Latest / The MEND Fly Fishing Podcast / Episode 126 - Q&A Techy Yarn Rig vs Tight Line Rig
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, here we are. Welcome. Episode 126, the MEND podcast.
- 0:05Host Joe Roeder. I'm going to do a solo cast, a little bit shorter format today.
- 0:10I've been wanting to tag on a lot of questions and comments from the YouTube
- 0:14channel and other questions that just get sent to me at the end of the episodes.
- 0:19But when I interviewed Steve and Bob regarding their BC trip,
- 0:24steelhead fishing, we just kind of ran out of time.
- 0:25So I figured I would just break it into another episode, go through a bunch
- 0:29of the comments and yeah, just keep the comments rolling. It's,
- 0:32I try to get back to every single one of them. I'll answer them in kind of short
- 0:35format on the YouTube channel.
- 0:38And if you listen to the podcast on your favorite podcast app,
- 0:43just know that these are on YouTube.
- 0:45They're audio only, but that's a really great way to just interact.
- 0:48If you find that episode, that's where I get a lot of the comments that we come out here.
- 0:53So this last week, I posted a video that I wouldn't say I was hesitant to do
- 1:00it, but I questioned how much it would resonate with just anglers and viewers.
- 1:05And I've just taken a keen interest over the past year or two years,
- 1:10really, in just trying to figure out how to help the do-it-yourself wade fishing-based angler.
- 1:18Just simplify things understand things better so you can make great decisions
- 1:22and best utilize your time on the water so so much the content i've been working on creating just.
- 1:28If you if you enjoy doing guided you know boat trips wonderful keep it up you're
- 1:33in good hands but if you're trying to have.
- 1:36A more satisfying experience on foot and that doesn't necessarily mean just
- 1:41flat out catching more fish,
- 1:43that could be just doing things a little bit cleaner, a little bit better,
- 1:48a little bit more fluidly or in a way that's kind of new and creative that really
- 1:54embraces the soul of fly fishing, which to me is.
- 1:58I gravitated towards fly fishing simply because it was an ultralight tackle sport.
- 2:02So I've been on a bit of a crusade trying to get people up to speed on the differences
- 2:08and the pros and cons as to why you would indicator fish versus why you would tightline nymph.
- 2:14And there's lots of great reasons to do either one.
- 2:18And I would encourage you, like, even if you list the podcast first,
- 2:22There is a video on the channel that was posted in late October, 2026, just recently.
- 2:30But if you're listening to this podcast later on, it's about when it was posted
- 2:33on the channel and it's something about my yarn, my yarn rig,
- 2:38something to that effect.
- 2:39I don't have the exact title, but just jump over to the channel and put yarn
- 2:44in the search bar for our channel and you'll be able to see that. So...
- 2:49I went out and did some weight fishing, fished for an hour and a half,
- 2:52and I really wanted to demonstrate to folks why an ultralight, delicate,
- 2:59yarn-style indicator rig is, one, it's effective. Nobody would argue that.
- 3:05New Zealand is the most technical trout fishery on the planet,
- 3:08and that's what they use. They
- 3:10use very sparse, very delicate yarn indicators with very long leaders.
- 3:14And I think some of those same practices are underappreciated in the American
- 3:18West, where we have a lot of fisheries that are really dominated by guide boats
- 3:22that cover a lot of water, and it's okay to use a bubba bobber.
- 3:27And that could be your basically, it's funny, we'll revisit this.
- 3:32I'll just say thingamabob or oros or airlock or whatever.
- 3:35But we're going to revisit that because I had a really funny comment on the
- 3:39podcast asking me to explain some of these goofy terms that we often throw around.
- 3:44But I think the West has been really dominated by that. And I would say even
- 3:50as little as 10 to 15 years ago, the trout fishing was easier.
- 3:54I don't necessarily think the trout fishing, I hate to use the term better,
- 3:58because I think that's such a, it's such a qualitative assessment.
- 4:01But I think the fishing was easier.
- 4:05And I think the fish tolerated a little bit more noise. They didn't mind a little heavier tippet.
- 4:10There was just, I think the anglers 10 or 15 years ago didn't have the same
- 4:14resources, the same fly selection that we have now.
- 4:18Rods, lines, leaders, access, onX maps.
- 4:22All of this has made it easier, and I'll roll trout routes into that Onyx Maps
- 4:26comment, but it's all made it much easier for the angler to access the water.
- 4:30And the anglers are much better.
- 4:32I mean, the average angler is so much better equipped now, both with tackland
- 4:37until then just a decade ago.
- 4:40But I think the fisheries are still strong. That's one great thing about rainbow
- 4:43trout is they generally, they're very adaptive, and they will become very secretive
- 4:48and very selective and very discriminating on what they decide to feed on.
- 4:52So the rainbows, the quality of the rainbow fisheries has persisted.
- 4:57A recent biological study on our home river, the Acoma River,
- 5:01has demonstrated that the fish population has been on a very slow increase over
- 5:06the last 25 years, both in,
- 5:08I mean, these are slight numbers, but fish population and average size has grown slowly for 25 years.
- 5:14So I don't know, give it another 10 or 15, if we can keep that trend going,
- 5:18we'll have something even more special. But the fishing has definitely gotten
- 5:22a bit more technical. So I think the American West is a bit behind a lot of
- 5:26other places in the world when it comes to just delicate.
- 5:29Kind of kitty glove style approaches to the fishery.
- 5:33So anyway, in this video, I go out and wade some public water here in the canyon,
- 5:40parked at a public access, walked 100 yards, went fishing, caught several nice
- 5:45trout in just an hour and a half or so.
- 5:48A satisfying experience for me. And I did it on a yard indicator system because I think,
- 5:52there are times and there are certainly conditions and anglers that will prefer
- 5:57that you know definitely over over tight line nymphing and there's a certain
- 6:01stealth to fishing yarn that you're not going to get on a bubba bobber,
- 6:06and you have more range and there's lots of reasons you would choose like a
- 6:11yarn decayed or style rig
- 6:13or a new zealand rig we'll we'll use those two terms interchangeably versus
- 6:17tight lightning thing and one could be wind one could be i'm on very long white
- 6:23seams and i need a much longer presentation,
- 6:26so my my presentation window might need to be four to six feet on a given seam
- 6:32where the fish needs to really see that fly have that fly down in the column
- 6:35right where it needs to be four to six feet before it gets to the fish,
- 6:39some of these more wide open seams on large rivers that's just going to be what's
- 6:42required of the angler we may not be able to approach the fish,
- 6:46and get to kind of that near point blank range that.
- 6:49We have when we tightline fish.
- 6:51So, and there's lots of times a suspended nymph that's just hovering and floating
- 6:56and drifting along mid column just looks better than a fly that's either rising,
- 7:01or dropping, which it often is on a tightline nymph rig.
- 7:04It's hard to hold that fly mid column with a tightline rig.
- 7:08So these are great tools for somebody who's trying to maximize efficiency on
- 7:15some of these, some of these Western, that just doesn't even have to be Western, just.
- 7:20Some of these rivers that have a lot of public access where the trout have a
- 7:23bit of an education and they don't eat chubby chernobles and pat stones the
- 7:26way they the way they did years ago so the the video really speaks to that and
- 7:32thanks to a lot of the comments that we had on there because,
- 7:35i went and filmed that a bit spontaneously simply because i was personally passionate
- 7:39about trying to share that message that there there are multiple ways to approach
- 7:45and you could you could simply pick the one you enjoy.
- 7:49One is not better than another.
- 7:51And one point I made in the video, and we'll roll through a few of the comments
- 7:55that were on there, is that I hear an equal, and I'll tell you to just,
- 7:59anglers got to knock this off because it demonstrates your ignorance when we
- 8:04hear these types of comments.
- 8:05An equal number of anglers will say indicator fishing is not fly fishing.
- 8:09The same numbers say tightline nymphing is not fly fishing.
- 8:13And it's humorous to a degree, but it's also a bit annoying because in order
- 8:19to be a well-rounded angler and meet the fish kind of where they're at in.
- 8:25Any given watershed throughout the year, there's going to be times where one
- 8:30is simply going to outproduce the other.
- 8:32And I'm not a trow counter. I just like to have what I deem a satisfying experience.
- 8:37I do want to catch some fish and I also want to do it in a way that's clean,
- 8:40fast, fun, and efficient.
- 8:41And I'm not banging my head against the wall in where to do it.
- 8:44But I hear that argument all the time. And humorously, I joke that throwing
- 8:49streamers the size of Apollo's is not fly fishing. That's just lure fishing at that point.
- 8:54We're just getting territorial and aggressive strikes enough that fish want
- 8:59to chase that small fish out of their territory and attack it.
- 9:03And that's not necessarily a fly, quote unquote. Now, I'm
- 9:08I'm humorously jesting at that, but nobody ever says streamer fishing is not
- 9:12fly fishing, but God, they will just come to blows about indicators versus tightline
- 9:17fishing, which one's more pure.
- 9:18And I like both. If I had to say one is more pure than the other,
- 9:23I would kick out bubba bobbers right away. That's just a tackle item.
- 9:27And I would say, you know, run yarn because it requires delicacy, touch, finesse.
- 9:35You you have to throw a really proper casting loop in order to get distance
- 9:38because we haven't added any artificial weight to the line to to help you load
- 9:42the rod you know and frankly for a first time nymph fisherman bubba bobbers are.
- 9:47They're just easier they're going to help you load the rod at short range you
- 9:52it's okay to throw a big open casting loop because there's enough mass,
- 9:56that the line will still get you enough range whereas yarn you do need to throw
- 10:00kind of you You have to throw really tight loops in order to get any kind of
- 10:03distance. They're stealthy. They land quiet.
- 10:06They give great feedback on which way the yarn leans. If it leans one way versus
- 10:10another, it's going to tell you things.
- 10:12You get to see what's called the downshift. And I explained that in the video.
- 10:16But the downshift, when you're a really astute yarn angler, you'll see the downshift.
- 10:22And what the downshift is, is when that bug gets to depth, it engages with the
- 10:26slow water in the middle or bottom half of the water column.
- 10:29They'll actually see that yarn
- 10:31subtly get slightly deeper in the surface film and slow its rate down.
- 10:37And when you learn to read that type of feedback, and then you learn how to
- 10:41handle your line, your bends, and your casts in order to extend or prolong that
- 10:46period of time when you're in the downshift,
- 10:49you become an incredibly capable angler. So there's a really high ceiling to
- 10:55how we can manipulate yarn.
- 10:57And I've been fishing this indicator style.
- 11:00I mean, off and on, I started guiding in 2000. So it's 2026.
- 11:04So 26 seasons, I started with yarn, eventually gravitated towards tying in yarn
- 11:10with an overhand knot system, which we'll talk about as I respond to a few of the comments.
- 11:16To tying my yarn in with an overhand knot, dabbling with you know pre-made yard
- 11:21indicators i still love the the new zealand style rig where we use a little
- 11:25piece of tubing to create kind of a nipple on the bottom of the indicator.
- 11:30There that's a great system too and it it's adjustable up and down the line
- 11:35which i use some of the time i don't always use that a lot of times i just fix and tie the yarn in,
- 11:41so that there is absolutely nothing that adds water weight or weight to my leader it's just a feather.
- 11:48That yarn is so delicate and so light, so responsive. And there's a lot of really
- 11:53cool things like twitching your nymphs that you can actually do with yarn.
- 11:58You can make the yarn leaning a little bit from time to time to raise your nymph
- 12:02up in the column and then release tension to drop your nymph vertically in behind
- 12:07a rock. There's all sorts of techie things you can do.
- 12:10And film the video parts of it because I want people to be encouraged or inspired
- 12:15enough to not just try switching to yarn once or twice and just enough to hate
- 12:20it and then giving up on it because i think if you were to fish it for a year,
- 12:25and i know some of these little is little cliches get redundant a podcast but,
- 12:30if i had to prescribe somebody a fishing technique for like one year just do
- 12:34the same thing for one entire year don't,
- 12:37don't streamer fish don't even dry fly fish don't do anything else,
- 12:42just fish a single nymph under Yarent and get extremely good at it, you'd be undefeated.
- 12:50It requires that much delicacy and finesse. It just takes reps in order to get there.
- 12:54So especially like if you take out seasonal cutthroat streams,
- 13:00like seasonal mountain cutthroat streams, which lend themselves to dry fly fishing,
- 13:04really from like late May through September.
- 13:06I mean, those are, we're talking more about the year round streams that do receive a bit of pressure.
- 13:12And we don't have that kind of that luxury of consistent dry fly fishing.
- 13:16You get our dry fly fishing on a lot of these big tailwaters is really isolated,
- 13:21just low light, low light and really productive hatches.
- 13:24If you're going to be an everyday fisherman that throws a date on the calendar,
- 13:30hey, you're going to head out in November, February, March, April,
- 13:33whatever, you're going to need to, you're going to want to have some really
- 13:37good subsurface techniques.
- 13:39And it can't always be streamers. It can't always be spay. It can't always be
- 13:42dry, but it could always be a nymph, especially that single dimph rig.
- 13:46So anyway, check that video out. It got really great feedback,
- 13:50great response, even though I always fail to really capture the romance or the
- 13:55essence of what I'm trying to explain.
- 13:57But I'm going to roll through comments here.
- 14:01This is atlongjd11, and he says, love the channel and this video. Thank you.
- 14:06I really like how you're fishing the NZ indicator, and I have one question.
- 14:09Can you explain the loop-to-loop connection?
- 14:12Yeah, so I don't, there's times where I will run a tippet ring immediately below
- 14:18my yarn indicator, and oftentimes I'll put that tippet ring on an open loop.
- 14:23So I will tie a loop knot, like a non-slip mono loop, so that tippet ring is
- 14:28loose and can hinge around. So that's one way I'll set it up.
- 14:32And then I'll run a short drop line. And my goal is really to hang a pretty,
- 14:37you know, fairly dense nymph and hang it straight below that really on like
- 14:42a short leash style nymph.
- 14:45Almost like a hopper dropper, I guess. But the hinge allows that fly to sink
- 14:49really quickly. And I'll often do that in swifter currents,
- 14:53in pocket water where I really want instant drop on the nips.
- 14:56I really need to cut through some fierce currents.
- 14:58And so that's often the way I'll fish that.
- 15:01The other way I'll fish it is I will just tie a small loop.
- 15:06It could be a perfection loop, but typically I'm going to do a triple surgeon's loop,
- 15:10because a triple surgeon's loop holds so much better in lighter line, like say,
- 15:150x or say 10 pound test or less
- 15:19you really have to do a triple surgeon's loop and so i'll tie in a loop immediately
- 15:24below my yarn indicator and then i will do a triple surgeon's loop on my tippet
- 15:29end and i will loop to loop it with a handshake connection,
- 15:33and that adds a little bit of stiffness to the leader right below the indicator
- 15:38so the first few inches will be a little bit stiffer and it tends to cast a
- 15:42little bit better in the wind, tangles a little less, especially if I'm guiding, that's a concern.
- 15:47But it also can slow the sink rate down of the nymph just a tiny bit,
- 15:52especially if I'm fishing, say, four feet deep below my indicator.
- 15:56Sometimes I do want that nymph to sink a little bit more slowly as those fish
- 16:00will pick that nymph up on the descent.
- 16:03You know, as nymphs come pouring down a riffle, everything's on the surface,
- 16:07and then eventually those nymphs are going to fall out of that surface current.
- 16:11When it hits slower water which is where often trout are hold and i found the
- 16:15fall rate to the fly is is really important so,
- 16:20i just loop to loop it and then i'll i'll i'll hit on tip at length in one of
- 16:24the other comments here so
- 16:26this is in regards to that same video that that was recently posted and i said
- 16:30serious question would you have preferred to tight line that run it's a great
- 16:34question and uh the answer is too full.
- 16:38I probably would have preferred to tight line a couple of the rock piles that
- 16:41I was fishing there, like really isolated little spots.
- 16:43And if I were tight lining, I would have probably picked a couple of the really
- 16:48fishy ledges and buckets and worked much slower because I can't cover water very fast. But.
- 16:54The piece of water I fished in like an hour and a half, I covered a lot of water
- 16:58and I was really fishing it like an upstream, almost like an upstream dry fly
- 17:02approach where I could throw about a 30 to 40 foot cast back upstream,
- 17:06and I could drift down some of these longer foam lines and these longer seams
- 17:10and really hold the drift in position.
- 17:12So it'd be a coin toss on which one is more effective. And I enjoy both of them.
- 17:19Tight line nymphing I like because it's so clean when I hook fish.
- 17:23It's a tight line grab. it's instant connection with the trout there's no sloppy slackline hook sets,
- 17:29but i i still really enjoy throwing a 35 foot delicate shot with a new zealand
- 17:36style yarn indicator like up to a seam and actually hitting like really fine targets,
- 17:42like i don't really want to have to pick one but from an effectiveness standpoint
- 17:46i'd say toss up and there are days that i'll use both and.
- 17:52Indicator fish going to be much more effective than tight lining and vice versa,
- 17:56i mean really the ultimate system you know without people diluting you know what,
- 18:01what they're what they're going to learn is being being a being good yarn fisherman
- 18:07you know and and really understanding how to set the yarn up how to cast it
- 18:11well how to have enough line speed to blow the water off it and keep the yarn,
- 18:15buoyant so that you can run a smaller yarn indicator which is more sensitive
- 18:19cast better drifts better, et cetera,
- 18:21but you don't waterlog it with roll casts and bad, you know,
- 18:25just bad line management.
- 18:27So I enjoy casting the arm because I get to throw it a full line speed.
- 18:32Without an angler, you know, being diluting, you know, their educational intentions,
- 18:38because I think getting good at one trade craft is really important to stick with things.
- 18:43But the ultimate would be a Yarn Decatur fish my way upstream.
- 18:46I get to a little, and I'm having, say, you know, little to no success.
- 18:51And I come up to a very harsh ledge or a bucket. And I'm like,
- 18:54okay, I could spend 30 minutes fishing this ledge. I know there are fish here.
- 18:58That's the time I'll clip that Yarn Decatur off.
- 19:02I'll tie on one of the Egan's zero nymphing leaders. You can build your own
- 19:07or whatever. I don't care how you do it. The easy button is an Egan's micro leader.
- 19:11We sell them at Reds, big surprise. But I'll tie that Egan's micro leader onto
- 19:16the end of my tapered leader.
- 19:18And if I'm using one of my long light rods, like my Hardy Tactus or this new
- 19:23TFO blue ribbon that I've been vetting,
- 19:25even my Winston 10 foot four weight air two reach, Like any long,
- 19:30like say 10 foot, delicate three weight or four weight.
- 19:34Well, it might not be a perfect rod for fishing mono. I can still dig fish out of there.
- 19:40You need really a minimum of like a nine, nine is borderline on rod length.
- 19:44You really need 10 feet, in my opinion, to hold drifts.
- 19:49And as long as the rod is delicate enough for you to cast a single nymph on
- 19:53mono, you can, it's harder than you think. If you've never done it before,
- 19:57just take my word for it. It's more technical than you think. It is not a shortcut.
- 20:02It's a very technical tool that in the right hands is great, but you can do both.
- 20:07And then when I'm done digging fish out of a tight little bucket where I just
- 20:13can't get them with the indicator, I can't get down quick enough.
- 20:18I can't hold that nymph at the bottom half of the water column.
- 20:20Maybe I'm missing fish because they're delicate strikes. There's a bunch of
- 20:23reasons I might prefer a tight line for that spot.
- 20:26Or I might want to run a jig. I might want to run a little stream or a crayfish.
- 20:31I can easily bring that micro leader, that tight line nymphing leader with a
- 20:35cider and all that back in, snip it off, tie my yarn back in.
- 20:39In two minutes, I've set my rig back up and then I can go prospecting and play
- 20:45the coverage game with my yard decator. So I think a two-pronged approach for
- 20:49being a good technical nymphorism is the right recipe.
- 20:54And that's one reason I'm super kind of interested in figuring out how to,
- 21:00you know, both vet product but find rods that are appropriate for that crossover
- 21:05style fishing and to to this day that hardy tactus currently is the the best
- 21:10rod i found for it followed that at the top end price range and then
- 21:14that tfo blue ribbon for more of a value proposition is better especially that
- 21:1910 foot three weight the 10 foot three weight blue ribbon definitely is better for the crossover so,
- 21:25it's a good question i've got a question okay my son my son has a question for
- 21:29me here he's on the pod today how uh,
- 21:32how much different does the yarn fish than just a big foam body dry like a chubby
- 21:37or a hopper dropper it's good question.
- 21:41There's there's pros and cons okay so i think you heard the question but like
- 21:44okay why not just use a chubby chernobyl okay first off junior you're polluting
- 21:49everybody else's dry fly fishing by whacking the water with that chubby chernobyl of years.
- 21:54But in more seriousness, there are times, like especially in a light wind,
- 21:59that the belly and the hook gape of a chubby Chernobyl will hold that,
- 22:06say, indicator. It's dry flights and indicator.
- 22:09It will be stickier on the water. It will hold in a little bit of wind better
- 22:13and it will actually anchor in better for your mending.
- 22:17So there are times that it could be more effective just simply use a big dry fly.
- 22:24The difference is when it comes to like becoming like, we're talking about that
- 22:29next level, that 301 angler, where when I mend a yarn decatur,
- 22:34let's just say a strand of yarn, okay?
- 22:36I can pick that strand of yarn up and I can mend that strand of yarn very delicately,
- 22:42while leaving my nymph subsurface.
- 22:45My nymph becomes a pivot point and I can pick that delicate strand of yarn up
- 22:51and I can actually mend my strand of yarn over toward the nymph.
- 22:54And then I can generate slack to the nymph, creating a more instantaneous fall
- 22:59so I can get the fly to drop where I want, when I want, so that I can take little bites that are on.
- 23:04Another example is, so say I'm fishing, say I've got five feet a drop between
- 23:09my yarn decatur and my nymph, and I make a cast out.
- 23:13I can see that my fly is in the seam that I want, or my fly is up along a brush
- 23:18line, a log, or a cliff wall, or a cut bank.
- 23:22And my indicator is now four or five feet away from the cutback.
- 23:26My fly is near the cutback, but I really need both my indicator and my fly to be in there.
- 23:31I can take and throw a little overhand punch mend and I can punch my indicator
- 23:36in there and put it right over the top of my nymph.
- 23:38And I cannot do that with the old chubby Chernobyl.
- 23:42I'm guessing the nymph will dictate the yarn a little bit more than it can move like a chubby.
- 23:48So if the dam gets in a really slow section right along the bottom,
- 23:52it'll have a little bit more control over the indicator if it's young.
- 23:56Yeah, I got what you're asking there. So we're on a road trip right now.
- 24:00We're driving to Idaho to go fly into the backcountry on a bush plane and hunt,
- 24:06deer and elk for a week right off the river right to the car.
- 24:10So what Jensen was asking was whatever suspension device you have.
- 24:16Okay, so you got, could be anything, right? Could be Chubby Chernobyl.
- 24:20Elkair Caddis, Yarn Decatur of all sorts, or a Bubba Botter.
- 24:25There's a relationship between the nymph having control of the indicator or
- 24:29the indicator having control of the nymph.
- 24:32And what you really want is you want the nymph to have control of your suspension device.
- 24:36And the more delicate the indicator is, the more subject to manipulation it is by the nymph.
- 24:44So that's what you're asking. Yeah, like it'll stall out better.
- 24:47Like that nymph will just be moving way slower down there than if it gets ripped
- 24:51by a bobber or a big chub yeah you get your nymph to depth and then that nymph
- 24:56will will slow that yarn indicator down if it's a delicate strand of yarn,
- 25:01it's well treated buoyant you've handled it well you've kept it fluffy the the
- 25:06nymph will steer that strand of yarn around and set the pace versus the bigger the indicator
- 25:12and the more force the current can apply on that indicator the more negative
- 25:17impact the more negative input there is is going to be on the drift so,
- 25:22there's a lot to be said for the delicacy of it and,
- 25:25some of this stuff takes a while that's why like i'd encourage you like if you're
- 25:28going to do this like you you got to kind of commit to it because
- 25:32it would be incredibly arrogant for any of us and i have talked about this a
- 25:36lot with my own journey in tightline nymphing i dismissed the technique rather
- 25:40than admitting like i just sucked at it for a long time. I was in utter denial.
- 25:45So don't be in utter denial on yarn is really one thing that you have to get good at. And.
- 25:50Furthermore, like soggy yarn does not catch, like does not catch very well.
- 25:55They just don't bite it as well. I can see the difference when I'm guiding and
- 25:58we're talking thousands upon thousands of guide days.
- 26:01I have one angler who doesn't have good line speed and a good cast and he's,
- 26:06consistently got soggy yarn.
- 26:09He or she, to be totally PC, he or she
- 26:13is an aggressive mender and is just swamping that yarn with these crappy men's
- 26:18with no delicacy, no finesse,
- 26:20inevitably the yarn gets soggy, the current can pick up just a little bit more,
- 26:25have a little bit more input, those surface currents, and that soggy yarn will
- 26:28not get half the strikes.
- 26:30So I get to see it real time on what a difference it makes, whether that yarn
- 26:35can actually be dictated.
- 26:37The nymph can actually dictate pace of yarn.
- 26:40And soggy yarn does not fish.
- 26:42Make sure you treat it right, cast it right, be a good overhand caster,
- 26:46learn to false cast properly without tangling and build blind speed. So,
- 26:51Yeah, some really good questions there. All right, Alex B says,
- 26:55hey, salesman guy, in case you're wondering, that's me.
- 26:59You're not adjusting your fishing depth by sliding the yarn up or down?
- 27:03Joe, thanks for another great video. Really like your tips on mending that happened to be in that video.
- 27:09No, like Eric Nickham, that's a constant on the podcast has mentioned this a
- 27:13couple of times. Like a lot of times we're just gonna pick an average depth,
- 27:18especially if we're boat fishing. Now, this instance wasn't boat fishing,
- 27:22but we're going to pick an average depth.
- 27:24And if I had to pick an average depth nymph for the rest of my life,
- 27:27it would probably be three feet.
- 27:30I would say I'd rather be a little on the short side than a little on the deep
- 27:33side. And I'll pick an average of three feet.
- 27:36Now, a traditional, like, I don't say traditional, but like a New Zealand strike
- 27:40indicator tool kit will allow you to slide the indicator around on the leader.
- 27:45Well, that can be really handy, especially for me personally,
- 27:48like in really cold water where I've really got to work it down right to the
- 27:53deepest part and find the thermocline that the fish are in.
- 27:57It is really handy for that, but for most of my spring through fall fishing,
- 28:02I can pick a pretty average depth because in a given drift, I might encounter
- 28:07water that's 12 inches deep to five feet deep all in one drift.
- 28:10And so I'm just going to manipulate my mending and how fast I let that nymph fall.
- 28:17So there's ways to keep a, you know, slow the fall rate on a fly.
- 28:23For instance, if I throw what's called an anchor mend or a pivot mend,
- 28:27and I mend that indicator back up, and I force slack to that nymph,
- 28:30the nymph's going to fall instantaneously.
- 28:32So that wouldn't be a good idea to do with three or four feet of drop in 18 inches of water.
- 28:38So instead, I might cast out and just mend barely up to my indicator and let
- 28:43that fly fall a little bit more slowly.
- 28:45So there's a lot of fishing technique involved.
- 28:49It's not all about just having the right depth on your indicator.
- 28:53Inversely, if I'm fishing in five feet of water and I need all three feet of
- 28:57my drop, I'm going to mend it and handle it in a way where I'm going to mend
- 29:02very specifically and drop that flight directly underneath the indicator as quick as I can.
- 29:07And then I'm going to fight to kind of hold that position by slowing that indicator
- 29:12down artificially, because I know if my fly is three feet underneath there,
- 29:16it's in slower currents.
- 29:18So I'm going to put a little bit of back pressure on my indicator to try to
- 29:21hold all three feet of drop.
- 29:24So good question. I think there's pros and cons to both.
- 29:27Personally, I think I fix my tippet length more often so that I can have pure
- 29:34tippet, whether it's 5X or 6X. And I've become increasingly kind of in a honeymoon phase.
- 29:41I got a little love affair going to 6X right now.
- 29:44I've really just found it to be at quite an advantage over even five just because
- 29:49the sink rate and how fast I can get smaller flies to sink.
- 29:54But then I can run pure tippet all the way from the indicator down.
- 29:57When you slide indicators, you're
- 29:59probably approaching kind of that middle section of a tapered leader,
- 30:05where you're asking a lot of thicker line below the indicator to either sink,
- 30:11or cooperate with the fly, which thicker line does not cooperate with small flies very well.
- 30:15So yeah, I'm probably running a fixed line.
- 30:18And then there are little natural junctions during your day if i break off or
- 30:22i tangle or i'm changing flies maybe i'll maybe i'll cut 12 inches to tip it
- 30:26off if i'm if i'm coming up with a little algae or junk on my fly or i'm snagging
- 30:30or having a few more false positives on the hook set.
- 30:34I might just shorten it real quick while changing flies which doesn't require
- 30:37any additional knots i just one snip tie the other fly on and i shorten it a
- 30:41foot inversely if i need to
- 30:44to re-rig or something i don't mind just adding a little piece of tippet from
- 30:48time to time it's really not that big a deal so,
- 30:51you you can have a fixed indicator system which is my preference because i i
- 30:55want pure tippet below the indicator so.
- 30:59Yeah this was one of the best comments that we had i i thought this was absolutely
- 31:03worth sharing because i think this this this person brought up a really really
- 31:07great piece of advice that i didn't explain but once i read it i was like yeah
- 31:12absolutely that's worth mentioning,
- 31:14and uh this This is what buy from SGR,
- 31:19SGRAMMD.
- 31:21On on on youtube at times you seem to be casting straight upstream i don't nimp
- 31:27much but i do fish soft tackles upstream and always try to angle 20 degrees
- 31:32to the right or left to avoid lining the fish,
- 31:34it's a great point in the video i do cast upstream straight upstream quite a
- 31:38bit i was really trying to demonstrate a point that,
- 31:42with that with that ultralight indicator system i can land that long leader
- 31:46rig and that delicate yarn i can land that over the top of fish and get away with it.
- 31:51But a 20 degree angle, once I read that, I was like, yeah, that's absolutely
- 31:54optimal because my, my, my line's not lining the fish and it does seem to drift
- 32:01a little bit better on that slight angle.
- 32:04And, uh, the hookups do seem to be a little bit better too. I thought that was
- 32:07a really profound comment and an excellent props to that angler upstream soft
- 32:13tackle fishing is that's like, that's class act style fishing.
- 32:17I'm not very good at that. It's very hard and that's that's really cool that,
- 32:22that he does that so that's basically if i'm if i'm predicting what he's doing
- 32:25right he's just throwing a wet fly upstream long leader and fishing it just
- 32:30barely under the surface watching or sensing,
- 32:33for for strikes and that's a great technique but damn technical,
- 32:38during a hatch when those fish are feeding just subsurface right when you start
- 32:42to see especially at mayfly hatch come off yeah very cool way to fish requires
- 32:46a lot of it's a like kind of guru level skill there.
- 32:51This is a good comment here. This is from at Michael Zobrist.
- 32:55I just watched this video for the second time.
- 32:57Well, that's quite something because the thing's 35 minutes long.
- 33:00So thanks, Michael. It must've resonated with you.
- 33:02I've used yarn on occasion. I've been using three nymphs with a cork strike indicator.
- 33:07It's been productive, but tangles and just getting good drifts is a chore.
- 33:11I'm going to try using yarn with just one nymph now that I've watched your video.
- 33:14Your instructions are excellent.
- 33:15One thing I would ask is attaching the yarn to your leader, what exact the method
- 33:19to use so one three flies into corky sounds absolutely miserable
- 33:24i use corkis a little bit when i was first learning to river fish and gosh they
- 33:29do tangle having that weight on your line it's just clunky,
- 33:33a lot of weight moving objects there are three nymphs,
- 33:36i've done that once or twice in my life but you can you know when you when you
- 33:41add up the time it takes to fish a single nymph and.
- 33:45Check a cup check a spot with six or eight good drifts to feel like you've adequately
- 33:48covered it to cut that nymph off and put another nymph on is is just it's a
- 33:54great opportunity to just rest the spot that you're suspicious of where you
- 33:58feel like there's trout holding,
- 34:00give them a break for a moment throw another fly at them,
- 34:03and then throw your third fly at them and you can even start by working smaller
- 34:07to larger or lighter to heavier and you can have a system where just simply
- 34:11changing a fly, I can change a fly a heck of a lot faster than I can move spots or retie a tangle.
- 34:18So I become increasingly an advocate for the single fly rigs.
- 34:23One of the things is better for the fishery, the ecosystem. I think less flies,
- 34:26throwing less flies at fish overall is better. And I don't feel like I'm missing
- 34:31out on catching. There are times that we'll run two flies occasionally,
- 34:35but I generally plan as a single fly.
- 34:39Yeah, here's a great comment from Midwest Dad. This is pretty funny,
- 34:42actually. So I made that joke about flies the size of Apollos not being fly
- 34:46fishing, and they're just lures.
- 34:49And he asked if I just declared war on the slide end.
- 34:53No, we sell way too many of the Gallup streamers to declare war on Kelly Gallup.
- 34:59That's not a war I'd want to fight anyways, but it's just humor.
- 35:03There were some other good, like if you want to go read the comment on YouTube,
- 35:06there were actually some other really good replies to that.
- 35:09That fellow's comment. But yeah, thanks for the comment. It's funny, actually.
- 35:13Good laugh out of that. Okay.
- 35:15This is just a small comment, reinforcement, that I just want to give a shout out to FTO, FTOTF1.
- 35:22I used to river fish a lot, and yarn is the most sensitive out of any of the indicators. And.
- 35:27And then there were some really good replies to him. And I think this,
- 35:31this fellow just gets it, man.
- 35:32It's, it's, it's, it's not the shortest path to, to successful nymphing,
- 35:38but it is the path for becoming a good, really strong, independent,
- 35:42you know, bulletproof weight fisherman.
- 35:45Yeah. Oh, oh, this was a reply, I think.
- 35:48Yeah. This, there was an ongoing conversation. They were asking,
- 35:51do you have a favorite bulk brand of craft store yarn or only selling the pre-spalled
- 35:56yarn? So, yeah, good question on the yarn.
- 35:59If I were just jumping into this, just get the spools of the super performing
- 36:03hydrophobic synthetic yarn from the Strike Indicator Company. Buy it at Reds.
- 36:08We're not sponsored. Just ask a shop at Reds. We've got it all.
- 36:11But it comes on a nice, neat little spool, almost like a tippet spool.
- 36:15And then you just pull out a couple inches of yarn, cut off what you need for
- 36:18whatever setup you've got, and tie it in.
- 36:21I do have a skein of yarn that I bought at a craft store over 20 years ago and
- 36:26I'm still feeding off of that same skein of yarn,
- 36:28And it is some of the best yarn that I have used to this date I would put it
- 36:33the same category as that that hydrophobic synthetic stuff that we sell at reds,
- 36:38But what's going to happen is if you go try to buy craft store yarn You're going
- 36:41to buy a handful of skeins of this Trying to find something that one Is soft
- 36:46enough that the tippet on an overhand knot can actually bite into it
- 36:50because some of them, like the poly yarns are just too coarse,
- 36:53and the knots just come open.
- 36:55So it has to be soft enough in order for the knot to compress it.
- 36:58You'll end up kind of dinking around. You're not going to, you're going to be
- 37:02stepping over dollars to pick up dimes, you know, with the craft store thing.
- 37:06But there was a suggestion, it's called Bonnie Braid and it's commonly used
- 37:10for yarn indies. But I did type in Bonnie Braid like on Amazon and there was like 8 billion.
- 37:17I mean, it's a big, like there's a lot of options. It's a macrame yarn So I
- 37:21think you might Chase your tail on that But there you go Bonnie Braden.
- 37:25The polypropylene-style macrame yarn can work, but the indicator yarn is so
- 37:30cheap that it comes on that nice, neat little spool. I think you're going to
- 37:32be money way ahead just buying the right stuff.
- 37:35Okay, this is funny. This is the most hilarious comment of the week.
- 37:38I watched the whole video and live in trout habitat around the Great Lakes,
- 37:42specifically Lake Erie. I want to understand this terminology better so when
- 37:46I take my kids fishing, I can explain to them what's with all these words you're saying.
- 37:51I watched the podcast to see if it answered my question. like a seam, mending.
- 37:56You know all the words you say, but they don't have clear definitions.
- 37:58Thingamabob, rod hopper, hootenanny cobbler, slobbersnack, double apple over
- 38:04and sneaky linking. What are all those things?
- 38:10That is so funny. Yeah, we definitely are at fault for using a lot of slang
- 38:15terminology, but I will hit on a couple of these.
- 38:18So a bubba bobber, if I say that, i'm talking about any plastic or poly bobber
- 38:26system and that could be like dude
- 38:27that's a strike indicator it's a strike indicator it's a bobber man is it,
- 38:33sure strike indicator whatever bobber strike indicator those two terms by some
- 38:38point out those two terms are just used interchangeably we say strike indicator it's,
- 38:43If it floats and suspends your fly, it's a bobber, okay?
- 38:48A thingamabobber is just one of those bubba bobber types. It uses trapped air technology.
- 38:54It's basically like a durable balloon is a thingamabobber.
- 38:59Oros are made from foam.
- 39:01Airlocks are made from foam. They have some different features of the different types of indicators.
- 39:06I always keep a handful of those in my tackle bag in the event it's really,
- 39:11really windy or we're fishing some really heavy flies in really swift currents.
- 39:16And, or I've got beginners that don't mend or cast particularly well when I'm
- 39:21guiding and we need to keep that bobber afloat. So...
- 39:26Hopefully that explains some of the indicator terminology. Mending is,
- 39:31the definition I use for mending when I teach beginners or teach fly fishing
- 39:35for the first time is mending is any manipulation that you do to your line,
- 39:42to promote a more natural drift.
- 39:44It's a strategic manipulation of the line to aid in your presentation.
- 39:48You can mend upstream, you can mend downstream, you can make a neutral mend
- 39:53that is just simply meant to break existing tension in the line,
- 39:56but you don't really want your line, you know, upstream or downstream.
- 40:00You just want to break tension. That's a hump mend.
- 40:03It's any manipulation of the
- 40:04line that allows the fly to have an opportunity at a more natural drift.
- 40:10And I'll use the term drift loosely because we do mend even when we're fishing,
- 40:15on streamers or spay fishing because we may want to alter the path that the fly is swimming.
- 40:22So mending is done not only on dead drifting where we might present a slack
- 40:26line drift to a dry fly or a nymph, but we might also do it to a streamer because
- 40:32I want to alter the path of the streamer.
- 40:34I may see a rock pile, a log, a stick, or a shadow, and I'm like,
- 40:38oh, I need my streamer to swim through that suspicious area where Mr.
- 40:44Lunker's living, and I can mend
- 40:46my line so that my fly will then swim and intercept that suspicious area.
- 40:52So, mending is done with the rod tip, mending you can, you know,
- 40:56you may add slack to the line when you mend, that's a possibility.
- 41:00It's any manipulation of the line that we're doing. A seam line,
- 41:05that was the other non-sarcastic one here.
- 41:08A seam line is just a transition between slow and fast currents.
- 41:12And in a seam lines, when you're in water, that's just characterized as swift.
- 41:17You're looking for seam lines where they're swift against slow water when you're
- 41:21in and you want to be in that transition or the fish might have half their body
- 41:25in the slow water, half their body in the fast water. Food tends to accumulate on that edge.
- 41:30When I would characterize water as slow, I'm actually looking for more of what
- 41:34I would describe as a riptide, where there's a fastest line of current moving through a slow area.
- 41:40And that would be a different type of seam line. And then there are micro seams,
- 41:45which are not the main seam line in the strongest current, but they're seam lines that are,
- 41:51in, you know, like a subcurrent, a river within the river, if you will,
- 41:56that are like micro seams.
- 41:57So I'll just touch Touching on a few of the ones that are obvious But we'll
- 42:01try to do a little bit better job Explaining some of this stuff,
- 42:06I don't know Slobber snack Or a few of the double apple oval And sneaky linky
- 42:12I don't know those ones Nickname for a TJ hooker.
- 42:15That's the slobber snack dude I like that That might be what I name If I take
- 42:22any of my personal flies to market Man I might just poach that slobber snack This is funny.
- 42:27This is more common. Streamers are not flies.
- 42:30Fly fishing is not fly fishing. That's in response to my joke about,
- 42:36you know, streamers the size of Apollo's. You're just lure fishing. Okay.
- 42:40Comment from Don Jow, 5742. He says, thanks for this content.
- 42:46Well done. Love the yarn. Typically use Dorsey. Okay.
- 42:49One, I like what he said here because this guy gets it and it's nice to know
- 42:54there are a few, you know, a little bit of this cool following behind yarn.
- 42:58One can tuck cast through yarn, which a tuck cast, I'll start to define things
- 43:03as we go, but a tuck cast is when,
- 43:06you drop your nymph or your weighted fly on the water first and then you you
- 43:11let slack line hover down on top of the weighted fly
- 43:15so that the fly is not on tension so that it can sink more effectively that's
- 43:20tuck cast you can tuck cast the streamers you can tuck cast with nymphs,
- 43:24you can actually tuck cast with a dry fly because there's a lot of times i want
- 43:28slacker on my dry so i can tuck cast it,
- 43:31let it float several feet then mend it so that my my line might be clearing
- 43:36whirlpools or nasty currents,
- 43:38lots of reasons you might use a tuck cast and tuck casting with yarn is so much
- 43:44better because the yarn will just gently parachute down to the water right over
- 43:48the top of the nymph allowing that to nymph to really sink in place,
- 43:52so that you're not wasting any of your drift time trying to get the fly down.
- 43:57So as you get better drift feedback, you know, meaning what I was talking about
- 44:00earlier, watching for downshifts or watching that indicator lean or tilt one
- 44:05way or another so that you know what the fly is doing under the surface.
- 44:09And you can refine it for more demanding conditions like low water,
- 44:12you know, low water, spooky fish, more discriminating fish that need nothing but perfect.
- 44:18That's kind of what we have, you know, throughout a lot of rivers around the
- 44:21country, especially at the end of the season where they've had a whole summer's
- 44:24education, they demand perfect.
- 44:28He hopes to find more information or get more information, it sounds like,
- 44:32on crossover rods, because I think that's a really great, great approach is
- 44:36to give yourself the option of a couple of light technical strategies.
- 44:39Okay, moving on from that, again, do one more comment, and then we'll think about wrapping up here.
- 44:46But this was a question about a waterproof pack, and I'm going to hit this question
- 44:52because this week Fishpond is rolling out a whole new line of waterproof packs,
- 44:57and they're pretty cool.
- 44:58And I did three different reviews on the packs And those reviews will come out
- 45:03later this week sometime,
- 45:05But products set to hit the shelf in the next few days And so I just got done
- 45:09reviewing this But this was a question on an older video But it's one thing
- 45:13I should have touched on When I reviewed these other packs if I didn't I may have mentioned this But,
- 45:18one really big question about like fishing packs in general Is like do you even need a waterproof pack?
- 45:23And I cover that a bunch in those video reviews So if you're thinking about
- 45:28a new pack, you're debating, you know, you know, forking over some dough and
- 45:31getting a submersible, you know, totally waterproof pack.
- 45:34Watch those videos because I talk a lot about who might need it and the pros
- 45:38and cons because I don't think everybody needs a waterproof pack.
- 45:41And it's not just a budget thing. They're more expensive, but you may not want
- 45:46a waterproof pack. It may not be for you, but...
- 45:49May not be too smart a question, but since you were in the heat,
- 45:52any condensation inside the pack, if you were in the sun, humidity for a long period of time.
- 45:56And yeah, what happens with those packs, especially when it's hot,
- 46:00if you put anything damp or introduce any water to a waterproof pack,
- 46:05and then you zip it up and then it gets baked in the sun, it turns into an absolute sauna in there.
- 46:11And what'll happen is if I put a wet lens cloth, anything damp,
- 46:16a wet tool even, a damp fly box, anything inside contact the water and I put
- 46:21it in that pack and zip it up, that water winds up on everything in there.
- 46:26If it's your wallet, your fishing license, a dry lens cloth that you had in
- 46:30there, everything winds up humid. So it'll get 100% humidity inside that pack.
- 46:35And versus a breathable material will actually dry out in the sun and items
- 46:41inside the pack, it can actually get rid of a lot of that moisture.
- 46:44So it's a good question. And I've had absolute vapor lock on cameras before
- 46:50inside waterproof packs.
- 46:52And I'll put my camera in there. I'll get a little bit of moisture in that pack somehow, some way.
- 46:57Maybe I left the zipper open when we were jetting across the bay or going,
- 47:01you know, rolling through some rapids.
- 47:03And then that pack sits in the heat and it gets baked and it will cook that
- 47:07water right inside your lenses and it will really really dampen everything inside so.
- 47:14I thought that was a good question because those other pack reviews are coming
- 47:17out it's we're entering black friday and the winter season when everybody's kind of retooling
- 47:23it's kind of an arms race to get geared up in the off season so we hit the kind
- 47:27of hit the ground running in the spring so i'm sure a lot of you're going to be looking at packs,
- 47:31doing a little upgrade or just freshen up your kit a little bit so,
- 47:35go watch those fish bomb videos because i think it'll really help delineate
- 47:38you know whether you actually need one of those or not if it's uh it's the right gear for you so,
- 47:43Thanks for listening to the pod. We'll catch up next week after we get back
- 47:47from our big backcountry adventure to Idaho. Peace.