Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E027: Bitcoin’s Role in Financial Advisory with Andy Edstrom
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of doctors 1974198792972000.
- 1:44And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:45It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:53when we sell. And we jumped in, we're jumping
- 1:58in the deep end, the cold water, big week, Thanksgiving week here
- 2:02in the United States. A lot going on in the markets.
- 2:05CZ, they got them. Ladies and gentlemen, we got
- 2:10them. I think that's what Merrick
- 2:12Garland's going to say in a couple hours here.
- 2:14What do we think off the? Cuff.
- 2:18Off the cuff reactions to the to the Binance news.
- 2:23It seems. That.
- 2:24CZ is not SAFU. Mm hmm.
- 2:30Well, Andy, that's what we're talking about.
- 2:31It's a good deal for, Czi said. It probably went to him.
- 2:35They said you see what just happened to Sam Bankman.
- 2:37Friede's going to federal federal prison.
- 2:39It's not gonna be nice there for many years, many decades,
- 2:43probably the rest of his life. Hasn't been sentenced yet.
- 2:45We'll find out early next year. CZ Do you want to spend your
- 2:50life in A? U.S.
- 2:51Federal Prison? Or do you just want to give us 4
- 2:531/2 billion dollars? Yeah, it is a phenomenal
- 2:57precedent if you're sitting in the government's staining in the
- 3:01government's shoes right now. Love to love to see Max damage
- 3:05done to, to the first quote, UN quote victim of, of government
- 3:10efforts to bring the scammers to justice.
- 3:13Definitely, definitely. Strength strengthens their
- 3:16negotiating position with CZ for sure, yeah.
- 3:20Still a pretty good deal for CZ in my book.
- 3:23I mean I I don't remember what his his net worth is, but I I
- 3:29recall it at the peak being 10s of billions.
- 3:33And Marty, you were saying that C ZS on personally on the hook
- 3:37for only a small portion of the $4 billion fine that they're
- 3:41levelling against finance. So he's walking away with
- 3:45billions still. Yeah, he's on the hook for 50
- 3:48mil. But I think he personally has to
- 3:50pay the CFTC and then Binance as a whole conglomerate is on the
- 3:56hook for 4.3 something billion dollars.
- 4:01So we say in the finance business is just cost of doing
- 4:04business, right? That's the interesting thing.
- 4:07Thing like what is Binance? Is the business gonna look like
- 4:13after this? I think it's gonna be completely
- 4:14neutered. KYC AM L.
- 4:17Compliance is gonna be through the roof.
- 4:20The specific charges that were levied stem from the Bank
- 4:23Secrecy Act, particularly dealing with Iran, facilitating
- 4:27some transactions for that country, which is sanctioned by
- 4:31the US and the US regulators. I imagine they're gonna have To
- 4:37Do List a bunch of the unregistered securities that
- 4:40they have on on their platform and I wonder.
- 4:46This leads to a mass exodus from finance.
- 4:48Who knows? Maybe it's very sticky,
- 4:49particularly in certain parts of the world, like the global S,
- 4:53where it's used as a payments rail and a bank account for many
- 4:56people. And then I said it, Michael.
- 5:03Payment Rail. I said Global South.
- 5:05Emerging Emerging Markets. I'll take the other side of
- 5:10this. I think this is just a
- 5:11metaphorical scalp. I think he CZ did it because
- 5:14it's the cost of doing business to get this bull market taken
- 5:17off and the ETF to happen. I think that you know we talked
- 5:21about this six, not six months ago, I don't know it was three
- 5:23or four months ago where CZ is the ultimate pirate and
- 5:26businessman that he takes a step back.
- 5:28He's still going to shadow run the company.
- 5:31What Marty referenced they probably do for the first three
- 5:33to six months until bitcoins at 100K, and then they just rip,
- 5:37rip it right back open and make billions and he's on the run
- 5:40again. Wouldn't shock me.
- 5:43I think, I think what we're referencing here is a
- 5:45traditional playbook we've seen by like Arthur Hayes, bit Max
- 5:48and a lot of these firms, but I think these guys are playing a
- 5:52different game and it's shown because they're the biggest.
- 5:54And been the baddest in the industry and that like I don't
- 5:57think they had the precedent when we referenced with the FTX
- 6:00was a fundamentally different charge on like I was actually
- 6:03like well I guess sanctions is one thing.
- 6:07So the sanctions and if they can prove like they were onboarding
- 6:09Iranian firms but they're not AUS domino style entity.
- 6:13So they would have different precedent.
- 6:17The bigger one is like if they were offering access to US
- 6:20customers which obviously comes with you know.
- 6:23Charges, but I don't think it's like SPF stuff.
- 6:27So I don't think that was like on the table.
- 6:28It's more of like, do you want us to continue to come after?
- 6:31Maybe it is, I don't know. Yeah, FTX, pure Ponzi finance
- 6:37yet to be known. That's another thing.
- 6:38I mean you mentioned it paved the way for the ETFI think that
- 6:41was one of the big hold UPS with ETF approval was hey, there's
- 6:46this offshore exchange doing a lot of volume, quote UN quote
- 6:50volume that we need to clean up. I found the quote Dylan Le Clair
- 6:56posted this snippet citing some of the objections the New York
- 7:05Stock Exchange has about Bitcoin as a as an asset and and you
- 7:11know, ostensibly part of why ETF has not been approved yet but
- 7:17the the Commission raised. The presence of possible sources
- 7:23of fraud and manipulation in the Bitcoin stock market.
- 7:26Such possible sources have included persons with a dominant
- 7:30position in in Bitcoin, pricing, trading based on material, non
- 7:38public information, manipulative activity involving purported
- 7:43stable coins including tether, and fraud and manipulation at
- 7:47Bitcoin trading platforms. So those are, you know, the
- 7:50objections raised to date about why Bitcoin is not a mature
- 7:54enough asset and market to warrant an ETF.
- 7:59And if you read between the lines there, I think a lot of
- 8:02the objection is about Binance and the purported activity there
- 8:08manipulating the price of Bitcoin and then engaging in
- 8:12some sort of outside of the rules market activity.
- 8:19And so that could be, you know, could be some of the main
- 8:22objection to date about an ETF and that may now be sufficiently
- 8:29cleared maybe just in terms of kissing the ring more than
- 8:33anything. But that might be enough for,
- 8:37you know, regulators to say that they've cleaned up this market
- 8:40and it's now safe for, you know, Black Rock's investors and the
- 8:44like. Yeah.
- 8:46And that and it that's further like emphasized with the Kraken
- 8:49news that came out like a day before about the SEC suing them,
- 8:53which is effectively that I'm saying they're not a broker
- 8:55dealer and they're offering securities, which is also funny
- 8:57because we think about the big boys showing up that they're
- 9:01probably going to deem these securities and then you can
- 9:03trade them. But you just have to go through
- 9:04the proper channels with these new entities that have stepped
- 9:07in since the recent fallout in 2022 with like Edx and Citadel
- 9:10and BlackRock. So it's not like they're
- 9:14changing anything. We're still gonna get altcoins.
- 9:16It's just you had a you know file file with the SEC and kiss
- 9:21the ring and you know. Well, I wonder, I wonder if
- 9:25they'd even be able to do that via the regulated broker
- 9:29dealers. Because if they're unregistered
- 9:32securities, you have to go through a whole registration
- 9:34process. And can you do that
- 9:36retroactively? I'm not sure.
- 9:38Completely ignorant. If you pay enough in fines, if
- 9:42you pay the right amount of money, right?
- 9:44Yeah, yeah. I think Andy's got the right
- 9:47perspective. He's, he's seen that the answer
- 9:50to everything is you can do anything with enough of a fine.
- 9:55That's how finance works, isn't it, Andy?
- 9:57That's it. That's it.
- 9:58Pay the right people and and the game goes on.
- 10:03The The Cantillionaire money printing game, which is?
- 10:09Every bit as big a game and quote UN quote crypto as it is
- 10:13in Fiat land. Yeah.
- 10:17In my humble opinion. Yeah, and Kraken's getting
- 10:19double whammy. They paid a $30 million fine
- 10:22early this year. Jesse Powell came out with a
- 10:25tweet yesterday, pretty aggressive against Department of
- 10:29Justice. Whoever levied the suit against
- 10:31them, the SEC came out against the SEC and said what the hell
- 10:35are you guys doing? We just went through this.
- 10:38We'll get back to the battle lines and fight you again.
- 10:40But yeah, it seems like there is a lot of action on the
- 10:45regulatory front trying to clean up the market perceptively and
- 10:49that's what people are reading through all this.
- 10:51They're cleaning it up before the ETF.
- 10:52Speaking of ETF news, that was another thing that drops I think
- 10:55at the end of last week. Maybe it came out over the
- 10:57weekend, but a lot of the companies that have filed for
- 11:01ETFs. Bitcoin ETS made revisions that
- 11:05essentially dictated that it would be cash in, cash out, and
- 11:09they wouldn't be offering Bitcoin in kind Redemptions,
- 11:13which is pretty big news too. Shouldn't get swept under the
- 11:16rug. We should talk about that as
- 11:17well 'cause we covered the BlackRock filing many months ago
- 11:22and that was a big part of it, that you could take it in kind.
- 11:25Now that seems to be completely different.
- 11:28Yeah, I I didn't even catch that, that that has definitely
- 11:30flown under the radar. That is huge news in terms,
- 11:34particularly in terms of like ETF investors getting access to
- 11:39Bitcoin itself rather than, you know, a a derivative product
- 11:45that isn't actually Bitcoin and has always more than fun.
- 11:50I think. Well, they are buying Bitcoin.
- 11:52I think it's the mechanism as how they're purchasing it in the
- 11:56open market. It's not necessarily like
- 11:58there's a we put it in one of the chats when Marty first
- 12:01shared that shows some of the like diagrams on like the
- 12:04proposed format. So it it definitely is Bitcoin
- 12:07being purchased and stored. It's just the process I think is
- 12:11a little bit non traditional than what was initially like
- 12:13thought. Yeah.
- 12:14But I don't think end customers could take it in kind anymore.
- 12:17Yeah, well, that was always going to be the case.
- 12:20Well, it was authorized. Yeah, go ahead.
- 12:23Yeah, the well the the documents.
- 12:24The documents made it sound like end users would be able to take
- 12:29Bitcoin. But it was always going to be
- 12:31the authorized participants, which were a a separate set of
- 12:35like whitelisted broker dealer firms who had permission from
- 12:38BlackRock to do in kind redemptions in large batches.
- 12:43And so there are a lot of little stipulations there that were
- 12:45hidden, but. You know in theory the end user
- 12:48would be able to take in kind redemptions.
- 12:50But now if you're taking dollars, then you always have a
- 12:55taxable event. Because if you're holding
- 12:56Bitcoin but you have to take out dollars you you are guaranteed A
- 13:00taxable event when you withdraw. But in the previous world you
- 13:04know if you were a large enough player you could withdraw your
- 13:07Bitcoin without a taxable event. In theory, now, that wouldn't be
- 13:10the case. Yeah, they put the nail in the
- 13:14coffin. There was hope.
- 13:15That this form of paper Bitcoin would not be Roach, motel,
- 13:20Bitcoin or never ever kill coins shall coins exit.
- 13:26That's the phrase you had for GBTC for the last few years and
- 13:29it has proven extremely true. And now there's going to be a
- 13:32new and upgraded version of Roach Motel.
- 13:36I wonder, I'm I'm generally curious if that's a big surprise
- 13:40like from. Folks that have been listening
- 13:42to this or even this group because I I thought we had
- 13:45talked about it when it first came out.
- 13:46I remember from somebody pretty senior at one of the big banks
- 13:49referring to me why? Like independent of any game
- 13:52theory or economic incentive for Grayscale to hold all the
- 13:55Bitcoin from a pure logistical perspective, in KYCML it was
- 13:59impossible because of the intermediaries in the middle to
- 14:02deliver from like an O FAC compliant and somebody wanted to
- 14:05take their delivery of the asset and sending that Bitcoin
- 14:07transaction. I heard that about a year ago
- 14:09and it always stuck with me because if you think about like,
- 14:11imagine BlackRock by way of Coinbase, by way of any but
- 14:15intermediary you purchase, sending the Bitcoin to a address
- 14:18that you hold. It sounds literally impossible.
- 14:21Like at the stat, the current state we're at maybe three years
- 14:24from now from these incumbents, they'll be able to do it.
- 14:26But like, I I would bet AI would have bet a year ago, six months
- 14:30ago. And I guess we just found out
- 14:31last week that that will never happen because it just doesn't
- 14:33seem logistically possible. Yeah, I I guess, I I guess I
- 14:38always assumed that like if you were a big enough player that
- 14:43and a big enough client of BlackRock in particular, that
- 14:46they would make it possible for you.
- 14:49But now not. I mean like I don't even know
- 14:51who who that would really mean. Is that like CalPERS, that, like
- 14:54if CalPERS five years from now wanted to withdraw their
- 14:57Bitcoin, they would be able to wrangle that, you know,
- 15:03allotment from directly from? BlackRock, but now you know tax
- 15:10will invent instead. And directionally, I, I can't
- 15:16even imagine it'd be part of the process to not even approve it
- 15:19until that was in place, right? I think you're correct, Michael
- 15:25and headbutt. Well, that's, I mean that's the
- 15:29funny part about regulations. You think we're thinking long
- 15:32term here? And comparing this paper Bitcoin
- 15:36product to other products thesis is that we transition to a
- 15:41Bitcoin standard. People are going to want to use
- 15:44their Bitcoin. That's why we don't recommend
- 15:46you get into the ETF in the 1st place.
- 15:49Because before this news broke, we said even though there is
- 15:54technically an in kind redemption clause in this
- 15:57filing, it's unlikely that you'll ever actually get the
- 16:00Bitcoin delivered. Now it's abundantly clear
- 16:03that's. Technically going to be
- 16:05impossible via this vehicle, but you'd think they would fight for
- 16:11that in kind redemption clause just to give people hope that
- 16:14they could do it in the future. Now I actually think this
- 16:17product is way less competitive with offerings like on Ramps
- 16:20Trust or just pure spot Bitcoin via multi institution custody
- 16:27product. Yeah, I think it's a great point
- 16:29that like how quick they were to concede one of the most
- 16:33important properties. Of of the offering that they
- 16:36were trying to put in place. I mean that really undercuts the
- 16:42the like you're only going to go into BlackRock because it's more
- 16:48convenient than the alternatives that would give you exposure to
- 16:52spot Bitcoin without a taxable event and but now you know if if
- 16:58you're guaranteed A taxable event versus.
- 17:03You know, how much is that convenience of being in
- 17:06BlackRock really worth to you if you're investing in Bitcoin in
- 17:10the 1st place? Like you're investing in Bitcoin
- 17:13because you believe in the asymmetric upside of this thing,
- 17:16and so you're investing with the expectation that you'll have a
- 17:21large taxable event in the future in the best scenario.
- 17:25So. So why?
- 17:26Why put yourself into that vehicle versus pursuing spot,
- 17:30spot, Bitcoin or? And in particular an an easier
- 17:34vehicle, a private placement trust like on RAMP Bitcoin trust
- 17:39that allows for in kind redemptions without a taxable
- 17:43event. Yeah, and yet.
- 17:47It just shows how Marty, as you like to say and have been saying
- 17:52for years since I've heard you on TFTC, the first time we are
- 17:55so early. Yep.
- 17:57We're so early that still. Most of the people out there who
- 18:03will buy this ETF or frankly, who will buy any form of actual
- 18:08Bitcoin or paper Bitcoin or derivative Bitcoin, yeah, they
- 18:11still are unaware of the subtleties of these points.
- 18:15I guess in their defence, you know, we all forget after a
- 18:19while how it took a little bit of time for us to understand
- 18:24these these differences and. Education is it always takes
- 18:30longer than we think it will. This is why Bitcoin educators
- 18:34will have plenty of work to do yet for a good number of years
- 18:38here. And yeah, people just still
- 18:41don't know we're still so early. 100%, yeah.
- 18:46And this? Just highlights this insanity of
- 18:48the regulatory landscape too, because you think mechanically.
- 18:52It's just use BlackRock as an example.
- 18:54You buy shares in the BlackRock ETF that gets you exposure to X
- 18:58amount of Bitcoin, sits in the fun and one day you want to sell
- 19:02those shares and take the Bitcoin in kind like BlackRock
- 19:05has the KYC, AM L those customers, maybe they have a
- 19:08preferred partner. It's like alright, we're gonna
- 19:10redeem this in kind with Fidelity.
- 19:12Now to get your Bitcoin, you have to go to Fidelity, go
- 19:14through their KYC process, then give them a Bitcoin address to
- 19:18receive from. Like it seems pretty simple,
- 19:20straightforward. At least to me, like how they
- 19:23would mechanically do the in kind redemptions.
- 19:26Maybe I'm maybe I'm too too much of A simpleton and missing a lot
- 19:31of intricacies, but it seems like it could create a pretty
- 19:34simple process here if you actually tried.
- 19:39Yeah, one. One theory I've heard is this is
- 19:42partially why they went with Coinbase from somebody like
- 19:45pretty deep in the space is why they went with Coinbase if they
- 19:47ever need to offer that because Coinbase obviously has the
- 19:49wallet architecture and it's going to be already in the same
- 19:52like edge count. I think they have that call
- 19:54option to do it, but without doing it up front because they
- 19:57obviously wanted to sit within the fund.
- 20:00The thing Andy references like. The scary part is it just feels
- 20:03this is like we're being around the space and Marty probably
- 20:05knows best, like pattern recognition of the cycles.
- 20:08It's like. I feel like this same thing that
- 20:10was being discussed was about Black Block Fi's lending product
- 20:14and people telling not to go into it because of all the
- 20:17things that people knew about the asset and re lending and no
- 20:20bailouts and all things we've talked about that there's
- 20:27another topic. Oh, it's a quick it's crazy how
- 20:30quick we forget like last year a bunch of centralized exchanges
- 20:34blew up and I'm guilty of it. I feel like it just it's like it
- 20:37was 10 years ago that you know, we lost like half the market if
- 20:42not more. And I don't think people coming
- 20:44into this next wave or even going to remember or think about
- 20:47it, it's just going to be, I mean some will, obviously we're
- 20:49talking to some of them, but I think it's going to get swept
- 20:52under the rug again. And we're just going to be back
- 20:53to square one with, you know, centralized exchanges holding a
- 20:56large portion of net new clients or net new Bitcoin holders
- 20:59coming in. Say it ain't so.
- 21:06I hope you're wrong, but I think you're right.
- 21:10Yeah, that, that. That's just the cycle, right?
- 21:12Like everybody learns the hard way about Bitcoin and it just,
- 21:18it takes everybody burning their hands on on all of the things
- 21:21that Bitcoin has designed to save you from first and
- 21:27foremost, centralization. Everybody gets screwed by some
- 21:31sort of mistake there. Copies of digital scarcity.
- 21:35You know, altcoins. Everybody makes the mistake of
- 21:39diversifying and and only then once you've seen your Bitcoin
- 21:44holdings shrink, do you then realize, oh, this is the one
- 21:49thing that I want to be holding. So let's just hold that and and
- 21:52actually use the properties of the asset, which are why I want
- 21:57to hold it and why everyone wants to hold that particular
- 22:01asset. And that doesn't mean putting it
- 22:04on block fi or even leaving it with BlackRock or GBTC.
- 22:10You got to, you got to hold it on chain.
- 22:14Self custody is great if you're up for it.
- 22:19Multi institution custody if if self custody is not yet for you
- 22:24or doesn't suit your circumstances.
- 22:28But yeah, you know. Everyone goes through the
- 22:31adoption curve on their own way of like of starting from total
- 22:38novice to eventually incorporating Bitcoin into their
- 22:46portfolio as like the the base the the foundation of their
- 22:49portfolio or at least that's been you know my experience and
- 22:53what I've seen everybody else go through.
- 22:57You get far enough down the. Educational journey and it
- 23:00becomes your unit of account. But that journey requires, you
- 23:07know, going through all these different phases of education
- 23:13before you can eventually get to the other side and and, you
- 23:17know, reach that plateau of of treating Bitcoin as your unit of
- 23:22account rather than some speculative asset, which is how
- 23:26it starts. You know, the beginning of that
- 23:28journey is always some speculative asset that you'll
- 23:31add to your portfolio because it might juice performance a little
- 23:34bit and you might as well sit in GBTC if that's all you think.
- 23:38But you know most of the world is is.
- 23:42Most of the world still thinks Bitcoin is is Monopoly money.
- 23:45But the few people who are interested in Bitcoin, the vast
- 23:49majority of them see it as some sort of risk on asymmetric bet.
- 23:56And have yet to learn about Bitcoin as a savings technology
- 23:59or even the digital gold hypothesis or or you know
- 24:03investment case. And so everybody, everybody is
- 24:06it's it's not even it's earlier than than we even think because
- 24:12you can count up all the people who are interested in Bitcoin,
- 24:15all the people who come to Bitcoin conferences even.
- 24:18And the reality is, most of them don't understand Bitcoin as as a
- 24:23savings vehicle. And so that means that even the
- 24:27people who are interested in Bitcoin are still not yet at the
- 24:31place where they've incorporated Bitcoin into their portfolio, to
- 24:34the extent that they eventually will.
- 24:36And we're that much earlier to Bitcoin than people even
- 24:38realize. We're so early, they launched an
- 24:42XRPETF and we believed it for half a day.
- 24:49Brilliant. And for people who didn't hear
- 24:51that one BlackRock. Has now issued notice that it is
- 24:57planning to launch a Bitcoin ETF, but then also an an
- 25:02Ethereum ETF and some scammer out there.
- 25:05Some opportunist created an A XRPA Ripple altcoin copy of the
- 25:13same sort of filing notice and plastered it all over the
- 25:18Internet. And people you know fell for it
- 25:21hook, line and sinker for. For about an hour.
- 25:25Price pumped, then dumped. Price pumped, I think it was
- 25:28like 17% in in the space of like 15 minutes.
- 25:33So whoever you know, whatever I I guess what does that fall
- 25:39under Andy, that that's that's not it's manipulation I guess
- 25:42just. Price manipulation?
- 25:44Sure. Price manipulation.
- 25:45And I'm sure the SEC would love to get their hands on whoever
- 25:49that was. But you know the the anonymity
- 25:51of global crypto markets? Who knows?
- 25:55So I'm going to look at. Both of the last two topics.
- 25:59So first of all, in terms of, you know, having to go through
- 26:02each of our personal journeys to understand Bitcoin, I've become
- 26:06a total Bitcoin ageist. And what I mean is, you know.
- 26:10Any time someone wants to talk about Bitcoin, I just, I I
- 26:13interrupt those and ask them, of course, you know what, in what
- 26:16year did you buy your first Bitcoin?
- 26:18And that informs the whole rest of the conversation?
- 26:22Because, yeah, because if you haven't been through at least a
- 26:25couple of cycles, you just don't have the, the muscle memory, you
- 26:30know, the lived experience of the of how it's how things have
- 26:34gone down. And then Speaking of Ripple.
- 26:37So my Barber, the guy who cuts my hair, big XRP guy, and he he
- 26:45always wants to talk, wants to talk crypto with me and I I I
- 26:51exercise my patience. Last time I went in for a
- 26:54haircut, though, he says. Oh, you got to meet this guy who
- 26:58you know is I think is does deliveries from the from the
- 27:01restaurant next door, and the guy comes in while, you know,
- 27:04we're halfway through the haircut.
- 27:07And he just out of the blue, just starts pitching me some
- 27:09random crypto. Right.
- 27:11And I just, I just interrupt and I just probably say, OK, what
- 27:15what year did you first buy Bitcoin?
- 27:16It says, OK, 2021. And I'm like, I appreciate that
- 27:21you're excited about this thing. You know, I'm not interested in
- 27:24the pitch. Thank you very much.
- 27:26And of course he's, you know, he's a zealot.
- 27:28He's, he's going, oh, no, no, You don't understand the the
- 27:30huge opportunity that's coming with this thing.
- 27:33I just said no. So I'm sorry, Sir.
- 27:35You don't understand. I'm sure someday you will.
- 27:39I look forward to talking with you about it.
- 27:41Then. I'm here to get my haircut.
- 27:43Have a nice day. It's brutal.
- 27:47It's just brutal cause I've been in, I've been in his shoes in a
- 27:50different, you know, different life, a different version of it,
- 27:53a little bit less aggressive version of it, but you genuinely
- 27:56believe when you're when you're an altcoin or you genuinely
- 27:59think you're on to something because you just don't
- 28:03understand yet. And I've been in his shoes, I
- 28:07guess. You know, you just you just
- 28:10can't. Yeah.
- 28:11Yeah, Andy, we've been there. Well, never in a barbershop
- 28:15pitching. But you don't.
- 28:18Want to pitch? In offices.
- 28:22I've had, I've had the barbershop pitch, I've actually
- 28:24had the barbershop, the Barber, Ripple Ripple shill before and
- 28:28it's hard to tell somebody with scissors right by your ear that
- 28:32they've put their money in something.
- 28:34Something terrible that did she get away from.
- 28:35You want to tell your Barber to have fun staying poor when he's
- 28:38when he's cutting cutting the hair around your ears.
- 28:43Oh man, is that why you always wear earphones, Marty, 'cause
- 28:47you lost one of your ears to your Barber?
- 28:48Yeah, you just don't want. To show it the shit, Quinn
- 28:50Barber got me. You set him on the right path,
- 28:53though eventually waited till after paid had the conversation.
- 28:58Hey, maybe you shouldn't be holding on to Ripple.
- 29:00It's it's hard I I've actually I've stopped.
- 29:03Talking about it with my friends at all, like I I don't think
- 29:06that, you know, I've I've pitched for a handful of years
- 29:12Bitcoin through, you know, all phases of of the market and I
- 29:18don't think I will pitch it to any of my friends for this next
- 29:23bull market. I people have either listened or
- 29:26or they'll you know figure it out a different way.
- 29:30I was thinking about that more of like pitches.
- 29:34I was thinking about something Marty was talking he he
- 29:37referenced he was chatting with some folks and explaining
- 29:39Bitcoin versus other stuff. And I started like thinking back
- 29:41to those conversations I've had and then also previously and it
- 29:45it's there's a common thread that nobody ever picks it up
- 29:47unless unless they're interested.
- 29:50Like if they come to you and and say, hey, take like explain to
- 29:53me what's happening here, you generally have a good chance.
- 29:56But if you're going in trying to explain it, it's basically
- 29:58batting 0 because it just doesn't.
- 30:01They have to have some interest or curiosity or it doesn't make
- 30:04any sense. Yeah, you just end up cell
- 30:06phoning yourself looking like Charlie Day.
- 30:08And it's always sunny during the Pepe study episode.
- 30:12Like, trust me, yeah. It's so true.
- 30:17Definitely that guy. Had the same condo with a
- 30:20financial advisor prospect earlier today for on ramp and he
- 30:26he was talking about you know how he's trying to get his
- 30:28parents on how do you do it Andy?
- 30:31How do you get people into Bitcoin?
- 30:32And I go, I used to try and now I don't try anymore.
- 30:35I I accept inbound questions and I do my best.
- 30:39And I refer people to educational materials, some of
- 30:41which I have created, some of which you gentlemen on this call
- 30:45have created and. That's all you can do.
- 30:50I think that's a big part in the the Bitcoin only though.
- 30:53I think like we're chatting with another one.
- 30:55We can talk maybe later in the pod with the NRA firm.
- 30:58He's like, I don't know what's you know up from down and all
- 31:02this. I was like look what will
- 31:02happily educate you. But it's only Bitcoin and we can
- 31:04explain why and why that'll help your net clients in coming in.
- 31:08And I think ideally we can just start there and then you don't
- 31:12have to go through the pain and trying to.
- 31:14You're right. It's whatever the term is.
- 31:15It's always harder to refute BS than to than to like spout it.
- 31:20And so it's if we can just get ahead of like the education at
- 31:22the first touch point of like, this is the thing, don't go any
- 31:25other way. If you do, it's on you.
- 31:27I think you'd probably make everything a lot.
- 31:29Smoother. Yeah, I believe that's
- 31:31Brandolini's law. BS is 100 X harder to refute
- 31:36than it is to put out in the world.
- 31:39Good one, no? But this provides especially
- 31:41when, especially when somebody's bags are tied to it.
- 31:44Right, once you got a heavy a heavy load of XRP, you're done.
- 31:50Thanks for tuning in to the last trade.
- 31:53If you're enjoying the show and want to dive deeper, check us
- 31:56out at on rampbitcoin.com where you'll find a full suite of
- 32:01institutional grade research and analytics including our recently
- 32:05published white paper, Bitcoin's full potential valuation and our
- 32:09new tool, the On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 32:15This provides a good segue to jump into Andy.
- 32:19Your back story recently joined on RAMP.
- 32:21You've been having these conversations with Rias wealth
- 32:24managers for years now, and I guess that's how we can approach
- 32:29like your history in the traditional wealth management
- 32:32space, why you came to Bitcoin, what your experience has been
- 32:37like in. For where the disconnect lies on
- 32:40both ends, like bitcoiners trying to pitch to wealth
- 32:42managers and then wealth managers trying to understand
- 32:45Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, by the way, Andy,
- 32:47welcome to on Ramp. We're excited to have you pretty
- 32:53awesome development in the last few weeks for for folks who
- 32:56don't have their ear to Bitcoin Twitter at all times we we.
- 33:01So Andy, I guess as part of your story there, make sure to
- 33:05incorporate that you know recent developments.
- 33:09Absolutely. Well, I'm super stoked to be
- 33:12here with this elite team, which is small but growing and OK, so
- 33:20yeah, my my finance and Bitcoin story.
- 33:23So first decade for me was Tradfi working on the dark side
- 33:29Goldman Sachs investment banking private equity fund that spun
- 33:34out of The Carlyle Group. And then the multi billion
- 33:37dollar hedge fund that was bought by, you guessed it,
- 33:41BlackRock. So that was first decade for me,
- 33:45second decade. I decided to join the family
- 33:48business that's a firm called Westcap Group, which does
- 33:52financial advisory and wealth management.
- 33:55And so that's been a fun journey for multiple reasons.
- 33:59Great working with family, you know, great.
- 34:01You know, sort of being my own, effectively my own boss.
- 34:05Working with actual people instead of faceless
- 34:08institutions. All of the above growing
- 34:12obviously, and some lifestyle benefits as well.
- 34:16So I found you know I was a three exposure guy on Bitcoin
- 34:21like many people are third exposure.
- 34:23Well first was an article only Economist 2013.
- 34:25I didn't get it all. Second exposure I think was 2016
- 34:29was the Ethereum hard forks on article didn't get it at all.
- 34:32Third exposure had a very small a very smart friend who now is
- 34:38very senior in AI at Facebook. And he had a friend who he
- 34:44introduced me to who was raising a fund, a crypto fund of all
- 34:48things. And so that's how I started to
- 34:51fall down the rabbit hole, bought my first Bitcoin the day
- 34:54after the B Cash hard fork. Not because I was waiting for
- 34:58the fork to see what would happen, but because I was just
- 35:01trying, trying desperately to fund my Coinbase account.
- 35:04And that was when the when the money cleared or the first of
- 35:07the money cleared, so you know, did all coin stuff.
- 35:12For about a year, and then in the beginning of 2019, at the
- 35:19bottom or the local bottom was 3K Bitcoin started writing a
- 35:23book called Buy Buy Bitcoin, and that was partly to test my own
- 35:26thesis on Bitcoin like, Oh my God, I I bought at a pretty
- 35:31decent price. Price went up a lot, then
- 35:34crashed. Now I'm actually underwater on
- 35:36my purchase. What's going on here?
- 35:39You know, am I wrong or or does this thing actually have legs?
- 35:43So I published that book in 20 in September 2019.
- 35:49I actually met Corey Clipston of Swan I think the next month.
- 35:53I sent him a copy and he and I sat down and it was it was
- 36:01Lovett's first sight, so to speak.
- 36:03I immediately recognized Corey was multi talented.
- 36:06Brilliant. Ambitious and had a vision and
- 36:11so I decided to write a check into the seed round at Swan and
- 36:17you know was an advisor there and then was in a position to
- 36:22was he asked me to join the board.
- 36:24This was in 2021 and we had a departure.
- 36:29I was still working full time in my financial advisory practice
- 36:34and just, you know, really very, very part time advising Swan.
- 36:38And our the guy that he had hired, Corey had hired to launch
- 36:42Swan Advisor services departed. And so I talked with Corey
- 36:47about, you know, hey, we need to get this thing off the ground, I
- 36:50guess I'm the guy to do it And he said, yeah, I guess you are
- 36:54So spent about 10 months from zero to version one of that
- 36:59product, launched it into the marketplace and yeah, you know
- 37:05got got good traction. Of course, then the year 2020,
- 37:10well, late 2021 to 2022. I hope I'm getting my timing
- 37:16right, but let's just say a lot of a lot of things happened and
- 37:22and yeah, so anyway, so I ended up departing Swan a number of
- 37:29months ago and honestly, I'd always wanted to work with
- 37:33Jesse. Jesse is one of my closest
- 37:36friends in Bitcoin. I saw that that the team that
- 37:41had already been assembled, you know whether it was Kevin, where
- 37:47it was, you know Marty and Michael obviously on this call
- 37:50here, whether it was Cam, they're, you know, it's too long
- 37:55to list to to name everyone including our great advisor
- 38:00Bill, you know David, David Thayer, I was just keen.
- 38:04To to be working in Bitcoin again and specifically I was
- 38:08keen on this team and multi institution custody.
- 38:13I mean the events of the last couple of years just shone a
- 38:18spotlight on on the fact that any single custodian is a risk
- 38:27and it's especially it's a risk for individuals, you know, who
- 38:32should self custody anyway. But it's especially a risk for
- 38:37anyone managing money on behalf of somebody else because most of
- 38:43those folks are fiduciaries and they have duties of care that
- 38:47they have to observe. And in a world in which multiple
- 38:52single custodians have failed, they need a a better solution.
- 38:57So I think the time is now in two respects, one for multi
- 39:02institution. Custody, given what's already
- 39:05happened in the space and #2 financial advisors finally being
- 39:10ready I think to move in mass, that's partly because of the ETF
- 39:15like we talked about before. But yeah, facts and
- 39:18circumstances are aligning for a huge opportunity ahead for the
- 39:24financial advisory space for on RAMP in particular, which has
- 39:28multiple products not just for financial advisors.
- 39:31And I couldn't be more excited about doing my small part to
- 39:36help build the platform. Yeah.
- 39:40And for for context for numbers, I was just looking at the most
- 39:42recent. So there's $110 trillion managed
- 39:45by RA as recently as 20/20 as the numbers were reported.
- 39:50And so you think about like to Andy's point, they've been
- 39:54hesitant for a number of reasons.
- 39:55I think 80% of that wealth that's been like crypto related.
- 39:59So somebody that's been managing their wealth with the financial
- 40:02advisor, 80% of it sits outside of the purview from the the
- 40:08billing or the visibility for a number of reasons.
- 40:11And you can speak to them. But the main point here is like
- 40:14directionally build the right product solutions and also the
- 40:18timing. I think we're all aligned that
- 40:21there. There couldn't be a better time
- 40:23to get out in the market and educate advisors and give them
- 40:25the right resources so they can educate the end client on all
- 40:28the things we talk about here about preserving wealth and
- 40:30doing it the right way. So we're we're definitely as
- 40:34excited as Andy is and I think there's a huge opportunity ahead
- 40:37of us. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 40:42Andy, thrilled to have you. And.
- 40:44It it is interesting hearing how your evolution, your journey has
- 40:50has had learnings even even after you arrived at Bitcoin and
- 40:55you know have have been a bitcoiner for some time.
- 40:59But you know, custody has become a a a fresh topic of of of
- 41:05interest for everyone involved in Bitcoin and.
- 41:10You know that as you say shines a light on the possibilities of
- 41:14of multi institution custody specifically.
- 41:18And I really think that we are like we are entering a new era
- 41:21of Bitcoin custody that is going to be all about multi
- 41:26institution custody because it is a superior way to custody
- 41:32assets than any other version that exists in the traditional
- 41:36asset landscape. It it's brand new to the world.
- 41:39And it's a very exciting time and and new wave to be riding as
- 41:47because of that. And you know I think it just
- 41:50sort of speaks to how everyone in Bitcoin is still learning.
- 41:54All of us on on on this podcast are are very much still learning
- 41:58about Bitcoin. I learned, I learned something
- 42:01new about Bitcoin every week. And, you know, I think sometimes
- 42:04people are a little bit surprised that, like, I'm on
- 42:07Twitter. Completely ignorant about
- 42:11aspects of Bitcoin, especially recently I I stumbled into a
- 42:15gaff of of believing that that transaction fees are the same
- 42:21for different types of Bitcoin transactions, but but they're
- 42:26different for for, you know, there's a different block space
- 42:29demand for different types of Bitcoin transactions based on
- 42:33how many. UTXOS are going into it and how
- 42:36and if it's multi multi sig or not.
- 42:40And you know that was a learning moment that I had this week just
- 42:44because I don't spend that much time interacting with the with
- 42:47that side of Bitcoin, the the really technical, you know on
- 42:53chain side of Bitcoin or the mining side of Bitcoin for that
- 42:56matter. But you know, as bitcoiners,
- 42:58we're all learning and. And that includes learning about
- 43:02custody, you know, even for for us finance professionals, Andy,
- 43:07you, me who think we know a thing or two about custody and
- 43:13custodying assets. But then Bitcoin shows a way for
- 43:17this digitization of value to create a superior form of
- 43:22custody than has ever existed in the traditional asset landscape.
- 43:26It's just a very exciting time, Andy.
- 43:29Are you cooking a Thanksgiving Turkey or what's?
- 43:31What's going on with that? So here's the honest answer.
- 43:36I actually thought this this zoom was supposed to happen an
- 43:41hour later. My mistake.
- 43:43And I had I had just laid down to shut my ass to take a nap,
- 43:46basically. And it's I was going to snooze
- 43:48for 45 minutes and that was my alarm to to wake me up me up in
- 43:53advance of 1:30 PM, which, oops, was an hour late if it wasn't.
- 43:59If it wasn't Thanksgiving week, I would have called out.
- 44:00It was just a funny can go on. Oh man.
- 44:04Well, you know, I might be a little shorter on sleep than I
- 44:08have been. Perhaps in the last couple
- 44:10weeks. Maybe on the count of things, on
- 44:13all the work, all the work getting up to speed here at on
- 44:16ramp. Yeah, Once again, yeah, it's
- 44:22definitely a good reason. What one thing I don't know if I
- 44:24shared with the the team here that I'm insanely excited about
- 44:27and this goes back to Jesse, the stuff he does know or he does
- 44:29very well is the content being produced.
- 44:32Because I think as we're learning from folks that we've
- 44:34known in the industry that even if you do go and win the quote
- 44:38UN quote logo at an RA and you go partner because they actually
- 44:41want to look at digital assets and get their clients exposure,
- 44:45that's actually in my understanding it's very hard.
- 44:48But that's almost the easy part in the equation.
- 44:50The real hard part is getting the advisors ultimately that are
- 44:55are part of the RAA or part of the wealth management team
- 44:58educated on the assets or assets or asset or assets if it's
- 45:02crypto or Bitcoin only. And like having some kind of
- 45:05fundamental thesis on why they're taken to their client
- 45:07and then ultimately having the materials to take to the end
- 45:10client to look at the asset and look at it from a portfolio
- 45:13allocation and what are all the attributes and how do you want
- 45:15to think about it from a from a time scale.
- 45:18And where I think our team that's assembled and being
- 45:23assembled along with the content is uniquely positioned for that.
- 45:26Because it's one thing to go again when the the logo quote UN
- 45:30quote and work with the wealth management team, but the other
- 45:33thing to empower them with the right resources, education, the
- 45:36terminals, a component of it to really provide that in client.
- 45:39One, it's only Bitcoin. But then two, here's all the
- 45:42information to really look at it from different perspectives that
- 45:45we all know. There's no silver bullet in the
- 45:46space. It's really putting it all
- 45:48together. And so I'm really excited about
- 45:50that because I don't know if it's really been done well yet.
- 45:52I think Fidelity's probably the closest and they're really
- 45:54picking up steam, but I think that's personally like something
- 45:57I'm really excited about. Absolutely.
- 46:01One of the one of the truisms of the space that was true years
- 46:05ago and it's still true today, is education, education,
- 46:08education, I mean. It's it's the topic is so
- 46:13multifaceted, so complex, so difficult for people to
- 46:19understand, you know, plus just the basic cost of admission in
- 46:24terms of doing, doing the work. I mean there it's like anything,
- 46:27it's like any learned set of knowledge.
- 46:31It's yes, if you have someone pushing great content at you.
- 46:37Just like having a great teacher in school, you know, much
- 46:41reduces the difficulty of absorbing the information,
- 46:46that's super important. Just as of course is, you know,
- 46:50effort, expenditure and engagement on the part of the
- 46:54learner. And so somewhere in the middle
- 46:58of those two things is where learning and understanding
- 47:02Bitcoin occurs. And yeah, it's got to, it's got
- 47:06to happen on both ends. And fortunately, fortunately now
- 47:11fortunately we've been watching Marty for, I'm listening to
- 47:13Marty for long enough that we all have some sense for things
- 47:17that work and things that don't work in the in the educational
- 47:21area. And so yes, we, we have a very
- 47:26solid team that's been educating people and talking with people
- 47:31about Bitcoin. For a very long time, and I
- 47:34think that's a huge leg of the stool for the success of on
- 47:38ramp. We all stand on the shoulders of
- 47:42giants. There were, there was many
- 47:45educators before me as well. But no, that's, I mean, I've
- 47:48been doing this podcasting, writing newsletters for 6 1/2
- 47:53years now, which is hard to imagine, hard to believe an old
- 47:56veteran now, but that's the one thing that makes me most bullish
- 48:00over the course of that six years is the sea.
- 48:03The amount of content creation and people can besmirch the the
- 48:07industry of content creation, but it does have a lot of value
- 48:10And that's one thing that is really bullish over the last 5-6
- 48:15years particularly is that there's been a ton of high value
- 48:19content creators that really understand Bitcoin and more
- 48:22importantly how to articulate it to different audiences.
- 48:25Because my flavour of delivering the message is much different
- 48:28than Andy or Jesse or. Peter Mccormick's or other
- 48:33people in the world and people really resonate with particular
- 48:38ways of portraying a message, which is important.
- 48:41So we've had many different types of educators come to the
- 48:45market over the last five years portraying the message in a very
- 48:49particular way that resonates with particular types of people,
- 48:52which is really good. It's just going to help speed
- 48:54things up as we move forward. Yeah, I I think that's that's
- 49:01like a it's a big part of how this all goes is every year,
- 49:06every cycle, really the barrier to understanding Bitcoin drops
- 49:13because the events in the world help help make the Bitcoin value
- 49:20proposition a little clearer. But I think bigger than that is
- 49:24the quality of educational resources.
- 49:27And and the number of educational resources keeps
- 49:30growing and you know we're all collectively homing in on on you
- 49:38know the core message at least to people like us.
- 49:44You know I I think I've improved as a as a Bitcoin educator.
- 49:47I'm sure Marty and Andy feel that they get to the to to the
- 49:52nut of it a little bit faster or.
- 49:55With greater ease and and brush aside all the noise more
- 50:00effectively when communicating the value proposition of
- 50:04Bitcoin. And we're all doing that as an
- 50:06industry where we're doing that as an asset class.
- 50:09It's becoming clearer and clearer what this thing is and
- 50:12that only continues. It's kind of hard to imagine
- 50:16Bitcoin education getting better and simpler.
- 50:19But it it will, it has and it will continue.
- 50:24And that will reach so many more people.
- 50:26And you know, all the all the people that glaze their glaze
- 50:29over when you talk about Bitcoin.
- 50:31Eventually the the message will become so simplified and so
- 50:37clear that that will get through to them and that glazed overlook
- 50:41will be instead the epiphany look of of realization.
- 50:48Yeah. And that's my hope.
- 50:51That's my hope guys. It's working.
- 50:54It's gonna keep. Trucking one day at a time, one
- 50:56week at a time, one month at a time, one year at a time.
- 50:59Slowly but surely, more and more people will come.
- 51:01The waves get bigger. People will stay get larger.
- 51:04The amount of people who stay get larger.
- 51:05Yeah. And and the people who take take
- 51:07the risk are rewarded. And then they, you know, a cycle
- 51:12later. They're they're the people that
- 51:17other people listen to. You know, like like I, I was
- 51:21talking to a a wealth manager earlier this week who has his
- 51:26clients, small group of his clients, a pretty heavy
- 51:30allocation to Bitcoin in particular because he wants that
- 51:33before the halving. So he's either going to be
- 51:36proven very right and, you know a lot more clients are going to
- 51:41want his advice, or we're all wrong.
- 51:46This is going to be one of the other and and the halving is
- 51:49coming along to to mechanically show us who is right and who is
- 51:54wrong. Yeah, that's it.
- 51:56I was the the one of the conversations I was having
- 51:59earlier in the day today with the financial advisor was on
- 52:03that topic. His perspective, he was talking
- 52:05to his business partner, his senior partner really into whose
- 52:10shoes he may step, you know when that person retires.
- 52:14And the conversation was, you know something along the lines
- 52:18of his partner saying, you know, look I understand you want to
- 52:22put this in the portfolio, you know, so that your clients
- 52:27portfolios perform well given the facts and circumstances and
- 52:32likely we're in a bull market and the halving and the ETF and
- 52:35all the positive catalysts and he corrected his partner saying
- 52:40no, I don't think you understand.
- 52:42Yes, this is for the benefits of the of the clients, but it's
- 52:46also a defensive self preservation move for our
- 52:50business as an advisory firm. Because if we miss this
- 52:54opportunity after it's been, I don't want to say this obvious,
- 53:00but it's been apparent for a long time what value this asset
- 53:04Bitcoin offers. You know we're going to.
- 53:08We're going to be in a tough spot if we, if we miss this
- 53:11opportunity essentially a second time around, a second cycle
- 53:15around, you know, it was, it really wasn't on the radar 2
- 53:19cycles ago, but last cycle it certainly was.
- 53:23And yeah, we're we're finally getting to the point where
- 53:27really honestly, fiduciaries are probably negligent.
- 53:32They're certainly negligent if they haven't done their research
- 53:35and understood Bitcoin, you know.
- 53:38Advisors have every right to do their proper due diligence and
- 53:42the research and reach the conclusion that Bitcoin isn't
- 53:46appropriate for their clients for whatever reason.
- 53:50That would be a surprising conclusion, but in theory they
- 53:54could. But yeah, at minimum they need
- 53:57to be educating themselves doing the work, and I'm pretty
- 54:02confident that those that do the work.
- 54:05Are going to end up accumulating, buying and
- 54:08accumulating on behalf of their clients.
- 54:12Andy, can we like expand on that like game out, How do you see
- 54:15this at least next cycle playing out?
- 54:17Because I know like the last cycle there was a lot of Ras
- 54:20kind of getting set up and then FTX happened and they basically
- 54:24all hands off and like, all right, we're not touching any of
- 54:26this. But like do you see price
- 54:29appreciation and then wanting to get in because they're looking
- 54:32at raising, you know, fees and assets under management?
- 54:34Or is it, you know, kind of bottoms up from the end client
- 54:36being like you need to hold this thing or I'm going somewhere
- 54:39else effectively, like what takes it away from being
- 54:43radioactive? Because that's where I feel like
- 54:46that's the part of the market that's most radioactive where
- 54:48you don't know. I was just chatting with one
- 54:51again before this call and he was like, I don't want to keep
- 54:52you up to the to the recording. I was like, no, no, it's perfect
- 54:54because this is getting me set like to go and in that term
- 54:57radioactive came up because I didn't know how to position it
- 55:00with him because it's the one persona that can be like we're
- 55:04never touching that. That's insane And he loved that
- 55:07like term. So I'm just curious like how do
- 55:08we get past that or is it just going to be multiple cycles
- 55:11before we we kind of or is it a graduate suddenly type thing?
- 55:14Yeah. Now Michael, I I love that
- 55:16question and it's obviously key key to the development of the
- 55:19business and the industry. And look I was, I'll be the
- 55:22first to say I was wrong. I thought last cycle we were
- 55:26ready. That's right.
- 55:28I went and and I built a product in anticipation of lots of
- 55:32demand from financial advisors on behalf of their clients and
- 55:36yeah, then. Then FTX blew up and and three
- 55:42AC before that, you know Doquan and all the shenanigans.
- 55:47So I thought that cycle was a cycle.
- 55:50I'm even more confident this time around though, because not
- 55:55least because the four year cycle has maintained, not least
- 56:00because SPF just got convicted on all counts in dramatic
- 56:05fashion, so that. I think period is hopefully
- 56:10behind us. Yeah.
- 56:13I think the facts and circumstances we already talked
- 56:15about with finance losing market share with Coinbase, you know,
- 56:24at one-on-one side being sued by the SEC, but on the other side,
- 56:29you know being offered the potential carrot of getting all
- 56:33this custody business from the ETF.
- 56:37ETFs, plural. So anyway, but how will it go?
- 56:40For sure there's bottom up demand.
- 56:42I mean, how many times does Bitcoin have to not die and come
- 56:46back from the dead for clients to pay attention and demand
- 56:53either to own it or to understand it, or you know, to
- 56:57have it included by financial advisors in their portfolios.
- 57:00That's for sure a big part of the situation.
- 57:05Another part of it is, yeah, the more and better educational
- 57:08resources, it's easier for financial advisors to get up to
- 57:10speed. A major part for for FA is yeah,
- 57:15is being able to bill and collect fees on this stuff.
- 57:20Obviously they'll be able to do that with the ETF and a Schwab
- 57:24account, but that being paper Bitcoin is a with a single
- 57:28custodian is a poor substitute for actual Bitcoin with multi
- 57:33multi institution. Multi SIG custody.
- 57:36So yeah, I think that I think that all of these, I think of
- 57:41all of these factors as being significant and just you know
- 57:47just pure size. I mean if this bull run turns
- 57:51out the way I think it will, the way probably all of you in the
- 57:54room here think it will, I mean that puts Bitcoin on the map as
- 58:00a multi trillion dollar asset class.
- 58:03That's pretty hard to ignore. It's at that level.
- 58:06It is the perfect combination of too big to ignore, but also
- 58:10still tiny in the grand scheme of global assets of hundreds of
- 58:17trillions of dollars. You know, close to a quadrillion
- 58:19dollars in global assets, you know, a few trillion is is still
- 58:24peanuts. Doesn't move the needle so.
- 58:27It's, yeah, it's it's all of the above, the market maturing.
- 58:31Who knows, maybe maybe we get more sovereigns involved in this
- 58:35cycle. Clearly we're going to get
- 58:37institutional money and clearly we're going to have just more
- 58:41average investors, average people that want to save their
- 58:45money in something that is limited supply, not something
- 58:49that the government can keep praying more of.
- 58:53Yeah, I I've like. A scale that on one side keeps
- 59:00having pebbles added to it. And you know at some point
- 59:05there's a tipping point, right? And Andy, you mentioned you said
- 59:09a word earlier, you said the word negligent and that I found
- 59:14that very interesting. At what point do you think it
- 59:17becomes negligent for wealth managers, financial advisors to
- 59:24not be? Getting educated themselves or
- 59:30talking about the possibility of a Bitcoin allocation with their
- 59:33clients. Yeah, so I went public on that
- 59:38score I think a couple years ago.
- 59:40I can't remember the exact time frame, so my feeling is that
- 59:46we're already there now. The counter argument would be
- 59:49well, OK, but since then there have been failed custodians.
- 59:55You know, there have been ruggings.
- 59:58There have been, there has been some ongoing regulatory
- 1:00:03uncertainty. Some would argue, although
- 1:00:05really if you do the work on Bitcoin, you see that Bitcoin is
- 1:00:08basically a regulatory Teflon. So I think, I think someone who
- 1:00:14would argue, no, it wasn't, you know, it wasn't negligence
- 1:00:18several years ago for those, you know, would highlight those
- 1:00:23reasons. But yeah, I think that with
- 1:00:26custody solved, I think that with Bitcoin's price correlation
- 1:00:35to stocks and other risk assets, you know, reversing back towards
- 1:00:400 like it used to be, you know, it was it was an uncorrelated
- 1:00:45asset and then it was correlated for a while and then
- 1:00:48uncorrelated and then correlated again and now it's uncorrelated
- 1:00:51again. So over the long run,
- 1:00:54uncorrelated, yet there have been periods of time when the
- 1:00:56correlation has been higher with other risk assets.
- 1:01:00I think that factor helps. And yeah, I think that I think
- 1:01:06that getting some of these prosecutions and legal issues
- 1:01:13behind the industry are all supporting facts, argue in
- 1:01:17favour of it being negligent not to at least do one's due
- 1:01:24diligence and research on Bitcoin and arguably to to own
- 1:01:29it in in all client accounts. Certainly I've felt that it's
- 1:01:33negligent to not own Bitcoin for my clients.
- 1:01:37And I have, you know, felt that way and and executed on that
- 1:01:41feeling for several years now. I I think it's romantic when we
- 1:01:45talk about the negligence or like treasuries need to hold.
- 1:01:48I think what ultimately happens is the game theory just plays
- 1:01:51out as it's supposed to where like to going gaming out.
- 1:01:55If a client's hold 1 to 2% right now, if we're seeing 80% hold
- 1:01:59them off platform and it's 1 to 2%.
- 1:02:02And based on what Andy referenced, we did A5 or 10X
- 1:02:06well that now that's 10% potentially of the client's
- 1:02:09portfolio. And at 1 to 2%, I think like
- 1:02:12when I referenced, I'm, I'm working through this as Andy was
- 1:02:14saying, it's like we said radioactive.
- 1:02:17And while it's radioactive, it's kind of like radioactive because
- 1:02:21those those people are the loudest.
- 1:02:22And so it's probably less radioactive for that segment of
- 1:02:26the market. It's more of mutual, but it's
- 1:02:29mutual to maybe negative. But because it's only 1 to 2%,
- 1:02:32it's like, well, what's the upside in going and investing in
- 1:02:36infrastructure resources for it because.
- 1:02:39It's only 1 to 2% and I don't mind it being off platform if I
- 1:02:41just get it out of my way and I don't even want to bill on it.
- 1:02:44But then if it goes to 10X, if again staying still, there's no
- 1:02:48more demand from clients like capital outside of the account
- 1:02:51or net new clients. Now it's like, well I'm missing
- 1:02:53out on 10% and on a book if somebody managing you know a
- 1:02:57couple 100 million. That becomes a material from
- 1:03:00what you're paying. So I think like does that make
- 1:03:02sense Andy on that could be another driving force is just
- 1:03:04basically the clients a balance. It gets so, so high relative to
- 1:03:09their overall overarching portfolio that they're like,
- 1:03:12hey, bring this in house, we have a solution for it and we
- 1:03:14can now Bill. Yeah, absolutely Michael.
- 1:03:17I mean imagine yeah the client who has substantial portion of
- 1:03:21their overall assets in Bitcoin and their financial advisors.
- 1:03:26It's still pretending like it doesn't exist.
- 1:03:28You know like can't can't talk about it can't acknowledge its
- 1:03:32existence like Bitcoin. What that's like what is that
- 1:03:36like the word Voldemort. Like it can't, can't be uttered
- 1:03:38Word that cannot be uttered. I mean it's it's it's it becomes
- 1:03:43ridiculous as you say when the numbers start to become material
- 1:03:47for the client. The other thing I'll add too
- 1:03:50that comes to mind is narratives and and FUD.
- 1:03:54You know, I think it was almost two years ago I published an
- 1:03:57article on Bitcoin Magazine and the title was something like
- 1:04:01Bitcoin is the most ESG friendly investment in my client's
- 1:04:05portfolios. And people at the time thought
- 1:04:08that was nuts. I mean that was sort of peak
- 1:04:12peak blowback in terms of, you know, energy usage and and the
- 1:04:16environmental narrative, Marty. I know that's near and dear to
- 1:04:20your heart. And I've actually been surprised
- 1:04:25at how quickly and thoroughly that has reversed.
- 1:04:29I used to get questions and comments from multiple clients,
- 1:04:35the moaning basically energy usage of Bitcoin as well as you
- 1:04:39know, criminality in Bitcoin and obviously that's just been
- 1:04:43factually erroneous for years now.
- 1:04:46But I have been surprised and pleased at how quickly the
- 1:04:52narrative has shifted to the OR in the correct direction, which
- 1:04:58is, which is the opposite of where we were in terms of the
- 1:05:02the narratives and the FUD just a year, year and a half ago.
- 1:05:09Yeah, it it, it's such an exciting story, you know, like
- 1:05:14Marty, I know that you disagree with with all things ESG, but.
- 1:05:19And like I'm I'm I'm thrilled to see you know the positive spin
- 1:05:23of of Bitcoin as like a as a as a good ESG quote UN quote good
- 1:05:27ESG until they. Rug you, Jesse, until they rug
- 1:05:31you. So we're.
- 1:05:32Going to rug ourselves. Yeah, well, you know, like,
- 1:05:36like, I love, I love hearing the arguments about like, methane
- 1:05:39capture. Like there's no other use case
- 1:05:41that really it really makes sense to try to do methane
- 1:05:44capture for and make it economic.
- 1:05:47But here's Bitcoin to like plug into your landfill and capture
- 1:05:51methane. If, if that's what everybody is
- 1:05:53worried about, here's Bitcoin it it just, it plugs in to satisfy
- 1:05:57just panacea for for environmental concerns And you
- 1:06:02know, whether or not we should be focused on that at all.
- 1:06:05Different story, but like, I just love that, that there's an
- 1:06:08exciting narrative that people can can focus on with regard to
- 1:06:12some of these hot topics that that people care about.
- 1:06:15I agree with that. But only up to a certain extent.
- 1:06:17We discussed it last week. The the one thing I worry with
- 1:06:20the Bitcoin mining industry catering to ESG is the
- 1:06:23particular line of thinking that we're gonna incentivize the
- 1:06:26build out of wind and solar. And as we discussed last week
- 1:06:29with the 1st 20 years, 22 years of this century and what Germany
- 1:06:33did to more than double the capacity of energy generation,
- 1:06:36but actually reduce actual generation over that decade
- 1:06:42while doubling prices. And decommissioning nuclear,
- 1:06:46coal and natural gas plants, Like, that's the one thing I
- 1:06:48worry about is if you cater too hard to the ESG and you go along
- 1:06:52with it, like, yeah, we'll build all your wind and solar.
- 1:06:54That, number one, is not going to be economically viable in the
- 1:06:59long run because those things are heavily subsidized.
- 1:07:01And if Bitcoin's successful, the subsidies go away and your
- 1:07:04mining operation becomes unprofitable overnight.
- 1:07:07And then number two, more broadly speaking, it's just not
- 1:07:10good for the grids. I don't want to.
- 1:07:13Dive too deep into this and right under ESG parade, Jesse.
- 1:07:16But that's but. But I I think it's an important
- 1:07:19it. It is an important frame because
- 1:07:21this reminds me of this is a little controversial but Malay,
- 1:07:25if that's his name the the president he went viral with a
- 1:07:27pretty crazy 2 minutes but he references you don't negotiate
- 1:07:31with these people. The reason why you don't is
- 1:07:33because of the concept Easy, easy choices, Hard life, Hard
- 1:07:37choices, Easy life or easy conversations.
- 1:07:40Hard life, hard conversations, easy life.
- 1:07:42It's like if you get ahead of it and you frame, it's supposed to
- 1:07:45waste or not waste, it's supposed to use lots of energy
- 1:07:47and that's good. And then you break it down, then
- 1:07:49you back into OK, well maybe it's harder up front, but then
- 1:07:52you set yourself up for success further down versus the the
- 1:07:56catering or whatever reference. So anyway, that's just more of
- 1:07:58like the positioning that it can be.
- 1:08:00It's similar with the Black Rock stuff.
- 1:08:02It's like, Oh yeah, it's great price pumps until everyone gets
- 1:08:04rugged and they're like, oh shit, we should have had the
- 1:08:06hard conversations. Yeah.
- 1:08:10And speaking with, I mean we're talking about somewhat internal
- 1:08:16bullish catalysts, whether it's education, the ETF imminent
- 1:08:22approval, finance getting pushed to the sidelines, the the
- 1:08:27thrift, the grift, excuse me leaving the industry, but
- 1:08:31externally too, I wrote about this in the newsletter last
- 1:08:34night, like the geopolitical situation is really.
- 1:08:38Setting the stage for a Bitcoin pump because things at the
- 1:08:42international foreign exchange level are really beginning to to
- 1:08:46get frothy. You had Saudi Arabia, their,
- 1:08:52their Minister of Foreign Affairs basically come out last
- 1:08:55week and we're going to go on a tour to try to push for de
- 1:08:59escalation between. Gaza and Israel and explicitly
- 1:09:04mentioned that they're gonna go to China first, saying, hey,
- 1:09:06China in our mind is the most important geopolitical partner
- 1:09:10that we want to convince for this particular issue, which is
- 1:09:14a big signal it's not the US that they're gonna go to #2.
- 1:09:19Right off the heels of that announcement, China and Saudi
- 1:09:21Arabia announced that they're opening up a currency swap line
- 1:09:24of $7 billion over the next two years and that they're going to.
- 1:09:29Begin settling trades outside of oil.
- 1:09:32Between the two countries and their native currencies, $7
- 1:09:35billion is a drop in the bucket if we're speaking about global
- 1:09:39assets and global markets. However, it is a step in a
- 1:09:43direction away from US hegemony and Saudi Arabia really leaning
- 1:09:49on US. And then on top of that, rumors
- 1:09:52are beginning to spread that China is underwriting loans in
- 1:09:57Latin America. In Africa, particularly for raw
- 1:10:01materials, energy resources and they're giving these countries
- 1:10:06dollars up front, but on the back end they want to be paid
- 1:10:09out and yuan. And so at the international
- 1:10:13level you can see the the steps away from the US dollar reserve
- 1:10:17system for the world beginning to to materialize in the.
- 1:10:22The drum beat of Saudi Arabia joining BRICS countries gets
- 1:10:26louder and louder, which is just gonna be incredibly chaotic for
- 1:10:30global currency markets. And as we've said before, we
- 1:10:35should expect this to continue this trend to continue.
- 1:10:38I would argue that it's the wrong solution.
- 1:10:40I don't think Saudi Arabia, China, India, the BRICS
- 1:10:43countries are gonna be able to create a formidable Fiat
- 1:10:46currency that is better than the dollar or.
- 1:10:51Better than more importantly, better than Bitcoin.
- 1:10:53Like I think the solution to this is the apolitical monetary
- 1:10:58rails which which is the Bitcoin network.
- 1:11:00But there will be a period where due to the geopolitical pissing
- 1:11:05match that the the world powers find themselves in, the group
- 1:11:09will try to defect from the US, create their own currency that
- 1:11:12will inevitably fail, and then people will realize how Bitcoin
- 1:11:14was the answer the whole time. And that's a massive tailwind
- 1:11:17for Bitcoin adoption over the next decade.
- 1:11:22That's it. I couldn't couldn't have said it
- 1:11:25better myself. I really like the way it's
- 1:11:28playing out to, which is probably all of us at one point
- 1:11:35thought that hyper bitcoinization was happening
- 1:11:37right now, right now being some point in the last however many
- 1:11:41years, and at the same time that the dollar will lose market
- 1:11:47share to Chinese Yuan or other countries, it's still so
- 1:11:54dominant that it's likely to take a very long time.
- 1:11:58And this gives more time for companies like us to build on
- 1:12:03Bitcoin and also for the protocol itself to continue to
- 1:12:07harden. And so yeah, I am simultaneously
- 1:12:13bearish on the dollar in the very long run.
- 1:12:17And yet not that bearish. You know in the in the short and
- 1:12:22medium run I think the dollar probably has a lot of legs left.
- 1:12:28I think that as maybe you were implying Marty, you know in in a
- 1:12:33in a world that's become more multi polar, people want
- 1:12:36different options and if you want different options maybe one
- 1:12:39of those options should be Bitcoin.
- 1:12:41But oh by the way you're probably not going to dump the
- 1:12:43dollar anytime soon. Oh, and also if stable coins
- 1:12:47continue to flourish, that's incremental demand for dollars
- 1:12:51at the same time that Bitcoin is taking market share from
- 1:12:56everything. And so, I mean it's it's it's
- 1:12:59kind of a perfect story and process of evolution for
- 1:13:06Bitcoin, which is it's not happening too slowly and it's
- 1:13:10not happening too quickly. It's sort of the Goldilocks
- 1:13:13scenario at the moment. I granted that could change at
- 1:13:16any time. Who knows what the future holds,
- 1:13:18you know, maybe it'll be a a more violent transition that of
- 1:13:22course that's possible. I hope it doesn't go that way.
- 1:13:26I used to worry more about it going that way.
- 1:13:28I actually worry less about it going that way.
- 1:13:30But that's just my two cents and and my perspective on how I
- 1:13:35think it's most likely to play out.
- 1:13:39Yeah, we're we're all afraid that it hyperbic organization's
- 1:13:42going to happen and it's going to be too jarring for the world.
- 1:13:45But it turns out people are really slow to realize the value
- 1:13:49of this, the value proposition here and slow to adopt.
- 1:13:53And so it kind of works itself out.
- 1:13:54But Marty, what you were talking about all these, all these
- 1:13:57events right now, this is what Zoltan, Zoltan Pozar was writing
- 1:14:03about? Almost two years ago at Credit
- 1:14:08Suisse, when Credit Suisse was a thing and the the Ukraine war
- 1:14:13had just broken out, and he wrote this incredible piece
- 1:14:18proclaiming the death of Bretton Woods 2 monetary system and the
- 1:14:25beginning of Bretton Woods 3 monetary system, which he
- 1:14:29characterized the time as as a shift from inside money.
- 1:14:35To outside money and it's a little bit of ambiguous term,
- 1:14:40but what he meant was that for the last 30 years the global
- 1:14:49reserve currency and and and currencies that you know all the
- 1:14:53all the big currencies have been somebody's liability.
- 1:14:56You know you you hold U.S. Treasuries, that's the global
- 1:14:59reserve currency and it's the United States liability.
- 1:15:05And that is fine so long as there's stability and and no
- 1:15:10risk of any kind of default soft or hard inflation or, you know,
- 1:15:15throwing your hands up and saying I won't pay it And now
- 1:15:20with cutting Russia off from the SWIFT banking network and
- 1:15:28seizing their foreign exchange reserves.
- 1:15:30Suddenly that era's over and that that's what happened almost
- 1:15:34almost two years ago now. And Zoltan pointed out that that
- 1:15:38means, you know, the the global monetary system has to gravitate
- 1:15:42towards a a new de facto for what is money and what will be
- 1:15:47used as reserve currencies. And the shift has to be away
- 1:15:52from liabilities, away from inside money and and towards
- 1:15:55outside money. OK, money that has value.
- 1:15:59Outside of the financial system, meaning commodities, meaning
- 1:16:03things that that have a a a market value because they're
- 1:16:08commodities, they're tangible things that people need and
- 1:16:12trade for. And he meant oil and gold.
- 1:16:17And he at the very end of that note observed that, you know,
- 1:16:23he's not a Bitcoin bull. But if any asset stands to gain
- 1:16:28from all this, it's probably Bitcoin.
- 1:16:31And here we are watching that play out now with, you know, the
- 1:16:35with Argentina having so much problem, so many problems
- 1:16:40fiscally that they've elected anarcho capitalist politician,
- 1:16:46which is a very interesting and sort of exciting development.
- 1:16:51A libertarian is now president of Argentina.
- 1:16:54And is a Bitcoin bowl. And what does that mean for
- 1:16:59Latin America? Because we have El Salvador That
- 1:17:03has already shifted. Was already dollarized, meaning
- 1:17:09that the dollar was legal tender there.
- 1:17:14And they added Bitcoin. So Bitcoin is also, you know, an
- 1:17:19official currency of El Salvador.
- 1:17:20They have. They have too.
- 1:17:22Could that happen to Argentina now?
- 1:17:26Maybe. Maybe they dollarize, maybe they
- 1:17:30also add Bitcoin because you know if the if the if Malay
- 1:17:36follows through on that intent and then then you're talking
- 1:17:40about Latin America, seeing these Canaries really countries
- 1:17:45that have had weakness in this era of inside money.
- 1:17:52And and El Salvador, you know, was a was a broken state for so
- 1:17:56long that the populist, populist appetite shifted towards let's
- 1:18:01change it, let's let's radically shift and let's try something
- 1:18:06new. And that has led to, you know,
- 1:18:08to Bitcoin. And the same might be happening
- 1:18:12in Argentina. And as those cases prove prove
- 1:18:16fruitful, more of Latin America may may follow.
- 1:18:21Other Canaries in the global monetary landscape, I mean
- 1:18:25countries whose currency are not as strong as the dollar, but I
- 1:18:30guess not as weak as El Salvador as old currency and and
- 1:18:34Argentina's recently. And so you're you're seeing this
- 1:18:38this shift in real time of the dominoes falling, the Canaries
- 1:18:42falling that that caused a a shift away from U.S.
- 1:18:47Treasuries or other even weaker currencies than that.
- 1:18:51And towards the the the case for a bricks based oil and gold
- 1:18:56backed currency. And meanwhile, Bitcoin just
- 1:18:59keeps getting stronger and keeps being the actual solution that
- 1:19:03people will eventually find as they search for the best kind of
- 1:19:07outside currency in this new Bretton Woods 3 era.
- 1:19:14Yeah. I think this is an important
- 1:19:15discussion because most people would think, like, you come on,
- 1:19:17we're going to, you know, Bitcoin wins.
- 1:19:19It's all game over. And this is really nuanced in
- 1:19:21the sense of, like, if you look long enough, you see how that
- 1:19:24plays out. But then there's this
- 1:19:25intermediary period and it's a very long period, probably 10 to
- 1:19:2820 years. And I think about it like what
- 1:19:30Andy and and Jesse were describing.
- 1:19:31You know Marty, it's like Bitcoin sits in the center and
- 1:19:33then these like 3 currencies oscillate around and it's the
- 1:19:37dollar and then it's whatever they create and then it's gold.
- 1:19:41Whatever they create is like this quasi CVC.
- 1:19:43And it just continues. Like as people get educated and
- 1:19:45rugged, you just keep taking more and more of the market
- 1:19:47share. And we're just going to keep
- 1:19:48going back and forth. And Bitcoin's going to do.
- 1:19:49I mean, gold's going to do its thing.
- 1:19:51And then people are going to wake up one day when they get
- 1:19:53the tungsten and, you know, tons and tons of it.
- 1:19:55They're like, wait, why are we transferring this thing around?
- 1:19:57And planes and they're shooting them down and they're like, oh,
- 1:19:58it was Bitcoin the whole time. And we're just watching them,
- 1:20:01like, try to create Bitcoin and they already exist.
- 1:20:04But to Andy's points, like, it's kind of exciting.
- 1:20:06I'm grateful after you look. Longer at it.
- 1:20:09It's like we got time to build stuff and you know, not be
- 1:20:12scrambling and it's less chaotic and we can sit here and do this
- 1:20:15and educate and then build products and services and and so
- 1:20:18it's it's fun that in my opinion it's gonna take a little longer,
- 1:20:21'cause I think it's a natural course of things.
- 1:20:23And selfishly, it'll allow us to stack more sets, you know?
- 1:20:26Yeah. And and the risk of persecution
- 1:20:28is higher if if it's more sudden change, the gradual change is is
- 1:20:32much better for Bitcoin holders in that sense.
- 1:20:36When, When Marty? I remember a few years ago
- 1:20:41making the astute point that this stuff takes time.
- 1:20:44What was there a singular moment in your mind when you sort of
- 1:20:48came to that, that realization with respect to Bitcoin?
- 1:20:51Or was it just learned, you know, over time by you?
- 1:20:57I mean, the old patience is a virtue falling back to that
- 1:21:02number one, but no #2 really understanding.
- 1:21:05Like Early Days New York of the of my show and my newsletter
- 1:21:10really diving into bit devs and the protocol development.
- 1:21:15Like it literally to build out the infrastructure that will
- 1:21:17onboard people takes time. I think that it's interesting
- 1:21:22'cause it really runs in parallel to the education piece
- 1:21:25that we've been talking about throughout this conversation.
- 1:21:27It's like they both take time. And literally, if we're gonna
- 1:21:30onboard billions of people, it's gonna take time.
- 1:21:33To build out the protocol infrastructure and the layers on
- 1:21:35top of it and all the tools and services that help people get on
- 1:21:41board and on the Bitcoin, that literally takes time to build
- 1:21:44that. So was it Bitdev's New York when
- 1:21:49they're pulling up the list of bips and you realize that a lot
- 1:21:52of these things have already been on the docket for years,
- 1:21:54and maybe this stuff's gonna take a while.
- 1:21:57Yeah, I mean getting changes in the Bitcoin happens at a a a
- 1:22:01glacial pace. That was really internalized,
- 1:22:04going to bit devs like I remember my first bit devs ever
- 1:22:07was January 2015, couple months after I moved to New York from
- 1:22:12Chicago, and they had just announced SegWit there, like how
- 1:22:18it would work, you know, it wasn't until 2 1/2 three years
- 1:22:21later that it actually got implemented.
- 1:22:24Wow. Yep.
- 1:22:29Which in the. Grand scheme of history is not
- 1:22:32that long. Feels like a long time though.
- 1:22:34A lot of things happened in a few years in Bitcoin.
- 1:22:39Yeah, this time last year, this time last year feels like a
- 1:22:43decade ago. And all the exchanges and
- 1:22:45everything, just it was literally just a year ago.
- 1:22:47Yeah, that's insane. Gentlemen, this has been great.
- 1:22:51Shall we wrap up Thanksgiving week?
- 1:22:52What are we thankful for? I'm thankful.
- 1:22:58That I only have to eat Turkey once a year, and that every
- 1:23:01other day of the year I can eat beef instead.
- 1:23:06That's good. I'll, I'll go.
- 1:23:09I was gonna say it earlier when we moved on.
- 1:23:12One of the things that really exciting like going back to
- 1:23:15getting a little sentimental is why we're gonna win is the
- 1:23:19financial advisors like, I don't know and maybe I'm missing an
- 1:23:22asset. Maybe you can be honest where
- 1:23:24financial advisor is incentivized to have purview and
- 1:23:26bill on the assets and direct relationship with the client and
- 1:23:31never have I seen such obviously like the importance from the OR
- 1:23:38the recognition of importance from a financial advisor for
- 1:23:40their clients to get exposure in the right way when you're in
- 1:23:43these like networks. These groups where I had met one
- 1:23:46a couple years ago and I'm in Pittsburgh visiting family and I
- 1:23:49met with him in person and he told me at this coffee shop that
- 1:23:51he meets after work and sets up the treasure for the the person
- 1:23:55outside of work hours and outside of the billable hours to
- 1:23:59get them set up in the right way.
- 1:24:01And there's those are individuals all over the country
- 1:24:03probably all over the world doing that And so outside of
- 1:24:06family and and all of that being thankful, like I'm just thankful
- 1:24:09for the people in the space that are very interested and and
- 1:24:12willing to go out and step outside and that's why we're
- 1:24:13ultimately going to win is because you can't like stop
- 1:24:16that. Like there's no there's no
- 1:24:17there's an idea that's just like always going to be there.
- 1:24:20So yeah. Me too.
- 1:24:22And several of those advisors who are doing right by their
- 1:24:26clients are personal friends and I'm grateful for them also.
- 1:24:33Yeah, I I'm grateful for a lot of things.
- 1:24:36New chapter right now for me moving to Texas and a lot a lot
- 1:24:41of excitement around all that and and the family is.
- 1:24:44Is is happy and and settling in so that's really the the story
- 1:24:49of of this Thanksgiving season for me but to to bring a little
- 1:24:53bit of Bitcoin into it because that's what people really care
- 1:24:56about. I I just realized we I think we
- 1:25:00are now well depending on block average block time going forward
- 1:25:04we are at or just under five months until the next having.
- 1:25:09So once we're in four and change that feels awfully close.
- 1:25:13And I'm thankful for that. You love the having.
- 1:25:19I love the having. The having is the having is
- 1:25:24Christmas. The the feeling of Christmas
- 1:25:26when you're a child. That's that's what the having is
- 1:25:29for me now. And it's all the more special
- 1:25:33'cause it only happens once every four years.
- 1:25:36It's not even every year. It's Christmas.
- 1:25:38Time's the Olympics. It's.
- 1:25:41The Olympics, The presidential. Yup, lines up a presidential
- 1:25:45election season. Which I think is why I think
- 1:25:48it's that's why it's four years cause how many years are you in
- 1:25:51college, high school? Four years.
- 1:25:53Four years. Olympics.
- 1:25:54Four years. World Cup.
- 1:25:56Four years. Presidential election, four
- 1:25:58years. There's so many rhythms in in
- 1:26:00life that I think that's why Satoshi was like 4 years seems
- 1:26:03to be Lindy. Let's go with that.
- 1:26:08I guess I'll wrap it up here, yeah.
- 1:26:13I'll echo what you said Jesse thankful for my family, wife,
- 1:26:16two boys, mother, brother, sister, tough year for us
- 1:26:20personally lost my father, but I think the the family support,
- 1:26:25the friend group support and most important my dad was really
- 1:26:28passionate about what we are doing here in Bitcoin.
- 1:26:30And so I'm thankful that we have something that we're passionate
- 1:26:34about to work on, really go for. Makes it easy to wake up every
- 1:26:39day. Gives you a purpose in life,
- 1:26:41happy to have purpose. There's a lot of people out
- 1:26:43there who don't thankful for that.
- 1:26:47We're thankful for you Marty take take taking the the load
- 1:26:50off our shoulders and we get to show up and and you steer the
- 1:26:54conversation so. You guys aren't half bad, so I'm
- 1:26:58don't sell yourself short. Half good, though.
- 1:27:02We're gonna get better. We're gonna.
- 1:27:04Improve. Yeah, Yeah.
- 1:27:06Next. Next Thanksgiving we're gonna be
- 1:27:07half good. I like that.
- 1:27:10Half good. We get the quarter.
- 1:27:12Good. Half bad quarter.
- 1:27:14OK. I'm kidding.
- 1:27:16It's a pleasure. It's been fun doing this.
- 1:27:18Thankful for the show. It's been a new addition to my
- 1:27:22content. Sweet, I guess you could say.
- 1:27:27Portfolio. How about?
- 1:27:28Portfolio, Content portfolio. And I've said this before, but
- 1:27:31it really allows me to scratch an itch that can't really
- 1:27:35scratch on rabbit hole. Recap it all the time, or TFTC
- 1:27:38even for that matter. So.
- 1:27:40Thankful for this, gentlemen. Enjoy your Thanksgiving.
- 1:27:43We got to blur out blur out, rabbit hole recap on this.
- 1:27:46So if anybody you know there's a lot of listeners that may not
- 1:27:49hurt have ever heard of it. We don't want them to see Marty
- 1:27:52Jones and. Go check it out.
- 1:27:53This is top of funnel for rabbit hole recap.
- 1:27:55This is If you're listening to this, you've already eaten your
- 1:28:02Thanksgiving dinner. Hopefully it was a good one.
- 1:28:06You enjoyed it. Hope you're safe.
- 1:28:10Bitcoin safe that you're doing well out there Michael.
- 1:28:16You look like you want to say something, Michael.
- 1:28:17I was just gonna say I didn't know if we were gonna drop this
- 1:28:20before Thanksgiving. Like it's a travel Wednesday.
- 1:28:23Do we? Do we decide on the air right
- 1:28:25now? Just forget everything I just
- 1:28:27said and go for it. And enjoy your Thanksgiving,
- 1:28:34Logan. We're dropping it tomorrow.
- 1:28:37All right, gentlemen. As always, it's a pleasure,
- 1:28:41Andy. Thank you for joining us.
- 1:28:43Pleasure's all mine stoked to be a member of this elite team.
- 1:28:47We're gonna do great things. We're gonna win.
- 1:28:51We're gonna win. Love it.
- 1:28:53See you guys next week.