Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 Index Inclusion Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00OK, let's let's unpack this. We hear about the S&P 500 and
- 0:03the NASDAQ 100 all the time, right?
- 0:04Market headlines. Constantly.
- 0:05They're like the barometers. Exactly.
- 0:07But they're also these, well, incredibly exclusive clubs for
- 0:11corporate America. We want to dive into the actual
- 0:14rule books today, the criteria that decide who gets in managing
- 0:17literally trillions of dollars. Right.
- 0:20And the mission here is really to get beyond just big
- 0:22companies. We need to understand the the
- 0:25fundamental philosophy behind each index.
- 0:28They're quite different. How so?
- 0:30Well, think of the S&P 500 as maybe the art of index creation.
- 0:35It's curated A proxy for the broad economy focused on
- 0:39stability and representation. OK.
- 0:42So if that's the art, then the NASDAQ 100, that's the science.
- 0:45Precisely. It's much more mechanical, rules
- 0:47based, like an engine geared towards innovation, high growth
- 0:51sectors. It's reflecting a very different
- 0:53slice of the modern economy. And that difference, art versus
- 0:55science, that's key, isn't it? It affects who gets chosen, and
- 0:58maybe more importantly, what happens after they get in.
- 1:01Absolutely. We'll get into why that famous
- 1:03stock price bump from joining the S&P 500 seems to be, well,
- 1:07fading away. While joining the NASDAQ 100
- 1:10might actually offer a more lasting structural advantage.
- 1:13Interesting. OK, let's start with the big
- 1:15one, the 500, the global standard, right?
- 1:19And the first misconcetion to clear U is that it's not just
- 1:22the 500 largest U companies. It's designed to be a benchmark,
- 1:25yes, but a curated 1. Curated how?
- 1:28What are the hurdles? There are quantitative hurdles,
- 1:31definitely just the first filter really for a new company trying
- 1:34to get in the market cap requirement is significant.
- 1:36As of mid 2025, it was over $22.7 billion.
- 1:41OK. Big companies, but you said
- 1:42that's just the start. Yeah, the real gatekeepers, the
- 1:45one that often causes the most debate.
- 1:46Is financial viability profitable?
- 1:48Oh, the profit rule. This is quickly this.
- 1:50Is what keeps some of those fast growing, maybe not yet
- 1:53profitable tech disruptors outright keeps the index stable.
- 1:56Exactly maintains that established feel.
- 1:59The rule is pretty strict. You need a positive sum of gap
- 2:02earnings. That's generally accepted
- 2:03accounting principles over the most recent 4 consecutive
- 2:06quarters. Four quarters in total.
- 2:08And this is crucial. You also need positive gap
- 2:11earnings in the single most recent quarter.
- 2:13So sustained profitability plus recent positive performance.
- 2:18It shows the company isn't just large, but financially mature.
- 2:22OK, numbers hurdles cleared. But then there's the committee.
- 2:26This is where the art comes in. This is where it gets really
- 2:28interesting. Yeah, you got the US index
- 2:30committee, 10 full time S&P global employees.
- 2:34They have discretion. They move beyond just the
- 2:36numbers. What's their main goal then, if
- 2:38not just size and profit? Their mandate is sector balance.
- 2:42They use the GIC S system, the global industry classification
- 2:45standard, to make sure that the S&P 500 actually mirrors the US
- 2:49economy across different industries.
- 2:51So a huge, profitable company could meet all the criteria, but
- 2:56the committee might still say no.
- 2:57Absolutely. If, say, the technology sector
- 3:00is already heavily weighted in the index, they might pass over
- 3:03a qualifying tech company. Even a big one.
- 3:05Even a big one. They might instead choose a
- 3:08smaller, eligible company from an underrepresented sector like
- 3:12industrials or utilities to maintain that balance.
- 3:15That's the human judgement, the curation.
- 3:17That really does make it feel more like a managed portfolio
- 3:20than just. A list, it essentially is and
- 3:22once a company is in its influence is determined by its
- 3:25float adjusted market capitalization, OK.
- 3:27Break that down. Float adjusted Market cap
- 3:30weighted. It just means they only count
- 3:32the shares that are actually available for public trading the
- 3:35float. They don't count shares held
- 3:37tightly by insiders or governments that aren't really
- 3:40trading. So it reflects the tradable
- 3:42size. Exactly.
- 3:43It prevents the index weight from being skewed by locked up
- 3:46shares, and it means the giants, your Microsoft's, your Nvidia's,
- 3:49have the biggest impact based on their actual market presence.
- 3:52Got it. OK.
- 3:53So S&P 500 size, profit, sector balance, committee discretion.
- 3:58Now let's contrast that with the NASDAQ 100.
- 4:00You called it the science. How does that engine work?
- 4:02It's built differently from the ground up, much more
- 4:04transparent, much more quantitative.
- 4:07The first big rule is exclusivity.
- 4:09To be in the NASDAQ 100, your primary U.S. stock listing must
- 4:13be on the NASDAQ Stock Market. Period.
- 4:16So right off the bat, any company listed primarily on the
- 4:19NYSE is out. Correct.
- 4:21Doesn't matter how big or innovative they are, if they're
- 4:23NYSE listed, they're not eligible for the NASDAQ 100.
- 4:26And there are sector exclusions too, aren't there?
- 4:28Yes, very explicit ones. The index aims to capture modern
- 4:32industry innovation growth, so it's specifically excludes
- 4:36companies in the financial industry.
- 4:38Think big banks, brokers, insurance companies, REITs, real
- 4:42estate investment trusts are also out.
- 4:44Keeping the focus tight on tech, consumer healthcare, industrial
- 4:48innovators. Pretty much.
- 4:49But the absolute core difference, the philosophical
- 4:51split from the S&P 500, is the lack of any profitability
- 4:54requirement. None at all.
- 4:56That seems bold. Doesn't that make it riskier?
- 4:58It makes it different. The index isn't aiming for the S
- 5:01and PS definition of stability. It's aiming to capture large,
- 5:05dynamic, often disruptive companies.
- 5:08These companies might be investing heavily in growth,
- 5:10pushing off profitability for later.
- 5:12So what do they need besides being on the NASDAQ?
- 5:14Size mainly, and liquidity. They need a three month average
- 5:18daily traded value of at least $5,000,000, showing there's real
- 5:22market interest. Pass the lifting filter, the
- 5:24sector filter, meet the size and liquidity tests, and you're
- 5:27likely in no need for four quarters of GAAP profit.
- 5:30OK. So it lets in potentially
- 5:32unprofitable growth giants. How do they manage the weighting
- 5:35then? Is it just pure market cap?
- 5:37It's modified market cap weighted.
- 5:39They recognize that letting and purely growth focus companies
- 5:42could lead to concentration risk.
- 5:43Meaning a few huge winners could dominate the index.
- 5:46Exactly. So they built in risk management
- 5:48caps. No single company could be more
- 5:50than 24% of the index. And perhaps more importantly,
- 5:53there's a group cap. All the companies that
- 5:55individually weigh more than 4.5 percent, their combined weight
- 5:59can't exceed 48%. Right.
- 6:01And that rule actually got triggered, didn't it?
- 6:03Fairly recently? It did.
- 6:05Perfect example, July 2023 we had the huge rally in a handful
- 6:10of the mega cap tech stocks A. Magnificent 7 effect.
- 6:13Precisely. Their combined weight blew past
- 6:15that 48% ceiling, so NASDAQ had to perform what they called a
- 6:19special rebalance outside the normal schedule purely to bring
- 6:23those weights back into compliance with their own rules
- 6:25from the giants. Spread the influence.
- 6:27Pure mechanics. That mechanical nature, the
- 6:30index, has to buy or sell based on the rules.
- 6:33That's what fuels the index effect, right?
- 6:35When a company gets added, passive funds have to buy it.
- 6:38Trillions of dollars have to move.
- 6:39That's the core dynamic. And for years, getting into the
- 6:42S&P 500 because of this effect was seen as, like the ultimate
- 6:46validation, a golden ticket. But you mentioned earlier that
- 6:49this S&P effect, it's not what it used to be.
- 6:52It's really faded. It's fascinating how market
- 6:54efficiency works. Back in the 80's, the 90s
- 6:56research showed a clear certification effect.
- 6:59Getting the S&P nod meant an abnormal return of maybe 3% to
- 7:028%. Seen as a stamp of approval from
- 7:04the experts on the committee. Right.
- 7:06The market saw it as S&P saying this company is solid, stable,
- 7:09important. But Fast forward to research
- 7:12post 2010, that premium is basically vanished.
- 7:16Vanish. Why?
- 7:18Well, a couple of reasons. Markets are just faster, more
- 7:21efficient arbitragers. Hedge funds.
- 7:24They're incredibly good at predicting who's likely to meet
- 7:26the S&P criteria before the announcement.
- 7:28They front run the news. Exactly.
- 7:30They buy the stock before the official inclusion, so the price
- 7:33bump, if any, happens earlier and is much smaller.
- 7:36By the time S&P actually confirms it, the surprise
- 7:39element is gone. And it also turns out the
- 7:40companies getting added were already winners anyway.
- 7:43That's the other key finding. The companies being added often
- 7:45showed massive market cap gains like 56% and huge earnings
- 7:49growth, 57% EPS increase before they even got the call.
- 7:52So the inclusion isn't causing the great performance.
- 7:55It's more like acknowledging performance that was already
- 7:57happening, existing momentum. OK.
- 7:59So the S&P certification pop is mostly gone.
- 8:02How does the NASDAQ 100 effect compare?
- 8:04No committee, so no certification, right?
- 8:07Right. And that's why the benefit seems
- 8:09different, maybe more structural, more durable.
- 8:12Because NASDAQ inclusion is just rules based.
- 8:15The market doesn't interpret as some qualitative judgement, it's
- 8:18just confirmation of size and listing venue.
- 8:21So what is the benefit then? The primary benefit seems to be
- 8:24a powerful liquidity effect. When a stock joins the NASDAQ
- 8:28100, it's trading volume tends to increase significantly.
- 8:32Bid ask spreads often tighten. Meaning it becomes cheaper to
- 8:36trade the stock. Yes, lower transaction costs for
- 8:38everyone, and you also see a durable increase in Wall Street
- 8:41analyst coverage, more institutional attention.
- 8:45It's less about prestige and more about becoming deeply
- 8:48embedded in the global investment plumbing.
- 8:50Better liquidity, better visibility.
- 8:52Let's make this concrete. Let's look at some real
- 8:53companies on the watch list. This really shows how getting
- 8:56into these indices can be a major strategic goal.
- 8:59Palantir PLTR. It's a fantastic case study
- 9:01here. They navigated both rule books
- 9:03very deliberately. Now, so for the S&P 500.
- 9:06For the S&P, Palantir easily met the size and liquidity rules for
- 9:09a while, but they were stuck outside.
- 9:12Because of that financial viability rule.
- 9:14They needed four straight quarters of positive gap
- 9:17earnings. The profitability hurdle.
- 9:19Exactly once they finally achieved that, reported that 4th
- 9:21consecutive profitable quarter, their inclusion in September
- 9:252024 became almost inevitable, assuming the committee saw
- 9:28sector fit. OK, so profit was the S&P key.
- 9:32What about the NASDAQ 100? Completely different story.
- 9:34Their inclusion in December 2023 wasn't about profit.
- 9:38It happened almost immediately after they made a purely
- 9:40strategic move. They transferred their primary
- 9:43stock listing from the NYSE to the NASDAQ exchange.
- 9:47Taking that exclusivity box. Precisely.
- 9:49They knew their size qualified them.
- 9:51The only thing holding them back was the NYSE listing.
- 9:54They switched exchanges specifically to meet that NASDAQ
- 9:56100 rule. Textbook strategic move to gain
- 9:59index inclusion. Fascinating.
- 10:01OK, looking ahead, who else is testing these boundaries?
- 10:03The Trade Desk, TTD. Yeah.
- 10:04TTD looks like a strong S&P 500 contender.
- 10:08Big influential company in digital advertising, but like
- 10:11Palantir, it hinges on them maintaining sustained
- 10:14profitability to meet that Jap rule.
- 10:16And, of course, how the committee views the tech ad
- 10:18sector's current weighting. Then you've got the crypto
- 10:20related names, Coinbase, Koi, yen.
- 10:23Now that's where it gets really interesting.
- 10:24Coinbase is definitely large enough for both indices, but the
- 10:29S&P 500 path is tricky. Why?
- 10:31Because its profits are super volatile, tied directly to
- 10:34crypto trading booms and busts, kneeling 4 consecutive positive
- 10:37gap quarters can be tough. Right.
- 10:39Depends entirely on the crypto market cycle.
- 10:41But for the NASDAQ 100, profitability doesn't matter.
- 10:45If it meets the size, liquidity, and NASDAQ listing requirements,
- 10:48its inclusion would be a huge moment, kind of a mainstream
- 10:50validation for the digital asset space within a major index.
- 10:53And what about MicroStrategy MSTR?
- 10:56They're huge Bitcoin holders. Also highly ranked by market cap
- 10:59among NASDAQ eligible companies. No profitability requirement to
- 11:03worry about there. If MSTR gets included, index
- 11:07funds tracking the NASDAQ 100 would suddenly have significant
- 11:10indirect exposure to bitcoins price swings.
- 11:12Because so much of Microstrategy's value is tied to
- 11:15its Bitcoin stack. Exactly.
- 11:16It raises really interesting questions about what constitutes
- 11:19a tech or growth company in the modern era.
- 11:22So wrapping this up, what's the big take away?
- 11:24S&P 500 versus NASDAQ 100. I think it boils down to this.
- 11:28The S&P 500, with its committee and profit rules, remains the
- 11:32benchmark for established, stable, financially viable
- 11:35companies across the broad economy.
- 11:37It values consistency the. Art of curated stability.
- 11:40Right, whereas the NASDAQ 100 is the indicator for large scale
- 11:43dynamic growth. It prioritizes size, liquidity
- 11:46and being listed on NASDAQ explicitly accepting companies
- 11:49that might still be investing heavily rather than showing
- 11:52consistent profits. The science of growth capture.
- 11:55And that central tension we discussed, objective rules
- 11:58versus subjective judgement, is always in play, especially with
- 12:01the S&P committee. But the effects of getting
- 12:03chosen are changing. Definitely.
- 12:06Market efficiency seems to have largely killed that old S&P
- 12:09stamp approval price pop. The enduring benefit now for
- 12:13inclusion in either index looks more like that structural
- 12:16improvement. Better liquidity, tighter
- 12:18spreads, more visibility. So a final thought for our
- 12:22listeners to chew on well. Think about those potential
- 12:24digital asset additions, Coinbase, MicroStrategy.
- 12:28Their possible inclusion forces us to ask how much exposure to a
- 12:32completely new and, let's face it, volatile asset class like
- 12:35crypto should these traditional benchmarks take on.
- 12:37Before they fundamentally change what they even represent.
- 12:39Exactly at what point is embracing the new economy risk
- 12:43altering the core identity of indices designed to track
- 12:45established American Enterprise? That evolution is definitely
- 12:48something worth watching closely.