Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / Episode 112: LDG's Thoughts on the Inaugural USL Super League Season, and Why the League Is Valuable for the American Women’s Soccer Landscape — The Women’s Soccer Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome back to the Women's Soccer
- 0:01Podcast. I'm your host, Liam Greco. You may know
- 0:03me better as LDG. Last week was a double interview
- 0:06week, which was really, really fun, but I'm really
- 0:09excited to just be back on the mic with me and
- 0:11you before our amazing interview with Maggie
- 0:13Graham comes out later this week. As USL Super
- 0:16League recently ended its season and I didn't
- 0:18really get to cover it as much as I would have
- 0:19liked to this year, I wanted to do just like
- 0:21an end of season summary of all my faults in
- 0:24the league. We did a preview episode and in that
- 0:26episode I set target objectives that I wanted
- 0:29the league to reach that weren't necessarily
- 0:31quantifiable. It says incredible development
- 0:34of the Super League and how it's a really good
- 0:36case study for the season as a whole as to what
- 0:40the Super League can be really successful at.
- 0:42And I think this is going to be a really great
- 0:44episode for... anyone, regardless of whether
- 0:46you watched every single match or barely tuned
- 0:49into the Super League. It's a really exciting
- 0:50development in the general landscape of the pyramid
- 0:53of women's soccer in the U .S. And so I think
- 0:55it's only right that we talk about the second
- 0:58Division I league in the U .S. So let's get right
- 1:00into it. And I'll talk about my initial skepticism
- 1:02surrounding the league. I was one of the first
- 1:04podcasters to do a full league breakdown. I did
- 1:07it in June. So the rosters at that point had
- 1:09already been A few teams have not even had a
- 1:13single player, but others have had close to a
- 1:15starting lineup. And that was where I really
- 1:17struggled because I couldn't really see the vision
- 1:19of the league at that point. I felt like the
- 1:21Super League was really trying to market itself
- 1:23in a lot of different ways that were not coherent
- 1:26and cohesive. I felt like the league as a whole
- 1:29was trying to frame 20 different images to what
- 1:32the brand could be. Because at the end of the
- 1:34day, when you're entering a landscape, where
- 1:36there's already a Division I Women's Soccer League,
- 1:38when you're also trying to take on that role,
- 1:41you have to have something that differentiates
- 1:42yourself, besides the calendar and stuff like
- 1:44that. It's not, at the end of the day, enough,
- 1:47really, for me as a consumer at least, to see
- 1:50this league as a unique, special product. So
- 1:52at first, I wanted to just watch the season,
- 1:57and I was very clear about that in that preview
- 1:59episode. At the end of the day, what matters
- 2:02most is once the ball kicks off, what is going
- 2:05to happen with the season. And so I had a lot
- 2:07of ideas surrounding this league in that episode
- 2:10that I really want to clarify because I truly
- 2:12am a proponent of the Super League, as I'll get
- 2:15into today. I think I love the idea of growing
- 2:17the pyramid at first with the Division II League,
- 2:19as the Super League was initially going to fulfill
- 2:22that role. At the end of the day, plans change.
- 2:25They move up to Division I league, which I think
- 2:27makes sense from a sanctioning purpose because
- 2:29you professionalize the league to a much higher
- 2:32degree. If the Super League was Division II,
- 2:34I don't think some of the players that are in
- 2:36the league now would be there. I don't think
- 2:37that a player like Lexi Nismo would have gone
- 2:40to Dallas Trinity if the Super League wasn't
- 2:43a Division I league. And at the end of the day,
- 2:45as a product, it makes sense for them to approach
- 2:48the Division I landscape. Looking back on it,
- 2:52I would reevaluate my thoughts because I do think
- 2:55that the league is necessary because there's
- 2:59a lot of players in the U .S. who would never
- 3:01make the NWSL. And I would say 90 % of the players
- 3:04in the roster right now are that space before
- 3:07the Super League happened. Now the Super League
- 3:09has happened. I think what we're going to see,
- 3:11you know, this offseason will be a really great
- 3:12study for the Super League. Nico Purcell, who
- 3:15we'll get into a little bit later, has already
- 3:16transferred from... Brooklyn FC to the Seattle
- 3:19Reign and I think the thing that's not the best
- 3:22look for the Super League is she only signed
- 3:23a short -term deal right now with the Reign because
- 3:25one of their players Cassie Miller is on a 45
- 3:28-day injury list so I think considering that
- 3:30Nico is one of the only players who got and called
- 3:32up from the Super League to the youth national
- 3:33team and she's one of the better players in the
- 3:35league it's not a great sign for the league that
- 3:38they're losing players like that and so we'll
- 3:39get into that a little bit later because I truly
- 3:41do think the talent on the pitch this season
- 3:43was quite good my one worry though is because
- 3:45the Super League I think exceeded a lot of people's
- 3:48expectations with the on -pitch quality. A lot
- 3:50of those players could get poached by the NWSL,
- 3:52considering that the minimum salaries at the
- 3:55time of the league starting were similar. The
- 3:57NWSL's minimum salary has gone up so much in
- 3:59that time, and I really don't see how the Super
- 4:01League could sustainably or reasonably pay anywhere
- 4:04near the salaries that the NWSL pays. So at the
- 4:07end of the day, I think that's going to be a
- 4:08really interesting thing to watch out for, because
- 4:10even though now we've seen a full season of the
- 4:12league, we haven't really seen a lot of movement
- 4:14besides the Purcell transfer. Between the two
- 4:17leagues, it's going to be a really interesting
- 4:18point for fans of both the Super League and the
- 4:21NWC to watch out for. Because at the end of the
- 4:23day, for the Super League to succeed, there needs
- 4:26to be a little bit more sustainability. And we'll
- 4:29talk about this a little bit later in more detail.
- 4:31But Brooklyn and D .C. are the two teams right
- 4:34now who have released. their end of season roster
- 4:37lists. And essentially it's like at the end of
- 4:39the year, there's that one day at the end of
- 4:40the year, usually nothing really that see if
- 4:42it comes out, except for like two or three players
- 4:44saying goodbye to the club. These lists had,
- 4:46I think at least 10 people on both of them, if
- 4:48you include Purcell in that group for Brooklyn
- 4:50FC. So it really is concerning. I would argue
- 4:53for two clubs that had a lot of struggle and
- 4:55performances, but also had some. glimpses of
- 4:58hope for the league. If there's this continuous
- 5:01turnover, we're going to see every single season
- 5:03starting out like it did this year, where there's
- 5:05a lot of lack of consistency, a lack of fluidity
- 5:09throughout the side. And at the end of the day
- 5:10for a product, that's not going to look good.
- 5:12I think a lot of people who supported the Super
- 5:14League this season as a novelty. there's going
- 5:17to need to be that push to bring people back.
- 5:19And that's the concern I have most because attendance
- 5:21this year wasn't great, but I wouldn't say it
- 5:23was bad either. There were some markets who really
- 5:24thrived, others that were quite lackluster. But
- 5:28I do question as a whole how this product can
- 5:32sustain itself after year one. Year one was very
- 5:34impressive, and I agree with that. And I do think
- 5:36that the Super League... can coexist with the
- 5:39NB cell. If I'll answer that question right now,
- 5:41even though that was supposed to be something
- 5:42I was going to talk about later on, because at
- 5:44the end of the day, the Super League does have
- 5:45a lot of qualities that differentiates itself
- 5:48from the NB cell. In the NB cell, young players
- 5:49barely get minutes. Look at sides of the season
- 5:52that signed lots of rookies. And once you're
- 5:54someone like Lily Wheeler, Sarah Shupan's kids
- 5:56getting called up to the U23s, the full national
- 5:58team even for Lily now, that... At the end of
- 6:01the day, you're not going to get the minutes
- 6:02you deserve as a player to develop. And you don't
- 6:05want to be in that period of stagnancy where
- 6:07you're just at the back of the bench. So I think
- 6:08for the Super League, that is something that's
- 6:10truly a very valuable asset of the league. That
- 6:13was good. I love the idea of bringing women's
- 6:15soccer to more markets. And I still stand by
- 6:18what I said in the first episode, however, because
- 6:19I really don't understand why putting a team
- 6:22in the same stadium as the Washington Spirit
- 6:24stands by that. Or if it's a really good business
- 6:26decision, because at the end of the day, no one's
- 6:29really going to choose. DC Power, a club that's
- 6:31really struggled over a Washington Spirit side
- 6:33that has some of the biggest superstars on the
- 6:35US Women's National Team. I do wonder that the
- 6:40Super League is going to struggle to sustain
- 6:44some of the markets. I don't think the league
- 6:45as a whole is really in danger of imploding,
- 6:48but I think some specific markets, DC Power being
- 6:51one of them, could really, really struggle, especially
- 6:54considering the investment of other teams like
- 6:56Tampa Bay Sun. who just recently announced their
- 6:59intentions, albeit it's a rough draft, but still
- 7:01an incredible movement to build the largest,
- 7:03I believe, women's soccer -specific stadium in
- 7:05the U .S., just beating Denver FC's, we don't
- 7:09know their nickname yet, but the new Denver club
- 7:11and NWSL, their stadium, that's 14 ,500, the
- 7:16one that they're building. That's crazy to see
- 7:18the Suns' immense, I feel like, just ambition,
- 7:23considering that the Super League. hasn't been
- 7:27in existence for a long time. It's been great
- 7:28to see that they've been putting their foot in
- 7:30the gas pedal really long. And I want to talk
- 7:31about three clubs who I actually worked with
- 7:33earlier this year for episodes. And I'm trying
- 7:35to shout out these interviews, but I think truly
- 7:36having players on the show, like Carly Giamona,
- 7:40the son, but then also having a GM and associate
- 7:42head coach. We had Chris Petruccelli from Dallas
- 7:45and also Ali Rogers from Fort Lauderdale. These
- 7:47are three of the biggest clubs, I would argue.
- 7:49Off the field, they were very successful. Obviously,
- 7:51Tampa and Fort Lauderdale played that Florida
- 7:53Derby in the final. But I think it was really
- 7:55good to see the fact that those three clubs were
- 7:59trailblazers off the field in different ways.
- 8:00I think with Fort Lauderdale building that one
- 8:03stadium and renovating it and also looking for
- 8:05the club, it just really spoke to the professionalism
- 8:09of the ownership group and buying in from owners
- 8:13to players to staff. Obviously, Champ, we talked
- 8:15about the stadium. And for Dallas, playing in
- 8:17the Cotton Bowl is a really big statement of
- 8:19intent for the team and the league, which I think
- 8:21is a really good sign for that new Super League
- 8:24as a whole to have ownership groups that are
- 8:27putting their teams in stadiums. Patricelli admitted
- 8:28himself that the Dallas -Turney side is not going
- 8:31to be ever close, at least in the immediate future,
- 8:34to filling up that whole stadium. But just playing
- 8:36there, I think, for the players, the really cool
- 8:38aspect of the league and playing in such a historic
- 8:40venue. is only going to help the league at the
- 8:42end of the day. Speaking of the Trinity's sporting
- 8:44side of things, I think that the loans that Dallas
- 8:48has had by bringing in players like Sam Meza,
- 8:51who we'll get to a little bit more later, but
- 8:52then also the trio of Washington Spirit, international
- 8:55players who, of course, not to be sold to international
- 8:57spot regulations, may not have had the quality
- 9:01now to fill one of those spots, considering the
- 9:03immense competition within the Spirit side. But
- 9:05then it also allows them to go to a new club
- 9:07and have a chance to develop and get minutes.
- 9:10And I think for the Spirit, having those players,
- 9:12so to speak, on their radar and being able to
- 9:15keep rights of them for eventually one day when
- 9:17they do come back to the NWSL, I think is a really
- 9:20smart move from a lot of aspects. I think the
- 9:23leagues have not competed against each other
- 9:24like people feared. I think the fact that the
- 9:27NWSL is willingly loaning a lot of players to
- 9:28the Super League speaks about not just the opportunity
- 9:32that the Super League has to, you know, strengthen
- 9:35its talent pool, but for main players who have
- 9:37that experience in a top club environment. But
- 9:39also I think it speaks to the NWSL team's trust
- 9:43in the Super League for development because at
- 9:44the end of the day, teams wouldn't be loaning
- 9:46players out to the Super League if they didn't
- 9:48trust those clubs to develop their talents. And
- 9:51I think middle players like Mackenzie Weiner,
- 9:53who was contracted out of the range, she was
- 9:56there in Spokane on loan for the first half.
- 10:00of the season, and then her Reign contract expired.
- 10:03She signed with Spokane for the rest of the season.
- 10:05I think she's departing the club now based on
- 10:07Instagram posts, but I haven't heard anything
- 10:09official yet. But I think it just really speaks
- 10:10to how players can get in those environments.
- 10:13The fact that McKenzie liked Spokane enough to
- 10:16leave the Reign, I don't know if the Reign...
- 10:18didn't resign her we don't obviously know the
- 10:20negotiations there but the fact that she's spending
- 10:22a half a year there on loan as more of a development
- 10:24move and then like that environment enough for
- 10:27her personal development to stay there speaks
- 10:29volumes about the league i think for any young
- 10:30player i would really recommend going to on loan
- 10:34to super league if you get into that maybe sell
- 10:35just because minutes are so valuable. And Sam
- 10:38Meza has really been a living example of that.
- 10:412024, Meza got zero minutes with the rain in
- 10:43the regular season. And she appeared in the Summer
- 10:46Cup. She looked pretty good. But at the end of
- 10:48the day, the rain midfield was pretty loaded
- 10:50with talent. And so ultimately, she kind of knew
- 10:53based on the interview that we read with friend
- 10:55of the pod, Theo Lloyd -Hughes, the minutes that
- 10:58she was going to need for her development weren't
- 11:01going to be available for her at the rain. And
- 11:02I think... It's a really mature decision from
- 11:05a young player to acknowledge that and then look
- 11:07for other options. And Chris Petrucelli, of course,
- 11:09who we've been on our show before, went in for
- 11:12Sam and acquired a beast of a player. And going
- 11:15from not making any appearances in the regular
- 11:18season to player of the month for the Super League
- 11:20in November really speaks volumes to how those
- 11:23minutes can really just give a lot of players.
- 11:26confidence again. Sam hadn't really experienced
- 11:28that few minutes in her whole career. She was
- 11:31a pretty big player for UNC in college. That's
- 11:33why the rain paid $125 ,000 to get the pick that
- 11:37they would ultimately use to draft Sam. And I
- 11:39think it really speaks to how Meza had zero minutes
- 11:43last season in the regular season. She went on
- 11:45loan for half a year with the rain. from the
- 11:47Reign to the Trinity. She comes back into this
- 11:49preseason with the Reign. She plays incredible
- 11:52football. She gets a lot of starts this year.
- 11:54And then ultimately, she was recognized by Emma
- 11:56Hayes and the U .S. Women's National Team, who
- 11:57have seen the incredible work that Laura Harvey
- 12:00has done developing young talent. They've now
- 12:02called in, I think, five Reign players on the
- 12:05U23s, along with the senior team. And I think
- 12:09it really speaks to how NWSL is the only place
- 12:12that players should be going for development
- 12:13because at the end of the day, the Super League
- 12:16environments are competitive enough and have
- 12:20the resources to help these players thrive. And
- 12:22I think if there's any questions surrounding
- 12:23that, those should be rebutted because Sam's
- 12:26example of how she was able to put in the work.
- 12:31get the chance to play consistent minutes with
- 12:34the Trinity, and then ultimately she took that
- 12:36back to the NWSL. And so that's a really good
- 12:38example of how these relationships between the
- 12:41two leagues don't have to be very competitive.
- 12:44They can ultimately lift each other up. Sam was
- 12:46a player who really helped fill out a midfield
- 12:50that was struggling with creativity after she
- 12:52left for a while. And that was seen. Her hole
- 12:54in the midfield was definitely there. And I think
- 12:57it also allowed the rain to... bring in other
- 13:00players in that summer, like Mondesir, and then
- 13:03Meza can come back and start matches. So I think
- 13:07these relationships are really mutually beneficial.
- 13:11And I do hope that more players go on loan from
- 13:15the NWSL to the USL. And I think there's also
- 13:18ways that USL players can come to the NWSL. I
- 13:21know that in the Summer Cup last year, Maya Gordon...
- 13:24And Jill Aguilera went on loan from the Super
- 13:27League to the Spirit because the Spirit had so
- 13:30many players away at the Olympics that they needed
- 13:32players for the Summer Cup. So that's another
- 13:33example of how the USL can help the NFL this
- 13:36year with two expansion teams coming in. I think
- 13:38we'll see many more moves like Niku Purcell,
- 13:41who are top performers in the Super League, can
- 13:44find. a contract in the NWSL. So that's really
- 13:47all I have to say about the relationship between
- 13:50the two. And I want to get back to focusing on
- 13:52the Super League independently. On the pitch,
- 13:54the roster building side of things was definitely
- 13:56something that I think even the Super League's
- 13:58most avid fans were questioning at first. Because
- 14:00when I recorded that episode in June, I was concerned
- 14:03with the Super League's attempt to broaden the
- 14:06growth of the country's only real sustainable
- 14:09women's soccer league by trying to pluck players
- 14:11from the NWSL. And I think that was a threat.
- 14:14to the NWSL that was very valid at the time.
- 14:16No one really knew the direction the Super League
- 14:18would take. I really don't think that ended up
- 14:21happening. I think the Super League targeted
- 14:23a lot of young players who maybe had gotten drafted
- 14:25by the NWSL, had been in camps, but didn't ultimately
- 14:27sign the contracts. At points, you really wonder
- 14:29if some teams are even going to be ready to start
- 14:31the season. Well, as I mentioned earlier, other
- 14:34clubs like Fort Lauderdale really got off to
- 14:36the races early and along with Tampa Bay with
- 14:39signing players. Brooklyn, who was one of the
- 14:41later teams for the party, actually had a great
- 14:43start to the season, which I think maybe helped
- 14:45defeat some of the negative optics surrounding
- 14:49the league at first, because it is quite unprofessional
- 14:51to see some teams that seemingly weren't invested
- 14:55in the club at first. The Super League roster
- 14:56for Brooklyn FC felt quite thrown together in
- 14:59some ways. There's a lot of talented players,
- 15:01but I think the cohesiveness of the team wasn't
- 15:04there, and as other teams became more cohesive.
- 15:07the Brooklyn FC side struggled. And so for me,
- 15:09even though obviously the novelty made the first
- 15:12few games exciting, I liked the spring season
- 15:14more than the fall season because I feel like
- 15:16we finally got to see players come into their
- 15:18own within their team systems. And I felt like
- 15:20teams were building identities during the season,
- 15:23even before stepping on the pitch. I thought
- 15:25that the branding at Super League was phenomenal.
- 15:28Every team's craft gave them a... virtual or
- 15:32visual identity that you can kind of depict in
- 15:35your head before they even step on the field,
- 15:37which I really loved. And I think the teams that
- 15:40impressed me the most off the field also impressed
- 15:42me a lot on the field. Because at the end of
- 15:45the day, the clubs that were being more advantageous
- 15:48and moving more quickly with the branding, with
- 15:51signing the coaches, with signing players, were
- 15:54the clubs that had more times to gel together,
- 15:56had more training sessions to ultimately... progress
- 15:59towards the common goal of winning the Super
- 16:02League title, which Tampa Bay Sun were the first
- 16:04to achieve with the Ascent and the Shield as
- 16:07well, which I think is important to mention.
- 16:09But at the end of the day, there are some clubs
- 16:11that I really just felt were never prepared to
- 16:15step in the field. Lexington was a team that
- 16:17really at points I was kind of concerned about.
- 16:20I think when watching the Super League, the league
- 16:22as a whole was quite competitive from the top
- 16:23six teams. But there was a few teams in the bottom
- 16:26two specifically that were really struggling
- 16:28at points. And I almost felt bad for some clubs
- 16:30that I really just didn't feel like at some times.
- 16:33We're at the level of the rest of the league.
- 16:35And it really makes you question that divide
- 16:37that we've seen in the NWSL, I'd argue, even
- 16:39with investment from the top clubs and the top
- 16:41ownership groups to the bottom ownership groups
- 16:43of the league. I think there's been a little
- 16:45bit of a hierarchy in both the NWSL and the USL
- 16:47Super League. And I really hope that the Super
- 16:49League can look towards the NWSL and try and
- 16:52not make the same mistakes that the NWSL did
- 16:54make at the beginning of their existence. Because
- 16:56I think the fact that the league has a mere baseline,
- 17:00I think. One positive that was undisputed before
- 17:04the season was that the Super League was creating
- 17:06more jobs in America for women's soccer players
- 17:09to not have to go play overseas if they don't
- 17:11want to. Because at the end of the day, the NWSL
- 17:13has been expanding quite rapidly, but it's still
- 17:16not enough spots to really give a lot of players
- 17:21a chance. I think when you look at the NWSL draft,
- 17:23sure. 56 players got drafted in a recent draft,
- 17:27and some get invited to camps. But even Livani
- 17:30Valko has been a pretty star performer, I would
- 17:32argue, for the Fort Lauderdale side when she
- 17:34was on the pitch before getting injured. She
- 17:35got drafted with BASC in the fourth round, which
- 17:37is a little bit later than anyone expected. She
- 17:39went into the three -season camp. I don't think
- 17:40she got signed with the club, or she doesn't
- 17:43get signed. I don't know what happened there.
- 17:45She didn't make the roster at the end of the
- 17:46day. And then she goes in with Fort Lauderdale.
- 17:49She does pretty well. She gets the starting spot
- 17:52and she really becomes an instrumental part of
- 17:54that back line. And so I think this is a path
- 17:56where the players should not be undermining or
- 17:58undervaluing. And I think, of course, every player
- 18:01wants to play in the NWSL alongside stars like
- 18:05Trinity Rodman and Corey Bethune and, you know,
- 18:07Triple Espresso under these big markets and big
- 18:10crowds. But at the end of the day, I think. From
- 18:13a developmental standpoint, the Super League
- 18:15is a great option that I truly believe more agents
- 18:18and young players should be looking out for because
- 18:21in NWSL, there's not the great path right now
- 18:24for players to get minutes. And so I truly do
- 18:28believe unless you're one of those top, top rookies,
- 18:30you're not going to get those minutes and Super
- 18:32League might be a better option for them. Even
- 18:34though this is a new product and I do feel like
- 18:37for a first season, the Super League's on pitch
- 18:40quality is pretty good. It was still a clear
- 18:43step below in my eyes from the NWSL. I know that
- 18:45might be a little bit debatable for some Super
- 18:47League fans, but I feel like top players really
- 18:51were some of my favorites to watch in the Super
- 18:55League. I really loved watching someone like
- 18:56an Allie Thornton, who I thought was just so
- 18:58fun to watch. Her play was multidimensional.
- 19:00She could score in lots of different ways, and
- 19:02I think as a whole. The Super League had a lot
- 19:04of decent strikers, but there was none that stood
- 19:07out to me so much that I was like, okay, Anubis
- 19:10Alti needs to get her a contract. I think Amina
- 19:12Akic, obviously. I know I'm saying two players
- 19:15who won awards, by the way, which are not exactly
- 19:17controversial or how it takes players who are
- 19:19under the radar either. But I think Amina won
- 19:23the title of the year for such a reason, because
- 19:24her creativity, her left foot is golden. We've
- 19:27seen her in the NWSL. She scored a couple free
- 19:29kicks. She didn't really get a lot of minutes
- 19:30of racing, which is why she went over to Australia.
- 19:32And then when she said she was coming back to
- 19:35the U .S., I assumed she was going to come back
- 19:36to the NWSL, but I assumed wrong. And I think
- 19:39the Super League was a great opportunity for
- 19:40her. I do question. By the way, as I'm recording
- 19:43this, I'm recording this on June 22nd. So some
- 19:47of the lists have not come out yet for players
- 19:49that are leaving the club. So I don't know all
- 19:51the details about them. So I'm just going to
- 19:53focus on the clubs that I do know about. But
- 19:54I really do wonder, like, I think if I had to
- 19:57pick some players that could be poached by NBSL
- 19:59teams, because if you have to remember, these
- 20:01expansion sides have limited budgets. They don't
- 20:03have a draft. They don't have an expansion draft
- 20:05to bring players in. So the Super League really
- 20:07is going to be... a key market for them to post
- 20:09players from. Any free agents that are available
- 20:11out there are going to be looked at. And I think
- 20:14the fact that Nico Purcell was drawn back to
- 20:17the Reign, which is obviously her hometown club,
- 20:20but also for not a starting role, definitely
- 20:22not, I don't think, a backup role either. If
- 20:24she does make the roster, it'll be third string.
- 20:27I think it does show to me that Nico Purcell
- 20:30does have that ability to pick players from the
- 20:32Super League. And I think the Super League should
- 20:34be worried about that. I'm viewing this more
- 20:35from... less of like an NWSL should do this and
- 20:38more of a Super League for it to keep its best
- 20:42star players should really make sure that their
- 20:46top salary is higher than the NWSL minimum salaries
- 20:48that they can pay some of these players more
- 20:50than they would have gotten paid in NWSL just
- 20:52because I do think that the league had a lot
- 20:56of top players that showed glimpses of high quality
- 20:59but I feel like consistently players didn't have
- 21:03the opportunity to play together. I feel like
- 21:05there's lots of games where really talented players
- 21:07weren't there. There's small benches, lots of
- 21:10starting lineup rotation. I just don't think
- 21:12in general players were really set up to succeed
- 21:14in a lot of areas. And I guess that's just what
- 21:16comes with being a lower division. Even the Super
- 21:19League is still a Division I league. This USL,
- 21:22we see a lot more roster turnover and a lot less
- 21:24consistency on the men's side. So I presume not
- 21:27considering a lot of the ownership groups are
- 21:28shared, some of those characteristics might bleed
- 21:31into the women's side for worse, I would argue,
- 21:33because that coherency is only getting hung with
- 21:36consistency. And if clubs don't have the ability
- 21:39to keep players in, I do wonder if that player
- 21:42quality and that's on that. so to speak, versus
- 21:47NWSL will succeed? Because I think that at the
- 21:49end of the day, for the league to succeed, which
- 21:51is what we'll get into, to what extent does it
- 21:55need to draw the attention of NWSL fans? This
- 21:57is a question that I'm going to ask a lot because
- 21:59NWSL, generally speaking on the sports landscape,
- 22:02is still a pretty niche league. It's much less
- 22:04popular than a lot of other sporting leagues
- 22:07that capture headlines on a week -to -week basis.
- 22:09And so the Super League is trying to pull fans,
- 22:12understandably so, already supporters of women's
- 22:15soccer, they need to capture their attention
- 22:17with a product that can rival the quality of
- 22:20the NWSL. Is that a fair task to ask Cooper League
- 22:23sides? I don't think so. And I think for me watching
- 22:26the Super League, I don't watch expecting the
- 22:29same things I expect when I watch the NWSL. I
- 22:31don't know if that's a fair comparison necessarily,
- 22:33but I think they're two different products that
- 22:36highlight two different parts of America, America's...
- 22:40ever -changing women's soccer landscape that
- 22:42I think both are really valuable. The Super League
- 22:44has produced a player in Sam Meza who I wouldn't
- 22:49necessarily say wouldn't be on the U .S. team
- 22:51if she hadn't gone to Dallas Trinity at any point.
- 22:54But I think for her to have gotten a call up
- 22:56this soon, I think that loan definitely probably
- 22:59got her on the map of the brain. Seeing how well
- 23:02she performed at the Trinity probably made Leslie
- 23:06Gallimore and Laura Harvey be like... Let's get
- 23:08her back in the club and starting in these matches.
- 23:11So I think the Super League really has a good
- 23:13opportunity there to continue pulling in players
- 23:16on loan because at the end of the day, more top
- 23:18college players are going to come out of the
- 23:20D1 and D2 and D3 or any up level really within
- 23:24college. And they're not all going to get roster
- 23:26spots at the end of the sale. And there's more
- 23:29roster spots that need to be filled in the Super
- 23:33League than the end of the sale. So I think this
- 23:35is a really good opportunity this offseason for
- 23:37the Super League to look. I have a lot of players
- 23:39who are graduating in the summer and really put
- 23:42off the pitch there to say, you can be an instrumental
- 23:44part of our team. You can join our team at the
- 23:46beginning of the season. Because that's the good
- 23:48thing about the Super League is it captures both
- 23:50the players who graduate in the summer and both
- 23:52who graduate in the winter. Because now if they
- 23:54want to be still draft. There's no incentive
- 23:56for players to rush to graduate early. They could
- 23:58join just like Haspo did in the summer with NNB
- 24:02Cell, and that's totally fine. Or they can join
- 24:03like Kira Locker did in the middle of the year,
- 24:05the Super League season, which happens to coincide
- 24:08with NNB Cell off -season. So I think the fact
- 24:11that there's this crew, and I know that NNB Cell
- 24:13has that month break, but the Super League arguably
- 24:15has a much more... clear one way for players
- 24:18to come into the team and really acclimate before
- 24:21stepping on the pitch, which I think is a really
- 24:23good positive that Super League should aim to
- 24:25lean into. More positive notes. I feel like two
- 24:28teams are really exemplary at building their
- 24:31rosters out for season one, but also laying the
- 24:33groundwork and the infrastructure for the sides
- 24:36to stay successful over the next decade. I think
- 24:39the Tampa Bay Sun from the get -go clearly had
- 24:42a vision of what they wanted their club to be.
- 24:45The high school stadium wasn't admittedly ideal,
- 24:48but I feel like they knew from a roster point
- 24:52of view that they needed to build a team with
- 24:55a mix of former NWSL players, international players,
- 24:59and then also players who are fresh out of college.
- 25:01I think they did just that. And ultimately that
- 25:03won them the championship of the playoffs. But
- 25:06I think what the Sun did really... well was they
- 25:08were one of the first teams to actually start
- 25:10signing players. And I think by doing that, they
- 25:13started to have their identity much earlier rather
- 25:16than just trying to find it as the season went
- 25:19on. I feel like the Suns roster was built with
- 25:21a lot of intention, which was really interesting.
- 25:23The Carolina Ascent, who are the Shield winners,
- 25:26took a different approach from the Sun for building
- 25:29their franchise. But they were also one of the
- 25:30teams that was making headlines, signing Phillip
- 25:32Poole, who was a former U .S. Women's National
- 25:34Team assistant head coach, to lead the side.
- 25:37And also making headlines through ensuring infrastructure
- 25:39was great from the get -go, which other teams
- 25:42failed to accomplish. Their stadium was an incredible
- 25:45facility for the club to play at. It was the
- 25:48perfect size, around 10 ,000 seats. And ultimately,
- 25:50with the Sun taking the on -field push at the
- 25:54beginning of the year, I felt like the Sun was
- 25:56the best off the field. They had the highest
- 25:58attendance all year long, accumulatively. They
- 26:01had the highest attendance for a single match,
- 26:03highest attendance all year throughout. And that's
- 26:05a trend that I'm really going to be watching
- 26:06because league as a whole if the USL Super League
- 26:09wants to truly catch up to the NWSL or at least
- 26:12stay competitive in function I think they need
- 26:15to draw more fan attention because the overall
- 26:18league average is sub two and a half thousand
- 26:21fans and that's with a lot of matches not being
- 26:23reported and ultimately that doesn't really get
- 26:26the job done in my eyes because you look at how
- 26:28expensive building a franchise is and you look
- 26:31at other franchise groups that want to invest
- 26:34in the league Teams that are in the NWSL are
- 26:37so coveted right now, expansion sides, because
- 26:40of the ROI, return on investment. And ultimately,
- 26:43when I look at the Super League, I really do
- 26:45struggle to see with certain sides not really
- 26:49having a lot of investment in their teams. That
- 26:52will power, I guess, from ownership to really
- 26:56care about their teams. And I think from what
- 26:59I'm seeing, I do question to some extent how
- 27:03much a few franchises that aren't investing as
- 27:07much can drag the whole boat down I think we've
- 27:10seen that in the past in sports leagues that
- 27:13a few teams can be incredibly ambitious but when
- 27:17other sides in the league aren't there right
- 27:18behind them pushing them there gets to a place
- 27:21of stagnancy and in Europe a lot of the competition
- 27:24that occurs isn't really in the league. It's
- 27:26in the Champions League. And I think even though
- 27:28the Women's Super League is obviously the most
- 27:29competitive league, we've seen a lot of players
- 27:32who've spoken about coming to the NWSL. Esther
- 27:35said the NWSL is like playing in the Champions
- 27:38League week in and week out. And I want the Super
- 27:40League to get to a point where players can feel
- 27:42that competitiveness and not have some of the
- 27:44matches that we saw this season where they weren't
- 27:46as close. And I think... The one thing to mention
- 27:50is I talked about how all the teams were in states
- 27:52that had NWSL teams. But I think it's important
- 27:54to mention that the markets that were removed
- 27:57by NWSL teams by, let's say, about three hours.
- 27:59These include, by the way, Dallas or Lauderdale,
- 28:02Carolina. These markets worked. But I think some
- 28:04markets were just too close, simply speaking,
- 28:08to NWSL markets. Obviously, D .C. Power playing
- 28:11in the same stadium. They played third fiddle,
- 28:13too. the DC United side and then also the Spirit.
- 28:17So at the end of the day for them, they had a
- 28:19lot of midweek games and their side wasn't producing
- 28:22the results I'm sure they would have wanted to
- 28:24on the pitch. So that obviously has an effect.
- 28:26And by the way, this isn't necessarily to critique
- 28:28the league as a whole. I am a big proponent of
- 28:31the Super League. I think with every league,
- 28:33there's always room to grow. And I think the
- 28:35whole point of this episode is I keep on spoiling
- 28:37it because I don't want the message to be lost
- 28:39and that I truly think this is really big. thing
- 28:44for women's soccer this is a great opportunity
- 28:46to expand the player pool in the U .S. by giving
- 28:49players a chance to stay pro not having to go
- 28:52overseas because that's a deterrent for a lot
- 28:55of players that could make the U .S. women's
- 28:57national team just like Sam Meza that maybe get
- 28:59a roster swap and then it'd be sell or don't
- 29:01get the minutes that they want. And look, we've
- 29:03seen in the past that we saw so many players
- 29:05who retire early without getting minutes. And
- 29:07this is a great opportunity for those players
- 29:10who maybe didn't get the minutes that we sell
- 29:12to come to the Super League. Even players who
- 29:13just feel like they match with a club's identity
- 29:16more in the Super League and want to be a centerpiece.
- 29:18The Super League is a great opportunity for that.
- 29:20And I think even though the average fan, so to
- 29:22speak, may choose watching Triple Espresso over
- 29:25up and coming prospects, I think it's important
- 29:27to acknowledge how The markets that the Super
- 29:32League are in, like Spokane, that I think some
- 29:34NWSL supporters have unnecessarily ridiculed,
- 29:37are actually going to be the backbone of this
- 29:39league. Because markets like Spokane are never
- 29:42going to really get the same treatment that an
- 29:46NWSL team would get, because they're not going
- 29:48to get an NWSL team, right? They're a few hours
- 29:51away from Seattle, so that's the closest NWSL
- 29:53team that they have to them. for the same state.
- 29:56I think Portland's probably even closer when
- 29:58you think about geographically, even if they're
- 30:00in separate states. So I think I retract that
- 30:04statement that I said earlier, because I did
- 30:06say like the Super League needs to find an angle
- 30:09because the fans of teams in DC aren't going
- 30:12to leave Shaney Rodman and cry with him to watch
- 30:15a new club. I think that the Super League really
- 30:18needs to lean into these markets that truly do
- 30:20not have access to women's soccer. I, as a fan,
- 30:24the Super League, if that their target audience
- 30:27should be people who love watching the NWSL,
- 30:29but don't have an NWSL team in the market. For
- 30:32me, I'm pretty much in the middle from Brooklyn
- 30:35FC and Gotham FC, and I'm going to choose Gotham
- 30:37FC. most of the time because Brooklyn FC is very
- 30:40far trained right away. It's very isolated. And
- 30:43again, these are just individual aspects of each
- 30:45club that have been taking turns. And a lot of
- 30:47people have been confused about why Brooklyn
- 30:49FC hasn't gotten the attendance that their team
- 30:51deserves, especially when they're playing such
- 30:52incredible football to watch. from home but i
- 30:55think really from a marketing perspective it's
- 30:58hard to see the super league playing games in
- 31:00february in front of 200 people because these
- 31:03players are so talented and i think this is just
- 31:05one area the super league is going to have to
- 31:07continue evolving in because spokane markets
- 31:11like that are never going to have access to triple
- 31:13triple express and players like that so it's
- 31:15a perfect smaller city to build a community around
- 31:17the club and they were actually in the top half
- 31:20half of attendance in the Super League this season,
- 31:21beating teams like Brooklyn and DC, proving how
- 31:24bigger markets are not always a better option
- 31:26for this league. And I would actually argue are
- 31:27the worst option because you want cities that
- 31:30are invested in Spokane's effort, are invested
- 31:32in Fort Lauderdale United. You want cities that
- 31:35can give their all to this team. And at the end
- 31:37of the day for the Super League. in some of the
- 31:39markets that they're currently in right now,
- 31:41I would say DC and Brooklyn being two of the
- 31:42based ones, they're not getting that reception.
- 31:45Lexington, I know, has also had their own attendance
- 31:47struggles, but I think we look to the NWCEL side
- 31:49of things, and Louisville, who are having one
- 31:50of their best seasons ever, are still having
- 31:52struggling attendance. So I think at the end
- 31:54of the day, you have to look within communities
- 31:56and really question, is the need there for another
- 32:01women's soccer team, right? I think to really
- 32:04assess whether or not the Super League is bringing...
- 32:07women's soccer to more new markets, we need to
- 32:08question if the markets that they're placing
- 32:10themselves in are markets that are saturated,
- 32:13so to speak. They have women's soccer team. Okay.
- 32:16DC has Washington Spirit. We don't need to put
- 32:18a team there. That's, I think, a next step that
- 32:21I really want to see the Super League, that I
- 32:23guess level of restraint of not just expanding
- 32:25recklessly. I know you need eight teams to start,
- 32:28which is why DC and Brooklyn are kind of thrown
- 32:30in there at the end. But I think when it comes
- 32:32to expansion in the future, one thing I really
- 32:34would like to see is a little bit more strategic
- 32:36thinking in regards to where the markets are
- 32:38being placed. Straight perspective, I talked
- 32:40about the end of season roster updates that have
- 32:43been occurring for both Brooklyn and DC. And
- 32:45I think it's really concerning to me because
- 32:48substantial amounts of roster turnover, as I
- 32:50mentioned earlier, is not going to lead to St.
- 32:52Louis on the pitch. And I think we saw how players...
- 32:55got to gel over the course of the year. But if
- 32:56that process continues to happen, new teams coming
- 32:59in, that gelling process is just going to continue
- 33:01happening. And it's not good for players. It's
- 33:03not good for staffs. And I think the lack of
- 33:05momentum that's really going to carry over could
- 33:07be problematic for teams. So I think sides like
- 33:10Tampa that I presume are going to keep more of
- 33:12their players over season to season are going
- 33:14to have a significant advantage. Because also,
- 33:16I'd argue it's really bad for job stability to
- 33:18the players. We talked about how this league
- 33:20could be a great opportunity to increase the
- 33:21number of jobs in women's soccer in the US. But
- 33:25if players are continuously leaving the Super
- 33:27League, I don't think roster years are announced
- 33:30when you sign a contract. We don't know how long
- 33:32contracts are publicly speaking. I don't even
- 33:35know if those are established privately. So I
- 33:37think it's important to really get to the nitty
- 33:40gritty nature of this is that the Super League
- 33:42needs to really address this issue, in my opinion,
- 33:45because at the end of the day, even though there
- 33:47might be ownership crossover, the US Super League
- 33:50is not a division two, division three league.
- 33:52It's a division one league. And if fans want
- 33:55to be treated, if the league wants fans to treat
- 33:59it like such, it needs to show a level of professionalism
- 34:02that I think has really been concerning to me.
- 34:05And I think it's really sad to see so many players
- 34:07go. And I think I get that this is a part of
- 34:10sports, right? I understand player turnover from
- 34:12your year is very natural, but the fact that
- 34:14there's... like 10 plus players getting all announced
- 34:17to be departed. Brooklyn FC is no goalkeeper's
- 34:20son right now, right? And I think that's the
- 34:21thing that's really concerning to me is like.
- 34:23Is there a plan here? I understand sometimes
- 34:25when teams start ways to players that maybe don't
- 34:28fit the project as a whole. But when you're letting
- 34:30go of so many players, it really does make me
- 34:32question whether these markets are planning adequately
- 34:35and know who's coming in after this. Because
- 34:37a lot of the players that were left behind by
- 34:39DC and by Brooklyn are top quality players who
- 34:43many teams would really value in the Super League.
- 34:45So I think that's one thing I'll be really looking
- 34:47at because at the end of the day, for this league
- 34:50to be successful, and that's one of my things
- 34:51was saying, individual teams establishing their
- 34:54clear brand and identity. And I think a lot of
- 34:56teams did achieve this this season, but for those
- 34:58brands to be continuous and to carry over to
- 35:01the next season, there needs to be a level of
- 35:04transparency within the club, players being able
- 35:07to feel like they're part of that identity and
- 35:10also staying for a while. Hopefully the club
- 35:12can provide a good experience for players to
- 35:15want to come back. And obviously, we don't know
- 35:17what side of things. Was it the players who left
- 35:19these teams? Was it the teams who needed to move
- 35:22on from players because it wasn't the right fit
- 35:24anymore? We don't know. And I'm sure it's just
- 35:26a mix of both. But at the end of the day, that's
- 35:28something I think should be concerning and should
- 35:30be something the Super League looks to address
- 35:31over the next few years. Before we end by talking
- 35:34about... The ultimate question, was the season
- 35:37of the Super League successful? I want to talk
- 35:40about the idea of an open cup because I think
- 35:42it's something that's really interesting to me
- 35:43because if you look on the men's side, the open
- 35:46cup exists and not all MLS teams currently participate.
- 35:48I believe most of the teams that are in there
- 35:50for the MLS are playing with second division
- 35:53squads. And I think especially for teams like
- 35:56Gotham, Washington, Orlando, who already are
- 35:58in. the CONCACAF Champions League, I don't know
- 36:01how this would fit into their schedule. So I
- 36:03think an Open Cup is a great idea. What I was
- 36:04suggesting is that I think for Gotham, Orlando,
- 36:08and Washington, they probably shouldn't play
- 36:10their best teams if they're going to participate
- 36:11in the Open Cup, because I don't think from a
- 36:14fixture congestion point of view, it would really
- 36:18be feasible. And that's the thing, obviously,
- 36:20with everything in soccer is the calendar, the
- 36:22jam -packed calendar that already exists. So
- 36:25adding new competitions, I think, would be crazy.
- 36:27I love the idea of an Open Cup. I think it'll
- 36:29be super, super fun because there's obviously
- 36:31now going to be NBSL Division 2 potentially joining
- 36:34in and then also the WPSL and Division 2. So
- 36:37it's going to be a lot of new leagues. And that's
- 36:38what I was also thinking about was from an NBSL
- 36:412 perspective is are they going to try and poach
- 36:43USL Super League players? I know it's a division
- 36:45down, but the fact that they're in tandem connected
- 36:47to the main team, I wonder if NBSL squads are
- 36:50going to say, look, we really value you as a
- 36:52player. We think you're going to be a great player
- 36:54for the club in the future, but we don't know
- 36:56if you get minutes with us now. I think that
- 36:58whole idea of players going to the Super League
- 37:00to get minutes could diminish if NFL clubs are
- 37:03able to make an appealing enough pitch to bring
- 37:05players into the Division II sides for a little
- 37:07adjust after college and then bring them into
- 37:09the first team. I don't know. Again, these are
- 37:10all hypotheticals because at the end of the day,
- 37:12the soccer landscape is changing so much so quickly.
- 37:15So I think that's going to be two really interesting
- 37:18things to watch out for. Okay. Now the question
- 37:21that you've all been waiting for. Was it successful?
- 37:22I know I've said it a million times, but I spoiled
- 37:25it, but I still want this thing to end. Yes.
- 37:27It was. I think teams did establish a lot of
- 37:31infrastructure. I think they are not set up to
- 37:33fall victim to the curse, so to speak, of previous
- 37:37leagues. I think two areas they could grow is
- 37:39getting people in the seats in general, fan engagement,
- 37:42other league. I think from a marketing perspective,
- 37:44there's a lot of area to grow. There's a lot
- 37:46of great stories in the league. There's a lot
- 37:47of amazing branding that's going on from individual
- 37:50clubs. I think as a league as a whole, there
- 37:52needs to be word spread around about it. I don't
- 37:54think that a lot of people... really know about
- 37:56the Super League yet. And I think a lot of its
- 37:58mission that's been established as the league
- 38:01has gone on, I guess you could say, has been
- 38:04transparent. I think for fans of women's soccer
- 38:06or soccer in general, this is a great opportunity
- 38:08to see some of the world's best players, I guess
- 38:12you could say, some of the top American youngsters.
- 38:15up and coming players in your local market. So
- 38:17that's, I think one thing that could work on
- 38:19and also towards economic sustainability. We
- 38:21know the curse of a lot of sports leagues, men's,
- 38:25women's, soccer, non -soccer, all leagues have
- 38:28really struggled with that one big question of
- 38:31growing too fast. And I wonder if this expansion
- 38:33process from the Super League could do that.
- 38:36And I also think just from an individual club
- 38:38standpoint, I know clubs are single entities
- 38:40in the Super League. They work separately. I
- 38:43don't think. by the way, I'll say this right
- 38:45now, the league is in danger of folding. I think
- 38:48some clubs may struggle to sustain themselves
- 38:51over time, but I think a lot of the clubs in
- 38:55the leagues have everything that they need to
- 38:58work on, but also they have established that
- 39:01makes sense. I think every single club has things
- 39:03that they've done in each aspect of the club
- 39:06building process, but also no one's perfect,
- 39:08right? I think. even though some clubs are different
- 39:10stages, I really like what TC Power is doing.
- 39:12For instance, they're bringing in someone like
- 39:13Angel Reese and Francis Tiafoe, who's at their
- 39:16first match. Reese is a minority owner for the
- 39:18club. I don't know if Tiafoe is publicly invested,
- 39:20but I know he was at their first home match at
- 39:22Audi Field. I love seeing these partnerships
- 39:24that the community of the power are trying to
- 39:27make with their fan base. And I think these are
- 39:30different areas that will continue to grow. So
- 39:32that's just my 40 minute thought sessions. I
- 39:36really loved doing this episode. It was not super,
- 39:39planned out intentionally. I really was just
- 39:41trying to look at what I said in the past and
- 39:44then also like what I saw you all online and
- 39:47the DMs and the comments talking about this league
- 39:49because it's a really exciting new project, of
- 39:51course, but I also think there needs to be these
- 39:53kind of conversations surrounding it. I haven't
- 39:55really seen a lot of coverage surrounding the
- 39:56Super League. There was an incredible final that
- 39:58Cecile Flo Nielsen scored an amazing goal for
- 40:01the Sun to win it in extra time. But yeah, that's
- 40:05just on the first season of Super League. I'm
- 40:07really excited to see this summer, all the transfers
- 40:09from women's soccer, European leagues, leagues
- 40:11all around the world, both the Super League and
- 40:13the NFL, of course. So let me know your thoughts
- 40:16in the comments. Leave me a review. Five stars,
- 40:18of course. Hopefully, if you thought this episode
- 40:20was good, tell your friends about the show. Follow
- 40:22us, review your podcast. We're also on Blue Sky
- 40:24and Instagram now. I know a lot of people have
- 40:26moved over and we have too. We post mostly on
- 40:29both platforms. We post pretty much. everything
- 40:31on both. So follow us on both if you want, because
- 40:34some platforms have unique posts as well. So
- 40:37that's all for me today. Thanks so much for listening
- 40:40to this episode of Women's Soccer Podcast. I'm
- 40:42your host, Sam Greco, signing off for the 112th
- 40:45time. Peace out from your host, LDG.