Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 6 Episode 20: Shame, Love & the Truth About Male Violence
Transcript
- 1:06Ruth Reymundo: And we're back.
- 1:07David Mandel: And we're back.
- 1:08David Mandel: Hello.
- 1:08David Mandel: Hi, good morning.
- 1:09David Mandel: Good morning.
- 1:10David Mandel: We are sitting and having our first conversation podcast episode in a long time.
- 1:17Ruth Reymundo: We are.
- 1:17Ruth Reymundo: And actually, we're doing it in a somewhat new location.
- 1:22Ruth Reymundo: Not really.
- 1:23Ruth Reymundo: Not really.
- 1:23Ruth Reymundo: In my office in the house.
- 1:27David Mandel: You've been a tooper for the year.
- 1:28David Mandel: On a futon.
- 1:28David Mandel: You've been a trooper for years where you've been actually in the common space for a long time, and now you've got your own office.
- 1:35Ruth Reymundo: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:35Ruth Reymundo: It's good.
- 1:36David Mandel: And um very good.
- 1:36David Mandel: All my art is in here.
- 1:37David Mandel: We're surrounded by my artist.
- 1:39David Mandel: So you are joining us for our one of our maybe one of our end-of-year episodes for Partner with Survivor for 2025.
- 1:48David Mandel: I'm David Mandel, CEO and founder of the Safe and Tether Institute.
- 1:52David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:52Ruth Reymundo: And I'm Ruth Reymundo Mandel, and I am the Chief Business Development Officer and Co-owner.
- 1:59David Mandel: And we are joining you from very cold, very cold Masako Tunksis Land.
- 2:05David Mandel: And Ruth is uh is in rebellion this morning.
- 2:09Ruth Reymundo: My body is in rebellion.
- 2:11David Mandel: Rebellion.
- 2:12David Mandel: But we are on uh it's cold, there's snow on the ground.
- 2:17David Mandel: Um and I know some of you who never see snow want to see snow.
- 2:21David Mandel: And it is beautiful.
- 2:22Ruth Reymundo: But it's not just snow, it's chunks of ice.
- 2:24Ruth Reymundo: Sometimes the river gets so icy that there's like ice castles in the river and amazing formations.
- 2:32Ruth Reymundo: And they're beautiful.
- 2:33David Mandel: But it is cold.
- 2:34Ruth Reymundo: Yes, extremely cold.
- 2:35David Mandel: And for bodies that don't like cold, it's hard.
- 2:37David Mandel: And so we're on the Tunxus Mosako land, and just want to acknowledge the uh indigenous owners and any elders, past, present, emerging who are listening in on this episode.
- 2:49David Mandel: And so we're gonna do this in two parts.
- 2:51David Mandel: Um we're gonna discuss sort of some of the highlights of 2025.
- 2:55Speaker 1: Mm-hmm.
- 2:56David Mandel: And then dive into a topic that's been on my mind a lot lately.
- 3:00David Mandel: And I'm not even gonna tell you what it is.
- 3:02Ruth Reymundo: Well, I'll be curious to know what your highlights are and what my highlights are, because I think that we might have different highlights, but you go first.
- 3:09Ruth Reymundo: I want to hear your highlights.
- 3:10David Mandel: Oh my God.
- 3:11David Mandel: All right.
- 3:11David Mandel: You know, I um I guess the obvious ones are that uh my book was published, Stop Blaming Mothers and Ignoring Fathers, How to Transform the Way We Keep Children Safe from Domestic Violence was released this year in both Dutch and Japanese.
- 3:32Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 3:34David Mandel: And um so the Dutch version, I just was over there in the Netherlands for the first time.
- 3:40David Mandel: It was wonderful.
- 3:41David Mandel: The people were amazing, um, the being in Amsterdam was amazing.
- 3:47David Mandel: And I did three days of master classes around the book for different audiences, family law, child protection, and domestic abuse sector.
- 3:54David Mandel: Then I did this event um which had 850 people, normally like 400, and everybody got a copy of the book.
- 4:04David Mandel: Um, and so the book sold out of its first run of a thousand in the Netherlands, and they're printing another thousand.
- 4:12Ruth Reymundo: That's great.
- 4:12David Mandel: So, anyway, these are just uh I for me it's a little bit boggling and amazing, and I'm honored, and I got to give a copy of my book to uh um the mayor of a small town in in in the Netherlands who's standing up for women, making herself accessible, and uh says email me.
- 4:33David Mandel: You know, she's fighting femicide.
- 4:35David Mandel: Uh gave her a copy of the book, was on the dais with survivors, uh with other professionals who are leaders in the Netherlands, and that's amazing.
- 4:44David Mandel: And then you and I are going to Japan in March.
- 4:47Ruth Reymundo: That's that's in 2026.
- 4:48Ruth Reymundo: That's cheating.
- 4:49Ruth Reymundo: That's cheating.
- 4:50Ruth Reymundo: You actually have to just do 2026.
- 4:51Ruth Reymundo: You can't be forward-looking.
- 4:55Ruth Reymundo: So sorry.
- 4:56David Mandel: All right, all right.
- 4:56David Mandel: So it's your turn.
- 4:58Ruth Reymundo: So I would have to say that, you know, it's it's been a really amazing year underpinned by a tremendous amount of changes in political and funding environments and questions about how frontline services are going to be delivered, and in engaging with a lot of people around that question, around collaboration for how they're going to continue to deliver really domestic abuse-informed care has been actually an interesting highlight of my year.
- 5:40Ruth Reymundo: Talking to people about how they're pivoting, talking to them about their concerns, uh, talking to them about the challenges that they have, particularly if they're engaged with Latino and migrant populations in the United States.
- 5:58Ruth Reymundo: Um my highlight has actually been spending more time in my hometown in California and Santa Rosa, um, especially in connection with the land and with the intertribal council there.
- 6:17Ruth Reymundo: And um really healing and reconnecting in those type of uh land-based and and my hometown-based relationships, that has been a real healing thing for me.
- 6:34Ruth Reymundo: And that that is part of the work.
- 6:36Ruth Reymundo: That may not be safe and together work, but it is actually part of the work.
- 6:42Ruth Reymundo: Tending to our relationships, healing our trauma, reconnecting with others and hearing their ideas and solutions and struggles.
- 6:54Ruth Reymundo: To me, is the most beautiful thing about doing this work.
- 6:59Ruth Reymundo: And the other piece of that, which kind of fits with that, um, was I was felt really honored and really grateful to contribute to Alabama AM's uh you know, seminar conference on AI and social work technology.
- 7:23Ruth Reymundo: And I know that there's just a few of these starting to pop up around the world, around the globe, and I see them happening where people are very concerned about how technology is gonna deepen the harms and impacts of biases of systems that are already very biased, that are already doing deep harm in very specific communities.
- 7:52Ruth Reymundo: And I loved being a part of that collaboration and uh, you know, thank you for the invitation to Alabama AM and their School of Social Work, and to uh uh Dr.
- 8:08Ruth Reymundo: Lasharia Turner and to um also to Helen Feischel.
- 8:14Ruth Reymundo: You know, really grateful to them for their invitation and for all of the work that that they're doing to try to make people more safe in the context of this evolving world.
- 10:03Ruth Reymundo: And I love I love that.
- 10:05Ruth Reymundo: I love I love being in those spaces where there's a tremendous amount of deep listening and creativity happening because we are all very challenged by the edges of innovation, by the edges of change that we're not we're not in control of.
- 10:27Ruth Reymundo: So really just those those are my highlights.
- 10:29Ruth Reymundo: Very different than yours.
- 10:31Ruth Reymundo: Uh and I just I love that that collaboration around the the globe is is growing because that's what we need.
- 10:42David Mandel: You know, it's it's um I love listening to talk about community and connection and healing and relationships.
- 10:47David Mandel: And for me, um that showed up this year in research projects we did in in Australia, where we actually looked at the application of the model in child and family settings in New South Wales, and also um about to get the results of uh the application of the model in Aboriginal settings.
- 11:11David Mandel: We partnered with the University of Melbourne, uh Ministry of Health in New South Wales and two um well, Mendon Katungle, two amazing Aboriginal controlled organizations, health organizations, to see about how the the model applies in those Aboriginal-led spaces.
- 11:29David Mandel: And so for me, that that exchange, that that kind of discussion, that learning together is is is my version of what you're talking about, so being in community, being connection, being in dialogue.
- 11:43David Mandel: Um and one of the best compliments I think I've gotten from a researcher is uh this is out of a researcher in Scotland actually, so this is in a different setting, saying in researching the model, they they s they said, Well, you're one of the best examples of being flexible and adaptive to uh context, to location and culture while keeping track of the core of what the model is.
- 12:12David Mandel: And I think to me, that's such a beautiful compliment because it's it's mirrors this idea that there is something uh important to express and protect in the model.
- 12:26David Mandel: And at the same time, we need to be in dialogue.
- 12:29David Mandel: And I I've been this is my entire career.
- 12:31David Mandel: When I would train people directly to be consultants using the model, I'd say there's an art and a science.
- 12:36David Mandel: I said the science is when when you when you can do it right or wrong.
- 12:40David Mandel: If you don't talk about perpetrators' patterns, you're not doing it right.
- 12:43David Mandel: But how you do that, how you do that is going to be different than how I do that.
- 12:50David Mandel: And so for me, there's a through line from that individual coaching I did to this larger work we're doing now, which is how do you hold on to both the art and the science?
- 13:00David Mandel: How do you hold on to the specificity of the model, the innovations, and then at the same time be in dialogue.
- 13:08David Mandel: Be in dialogue with Australia, with Aboriginal context, with uh with same-sex communities, with I mean, you know, sort of how do you really speak to women's use of violence against male or female partners in a way that honors the model itself.
- 13:25Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 13:25Ruth Reymundo: So it's it's it's it's so important.
- 13:29Ruth Reymundo: I think of the the I went I was in New Orleans this year and I was presenting at a conference.
- 13:37Ruth Reymundo: Um, and it was the um family therapy conference.
- 13:42Ruth Reymundo: So there's a lot of foster care providers there.
- 13:45Ruth Reymundo: And I went, of course, I went to a couple art studios because I had to, and one of them was the 11th Ward Mural uh project that's preserved, but it was there was there was written on the wall, and there's no author, so I don't know who to attribute this to.
- 14:05Ruth Reymundo: Written on the wall in this huge warehouse was this sentence, and it hit me like very deeply in my body.
- 14:15Ruth Reymundo: Like when I when I experience things that feel like truth, it's like that old saying, you know, you feel it in your bones.
- 14:22Ruth Reymundo: I feel it in my bones, like I feel it inside my body.
- 14:25Ruth Reymundo: And it said, organize around your values, your common values, not your common trauma.
- 14:34Ruth Reymundo: And I think that in this industry, it is very easy for us to center trauma because we have to, because it is it is what is being caused, it is what we're trying to to articulate and of and to uh avoid or to support, right?
- 14:54Ruth Reymundo: But that belief of organizing around one's common values is so powerful, and I really do feel like when you created the model, that's what you did.
- 15:07Ruth Reymundo: You didn't center the trauma or the conflict piece of it.
- 15:14Ruth Reymundo: You centered the the things that would nourish and create a better outcome and a better reality.
- 15:23Ruth Reymundo: And that's about values, that's about our core values.
- 15:26Ruth Reymundo: So I really wanna, I really want people to start noticing as you walk through the world of advocacy and you walk through the world where people are claiming to defend other people's rights, are they organizing around common values or are they organizing around trauma?
- 15:47Ruth Reymundo: And not to say that we don't need both of those things, because we do.
- 15:52Ruth Reymundo: I'm not saying that we don't need both of those things, but at least for me and for my advocacy and for my way of being in the world, I am much more attracted to people who organize around common values that we can all agree upon and then achieve those common values in a variety of ways because we are all individuals.
- 16:18Ruth Reymundo: There's no black and white answers here.
- 16:21Ruth Reymundo: There's no one size fits all, there's no one definition that rules them all.
- 16:26Ruth Reymundo: And in fact, that attitude itself, and I'm gonna pause there, that belief system itself is dangerous and lends itself to coercion and to abuse of other perspectives.
- 16:42Ruth Reymundo: And I can say that I think feeling it in my bones, because I'm a person who has that history in me, right?
- 16:51Ruth Reymundo: It comes it comes with my family.
- 16:53Ruth Reymundo: I don't know.
- 16:54Ruth Reymundo: It's just in me.
- 16:55Ruth Reymundo: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 16:55David Mandel: You know, I I I love so much of what you're saying, and it actually gives a natural pivot, I think, to the second half of the topic that we talked about talking about.
- 17:03David Mandel: But I I do think that w it reflects this idea that the model has grown globally, the safety of the model has grown globally through attraction, not through promotion.
- 17:13David Mandel: It's it's been people have wanted it and chosen to engage in it.
- 17:18David Mandel: Right.
- 17:23Ruth Reymundo: It's more like here's how we support better things to happen.
- 17:27David Mandel: And so I I I'm gonna introduce the second half topic with a story and and then I'll kind of say what this has been about for me lately.
- 17:36David Mandel: Um When I did work, so many of you know that I started my work um working with domestic violence perpetrators, running groups for them, most almost all exclusively male.
- 17:49David Mandel: And I would sit with these men and talk to them.
- 17:53David Mandel: They'd been arrested, most of them, but not all of them, and I would talk to them about their behavior.
- 17:57David Mandel: And for me, the measure of success was could I engage them in a way that made their partner safer?
- 18:06David Mandel: Um, that improved their partner's self-determination, more freedom and quality of life.
- 18:12David Mandel: That was the the benchmark foundational marker of that work.
- 18:17David Mandel: And it was a response to the reality that this person sitting in front of me had chosen to be violent, whatever their background, and many of them come from backgrounds where they've been abused themselves and grown up in abuse, and so I see that as well.
- 18:33David Mandel: And they were hurting other people and continued to, as adults, to choose that, engage in that.
- 18:39David Mandel: And it felt important to be able to talk to them about that because one, they were harming other people, including their partners and children.
- 18:47David Mandel: And I had a deep and still do, deep abiding belief that their violence harmed them as well.
- 18:55David Mandel: And I know sometimes we only see the harm done to others, which makes sense, or the benefits that men accrue from violence or control.
- 19:02David Mandel: Totally understand that.
- 19:04David Mandel: And for me, sitting with them, I would hold both things, and I would see that and believe that if you're afraid of being lost, of losing somebody, I mean if you're afraid of your partner leaving you because maybe what you experienced as a kid, wherever it came from, and then you use violence and control to manage your fear.
- 19:23David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 19:24Ruth Reymundo: It's a poor strategy.
- 19:25David Mandel: It's a awfully poor strategy because what it does is actually create the conditions of greater insecurity.
- 19:32David Mandel: Of loss.
- 19:34Ruth Reymundo: Well, yeah.
- 19:34Ruth Reymundo: You break somebody's trust.
- 19:36David Mandel: That's right.
- 19:37Ruth Reymundo: You demean them, you give them trauma, you you you take away their liberty.
- 19:42Ruth Reymundo: That's right.
- 19:43Ruth Reymundo: And then you're gonna you're not that person is not gonna want to be called.
- 19:47David Mandel: If you're living inside your story, then you see that distance between you and them as proof that you were right, and it accelerates your can accelerate your abuse and control.
- 19:57David Mandel: And you feel more justified.
- 19:58David Mandel: You go deeper into that dysfunctional story, that justification.
- 20:02David Mandel: So I would sit with men.
- 20:04Ruth Reymundo: And there's a lot of self-abuse happening there.
- 20:06David Mandel: And a lot of self-abuse happening.
- 20:07David Mandel: And I would sit with those men, and I, even if he didn't see it, I would try to speak to his highest self-interest and see that there was a benefit to him if he could stop his abuse and control.
- 20:20David Mandel: Right.
- 20:20David Mandel: Okay.
- 20:21David Mandel: Yeah.
- 20:21David Mandel: And and that's really that's really where my my roots are in this way, right?
- 20:29David Mandel: This is where and why is this relevant to it?
- 20:32David Mandel: Because I haven't done that work in I don't know what I've done.
- 20:33Ruth Reymundo: Well, some of but so some people some people would would say, you know, okay, great, his highest and best good.
- 20:41Ruth Reymundo: What does that mean?
- 20:41Ruth Reymundo: Because a lot of people's frameworks is simply punishment and and and within the systems that we've created, within the carceral systems, prison.
- 20:51Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 20:51Ruth Reymundo: Legal punishment.
- 20:53Ruth Reymundo: That's their only reference and framework.
- 20:55Ruth Reymundo: So so how how do you deal with that empathy when you have that perspective that's very truncated by that?
- 21:03David Mandel: I don't, you know, I don't know the answer to that, actually.
- 21:06David Mandel: I'll tell you what what's been bugging me lately.
- 21:08Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 21:09David Mandel: And maybe it you know, maybe we can connect the dots between what you just said and and and and what's been bugging me lately.
- 21:16David Mandel: Because this is was one of those episodes you came to me and said, What do you want to talk about?
- 21:19David Mandel: And I go, I want to talk about the fact that I feel like every time somebody wants to talk about men's violence, that they are getting accused right now of shaming men.
- 21:33Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 21:34David Mandel: And that that that discussions about men and boys often get prefaced with, well, I don't want to shame men.
- 21:42David Mandel: I don't want men and boys to feel shamed.
- 21:44Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 21:45Ruth Reymundo: And and and and and what I want to say is You know, I'm just gonna can we stop for a second?
- 21:51Ruth Reymundo: Can we stop for a second on the premise that men and boys feeling shame is a bad thing?
- 21:57Ruth Reymundo: Shame is something that people feel.
- 22:00Ruth Reymundo: Shame is something people feel for all sorts of reasons, and we should all be curious how we can support people when they're feeling shame.
- 22:11Ruth Reymundo: Rather than them shutting down, lashing out, being violent.
- 22:17Ruth Reymundo: We may know that men are more violent and resistance when they feel.
- 22:22Ruth Reymundo: Shame and we should be curious about that.
- 22:24Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 22:29David Mandel: But I think it's it's this.
- 22:30David Mandel: Right, this is exactly this sort of my my fear or worry or my response to sort of this reflexive, don't shame men and boys.
- 22:38David Mandel: You're gonna shame men and boys.
- 22:39David Mandel: We shouldn't do that.
- 22:40David Mandel: And we know the conversation is much more one-on-one level nuanced.
- 22:45David Mandel: If you listen to people in in restorative justice fields, right, which is not the carceral approach you're talking about.
- 22:52David Mandel: They're talking about how do you engage in healing and restoration and creating wholeness versus punishment for the sake of punishment.
- 23:01David Mandel: Right.
- 23:01David Mandel: They would talk about inclusive or exclusive shame.
- 23:05David Mandel: And the goal of restorative justice would be inclusive shaming.
- 23:10David Mandel: The idea is you're still part of our family, you're still part of our community.
- 23:15David Mandel: What you're describing with that carcel approach is you're outside the bounds.
- 23:19David Mandel: You're you're no longer one of us.
- 23:22Ruth Reymundo: Well, hey, so so so let's let's just hold on a second, because there's a lot of belief that that each of these camps is like the restorative justice people are like, uh, you know, this type of group accountability is perfect and wonderful.
- 23:39Ruth Reymundo: I don't believe that.
- 23:40Ruth Reymundo: And then and then there's the, you know, all all carceral punishment is wrong.
- 23:45Ruth Reymundo: I don't believe that either.
- 23:46Ruth Reymundo: I get that.
- 23:47Ruth Reymundo: I'm just gonna say I'm gonna say that I'm always gonna be consistent in not landing in either camps.
- 23:53Speaker 1: Right.
- 23:53Ruth Reymundo: Because what for me, I'm always asking the question of what doesn't dehumanize the person but brings about containment for violent people because there truly are violent people who need to be contained.
- 24:08David Mandel: Right.
- 24:08Ruth Reymundo: There there are truly psychopaths.
- 24:11David Mandel: Right.
- 24:11Ruth Reymundo: And I've met them, and they cannot be contained unless you contain them.
- 24:15Ruth Reymundo: I agree.
- 24:16Ruth Reymundo: Unless you create a boundary round.
- 24:17Ruth Reymundo: And then and then there are there are communal ways that that restorative justice process gets weaponized against victims in communal settings, and that is real.
- 24:33David Mandel: Yes.
- 24:33Ruth Reymundo: That is real.
- 24:34David Mandel: Oh, we've seen that.
- 24:35David Mandel: I've I've talked to people who are not going to be able to do that.
- 24:36Ruth Reymundo: When you are in a rural setting, that's right, and you're you are people know each other, they're related, they're related, the family has power, and you're in that communal justice setting and they get to determine what the justice is, you are.
- 24:49Ruth Reymundo: Yep.
- 24:49Ruth Reymundo: I'm not going to use a curse word, but you understand what I'm saying.
- 24:52David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 24:53David Mandel: So I agree with you.
- 24:54David Mandel: I mean, I used to say my way of saying it was domestic violence perpetrators are a heterogeneous group in terms of their behavior patterns and also their ability for being rehabilitated.
- 25:04David Mandel: Now I think that section that they can't be engaged in rehabilitated is actually quite small relative to the larger group.
- 25:10David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 25:10Ruth Reymundo: We don't know yet because we don't assume that we're not going to be able to do that.
- 25:13David Mandel: But but but that that that but we have to hold that place for exactly what you said that some folks need containment and and and need that external uh whether it's incarceration or something else, or it's a or it's a it's electronic bracelet or something.
- 25:29David Mandel: But but I'll tell you something that just so within this, so what what disturbs me is when people are not courageous and fearless in this conversation about accusing people who want to talk about male violence against men and women, that that that we're somehow by talking about it, we're simply shaming them.
- 25:54David Mandel: And and I and I I feel the um I have to say the defensiveness in that position of those people, the misdirection, the gaslighting.
- 26:05David Mandel: I recently read something that said that was really in the context of of of how men are getting the short end of the stick about conversation around violence.
- 26:13David Mandel: And they said, well, the majority of of homicide victims are male.
- 26:19David Mandel: Which is absolutely true.
- 26:21David Mandel: Globally, it's eighty one percent, in Australia it's sixty nine percent.
- 26:24David Mandel: You know, these are numbers I've been looking at.
- 26:27David Mandel: I think this is, you know, isn't isn't talked about in the domestic violence community, and I'll explain why in a minute, why I think that is.
- 26:35David Mandel: But when we look at homicides globally, men are the the biggest portion of victims.
- 26:45David Mandel: Victims, okay.
- 26:47David Mandel: So so I want people to hear that, and that's a real concern when we come to the same thing.
- 26:50Ruth Reymundo: Men are deeply impacted by violence.
- 26:52David Mandel: By violence, by men's health, and and this has that's homicide.
- 26:56David Mandel: We can make that not homicide.
- 26:57Ruth Reymundo: We can extend that out to suicide as well.
- 26:59David Mandel: Right, exactly.
- 27:00David Mandel: These are real things.
- 27:01David Mandel: But this same article would not, did not say that the vast majority of the perpetrators are men.
- 27:10David Mandel: Are men.
- 27:13Ruth Reymundo: That's an inconvenient context.
- 27:16David Mandel: Globally, it's 95 percent.
- 27:17David Mandel: This is the the the the the U.N.
- 27:19David Mandel: criminal justice stats.
- 27:20David Mandel: Yeah.
- 27:21David Mandel: 95 percent of perpetrators of homicide are male.
- 27:24David Mandel: In Australia, it's 87 percent.
- 27:27David Mandel: Yeah.
- 27:27David Mandel: And and and so I'm gonna talk about domestic abuse in in a second, but but I just to me, these are simple facts that we all can agree on.
- 27:38David Mandel: And somebody once said, I don't know if it was Mark Twain or somebody else, there's somebody famous quote that I'm probably getting wrong, which is you you're entitled to your own opinions but not to your own facts.
- 27:47Ruth Reymundo: Like and so and in the age of the internet where a simple Google search could tell you who the vast majority of violent crime victims and perpetrators are, we always come back to the same place.
- 28:01David Mandel: Right.
- 28:01David Mandel: Men.
- 28:02David Mandel: Right.
- 28:02David Mandel: And so and so when we get down to women as victims of of homicide, the the the the women are are predominantly much more likely to be victims of domestic abuse.
- 28:15David Mandel: Of partners, or interim partners or ex-partners, and men are more likely to be victims of of strangers or acquaintances.
- 28:20David Mandel: Right.
- 28:21David Mandel: And and that women pr four out of five, I think the numbers are again in Australia, their homicide perpetrators are male.
- 28:29David Mandel: So whether we're talking about the murder of women or the murder of men, the the the unquestionable gender, uh predominant gender is male.
- 28:40Ruth Reymundo: If we're talking about the largest cost, both social, cultural, governmental, for intervening in violence, for maintaining violence, and for dealing with the health implications of violence, we always come back to men.
- 29:02David Mandel: And this is just to be super clear, this is widely disproportionate to men's uh ratio of men and to women in the population, right?
- 29:10David Mandel: Which is about 50-50.
- 29:11Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 29:12David Mandel: You know, close to that.
- 29:13David Mandel: And so we have this much greater percentage of men perpetrating violence.
- 29:19David Mandel: Which which again, so if you're uncomfortable, this is where I want to lean in.
- 29:23David Mandel: And I feel this so strongly.
- 29:25David Mandel: If this is making you feel uncomfortable, if this is making you feel like you're unbashing men, then what I'd ask you to do is take a breath, take a beat.
- 29:34David Mandel: And why sit with your discomfort.
- 29:37Ruth Reymundo: And why is it making you uncomfortable?
- 29:38David Mandel: And if you feel like somehow talking about this is shaming of men, again, ask yourself why are these simple facts now, these are hard facts, these are disturbing facts, these are facts that need to be seen and looked at.
- 29:54Ruth Reymundo: And talked about.
- 29:55David Mandel: And as a and and again, I feel like, you know, this is where I come in.
- 29:58David Mandel: I'm saying this as a man, and I'm saying this as a man who's uh had a great relationship with his dad, has a has a wonderful relationship with his brother, has long-term 40-year-old, you know, 40 years of friendship with with men.
- 30:12David Mandel: Yeah.
- 30:12David Mandel: I talk to my male friends on the on the uh on the phone every day, sometimes, and I I uh you know You guys have a men's group.
- 30:20David Mandel: I have a men's group that I've been part of.
- 30:22David Mandel: Right.
- 30:22David Mandel: You know, that I think that that I've been accused of being a traitor to somehow men, or not loving men, or not caring about men.
- 30:30David Mandel: And why I started with a story that even when I work with men who are violent, I cared about them.
- 30:36David Mandel: And so this is about care.
- 30:40Ruth Reymundo: Men who want to continue to be violent will feel not cared for when you point out that male violence is a problem.
- 30:48Ruth Reymundo: It's that simple.
- 30:50Speaker 1: Right.
- 30:50Ruth Reymundo: It's really not hard.
- 30:51Ruth Reymundo: And in the day and age of information that is easily and readily accessible, global crime statistics, it is so basic and gaslighting for men to tell us that men are not impacting male health and male safety and male mental well-being and male stability, and to tell us we can't talk about how men are impacting men.
- 31:18David Mandel: Or we're shaming them.
- 31:19Ruth Reymundo: Or we're shaming them.
- 31:20Ruth Reymundo: That is, and I'm gonna say this as a woman and as cranky survivor, that is absolutely an emotional reaction, not grounded in reality, and shows a tremendous amount of desire to gaslight and control the space.
- 31:36David Mandel: And so for me, uh what I'm looking for, when I because I I believe there are and I know, like I I support and promote work like Matt Brown's work and Sarah Brown's work, you know, the inner boy work, you know, She Is Not Your Rehab, where Matt and Sarah they talk with deep feeling and caring about men's trauma.
- 31:59Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 31:59Ruth Reymundo: Or Jack and Lisa Bowlman and also men's responsibility for their behavior.
- 32:04David Mandel: We talked um, you know, we talked on the podcast the other day, you know, with interview um where we were talking about fathers and and responsible fatherhood and and the importance of that.
- 32:16David Mandel: It's in the conversations I was talking to somebody online on LinkedIn about who was talking about men and shame and the need to sort of not shame men and I and uh and and I really engage, you know, when people are open to engage them, I really engage and said, what's the language that you use to to h you know address men's violence and not shame them?
- 32:36David Mandel: And he gave me language that was sort of that starts with, you're responsible for your behavior.
- 32:42Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 32:43David Mandel: And the next line is, and there's help for you.
- 32:45Ruth Reymundo: Yeah.
- 32:46David Mandel: You can do better.
- 32:47David Mandel: And and it's not for me, it's not until we get to that like if if if you cannot talk about violence, if you all you talk about is not shaming men, but you don't have the courage or the knowledge or the confidence.
- 33:00David Mandel: I mean, I don't know what it is.
- 33:02Ruth Reymundo: Maybe people don't have the willingness.
- 33:03Ruth Reymundo: Or the willingness because quite frankly, uh a lot of people believe that masculinity requires force.
- 33:15Ruth Reymundo: It requires dominance and it requires violence.
- 33:19Ruth Reymundo: And they don't want to be quote unquote shamed for something that they consider is innate, that they don't have control over, and they've been told by people they don't have control over it, even by people who claim to be feminists.
- 33:36unknown: Right.
- 33:36Ruth Reymundo: They say that it's a biological, natural imperative that men are violent and then they endlessly keep us in this cycle of violence because they say men can't change and they don't want to invest in it either.
- 33:48Ruth Reymundo: And that, hello, feminists, I'm looking at you, that is a problem.
- 33:52Ruth Reymundo: Right.
- 33:52David Mandel: And if you're you're if you are can only talk about men as victims and you don't you can't sort of say that men are predominantly the victims of other men, yeah, then you you are an apologist for male violence in my mind.
- 34:08Speaker 1: Right.
- 34:09David Mandel: You're not really talking about protecting men from unnecessary shaming.
- 34:12David Mandel: And and I want to be really clear, you know, because this is this is these are the conversations, you know, that we talk about, I talk about, I've talked about for years that both men and women can be violent.
- 34:24David Mandel: We have on the podcast authors that talk about women's use of violence in intimate relationships.
- 34:29Ruth Reymundo: And we ha we talk about male victims as well.
- 34:31David Mandel: And we talk about domestic violence in queer relationships.
- 34:33David Mandel: You know, there's there's there's to me, I I look for that consistency in myself as well, that I'm not afraid to talk about that.
- 34:43David Mandel: You talk about violence in your life from women.
- 34:45David Mandel: Yes.
- 34:46David Mandel: You know, and so we we it's not like we we so so we can we can do both.
- 34:54R: I think it's very hard when structures have been set up and people's minds have been trained by these very decontextual, label-based um ways of defining violence.
- 35:09R: There's a whole industry that's popped up all over the world.
- 35:12R: Funding streams that maintain these tags and terms, so to speak, and and and literally train people into these very narrow ways of viewing violence.
- 35:25R: That is the power of tagging and labeling an ontology.
- 35:29R: Yeah, and bringing ontology.
- 35:31David Mandel: Bring on your ontology words.
- 35:33R: And and and who has controlled the ontology.
- 35:35R: And we know who's controlled the ontology.
- 35:38R: And this is where context becomes really important and where abusers do not like context.
- 35:47R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 35:47David Mandel: Right.
- 35:47David Mandel: And that's the whole other conversation when when when people will throw out sort of the the gender symmetry argument and say that men and women are just as violent, that when you dig the next level down, then start talking about course control, and you start talking about impact on functioning, and you talk about sexual assault, and you talk about homicide, and all these things shape the environment.
- 36:10David Mandel: There's no there's very little gender symmetry.
- 36:13David Mandel: There's asymmetry, like I was talking about.
- 36:15David Mandel: And and we again I I I want to be um fearless.
- 36:23David Mandel: I think we can be fearless.
- 36:25David Mandel: I I I believe we can be courageous.
- 36:27David Mandel: These facts shouldn't scare us, and we should be flexible and responsive.
- 36:31David Mandel: And what I mean by that is if you come to me and say, I've got a woman who's violent, this is was my practice for years.
- 36:37David Mandel: I've got a woman who's violent.
- 36:39David Mandel: I'm gonna say to you, tell me about her parent of course control and actions take and arm the kids.
- 36:44R: Same thing you'll say.
- 36:44David Mandel: Same thing if it was a man.
- 36:45David Mandel: And so to me, I feel like this is the integrity I'm looking for other people.
- 36:50David Mandel: Yeah.
- 36:50David Mandel: Which is sort of that you you can see that um women are doing double or triple still of the caregiving at homes.
- 36:59David Mandel: They're just reading about this or home chores.
- 37:02David Mandel: Like we have to be able to say that.
- 37:04R: Yeah.
- 37:05David Mandel: And the women's lives, you know, they report to us over and over again that they're still being shaped of fears of male violence.
- 37:10David Mandel: That we have to listen.
- 37:13R: And we and we have to we have to really be honest about power and control.
- 37:19R: Right.
- 37:20R: And really learn power dynamics and what those mean.
- 37:24R: It's very hard for people, I think, to be pattern-based and contextual.
- 37:28R: For some people it's easier, you know.
- 37:30R: Um, and and one of the things that I would really want to challenge our listeners to do is to feel in themselves the places where they have a little bit of attachment or reactivity around these type of labels and around naming these realities, and really observe what that fear of naming it is.
- 37:56R: Um and and I think a lot of times, um, not only be not just the structural issues, the ways that we've been taught to talk about these issues in education and academic programs, through research studies, through government funding, you know, labeling, which is the way that we often limit ourselves in our conversation.
- 38:19R: But I think at the very bottom of it, that if we're truly honest about behavioral patterns, we'll we'll tell ourselves that we're uncomfortable because following behavioral patterns means that we have to be more personal, more relational, that we have to really dive down into what power and control means for us in our own relationships and in our professional relationships.
- 38:44David Mandel: That's right.
- 38:44R: That's where people become uncomfortable.
- 38:47David Mandel: And I think it's uncomfortable.
- 38:48David Mandel: I think it's easier, and I do think this is real.
- 38:50David Mandel: I think it's easier to um sort of see a behavior like violence and make somebody one-dimensional.
- 39:00David Mandel: I think that's the other side of what you're saying.
- 39:03R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Yeah, dehumanization.
- 39:04David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Dehumanize them.
- 39:05David Mandel: And I think I think that um we can do both.
- 39:09R: And I think for me the Wait, we can dehumanize and humanize.
- 39:13R: Wait, what do you mean?
- 39:16David Mandel: We can sort of look in your face.
- 39:18David Mandel: We can name the violence, we can name it as a problem, we can speak the truth of the hurt it does and not dehumanize people.
- 39:26R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Well, some people want to dehumanize people.
- 39:28R: Like let's there's a there's a very long tradition of dehumanization in some cultures.
- 39:32R: I understand that.
- 39:33R: And I understand that.
- 39:34David Mandel: But I think I I guess the kind of move to wrapping this up, to think about this is this idea that for me, that I I want this conversation about male violence, male violence against men and boys.
- 39:47David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 39:48R: And women and girls.
- 39:49R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 39:49R: Girls.
- 39:50David Mandel: That's right.
- 39:50David Mandel: You know.
- 39:51R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: And animals and the earth.
- 39:53David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: Right, exactly.
- 39:54David Mandel: That that if if 40 percent of Australians are growing up in homes of domestic violence, that's a lot of boys growing up in homes of domestic violence that I'm concerned about as well as girls.
- 40:04R: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: And we're concerned not just about their immediate physical well-being and safety and health.
- 40:12R: We're worried about the coping mechanisms, the behavioral patterns, the lessons they're learning about relationships and how they're gonna apply that to their future life and harm themselves and others.
- 40:24David Mandel: Trevor Burrus, Jr.: If you don't see the connection between those numbers and the high rate of male suicide, you're missing something really obvious and really you're painfully.
- 40:31David Mandel: And you're claiming to be an advocate for men's health, and you're missing this.
- 40:36David Mandel: And so for me, uh what I want to communicate, and I feel really strongly about it, I feel very emotional about this, which is that when you hear me talk about men's violence, this is about loving loving men.
- 40:49David Mandel: Helping men.
- 40:52David Mandel: Um obviously, and also helping the people that are hurting, which was, you know, the the the driving force behind this this work, this career, this passion of mine.
- 41:05David Mandel: But but I also want you to hear that that it's sort of like that there's this deep desire to help men be in balance.
- 41:14Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 41:14David Mandel: To be in balance.
- 41:15David Mandel: If you're being violent, you're out of bal like like the kindest thing I can say is the most neutral say way to say this in some ways, you're out of balance.
- 41:24David Mandel: Being in violence is out of balance with yourself, with other people, with your community.
- 41:31R: So that I'm gonna qualify that.
- 41:32David Mandel: Yeah.
- 41:33R: I'm gonna be more specific.
- 41:34R: Being violent to your family members and to your friends and in contexts where nobody is attacking your liberties and your person is out of balance.
- 41:46David Mandel: That's right.
- 41:47R: Because I do protect violence as an energy in nature, and we're part of nature, and we do get to protect ourselves.
- 41:55David Mandel: That's right.
- 41:55David Mandel: Violence in the genuine self-defense.
- 41:59R: Self-defense is a is a is a right of us as animals and humanity.
- 42:03R: But you are out of balance if your violence and your coercion undermine your relationships and your connections and harm yourself and others.
- 42:17David Mandel: And so I want people to hear that.
- 42:18David Mandel: I want people to I want us to together follow.
- 42:22David Mandel: This idea that talking about men's violence is not automatically shaming men and boys.
- 42:30R: It's actually loving.
- 42:31David Mandel: It's actually loving.
- 42:32David Mandel: And calling them to account and saying that's not okay is is one of the highest gestures of love and of friendship.
- 42:41David Mandel: And I'll and I'll just end on another personal note.
- 42:44David Mandel: This men's group that I mentioned earlier I've been part of, we have a commitment to each other to confront each other.
- 42:51David Mandel: And that's not aggressive, that's sort of saying when you see something that the other person is doing that's harmful to themselves or other people, that it's a loving thing to name that.
- 43:03David Mandel: And I still remember one of one of the things that I I'm most proud of of in some ways is a close friend of mine working out his estrangement issues with his son.
- 43:14David Mandel: And his son had a daughter.
- 43:17David Mandel: There's no was no violence in this situation.
- 43:19David Mandel: And the son wasn't seeing his daughter because he was angry at the child's mother, the daughter's the daughter's mother.
- 43:29David Mandel: And my friend was not pushing in on his son and his fatherly responsibilities.
- 43:34David Mandel: I said, as the grandfather, I know you're trying to work out your relationship with your son and you're trying to protect it.
- 43:41David Mandel: But if you don't push in on your son and his responsibility to his daughter, every day goes by, she doesn't have a dad in her life.
- 43:49R: Yeah.
- 43:51David Mandel: And I played small some small part by pushing him, he pushed his son, and now his son has a good, strong, constructive, everyday relationship with his daughter.
- 44:04David Mandel: And and to me that's loving him.
- 44:07David Mandel: I wasn't trying to shame him.
- 44:09David Mandel: I wasn't trying to shame his son.
- 44:11David Mandel: I was trying to say, remember this girl, remember this daughter.
- 44:15R: Yeah, but also he suffers and she suffers in the severing of that connection.
- 44:20David Mandel: That's right.
- 44:20David Mandel: And he's much more enriched from what I hear by his relationship with his daughter.
- 44:23David Mandel: So I I I I I think we just need to get better at this.
- 44:28R: All right.
- 44:29David Mandel: And not be afraid of it.
- 44:30R: Let's get better at it.
- 44:31R: We can teach you how not to be afraid of talking to men.
- 44:35David Mandel: I guess so.
- 44:35David Mandel: We can do it.
- 44:36David Mandel: That's what we're doing.
- 44:37R: We can do it.
- 44:37R: We can do it.
- 44:38David Mandel: We're doing it.
- 44:38R: We can do it.
- 44:39R: You can take the cranky survivor tactic, or you can take the David Mandel tactic.
- 44:43R: I don't know.
- 44:43R: There's one of your two choices.
- 44:45R: And then we'll bring guests on that'll help you to learn other tactics.
- 44:49R: That's right.
- 44:49R: But you've been listening to Partnered with Survivor, and I am still Ruth Raimundo, and you're still David Mandel.
- 44:57David Mandel: Let's just make a change.
- 44:58David Mandel: And please subscribe, follow, share this podcast.
- 45:02David Mandel: Check out Save at the Other Institute.com.
- 45:05David Mandel: Uh buy my book in Dutch.
- 45:08R: Yeah.
- 45:08David Mandel: Or Japanese.
- 45:09R: Japanese or English?
- 45:10R: Or English?
- 45:11R: Maybe soon it'll be in Spanish.
- 45:13R: Who knows?
- 45:13R: It's coming.
- 45:14R: What's coming next?
- 45:15David Mandel: Who knows?
- 45:15David Mandel: But anyway.
- 45:17R: And we are out.
- 45:19David Mandel: Out.