Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 6 Episode 12: Power and Pulpits: The Truth About How Religious Leaders Groom Adults
Transcript
- 0:16David Mandel: and we're back, we're back.
- 0:17Ruth Reymundo: Hi, hey there, how you doing today maybe I shouldn't ask you today that that's it.
- 0:23Ruth Reymundo: You're here, we're doing this Relevant topic.
- 0:26David Mandel: Relevant topic?
- 0:27Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, exactly, so anyway well, welcome to Partnering with a Survivor.
- 0:31Ruth Reymundo: I'm David.
- 0:34David Mandel: Mandel, the CEO of the Safer Dealer Institute, and I'm Ruth Ramundo-Mandel and I am the co-owner and chief business development officer.
- 0:39David Mandel: And today we're going to be talking with Jamie Simpson and I'm going to read her bio in a second, but we did recently have a podcast collaboration with her.
- 0:53David Mandel: Her podcast is cheekily named, but very seriously named, about church and religious leader sex abuse and abuse of power and religious leader sex abuse and abuse of power don't fuck the flock, which is a very good rule to live by.
- 1:12Ruth Reymundo: So, before we get going, we just want to acknowledge the land that we're on, which is Tungstis Misako land, and those are the traditional owners of the land and, just for me, being here is a real honor.
- 1:29Ruth Reymundo: Any season season of the year, but it's summer, it's warm, uh, the trees are just amazing, the river is amazing, it cools you off and and this is just a just a beautiful and powerful place to to live and to work, and we've got a um, a well on our property that ruth and I sit on and just feel the energy of the land and the property, and it just want to just acknowledge the land itself and then the indigenous people who have been owners of this land for thousands of years.
- 1:59David Mandel: Right, yeah, actually I would like to add to that land acknowledgement, though I'm not in my native land of California or Santa Rosa County to be harmed, murdered, eradicated, terminated, dispossessed of their land by the United States government's active termination behaviors, their violence.
- 2:32David Mandel: So I just want to acknowledge the Pomo and the Pomo people, which is the land where I was born on, and I want to read Jamie Simpson's bio before we get started and officially introduce her.
- 2:44David Mandel: You know I'm really honored Jamie and I have been in connection for a bit now and I've been following her work and her research and it's extraordinarily important and pertinent considering the large scope of religious institution abuse and abuse of power, abuse of children abuse, sexual abuse, financial abuse, exploitation of labor.
- 3:10David Mandel: So Jamie is a qualified counselor, individual and group supervised.
- 3:16David Mandel: She's an intercultural trainer and academic consultant currently based in Sydney, and Jamie's focus is counseling domestic violence victims, survivors and clergy, sexual abuse victim survivors and clients living with spiritual religious trauma, and providing training and support to professionals developing their careers within this industry.
- 3:41David Mandel: Jamie is also a unit coordinator and online learning advisor for the graduate certificate in domestic violence response and Jamie holds a master's of philosophy in criminology, social justice and a graduate certificate in domestic violence, a master's in counseling and a bachelor's degree in counseling and an advanced diploma in counseling, counseling and majoring in child development and parenting.
- 4:06David Mandel: Jamie also has qualifications in advanced practice in male family violence interventions, sexual violence, addiction counseling, suicide prevention, training, religious trauma crisis response counseling and a variety of counseling interventions.
- 4:24David Mandel: Response counseling and a variety of counseling interventions.
- 4:31David Mandel: So, Jamie, you are highly credentialed and you are also out there doing amazing work.
- 4:34David Mandel: Thank you, Welcome, and I don't know if you want to introduce yourself in your own words or do a little land acknowledgement as well.
- 4:41Jaime Simpson: Yeah, thank you so much.
- 4:42Jaime Simpson: So, wow, I want to get to know myself after that introduction.
- 4:46Jaime Simpson: So studying has been actually one of the most important ways I've been able to process my own healing and trauma from clergy sexual abuse.
- 4:56Jaime Simpson: So that's probably why I've got so many qualifications, because I just continued to learn.
- 5:01Jaime Simpson: But I am actually in Australia, like you said, in New South Wales, in Sydney, and it is freezing cold today, so it's our winter time and it is pouring rain, so I don't have the beautiful weather that you have there.
- 5:13Jaime Simpson: But I'm on Darwile land in the Sutherland Shire and, yeah, I just pay my respects to the elders, past and present, and know that this land has never been ceded.
- 5:22Jaime Simpson: So I appreciate the opportunity to be here with you both.
- 5:26Jaime Simpson: You both, as I've said in my own podcast, you're both incredibly inspiring for me and to come onto your podcast is a real honor.
- 5:33Jaime Simpson: So thank you.
- 5:34David Mandel: Well, thanks for joining us, and you know I'm going to start off just you know, very direct, because you address particularly church, and pastor or religious leader led abuse of power, grooming, sexual abuse, and your research uncovers how pastors groom adult congregants.
- 5:58David Mandel: Yeah, so there's a lot of research into child sexual abuse by religious leaders, but there's not a lot of conversation about adult abuse of congregants and emotional manipulation and professional boundary violations.
- 6:14David Mandel: So how does your work challenge the way that society and institutions like churches frame consent when a power imbalance is at play?
- 6:28Jaime Simpson: Yeah, thank you.
- 6:28Jaime Simpson: That is such an important question.
- 6:30Jaime Simpson: But before I begin with that, I just want to acknowledge that, whilst I'll be using gendered language because it reflects the sample in my research, so where male pastors were identified as the person who chose to exploit the female congregant, I do know that male victims of clergy abuse also exist.
- 6:48Jaime Simpson: I just didn't have that sample size.
- 6:51Jaime Simpson: So hopefully in my next research I will be hearing from male survivors.
- 6:55Jaime Simpson: But if there are male survivors listening, please know this doesn't negate your experience in any way.
- 7:02Jaime Simpson: So framing what meaningful consent is versus abuse of power and sexual exploitation is actually centred at the centre of my research work.
- 7:14Jaime Simpson: So in Australia well, probably globally really I think that there's this misconception surrounding consent that as soon as you turn 16 in Australia you are legally able to consent to enter into a sexual relationship, and there's also this myth that sustains the narrative that people above the 18 years old cannot be groomed and that sexual relationships between adults are inherently consensual.
- 7:44Jaime Simpson: So at the heart of my research was exploring sexual exploitation in faith communities of congregants who were 18 at the time the sexual abuse acts were perpetrated.
- 7:55Jaime Simpson: So there's also this societal expectation and myth around sexual violence that it typically implies overt aggression or physical coercion into sexual activity, and because of this, many survivors themselves don't resonate with terms like rape or sexual violence, because it's essential to recognize that grooming processes aren't overtly abusive and violent.
- 8:20Jaime Simpson: So in Australia and I'm sure it's similar where you are too when pastors abuse their position of power to enter into a sexual relationship with a congregant, it's often named an affair or adultery or a moral fall, and it's seen as a moral, but it's not often seen as illegal in an Australian context, so it's often named a co-equal perpetration of sin, and that really overlooks the significance of sexual coercion through influence and authority.
- 8:52David Mandel: Yeah, I think that one of the things that people have a really hard time understanding is that coercion is not always an overt threat of violence or harm.
- 9:04David Mandel: Coercion is also a power dynamic differential, where the implicit understanding is that one person has authority over another person and that they have the ability to impact their lives intimately, whether that be their connection with their community and their family and their religion, or that has to do with their job.
- 9:28David Mandel: And in a lot of these rural areas where church and faith-based organizations are providing school care and hospitals, that that type of grooming and boundary cross is incredibly dangerous and it is systemically dangerous.
- 9:48Ruth Reymundo: So this is making me think about.
- 9:50Ruth Reymundo: You know we and we've talked about this topic already on your podcast, so I'm thinking about it from a different angle this time a little bit going.
- 9:58Ruth Reymundo: Trained as a therapist and I'm licensed, you know that we have ethics and responsibilities, that we're taught that we cannot have romantic or sexual relations with our clients.
- 10:11David Mandel: Yeah, okay, that in theory, but not necessarily but it's formally articulated I mean, I'm not talking about the reality of what happens.
- 10:22Ruth Reymundo: You know, is there a similar injunction explicit in major religious institutions?
- 10:29Ruth Reymundo: You know, and I'm not talking about, you know, catholicism, you know where celibacy is the exit standard publicly.
- 10:37Ruth Reymundo: But but in other, in other church-based institutions, is there an explicit set of rules that says that you are not allowed to have a relationship with your congregants.
- 10:49Jaime Simpson: Yeah, look, you bring up some really great points here.
- 10:52Jaime Simpson: Firstly, the religious space is so unregulated so we don't have external governing boards.
- 10:59Jaime Simpson: Here in Australia anyway there is no external, independent governing board that regulates faith based spaces.
- 11:06Jaime Simpson: So we have in Australia APRA, which regulates psychologists, doctors, health practitioners, chiropractors, gym instructors, social workers, and if they were to engage in a relationship with their client, with their patient, they would be brought up to that governing board or that independent body.
- 11:25Jaime Simpson: They would be sanctioned, they would lose their credentials.
- 11:28Jaime Simpson: They may not ever be allowed to practice again.
- 11:32Jaime Simpson: However, in Australia and I know America is similar they are often governed by their own internal eldership board and they do not see this as abuse.
- 11:42Jaime Simpson: They see it again as a fall from grace.
- 11:45Jaime Simpson: They see it that the pastor engaged in adultery.
- 11:49Jaime Simpson: So even last year we had a headline in Australia where it said the megachurch was rocked by a cheating scandal.
- 11:55Jaime Simpson: Right Pastor in a position of power engaged in sexual acts with a staff member and they called it a cheating scandal.
- 12:02Jaime Simpson: So even in Australia the governing board still calls it improper behavior.
- 12:06Jaime Simpson: So because it's not named abuse, it's not seen as abuse in the wider community, which brings us to that concept of undue influence right.
- 12:19Ruth Reymundo: So if I'm sitting, you know, with a group of church members and not in the specific context of an allegation of sexual abuse by a pastor or minister, and said is there a power difference between a congregant and the person who's up in the pulpit preaching on Sundays or wherever, what would the average congregant say?
- 12:46Ruth Reymundo: What would be the kind of layperson's understanding of that dynamic?
- 12:53Ruth Reymundo: Would they say, yeah, they have more power in this setting.
- 12:55Ruth Reymundo: They have more power than I do, like if you explored that and maybe you did any research, but what would be the statement they'd make?
- 13:03Jaime Simpson: Yeah, that's a really great question because I think that's very specific to each denomination.
- 13:09Jaime Simpson: I think most people would see a reverence and they would see that that person is much closer to God.
- 13:15Jaime Simpson: So they would see that there is a power in balance.
- 13:17Jaime Simpson: They also then see that pastor in one way is infallible, also then see that pastor in one way is infallible, and then they also see that pastor as an equal right.
- 13:30Jaime Simpson: So they've got these two very different equal in terms of that.
- 13:35Jaime Simpson: They're humans and humans sin, so they project that back on the congregation.
- 13:41Jaime Simpson: If that pastor sins, look, he's a man of God's shore and he's a man after God's own heart.
- 13:47Jaime Simpson: Like David was in the Bible.
- 13:48Jaime Simpson: But look, david sinned, david had an affair, david committed adultery.
- 13:55David Mandel: David also murdered somebody.
- 13:56David Mandel: Didn't David send somebody to be killed?
- 14:00Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, Didn't he use his power to murder his love object?
- 14:06Jaime Simpson: Yes, yes, but unfortunately, it's never been preached like that right.
- 14:11Jaime Simpson: So again, the lack of understanding on what constitutes meaningful consent and undue influence is really important concepts when we discuss sexual grooming and exploitation by any professional.
- 14:25Jaime Simpson: So outside the church people will say to me absolutely, that's a power imbalance.
- 14:30Jaime Simpson: What a betrayal of trust.
- 14:32Jaime Simpson: Inside the church.
- 14:34Jaime Simpson: He had a moral fall.
- 14:35Jaime Simpson: He sinned, he's human and he's tempted more because of his position of power, or she's a Jezebel who seduced him into sin.
- 14:48Ruth Reymundo: But the sin, if I'm understanding it, is often framed as a sexual falling.
- 14:54Ruth Reymundo: But the sin isn't the abuse of power.
- 14:59David Mandel: That's right.
- 14:59David Mandel: What's really interesting is, if you look at cases and I would love somebody to do this study, somebody, please do this and that is that when pastors have been caught or religious figures have been caught in financial crimes, they're not often framed as having a moral failing Right.
- 15:22David Mandel: Because they've stolen money from the church and from people who have given that money to the church, they are often charged with a crime.
- 15:32David Mandel: So obviously, religious institutions have a very different measure of what is a sin that is punishable by secular law, and expediently.
- 15:45David Mandel: Apparently, violence towards women and children, sexual abuse of congregants doesn't fall under that, and that's the curious thing.
- 15:53David Mandel: That's the thing that I think we all have to kind of center ourselves around and ask the question why?
- 15:59David Mandel: What is their recruiting practices in the sense of what type of humans are they putting into those positions of power?
- 16:07David Mandel: What is their pattern of an institution around defending violence towards women, children and people who are in their care?
- 16:17David Mandel: And why do we keep giving religious institutions the authority to care for the vulnerable in orphanages, hospitals and foster care when they are not accountable to an outside source?
- 16:30David Mandel: What is going on here?
- 16:32David Mandel: That's always my question.
- 16:33David Mandel: I land on those questions every single time, because if we don't ponder that and we claim to be a organization or a religion, that is truly close to God.
- 16:48David Mandel: We are opening a big, wide doorway for what religious people would call demonic evil to infiltrate churches and to use their resources for their self gain and pleasure.
- 17:04David Mandel: Lurid pleasure, that's just real.
- 17:06David Mandel: I'm very tired of people not recognizing that the church does treat different types of quote unquote sins and breaches of power, abuses of power differently and always.
- 17:20David Mandel: Domestic violence, child abuse, sexual sin falls in the just go to confession and it's a moral failing.
- 17:26David Mandel: But financial robbing of the church is litigated in secular courts and they are punished and those men are removed.
- 17:37David Mandel: So why?
- 17:39Jaime Simpson: yeah, no, it's so true.
- 17:41Jaime Simpson: It's so, so true.
- 17:42Jaime Simpson: And in america, there are 14 states where it is a crime for a pastor to engage in sexual acts with a congregant that they have a pastoral counseling relationship with, no matter of the age.
- 17:56Jaime Simpson: We don't have those same laws here in Australia.
- 18:01Jaime Simpson: Again, I find it just absolutely unbelievable that sexual sin, so to speak, and I would call it sexual exploitation or abuse, they just think the answer is forgiveness.
- 18:17Ruth Reymundo: Right, that's going to solve the behavioral pattern, so I just want to ask about one more thing, about this idea of grooming and influence.
- 18:27Ruth Reymundo: Ask about one more.
- 18:28Ruth Reymundo: Thing about this, um idea of grooming and influence, because I think it's you know, we we see the challenge, I think in lots of cases around course of control and yes people struggling with this in terms of domestic abuse, understanding, and so I think unpacking it can only help.
- 18:39Ruth Reymundo: So use the word infallible.
- 18:41Ruth Reymundo: You know when I ask about a power imbalance, infallible.
- 18:43Ruth Reymundo: Can you talk a little bit about the role of how religion, often in Western world, formulates God as male?
- 18:53Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, and what that means, even though God is unknowable and is beyond our conception, but we figured it out that he's male at the same time.
- 19:04Ruth Reymundo: It's fascinating to me.
- 19:05David Mandel: You know who figured that out.
- 19:06David Mandel: It was some men who figured that out the same time.
- 19:08David Mandel: It's fascinating to me.
- 19:09David Mandel: That's so we figured that out.
- 19:09David Mandel: It was some men figured that out.
- 19:10David Mandel: Well, but it's like I was like okay, I'll buy into the unknowable.
- 19:14Ruth Reymundo: Unknowable, but we can, we can label.
- 19:16Ruth Reymundo: We can label god as being male for some and beyond human conception.
- 19:20Ruth Reymundo: But they're male, but, but, so that?
- 19:22Ruth Reymundo: But that's what people are are inculcated.
- 19:24Jaime Simpson: That's what people are inculcated, that's what people are going to call it when they believe yeah.
- 19:28Ruth Reymundo: So, when the pastor or the religious leader is male, what's your understanding of the influence that may play on this grooming and this power?
- 19:39Ruth Reymundo: And power.
- 19:39Jaime Simpson: Yeah, yeah, Look, it was really interesting in my data because the pastor often acted in a father figure role to a lot of these congregation members, right?
- 19:49Jaime Simpson: So there is such a level of patriarchy within these denominations where women are inferior, right Women are seen as the servant or you are subjected to your male headship, and even in faith-based Christian marriages the head of that household is the male and you must submit at all times.
- 20:18Jaime Simpson: So those messages surrounding submission to male leadership, submission to authority, submission to your church leader, are embedded in the evangelical identity.
- 20:30Jaime Simpson: So it's not uncommon in my research for the respondent to have an incredible amount of cognitive dissonance because they truly believe that that pastor was a representation of god and therefore that pastor would do no harm to them.
- 20:46Jaime Simpson: So anytime that they were spending time with that pastor, they thought it was mentoring, they thought it was spiritual discipleship, they thought it was someone being their father figure because they thought they were infallible.
- 20:59Jaime Simpson: Right, the pastor then would equalize the relationship by starting to disclose things about his life.
- 21:06Jaime Simpson: So, oh, you know I'm really unhappy in my job.
- 21:09Jaime Simpson: All the other ministers you know that I work with, you know they're really, really tough.
- 21:14Jaime Simpson: Or my marriage is on the brink and you know I'm so glad God brought you here to support me.
- 21:21Jaime Simpson: So they then tried to equalize that relationship.
- 21:23Jaime Simpson: So it appears that it's going to be a consensual relationship.
- 21:27Jaime Simpson: But for the congregant who has been taught that this person is the closest person to God, you are to override everything, and women in general, and especially teenage girls in our youth ministries we were told to override every instinct in our body and trust the male leader right.
- 21:47Jaime Simpson: So trust the leaders above.
- 21:49Jaime Simpson: You will do no harm.
- 21:50Jaime Simpson: So that male authority, that male headship, God as a male God, means that you as a female should submit, even if it's against what you feel inside you should be personally doing, because clearly you are in the wrong, because your leader knows best.
- 22:07David Mandel: I kind of want to put a pin in the consent conversation, because it's impossible to have an atmosphere of consent where somebody's already removed your judgment and your ability to make choices and discern for yourself, or to say no or to not be abused physically, because many religious leaders do enforce these things with physical harm to their victims or threats of exposure, threats of disjointing them from their community and from their religious or from saying that they're going to go to hell.
- 22:51David Mandel: And it was interesting because recently david was listening to, uh, an interview of a political candidate in texas texas, yeah, evangelical with you know, right now in the united states evangelicals are
- 23:06David Mandel: pretty religious extremists, um, and very difficult.
- 23:11David Mandel: They're very non-consent based and they're really supporting some horrific behaviors.
- 23:15David Mandel: Um, but this person pointed out that even when in the bible the story of the holy spirit coming to mary, they, the holy Holy Spirit, asked Mary if she consented.
- 23:30David Mandel: Now, of course, huge power dynamic differential, but in the Bible it made sure to make clear that Mary said yes to becoming pregnant with a deity.
- 23:41David Mandel: Now that has been completely stripped out of every single tradition and narrative and that has been taken and that has been erased.
- 23:53David Mandel: And once you start training people that a religious authority figure can do anything they want to you and that god said that they could, you are already abusing somebody absolutely yeah, and I was really clear in my research.
- 24:09Jaime Simpson: It's actually when, looking at the literature surrounding consent, I wanted to highlight that consent isn't just about saying yes, it's about the freedom, as you say, and power to say no without fear, without shame, without spiritual consequence.
- 24:24Jaime Simpson: And let's say, even if the congregation member wanted to engage in the sexual act with the pastor right, when the pastor's breached, broken down every defense in them, made them feel special, made them feel that they're loved, made them feel like this romantic deception that they use or the therapeutic deception.
- 24:41Jaime Simpson: It's that pastor's job at all times to do no harm to that congregation member right in that position of power.
- 24:48Jaime Simpson: But when we look at meaningful consent, it means that a congregation member, a client, a patient can say no without the possibility of harmful consequences to self, to treatment or to the relationship yeah, and I think that that means we have to pay attention to what happens after that interaction happens.
- 25:12Jaime Simpson: Absolutely so, you.
- 25:14Jaime Simpson: It needs to be informed, which means we both agree.
- 25:17Jaime Simpson: Right, it needs to be mutual.
- 25:18Jaime Simpson: We both agree.
- 25:19Jaime Simpson: All possible consequences must be acknowledged.
- 25:24Jaime Simpson: Now, when you look at the injuries that resulted for the congregation members in my research, those consequences certainly were not understood.
- 25:35Jaime Simpson: You know the threats of ostracism from your community, the threats of exposing your secret shame and your secret sins, the threats to your family, the threats of suicide.
- 25:47Jaime Simpson: 33% of pastors threaten suicide.
- 25:49Jaime Simpson: So it's interesting in my research because when we look at grooming, a lot of people just think it's about children that are groomed, right.
- 25:57Jaime Simpson: When it comes to adults being groomed, it actually more likely reflects what happens in domestic violence relationships with adults, more that coercive controlling behaviours.
- 26:08Jaime Simpson: So in my research I was really able to clearly state that the sexual exploitation was a form of gender-based violence as it sits under the umbrella of coercive control.
- 26:19Jaime Simpson: Because the same grooming tactics were employed to break down the congregation member to enter into that sexual act.
- 26:27Jaime Simpson: The same post-abuse maintenance tactics were employed to keep that congregation member silent.
- 26:35David Mandel: I just want to reiterate one thing that you said, because I think it's incredibly important, and I'm going to link it to the perpetrator pattern-based approach, and that is that oftentimes pastors claim that they entered into a consensual relationship yeah, their religious faith in their community.
- 26:55David Mandel: Once you have that pattern established, you absolutely know there was not a consensual relationship.
- 27:12David Mandel: Once the person who engaged in that relationship comes forward and says I was abused, you know you didn't have a consensual relationship and you have to map the pattern.
- 27:24David Mandel: That's right.
- 27:26Ruth Reymundo: And I have to imagine that there's a tremendous amount of gaslighting, which is, if you go public, look what's going to happen to me.
- 27:35David Mandel: Right.
- 27:36Ruth Reymundo: Is that what you mean?
- 27:37Ruth Reymundo: Do you know what's going to happen to me reputationally?
- 27:39Jaime Simpson: You would destroy the church.
- 27:41Jaime Simpson: You're going to destroy the church.
- 27:43Ruth Reymundo: So you know, this grooming conversation, we could talk about it forever Because I think the similarities are.
- 27:49Ruth Reymundo: I mean, people would ask me well, because the word grooming is, you know, didn't used to be used as much as it is now.
- 27:58Ruth Reymundo: It's used in horrible ways, you know, in certain settings, but it used to be used to talk about kids and sexual abuse.
- 28:05Ruth Reymundo: That's where I first heard it and was first exposed to it.
- 28:07Ruth Reymundo: And then people would ask me, when I was doing presentations on domestic abuse, about grooming, or I would talk about grooming in the context of domestic abuse and I think we can look at individual grooming, but in this context and domestic abuse context, cultural grooming, institutional grooming, religious, spiritual yeah, values or kind of perspectives grooming is, you know, and you don't need to go, you know, on the religious side, you, you don't need to go any.
- 28:37Ruth Reymundo: We can't go further back than adam and eve, I guess.
- 28:39Ruth Reymundo: Right, you can't go any further yeah, you can.
- 28:41David Mandel: The sumerian no.
- 28:42David Mandel: But and I'm going back in the bible before you- go back within the context of the story.
- 28:46Ruth Reymundo: right right there's Adam and Eve, there's sort of the creation of the earth and Adam and Eve, I have a long memory, yeah.
- 28:50Ruth Reymundo: But I'm just saying you know that, you know the fall right, you know who's to blame for that right.
- 28:56Ruth Reymundo: So there's, you know sexually abusive, you know relationship and she said relationship, she was sorry, sorry.
- 29:12Ruth Reymundo: Sorry, but situation.
- 29:13Ruth Reymundo: I'm sorry, you know, but she said one of the reasons why she didn't she felt trapped was she had been taught in her home and religious environment.
- 29:25Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, that she was like a dirty piece of gum or something like that if she had premarital sex.
- 29:31Ruth Reymundo: That just the just the you know.
- 29:34Ruth Reymundo: So she was made more vulnerable by her religious teachings right doesn't excuse the abuse that that, that, that that he and those, the other people perpetrated against her, but but she's absolutely clear, for instance, that she was made more vulnerable and more and more isolated and more yeah um, shamed by what she was taught that that's, that's.
- 29:57David Mandel: I think that that that's something that we we we need to put a little bit of a pin in and, as a person who was raised in a catholic institution, sexually child sexually abused.
- 30:06David Mandel: They're groomed there and there were priests and nuns who came to live there and religious leaders that came into contact routinely with that institution and still support it that you know, we were taught in fact, we were taught saints.
- 30:22David Mandel: There's a saint in the Catholic Church, st Maria Goretti.
- 30:24David Mandel: There's a saint in the Catholic Church, st Maria Goretti.
- 30:27David Mandel: Maria Goretti is a saint because she died instead of allowing herself and this is the language of better for you to be murdered and die, and that you have to forgive your rapist.
- 30:53David Mandel: One of the reasons she was made a saint was because, before she died, she said she forgave her rapist.
- 30:58David Mandel: And so the rapist who raped her and murdered her was at the Vatican when the Pope made her a saint and said she was a saint for those reasons that she died instead of being raped and that she forgave her rapist and murderer as she was dying.
- 31:17David Mandel: What is that telling women and girls?
- 31:21David Mandel: What is the point of that?
- 31:23David Mandel: Because there is a point to that.
- 31:24David Mandel: That is systematic institutional grooming.
- 31:30David Mandel: Absolutely the whole congregation is groomed yeah.
- 31:34Jaime Simpson: Yeah, and even boys.
- 31:35Jaime Simpson: So in my data we looked at, I mapped the institutional messages that actually created an environment that was conducive to sexual exploitation, right?
- 31:46Jaime Simpson: So those messages of forgiveness, the messages of the purity culture, david, that you were talking about, where you're a chewed up piece of gum, we were told men you are the accelerator and women you are the brakes.
- 31:59Jaime Simpson: So pastors would say to the congregation member I'm really attracted to you, so it's your job to make sure you hold the boundaries of this relationship.
- 32:09Jaime Simpson: Now that to external people may seem really foreign, but when you've grown up believing you are the brakes to that man's sexual desires, then you are already internalizing those messages.
- 32:25Jaime Simpson: Then you've got the whole honor, culture, loyalty culture, submission, biblical teachers on humility, grace.
- 32:34Jaime Simpson: What does it mean to be a proverbs 31 woman?
- 32:37Jaime Simpson: So there's this woman in the Bible who's a proverbs 31 woman, who you know no one can ever live up to because she's so incredible.
- 32:43Jaime Simpson: But you were taught that this is who you need to be.
- 32:46Jaime Simpson: And then we've got secrecy, we've got nepotism and we've got submission and hierarchy.
- 33:03David Mandel: So all those biblical teachings actually create that environment for abuse to thrive.
- 33:08Jaime Simpson: It absolutely does.
- 33:09Jaime Simpson: It absolutely does.
- 33:11Jaime Simpson: But just to like, like you said, to put the pin in consent, in australia we have this new meaningful consent laws which I think are phenomenal.
- 33:15Jaime Simpson: They're only in queensland, but they say somebody.
- 33:18Jaime Simpson: There is no consent when somebody acts, because the person is overborn by the abuse of a relationship of authority, trust and dependence.
- 33:29David Mandel: Well, one of the things that I'm going to pivot to now is I'm going to pivot to the institutions because there's many individual perpetrators and there's a very clear pattern of humans who desire power and control, who may be mentally ill, violent, criminal, finding solace and benefit in institutions that teach them that, because they're men and because they've gone through certain trainings, that they have an infallible right to the thing that they deem necessary to do in their congregation.
- 34:10David Mandel: And I'm going to make a call to the institutions because what I don't see happening and I would love for people to prove me wrong Somebody, please prove me wrong.
- 34:21David Mandel: Point me to where there are global, interfaith, interreligious conversations happening about how to prevent predators, mentally unstable and criminal humans from uptaking the mantle of your religious authority, your brand, your religious brand, and using it to cover up their crimes, their violence, their sexual violence and their criminality.
- 34:57David Mandel: And I don't see that happening.
- 34:59David Mandel: I do not see that happening.
- 35:01David Mandel: What I see is the same pattern emerging that we see in other contexts, where there's a tremendous fixation on victims yes, where Catholic universities are now studying victims to see where their vulnerabilities are and what trauma have, what trauma responses occur because of the perpetration.
- 35:23David Mandel: But I don't see self-focus, I don't see them looking at the plank in their own eye.
- 35:30David Mandel: I see them engaging in conversations about safeguarding that still is non-transparent and that still is led by people who are internal to those organizations and who do not actually ascribe to what real child abuse and abuse of power is.
- 35:56David Mandel: They disagree with those things.
- 35:58David Mandel: Yeah, there's still widespread conversations in many Christian sects and I'm talking the big three, yeah, all three Abrahamic faiths about child marriage, about women as property, about forced reproduction and in ignoring wholesale of men's violence as a sin.
- 36:25David Mandel: And so we have to start asking, when we hear comprehensive silence and really a lack of interfaith curiosity as to why people are attracting mentally ill, unstable, violent criminal men to their leadership, we have to wonder why there is silence.
- 36:46David Mandel: So, if I'm wrong, if there is some strong interfaith you know self-examination happening, trying to plan to exclude men and boys from seminaries and pastorships and religious authority, who have patterns of violence and sexual violence and who are obviously not stable humans, then what is going on?
- 37:12Jaime Simpson: Yeah, I 100% agree.
- 37:14Jaime Simpson: I'm not hearing it happen in at all.
- 37:16Jaime Simpson: And again it comes back to their theology, the theology of forgiveness.
- 37:20Jaime Simpson: It is such a dangerous theology because you have these perpetrator pastors who find solace in places like churches because they can continue to go on and perpetrate and just ask for forgiveness.
- 37:36Jaime Simpson: So there is no governing structures or accountability structures in place.
- 37:41Jaime Simpson: That is mapping that perpetrator behaviour, because they see everything as isolated incidences.
- 37:48Jaime Simpson: So it's like the domestic violence space again, before coercive control came into Australian context, police would see every act as an individual act of behavior.
- 38:00Jaime Simpson: So if a pastor perpetrates abuse in one church and then gets moved to another, they are not mapping that behavior.
- 38:06Jaime Simpson: They've just gone, oh, another.
- 38:06Jaime Simpson: They are not mapping that behaviour.
- 38:07Jaime Simpson: They've just gone.
- 38:08Jaime Simpson: Oh yeah, they're forgiven for that.
- 38:09Jaime Simpson: We've now moved them on to the next parish.
- 38:11Jaime Simpson: So it comes back.
- 38:14Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, go ahead no finish.
- 38:16Ruth Reymundo: Jamie, I'm sorry.
- 38:17Jaime Simpson: Yeah, no.
- 38:18Jaime Simpson: So I think your mapping of perpetrator behaviours, mapping of institutional behaviours, are key, but also, yeah, looking at from just a basic fundamental human rights and human resources perspective, who's hiring these people into these positions?
- 38:39Ruth Reymundo: I have two questions.
- 38:40Ruth Reymundo: One's going to be about domestic abuse specifically, but one's going to be about patterns.
- 38:43Ruth Reymundo: I'll do the pattern one first.
- 38:44Ruth Reymundo: You know, and one's about you know not.
- 38:49Ruth Reymundo: You know, if we're looking at this through a christian lens and I'm not not being christian, you know myself it what would be if I'm looking at this internally and saying, going off ruth's comment here, um, you know, going out for a conference saying you know, where's the effort to sort of address this, where's the systematized way to screen and consider this a serious problem and look at it.
- 39:12Ruth Reymundo: If I actually was inside a church environment and I wanted to do that?
- 39:17Ruth Reymundo: What would give me religious?
- 39:19Ruth Reymundo: What would I stand on religiously?
- 39:24Ruth Reymundo: Stand on religiously Like what?
- 39:25Ruth Reymundo: Would I be coming to my congregation or the church elders and say we need to address this because it says in the Bible, because our teachings say that.
- 39:40Ruth Reymundo: What would I be leaning on as a message?
- 39:50Jaime Simpson: of accountability and change.
- 39:51Jaime Simpson: I don't know if you've thought about that and you've seen that.
- 39:53Jaime Simpson: Well, if we go back to the Christian faith, you can lean on the life of Jesus.
- 39:57Jaime Simpson: If we just purely looked at Jesus, jesus was against the church.
- 40:03Jaime Simpson: Jesus flipped the tables in the church and said you are making a business out of this church, right?
- 40:12Jaime Simpson: So if you truly were a follower of who they claim Christ to be, he stood up for women, he fought for women, he fought for children, he rebuked the Pharisees and the religious people.
- 40:29Jaime Simpson: But what is really interesting, right?
- 40:33Jaime Simpson: So if we want to shift the focus, say, from the vulnerabilities of survivors to the scale of male pastors committing sexual violence against women and children in these institutions, that shift demands that institutions start examining the systemic enablers, the passive bystanders and the leadership failures that allow those patterns of harm to flourish.
- 40:59Jaime Simpson: So you can bring scripture into it.
- 41:02Jaime Simpson: But if you've got a board of elders who are all financially benefiting from having that pastor in a position of power, because most of them are very charismatic the preacher's circuit it's known as you can earn, you can be $100,000 paid at a conference to speak at.
- 41:23Jaime Simpson: So the financial kickbacks are absolutely extreme, and in America it's even more extreme.
- 41:30Jaime Simpson: You know they've got the private jets and they've got all that.
- 41:32Jaime Simpson: So to shift and to demand institutions to examine themselves in a system where there's significant financial kickbacks, they all promote each other, that true accountability that involves so much discipline, process, independent investigations and clear professional boundaries, like we do experience in other settings.
- 41:56Jaime Simpson: Who's got the moral courage to do it?
- 42:01David Mandel: Yeah, I mean one part of this is that the embedded attitude that a faith-based belief means that you have the inside track on God's authority and God's word.
- 42:16David Mandel: That's right and nobody has authority over you.
- 42:18David Mandel: There's a lot of religions that resent secular government poking their nose into their business and holding them accountable in legal and financial ways, because they really seem to have a vested interest in non-transparency, absolutely In unaccountability.
- 42:43David Mandel: And I would like to just say that, though a lot of evangelical and Protestant groups may train their pastors at a later age, a lot of Catholic groups actually recruit boys as young as 13 into pre-seminary boys and those boys are then taught that they are the religious authority and the Catholic church, which is one of the wealthiest institutions, religious institutions in the world.
- 43:17David Mandel: Land-based wealth then provides those boys with a whole lifestyle and it is their own ability to work.
- 43:27David Mandel: They provide for their housing, they provide for the.
- 43:32David Mandel: You know the volunteers and women that upkeep their houses and cook for them and provide them, you know, all sorts of free services, and they are supported by the church and the donations of the clergy of the parishioners.
- 43:54David Mandel: So there are some systemic and historic practices, yeah, recruitment of young boys, people who are not properly assessed for their mental and behavioral fitness and then ignoring systemic ignoring of patterns of behaviors, of abuse of power, of abuse of sexual power over their clergy.
- 44:26David Mandel: So it's not even as if these organizations have given a thoughtful eye to why it is they're attracting predators.
- 44:38David Mandel: That's right.
- 44:41David Mandel: I agree actively in practices which encourage unstable, immature, sexually stunted and even violent and criminal men, and a great example of this is that recently you've seen a slew of conversions to the Catholic Church.
- 45:02David Mandel: Right, famous people like Russell Brand who, by the way, is now the head of a prayer app.
- 45:06David Mandel: He's on a prayer app.
- 45:06David Mandel: Right, famous people like Russell Brand who, by the way, is now the head of a prayer.
- 45:09David Mandel: He's on a prayer app.
- 45:10David Mandel: Yeah, men who have domestic violence patterns, men who have patterns of sexual assault and rape.
- 45:16Jaime Simpson: Who was baptizing people in white underwear, mind you, and no one seemed to care.
- 45:21Jaime Simpson: Baptizing people whilst he's waiting trial for sexual abuse, that's right.
- 45:25Jaime Simpson: And he's baptizing people whilst he's waiting trial for sexual abuse.
- 45:26Jaime Simpson: And he's baptizing young girls and little girls, that's right.
- 45:31Ruth Reymundo: In a river in white underwear, that's right, so this is really crazy yeah, well, I'm still back at the, the.
- 45:38Ruth Reymundo: What you said about the story about the, the, the, the sainthood and the the guy being there, I mean just that's right, you can't, it just is the pope honored, honored guest so going back to my, you know what I'd asked about or suggested about domestic abuse.
- 45:57Ruth Reymundo: I have a question about your research and you may have found this out or maybe not have been the scope but, of those women who were abused by clergy, how many of them?
- 46:08Ruth Reymundo: Or do you have a sense of how many of them were in homes where they were also being abused by their partner?
- 46:15Jaime Simpson: And that was part of what they were seeking that help for.
- 46:17Jaime Simpson: Yeah, there was actually only two who were married and one was in a domestic violence relationship and had disclosed that to the pastor.
- 46:30Jaime Simpson: More commonly were women who had been sexually abused as children and had disclosed that to their pastor as well, but a high percentage of the respondents grew up in a high-control evangelical faith community.
- 46:51Ruth Reymundo: And if you use the numbers in the recent Australian child maltreatment study, at least 40% grew up in a home of domestic violence and 60% of them grew up at least in homes where some form of child maltreatment happened.
- 47:04Jaime Simpson: Those were the Australian population numbers One in three in the maltreatment study and that was represented in my data as well.
- 47:12David Mandel: Yeah.
- 47:12David Mandel: So I just again want to put a pin in the fact that those pastors are intentionally predating upon people who are already predated upon.
- 47:20David Mandel: So that's a high level of predation and intense.
- 47:24Ruth Reymundo: Well, I think and I think a lot of people listening will, and this is so common they'll want to make this about the survivor's history right.
- 47:33Ruth Reymundo: Yes, versus about the duty of care is even higher.
- 47:37Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, position, spiritual or otherwise, and you know somebody's been traumatized, the responsible and human thing is not to exploit that.
- 47:53Ruth Reymundo: Not to exploit that and in fact sending the message that there's nothing wrong with them and that God loves them and that they're not having to do something for you to somehow prove their worth or value.
- 48:09Ruth Reymundo: So just you know it's.
- 48:12Jaime Simpson: But that vulnerability lens exists in every space the domestic violence space, the sexual abuse space, the AOD space and we really desperately, as professionals, need to move away from that vulnerability lens and we need to stop using vulnerabilities as a weapon for victim blaming.
- 48:36Jaime Simpson: Right, and that's not what you're doing.
- 48:38Jaime Simpson: You guys are amazing at this and I think I've probably learnt more from you about this than any other professionals.
- 48:43Jaime Simpson: Thank you, but too often churches always say well, you know she was lonely, or she was struggling with her mental health, or you know she's a Jezebel who's trying to seduce a pastor into sin.
- 48:55Jaime Simpson: And, as you said, ruth, this actually shifts the attention away from the calculated behaviors of the perpetrator and wrongly implies that the survivor was responsible it also shifts the focus away from the the duty to protect of the institution and I wonder and where and where are I mean?
- 49:17Ruth Reymundo: and where are the, the, the religious leaders who do not exploit their position right?
- 49:25Ruth Reymundo: yeah who look at their congregation with respect and treat those vulnerabilities with the care that they deserve.
- 49:35Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, and, and we're, because, you know, here we are talking about institutions and institutions are made up of people and institutions are, are, you know, are are set up on a series of rules that people create.
- 49:47Ruth Reymundo: Even whatever you believe about, you know religion, that and that you know that it has, it puts a taint on the entire institution, but it's a taint on the entire setup.
- 50:03Ruth Reymundo: It makes us, you know, when a law enforcement officer violates their power and uses it against a civilian, it blows back against you know, entire police forces and we see that shaping the way people see police forces.
- 50:18Ruth Reymundo: For instance, where are the?
- 50:20Ruth Reymundo: Who are the?
- 50:21Ruth Reymundo: if I again this is me kind of saying if I say to you who are the leaders, in Australia who are speaking up particularly male leaders who are speaking up against this behaviour, not focusing on victims, focusing on their colleagues, their peers.
- 50:39David Mandel: And their institutions.
- 50:40Ruth Reymundo: And their institutions.
- 50:40Ruth Reymundo: Who would you name?
- 50:42Ruth Reymundo: Who are the top three people?
- 50:43Jaime Simpson: You know there are some incredible um advocates out there who are males.
- 50:48Jaime Simpson: Um, they get branded, though.
- 50:50Jaime Simpson: They get branded as either being, um, you know, bitter, or, oh, you know, their faith gets branded that they're backslidden or they're deconstructing, or you know they've got an axe against you know, someone famous or something.
- 51:09Jaime Simpson: So there are some and, look, I would say the denomination I'm really respecting here in Australia is the Anglican denomination.
- 51:18Jaime Simpson: They are working really hard in the domestic violence space and the sexual violence space.
- 51:23Jaime Simpson: They do call clergy sexual abuse of an adult congregation member exploitation and abuse where the denomination I predominantly focused on, because my research was limited to evangelical and Pentecostals.
- 51:35Jaime Simpson: They call it improper behaviour.
- 51:37Jaime Simpson: Right, so we do have them, but it's also segregated.
- 51:42Jaime Simpson: So what the Anglicans are doing isn't going to make a difference in what the evangelicals are doing.
- 51:46Jaime Simpson: What the evangelicals are doing aren't going to touch what the Anglicans are doing, isn't going to make a difference in what the evangelicals are doing.
- 51:48Jaime Simpson: What the evangelicals are doing aren't going to touch what the Catholics are doing, because it's all so segregated.
- 51:54Jaime Simpson: And that's why I would love to see that governing body, an external governing body, that can somehow bring it all together and focus in on that targeted predatory behavior that the pastors employ to exploit some of those vulnerabilities.
- 52:13Jaime Simpson: Yeah, but that shift would have so much uproar because of that separation of church and state right.
- 52:21David Mandel: Well, you know, I think that even with that idea of the separation between church and state, that one can have an external interfaith body.
- 52:35David Mandel: Yeah, that is independent.
- 52:37David Mandel: Right that isn't governed by a government, but that, in all reality, what we all have to do is that, if we really truly believe and love our faiths, that we have to focus on ousting, excluding and not including perpetrators.
- 52:58David Mandel: Absolutely, the institutions have to show good faith that they're actually attempting to do that in a transparent way good faith that they're actually attempting to do that in a transparent way Instead of avoiding accountability, hiding money, trying to disprove survivors' claims, constantly to avoid accountability.
- 53:20David Mandel: you know there was large interfaith collaboration globally to address the reduction in faith-based attendance and to address the quote-unquote culture wars.
- 53:33David Mandel: But there has not been wide interfaith collaboration to address the child sexual abuse, the abuse of women, the criminality, the patterns of criminality, the organized criminality, the hiding of money within the churches themselves.
- 53:52Jaime Simpson: Or why are people leaving?
- 53:54Jaime Simpson: They're not even addressing.
- 53:55Jaime Simpson: Why are people actually leaving?
- 53:58Jaime Simpson: Those are some of the reasons why right there.
- 54:00Jaime Simpson: That's right, right there.
- 54:03David Mandel: So, if you really love your faiths I know that this has probably been a difficult episode for you to listen to, but you have a duty to protect the integrity of your faiths and to cease to allow these things to live in them in such an active and persistent way.
- 54:24Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, I think it's so important and I think, jamie, your research is so critical and I'm so glad we can highlight it and we can bring it forward.
- 54:35Ruth Reymundo: And I just think this question about how we challenge and question in some ways, lovingly, sometimes not institutions and say, if you're, if you're not, you're not working.
- 54:47Ruth Reymundo: Think about some of these things, because this is this is what's important, whether it's law enforcement, whether it's ministry.
- 54:54Ruth Reymundo: So I want to move to wrapping up and ask you just you know what your message is for professionals, spanning the gamut of religious leaders to therapists.
- 55:10Ruth Reymundo: You know what do you want them to take away from your research in this podcast?
- 55:16Jaime Simpson: Yeah, sure.
- 55:16Jaime Simpson: Well, I think.
- 55:19Jaime Simpson: Firstly, if we look at how professionals respond to patterns of adult grooming, firstly, churches need to recognize that this is happening, you know, not turn a blind eye to it in any way, and they need to be trained, like you know, joining one of your programs, for example because what you're doing in this space is incredible and the same patterns of behavior, like I said, that exist in the domestic violence space exist in the faith space.
- 55:48Jaime Simpson: So, being able to understand power and undue influence, looking for patterns and not incidences, shifting that focus from vulnerability to, you know, perpetrator behaviour as well, but in terms of, say, counsellors and caseworkers, just don't replicate the same power and abuse dynamics.
- 56:08Jaime Simpson: You know survivors truly need you to bear witness.
- 56:14David Mandel: And what would you say to survivors?
- 56:16David Mandel: I'm sorry, Jamie.
- 56:17Jaime Simpson: No, you're right.
- 56:18Jaime Simpson: Oh, wow, survivors.
- 56:20Jaime Simpson: I'm sorry.
- 56:20Jaime Simpson: It's so awful that you've been exploited and your trust was exploited.
- 56:26Jaime Simpson: You know, I kind of have a bit of a theory and I believe that perpetrator pastors often target those who possess the very qualities they lack themselves.
- 56:36Jaime Simpson: And in my research I found that survivors they weren't naive, they weren't promiscuous, they weren't morally compromised.
- 56:44Jaime Simpson: On the contrary, they were actually women of faith who encompassed a deep integrity, had strong moral compasses and a genuine love for God and their faith in their community.
- 56:59Jaime Simpson: They're intelligent, committed, passionate about Jesus and justice and they never would have pursued a relationship with a pastor and I think that's why they're targeted, that the pastor really wanted to distill those qualities and traits within them.
- 57:15Jaime Simpson: So, for survivors, I want you to know you weren't complicit.
- 57:18Jaime Simpson: You were chosen not because of your weakness, but often because of those beautiful convictions and compassions and clarity of purpose, and what happened to you was not your fault.
- 57:31Jaime Simpson: And those things that were targeted your faith, your loyalty, your goodness they still belong to you.
- 57:41David Mandel: That's very powerful, jamie.
- 57:42David Mandel: Yeah, that's beautiful.
- 57:43David Mandel: Thank you, that'd be great.
- 57:45Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, thank you so much, Jamie, for your research.
- 57:48Ruth Reymundo: Thank you for having us on your podcast.
- 57:49Ruth Reymundo: Thank you for joining us on this podcast, thank you.
- 57:52Ruth Reymundo: We really appreciate it.
- 57:54David Mandel: Keep at it, Keep at it yeah you too, and one of the things that I actually said to my mother today.
- 58:00David Mandel: I said to her because I found out I'm going to need another surgery for my injuries that were caused in a Catholic institution.
- 58:08David Mandel: And I said, mother, why did you think that violence was a way to create faith in other people?
- 58:14David Mandel: And I would like for you to really ponder that, why there are so many people that believe that violence and coercion are a way to create faith.
- 58:25David Mandel: Because a lot of us still peck away at this topic, not because we hate our faiths, but because we actually loved our faith and wanted to stay in connection with it, and somebody robbed that from us.
- 58:43David Mandel: That's right.
- 58:44David Mandel: So please know that our criticisms are an attempt to create a better environment for people of faith to continue to live and be connected to their faiths with integrity and safety.
- 58:59Jaime Simpson: Yeah, absolutely Well, thank you so much, it's wonderful.
- 59:02Ruth Reymundo: Thank you, thanks, jamie, and thank you to our listeners.
- 59:05Ruth Reymundo: You've been listening to Partner with a Survivor.
- 59:07Ruth Reymundo: I'm David Mandel, ceo and founder of the Safety Other Institute.
- 59:10David Mandel: And I am Ruth Ramundo Mandel and I am ready to change some stuff here.
- 59:16Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 59:16Ruth Reymundo: So if you like this podcast, please follow us, please share it with other people, please subscribe on whatever platform you're listening to.
- 59:22Ruth Reymundo: If you want to learn more about us, go to safetyotherinstitutecom or take one of our courses at academysafetyotherinstitutecom and keep getting the message out about all this stuff.
- 59:35Ruth Reymundo: So with that we are out, thank you.