Latest / Killer Destinations / 204. VICTIM OR KILLER: Peter Sullivan - Birkenhead, England 1986
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Kathy with the K. And I'm Kathy with the C. And this is Killer Destinations.
- 0:09[SPEAKER_01]: Today's destination is Birkinhead, England.
- 0:12[SPEAKER_01]: Located along the west coast of England, the name is thought to mean headland overgrown with birch, which once grew in abundance in the area.
- 0:22[SPEAKER_01]: The city is on the world peninsula separated from Liverpool by the River Mercy.
- 0:27[SPEAKER_01]: Burkinhead is often overshadowed by Liverpool, but has its own unique and interesting history.
- 0:33[SPEAKER_01]: The very first public park in the city that was opened in eighteen forty-seven, Burkinhead Park, inspired the creation of the World Famous Central Park in New York.
- 0:44[SPEAKER_01]: The park was visited by famous landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted, who took his inspiration back to the United States.
- 0:53[SPEAKER_01]: Today, Birkinhead has plenty to offer visitors, including green space, independent music venues, and art galleries.
- 1:01[SPEAKER_01]: But in nineteen eighty six, Birkinhead residents were shocked to learn that a new kind of terror had breached their town.
- 1:14[SPEAKER_00]: The town of Birkin had a woke on a sunny August morning in the late States to horrifying news.
- 1:20[SPEAKER_00]: To many, it shocked them to their core.
- 1:24[SPEAKER_00]: In the early morning hours of August second, a young woman named Diane Sindel was brutally murdered for seasoned police officers.
- 1:31[SPEAKER_00]: It was one of the most heinous crimes they had ever seen.
- 1:35[SPEAKER_00]: Twenty-one-year-old Diane was from the town of Seekome in Whirl, which was just a couple of miles from where her body was found.
- 1:43[SPEAKER_00]: Her family owned a well-known florist business.
- 1:45[SPEAKER_00]: Diane was often seen driving around town in her blue fiat van that she used to make deliveries for her family.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_00]: But in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in
- 2:04[SPEAKER_00]: On the night I and Cinderella was murdered, she was working at the pub and had gotten off work just before midnight, but she never made it home.
- 2:14[SPEAKER_00]: However, her van was found in Birkinhead, which was about three miles from the Wellington Hotel where she worked.
- 2:21[SPEAKER_00]: and the gas tank was empty.
- 2:24[SPEAKER_00]: It was assumed that she had run out of gas and started walking to a twenty-four-hour gas station because the road she was on, which was Borough Road, was a busy road and it was very well lit.
- 2:34[SPEAKER_00]: Tragically though, Diane's half-naked body was found a few hours later by a dog walker in an alleyway that was just off Borough Road.
- 2:43[SPEAKER_01]: Needless to say, the community was horrified because Diane was such a well-known person and very well-loved, always upbeat like you said.
- 2:54[SPEAKER_01]: Police immediately began looking into her death and no suspects immediately rose to the surface and they tried backtracking and interviewing people when she was last seen what she was like when she was, you know, leaving the pub, all this kind of stuff.
- 3:10[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway,
- 3:11[SPEAKER_01]: No suspects were bubbling to the surface.
- 3:13[SPEAKER_01]: So a few weeks after her murder, BBC's crime watch decided to reconstruct her last movements.
- 3:23[SPEAKER_01]: And that we have seen this in many cases where they do this in England.
- 3:26[SPEAKER_01]: And they're doing it to try to tickle the memory of the public.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_01]: They're looking for help.
- 3:30[SPEAKER_00]: And they usually have actors playing the people who are deceased or involved, you know, co-workers, whatnot.
- 3:36[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 3:36[SPEAKER_01]: And put them in the same club it.
- 3:38[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 3:39[SPEAKER_01]: And a taxi driver told crime watch that the night that she ran out of gas, he had seen a woman in a man arguing on the side of the road that she was on.
- 3:51[SPEAKER_01]: And he said to the police, it was clear that they knew each other.
- 3:56[SPEAKER_01]: But it was also clear that they were in a fight.
- 3:59[SPEAKER_01]: No real description of the man came forward such that he could ever be identified.
- 4:04[SPEAKER_01]: But the taxi driver thought it was odd and he took note of it.
- 4:08[SPEAKER_01]: So the taxi driver saw this couple a little bit after midnight and according to crime watch sort of the next chronology of events was resonance reporting to police that they heard screaming which they believe was between twelve thirty and two a.m.
- 4:26[SPEAKER_01]: This fit into the scenario of what occurred during Diane's attack.
- 4:32[SPEAKER_01]: When Diane was found, she had a fractured skull.
- 4:35[SPEAKER_01]: She had facial laceration and bruising.
- 4:39[SPEAKER_01]: She had mutilated breasts, and she had injuries consistent with a sexual assault.
- 4:44[SPEAKER_01]: It was horrific and violent, and she would have been screaming.
- 4:48[SPEAKER_01]: And according to court records, she died from a brain hemorrhage, which the doctor believed was a result of blows to the head.
- 4:57[SPEAKER_01]: But he also said that he believed she lived for a period of time after these injuries were inflicted.
- 5:05[SPEAKER_00]: And so of course, calf understandably, everybody was running scared, but particularly women and girls.
- 5:11[SPEAKER_00]: They were afraid to leave their house.
- 5:13[SPEAKER_00]: They didn't have a suspect in the murder case as Kathy said.
- 5:16[SPEAKER_00]: They didn't want to be on the streets alone.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_00]: They didn't want to be in the house alone.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_00]: And so even their fathers and brothers and husbands and boyfriends and whatnot were telling them, okay, you stay in wherever I'm picking you up from until I'm at your front door.
- 5:28[SPEAKER_00]: Like, don't even walk out the friend door to come meet me at the curb if I'm picking you up.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_00]: And so it was from school.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_00]: It was from work.
- 5:33[SPEAKER_00]: It was for anything else to do to friends houses.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 5:37[SPEAKER_01]: Nobody was walking.
- 5:38[SPEAKER_00]: But Kath, the residence described Diane's murder as feeling different.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_00]: That's what had everyone on edge as it was just different.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, obviously, it was horrific.
- 5:48[SPEAKER_00]: But what happened was, of course, as we said, Diane had out of gas and left her car and started walking a busy, well-lit road to go find a twenty-four-hour gas station.
- 5:58[SPEAKER_00]: And so all of these women could see themselves in the same position.
- 6:02[SPEAKER_00]: And so to them it was like you pluck out a normal slice of life and that's what got her killed through no fault of her own.
- 6:10[SPEAKER_01]: I've run out again.
- 6:11[SPEAKER_01]: You probably have never.
- 6:12[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 6:12[SPEAKER_01]: Cassie's like paranoid and she keeps it always like above halfway in her tank where I'm like, oh, look it.
- 6:18[SPEAKER_01]: I'm on E. I bet I can make it.
- 6:20[SPEAKER_01]: Thirty seven miles.
- 6:21[SPEAKER_00]: It says I've got thirty eight.
- 6:22[SPEAKER_00]: I can do thirty seven exactly.
- 6:24[SPEAKER_01]: No, I have run out of gas multiple times and honestly most of the time, it's just because I'm not paying attention.
- 6:30[SPEAKER_01]: Like I'm so focused on whatever I'm doing or wherever I'm going and not driving
- 6:33[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and my last car for whatever reason it was like three times I ran out of gas in that car that gas thing would ding and it was like the car would die So it's like I became like Pavlov's dog like it'd be it would ding and I'd start shaking like oh my god, oh my god, oh my god, give me the gas station
- 6:50[SPEAKER_01]: It was like ridiculous.
- 6:51[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I guess I actually, I did run out of gas one time, but it wasn't my fault.
- 6:56[SPEAKER_00]: Were you with somebody?
- 6:57[SPEAKER_00]: I was not.
- 6:58[SPEAKER_00]: It was back.
- 6:59[SPEAKER_00]: Sounds like it was your fault.
- 7:00[SPEAKER_00]: No, it actually wasn't.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_00]: Mm-hmm.
- 7:01[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so do you remember?
- 7:02[SPEAKER_00]: So when my sister and I both drove, my sister was a year older than I was, she had a car that I then shared with her for about a month.
- 7:09[SPEAKER_00]: And she had gotten home, and I got in the car to drive and go somewhere, and I made it like to just outside of our track.
- 7:15[SPEAKER_00]: And you know that was like, no, like, at all.
- 7:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 7:18[SPEAKER_00]: And the car died.
- 7:20[SPEAKER_00]: That's not my fault.
- 7:22[SPEAKER_00]: I couldn't have gotten a gas station if I'd wanted to.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, the crazy thing about that story is that you only had to share a car for a month.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 7:30[SPEAKER_01]: That's crazy.
- 7:31[SPEAKER_01]: Why?
- 7:31[SPEAKER_01]: Because we had one great station wagon with an orange strip down the side.
- 7:36[SPEAKER_01]: I know.
- 7:36[SPEAKER_01]: That would be shared by five people.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_01]: It was like a beat down.
- 7:42[SPEAKER_01]: No, it's my turn.
- 7:43[SPEAKER_01]: No, it's my turn.
- 7:43[SPEAKER_01]: Like the most physical violence happened.
- 7:46[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's actually not true.
- 7:47[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 7:47[SPEAKER_01]: There was a lot of other fights that happened among my siblings.
- 7:50[SPEAKER_01]: But to this day, we are great friends.
- 7:52[SPEAKER_01]: We fought a lot when we were young.
- 7:54[SPEAKER_01]: Like total, knocked down, dragged out Gen X fighting.
- 7:59[SPEAKER_01]: It was brutal.
- 8:00[SPEAKER_00]: But it would also pissed her family.
- 8:02[SPEAKER_00]: Or it would also pissed whatever brothers off is Kathy would let me drive the car and not him.
- 8:08[SPEAKER_00]: And it was when we were under age granted, but we were the same age.
- 8:11[SPEAKER_01]: This is, in fact, it's speaking of Gen X fighting and this is a side note and we will, we will then move back to the story, but there is like a famous picture of my sister and I every other year we'd wind up on the same soccer team just because of our ages, even though she was younger than me.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_01]: There is a picture that my dad took and she is so angry at me.
- 8:29[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what I did, but I'm one hundred percent certain I deserve this.
- 8:33[SPEAKER_01]: She has my hair, just clutch in her hands.
- 8:37[SPEAKER_00]: And the team picture?
- 8:38[SPEAKER_01]: It's in our soccer uniforms.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_00]: But it wasn't like a team picture.
- 8:41[SPEAKER_01]: I was probably, God, I'm guessing I was fourteen and maybe she was twelve.
- 8:45[SPEAKER_01]: And she looks like she is trying to tear my hair out.
- 8:48[SPEAKER_01]: I should post that on Instagram.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: You said.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my God, that's what we're gonna do.
- 8:52[SPEAKER_01]: For our listeners, everybody else will have no context.
- 8:55[SPEAKER_01]: But for people who are listening, they'll see the Instagram ago.
- 8:57[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, that's the one she was talking about.
- 8:59[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 8:59[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, I'm sure I deserved it.
- 9:01[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 9:02[SPEAKER_01]: Now back to the story.
- 9:03[UNKNOWN]: lol
- 9:09[SPEAKER_00]: In the wake of this terror, one of the things they did Kathy is they held a reclaim the night march.
- 9:15[SPEAKER_00]: And this is something that originated in leads, which is about two hours away, ten years prior, and it was after the Yorkshire Ripper had gone through their town.
- 9:24[SPEAKER_00]: And it scared everybody, obviously.
- 9:25[SPEAKER_00]: This was a serial killer who in the seventies and eighties killed thirteen women and attempted to kill seven more.
- 9:32[SPEAKER_00]: So this was something that just had shut leads down, and so they did this reclaim the night march.
- 9:37[SPEAKER_00]: So they held a similar march in Birkinhead because the women had been told just stay indoors.
- 9:43[SPEAKER_00]: And you know, that's not an acceptable answer when there's fear.
- 9:47[SPEAKER_00]: You don't combat fear by blocking yourself behind closed doors.
- 9:50[SPEAKER_01]: The day after Diane's murder, there were people who saw a fire in nearby Bidston Hill.
- 9:58[SPEAKER_01]: And this is an area that's primarily a public land.
- 10:01[SPEAKER_01]: This fire was not on a residential property.
- 10:04[SPEAKER_01]: And the eyewitnesses told police that they saw a man running from this area that looked like somebody they knew named Pete.
- 10:13[SPEAKER_01]: When the detectives brought this couple in, who had seen the man running from the fire, they brought him in for a lineup, which, by the way, in England, they call a, what is identity parade, which makes it even sound like fun, you know?
- 10:26[SPEAKER_01]: I wouldn't do an identity parade today to start renaming that.
- 10:29[SPEAKER_00]: Let's normalize it.
- 10:33[SPEAKER_01]: But anyway, they brought them in for a lineup and they couldn't identify anyone in the lineup.
- 10:39[SPEAKER_01]: So at one point detectives were so exasperated, they considered interviewing every man in Burkinhead and they wound up interviewing, I want to say, three thousand people.
- 10:50[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, something like that.
- 10:51[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there was so much outrage and there was so much terror as a result of poor Diane's murder.
- 10:58[SPEAKER_00]: And what does this remind us of?
- 10:59[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I don't know.
- 11:00[SPEAKER_01]: We've done so many cases.
- 11:01[SPEAKER_01]: What do you think, you know, Colin Pitchhork?
- 11:03[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, yes.
- 11:04[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, my gosh.
- 11:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 11:05[SPEAKER_01]: The police in the Colin Pitchhork case, and I wish I had what number episode that was sent a letter to all the men between, you know, certain ages in the area surrounding where these poor girls were murdered and asked people to come in voluntarily and give blood samples, which hundreds of men did.
- 11:26[SPEAKER_01]: And when you read the newspapers at the time about that one, it was like, I came in because my wife was telling me to, but it was more like, like, who knew me because my wife was telling me, actually, I can't do that.
- 11:35[SPEAKER_01]: That's a terrible accident.
- 11:39[SPEAKER_00]: That was an accident.
- 11:43[SPEAKER_00]: It was a train ride.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 11:46[SPEAKER_01]: But once the BBC Crime Watch show came out, many, many more leads poured in about the Bidston Hill fire.
- 11:56[SPEAKER_01]: People were like, oh, I saw it, but I didn't see anybody running, you know, that kind of stuff.
- 12:00[SPEAKER_01]: However, the descriptions of the people who came forward prompted police to actually go back to the person named Pete because the original people who reported the fire said they it looked like the man they knew Pete.
- 12:15[SPEAKER_00]: And it never explained why they were able to identify this guy Pete because he actually had been part of that identity parade.
- 12:22[SPEAKER_01]: So he was part of a line up that included a bunch of others and the eyewitnesses still couldn't pick out their buddy Pete.
- 12:28[SPEAKER_00]: These two are actually not their buddy, but it's just somebody they knew around town, but they didn't point to him correct.
- 12:34[SPEAKER_00]: On September twenty-third, in nineteen eighty-six, more than six weeks after Diane Sindel's murder, detectives brought in twenty-nine-year-old Peter Sullivan for questioning.
- 12:45[SPEAKER_00]: He was an unemployed laborer from Birkenhead, and according to detectives, while they were talking to him, he gave several different versions of events as to what he was doing on the ninth of Diane was killed.
- 12:57[SPEAKER_00]: So, after many hours of interrogation, Peter broke down crying and confessed that he in fact was the person who murdered Diane Sindel.
- 13:06[SPEAKER_00]: Then he withdrew the confession and then made the confession again.
- 13:10[SPEAKER_00]: But he had not been able to speak with a solicitor and so he was finally allowed to speak with one two days after this and when he did he then withdrew his confession again.
- 13:20[SPEAKER_01]: So when you say two days was he in custody during those two days?
- 13:24[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, it was over the span of four days, but it wasn't a four day long interrogation.
- 13:29[SPEAKER_01]: It was two day interrogation.
- 13:31[SPEAKER_00]: After he redacted his confession, he just said to police, I made it up.
- 13:34[SPEAKER_00]: Like this is hard.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_00]: I don't want to be here.
- 13:37[SPEAKER_00]: One of the things that they said about Peter was that he had learning disabilities and he was, I think the phrase they used was highly suggestible.
- 13:46[SPEAKER_01]: I read the same thing as well, and I also watched a documentary and they had an interview of his father.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_01]: They were quoting the father.
- 13:53[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't the father being interviewed back then.
- 13:56[SPEAKER_01]: But the dad said, he is the type that doesn't stand up for himself.
- 13:59[SPEAKER_01]: He's not confrontational.
- 14:01[SPEAKER_01]: If people confront him, he walks away.
- 14:04[SPEAKER_01]: And so was described as very passive virus family and very like wants to get along, doesn't like any kind of kerfuffles, you know, very much unlike what this person had to be to murder Diane.
- 14:20[SPEAKER_00]: So this police interrogation had to been very difficult for him.
- 14:24[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, totally agree.
- 14:29[SPEAKER_00]: So trial began less than a year later in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in.
- 14:33[SPEAKER_00]: So trial began less than a year later in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in, in,
- 14:58[SPEAKER_00]: and then it talked about him sexually assaulting her and the attack was referred to as being frenzied.
- 15:03[SPEAKER_00]: And then of course the jury was told about his confession.
- 15:07[SPEAKER_00]: They said that Peter initially denied his involvement and provided an alibi and then later he gave the confession but told detectives that he couldn't remember what really happened because he'd been really drunk at the time.
- 15:18[SPEAKER_00]: The other thing that came out, Kath, is that there was testimony from a dental expert that Peter's bite exactly matched a bite on Diane's body.
- 15:28[SPEAKER_00]: The defense countered with what we have just talked about that he had learning disabilities and he was highly suggestable and apparently very versatile confrontation when he confessed to the police.
- 15:36[SPEAKER_00]: The Kath, it was also revealed at trial through the defense that the reason that Peter hadn't been given a solicitor for two days is that the detectives felt that adding a solicitor might be a
- 15:47[SPEAKER_00]: hindrance in their interrogation of Peter.
- 15:50[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe maybe maybe just a scotch.
- 15:52[SPEAKER_00]: It tells me they really don't have Miranda rights in England.
- 15:55[SPEAKER_01]: They don't.
- 15:57[SPEAKER_01]: They do they do add munitions.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_01]: They do do add munitions, but it's obviously it's Miranda versus Arizona.
- 16:03[SPEAKER_01]: It's our Miranda.
- 16:06[SPEAKER_00]: After nine hours of deliberation, Peter Sullivan was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison, but what that meant is he was required to serve a minimum of sixteen years, and then he'd be eligible for release.
- 16:18[SPEAKER_00]: And then Kathy, this is so sad.
- 16:20[SPEAKER_00]: BBC Northwest Tonight reported how, when he was pronounced guilty, Peter just stood in the courtroom silently.
- 16:28[SPEAKER_00]: His mother broke down and screamed, and his sister actually fainted.
- 16:33[SPEAKER_01]: And Kath, I read somewhere that his mother was so appalled.
- 16:38[SPEAKER_01]: And she said that Peter was looking forward to the trial because he knew then he would be found innocent and be able to go home.
- 16:45[SPEAKER_01]: And one of the things his mom said was that he had everything.
- 16:50[SPEAKER_01]: He had a wife that he never thought he'd have and a child, a little boy, I believe, at the time.
- 16:56[SPEAKER_01]: And so her whole point was never in a million years would he have done this kind of thing.
- 17:01[SPEAKER_00]: You know, the other thing, Kathy, that I saw, and, again, this is in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in in
- 17:22[SPEAKER_01]: So because Peter Sullivan was sentenced to a minimum of sixteen years, he was eligible for parole in two thousand three, which he applied for.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_01]: However, at his parole review hearing, he absolutely professed his innocence, and that's not what parole boards want to hear.
- 17:39[SPEAKER_01]: So that was two thousand three.
- 17:41[SPEAKER_01]: Fast forward to two thousand eight.
- 17:43[SPEAKER_01]: This is twenty one years into his sentence.
- 17:46[SPEAKER_01]: Peter applied to the criminal cases review commission for assistance.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_01]: And Kath, as I understand it, this is a public entity in England, and you can apply to them if you believe your case involves a miscarriage of justice.
- 18:01[SPEAKER_01]: And they actually have subpoena powers, they have authority to interview witnesses, they have authority to obtain police records, medical records, all this kind of stuff that goes along with innovation.
- 18:11[SPEAKER_01]: And if they believe they have new evidence or something nefarious happened initially, they can send your case up to the court of appeal and say, please hear this again.
- 18:23[SPEAKER_00]: You can still appeal to the Court of Appeals in England, but of course, obviously having this statutory body behind you saying, oh, we think we found stuff to definitely helps your case.
- 18:33[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 18:33[SPEAKER_00]: Because it means you'll get it.
- 18:34[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 18:35[SPEAKER_01]: And they can also, they also review expert witness testimony and they could look at whether these same test applied a day, you know, that kind of thing.
- 18:43[SPEAKER_01]: So it's, it's a, it's a borne with a lot of juice.
- 18:47[SPEAKER_01]: So Peter specifically asked them, in two thousand eight, could you please look into the DNA evidence?
- 18:53[SPEAKER_01]: We have, you know, all of these miraculous scientific advances and my case should be part of that.
- 19:02[SPEAKER_01]: And the CCRC basically said, no, they were told by forensic experts that it would be unlikely that there would be sufficient DNA to find anything of note.
- 19:15[SPEAKER_00]: The other thing that I read calf is that even though in two thousand eight, they were obviously far and beyond what DNA testing started out as being, but they were also afraid that there wasn't enough for them to test, and if there was, they would diminish the entire sample.
- 19:29[SPEAKER_00]: Only to find out there wasn't enough to test something like that.
- 19:33[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so Peter's application was rejected by the CCRC.
- 19:38[SPEAKER_01]: Now in two thousand nineteen, this is thirty two years into his sentence twice the minimum that the judge had ordered him to serve.
- 19:47[SPEAKER_01]: He goes back to the court of appeals and he asks them for two things.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_01]: He asked them to look at the reliability of the disputed bite marks being consistent with his teeth.
- 20:00[SPEAKER_01]: And he also wanted them to look at his intelligence and suggestability and really kind of like Monday morning quarterback, the confession that he gave to the police because he was saying it was under duress.
- 20:14[SPEAKER_00]: and without his solicitor that they had refused to grant him for several days.
- 20:18[SPEAKER_00]: The other thing path as I was reading is that in twenty nineteen so we had said the bite mark was something of course they came out of in the first trial and was like it is identical to Peter's teeth.
- 20:27[SPEAKER_00]: By this time in courts across the world there was a lot of suspicion on bite mark identity because people can have the same teeth.
- 20:35[SPEAKER_00]: They can have the same structure.
- 20:37[SPEAKER_01]: But it's also the difficulty of taking and impression.
- 20:41[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 20:41[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 20:42[SPEAKER_01]: And the thing is in his initial trial, that's what the prosecution said.
- 20:47[SPEAKER_01]: This is the same as a unique fingerprint.
- 20:51[SPEAKER_01]: And by twenty nineteen, a lot of courts were like, you know what?
- 20:54[SPEAKER_01]: We're not sure this is really scientific.
- 20:56[SPEAKER_01]: We're not sure this actually meets the test of reliability.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_01]: So the court of appeals took more than two years to review Peter's case, but they concluded that it was untimely made and his application could not undermine the totality of the evidence that the prosecution presented to convict him.
- 21:19[SPEAKER_01]: Once a court of appeal rejected his application, his attorney Sarah Mayett again went back to the CCRC and said, help us out.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: We are in twenty twenty one.
- 21:32[SPEAKER_01]: We want this case reexamine in light of all the scientific advances that have been made.
- 21:38[SPEAKER_01]: She again raised concerns about the bite marks.
- 21:42[SPEAKER_01]: She also raised concerns about the police interrogation, you know, taking away his will, essentially.
- 21:49[SPEAKER_01]: And she again requested that the DNA be tested because here we are in twenty twenty one and it had not been tested ever.
- 21:59[SPEAKER_01]: in the background what was happening with the criminal courts review commission is that they had been highly criticized.
- 22:07[SPEAKER_01]: I think there were really there were two recent cases where DNA exonerated people and those individuals had to fight like hell to get the DNA retested.
- 22:19[SPEAKER_01]: So now here comes Peter in a very highly publicized case with an attorney asking for DNA testing and they were like, here you go, ma'am.
- 22:29[SPEAKER_01]: What else do you want?
- 22:30[SPEAKER_00]: Can we bring you some coffee while you're waiting?
- 22:31[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
- 22:33[SPEAKER_01]: You look hungry.
- 22:35[SPEAKER_01]: They knew that they had to take the Seaman samples found on Diane's Sindal's stomach and test them.
- 22:43[SPEAKER_01]: DNA testing revealed a male profile that was not consistent with Peter Sullivan.
- 22:51[SPEAKER_01]: It was also not consistent with any of Diane's relatives or her fiancé that she was engaged to in nineteen eighty-six.
- 23:05[SPEAKER_00]: Peter Sullivan's case was overturned by the Court of Appeals on May thirteenth, twenty twenty five, so just a couple of months ago.
- 23:12[SPEAKER_00]: And they also ordered him to be immediately released from prison.
- 23:15[SPEAKER_00]: When he was released, he had served more than thirty eight years in prison for a crime he did not commit.
- 23:24[SPEAKER_00]: and Kathy, at the age of six-eight, he was believed to be the victim of the longest miscarriage of justice by a living person in British legal history.
- 23:34[SPEAKER_00]: The only miscarriage of justice believed to have been longer than Peter Sullivan's thirty-eight years happened to a prisoner named Derek Bentley who in nineteen fifty-two was convicted of murder.
- 23:46[SPEAKER_00]: With DNA evidence his case was actually overturned in nineteen ninety-eight, so forty-six years after his conviction,
- 23:53[SPEAKER_00]: tragically, though, he was actually hanged for his crime in nineteen fifty three, just a year after he'd been convicted.
- 24:02[SPEAKER_01]: Kath, do you know when that situation did his family petition and petition and petition to have the DNA reviewed?
- 24:08[SPEAKER_01]: I have to believe that's the case because why else would they?
- 24:11[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 24:12[SPEAKER_01]: I would want my loved ones DNA reviewed.
- 24:14[SPEAKER_01]: You know what I mean?
- 24:15[SPEAKER_00]: I'd say it.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_00]: If knowing they were innocent, you don't want them in history.
- 24:20[SPEAKER_01]: And hanged.
- 24:20[SPEAKER_00]: And you don't want them in history to be known as the process.
- 24:23[SPEAKER_01]: That's what I thought about actually with Peter.
- 24:26[SPEAKER_01]: You know, you have a guy with, you know, learning disabilities.
- 24:29[SPEAKER_01]: He's a global person and he has to live with these names attached to him.
- 24:34[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 24:34[SPEAKER_00]: Like the Ripper and, you know, I mean, just even in the newspapers after he was released after having the case overturned, they referred to the beast of Birkinhead has had his case overturned.
- 24:46[SPEAKER_00]: According to reporting by the BBC, Peter Sullivan took part in this hearing via a video link.
- 24:52[SPEAKER_00]: And when he was told that his conviction was being overturned, he apparently put his hand over his heart and started sobbing.
- 24:59[SPEAKER_00]: A statement was read by his lawyer Sarah Mayett on his behalf.
- 25:03[SPEAKER_00]: And it said, what happened to me was very wrong, but it does not detract or minimize that all of this happened off the back of a heinous and brutal loss of life.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_00]: I am not angry, I am not bitter.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_00]: I am simply anxious to return to my loved ones and family as I've got to make the most of what is left of the existence I am granted in this world.
- 25:27[SPEAKER_00]: Kathy also speaking after the hearing was Peter's sister Kim.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_00]: Now I have to tell you I was so happy to see this because as we said he's a little slow, highly suggestible and whatnot and if you've been in prison for thirty eight years especially knowing your innocent this entire time, how do you get released and just be normal?
- 25:44[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 25:44[SPEAKER_00]: And the answer is you don't.
- 25:46[SPEAKER_00]: But his sister Kim was there and she was talking and she expressed her sympathy for Diane Cindy's family and despite the fact they got Peter back, nobody won like this.
- 25:55[SPEAKER_00]: This is not a win for anyone.
- 25:57[SPEAKER_00]: She said they've lost their daughter.
- 25:59[SPEAKER_00]: They are not going to get her back.
- 26:01[SPEAKER_00]: We've got Peter back and now we've got to try and build a life around him again.
- 26:06[SPEAKER_00]: It's such a shame this had to happen in the first place.
- 26:10[SPEAKER_00]: So I was just glad to know he has a safe landing spot for sure.
- 26:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there's you could tell there's a lot of people who are always pushing for his innocence.
- 26:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 26:18[SPEAKER_00]: You know, never lost their belief.
- 26:20[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 26:20[SPEAKER_01]: Now, thank God.
- 26:21[SPEAKER_01]: So Mercy side police have reopened their investigation, obviously, in light of the verdict being overturned and they submitted the new DNA through the database and came up with nothing.
- 26:35[SPEAKER_00]: So one of this was in this was their nationwide database.
- 26:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 26:38[SPEAKER_00]: This was all of the UK.
- 26:39[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
- 26:39[SPEAKER_01]: And they also sent letters to people who were identified in the original investigation in in nineteen eighty six and said, Hey, can you please come forward?
- 26:48[SPEAKER_01]: We'd love to eliminate you as a suspect.
- 26:50[SPEAKER_01]: Will you donate your DNA?
- 26:52[SPEAKER_01]: And there were announcements by the police basically saying, We're taking this seriously.
- 26:57[SPEAKER_01]: We are not giving up.
- 26:59[SPEAKER_01]: So if you were around back then in nineteen eighty six and you had suspicions about someone or
- 27:06[SPEAKER_01]: You know, something unusual happened that you remember, come forward and talk to us.
- 27:10[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't matter if these people are dead because we can always do familial DNA.
- 27:15[SPEAKER_01]: Even though the person is deceased, it doesn't matter.
- 27:18[SPEAKER_01]: And understandably, there is now a renewed concern and mercy side because a killer has been roaming and unpunished for nearly forty years.
- 27:32[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what kind of crimes have to be committed to be placed into their DNA database.
- 27:39[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if it's any felony.
- 27:40[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have to be murdered.
- 27:41[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not sure what their database consists of, but for this DNA not to be in any database, like this guy flew under the radar.
- 27:51[SPEAKER_01]: In Birkinhead, fresh flowers and small notes are still left at a small black granite memorial for Diane Sindel in front of the alleyway where she was found on Burr Road.
- 28:05[SPEAKER_01]: At the top of the memorial is her name and date of death.
- 28:08[SPEAKER_01]: Directly below that it says, because she was a woman.
- 28:14[SPEAKER_01]: Below that it says, in memory of all of our sisters who have been raped and murdered, we will never let it be forgotten.
- 28:27[SPEAKER_00]: So, thanks for listening.
- 28:29[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for listening.
- 28:30[SPEAKER_00]: Please subscribe.
- 28:31[SPEAKER_00]: Please tell all your friends to subscribe.
- 28:33[SPEAKER_00]: And if you have case suggestions, which we've actually just got a few of them in, we'd love to hear them.
- 28:38[SPEAKER_01]: What she said.