Latest / Falcon Forward / How to Handle a Surprise $60K Insurance Audit
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: All right. welcome to Falcon Forward. I was making sure we were actually recording. so we're live in the moment, but you'll be listening to this later. excited to talk. So today's topic is going to be I guess we're diving back into some of the insurance details. So this is gonna be an educational session if you're in the insurance world or just wanna learn more about insurance, but our topic is gonna be audits. So we were talking before this about a particular scenario that we're gonna kind of raise and and walk through. we I actually had this this conversation, exact conversation with two of our newer brokers in the in the last week. So when I saw that this was the idea, I was excited. So anyways, Mike, how are you doing? And I'm I'm excited just to dive in. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, I'm I'm doing fantastic. you know, when we put together these podcasts, the idea is we want to create these for our employees as well as for prospective employees, people are that are thinking of joining our firm. and the idea is what is something that we're working on that came across our desk that required us to do, you know, put on our insurance thinking hats. You can see Peter and I are both wearing our thinking hats today. Peter Brecht: Yes. Mike Tanghe: and came out to a positive outcome for the client that wasn't readily appeared. So with that, we thought we'd talk a little bit about your client gets a large audit. Like, what do you do in that situation? So I can jump in and give a little description of something that came up with names and details changed to protect the innocent if you'd like. Peter Brecht: Let's do that. I think that's a good start. Mike Tanghe: Awesome. Okay, so we had a client that we'd written for a very long time, number of years. And it represented a substantial account, so they were paying in the hundreds of thousands of dollars of premiums. they had several different divisions with their company, and they had kind of a smaller, like the you know, represented a fraction of their total premiums was a a property management group that they had. and we had written that with a same carrier for a number of years. That carrier based the general liability. On payroll, so very common to for general liability carriers. They're either going to base it on payroll sales, square footage is another common thing that they would do or number of units. But in this case, they're based on payroll, and it was with a again relatively small policy that was not audited. So the carriers, you know, almost all contracts will say we reserve the right to audit, but an account has to be a certain size and premium for the carrier to expend the cost of actually doing an audit. And that's kind of goes carrier by carrier. So the situation was we'd written it with this account for that carrier with a very long time. That carrier non-renewed. So again, something that happens, you know, fairly frequently on things. So, okay, no, no problem. We're independent brokers. We got a whole bunch of options for these folks. So we went out to the market and we found another carrier that said, hey, yeah, we like this class of business and we'll write it. So we sent over the expiring information to that carrier. We got a quote from that carrier. and coverages were equal or better. Pricing was, you know, in the same ballpark. Everything looked good. And we issued the new policy. That was done three years ago. And so that carry again has the right to audit. Remember that hadn't been done in prior years. And that carrier is one of those that, you know, most carriers, if they are going to audit, they're going to do it right after. So you even may get the documents before your policy expires. This carrier, for Peter Brecht: Okay. Mike Tanghe: whatever reason, sometimes they take a little while to do so. And then they're pretty lax on letting insureds respond. So one year goes by. That policy should have been audited. on it. We have our next period. That goes by. That 12-month period goes by. Now we're midway through our third policy year with this carrier and that audit from that very first year is finally getting completed. And what what what's kind of escaped everyone's knowledge was the rating basis from the previous policy, the previous carrier, was rated upon payroll. Again, fairly common to do. And remember that policy had never been audited before. So the customer would give their payroll number each year and pay their premium and that was it. What what kind of escaped some people's understanding was that the new policy was rated upon sales for this this company. And so now we're one, two, we're in the third year of this policy. They're finally auditing that first year policy, and what was a 10 grand premium? All of a sudden our customer got a bill in excess of sixty thousand dollars for that audit. and so you know, when something like that happens, just you know, put yourself in your producer's shoes. like what's the reaction there? it's typically not a good one. not something that people are super excited to see and you know my gosh you kind of go through the whole range of what is this right and so if you're in that position you know you wrote this policy for 10,000 you've since renewed that policy two more years and you get a sixty thousand dollar bill like what do you do? what what's that next step? So what I thought we could do is we'd run through if you're in that same position or similar position, what things can you do to help out your client? Help out yourself in your own stress level and then hopefully Peter Brecht: Yeah. Hmm. Mike Tanghe: retain that account, which if we spoiler alert, we were successfully able to do in this situation. So so Peter Brecht: There you go. Mike Tanghe: first thing you want to do in those situations, Peter, is you want to figure out is this a forced audit? So, and what's the easiest way to tell if something is a forced audit? Is let's say their prior policy was based on, again, we'll use nice simple math here, a million dollars of whatever, of sales, of payroll, of of whatever. And if you get that audit worksheet bat and it's 1.5 or two, or it's an exact number. Remember, this is an audit, meaning they want to use actuals. If your audit is using round numbers. It's a pretty good guess that the carrier is saying, hey, we've asked you for this audit information. We didn't get anything back. Peter Brecht: Hmm. Mike Tanghe: So we're gonna quote force this audit upon you by just picking a really big number, usually a multiple of 50% or 100% or even 200, 250%. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: So if you have an even number there, that means, hey, someone's estimating something. and the it's effectively they want to send a big bill across your desk to be like, all right, we've asked you for this, you haven't given it to us yet. Here's your big bill. And what happens then is the carrier calls up and says, What is this? my gosh, I can't you know a customer calls up, Well I can't believe we got this. what do I do? And the short answer is you call the billing department. and you say, or first call the audit department and say, hey, appears that they didn't respond to this. Can you put this audit on hold? and they may have you call the the billing department as well. Sometimes they'll do it automatically on their own. But first thing is we're gonna put this big invoice on hold so it doesn't get passed due. Then we're gonna find out from the auditor, hey, who are you trying to contact at our client? And maybe they had the wrong person, maybe the wrong information, wrong number, etc. but find out and basically you want to make sure that auditor and insured are talking to each other and that getting them the accurate information and then you get that audit revised it comes back at what you had thought it would be and that billing invoice gets reversed or canceled out and then everyone is fine so that happens probably too frequently but again not not something that's too crazy to get fixed some carriers will be a little bulky on it on doing it but I've never seen a carrier refuse to redo a forced data. So questions at all on any of that or how any of that piece works. Peter Brecht: no, I I I I mean that's crazy that they just pick a number, but they're I guess they're in in a sense maybe trying to get your attention so you can actually get things done. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Mike Tanghe: A hundred percent, yeah. If they sent it for you know 10% over, the client would just pay it. so they want to pick a number that they know is too big. and there's been a few times actually where I've had clients that probably shouldn't say this on a recording, but let's say they they you know their product did fantastic, way way bigger than they thought. And even a forced audit at 2x doesn't equate because they were actually six, seven, eight X higher. So it was in their best. So when clients are like, well, I'm just not gonna respond because Peter Brecht: Interesting. Mike Tanghe: this is actually less than what I actually did. Peter Brecht: Yeah, yeah. Mike Tanghe: that's not how the system's intended. And effectively when when the carrier underwrites that account the next year, they're gonna recognize, hey, this is what went on, and you're probably gonna get non-renewed or canceled, or you're just gonna lose that because you effectively Trying to pull a fast one on your client. So much better to go back to the insured in those instances where you're massively blue through your numbers and say, Hey, can we renegotiate our rate on this? Because things were way better than we thought. That's the kind of step that would get you a long-term partner with your insurance carrier, not just hey, I'm gonna pull Peter Brecht: Tchau chao. Mike Tanghe: a fast one and you know, basically screw these guys over for this year and then go find a different market. So yep. Peter Brecht: Got it. Okay. Good to know. Mike Tanghe: Alright, so next step. What if it actually is accurate? So the client did give the information that was requested and it was a lot bigger than what you had before. So what do you do in those situations? the big thing there is you gotta dig into the details. so You know, effectively you want to get copies of the worksheets from the auditor. You know, what did you base this upon? you want to sync up with your insured to find out you know, is this number actually accurate? because this is way different than what you told us at the the beginning of the policy year. and find out like if it's a work comp, like or even general liability, are they being misclassified? So they are are they being put in a in a more expensive class code or rating code that would cause the premium to spike up? is there certain things like are they including overtime if it's a payroll? or are they including tips or per diems or other bonuses? But basically you want to dig into every little piece of data that was used to calculate this and and vet it to make sure it's accurate. And there's other things too, like if it's a work comp policy, like are the owners and officers included in this, which some policies are, some policies aren't. some states will allow you to cap what's paid to an owner or officer of the company, which again, if you're a small company and you're underneath that cap, that never comes up. But if things, you know, keep going well and you start being able to take more money out of your your business, then you can exceed those things. And if it wasn't set up that right in the beginning, then quite possibly you can kind of blow through that and and not realize that it should be get Done. And then certain states like Nevada, for example, if you don't write a lot of business in Nevada, if if you're Nevada based, you'll know that they cap employee payroll at 36,000. But if it's, you know, you have a customer that opened up a new branch in Nevada, it's a business-friendly state, or or you're just kind of dabbling, I'll call it in Nevada, you may not realize that that there's certain caps that apply. So you want to dig into each piece of that data and make sure it's accurate. and then also just again really revisiting those class codes. Are they accurate? Does what the auditor's saying match up with what these employees are actually doing? Anything that's incorrect in there, you need to get corrected. So that's kind of your next step of auditing the audit. So questions at all in any of those categories. Peter Brecht: No, I mean, how in your experience, how often are these audits wrong? I I I guess it's because like to me, it's it's a lot of work like my you know, you get a bill and you almost want to just say, Man, that sucks. It is what it is. but really digging into it, I mean, how often do clients want to dig into that? And then part of that is like when they do, do Do they find issues or and how does the broker, account manager, partner with them to kind of get them through that? Like what's that picture like? Mike Tanghe: Yeah. so great question. You know, how often is something wrong? I mean, I would venture that almost every audit has some inaccuracies, but it it it needs to effectively rise to a pain level for and and that pain level could be different for e for each client. you know, in this situation that we were talking about, it was you know, six X for the current year and then multiplied by three years, you know, so it was almost a couple hundred thousand dollar level that warranted this this deep dive on stuff. You know, if It was a thousand dollar policy and they got an eleven hundred dollar you know, would you go to those same levels? I I guess it would depend on the that particular client. I could see some small nonprofits that are, you know, hey, we really need to drill this down because this would be devastating to us and our mission. but the point would be is you know, data's only good is what gets put in on stuff. And if These are humans that that are putting these things through. They're not done by AI or anything like that. and so you gotta make sure that what goes in is accurate. So long answer to your question would be it depends on the client, depends on the issue. Certainly if it's a unexpected large increase, then 100% that's gotta be something we dig into. Peter Brecht: Got it. All right. I'm only laughing because I think if I start counting how many times we say it depends, it's probably our most Mike Tanghe: Ha ha. Peter Brecht: famous. But we should rename the podcast. I'm just just kidding. Yeah, yeah. Anyways, no, Mike Tanghe: I like that. Right. it depends. Peter Brecht: it but it is true. I mean everything's variable, that's why we do what we do. So you know, we gotta know the best way through it. So all right, well, moving moving forward on it. you know, I I guess the where where my questions were this week really came up on the subcontractor. And the 1099 side. So you know, working with oil, oil and gas companies, whether they're in engineering or, you know, consulting, I mean, a lot of them utilize in the construction world subcontractor 1099s. I know that's true for other industries as well, but that's where a lot of the stuff I work on. So I'd love to dig into that a little bit more and I I see that it's coming up here as our next piece. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, so a a very common issue with and this would be on like a it could be on WordComp or GL would be the with related to the use of subcontractors. and so and this is something that you know has been a massive kind of tug of war in in between states, between employers, between insurance companies, is related to the classification of ten ninety-nine contractors. and it why is this a big deal? so if you have an employee, you're responsible. Provide workers' compensations for that employee. You pay taxes on this, this so the employer portion of the withholding taxes. and there's you know a pretty big cost that is outside of just this what the employee gets paid or their employees take home pay on it. So the end around for a lot of people on doing that was well, instead of calling them employees, we're just gonna call them subcontractors. and so and and it's perfectly fine to use subcontractors, but they have to meet a definition. And Again, kind of getting back to the, you know, is this an employer or subcontractor? It depends. going back to our our pseudo name of our podcast. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: So different states will have different tests that you have to to meet. but effectively if someone if you're hiring someone for a job and they have expertise in this job and they're working on their own hours, they're you're not telling them how to do the job, you're just you know effectively saying, Hey, I need this done, get it done and they come in and get it done and send you a bill, okay, that's something that could be considered a subcontractor Or 1099. If it's you know, hey, you must work these hours and you must do this, this, this, this, then that's likely employee, regardless of how you're classifying them. So when an auditor comes along, they're not gonna necessarily care about the tax standpoint of things, but they're gonna worry about the liability because if you truly are hiring a subcontractor, they should have their own insurance. meaning that they shouldn't be using your insurance like an employee would, they should have their own. so that's obviously a less risk for an insurance company. So if you're you know bringing on people paying Is a 1099 from a tax basis, but they don't have their own insurance and they're operating under your control and they're doing everything else, they look like an employee. just like the IRS, the insurance company is going to then say, Okay, we're picking up exposure for what this person's doing, whether it be on a work comp side, whether it be on a liability side. So we need to charge you appropriately for that. so the easiest way to get around that, or not get around it, but to make sure it doesn't apply to you, would be get certificates of insurance, have a subcontract with these. people that specifies roles and responsibilities and then if you have certs of insurance then 100% that is a 1099 and the insurance company isn't gonna double charge you for that for that person You don't have that, and you're getting paid by your customers to do work and it's being done by people that look and act like employees, even though you're calling them ten ninety nines, then insurance company's gonna wanna try and pick that up. and where that happens is in the audit. So if that you find your customer in that case, first thing and again large audit. unexpected and it's due to a subcontractor expense, then the first thing you want to do is go back to your client and say, hey, do you have contracts on these people? Because sometimes, you know, again, a lot audits used to be in person, but now I'd say almost 100% of them are done remote. And maybe the person at the insured missed completing that request or or just thought it wasn't important. So first off is do they have these certs? Okay, great. We solved that problem, get them over the auditor, get that backed out. If they don't, then it's trying to make the argument. Okay. Okay, do you have contracts with these people? And if you keep going down the line and they really don't have anything to prove that these people were 1099s and and non-employees, then you know what I would do in that situation is go back to the underwriter and say, hey, listen, Here's the deal. These people, they they've worked with them for a long time. They are they are contractors, they just don't have the proof. Can we get some sort of break on that rate? Because it's not the same risk. you know, if you say, hey, they do 10 hours a week over the a quarter for them, you know, again, that's not like, but if if it's 40 hours a week that they're working and billing, and everything looks like an employee, then the conversation with your insured is these are gonna get classified as employees regardless of what you call. So yep. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. So sidebar on this. you know, some companies are like a hundred percent subcontractor almost, right? And and but Mike Tanghe: Yep. Peter Brecht: come across that. so in those cases, and again, this is kind of off the audit subject, but I have you, so I'm gonna ask you. if if there's a, let's say there's a work comp claim, right? and there's an independent contractor agreement that, you know, the independent contractor has to carry their own workers' comp for a million dollars, whatever statutory is. but then the company also carries workers' comp that insures or goes, you know, they're putting payroll from the independent contractor into that work comp. Whose work comp responds? Because there's in in this case, it's almost like I would say it's the independent contractor and then, but they're both the same limit. Like you can't, you know. So how would that work? Seems confusing to me, or maybe it's an incorrect setup, I don't know. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, it it definitely can. And so what large Companies or larger companies that work with a lot of subcontractors who sort so almost like these staffing firms. what a lot of them will say is, Hey, we know the game here between 1099s and employees, and we know all that kind of stuff. So guess what? We don't care. We're gonna require you to carry work comp on these people, even if they are independent contractors. Because we don't want to deal with this, are they employed, not employed, blah blah blah. We're gonna make sure that Peter Brecht: Yeah, yeah. Mike Tanghe: you have the highest coverage. so in in that That is something that's not uncommon, especially in in industries where they use a lot of like temp labor or short-term labor on stuff. And these could be highly skilled, these could be tech people, these you know that are working on a so it's don't just think you know it's someone picking up trash at minimum wage or something in a parking lot. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Right. Mike Tanghe: so and then if there is a claim in those instances and the people have their own work comp, then it's gonna dictate, you know, it depends, depends what the contract says between the employer that is carrying work comp and the person that they're subbing things out with. If the contract says, hey, we're gonna be primary, then they're gonna be primary. if it if it's unclear then they'll both policies would likely respond in the event of an injured employee. So but yeah very common where if it's these gray areas that the big person, the person who dictates the terms and that people want to work with are like, all right, I guess I got in as an insurance company it's actually Those are great policies to write because someone Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: is mandating that you have to carry the coverage and arguably you have coverage elsewhere or it's duplicated. insurance Peter Brecht: Yeah, that's crazy to me. Mike Tanghe: companies actually like those policies. Peter Brecht: Yeah. So so like if there were a claim though, could the hiring company then like let's say of the of the subcontract say, Hey, it's on you because we require you to carry, you know, the insurance and and then it's basically like, well, you know, you gotta go get it handled yourself. Like is that sort of the the workflow or I I I yeah, yeah, yeah. Right. Yeah. Right. Mike Tanghe: Well, it would it again, that's where that it depends. It depends what that contract says. If the contract is unclear, then both policies are gonna respond and they'd probably a portion they'd say, Okay, it's a hundred grand, we're just gonna put in fifty. Peter Brecht: Right. Mike Tanghe: Or one will say, Hey, you're closer to this person, so you do the whole claim and then we'll just chip in a percentage of what we think we're responsible for. so Peter Brecht: Sure. Yep. Mike Tanghe: again, why is it important to have clear contracts? 'Cause you wanna avoid those situations of like, man, what do we have here? Let's Peter Brecht: Yes. Mike Tanghe: figure this out. We wanna instead say, our contract says you're primary, we only sit excess. So you handle it all, and if you go out of business or you fail or will you blow through your limits, then we'll chip in. Peter Brecht: Yeah. All right. And so this is why for my two producers that are listening to this, I know your ears are burning as we're hearing this, but this is why on every single submission we are asking for independent contract agreements and want to review them. Because not only does the underwriter care, but we also want to have eyes on it so we know how that's structured and we can present that properly. So it's not a question of just like, man, I need more paperwork. Like MSAs, independent contract agreements, JOAs, all that stuff matters. So anyways, yeah, just wanted to kind of point that out. Mike Tanghe: Absolutely. Yeah, and a lot of people, you know, you you like w we need to as brokers to be asking for that information and guiding our clients on it. And you know, yes, we're not attorneys and and but we've looked enough at these things that we can say, hey, this doesn't appear good, run this by your attorney, or here's where our concern Peter Brecht: Correct. Mike Tanghe: is. And that's bringing value to clients because you know, if you you start out, you hang up your shingle and hey, I'm I got a client, sweet, awesome. client says they need some stuff, I go on Chat GPT, get a contract, and client accepted it. Great. Now I keep going on. Now I've grown, growing, growing. You know, that is not atypical. a lot of clients fall into that same thing. And it's if we're just assuming, well, these guys, they're a nice company, they've been around 10 years, they've have all this in place, you know, again shame on us in those situations, but absolutely we should be looking at that and helping clients out. And it's it's much more than just hey, here's your premium, here's your policy renewal. It's hey, are you Peter Brecht: Correct. Mike Tanghe: set up things and we've talked pri other podcasts about the importance of how contracts come into play when there's messy claims and the difference between s a good one and something not good or missing is literally life-changing for these businesses. So Peter Brecht: We will close that sidebar. Mike Tanghe: Yes. Peter Brecht: thank you for jumping off with me. Now kind of back to audits, right? So we've Mike Tanghe: Yep. Peter Brecht: gone through subcontractors and how that works. Now the the the the next piece of this is the dispute process, right? So Mike Tanghe: Yep. Peter Brecht: what is that what does that step entail? Mike Tanghe: Yeah, so any sort of issues that you find out that it's again here it just becomes good communication. So my I always like to call it respecting the chain of command. So who's the person who put it together? I'm gonna go to them first and just say, hey, here's stuff that we found that appears to differ from what you came up with. and you know, was it a just a mistake? Great, let's work it out. so kind of starting with that chain of command. So but you gotta give them that information. So how do you clearly, concisely present that to them? I always like to do a phone call first and just say, let's talk through this and man, you know, okay, perfect. Send it over. So you're not just sending someone an email that they're gonna read. You you know, you wanna set the table of how they should be reading this email and a friendly phone call explaining it to me goes immensely far versus just I'm gonna send something to someone and you know maybe they're in a bad mood they just got yelled at by another not nice broker and here us friendly broker trying to help them out and they're reading this email feel like they're being attacked. so f have a phone call, frame what you're gonna do and then send over whatever you did in here's the summary, here's the data that that points our stuff up, you know, offer do a phone call to walk them through it. But do that that dispute. If there is you know some sort of large bill outstanding talk to that auditor. say hey are you gonna put this billing on hold or is that something we need to contact but you want to make sure that you address the billing piece so it's not going past due or other installments that they're paying aren't going towards it you just you got to put a freeze on that. And then hopefully you're you're good. You know they look at it they agree with you they fix it and everyone's happy and you go on. Peter Brecht: I love it. Mike Tanghe: Yes. Peter Brecht: so with with these disputes, right? So we've talked before in the past, and this has come up a couple times with prospective clients, is like, hey, we got this huge audit bill, we don't know where the hell it came from, we don't know why we're getting it. but but there's a timing and a place to sort of have these dispute discussions sometimes. It's like, you know, it's generally not best to do it like right after you renew it if you can help it. You want to kind of get ahead of it. like what are some of the reasons for that? I think. it's it's obvious that, you know, the the there's there's an incentive to kind of resolve it quickly, but you don't always have that luxury. But when you do, what's some of the timing ideas here? Mike Tanghe: Yeah, I mean is as soon as it presents itself, you wanna get it so it's not lingering along. but Peter Brecht: Yeah. Correct. Mike Tanghe: yeah, and it it's really indicative of when the carrier has requests stuff. and then, you know, when the client gets around to completing the audit. but yeah, you know, timing is whenever it presents itself of of getting on it just so everyone can get things off their plate, for sure. Yep. Peter Brecht: Okay. All right. not not my most eloquent of questions. now there are cases though, right? And and audits can be correct, right? We mentioned, you know, that there's there can be deficiencies. but if it is a hundred percent, you know, man, it's it's tough as a broker, I think, to not be able to do anything. I I think like that's 'cause like we wanna we wanna help people. That's ultimately the end of the day what I feel like we're we're here for, at least for me personally. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: But like What what what what do we do there when it's, you know, and Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: and reality is, hey, insurance is insurance, you know, they wanna they put it in their insurance agreement that we can audit and it's there for a reason. But you Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: know, hey, knowing and I guess maybe even thinking through this too, Mike, is like on a forward basis, it's good to be able to say, Hey, for every thousand dollars of payroll, you're gonna have, you know, this amount for insurance, you know, that kind of thing. So you can almost plan ahead, but I'm getting off track there, but just another thing Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: to think about. Mike Tanghe: No, so in this if people listen this long to the podcast, first of all, God bless them. appreciate it. But this Peter Brecht: Yeah. Yes. Mike Tanghe: is I'd say the the the most important piece about what we're gonna talk about is you have a client, they have a large audit, you've gone through all these other steps and it's accurate. So now what do you do? You know, one thing is be like, hey, like Sorry, client, you now have to pay this bill of 6x that you had thought and not only do you have to pay it for two years ago, but you're gonna have to pay it for last year and you're gonna have to pay it for next year. like that is not a fun conversation and f frankly, it's probably a a a client-ending relationship on stuff because some somewhere some something broke apart. And again, could be the insured's fault. they hey, this is what you always told us you did. But you know, so it's not necessarily an error is an emission on things, but it's it's something that somewhere things went off the rails, and who's gonna be the one who who's held fault for that? So so this is where a broker has to get creative, and this is where, you know, again, the the best part of this podcast will will come from this piece is now you gotta start thinking like a business owner and thinking like Hey, what can we do here to to sell this? So f again, you need data for this type of thing. but has this been how is this account performed? have they had any losses? if they haven't had losses, that's gonna give you some ammunition for your argument that you're gonna make. If they've had a bunch of claims, then it's gonna be very, very tough to do so, especially if the claims were larger than what was expected, because that meant the carrier really wasn't getting enough premium for the exposure that was going on. How long has this person been a client of yours? And how long have they been a client of that particular carrier? is another big question to ask. Are there other lines of business that this carrier has with this particular client either currently or the ability to write more with that? Like, are there other lines that this carrier could take on? and then first of all, how like how did we get here? Where was this missed? Was it an issue with the carrier? in in this particular client that we're talking about, what we were able able to find out in looking through was prior policy was rated upon payroll if remember that and then the current policy is is was rated upon sales but that was never explained by the underwriter to us it was just we sent them accords based upon payroll and we got a quote based upon sales and there was no pointing that out on it. So We were able to go through and and and basically arm ourselves with that information. And then we talked earlier about respecting the chain of command. So first we go to the auditor, and auditor's like, hey, this is accurate. I did my job right, I did all these things, it's accurate. Okay, perfect. can't argue with that, right? We already went through our steps and and confirmed that they did that accurate. Then go into the underwriter and say, hey, underwriter, we need your help here. Like w you're our partner on this account. And here's the situation. This has been a long-standing account. It's performed well. It's been profitable for you. Here's where the discrepancy happened in this switching from sales or payroll to sales. and here's what our ask is. and depending on the underwriter's level, they may have to get management involved on things. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Mike Tanghe: and if that ultimately doesn't work, then it's going to our marketing rep that we have and talking to them and giving that same case. And what again, spoiler alert for this particular client, we were quite excited in that we were able to get the marketing rep to say, yeah, hey, actually, this is a great account. And hey, we can see where this discrepancy happened. and we can Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: see where we as a underwriter did not communicate to you as the broker on that change in the rating basis. And this is an account that we already write other lines of coverage on, and that this is an account that has a large work comp renewal coming up that we would love to compete on. and this is an account that you know we want to partner with you Falcon West on and this carrier amazingly agreed to back out the audit for that prior year back out the audit for the current year and Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: back out the the upcoming audit as well so Peter Brecht: Awesome. Mike Tanghe: again so a client looks at this and he's like man all right stuff happens right everyone who's in business knows that stuff happens it's how do you react when that happened And then how do you fix it? And so we took something that could have been effectively disastrous with this client and we were able to figure it out. clients happy, clients like, yep, these guys did what I expected them to do. you know, that that will certainly engender our relationship with them. The carrier recognizes that they they helped us out. So guess who's gonna get more opportunities and Peter Brecht: Right. Mike Tanghe: guess who's gonna get more business with us. So again, from a business perspective, brilliant on their side. and again, they look that you know what what what was the intent here on this how do we unravel something that wasn't inaccurate necessarily but wasn't fair and we're able to get that's figured out and then the last piece I would kind of educate people on is you know you don't want to go down silently on any of these things. So if you're going through all these steps and you're feeling frustrated, reach out to a peer, reach out to another broker and say, Hey, here's the situation. Is there anything that you would do different? is there management with your company? so this particular case was something that the broker had reached out to me. we had a phone call, we brainstormed, we looked at it, and I was able to give him a couple of tidbits that ultimately helped. case out on. So you know to me that is exciting. That's a it's something that makes me feel good and you know gives you that that good team feeling so all in all following those steps hopefully that you know more often than not they'll come to a positive outcome and you go from there. Peter Brecht: Love it. Mike, I had another question I was gonna ask you, but we're gonna save it for next time because we are hitting the 34 minute Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: mark here with this topic and we'll keep it clean. So this is a great piece of educational content. I love just kind of documenting how Mike handles things and we can kind of replicate it so in the future. So great success for this account. Loved hearing those wins that we have as a team and just all the people that come together. So anyways, it's Wednesday. I'm gonna get this off to our to Carl Keene so we can get it edited and we'll get it at everyone's hands. Mike Tanghe: Awesome. always great to chat with you, Peter. if anyone has any other thoughts or feedback on how they would handle things, and actually I did put together a checklist of how to basically the steps that we ran through here. So happy to share that with anyone inside or outside of our organization if it's something that's of interest. Peter Brecht: Actually I'll I'll make sure that we get it up as an article for this week. So we'll we'll post it up and we'll make it available on the website. So awesome. Mike Tanghe: Sounds good. Peter Brecht: Thanks guys. Until next week. get after it. Thank you. Bye. Mike Tanghe: Thanks.