Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Geoff Bacino - John McKechnie & Alonzo Swann - an EX- NCUA Roundtable
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trekel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here today with three former NCA folks from my time at NCA, all
- 0:09three of which have been on the podcast.
- 0:12Individually in a couple groups of of two.
- 0:14But today we're expanding it to four and I'm excited to have John
- 0:19Ney, Alonzo Swan and Jeff Bino.
- 0:22That's the order.
- 0:23They're on my video here.
- 0:25And guys, why don't you introduce yourself on what you did at NCA when you
- 0:29were there, in case a listener doesn't know and what it is you're doing now.
- 0:32And we'll start with John up in the upper left hand corner.
- 0:36McKechnie: I'm not.
- 0:37After all these years, I'm still not completely certain what I did at NNC A,
- 0:40but os ostensibly my title was Director of Public and Congressional Affairs.
- 0:45I was there during a pretty exciting time, as we all know, during the the financial
- 0:49crisis back in 2008 and through 2010.
- 0:53I have, since 2011, I've sh hung out my shingle.
- 0:56I'm doing my own thing on the consulting side working in the credit union space
- 1:01as well as with the home loan bank.
- 1:03One of the federal home loan banks and some of the mortgage
- 1:06and insurance firms out there.
- 1:09So just trying to stay busy.
- 1:10The last couple weeks have been a bit of a challenge with the
- 1:13federal government shut, but we can get to that in a few minutes.
- 1:16Treichel: Yes, we can.
- 1:17And speaking of Federal Home Loan Bank, Alonzo, why don't you go next?
- 1:20Swann: All righty.
- 1:21Claim of fame.
- 1:21I started in the early eighties with NCUA as an examiner.
- 1:25Worked my way up through the agency and moved ended up as director of
- 1:29supervision in about the 1990 timeframe.
- 1:33Had moved out to Chicago, my home area in 94, and finally I got promoted to regional
- 1:41director in 19 97, 98, officially.
- 1:44And retired from that position after 13 fun years except
- 1:49for the last couple in 2010.
- 1:52And during that same time, I side saddled in the air Force, retired as
- 1:55Lieutenant Colonel same year, 2010.
- 1:58And, took a, took three years off and after that decided I still had some
- 2:03purpose in life and ended up at the federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta,
- 2:07where today I'm their credit union strategist and I've been there going on
- 2:11my 13th year having a good time still.
- 2:13Treichel: Wow.
- 2:1313 years.
- 2:14That's amazing.
- 2:15That's amazing.
- 2:16And we had a lot of fun and a lot of regional director meetings where
- 2:19we would we'd hear from the powers that be about what they wanted to do.
- 2:23Maybe it was even Jeff telling the powers that be what we should do.
- 2:26And then we would break up in huddles and try and figure
- 2:29out how to get it done right.
- 2:32Bacino: Now that's what you're gonna tell the people, mark, is that we,
- 2:35as the board would tell you what to do and you guys would go do it.
- 2:38'cause I tell you, sometimes at the board level, we thought, wait minute
- 2:41we're telling 'em what to do and they're still doing what they wanna do.
- 2:43I'll segue in if you want.
- 2:44Treichel: You got it, Jeff, you're up.
- 2:46Bacino: Fortunate enough to have been appointed by Bill
- 2:48Clinton to be on the board.
- 2:49Back in late late 2000.
- 2:52Served down for about a year and a half, then was appointed by George W.
- 2:56Bush, which makes me true bipartisan to be on the Federal Housing Finance Board.
- 3:00So basically everybody on this call has some credit union and
- 3:03Federal home loan bank as well.
- 3:05After I left the finance board went off on my own again.
- 3:08I managed three trade associations, the association for Credit Union Audit and
- 3:13Risk Professionals, which is internal auditors, ERM, compliance and risk folks.
- 3:18I managed the Metropolitan Area Credit Union Management Association, that's
- 3:22Maryland, dc, Virginia Credit Unions and the National Council of Postal Credit
- 3:27Unions, handful of retainer clients and just like John trying to keep busy
- 3:32and trying to stay ahead of the law.
- 3:34Treichel: Ahead of the law.
- 3:35That's always a good thing.
- 3:36That's always a good thing.
- 3:37Speaking of law, the NCA Board by law is supposed to have three board members.
- 3:41And speaking of regulations, you're not supposed to commit eight false starts
- 3:44when you're trying to beat the ravens.
- 3:46Swann: Boo-hoo,
- 3:47Treichel: probably
- 3:47Swann: harder
- 3:48Treichel: filming this after having visited Minnesota to see the Vikings beat
- 3:53the Ravens and I had everything perfect.
- 3:55Really good seats, other than the fact that the Ravens outplayed us.
- 3:59And and now we got two Chicago Bears fans that are gonna beat up on me on Sunday.
- 4:03Probably just like the Bears will beat up on the Vikings.
- 4:06So
- 4:07Bacino: we can help,
- 4:08Treichel: But supposed to have three board members.
- 4:10We only have one board member, NC a's in the middle of budget season, not having
- 4:15a lot of board meetings, but they just did their budget briefing last week.
- 4:18Is there, are there any updates on, on, where we're at as far as the
- 4:22Supreme Court, where we're at on Tanya Ska and Todd Harper and their
- 4:27efforts or anything to share on that?
- 4:29Any of you guys?
- 4:33McKechnie: I went to the budget briefing last week and it was,
- 4:37it's, everybody's in a good mood.
- 4:39When you hear about a reduction in the budget.
- 4:41That right there, it gets everybody off on the right foot.
- 4:43I would say that the industry made, I thought the industry made
- 4:46some pretty constructive comments to chairman Houtman about how the
- 4:50agency needs to prioritize resources.
- 4:52There were, there was, there were some adults in the room.
- 4:54I thought it was smart.
- 4:55A lot of smart commentary.
- 4:57I think the undercurrent might.
- 4:59The one takeaway I would have is, that's an undercurrent of caution would be, we
- 5:02wanna make sure that the reduction in revenue and resources doesn't lead to.
- 5:08Cutting corners on the supervisory part.
- 5:11And I think we all know that, prioritizing more complex credit unions makes sense.
- 5:15And Alonzo especially knows, and mark, you, you both know this from the exam
- 5:20side you prioritize complex credit unions, but a lot of losses unfortunately occur
- 5:25in some of the smaller institutions.
- 5:27I don't know how to, I don't know how to balance that
- 5:29Treichel: well and there was one commenter about, small credit unions.
- 5:33You shouldn't have to go on site.
- 5:34And that's where the fraud can happen.
- 5:36Alonzo.
- 5:36You think of back in, in the days when, you get a phone call and it's
- 5:41the credit union's balance sheet says it's 18 million, but it's not.
- 5:45And all of a sudden something that.
- 5:47Looked like it was a place that you could skip over or spend a little
- 5:51bit of time turned into a place that you should have been spending
- 5:53more time from the beginning on.
- 5:54Any thoughts on that Alonzo?
- 5:57Swann: Yeah.
- 5:57You always have to balance your risk and one of the big major changes, of
- 6:01course, when I was an examiner believe it, or for the first two years until
- 6:06I volunteered, I never traveled.
- 6:08So everything was local.
- 6:10I could I went to same credit unions over and over again, knew the
- 6:13people, which I think is the most important thing you get from onsite.
- 6:17It's not going in there to look at the books.
- 6:18It's getting to know the people and looking out the corner of your eyes
- 6:22and that's one of the things you miss.
- 6:23And one of the other things I miss, 'cause I had predominantly small credit unions,
- 6:27is that many times I had to help them.
- 6:30And I had time to do that.
- 6:31Not much, even though I learned that old Chinese fish story,
- 6:34so we got that rectified.
- 6:36But I think that's gonna be missing when you just stop in.
- 6:39I I'd like to think wise enough to know it was different in some cases, but I
- 6:44think that assistance that I provided made them look forward to me coming.
- 6:48And it did.
- 6:49It wasn't the amount of time I stayed, I think it was just the comfort.
- 6:52I always said if I were on the credit union board.
- 6:55And I always told them this I'm the person who comes in and checks your
- 6:59weight to see whether you gained any or lost any or whether you remain the same.
- 7:02So that view, I think, is going to be missing that side.
- 7:06Look out the side of your eyes.
- 7:08That's what you're gonna miss when when you go a long time in between visits.
- 7:11Treichel: Sure.
- 7:11Yeah.
- 7:12And you're in the credit union, you're glad they're not coming.
- 7:14But when you're the regulator and you're not there as much or you're
- 7:17not on site the pen, and we have.
- 7:21Yeah, are we have, you look at the Wall Street Journal, you look at Bloomberg
- 7:26CU Today info or whatever you hear different pockets of delinquency is
- 7:31going in this direction, and then we hear the layoffs and different things.
- 7:33So they're shrinking at a time that, at least the big and maybe
- 7:37the middle size credit unions are glad they're not coming in as much.
- 7:41But the pendulum of having less staff and doing less swings back historically
- 7:46with losses that then have a new board say maybe we need more staff.
- 7:50And so those pendulums will swing.
- 7:52And Jeff, you were on the board what's your thought on on, on the budget and
- 7:55anything that might have been said last week or just your take on it in general?
- 7:59Bacino: I think, obviously credit unions are happy anytime you cut the
- 8:02budget and I'm gonna go out on a limb.
- 8:04I think the last time it was cut happened to be when Dennis and
- 8:07Yolanda and I were on the board.
- 8:09It, it does take a concerted effort to do it.
- 8:11They have had some advantages.
- 8:13You lose 20% of your staff.
- 8:15And I don't think what people are focusing on is you're also not
- 8:17paying two board members as well as their executive assistants and
- 8:21their administrative assistants.
- 8:22So you do have a little bit of savings there.
- 8:24Look, if you're talking about trying to just pinch pennies, you all of
- 8:27a sudden have, two thirds of your salary at the board level taken out.
- 8:31I do think it's important for credit unions to realize a couple things.
- 8:34Number one, obviously the budget is decided every year they will.
- 8:38Sometimes you guys at the agency will sometimes go in at a six month mark,
- 8:42and so what you're seeing now, as you just said, might change when you get.
- 8:47A complete board.
- 8:48In other words, you might get three board members and they say, wait a
- 8:51minute, we think we've had too many losses over the last six months.
- 8:54We need to beef this up.
- 8:55So in a way it's I guess a temporary high to be sure.
- 9:00But from a credit union's individual standpoint, I've heard from a lot
- 9:04of them that, you know, yes, they enjoy not seeing the examiners often.
- 9:08That's great.
- 9:09But I've also heard.
- 9:10What you're seeing is two things.
- 9:11Number one, sometimes the examiner's just checking a box, checking a
- 9:15list, saying, okay, do you have this?
- 9:17Do you have this?
- 9:18And and then focusing, I hate to say this, on the wrong things.
- 9:22Again, I think it's probably most likely because of a
- 9:25little bit of an inexperience.
- 9:26And Alonzo, you did this a long time.
- 9:28Mark, you followed this for a long time.
- 9:30You re that you reach a comfort level with your.
- 9:34Examined credit unions, and I think we're losing that right now.
- 9:38One of the things that I heard from my internal audit group was they're seeing
- 9:42that some of the examiners are coming in, and as I said, they're checking the boxes.
- 9:46But the reality is they're not digging deep enough and they leave
- 9:51and the internal auditor say, wait a minute, we still have these problems.
- 9:54Management is saying, no, they said we're good.
- 9:56It's gonna, it's gonna remain to be seen, obviously, what happens
- 9:59over the next couple months.
- 10:00But I think it's really gonna be interesting to see what happens
- 10:03when you get a full board.
- 10:05Treichel: Sure.
- 10:06And Alonza, you'll think of it, I think this will resonate with you.
- 10:10The concept of a lighter touch, you're hear less hours, you're hear
- 10:13less hours, you're hear less hours, and then the next time there's some
- 10:16stats and the numbers are worse and you show up with more people.
- 10:19And the examiners point out, Hey, four years ago you did something
- 10:23that violates the Federal Credit Union Act and we didn't catch it.
- 10:26But you've been doing it wrong for four years, and the credit union
- 10:28instinctively says you didn't bring it up for four years, and
- 10:31now all of a sudden it's my fault.
- 10:32Isn't that your job to point it out?
- 10:34And as Bob Blattner what said.
- 10:36Yeah the sovereign can always correct itself and say, Hey, we missed the
- 10:40boat for three years and now we're here to say that you can't do this.
- 10:43And you'll see that, when a new examiner comes in, when you're not
- 10:47as familiar with the credit union.
- 10:49And if you're doing less of a deep dive, even if it's the same one,
- 10:51all of a sudden you have to dig a little bit deeper two years down.
- 10:54So it's great right now to not have 'em coming in as much, but there's
- 10:58unintended consequences of that.
- 11:00And Alonzo, any thoughts on that?
- 11:02Swann: I agree with you.
- 11:02And just to get back to the big board, board picture, 'cause I do
- 11:05Treichel: Yeah.
- 11:06Swann: Want to just comment on that.
- 11:07I think the our country via the Constitution was built on compromise.
- 11:13I think you just find things, when my priority is this and yours is that,
- 11:17let's find a way to get to a win-win.
- 11:19And it's no different during the exam process as well, but I think that's
- 11:22what you miss when you don't have the other two board members there.
- 11:25And it's the look out the corner of your eye.
- 11:27I want to go left.
- 11:29And you normally have somebody on your right there to say
- 11:31maybe you shouldn't go that way.
- 11:33Now you don't.
- 11:34And that debate of the of policies and procedures, regulations, whatever,
- 11:39is I think was healthy and is healthy for not only the NCA Board, other
- 11:43boards, but our country as well.
- 11:45I think that's the downside of not having a full compliment.
- 11:48As the chairman always has.
- 11:51More of the gavel, if you will, but than one person on their side.
- 11:54But you still have to accommodate those on the other side as well.
- 11:59So I think there's just that banter that happened during the board meetings,
- 12:02those disagreements that happened.
- 12:04Why while you may not like sitting through.
- 12:06Two and three hour board meetings, but it's the final product that counts.
- 12:10And if it if it's a compromise that makes for a better product, I think we're better
- 12:15As far as the exam itself, I like I said, I think if you stick to the material
- 12:19things as an examiner, normally, you miss a regulation and you can always say, Hey,
- 12:23unless it impacts you in a major way.
- 12:26I'm just pointing it out now and we just need to get it fixed.
- 12:30I focused as an examiner and I think most, at least I tried to get
- 12:33my examiners when I was regional director to focus on the material.
- 12:37Treichel: Yep.
- 12:38Swann: And like I said, I there's not many material issues that are going to
- 12:42affect credit unions and that's how you explain when you find it immaterial.
- 12:46One.
- 12:47I wasn't looking for it, quite frankly.
- 12:49That's one you should have called,
- 12:50Treichel: right?
- 12:51Said.
- 12:51Said.
- 12:51John.
- 12:52I can see you've got something to add
- 12:53McKechnie: here.
- 12:54Yeah, I was thinking Alonzo stimulated some thoughts.
- 12:57I also had at the budget briefing.
- 12:59It wasn't explicitly addressed during the briefing, but you wonder.
- 13:04If there's gonna be a look at cost savings that are maybe partially generated by
- 13:09the fact you don't have as much staff.
- 13:11People are talking about the ones program, for instance, how they,
- 13:13that may be a, may be changed in some way, if not done away with.
- 13:17I haven't heard that come out at any, anybody at the board level over there.
- 13:20But you wonder if the number of regions might even go down.
- 13:23Again I don't know.
- 13:24I'm asking these questions rhetorically not because I know some inside
- 13:28information, but I just think these are the kind of things that.
- 13:31Probably you're gonna be on the table and at least thought
- 13:33about as we move into next year.
- 13:35Treichel: Yeah, there was, and they're doing a review and a study and they
- 13:38have some money in the budget to.
- 13:40To take a look at that.
- 13:41So yeah, they are.
- 13:43And then, you know what board will do that, right?
- 13:46Because let's say you were gonna get rid of ones that's a regulation change.
- 13:51Or if you're gonna change the structure of ones then you get into that whole what's
- 13:55essential, what can one board member do?
- 13:57What's a quorum?
- 13:59What e even if you conclude that you.
- 14:03Might be able to do it as a board member of one.
- 14:05Do you wanna do it as a board member of one and then have somebody else come back
- 14:10and question whether you can, so they
- 14:12McKechnie: get a little
- 14:12Treichel: complicated?
- 14:13McKechnie: That's a legit all fair point.
- 14:14So I will say the one thing I've heard from agency, legal staff is that they look
- 14:20at the Department of Justice filing in one of the, one of the board members appeals
- 14:26between Todd Harper and Tony Otsuka.
- 14:30And the DOJ one of the, one of the filings from DOJ said, we consider a single
- 14:37member board to be a quorum of one.
- 14:39Meaning DOJ is saying they can do rulemaking and so they can do rulemaking.
- 14:45But you're right, that's, that seems to be very possibly
- 14:50challenged in some future court.
- 14:53So it's we are in an uncertain period on that front.
- 14:57Treichel: Yeah.
- 14:57A DOJ says that, and for the longest time we thought a board
- 15:00member could only have one term.
- 15:03And then that term was redefined as if you had one day, less than
- 15:07six years that wasn't the term.
- 15:08And you can get another six year term.
- 15:10So you can get 11 years, 365 days.
- 15:14It was, I don't know if that was DOJ who opined that maybe was Biden's, that
- 15:17McKechnie: was a Biden White House.
- 15:19Legally.
- 15:19Treichel: Okay.
- 15:20Yeah.
- 15:20But everything, there's all that, there's all that subterfuge
- 15:23or legal opinion, whatever you wanna call it behind the scenes.
- 15:27Bacino: Well Mark, you asked one of the other questions you asked about
- 15:30was anything new on the legal front?
- 15:32Treichel: Yes.
- 15:33Bacino: And while I am not a lawyer and I don't play one on tv, I do
- 15:36know that there's the case of Rebecca Slaughter, who I think is the FTC, the
- 15:40commissioner that the administration fired the Supreme Court has decided
- 15:44to hear her case on December 8th.
- 15:46And lawyers that I know all say, look, that's a precursor.
- 15:51To the NCUA case.
- 15:54There was also a story today that the, some of the lawyers have asked
- 15:57Supreme Court to look at this and decide if they're going to take it on.
- 16:01So all those things start to enter into the timetable.
- 16:05The unfortunate thing is you're probably not looking at anything
- 16:08past the first of the year, at best, before you've got a decision.
- 16:13Now I think the question still comes up.
- 16:16Chairman Hopman term expired in August.
- 16:18Treichel: Yeah.
- 16:19Bacino: And he and Sarah can have bang been doing, I think yeoman's
- 16:23work in keeping everything going.
- 16:26But it make him a point when he says, you know what, I'm moving on too,
- 16:29and he brought this up at the start of the previous board meeting where
- 16:33he said you could get down to zero.
- 16:36I think the same kind of legal questions come up with either one or zero, which is.
- 16:41Let's say you pass a rag, what's to stop a credit union or anyone from suing later on
- 16:46to saying it wasn't legally decided upon.
- 16:49So you got a whole bunch of things that are happening now and again,
- 16:53it's, as John said, we are unchartered waters and we really are, because
- 16:58again, the previous norms don't hold.
- 17:02And if the administration's allowed to get rid of the two Democratic board
- 17:06members and then put two board members of whatever party they want into that place,
- 17:12because evidently the act doesn't apply.
- 17:15So why would you want it to apply in terms of party?
- 17:18Ah, it's
- 17:18Treichel: just the act.
- 17:19Bacino: Yeah.
- 17:19It's in terms of party but again, as a former board member.
- 17:24I would be really worried about that.
- 17:26From a personal standpoint, I lived in this area.
- 17:28It was easy for me to do this, but if you're coming, from somewhere else,
- 17:31and you've gotta make a decision about uprooting your family, moving
- 17:34people, I don't, I think you're gonna lose a lot of people who would even
- 17:38consider it if they know that President changing party, or worse yet, just
- 17:43getting upset with what your decision was, you could be out of a job.
- 17:47Treichel: And you talk about going, zero, right?
- 17:49We have one board member right now.
- 17:50He he gets hit by a bus.
- 17:52There are zero board members, he resigns, gets a better job, wants to
- 17:55go do something else where he, whatever he goes and does, if it's outside of
- 17:58government, he is gonna make more than he's making as a board member, right?
- 18:01So he's got all of those personal situations going on.
- 18:04And Alonzo Ima imagine walking into work as executive director of NCA and you go,
- 18:10okay, now there are no board members.
- 18:12We were wondering what a one board office.
- 18:16Had the authority to do or not do, what do I as executive director, as a
- 18:20staff member, have the ability to do?
- 18:22Even though the de the delegation says if the.
- 18:25If a plane goes down with all the board members, the executive director has
- 18:28the authority, and oh, by the way the, we don't know the executive, current
- 18:32executive director could be taking the buyout by the end of the year.
- 18:34Maybe not, but certainly everybody would reflect on their down 23%.
- 18:39There are no board members that could get a little chaotic here.
- 18:43Should help him decide to walk.
- 18:46Swann: Agree with what you totally we're.
- 18:48It's a quite frankly, it from the staffing perspective, it's just a
- 18:52matter of you just do what you do.
- 18:54And there's a lot of things that we, like you said, probably would've
- 18:57done differently, but the power.
- 19:01The power of the federal Credit Union Act is vested in the NCUA board.
- 19:05I always remembered that as
- 19:07Treichel: Never violate the delegations established by a board that's no longer
- 19:11there, maybe you still have the authority.
- 19:13It gets kind.
- 19:14The higher up you are as if you're the highest staff member at NSU
- 19:18a, that would, I would be losing a lot of sleep with no board.
- 19:22It's good to have that one board member there.
- 19:24And I can't see Kyle walking away, 'cause
- 19:26McKechnie: Well,
- 19:26Treichel: no, he committed to the next step in his journey.
- 19:28McKechnie: I don't know anything firsthand.
- 19:32I do the one conversation I've had with the administration in the last few weeks.
- 19:36Is that, they're cognizant of the fact we have one board member.
- 19:39We, they're cognizant of the fact that he's serving in a holdover capacity.
- 19:46And beyond that, I think everything's somewhat frozen in place until
- 19:49the Supreme Court decides that Humphrey's executor case Sure.
- 19:53Treichel: That we've
- 19:53McKechnie: spoken about on your podcast in the past.
- 19:56What if, but that, that may not happen.
- 19:59That a decision in that may not occur.
- 20:02As late as ne next June.
- 20:03That's a long time to be in this uncertainty, but it's possible.
- 20:07We've had a single member board with one day exception since April of last year.
- 20:12Life goes on.
- 20:15Treichel: That it does.
- 20:16Everybody has a little bit of connection with Federal Home Loan Bank.
- 20:19They really stood up and provide some liquidity opportunities back a few years
- 20:24ago when there were liquidity challenges at institutions and then following
- 20:29Silicon Valley Bank and different things.
- 20:31It it's it's an amazing, resource for credit unions.
- 20:34Any general thoughts on what you guys are seeing out there as it relates
- 20:39to the financial use of Federal home loan bank or liquidity, et cetera?
- 20:47Swann: I like to think I've been a part of this, but I think the use of
- 20:50federal home loan banks by credit unions has risen exponentially over the 12
- 20:54years I've been with Atlanta's bank.
- 20:56I, it comes from more understanding, just understanding
- 20:58it over the last couple years.
- 21:01Let me, lemme step back.
- 21:02'cause my in my initial years I, I was recruiting credit unions to join
- 21:07and as I told them, it's a benefit that I'm going to tell you a lot of
- 21:12positives from having, and I'm gonna give you a short list of negatives and
- 21:20the short list of negatives is none.
- 21:23And a long list of positives.
- 21:24So I would go through that.
- 21:25But probably the biggest obstacle, one of the biggest obstacles I had was pushback
- 21:30from NCA examiners, to be quite frank on the value of joining the NCA board.
- 21:36I'm sorry, federal Home Loan Bank.
- 21:37Bacino: Yep.
- 21:37Swann: And but fast forward to today and over the last couple years.
- 21:42I've gotten a lot of, we've gotten a lot of new members in Atlanta.
- 21:45I don't know about the other 10 banks, but we've gotten a lot of
- 21:48new members based on recommendations that they joined from NCUA examiners.
- 21:54I, I think, the value of being a member, like I tell folk all the
- 21:58time, if the big ones are doing it you should figure out a way to do it too.
- 22:06So I think we're just seeing that and obviously.
- 22:08Through the COVID period and SVB bank episode.
- 22:12I think just the value of being a member of Federal Home Loan Bank has
- 22:16come up to speed in everybody's mind.
- 22:17I spent the last couple weeks in a hundred, in the a hundred million dollar
- 22:21range credit unions and a couple sub hundred million, and we were talking
- 22:26strategy on how to use the bank.
- 22:28We have affordable housing products as well.
- 22:29Just learning those things.
- 22:31We're just seeing, like I said, the value coming up exponentially and how
- 22:35to fit it in into your strategic plan.
- 22:38As we like to say, we're not a vendor.
- 22:40We're your strategic partner.
- 22:42You do good.
- 22:42We do good.
- 22:43We're a co-op just like you.
- 22:45I'm seeing that more, that understanding come up to speed, if you will.
- 22:48Treichel: That's great.
- 22:49John, Jeff, any thoughts on that?
- 22:52McKechnie: I wouldn't, I wanna mention.
- 22:53Alonzo covered the waterfront on Homeland Bank and before Jeff goes,
- 22:58I just wanna mention, we just got a credit union's work to get some congress
- 23:02to do something good on the clf.
- 23:03That's something we don't talk about much unless there's a problem.
- 23:06But just got a little bit of a modernization provision put into the
- 23:10defense bill that would expand the ability of the CLF to be more flexible.
- 23:15I know that's not an exciting topic, but I remember very well in the early
- 23:20days of the crisis in 2008 when that started washing up on the shore, that
- 23:24was a liquidity problem much more than a capital asset problem initially.
- 23:29So one day we're all gonna be grateful that the CLF is more.
- 23:33More agile, faster on its feet, still has to become law because the defense
- 23:38bill hasn't passed both chambers yet.
- 23:40But the corporates were very involved in that.
- 23:42I know defense credit Union Council got very involved in that.
- 23:45It's, it's an, it is an important if our can issue.
- 23:49I just wanted to throw on the table.
- 23:51Treichel: No, great point, Jeff.
- 23:53Bacino: I was gonna say when I joined the finance board, be blunt, I knew
- 23:57what the federal home loan banks did.
- 23:59I didn't know exactly how well they did it.
- 24:02And you know when the financial crisis started in 2007, and I always use that
- 24:06date because that's when our economist came to me and said, our advances
- 24:11are up tremendous over the last.
- 24:13A couple months, I think I've told this story to you guys before, and my question
- 24:17to him was, is that good news or bad news?
- 24:19He goes I think it's bad news.
- 24:20And sure enough it was, is we started to enter that crisis.
- 24:22But I'll tell you what, the Federal Home Loan banks initially were probably about
- 24:26the only source of liquidity for a lot of institutions, including credit unions.
- 24:30And as I said I've grown to become a big supporter.
- 24:33Alonzo mentioned how they're cooperatives.
- 24:34They're really as much a cooperative as a credit union.
- 24:37And, and so I'm hoping that credit unions continue looking at
- 24:41them as a source of assistance.
- 24:43The interesting thing was yesterday the administration mentioned that they
- 24:46were looking at a 50 year mortgage and federal Housing Finance Authority.
- 24:51The successor of my agency came out in big support of that.
- 24:55And I think when you start to talk about housing and the role that,
- 24:58that Fannie Freddie and the Federal Home Loan banks can play in that.
- 25:02I'm not sure going to a 50 year mortgage is gonna be the solution.
- 25:07Treichel: That's not the best way to achieve affordability.
- 25:09I, i is what you're saying.
- 25:11I would tend to agree with that.
- 25:12I think England has a 50 50 year so we know it can't be a good idea.
- 25:16Swann: Don't they add that up in Minnesota too.
- 25:17Mark, mark.
- 25:19Just kidding.
- 25:19Just kidding.
- 25:20Treichel: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 25:22Exactly.
- 25:22McKechnie: Now did you guys see, though, today there was news that
- 25:25Fannie Mae has decided to drop their credit score threshold down
- 25:30to people with a six 20 score?
- 25:34And I have to admit, that's one of those things that just sent
- 25:37a chill down my spine in a sense that, history sometimes repeats.
- 25:42I'm not predicting, I'm not smart enough or knowledgeable enough about the housing
- 25:45market to predict a problem, but man, I, that kind of thing I think could lend
- 25:52to maybe some credit quality problems.
- 25:55It got my attention.
- 25:56Treichel: Yeah.
- 25:56And then the other side too, Alonzo I would agree, depending
- 26:00on how you do it, you can make a good loan to someone of six 20.
- 26:03But what are the other parameters around it?
- 26:05But the affordable housing situation with regulations that make it
- 26:09harder for people to get their properties up to speed because of
- 26:13regulations that are on top auto.
- 26:15There, there's so many homes a year that go out of circulation and there's not
- 26:20enough being built that then circling back to something Alonzo said about
- 26:24the there, I know the federal home loan banks have some sort of goal.
- 26:28An objective to providing specific money and grants and
- 26:32things for affordable housing.
- 26:33Do I have that right?
- 26:34Lonzo?
- 26:35Swann: Absolutely.
- 26:36By statute.
- 26:37All federal home loan banks have to put 10% of their profit every year
- 26:41back into affordable housing products.
- 26:43And all of the banks over the last couple years have actually.
- 26:47Went over 10.
- 26:48They have the board of the federal home loan banks have the
- 26:51ability to take it up higher.
- 26:53And I know in Atlanta we went up to 15% last year and we when you go above 10,
- 26:59the rules are set on what you can do.
- 27:00But when you go above 10, you can design products that may
- 27:04fit your space a little better.
- 27:06Oh,
- 27:06Treichel: sure.
- 27:06Yeah.
- 27:07Swann: That's what we've done and we saw use uses of the product just explode.
- 27:12And our board has added additional funding to try to keep up.
- 27:15But it's been fun to watch and like I said, just the advance side credit
- 27:20unions are coming up to speed on it.
- 27:21We have a few who have been planning the space for a long time and now we're
- 27:25getting more and more every day that are using those affordable housing products.
- 27:29Treichel: That's great.
- 27:30That's great.
- 27:31Swann: And when you cobbled that with the last couple years after
- 27:34SVB, quite frankly, being a liquidity disaster, it was we've been having
- 27:39record record breaking profits.
- 27:41When you go back to 2021, during COVID, it was 10% of a little bit,
- 27:46but 23, 24, 25 was, it was 10%.
- 27:49It was actually 15% of a lot
- 27:51Treichel: of a big number.
- 27:53Swann: Yeah.
- 27:54Treichel: That's fantastic.
- 27:55So speaking of a big number the budget or the government's running outta money
- 27:59and they and they had to shut us down, the government down, but it looks like
- 28:03the Senate has voted to reopen and you politic, you guys who follow politics more
- 28:09than me know that once the Senate says it, the house basically has to come in town.
- 28:14Do the same thing.
- 28:15They don't put it that way, but it seems like the house is high
- 28:17school and the Senate is college the college seniors voting.
- 28:21But thoughts on the, where we're at with that what it might mean
- 28:24or not mean for credit unions that the government's back open.
- 28:31McKechnie: I don't know when this is gonna be aired, but tomorrow.
- 28:34Okay.
- 28:34This is we're recording it on Veteran's Day Tuesday.
- 28:38Supposedly the house is gonna vote sometime tomorrow
- 28:41afternoon or early evening.
- 28:42This.
- 28:43Still to reopen.
- 28:44The government may actually be on the President's desk
- 28:47tomorrow night, Wednesday.
- 28:48And I hope that happens.
- 28:49I'm flying tomorrow, so I'm really interested in that.
- 28:52But I don't know what le I don't know if there's a lesson I will mention that a
- 28:56lot of credit unions were very interested in what might happen with the community
- 29:00development financial institution fund.
- 29:03And that's apparently going to be restored to some degree.
- 29:07This new agreement and hopefully there will be enough staff in the
- 29:12building to administer that fund to treasury when things get back
- 29:15to normal, whatever normal means,
- 29:17Treichel: whatever the new normal is.
- 29:18Yeah.
- 29:19Interesting.
- 29:22What else guys, is there, are there any topics that have been big in
- 29:25credit unions that you, we want to tackle here before we predict who
- 29:28wins the football games next week?
- 29:32Bacino: I would, I'll go back to John's comment for a minute
- 29:35about the government shutdown.
- 29:37I think obviously, it's, it's both parties.
- 29:39Okay.
- 29:40Anyone who wants to try to tell you it's not is frankly lying.
- 29:43And John will probably back me lately what surveys have shown
- 29:45is that whereas in the past.
- 29:48The general American populace would pick one party to blame.
- 29:52Now it's they're picking 'em both, which I guess is fair because I
- 29:54said I think it's both of them.
- 29:56And mark, you said that the Senate was college and the house was was high school.
- 30:00It is, and again, mainly due to the filibuster that you've gotta.
- 30:03Get over in the Senate side.
- 30:05But what's gonna be interesting, obviously, speaker speaker Johnson
- 30:09has kept the house out of session,
- 30:11Treichel: right?
- 30:11Bacino: Since this happened.
- 30:12Now there are some that are in the conspiracy theory that says he kept it
- 30:16out because otherwise he's got a swear in the new congressperson from Arizona who.
- 30:20Be the 218th signature on the Epstein file opening.
- 30:23So you got a whole lot of things going on in town and a cover on top of that.
- 30:29You've got the elections from a week ago today in Virginia
- 30:32and in New Jersey, and then the California redistricting proposal.
- 30:36And obviously Democrats did very well, which, if you're a Democrat, you
- 30:39look at that and say that's a trend.
- 30:41And if you're a Republican, you look at it and say those were.
- 30:43Purple and blue trending states.
- 30:45Anyway, so it doesn't matter.
- 30:46The reality is it matters only until probably about.
- 30:51Two a couple weeks from now.
- 30:52You can't extrapolate out, but the one thing that I think the Democrats
- 30:56are finding from this shutdown is they're gonna have to figure out a
- 30:59way in the midterms in 26 to pick up at least one of the two chambers.
- 31:04They gotta pick up the house or they gotta pick up the Senate because
- 31:07without either of them, without the White House, you pretty much are
- 31:11at the mercy of the other party.
- 31:13And, frankly, for the most part, I think Republicans do a better job of Democrats
- 31:17of holding the fort, and so I think it's gonna be incumbent if Democrats want to
- 31:21change the focus, especially heading into the 2028 presidential election that I know
- 31:26nobody really wants to talk about now, but I think the Democrats are, have to
- 31:30try to figure out a way come out or high water to when at least one, ideally they'd
- 31:34like to, with both chambers coming at 26.
- 31:38Treichel: John Alonso, any thoughts on that?
- 31:42Swann: John, you go ahead.
- 31:43You the,
- 31:43McKechnie: well,
- 31:44Swann: that's your lane.
- 31:44McKechnie: It, yeah, we don't have much else to go on than to, to predict the
- 31:50future than what happened last Tuesday.
- 31:52So it's a good way to look at it.
- 31:53There's midterms usually hard on the White House, the party that holds the
- 31:57White House New Jersey and Virginia.
- 32:00Red.
- 32:01Jeff said they're bluish, purplish.
- 32:02I think they're both kind of democratic STA states now that
- 32:05Virginia, with the exception of the last governor's race has been.
- 32:09Very democratic state at the statewide level for most of this century.
- 32:14So I'm not surprised they won the governor's race there
- 32:16again in New Jersey as well.
- 32:19You got a socialist mayor in New York now.
- 32:22Whatever we want to do to read tea leaves, it's fun.
- 32:25Not sure how useful.
- 32:27It is, but it's, it is all we got to go on, like I said, until next November when
- 32:31we're gonna have a midterm to deal with,
- 32:33Treichel: the socialist mayor, candidate of Minneapolis did not get in though.
- 32:38So that's, the tide is turning there in Minneapolis.
- 32:41McKechnie: Yeah.
- 32:41That's great.
- 32:42And you didn't, but you didn't elect a conservative Republican
- 32:45to replace to It was a very, it was the left hand didn't know what
- 32:49the far left hand was doing there.
- 32:51Treichel: And Jeff, when you bring up Epstein, which I think is the first time
- 32:54that's been brought up on the podcast,
- 32:56Bacino: give it to
- 32:56me.
- 32:57Treichel: Of course.
- 32:57You're talking about Mike Epstein, the slugging first basement of the seventies.
- 33:02That was part-timer for the Oakland A's, and he
- 33:06McKechnie: played with the Orioles.
- 33:07At first he
- 33:07Treichel: was, he was an Oreo.
- 33:09Of course.
- 33:09He, everybody was an orle back then.
- 33:11McKechnie: Sure.
- 33:11Bacino: Now his files are a little different than obviously former.
- 33:15Treichel: Yeah.
- 33:15Bacino: Jeffrey Epstein,
- 33:16Treichel: the Mike Epstein files.
- 33:18Bacino: Yes, the 20 minutes, that's the run.
- 33:22That's what the White House should do is release his files.
- 33:24Just go.
- 33:24We gave but John did talk about, John did talk about Virginia and
- 33:28New Jersey being basically allow.
- 33:32I'll concede that they're more blue states.
- 33:34The one thing that did impress me though both of them, both both candidates,
- 33:38Cheryl and Bamberger out polled Harris and everybody else that running in
- 33:43that state in a while as a Democrat.
- 33:44Governor Murphy in, in New Jersey barely won election reelection four years ago.
- 33:49So I think if, again, I will go back to my point, Democrats are gonna need
- 33:53to figure out a way to right the ship.
- 33:56Otherwise it's gonna be real tough sledding for them heading into 28.
- 33:59It was good news as John says, it's really only good for a while and it is
- 34:03and frankly, November 26 is, is still.
- 34:06A year away.
- 34:08So
- 34:08I
- 34:08McKechnie: don't think that, and by the way, Jeff, you're right about
- 34:10even more right about Virginia because they, Democrats now have the biggest
- 34:13majority in the State House of delegates that anybody has had in 40 years.
- 34:18They got a big, it was a big night for the Democrats.
- 34:20I'm not arguing that it's it was, if I were a Democrat, I would be very happy.
- 34:27Swann: Yeah.
- 34:27I think just to put my 2 cents in as a regular citizen, if you will I think
- 34:31what really won is moderate politics.
- 34:34And that's where it's gonna come down.
- 34:36So if you have two moderates running against each other, one
- 34:40Republican, one Democrat, you could probably get a closer race.
- 34:43But if you have somebody who has been branded on the, either the left or
- 34:49the right I think the, is picking the one that's closest to the middle,
- 34:54if you will, if that makes sense.
- 34:55I'm moderate.
- 34:56I swing both sides.
- 34:58I'm not voting for a French candidate on either side.
- 35:01So I think that's what the election probably showed us that was the
- 35:06big predictor of the midterms.
- 35:09It's gonna come down to candidates.
- 35:11Treichel: As it should.
- 35:11That's great.
- 35:12I like that.
- 35:12I like that.
- 35:13Take Very good guys.
- 35:15I'm gonna predict, let's see the Vikings and the Bears.
- 35:18Oh gosh.
- 35:1931, 30 Vikings
- 35:24Bacino: Let you go first.
- 35:26Swann: No, I got The Bears will score 27 points and the Vikings will just score 17.
- 35:33Treichel: Okay.
- 35:3427 17, Jeff.
- 35:35Bacino: If last, the last two weeks of Bears Games have been any
- 35:38indication, this is gonna come down to something that's pretty close.
- 35:41And as a Bear fan, I'll take the Bears 24 20.
- 35:44Treichel: 24 20.
- 35:45And John, you can either opine on our teams or you can tell
- 35:47us how the Ravens are gonna do.
- 35:49McKechnie: We're playing the Browns, which on paper I think everybody's gonna give.
- 35:53The Ravens designate us as their favorites, but they always play us tough.
- 35:57And it's in Cleveland and we lost there last year.
- 36:01So I'm not gonna predict I'm a natural, such a natural
- 36:04pessimist when it comes to sports.
- 36:06I'm just gonna keep my mouth shut.
- 36:07Bacino: Yeah, I'll do
- 36:08Swann: this.
- 36:08It's the Ravens Browns this week.
- 36:10McKechnie: Yeah.
- 36:11Swann: Oh, that's gonna be like the game last night.
- 36:13Green Bay.
- 36:14Green Bay, Philadelphia.
- 36:16Game zero zero.
- 36:16Halftime.
- 36:17Treichel: Another ten seven coming.
- 36:19Swann: Yeah.
- 36:21Bacino: And we'll predict this though, that the Ravens will win the division.
- 36:24McKechnie: Alright.
- 36:24Treichel: Yes,
- 36:25McKechnie: I like that.
- 36:26Bacino: I'll give you that.
- 36:27McKechnie: I like it.
- 36:28Swann: That the lions will win.
- 36:31We'll win our division.
- 36:32Treichel: Yeah.
- 36:32Lion's got us even though we beat them.
- 36:35For the record, let me, that was our be, that was our Super Bowl.
- 36:38All right guys, as always, this has been fantastic.
- 36:41I wanna thank you all for being available and we'll do this again down the road.
- 36:46Good to see the three of you all on one screen,
- 36:49Bacino: four horse movie, apocalypse.
- 36:51Treichel: All of the ayp episode is, it Will Be Live tomorrow.
- 36:56And listeners, I want to thank you for listening and or watching Mark
- 36:59reel, signing off with flying colors.