Latest / Arroe Collins: Unplugged & Totally Uncut / Pod Crashing Episode 434 The Peacemaker Podcast From Ryan Krull And Ben Westhoff
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Over ten years, I've been blessed with the opportunity to
- 0:02share conversations with those that have appeared on NBC's The Voice.
- 0:06It's time to showcase them. Put them all in one place.
- 0:10Arrow dot net A r r oe dot net. If
- 0:14you're a fan of NBC's The Voice, or if you're
- 0:17just discovering it, go listen to the roots of where
- 0:20we are today. A r r oe dot net. Enjoy
- 0:24your exploration. Hey, welcome back to the conversation. Let's do
- 0:28some pod crashing. Episode number four thirty four is with
- 0:31Ben Westoff and Ryan Krall from the Peacekeeper podcast. Oh,
- 0:36the two of you guys. What an amazing podcast in
- 0:39the way of understanding. I don't know, there's just a
- 0:43it opened up my heart, my eyes, my emotions because
- 0:46when I heard of the peace Maker and it's one
- 0:49of those where I'm going, well, wait a second, that's
- 0:51what I study. I study peace I study this. But
- 0:53then we see a different side of this story because
- 0:57you guys went in and did the homework.
- 1:01Speaker 2: Yeah, well, thank you for your interest. It's this crazy
- 1:05story of this suicide cluster at a prestigious Missouri college
- 1:11and it takes place at a fraternity called Alpha Kapa Landa,
- 1:16and one school year, one fraternity member after another started
- 1:23killing themselves and they all had connections to the same guy.
- 1:27They were all super close with the same guy called
- 1:31Brandon Grossheim.
- 1:33Speaker 1: So right away, I mean, I'm going to tell you
- 1:35how I felt. And when I was going into each episode,
- 1:37I felt like, is this a cult? Is this guy
- 1:40controlling people's minds? What is going on here? To where
- 1:43it's happening? And so the mystery that you guys put
- 1:47into this, I think it's the glue that keeps us
- 1:49all going to the next episode. I got to hear more,
- 1:51give me more, I gotta have it.
- 1:55Speaker 3: I'm glad you feel that way, because I know we
- 1:56felt that way whenever we were making this thing, just
- 1:59we had we always wanted to talk to that next person,
- 2:02get that next interview, find out that next piece of
- 2:05the puzzle, and what a complicated puzzle it is. And
- 2:10I mean, yeah, it's in some ways you just can't
- 2:12even believe the story, given the fact that you know
- 2:16these were kind of well to do kids, you know,
- 2:19came from good families, right this prestigious university, and you
- 2:22know you're not the first person to draw, you know,
- 2:25the parallel to to a cult here. While obviously the
- 2:29fraternity was not a cult, there is maybe, at least
- 2:32in some people's minds, a similarity where I think it's
- 2:36kind of well known that the cult leaders prey on
- 2:38people's vulnerabilities. Maybe they're their sense of community, that sort
- 2:43of thing, companionship. And the people who think that Brandon
- 2:46Grossheim has some serious explaining to do, they accused him
- 2:49of similar things, kind of seeking out vulnerable people, praying
- 2:53on those vulnerabilities, and you know, sort of turning their
- 2:58close relationship is something pretty twisted.
- 3:01Speaker 1: Well, I had a WTF moment though, when I heard
- 3:04that that, you know, that Jake's girlfriend was now at
- 3:07the side of Brandon. I'm going, what what are you
- 3:10talking about?
- 3:11Speaker 2: This?
- 3:11Speaker 1: This came from out of left field.
- 3:14Speaker 2: Yeah, this guy, Brandon Grossheim, is being sued by some
- 3:18of the parents of the victims for encouraging allegedly their
- 3:23sons to kill themselves. And this is one of the
- 3:26details that they bring up. They said, not only did
- 3:29he date the girlfriend of the second suicide victim, but
- 3:34he dated girlfriends of other suicide victims as well.
- 3:38Speaker 3: You know, it's almost like some guys have a.
- 3:41Speaker 2: Type, you know, some guys like blonde, some guys like
- 3:43Brunette's and this guy seemed to like dating girlfriends of
- 3:47suicide victims.
- 3:49Speaker 1: Mmmmm mmm. One of the things that I that I
- 3:52put in my notes in experiencing the podcast, and it
- 3:55is experiencing it. It's not listening to it, it's physically
- 3:57experiencing it, because that's the kind of emotion that you
- 3:59put in to it. The depth of this story, it's
- 4:02going to put people in a cavern of multiple questions
- 4:05as well as fear you are affecting us on this
- 4:08side of that speaker, I'm so glad to hear.
- 4:13Speaker 3: You say that, because that's definitely something we were shooting for.
- 4:17This is a complicated, sorts of nuanced story, and I
- 4:20know maybe the central question at its core is what
- 4:25is Brandon Grosstheim's palpability here? And for me, with the
- 4:29cavern I kept finding myself in was you know, some
- 4:32days I would think, oh my god, this guy needs
- 4:35to be locked up. Other times I'd be more sympathetic
- 4:39to him and thinking, man, this guy's just profoundly unlucky
- 4:41to keep having people close to him to take their
- 4:43own lives, and some days whenever we were working on
- 4:45this thing, you know, I'd alternate back and forth in
- 4:48the course of one day, in the course of one
- 4:49eight hour workday. So I really hope that people, you know,
- 4:53who are listening to these eight episodes, they'll have their
- 4:56own kind of journeys going back and forth. And we
- 4:59really try to embrace all angles of this thing. If
- 5:02everyone a fair hearing, we're not trying to tell a simple,
- 5:05simple story. We understand this is complicated, and we're trying
- 5:08to just lay it all out, as you know, as
- 5:12an intriguing way as possible.
- 5:14Speaker 1: You said one of my favorite words, complicated. Now I
- 5:17want to see your guys's notes. I want to see
- 5:19what you guys put on paper on that yellow tablet probably,
- 5:22and you were you were trying to build this story,
- 5:24and it was like, okay, are we doing this in
- 5:26chronological order? What are we going to do? How can
- 5:27we put it in here? Because I would love to
- 5:29see how you built this podcast.
- 5:33Speaker 2: Yeah, well, there are there are actually five victims in
- 5:37this story. That's a little bit of a spoiler because
- 5:41the last victim was actually not a traditional suicide. In fact,
- 5:46she pretty much drank herself to dot and the last
- 5:50person she saw before she died, like minutes before she
- 5:54died was you can probably guess right how this guy
- 5:57Brandon gross High And so how did these stories all
- 6:01tie together? That was kind of the central storytelling part
- 6:05of it that we wanted to figure out what was
- 6:07motivating him and how did this all happen.
- 6:11Speaker 1: I'll tell you where I freaked out. He wouldn't touch
- 6:13that second body. It was too stiff. I'm going that's
- 6:15kind of a bullshit answer. What are you talking about here, dude?
- 6:18I mean, what do you mean it was too stiff?
- 6:20I mean, what would you guys have done? Would you've
- 6:21taken the body down?
- 6:25Speaker 3: Yeah? That is such a good question. And so many times,
- 6:28you know, I wondered myself, what would I do in
- 6:31this situation? What would I do in that situation? And
- 6:33I think one of the things that really makes this
- 6:36up an experience, like you said, rather than something you
- 6:39just listened to, is we were very lucky from a
- 6:42reporting perspective in that the we were able to get
- 6:46the audio from the bodycams of the police officers who
- 6:49again and again kept responding to this one fraternity house
- 6:54every time someone took their own life. So we kind
- 6:57of using that audio from bodycams that was in the
- 7:00exact moments after these things happened, plus interviews with people
- 7:05kind of reflecting with a little bit of hindsight, we
- 7:07are really, you know, trying to put people at this
- 7:10fraternity house as these events are unfolding. And yet for
- 7:13me and I hope for listeners, it does spark that
- 7:16question of you know, we're putting you in this position.
- 7:19We're kind of making you feel like you're in this
- 7:20space and time what we do. So that's exactly I'm
- 7:23so glad to hear you say that, because that's exactly
- 7:25what we were hoping listeners and viewers would get out
- 7:28of this.
- 7:29Speaker 1: Well that body cam sound, that to me, added a
- 7:32texture to your podcast which made it unique in its
- 7:34own right. And I'll tell you what, I paid such
- 7:36close attention to it because those microphones will pick up everything.
- 7:40So I was listening to the background, I was listening
- 7:42to the people talking, I was listening the way people
- 7:44were moving. So it really does work in the way
- 7:47of painting that picture for listeners.
- 7:48Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm so glad to hear hear you say that.
- 7:50And yeah, the kind of quirk here. I guess you
- 7:53could say, is I do a lot of reporting just
- 7:56as a kind of day to day basis, and so
- 7:59often and you want to get a hold of records
- 8:02from law enforcement in the courts, but they can't release
- 8:06things like bodycam audio because there's a pending criminal investigation.
- 8:11In this case, the criminal investigation is all wrapped up,
- 8:15and it's really just there's one mother who the mother
- 8:20of one of the sons who took his own life.
- 8:22She's leading this civil action against Brandon and she's a
- 8:26big resource for us. We interview her quite a bit
- 8:30as part of the podcast. And it's because there was
- 8:34no criminal liability anymore. It's just a matter of this
- 8:37guy going to trial on a civil basis. That there
- 8:40was kind of an unusual amount of material that was
- 8:43opened via Missouri's public record laws, and we really, I hope,
- 8:47made the most of it in order to kind of
- 8:49create this unique listening experience.
- 8:51Speaker 1: So what would you have done if you would have
- 8:53been one of the students on the campus And here
- 8:55comes Brandon wearing Jake's clothes. You see how this emotionally
- 8:59gets to me. He's wearing Jake's clothes, dude.
- 9:03Speaker 3: Yeah, I think I would have done what the fraternity
- 9:06ended up doing, which is about halfway through the academic
- 9:10year that this all took place. They basically booted Brandon
- 9:13out of the fraternity and he lived still in Kirksville,
- 9:19near campus, but at an apartment complex. And you know,
- 9:22this is just where it gets hard to believe and
- 9:25just even more tragic. But there were two more deaths,
- 9:28including the one that Ben mentioned about the young woman
- 9:30who basically drank herself to death at that apartment complex
- 9:33where Brandon moves into. So it's just even after the
- 9:37fraternity kind of got rid of this guy, just tragedy
- 9:40and death continued to follow him.
- 9:42Speaker 1: Please do not move. There's more with Ben West and
- 9:45Ryan Kroll coming up next the name of the podcast,
- 9:50The Peacemaker. We are back with Ben West and Ryan
- 9:54Kroll as the journalist as the producer. How did you
- 9:57locate balance in this storyline? Because it can go in
- 10:01any direction, and when you're talking about suicide those of
- 10:04us on this side as well as that campus, that
- 10:06gets inside the head and heart and can actually poison us.
- 10:08But I don't feel that in this podcast.
- 10:12Speaker 3: Oh I'm so glad to hear you say that, So yeah,
- 10:14we're definitely like, you know, we wanted to tell the
- 10:16story from all sides. But then yeah, we're also very
- 10:20cognizant of this phenomenon of suicide clusters, and this is
- 10:24the case where reporting on suicide can actually lead additional
- 10:31people to take their own lives. There can be a
- 10:34contagion effect, So we wanted to be you know, extra
- 10:37responsible and how we were reporting the story, and we
- 10:40include a lot of resources about what to do if
- 10:44you yourself are experiencing suicidal idiation or a loved one is.
- 10:49And because exactly to your point, we didn't want to
- 10:52romanticize glorify suicide in any way, shape or form. So
- 10:57that was kind of a prime directive for us from
- 10:59the yet go was how can we tell this story
- 11:02about suicide cluster and contagion without being a vector for
- 11:07it spread. And we, you know, we didn't just trust
- 11:09ourselves for that. We talked to a lot of suicide
- 11:11prevention experts for in the podcast. They kind of gave
- 11:16us some guidance on how to report this, and I
- 11:18think the podcast is much much better for it.
- 11:22Speaker 1: How did Josh Thomas find it in his heart to
- 11:24trust Brandon because I mean, I mean, if you if
- 11:26you've got a lot of stuff that's going down and
- 11:28and fingers are being pointed somewhere, it's like Josh still
- 11:30hung in there.
- 11:33Speaker 3: Yeah, that is that was a great question. So, yeah,
- 11:35he was the third fraternity member to take his own
- 11:40life and that was in the this that was in
- 11:43the spring, whereas his two fraternity brothers had already taken
- 11:47their own life and the fall, the previous fall. So
- 11:50that that is a great question, and you know, you're
- 11:52sort of wondering, Yeah, with the benefit of hindsight, how
- 11:56could this guy open up and connect with with Brandon
- 11:59and the way that he did. I guess I guess
- 12:00I would just say that you know that that fraternity connection,
- 12:05I mean they call it a brotherhood for a reason, right,
- 12:07Like it's it's a very close connection. It's a close bond.
- 12:12And he would have been someone who knew Brandon before
- 12:15those two guys took their own life, before Brandon kind
- 12:18of got this reputation. So I think it's you know,
- 12:21kind of you can't put yourself in his shoes and
- 12:24see how Jake might have confided in him, and also
- 12:27kind of one of the things that we kept hearing
- 12:29about whenever we were trying to better understand Brandon, people
- 12:33who knew him told us this. They said, you know,
- 12:35be sort of sought out people who were in states
- 12:37of crisis, people who were depressed, who were kind of
- 12:40going through it. You know. So it's seems very very
- 12:43likely that he would have sought out Jake in that
- 12:47exact I'm sorry, Josh, in that exact in that exact instance.
- 12:50Speaker 1: Yeah, but you know, here's here's the thing, dude, is
- 12:52that I I don't. I think it's because I would
- 12:54say that I'm a people watcher or a silent wolf.
- 12:57I can spot somebody who was down in a heart
- 13:00But this podcast is going to change me because I'm
- 13:03not going to go see I'm the solution maker or
- 13:04the peacemaker. But god dang, this guy could spot him
- 13:07in a heartbeat. And it's like, okay, so where are
- 13:10we going with this than mister Brandon.
- 13:14Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, exactly. So he that was the nickname he
- 13:18gave himself, was the Peacemaker, because you know, he's basically,
- 13:24to kind of paraphrase, you know, he's with someone who
- 13:26fancied himself like a you know, a guidance council and
- 13:30amateur psychologist, that kind of thing, and he thought he
- 13:32could bring peace to people who are going through turmoil,
- 13:37and yeah, he really I think, you know, we have
- 13:40a line in the podcast he kind of ran towards
- 13:43other people's affliction the way that some people who fancy
- 13:46themselves heroes might run towards a burning house. Right, he
- 13:50sort of saw there was this problem. And I think
- 13:53people who maybe want to go to him the benefit
- 13:55of the doubt might say that he thought he was
- 13:57the man to solve it, right, he thought he had
- 13:59the answers. But clearly you have to it's pretty plain
- 14:04that was not the case, given the fact that these
- 14:06guys all took their own lives. So we don't know
- 14:08exactly in every instance what he said to these young men,
- 14:11but I mean, holy smokes, like the outcome is just
- 14:14the worst of the worst that they ended up ending
- 14:16at all.
- 14:17Speaker 1: And my heart is still flooded with so many deep
- 14:19questions in the way of wanting to know why isn't
- 14:22Brandon considered to be a serial killer, probably because he
- 14:25didn't do the actual killing? And number two, why is
- 14:27nobody brought up why isn't anybody brought up doctor Kavorkian
- 14:30because he sat with people too, and it's like, because
- 14:33I'm trying to figure out is Brandon a good guy
- 14:35here or a bad guy? And oh my god, am
- 14:37I going to court for saying that?
- 14:40Speaker 3: Sure, sure, I see what you're saying. So, yeah, the
- 14:42Kovorkian angle is interesting one. And he was like kind
- 14:45of a reference point for Ben and I whenever we
- 14:47were really the same. Yeah. Yeah, but I think the
- 14:51key sort of difference here. I don't pretend to be
- 14:53an expert on doctor Kiborkian, but you know, he was.
- 14:57He was working with people who I believe, you know,
- 15:00had terminal illness, who wanted to in their own life,
- 15:03and it was kind of a more uh, you know,
- 15:07measured considered act as strange as that it is to
- 15:10say about suicide. Whereas in the case of these young
- 15:14people at this university, I mean, they were in many
- 15:17cases depressed or had other kind of mental health issues.
- 15:19But you know, those are temporary problems that can be solved.
- 15:23You know, suicide is a permanent act. So it's it's
- 15:26just not the way to go under any circumstances for
- 15:29someone who is, you know, struggling with depression, that sort
- 15:32of thing. Uh So I get the Gavorkian angle for sure,
- 15:37but kind of give you a little bit you look
- 15:39at a little more complicated to use that word. Again,
- 15:42those are those are just these are just totally different circumstances.
- 15:46Speaker 1: So when when you went into this project, did you
- 15:48already know that he stole the money and drugs and
- 15:51and the thing or did that come to you is
- 15:53a oh my god, w TF moment?
- 15:57Speaker 3: That's a great question.
- 15:59Speaker 4: Is this It can beficult to remember which you learned
- 16:02when a lot of the initial facts of this case
- 16:05were in this lawsuit that was filed by the parents
- 16:08of some of the victims the suicide and victims against
- 16:11Brandon gross Teim.
- 16:13Speaker 3: I won't know that. I can't remember exactly if I
- 16:16believe the idea that he took things was something that
- 16:20came from interviews we did with fraternity members. The detail
- 16:25about wearing the clothes of the victims was in that
- 16:29initial lawsuit. But really, I mean, anytime you read a lawsuit,
- 16:33it's just it's usually kind of bare bones information, that
- 16:37sort of thing. There's not a lot of detail. And yeah,
- 16:39we had a lot of you know, holy cat moments
- 16:42whenever we really started talking to the people who were
- 16:45there at the time and were sort of attendant, you know,
- 16:48witnesses as all of this was going down. I think
- 16:52the one thing that really kind of sticks with me
- 16:55was Ben did this great interview with a woman who
- 16:58was at Truman Stand at the time, who knew a
- 16:59lot of these people, knew Brandon, and she said that
- 17:02she heard that Brandon actually texted instructions on how to
- 17:06tie in noose some of these young men. And that
- 17:09is just like a very visceral detail that it just
- 17:13you know, has stuck with me every day ever since
- 17:15I learned about it. And I should say that this
- 17:18is just that's what she says. You know, we don't
- 17:20have that text message, but I mean, but that's something
- 17:23that you know, has really stuck with me.
- 17:25Speaker 1: See, that's the kind of stuff that I will not
- 17:27watch it on YouTube. I don't need to learn how
- 17:29to do anything like that because I and then for
- 17:33him to do that, it's like, dude, you stepped over
- 17:35across that line. Now what's next. It's almost like you
- 17:37gave me an invitation.
- 17:41Speaker 3: Yeah, exactly. And that's that's the polar opposite of what
- 17:43you want to do. Whenever someone is expressing, you know,
- 17:46thoughts of suicide, that sort of thing, you want to,
- 17:49you know, redirect them towards resources. You don't want to
- 17:52be a resource of how to kill yourself. I mean
- 17:54that should go without saying, but clearly you know it
- 17:57does need to be said.
- 17:59Speaker 1: Your journal is just mind blowing to me because you
- 18:02guys understand it. You physically have got to be able
- 18:04to see who your listeners are. And I can feel
- 18:06that you do what is your next project because you
- 18:09can't be stopping at this one. You're too damn good
- 18:11at what you do.
- 18:14Speaker 3: I really appreciate you saying that, And yeah, we are
- 18:16thinking about what we want to do next. One idea
- 18:19that we've been bouncing around is in my and Ben's
- 18:23hometown of Saint Louis, there was this cult that was
- 18:27occupying really high end real estates in the suburbs and
- 18:33they've now been indicted on forced labor conspiracy for forcing
- 18:38people to work ellish hours at a sort of holy
- 18:43hall center, calling up people, getting them to donations to
- 18:47getting them to give donations to a fake church. And
- 18:50it's just a fascinating story for a lot of reasons.
- 18:53One of which is that one of the mansions they
- 18:56occupied was sort of famous locally because it used to
- 19:00belong to the rapper Nelly. So it's a totally different story.
- 19:05But I think to your previous point, it has to
- 19:08do with someone praying on other people's vulnerabilities, other people
- 19:12desire for a sense of community. So yeah, we are
- 19:15looking into that to kind of explore how this cult,
- 19:18which by all accounts lasted for about eighteen years from
- 19:22its inception, how it got so big It generated over
- 19:26fifty million dollars occupied, Like I said, a lot of
- 19:30these this high end real estate in Saint Louis and elsewhere.
- 19:32So we're really kind of curious to, you know, exploring
- 19:35the why and the how of that.
- 19:36Speaker 1: Wow, You've got to come back to this show when
- 19:38that happens, because I want to continue having a conversation
- 19:41with you. Dude.
- 19:43Speaker 3: Hey, Mike, I appreciate it, so appreciate that. And yeah,
- 19:45whenever that thing comes out, you'll be our first stop.
- 19:48Speaker 1: AXL will you be brilliant today? Okay?
- 19:52Speaker 3: Hey, yeah, you did the same. It was great talking
- 19:53to you.
- 19:54Speaker 1: Thank you. God, Damn, that's fucking scary shit, Come on,
- 20:02stop