Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / $2.5 Billion, Egos, and Why Big Numbers Need Context
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark Kel with another
- 0:02episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05The motivation for this podcast is a conversation that I had back at NCA in
- 0:112008 or 2009 during the corporate Credit Union crisis and what something was said
- 0:18that always stuck with me and it was.
- 0:21The concept of a billion dollars and how much it actually was, and I've been
- 0:25thinking about that a lot with things that are in the news, whether it's
- 0:30fraud with a billion dollars, or whether it's cost overruns at the fed of the.
- 0:36Of for buildings of $2.5
- 0:38billion.
- 0:39And then of course we have the politics that's going on between the Trump
- 0:42administration and the Federal Reserve.
- 0:44Been thinking a lot about that.
- 0:46I've got some visuals I've created that I'll be putting out on
- 0:48LinkedIn and linked to this podcast and I put my thoughts together.
- 0:53On the concept of this from a neutral perspective, because I am quite neutral
- 0:58on this, I can see both sides of it.
- 1:00And so with that, I'm gonna dive right into this podcast
- 1:04which I've called the 2.5,
- 1:07which I have am calling $2.5
- 1:09billion Egos.
- 1:11And why Big numbers need context, if you've been following the headlines,
- 1:16if you've been following the headlines, you've seen the latest
- 1:19clash between President Trump and Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell.
- 1:23This time it's over the Fed's building renovations and the now famous $2.5
- 1:28billion price tag, depending on which side you listen to.
- 1:33This is either reckless waste or total normal construction overruns
- 1:37being turned into a political weapon.
- 1:41My take, it's probably a little bit of both or a lot of bit of both,
- 1:45because here's the truth, nobody really wants to say out loud.
- 1:49Big government construction projects almost always cost more than their
- 1:53plan to cost, and big political figures almost always wanna put
- 1:59their fingerprints on the blueprints.
- 2:02That combination is not new, it's not unique to the Fed, and it's
- 2:06not unique to this administration.
- 2:09But when the number gets to 2.5
- 2:12billion, it deserves real context, not just talking points.
- 2:17So let's do the math.
- 2:19Why we lose perspective on billions.
- 2:21Most of us can picture a million dollars, a billion dollars, not so much.
- 2:27So here are three ways to think about $2.5
- 2:31billion First.
- 2:33Stacking dollar bills.
- 2:35This is the reference to what was said in the corporate crisis
- 2:38back in oh eight and oh nine.
- 2:40A single $1 bill is about four thousandths of an inch thick, not thick at all.
- 2:47If you stacked 2.5
- 2:49billion in $1 bills, that stack would be very high.
- 2:56How high?
- 2:57Actually 170 miles high.
- 3:01I'm gonna repeat that.
- 3:02$2.5
- 3:03billion in $1 bills stacked, assuming they wouldn't get knocked
- 3:09over and assuming there was no wind, would be 170 miles high.
- 3:15That's not just above airplanes.
- 3:17That is well into space.
- 3:20So that's your first data point.
- 3:22A tower of cash reaching into orbit.
- 3:27Second housing typical.
- 3:29All-in construction costs for apartments today are roughly 300,000 to $500,000
- 3:36per unit, depending on market and building type at that range, $2.5
- 3:42billion could build about 5,000 to 8,000 apartments at just two people per unit.
- 3:50That's housing for 10,000 to 16,000 people.
- 3:54Yes.
- 3:5510,000 to 16,000 people could be housed easily at a cost of $2.5
- 4:01billion.
- 4:02That's not one building that is multiple neighborhoods.
- 4:07Third, looking at time, if you spent a thousand dollars
- 4:11an hour every hour all day.
- 4:17Every day it would take about 285 years to spend $2.5
- 4:23billion longer than the United States has been a country.
- 4:28So yes, we're talking about a lot of money.
- 4:31Why neither side is shocking on this topic.
- 4:35Now, I don't find it shocking that a major renovation of historic federal buildings
- 4:40costs far more than originally projected.
- 4:43Anyone who's ever remodeled a kitchen knows how that story goes.
- 4:48Now, multiply that by asbestos security requirements, historic preservation,
- 4:53and federal procurement rules, costs go up, timeline, slip, scope changes,
- 5:00and that's the reference to everybody needs to influence the blueprint.
- 5:04That's part of this story, that part of this story is not unusual.
- 5:08What's also not unusual?
- 5:10Political egos wanting influence over major projects and political
- 5:15opponents using big numbers as leverage.
- 5:19That happens in agencies, that happens in Congress, that happens in state
- 5:24houses, and it happens in city halls.
- 5:26So I'm not shocked by the construction overruns, and I'm certainly
- 5:30not shocked by the politics.
- 5:32So why does the context still matter?
- 5:36Here's why.
- 5:37It does.
- 5:38When numbers get this large, you can't just say that's how projects go.
- 5:43Because $2.5
- 5:44billion is not a rounding error.
- 5:47It's not just another change order.
- 5:49It's a level of spending that has real opportunity costs, even if
- 5:54the spending itself is justified.
- 5:56And that's where public institutions owe the public something more than slogans.
- 6:02They owe clear explanations of scope, transparent cost, drivers,
- 6:06and honest discussions of trade-offs.
- 6:08Not just it's complicated.
- 6:10Trust us because of this scale, trust has to be earned with the math, even if you
- 6:16are the Uber independent Federal Reserve.
- 6:20So the real risk is the power struggle.
- 6:22Where this gets risky is not in the drywall or the HVAC
- 6:26systems or the asbestos.
- 6:27It's the power struggles When construction spending becomes part of a broader
- 6:32fight over who controls monetary policy.
- 6:35Now you're mixing infrastructure disputes with institutional independence.
- 6:40That's not healthy for markets.
- 6:42It's not healthy for regulators, and it's not healthy for elected officials either.
- 6:48Once both sides start framing this as a test of authority instead of
- 6:52a debate over budgets and policy, everyone starts digging in and when
- 6:57egos harden, solutions get harder.
- 7:00So here's my thoughts and where I land.
- 7:02I don't assume bad faith by the Fed just because costs went up and I
- 7:06don't assume bad faith by politicians who question massive spending.
- 7:11Both things can be true at the same time.
- 7:14Big projects really do cost more than planned, and $2.5
- 7:18billion still deserve serious scrutiny and $2.5
- 7:23billion still deserves serious scrutiny.
- 7:27What we don't need is theater.
- 7:29What we do need is context, because once we understand the scale of the
- 7:33money, the conversation gets a lot more serious and a lot less performative.
- 7:38And when you're dealing with both public trust and financial markets,
- 7:42less performance and more transparency is usually the better path.
- 7:47As always, I want to thank you for listening.
- 7:49Thank you for watching.
- 7:50This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.