Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Winning Business Litigation Depositions: Preparation, Testimony, and Strategy
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Lori Kripp -Martin, a certified family law
- 0:06specialist and former vice chair of the BHBA
- 0:09litigation section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:12our speakers today, Michelle Friend and Anders
- 0:15Sleit. Anders Sleit is a principal attorney and
- 0:18practice group leader of the commercial litigation
- 0:21group at Offutt Kerman, with over 10 years of
- 0:24experience representing small businesses, banks,
- 0:27credit unions, property owners, and individuals.
- 0:30litigation matters throughout Virginia and DC.
- 0:34Drawing on his deep familiarity with local courts
- 0:36and judges, he focuses on reaching efficient,
- 0:40fair resolutions and commercial disputes. A Virginia
- 0:43native and real estate enthusiast, Anders also
- 0:46routinely advises clients on real estate matters
- 0:49ranging from by sell lease transactions and title
- 0:54disputes to eminent domain and landlord tenant
- 0:57actions. Michelle B. Friend is a principal attorney
- 1:00with the firm's Los Angeles commercial litigation
- 1:03practice group. With over 20 years of experience
- 1:06in matters involving contracts, fiduciary duties,
- 1:09fraud, real estate, business dissolutions, employment.
- 1:12trade secrets, trademarks, and trusts. Michelle
- 1:15also provides general counseling for mid -sized
- 1:19businesses and religious organizations. She has
- 1:22resolved numerous breach of contract actions,
- 1:25employment disputes, and commercial real estate
- 1:27issues. Before practicing law, Michelle was a
- 1:30certified public accountant at a national commercial
- 1:33real estate management company. And now let's
- 1:36get started. Thanks so much, Lori. Pleasure to
- 1:40see everybody. Well, not see, but be with you
- 1:42all today. Thank you very much. I'm a big fan
- 1:46of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. So grateful
- 1:48to be here today. Thank you so much for having
- 1:54us. I'm Anders Slate. It's nice to be here with
- 1:56my partner, Michelle, and nice to speak to you
- 1:59all. We're looking forward to speaking with you
- 2:01all about business depositions, particularly
- 2:05in the litigation context, strategy pointers.
- 2:08We're kind of going to give you an overview of
- 2:11how you want to approach that deposition, whether
- 2:13you're taking it or you're defending it on behalf
- 2:16of your client. So looking forward to your comments
- 2:19and questions. If you have those as we go along,
- 2:22we're happy to field those questions or comments
- 2:25whenever they arise. Don't feel bashful or shy
- 2:28about interposing those and we'll address them
- 2:30as they go along. Next slide, please. No. So
- 2:43just a little bit. Previously, I was just our
- 2:47backgrounds and just you heard our backgrounds,
- 2:49but I'm a litigator practicing in Virginia and
- 2:52D .C. I've been doing it for at this point 13
- 2:55years. So a lot of focus, my focus on business
- 2:57and real estate. I'll let Michelle just briefly
- 3:00touch on her bio. And here's our contact information
- 3:03to the extent you want to get a hold of us. Yes.
- 3:06Thanks, Anders. I am Michelle Friend. I am actually
- 3:11a former president of the barristers of the Beverly
- 3:13Hills bar back in, I was trying to remember,
- 3:15I think it's 2003. I've been living, meeting
- 3:18in Los Angeles for almost 27 years now. So, and
- 3:24I am the, it's called the Leadership Council.
- 3:27So I'm one of the leads of the Los Angeles office
- 3:29of our law firm, which is an AMLA 200 firm based
- 3:34in Maryland. So thank you. Looking forward to.
- 3:38presenting with you, Anders, let's get started.
- 3:43All right, so any litigator, any trial attorney
- 3:45knows the impact and the importance of depositions,
- 3:49right? But sometimes, you know, clients too often
- 3:53either overlook them or under prepare for depositions,
- 3:56right? Even maybe in spite of your stage counselor
- 4:00or trying to schedule time to meet and prepare
- 4:03for them. So that's always the tricky part, particularly
- 4:06in a business litigation matter. We've got a
- 4:08client, it's busy running their business, dealing
- 4:11with operational problems, right? Maybe having
- 4:13limited time. to set aside to prepare for it,
- 4:17but it's absolutely critical and something that
- 4:20we highly encourage you to focus on when you're
- 4:23preparing for a deposition or to defend a deposition
- 4:26or to take a deposition, right? Treat it like
- 4:29it's, you know, you're getting ready for trial.
- 4:32Don't undersell it, don't under prepare because
- 4:36too often these days cases are resolved short
- 4:38of trial, short of, you know, some type of, you
- 4:43know, court outcome. And the deposition can be
- 4:46really the only opportunity maybe for your client
- 4:49to be heard, to tell their story, right? That's
- 4:51an important aspect to any case is the storytelling
- 4:55aspects. And sometimes that may only come out
- 4:57in deposition, particularly if the matter is
- 5:00resolved before trial. So we want to give you
- 5:02that overview. Of course, you see the code citations
- 5:05here as far as how deposition testimony may be
- 5:09used at trial. right and consistent statements
- 5:12for impeachment purposes or party admissions
- 5:16right all of that is is fair game but you know
- 5:19I really want to stress the importance of preparation
- 5:22and really using this as an opportunity to frame
- 5:26your case of course to obtain an additional discovery
- 5:29that may help your case and critically if you're
- 5:32defending it to prepare your client for or the
- 5:35witness for what to expect during the deposition.
- 5:40We're going to approach this from both sides
- 5:43because business cases are one area of the law
- 5:46where we tend to represent both plaintiffs and
- 5:49defendants because it just depends on what the
- 5:53issue is. If it's a breach of contract case,
- 5:55that could be either side. More employment -related
- 5:58disputes, you might be more on the defense side.
- 6:00We're going to approach it from both directions
- 6:03and give you a broad overview and some more specific
- 6:06examples of both business cases as well. Next
- 6:09slide. Okay, so just a couple of basics here
- 6:16as far as effective deposition testimony. Of
- 6:19course, number one aspect, and the first thing
- 6:22to tell your client or witness that you're preparing
- 6:24for deposition, testimony has to be truthful,
- 6:27right? It's given under oath, under the code
- 6:29section cited right there. Too often that's easily
- 6:34overlooked, but that should be the first and
- 6:35the last thing that you tell the witness that
- 6:39you're preparing for the deposition, right? Tell
- 6:41the truth. Right. And then when you wrap up the
- 6:44prep session, remind them of that, because any
- 6:47inaccurate testimony, whether intentional or
- 6:49careless, can cause problems. Right. Particularly
- 6:53if it comes out later in the case. And I would
- 6:55also point out that under the rules of professional
- 6:59conduct, I believe it's rule 3 .3, you know,
- 7:02as an attorney, you have an obligation to correct
- 7:05any sort of factual inaccuracies that you're
- 7:10aware of. Right. witness, it testifies to something
- 7:14on the road that you know is untrue. You have
- 7:16a duty to come forward and correct that as an
- 7:19attorney. So truthfulness, number one, right?
- 7:23And I would just, if I could add to that, one
- 7:26thing that I'll find a lot of times with business
- 7:29owners or anyone really preparing for these depositions
- 7:32is they want to, they may not want to tell you
- 7:36everything. And so it's really important to implore
- 7:42them to be fully honest with you in their preparation
- 7:45of the deposition because you can help them.
- 7:49For number one, there might be documentation
- 7:51or other things out there that they don't know
- 7:54is coming and if you don't know it's coming,
- 7:56you can't properly prepare them and can't properly
- 7:58defend them in the case. Secondly, you can prepare
- 8:02them for the difficult questions that might arise.
- 8:06so that they're not put into a position of having
- 8:09to feel like they're going to lie about something.
- 8:12You want them to maintain truthfulness and you
- 8:14can practice. If you know your weak areas, that's
- 8:17the best way that you can help defend a person
- 8:21in a deposition, knowing their weaknesses and
- 8:23prepare them really well for those questions
- 8:27that may arise. So it's very important to tell
- 8:30them, hey, look, this is between you and I, remind
- 8:32them of the attorney -client privilege, and I'm
- 8:34here to help you get through this in the best
- 8:37way that we can. Next point. Absolutely, yeah.
- 8:42Couldn't agree more. Sorry, I said next point,
- 8:45and you went next slide. I apologize if you could
- 8:47go back. Thank you. Just quickly here on this
- 8:52slide, listening, right? Too often in depositions,
- 8:55witnesses will jump ahead, right? They'll start
- 8:58answering question before the attorney has finished
- 9:01answering it. So teach your clients, just stop,
- 9:04pause, right? Or if you're preparing a witness
- 9:06for a deposition, teach them to pause before
- 9:10beginning an answer. Let the attorney examining
- 9:14finish their question and then the witness should
- 9:18go ahead and start. answering it. Number one,
- 9:21it gives the witness time to prepare and to consider
- 9:24their answer. The transcript is not going to
- 9:26reflect any type of pause, you know, two or,
- 9:29you know, five seconds before starting the answer.
- 9:33It is just going to show the question and the
- 9:34answers. So witness can take their time in listening
- 9:37to the full question. being prepared to answer
- 9:40it. It also allows time for objections to be
- 9:42interposed if needed. And if you're examining,
- 9:47be flexible in your approach. Don't stick to
- 9:49your script. You should have a list of topics
- 9:53that you want to go over with the witness in
- 9:57your deposition. That should be prepared in advance.
- 9:59But you should be flexible if the witness gives
- 10:01you an answer and gives you some additional information
- 10:04that you weren't expecting. Feel free to explore
- 10:07that. You don't need to stick to one, two, three
- 10:10with scripted questions. That's a little bit
- 10:12of an inflexible approach and might distract
- 10:17from opportunities to learn more during the deposition,
- 10:20which is its principal purpose. Finally, just
- 10:24teach your witness to be concise in their answers.
- 10:28The worst thing that can be done is to answer
- 10:29the question and then go on by providing a lot
- 10:32more detail, a lot more context, and it's very
- 10:35natural for a witness to want to do that, particularly
- 10:38if they're an adverse party to the examining
- 10:40attorney. But then that just gives additional
- 10:44opportunities to the witness or to the examining
- 10:47attorney to explore more areas because they've
- 10:49kind of opened the door. So the best thing to
- 10:52do is to teach the client or the witness to just
- 10:55answer the direct question and nothing more and
- 10:59be concise. Yeah, I think that's a really important
- 11:02point because your goal I always remind my witnesses
- 11:05especially Folks in leadership roles who are
- 11:09who are used to wanting to make sure their team
- 11:12understands what they're conveying and you just
- 11:15really the point in here is not for the Questioning
- 11:20attorney necessarily to understand it's to give
- 11:23the answer just to the question So you don't
- 11:25ever want to elaborate if you don't Even when
- 11:30they really want to, it's best to not elaborate
- 11:34in any context, which is very unnatural and normal
- 11:38conversation. So it's really important to practice,
- 11:41really practice back and forth questioning on
- 11:43things. Next slide, please. Okay, of course.
- 11:53Here are all the requirements and the statutory
- 11:56citations when you're getting ready to notice
- 11:58your deposition. We're not going to go into these
- 12:00in great detail, but of course, when you've got
- 12:04your date and your time set up, you've confirmed
- 12:07that with opposing counsel or the opposing party,
- 12:10whatever the case may be. You need to set out
- 12:13the date, time, location, whoever the name of
- 12:15the witness that's being deposed, how you're
- 12:18going to record it. All of those particulars
- 12:20are important. want the witness to bring any
- 12:23documents, you know, with them to the deposition,
- 12:27make sure that you specify that and any categories
- 12:30of records or documents that you're looking for,
- 12:34right? Yeah, go ahead, Michelle. I was just going
- 12:37to say something unique to California for those
- 12:40litigating in California required when seeking
- 12:43Personal records, there's a section. It's listed
- 12:46here in 1985 .3 for consumer records and 1985
- 12:50.6 for employment records. It's really important
- 12:53to send out those notices to consumer to give
- 12:55them an opportunity to object to the deposition
- 12:58or to the documents that may be produced. So
- 13:06when you're looking at this, hone in very specifically
- 13:10on what the definition of consumer is because
- 13:15sometimes people tend to think it's more expansive
- 13:18than it is. So I'll read it to you. Consumer
- 13:20means any individual partnership of five or fewer
- 13:24persons. So just five or fewer persons association
- 13:28or trust, which has transacted business with
- 13:31or has used the services of the witness for whom
- 13:33the witness has acted as an agent or fiduciary.
- 13:37So You know, this may come up in like bank subpoenas
- 13:40and other things. And it talks about the personal
- 13:43records are listed very specifically as well
- 13:46in 1985 .31. And it's very specific as to what
- 13:50kind of witness these types of notices are required
- 13:54for. Physician, dentist, ophthalmologist, optometrist.
- 13:58You know, it goes on medical center, state or
- 14:01national bank, state or federal association,
- 14:04credit union, trust company, things like that.
- 14:07But sometimes you'll be subpoenaing a party who
- 14:10maybe that you're subpoenaing a bank, and so
- 14:12it falls under that definition of personal records
- 14:15in section one, 1985 .3A1. However, it's not
- 14:20a consumer under the definition of 1985 .3A2.
- 14:24So just really pay attention to both as to whether
- 14:27this is required. And then specifically with
- 14:30employment records, people have a right to know
- 14:33whether you're in... whether you are subpoenaing
- 14:36records from their employer, current or former.
- 14:39So follow very carefully the procedures in 1985
- 14:43.6 if you're ever looking for employment records
- 14:47of someone. Okay. Next slide, please. So oftentimes
- 14:56in business litigation matters, you're going
- 14:58to need to depose a non -party witness or subpoena
- 15:01them for records that may be relevant to your
- 15:05case. It could be a financial institution, a
- 15:07bank, as Michelle was just referencing. It could
- 15:09be a competitor or vendor of the opposing party,
- 15:14right? It's a very common... witness that you
- 15:18may need to depose in the course of your litigation
- 15:21matter, right? So there are specific statutory
- 15:24rules required for non -party witnesses. Of course,
- 15:27you need to subpoena them, of course. They're
- 15:28not a party to the case. If you want to get discovery
- 15:32from them, whether it's documents, records, or
- 15:34take their deposition, of course, you need to
- 15:36issue subpoena and have that duly served upon
- 15:39the non -party. Be prepared for pushback or objections
- 15:44from the non -party. It happens all the time.
- 15:47And part of my practice involves representing
- 15:50non -parties when they receive subpoenas in the
- 15:54course of their regular day -to -day operations,
- 15:56right? Nobody wants to respond to a subpoena
- 15:59for a case that they don't have anything to do
- 16:01with. So it's always a common area for arguments
- 16:06and objections. you know generally the the expectation
- 16:10is to reduce the burden on the non -party right
- 16:13focus on only what matters for that particular
- 16:16case or litigation as it pertains to the non
- 16:20-party right so that's why there's generally
- 16:22speaking geographic limitations on you know um
- 16:26how far that non -party witness may be required
- 16:28to travel for the for the deposition but I always
- 16:31want to keep in mind, you know, reducing that
- 16:33burden on the third party. Number one, it's just
- 16:35good practice. Number two, it helps to avoid
- 16:38any unnecessary disputes over subpoenas to non
- 16:41-parties. And number three, hopefully it will
- 16:44help you get the information and the documents
- 16:47that you may need for your matter. So it's my
- 16:50suggestion when you're dealing with a non -party
- 16:52witness. Michelle, anything to add? Yeah. Yeah,
- 16:54I was just going to add, occasionally you'll
- 16:57come across the witness who voluntarily wants
- 16:59to support your case in any way. And regardless,
- 17:04even if they say they're going to show up for
- 17:06trial or show up for a deposition, still issue
- 17:09the subpoena because there's no requirement for
- 17:12them to come unless they have that subpoena in
- 17:15hand. So regardless of how cooperative they are,
- 17:20it's your, you know, your client's best friend,
- 17:23whatever it is, it doesn't matter. Always, always,
- 17:26always issue that subpoena to them. And, you
- 17:32know, sometimes this comes up in non -party subpoena
- 17:35issues arise in arbitration as well. I've seen
- 17:38that number of times where folks are trying to
- 17:41get orange courts where you're issuing subpoenas
- 17:45to out -of -state witnesses or, you know, beyond
- 17:48the 75 miles and the witness doesn't realize
- 17:51those limitations and so they show up anyway
- 17:53or they think they have to travel, you know,
- 17:56from Michigan or whatever, even though it wasn't
- 17:59served and there might not be jurisdictional
- 18:02things. So if you're on the side of wanting the
- 18:05witness there, you can go for it and see if they
- 18:08object and if they don't want to come. If you're
- 18:12on the side of, gosh, I really don't want that
- 18:14witness appearing in this trial, then you might
- 18:16want to call up that witness and say, hey, you
- 18:18don't really have to come up even though they
- 18:20issued a subpoena because of whatever reason,
- 18:23limitations there are. You can play that whatever
- 18:29card, however it best suits your case and your
- 18:32client. But in arbitrations, I've actually seen
- 18:34it go a number of different ways because the
- 18:38rules are a little different in arbitration.
- 18:40And in some cases, there's been law that says
- 18:43an arbitrator does not have the power to require
- 18:47out of state. witnesses to appear in an arbitration,
- 18:51but I've had arbitrators do it. So, you know,
- 18:54it's sort of you don't know exactly what you're
- 18:57going to get. So it's things to consider. So
- 19:01you may get the the testimony or the documents
- 19:04that you want and you may not. You might have
- 19:05to fight for it. Next slide, please. OK, so employee
- 19:12depositions, if you're representing. a plaintiff
- 19:17against an employer. And you're really thinking
- 19:22about what depositions you want to take. There
- 19:25may be witnesses that you have that are former
- 19:29employees. There may be current employees. And
- 19:31there are sometimes you really want the high
- 19:33level executive to be the witness in the case.
- 19:37Sometimes, and I'll go over this in a later slide.
- 19:40but sometimes you're just looking for the person
- 19:42most qualified at the entity. So what you need
- 19:45to do is really think through who it is that
- 19:48you want to testify and what order you want to
- 19:53take those, the testimony of those witnesses.
- 19:56So for example, you may really want to, maybe
- 19:59you at some point in your case, you want to take
- 20:02the high level executives deposition, but maybe
- 20:05you want to take the former employees deposition
- 20:08first. to see what they're going to say because
- 20:10they're not beholden to that high level executive
- 20:13anymore. You may want to take a current employee's
- 20:17deposition before the former employee's deposition.
- 20:20Just thinking through the issues as to why, what
- 20:23might be beneficial is really important when
- 20:26you're planning your case as to what depositions
- 20:29you want to take of the other side. Sometimes,
- 20:33depending on the size of the company, it can
- 20:35be quite difficult to get the deposition of a
- 20:39high level executive. There will be cases, you
- 20:42know, say I've got a regular just breach of contract
- 20:46case against whatever, Amazon. And I say, I'm
- 20:53gonna really get them and I'm gonna take the
- 20:55president of Amazon over this case, you know,
- 20:57and they're gonna fight you on it and you may
- 20:59not get it because you have to show there's some
- 21:01sense of necessity. to take that because of the
- 21:05level of the executive in the case. The people
- 21:08from Amazon are going to fight you on that. So
- 21:11consider the necessity and the availability of
- 21:13the person. Oftentimes you can actually, of course,
- 21:18get those depositions, but just think that through
- 21:21because they will be definitely fighting you
- 21:25on that. When you're taking the deposition of
- 21:27current employees, consider their role in the
- 21:30entity and the supervisors that they have because
- 21:34they work for the company still. Their testimony
- 21:38will be of a certain flavor depending on who
- 21:41their boss is. Sometimes their boss may be sitting
- 21:44in the room with them. They may be required to
- 21:49follow a certain line of company lines so to
- 21:53speak and so they may not be as comfortable with
- 21:57you and as honest with you in their preparation
- 22:00or in their in their depositions when they're
- 22:04taking the cake when you're taking their deposition
- 22:06so just think of that and really explore those
- 22:09roles who is your supervisor how long have they
- 22:12been your supervisor you know if you're the plaintiff
- 22:14taking those plaintiffs counsel taking those
- 22:17cases think about that and how they may be affecting
- 22:23that current employee's testimony. Former employees,
- 22:27if you're the one taking the deposition, consider
- 22:30if, first of all, you're gonna, you may need
- 22:33to, you probably will need to subpoena them.
- 22:36Sometimes, and we'll get to the defense in a
- 22:40second, but sometimes the lawyers that are defending
- 22:44the company will also defend the. former employees,
- 22:46and sometimes they won't. So you'll just have
- 22:50to see how that's going to play out. If you're
- 22:52the one taking the deposition, consider what
- 22:55questions you want to ask them that they will
- 22:58now feel free to answer. And sometimes you'll
- 23:03be really lucky, and there'll be someone who
- 23:05will want to say all kinds of stuff about their
- 23:07former employer. And sometimes you will be in
- 23:11a position where they really want to keep their
- 23:14reputation and keep their relationship good with
- 23:17their former employer so they're very guarded.
- 23:20So in those cases, you really want to, first
- 23:23of all, test the waters to see where they stand
- 23:25as the one taking the deposition. And then also,
- 23:30how long they've been gone, what relationships
- 23:32they still have with the company, really explore
- 23:35all that stuff, and then get into it. what they
- 23:39do and what they did at the company and the issues
- 23:42in your case. It may be that you take the deposition
- 23:48testimony and then I've had this happen before,
- 23:51you get later closer to trial and all of a sudden
- 23:54they were more willing to tow the company line
- 23:57at the beginning of the case. and then you get
- 24:00closer to the trial and they're not so happy
- 24:02with the former employer anymore and they want
- 24:05to say all kinds of other things. And so it's
- 24:07kind of good to touch base with those folks if
- 24:10you're the ones taking the deposition. represented
- 24:16by counsel or not, that'll just depend on how
- 24:19you handle that. But they may change the story,
- 24:21just keep that in mind. So be very prepared when
- 24:23you're going to trial with respect to former
- 24:26employees that you have really good handle on
- 24:32their deposition testimony so that you are really
- 24:34prepared to impeach them and get them to say
- 24:37other things that you need them to say. Now switching
- 24:40to the defense, when you're representing a high
- 24:43level executive, Like I said earlier, you may
- 24:47want to file some motions and other things to
- 24:52try to stop the deposition from moving forward
- 24:55based upon that person's availability and so
- 24:58forth. You may just say they're not available
- 25:01and then let the other person move to compel
- 25:03and then you can work it out that way. It may
- 25:06be that they have to come testify, which many
- 25:09times they will, but When you're preparing a
- 25:12high level executive, this is really critical.
- 25:16They are often so, first of all, busy and don't
- 25:19really have time and don't want to deal with
- 25:21it. You got to make sure they make the time to
- 25:23prepare for their deposition. And secondly, something
- 25:26that's really important is to do role play with
- 25:30them in the deposition because they are so, I've
- 25:33seen it time and time again, where a high level
- 25:35executive, they're so comfortable in many circumstances
- 25:39in the boardroom and operations and everything
- 25:42else, but boy, put them in that witness chair
- 25:44and all of a sudden they're sweating. So you
- 25:46just really want to make sure that you I highly
- 25:49encourage doing videotape prep with the high
- 25:54level executive in particular so that they can
- 25:57see what they look like on camera. Really prepare
- 25:59them well, because there's there's. High likelihood
- 26:04that that deposition will be recorded, video
- 26:06recorded. You want them to see what they're going
- 26:09to look like. They are the face of the company.
- 26:11And it's critically important that you prepare
- 26:13them extremely well. And just tell them, your
- 26:17media people are going to want this. Everybody's
- 26:19going to want this. You have to be very prepared.
- 26:24And so current employees, same. Again, you're
- 26:26going to want to prepare them for. you may want
- 26:30to prepare them with their supervisors and partially
- 26:34and then partially not because you want to see
- 26:38you want them to be honest with you and they
- 26:40got to understand even though you represent the
- 26:43company, it's important for them to be honest
- 26:45with you because you don't know what the plaintiff's
- 26:47attorney's gonna, the other side's attorney's
- 26:49gonna have. So they need to be prepared and you
- 26:52need to tell them, look, anything you have to
- 26:54say, you gotta tell me now so that we're ready
- 26:56when this comes forward. Just with any other
- 26:59witness, it's really important with a current
- 27:01employee. And sometimes in the preparation when
- 27:06you're defending a company and you have a current
- 27:08employee, They will start telling you things
- 27:11and they'll want to know whether you're their
- 27:14lawyer or the company's lawyer and You know that
- 27:19there you've developed a rapport with them. You
- 27:22made them comfortable Which is really important,
- 27:25but it's also important to remember your role.
- 27:28You do not represent the employee as an Individual
- 27:33you represent the company I'm assuming in this
- 27:37case, so when you represent the entity and the
- 27:40current employee starts telling you things that
- 27:44may be problematic and a conflict of interest
- 27:48for you. you need to be very careful treading
- 27:51that line and they may need to have separate
- 27:53counsel in some cases. And same thing with former
- 27:57employees. Under the labor code, there are provisions
- 28:01that require an employer to defend a former employee,
- 28:04like say the company gets sued and the employee,
- 28:07former employee gets sued as well, happens a
- 28:10lot. especially like trade secret cases and other
- 28:12things. So if the former employees is actually
- 28:17a named defendant in the case, it may be OK for
- 28:21you to defend them at the same time, but they
- 28:23may need separate counsel as well. So and under
- 28:26the labor code, typically the employer is going
- 28:29to be required to provide that separate counsel
- 28:31for them. And you're going to want to address
- 28:33all of these kinds of issues. Because again,
- 28:38you're defending the entity and if you have an
- 28:41employee, regardless of what level they are,
- 28:43high level, current, former, if they have some
- 28:46kind of conflict, you need to get them separate
- 28:50counsel. I guess, again, I put on here a subpoena
- 28:57may be required. You can accept service. If you're
- 29:00representing the entity, you can tell counsel,
- 29:02I'll accept service of their subpoena. You don't
- 29:04have to go track them down. I typically will
- 29:07do that. I won't make the other side go subpoena
- 29:10former employees. I'll just accept service for
- 29:12them. So no reason to make it difficult on your
- 29:20professional colleagues opposing counsel. Anything
- 29:24you wanted to add? I know I said a lot there.
- 29:26Go ahead, Anders. I think you hit most of the
- 29:31high points. I think just focusing on, you know,
- 29:33kind of the strategy as far as how you want to
- 29:35depose these witnesses, the employee witnesses,
- 29:38in what order. Think about that carefully kind
- 29:40of before you move forward and don't always think
- 29:43about going for the, you know, the highest level
- 29:45person first, right? Because And that's where
- 29:48your written discovery, your interrogatories,
- 29:51your document requests are going to be important
- 29:53to inform your decision. Maybe you'll get a sense
- 29:56of, well, this person perhaps is a disgruntled
- 29:59employee, or perhaps they may be more willing
- 30:01to share than current employee or the high level,
- 30:05right? So just look at your written discovery,
- 30:06see how that can help inform your deposition
- 30:09decision making. Great. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 30:17entity depositions. So we talked about, you get
- 30:19to hear me again, we talked about the witness
- 30:23depositions for the entity. Now we're going to
- 30:25talk about the entity depositions. So say you're
- 30:29representing the plaintiff in the case and you
- 30:31want to take the deposition of ABC entity, you're
- 30:36going to issue a subpoena called the person most
- 30:38qualified subpoena, or we often call it the PMQ.
- 30:44subpoena, and it's when you do that, the key
- 30:48thing to do is you have to put in there a description
- 30:53of what the testimony is going to be. So you're
- 30:56saying, I am going to depose the person most
- 30:59qualified at XYZ entity, defendant XYZ entity
- 31:05or third party XYZ entity, whatever the case
- 31:08may be. and on the topics attached, and then
- 31:11you're going to have a description of the testimony,
- 31:14either in your notice of deposition or your subpoena,
- 31:17depending if it's a party or non -party entity.
- 31:20And in that, that's the critical piece, is what
- 31:23is the description of testimony? And you want
- 31:26to be broad enough so that you get all the information
- 31:31that you need, but you also need to be narrow
- 31:34or descriptive enough so that the entity knows
- 31:38which person to choose to come and testify, who
- 31:41is the most qualified at the entity to testify
- 31:44about these particular topics. And it's very
- 31:51important for them to, if you're the person choosing
- 31:55that, because when you're issuing that subpoena
- 31:57to an entity, you don't get to decide who the
- 32:00entity chooses. They decide who's. the most qualified.
- 32:04When you're representing the entity in this case,
- 32:07it's really important to consider who is the
- 32:09most qualified to testify on these particular
- 32:11topics. And oftentimes it's not one person. It
- 32:15may be multiple people that have to appear because
- 32:17the different topic areas depending on the entity.
- 32:22So oftentimes it's a sort of higher level person
- 32:26that may have, you know, they supervising the
- 32:31people who are doing the job of the types of
- 32:34topics you want to talk about, but they'll have
- 32:37the supervising person come in to do the testimony
- 32:40because they're the most qualified to talk about
- 32:43it from a more broad standpoint. So those are
- 32:47the two, that's the really key piece when you're
- 32:50issuing that deposition notice or subpoena of
- 32:53what is the description of the testimony. And
- 32:57when you're preparing the most qualified witness,
- 33:00here's the piece that you're going to really
- 33:02want to think about is go over each area of the
- 33:06description of testimony. So, you know, say there's
- 33:10a list of 10 different things. Look at piece
- 33:12number one. OK, I want you to testify about manufacturing
- 33:18these widgets. OK. I'm the best person to talk
- 33:21about manufacturing of these widgets. What did
- 33:23you have to do to prepare for this? Well, I had
- 33:25to talk to the people on the line, and I had
- 33:27to know what the process was. I needed to talk
- 33:32to our billing people, our purchasing people,
- 33:35and there's a whole scope of people that they
- 33:37might need to get input in just to prepare for
- 33:41that. A lot of it they already know. And that's
- 33:44going to be a distinction that you have to think
- 33:47about in these cases is sometimes the person
- 33:50most qualified to testify is not necessarily
- 33:54the person most knowledgeable on each topic.
- 33:57And that will come into play later when you're
- 33:59talking about trial testimony. But for when you're
- 34:01taking depositions, it's the person most qualified
- 34:04so that you can get. the most information that
- 34:08you can out of a single deposition because when
- 34:10you're representing an entity, you typically
- 34:12only want there to be one witness. You don't
- 34:14want to have to bring in six different witnesses
- 34:17to talk about things on one entity deposition.
- 34:21Next slide. So when you're preparing for a deposition,
- 34:29whether you're defending the deposition or taking
- 34:31the deposition, preparation is key. It's the
- 34:34most important aspect that you can do in your
- 34:36role as an attorney is to make sure that you
- 34:38are prepared to get the information or to prepare
- 34:41the witness to testify truthfully and appropriately
- 34:45for the purposes of your case, right? So I like
- 34:49to start with kind of looking back at what are
- 34:52the elements of the causative action issue in
- 34:55your case, right? It could be breach of contract,
- 34:57trade secrets, or some employment related, you
- 34:59know, causes of action, right? There may be multiple.
- 35:03So start with kind of a decision tree or, you
- 35:06know, breaking it down into the elements of those
- 35:09causes of action, and kind of see how that breaks
- 35:12into your questioning, right? If you are the
- 35:15examining attorney, what do you need to cover?
- 35:17What do you need to prove at your trial? Think
- 35:20of it, you know, if you're preparing for the
- 35:23trial, what do you need to prove? What are the
- 35:25facts that you need from that particular witness
- 35:27or how might they fit into that piece of the
- 35:30puzzle, right? Of course, you're going to want
- 35:33to look and review the pleadings, right? The
- 35:36complaint, the answer, anything else, any other
- 35:38motions that might come into play that you could
- 35:41ask the witness about, prior statements, discovery,
- 35:46right? Those are all fair games for and good
- 35:49topics that you want to cover with the witness
- 35:52during your examination. So jury instructions,
- 35:55right? It can often be a good place to start
- 35:58because it gives you a good foundation for what
- 36:02you need to prove on that particular claim or
- 36:04disprove if you are the defending on the defense
- 36:07side. So just know your role, know what you need
- 36:09to prove at trial. And that should be the roadmap
- 36:12for what you want to cover during the deposition.
- 36:16If you are defending the deposition, make sure
- 36:20that you are pairing the witness appropriately.
- 36:22Michelle referenced it earlier. High -level executives,
- 36:26people at organizations and companies, they're
- 36:28busy. They've got other things going on. They're
- 36:31dealing with their operations of their business.
- 36:33They don't want to set aside two, three hours
- 36:36to... or four hours to meet with an attorney
- 36:38to prepare for it. They do not, right? It's always
- 36:42a roadblock, always an obstacle. And your role
- 36:44is to educate the client or the witness as best
- 36:47you can about why it's important. Why do we need
- 36:49to set aside this time, right? Because they may
- 36:52think they know everything, but you know, that's
- 36:55not, this is not what they do every day, right?
- 36:56Taking depositions or sitting in on depositions,
- 36:59unless it's a super qualified witness like an
- 37:02expert or somebody like that. So make sure you're
- 37:04setting aside the time to talk to them about,
- 37:06you know, how, what they can expect, right? Even
- 37:10beyond the substance, right? You know, just sort
- 37:12of tactics as far as taking a pause before answering,
- 37:16ask for questions to be repeated or rephrased
- 37:18if needed. You know, the use of silence and depositions.
- 37:22And then finally, as Michelle mentioned earlier,
- 37:25you know, take a video, right? If you're gonna
- 37:27do a mock deposition, right? Take a video and
- 37:30record it, you know, maybe a couple of days in
- 37:33advance of the deposition so that the witness
- 37:35has time to review it, to look at the video and
- 37:39see what they, how they responded to each question,
- 37:42how they kind of acted under pressure, so to
- 37:45speak. I think it could be a really important
- 37:47way to prepare. You're not gonna be able to do
- 37:49that in every case, right? It may not. But it's
- 37:53a good idea if you can build in time and get
- 37:55your witness to set aside that time Yeah, and
- 38:00I would say for some businesses especially closely
- 38:03held and Some of the smaller ones where this
- 38:07is their baby, you know, this business is baby
- 38:10and they just Get take it so personally and they
- 38:15might have a lot of anger or they might have
- 38:17a lot of like I want to screw that person and
- 38:20they want to prove their right to the other side.
- 38:24And it's really important to educate them on
- 38:28this is not trial. This is not your turn to prove
- 38:33your right to the other side. All you're doing
- 38:36is feeding them more information to use against
- 38:38you. So changing that mindset is very important.
- 38:44And don't afraid to be mean don't afraid to be
- 38:47mean to your client and your questioning because
- 38:49the opposing counsel may be Asking them really
- 38:54difficult questions and a very pointed and way
- 38:58like You know, oh you didn't do that. What's
- 39:02wrong? You know in a very accusatory way you
- 39:05have to prepare your witness for that and just
- 39:08just any kind of strategy that the other side
- 39:11may use. You've got to ask them the tough questions.
- 39:15Don't be easy on your client when you're preparing
- 39:17them. Next slide, please. Okay. When you're in
- 39:26the role of the examining attorney, how should
- 39:29you go about questioning the witness? Everybody
- 39:32will have their own style, and that's the number
- 39:34one thing I would say is use the style and approach
- 39:38that suits you best. It's no sense to take on
- 39:41another role or another approach that doesn't
- 39:44necessarily suit your skills effectively. But
- 39:48personally, when I'm deposing a witness, I like
- 39:51to try to disarm them. And some people will do
- 39:54this to try to build up rapport, particularly
- 39:56if it's an opposing party. And they'll start
- 39:59by trying to not be confrontational, at least
- 40:03at the outset, to try to build that rapport and
- 40:05reduce defenses. So you need to, if you're on
- 40:07the defending side, you need to prepare your
- 40:10client for that potential approach. I've seen
- 40:12attorneys that take kind of a sort of a, you
- 40:17know, a dumber role, right? They act dumb during
- 40:20the deposition to try to disarm or try to, you
- 40:22know, act like they don't understand to get the
- 40:25witness to open up and sort of explain more,
- 40:28right? So coach or teach your clients or your
- 40:32witnesses that you know to expect that right
- 40:34if it's the opposing party's attorney they're
- 40:36not your friend no matter how nice or approachable
- 40:39they may seem during the deposition because of
- 40:41course when it comes to trial you know the coin
- 40:44may flip and they'll they'll pull out an inconsistent
- 40:47statement from the deposition transcript and
- 40:49use that to impeach you as a witness so you need
- 40:52to be able to uh teach the the witness to expect
- 40:56that right, make sure that they're answering
- 40:58the questions appropriately, truthfully, and
- 41:00concisely and not, you know, going on as we talked
- 41:03about earlier. You know, as far as the approach
- 41:07generally speaking, you'll start kind of big
- 41:10picture, right, start with background, you know,
- 41:13general topics before you think of it like a
- 41:15funnel is what's usually, you know, the usual
- 41:20kind of outline that is done is start big picture,
- 41:23high level, right? And then kind of build down
- 41:25to, you know, a crescendo of whatever your, you
- 41:28know, key elements or your key factors for your
- 41:31case. And then as the examining attorney, you
- 41:34would move on. If you've got a helpful admission,
- 41:38right, from a witness, you don't need to go back
- 41:41to that, right? If they've given you a helpful
- 41:44answer, you know, just know that that's going
- 41:47to be recorded and then move on to another topic.
- 41:50So Direct confrontation can be effective usually
- 41:54later, maybe after you've built up that rapport.
- 41:57And particularly when you're getting down on
- 41:59something very specific, that can be an effective
- 42:02way to approach the witness. Next slide, please.
- 42:11Okay, so what do you do if you're the defending
- 42:14attorney, right? you know, it's not a passive
- 42:17role. You should be actively listening, actively
- 42:20paying attention to the questions asked, right?
- 42:23Of course, and number one is preparing your witness
- 42:26before that deposition to make sure that they
- 42:28understand what to expect, what the role is and
- 42:31how the process is going to play out. Of course,
- 42:34during the deposition, you need to make sure
- 42:35that you're protecting attorney -client privilege
- 42:37and any other privilege such as work product
- 42:39or trade secrets are inquired into, right? You
- 42:42want to state your objections on the record to
- 42:45any questions. If it's something, a question
- 42:47that calls for a privileged information, it may
- 42:49be appropriate to instruct the witness not to
- 42:52answer as applicable, depending on the context
- 42:55of the question, right? But just make sure that
- 42:58you're keeping an orderly record. You know, your
- 43:00client, the witness isn't being abused or badgered
- 43:03during the deposition, right? You need to call
- 43:06for breaks, you know, on a reasonable basis.
- 43:09You know, you're there to kind of make sure that
- 43:11things go smoothly, things go appropriately.
- 43:14The witness is answering the questions. You need
- 43:16to be prepared to step in and counsel or tell
- 43:19the client to answer if they're not being, you
- 43:23know, forthright in their position. and then
- 43:26just protect, you know, any sort of trade secrets,
- 43:28confidential issues that may come up and assert
- 43:31those objections when you need to. There are,
- 43:33you know, available avenues for relief from the
- 43:36court, protective orders, right? You can file
- 43:39the appropriate motion and put it before the
- 43:41court if an examining attorney is going kind
- 43:44of, you know, beyond what you think is appropriate.
- 43:47That can be addressed later on. Yeah, and sometimes,
- 43:54you know people will do things like I remember
- 43:57once I was when I first started practicing that
- 44:00I had this very verbose client and preparing
- 44:06for the deposition it was just really difficult
- 44:08to Get her to not keep talking and want to explain
- 44:13everything and at one point in the deposition
- 44:16I just kind of kicked her under the table and
- 44:18she turned to me on the record and said why'd
- 44:20you kick me? Oh no, that wasn't a good way to
- 44:27approach it. So that's why you're just always
- 44:30preparing and there's ways that maybe you need
- 44:34to use a break or something to help your client
- 44:38really hone in. Hang on, this isn't your friend.
- 44:41This is a lawyer that's questioning you and using
- 44:44everything that you say against you. So don't
- 44:47forget that. Next slide. This is kind of builds
- 44:54off the last slide, and we're not going to go
- 44:57into this in great detail, because I think we're
- 44:58running a little bit short on time. But make
- 45:02sure you tell your clients or your witness that
- 45:04you're preparing, right? They can request that
- 45:07the question be rephrased, right? Don't testify
- 45:10as counsel. That's for the witness to do. You're
- 45:13there to state objections, to maintain an orderly.
- 45:16process and record to counsel the witness during
- 45:21breaks as appropriate. But don't testify through
- 45:24the witness. Don't answer the question on the
- 45:26record. Just state your objections and allow
- 45:28the process to move on. If it's a privilege issue,
- 45:31of course, you can assert that and direct the
- 45:34witness not to answer. But yeah, just know your
- 45:39role as the defending attorney. And there's,
- 45:43of course, the protective order that we talked
- 45:45about earlier, code citations there. If you need
- 45:47to avail yourself of that and file a motion with
- 45:50the court as needed, you can always state on
- 45:53the record that you intend to do that, ask the
- 45:56examining attorney to move on to another line
- 45:58of questioning. And so that you can address that
- 46:01protective order where needed, particularly if
- 46:03it's trade secrets or other things that are involved.
- 46:07Yeah, I mean, hopefully you can work it out.
- 46:10I have a rare occasion had a lawyer just stand
- 46:14up and leave and take their witness with them
- 46:16out during the deposition. But usually, you should
- 46:19be able to work that out with counsel. And if
- 46:22you're in an impasse on things, it may be that
- 46:25you need to just switch to a different topic
- 46:27in your questioning and preserve that to file
- 46:30a motion later if there's some kind of bad conduct
- 46:34in a certain area of questioning. Next slide.
- 46:42Okay, of course, if any sort of objections need
- 46:46to be raised, right, as far as the form of the
- 46:49question, right, you know, calls for speculation,
- 46:52lack of foundation, right. You want to state
- 46:55those objections on the record. You may be substantive
- 46:59objections to interpose as well, whether it's
- 47:02related to relevance or opinion or other substantive
- 47:05objections. There's just a handful here which
- 47:08that's not an exhaustive list but want to make
- 47:10sure that you are familiar with the categories
- 47:12of objections you may need to raise during the
- 47:15objection to preserve your client's rights down
- 47:18the road. Next slide please. Okay so if you have
- 47:28a privilege issue that comes up that's when you
- 47:30should instruct the witness not to answer. Only
- 47:33when there's a privilege issue is when you should
- 47:36instructing the witness not to answer. Of course,
- 47:38attorney -client privilege is the big one that
- 47:40comes up. Work product as well, but we've also
- 47:43mentioned trade secrets or IP -related rights.
- 47:46Those may be where you need to invoke the court
- 47:50for a motion for a protective order, particularly
- 47:52if there's questioning about a trade secret issue
- 47:55that you think is immune from discovery or subject
- 47:58to a protective order. then that's where you
- 48:02could try to work it out with the opposing counsel
- 48:04to have them move on to another line of questioning,
- 48:07state your objection on the record, and then
- 48:09either you work it out or if you need to file
- 48:11a motion on either side for a motion to compel
- 48:14or a motion for the protective order, those rights
- 48:18are in place. So don't instruct the witness not
- 48:21to answer just because it's a bad fact or it's
- 48:24an uncomfortable question. Depositions are uncomfortable
- 48:27by nature. Nobody wants to be there. particularly
- 48:30on the witness side, nobody wants to be answering
- 48:32the questions. Oftentimes it may be a difficult
- 48:37or an emotional case depending on the facts or
- 48:39the circumstances. That's where you need to prepare
- 48:42the witness in advance, know what the weaknesses
- 48:44are and prepare the witness to answer those questions.
- 48:49And you shouldn't object just because it's an
- 48:52uncomfortable question unless a privilege issue
- 48:56applies or some other objection. you know, the
- 48:58witness should be answering the question. Next
- 49:03slide. OK, one thing that you'll see oftentimes
- 49:10in depositions and it may be useful for you as
- 49:13an examining attorney is just to use the power
- 49:16of silence, right? Pregnant pauses. So I've done
- 49:20this frequently where I ask a question, right?
- 49:23Let the witness answer the question and then
- 49:25just Sometimes the witness will answer the question.
- 49:31They're trained to answer just that question.
- 49:34But if you sit there and be silent for a few
- 49:37seconds, oftentimes the witness will fill the
- 49:41air with silence. So if you're defending the
- 49:43deposition, you want to teach your client, as
- 49:45we've talked about before, just answer the question,
- 49:47be concise in your answer. Don't be afraid to
- 49:50have a room that's silent because the attorney,
- 49:53the opposing, the examining attorney may be using
- 49:56that as an opportunity to get additional information
- 49:59out. It works very often. You'd be surprised
- 50:02if you haven't tried it before, but because people
- 50:06just naturally want to fill the air with words
- 50:10rather than just waiting for the next question.
- 50:13So it can be an effective examination tool. If
- 50:16you're defending, just be prepare it and tell
- 50:19your clients about this or your witness about
- 50:21it so that they can understand and expect that.
- 50:29Okay, next slide, please. Okay, of course, during
- 50:34the course of a deposition, reasonable breaks
- 50:36are always allowed, right? So long as a question
- 50:40isn't pending, you can't take a break. Generally
- 50:42speaking, while a question has been pending,
- 50:44you need to answer that. The witness should answer
- 50:45that question. and then the break can be taken.
- 50:50Usually it's, you know, breaks are going to be
- 50:52about every hour or 90 minutes, but you'll work
- 50:55that out with the opposing party, opposing council.
- 50:59Depending on how long you expect the deposition
- 51:01to go, that's something that you should work
- 51:03out, you know, usually off the record so that
- 51:06you can figure out, well, maybe I've got 30 minutes
- 51:08more we can push through or I've got, you know,
- 51:10at least another hour. It's a good time to take
- 51:12a break. Make sure that as an attorney, you're
- 51:16not conferring the witness during a pending question,
- 51:19right? Let the witness answer the question. And
- 51:22then if it's time to take a break after that,
- 51:24that's when you can confer with the witness afterwards
- 51:27about what's to come. But those are the limitations
- 51:32you should keep in mind. Next slide, please.
- 51:40Okay. Deposition is generally going to be limited
- 51:43to seven hours under section 290. So we have
- 51:48the citation there. So just bear that in mind.
- 51:50If your case falls under these exceptions, you
- 51:53may be able to get more than that. And I'll let
- 51:56Michelle speak on that a little bit more. Sure.
- 51:59For complex cases, expert witnesses, or agreement
- 52:02of counsel or court order, those are the typical
- 52:05exceptions. There's actually three more under
- 52:072025 290. A case brought by an employee or applicant
- 52:12or employee against an employer for acts or emissions
- 52:15are rising out of a relating to the employment
- 52:17relationship. Those are not limited by the 7
- 52:20hour. Or any deposition of a person designated
- 52:23as the person most qualified the PMQ depo that
- 52:27we talked about earlier. And finally, to any
- 52:32party who appeared in the action after a deposition
- 52:34has concluded. then in that case, the new party
- 52:37may notice another deposition subject to the
- 52:40requirements of this section. So those are three
- 52:42additional exceptions that sometimes arise. You
- 52:46know, it's interesting with respect to the PMQ
- 52:48depot, I had a case recently where the lawyer
- 52:54wanted, they noticed the deposition for the individual
- 52:57that he wanted to depose and he noticed it for
- 53:01the PMQ and the PMQ because it was a closed sale
- 53:04business and there's really the same individual
- 53:07is the only guy he combined the PMQ and the individual
- 53:13deposition together and normally I wouldn't do
- 53:16that I would separate them out because you have
- 53:19unlimited time with the PMQ depot and you only
- 53:22have you have seven hours with an individual
- 53:25so that could cut both ways because if it's unclear
- 53:30then maybe you get a long time for the individual
- 53:33deposition because you're not really sure where
- 53:35the PMQ is and where the individual is. But typically
- 53:38I would separate those out and say this person
- 53:41is testifying now as an individual and then stop
- 53:45it and start the next deposition for the PMQ.
- 53:49And then the PMQ deposition, as I said before,
- 53:52only it doesn't have a time limitation to it.
- 53:59And I do see a question on Zoom depositions.
- 54:04So I'm going to just note that for you, Anders.
- 54:06So as we go through this, we will talk about
- 54:08that briefly at the end. So thank you, Larry,
- 54:11for raising that. Go ahead. Did you have anything
- 54:13else on this slide, Anders? No? Next slide. Exhibits.
- 54:23Handling exhibits. Always make sure you organize
- 54:26everything in advance. Ideally, everything is
- 54:28bait stamped in advance. It's so time consuming.
- 54:33If you have a stack of documents that say it's
- 54:36one exhibit and it's 35 pages and they're not
- 54:39numbered to sit there, and maybe some of them
- 54:43are numbered internally as they existed natively.
- 54:47But if you don't bet, it just saves so much time
- 54:49to show up with everything bait stamped. I have
- 54:52seen Council that intentionally show up not bait
- 54:57stamp just because they'd like to make it more
- 54:59confusing for the other side. I don't find that
- 55:02effective. I find it silly and a waste of time,
- 55:05but I understand some folks find that to be a
- 55:08strategy just to make things more difficult for
- 55:10the other side. Mark them sequentially as you're
- 55:13going through the deposition. So ideally, if
- 55:17you can do it a really nice way if you're to
- 55:20to do your depositions is to go sequentially
- 55:23all the way through. So say you have 10 witnesses
- 55:26between both each side of the case. Just start
- 55:32with one and keep going forward. And then if
- 55:34you're in your third deposition and you want
- 55:39to use an exhibit that was introduced in the
- 55:41first deposition, that's exhibit one. Go ahead
- 55:45and call it exhibit one previously marked in
- 55:48the deposition. Say it was marked in the deposition
- 55:50of, you know, Miss A and now we're in the deposition
- 55:54of Mr. B, then you just say in Mr. B's deposition.
- 55:59I'd like to now mark what was previously marked
- 56:03as exhibit one in Miss A's deposition. in this
- 56:06document and so just use the same numbering in
- 56:09the same document so that way it makes it so
- 56:11much easier for trial preparation when you're
- 56:13doing your exhibit lists and everything that
- 56:16just it works out really well if you can keep
- 56:18everything sequentially. So what I typically
- 56:20do is I will actually just keep a notepad with
- 56:24me or you can type it however your style is to
- 56:27just have in line what each exhibit is as you're
- 56:30going through every deposition in the case. So
- 56:32I find that to be really helpful. And also make
- 56:36sure that you have copies for counsel and witnesses.
- 56:40And authenticating the exhibits during the deposition
- 56:43is very helpful for emotions and trial as well.
- 56:46So make sure if you're just putting a deposition,
- 56:48if you're putting an exhibit in front of a witness,
- 56:49make sure they authenticate it while you're sitting
- 56:51there so that then it's already done and you
- 56:54don't have to worry about it later on. You can
- 56:57use that testimony as the authentication. And
- 57:00preparation of exhibits in advance is particularly
- 57:03important for Zoom depositions because Usually
- 57:07you want to provide all those exhibits. Ideally,
- 57:11it's very helpful if you can provide the exhibits
- 57:12to the court reporter in advance so that they
- 57:15have everything and you can even, you know, I
- 57:19often will just email them to counsel that morning
- 57:21of the depot or the day before just so you have
- 57:24it in hand so it's all ready to go and you don't
- 57:28waste a bunch of time. on the zoom deposition.
- 57:31And a lot of times I'm doing zoom depositions
- 57:34with somebody because they're out of the country
- 57:36and another time zone, things like that. So,
- 57:40you know, I've had some recently where the deponents
- 57:42in the Middle East and they're just in a totally
- 57:45different time zone than us. And it's the days
- 57:48are flipped. And so when it's 10 o 'clock at
- 57:51night for them and to sit there and try to mess
- 57:55around with exhibits and other things, it just...
- 57:57It isn't helpful. You have interpreters and you
- 58:00have other things. So it's just really nice to
- 58:02have that all cleaned up and ready to go. Oh,
- 58:08well, there's a question about speaking of Zoom
- 58:10depositions. If you have a deponent in another
- 58:12country but it's done over Zoom, do you stipulate
- 58:15that you're applying the rules as though they
- 58:17are domestic? Yes, I do. I apply them under California
- 58:20rules. I don't know, Anders, if you have a different
- 58:23view on that. Yeah, that's how I've done it as
- 58:27well. Yeah. Yeah. OK. We're getting really short
- 58:30on time, so if we could zip through the last
- 58:32view. Review. I think the last one was just reviewing
- 58:42the transcript. Just make sure your client knows
- 58:46that they can make changes. any changes that
- 58:50are made are going to be commented on and they're
- 58:53subject to commenting on later on. So make sure
- 58:55they're important, they really need it. It's
- 58:57better for you if you're really paying attention
- 58:59during the deposition to get them to correct
- 59:02what they said during the depo rather than waiting
- 59:04until later. So that's why it's really important
- 59:06again as defense counsel to, it's not a passive
- 59:09role, it's active. You got to be constantly thinking.
- 59:12Next slide. We've spoken before about various
- 59:17motions that you may have to file either after
- 59:21or before the deposition, but force a motion
- 59:24to compel. You may have instances where a witness
- 59:27just doesn't appear for the deposition that you've
- 59:29duly noticed. You may have issues related to
- 59:31a witness's refusal to answer certain questions
- 59:34during the deposition that would require a motion
- 59:36to compel. If you have trade secrets or other
- 59:40confidential business information that you need
- 59:42to seek a protection for, that you want to move
- 59:44for a protective order, And finally, you know,
- 59:47kind of last case if there's a sanctions issue,
- 59:49right? Somebody's abusing or misusing the discovery
- 59:52process or they haven't showed up for a deposition
- 59:54after it was noticed and they were ordered to
- 59:57attend, you may want to move for sanctions. Those
- 1:00:00can be severe depending on the circumstances
- 1:00:02of your case. Yeah, I've had that before. I've
- 1:00:05seen that where we've had it where the party
- 1:00:09was really, really important and didn't show
- 1:00:11up to depositions. And so the judge didn't let
- 1:00:14that person testify at trial at all. So judgment
- 1:00:17went totally against him for a lot of money.
- 1:00:19So it's really important to floor upon your client.
- 1:00:23They better show up. Next slide. We're really
- 1:00:26at time. So we're going to really zoom here.
- 1:00:30Use of depositions at trial. I'll just say really
- 1:00:32quickly on this. you really can use them for
- 1:00:36any purpose. And especially video depositions,
- 1:00:39I've seen people use them instead of calling
- 1:00:41the person as a witness in their testimony, because
- 1:00:44you like how the person looks on the camera as
- 1:00:49an opposing counsel. So you may just never call
- 1:00:53them and say, you know what? Their video is so
- 1:00:54good for my case. I'm just going to play that
- 1:00:56video. And so I've seen that a number of times.
- 1:00:59And of course, it's very powerful. in impeachment
- 1:01:02use as well, or in non -parties where they can't
- 1:01:05come, or the witness is unavailable, you know,
- 1:01:07they're in another country or whatever, having
- 1:01:09that deposition testimony on video is very helpful.
- 1:01:14I know we're over time, so is there anything
- 1:01:18quickly we should, if we could just skip to again?
- 1:01:22Oh, notice to appear trial. I touched upon this
- 1:01:24briefly. When you have an entity testimony at
- 1:01:28trial and you're doing the notice to appear,
- 1:01:30And again, the thing to think about is they're
- 1:01:33sending the person most qualified to a deposition,
- 1:01:35but they may not be the person most knowledgeable.
- 1:01:37So for trial purposes, you do need to call the
- 1:01:42notice that the testimony of the actual individuals
- 1:01:46that have personal knowledge. Otherwise, it will
- 1:01:48be hearsay and you will have problems at trial.
- 1:01:51So make sure that you have the correct people
- 1:01:55with actual personal knowledge of. the questioning
- 1:01:58and the areas of testimony that you're going
- 1:02:00to talk about. Next slide. We talked about this
- 1:02:06a little bit before, but you shouldn't note the
- 1:02:08ethical rules, rule of professional conduct 3
- 1:02:10.3, which requires a duty of candor to the tribunal
- 1:02:13and opposing counsel. So if a witness testifies
- 1:02:16falsely and you know that as an attorney, you
- 1:02:18have to disclose that and make sure that the
- 1:02:21record is corrected. Again, stress to your the
- 1:02:24witness that they need to be testifying truthfully,
- 1:02:27honestly, completely. And that's the number one
- 1:02:30duty for witness and preparing them for deposition.
- 1:02:33Next slide, please. Yeah, I think this is I think
- 1:02:40the rest of our slides you could probably view.
- 1:02:42I'm cognizant of the time that we're over. So,
- 1:02:48Anders, I don't know if you have anything specific
- 1:02:50you wanted to address on these remaining ones.
- 1:02:53So What I would like to do is just focus a little
- 1:02:57bit, spend a minute on Zoom depositions because
- 1:03:00the questions were asked in the chat. When you're
- 1:03:04preparing for a Zoom deposition, do it on Zoom,
- 1:03:08prepare your witness on Zoom. And so they see
- 1:03:11themselves on camera and tell them where to look
- 1:03:13because sometimes we're looking over here, we're
- 1:03:15looking at a document and then it's recorded.
- 1:03:18So you still have to... You still have to notice
- 1:03:22the deposition is being recorded or not because
- 1:03:25as a video deposition, because just because you're
- 1:03:28doing it on Zoom doesn't mean it's going to be
- 1:03:30recorded to be used later as you are sitting
- 1:03:33in a conference room with a videographer. So
- 1:03:35just make sure you put that distinction in your
- 1:03:37notice. And again, with exhibits, prepare well
- 1:03:42in advance because you're going to be putting
- 1:03:43it off on a screen. Practice that. so that you're
- 1:03:46comfortable with putting them on the screen.
- 1:03:48And when you're defending a zoom deposition,
- 1:03:50something to really think about is whether you're
- 1:03:52going to be sitting in the same room because
- 1:03:55you're not going to be on camera with your witness.
- 1:03:58You know, it's easy when you're alive and you're
- 1:04:00defending a deposition and you're sitting next
- 1:04:03to your your your client. But when you're on
- 1:04:08Zoom, you might be in a completely different
- 1:04:09building, a different state, whatever the case
- 1:04:11may be. So you just have to really practice that
- 1:04:15and prepare for that. Because I have seen some
- 1:04:17lawyers where they'll be in the same room or
- 1:04:22the same location, but maybe in different rooms.
- 1:04:24Because you can't really sit in the same room
- 1:04:26because you can't be on camera the same and the
- 1:04:29microphones don't work properly and the speakers
- 1:04:31and so forth if you're sitting in the same room
- 1:04:34typically. Those would be my key things for Zoom
- 1:04:38depositions. I don't know, Anders, if you have
- 1:04:40anything to add to that. I would just add, absolutely
- 1:04:44get your exhibits organized in advance because
- 1:04:46you want to be able to make sure that you're
- 1:04:48smooth and streamlined when you're sharing your
- 1:04:51screen or sharing the exhibits. Definitely send
- 1:04:54them over to opposing counsel in advance. To
- 1:04:56Heather's point, sometimes things will come up
- 1:04:58on the fly. You need to be able to adapt, you
- 1:05:01know, so just be comfortable with that. And lastly,
- 1:05:04if you're going to play any sort of audio or
- 1:05:06video during a deposition that you want to witness
- 1:05:10to authenticate a video or something, you have
- 1:05:12to share your audio, particularly through Zoom.
- 1:05:16That's just something I know from experience,
- 1:05:17because having done it, so just be ready for
- 1:05:20that. It's a little bit of a two -step process,
- 1:05:23sharing your screen and then also sharing your
- 1:05:26audio. So if you're playing anything like that
- 1:05:28during a Zoom deposition, make sure you focus
- 1:05:31on that. Any other questions? We're happy to
- 1:05:33address them. I know we're over time, but so
- 1:05:36thank you so much for your time and we're happy
- 1:05:38to present to you all. Thanks everybody.