Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP132: What Does A Modern Ecommerce Technology Stack Look Like & Why
Transcript
- 0:02Uh, in, in in Surrey platform podcast, hosted by myself James
- 0:05guard. And my colleagues, Paul Rodgers.
- 0:07Hello may hate it. Yeah, good.
- 0:09Thanks. How are you, dad?
- 0:11Yeah, it's Monday. Let's start the week with
- 0:12another cracking episode. So let's set up what we're
- 0:15talking about and then we'll just rambling a lie at everybody
- 0:18as we usually do. Thanks for tuning back into all
- 0:21our regular listeners and if it's your first time we hope you
- 0:23enjoy it, we drop an episode every week, we'd love you to
- 0:26subscribe to get new alerts. And we also love a like on
- 0:29YouTube Spotify. By or apple, if you enjoy the
- 0:31content. So today, we're talking about,
- 0:33what is the modern tech stack look like for e-commerce.
- 0:36And why does it look like this? Now, we are.
- 0:39We're focused on like Brands direct consumer smes.
- 0:41We're not looking at large Enterprise that have their own
- 0:43engineering functions with it. That is very much a different
- 0:46space and there's so much variance are so we're looking at
- 0:49how we can't the modern you come seem to use an e-commerce
- 0:52technology and what else? They're plug in and around it to
- 0:54achieve the functionality. So key things going to cover our
- 0:59move towards a Driven systems and how it's changing the tech
- 1:01people use the evolution from all-in-one to Best in Class
- 1:06which are the most common third-party systems that people
- 1:09are using and how they're like SAS and pass.
- 1:12And by that we mean software as a service or platform as a
- 1:14service and the role of middleware.
- 1:17A trps etc. So we're gonna work from the
- 1:19back to the front of the solution stack.
- 1:23Does that survived? I introduced at Coachella by
- 1:25just wobbled on, I think? Yeah.
- 1:28No, I think that's it. Really let's just come Right
- 1:30open discussion around like, you know, how, like where the world
- 1:33going and like some of the trends we've seen, but, I guess.
- 1:37Yeah, go and myself, and Paul normally have loads and loads of
- 1:40detail. Nice.
- 1:40But we decided we're going to just completely ad-lib this and
- 1:43see how we get on. We do based on our own
- 1:45experience but also from people we know and the in-stream what
- 1:47they're doing with technology. I think the key situations, this
- 1:50is many organizations have moved away from a mindset point of
- 1:54view from the one source of Truth platform where you buy
- 1:56into a platform you go back five or so years, you buy a magenta.
- 1:59You I ate at the moment with Salesforce comes cloud is now
- 2:02hybris. And you expect the e-commerce
- 2:04platform tears, do almost everything, it's the
- 2:06application, it's the all the logic, the business rules it
- 2:09compiles, the code. It generates the HTML for the
- 2:11front end. He does some of the order
- 2:14manager does. Our people then try and hack it
- 2:16to build out things like bi on it?
- 2:18Well actually the the ecosystem marketing technology time world
- 2:22has moved on so rapidly. There are so many best-in-class
- 2:25Tools in each of these Specialists capability areas
- 2:28that actually the efficiency of trying to hack.
- 2:29Your Ecommerce platform to achieve some of the things that
- 2:31it's not designed to do isn't that sensible?
- 2:34You end up spending a lot more money and development and a lot
- 2:36more effort in maintenance. So increasingly we're seeing
- 2:40businesses that are defining, what e-commerce mean.
- 2:42So basically e-commerce is about managing comments.
- 2:46Pages product page is priceless Pages.
- 2:49It's managing the basket. The checkout, it's those selling
- 2:52functionality capabilities and then often everything else can
- 2:55be done by the assistant. If I don't prove to others for
- 2:58like sometimes, even e-commerce is Literally the shopping basket
- 3:00and check out right. Yeah, exactly.
- 3:03That's it, that's kind of over the last couple of years
- 3:06particularly with the SAS platforms.
- 3:08It feels like people are a lot more willing to kind of work
- 3:12with a broader set of Technologies and kind of benefit
- 3:15from like smaller best-in-class, kind of solutions.
- 3:19Like and I feel like he's got quite an obviously, there's pros
- 3:21and cons to this approach and you know, there's variables
- 3:24where maybe it doesn't scale quite as well.
- 3:26But you know, in like a good example is in the shop firework.
- 3:29World you'd use a third party for a wish list, which seems
- 3:33like so granular. But equally, like that kind of
- 3:37app is like the feature sets really strong, you know, they're
- 3:40only focusing on that, they support everything.
- 3:43Like it's not Advanced sharing your guest, wishlist do
- 3:46integrate directly with your ESP.
- 3:49You know, they're just constantly adding new
- 3:50functionality in that little niche area, and I do definitely
- 3:54like that. And I think that kind of like,
- 3:56yeah, just small SAS solutions kind of integrate Environmental.
- 4:00API is and also like amongst the ecosystem as well.
- 4:04Has been a really good thing for Brands and Merchants, it's make
- 4:08things more manageable if you can get ya a lot more
- 4:11functionality that way as well. Yeah.
- 4:13And I find it interesting because I think culturally some
- 4:15businesses struggle to adapt to a hanging me.
- 4:19So we need that that platform on top on that tool and and we're
- 4:22doing it through the API, but the platform's not doing it.
- 4:24But I've got this extra layer and some people find that really
- 4:28hard to shift to make and they say, It's added complexity and
- 4:31risk versus actually, this is modern architecture.
- 4:33And actually a lot of businesses that scaled really successfully
- 4:35at doing this, and I think the important discussion I see and I
- 4:39try to encourage people have now is it's what are you buying an
- 4:42e-commerce platform? For not, how can we make our
- 4:45e-commerce platform? Do okay, returns management.
- 4:48All the manage business intelligence is what is the role
- 4:51of the from platform? And how does it enable those
- 4:53additional capabilities? Because trying to shift away
- 4:56from thinking, it will do everything to how does it
- 4:58enable? What's the other?
- 4:59Lynn, you need and therefore, what is the role e-commerce
- 5:02plays with additional pulling to achieve your business
- 5:04functionality and do your mind as long as the functionalities
- 5:07of speed in a cost-effective way.
- 5:09So I think that simple. So with that in mind, let's
- 5:13let's dive into number one. I think this is really important
- 5:15question, I'll let you go first, this is how have API first set
- 5:20up to change like equal s in the e-commerce stack because it is a
- 5:23mind shift away from actually everything is managed within the
- 5:28e-commerce platform. Yeah, I think, you know, kind of
- 5:31touched on it, make it go around it, I think it just, I mean,
- 5:34that's kind of like the first step for building an ecosystem
- 5:38within the majority of the platforms out there now that are
- 5:42going API. First, you know, we're trying to
- 5:44encourage one of the tap Partners to build out
- 5:46Integrations, you know, build out.
- 5:49Yeah, kind of functionality around the platform so I think
- 5:51that's a big part of it. And I feel like nowadays that's
- 5:55the benefits that I just getting clearer and clearer to Brands
- 5:58because it allows you to Things faster, you know the costs are
- 6:01much lower etcetera. The yeah I also think it allows
- 6:06people to be kind of like, you know, more agile, you know, that
- 6:10you end up thinking, I guess that you look at.
- 6:14I've obviously worked a lot over the years for Magento and some
- 6:17of the other platforms of maybe not kind of a standardized as
- 6:22some of these kind of API driven platforms.
- 6:24And I think as a lot of benefits from like a maintenance
- 6:26perspective, I think it's nicer to work from a development.
- 6:30From a developer perspective as well.
- 6:33Yeah, it feels like overall at the benefits and mainly around
- 6:36kind of agility. And yeah, simplifying things a
- 6:40bit more. Yeah, I think that's key and
- 6:44also it's an abstraction of logic because if you go back to
- 6:48the traditional way, in e-commerce system works, is you
- 6:51have all of the, the core application, the foot and the
- 6:53functionality in that e-commerce system.
- 6:56You have the data and you have a logic that defines How that data
- 7:00is used and what functionalities are able to be executed off the
- 7:03back of that. And if you want to change how
- 7:06any of that data is presented or Works wish list, if you want to
- 7:10change the flow in a wish list, you have to change the logic in
- 7:14the core application to enable that, otherwise it just doesn't
- 7:17work, whereas if the data is obstructive or an API and you're
- 7:21using them, headless CMS, or a front end, you can change that
- 7:26flow without needing to change anything in the back end.
- 7:29Of the application. You just draw the data from it
- 7:32and pass the data back. I think that's that's been quite
- 7:35a Evolution and also again, back to those mindset shifts of
- 7:39people realizing that you're not constrained and they used to
- 7:43have to go to into RFP to go. I how exactly does it work to
- 7:47understand it versus like, how do you want it to work and how
- 7:49can I get the data? So you change the question in as
- 7:51well, in modern eCommerce sites? Yeah, I'm saying yeah I think it
- 7:55just gives you more flexibility. Like I'm obviously I've been
- 7:59working at the shop so I recently and I've I'm a big
- 8:02advocate of just like taking things out on the platform.
- 8:05Like visual merchandising is a good example where that you've
- 8:08got. If you have multiple stores and
- 8:10you end up kind of, you know, using the shop via API is
- 8:13building your kind of sort order and then pushing it into
- 8:17different stores. It's a lot more efficient, you
- 8:19know, Shopify isn't really designed.
- 8:22It is kind of designed for Visual merchandising it's not as
- 8:24advanced as some of the third parties.
- 8:26And, you know, this is not going to allow for really complex
- 8:29business logic. So in that scenario, you're much
- 8:31better off kind of taken out of the platform.
- 8:34And I think that is it just a trend that we're seeing and I
- 8:36think there's a lot of benefits to applying that approach to
- 8:39thing. Yeah, definitely.
- 8:41Okay. So so essentially what we're
- 8:43saying AP I'm for anybody sorry about the terminology course.
- 8:46Some people might be cheaper than not knowing it we're
- 8:48basically what's this? I keep forgetting it's like ons,
- 8:51programmer interface, The ability to basically put a call
- 8:57into request, a specific piece of data from a system and
- 9:00receive that data back and then you can decide how you use that
- 9:02data. So, yeah, I guess it's just an
- 9:05effective way of exchanging information between different
- 9:07systems. So, we talked about how the fact
- 9:10that a lot of the, the platform, especially modern sat move to
- 9:12API first. Now, let's move towards the
- 9:16back. End with that context in mind
- 9:19and work from Back to Front. We're not going to talk about
- 9:22Legacy systems like PS because they are independent to platform
- 9:26while in mostly constructions. They're independent.
- 9:29Let's what we're going to start off with a slush around
- 9:32middleware and some of you may have come across middleware so
- 9:36these can be a technology at sits in between your eCommerce
- 9:42and system and back-end Solutions like erps and it
- 9:46facilitates the data exchange between the two of them I think
- 9:49I'm seeing increasing it away been using two ways.
- 9:51Number one is, people are going And investing in specialist
- 9:58providers like patchworks who that's what they do.
- 10:01They provide it and integration layer and they have breathing
- 10:04connectors for different e-commerce platforms.
- 10:06Different, erps like Bigcommerce to sap business.
- 10:11One, for example, or there are agencies have built their own
- 10:14proprietary middlewares, they might work on one or two
- 10:17platforms. They built their own middleware,
- 10:18connector to work across those. So when they are selling
- 10:21Solutions into clients, they don't have to bring the third
- 10:24party, they use their own. And the reason for this, I
- 10:26guess, my one point on the line, don't you pull over lady done
- 10:30quite a bit of work around with clients and middle areas.
- 10:33Is that basically, there are times when you need to change
- 10:38the data between the two systems because these big performance
- 10:40are not identical and you have a choice, where do you do make
- 10:44that change? Do you have to do customization
- 10:46in e-commerce out? Put things in the right format
- 10:48to get to an, ER, P. If you try and make changes in
- 10:51Erp, they typically end up being more time-consuming.
- 10:53Falsely more complex and more risky.
- 10:56I've seen a lot of businesses try to do in and customize any
- 10:58IP level and it seems to take a long, long time to get it, and
- 11:02it doesn't always work effective in there.
- 11:03Can be knock-on impact on the business.
- 11:05You don't wanna mess around with uip if you don't have to, so the
- 11:08middleware extracts that and avoid, um, to do that.
- 11:11And it creates that kind of divorce in of the two systems
- 11:15that I guess that's my perspective on why middlewares
- 11:17becoming more popular especially in SME projects.
- 11:21What about you Paul? She'll take enough.
- 11:23Yeah, I think my view is the same as yours that we've worked
- 11:26quite a bit over the last few years.
- 11:27We've made aware providers, like, for you'd work with on a
- 11:31build or every platform and put it Workman agency, and they
- 11:34would build all your Integrations via apis.
- 11:37And it will be, you know, completely bespoke.
- 11:41Whereas, now, if and we typically prefer middle are just
- 11:44because it gives you more flexibility.
- 11:45Because, you know, once you're downloading all your data into
- 11:48this kind of middle wire layer, you can essentially, you know,
- 11:52clean the data. And then To anywhere, like, you
- 11:54know, makes it easier to put in a bi platform, you know, if you
- 11:58want to change one of your back office systems, you're in a much
- 12:01better position to do a also, we worked bit with some of the
- 12:05specialists in or not Specialists.
- 12:07But, you know, some of the companies that have managed
- 12:09services around these Integrations to be attached,
- 12:12works or like Asian or Vellum knee or whoever else.
- 12:16And I think working with those guys as well.
- 12:19It's like the equivalent of all the other stuff we've talked
- 12:23about around Kind of like strapping out Best in Class and
- 12:25essentially, you're giving the Integrations to a company that's
- 12:28completely independent only manages integration.
- 12:31You know, they'll build out the Middle where, you know, add any
- 12:33logic you need. If you're, you know, if you've
- 12:36got any complexity around inventory or whatever else, and
- 12:38I think it's just, yeah, it's one that D risks projects and to
- 12:43I just think it's more Modern Way of working and you know it
- 12:46gives you that room to not one of the things that we've seen as
- 12:48well as people introducing, you know, new warehouses or be no
- 12:53more. Still is using the same stock,
- 12:57inventory source, and like that piece of metal and it makes
- 13:00everything like that so much easier or like, you know, it
- 13:02could be like queuing or whatever else.
- 13:04But yeah, I just think it's like another layer where you can
- 13:07manage logic further, you know, to keep that complexity down.
- 13:12I think that's it's keeping closely and I like the comment
- 13:14you made about feature flexibility is one of the big
- 13:17challenges. If you do point to point between
- 13:19e-commerce an Erp, If the Erp changes, I have seen business
- 13:24change Erp as a could be a massive Global expansion of.
- 13:28Suddenly the international scene, makes the current Erp not
- 13:30fit for purpose and scalable, the limitation on multiple
- 13:34warehouses cetera, multiple stop for management and you suddenly
- 13:37realize the complexity of shifting eops is huge.
- 13:40It's a massive project to then have to worry about the
- 13:43integration young be Commerce and how you face that.
- 13:46So, you don't just disrupt your front-end Commerce, and all the
- 13:49taken capability. Else to do to do that
- 13:53independent of the e-commerce, e-commerce engine crack on with
- 13:55their own roadmap. And not worry about it is is you
- 13:58know, it'd be the risks projects massively.
- 14:04Okay, so let's move on to another type of application.
- 14:09Something I know that you've got way more experience working with
- 14:11me, but this is the role of the pin or product information
- 14:13management system. And interestingly, you started
- 14:16something about to me about this couple of years back and I
- 14:18didn't see many clients looking at are and now more of my My
- 14:21clients are having conversations, it seems to fit.
- 14:23So we're basically talking about a tool that is specialist around
- 14:27managing product data, and in can handle promotions and
- 14:31pricing data from Erp into it to spit out into other catalogs,
- 14:34and it seems to work. Well, in the models SAS world,
- 14:37where there are some limitations, or a multi
- 14:39storefront translations, the ability to have a more robust
- 14:44data model and the Pym where you can put in all of that data at
- 14:47source and it can manage it effectively.
- 14:49So you can have a hierarchy for a product with The different
- 14:52translated versions and then use their API to fire into the
- 14:56relevant. Storefront in e-commerce to
- 14:57avoid um to do lots of customization or configuration
- 15:00in e-commerce platform, where you took, it typically doesn't
- 15:03do it as effectiveness of pain. So that's my context.
- 15:06So I over to Bob. How are you seeing a pin being
- 15:09used? And why is it being is?
- 15:10Yeah, so think, I mean we've tended to use Pimm's a lot for
- 15:15that multi-store, from piece like you say, just so that you
- 15:18can essentially put as much as you can into a Tim and then push
- 15:22it into different stores. Like if you've got six to ten
- 15:26English-speaking stores, you definitely don't want to be
- 15:28doing. Let's see at all.
- 15:29You might not want to be doing CSV import.
- 15:32You don't want to be making changes in each of those
- 15:35individual admin instances. Of him can make a lot of
- 15:38difference and same with like, you know, imagery and everything
- 15:41else. But in addition to that, I
- 15:42think, you know, pens usually have kind of different workflows
- 15:47as well, that can add a lot of value in terms.
- 15:51Of the actual kind of like back-end content management and
- 15:54kind of like building out of content.
- 15:57Yeah, they'll have things like approval layers.
- 16:00Like, there's various different kind of like features that can
- 16:03actually benefit the merchandising Recon team as
- 16:06well. And in addition to that, you've
- 16:08got the multi-channel piece or like some of our clients in the
- 16:12past, have had, you know, they've used a pimp support
- 16:14wholesale, and passing information, product
- 16:17information, out to wholesalers or marketplaces, or yeah, any
- 16:21other Kind of channels, but I think we've typically seeing the
- 16:24benefit like you say in those kind of projects where people
- 16:29have got 5 to 10 and Shopify stores.
- 16:32And they want to manage as much as they can globally.
- 16:35And we've even had clients handle things.
- 16:37Like the not visual merchandising, but like the
- 16:41Sorting of products. So they don't like a bit of
- 16:43logic within the Pym that basically pushes the order of
- 16:46products of in collections and into the stores as well.
- 16:49And it's that same thing I was talking about.
- 16:51They read this kind of taking stuff out of the platform and
- 16:53just trying to make it more efficient and using something
- 16:56that's best in class but yeah I'm definitely an advocate of of
- 17:00pins. Yeah I'm increasingly.
- 17:04So when it comes down to challenge at the translation bit
- 17:07because I'm quite a few platforms it's really hard to
- 17:12get translated versions of product data working effectively
- 17:17and in those multiple storefronts but the ability to
- 17:20select which Versions of which data just through a simple
- 17:23business, rule gets sent and then you'd have to worry then
- 17:26the storefront receives, only the information it needs.
- 17:30I think that's real and the other one was from which I
- 17:32hadn't realized and you find it to me while back was promotion
- 17:34scheduling. So there are some platforms
- 17:36where to try and get a promotion to go live in the local
- 17:40timezone. In all the countries you want it
- 17:42to versus in. The default time zone at the
- 17:44store is a real pain and the ability to do that and be able
- 17:48to specify when something gets sent down to go live.
- 17:50I think there are Certain use cases where it really does help
- 17:53especially when people got high, velocity promotional campaigns
- 17:58acceptance. Okay, let's go on to the next
- 18:01one. CMS is in front ends.
- 18:03So again, this I think this is definitely an interesting was,
- 18:06I've got a few projects at the moment, we're because a lot of
- 18:10platform, they're not an e-commerce platform isn't a CMS.
- 18:14It has some content management capabilities and unfinished,
- 18:17page builder, basically their most important page builder as
- 18:20well. So simple drag, and Drop, when
- 18:22you start to, get wanted to Advanced logic of you
- 18:26distributed workflows for Global content teams.
- 18:30You want to have publisher controls.
- 18:31You want to be able to customize content.
- 18:34You want to create ones publish to multiple locations, you start
- 18:38adding on what is essentially, what modern content seems
- 18:41really, really want the page. Builders become much harder and
- 18:44more complicated to use, because you end up duplicating effort
- 18:47and that's where more people now, using CMS has and
- 18:50specifically in Context of maybe the CMS is the front end and
- 18:54it's just using the API to draw the Commerce data from the
- 18:58e-commerce platform, or a CMS has been used heedlessly like an
- 19:01e-commerce platform is headless Lee and there's a specific from
- 19:05an app on top of that as well. So I think it's really
- 19:07interesting that more and more people have turned to the root
- 19:10of every platform and not just looking at e-commerce platform.
- 19:13They're looking at getting the right CMS alongside it at the
- 19:16same time. Well, what's your take on this?
- 19:19Yeah. So I think I think there's
- 19:21definitely Really situations where Independence EMS is a
- 19:25needed of different levels that we've had a few clients.
- 19:28If he is contempt for in a similar way to appear them,
- 19:32where they've essentially manage content and then pushed it into
- 19:35multiple stores and not necessarily in a headless
- 19:38manner. I think I'm not usually a
- 19:41massive Pro of a massive fan of headless but I think that's also
- 19:45just because of the like level of client that we're dealing
- 19:47with and we've seen a number of people kind of regret going down
- 19:52That route. But equally I have been
- 19:53impressed with something like the solutions are being built in
- 19:56that kind of Market. I just think that usually
- 20:00there's quite a lot to lose as well as kind of gained, I guess
- 20:04depending on the brand or business.
- 20:08Yeah. And then I think I think you've
- 20:09probably done a lot more than I have with some of the more like
- 20:12Enterprise Solutions like the Epi service of the world like
- 20:15true kind of like you say content Management systems and
- 20:19you know, they've got all the kind of workflow.
- 20:21Management and like complex kind of scheduling and content
- 20:25planning and all of that kind of stuff.
- 20:27Most of what we've done has been typically more in platform or
- 20:30using something like contempt for alongside the platform.
- 20:35Yeah, I think when you've got when you're not have any content
- 20:39and editorial LED on your site and you've got basic content
- 20:42needs, then the page Builders a visual.
- 20:43Dragon got page, Builders can work really really, really well
- 20:46and you don't need the additional license fees.
- 20:50And think what I've seen with clients is when they want to get
- 20:52a little bit more advanced in the types of content.
- 20:54They're using, they want to generate more interactive.
- 20:58The content they want to rapidly deploy, New Concept for my, so
- 21:01they need to keep building new layouts.
- 21:04They have multiple sites, they've got different editors
- 21:08they've got different permissions for who can do what
- 21:10and when they want to schedule publishing and want to preview
- 21:13in the future to see what it really looks like.
- 21:15When that contents due to go when you start to move to that
- 21:18next level page Builders, they don't give you what you want and
- 21:22actually you end up spending more time managing the content
- 21:26then then doing the fun stuff which is the the creating and
- 21:30coming up with a new campaigns. But I agree with you about the
- 21:33head and sing like, Headless, is always just a word isn't in the
- 21:35end of the day. It's do you need?
- 21:37I think the other thing I like about some of the headers
- 21:40capabilities. You could have a CMS.
- 21:42That's got. An Escape Route has been is also
- 21:43capable of being the front end and if we don't have to you just
- 21:47then the Headless part is the e-commerce application.
- 21:50Putting the data in so that the CMS can compile all the pages
- 21:53correctly to display all the Commerce Pages.
- 21:55Plus all of the pure content Pages, what is a lian's in a
- 22:01word, it's Freedom, the freedom to build, Build a digital
- 22:04experience as Limitless as your vision create preview schedule,
- 22:09and manage. All your content in one easy
- 22:11place. Find out more at amply and
- 22:14starts calm and plants experience freedom.
- 22:20Searching merchandising, and that's another key area for
- 22:23projects. You work on, what are you?
- 22:25How are you seen people use these versus native capability
- 22:28in a platform? Yeah.
- 22:30So almost all of our clients now is a third-party, quite often.
- 22:34They're not always the same, actually, so we obviously work a
- 22:37lot with Clay view, but equally we work with loads of others.
- 22:41Like I've Golia attract tagless Kim Annex and the Shopify world.
- 22:46There's loads of others out there.
- 22:49I Can I think it's really important?
- 22:52So searched most people for the last kind of 45 years of used an
- 22:57independent search. Lucien merchandising I've said,
- 23:00more of a recent Trend and a lot of people, you know, like Claver
- 23:03and I'll go, you've got merchandising products that
- 23:06they're kind of add-ons to the search side.
- 23:08I've said, recently, we've been working about tag lifts, and
- 23:12then we've also got a few clients use and Kim an X,
- 23:14they're both more been Commerce and Shopify Focus that I think.
- 23:19They're really good for essentially, again, pulling
- 23:22something outside of the platform, then they basically
- 23:25just push the order of products in, by the API to Shopify.
- 23:28But you can build a lot more business logic.
- 23:30And I think that's how I like to work with the merchandise and
- 23:34side one that we've both been talking about recently.
- 23:37I think those really impressive is Advanced Commerce.
- 23:40I really like, where that's going.
- 23:42I think obviously, like that Andres, the founder of attract
- 23:46and a lot of that kind of, like, you kind of Next logic
- 23:50management stuff that attract, his always been really strong
- 23:53whether they've been built into advanced commands.
- 23:55I think there they'll bring a lot to this space.
- 24:00Although they're still quite new.
- 24:02But yeah. So I think from our side, it's
- 24:04really in an ideal world that merchandising side, you know,
- 24:08you'd have one platform, again, building logic that can
- 24:16essentially manage multiple stores in a in one blow.
- 24:19Global place. So that's typically like the big
- 24:22challenge that we're trying to get a fix for most of our
- 24:27clients. Yeah, I think you're right, I've
- 24:30definitely seen this where where people have typically relied on
- 24:35basic merchandising capabilities in platform.
- 24:39So yeah, been up to change the sort order.
- 24:41Maybe add a few basic business rules about where you've
- 24:43prioritized I showed bestsellers but mainly it's been manual
- 24:47using I guess in Gentile, modules are honesty where you
- 24:51can drag and drop and it's even it's a simple interface to use.
- 24:55But it doesn't allow that advanced logic where you can
- 24:57blend. Yay, like you're saying can
- 25:00blend the the machine learning piece with business logic
- 25:04Contour, you can set cocktails, you can be very micro in your
- 25:07targeting I think increasingly more people are going to the
- 25:12robo but the interesting bit is whether or not you need an AI
- 25:16know melt or you just need better visual merchandising
- 25:18capability because A business that is not getting loads and
- 25:21loads of people spending doing lots and lots of sessions.
- 25:26Therefore has a reduced merchandising opportunity and
- 25:30also where if you have very low volume purchase.
- 25:32Sorry yeah, low volume, High average order value, you got
- 25:35less purchase frequency with which to get meaningful learning
- 25:38to make those recommendations. And then I start to see that the
- 25:40balance where people shy away, they focus on the search piece
- 25:44Less on the merchandise and they stick to the visual
- 25:46merchandising time, they do more brand lead.
- 25:49I'm recommendations and associations because they just,
- 25:53you just don't get the advantage of an AI to learn that that
- 25:56situation as much. Yeah, I think we've had a lot of
- 25:59clients of invested in some of these products and just ended up
- 26:02doing everything manually and not really isn't too much of the
- 26:06kind of automation stuff. One thing I would say is that I
- 26:10think with one of the benefits of headless or some of them were
- 26:15open platforms, is that you can you're more likely to be Be able
- 26:19to do personalized personalization within the
- 26:23product grid without compromising and another area.
- 26:26So like taking the Grid at the platform and having a JavaScript
- 26:29grid, you know, and I think that that's something you see a lot
- 26:33of Shopify Bigcommerce and there are it always causes little
- 26:38issues, my experience. But I think that is one benefit
- 26:41of having. Yeah.
- 26:43Complete access to the server and everything else.
- 26:46Obviously, it's all server side. So basically the The e-commerce
- 26:50platform already knows which ought to put in for that person
- 26:53because it's done behind the scenes and, therefore, rather
- 26:56than at runtime in the browser that it's making the change.
- 26:59Yeah. Or even in the browser that you
- 27:00are just able to essentially kind of say, in the past.
- 27:05We've had clients use pre-render and they're able to them serve
- 27:08like a server-side snapshot to Google, for example, or like to
- 27:12search engines. Even and I know there's
- 27:15debatable around the JavaScript stuff and search engines the
- 27:19Yeah. And you know various other
- 27:21things you just got more freedom but I don't think that's that
- 27:24big a thing to be honest. And again I feel like
- 27:26personalization a bit like some of the other areas where it's
- 27:29debatable how much value it really adds for like a certain
- 27:32type of, there's a green. I think there's I'm probably
- 27:37going to be be laughed at for saying this as a consequence on,
- 27:40but I think personalization is overrated and the caveat that,
- 27:44that I have seen a couple of good use cases, where it has
- 27:48been used, but A lot of the time it feels like it's basically
- 27:52just repeating the same things to a lot of different people so
- 27:55it doesn't feel personalized. It feels very similar to setting
- 27:58up segments and then targeting based on behavioral learning
- 28:01within the segment rather than through one to one.
- 28:03But anyway that's a discussion for another day.
- 28:06The next one, I find interesting.
- 28:08And I'm definitely seeing an up taking us over the last few
- 28:10years. What I used to see this only in
- 28:13bigger businesses, but this customer service customer, pick
- 28:15it in. So the likes of zendesk I know
- 28:18gorgeous is made like big Waves incise world and I quite a few
- 28:21businesses that have worked with people who've moved over because
- 28:24they found the pricing model to work really well one and the
- 28:27capabilities. Good.
- 28:28I see more people thinking about this more accurately and and the
- 28:31e-commerce driver is we've got to get better management of like
- 28:34inbound inquiries and we've got to have better visibility so
- 28:37that we know how well we're doing and we can measure our
- 28:39service levels but also that we can get better flows to ensure
- 28:43that we prioritize actions and can act on stuff and don't lie.
- 28:46Things sat around in boxes. Basically, how are you?
- 28:49My you seen it up taken up or you just seen a concern
- 28:51massively. I think almost all of our client
- 28:54is like a gorgeous or a real maze, or I forgot what the other
- 28:58ones could but some of the modern ones that can just do a
- 29:02bit more with data so that they'll pull more data out of
- 29:07all of the other third parties econ platform.
- 29:09It's a lot more automation. They pushed more data into your
- 29:12CRM or ESP most of them. Now do what's up, as well?
- 29:16Which is like a massive requirement for luxury.
- 29:19Brands. Yeah more kind of like features
- 29:22around International. Yeah, we've definitely seen
- 29:25quite a big shift towards these tools.
- 29:28I think zendesk is obviously really good as well, but I think
- 29:31it's just more General and a lot of our clients partly prize
- 29:35partly just because these tools are a bit more specific to like
- 29:39the SAS ecosystems and can give you a bit more.
- 29:43Yeah, kind of few more features when it comes to like actually
- 29:47understanding the customer Are not reporting and all of that
- 29:50kind of stuff. Yeah, I think for me it's just
- 29:53the the change in use of it is per forer's.
- 29:56Customer inquiry. Used to be formed, send us an
- 29:58email and that email sitting in box, it might get a reply to you
- 30:02quickly, it might not, but then there's a manual dependency of
- 30:04somebody to decide whether it's prioritizing or the ability to
- 30:07put flow-based rules in and to shift them to different keys
- 30:11with different people to pull up on based on.
- 30:12Whether this is, as, you know, you've got a really pissed off
- 30:15customer that needs to Serious. Okay, let's put them into the
- 30:17hyper care team. So, having the ability, Ability
- 30:19to flow things, and you can either do that yet in your, in
- 30:22these different systems, or you can have rules where you spit
- 30:24out into other systems like crms, but just automating
- 30:28processes to take the manual headache away from customer
- 30:31service teams is, is a big benefit to efficiency.
- 30:36Let's go on to our last. But by no lean mean, going to
- 30:39speak means least topic shippin, shipping an order management
- 30:44again. This is an area where in this
- 30:46modern e-commerce world. I see more people going down
- 30:48specialist. Liberate and less trying to just
- 30:51build everything into an e-commerce platform or just to
- 30:53absorb logic from like warehouse management system into
- 30:56e-commerce. So e-commerce will have shipping
- 31:00matrices needs to have it because it's called and be able
- 31:02to know where this can be shipped to what the cost of
- 31:05doing it is excetera, but actually a lot business.
- 31:09Now as they expand either with that service offering or
- 31:12internationally, have a lot more complexity in terms of trying to
- 31:16keep their shipping costs down because it's such a competitive
- 31:18area for business. To not charge really high fees
- 31:21and not be so exposed to cost that it becomes prohibited to
- 31:24manage so things like volumetric mean, I'll just shave off.
- 31:27You know percentage points from caused by being added to select
- 31:30the right. Carrier based on the particular
- 31:33bundle of items you've got on the sizing and so you can save
- 31:36money on your shipping and I'm seeing more and more people
- 31:39looking at the likes of shipper hq's because you've got the
- 31:43connectivity with the carriers in there.
- 31:44But also you've got the ability to build up more complex logic
- 31:47and for it to make the decision for you.
- 31:50Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 31:51I mean I think probably less so recent it in the past we work
- 31:56with a few businesses of had really complex requirements
- 32:00around shipping and kind of like logic around where certain
- 32:03products can be shipped and can't be shipped and different
- 32:06like shipping methods as well. I white gloves, Etc.
- 32:10And yeah, we've worked very separate queue in particular, is
- 32:13probably the only one we've really worked with.
- 32:15And, but now I think that's one. That's important.
- 32:18And I think a lot of the stuff that you just talked I starting
- 32:20to people are starting to look at it for returns as well, which
- 32:24is an interesting one. So offering different like
- 32:27returns options and costs and things like that based on what
- 32:32they know about the customer. And all of that kind of stuff,
- 32:35which is quite, which quite interested in the same principle
- 32:38because I think there's quite a lot of cost that and, you know,
- 32:41you'll get certain customers will just return, You Know, by
- 32:4459 and return 14, and they'll be like a Serial returner Etc.
- 32:48And I think, I think a sauce with The first weren't they the
- 32:51started to look at the cast and realize that certain people
- 32:54there is hemorrhaging money and then you layer on like the cost
- 32:57of acquisition and cash back and everything else and suddenly
- 33:01they're just like, yeah, hemorrhaging money on customers.
- 33:03So I think that would be another one ends up going that way as
- 33:08well. Yeah, there's definitely a trend
- 33:10in the last couple years towards not just seeing returns as a
- 33:15free obligation for everybody as I actually The business has got
- 33:21to be profitable if it's going to Services customers and you
- 33:25have to, you have to provide a great service because that's
- 33:27customer service fee. But you've got to do it in a way
- 33:29that's affordable and the most important things that
- 33:31transparency around as that. But yeah, I think I think that
- 33:36kind of covers that one. So let's the other one, which
- 33:39I've been less involved with, to be honest.
- 33:42Is order management. Are you seeing people invest in
- 33:47a specialist OMS is or you seeing it?
- 33:50All being pushed into Erp. Yes.
- 33:52I think to be honest, when not that I'm actually surprised
- 33:56we're not because it comes up all the time.
- 34:00A lot of our clients don't have erps and they're like,
- 34:03essentially just cutting corners and maybe doing stuff in the
- 34:08econ platform. Like, we've got client moment
- 34:10that's going to end up using essentially have like to
- 34:12fullback warehouses on top of their main warehouse and like,
- 34:17all of that stuff around how you like efficiently.
- 34:20That should probably be in an LMS and some of the
- 34:23multi-channel stuff as well. But to be honest, very few of
- 34:26our clients have had no Mass. They've just kind of like built
- 34:29things into an Erp or, you know, taking the hair and just dumb
- 34:32things in a very simple way and you compact form that I'm
- 34:35surprised that we've not seen more clients looking to invest
- 34:39in this area. Yeah, I've had a few interesting
- 34:43discussions or some projects recently which were like
- 34:47Bigcommerce projects and Magento projects and in the end,
- 34:50especially so mess. It was just couldn't get the
- 34:52quite get the cost justification and they ended up doing the
- 34:56order routing through the existing PRP which, which I
- 35:00often think that that's if you have any RPG that can do all the
- 35:03roots and you can have some logic in there.
- 35:05That's normally the starting point and becomes a lot harder
- 35:09to get all of that old build, all that order routing logic.
- 35:11To e-commerce because it can be very complex when you've got
- 35:14special. When you got the split shipments
- 35:16in B2B is one of the area's, it's really hard.
- 35:18If you've got a multi-level account where you might have a
- 35:23client who's got six different businesses, and people are
- 35:26ordering across businesses and their shipping to like four or
- 35:29five different locations, and you've got a parcel and split
- 35:32it, and you've got to select different stock depending on
- 35:35where it's coming from different stock Holdings.
- 35:37It can soon become really, really got.
- 35:39You suddenly realize the Ridiculousness of trying to Do
- 35:41that in an e-commerce system versus in a special service at
- 35:44Miyabi. But yeah, I think that, I think
- 35:46that more simplistic models. Erps work really, really well
- 35:49without needing special somos, and some Erp providers have
- 35:52proper home. S modules anyways.
- 35:56Okay? So that's that's brought us.
- 35:57The end of our discussion for today.
- 36:00Are we missing anything obvious? Is there anything else where
- 36:02you're really seeing an increase in usage?
- 36:06Alongside the core e-commerce application.
- 36:10I think the bit the big ones, like you say, like people are
- 36:13looking at pims, people are looking at more Specialists like
- 36:16VM in platforms, bi is another one to be fair.
- 36:19That's the only other one where I feel like a lot of businesses
- 36:22are starting to invest more in like building out their own
- 36:25reporting stack to make sure that they're kind of getting
- 36:28fully accurate data. Etc.
- 36:30But now I think we've covered the main ones I've seen.
- 36:33Yeah I think I think my pot and comment very wrong today is is
- 36:37basically going into if you're going in.
- 36:39A platform selection or a migration or re-platform if you
- 36:42want to call that, go in with a very clear definition, for
- 36:46e-commerce means to you and what you want your eCommerce platform
- 36:48to do because all the while you stop trying to make it to do
- 36:51wider and wider things, you lose your focus, you start trying to
- 36:54get an e-commerce platform, look at all of this and you're going
- 36:57to be, it's Fool's Gold mostly because they don't exist or if
- 37:00they do the cost to them is so expensive, think about the
- 37:05functionality you need and have a very pragmatic conversation
- 37:07about which other system. Eames best-in-class will work
- 37:11with the e-commerce platform to deliver that.
- 37:12So you've got the best possible output and then look at the cost
- 37:16efficiency of that versus trying to customize the crap out of
- 37:18something that wasn't designed to do that.
- 37:20But that's my point. Comment anything from you may
- 37:23then think so. No, I think yeah.
- 37:25It's been an interesting discussion.
- 37:26I mean yeah, like similar to what you just said?
- 37:28I'm in take stuff out of the platform, you know, specialist.
- 37:31But yeah, no, I don't, I don't think anything else to add
- 37:34really well. So folks are on Feliz and we
- 37:37hope that's been useful and interesting.
- 37:39Afraid to challenge anything. We said, as always, yeah, hats
- 37:42on LinkedIn or Twitter, always open for conversation to keep an
- 37:46ear out for the episode for next week.
- 37:47We drop on every Tuesday. If you haven't subscribed,
- 37:50please do and we were genuinely love a rating on Apple Spotify
- 37:53or YouTube. Thanks very much and take care.
- 38:03More information on this topic, head over to re-platform dot.
- 38:06F m, for our audio podcasts to discuss a project or if you like
- 38:10to chat about any of the topics covered in this episode in more
- 38:12detail. Please reach out to myself James
- 38:14card and my co-host Paul Rodgers via LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 38:17Thanks again for listening and keep your ears peeled for the
- 38:19next episode.