- 9:56percentage points of the population, we're still talking
- 10:00about a desperate need to recruit soldiers.
- 10:02So there is a need to bring in people who who who may or not
- 10:07may not be loyal to the Roman state, may or may not be
- 10:10indoctrinated in Roman ideology. There's a need, obviously, to
- 10:17pay those soldiers an increasing amount of money and the Roman
- 10:22silver currency, as I'm sure you probably talked about on your
- 10:25podcast, Roman silver currency has been almost entirely
- 10:29devalued at this time. There's really no silver of.
- 10:32So this is a a beautiful 3rd century coin which we can see is
- 10:36a is almost 100% bronze. There is no silver in this coin.
- 10:40Exactly. So you know that just just like
- 10:42a thin washing of silver, Aurelian reset the standard at
- 10:465% silver for the what? A coin that used to be almost
- 10:50100% silver. So anyway, the point is that the
- 10:53soldiers aren't happy with this situation.
- 10:55They're increasingly getting nominal pay raises, but they,
- 11:00the, the, the actual currency is not going as far as it ought.
- 11:04There's price inflation. It, it's a really chaotic time.
- 11:08And Diocletian is, you know, in the midst of this crisis period
- 11:12coming into power. And by the way, when he he comes
- 11:17into power, it just he just kind of looks like he's going to be
- 11:19another one of these 3rd century emperors that killed his
- 11:23predecessor, might last a year or 18 months and is probably
- 11:27going to get killed by some other guy.
- 11:30What makes him different than what you know, I guess when we
- 11:32look at him, what makes diocese different than other emperors
- 11:36because the 3rd century, you know, we have Tacitus that
- 11:40becomes emperor after a really and doesn't even want the job
- 11:43and we need to. He doesn't live very long trying
- 11:45to survive in military camps. Like you have a lot of these
- 11:47guys that don't have a very long lifespan, and even if they do
- 11:51the things they're supposed to, like Aurelian, someone else
- 11:53kills them. So what makes Diacles different?
- 11:57Yeah. So again, initially it's tough
- 12:01to tell because he's just, you know, he's one of these just
- 12:05would be emperors, but it's we don't know as much about his
- 12:08personality. But one of the things that we
- 12:10see very early on is a pragmatism.
- 12:13So when he becomes emperor, he changes his name to Diocletian.
- 12:18He realizes that he does have to adopt some trappings of imperial
- 12:24ideology. So he takes on a series of new
- 12:26names. Aurelius, Valerius.
- 12:31These are our family names in of previous emperors.
- 12:36He changes his Greek name Diocles to Diocletianus, which
- 12:41is a kind of Latinized version of his name.
- 12:44So he does this. He also immediately seeks an
- 12:48ally. So rather than try to just be a
- 12:51regional usurper and emperor and, and I have to fight it out
- 12:56with, you know, 3-4 other guys. He reaches out to another
- 13:03military commander, a guy named Maximian, who is, we don't know
- 13:11if Diocletian and Maximian had known each other well, but they
- 13:14were both soldiers. They seem to have similar
- 13:16background. And Diocletian makes the
- 13:18pragmatic decision to make an alliance with this guy.
- 13:22Basically like you be empire emperor of part of the empire,
- 13:26all the empire of another part of the empire and will will sort
- 13:29of combine and agree to like a non aggression pact and we'll
- 13:33kind of fight the others. And while other 3rd 3rd century
- 13:37emperors maybe tried to do that, they were not very effective at
- 13:41doing this. If I can say maybe one other
- 13:44thing that we know about Diocletian that kind of makes
- 13:46him different. He understands the power of
- 13:49religious propaganda. So one of the things that he
- 13:53does with Maximian is he, you know, these people are not
- 13:56related. They're not related by blood.
- 13:58There's no obvious connection between them, but what he does
- 14:02is he says, all right, my divine protector is going to be
- 14:06Jupiter, the the chief deity of the Roman pantheon.
- 14:11And Maximian's protector is going to be Hercules, who's sort
- 14:15of the son of Zeus. He's the Lieutenant, or excuse
- 14:20me, the son of Jupiter, also Zeus, same God.
- 14:23He's the Lieutenant of Jupiter. He's the executor of Jupiter.
- 14:26So there's this relationship in the cosmos, the relationship in
- 14:31the in the in the pantheon that could explain Diocletian's
- 14:37relationship with this emperor that he partners with.
- 14:39So it's a he's both pragmatic and he understands the value of
- 14:44religious symbols. Well, it's interesting too, I
- 14:47guess, looking at the religious angle as well, because he also,
- 14:50I guess in some ways he's more effective at it and in some ways
- 14:53he's a little bit more maniacal, if that makes sense.
- 14:56But in, in comparison to how Decius tries to handle the
- 15:01restoring the PACs Deorum or the peace of the gods, that's also
- 15:03something he puts a lot of attention on because he's
- 15:06realizing, OK, if things aren't going so well at Rome, well, the
- 15:08gods aren't very happy with Rome.
- 15:10So we have to restore this. This PACs Deorum.
- 15:13Right, that's right. And, and eventually now
- 15:16Diocletian will try his hand at some heavy-handed religious
- 15:21conformity. Maybe we we can talk about it
- 15:23now or maybe we'll talk about because that happens pretty late
- 15:26in his reign. He goes hard after the
- 15:28Christians. Well, I guess let's save that
- 15:29for in a little bit later, but I think that the thing we should
- 15:33kind of talk about first is you started referencing what's going
- 15:37to become the Tetrarchy. So I think this is a good place
- 15:39for us to kind of start our our conversation about what
- 15:42Diocletian does. So let's talk about the
- 15:45reorganizing of the empire. You know, what is the Tetrarchy?
- 15:48How does he organize it? How did these Tetrarchs portray
- 15:52themselves as well? Because I think that's also a
- 15:54very interesting part of it. Yeah, that's a huge part that
- 15:58really makes this different than what we saw before in the 3rd
- 16:02century. So the first thing, and this is
- 16:05my own opinion, I don't see the Tetrarchy as fully formed in
- 16:10Diocletian's mind when he takes over it.
- 16:13It seems to me like it's it's a pragmatic choice that evolves as
- 16:18circumstances present himself. And this to me, there's a lot
- 16:22that Diocletian gets wrong, but there are definitely some ways
- 16:26in which we see Diocletian being I think very smart and the
- 16:29tetrarchy I think is very smart. So as I mentioned, he reaches
- 16:32out to Maximian and allies with him.
- 16:35They become Co emperors and and agree to sort of rule two
- 16:40different parts of the empire. The problem that both of them
- 16:44face. So Maximian in the West has to
- 16:47deal with a variety of usurpations.
- 16:50The island of Great Britain is in tumult, the Danube River, the
- 16:56the Rhine River. So those boundaries are porous
- 17:00at this time. And he has to deal with
- 17:02usurpations and rebellions. Diocletian also has to deal with
- 17:06some of that too. But the, the realization it, you
- 17:09know, by the time we get, so that all happens in 285 and 86
- 17:15and by the time we get to the early two 90s, it's very clear
- 17:18that that there are going to need to be further divisions
- 17:21that even 2 emperors cannot really put to bed the crisis,
- 17:26all of these elements of the crisis.
- 17:28So what Diocletian does is he has both he and Maximian adopt
- 17:35kind of subordinate emperor. So Diocletian and Maximian are
- 17:40going to be titled Augustus. Each of them are going to be
- 17:43like senior emperors. And then the two emperors below
- 17:47them. In the West the emperor's name
- 17:49is Constantius and in the east the emperor's name is Galerius
- 17:55and those two are going to be Caesar's.
- 17:57So you got the two Augusti and the two Caesar.
- 18:00So 4, 4 emperors are going to rule a kind of divided empire.
- 18:06And then you asked about representation.
- 18:10And that's really key because right now 4 emperors ruling
- 18:15different parts of the Roman Empire is not new during the
- 18:18crisis of the 3rd century, you have that kind of thing all the
- 18:20time. They're all, they're just
- 18:21fighting each other. They're they're, they're
- 18:23pursuing their individual interests in different regions.
- 18:26But if the Tetrarchy, the rule of four men is going to sell as
- 18:32something different, it needs to be presented as unified.
- 18:36It needs to be as though it needs to be very clear that
- 18:39these 4 emperors are on the same team.
- 18:43They're like family. And there is a slew of imagery,
- 18:47and much of it well. That's what I was going to point
- 18:48out. There's a lot of Stella out
- 18:50there that that show all four of them at the same time.
- 18:53That's right. So if you go to, I think it's in
- 18:56Venice right now, you can see a, a, a, a porphyry statue of the
- 19:02Tetrarchs. And it's four men with the same
- 19:06face, the same posture, the same military cloak, the same
- 19:10haircut, the same crown, the same position that got their
- 19:14hands on their swords ready to draw their swords.
- 19:17Their other hand, their other arm is around another emperor,
- 19:21embracing him. You have no idea which emperor
- 19:23is who. You just know that there are
- 19:25four guys that look exactly like that communicates to anybody
- 19:30that would have seen that, that these 4 emperors are a lot are
- 19:34aligned. They're, they're
- 19:35interchangeable. Yes, they're individual men, but
- 19:38they are aligned. They swap names with each other.
- 19:41So they, they, they carry the names of each other.
- 19:44They exchange women. So we, we've got like the
- 19:48daughter of, of one becomes the, the, the wife of the other, you
- 19:53know, and then they're those sorts of family connections as
- 19:55well. Even the coinage, if you look at
- 19:58the coinage of each emperor, they, OK, it has the individual
- 20:01emperor's name and face on it. But on the other side of those
- 20:05coins, you see all four men. And again, very generic looking,
- 20:10all sacrificing at similar altars in a similar military
- 20:14camp. So there's a very clear attempt
- 20:18to portray these men as aligned and unified and almost in a
- 20:22sense, interchangeable. So I guess looking at some of
- 20:27the other reorganizations he does what we'll get into kind of
- 20:30the monetary part of it and some of the other things in a few
- 20:32minutes. But I guess looking at it,
- 20:34there's some things that he does in terms of how borders
- 20:37function. There's new positions he creates
- 20:40as well, which I think it's the Dukes and is it cometes or
- 20:43comets that he creates as well? So he creates these new
- 20:46positions, which later on will kind of become Dukes and counts
- 20:49and kind of the the medieval world.
- 20:50So let's talk about those reorganizations.
- 20:53You know, what does he do? You know, kind of with the army
- 20:56and also with the borders. Yeah, my, my view of Diocletian,
- 21:00I think you could summarize it as he militarizes the Roman
- 21:05society. I mean, I like your term too.
- 21:07He he makes it, he makes the Roman Empire into a kind of
- 21:10machine. Diocletian comes out of the
- 21:12military. He comes out of a context in
- 21:14which there are people on top that give orders.
- 21:17There's a chain of command, there's implementation of those
- 21:20orders. There's ruthless discipline in
- 21:24cases where the orders are not followed.
- 21:26And his reform really kind of reflect that mentality.
- 21:31So we we get inside his head and that helps us understand why he
- 21:37he does what he does. And, and really all of this
- 21:40begins with with the military. So the Roman military was
- 21:43already pretty large by the time Diocletian takes over.
- 21:47It was split up among different like emperors and usurpers, but
- 21:52it was probably around maybe 3 to 400,000 men were serving in
- 21:57these militaries at the time. Diocletian takes the military
- 22:01and rapidly recruits. We get to something like 500 to
- 22:07600,000 soldiers maybe in the in the Roman military puts those
- 22:13soldiers at at key strategic locations along the Roman
- 22:18borders. So that that military
- 22:21restructuring is, is very important.
- 22:24He subdivides the Roman provinces so that they can be
- 22:30sort of carefully managed, carefully controlled, carefully
- 22:33taxed. That recruitment can happen,
- 22:36conscription can happen in those provinces.
- 22:39There's all of that. The sort of bureaucracy is
- 22:43multiplied. So again, like thinking like a
- 22:45military commander, you want a clear sort of hierarchies.
- 22:51You don't just want in, in the tax room on a, the, the system
- 22:55of, of government in provinces is like one guy goes to be a
- 22:59governor. He might take his brother with
- 23:01him. He takes a few slaves with them
- 23:03and maybe like a, you know, I don't know, an accountant or
- 23:07something. And then other than that, he has
- 23:08to like, work with the locals. Diocletian's vision for
- 23:13provinces is highly militarized and regimented.
- 23:17The governor goes, he's over a much smaller portion of land.
- 23:22He has an army of bureaucrats with him.
- 23:24I mean, the number of officials under Diocletian in the
- 23:27Tetrarchs probably multiplies from maybe a few thousand
- 23:31overall in the entire Roman Empire to like 2530 thousand.
- 23:36I mean, it's just a huge increase.
- 23:38So I, I guess just to give our listeners and viewers a bit of
- 23:41an idea, you, you mentioned that 500 to 600,000 number.
- 23:45How does that compare to other times in Rome's history as well
- 23:50as we look at what these soldiers look like?
- 23:52I think very often people have that idea of, you know, the,
- 23:57the, the Lorica segmentata that, that famous Roman armor that we
- 24:01see in every movie we've ever seen.
- 24:03How did these soldiers actually look in comparison to the ideas
- 24:06of what we have about Roman soldiers?
- 24:09So yeah, during the Roman, like the earlier Roman Empire, you
- 24:14would have maybe like I think you know, Augustus probably has
- 24:19once he dismisses a good chunk of of his army after the civil
- 24:22war, he still has about 100,000 soldiers.
- 24:26Over time you get an increasing number of non citizen soldiers
- 24:31but at any given time we're maybe talking about, I don't
- 24:36know, half the soldiers are non citizen at most.
- 24:40But even then they're these non citizens would be split up.
- 24:44Like even Marcus Aurelius, he brings in a bunch of Germanic
- 24:47peoples after the mark during the Markomanic wars, he brings
- 24:52in, you know, 1020 thousand of, of of those soldiers.
- 24:56He, he divides them up, splits them up, sends them to different
- 24:59places and the ideas so that they will simulate to imperial
- 25:03ideology under the tetrarchy. Again, the the not only is the
- 25:07army much larger, but it is heavily reliant upon outsiders.
- 25:13It's reliant upon Goths and Franks, various Germanic peoples
- 25:19and there's a name for this. The Romans call these Federati.
- 25:23And these are like allied cohorts of soldiers that in in
- 25:30some cases are even like kind of self-contained units where they
- 25:35they even have kind of their own native like command structure.
- 25:39So not only are they not assimilated into Imperial
- 25:44ideology, not even sort of this the same existing military
- 25:49structure, are they existing And they have kind of their own
- 25:52weapons, they have their own armor, they have their own
- 25:55tactics for fighting. So there's like this kind of
- 25:59hodgepodge army that's created. So I guess looking at the other
- 26:05big lever here and and that's the money, you know, I've heard
- 26:07various numbers about kind of where Rome was at on the
- 26:10inflationary scale. The one I've heard most often is
- 26:14that we're somewhere around 10,000 to 15,000% inflation in
- 26:17the early two 80s. But I guess looking at how
- 26:20Diocletian handles the money issue, like what does he do from
- 26:24kind of a money and a tax structure issue?
- 26:27Yeah, let me give a little bit of context and probably your
- 26:30listeners can get that too if they go back and listen to your
- 26:32episode about 3rd century crisis and and money.
- 26:36But just for folks that are catching this right now.
- 26:39So in the 3rd century, 1 Diocletian is coming of age.
- 26:42Growing up, the Roman monetary system is almost meaningless in
- 26:47some parts of the Roman Empire. Now, in cities nearby where
- 26:52monetary values could be enforced, maybe you have still
- 26:56have some kind of functioning monetary system.
- 26:59But the Roman silver coinage, as we said at the beginning of the
- 27:02podcast, had been entirely debased.
- 27:05By the time we get to the two 70s, we get pretty massive price
- 27:10increases. Yeah, some, I mean, at least
- 27:12sort of 70 fold or so price increases.
- 27:17The demands of Diocletian and his tetrarchy obviously create
- 27:22huge strains on the monetary system because all of these
- 27:26soldiers, all these bureaucrats, the tax system, the the
- 27:32provisions for the soldier, all that all that has to be paid
- 27:35for. And Diocletian does not have a
- 27:38bunch of gold and silver mines that he suddenly discovers like
- 27:42you can't multiply gold and silver.
- 27:45So of course. Was it true that they'd also
- 27:48lost access to some of their minds at this point?
- 27:50Like once in Dacia and and areas like that.
- 27:53Correct the most productive mine or one of the most productive
- 27:56minds at least in Dacia Albertus Mayer has been has been lost at
- 28:02this point and and and then even mines that were not lost.
- 28:06This an argument by the way, that I make in part in pox or
- 28:09mono my book. Once you start getting these
- 28:12disease outbreaks, those mines get abandoned and it's very
- 28:16hard, especially we've got an underground mine.
- 28:19Those tend to get flooded. So it's it's very difficult even
- 28:23though the Romans do have Archimedes screws there, there
- 28:26are ways to pull water out. It's just too much of an effort
- 28:29in some cases. So even like mines in Spain,
- 28:32which which are still under the control of the Roman Empire
- 28:36cannot be reopened. So you have the loss of mines in
- 28:40provinces that the Romans no longer control, and then you
- 28:43have the loss of minds in Roman territory because of these
- 28:47various calamities that have occurred over the last century
- 28:50or so. So, so he's got no source.
- 28:52He's got no new source of silver and gold.
- 28:54So as a result, he, you know, you got inflation already going.
- 28:59And the, the, the, the goal here is to kind of change the values
- 29:07of coinage. So there's a currency decree,
- 29:09there's a, there's a maximum price decree, and then there's a
- 29:11currency decree. So there's two separate kind of
- 29:15monetary and, and price policies that we see under Diocletian.
- 29:19So the the monetary decree we find in an inscription in
- 29:27Aphrodisias, which is a city in Asia Minor, and there's a lot of
- 29:32inscriptions that survive in that city.
- 29:34So he tries to double the face value of certain coins just by
- 29:39decree. So there's a silver coin that's
- 29:41being used in the Roman Empire that is not minted in great
- 29:45numbers because there's not a lot of silver called the
- 29:47Argentas Argenteus, excuse me, and that was worth 50 denarius
- 29:53coins. That's now going to be worth 100
- 29:55denarius coins. The, that there's like a, a
- 29:59bronze silverish coin. We call it the radiate.
- 30:02I think you may have just held that up.
- 30:04That might be the coin that you just had, the antoninianus.
- 30:07Yeah. So that that was raised, that
- 30:11had been worth 10 denarius coins.
- 30:13That was now going to be worth 20.
- 30:15So it's just like a a by Fiat, just saying all the coins are
- 30:19worth double basically. That's one side of that.
- 30:24How does that work in the marketplace?
- 30:25Like, like how do people are they willing to accept that
- 30:29idea? Because I know even modernly, if
- 30:30you told somebody, hey, your dollar is now worth blah.
- 30:32We, we see how that kind of goes.
- 30:34How do people in the marketplace and and kind of regular Romans
- 30:38look at? This.
- 30:39Yeah, this is a challenging, this is a challenging question
- 30:42to answer because it's a more speculative and comparative
- 30:46answer than like then finding like hard evidence.
- 30:49But if we look at the way that Romans behaved in past
- 30:53debasements and like 1 indicator of behavior would be hoarding.
- 30:58So if, if people have concerns about coinage, they might keep
- 31:06back older coins that have higher quality silver content or
- 31:11even in this case bronze content, because with the, the,
- 31:14the monetary system is so bad that even bronze is having an
- 31:19increased monetary value. I would compare it to what has
- 31:21happened with the penny. There are there's like a
- 31:24legitimate issue with pennies. I don't remember the date.
- 31:27It's like 1983 or something right where the the penny goes
- 31:30off a a copper standard and. It costs more money to actually
- 31:34make a penny than a penny's worth.
- 31:36Exactly. And and so, so even like low
- 31:40denomination coins and you find these huge giant hordes of low
- 31:47denomination coins cropping up in the late 2 hundreds, late 3rd
- 31:52century AD. Like there's the the foam horde
- 31:55in Somerset, England, which was like, you know, 50,000 plus of
- 32:01these of these, you know, debased coins.
- 32:04Now, who knows? There could be religious
- 32:06reasons, there could be economic reasons.
- 32:08But the point is it does look like the marketplace reacts with
- 32:13skepticism to these changes. Now, I will just briefly say
- 32:18Diocletian desires to enforce all of his edicts and he uses
- 32:24pretty harsh language. He prescribes capital punishment
- 32:28in some cases for economic crimes.
- 32:32So the the monetary like like where Diocletian is, where the
- 32:36emperors are, Nycomedia, Milan, some of those sorts of places.
- 32:40My guess is if you did not adhere to the official values,
- 32:45you might get reported. There's going to be some trouble
- 32:48there. If you're out in the
- 32:50countryside, you're probably taking those coins, you're
- 32:53melting them down, you're selling them for the the metal
- 32:55value, you're ignoring the the the Fiat value.
- 33:01So I, I guess looking at then the, the, the edict of maximum
- 33:05prices that you, you spoke about earlier, you know, what is that
- 33:08and how does that fit in Diocletian strategy?
- 33:11Yeah, this is the more famous edict maybe the maybe the thing
- 33:14that Diocletian is most famous for 2nd to forming the
- 33:18tetrarchy. So in addition to the currency
- 33:22reform, Diocletian does something that really no emperor
- 33:27to my knowledge have had done before.
- 33:29And it's really hard to find a comparable precedent really
- 33:33anytime in the history of sort of Europe, the Mediterranean.
- 33:38I mean, it's just really hard to find something like this.
- 33:40What he does is he puts out in, in many of the large cities of
- 33:46the Roman Empire in stone, a schedule like a listing of
- 33:52maximum prices that can be charged for a whole variety of
- 33:56things. Like it's pretty comprehensive.
- 33:58It's, it's labor, you know, wages for day laborers, wages
- 34:03for various kinds of specialized labor.
- 34:06It's, it's gold, it's wheat. It's, you know, just, you know,
- 34:12a variety of goods that a person could buy on the marketplace and
- 34:17there's just a ceiling that's put on all of those prices.
- 34:21And there's like a preamble that goes along with it.
- 34:25And it is really illuminating. I would encourage your
- 34:28listeners, your, your viewers to just read the preamble of the
- 34:33edict on maximum prices. It takes about 3 minutes to
- 34:35read. And it just, it just lays into
- 34:39speculators and greedy men. And that's really the cause of
- 34:44the current economic crisis. It has nothing to do with
- 34:49currency debasements or Fiat, you know, currency reforms or
- 34:55anything like that, or the increase in the size of the
- 34:57military, the bureaucracy and the other.
- 34:58No, it's just greedy. Somehow greed just happened, and
- 35:02that's caused prices to increase.
- 35:04And so there's going to be a capital penalty for anybody who
- 35:09buys and sells at prices below these maximum prices.
- 35:13Oh my gosh. Well, you mentioned earlier the
- 35:16idea of we, we were talking a little about the, the Pacsaorum
- 35:20or the peace of the gods. And you mentioned persecutions
- 35:23that that Diocletian is actually well known for.
- 35:26And I know some of my, some of my friends in other parts of
- 35:29Eastern Europe, in their countries, they call it the age
- 35:31of martyrs. And I and I guess when we look
- 35:34at that, what, what was Diocletian trying to do and how
- 35:37did he approach that? All right, so I'm going to sound
- 35:40like a broker record, so I won't say too much, but again, you
- 35:43have to get inside his head. So Diocletian is a military man.
- 35:47He also wants to regiment, not necessarily a particular deity.
- 35:53So this is not like Oralian. Oralian particularly wants the
- 35:57Romans to worship the unconquered son Solindictus.
- 36:01What Diocletian wants is he wants traditional Roman values,
- 36:06which he associates with traditional Roman religion to to
- 36:10be honored across his empire. So in three O 3.
- 36:16This is late in Diocletian's reign.
- 36:19He issues a a series of edicts. So they they they follow over
- 36:26the course of the next few years and they are targeted
- 36:30specifically at Christians. So under Trajan Desius, who you
- 36:37already mentioned, there's some there's some historians and and
- 36:40I kind of lean this way, although I understand the
- 36:43counter arguments, there's some arguments that Trajan Desius was
- 36:47not necessarily going after Christians.
- 36:50He was just kind of going after non conformist more generally.
- 36:53And then Christians became identified as like the the main
- 36:57problem of religious nonconformity.
- 36:59Diocletian is not like that. He he is specifically going
- 37:03after Christian. So the edicts describe things
- 37:07like the burning of churches? Yeah, the burning of scriptures.
- 37:13Christian clergy are to be stripped of any privileges and
- 37:20rights that they have. If a Christian clergy will agree
- 37:25to sacrifice to the traditional Roman gods, they will be, you
- 37:31know, forgiven. And there are accounts of
- 37:34Diocletians, thugs going to churches in Nycomedia, for
- 37:39example, finding the scriptures, burning them, killing priests,
- 37:46killing Christians. By the time we get to his fourth
- 37:49edict in three O 4, I believe that is there's just a blanket
- 37:54demand for universal sacrifice, which is like Trajan Desius.
- 38:00One thing I'll just say about this.
- 38:02So in the tetrarchic system, you do have 4 emperors.
- 38:06So Diocletian is the one that wants this persecution.
- 38:09Not all of the emperor's agree with this.
- 38:12So in the east where Diocletian is, the persecution is
- 38:16especially heavy-handed. Widespread destruction of
- 38:20churches, widespread executions, thousands, 10s of thousands of
- 38:24Christians maybe are killed in what is called the great
- 38:27persecution. But in the West where especially
- 38:30where this Caesar Constantius is, so that's like the island of
- 38:35Great Britain, parts of Roman Gaul, now modern France, the
- 38:40edicts are not enforced and it's he's very lenient.
- 38:44So under Diocletian is where we see the the most persecution.
- 38:49And that's interesting because I have a lot of friends in Serbia
- 38:51and they, they, they talk very consistently about what
- 38:54Diocletian did, where in other parts of the empire, as you
- 38:57said, you, you just really don't hear that much about it.
- 38:59So it is, it's, it's kind of interesting to see that.
- 39:02Yeah, that's right. And of course, Constantius, you
- 39:07know, maybe he's a Christian or maybe his wife is a Christian or
- 39:11his mistress is a Christian, but also probably a lot of his
- 39:15soldiers are Christians. So Diocletian is commanding an
- 39:19Eastern army. Again, the sort of
- 39:21regionalization of the army matters.
- 39:23Those those people would be all about sun worship, all about the
- 39:28worship of the traditional gods. That's totally fine with them.
- 39:31Whereas Christianity had really taken hold among some soldiers
- 39:38in the West. So even if Constantius was not
- 39:41himself like a a, a, a true Christian, maybe it was just a
- 39:45nominal Christian. Either way, it made sense for
- 39:49him politically to not enforce Christianity.
- 39:52His own soldiers, who some of whom would be were Christians,
- 39:55would be carrying out that persecution.
- 39:56There's no way that they're going to do that.
- 39:59Well, so now we're, we're at three O 4 and three O 5 is
- 40:02actually the year that Diocletian does something very
- 40:06strange and that no emperor in the 3rd century really has the
- 40:10opportunity to do. And and he retires and goes to
- 40:12farm cabbages. So, so how does this come about?
- 40:16And I guess, how does Diocletian approach what will come after
- 40:20him? Yeah.
- 40:21So the idea here is that this is going to be the tetrarchy is
- 40:26meant to not just be a momentary system.
- 40:29So Diocletian, like I said, maybe this comes about
- 40:32pragmatically. Maybe he didn't start out
- 40:34envisioning this is like a permanent arrangement.
- 40:38Maybe he was just making deals and and trying to survive.
- 40:41But in the end, it it's not a bad system.
- 40:43So the the like politically it, it does bring stability.
- 40:49The ideology works like it it, it there had there's a logic to
- 40:53it. And So what Diocletian decides
- 40:55that he is going to do is he is he and Maximian are going to
- 41:01step out of office in three O 5. And this happens to be the 20
- 41:05year mark. So it's a kind of a nice, it's
- 41:09kind of a nice round #4 sets of five.
- 41:12They've accomplished what they've desired to accomplish.
- 41:15And it's also if Diocletian is alive, maybe his, his sort of
- 41:21personal presence, the fact that he's still there would kind of
- 41:25help maybe the the system continue to function.
- 41:28He kind of would move into like a wise father role where he's
- 41:32not doesn't have political power, but he just kind of he's
- 41:35kind of the spiritual father that's still alive.
- 41:38So what happens is the 2 Caesar's get elevated now to
- 41:43being Augustus. So Constantius becomes Augustus,
- 41:45Glarious becomes Augustus, and then those two guys are going to
- 41:49appoint by merit to new Caesars. This this prevents this creates
- 41:55problems because they both have biological children, biological
- 41:58sons who get bypassed. But anyway, that's probably
- 42:01another topic. But so so the idea is that
- 42:04there's going to be a kind of succession and it's based on
- 42:07merit. And this is kind of similar to
- 42:10what the Roman Empire has in its early phase the the the emperors
- 42:14are going to adopt maybe. The Five Good Emperors are
- 42:19similar to that. Yeah, it's not.
- 42:20I mean, they're they're they're still like family connections
- 42:23with the five good emperors, but they're not direct like father
- 42:27son, transfers of power. So, so and Diocletian, by the
- 42:32way, you know, he was becoming I'll, he was getting older.
- 42:37So you know, there are pragmatic reasons for this too.
- 42:39But he does make Maximian, his Co Augustus retire at the same
- 42:44time. And as you rightly said in your
- 42:45question, I this just like never happens.
- 42:49Like most emperors either die in office or especially at this
- 42:54time, they get killed, they get stabbed in the back by one of
- 42:57the, you know, one of their Praetorian guardsmen or, you
- 43:00know, some usurper or something like that.
- 43:02So it was kind of the final Test for the tetrarchy.
- 43:06It was, you know, you, you mentioned the idea of machine,
- 43:09the tetrarchy kind of is the machine like it that, that, that
- 43:14the, it's like next man up. It's like we, we can, we can
- 43:18sort of have this almost mechanistic replacement of
- 43:22emperors and the system will keep going.
- 43:25The, the governance will still exist.
- 43:27And and it's like the military, right?
- 43:29The Millet, the Roman military, is eternal.
- 43:32Even if the commanders change, the soldiers change, the
- 43:36tetrarchy can still function as an institution.
- 43:38At least that's his vision. So how long does the tetrarchy
- 43:43last? Because you know, those of us
- 43:45that that do know a little bit more about Roman history realize
- 43:48it doesn't last very long. So so how long does the
- 43:51tetrarchy last and and kind of where does it go from there?
- 43:54No. And, and, and you know, the,
- 43:56the, the challenge of this question is it, it's like, in
- 44:00one sense you could say it, it lasts for a few decades and
- 44:05another, since you can say it doesn't last even a few years.
- 44:08It sort of depends on how we define that.
- 44:09Because immediately after what, within a year of Diocletian and
- 44:16Maximian retiring and the new Caesars coming in and the new
- 44:19Augusti being elevated, will the sons of Constantius and Maximian
- 44:25both decide that they would like to be emperors?
- 44:27And it doesn't help that Constantius ends up dying really
- 44:31far away from Rome. He he dies all the way out in
- 44:34northern Britain. So his son Constant, excuse me,
- 44:38his son Constantine is just there with his father's
- 44:42soldiers. He's interested in becoming
- 44:45emperor. So you know that you could
- 44:48almost say the tetrarchy fails at that point because even
- 44:51though there are attempts to regulate the tetrarchy and sort
- 44:56of like graft in these rebellious figures at any
- 45:01there's really no other time within the first year or two
- 45:05after Diocletian abdicates that you have a kind of regular 4
- 45:10emperors 2 Augustus's two Caesars really succession breaks
- 45:15down by by three O 6. And after that you you don't,
- 45:20you have something between a free for all like the crisis of
- 45:23the 3rd century and then kind of a nominal attempt to whitewash
- 45:27this with the the tetrarchy language and apparatuses.
- 45:32Well, and it's interesting too, because it kind of seems like
- 45:34from then it's just constantines March to to Milvium bridge over
- 45:38a few years and then he he kind of comes out the man on top.
- 45:41Yeah, that's right. Constantine is sort of exactly
- 45:45the right guy to take advantage of this sort of situation, and
- 45:50it helps him that the the kind of the existing emperors and the
- 45:56tetrarchy, not all of them, but Galerius the the senior kind of
- 46:00the most senior figure. After Diocletian and Maximian
- 46:04retire and then Constantius dies, Galerius is the next most
- 46:07senior guy. He recognizes Constantine.
- 46:11So that gives Constantine some legitimacy.
- 46:14You know, some, some weird stuff happens too with.
- 46:19So Maximian's son is one of these rebels.
- 46:22And then Maximian comes out of retirement to try to help him.
- 46:26Diocletian gets kind of asked to, to come back and, and, and
- 46:31make a comeback and sort of sort out all the system and he just
- 46:35refuses. He's well.
- 46:37Well who? Who could walk away from their
- 46:39cabbages? You know what I mean?
- 46:41That's right. Why would he want to quit his
- 46:43farm? I get it.
- 46:45Why would he want to? He's already cleaned up the
- 46:47Roman Empire one time. It's sort of like, look, I've
- 46:51already fixed this. I'm not, you guys broke it, You
- 46:54fix it. Yeah, leave me to my to my
- 46:57cabbages. So Diocletian does not intervene
- 47:00in the system, which is pretty interesting.
- 47:02And it kind of suggests again, you asked about his personality.
- 47:06Maybe it tells us a little bit about him too.
- 47:08You know, he was a soldier. He was a military man.
- 47:10But he clearly, he has a sense of propriety, he has a sense of
- 47:14principle. He, he, he wants to, you know,
- 47:18it's not just grasping for power for any good reason.
- 47:21Unlike Maximian, his, his, his Co Augustus Diocletian is sort
- 47:25of content with what he's done. He's he's happy with his legacy.
- 47:29If the other people are going to wreck the the Tetrarchy, it's
- 47:31kind of on their heads. Well, he seems to have kind of
- 47:34learned the lesson that that Marius couldn't learn, and
- 47:36that's retirement is a good place to be.
- 47:38That's right. You Marius would have maybe
- 47:40lived a little bit longer. Well, I mean, I think he dies of
- 47:43natural causes, but he certainly would have lived peaceably in
- 47:47the last periods of his life. Well, I guess looking at kind of
- 47:50Rome before Diocletian and after Diocletian, when historians look
- 47:54at it, they call early Rome the Principate, and 284 seems to
- 47:58kind of be that marker year we go from the Principate to
- 48:01something called the dominate, which is a different Roman
- 48:04Empire. How would you kind of compare
- 48:06Rome before Diocletian to Rome after Diocletian?
- 48:09Yeah. This is a really nice
- 48:12distinction. So the the the prior to
- 48:17Diocletian really prior to the 3rd century and some historians
- 48:22would even argue maybe this ends with Marcus Aurelius, but you
- 48:27have what's called the principit.
- 48:28You have rule by a first among equals, the prinkets.
- 48:34And what he is, is a kind of fellow elite.
- 48:40So he has imperial power, but he is also a civilian.
- 48:45He's commander of the military, but at the same time he is a
- 48:48senator. He comes from a cadre of
- 48:52aristocrats always. And he is is sort of one of them
- 48:57at the same time. So there's a sense in which he
- 49:00is, he should not be, he's elevated, but he should not be
- 49:04worshipped as a God by other Romans.
- 49:07He should not be given, you know, he should not be
- 49:10considered a master. And there are a few Roman
- 49:13emperors that try to pull this stuff on their colleagues and it
- 49:17is roundly rejected. So somebody like Domician who
- 49:21wants to be called Dominus Ed Deus, he wants to be called God
- 49:25and master. This is not going to fly.
- 49:28Or Caligula would be another example.
- 49:31Or Commodus who wants to be called the Roman Hercules.
- 49:34This is all unacceptable with the mission.
- 49:38Or excuse me, with Diocletian and the dominant, these forms of
- 49:43not just elevating an emperor, but worshipping an emperor
- 49:47become standardized. So it's not just an absolute
- 49:52monarchy, it is almost a, a, a, a, a God on earth kind of
- 49:59situation where Diocletian, when you go into his presence, you
- 50:04are to prostate yourself before him.
- 50:09The colossal statues of him and his subsequent emperors are are
- 50:16all over the place. He is.
- 50:19He is, in effect, a kind of God on earth.
- 50:22He, he is. This is when we start to see
- 50:25emperors with a nimbus, which we know in in Christian tradition
- 50:29as a Halo, a sign of divinity actually around their heads in
- 50:35the way. That he one of the first to wear
- 50:37a diadem as well, is that correct?
- 50:38Like a small crown. Yeah, so that's the other thing
- 50:41that we see. We see the diadem.
- 50:44So all you know, so it's in the way they dress, it's in the way
- 50:46they're approached, it's in the way that their titles work, the
- 50:50entourage that they that they bring with them.
- 50:53It all just suggest, you know, the level of command over just
- 50:57the entirety of the Roman economy and society, culture,
- 51:01religion, these are all. Now it's not as though a switch
- 51:04is pulled when or pushed when a gut, when Diocletian comes into
- 51:08power. Like we can see these things
- 51:10evolving over time, but under Diocletian it's really
- 51:13crystallized and we see that carry on.
- 51:16So even though the tetrarchy falls apart, the idea of the
- 51:20emperor as Dominus, as Lord, as a kind of God like figure that
- 51:27carries on, that survives. So the question I would have for
- 51:30you is, is something that people will often go back and forth on
- 51:33and some tell me I'm totally wrong.
- 51:35But I'm curious, do you see these reforms of Diocletian kind
- 51:39of creating more of what an early medieval world is going to
- 51:42become or, or what are your thoughts on that?
- 51:46I think that there are definitely some some proto
- 51:52medieval structures. So one of the things that that
- 51:56we see under Diocletian now, he doesn't create it, but it, it
- 52:01really flourishes under the tetrarchy.
- 52:03And then in under the, the kind of the, the waning sort of
- 52:09decades of the tetrarchy is something called the colonnade.
- 52:12So the colonnade is one of these ways of, of stabilizing tax
- 52:18revenue. The, the Romans would have a lot
- 52:21of difficulty collecting individual income taxes.
- 52:23That is just not realistic in the Roman.
- 52:25They just don't have the bureaucrats for that.
- 52:27But what you can do is you can take free laborers and you can
- 52:33tie them to plots of land. You can say, all right, your
- 52:36plot of land is this plot of land and we can sort of assess
- 52:41that. So as long as the workers stay
- 52:44on the land and we know where the land is and we know who owns
- 52:47it, we can assess that land in the most exploitative,
- 52:53maximalist way possible. We get as much tax revenue as we
- 52:57can. There aren't as many loopholes.
- 52:58So the the these guys that worked the land that became tied
- 53:02to the land were called colony. They were not technically
- 53:06slaves. They were free, but they weren't
- 53:08practically free. They couldn't just leave the
- 53:11land. They had their landlord that
- 53:13sort of controlled their resources, That took a good a, a
- 53:17portion a a large portion of their produce and then paid that
- 53:22as tax on their behalf. That is a, a, a pretty strong
- 53:27precursor to serfdom. I think that that kind of looks
- 53:31like that. I think we also see some ties
- 53:35with hereditary professions. So it wasn't just field workers
- 53:39that were kind of regimented around this time, but anybody
- 53:43that was involved in some kind of essential work.
- 53:46So shipbuilders, captains of ships, bread makers, soldiers
- 53:52for sure those, those guys that did those jobs, the the
- 53:58Tetrarchs wanted to make sure that those people continued to
- 54:02provide for the military even when they were dead.
- 54:05And they didn't want market, the vagaries of the market, figuring
- 54:09out if if there would be bread shortages and soldier shortages.
- 54:12So you were required, if your father was in one of those
- 54:15professions, to follow in his footsteps.
- 54:19This was true, again, at kind of the labor level.
- 54:22It was true even in like city councils, which is a pretty
- 54:25noble position. If you were a local elite.
- 54:28Normally it was a privilege to serve in the City Council.
- 54:30You were able to build baths and clean canals and you could do
- 54:35this in your name. Now you did it with your own
- 54:37money. But under Diocletian and the
- 54:39Tetrarchs, these were made hereditary.
- 54:41So if you were the son of a city councillor, you needed to follow
- 54:46in your father's footsteps and also provide those services even
- 54:49if you didn't have the money to to follow in his footsteps,
- 54:52which created huge financial strains on the empire.
- 54:58Well, Colin, the, the, the last question I have for you is, is
- 55:01for, for people that would have heard the whole episode.
- 55:03I know it didn't really come up in our conversation, but it
- 55:05would be from the cold open from before we actually speak.
- 55:09I open with the question of did Diocletian save Rome?
- 55:12And the question I have for you now is, did Diocletian save Rome
- 55:16or, or, or what did he actually do?
- 55:18I'm of mixed opinion on this. If you would have asked me this
- 55:22question maybe five years ago, Jeremy, I would have said
- 55:25absolutely not. I would have seen Diocletian, as
- 55:30you know, I would have really emphasized the economic policies
- 55:33which are a disaster and I haven't certainly haven't
- 55:36changed my mind on that. So there's there are definitely
- 55:38some things that he does that are are destructive, are
- 55:43economically destructive, religiously destructive.
- 55:46The persecution of Christians I'm not very excited about,
- 55:50although you know in in Providence this turns out to be
- 55:55to lead to the church triumphant under Constantine and subsequent
- 55:59emperors. However, I think when we look at
- 56:01the tetrarchy, when we look at the political reforms, this is a
- 56:06way in which he saves room. The the reality was even Oralian
- 56:11through brute force could not and he is a force of
- 56:15personality. He is a ruthless, brutal man who
- 56:20in five years reconstitutes the Roman Empire.
- 56:23When he died that falls apart. So it seems like it was not
- 56:29possible for one man to rule the Roman Empire.
- 56:32And what Diocletian does is systematize the idea of a kind
- 56:37of multi emperor rule. And I think even though the
- 56:42tetrarchy itself fails the the general model of having multiple
- 56:48emperors rule, if they can agree to unite, when that happens in
- 56:54the the 4th and 5th century, it can work in places when
- 57:00exception is Constantine. Constantine is able to rule the
- 57:03Roman Empire on his own. He has the benefit of
- 57:05Christianity to help him do that.
- 57:07But even when his sons take over, it's a total disaster.
- 57:11So I, I think that the, the I, his tetrarchy was a lifeboat for
- 57:19the, for the Roman political structure.
- 57:22And, and it's sort of also even some of the negative things that
- 57:26we see with Diocletian kind of test the resilience of the Roman
- 57:31Empire and lead to the, the empire is able to come up with
- 57:36antidotes to some of those problems.
- 57:38Christianity a a a more stable, some stable monetary reforms,
- 57:44just a variety of things that happened later that do,
- 57:47especially in the 4th century, kind of preserve elements of the
- 57:51Roman Empire. Well, very cool.
- 57:54And we we kept the promise of our cold open by answering the
- 57:57question. So Colin, I, I really appreciate
- 57:59you doing this today for people that want to find out more about
- 58:03you or or follow what you're doing.
- 58:04I know you have a really great podcast.
- 58:06I would recommend they check out but where can people find you?
- 58:09Thanks, Jeremy. So yeah, first of all, the the
- 58:11podcast is a great spot, the PAX room on a podcast that's
- 58:14available anywhere. I'm doing a YouTube channel
- 58:17where I occasionally upload some lectures so folks can search for
- 58:20me on YouTube. I'm Prof CPE.
- 58:23They can also find me on X under that same handle, Prof CPE.
- 58:27Check out my book Hox Romana, The Plague that Shook the Roman
- 58:30World. And I think that's that's
- 58:32probably about it. Very cool.
- 58:34Well, Colin, thanks for hanging out with me today.
- 58:37And also a shout out to Matt Lewis from the Gone Medieval
- 58:40podcast, who we had on my other channel, which is hidden Forces
- 58:44in History. Look at the power structures
- 58:45behind history. We did an episode on Richard the
- 58:47Third, but I actually discovered you on his show where he talks
- 58:52about Assassin's Creed. So definitely a great show to
- 58:55check out as well. So a reminder of all you've got
- 58:57there to like this video, leave us a comment and smash that
- 59:00subscribe button. And thanks for hanging out,
- 59:02everybody. Thanks a bunch, Jeremy.
- 59:04The Ecletian didn't fall. He retired, and that's what
- 59:06makes him so difficult to categorize.
- 59:09He was right about almost everything.
- 59:11The diagnosis, the institutional design, the need for structural
- 59:16reform, and the machine he built outlasted him by 150 years in
- 59:20the West and nearly 1000 years in the East.
- 59:23But here's the pattern Every tool he used to hold the empire
- 59:27together. The expanded bureaucracy, the
- 59:29heavier tax burden, the militarized frontier, the price
- 59:33control became a weight that his successors couldn't carry.
- 59:37This wasn't just a Roman problem.
- 59:39It never is. This has been the Roman pattern.
- 59:41I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate. Be sure to like this video,
- 59:44leave us a comment, and smash that subscribe button if you
- 59:47want more of the Roman pattern.