Latest / Frontier Futures for Children / Episode 1 | Scaling where it’s hardest: High-tech dreams in low-resource realities
Transcript
- 0:00Helen: Hello, and welcome to Frontier Futures for Children, a brand-new podcast
- 0:05about the very latest tech innovations designed to improve the lives of children,
- 0:09young people, and their communities.
- 0:12I'm Maddy Savage.
- 0:13I'm a tech and business journalist based in Stockholm, Sweden.
- 0:16Yemi: And I'm Yemi Lufadeju from UNICEF Office of Innovation,
- 0:19which is also based in Stockholm.
- 0:21Yemi, before we get started, it's my guess that most people probably don't
- 0:26associate UNICEF with tech and innovation?
- 0:29No, you're absolutely right.
- 0:30It's a lesser-known dimension of UNICEF.
- 0:33People know us best as a champion of children's rights, especially in conflict
- 0:37and crisis, but we also help develop cutting-edge technologies to solve
- 0:41problems that shape children's lives.
- 0:43So think vaccine trackers on blockchain and AI-powered air
- 0:47quality monitors in schools.
- 0:50Our work is made possible with support from a diverse group of partners, and
- 0:53that also includes this podcast series.
- 0:57But the conversation here is wide open, so think of it as a global
- 1:01conversation, a global discourse, for the social impact space that's
- 1:05focused on innovation for children.
- 1:07And Maddy, you're here to make sure that we ask the questions
- 1:11that matter, aren't you?
- 1:12Maddy: Yeah, that's right.
- 1:12We won't be shying away from challenging questions.
- 1:15Throughout the series, we'll be digging deep into some of the opportunities, the
- 1:19challenges of using technologies like AI and blockchain, and we'll have guests,
- 1:24a wide range of guests from scale-ups and other nonprofit organizations to
- 1:28journalists, university researchers, and we will be transparent if any
- 1:32of the guests are UNICEF partners.
- 1:35So Yemi, let's crack on.
- 1:36I'm so excited for you to introduce our first topic.
- 1:39Yemi: So for our first episode, we're addressing the Holy Grail for every
- 1:44social impact company, and that's scaling.
- 1:48Maddy: Yeah.
- 1:49So what does it take to move from, say, a 10-person pilot to a
- 1:53scaled tech solution that reaches thousands or even millions of people?
- 1:58That is the big question that we're looking into on this episode.
- 2:01And I mean, scaling is the dream for most tech entrepreneurs, if not all of them.
- 2:06But numerous global studies show that the vast majority of startups
- 2:10don't make it past those early years.
- 2:14And in social impact, the stakes and the challenges are even higher.
- 2:17You're not just building a business to make money, you're trying to improve
- 2:20people's lives, whether that's healthcare, education, disaster prevention, and you're
- 2:25often doing it in the toughest conditions.
- 2:27Limited funding, maybe unreliable transport, energy supplies, all
- 2:31sorts of logistical hassles.
- 2:33So in this episode, we're going to get insights from guests in a
- 2:36few different places, Rwanda, the Netherlands with a perspective
- 2:40from India as well, and the UK.
- 2:42But first, we've got a guest right here in the studio with us in Stockholm.
- 2:46Yemi: Absolutely.
- 2:47So yes, a big hello to Helen Samuelsson, innovation advisor at
- 2:52the Swedish International Development Agency, Sida, which helps finance
- 2:57entrepreneurs in emerging economies and is also a UNICEF partner.
- 3:01Thank you.
- 3:02Hi, Helen.
- 3:03It's good to have you here.
- 3:05Also joining us on the line is Mimi Billing, who is Europe editor for
- 3:10the tech news website Sifted, which is backed by The Financial Times.
- 3:15How are you both?
- 3:16Mimi: I'm great.
- 3:17Thanks for having me.
- 3:18Helen: Yeah, so am I. I'm very honored to, to be here
- 3:22participating in this podcast series.
- 3:25Maddy: Super.
- 3:25So Mimi and Helen, I'm going to start with the questions, and we thought
- 3:29we'd kick things off with actually a social impact success story from a
- 3:33company that's helped a lot of children and their communities, and we're
- 3:36going to get you both to listen in.
- 3:38So let's introduce our next guest.
- 3:40Lots of guests in this first episode, so exciting.
- 3:43On a video link, we have Divya Gupta.
- 3:45She's based in Amsterdam in the Netherlands, and she is Chief Business
- 3:48Officer for Qure.ai, which has developed remote scanning software that's designed
- 3:53to help doctors in low-resource settings.
- 3:56Divya, welcome to the program.
- 3:57Divya: Hey, thanks, Maddy, for having me.
- 4:00Maddy: So Qure.ai started out as a small company in India back in 2016, but it's
- 4:05grown a lot, and we've got a challenge for you, and that's to give us the company's
- 4:09scaling story in elevator- pitch style.
- 4:12So you've got just a couple of minutes.
- 4:14We want to know what you do, how you scaled, and what your
- 4:17impact looks like in numbers.
- 4:18Divya: Sure.
- 4:19Happy to share.
- 4:20So Qure is the world's most adopted healthcare AI solution today.
- 4:25What we do is we use AI to help healthcare programs triage diseases
- 4:31faster, better, and cheaper.
- 4:33We are driving early detection in diseases like tuberculosis, lung cancer,
- 4:38and specifically for children, we do a lot of work in pediatric TB, pediatric
- 4:42pneumonia, which we know are one of the largest drivers of under-five mortality.
- 4:47In the last 10 years, it has been 10 years, it feels much longer, I have
- 4:52to say, but in the last 10 years, we have been deployed in over 100
- 4:55countries, including more than 30 in Sub-Saharan Africa, Southeast Asia,
- 5:01NHS in the United Kingdom, as well as the US provider market, right?
- 5:05So it's quite the diversity.
- 5:08We have over 5,000 users, and we have impacted more than 40 million lives.
- 5:13We are top evaluated by the WHO twice.
- 5:16We have more than 26 FDA clearances.
- 5:19We are CE-approved, and we have very strong scientific rigor, so
- 5:23we are peer published in over 75 scientific peer-reviewed journals.
- 5:27And we genuinely believe that AI can make a meaningful difference in the
- 5:32fight towards health equity and have spent the last decade in bringing
- 5:36these solutions to the most remote and difficult to operate regions.
- 5:41On how did we scale and what helped us with the scale, I think the, one
- 5:47of the first parts is really having a clinical solution that works, right?
- 5:50That's a par for the course.
- 5:51Having the clearances, having the clinical evidence.
- 5:54So we are not just a tech company, we are a health tech
- 5:57company, so the onus is higher.
- 5:59But then it's really to demonstrate return on investment, and that I think is
- 6:03something that is super crucial for scale.
- 6:05We've been able to do that very, very successfully in
- 6:08tuberculosis and lung cancer.
- 6:10Happy to share more insights going forward.
- 6:12Maddy: Okay, Divya.
- 6:13Woah, you stuck to the time, so congrats for that, and congrats for a
- 6:17very successful, rapid growth story.
- 6:20You touched on this a little bit, but what do you think was most
- 6:23important in making scaling possible?
- 6:25Aside from having the solution and the funding, what were the other
- 6:28things going on within the business?
- 6:30Was it the talent, the logistics?
- 6:33Divya: See, talent and having a very strong purpose is very, very-- is the
- 6:36starting point because I think if you have great talent, first you recruit great
- 6:41talent, but then keeping them motivated and keeping them really inspired to stay
- 6:46with you for the long haul, and we, I think in Qure, have been able to have
- 6:50employees who've stayed with us right from the beginning, right from inception.
- 6:53That happens when you have a very strong mission as a company.
- 6:58Of course, the culture of how we deliver that solution.
- 7:02From a business point of view, having the goals very clearly set, a very flat
- 7:06hierarch- non-hierarchical organization for ideas to be able to stem up.
- 7:10Technology is changing so rapidly that what worked 10 years ago will
- 7:14not work any more today, so we have to be open to new ideas which very often
- 7:18come from the youngest in the team.
- 7:20So I think that is, that is number one.
- 7:22But externally, as I said, I think there's a very important aspect of not
- 7:27only providing fantastic clinical care and clinical solutions, regulatory
- 7:32solutions, but really ensuring that the financial mechanisms work.
- 7:38If a client, that could be in Africa, that could be in US, is using your
- 7:42solution, assumption is that it works.
- 7:44Assumption is that it helps them detect diseases better.
- 7:47But does that also make financial sense for them?
- 7:50And that is the part that I think we've heavily focused on because that's how
- 7:54we can convince health ministries who are severely, severely stretched for
- 7:58budget and finances to prioritize the use of AI even before AI was cool, right?
- 8:04And this is the part which I think we have to understand that AI is
- 8:08not just a hype for the future.
- 8:11AI is making a difference on
- 8:12the
- 8:12Divya: ground today in Africa, in Southeast Asia, in regions where
- 8:17even internet does not exist.
- 8:19So a lot of the assumptions in our head about what is needed for AI to
- 8:23work on the ground can be challenged.
- 8:25Maddy: Yeah, Divya, I think we'll be touching a lot on those
- 8:28issues throughout this series.
- 8:29I just want to briefly ask you, you mentioned that you have, there are a
- 8:33lot of regulations, you've had to be checked by various different bodies,
- 8:37and I was going to say trust is also very important, not just when it comes
- 8:41to authorities, but also for patients.
- 8:44As healthcare goes more digital, patients want to know, "How is my data
- 8:48being used?" We do know stories about various data leaks around the world
- 8:52which might cause jitters amongst both patients and investors, I suppose.
- 8:55So how have you navigated that, especially working in so many different markets?
- 9:01Divya: So far, we as an organization have mostly been working directly
- 9:05with the healthcare providers, which could be the government,
- 9:08which could be a hospital, right?
- 9:09So both public and private.
- 9:11And even then, there is a documented angle of data security and safety, right?
- 9:17The HIPAA compliance, the GDPR, the necessary audits.
- 9:21We of course do all of that.
- 9:23Even after you do all of that, like you said, Maddy, trust
- 9:26comes down to an individual.
- 9:28An individual, a user, an IT personnel in the, on the site, the patient who
- 9:34is receiving the results, the doctor or the healthcare worker who is working.
- 9:38For them to trust that this is something that is actually benefiting
- 9:43them, that comes with time.
- 9:45That is not going to come only with a piece of paper, right?
- 9:49That comes only when they actually start seeing the benefits.
- 9:52So as a health tech company, we can't just provide a solution which
- 9:55has all the documented clearances and the approvals and the audits.
- 9:59We have to invest time in making sure our interaction is more with
- 10:03the people delivering care than with the patient directly themselves.
- 10:07But if the people who are delivering care, the healthcare workers, the
- 10:10nurses, the doctors, if they are convinced and if they see that this
- 10:13is making an impact, more often they can translate that to the patients.
- 10:17Maddy: Thank you, Divya.
- 10:18We'll come back to you a little bit later, but some really
- 10:20interesting insights there.
- 10:21Yemi: So I think this is a good place to bring you in, Mimi.
- 10:24I think Divya has shared like a multi-layered scale story.
- 10:27It'll be good to get your perspective on what you've heard about their journey.
- 10:32Mimi: Well, I'm really impressed, so well done.
- 10:36And what I think is really important here is what you mentioned,
- 10:39like return on investment.
- 10:42And what I see in a way from many social impact companies, that has
- 10:46maybe been one of the problems, that they haven't been able to fully
- 10:50monetize their ideas and so on.
- 10:52I think it's maybe, as Divya was saying here, like in health tech, and if you
- 10:56have the clinical trials, you have everything working, then it's maybe
- 11:00easier to come in, not as a social impact company, but actually as a
- 11:05health tech and just not even like putting that label on you in some way.
- 11:10And I think maybe also, obviously, we know that AI is the hottest thing
- 11:15going around, and it's actually eating the social impact lunch in some ways.
- 11:19So by being able to actually use it to your advantage to use n- all the
- 11:25new technologies out there is so important to actually make it, right?
- 11:30Yemi: Thanks for that, Mimi.
- 11:31What I'm hearing you say is like it makes sense to have, make a business
- 11:34case, and then the social impact is a nice thing that comes out of it.
- 11:38You've interviewed hundreds, probably thousands of startups for Sifted.
- 11:42What, in your opinion, actually separates the few that scale
- 11:47from the many that don't?
- 11:49Mimi: I think this is really difficult because, I mean, even if we look at
- 11:54the kind of success stories, from a social impact view, if you look
- 11:57at a French company Ÿnsect, the
- 12:03agri-food company that's doing, well, uh, meat-- well, worms.
- 12:08Sorry, I'm really bad at, you know, kind of details.
- 12:11But they scaled so well, and they raised about six hundred million euros and, and
- 12:17then they more or less went insolvent.
- 12:20So I mean, it's so much to do with both, like, being able to first scale
- 12:25up obviously and get all the investors involved, but then also keeping that
- 12:29scale, right, and continuing on that path.
- 12:32And I think sometimes there's also a difficult, difficulties for whatever
- 12:36company you're in, and if you're for social impact company, I mean,
- 12:40we've seen a huge change over the last ten years when grants were both
- 12:45available and fine to take, and now it's more like, well, you have to
- 12:49grow at the same speed as AI startups.
- 12:51And that's obviously really difficult to do if you're trying to solve a
- 12:57real issue with clean water or with fertilizers or something like that.
- 13:02It takes much longer, and it feels like the venture capital side of things are
- 13:07not-- well, th- they can't wait that long because everyone else is running so fast.
- 13:12Yemi: It's an interesting point you've made about how the businesses
- 13:15could scale, but they also have to kind of stay in business as well.
- 13:19And I think perhaps, Helen, it would be good to get your thoughts on this because
- 13:22you bring an interesting perspective, and it might deepen our understanding because
- 13:27you have the funding vantage point.
- 13:29So what difference do you think emerging markets, startups in emerging
- 13:34economies have that maybe founders and funders often underestimate?
- 13:39Helen: First of all, I just wanted to say that if I had one clear
- 13:43answer for that, I don't think that I will be sitting in this room.
- 13:46I would be sitting in boardrooms and probably having a blast
- 13:50solving all of the problems that I'm aiming to, to work with daily.
- 13:54But what I see and what I quite often encounter is that a lot of companies
- 14:02have the solution for a problem.
- 14:04They have invented something or they have created a business model, but there
- 14:09is no ecosystem to plug it in with.
- 14:12So what we are trying to do when we are supporting governments, and we
- 14:16are working with capacity building, especially relating to innovations,
- 14:19is increasing and extending the enabling environment for innovations.
- 14:26And when it comes to the AI and digitalization and frontier tech, it's
- 14:31got a lot to do with connectivity.
- 14:34I am not surprised that this is one of the companies that was based and
- 14:38started working in India, and that is also due to the fact that 5G is in
- 14:43comparison to other countries, cheap.
- 14:45Meaning that you can go out on the countryside working with the parts of
- 14:50the populations that you are wanting to work with and are also aiming
- 14:56to support and do scale testing.
- 14:59Doing that in other countries is currently not possible due to the fact that there
- 15:04is no 5G in those areas, and if 5G is available, it's very, very expensive and
- 15:11there's a tremendous also lack of devices.
- 15:14So I think it's a combination of numerous things that are needed to
- 15:18work forward and that you really have to, both as an entrepreneur and
- 15:23as governmental entities and also innovators, being able to understand
- 15:30which part of the puzzle you are.
- 15:32If you're a blue part of a puzzle, are you the ocean, the sky, a lake,
- 15:38or something completely different?
- 15:40And being able to create that common picture, I would say, is
- 15:44what is needed if you want to scale.
- 15:46And then also convince investors that once you know that you are a part of the
- 15:52ocean, that that part of the ocean is the best part to invest all of the money in.
- 15:57Yemi: I love the analogy of the ocean, and the point you made that I think
- 16:01really resonates is about the ecosystem.
- 16:03And I think maybe if we zoom out a little bit, Mimi, it'd be good to get
- 16:07your sense of what you think is one of the biggest challenge or, you know, the
- 16:12biggest challenges to scaling today.
- 16:13And how do you think that's changed over the years?
- 16:16We know Divya was talking about her journey over 10 years, but also,
- 16:20like, how has social impact tech space matured in the last decade, say?
- 16:25Mimi: Hmm.
- 16:26I think that, I mean, 10 years ago, I don't think it's actually
- 16:31much harder now than it was then.
- 16:34I think it can be easier and harder.
- 16:36I think that the technology that we have available now makes it easier to actually
- 16:41create solutions than it was 10 years ago.
- 16:45Obviously, then we could say, well, the competition is much greater
- 16:48now because now everyone can make these kind of solutions possible.
- 16:51But I think that maybe the biggest one right now why it's difficult to
- 16:55scale for social impact company is that you need really, again, just to
- 17:00show that you both have customers.
- 17:03You have to see that you have money coming in.
- 17:06You cannot just be like, "Well, we'll, we'll sort that later."
- 17:10That doesn't work anymore.
- 17:12you probably could do that 10 years ago.
- 17:14You know, if you look at some of the companies coming out 10 years ago, there
- 17:18was very focused on immigration, for example, and helping people coming to
- 17:24different countries because of the wars.
- 17:28Now, you probably wouldn't see those kind of companies actually
- 17:31getting any money at all.
- 17:32So I think it's really interesting to see that it's a harder environment today,
- 17:38and people don't care as much maybe about impact as they did for 10 years ago.
- 17:43Maddy: Yeah, Mimi, I wanted to ask you about that, actually.
- 17:46You mentioned initiatives to help people fleeing wars, moving to other countries.
- 17:52We've also seen other places deprioritizing cutting fossil
- 17:56fuels, whereas before there was a big green push a few years ago.
- 18:00Diversity projects have also been cut back.
- 18:02So how much do you think these shifting priorities in some
- 18:05countries are starting to slow or impact social impact innovation?
- 18:09Mimi: I think they impact a lot because they, they show to the society that
- 18:14this is not important right now.
- 18:16I mean, even like we often look at USAID, what they do is obviously very important.
- 18:21What's happened in the US with the cutting of USAID has had an impact, but this has
- 18:26also happened in France when they have cut their money going to development.
- 18:31So I do think this actually creates a narrative in society that says that
- 18:37this isn't that important right now.
- 18:39Obviously venture capital is their own little bubble,
- 18:42and it's about making money.
- 18:43But if we don't have the public money helping, then, it's not so much someone
- 18:51who wants to take a risk on, I suppose.
- 18:53Maddy: Hmm.
- 18:54And we don't have politicians representing that side of the view, but their argument
- 18:58would be that, "well, the money needs to be spent within the country. We need
- 19:01to focus on strengthening the economy." There's other things that they want to
- 19:05focus on with taxpayers' money instead.
- 19:08Helen, we've even seen Sweden cutting back on some grants, some overseas aid.
- 19:13What does that mean, do you think, for you, for startups in emerging markets?
- 19:19Helen: I am also not a politician, but we are still working with
- 19:24the steering that we receive.
- 19:26And based on that, there is a push to work more with the private sector.
- 19:32There is a push to engage more actors and to mobilize private capital.
- 19:37And what we are also trying to do is we are trying to push and also work
- 19:43with the different banks, because the traditional due diligence processes are
- 19:47quite unmodern, and it has been way too easy, at least in my opinion, to say 'no'.
- 19:54So I think that there are several things that also we as a sort of governmental
- 19:59actor can do in order to create some noise, and also supporting companies
- 20:07where, that we actually do believe in through the mechanisms that we
- 20:10have, in order to actually showcase that there are good examples out
- 20:16there and that also impact companies and social companies, that they are
- 20:23a really, really good investment.
- 20:25Maddy: And what about focusing specifically on tech
- 20:28innovations used by children?
- 20:31Are there any specific roadblocks or challenges when it comes to funding
- 20:35and scaling tech innovations for them?
- 20:39Helen: I would say that working with innovations, there are always roadblocks.
- 20:43Trying to convince actors to move into areas that are slightly unknown,
- 20:49and also where evidence is lower.
- 20:52or not necessarily evidence is lower, but there are other forms of evidence.
- 20:58And I would say with AI, for example, the judgement of AI is quite often
- 21:05higher than on normal human doctors.
- 21:09That if an AI fails to detect something, then the whole sort of AI
- 21:15process is, to some extent a failure.
- 21:19However, when doctors are following protocols and are still missing
- 21:23things, it is still sort of believed to be within the margins.
- 21:28So I think that we have to increase the pool and sort of increase the
- 21:34box of where we are, um, l- looking into the, the different companies and
- 21:40- Maddy: Mm-hmm…
- 21:40Helen: and the setups for that
- 21:41Maddy: I can see Mimi nodding on our video link.
- 21:44Did you want to add something to the conversation?
- 21:46Mimi: Yeah, I think this is really interesting, and I've been looking a
- 21:49little bit into ed tech as well, and which has been a very difficult place
- 21:54to get into for startups as well and trying to change how education is done.
- 21:58And I remember back in the day, so many, many of you might know Sana AI,
- 22:03which is this AI startup that started, like, quite a few years ago, actually.
- 22:09Eight years ago or so.
- 22:10And they actually started off as trying to change education by actually
- 22:15introducing AI to schools very early on, and trying to help people which had
- 22:20problems in learning in this same way, so they can actually use AI to help them.
- 22:24However, because they couldn't actually get the buy-in from schools or from
- 22:29governments and so on, they did a pivot, and now they obviously, you know, was
- 22:34acquired by Workday for $1billion US , and is nothing to do with edtech anymore.
- 22:40And I feel like that's such a, such a loss in some way.
- 22:43That's, I think so many of these kind of social impact companies realize
- 22:47that it's so difficult to actually both make money and to become, and
- 22:52scale successfully, that they just turned the other way and just become
- 22:57another kind of company instead.
- 22:59Maddy: Mm. We will be looking into edtech, so technological solutions for
- 23:03children and how we get round some of the challenges on that in a later episode.
- 23:08Just briefly, we'll go back to Divya.
- 23:10You've been listening in, and you told us about the success of Qure earlier.
- 23:15But we are wanting to be honest and transparent about the
- 23:18challenges of scaling as well.
- 23:20Can you share any pain points for you as you try and grow even further?
- 23:25Divya: So many!
- 23:26I think there were a few that were touched on.
- 23:31Let's start maybe operationally.
- 23:34We see or we talk a lot about tech and what it can do, but the infrastructure
- 23:38ground realities don't often match, right?
- 23:41Whether it is internet, whether it is even computer literacy.
- 23:46We actually see sometimes in many programs that the most educated healthcare
- 23:52worker ends up being stuck behind a laptop, whereas that person should
- 23:55be actually in front of the patient.
- 23:58And so these are all challenges in our mind which we have to resolve,
- 24:01which we want to use tech to resolve.
- 24:03Internet, power, electricity doesn't work in so many times, so we've had
- 24:07over the years to make sure that our battery lives can sustain a full day.
- 24:12But I think more fundamentally, I think a lot of us or a lot of the people spoke
- 24:17about funding, and that is definitely a very important question about financial
- 24:23pathways for any company to scale.
- 24:25I think most operational topics are solvable if there
- 24:28is an economic backing to it.
- 24:31And in the last year, I think decision delays have been the most
- 24:37troublesome, I think, in terms of scale.
- 24:40We are an optimist in that sense because we see that digital health
- 24:43solutions like ours, amongst others, are actually saving costs for countries.
- 24:49So this is an opportunity for countries to be able to re-evaluate their budgets
- 24:54and rethink how things were done.
- 24:56But change is very hard, right?
- 24:59To stop doing something that you were doing for the last many decades, that is
- 25:03the part which I think is the hardest.
- 25:05Even if you have proven financially that this makes sense, even then,
- 25:10making sure or figuring out the right change agents is the part which is the
- 25:14hardest and the most, I think also then the most beneficial if one is able to
- 25:19get a health minister or a person in the health ministry who can see that,
- 25:23'okay, this is going save me money, I just have to change the way things
- 25:26were done in the last few years'.
- 25:28That has been hard for us, because the gut reaction is to cut everything
- 25:33new or to cut everything innovative.
- 25:36But actually, it's the new and the innovative which can save you money
- 25:39overall, which is the need of the hour.
- 25:41Yemi: So Divya, I'm curious, knowing what you know about launching and
- 25:46scaling, if your company was to start today, what would you do different?
- 25:55It's a head-scratcher.
- 25:57Divya: We, we know that clinical efficacy and publications and scientific
- 26:01evidence is important, but I think the realisation that operational evidence is
- 26:08equally important, it's not secondary.
- 26:10I think we would get to that faster.
- 26:13I think it took us a little bit, a little bit of time to realize that
- 26:18your early adopters get wowed by the clinical publications and the
- 26:24clinical outcomes, but the scale comes when there is financial viability.
- 26:31So if we were starting Qure again, or when we do new launches today, we put
- 26:37building operational evidence at the same priority as building clinical evidence.
- 26:41It is not a nice-to-have, it is a necessary-to-have.
- 26:46Yemi: Absolutely.
- 26:46Interesting.
- 26:47Thanks for that.
- 26:47Maddy: Hmm.
- 26:48Okay, we're going to wrap up this part of the discussion now.
- 26:51Thanks to all of you, though.
- 26:53But the podcast isn't over yet.
- 26:54We've got a few more guests logged on to join the conversation, and then towards
- 26:58the end of the episode, we're going to wrap up with a look at some of the core
- 27:01trends in social impact and frontier tech as we move into 2027 to also help us set
- 27:07the scene for the rest of this podcast series, Frontier Futures for Children.
- 27:11But right now, we're going to take a very quick break.
- 27:14Welcome back to Frontier Futures for Children, a brand-new podcast
- 27:18about advanced social impact innovations that help children
- 27:22and young people around the world.
- 27:23With me, journalist Maddy Savage, and my co-host, Yemi Lufadeju,
- 27:27from UNICEF Office of Innovation.
- 27:29And by the way, if you're listening to this rather than
- 27:32watching, we are available in video format on Spotify and YouTube.
- 27:36Yemi: Absolutely.
- 27:37So before the break, we heard a scaling success story from Divya,
- 27:42the chief business officer for Qure.ai , a company that uses AI and
- 27:47other software to improve healthcare for children and their communities.
- 27:51We also got some insights on overcoming scaling challenges from our guest here
- 27:56in the studio, Helen Samuelsson, from the Swedish International Development
- 28:00Agency, and also from Mimi Billing, tech journalist and Sifted's Europe editor.
- 28:08So now we're going to get the social impact investor perspective
- 28:12with reflections from two more ecosystems: the UK and East Africa.
- 28:17Joining us by video link now, we have Lina Ng'inja, head of
- 28:23partnerships for the nonprofit startup hub Norrsken in Kigali, Rwanda.
- 28:28We also have Paul Miller OBE, founder of Bethnal Green Ventures, a social
- 28:33impact VC fund based in London.
- 28:37It's so good to have you both on.
- 28:38Thanks for joining us.
- 28:39Paul, we'll start with you.
- 28:42Bethnal Green Ventures backs founders working on using frontier tech like AI
- 28:47to solve some of the hardest problems.
- 28:49It'll be great if you can tell us about these solutions and your take on how it
- 28:52takes a company or what it takes for a company to build from scale to impact.
- 28:59Paul: Sure.
- 28:59Well, yeah, thanks for having me on.
- 29:02Absolutely.
- 29:02I mean, we're seeing so many interesting founders at the moment, coming through
- 29:06the door, who've got real deep knowledge of the problems that they're trying to
- 29:10solve, whether that's to do with children or to do with climate change or to do
- 29:14with agriculture, whatever it might be.
- 29:15I think the amount of founders that we see coming from all over
- 29:20the world is just incredible.
- 29:22And that is really what's driving the growth of like the, the social impact
- 29:27tech space, the tech for good space, I think, um, that these founders who,
- 29:31who really understand the problems and they're, they're very hungry to build big
- 29:35businesses as well now, I think in a way that's different maybe from 10 years ago.
- 29:40So the ambition that you see from the best founders is just incredible
- 29:44and, and the knowhow that's around for them to learn from as well.
- 29:48You know, just the experience of the impact investing sector, um, is so much
- 29:53more now than 10 years ago as well.
- 29:55So there's the, the support is there.
- 29:57Actually, I think the finance is there, there's definitely 10 times more money
- 30:00available for, for impact startups than there was a little while ago.
- 30:04So yeah, iit's actually a really good time, I think, to start an impact startup.
- 30:09Yemi: That's interesting, and I think what you said about them understanding
- 30:12the issues because they live in those communities is a good one.
- 30:16So my next question, I think might save a few startups from self-sabotage.
- 30:20So it'll be good to get your perspective on what the typical errors and mis-steps
- 30:24are that you've seen some social impact founders make, the sort of mistakes
- 30:28that stunt their growth and their scale?
- 30:31Paul: Yeah, I mean, there's a few.
- 30:34One is, is to some extent, misunderstanding the problem
- 30:39they're trying to solve.
- 30:39So, you often find founders who maybe have got an idea of the big
- 30:44problem they're trying to solve, but not necessarily the customer
- 30:48problem that they're trying to solve.
- 30:49And in truth, you need both.
- 30:51You need, you need to, like, act like an entrepreneur to solve the problem
- 30:54of your customers, but you need to understand and think like a system.
- 30:58And that's the only way that you're going to scale, because otherwise you're just
- 31:01going to run up against the barriers that the system puts in your way.
- 31:06So I think that's a really important mindset that we look for in founders, is
- 31:10that ability to go up the different levels of the problem that they're trying to
- 31:14solve and understand them all the way up.
- 31:16So that's a really important thing to get your head around.
- 31:19And an obvious part of that is understanding how are you going to make
- 31:22money, you know, who's going to pay for the thing that you're building.
- 31:25Is it the people that it benefits, or is it somebody who benefits from
- 31:28those people And understanding that potential for a business model for
- 31:31what you're trying to do is super, super important, and we really try to
- 31:34get people to do that from day zero.
- 31:36You know, you can't just add it on afterwards.
- 31:40You can change it, but you can't add it on.
- 31:43Maddy: Paul, I've been watching Lina nodding away, so obviously perhaps
- 31:48sharing some of the same challenges.
- 31:49But tell us a bit about what it's like in East Africa at the moment.
- 31:52Norrsken is at the heart of the ecosystem there.
- 31:55Is it getting easier for social impact startups to scale there
- 31:58compared to a few years ago, or not?
- 32:01Lina: What we have observed here at Norrsken is, um, two sides of the coin.
- 32:05So yes, it's getting easier, but also no.
- 32:08So I'll just talk through just some of the points that I think for both of those.
- 32:12So yes, in terms of what we've seen in the last few years.
- 32:15So talent networks have deepened and grown, right?
- 32:18So lots of people are getting the skills in order to support
- 32:22these companies, and in the right way to help them scale, right?
- 32:26So that, that is something that we have seen quite a lot
- 32:30of growth in terms of talent.
- 32:32We've also seen that a lot of African entrepreneurs have
- 32:38done a lot of experiments.
- 32:39So we've done a lot of experiments, we've done a lot of tests, so we know what
- 32:42works, what doesn't work, and this is generally the right trajectory towards
- 32:48growth and scaling of these companies.
- 32:51We also see that African startups have received a lot of funding.
- 32:56So if you look at 2025 alone, over 3 billion US dollars
- 33:01have come onto the continent.
- 33:04And what this means is that, yes, there's definitely some scaling happening, right?
- 33:10And then there are lots of hubs and ecosystems, such as Norrsken that
- 33:14have built communities and support for these entrepreneurs that then
- 33:21helps them in scaling and growing.
- 33:23So this support includes technical assistance.
- 33:26I think, Helen spoke about that earlier.
- 33:29It also includes funding, so whether it's from the VC side or
- 33:32helping channel funding to them.
- 33:35I'll just slightly speak about the no side of it.
- 33:37So some of the key things that we're seeing in the ecosystem
- 33:41that still are challenges are, for example, market structures.
- 33:46So we have fragmented markets, we have issues around some regulations
- 33:50and policies or implementation of policies that would otherwise really
- 33:55benefit the businesses, but it's just not being done very wellacross.
- 34:01We are also seeing debt being quite heavily used, um, in, in, um, yes,
- 34:09I'm going to say East Africa, but Africa generally, which can be quite
- 34:12stringent for early businesses, but even scaling businesses on the continent.
- 34:19But I think if we're thinking about is the scaling wall getting higher?
- 34:24It is slightly getting higher, mainly because of something that you mentioned
- 34:30before, so reduction in Western aid.
- 34:34And that has-- it's kind of tightening the belt in terms of the funding necessary
- 34:40to get these businesses to scale.
- 34:43Maddy: Hmm.
- 34:44So some challenges getting funding, but also some examples of self-reliance
- 34:49and kind of thinking outside the box and finding other ways to do things.
- 34:53What are the investors that you chat to specifically looking for when
- 34:57they try and identify companies that will scale in your region, that will
- 35:01perhaps be able to come to overcome some of those hurdles you mentioned?
- 35:05Lina: Yeah.
- 35:05Um, so when we speak to investors, of course, it depends on the, the
- 35:12business that they're looking into, the sector they're looking into, or
- 35:15the industry they're looking into.
- 35:17So there's not one formula in terms of what exactly the investors are looking
- 35:22to when they want to invest in a company.
- 35:26However, there are some common areas that you definitely see.
- 35:29So number one, traction.
- 35:31So just something that shows that there's evidence that this model works, right?
- 35:36Evidence that your proof of concept works, even if it's a small scale business.
- 35:43Do you have, you know, did you move from 10 to 100 customers
- 35:47within the last three months?
- 35:48So that traction is very important to see.
- 35:51The founding team.
- 35:52So this is also something that is quite key.
- 35:56Lots of investors look at the capability, the skills, the knowledge, and the
- 36:02passion of the founding team, right?
- 36:04So one-man army teams sometimes are not very attractive for investors, whereas
- 36:13you find that we are encouraging the founders to come together with other
- 36:20like-minded entrepreneurs or founders so that there's a strong founding team, which
- 36:24creates a better belief for the investors.
- 36:27They also look at the market size, so is there enough market for
- 36:31the product that is being built?
- 36:36They look at are they able to take this outside the maybe country geography in
- 36:40which the business is currently domiciled, so that's a key one for, for scaling.
- 36:47And finally, I'd say they generally also look at is there a
- 36:52potential exit investment watch?
- 36:55Yeah.
- 36:55So when they're putting in their investment into this business, what
- 37:00does the end look like when they get their return on their investment?
- 37:05Paul: It's very, very similar in the UK.
- 37:08The traction piece is as much about the rate of growth as the absolute
- 37:14amount of revenue that you see in startups or the, or the amount of users.
- 37:19There's no such thing as a typical VC investor these days, I would say.
- 37:22We talk about the startup ecosystem, and that's because there's
- 37:26all kinds of creatures in it.
- 37:27You know, there's flora, fauna, there's big ones, little ones, fast
- 37:32ones, slow ones, and actually for a startup, it's about finding your match.
- 37:36It's about finding the kinds of investors, the kind of supporters
- 37:39that fit what you're trying to do, and, and again, there's just much
- 37:43more diversity in the ecosystem these days than there was 10 years ago.
- 37:47So I think, again, I, I think it's a great time to start.
- 37:50Maddy: Hmm.
- 37:50Thanks very much for joining this part of the conversation, Paul Miller from Bethnal
- 37:54Green Ventures and Lina Ng'inja from the nonprofit startup hub Norrsken in Kigali.
- 37:59Stay with us.
- 38:00We also still have Mimi Billing from the tech news site Sifted with us
- 38:04on video link, and Helen Samuelsson from Sida, the Swedish International
- 38:08Development Agency, with us in the studio.
- 38:11And we just wanted to bring you all back before we wrap up today's episode.
- 38:15We've also got Divya, I think, still hopefully on the line
- 38:17from the Netherlands as well.
- 38:19And we just wanted to ask each of you briefly what you think will
- 38:22be a core trend for social impact or frontier technologies as we
- 38:27move into 2027 to help us set the tone for the rest of the series.
- 38:30Just a couple of sentences from you each.
- 38:32Mimi from Sifted, let's start with you.
- 38:34Mimi: Oh, love to go first.
- 38:37Well, I think, everything like social impact as well as everywhere in any
- 38:42other sector, you need the role models.
- 38:44So you need, we need to see one company really making this work and becoming
- 38:50a big impact, social impact unicorn to get others to follow through.
- 38:54And I think that's also with VCs, with everyone.
- 38:57You know, as long as you have these kind of great, huge companies that
- 39:00show, shows everyone else that it can be done, then others will follow.
- 39:05Maddy: Helen, would you like to go next?
- 39:08Helen: Yeah, sure.
- 39:08No, I think that in general, at this point, I don't know.
- 39:13I don't know that much about the trend, and to some extent, I think that's also
- 39:17the reason why I'm working so much and focusing on innovation, because there
- 39:22are so many things that are going to be working and are going to be the new
- 39:28normal just within a couple of years.
- 39:31I read a study recently saying that most kids who are now in school, the jobs that
- 39:38they will have when they graduate are jobs that we cannot imagine or aren't
- 39:43sort of on the labor market today.
- 39:45So I think there is going to be a lot of changes, and as you mentioned, Mimi, I
- 39:49think that role models and also the people pushing the barriers, those are the ones
- 39:55that I'd like to showcase going forward.
- 39:58Maddy: Thank you.
- 39:59Divya from Qure.
- 40:01Divya: So we have the opportunity to empower healthcare workers with AI and
- 40:06genuinely think about multi-disease pathways rather than siloed disease
- 40:11pathways, as well as to actually decentralize care, to bring the
- 40:15care closer to where the patient is, which will make access faster.
- 40:21This is what I am seeing.
- 40:22This is what I… You know, we are also working on.
- 40:25This can reduce the challenges of access.
- 40:28This can bring down overall healthcare access costs even.
- 40:32Maddy: Thank you.
- 40:33Lina from Norssken?
- 40:36Lina: Yeah, thanks, Maddy.
- 40:37I think for my parting shot, it's building resilient local ecosystems Just
- 40:44the effect of dependency on external ecosystems, sometimes we've seen what
- 40:52that does to the entrepreneurship and social impact-driven businesses.
- 40:57So what that means is getting some more homegrown capital founders and
- 41:02more homegrown solutions, within the ecosystems in which we operate, and
- 41:07this is already starting, and'm very excited to see how it goes into 2027.
- 41:13Maddy: Thanks Lina.
- 41:14And last but not least, Paul from Bethnal Green Ventures, what do
- 41:17you see as the key trends or key things to focus on moving forward?
- 41:22Paul: Well, I think there's one particularly related to tech and children,
- 41:25which is I think we're going to continue to see the trust dropping between big
- 41:29tech and little people, essentially.
- 41:32The idea that we entrust the lives of young kids with these big tech companies
- 41:39who are rapidly becoming the least trusted organizations in the world at
- 41:43the moment, is going to be something that we're all going to have to grapple with.
- 41:46But I do think that leaves an opportunity for, for startups and
- 41:49people who can genuinely build trustworthy tech that, that helps kids
- 41:55achieve in life and take up all the opportunities that are in front of them.
- 42:00Maddy: Thank you so much.
- 42:01I'm afraid that is all we've got time for for this episode.
- 42:05Thank you so much to our big cast of guests for joining us.
- 42:07Right, Yemi?
- 42:08Yemi: Absolutely.
- 42:09You all deserve a huge shout-out and a massive thank you.
- 42:12So many thanks to Lina Ng'inja from Norrsken in Kigali, Helen Samuelsson from
- 42:18the Swedish International Development Agency, Paul Miller from Bethnal Green
- 42:22Ventures, Mimi Billing from Sifted, and of course Divya Gupta from Qure.ai.
- 42:28Maddy: Yeah, and thanks to all our listeners as well
- 42:30to our very first episode.
- 42:32We would love to get your feedback on the series.
- 42:34If you're listening on Apple or Spotify, you can give us a rating, and we also
- 42:38hope that you'll share the podcast, especially on LinkedIn, so that it reaches
- 42:41more people working in the social impact and tech scenes, and you can use the
- 42:45hashtag Frontier Futures for Children.
- 42:48Yemi: And of course, there's more where this came from, so be sure to
- 42:51subscribe and follow UNICEF Office of Innovation on social media platforms
- 42:55for updates and reminders on future episodes and some of the other projects
- 42:59we've got in the pipeline as well.
- 43:01So from me, bye, and thank you.
- 43:04Maddy: Yeah, bye for now.