Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Is This Gaslighting? (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto, what is gaslighting? What is the definition of gaslighting? According
- 0:06to Umberto Costagnetta, it is basically where you are you're using deceptive tactics to
- 0:13try to convince someone of something that's factually not true, and yet by doing
- 0:19so, you do it so much and you keep you're keeping characters, so
- 0:23to speak, that the other person actually starts like second guessing their own reality.
- 0:28Yeah, it's a good definition. So we get a lot of emails
- 0:32about this, a lot of questions, and a lot of people are using
- 0:35the word on the internet these days. So I asked people to submit their
- 0:41stories of gaslighting. We received a lot of We received a lot of submissions,
- 0:46and I thought we would read a sampling of those and find out how
- 0:51people are using the term. So in this episode, I want to define
- 0:56the term and also want to discuss related topics, related concepts, concepts that
- 1:03perhaps might be more apt. When people are describing situations where they might use
- 1:07the word gaslighting, there might be a more accurate, precise word to describe
- 1:12what they're going through. Maybe gaslighting is also changing over time. I don't
- 1:18know, But the main thing that I want to do in today's episode is
- 1:23try to learn how people are using it, and also validate people's experience,
- 1:27because if you're ever using the term gaslighting, as in that person gaslit me,
- 1:34in all likelihood that person harmed you, and it felt bad and it
- 1:41was perhaps even immoral what was done to you, and so you deserve validation
- 1:46regardless of what word one uses to describe it. Also, major trigger warning.
- 1:53We are going to be talking about gaslighting and anything related to it,
- 1:57so make sure that you take care of yourself and maybe not listen if you
- 2:01might be triggered. This is the Psychologist How a podcast. I'm your host,
- 2:06doctor Kirkanda. I'm a licensed therapist and I'm also a professor. Who
- 2:08are you brut? My name is and I'm an unlicensed computer keyboard operator.
- 2:14So the origin, as you mentioned, comes from a movie, but it
- 2:19actually goes back to a play, a British play called Gaslight nineteen thirty eight,
- 2:23American Hollywood films adapted to play in nineteen forty nineteen forty four. You
- 2:31know, people talk about how movies today, how they're always doing, you
- 2:35know, they can't come up with a new idea. Well, literally,
- 2:37in nineteen forty there was a name, there was a movie called Gaslight,
- 2:39and four years later there was the same movie based on the same play called
- 2:44same name name. So Hollywood's been doing this for a long time. And
- 2:49essentially, in this play slash movie, a man goes on a campaign to
- 2:53make a woman believe that she's losing her mind so I so he can get
- 2:59her jewel us or something. He somehow finds out that she has a bunch
- 3:02of money in the house and he can't find it, and so he slowly
- 3:07tries to make her believe that she is losing her mind by moving the couch
- 3:13ten inches or moving this and that, and when she walks in the room,
- 3:17she's like, why is the couch over there? And he's like,
- 3:20I don't know what you're talking about, and just over and over and over
- 3:23again. Spoiler alert. It doesn't work in the end, and the evil
- 3:25man is caught happy ending everyone. And in the nineteen seventies the term gas
- 3:32lighting started to show up in the psychoanalytic literature, and then in the last
- 3:38couple of years it started showing up a lot online. For example, Berto,
- 3:42you and I did an episode on gas lighting four years ago, and
- 3:46I recently listened back to it, and I asked you at the beginning if
- 3:50you'd ever heard of the term gaslighting, and you were being honest by saying
- 3:54you had never heard of it before. I don't. Yeah, I think
- 3:58that's about right. It was four years ago. I wonder what happened four
- 4:01years ago in our culture, in our society where that started happening a lot
- 4:05and people started using the term. Yeah. Kind of hard to know,
- 4:10totally hard, impossible, really, all right, So let's go into the
- 4:14definition here more descriptively. It's a verb to gaslight. The main definition is
- 4:20to purposely manipulate someone by psychological means to make them question their own memory,
- 4:28perception, judgment, or sanity. So this is as you describe Burdo earlier,
- 4:33and as in the movies in the play, this isn't trying to get
- 4:38someone to change their mind on one issue. This is trying to get someone
- 4:41and it isn't trying to convince someone of something. This is trying to get
- 4:45someone to, in general, almost arbitrarily in some instances, to get some
- 4:50you know, through arbitrary means, like moving a couch. You don't really
- 4:54care about moving the couch. You're trying to get someone to question their own
- 5:00sanity, judgment, memory, perception in general, not just about this one
- 5:05issue, but in general. You're trying to make someone believe that they don't
- 5:09have the ability to determine fact from fiction, right from wrong, reel from
- 5:13unreal. It's purposeful, it's manipulative, and they use psychological means, meaning
- 5:19that you know, you don't beat someone over the head with a bat to
- 5:23convince them of something. You use these very very machiavellian, very premeditated in
- 5:29the classic sense of the definition. Now the word might be evolving in recent
- 5:33years, so we can get into it, but in terms of how it
- 5:36had been used for so long, this is the definition. This is the
- 5:40definition that still is in the clinical literature. Another way to look at this
- 5:46is to gradually undermine the victim's confidence in their ability to distinguish fact from fiction,
- 5:50right from wrong, real from unreal, with the purpose of making the
- 5:54victim not only believe that they don't understand how to evaluate reality, but also
- 6:00to make them dependent and subservient to the gaslighter. So it's pretty specific,
- 6:06right, because it's based on a very specific situation in the movie and play
- 6:11Gaslight, and up until four or five years ago, this is how it
- 6:16was typically used. That I would see a campaign machiavellian premeditated trying to make
- 6:24someone question their judgment in general, to make the person dependent on and subservient
- 6:30to the gaslighter. Usually it was used in a clinical literature, in domestic
- 6:34violence intimate partner violence literature, which we'll get into later. And by the
- 6:39way, trigger ler on that. Now. By the way, it can
- 6:42be successful or unsuccessful to gaslight. So if someone tries to gaslight, like
- 6:47in the play in the movie The Dude, the evil guy tried to gaslight
- 6:54the woman, but it didn't work, And you wouldn't say that he didn't
- 6:57actually gaslight He just failed at gaslighting her, you know what I mean?
- 7:01Yeah, yeah, right, he was doing it. It's like it's like
- 7:05I guess it'd be attempted murder versus murder, you know, right, well,
- 7:12or even because for a while she was no. Well, so let
- 7:15me well, and I don't committed gaslighting. He committed gaslighting, right,
- 7:19So say I tried to gaslight you, and right from the beginning, you
- 7:24know that I am trying to gaslight you. You're still committing gaslighting. I'm
- 7:29still gaslighting, right, Yeah, I've still committed the gaslight verb. Yeah,
- 7:33it's like you're you're not not lying just because I didn't believe you exactly
- 7:38exactly. I was thinking more of like if if the goal was to ultimately
- 7:42drive the person in saying, you happen to have failed at your goal,
- 7:45but doesn't mean you didn't try right exactly. So, Now, as I
- 7:49said earlier, almost always gaslighting is in the context of an abusive relationship.
- 7:56A dominant partner is trying to gain control over their partner through various message through
- 8:01various methods. They will isolate the victim, they will physically abuse the victim
- 8:07usually as well, or intimidate, they'll put them down with name calling,
- 8:11they'll make the victim dependent on the perpetrator, and they will also gaslight the
- 8:16victim. So gaslighting is usually a part of an array of tactics, if
- 8:22you will, that will keep a victim powerless and subservient underneath the abuser.
- 8:31So that that's usually what we're talking about when we're talking about gaslighting, right
- 8:37in the same way that if you talked about name calling, for example,
- 8:43well, there's just name calling, like someone on the street calls you a
- 8:46name, and then there's name calling within a domestic violence or intimate partner violence
- 8:50relationship, where the name calling is part of a system to gain control and
- 8:58to put someone down. Gaslighting is the same way. Right. So now
- 9:05this often results in, according to our observations of humans, when you abuse
- 9:11people and gaslight people, that the victims will feel like they're going crazy.
- 9:16They'll feel like, am I losing my mind? I feel like I knew
- 9:22once how to judge the world, and now do I know? Am I?
- 9:26Am I going crazy? Did I forget that? Like? I swear
- 9:31that's what happened, But the other person seemed to really be convinced this other
- 9:35thing happened. And maybe I'm not good And we'll get into that later when
- 9:39we talk about the descriptions from people that people submitted low self esteem in general,
- 9:45just feeling like you aren't a smart, good person, subservience, confusion,
- 9:52anxiety, and depression. So mental illness, mental disorders of anxiety will
- 9:58develop under these circumstances. Depression, learned, helplessness, even psychosis can develop
- 10:05as your grasp on reality gets more and more taken away from you. You
- 10:09can even develop delusional symptoms. Okay, So in light of that definition,
- 10:18as we go forward. I want to develop the following checklist burto and you
- 10:22tell me if this makes sense to you. So gaslighting needs to have the
- 10:30following six elements. Generally speaking, One the gaslighter needs to be trying to
- 10:35get someone to question their judgment. Two, they're trying to get them to
- 10:41question their judgment in general, not just on one issue. They're being manipulative,
- 10:48meaning they're machiavellian. They're premeditatively trying to get someone you know it's and
- 10:56then number four is it's purposeful, meaning that it's not accidental or impulsive or
- 11:03something. And number five it's for personal gain. So it's not something that
- 11:09someone's doing for no reason, even if it doesn't make a lot of sense,
- 11:15but it feels to the victimizer as personal game. And number six is
- 11:18that And this is more of just kind of a guideline. It's almost always
- 11:22in the presence of an abusive relationship in general, that's not really a criteria,
- 11:28but that's something to think about. Like usually when we're talking about gaslighting,
- 11:33we're talking about abusive relationship, not always, and certainly the language is
- 11:35changing, and again we'll get into that in a bit. Or and or
- 11:43is it the following six things, which will define which is motivated reasoning,
- 11:48shamelining, mental illness, the Martha Mitchell effect, creeping normalcy, or Stockholm
- 11:52syndrome, which will define in a second so as when we read the stories
- 11:56from the submitters will evaluate those six criteria and or is it one of these
- 12:03other steps. I see what you're saying, Like, if it fits the
- 12:07six criteria, you're saying that's gaslighting. But if it doesn't, it might
- 12:11be one of these other related variants, right, related concepts, more precise
- 12:16concepts, And it could also be both. You could have someone both be
- 12:22gaslighting and have Stockholm symptom involved. But anyway, so burto tell me,
- 12:30is this gas lighting? Let's let's I'm gonna give a pistory example. Did
- 12:35you say history, Yeah, so I guess it is kind of pistory because
- 12:41it is psychology in Seattle history that five years or four years ago, I
- 12:45did an episode called sexism and Christine Collins. So there's a movie. In
- 12:50two thousand and eight, Clint Eastwood directed the film called Changeling. It's a
- 12:54terrible name for a movie. I mean, when you think of a movie
- 12:56called Changeling, what do you think it sounds good. It sounds like I'd
- 13:00be into. It's like a horror movie, kind of sci fi horror.
- 13:03This creature has landed and it's like alien or something. Yeah, and it
- 13:07can change into different people and you know, yeah, no, it is
- 13:11a historical drama. Angelina Jolie plays a woman in the nineteen twenties. So
- 13:18let me tell you the story and then remember this movie is called Changeling.
- 13:22Okay, So a real story about a woman named Christine Collins played by Angelina
- 13:28Jolie. Her nine year old son went missing in nineteen twenty eight and it
- 13:33made national headlines and the police found a boy who claimed to be like months
- 13:39later, who claimed to be her son, and it was a big deal
- 13:43because everyone thought the kid, the boy was dead. You know, it's
- 13:45like it's been months, he must be gone forever. You know, it's
- 13:48a big deal. So they found a boy who claimed to be her son,
- 13:52and so they and they had this big media event and the boy gets
- 13:58off the train and Christine Allen is like desperate, like, oh my god,
- 14:01my son. She immediately sees him and says and in her head she
- 14:07says, that's not my son, and she goes to the police. Officer's
- 14:09like, uh, that's not my son, but all and how much time
- 14:13had come by months? Okay, so it's not like years where she wouldn't
- 14:18recognize her own son, right, but then it be but enough time where
- 14:22maybe right, but you know it'd be hard, you know. And incidentally,
- 14:30the boy was like years older than oh my gosh, than the other
- 14:33boy than the real boy. Anyway, So the press is there and it's
- 14:39a big moment. Yeah, it's a big moment. And the police long
- 14:41story short, essentially pressure her. There's like, just take him home.
- 14:46You're probably just hysterical. It's it's probably him, don't don't make a scene.
- 14:52And she's like, okay, so she probably him. Oh yeah,
- 14:56So they bring him. So they because the police don't care, you know,
- 15:00they don't care about the actual case. They just want this woman to
- 15:05shut up, and they want a success, you know, they want to
- 15:07be on in the press as succeeding. So she goes home because you know,
- 15:13if you think sexism is bad today, think about nineteen twenty eight.
- 15:16So they they send her home and uh, you know, she comes immediately
- 15:22back. She's like, okay, now the cameras are away, it's not
- 15:24my son. He's I have a boy living in my house who's claiming to
- 15:28be my son. It's not him. I know it's not him. And
- 15:33they're like, are you sure. I mean, it's kind of been a
- 15:35long time. She's like, no, it's not my son, and der
- 15:39well, I don't know. I mean, maybe what is the son saying?
- 15:43Is the son saying like I'm your son? Yeah? Because he is
- 15:46on some kind of weird he eventually reported he was trying to meet a movie
- 15:52star because in Los Angeles. Yeah, he was trying to meet a movie
- 15:58star and he wanted to go west to meet his famous movie star in in
- 16:04California, and so he just said that to get free passage or something.
- 16:10But anyway, so he's this little psychopath in some ways, and she's freaked
- 16:14out by it. She goes to the police and this goes on for a
- 16:17long time. I don't know how long, but it goes on for a
- 16:18long time, and eventually get this brito. They commit her to a psychiatric
- 16:26ward, saying God saying that she has lost her mind. Oh my god.
- 16:33Yeah, that's so infuriating. No, this can't be a real story.
- 16:37This is like a good plot for Hollywood. So why in the world
- 16:41do you think they called it changeling? Why would clinics would call this movie
- 16:44changeling? I mean because maybe the boy changed. Yeah, the boy changed,
- 16:48yeah, but different. The boy is almost has nothing to do with
- 16:52it. It's mainly Angelina Jolie and her fight against sexism in the society.
- 16:59But anyway, I did a whole episode on this four years ago to talk
- 17:03about sexism. Is this gas lighting Burdoh? Yeah, I mean so,
- 17:11okay, it's not one person, although the boy. You could argue the
- 17:14boy absolutely gaslight But okay, based on your definition, I suppose that the
- 17:21intent probably wasn't to drive this person mad. There was ill intent. So
- 17:26let's go through the criteria again for trying to get someone to question their judgment
- 17:30and then two in general. Yeah, well, okay, that one's a
- 17:36little iffy. I think it's in the boy's best interest to get her to
- 17:40question her judgment, maybe in general, because then she'll maybe acquiesce this crazy
- 17:45notion too. Is it manipulative? Yes, absolutely, by both the cops
- 17:49and the kid. Yeah, because they both basically knew. The cops were
- 17:53pretty immediately thinking maybe we made a mistake. Is it purposeful? Was it
- 17:59on purpose? It is on purpose to lie to her. What's not on
- 18:03purpose? Again? Is I don't think they were like, Okay, let's
- 18:06turn this lady into an insane person. But it's purposeful, and that it's
- 18:10purposeful, they know they're lying, you know, Yes, yes? Is
- 18:12it for personal gain? Yes? For the boy it is, and for
- 18:15the cops it is because they wanted the case closed. Yeah. And then
- 18:18six, it's not necessarily a part of abusive relationship unless you count sexism that
- 18:23you could. Is it motivated reason? Well, we get into that later.
- 18:27But okay, so now is this a classic gas lighting scenario. No,
- 18:33because it doesn't involve an abusive relationship. But you could make a case
- 18:38that they were trying the boy and the power structure. We're trying to get
- 18:42her to question her judgment, to accept the boy as her son and move
- 18:48on with her life. So everyone, so other people win, The cops
- 18:52win, the boy wins, and she kind of wins maybe in their mind
- 18:56because she gets her quote unquote boy back right. Well, and if if
- 19:00you know, if you had called the movie gas boy, I'd be totally
- 19:03fine with it. Yeah, they should have called it gas boy. Um
- 19:07okay, So let's talk about different sorts of other, you know, other
- 19:14concepts that are related to gaslighting. First off, let's talk about some some
- 19:18synonyms. So mind games or head games are synonyms for gaslighting. Maybe on
- 19:25a smaller scale people might use those that person's playing mind games with me,
- 19:30or maybe a more maybe gaslighting is a form of a mind game or something.
- 19:36There's also crazy making, which is a synonym for gaslighting. Sometimes you
- 19:42can interchange crazy making with gaslighting. But it's also used in situations that make
- 19:48you like when you like, situations that make you second guess your judgment,
- 19:55like, um, have you know, have you ever been like you sign
- 20:00up for a website or something like I don't know, like some kind of
- 20:03web service and you try to cancel this the subscrit like Netflix or something.
- 20:08You try to cancel it and you cannot find the button for how to cancel
- 20:14it. Has that around that that feels crazy making because you keep thinking it's
- 20:18got to be somewhere, what's wrong with me? You know. The way
- 20:23they lay they do it masterfully, the way they lay it out, they
- 20:26make you think it's your fault for not finding the button you know what I
- 20:30mean, and then if you email them, they're like, it's it's on
- 20:33the website, and then you're you're thinking, what's wrong with me? And
- 20:37so it's crazy making because you start to question whether or not you're smart enough
- 20:42to even do it, so that the situation is set up to essentially make
- 20:48you feel like you're quote unquote crazy. Another concept is memory manipulation, which
- 20:52is perhaps a sub category of gaslighting, where you're trying to change someone's memory,
- 21:00but it's also broader than gas lighting in that well meaning therapist in the
- 21:03past and in the current will insert memories into their client's minds. You've heard
- 21:08of this, right, Berto, as I've heard about this idea. I
- 21:12haven't heard of cases where it worked or something like that, but certainly the
- 21:17like with making a murderer you remember with the brother sure yeah, in something
- 21:23yeah, And we even talked about this in the case of the kid,
- 21:26the cases where the kids were asked if they had been touched inappropriately in daycare
- 21:32in California and then slowly but surely they were told, well, are you
- 21:36sure you didn't, and then eventually like, yeah, yess I did exactly.
- 21:40Well meaning therapists perhaps will will manipulate memory in clients, and that's you
- 21:48could say is related to gas lighting kind of but not really right, it's
- 21:52it's it's different. Okay, So now let's talk about concepts that aren't really
- 21:56related to gaslighting but can be confused for it. So creeping normality, what
- 22:03do you think that means? Burto creeping normality? That's the what's that the
- 22:07Overton window or something like that's the basically if you get boiled alive like a
- 22:12frog, right, if you if you shift what's normal a little bit,
- 22:18and then people are like, well, that's weird. But then enough time
- 22:19goes by, you're like, well, I guess that's life. And then
- 22:22you shift it again. Well that's not okay, but I guess we're gonna
- 22:26have to deal with it. If you did it all at once, went
- 22:29from zero to sixty, everyone would rebel, the world would collapse. But
- 22:32you do it a little bit out of time, and then then you look
- 22:33back and all of a sudden you're like, what the hell are we doing?
- 22:37And no one can tell how we got to where we were. Right.
- 22:41This is also called gradualism or landscape amnesia. What's an example of this
- 22:47in our lives today. Well, this is I wrote a song. One
- 22:49of the songs I wrote for that concert where I opened for you a couple
- 22:53of years ago, was called Granny, which means frog and French, I
- 22:59think, and it was about us getting boiled like frogs, and it's about
- 23:03global warming in my case. In that sense, it's that a little bit
- 23:08by little bit, we're like, oh, yeah, that's weird. We
- 23:11had another smoky season this year. Well, man, that's weird. And
- 23:15then the next year it's like, yeah, oh there's no more snow and
- 23:18mountaineer, Oh, that's that's weird. Oh they just like I just saw
- 23:22a thing. All the kelp died and like I was like, oh that
- 23:25that's weird. And slowly but surely our world collapses before our eyes. But
- 23:29we're like a little bit by a little bit getting okay with it right.
- 23:33Also loss of privacy. I remember when the Internet first started to ask you
- 23:38questions about yourself, like could you give us your your credit card? The
- 23:44vast majority of people said, never ever put your credit card on the internet.
- 23:49And now people, just including myself, just throw it around, you
- 23:55know, Venmo and all sorts of things. Do you want me to remember
- 23:57your cared. Yes, absolutely, remember I don't I ever type my numbering
- 24:00it? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Some of us we just don't even
- 24:04want to read. We don't even remember. It's like, yes, computer
- 24:07and the internet, please remember it for me? Well yeah, but that
- 24:11but that's even that's just credit card. I mean, talk about cookies and
- 24:18monitoring and your home listening device that you you literally have a listening device in
- 24:22your house that is issued by a major corporation that's trying to market to you,
- 24:30and we just do it willingly. It's fine, you know. Now,
- 24:33is it bad or good? I don't know, but I do know
- 24:36that if you would have asked people twenty years ago to have one of those,
- 24:41you know, pucks or whatever, no one would have bought them.
- 24:45They would have thought that's absurd. There's just no possible way that would anyone.
- 24:49Whatever. But again, little by little, over twenty years, we
- 24:55lose a little privacy here, we hand over our privacy here, we do
- 24:59a little bit more here, and before long you're just like, yeah,
- 25:00what's the big deal. It's a good or bad I don't know. But
- 25:03that's what we call creeping normalcy. Another is mass shootings the United States yea,
- 25:08they become normal and we all understand that that so normal that we don't
- 25:11even report them. They're happening. They're still happening, by the way,
- 25:15They're happening almost every day or so. I don't know this frequency, but
- 25:19it was just a yeah, terrible spree against Asian community, right, and
- 25:26that one got into the news because of I don't even know. I guess
- 25:30because there's Asians or they're the number or something. I don't know, but
- 25:33mass shootings are happening all the time, and ten years ago, any one
- 25:37of those would have been strange enough that it would have been you know,
- 25:41top news for a month. But now it's like, yeah, you know,
- 25:44it's normal. Now, it's just it's just a part of our lives.
- 25:48Okay. So that's creeping normalcy. What you could see, how that's
- 25:52similar to gas lighting. So brainwashing, what's brainwashing definition brutal? I mean
- 25:57that one is similar to what you know you would do in it or it's
- 26:03kind of like what you were doing a cult where you would bring people in
- 26:06and then essentially convince them a total different reality about the world and their relationships
- 26:14and what they should prioritize and so forth. But usually usually you're not trying
- 26:18to drive them insane. You're actually trying to get them on your side and
- 26:22give you money, or just stay in your system, or live in your
- 26:26commune, or or maybe go commit suicide and mass or go kill a whole
- 26:30bunch of people. Whatever. But the goal isn't necessarily insanity normally, you
- 26:36know, normally, it's like it is control and you are deceiving. You're
- 26:40doing all those things, but with a different name. Yeah, it's very
- 26:44similar to gas slighting, and you could use them interchangeably in some situations.
- 26:52For example, with cults. You mentioned there's a lot there's you could you
- 26:56know, use this brainwashing tournament in a lot of cults, saying that,
- 27:00you know, just slowly isolating someone and saying this is the son of God.
- 27:07He does deserve to take your wife, he does deserve to take your
- 27:14money, you know, just slowly. Again, creeping normalcy in there a
- 27:17little bit too, as a way of getting control and dominance, but it
- 27:22doesn't have that element of trying to make the person question their judgment. In
- 27:26general, but you might use gaslighting to brainwash someone, but you don't have
- 27:32to use gaslighting to brainwash someone. The Manchurian candidate. The movie. Also,
- 27:38Patty Hurst is an example sometimes that people use for having been brainwashed.
- 27:45If you're not familiar with that story. I think there's a movie coming out
- 27:48about her. There's been other movies, but nineteen seventy four, member of
- 27:52a wealthy Hurst family and she was kidnapped by the Symbionese Liberation Army. I
- 27:57left wing militant organization basically a terrorist. You could say organization in the United
- 28:03States. I guess if you're a sympathetic you would just say left wing organization
- 28:07after a while. So she was kidnapped and they were going to use her
- 28:11for ransom. And after a while she joined the group and she believed in
- 28:17their cause and she didn't try to escape, and she even participated in the
- 28:21crimes like robbing a bank. And she was arrested and charged and she said,
- 28:27I'm a part of the I'm a part of this army. I'm a
- 28:30part of this group. When they know a confrontitor. She didn't say I
- 28:36was only doing it because people were you know, they've threatened to kill me.
- 28:40I mean, all she'd have to say is say that, and she
- 28:41would have been scott free. But she refused because she believed in the cause
- 28:45at this point and again rewind the clock. She's just a regular girl,
- 28:51rich girl, and she gets kidnapped and held at knife point and gunpoint for
- 28:56many weeks, and eventually she starts to believe it. So the defense was
- 29:00that she was brainwashed. The defense did not work. She was sentenced thirty
- 29:04five years until president until President Carter commuted or sentenced to the twenty two months
- 29:10served. Is this brainwashing, Burdo? I mean, we don't know the
- 29:14details obviously, but could be. I mean I would so it sounds like
- 29:18it. I would think it's like, you know, Stockholm syndrome, a
- 29:21bit like gaining sympathy for her kidnappers. But I who knows the details,
- 29:27like you said, because you know, you could imagine cases where imagine,
- 29:33you know, I like grew up in Colombia and there were the rebels.
- 29:36The rebels were originally fighting because there was a lot of injustice and a lot
- 29:40of wealth inequality. So imagine you are from a wealthy family, you get
- 29:42kidnapped, and while you're living in this commune, you get to see all
- 29:47the misery that people live in and kind of those disparities and then you start
- 29:51being like, well, yeah, what what the heck is going on?
- 29:52And then you turn to that side. Is that brainwashing? Yeah? Who
- 29:56knows, Like maybe they did apply really strong brain whing tactics all these things,
- 30:00so I could I could see, I could see it being a totally
- 30:03gray, gray area. But it doesn't like I wouldn't say that it's always
- 30:07an open and shut case. If you get kidnapped and then later you're for
- 30:11the thing that kidnapped you, it's always brainwashing that that that could be like
- 30:18saying that anytime you end up being convinced about a cause in any way,
- 30:22it's because of brainwashing. And that's too broad of a definition for my taste.
- 30:26Yeah, it's hard to know. We don't know the ins and outs
- 30:30of the interactions. But in Stockholm syndrome you bring up which actually just move
- 30:36on to that. That's another topic similar to gas lighting. So what's the
- 30:41definition of Stockholm syndrome? Burtle? Yeah, I believe I can't remember.
- 30:45I knew before why it was called Stockholm. I'm sure you'll tell me,
- 30:48But um, it's you get abducted or kidnapped and you end up developing sympathy
- 30:56for your kidnappers for your the people that have you held, and that that
- 31:00results in you actually maybe wanting to stay with them, or wanting to not
- 31:06be rescued, or you know, maybe joining their cause. Yeah exactly.
- 31:10Um I read recently why it's called Stockholm, but I believe that it's because
- 31:15there was a I think a bank robbery or something in Stockholm, and the
- 31:19hostages eventually wanted to um stick up for the bank robbers and you know,
- 31:29hostage takers and actually wouldn't testify against them after even after they were freed,
- 31:34that kind of thing. Yeah. So what percentage according to the FBI of
- 31:41hostage victims show evidence of Stockholm syndrome? Burtom Oh interesting? Five? Oh
- 31:48why do you say thirty? I was thinking maybe it's just the common human
- 31:52response. Well five percent, it's pretty common. And yeah, I think
- 31:56this includes short term and long term hostages. You know what I mean.
- 32:00If you're a hostage for five hours, it's probably not kind to develop.
- 32:02Stop. So do you remember Leeboyd Malvo and John Mohammed, the DC killers
- 32:10ers. Yeah? Yeah, so it's two thousand and two and John Mohammed
- 32:15was the older fella and Leeboid Malvo was. He was sixteen at the time,
- 32:22and they killed a bunch of people at seventeen, I couldn't find how
- 32:25many us is a lot. And they would do those sniper attacks from inside
- 32:30the car. They would yeah, sit in the back and it was a
- 32:36It was a very effective way of getting away with it because they would just
- 32:40wait on the sidewalk and wait for someone to, you know, the person
- 32:44they were trying to kill, and they would shoot them and then they just
- 32:46drive away and anyone seeing it would wouldn't see anyone with a gun, you
- 32:51know what I mean, because they would they had a way of shooting the
- 32:52person actually threw a hole in the back of the car. I think they
- 32:58like kahole in the in the break light or something and shot through that.
- 33:02Anyway, So this when it came to light who was doing this, they're
- 33:07like, okay, you got this this forty I don't know John Mohammed guy
- 33:12and he had this teenage boy and that they both participated in the killings.
- 33:16And again they used the brainwashing defense as they did with Patti Hurst. You
- 33:22could also say Stockholm syndrome. Do you do you think it worked burto So
- 33:28are you saying that was the boy originally kidnapped by him. No, I
- 33:32don't know how they I think they knew each other through family or I don't
- 33:36know. But what do you just based on the little Yeah? I mean
- 33:42it sounds to me like that there's probably some manipulation, you know, I
- 33:47would imagine that the older one like groomed him, which if you will to
- 33:54to join him and participate, which is it's definitely manipulative. It it might
- 34:00be I would call it potentially brainwashing, considering how dramatic the outcome was and
- 34:04how life ruining. Right, the question is, would leeboid malvo the teenager
- 34:09done anything like this? Oh yeah, on his own right? Probably not
- 34:14right? And at what point? So if you had a ten year old,
- 34:19I don't think anyone would fault the ten year old, right, you
- 34:21just be while he's influenced sixteen? What are we saying? That's old enough
- 34:25to data? But the jury did not have it and he's currently serving multiple
- 34:34life sentences. John Mohammed was executed two thousand and nine. Okay, so
- 34:40we've talked about gaslighting. You talked about mind games, which is similar or
- 34:45exactly the same as gaslighting. We've talked about crazy making memory, manipulation,
- 34:49creeping normality, brainwashing, Stockholm syndrome. Now let's talk about things that really
- 34:53aren't related to gaslighting. So I'm gonna tell you a word, borrow,
- 34:58and you tell me the the definition of it. Deception. What is deception?
- 35:06That is lying? Yeah? Right, it's attempting to mislead, You're
- 35:09trying to hide the truth, or you're trying to promote an idea that isn't
- 35:15true, and it's often for personal gain. So this is bad behavior,
- 35:19right, Yeah, Lying is bad, right, Lying is bad, deceivings
- 35:25except in some rare cases, but deception. Lying is bad and harmful and
- 35:30really hurtful. And so I say that because later on we might be saying
- 35:37is this gas lighting or not? Just is this gas lighting or deception?
- 35:43I think that part of my hypothesis is that people feel like if they tweet
- 35:50I'm being deceived, that won't get people to pay any attention. They're like,
- 35:54so what you're being lied to? Who cares? You say you're being
- 35:58gas lit? Now people are going to listen more for whatever reason, because
- 36:02the word is newer, feels more weighty, or something to it, you
- 36:07know. Yeah, I mean I think that's the majority of it. Right,
- 36:09it's there's a new term on the scene, and all of a sudden
- 36:14everyone was dabbing, you know, and so people are now being guestlet left
- 36:19and right and yeah, and language changes over time, and maybe like the
- 36:24word literally, for example, Yeah, when I was growing up, literally
- 36:30meant it literally meant what it meant. It meant that it was the opposite
- 36:36of figuratively. It was a synonym for actually. Right. Yeah, it's
- 36:40like he actually spit in my face, or you know, he literally spitting.
- 36:45I'm not using I'm not saying So that's a great example because if you
- 36:49said actually today actually still means actually. So if you're like I was over
- 36:52at Bardo's and he actually grabbed his guitar and smacked my finger with it,
- 36:58and someone would be like, that's horrible, and you know, I won't,
- 37:00I don't. I don't mean for real, wait what you said actually,
- 37:05right? But if you said literally, like you know, I think
- 37:07people, it leaves some room for interpretation. Now, right, he literally
- 37:10stepped he literally spit in my face. People, it's unclear how they're being
- 37:16how they're using it now. At first, I was like, stop saying
- 37:20that, but every word evolves over time, and I'm an oldie now and
- 37:23I just have to in the same way that when I go to McDonald's or
- 37:28you know, well McDonald's or a place where like I would expect to see
- 37:32certain prices, I'm so I'm always surprised because to me, I grew up
- 37:37where lunch at any fast food restaurant, Subway, McDonald's, you know,
- 37:40a pizza place was definitely under five dollars, Like in my head, five
- 37:46dollars if six dollars is like way too much for lunch at any restaurant,
- 37:52you know. I mean, I remember when I was, you know,
- 37:55working put with my bachelor's degree. I remember going to Taco bell and getting
- 38:01three tacos for a dollar. I would get six tacos for two dollars and
- 38:06it was including tax, so you just gave them two bucks and they gave
- 38:09you, you know, a bag of six tacos, and I was so
- 38:15poor, you know, that's that's all I could eat, right. It
- 38:16was just like I guess I'm eating these six terrible tacos. But but anyway,
- 38:22so the word gas lighting, I think it's changing, and that's I
- 38:24just have to live with that. Well, and sorry, I will add
- 38:28that in reality, i'd venture to say most people never even knew what the
- 38:34original meaning was. Yeah, like I didn't really like, I'm sure we
- 38:37did that episode, but in general, I don't know. One year it
- 38:40sounds like four years ago or whatever. I started hearing the term and then
- 38:45I just kind of went along with it, and I've probably used it here
- 38:46and there, and I wouldn't think twice if someone used it, because it
- 38:51was just a new word that got introduced. Yeah, but when you've been
- 38:54using it for so long and in the context of domestic violence, in a
- 39:00partner violence, it feels like a thing to It's a thing to me,
- 39:05you know. It's like it's like narcissism, right, or when people use
- 39:09the word code dependency, willy nilly or something I find I'm like, wait,
- 39:15what are you? How are you using the word? And at first
- 39:17I want to say, no, that's wrong, you're using it right,
- 39:22But then eventually the dam breaks and I'm like, Okay, I have to
- 39:28accept that it's being used differently. Now. You know, it's a weird
- 39:31space because if if someone just comes along and for the you know, the
- 39:37first person that used literally in a in the quote unquote wrong way. Should
- 39:42we just give into that that first person without knowing that that the tide is
- 39:45coming? But anyway, berto motivated reason, what's the definition of that?
- 39:50Motivated reasoning is like where I have a conclusion I want to reach because I
- 39:57have a vested interest in it. So you know, I want to sell
- 40:00cigarettes. So therefore I am going to, uh, you know, present
- 40:04the case for why cigarettes are fine, in fact, they're healthy. Do
- 40:07you know for you do you know they're unhealthy? Yea saying absolutely? That's
- 40:10actually not motivated or reasoning. Actually, okay. Motivated reason is when you
- 40:15you actually believe it. It's motivated. Your reasoning is motivated by emotions or
- 40:22bias. So okay. So an example would be you sell cigarettes. You're
- 40:27a cigarette salesman, sure, and you you get data going both ways that
- 40:34it's bad for you, it's good for you and when and you you crammed
- 40:37that all into your head and then someone comes up to you, you know,
- 40:39some customers says, well, aren't cigarettes bad for you? And you'll
- 40:43say no, no, no, no. Lots of studies show and you
- 40:45believe you hook yourself up to a lighter. You're not You're not lying so
- 40:49the cigarettes are good for you. Right. The executives had the actual data,
- 40:52but the salesperson in this case they, I don't know. You know,
- 40:57I'm looking at this data, not that data because I won't. Or
- 41:00another person, say a smoker, someone who actually is smoking, and you
- 41:05come up to and I say, why you're smoking, it's bad for you?
- 41:07They like, actually, it's it's not that bad for you. It's
- 41:10fine. Or if I quit, or if I only smoke five cigarettes a
- 41:14day, it's fine. We understand. That's emotional perceiving. It's disordered thinking.
- 41:19It's motivated reasoning. You your reasoning is being motivated by emotion. You
- 41:27know that is you know, because to the person's smoking cigarettes, for them
- 41:30to agree that it's unhealthy, they have to face their addiction, which they
- 41:37don't want to do, and so it's it's a bias that affects their reason
- 41:39case. So motivated reasoning is a very powerful effect that could be perceived as
- 41:46gas lighting under some circumstances, which we'll get into later. Okay, shame
- 41:52lying this is my term burto What do you think it means? I think
- 41:54it's kind of self evident shame lying. I am ashamed of some thing,
- 42:00and so therefore I'm gonna lie about it. Right. As an example,
- 42:04did you run off the cross country course into the bushes because you had to
- 42:12go to the bathroom in an emergency? No, of course I didn't.
- 42:15That would be crazy, right. Or a child will lie to get out
- 42:22of trouble. Right. You come around the corner and you see that a
- 42:29light is crashed on the ground, and you knew that your daughters were running
- 42:34around breaking you know, they were being rambunctious. Come around the corner and
- 42:37there's a there's a vase that's broken on the ground, and you're like,
- 42:42okay, who broke the vase? And they're like, we didn't do it.
- 42:45They're like, well, how did this happen? They're like I don't
- 42:49know. And you're like, were you being a rambunctious I thought I heard
- 42:52you being rambunctious. We weren't being rambunctious. We were just sitting here.
- 42:54Okay. They know that they bumped it and knocked it over and broke it.
- 43:00Are they gaslighting? Burtle? Are they gaslight? Yeah? Well answer
- 43:06tell me, well no, it's it's not. It's not a gas light.
- 43:09Right. But this but this is important because The shame line concept is
- 43:14extremely deceptive to the victim because under certain circumstances, it can feel like gaslighting.
- 43:22But it's more precisely defined as shameline. It's still wrong, it's still
- 43:29bad. You know, you catch someone who is who is cheated on you
- 43:34and they shame lie and they say I didn't cheat on you, that that
- 43:37you didn't you know, you read it wrong, or that was just a
- 43:42sarcastic text between me and if we were just joking around, you know that
- 43:46they're lying to you. Is that gaslighting or not? Well, I mean
- 43:52again, like see that this is I think where where the reality the rubber
- 43:57hit hits the road when people are just talking. That's fine, like you
- 44:01too, better stop gaslighting me? Fine, but he's it technically based on
- 44:07the criteria you laid out. No, just rattling off some other things that
- 44:09aren't gaslighting. We have mental illness, so some conditions cause people to have
- 44:15distortions or break breaks from reality, and those individuals are not technically gaslighting someone
- 44:22when they are lying because they're distorted or they're break broke from reality, and
- 44:28so that's not gaslighting. That's just it might feel like gaslighting, but it's
- 44:32it's not technically gaslighting. Okay. Another term here is the Martha Mitchell effect.
- 44:37Do you know what that is? Brutal? I don't think so.
- 44:39No. So the origin of this word comes from psychologist Brendan Maher named the
- 44:46effect after Martha Mitchell. So, Martha Mitchell was the wife of John Mitchell,
- 44:51US General Attorney General in the Nixon administration. Do you remember John Mitchell.
- 44:57He was one of the major people being uh, you know, testifying.
- 45:01So I learned about wife Rachel Meadow. Yeah, so the wife Martha
- 45:07Mitchell. She alleged, you know, earlier prior to all this coming out,
- 45:14that White House officials were engaged in illegal activities. She was saying,
- 45:19hey, by the way, Nixon and all them, because I hear about
- 45:22this through my husband, legal activities. She was and she was assessed by
- 45:30mental health people and diagnosed as being delusional because they were like, she sang
- 45:36all these crazy things. She's saying that there's legal activities and that the White
- 45:40House is monitoring her phone and you know, all these things that sounded outlandish,
- 45:47and so they diagnosed her as being delusional and tried to put her on
- 45:52you know, treatment, This sort of thing. Later she was vindicated.
- 45:57So, um, you know, similar to the Christine call In story,
- 46:01you have this well, but different in that it's accidental. You know,
- 46:06she comes in, someone comes into your office as a therapist and says,
- 46:10the government is after me, the president is doing all these evil things.
- 46:16You know, they're they're monitoring my phone. One of the first thoughts you're
- 46:21going to have as a therapist is is this person delusional? You don't usually
- 46:23think maybe it's true. That's not usually what crosses when they say the classic
- 46:29persecutory delusional statements. Usually think, oh, this is a mental illness.
- 46:34So this is an accidental effect where people and again you throw sexism in there,
- 46:39where you're not going to listen to a woman's opinion, and it creates
- 46:45this situation where everyone is convinced they're not gaslighting. They just oh, she's
- 46:51crazy, essentially, instead of maybe we should be listening to her, and
- 46:57essentially if they had listened to her earlier than, you know, Nixon might
- 47:01have been brought to justice earlier. That is crazy. Yeah, that's called
- 47:07the marth initial effect. We also have persuasive speech, which is not gaslighting.
- 47:14It's just trying to convince someone of something and not trying to question their
- 47:17own judgment. But then again, you might do that, right, you
- 47:21might say, hey, you know, you and me Berto where we might
- 47:23be fighting about, like the whether a movie is good or not. Well,
- 47:29a classic tactic that you and I will use against each other is your
- 47:34judgment is wrong. You don't understand, you're not looking at it right,
- 47:37you don't understand how to evaluate movies. You don't you didn't watch it correctly.
- 47:43That's a you know, I'm trying to you know, you and I
- 47:45are trying to get the other person to question their own judgment, right,
- 47:51is that gaslighting? Burto well, I mean it's it's also like this very
- 47:59funny technique of oh, like I used to do this, it's terrible.
- 48:02But you'd be like, oh ah, that's because you you haven't seen as
- 48:07many movies as I have, you know, or like some sort of like
- 48:09oh right, right, you didn't go to you didn't take music theory.
- 48:14Oh you know, it's like a really conceited But that's like gaslighting. That's
- 48:19just I mean, that's just trying to trying to be a jerk, right,
- 48:24But but it is akin to gas lighting, but not we wouldn't call
- 48:30it gaslighting because I'm not going on a mission to undermine your judgment, your
- 48:36belief in your own judgment in general. But we might be trying to get
- 48:40someone to question their judgment on this particular topic because we're trying to be We're
- 48:45trying to be persuasive. That's part of being persuasive is pointing out points that
- 48:50might convince the other person, including maybe you don't know what you're talking about,
- 48:55which of course isn't right nice persuasive speech, but it's a common persuasion
- 49:00of persuasive speech. And then of course propaganda, which you know has to
- 49:04do with usually used in the governments will send out propaganda to convince you that
- 49:12you know, the USSR is doing fine. But I will actually not use
- 49:16the word wrong sometimes, like I'll say that I, as a male,
- 49:22have absorbed the propaganda that men cannot have feelings. That's not technically propaganda,
- 49:29but I kind of like the word propaganda because it it I think accentuates the
- 49:34image I'm trying to say, which is this almost like a malicious organism organized
- 49:40intent to make people believe a certain idea that is false. But of course
- 49:45it's not propaganda. It's just cultural. It's a cultural notion that gets passed
- 49:49down through various different means. Might the government do it, kind of participate
- 49:52in it. Absolutely, But it's not strictly propaganda. But I like to
- 49:57stretch the word a little bit because it it feels poetic to me in the
- 50:00way that saying, you know, that person literally spat in my face feels
- 50:05a little bit more emphasizing. Okay, so let's go to the break,
- 50:08and when we get back from the break, let's actually go over people's submissions
- 50:14and talk about how people are using the word gaslighting. What do you say,
- 50:19Berto, let's do it so Berto, if you're trying to gaslight people
- 50:27and to become a patrons of the podcast, what would that sound like?
- 50:30Hey, I got your message last night. Oh no, you sent me
- 50:36a message. Oh you must have not you must have done it. Maybe
- 50:39it was a pocket message, but I got I saw that you were trying
- 50:43to reach me. Anyways, I figured that you were trying to re up
- 50:47your patron subscription. What do you mean you didn't have it? Of course
- 50:51you've had it. You've been our patron for years. Wait are you seriously
- 50:55not remembering? Is this maybe because of that thing we talked about. Well,
- 51:00you told me the other day about what your therapists said. Oh my
- 51:05gosh, you don't even remember that conversation. Oh I'm so sorry. Listen.
- 51:09I think the best and only course of action for you now is to
- 51:14re up your subscript, probably go up in a level before. Oh yeah,
- 51:19I think you're at the highest tier. Maybe we'll open up a new
- 51:22tier just for you. Okay, that sounds good. My god, you're
- 51:25eerially good at that. Okay. So a lot of people submitted their stories.
- 51:32I went on our Facebook page and asked, hey, you know,
- 51:36submit your stories of gaslighting and we'll read them on the podcast. And we
- 51:40can't read all of them because there were a lot of submissions. And also
- 51:44trigger warning because we're gonna be talking about severe abuse. So if you're triggered
- 51:49by that, take care of yourself, don't listen or do it. And
- 51:52you know breaks. So Anonymous from Hawaii said the following things. My ex
- 51:59partner gasol at me constantly. Many times. I expressed serious concern about the
- 52:06toxicity of our relationship, and I hurt I was by my partner's mistreatment.
- 52:12He would say that I was too young to understand relationships, and when I
- 52:16became his age, I'd realize how wrong I was. All the time,
- 52:21this became a frequent comment from him. He told me I was too sensitive
- 52:25and that I needed to build a stronger backbone if I wanted to make it
- 52:29in the real world. He would call me names. He would constantly tell
- 52:34me I was at fault for anything wrong with our relationship. He threatened to
- 52:37hurt himself if I left. He told me I would never find a boyfriend
- 52:40better than him and would regret it if I ever left him. He would
- 52:46punch walls, slam doors, and physically block me from leaving the house.
- 52:51When things escalated, I was constantly reassured that this was how relationships worked by
- 52:57him. I hated myself. I eventually hated myself to an extreme level.
- 53:01By the last year of our relationship. I felt completely worthless and broken.
- 53:07I believed everything he said, said to and about me. Burt, does
- 53:13this sound like gaslighting? To you? It does? It? Does?
- 53:16I mean the person was purposely trying to get this other person to essentially question
- 53:23everything they would have known or could have learned about relationships at about their specific
- 53:30relationship. They they seemed to use a lot of manipulative language, and and
- 53:37it was clearly involved in abusive relationship from the narrative. Obviously, I'm just
- 53:42taking the narrative at face value. And I think that the the person feared
- 53:50that if they didn't get this person, the abuser feared probably that if they
- 53:54didn't get this person to fully let go of their reason and just you know,
- 54:01give in, and that they would lose them. And then they were
- 54:06they were obviously afraid is so much that they would threaten to hurt themselves,
- 54:12which I think was manipulative as well. And yeah, to me, it
- 54:15sounds like it right exactly well said So first off, Anonymous from Hawaii,
- 54:20I'm sorry you went through that. That's just terrible, terrible victimization. I'm
- 54:27glad you got out of it. There's a lot of therapy to recover from
- 54:30that. You deserve that. I hope you get a lot of support.
- 54:34And I'm just so sorry you went through that. So let's go over the
- 54:37six elements here. Trying to get someone to question their judgment and to trying
- 54:43to get them to question their judgment in general. Burto didn't have that.
- 54:46Yeah, Yeah, there are two things that's stuck out to me. One
- 54:49of them was the the threat of self harm. That one is like,
- 54:55well, you know, you'd be you know, the implication you'd be responsible
- 55:00for me hurting myself. And then the second one, which was the more
- 55:02blanket one, was like, hey, this is how relationships are. Right.
- 55:07That one is really dangerous. That's like, hey, because it's a
- 55:12blanket statement any and it's basically a free pass anything I do or say.
- 55:16Now, I'm just gonna let you know that's how relationships are. She can't
- 55:20question any of it. Questioning any of it is you questioning human relationships in
- 55:23general. Right. Also, he would say that she was too young to
- 55:31understand relationships and that when she became his age that she would realize how wrong
- 55:39that she was. Right, So that's that's pretty clear. Right. It's
- 55:44like, you don't understand you're too young. When you're older, you'll understand
- 55:49you're young and you don't have good judgment. And you repeat this for years
- 55:55and you are unrelenting. The example that I give when I talk about gaslighting
- 56:01with my trainees is when when you're in a fight with your partner and you're
- 56:09both going back and you know you're saying, but you said this, and
- 56:14the other person says, I didn't say that, and you know, but
- 56:15you're wrong because this and the other person's I'm not wrong, you're wrong,
- 56:20you know, you kind of go back and forth. Right, Well,
- 56:22imagine if the person you're arguing with never once allows you to have a point.
- 56:31They never believe that they're to blame, They never relent. They are
- 56:37one hundred and ten percent sure that they are always right and you are always
- 56:42wrong. You might even if you're pretty sure you're right, you're never one
- 56:47hundred ten percent right. You never are one hundred ten percent confident you're right.
- 56:52You're never one hundred ten percent confident the other person's wrong. You're usually
- 56:55like, well, I'm you know, I'm ninety percent sure I'm right,
- 57:00and I'm ninety percent sure my partner is wrong. But I but I'm I
- 57:04don't have a personality disorder and such. I allow for a little bit of
- 57:09possibility there. Who knows. But if you're interfacing with someone that is so
- 57:15confident and they they never give in, then you might start questioning yourself because
- 57:22you're thinking, well, he has zero percent He says, there's zero percent
- 57:27chance that he's wrong. I think there's a ten percent chance that I'm wrong,
- 57:34So maybe I'm wrong. You know, when you interface with someone that's
- 57:37you know, it's like, um, when you're doing trivia games and you're
- 57:40on a trivia team. Have you ever done that before? Berto like a
- 57:45trivia In fact, we've done trivia, right, So when when a question
- 57:50comes up and you think you know the answer right, it's like a family
- 57:53feud thing. Right. You think, I'm pretty sure the answer is five,
- 57:57but Joe is a one hundred percent sure that it's six. You're not
- 58:02going to gamble on your five percent. Yeah, you're you're not going to
- 58:05gamble on that. You're eighty percent sure it's five. Joe is one hundred
- 58:09percent sure it's six. We're gonna go with Joe. So the same goes
- 58:14in relationships when you're isolated and no one else is around because they can't engauge
- 58:21what's really happening. We have this bias that breaks us down over time,
- 58:25and so that's what gas sliders will use against you is never given, never
- 58:31apologize, constantly give the message you don't know what you're talking about. You're
- 58:37too young, you're to this, you're too emotional, you're weak member that
- 58:42time when you were wrong. Well, this is one of those times,
- 58:44and you don't have any comeback to that because they've never admitted they were wrong.
- 58:49They've never said there's a possibility that they're wrong. They seem so confident
- 58:52and eventually you just become brainwashed or gas lit, which is you know,
- 58:58the condition. So going through our list here, it's manipulative, it's purposeful,
- 59:05it's per personal gain, as you said, to retain the relationship.
- 59:08And it's always, always in the midst of an abusive relationship. That anonymous
- 59:15in Hawaii pointed out that he would punch wall, slammed doors, physically block
- 59:19her from leaving the house when things escalated. So we're looking at, you
- 59:24know, a pattern of abuse that gaslighting was a part of. You know,
- 59:29there was a pattern of abuse and a subset of that abuse manifested in
- 59:32the form of gaslighting. Okay, so now let's read another example. Osana.
- 59:39She says, I'm being gas lit by my father. I'm having a
- 59:45pest problem in my apartment. At the moment, I called my father a
- 59:49few days ago asking for help. I knew what his reaction would be,
- 59:53but I was hoping to get support for my pest problem in my apartment.
- 59:59Well, as usual when I get emotional, he starts to question my sanity.
- 1:00:02He denied that I had a problem, even though I told him I
- 1:00:07have evidence that there is a problem, and he said, I'm exaggerating.
- 1:00:12Berto is this gas lighting? Uh? No, I mean I don't.
- 1:00:17It doesn't fit the criteria laid out. I wouldn't even use it in the
- 1:00:22common parlance term myself. I would just be like, I don't know that.
- 1:00:25That seems a little more straightforward in my opinion. But so what is
- 1:00:31it? Is it? Well, first off, Auxana, I'm sorry you
- 1:00:36would do that. Your your father, in your description, sounds like he's
- 1:00:40mistreating you. He is, you know you have a pest problem. You
- 1:00:45know you have a pest problem. You're calling him for support, and why
- 1:00:50not support you? What's the what would be the harm in that? Why
- 1:00:53would he believe that you don't know how to evaluate those things? It's just
- 1:00:58unfair behavior. It's awful. So of the six motivated reasoning, shame,
- 1:01:02lying, mental illness, Martha Mitchell effect, creeping normalcy, Stockholm syndrome,
- 1:01:07what do you think it is? Neither? As an example, when I
- 1:01:09was a teenager. I was fifteen. My vision was getting bad and I
- 1:01:15was embarrassed about it and stuff like that. The teacher asked me, how
- 1:01:21come I walked up to the spelling words every day to write them down in
- 1:01:24my note book. Why I couldn't I just stay seated? I shamedled.
- 1:01:30I said, oh, I just I want to make sure I got them
- 1:01:32right or whatever. Okay, But then when I told my mom that I
- 1:01:36needed to go see an ophthalmologist, she said, no, you don't.
- 1:01:39I said, no, I think I do. She's no, no,
- 1:01:42no, your eyes are fine. Is that gaslighting? No? It was
- 1:01:45it lame. Absolutely. Eventually, eventually she finally relented and we did go
- 1:01:51and guess what I needed glasses? It was lame. I wasn't gaslighting.
- 1:01:54It was also not Stockholm syndrome. It wasn't shamelined well for her. I
- 1:02:00guess maybe there could be some shame about, like my son can't have eye
- 1:02:02problems. Maybe, but it's not the same thing. It's not like,
- 1:02:06well I better lie to him. It's more like she was in denial,
- 1:02:09you know. So I don't know. I don't have a good term for
- 1:02:13it. I think what the dad is doing is definitely crappy. Why why
- 1:02:16would you question your daughter like this? Why would my mom not believe that
- 1:02:21I needed Why would I be making up that I need to go to the
- 1:02:23right. It doesn't make any sense. Yeah, but it's not gas.
- 1:02:27So first off, I don't think we want to use the word lame anymore.
- 1:02:30That's ablest I get it. It is, yeah, because yea,
- 1:02:36some of the the idea you're saying is your mom was being as she was
- 1:02:38mistreating you, she was letting you down, she was disappointing you. But
- 1:02:45you're using a term of you know, that's synonymous with having a hard time
- 1:02:49walking. Essentially. That's funny because since I it's maybe because I didn't grow
- 1:02:52up here, because I've never I've only ever known the word lame as the
- 1:02:58common parlance, right, not cool man. Right. So for this person
- 1:03:04saying I'm being gassed up by my father, I said I had a pest
- 1:03:07problem. He said I was exaggerating the term I would use for this as
- 1:03:12motivated reasoning because I don't know, because we don't know what his reasoning was.
- 1:03:16But that would be the first hypothesis I would pursue if I was trying
- 1:03:20to determine what I would call this, because I would suspect that he has
- 1:03:25difficulty with emotion maybe, or he has difficulty with people asking him for help,
- 1:03:31or he has an addiction maybe, and he has shame about that,
- 1:03:36and he has a hard time being responsible for other people's issues. So I
- 1:03:43think that that would be the hypothesis I would go down. Is you know
- 1:03:45if someone told me so, I went to my dad, I told him
- 1:03:50I had a pest problem, and he refused to listen to me. He
- 1:03:54was totally convinced that I was crazy and I didn't know what I was talking
- 1:03:59about. I would imagine that's coming from a place of what I would call
- 1:04:02motivated reasoning. Now, if you, Osana, want to call that gaslighting,
- 1:04:08then everyone is entitled to call it that. But I'll just tell you
- 1:04:11what I would call it would be probably not gaslighting. Because now if in
- 1:04:16general, and you kind of hit it at it, Oshana, you said
- 1:04:19that as usually said, well, as usual, when I get emotional,
- 1:04:23he starts to question my sanity. So if that was part of a larger
- 1:04:27campaign, which it kind of sounds like maybe it was, then you could
- 1:04:30make an argument that that larger campaign is a gaslighting effort for some reason,
- 1:04:36maybe to control you or keep you down or something like that. I don't
- 1:04:41know, all right, So Subdi from India, She says, I was
- 1:04:45in an abusive relationship. He cheated and continuously lied to me and made me
- 1:04:50question my reality. He blamed me for provoking him to abuse me. He
- 1:04:58manipulated my friends to them against me. He denied things he said. After
- 1:05:02a year of therapy, I still suffer from self doubt. Burto Does this
- 1:05:08sound like gaslighting? That sounds more in the realm um. The friends part.
- 1:05:16You know, that's another one of those very controlling because you you know,
- 1:05:19if you are gaslighting someone, I would imagine at least at times,
- 1:05:24I'm successfully gaslight people. I always needed to isolate them because if you if
- 1:05:30you have them talking to too many other people, almost to anyone else,
- 1:05:33but certainly too many and people they trust, they're gonna start, you know,
- 1:05:39putting too much evidence against my gaslight efforts. So I don't want that.
- 1:05:45So I'm gonna want to say, hey, no, don't listen to
- 1:05:47your friends. Your friends. In fact, I'm probably gonna make up stories
- 1:05:49about the friends yeah, and lie and be like, oh, you don't
- 1:05:54even want to know what they told me about you, right, So it
- 1:05:58really spin things in that day. You know, you always said that she
- 1:06:00was always against you, and I saw it. You know, she's bad
- 1:06:04news for you, you know that kind of stuff. Yeah, this sounds
- 1:06:09very much like gas lighting. So again she says, he cheated and continuously
- 1:06:14lied to me and made me question my reality. He blamed me for provoking
- 1:06:17him to abuse her, so that it imagine you're being abused, you're being
- 1:06:26hit and mistreated, and then there's always this message of it's your fault.
- 1:06:32You're the one to blame for me abusing. You manipulated her friends to pit
- 1:06:40them against her. He denied things he said. So I'm reading between the
- 1:06:45lines a little bit too. There's probably a lot more in terms of a
- 1:06:47similar story of what Anonymous from Hawaii talked about, of this just never admitting
- 1:06:55you're wrong, always blaming the other person. Your psychological means you are breaking
- 1:07:01someone down. And the fact that she's saying, after you're a therapy,
- 1:07:05ere a therapy, I still suffer from self doubt, irrational self doubt.
- 1:07:11That's what happens to you when you're being gas lit. You will emerge on
- 1:07:14the other side and during where you actually you literally will doubt yourself. You'll
- 1:07:21doubt your judgment, you'll doubt everything about you. I meant necessarily you didn't.
- 1:07:28You didn't actually doubt yourself that much before. That's what gaslighting will will
- 1:07:33do to you. If if someone is lying to you or mistreating you,
- 1:07:41and you see right through it and at the end of the process you don't
- 1:07:45have any self doubt, then it might lend itself to another word like deception
- 1:07:51or shame, lying or motivated reasoning or just being in denial or something.
- 1:08:00So we hear this description of like ongoing gaslighting, ongoing blaming, ongoing pitting
- 1:08:05people against her, ongoing denying of things, never taking responsibility for personal gain,
- 1:08:13purposeful, all those things. Okay. Deicole from Massachusetts says, my
- 1:08:16husband has bipolar to disorder. He got the idea for us to get a
- 1:08:21dog. He asked me to locate shelters, research breeds, set up an
- 1:08:26appointment, and finally to submit paperwork to adopt the dog that we both wanted.
- 1:08:30Every step of the way, I was asking for reassurance that he really
- 1:08:33wanted to do this, saying he confirmed that he did. Finally the morning
- 1:08:36he was supposed to send the deposit for the dog, he flipped the script
- 1:08:41and told me he never said he wanted the dog, and I was ridiculous
- 1:08:45for thinking he could afford it. It was such an obvious gaslighting but it
- 1:08:50didn't work, or it was such obvious gaslighting that it didn't work. But
- 1:08:56it suddenly hit me how many times he had done this in the past,
- 1:09:00and it did work in the past to convince me that I was to blame.
- 1:09:02I do not really know if this is intentional behavior or just a result
- 1:09:08of polar opposite mindsets between two his two mood swings given as bipolar two.
- 1:09:14Berto. Does it sound like gaslighting? Not as much as some of the
- 1:09:17others. Again, I'm just I'm just going by your criteria, so I
- 1:09:21don't in any of these answers, I assume that I am finding the behavior
- 1:09:27bad. I'm sorry you went through these things. It sounds super, super
- 1:09:34not cool that you had to put all this work together. You got it
- 1:09:40all prepped up in the last minute, the rug was swept out from under
- 1:09:43your feet. That said, even though it's mentioned that this happened or this
- 1:09:48kind of behavior has happened before, I get a sense more of and whether
- 1:09:53it's there by bipolar or not, I get more of a sense of lying
- 1:09:58for convenience or maybe for shame. In this case, I'm not so sure
- 1:10:00if it was for a shame. It's like, I think that the person
- 1:10:03clearly clearly did have some ambivalence about getting a dog. Maybe they're not good
- 1:10:10at expressing their ambivalence. Maybe maybe they're they're okay enough to go along with
- 1:10:15it, but they're passive aggressive, and then they don't actually want to tell
- 1:10:18you what they really think. But when they're finally put to the like sign
- 1:10:24on the dotted line, they have no choice but to be like, And
- 1:10:28then they revert to lyne because they're like, I never wanted how I can't
- 1:10:31believe you thought I wanted it? So is it manipulative? I think so,
- 1:10:36But it just didn't it didn't quite fit the full criteria in my opinion.
- 1:10:40Yeah, if someone wants to say this is gaslighting, fine, it's
- 1:10:44not a technical clinical term, but in terms of the way I define it,
- 1:10:48it's possible. As the coal you say, maybe this is just a
- 1:10:53product of his mood swings, because when you suffer from bipolar, it's not
- 1:10:58uncommon given the two states of mind as you put them, to have completely
- 1:11:04different view of the world. Now, it's not normal or it's not typical
- 1:11:12for someone to emerge from one of the polls to not remember things precisely,
- 1:11:18especially if it was recently, because it sounds like these things happened kind of
- 1:11:23recently. So maybe it was a shameline mixed in with the bipolar there.
- 1:11:29I don't know, but there is one element that you talk about, Nicole,
- 1:11:32that could indicate if we knew more data that gaslighting is occurring, which
- 1:11:38is it suddenly hit me how many times he had done this before in the
- 1:11:41past, and it did work to convince me that I was to blame.
- 1:11:45So maybe this is the first time you've realized in this one instance, wait,
- 1:11:50I'm being gas lit on an ongoing basis, and this time it just
- 1:11:55didn't work because in the past. Because I'm guessing if it did work in
- 1:11:59the past, asked Nicole, I'm guessing that it wasn't just him denying it.
- 1:12:02It was there was that psychological, manipulative, purposeful effort to get you
- 1:12:10to question your own judgment. So from the story, it's not classical gaslighting,
- 1:12:17but I suspect that if we knew more, there would be more that
- 1:12:23would actually indicate an ongoing effort of gaslighting by the partner. I'm not sure,
- 1:12:27Patron Natasha from California. She wrote in and said, personally, the
- 1:12:30military's approach to sexual assault is the closest thing to how you define gaslighting that
- 1:12:35I've experienced. My squadron was recently out on the carrier and a female sailor
- 1:12:43was assaulted by a group of men in masks you know, trigger. Yeah.
- 1:12:48So my squadron's response was to talk to the women only about keeping ourselves
- 1:12:55safe and walking in groups, and they gave us all flashlights. I asked
- 1:13:00around, and none of the men in my squadron even new the assault happened,
- 1:13:04because no one talked to them about it. The assault was confirmed as
- 1:13:10a real event later over the innercom one morning. The worst part, though,
- 1:13:15is the way male sailors speak of sexual assault as an imagined event,
- 1:13:20as if all women are conniving and manipulative. The only reason a woman would
- 1:13:26claim to be raped is so no one can call her a slut. Misogyny
- 1:13:31serves to keep women apart, to keep us to compare ourselves with one another
- 1:13:36to not defend each other because we don't want to be a lame outcast,
- 1:13:41if you will, that can't hang with the guys. It's as if gaslighting
- 1:13:46is built into the system. That was much more vocal when I joined about
- 1:13:51all these kinds of injustice. Over the past four years, though, I've
- 1:13:56shrunken inside myself because of how alienating and lonely it is to be a woman
- 1:14:00with an opinion. I'm a bit ashamed of this, but I was tired
- 1:14:04of being excluded and associated with tension. I'm getting out next month, though,
- 1:14:10so hopefully the real world is more forgiving. So Berto, gaslighting?
- 1:14:15What do you think again? Going by to the definitions, In my opinion,
- 1:14:20the mails in this story, like the peer males, are probably acting
- 1:14:26more from motivated reasoning. They just don't want to believe it. It's not
- 1:14:29convenient for their worldview. And now some of them might be lying out of
- 1:14:33shame, or might be psychopaths, who knows, But the point is that,
- 1:14:38I mean some of them were committing the crimes, yeah, exactly,
- 1:14:41so they might just be like, no, what, I've never heard of
- 1:14:44this. Now you could claim the system maybe is doing at the very least
- 1:14:51propaganda, maybe even some amount of brainwashing or something, but I don't know.
- 1:14:56It just doesn't fit the criteria to me. No one's out to explicitly
- 1:15:00drive the people insane, and there's no And again I'm not in this situation,
- 1:15:08by the way, The situation is beyond horrible, even just that little
- 1:15:12brief account, Like I'm I can't believe it. It's terrible. Yeah,
- 1:15:15and it happens all the time. It happens all the time, so it's
- 1:15:18study, it's unconsortable. It's a statistic, statistical reality that sexual assaults are
- 1:15:25happening frequently in the military people of all genders, by the way, but
- 1:15:30particularly women, right right, Just so, only just going by definitions,
- 1:15:33I don't know, it doesn't exactly fit. But we certainly need a horrific
- 1:15:38word. In fact, i'd say, like I want to call this gaslighting
- 1:15:41of anything, because gaslighting doesn't sound bad enough. This is awful. It's
- 1:15:45sexist, it's misogynistic, it's criminal, it's harm terrible injustice. The military
- 1:15:53is presumably a force for good, right, It's supposed to be there to
- 1:15:59protect our interests, which presumably have to do with human rights. It's supposed
- 1:16:05to be there to protect the innocent, and all the while you have individuals
- 1:16:12in the military being harmed and then being a you know, gasolate if you
- 1:16:18will, by the system into believing that it's not a big deal or it's
- 1:16:23their fault they should it's if they had been in groups. You know.
- 1:16:27The way that Natasha says this, it's like, okay, ladies, it's
- 1:16:31your fault that this woman was attacked. Make sure that it says. So.
- 1:16:39My squadron's response was to talk to women only about keeping ourselves safe and
- 1:16:43walking in groups, and they gave us flashlights. So it's like, look,
- 1:16:46rapes are going to happen. It's just a part of reality. That's
- 1:16:50just that's you know, it's okay, it's normal. What's not normal is
- 1:16:55that you don't walk in groups and you don't have a flashlight with you.
- 1:16:58That's the problem. So this is an awful situation and it's been going on
- 1:17:06for decades. We've known about it for a long time, and it continues.
- 1:17:11I think there are obviously programs that are trying to reduce this, and
- 1:17:15I don't know the success rate, but clearly we still have a problem.
- 1:17:19And okay, so gas lighting checklist it's you know, for me, when
- 1:17:26I hear this story from Natasha, I actually like to use the word gas
- 1:17:32lighting and agree with Huberto that it almost we almost need a bigger word for
- 1:17:38this. We need to invent some you know, because misogyny doesn't fit it.
- 1:17:44You know, rape culture doesn't seem to encapsulate everything. You could call
- 1:17:47it institutionalized rape culture or institutionalized rape apologizing or systematics agenistic rape of women.
- 1:18:01You know, like there's some phrase that I think would encapsulate that. But
- 1:18:06gaslights as well, I think, Yeah, to me, it's it's a
- 1:18:11bit akin not the same, but a bit akin to the institutionalized brainwashing,
- 1:18:17gaslighting or worse about racism, you know, and certain areas of this country
- 1:18:24and things like that where it's like, what, there's no racism, you
- 1:18:27know, there's it's literally like what you see, don't trust your eyes,
- 1:18:30don't trust your ears that video clip, No, that's not that whatever you
- 1:18:35think, it's not real. It's not racism, it's not sexism. It's
- 1:18:39not this there that is mind control, that is lying to convince you that
- 1:18:45you're wrong in the in the face of all the evidence that you're seeing.
- 1:18:47Um so I suppose you know from certainly from the colloquial version of that,
- 1:18:51I've come to know of gaslighting. Yeah, that's like gaslighting one on one
- 1:18:56um, but it's almost like there there is this thing. It's when it's
- 1:19:00institutionalized, it's so much worse. Yeah, and the motivated reasoning a part
- 1:19:10of this, or the or the motivated or the motivation for the gas lighting
- 1:19:14actually would be a better way to put it. Is the same as for
- 1:19:17the Catholic Church. When victims came forward of sexual abuse by clergy, the
- 1:19:27power structure wanted one to protect the parishioners. I mean, they weren't psychopaths.
- 1:19:33The usually the power structure they cared about the victims, but they also
- 1:19:41cared about their institution. They cared about their jobs. They cared about the
- 1:19:47optics of the Catholic Church. They cared about retaining parishioners and thus money and
- 1:19:54power. If they lost parishioners, they lost money, they lost power.
- 1:19:59So they were in a bind in their own mind. On one hand,
- 1:20:02they want to protect. On the other hand, it's so much easier to
- 1:20:06deny the reality and to just move the clergy men too another location and sweep
- 1:20:15it under the rug because at least for tomorrow, it retains your power,
- 1:20:20it retains your livelihood, it retains your belief system. And hundreds or thousands
- 1:20:29of powered individuals made that decision, either collectively or dependently. And then what
- 1:20:35you have is an institution as a whole that is, in a sense systematically
- 1:20:45raping children and denying it and covering it up and excusing it away. So
- 1:20:51as a system, that's how it works. Individuals within that system. Because
- 1:20:58of the way the system operates you, because of the policies and procedures that
- 1:21:01they have that they use, and the culture of this system, the institution
- 1:21:11ends up gaslighting its parishioners, making the victims and in society believe that they're
- 1:21:16the crazy ones, when it's not necessarily this evil genius at the top of
- 1:21:24the pyramid going ha ha ha ha ha, I'm setting out to gaslight the
- 1:21:30people. It's the culture, it's the system. It's these individual little decisions.
- 1:21:36You know. Again, I don't know. We can't be inside the
- 1:21:41minds of the power structure. But a parishioner comes to you and says,
- 1:21:45this clergy person rates me. And let's say that the power person believes a
- 1:21:51story well that that power person is thinking, Okay, what do I do?
- 1:21:57On one hand, that clergy person needs to be punish. On the
- 1:22:00other hand, if I punish him, it's gonna get public and a lot
- 1:22:05of people are going to get upset, and there's gonna be press and there's
- 1:22:10gonna be news stories, and there's going to be movies, and I'm gonna
- 1:22:13get dragged into it, and the parishioners are going to get good dragged into
- 1:22:16it. No one wants that. What's the easiest way to do this.
- 1:22:20I'll I'll pray with the parishioner and say I'm so sorry this happened to you.
- 1:22:26I'll take care of it, and then I'll slowly and quietly suspend the
- 1:22:30clergy and send him to another state and everything and everyone wins that. You
- 1:22:35know, that's that's the that's the individual's decision making tree that they make.
- 1:22:41Of course it's immoral and wrong. We see that from the outside, but
- 1:22:44when you're on the inside and all the different factors, that's how a non
- 1:22:47psychopath can make a psychopathic decision. And then you compound that a thousand times
- 1:22:51and you have a psychopathic gas lighting institution. Am I making my case Berto
- 1:22:56you are, I'm just gonna call it platonium lighting. It's like, you
- 1:23:00know, they put up all these plutonium they put up all these street lights
- 1:23:03in your neighborhood, maybe in your whole city, and you start complaining that
- 1:23:08you're developing all sorts of illnesses, your skin is peeling away, you're getting
- 1:23:12really sick, and it's like you know, and then you're like, I
- 1:23:15think it's the lights. It's like no, no, no, no,
- 1:23:17it's not. You're just making things up. You always had that rash.
- 1:23:20Is this a true story? No, I'm just I'm just saying, like,
- 1:23:24it turns out they put plutonium rods in there. So the institutionalized version
- 1:23:28of gas lighting, I could just see that happening in the fifties and some
- 1:23:31Texas town it's like yeah, plutonium. Yeah, So the institutionalized versions plutonium
- 1:23:36lighting. But I was going to also say that you could imagine a more
- 1:23:42specific case of gas lighting where imagine, in this case the priest example,
- 1:23:45where you you abused me and it's like, no, actually you have demons
- 1:23:51and I need to work with you to exercise those demons, and then like
- 1:23:55going down a whole path of making the person believe they're actually possessed and all
- 1:23:58that sort of thing. Right, So, so individuals, So just getting
- 1:24:01back to the clergy, there were individual cases where that was happening, where
- 1:24:05someone came forward and the clergy or others would get the victim to believe that
- 1:24:14there's something they're they're they're crazy. You know, this was well depicted in
- 1:24:17the TV series Unbelievable that came out a couple of years ago. I didn't
- 1:24:21see that. Yeah, I thought you did. I thought we watched it
- 1:24:25together as Netflix. We talked. Oh wait, we talked with Christy.
- 1:24:29Yeah. Sorry, that's the one about the here in Washington State. Yeah,
- 1:24:32yeah, yeah, yeah, I thought I had it was I thought
- 1:24:35it was some show about priests or something. No, no about you know,
- 1:24:39it was about the rape victim that came forward and then the police convinced
- 1:24:44or you know, tried to carry you were gaslighting me about a show.
- 1:24:46Yeah, So to go to the military, you have a system that has
- 1:24:51a massive culture of sexism and misogyny, literal hate of women. There's plenty
- 1:24:58of people in the military openly who will say women shouldn't be here. I
- 1:25:02don't want them here, get rid of them. They're weak, they're stupid,
- 1:25:09they don't know what they're doing, they're two emotion. Whatever the ideas
- 1:25:12is, get you get rid of them, and you have a system that
- 1:25:18makes subordinates lack power and advocacy for themselves. You know, shut up,
- 1:25:25stay in your place, be a team player, these kinds of things.
- 1:25:29And then you have a culture and a policy baby around well, you know,
- 1:25:32sexual assaults. Yeah, the enlisted class will, they'll do stuff to
- 1:25:39each other sometimes, and we just all understand that they just have to put
- 1:25:44up with it. This kind of attitude, and then a literal attitude around
- 1:25:47well, if someone claims to be raped, it's probably them just trying to
- 1:25:53avoid being called a slut. We all understand that, you know, just
- 1:25:56just terrible misogynistic ideas. And as Natasha was saying, and you add all
- 1:26:00that up and you have tiny gaslighting moments and an institution that gaslights the women.
- 1:26:10The women are walking around going like wait, am I am I crazy
- 1:26:14for a feeling like there's something wrong with this policy of a woman was raped
- 1:26:19by a gang of masked sailors and US women are being pulled into a room
- 1:26:26to be told that we need to stick in groups and wear flash likes like
- 1:26:30wait, what's going on here? Without that confirmation from the outside. And
- 1:26:33then Natasha also says that there's this culture that pits women against each other so
- 1:26:40that they're isolated. They can't form a union if you will. So to
- 1:26:45me, it's not classic gaslighting in the sense of an abusive relationship, but
- 1:26:51I'm willing to use it in that situation. Right to me, in the
- 1:26:57same way that I'll say that there's propaganda that tells me as a man,
- 1:27:00I can't have my feelings that you know, that's not strict use of the
- 1:27:04term propaganda, I think gaslighting fits in this situation, even though it's not
- 1:27:11classic in terms of the Yeah, all right. Michelle from Yorkshire says,
- 1:27:17my experience with gaslighting was with the medical profession. Oh. Actually, I
- 1:27:23decided to read this one, Burt, because I thought you might be able
- 1:27:25to relate to it. It'll become very clear why I tended the doctor as
- 1:27:30I was struggling with an overwhelming fatigue and weight gang. I could not function
- 1:27:35at all. I'd hit a brick wall. I was informed that I was
- 1:27:40clearly depressed again and I needed to work on coping strategies and get a grip
- 1:27:44on my diet and I was sent away with entidepressants. Thankfully, my husband
- 1:27:48advocated for me, arranged another consultation, and demanded a full physical. I
- 1:27:54was contacted the next day with news I had severely underactive thyroid. So can
- 1:28:02you relate? And too, is this gaslighting? Oh my god, as
- 1:28:05you went through this, I literally did. I can so relate. It's
- 1:28:11um so just my little soapbox. Um, because I've been through it now
- 1:28:15now I know I had no idea. Just like everyone else, the thyroid
- 1:28:19is the most like important thing that happens in your body. I mean,
- 1:28:26I'm not It's like there's other important things, but the thyroid controls some very
- 1:28:30key things, including your heart, including you're you're breathing, your lungs,
- 1:28:33your everything. So like, the thyroid produces very important hormones. Okay.
- 1:28:38Now, at the same time, it seems to be the least understood thing
- 1:28:42when you go for an emergency. Um. I went through this where a
- 1:28:46little over a year ago, I was um feeling worse than I had ever
- 1:28:51felt, and I went to the er and they checked me out, and
- 1:28:56um, they just concluded it was probably anxiety. And I believed it,
- 1:29:00you know, so, because then it happened again like that the next week,
- 1:29:03and I went to another ear and there they looked at the notes.
- 1:29:08They talked to me like, yeah, you're just having a panic attack.
- 1:29:10So they prescribed me some anxiety pills, and I was like, oh,
- 1:29:14okay, all right, that must be it. I need to learn to
- 1:29:15relax now. Time went on, and then in the fall, I had
- 1:29:21it worse than before, and this time, luckily, it was bad enough
- 1:29:26to where they couldn't just blame it on some anxiety and they had to run
- 1:29:30more tests, and they discovered that I too had thyroid issues. And then
- 1:29:33all of a sudden, I looked back and I'm like, oh my gosh,
- 1:29:38I wonder how many times over the last few years I've been thinking I'm
- 1:29:41just having some weird, funny feelings or anxiety and I was actually having,
- 1:29:45you know, actual hormonal imbalances from my thirred. All right, So were
- 1:29:50they gaslighting me? I don't think so. No, they weren't that.
- 1:29:55Like they didn't mean like. I remember the guy in the in the ear
- 1:29:59the second e a year ago. He was so kind and spent so much
- 1:30:03time to me, and he explained that he suffered from anxiety, and he
- 1:30:06told me how pad he can feel, and I believed it. And look,
- 1:30:11I've actually had anxiety before, and I thought, yeah, you know
- 1:30:15he of course he wasn't trying to gaslight me or control me or made me
- 1:30:18question my own sanity. No, it was the opposite. Yeah, it's
- 1:30:23just that, Unfortunately, there are these symptoms that I wish people were more
- 1:30:30informed about people. I mean in the medical professional where they're like, well
- 1:30:32just for ships and giggles, yeah, let's run the following tests. Yeah.
- 1:30:38I would call this either medical incompetence. I would also call this motivated
- 1:30:45reasoning because as a as a clinician, you really emotionally want to solve the
- 1:30:51problem. Yeah, and you might be under a lot of pressure to get
- 1:30:56to the ex patient, and it's so much more venient to say this is
- 1:31:01an anxiety problem, this is your depression, because you write a script for
- 1:31:05antidepressant, sent them home, and you can move on to the next patient.
- 1:31:09Because you're being pressured by your superiors to do to have a high productivity.
- 1:31:14I'm quite positive ninety five percent of physicians would love to run all the
- 1:31:17tests with every single patient they have, but they can't. That's just not
- 1:31:23pay for it, right, So, so each individual is probably doing their
- 1:31:30best. They're probably some of them might be incompetent, some of them might
- 1:31:35not understand the thyroid. Some of them might be operating for motivated reasoning that
- 1:31:41they might later realize, Oh, I was probably not looking at it with
- 1:31:45an open mind. Yeah, but you have a system if we again want
- 1:31:49to similar to Natasha's example, want to say that you have a system that
- 1:31:55is gaslighting patients in that you have a system in the medical field, according
- 1:32:00to you and maybe to Michelle, that is for whatever reason, just ignoring
- 1:32:06the thyroid as an option. Yeah, maybe it's because it's rare. I
- 1:32:11don't know. I mean, I know a lot of people who have thyroid
- 1:32:14diagnosable thyroid problems, so it can't be that rare, you know, right,
- 1:32:17And so what is it about the system? You know, is everyone
- 1:32:21operating on good faith, but the system is oriented towards I don't know,
- 1:32:29cheaper treatment, you know, because if the thyroid is implicated, now you're
- 1:32:33talking about much more expensive things, more involved. Maybe so is that what
- 1:32:39the system is? Maybe there's a policy or a culture that is actually gaslighting
- 1:32:45patients into thinking like like, like we could look back at you Berto when
- 1:32:51before you were diagnosed, when you were going, you know, and don't
- 1:32:56let me put words in your mouth, but correct me if I'm wrong.
- 1:32:58You're like, you know, I kind of know what anxiety feels like.
- 1:33:00This doesn't feel like anxiety. Oh totally, That's exactly how I felt.
- 1:33:04I felt. But they but they keep telling me that this is anxiety and
- 1:33:09everything's fine, So it must be anxiety. My ability to gauge my own
- 1:33:14body and my own anxiety. I must be wrong. I must be wrong.
- 1:33:18I must I must not be able to evaluate that. I must have
- 1:33:23a bad evaluator of my own body and my own anxiety because they told me
- 1:33:30that it's that I'm fine, So it must be anxiety. I don't.
- 1:33:34I am now questioning my ability to you know, understand a fact from fiction.
- 1:33:42Yeah, and you started to question yourself, right, you know?
- 1:33:45Actually, so this reminds me so later on, So in the fall,
- 1:33:48after I had been diagnosed, so they put me on medicine. The medicine
- 1:33:53controls how much THID is produced, how much hormone is produced. But a
- 1:33:57couple of weeks in I started feeling horrible and so I ended up going back
- 1:34:03to the ER a couple of times because I felt horrible, and again they
- 1:34:08were like, yeah, I don't know, it's it's I mean, it
- 1:34:10sounds like they said you were you said they diagnosed you with the thyret thing,
- 1:34:15and that's probably that go home, and it's like okay, okay,
- 1:34:17fine, and so it was like, even though we knew this, I
- 1:34:21was still not getting help. And then I remember at one point I was
- 1:34:25even I was talking to someone I know and even they were like, well,
- 1:34:30are you sure it's not just like maybe you kind of being anxious about
- 1:34:34the fact that you've and I'm like no. It turns out that the medicine
- 1:34:40as they had prescribed it to me, the dosage was too high and it
- 1:34:44had dipped me too low, and now I was having hypothyroitism, and until
- 1:34:48someone finally listened to me at one of the ER visits, they were like
- 1:34:53okay, and then they ran a test and like, oh, yeah,
- 1:34:56I think you're too low finally, and I was like, thank goodness.
- 1:35:00So then they adjusted the dosage, but it was so frustrating. I'm like,
- 1:35:03why isn't anyone understanding that I get what you're saying, and I've I've
- 1:35:08felt that this is not that right. So is any one of those individuals,
- 1:35:13according to your estimation, maliciously trying to make you question your reality?
- 1:35:20No? Yeah, but the system was making you question your reality, yes,
- 1:35:27the way that the because your experience probably isn't unique, especially what Bischelle
- 1:35:33is saying. It's like an exact thing, right, or a similar,
- 1:35:36very similar thing. So in my as I start to hear these stories and
- 1:35:45sort of think about it, I think that there are situations where it doesn't
- 1:35:49strictly meet the old criteria of gaslighting, but we could sort of expand it
- 1:35:53in the same way that we might expand the word propaganda, like I would
- 1:35:58say. Anyway, okay, so let's talk about a couple more here.
- 1:36:03Berto, Actually don't. We don't have time, so let's skip down to
- 1:36:09this one. Well, no, let's see. Yeah, this one.
- 1:36:15A few years ago, my husband now X, and I were expecting a
- 1:36:19child and he smokes. We weed often, and I asked him to smoke
- 1:36:25outside instead of in our apartment, which he agreed to. I thought it
- 1:36:29might be better for the baby. I also had morning sickness that was very
- 1:36:32affected by any scent One day, I stepped into his office and I saw
- 1:36:36a huge plume of smoke coming out of his mouth. It was obvious that
- 1:36:40he had been smoking inside, against our agreement, Yet he insisted for several
- 1:36:45days that he hadn't been smoking. He was so insistent that I began to
- 1:36:49doubt myself. I had to remind myself of what I actually witnessed, Otherwise
- 1:36:55the facts started to feel twisted to me. Burto is this gaslighting? Oh
- 1:37:00my gosh, that facts started to feel twisted to me. That one is,
- 1:37:05you know, facts started to feel twisted to me. Sounds sounds scary.
- 1:37:12You know. That's when you're like, what, yeah, could so
- 1:37:15in that in that instance you would say, well, it's gaslighting esque at
- 1:37:17the very last. Yeah, right, But the is he on a mission
- 1:37:24to make you question your judgment in general or is it just about this issue?
- 1:37:30And is he shame lying? He's probably shamed. Yeah, Yeah,
- 1:37:32that's probably right. He's he's a he's terribly ashamed of either his behavior or
- 1:37:39his addiction. By the way, it's just the reason I'm thinking that there
- 1:37:43is a little bit there. But so you asked me, um to think
- 1:37:47of examples maybe that had happened to me or whatever. And I was thinking
- 1:37:51back to money issues with my dad when I was young, where he would
- 1:37:58he would just lie to my face about, you know, where something had
- 1:38:02gone or whatever, and because he's funny, just an astro son. This.
- 1:38:05You told the same story four years ago in the episode we didn't the
- 1:38:09same Oh my gosh. Yeah, okay, but it's good, it's perfect.
- 1:38:11Yeah. But that's the thing is that I actually think that was,
- 1:38:15now that you've given me these other definitions, that that was shameline that he
- 1:38:17didn't want and or just flat out manipulative to like, um, I don't
- 1:38:25know what the other word would be, but manipulation, you know, just
- 1:38:27like it wasn't actually he wasn't trying to drive me insane and he wasn't trying
- 1:38:30to um sort of um. Well, anyways, I think that it was
- 1:38:35more localized than that it was. I can't really tell you why I need
- 1:38:39this money. I can't really tell you what happened to your toy. So
- 1:38:44I'm just gonna pretend I don't know what happened to the toy. Yeah,
- 1:38:46that's weird that it's not in your closet, and in fact, he sold
- 1:38:50it because he needed the money. Right, the sequence in case people are
- 1:38:56not knowing is you would you wouldn't be able to find your toy, and
- 1:39:00you'd go to him like, where's my toy and he'd be like, I
- 1:39:01don't know where it is. It wasn't just any toy. It was the
- 1:39:04X wing Fighter and the tie Fighter. Yeah, something that you would definitely
- 1:39:12know if you like, and you would definitely know if you somehow threw it
- 1:39:15away or something. Yeah. And my closet was like a small close like
- 1:39:19it wasn't hiding in some that massive storage facility. So he would say,
- 1:39:26I don't know where it is, even though he absolutely did know where it
- 1:39:28was because he sold it. And and he would say, I don't know.
- 1:39:32You know, you you lose things sometimes, you know, maybe it
- 1:39:38who knows? And that's weird. Yeah. So does it have a gaslighting
- 1:39:43effect? Yeah? But is it gaslighting? I don't know if that's if
- 1:39:48people want to use it in that sense, Uh fine, But to me,
- 1:39:53I would call that more addictive shame lighting, which is really common for
- 1:39:58people who suffer from addictions. They will they're terribly ashamed and in denial of
- 1:40:04a lot of things, and they're also terribly dependent on the substance or the
- 1:40:09behavior, and they will do anything to retain that relationship with the substance,
- 1:40:15and including lying because to admit, yes, son, I took your stuff
- 1:40:21and sold it. Then they have to. Then it's well known, at
- 1:40:26least to one person, that they have a big problem and that they've got
- 1:40:30to change. If they, at least in this tiny little moment, just
- 1:40:33sort of shoe away the child, say anything to get the child to move
- 1:40:36away, they survived that one moment, retaining their connection to the substance.
- 1:40:43They don't have to question things. They don't have to answer any more questions.
- 1:40:46So is that gaslighting? Yeah, I mean it has a gas lighting
- 1:40:50effect, but I don't think it comes from that abusive place like that story
- 1:40:55we told earlier where someone goes on this campaign of trying to convince you that
- 1:41:00you were to blame for everything. You're too young, you don't understand things.
- 1:41:04I'm the smart one. Listen to me, obey you. The flip
- 1:41:09side example is a friend of mine had this X who absolutely was gaslighting him,
- 1:41:16absolutely where she would make up completely fabricated stories against his friends, including
- 1:41:26me, would convince had him convinced that because of her connections, she could
- 1:41:32ruin him in Seattle, in the scene that he was in just ruin him.
- 1:41:36So he had he was afraid. I remember because at one point he
- 1:41:41was trying to do something set up for something, some project he was doing,
- 1:41:44and I was like, oh, hey, why don't you do this.
- 1:41:45It's like, well, I'd like to, but I can't because she
- 1:41:47doesn't want me to, Like, well, but it's your project. No,
- 1:41:50you don't understand. She can ruin me if I don't do what she
- 1:41:54wants. Like he literally used that, literally used those words. And one
- 1:42:00point we she convinced him that I had kicked her out and told her she
- 1:42:05was never welcome again in my house. Whatever. So him and I didn't
- 1:42:10speak for like six months because he was so upset at me, and I
- 1:42:12had no idea why he was upset. And then come to find out and
- 1:42:15I was like, what are you talking about? It was absolute gaslighting.
- 1:42:19Absolute Yeah. So from our episode four years ago. At the end of
- 1:42:26the episode, I had this guide to how to protect yourself. So here
- 1:42:30are the summary. We'll end with this one. If you're being if you
- 1:42:34think you're being gasolate' do not isolate yourself and don't let yourself to be isolated.
- 1:42:41This is key because under certain conditions, all of us can be gasolate,
- 1:42:45all of us can be effectively gaslit. Stay in connection. Tell other
- 1:42:50people, a therapist, a friend, a family member, someone you trust
- 1:42:55that you can say, so, this thing happened the other day and my
- 1:43:00partner is totally convinced I'm to blame for it. I'm not really quite sure.
- 1:43:04Your friend will hopefully give you a straight answer that will help you.
- 1:43:10Need that. Also, just get emotional support. Also, you might want
- 1:43:15to shed light on the matter. Don't allow the story to just stay between
- 1:43:18the two of you. That's the abuser's tactic is never air our dirty laundry.
- 1:43:28If that is a way of keeping you under their thumb. That's a
- 1:43:30way of keeping the narrative under their control. And they know that. And
- 1:43:34so if you shed light on it, if you're just like you just type
- 1:43:40up the story and like hand it out to five of your friends, that
- 1:43:44is that's the kryptonite to the abuser, because when light is shown on the
- 1:43:49abusive behavior, the abuser knows that it will not stand up to scrutiny and
- 1:43:55they and they know the only way it could stand up with scrutiny. Is
- 1:43:58if they isolate the victim and convince the victim that everything is normal, like
- 1:44:02some of the stories we heard before. Also, stay in control of your
- 1:44:06own mind as best as you can. You know, keep reminding yourself that
- 1:44:10you're you're smart, you know things. You're not one hundred percent one hundred
- 1:44:15percent irrational. You know, you might be three percent irrational, but you've
- 1:44:19got ninety seven percent rational mind. You understand things. The other thing is
- 1:44:24is get away from the gas lighter. If you if you know what's happening,
- 1:44:28get away from the abusive person. I get with your other people,
- 1:44:32because that might be the only solution. Know that you deserve better than that.
- 1:44:38You deserve a relationship where someone respects you and listens to you and admits
- 1:44:42that they're wrong. This is a good litmus test. Everyone deserves to be
- 1:44:45in a relationship, whether it's friend, family, spouse, workmate, where
- 1:44:51other people admit they did something wrong and apologize to you. Maybe they don't
- 1:44:58say, oh my god, I'm a terrible person, but they say,
- 1:45:00oh, yeah, I made that mistake. You're right now, let me
- 1:45:03It's a good one, you know, like it If you're with people that
- 1:45:08never say that, know that you are not getting what you deserve. You
- 1:45:13deserve people where you even little things just like hey, that little thing you
- 1:45:17deserve. Somebody be like, you know what, You're right. I'm sorry.
- 1:45:20You know I did mean to, but I could see how that would
- 1:45:24hurt you, and I'm sorry I did that. Everyone deserves that and so
- 1:45:30many people do not have that for a lot of reasons. Also, fight
- 1:45:36back if you feel safe enough to do so in all the various ways,
- 1:45:41by saying no, you're wrong, I'm right. I know I'm right because
- 1:45:45I saw the pests in my house. I know this isn't just depression.
- 1:45:50I know that rapeists not normal, and that rapeists not women's fault. I
- 1:45:57know that. I just because I'm young, that that doesn't mean I know
- 1:46:02nothing. I know these things. Final word, Burtle, Yeah, I
- 1:46:06think that The main one that I think I would latch onto is reach out
- 1:46:13to others and find a community or if you don't already have one. I
- 1:46:17was thinking as you were saying those, you know, there are a lot
- 1:46:20of tools these days to express yourself, you know, make little Twitch videos
- 1:46:26or Instagram clips, or make a YouTube video or start your own podcast.
- 1:46:30And but even if you don't want to go to those extents, finding communities
- 1:46:35could be useful. Like I found a community about thyroid disease on Facebook,
- 1:46:41and I don't participate a ton, but I see and I comment here and
- 1:46:45there, and it's actually really helpful because guess what. I see stories from
- 1:46:50other people and I'm like, ah, yes, thank you, that's what
- 1:46:54happened to me. Or someone will say like, does anyone notice this symptom
- 1:46:57and other people be like, yes, I get that too, and all
- 1:47:00of a sudden, I feel like, oh, validated, right, And
- 1:47:02even to the point that a lot there are a lot of these stories where
- 1:47:05the people go, have you been to the doctor and they told you it
- 1:47:10was just anxiety, Like, yes, thank you. So you know,
- 1:47:13I think finding a community can help, you know, compare and contrast data,
- 1:47:18and that that can be helpful in this. Yeah, I'm so glad
- 1:47:21that you found that. Yeah, I know that you'd been struggling with your
- 1:47:26health this last year and kept trying. You know, we're dutifully going to
- 1:47:31the doctor the hospital, doing your job, and you were let down by
- 1:47:39the community, by the medical community over something that is at least common enough.
- 1:47:45You know, if you said, you know the gobbleegook gland blah blah
- 1:47:48blah. It's like I've known about hyper and hypothyroidism for just you know,
- 1:47:55just sort of you know, people talk about it. It's something that you
- 1:48:00hear about for twenty years, maybe, like to the point where I think
- 1:48:06maybe five years ago or something, I was like, oh, I'm feeling
- 1:48:10this and my wife was like, maybe maybe have something right with your thybroid.
- 1:48:14You know, it's just one of those things that it's at least well
- 1:48:15known enough. It's not like it's not like point zero zero zero one percent
- 1:48:18of the people, you know, we're talking about common enough that why can't
- 1:48:24the system at least ask that question and say, like, it's not like
- 1:48:27I'm like, well, I have a third brain in my nipple, all
- 1:48:32right, Well that doesn't for that episode of psychology in Seattle. Thanks for
- 1:48:36joining us out there, and please take care of yourself because you deserve it.