Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Chaos Agents: with Shannon Q. and Paulogia
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. There's video of
- 0:57this conversation if you want to watch it. The YouTube link is in the
- 1:00description box of the show. The masochist in me decided I need to invite
- 1:08some guests who are I don't know, most likely to derail the show and
- 1:14just take over because they are themselves hosts. They are strongly opinionated and really
- 1:19moral anarchists, and so I thought, well, who better than Shannon Q
- 1:25and Paula Jea. So welcome to the show, my friends. Good to
- 1:30have you. Thank you, sEH. That's a compliment, by the way.
- 1:34When I say you're most likely to just jump in and just tear things
- 1:37up. You like to break the furniture and whatnot in the best of senses
- 1:42like anarchists Ology, a host of the YouTube channel and social media pages,
- 1:49does a lot of counter apologetics. A former Christian diout Bible believing Christian.
- 1:57Would that be a fair way to say it. Paul absolutely Bible believing Bible,
- 2:00memorizing all of it. And he's one of those delightful atheists who knows
- 2:06more about the Bible than many of the Christians that he engages. And he
- 2:10has also said he is prepared to go to help to save the rest of
- 2:15humankind. And I'm coming back to that. Shannon Q's current handle on Twitter,
- 2:22which is still not X by the way, is Woke Drunk Girl.
- 2:28She's also a YouTube presenter and activist. Her probing topics include is their gender
- 2:34in Heaven? And she likes to post images of sweatshirts that say sorry for
- 2:38having great tits and correct opinions. Shannon Shannon will also not be paying more
- 2:47for burghers at Wendy's during prime time, and I think that's a moral stand
- 2:53that you should be anyway, I'm glad you're both here, my friend,
- 2:57you both Yeah, my Twitter handles always whatever the I think the funniest insult
- 3:01that comes through my YouTube channel or any other YouTube period appearances that I have,
- 3:07whichever one is the most uniquely insulting, I just take that and I
- 3:12make it my Twitter handle. That was Colin Show. I'm pretty sure at
- 3:15the Woke Drum they go after Paul and they're like, well, your argument
- 3:19sucks, or you're an idiot, or you're this, or you're worshiping the
- 3:23god of atheism. You know, they go after you and it's, oh
- 3:27my god, look at her hair. It's this weird shift that happens,
- 3:32and it has to do with your voice and your laugh and your appearance,
- 3:37and I don't know, it's just a different temperature. I'm not reading that
- 3:39wrong, am I, Shannon, No, I'd say that that's accurate.
- 3:42I'd say that most women in this space would probably share that experience too.
- 3:47It's more likely that when someone is hearing a woman talk about something that they
- 3:53disagree with or don't know how to argue against, they're going to directly attack
- 3:59them based on their appearance or based on their gender. And I just find
- 4:03it funny. So I take the power away from them by just not giving
- 4:08that any quarter in my world and just owning it. So that's why I'm
- 4:14the world structural. Forgive me. I saw somebody on online and she was
- 4:19talking about her direct message, you know, her inbox, and she's like,
- 4:25Okay, here's a guy who wants to go out. And so,
- 4:28I mean the idea is woman exists, man says she must want it,
- 4:32right, I mean, it just always seems to go down like that.
- 4:35Of course, it's a great bully tactic to go after whatever they think your
- 4:40greatest insecurity is. And so for someone like me, they try and go
- 4:45after my intelligence, assuming that that's the thing that I maybe am either most
- 4:49prideful of or most insecure about. And so I think they see a woman
- 4:55a lot of times and they imagine that the greatest insult they can give them
- 4:59is something with their appearance. Just since Shannon and I live in the same
- 5:02house, it is very strange to see the difference in our in how people
- 5:06attack us. So you're not wrong, No, you two know each other.
- 5:10I always forget no, never mind them, absolutely not that you can
- 5:13tell. Because it looks like I live in like love and light and he
- 5:15lives in a Dungeon, which is I think probably a symbolic. I want
- 5:20to get into the whole hell thing with Paul because he is prepared to make
- 5:26the ultimate sacrifice for the rest of us. First, I want to talk
- 5:29to Shannon. She deals and or at least speaks to labels. We get
- 5:34hung up on him. Here. Are you an atheist? Are you an
- 5:38agnostic atheist? Are you a gnostic atheist? Are you a hard atheist on
- 5:43the Dawkins scale? What's your number? Are you spiritual? Shannon? What
- 5:51do I do with all that? And what's your perspective? You tell me.
- 5:56My perspective when it comes to the realm of the debate over the definition
- 5:59of theism is that it's way overdone and overfocused on, and that people get
- 6:05hung up on it and try to tell each other what labels they should have,
- 6:10And I find that exceptionally frustrating. The label of atheist, if you
- 6:15own it like whatever you perceive it as for you, is what matters in
- 6:18the context of whatever conversation you're having or whatever perception you have about the reality
- 6:23that you live in. And labels are kind of something that only function inso
- 6:29much as they have like utility in this specific context. So in general conversation,
- 6:33if you describe yourself as an atheist, somebody's going to have like a
- 6:36philosophical or a psychological constructive of what that means. If they're confused about it,
- 6:42they can ask you and you can clarify. I agree that within like
- 6:46very specific realms of philosophy, you need to be more shored up with the
- 6:50terms and use them very consistently in a very specific way in that realm.
- 6:56Otherwise the ambiguity can bleed in and you're not speaking in as precise terms as
- 7:00you need to. But that's a very different realm than people who are just
- 7:04walking around day to day just deciding what to describe themselves as I'm a guy
- 7:11with atheist in the title of his channel. I understand the utility of labels,
- 7:15right. It's good to be able to sort of set yourself in at
- 7:17least a relative category. But I am struck by I don't know the reductive
- 7:24nature of it. I have people call my show and they're like, well,
- 7:26I don't know what to call myself, and I'm like, what do
- 7:28you want to call yourself? You don't have to call yourself anything. We're
- 7:31all on the journey, right, I mean life is a journey. Just
- 7:34take the journey and we'll figure out the terminology after that's fair, right or
- 7:39worse that the land on something that makes sense to them, and they'll start
- 7:42utilizing it, and if you ask them, they'll they'll clarify what it means
- 7:46the way they're using it, and it's usually lands somewhere around the colloquial understanding
- 7:49of the term atheists. But then you'll have people who are gatekeeping what you
- 7:55can call yourself because they only want you to use the terms the way that
- 7:59they're using in like really sort of like bespoke philosophical circles, and those are
- 8:03the circles that the general population travels in, so it's not the same sort
- 8:07of utility. And trying to force people into that corner where they now have
- 8:15to like use terms in a very specific academic way is I don't think it's
- 8:20beneficial. And it's also focusing on the entirely wrong thing, right, Like
- 8:24people are going through when they're deconverting quite often sort of like a gradient of
- 8:31self discovery regarding what they do and don't believe in, why they do and
- 8:35don't believe it. So having like a stringently applied label that can only be
- 8:41utilized one way that they need to like understand great deal of philosophy in order
- 8:48to be able to know that they align with doesn't seem to have a lot
- 8:50of utility to me. It doesn't seem beneficial for a person going through that
- 8:54journey. I can see how it is beneficial if you're trying to write a
- 8:58paper about somebody's position towards the existence of God and you need to use very
- 9:05definite terms that are understood very clearly in that realm, But I don't think
- 9:11it's the same thing in general society. And attempting to take it out of
- 9:13that realm and say, well, that also needs to exist here where we
- 9:18label ourselves, it just is a little bit ridiculous. And there's so many
- 9:22more, better, more interesting, more important things to focus on that when
- 9:26we consistently get caught up on it and argue about it, that seems kind
- 9:30of like a privileged position to me. To be able to spend so much
- 9:33mental energy focusing on what label somebody else should have because it doesn't adhere to
- 9:41your understanding of that label is a very privileged position, Like I'm lucky for
- 9:46you I'm so happy for you that you don't have better things to worry about.
- 9:50That's nice for you. But like, leave that person alone. If
- 9:54they say they're an atheist and you have a general understanding that that means that
- 9:58they don't believe in a God, and you ask them and they clarify,
- 10:03just move on with your day. Don't tell them that they have to justify
- 10:07philosophically the way that they're utilizing that word. You don't do that in any
- 10:11other realms. I'm not sure why we do it here. Let me bump
- 10:13over to Paul real quick. I'm sure you've got an opinion. Do you
- 10:16think some of that's insecurity? Like I call myself this, so I need
- 10:20everybody else who sort of aligns with me in terms of what opinion value whatever.
- 10:24I need them to validate me by identifying as me. Or is that
- 10:28reductive as well? I'm not so sure it's that necessarily. I think that
- 10:33it a lot of times. Well, as you know you've been in the
- 10:37realm of being a former Christian, I'm sure you get a lot of times
- 10:41Christians wanting to gatekeep who can use their label, Who is really a Christian?
- 10:45Who's not? That is a favorite pastime of Christianity is telling self declared
- 10:50Christians that they're not. I think part of it what I'm seeing, at
- 10:54least do and my counter apologists realm is that people want to make you say
- 11:00that you are a hard atheist so that they can give you a gotcha of
- 11:05well, you can't disprove God, so your position is ridiculous and to a
- 11:09Cartesian certainty kind of a level of things. And so if someone is casually
- 11:16using the term atheist, they think it's an opportunity for a gotcha, and
- 11:20if they force you to downgrade to agnosticism, then maybe there's a chance to
- 11:26convert you. That's how I see, at least from the other side,
- 11:31I see this going, and then internally it feels perhaps like it's I do
- 11:37think that we on the non belief side, and I prefer non theist.
- 11:41That's just my favorite word for it all. There is sometimes a hierarchy of
- 11:46we're the smart ones. We thought our way out of this thing, so
- 11:50we need to use the most intellectually rigorous language all the time as sort of
- 11:56this badge that we wear as we are smarter than the people who still believe,
- 12:03which I don't think so at all. I didn't gain a single LIFEQ
- 12:05point when I deconverted, So I don't know. It's it's both. It's
- 12:11both for the arguments and I think for your own ego. That's that's how
- 12:16I see it. I think it's sorry, I'm no, go ahead.
- 12:22I mean it's I told everybody you'd take over, and it's moral anarchy,
- 12:26so go ahead, go ahead. So do you think it's on two fronts?
- 12:28Though? Because I think that that's the case. I think that Paul,
- 12:31you're one hundred percent rate, and that when we're engaging with like an
- 12:35apologist, they want you to define what you believe in a very specific way.
- 12:41They want to like paint you into that corner so that they can use
- 12:45that as a way of like undermining your position. And I think maybe the
- 12:50two were even connected because there's a really philosophical atheists that exist in the public
- 12:54sphere, and they because they see that happening maybe and they feel as though
- 13:00they know how to answer that question, they possibly like genuinely want to arm
- 13:05people with the ability to better formulate their position in those circumstances so that they
- 13:13can articulate it better and kind of withstand that onslaught, but also maybe are
- 13:18a little bit frustrated that people aren't engaging in that space, or people aren't
- 13:24engaging well in that space, or at least as well as they think they
- 13:26could. So they get frustrated because they see these people, maybe even like
- 13:31us, who are engaging with apologists and not using the philosophical definitions, but
- 13:35having philosophical conversations, and they feel as though they're not well represented, or
- 13:41they're like little corner of the community isn't well represented in those instances, and
- 13:46they want thus to kind of like impose those definitions upon upon us so that
- 13:54they can be better represented, because we're kind of their proxies. Do you
- 13:58think that might be something I think that's I think those are the guys that
- 14:03gave us before I even became an atheist, the hat tipping, you know,
- 14:09Fedora. I think I think those are the guys that want to say,
- 14:15you know, atheism has to mean one thing, or agnosticism has to
- 14:18mean another. I don't know. I tend to just let people self identify.
- 14:24I think the most important thing in any conversation I have I have theists
- 14:28on all the time, Like defining terms is the first ten minutes of the
- 14:33show always because yeah, if you're just, and I'm willing to take almost
- 14:37anyone's definition in any word as long as we're just using the word in the
- 14:41same way. We need to move on and each conversation you have to ask.
- 14:45It's tedious, but you have to ask that question every single time.
- 14:48What do you mean by moral? What do you mean by right? What
- 14:50do you mean by Christian All? Just? I don't know. It's sure.
- 14:56I mean clarification I think serves everybody. It being the want of a
- 15:00language I don't find to be helpful, just in general. I don't know
- 15:03why I started with kind of a dry, sort of a clinical question,
- 15:07like I should have sort of segued it, you know, we should have
- 15:11dipped a toe into the shallows and ask a question like do you put salt
- 15:16on watermelon? Which, of course the answer is always universally yes, you
- 15:18must always salt watermelon. No? No, no, I'm sorry, I'm
- 15:26sorry. Do I have a watermelonline? Do I have a watermelon philistine in
- 15:31my midst? Because this we will fight. I have watermelon here in my
- 15:35fridge. I've never even contemplated doing that. Oh, it's pretty good.
- 15:41What is that never mind, I'm going to leave it to the comments.
- 15:46I don't like it happening. I'll try it after maybe. How can you
- 15:50eat watermelon without you have to say I'm agnostic about it? I've never had
- 15:54the experience. But are you an agnostic atheist? Are you a seeker?
- 16:00Are you on a journey about salted watermelon? I believe in salted watermelon.
- 16:06You're unconvinced actually has salted water the assaulted watermelon and melon hiddenness. She was
- 16:12unaware of it until I say, you know what, she's a salted watermelon
- 16:17denial it. We all believe in salted watermelon, even the people who don't.
- 16:21Don't want to get to that apologetic in just a second. Uh,
- 16:25Paul, you said that you are willing to like be Elsbeth and Dragon Slayer.
- 16:30You're willing to stack the lottery and go and endure the dragon fire.
- 16:34You are willing to go to Hell to save all of humankind. Talk to
- 16:40me about this particular statement and its context, if you would. Well,
- 16:45you missed the important opener, and that is that I'm not particularly a fan
- 16:51of people. People aren't my favorite. I don't universally love I am not
- 16:56all loving all benevolent. I tend to be a bit of a loner,
- 17:02but I often think about divine hiddenness when I'm out walking my pup and when
- 17:07I'm just doing around the house. Divine hiddenness, for me, is the
- 17:10strongest argument, and it still weighs on me a lot that if there's a
- 17:15God that wants to have a relationship with me, the prerequisite is that I
- 17:19know he exists. So anyway, the other day I was thinking about how
- 17:23you know, for God so loved the world, and that the greatest love
- 17:27is that one lays down his life for his friends. But I thought about
- 17:33this undertaking. Well, no, it's actually I think it's merely pragmatism.
- 17:37I think that myself, who doesn't even love every human, who doesn'tually necessarily
- 17:44like every human, I still would happily for the sake of billions of other
- 17:49humans, not only endure the torture and the death, but also do the
- 17:55descent to hell, just out of pragmatic I have a number of chldren in
- 18:00this world, and even just if for them, but I would do it
- 18:03even if I didn't have kids. Just I think out of pragmatism, most
- 18:07of us would do that. And we celebrate that in movies, we celebrate
- 18:11that in stories, people who sacrifice themselves for people they don't even know.
- 18:15And it doesn't take the greatest act of love in the world to do this.
- 18:21But it's even worse, of course for God when you lay on that.
- 18:25When Jesus did that, he knew after three days he was going to
- 18:27be exalted to glory. I wouldn't even be exalted to glory. I'm willing
- 18:33to just go and be the lone human in hell, you know, so
- 18:37that everyone else can have the party. And I'm guessing most people listening to
- 18:41this, if they thought about it, would also give their life in this
- 18:45way. So it's maybe this narrative we've been told about how this is the
- 18:52greatest act of love ever, isn't so great? It's funny On Good Friday
- 18:59every year, I insist on posting that meme that says, shout out to
- 19:03Judas for the long weekend. I don't know why. I just always thought
- 19:07that was funny. Still to come, we're going to talk about morality.
- 19:11If you don't know God, how do you know that rape and murder are
- 19:15wrong? If you crawled out of the muck, where would your moral compass
- 19:21even come from. Oh I'm going to talk with my guests about that after
- 19:26this. My patrons get this broadcast early and commercial free, and your support
- 19:38is so appreciated. Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews Continuing my conversation with fellow
- 19:48activists and friends Shannon Q and Polagea. Shannon Q, you recently engaged in
- 19:57a debate on YouTube with an activist an apologist named Duncan Atheism. Oh,
- 20:04dear God, that's what I said, most watched debate I've ever done.
- 20:11That's what I said after twelve minutes of watching. Duncan Atheism is also known
- 20:17by some other names. But just set that up for me, if you
- 20:22would, Shannon, Okay, so this was a little while ago. He's
- 20:26mostly known on the internet as Darth Dawkins. That's the most watched debate I've
- 20:30ever done. I've done several, but this is the most watched by fire.
- 20:34I don't actually consider it a debate. What happened was there's a channel
- 20:37called Modern Day Debate. He was supposed to be debating somebody else. That
- 20:42person backed out about like an hour before they were supposed to do the show.
- 20:48The show have reached out to me and said, would you be willing
- 20:51to do it? I said, I don't really do debates, but I'm
- 20:52happy to have a discussion. I would like to talk about, you know,
- 20:56if he wants to talk about why I don't believe most of my non
- 21:00belief hinges on the soul. That was like kind of my deconversion Lynchpin or
- 21:04morality, So let's talk about the soul. I went on to talk about
- 21:10that and progressed okay for a brief period of time, and then it clearly
- 21:15descended into it was very obvious that he was a presuppositionalist who really wanted to
- 21:22get me on a script and not actually talk about the topic of conversation that
- 21:26I was under the pretense we were going to be there to talk about.
- 21:32No, it didn't take long before he was like, oh, your performance
- 21:34today is absolutely abysmal, Shannon. You know, it's almost like you should
- 21:38be embarrassed for how you have represented atheists today. But he said something interesting,
- 21:44and I'll let you speak to this. He was saying, the reason
- 21:47you can know anything is because it was revealed by God. And you're like,
- 21:51well, hang on, how would you know? It was a revelation
- 21:53if he had not yet revealed it to you? Was I reading that?
- 21:57Right? How do you make the decision or how do you realize or acknowledge
- 22:03the revelation that you were getting if you can't know anything without God's revelation?
- 22:07Right? Right? That's what I thought was circular, because he was saying,
- 22:11basically, like the base of precept is that you know, like all
- 22:14the laws of logic, everything, like God is the base for that.
- 22:18But you have to justify that somehow. And the way that they seem to
- 22:21justify it is to say that it was divine revelation. But if it was
- 22:26divine revelation, to be able to know that it was divine revelation, you
- 22:29would have to just have like an infinite loop of divine revelation. And that
- 22:33kind of seems like nonsense. That doesn't seem like a solid founding. It's
- 22:36just an assertion. But he wasn't interested in exploring that. More so,
- 22:41his tactics seemed to be, or at least his rhetorical strategy seemed to be
- 22:45to abuse people, to put them on the defensive, and then once they
- 22:48were on the defensive, he could use that emotional reaction in order to kind
- 22:52of present them as maybe not as strong intellectually as him. And I picked
- 22:59up on that fairly quickly and realized I wasn't going to be able to have
- 23:02an honest conversation with him. So instead of trying to have a dialogue,
- 23:06because it was clear that that was disintegrating into nothing, I decided that I
- 23:10was just going to amuse myself basically and point out all of his rhetorical strategies
- 23:15to the audience as we were going. So it was a teaching moment.
- 23:19It was a preaching moment. Well this is people enjoyed. I don't know.
- 23:23Apparently it was a really no, it was never a dull moment,
- 23:26Shannon, when you're on and I get paul In on this one a little
- 23:30bit. I'm struck by the precept leap presupposition. I guess we need to
- 23:36define it. But the presuppositionalist always speaks in terms of these deistic, nebulous
- 23:42watchmaker first cause, the one who set the guidelines, the objective moral standard
- 23:48in place, and we can only know right and wrong because we are referring
- 23:52or leaning on that standard. But that's not a theistic argument like the William
- 23:57Lane Craigs, etc. Who get in to this first cause business and the
- 24:02objective moral standard business. Then they just they take this grand canyon size jump
- 24:08over to their specific God with a proper name. That's been your experience,
- 24:11palder Am, I do you know some people who've actually managed to or try
- 24:17to connect dots in some way? Oh? Yeah, No, I think
- 24:19you're talking about the leap of like the column cosmological argument, for example,
- 24:23really only proves that if you accepted it as sound and valid, that you
- 24:30would all you'd get to is that the universe has a cause. There is
- 24:33no dot dot dot therefore God. Now I'm gonna need to have you define
- 24:37kalam for those who may not be aware, because we're all speaking insider knowledge
- 24:41here inside. There enough terminology. Go ahead. When I say column cosmologic
- 24:45agreement. That's a label that has put on actually a family of arguments that
- 24:49basically wants to insist that everything that begins to exist has a cause. The
- 24:55universe begins to exist, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is ultimately
- 25:00the extent of disarguments. But Christians and Muslims and Theists often will wield this
- 25:07as if that gets you to a god and then you know, as you
- 25:11mentioned, secondly, to their specific flavor of Jesus that they prefer, and
- 25:17so obviously that's not going to work. I think the other thing you were
- 25:21alluding to was that oftentimes the presuppositional art argument really doesn't even get respect from
- 25:29other Christians a lot of times because it goes a step further than what you
- 25:32said in that they say not just that you can't know right and wrong,
- 25:37but you literally can't know anything. I can't know that there's coffee in this
- 25:41cup unless God at one point in time revealed to me that the universe is
- 25:47here. So they go that whole one step further. And that's what makes
- 25:49conversations like that Dark Dawkins one, and the way Shannon exquisitely handled that better
- 25:55than any pre conversation I've ever seen, is so frustrating because it gets so
- 26:00assively circular. They can, well, how do you know that? Well?
- 26:02How do you know that? Well? How do you know that?
- 26:03They They they terminate the infinite regress by just saying that God told them,
- 26:10which of course is ridiculous because, as Shannon pointed out, there's no mechanism
- 26:15in our brains to tell us that our maximum level of certainty is just our
- 26:21human maximum level of certainty, or that God came down and gave us that
- 26:26certainty. That's the thing. There's no mechanism to tell the difference. So
- 26:30that's the whole swirl. And so watching Christians fight Christians is a hobby of
- 26:34mine. So presuppositionalists camp not necessarily that respected compared to And they're the same
- 26:41arguments, says you pointed it ultimately, but the the high falutint Ivory Tower,
- 26:47the William Lane, Craigs and the other academics in these fields, they're
- 26:52ultimately not really giving that a different arguments. They're packaging it more intellectually or
- 26:57less intellectually. I mean, how much of that is just freaking word salad.
- 27:02I was reading an article by apologist I don't even know if he's still
- 27:06alive, and he's been doing it for half a century, Norman Geisler,
- 27:10and it's just I mean, it's all of these lofty terms, and it's
- 27:14you know, it's apps. It's like this, Well, now we have
- 27:18to get all exegetical because the Bible is not enough. So let me explain
- 27:21what God really meant in the Bible. But it does raise your question one
- 27:25who's Frank jerk is the one that's carrying on the torch for Norman guys I
- 27:30see guys Er. Somebody google that is Guysler. Still, never mind,
- 27:33it's not important. The ideas are important. Do we have some? I
- 27:40mean, how do you know murders wrong? How do you know rape is
- 27:42wrong? Is there an objective do you believe in objective ethics? How do
- 27:47you approach that? I don't even know who to start with. Either one
- 27:49want to jump in. We talk about this all the time, Paul and
- 27:53I because I think morality is one of the most interesting subjects to get into.
- 28:00I don't think that there's like an objective morality that exists in the ether,
- 28:06And even if there was, we don't We wouldn't have access to it,
- 28:08so it would be functionally useless. I think morality is the term that
- 28:11we give to our ongoing discovery of how to best interact with each other in
- 28:18society to all of our mutual benefit. That's what I think it is.
- 28:25I don't say, and I think that once you define it, like once
- 28:26you give it that term, you can do objective things to reach those goals.
- 28:32Like if you define the term morality as doing what's best to reduce harm
- 28:37and increase flourishing. If it's some combination of those two things, and I'm
- 28:41sure there's more nuanced than that, that would be like a ten thousand foot
- 28:44view, really really high level. Like, once you have that definition,
- 28:47you know that that's the goal, then you can do things to objectively reach
- 28:51that goal. But I don't think unless you agree upon that goal, which
- 28:56unmass most of us kind of do, that there's like an objective morality that
- 29:02exists out in the world. Well, let me play to your background in
- 29:06psychology real fast. If somebody comes to me and they're like, well,
- 29:10right and wrong, how do you what's right for you? If you were
- 29:12to harm somebody else and it benefited you, then that would be right for
- 29:17you. I mean, so you can go and steal from someone else because
- 29:22it benefits you and for you, and that would be right. How would
- 29:25you approach somebody who's saying that it's all relative and there can be no true
- 29:30right or wrong. Well, they're making the locus an individual. They're making
- 29:34the locus one individual person instead of trying to extrapolate it over a societal skill.
- 29:40If you extrapolate it over a societal skill, then that no longer is
- 29:44the case, because what might seem right for you or what your desires are
- 29:48don't translate onto the broader society. Because if we existed in a society where
- 29:53people were killing each other and stealing each other other things, that society wouldn't
- 29:57exist for very long. It wouldn't be tenable. So morality, if you
- 30:03define it as what's best for an individual, has that problem. But if
- 30:07you extrapolate it over a societal scale, then that problem no longer exists.
- 30:11And in fact, making an argument like that would seem trivially silly, because
- 30:15you're just saying an individuals should be able to do whatever they want. An
- 30:19individual is a component of that society, not the entire society, so it
- 30:23falls apart immediately. Well, Paul, let me come over to you.
- 30:27How would you address this? I mean, how would you determine right?
- 30:30How would you know that not salting watermelon is moral? How would you make
- 30:36that conclusion? Well, I guess I can go back to when I was
- 30:40a theist, when I was a kid. It's interesting that Jesus gave us
- 30:44the actual only two important commandments, and the first ones irrelevant because it doesn't
- 30:48matter. But when I was a kid, my parents actually would say,
- 30:52if you think about individual action you would want to do, just think about
- 30:56would you want to live in a society where everyone made that everyone made that
- 31:00choice, and if you wouldn't want to live in a society where everyone made
- 31:04that choice, then it's not the moral choice to make. Now that's very
- 31:10simplistic, but it plays to you know that it talks to what Shan was
- 31:15saying to society versus in general. I do think right and wrong are absolutely
- 31:19labels that people put on outcomes they prefer or yeah, outcomes that they prefer,
- 31:26or actions that they prefer or disprefer. We all do that, and
- 31:30it's the intuition that we have about what moral means and what right and wrong
- 31:36means that plays into the apologists or the Christians or the theist's hands, because
- 31:41it's one of those words that everyone brings to the table their own meaning about
- 31:45it, but we all just kind of into it that we're talking about the
- 31:48same thing, but we aren't necessarily so you can again, it's one of
- 31:53those words that if you pin someone down and try and make them define it.
- 31:56For example, if someone wants to define that morality is what God says,
- 32:00which was what some people tells me. Well, then we don't actually
- 32:04agree on what morality is, so I don't need to come up with an
- 32:07ontology for your morality because I don't even think that's the right way to define
- 32:14it. So they don't really mean that, though I'm a chaos agent.
- 32:17I'm sorry, but I don't think that they really mean that when they say,
- 32:20like the prescriptives who say that morality is just what God says, I
- 32:23don't think they mean that because if you ask them explicitly, like outright,
- 32:28if you say, okay, can you explain why something is right or wrong?
- 32:30They'll start to give justifications that fit within the framework that I just laid
- 32:35out, where you know, we're looking at societal harm and societal flourishing and
- 32:44we're trying to reduce harm and increase flourishing on a societal level. They'll start
- 32:47to give justifications that exist within that framework. So they're acknowledging the existence of
- 32:52the framework when they're making the argument to justify their position. But really,
- 32:57at base their position is God said, so therefore it's moral and it requires
- 33:00no more justification. But they find themselves providing those justifications because they intuitively know
- 33:06that it needs to exist within that framework. So I don't actually think that
- 33:09they really mean it when they say that, do you think I'm wrong about
- 33:13that? Or at least they don't realize that they don't really mean it.
- 33:15Well, I would agree that they that when push comes to shove, they
- 33:22actually want to be able to just say that, yes, torturing babies for
- 33:24fun is wrong in some kind of they want to appeal to the subjective sense.
- 33:31Of course, they want they What they'll say is, you're talking about
- 33:37epistemology, Shannon, not ontology, right, And so they'll say, well,
- 33:42we don't get caught in the weeds. The sophisticated ones, we'll say,
- 33:45we don't get caught in the weeds of how we determine the ethics and
- 33:47how we determine what's right and wrong. What we care about is this,
- 33:52you know, just where did it come from? And so they kind of
- 33:54leap frog over all that. I realize, I maybe those in the audience
- 34:00who don't know what the Jesus has. Two commandments were that I was referring
- 34:02to. The first is love the Lord your God, fall your heart and
- 34:06your soul in mind. And the second is like it, you know,
- 34:08love your neighbor as yourself. And I think that largely when you're talking to
- 34:13Christians, if you just kind of get them to say, well, let's
- 34:16not talk about the God part because that doesn't affect how we talk to each
- 34:20other, and if we can just talk about empathy, then they actually do
- 34:24kind of get stuck in exactly what you're talking about. Then they're stuck justifying
- 34:29why a lack of condemnation of slavery, or why women don't can't speak in
- 34:34the church, or like all of these kind of things they kind of get
- 34:37tripped up on. I'm interested in the people like two syllables reductive, they
- 34:44like a bomber sticker, and we're all we can all be guilty of this.
- 34:46I've seen atheists. I've seen people across the color and culture an opinion
- 34:52spectrum. We want simple, We wanted to fit in a byline. But
- 34:57Stan Barker up at Freedom from Religion found talks about morality in terms of minimizing
- 35:02harm. And I think we as human beings can into it what harm would
- 35:07be because we can relate to harm to us. But was it Sam Harris,
- 35:10who had written a book called Lying or It's something like that, where
- 35:15he was like, it's always wrong to lie, and you and I listened
- 35:19to that, were like, well, we need to be creatures of truth.
- 35:22Well I buy that on the surface, But is it ever moral to
- 35:25lie if you minimize harm? And the example I like to use indulge me
- 35:31is an abused spouse shows up at your door, my husband wants to kill
- 35:37me. Can you keep me safe? And you bring her in and lock
- 35:40the door, and you say, go in the back room, We're going
- 35:44to keep you safe. And then her husband shows up at the front door
- 35:46of the baseball bat and he says, is my wife here? And you
- 35:50say, no, you have lied, but you have acted to minimize harm.
- 35:57And so I mean, these are nuances that seem to disappear in the
- 36:01reductive, you know world that we live in. Shannon. I heard you
- 36:06say something, Yeah, I don't know you. I don't want to get
- 36:07lost too much in the weeds here. But would you agree that that's the
- 36:12moral thing at that point? Yeah, of course it is. And I
- 36:14think within the framework that we're looking at, it makes sense because you're couching
- 36:17it against the context of the individual circumstance. So there aren't any like absolute
- 36:23absolutes within that framework. There's just now, shalt not bear false witness.
- 36:29Right if you say, don't break you, I broke that commandment. But
- 36:32but right in this framework though, right, because this framework you like,
- 36:37which I why I think it's it's the better framework because I can easily justify
- 36:43that because I can say he was going to cause harm to her. That
- 36:45takes precedence over the lying. The lying is is the lying is bad because
- 36:50the lying causes harm. Like if you're lying to people, that is harmful
- 36:54to them. You are giving them false information on purpose likely to benefit yourself,
- 36:59and they're going to be incorrect decisions or determinations as a result of you
- 37:02misleading them. That's a potential harm to them. That is why lying is
- 37:06wrong. Within the framework that we're talking about, that you can say why
- 37:10lying is wrong because it's harmful in that situation, that lie isn't causing harm,
- 37:15it's preventing harm. So contextually there's nuance, and that's okay because the
- 37:22world is messy. People are messy, circumstances are messy, and you should
- 37:25be able to make micro adjustments to your behavior while existing within that framework without
- 37:31having to deal with the ridiculousness of absolutes. But in their framework, you
- 37:37do have to deal with the ridiculous of absolutes, I think, and you
- 37:40would have to come up to some dissonance in that situation because you have to
- 37:45both hold the position that lying is always wrong in every single circumstance and there
- 37:50is no exception because it's an absolute, and then also justify why in that
- 37:54instance lying is okay. And I've seen people have that conundrum put in front
- 38:00of them and they've actually just said, you know what, Nope, I
- 38:05would have to tell the truth, which is crazy to me. Like that,
- 38:08that is a bad framework. That is a framework that is going to
- 38:10lead to her right because it exists in absolutes. It doesn't allow for nuance,
- 38:15it doesn't allow for contextual analysis. That's not good. I don't know.
- 38:22Do you disagree with me on that or am I like? Am I
- 38:24batchit crazy? But that seems to me like it makes sense. No,
- 38:29No, those two things can exist in the same space. You can be
- 38:32crazy and you can I can both be right and crazy. Apaulagia, did
- 38:37you have anything before I moved to I just like to go, yeah,
- 38:39I like to throw into the example of for example, Rayhab, who's considered
- 38:44a hero of the faith in Hebrews eleven. And you know, but Rahab
- 38:49lied to keep the Israeli Israeli spies safe as they were, you know,
- 38:52going in and and now you know, she's considered a hero of the faith
- 38:57by the time the New Testament comes around. So even the Bible itself is
- 39:00incredibly inconsistent. And that's a general problem for as I delve in the Christian
- 39:07realm, is that a lot of times you can pull up versus to support
- 39:12virtually either position right, and you name the position. I used to even
- 39:15play the game on back in COVID days, where you know, you give
- 39:20me a position and I'll find versus to support either side of the issue.
- 39:24It's not that the Bible consistently condemns lying. That's the problem. And so
- 39:30you can find versus where of course it does condemn lying. Rahab live and
- 39:34she's celebrated. So when you are looking to a compilation of sixty six or
- 39:39however many books you consider canon, you are going to find problems. And
- 39:44that's why I think the meta ethic that Shannon was talking about is a far
- 39:50superior moral framework than a biblical interpretation when it's convenient. The same book told
- 39:57people that there should be slaves, as the abolitionists used to say that there
- 40:01shouldn't be slaves. That's a problem for that book isn't useful at this point.
- 40:08So anyway, those are my thoughts. By the way, I want
- 40:12to say for those watching on video, I feel a kinship with Shannon because
- 40:15we're both drinking out of a coffee cup the size of a crock pot.
- 40:20I saw you lift that thing and I was like, can you lift that
- 40:22with one hand? I was given this by my stepdaughter, and it's this
- 40:28massively. It's just huge. But I'm like, you know, some days
- 40:30you just have to pan down the java, and then there are some days
- 40:35that's lovely. Okay, we have this in agreement. I think all three
- 40:42of us. We look at the philosopher wildly popular and really we made him
- 40:51rich, the philosopher Jordan Peterson, and we wonder when his mind turned to
- 40:57rice pudding, like what was the moment of demarcation? Would either of you
- 41:01like to talk a little bit about the phenomenon of Jordan Peterson and your perspective.
- 41:07I'm not a great fan of Jordan Peterson. I think that his rhetoric
- 41:13is harmful, and I wasn't a great fan of his book. So I've
- 41:17read what is it called Twelve Rules for Life or whatever. I actually read
- 41:21that book because I was intrigued because he caused such a big stink up here
- 41:27at UFT and he's a Canadian guy, and he's a psychologist, and that's
- 41:32my field, so I wanted to kind of read his book. I didn't
- 41:36like a lot of the ethics of his book, like he was using very
- 41:40clear examples of patients that he had like almost like case studies in the books,
- 41:45and ethically, I didn't think that that was great because he was using
- 41:49a lot of descriptive information that would have made it easy to uncover who those
- 41:52people were. Min Is that a hip a violation you think, or is
- 41:57that one of those gray areas. I think it's a great area because he
- 42:00wasn't using their real names, but he was absolutely using like real details about
- 42:04their life. And I think that that for the same reason I don't like
- 42:08doctor Phil for that reason, like using patients or using people's mental health in
- 42:15order to you know, turn a profit in the public space just ethically.
- 42:20I have personal issues with that, and I didn't I didn't like it at
- 42:23all. And he was actually making admonishments of some of his patients, like
- 42:29which if the patient read the book, even if nobody else could figure out
- 42:32who that patient was, if the patient themselves read the book, and we're
- 42:37reading his personal opinions about them and his admonishments and how they were, he
- 42:42was using them as demonstration for demonstration purposes, for like, you know,
- 42:45how not to be in specific instances that would be directly harmful demonstratably so to
- 42:52them. And I did. I didn't like that. He's got some,
- 42:55you know, really bizarre arguments for the existence of God. He talks about
- 43:00the word salad, stuff, the metaphysical substrate. What the hell is a
- 43:07metaphysical substrate. I don't know what to do with stuff like that. It's
- 43:10kind of those deepities that a lot of the apologist use. I don't know,
- 43:15Paul, did you have any thoughts or well? My thoughts are that
- 43:19I feel like I don't understand why Christians in general or theists in general support
- 43:25Jordan Peterson and promote him in the same way I don't understand why they would
- 43:29promote a Donald Trump in that Neither of those men. Jordan Peterson, as
- 43:34you said, when he's asked a God related question, he punts as if
- 43:38he can. He does not want to answer that question, I think,
- 43:40because if anyone found out his true opinion, he would lose half his audience
- 43:45because he doesn't really believe it. The other thing he's doing, which I
- 43:49do not agree with at all, is advocate that because religion is a useful
- 43:54fiction, because he finds utility in it, that therefore it's good and let's
- 44:01let it prosper. I find that any way that Jordan Peterson professes that religion
- 44:08is useful, there are secular alternatives that do less harm. So why are
- 44:13you promoting this delev into mythology? And that you know, Joan, I
- 44:19interpret Jonah as this great you know, reawakening experience and all the all the
- 44:23ways he spins these stories for that crowd that he's talking to. And of
- 44:29course you know he's now in that right wing sphere, and so he can't
- 44:34come out and say, now, I don't believe this stuff. It's just
- 44:37it's it's useful to fool you people who are listening to me, why people
- 44:43celebrate that and by therefore you know, prop him up? Baffles me.
- 44:47I don't. I mean, do you have thoughts like why well I promote
- 44:52this guy? I? I don't. I've been blinking my eyes at the
- 44:55evangelical right in this country for or and more every day, to the point
- 45:01where it's almost like I'm about to have a stroke. But I am interested
- 45:07in something you brought up. So let me take that stream off the river,
- 45:10the idea, and on the surface, I get it. Religion provides
- 45:17community. There are lovely, wonderful, moral, kind, good people who
- 45:23are Christians, who are Muslims, who are Hindus, etc. The structure
- 45:30gives them comforts community. There are efforts that are charitable. They want to
- 45:38be inspired, they love the music. Does religion that has a supernatural component
- 45:46to it? Is there any context where you think, yeah, maybe it's
- 45:51okay, Maybe maybe it gives people comfort in a tough, difficult, often
- 45:55cruel world. Or is it always a cheat? I've said often in the
- 46:00past, and I'll say it in the future, and I'll say it now
- 46:02that if religion was completely innocuous, if it wasn't harmful, if it didn't
- 46:07attempt to enact harm onto society. You would nobody would even know my name,
- 46:10You wouldn't have heard from me. I wouldn't have said a word,
- 46:14but I would have just gone I would have just changed my belief system and
- 46:17just walked off into the sunset and gone about my life. But it does
- 46:22absolutely cause harm, and it's demonstratably causing harm that like that just one hundred
- 46:27percent is the case. Like we can see it, we talk to people
- 46:30about it, we can watch it manifest in society right now because religion is
- 46:35attempting to very much permeate like politics and the social structure, and that's causing
- 46:40harm to people, and they're talking about it. It's a very different question
- 46:44of could it be Could it be something that is just innocuous, Could it
- 46:47be something that's just not harmful? And I think maybe if you don't take
- 46:54it seriously would be my answer to that. If you're if you're not fully
- 46:59invested in really believing it to the nth degree, then maybe it won't be
- 47:06harmful. But Christianity is based on a book, and that book has harmful
- 47:13components to it. You know things about slavery, things about grape, things
- 47:17about misogyny, things about societal structures that aren't great, and that's always going
- 47:25to be the case because it's immutable. It's not going to change. So
- 47:30I don't think in and of itself, if it's taken seriously, it can
- 47:37ever not be harmful. But I think that people can invest in it two
- 47:40degrees that make their belief just kind of non a non issue, if that
- 47:51makes sense. I think there's gradients of it. It's like when I see
- 47:55and I'm so thankful always say this and forgive my listeners, Please forgive me
- 48:00for saying it for the thousandth time. I mean, and I've had some
- 48:04of them on the show, devout believers, they love them some Jesus,
- 48:07and they genuinely align with me. They call themselves they identify as Christians,
- 48:12and they have five Bibles in their house, and they probably quote Scripture and
- 48:15go to Sunday, go to meeting, right, But they have decided they're
- 48:20going to skip over the parts where God judged LGBT people, you know,
- 48:23and had the sodomite stone and children executed and the rape victims forced to marry
- 48:28the rapist after the dad was paid off. And hell, I don't believe
- 48:31God would ever make hell. So they've kind of custom fitted their own religion.
- 48:35And then whenever we see the Christian nationalists going ape shit in this country,
- 48:38they say, well, that's not true Christianity. And it's one of
- 48:43the biggest gripes I have right now with the moderate Christian because I think they're
- 48:50trying to distance their religion from the fundamentals of the religion. I'll throw it
- 48:58out there, Paul, I guess I'll start with you. Yeah, and
- 49:00I take a harder stance on all this. So Shannon said, you,
- 49:02you know, if religion didn't do active harm that you wouldn't know are I
- 49:07would still be out there absolutely, even if you could show that you know,
- 49:12practicing these religions is entirely benevolent, because I think that it's impossible not
- 49:17to do harm when you have an epistemology that takes on false ideas as true.
- 49:27That now, perhaps if someone ever came up with something uniquely religious that
- 49:30there is no secular counterpart for, fine, they will have a discussion.
- 49:34But I've yet to come across that example. So as long as religion is
- 49:37just one way to do it, the fact that you are espousing and teaching
- 49:42your children some kind of way of thinking of making decisions about the world that
- 49:47takes in unwarranted supernatural beliefs or any or you know, anti science beliefs.
- 49:54These permeate, these become when you start thinking this way. It's the kind
- 50:00of thinking that made me think that the earth was young for so much of
- 50:04my life, for example, and therefore because I needed to think the Earth
- 50:07was young, I needed to think about that. There's massive conspiracies in scientific
- 50:14and intellectual fields, and you just start bringing on board, Oh, maybe
- 50:17I shouldn't go to the doctor like you just there's ways of thinking that lead
- 50:24to harm because of the way of thinking that it's propping up the social benefits
- 50:30of religion. So I am going to be out here even if you find
- 50:36this benevolent version of any religion that you're still practicing, because to me,
- 50:40I care about whether it's true or not. And once we've talked about whether
- 50:45it's true or not, then let's talk about whether it's harmful or not.
- 50:50I want to talk about the best and worst from the apologists and the best
- 50:54and worst from atheist activists, because we don't always get right. We'll cover
- 51:00that next. Thank you. So much for listening. Talking here with Paula
- 51:13Gea and Shannon Q, both former believers and now activists who run their own
- 51:19channels debunking the bonk and helping other people to do the same. Okay,
- 51:25let me throw this out since we're going to attempt more nuance. People have
- 51:30a difficult time with this, But the perpetrators of bad ideas can at the
- 51:37same time, in the same space be victims of bad ideas. And I
- 51:44am amazed at the resistance. I get to that when I someone goes out
- 51:49and they're a Christian nationalists and they are I don't know, they're doing and
- 51:52saying really pretty bad things. Many aren't aware of the environment they came out
- 51:58of, the conditioning, the ductor nation, the cocoon, you know,
- 52:01the shell, the conspiracy stuff that they that is their normal. When did
- 52:07we lose the ability to say, yeah, they're doing great harm. But
- 52:10we also need to understand the the antecedents, right with the things that came
- 52:15before that produced the agent of harm, and then see them also as a
- 52:20victim. All right, Shannon Bird some psychology at me on this one.
- 52:27I think it's just a matter of we want to be able to point to
- 52:31the harmful person tied and condemn them, identify them as harmful, and then
- 52:38distance ourselves from them, like we an't want to be able to find a
- 52:42villain, And in the age that we live in now, like in the
- 52:44information age, it's very easy to find a villain. Like instead of people
- 52:50just being you know, someone off in the distance who might have an idea,
- 52:53but someone like you, you could you can be faced with them consistently,
- 52:58so you feel that harm more directly on a broader scale. So you
- 53:02want to like just get away from that person because you see them as doing
- 53:08harm. You don't really see them as, you know, just a human
- 53:12who's multifaceted. You see them specifically as someone who's causing harm. And I
- 53:16think for that's that's kind of a valid position to have, because you shouldn't
- 53:21have to put yourself in harm's way. But I do think that it does
- 53:23go to the nth degree because I think that we kind of break off into
- 53:27factions, and because we've broken off into factions, we've become increasingly polarized,
- 53:34and that increasing polarization causes insulation in the groups on both sides. And that's
- 53:43what I think is dangerous. And that's where I think that the dehumanization comes
- 53:45from, because dehumanization happens when we see people as a member of an outgroup.
- 53:50And now we're very much forming different factions that we can clearly identify as
- 53:55out groups, giving them labels, and then seeing every everybody within that oat
- 54:00group as somebody who is bad just definitionly because they belong to that group.
- 54:07Now, imagine if someone had stumbled across me when I was a Rush Limbaugh
- 54:10listener, right, but when I read Anne Coulter and watched Fox News and
- 54:16you know, went to and did think we were one nation under God.
- 54:19And I always think I wonder how I would have been treated if Twitter would
- 54:22have been around. Then, you know, would someone have loved the grenade
- 54:27over the wall at me and written me off and said I had to be
- 54:30crushed, I'm a lost cause I'm an idiot, or would they have made
- 54:35an attempt to try to engage the flesh and blood, three dimensional human being.
- 54:38And I've been guilty. Now, I don't give quarter to like the
- 54:42cesiopaths. I'm Ted Cruz, Marjorie Tay. I'm not talking about those people.
- 54:45I'm talking about the every days Paul you went to weigh in on this
- 54:49one before I move on. Sure. Well. One of the things that
- 54:52frustrates me greatly is when Christian or when people on my side of fence,
- 54:57non believers want to say you can't those people can't be reasoned with or they
- 55:01can't change their mind, and I stare blankly if I'm like, I am
- 55:05single digits of years out of this, and of course I like, I
- 55:09changed my mind, so I was as hardcore as it as anyone. I
- 55:15think you feel probably the same way, and that you know we were able
- 55:19to come out of this, so I have to jump in real quick,
- 55:22Paul, hang on. So if I come to you and I show you
- 55:25the meme that says you cannot raison people out of a belief they weren't reasoned
- 55:30into to begin with, you see that and the vein on your forehead pops
- 55:37out Like I have that reaction too. Yeah. No, I think that
- 55:40is absolutely ridiculous, because you think of any position you just hold without without
- 55:47scrutiny, of course, evidence will should be able to there's some level of
- 55:52evidence that can bring you out of anything you hold, whether you hold to
- 55:57it rationally or not. So yeah, I don't don't like that at all,
- 56:00And I think one of the things that I try and do, and
- 56:01I one of the things I love about you, Stef, is that I
- 56:05am for me. It's still so fresh that I can't help but have empathy.
- 56:08And I do think that in some ways I was a victim, both
- 56:13a victim of my community and things, but I also got to confess I
- 56:19was a self victim. I kind of bought into the black and white thinking
- 56:22and built my own cage around me. I ended up becoming more fundamentalist,
- 56:25I think, than the people around me due to my own misplaced ideas.
- 56:30So that empathy, man, I just I want people to feel comfortable talking
- 56:37to me and for me to never lose that notion that we are all just
- 56:45a product of the information that we're given and the environment that we have.
- 56:49I mean, obviously it's genetic components, but that someone is hopelessly lost on
- 56:55either side of the fence, is that it's not true. We need to
- 57:00empathize and we need so victim is the wrong word, but I do empathize
- 57:05with someone who can hold these ideas, and I hope I never lose that.
- 57:09No interject so sorry, I want to. I just want to say
- 57:14something because I think when we have this conversation, we tend to focus on
- 57:20the polarization, and that is important to like focus on an analyze. There's
- 57:22nuance, for sure, but also I like, I think that what people
- 57:29are getting at when they have this discussion is, you know, people are
- 57:31being unreasonable and they're saying people are bad on the internet or in person,
- 57:37and they should be doing something different. But it's it's also worth pointing out
- 57:42that a lot of these people are actively causing harm and it's not up to
- 57:45the people that they're harming to talk them out of that. I mean,
- 57:50it's okay if you're if someone's hitting you with a bat, just say that
- 57:53guy's hitting me with a bat. Somebody should stop him right like that the
- 57:59harm or I need to get away from him, and nobody else should go
- 58:02around him. He's hitting people with bats, right like you wouldn't You wouldn't
- 58:07chastise somebody or admonish them at that moment that he was wailing on you with
- 58:10the bat. Would not be the moment that a victim would say, tell
- 58:14me about your childhood. Can you speak to me about the cultural influences that
- 58:17brought you to this moment of violence, you know your reaction must be different,
- 58:22right, Yeah, I don't think that it's as black and white as
- 58:27like even we initially were talking about, because, like what I said is
- 58:30true, there's nuance and that we are becoming more polarized and we are out
- 58:34grouping like at a rapid breakneck speed, and then that does make it easier
- 58:37for us to just other people entirely and kind of strip them of their humanity,
- 58:43and that's a bad thing. But also if people are doing bad things,
- 58:47the people who they are doing those bad things too, or encouraging society
- 58:52to you know, push down, it shouldn't be up to them to know,
- 59:00have respectability discourse with them, to be like, okay, well,
- 59:05I guess the onus is on me to see your humanity even though you're not
- 59:08seeing mine, and have a rational discussion with you. Great for the people
- 59:14who who are capable of doing that, who want to do that, I
- 59:16think that there's great benefit in that, But that is not a reasonable expectation
- 59:22to have any of everybody in that circumstance. Does that make sense, yes,
- 59:27because I think there's nuance that needs to be explored. If you want
- 59:30to actually get to the root of the issue, and that's an important component
- 59:34to the conversation about it. Shannon, you were never religious, Do I
- 59:37remember that right? No? I was an Anglican. I was competitively religious.
- 59:42I was the first altered girl in my church. I was confirmed into
- 59:45the faith at eight years old. And I was the only female altar girl
- 59:50at eight years old at my church. Because I'm not sure if you're aware
- 59:53of this, but if someone tells me that's not things the girls usually do,
- 1:00:00I say, hold my beer. I'll be right back after I'm done
- 1:00:02doing it. Well, then good, I get to ask this question.
- 1:00:08I'm keeping you along that I anticipated, but we have what we call momentum
- 1:00:14in broadcasting, and I'm just enjoy you and I could probably chat all day.
- 1:00:20Do you look back at the shit you used to believe and the further
- 1:00:23you get away from it, it becomes more ridiculous, like exponentially day by
- 1:00:30day, and you think, how in the world did I ever hold that
- 1:00:34belief? Do you have that feeling? And is there a specific belief or
- 1:00:39three that fits that category. You're going to get such different answers from both
- 1:00:44Paul and myself. I want them I'll start with Paul, come on,
- 1:00:47you're freshly, relatively out of the faith. Do you look back more and
- 1:00:52more and go what the fuck? Well, obviously, the ones that are
- 1:00:57most actively embarrassing for me are the sciences related beliefs that I held. So
- 1:01:00for example, that you know, humans and dinosaurs were definitely around at the
- 1:01:04same time and they are, and the flood definitely happened, and the you
- 1:01:07know, the earth is six thousand years old, like, those are the
- 1:01:10ones that are a little more actively embarrassing, right and and and I've definitely
- 1:01:16looked back and ashamed about that. A lot of the other things. I
- 1:01:24think we kind of opened this with we talked a little bit about how,
- 1:01:28you know, yeah, I would make this sacrifice. Now, the more
- 1:01:30I think about atonement and and sin and this the whole human endeavor of selling
- 1:01:37us that we're sinful, which is a weird concept, that we've somehow we're
- 1:01:43somehow harming a god that can't be harmed and that that demands retribution like that,
- 1:01:50the more I think about those nues is those are the ones that I'm
- 1:01:52now kind of like, man, this this just doesn't add up. But
- 1:01:55I was, but the praise songs were kind of glossy or all of this
- 1:02:00stuff. But you know, I'm with you. I think the more we
- 1:02:04delve into those details, now you know the one that gets me. And
- 1:02:07I'm shocked I didn't pick it up. Well, I think you brought up
- 1:02:10the commandment thoush out love the Lord Thy God, and I thought, how
- 1:02:15can you command someone to love someone else? Right? I mean you it
- 1:02:20realized that you love someone, but how how how does compulsory love even work?
- 1:02:27And it never even occurred to me, Oh, I should go love
- 1:02:30God, but love doesn't work that way. I'll let you jump in Shannon
- 1:02:35beliefs beliefs that I had prior. I had a very different experience in Paul
- 1:02:40because I was never in like a fundamentalist type of faith. I was an
- 1:02:43Anglican. So what I'm the most embarrassed about is the fact that I didn't
- 1:02:47hold my faith to scrutiny at all. So I realized that I was holding
- 1:02:52embarrassing positions. After I started to try to become more faithful, like a
- 1:02:59bad thing happened to me and I turned to religion because as you do right,
- 1:03:02as you're told you're supposed to up, that's what you're supposed to do
- 1:03:06when when you need help is you're supposed to turn to God. So I
- 1:03:09turned to my Bible and I started actually reading it for the first time,
- 1:03:15and that's when all the questions started coming up, Like when I got to
- 1:03:17jumpthah and I was like, oh, okay, so God loves human sacrifice
- 1:03:20because that guy just killed his own daughter. So like God, that's a
- 1:03:22human sacrifice, right, So why that's not good? And then I got
- 1:03:28to numbers and I was like, oh shit, God causes abortions. If
- 1:03:31you suspect your wife maybe cheated on you, you can just you know,
- 1:03:37God will just take the baby rate out of her. So how am I
- 1:03:42holding this position on abortion? I'd realized that I wasn't scrutinizing anything. What
- 1:03:46I'm the most embarrassed of is that I just allowed a faith to be placed
- 1:03:51in my head without question and believe leadership instead of formulating my own opinions.
- 1:03:57And I will never do that again. And I'm raising a child who will
- 1:04:00ever do that. I'm raising a child who will formulate his own opinions.
- 1:04:03Who I'm teaching him how to think, not what to think. And I
- 1:04:08live a massive portion of my life being taught what to think and just accepting
- 1:04:14that without even realizing that I was until I actively attempted to hold it to
- 1:04:19scrutiny and see how it compared to the reality around me. So what I'm
- 1:04:23the most embarrassed about isn't a specific belief, It's how I lived my life.
- 1:04:29That's what I'm the most embarrassed about. That mind frame that I was
- 1:04:32in, that mindset where I just allowed someone external to me to tell me
- 1:04:38because I've believed that they had authority what I should believe. That's all right
- 1:04:44here at the last couple of bullet points, and you don't have to answer.
- 1:04:49But I'm looking for, is there an apologetic argument that you think,
- 1:04:57actually, that's not bad. I mean that it's correct. But is there
- 1:05:01an apologetic argument where you're like, well, actually, that's an intelligently reasoned
- 1:05:05question or challenge that we can engage with. And what's the apologetic argument that
- 1:05:12makes you want to put your head through drywall and scream? So I'm looking
- 1:05:15for is there a best and worst as far? And I'll start with pologia,
- 1:05:19because Paul, you engage apologists and those arguments all the time. Is
- 1:05:24there one that impresses you, and then one or two that make you crazy
- 1:05:29impressed. No, I do think that the one that I understand why it's
- 1:05:33compelling is the fine tuning argument, because it does obviously we are in this
- 1:05:41universe where we exist, and why is there something rather than nothing? I
- 1:05:46guess ultimately becomes that question. And if you're the kind of person who just
- 1:05:53needs to keep asking why one more time every time something's happened, Ultimately,
- 1:06:00I don't think any scientists or myself or anyone can satisfy you. And just
- 1:06:04saying well, maybe the universe is a brute fact, just like God is
- 1:06:08a brute fact. I get how that's not internally satisfying. So that that
- 1:06:13whole fine tuning argument wise or something rather nothing not not terrible in the same
- 1:06:18way, and that that's that's more of a yearning questioning type thing, as
- 1:06:25opposed to putting forth some kind of terrible syllogism. Maybe come back to me
- 1:06:30for the worst one. I need to think on that for a second.
- 1:06:31Well, you've got quite a rolodex, you know, going through the works
- 1:06:38of kin Haam and William Lane Craig and Frank Termine apologist to me and I
- 1:06:43personally would like to throw them all in a van and then just let him
- 1:06:46fight as they drive over the You know, I'd send him to Canada,
- 1:06:49but you'd send them right back to me. Shannon, Do you have a
- 1:06:56best or worst or both? I actually I'm gonna align with Paul. Is
- 1:07:00the fine tuning is the one to me that like, I can understand how
- 1:07:03it's adopted, So I'm not going to extrapolate or sorry, expound upon that
- 1:07:09because Paul kind of explained it. The worst one to me is actually when
- 1:07:13we talked about earlier, and it's the column because it's functionally just like walking
- 1:07:16up to me and going the universe has a cause And I'm like, okay,
- 1:07:20cool, now what and and because it's like it doesn't connect the premises
- 1:07:27to the conclusion at all. It's just like the conclusion is just an assertion
- 1:07:30the universe has a cause, therefore God caused it? Eh? Eh,
- 1:07:34like that what are you guys doing? Like who looked at that and was
- 1:07:40like, fine, like this cop exists, therefore God is functionally the same
- 1:07:44argument. I just think it's ridiculous. I think the one that gets me
- 1:07:50is science has proven the Bible. I mean or they'll make a claim like
- 1:07:55that and then they just go like, hey have an I stay and there's
- 1:08:00an assumption the Founding Fathers were all Christian. You know, there's zero digging,
- 1:08:03there's zero research, or they you know, pull up a website by
- 1:08:08David Barton, who's a pseudo historian who happens to agree with them. It's
- 1:08:13these weird claims that only exist on the surface. There's been no actual digging.
- 1:08:17They don't know why God's in the pledge, they don't know why God's
- 1:08:21on the money. They don't know the positions of the Founding Fathers, or
- 1:08:25maybe they deify them even though they didn't allow women to serve in government and
- 1:08:29own slaves and we're far from perfect human beings. And I just feel like
- 1:08:32this is you know, they make a claim and then they congratulate themselves and
- 1:08:36leave. That makes me crazy. Back to you, Paul, did you
- 1:08:40find one? Yeah? So the few that are kind of related, like
- 1:08:44Blind Watchmaker just always just makes me incredibly angry because probably because I definitely fell
- 1:08:49for it, not understanding how science works. But no, the worst one
- 1:08:54of all is look at the trees. It's just there, there's enough evidence
- 1:09:00Romans one. God gave us enough evidence that you do know that he exists,
- 1:09:06and I know your thoughts better than you do, because my book tells
- 1:09:09me that you know, you you really believe, So you're just suppressing the
- 1:09:13truth and the righteousness. To me, that's the absolute worst one, because
- 1:09:16the only thing that we can know for certain, better than we even know
- 1:09:23we exist, is the content of our thoughts. We don't know if our
- 1:09:26thoughts are true, but we know our content of our thoughts better than anyone
- 1:09:30else can. And if you're coming at me and saying my book tells me
- 1:09:34that the one thing you know is wrong, well then no, you're I'm
- 1:09:40justified in saying no, your book is just wrong. Your book doesn't know
- 1:09:44that I know that God exists. Well, hang on, so are you
- 1:09:47saying that they are making the claim that even the atheist believes in God,
- 1:09:51we're just in sin and denial. Absolutely, that's the very common Just everyone
- 1:09:59just everyone knows that God exists, and you're suppressing the truth of n righteousness
- 1:10:04is the phrase that they like to use, and that, Yeah, so
- 1:10:08they do assert that literally every human on the planet who's capable of thinking knows
- 1:10:15that God's exists in their hearts. God has given us enough evidence is divine
- 1:10:19qualities, these visible qualities, divine nature. It's written on our hearts.
- 1:10:25And because the Bible says it's written on our hearts that we know that God
- 1:10:28exists, the Bible can't be wrong. So therefore, Paul, the thoughts
- 1:10:33that you know that you have are wrong. You really do believe you're suppressing
- 1:10:38somehow. So that's I get that one all the time, and it's my
- 1:10:43least favorite. There's I think they call that in creation and in conscience.
- 1:10:47God is revealed all around you. You'd have to be blind or stupid or
- 1:10:51just in denial or lying to ignore the fact of God and the Designer,
- 1:10:58the Creator, the fat they're all around you. Last thing, I'm going
- 1:11:02to start with Shannon again, what are we doing poorly as activists? Maybe
- 1:11:10even counterproductive? What are you seeing out there in the ether. You're like
- 1:11:14me, you're on the front lines, and there are things that frustrate me
- 1:11:16about some of the tactics. What do you think we're doing well or need
- 1:11:21to do more of? And what do you think is counterproductive and we need
- 1:11:25to walk away from? I don't know, Shannon, you want to start.
- 1:11:28You wanting to pund over to Paul real quick, I'll give you a
- 1:11:30chance. I've got some clear answers. Okay, we need to do more
- 1:11:33community building and creating spaces for people that are going through deconversion, so that
- 1:11:41because people are coming out of religion all the time and it's difficult for them
- 1:11:45to find their footing and this is a bit of a space that's kind of
- 1:11:48chaos. It's not just all activists or chaos. It's not what I'm saying,
- 1:11:53but like the space when you come out of religion is difficult to find
- 1:11:59your footing on when you're kind of like rebuilding everything about your perception of the
- 1:12:04world and eu epistemologies. So I think we need to do a better job
- 1:12:09of creating spaces for people who are deconverting and just creating broader community as people
- 1:12:14who are non believers. Just in general. What I think that we're doing
- 1:12:20a good job of right now is kind of making some of the arguments seem
- 1:12:30tired. Like a lot of people who otherwise wouldn't have been familiar with things
- 1:12:33like divine hiddenness or the column are now more exposed, like granted somewhere between
- 1:12:42like a rudimentary level to like an expert level, like somewhere in that gradient.
- 1:12:45But a lot of people really understand the counter apologetics a lot better because
- 1:12:50we have so many different types of communicators in this space looking at it from
- 1:12:55so many different perspectives. Now, because this space is becoming more dise and
- 1:13:00more varied, with all different types of educators in all different types of different
- 1:13:04fields really coming to the forefront, I think that that is starting to happen
- 1:13:10a lot more, and I think that that's I think that's great. I'm
- 1:13:14seeing less of and I'm thankful I still see it. But in the meme
- 1:13:17verse, you know these zingers. Science flies you to the moon, Religion
- 1:13:23flies you into buildings, and there's always the Twin Towers, And I'm like,
- 1:13:28you know, science has also created thermonuclear web. I mean, I'm
- 1:13:33saying this reductive idea that science could not ever or has not ever been misused,
- 1:13:40or that people have not been able to use a religious model to do
- 1:13:43something else, even though the foundations are incorrect. It's so freaking reductive.
- 1:13:47Religion is a mental illness. There's a page on Facebook called Religion is a
- 1:13:54mental Illness. I had a whole video on that it's pinned. It's pinned
- 1:13:58to the top of a YouTube channel. Pisses me off the most. I
- 1:14:01was not mentally ill when I was a just makes me crazy, shin it
- 1:14:05makes me great, Like there's nothing about my disposition, personality, intellect,
- 1:14:14nothing about that changed the moment I realized that God didn't exist. But functionally,
- 1:14:18what you're saying, and this is why it's wild to me, is
- 1:14:21that I was mentally ill and then I changed my mind about something and that
- 1:14:29cured my mental illness. That's what you're saying, which is bananas. Okay,
- 1:14:36it's bananas and completely unhelpful. It's functionally like saying, well, if
- 1:14:42you have chronic depression, you can just you can change your mind one day
- 1:14:45and just not have chronic depression. Because that's that's the model under which I
- 1:14:49think mental illness operates. That you can have it, change your mind about
- 1:14:55something, and then not have it anymore. That's the position you have to
- 1:14:58hold, and it's it's I went into way more detail in the video it's
- 1:15:01pinned to the top of my channel. I went through the DSM. I
- 1:15:05went through all of like a bunch of history of mental illness. What the
- 1:15:10definition of religion is and how it's used in the field, why it does
- 1:15:15and doesn't apply, all of it in great detail, and still in the
- 1:15:20comments section after I lay it out and put all the resources down and like,
- 1:15:25here's the links, here's all the papers, here's the actual DSM,
- 1:15:29here's the ICU, here's all of the stuff that you need to put this
- 1:15:32together for yourself. People were literally still saying, I don't care what you
- 1:15:36say. I don't care what you say. Several of them assumed I was
- 1:15:41religious and came and I'm assuming probably didn't even watch it because I say I'm
- 1:15:45an atheist within the first ten minutes of the video, and they're like,
- 1:15:47y know, you religious people close religions, so you didn't even watch it.
- 1:15:51You didn't crazy to me, well, I mean, I think it's
- 1:15:57really an evidence of our own humanity, the idea that we think as higher
- 1:16:01primates and quote unquote you know, skeptics, etc. That we are immune
- 1:16:06from bad ideas or reductive thinking. I'm doing a whole speech on this later
- 1:16:11on in the year that gets into many of the things I think we do
- 1:16:15that are counterproductive. You can't go on a religious page and tell everybody grow
- 1:16:21up and expect everybody on the page to be like, you know what,
- 1:16:26I am really an intellectual infant. But now that you've done this drive by
- 1:16:30and told me that I am, I'm going to now become mature. It
- 1:16:33just I really really get frustrated. I think the thing that I'm seeing more
- 1:16:39of that I love, is we are educating people about identity beliefs, Why
- 1:16:45people rally and defend and why we have this visceral emotional reaction to identity.
- 1:16:51What is an identity belief? What's the psychology at play? How do you
- 1:16:57know make the crack that lets in the light understanding that kind of thing epistemology.
- 1:17:03I'm seeing more of those discussions. I'm trying to lead more of those
- 1:17:08discussions. I'm encouraged by that. I think that's one thing that I'd like
- 1:17:13to see, certainly more of Paul Best and worst. You got anything for
- 1:17:16me? I just maybe it's a counter to some of this stuff, is
- 1:17:20it? It's tough to know where the line is because I know in my
- 1:17:23own deconstruction journey, I needed Bill Nye, but I also needed George Carlin
- 1:17:30and Ricky Gervaise too intelligently poke some fun at you know, the Sacred Cows,
- 1:17:40as you've once put it to Seth. Now let me jump in,
- 1:17:42Paul, though, Is that the difference, Like, because I go hard
- 1:17:45at the ideas. Hell, I made the story of Susie video right,
- 1:17:48going after the ideas and saying it's safe to do so, and going after
- 1:17:53the person who holds the ideas. Would you draw a line of demarcation between
- 1:17:57the two. I absolutely would. But I I fear that sometimes when we
- 1:18:01say these kind of things, when I get my audience coming back to me
- 1:18:04is like you're you're wanting to tone police or you want everyone to use my
- 1:18:08tone. And I don't think that the tone that I use. While I
- 1:18:12think it it was a refreshing voice at the time, there's more a lot
- 1:18:15more like it now. I do think that all tones are needed. But
- 1:18:20I do love the what you just specified there. That the sarcasm, the
- 1:18:26biting, the attack is not at the intellect or the character or you know
- 1:18:32all not be smirching. You're right, it's it's to make fun of Well
- 1:18:36this, how would this arc idea even work? Or you know, do
- 1:18:41these ten commandments make sense? But I do think there is room for as
- 1:18:46you said, just for all tones, so that I don't think there's one
- 1:18:49right way to do it. Even though I choose to never swear, because
- 1:18:54I kind of Christian I was would have stopped listening when I hear the first
- 1:18:58F word. Well then you know, I'm just Everything after that is white
- 1:19:00noise. I do understand why sometimes more passion, you know, is a
- 1:19:06complimentary thing. So I do. I guess love that we are getting more
- 1:19:12of those voices. And as you say, I would encourage going after the
- 1:19:15ideas, I'm going to adopt that. Now that's a great So you defer
- 1:19:19the swearing to Shannon. So it's like cosmic equilibrium taking place there. We
- 1:19:28have fun debates in our house as to whether the Christian that I was would
- 1:19:31have thought that the Christian that Shannon was was a Christian. We we go
- 1:19:34back and we role play our old versions, and we definitely wouldn't have thought
- 1:19:39that each other were Christians in these own ways. It's it's kind of fun.
- 1:19:42Oh. The one we did was I'm sorry, you're Catholic. Oh,
- 1:19:45I thought you were Christian. We totally didn't like, Oh, Catholics
- 1:19:49are definitely Christians, you know, And then you see the splintering in the
- 1:19:55faith. I'm sorry you a Southern Baptist or a free will or an independent
- 1:19:59bat Baptist. You know, so infinite regress again. Yeah, we once
- 1:20:04had a twenty minute argument in our house about the appropriate way to take communion,
- 1:20:09both of us as atheists. We're arguing about the appropriate way to take
- 1:20:13communion because it was I didn't realize how vastly different it was at my church
- 1:20:18versus at his church. I was like, what do you mean you pass
- 1:20:21around a tray and like you eat a piece of bread, like you get
- 1:20:25a tiny wafer. You have to go to the altar, you have to
- 1:20:28sit in a certain way, you have to use a certain cop you have
- 1:20:30to say a specific prayer, you have to like you don't just you don't
- 1:20:34even stand up. I was like, I was mortified. I was like,
- 1:20:38what do you mean you don't even stand up? You just sit there
- 1:20:40and passively receive it. But then he thought that mine was crazy and that
- 1:20:45we were worshiping idols, and it was just it was twenty minutes of two
- 1:20:49atheists who will never take community again in their life, arguing about who's church.
- 1:20:56I think we had a Baptist Church, and they had they actually brought
- 1:21:00out right in front of everybody boxes of saltine crackers. So it wasn't even
- 1:21:04like the little holy looking wafer. It was we knew, well, this
- 1:21:08isn't the body of Christ, this is the body of Nabisco, lightly salted
- 1:21:13and hand it out to everybody. I don't know. I would be curious
- 1:21:16to be a fly on the wall during most dinner time conversations at your house.
- 1:21:21I don't see a ton of small talk. I don't do I get
- 1:21:26that vine does everything become a commentary on the culture and philosophy and religion Shannon
- 1:21:30needed. Shannon's had some just some difficult days at work these last few months,
- 1:21:35and so I spend my days trying to find videos like why feminism,
- 1:21:43Why the Bible says that feminism is wrong? Videos for Shannon to to get
- 1:21:46aligned with. This is this is the kind of thing you can just do
- 1:21:49to wait, wait, you purposefully light that fuse. You just say this
- 1:21:54is me on purpose on a daily basis, because he likes to watch me
- 1:21:58go off. Literally. I came home and work last night after we had
- 1:22:00dinner, and he was recording a video. After that when he came out.
- 1:22:04He put on I don't know if you know this podcast. It's called
- 1:22:06Standarrees, and it's this guy, Great Kocal, who I just he wrote
- 1:22:10a book called Tactics that I really don't like because it's just about how to
- 1:22:13manipulate people. Anyway. I don't like this guy and I don't like his
- 1:22:15institution. But he did a podcast specifically on why feminism is bad, basically,
- 1:22:25like somebody asked a question to him, which was, I have a
- 1:22:28friend who doesn't want to teach their child, their female child, about Christianity
- 1:22:32because they think it's against feminism. And he just went off about the most
- 1:22:35ridiculous shit for like twenty five minutes, and I just drank wine and at
- 1:22:40Paul will pose it and just listen to me yell, and then I'll walk
- 1:22:43away and I'll come back and you'll play it again. And that's how he
- 1:22:45likes to spend his time. It's just winding me up, watching me lose
- 1:22:49my shit and wander around the house screaming, and he just sits there and
- 1:22:54that's like, I'm his entertainment for the evening. And we talked, so
- 1:22:57you're both agents of chaos. It's the fucking Gary Haveermass book for like three
- 1:23:02and a half weeks when he bought that goddamn thing into the house. The
- 1:23:06motherfucking Gary Haveermass book. God damn that Gary haveermask. It didn't mean to
- 1:23:12get her started. I didn't mean to, no, but we are a
- 1:23:15weird couple. I think if that was your impression that we're a weird couple,
- 1:23:18you are on the money. No, i'd fire and ice. I
- 1:23:23love it, and I just love you both to death. You're so smart
- 1:23:27and I love your approach. And I've said this to you privately. I'm
- 1:23:30not just saying it for the benefit of the audience to make it sound more
- 1:23:33lofty than it is. I appreciate the fact that you are nuanced and you
- 1:23:38see people in three dimensions, and I think you were interested in discussions more
- 1:23:42than shouting at each other, and that's refreshing. So links to both of
- 1:23:46your channels, Shannon c Apology, get in the description box. Hopefully we'll
- 1:23:50get a chance to bump into each other on the road, and I will
- 1:23:54try to make a list or get a list from you, Paul of things
- 1:23:57not to bring up to get Shannon to her head explode over dinner or maybe
- 1:24:01we will. I don't know one or the other. I'm going to have
- 1:24:04to my moral anarchist is going to have to have that discussion before we meet
- 1:24:09again. Thank you both for coming. Great to talk to you. Thank
- 1:24:12you, SEV. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete
- 1:24:16archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking
- 1:24:20Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free
- 1:24:27thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.