Latest / Replay Reviews / "He'd Look for Me" 💀 | Red Dead Redemption II | Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00All right. Should we do the out of context summary?
- 0:02Go for it. In this episode, eyeliner at a time
- 0:07like this? What exactly does a party smell like?
- 0:11And what you want? Use your knees, young woman.
- 0:15I don't know if that's the same guy. Thank you
- 0:20for coming back from our replay reviews. My name
- 0:22is Leah. And my name is Kathy. We are two friends
- 0:24who are here to replay, review, and analyze your
- 0:27favorite video games. And since Kathy has never
- 0:29seen the games before, it helps me view them
- 0:31through her fresh eyes, almost like I'm discovering
- 0:34them again for the first time. We hope it'll
- 0:36be a similar experience for you. Here we are.
- 0:46Season 5, episode 1. I'm excited to just be focusing
- 0:50solely on Red Dead 2. I think it'll be fun for
- 0:54us to get more involved in a game. We're going
- 0:57to spend a season's worth of episodes on just
- 1:00one game, so it's going to be a lot. Anyway.
- 1:04Welcome to Season 5, as we've said. Doing Red
- 1:07Dead 2, as we've said. I want to say that the
- 1:11aesthetics of this game is just so unbelievably
- 1:13outstanding and amazing. While watching this
- 1:17with you, I kept saying like, wow, that's like
- 1:19a whole wallpaper. That's a screenshot. It's
- 1:21just so pretty. And I can't believe it's still
- 1:24aged out. And yet, it's just, yeah. Eight years.
- 1:29I'm pretty sure there's a person that like...
- 1:33sends in screenshots of landscapes from the game
- 1:35to their news station and like keeps winning
- 1:38like photo of the week or something we'll have
- 1:42to look that up but i'm pretty sure that's a
- 1:44thing that's how realistic this game is though
- 1:46to your point no physics is the term i never
- 1:49thought i would hear but here we are okay before
- 1:53we get started something new we're doing this
- 1:55season and potentially carrying over the same
- 1:57item the next season if we don't find it is we're
- 2:00gonna have a random item That we're going to
- 2:02be on the lookout for and see if it somehow pops
- 2:05up in the game in any form. So I know you had
- 2:08a couple ideas. Should we pick one? Flowers.
- 2:13Okay, I have that noted. We'll keep our eyes
- 2:15peeled. I didn't notice one in part one, but
- 2:18we were in the snow. So I knew there wouldn't
- 2:21be much of anything in chapter one. All right.
- 2:25So the first thing we see is a little explanation
- 2:27of where we're at. It's 1899. America is being
- 2:31tamed and outlaws are going extinct. We see a
- 2:34gang seeking shelter on the run from the law
- 2:37up in the frigid mountains. All right, so someone
- 2:41named Arthur was sent ahead to find shelter,
- 2:43and we soon meet him when he rides out of the
- 2:45snow, saying he found an old mining town. And
- 2:48then this is what I noted Molly with the eyeliner.
- 2:50She's just using coal to just cover her eyes.
- 2:53And then we also hear mention of John. He and
- 2:57someone named Micah were sent scouting up ahead,
- 2:59so we don't see either of them yet. We also see
- 3:01a young Jack with the group. Baby Jack. Baby
- 3:07boy. How many people do you recognize at this
- 3:10point? I'm terrible, but I recognize, obviously,
- 3:13Dutch, Abigail, Jack. That's probably about it
- 3:18at this point. I think, I can't remember when
- 3:20I recognized Uncle. Probably when I started laughing
- 3:23at him. Yeah, at that point, yes. I think I probably
- 3:26would have recognized Javier, but he looked very
- 3:29different. Yes, he looks very different. He looks
- 3:33normal here. He could probably still jump out
- 3:34windows pretty good, though. So they make it
- 3:37into a shed? What is that place? Or the mining...
- 3:42A ghost town, basically. A ghost town, pretty
- 3:44much. They find shelter. One of their people
- 3:46died, and Dutch just gives good speech, not thinking
- 3:51anything about Red Dead Redemption 1 and the
- 3:54Dutch we know then. I can see how he's a very
- 3:57inspiring... good leader like the speech he gives
- 4:00is very moon lifting despite everything happening
- 4:04and it makes him sound like he really is for
- 4:07the people in this group and even arthur like
- 4:10the nod of approval when he's listening to the
- 4:13to the speech that just says a lot but yeah like
- 4:16you said someone named davy just died and it
- 4:19sounds like someone named jenny died too and
- 4:22sean and mac are missing so chaos yeah And that
- 4:27kind of shows like the leadership Dutch has.
- 4:30And it is just it's so jarring to have the context
- 4:33of what we see in Red Dead Redemption 1 and seeing
- 4:37it here. After his speech, Dutch and Arthur head
- 4:40out to go find John or Micah. On the way, Arthur
- 4:44says, what really went down back there on that
- 4:46boat? And Dutch's response is, we missed you,
- 4:49which I find a bit flimsy. I have so many questions
- 4:52about that. And this is. A theory I need to continue
- 4:55to build as I get more pieces of information.
- 4:58But all I know right now is we miss you as in
- 5:02they purposely left him or he was somewhere else.
- 5:07Yeah. Arthur was not on the boat. Yeah. And we
- 5:11soon get a few more details. He says, do you
- 5:13think it was a trap in Blackwater? And in response,
- 5:16they knew we were coming. And it sounds like
- 5:19they have a stash hidden outside the town that
- 5:21they had to leave behind. So as they're riding
- 5:24through the night in the snow, they run into
- 5:27Micah, who leads them to a homestead that has
- 5:29been taken over by a rival gang, the O'Driscolls.
- 5:33Arthur and Micah are instructed to hide out of
- 5:35sight while Dutch goes up to the door. He calls
- 5:38out for help, and the O'Driscoll that answers
- 5:41the door just cracks me up the way he just goes,
- 5:43What you want? I don't know why it hits me so
- 5:46funny, but every time it does. At some point,
- 5:48they find a corpse and realize that these are
- 5:51the O'Driscolls. And so a shootout starts. And
- 5:53once things settle down, they search the property
- 5:55for anything that they can use. And this is when
- 5:58Arthur enters the cabin and goes, smells like
- 6:01a party. What's that mean? Alcohol? I assume
- 6:04so. Smoke? I mean, in modern day terms, that's
- 6:08like what? Alcohol, smoke, drugs. What does that
- 6:12mean, Arthur? Anything before Arthur goes to
- 6:16the barn and gets jumped by that guy. That's
- 6:18my next note. He goes and explores the barn outside
- 6:22because Dutch told him so. He goes and some guy
- 6:25just jumps him from behind or from above, pretty
- 6:28much. He just came flying out of nowhere. I know.
- 6:32It's a jumping spider. So pretty much the long
- 6:36and short of it is Arthur interrogates this guy,
- 6:39gets some more information about the O'Driscoll,
- 6:41and then you're left with a decision to either
- 6:43kill him or to let him go. And you chose, I'm
- 6:47assuming, you chose to let him go. And I'm wondering,
- 6:50is he going to regret letting him go? I'm kind
- 6:52of curious, what happens when you kill him and
- 6:55what happens when you let him go? How much does
- 6:57that change the story? From my perspective, I'm
- 7:00trying to play it in your mindset of, I've never
- 7:03seen this before. So we get the information out
- 7:07of them that we need, that where they're camped,
- 7:09why they're on the mountain, which is to rob
- 7:11a train. The options are, you can just continue
- 7:14to punch him, let him go, or kill him. So I decided
- 7:18to split the difference and just punch him and
- 7:20let him go. Because from your perspective, we
- 7:22don't really know what kind of person Arthur
- 7:24is at this point. Yeah. At some point, you start
- 7:28to see more about Arthur's personality when you
- 7:31don't have a choice. Right. It was a good call.
- 7:35Is your next note, what the f***, Micah? Because
- 7:38mine is. What is wrong with Micah? What is he
- 7:43doing? I don't have an explanation besides he's
- 7:46probably just trying to... He's chasing after
- 7:49a girl with ill intentions, is what I'm assuming.
- 7:53And he is just not taking instructions from Dutch.
- 7:56Isn't that cause for death in Dutch's eyes for
- 8:00when you're disobeying orders and subordination?
- 8:04Not only is he not taking... and stopping when
- 8:08people are telling him to stop, he pretty much
- 8:10burns the place down because he's such a stupid
- 8:13idiot. Yeah, he's being completely reckless,
- 8:16chasing around the table and then gets tired
- 8:18of that, so tosses the table over and sets everything
- 8:21on fire. It was funny because earlier in the
- 8:24scene, you were like, this might be a dumb question,
- 8:26but why don't they just move here if all this
- 8:28stuff is here? And now it's like, well, now they
- 8:31don't even have that choice. Well, after that...
- 8:37They take her back to camp with them. We find
- 8:40out her name is Sadie Adler and it was her and
- 8:43her husband's property. And she goes, he was
- 8:45my husband. And then the game cuts to his corpse.
- 8:49Like how disrespectful, even though the shot
- 8:53is pretty cinematic, but still. Going back to
- 8:56Dutch's personality and we'll have to do some
- 8:58kind of analysis. The fact that he's like reassuring
- 9:01her and not leaving her to die. I think that's
- 9:04how he inspires loyalty. This is like every single
- 9:07thing I know about him makes me so conflicted
- 9:10because I know what it ends up being. We're on
- 9:13the next mission and Arthur, well, Abigail walks
- 9:18up to Arthur and says, hi. And Arthur can absolutely
- 9:22tell she's not just saying hi. She has an ulterior
- 9:24motive and it cracks me up. He's very much just
- 9:26like, hi. What do you want? Can I leave? What
- 9:30she wants is for him to go search for John because
- 9:32he's been gone for a couple days. Also, why is
- 9:36Jon taking such a beating in this conversation?
- 9:38He's not even here. He's been taking a beating
- 9:41this entire game. And that's something we'll
- 9:44have to talk about is the relationship between
- 9:46Arthur and Jon and this group. But also, it makes
- 9:51me question why is Arthur not going out of his
- 9:54way to look for Jon or Dutch doing the same thing
- 9:57asking Arthur to find him when it seems like
- 9:59they would have done it for anyone else. Like
- 10:01the fact that they... bringing Sadie so easily
- 10:03into this group, but then they're also just letting
- 10:07John be out there by himself. I know. He's very
- 10:11resistant, but Hosea sends Javier and Arthur
- 10:13out to go look. And I just love the line that
- 10:18Javier says. He's like, if it was the other way
- 10:20around, he'd look for me. And that has to be
- 10:23a joke, right? From game one when John's hunting
- 10:27down Javier. I just didn't even think of it as
- 10:31a joke. Which, I don't know, I mean, the game
- 10:33is 16 years old, but the second game is more
- 10:36popular. Do we need to say spoilers for game
- 10:38one? Arthur asks Javier about the boat as well,
- 10:42and he says suddenly they were everywhere, speaking
- 10:45about Pinkertons, which the Pinkertons were Ross
- 10:48and Fordham from game one. And he says Dutch
- 10:51killed a girl in a bad way. Arthur responds,
- 10:54that ain't like him, though. So are we talking
- 10:57about Heidi McCourt? I was thinking, is this
- 10:59in addition to... Heidi, or what's going on?
- 11:04Because multiple questions. When the stranger
- 11:07man comes and talks about it, it almost feels
- 11:09like John was the one who killed her, right?
- 11:13But I'm wondering, did Dutch kill her to spare
- 11:18John from experiencing that? Or is he just taking
- 11:22the blame? I want to look now. Yeah. I still
- 11:25have the document of the full dialogue of the
- 11:28strange man meetings. Good thing you kept it.
- 11:30Post. Toast. Can you be quiet, please? So I have
- 11:37the dialogue document pulled up from the strange
- 11:40man from game one. He says, do you remember Heidi
- 11:44McCourt's face? She was the girl Dutch Vanderland
- 11:47shot in the head on the raid on the ferry a few
- 11:49years back. Same one you got shot on. Pretty
- 11:52girl until her eye was hanging out by a thread
- 11:54of tendon and her brain was plastered over a
- 11:56wall. Oh my God. Okay. So I'm pretty sure. That's
- 12:02who we're referencing. The fact that they notice
- 12:05that's so out of line for Dutch's personality
- 12:08makes me wonder what other things were going
- 12:11wrong during that. Or maybe was he like drugged
- 12:14up or something? How did Dutch killing her play
- 12:18out? I don't know. I would like to see that.
- 12:21I mean, not in a gross way, but I want to see
- 12:25what happened. It's kind of funny because you
- 12:28were just talking about how it shows. who Dutch
- 12:31was, at least that he took Sadie in. But then
- 12:34we have this immediate comparison of him killing
- 12:37this girl in a bad way, as Javier puts it. So
- 12:40it seems like maybe there's almost two sides
- 12:43to Dutch. Even in this episode, we're going to
- 12:46get whiplash from Dutch's personality, or at
- 12:49least I did, watching this, knowing that everything
- 12:51I know about his past and then his future. And
- 12:55it's also so weird to see that Javier was really
- 12:59eager to find John and was like, oh, this way,
- 13:02this way, come here. To see Javier being the
- 13:05only one to ask John if he's okay and then later
- 13:08down the road, we know that that's not the way
- 13:10their relationship is anymore. It's just, again,
- 13:13very jarring to see how certain things will play
- 13:17out that we don't know yet. Right. We have a
- 13:20lot of questions that can all be summed into
- 13:22what happened. So then we finally find John and
- 13:27he's on the ledge. And he looks battered. What
- 13:31happened? Yeah, we found his horse dead. So I
- 13:34think the wolves got his horse. And that was
- 13:37a distraction enough for him to make a run for
- 13:40it. But he still got bit in the face, I guess.
- 13:43So now we know how we got his scars. Also, I
- 13:45love the little brief RDR1 soundtrack. We fight
- 13:50off a few wolves that are still prowling for
- 13:52John to make it back to camp. But I just have
- 13:55to comment on when the wolves first show back
- 13:57up and John like... being carried by Arthur lifts
- 14:00his head to look and then just hangs his head
- 14:03again like he's just so done with these wolves
- 14:06you guys again I do feel bad that you had to
- 14:09kill them like I understand why but I wasn't
- 14:12a big fan of watching you kill them I know once
- 14:14you've been killed by wolves a few times in this
- 14:16game though you start to lose some empathy towards
- 14:19them so back at camp we hear that the plan is
- 14:23to keep heading east after the weather breaks
- 14:25the west is too dangerous for them And that's
- 14:28kind of where the scene ends, and then we start
- 14:30in on scene three, which is camp interactions
- 14:34and the mission Old Friends. So Arthur walks
- 14:38in on a conversation between Dutch and Hosea.
- 14:40Hosea seems concerned about the state of things.
- 14:43Dutch, not at all. He says, we need money. I'm
- 14:47kind of getting nervous about Hosea, that maybe
- 14:51he seems more like a consultant within this group,
- 14:55but people don't listen to him. And then I think
- 14:59he's going to get himself killed by Dutch. I'm
- 15:02kind of nervous about him. Yeah. Arthur then
- 15:05checks in on the rest of the gang members. And
- 15:07they all seem pretty dejected and obviously cold.
- 15:11Things get a little testy in the men's bunk.
- 15:14But Dutch puts an end to it. He thinks Colmo
- 15:16Driscoll is on the mountain to hunt them down.
- 15:20Arthur says, I doubt that. And he responds, no,
- 15:22you're just doubting me. And that kind of pisses
- 15:25me off. Like, you could just take a beat to think
- 15:27about it, Dutch. I'm getting the whiplash because
- 15:29he seems so stubborn. And I take back everything
- 15:32I said about him being a great leader because
- 15:34it's moments like this where he's not listening
- 15:36to someone who isn't acting emotionally. And
- 15:40that kind of drives me nuts. All right. What's
- 15:43your next note? Who is Annabelle to Dutch? Yeah,
- 15:48he says when they're talking about Colm on the
- 15:50way to their camp, he says, some things I can
- 15:51forgive, some I can forget. What he did to Annabelle,
- 15:54I can't do neither. And Arthur responds, you
- 15:57killed his brother. Which is a brave thing for
- 15:59him to say after the conversation they just had.
- 16:01But it also makes me respect Arthur so much more
- 16:03that he says the facts. He's not going to kind
- 16:08of tiptoe around things. And yeah, all we know
- 16:12about Annabelle is she was important to him at
- 16:14this point. But also, like, how long ago was
- 16:17this? How long have you been nurturing this anger?
- 16:21So they get to camp, or a ridge above the Driscoll
- 16:24camp, and they're spying with binoculars. And
- 16:26we see someone. running very awkwardly. I get
- 16:29it's snowing out, but his feet were not sinking
- 16:31into the snow. He was running like a fool up
- 16:34to Colm, who then double slaps him, and then
- 16:37he runs off. So Colm leaves, and then they start
- 16:42a shootout, clear out the camp, they steal dynamite,
- 16:45find a map, and learn that the train they were
- 16:48planning to rob belongs to someone named Leviticus
- 16:50Cornwall. Part of me feels like Colm has a deal
- 16:55with the Pinkertons saying that if you spare
- 16:57us, We'll give you another gang to go for. It
- 17:02makes me a bit worried about where is this information
- 17:06coming from. So Dutch does a little mini speech
- 17:10and says, we allowed ourselves to get a step
- 17:12behind in Blackwater. That won't happen again.
- 17:14And then they head back to camp. And on the way,
- 17:16Arthur captures the O'Driscoll that we saw get
- 17:19slapped. His name is Kieran Duffy. And he says,
- 17:22I've only been running with them a couple months.
- 17:25All right, moving on to scene four, which is
- 17:27the hunting with Charles scene. I have literally
- 17:29three bullet points. One. We meet Pierce and
- 17:33the camp cook, and he sends Arthur out hunting,
- 17:36and Charles demands that he go with even though
- 17:38he has an injured hand. He seems to want to do
- 17:42things even though he can't use his hands, and
- 17:46so he'll just guide Arthur into doing what needs
- 17:49to be done. He's a go -getter, and I like that
- 17:52about him. And he doesn't want to starve. That
- 17:55too. So Arthur kills a couple deer. And then
- 17:58when they're heading back, we learn that Charles
- 18:00has been with the gang six months. And Arthur
- 18:03has been with the gang for 20 years. All right.
- 18:08Scene five, next mission. It's a few days later.
- 18:12We hear Arthur's journal again. He checks in
- 18:15on John when Dutch interrupts. He says, I think
- 18:18it's time for the train. And I just have to say
- 18:20again, poor John, he takes another beating. Dutch
- 18:22calling him an idiot. Like, what has John done?
- 18:26And it's not his fault for falling off, like
- 18:28fighting wolves. You know what I mean? Is that
- 18:30he was brave enough to go out in the snow with
- 18:33Micah, but going separate ways. And he was doing
- 18:37for the good of the gang. So I don't understand
- 18:39why they're giving him such a hard time. Well,
- 18:42yeah. And why did we send the man with a gunshot
- 18:44wound out into the frigid night and not like
- 18:47Bill or Javier? Who are not injured. Anyway,
- 18:51Hosea wants to leave instead of robbing the train.
- 18:54He says, I just don't want any more folks to
- 18:56die, Dutch. Leviticus Cornwall is no joke. And
- 18:59I totally see where Hosea is coming from. Their
- 19:02gang is only going to get smaller and smaller
- 19:03if they keep losing people and it's going to
- 19:06be hard to survive. Right. But Dutch is just,
- 19:08again, so stubborn about wanting to take out,
- 19:13use his group to take out his own personal feud
- 19:16against Colm. So they get to where the train
- 19:20will be. Arthur helps Bill set the fuse. Things
- 19:25go wrong. The detonator does not blow. And Dutch
- 19:29kind of blames Arthur a little bit. And Arthur's
- 19:32like, oh, so now it's my fault? You're pathetic.
- 19:34But then later he says, well, I hooked up the
- 19:36wire, but we won't mention that. They should
- 19:38have known better to have Billy set things up
- 19:41and be the one who blows up the detonator. It's
- 19:43just Bill. Yes. I don't know where the Billy
- 19:47came from. I don't either. Probably outlast.
- 19:52Start to blend together. It ends up just being
- 19:56Lenny and Arthur that make it onto the train
- 19:58after they chase after it. There's a guard up
- 20:00ahead and Lenny's like, there's another guard
- 20:01up ahead. You want me to take him? And Arthur's
- 20:03like, sure. And he just runs up and shoves him
- 20:06over the edge of the train. I thought he was
- 20:09going to shoot him or stab him or something.
- 20:11That was so much better. There's a glitch where
- 20:14you had to keep stabbing the guy, the guard.
- 20:17And it just wouldn't let you kill him. And in
- 20:20that moment watching it is that previously you
- 20:22spared people from dying. Yet here, this is like
- 20:26the first time I'm seeing Arthur so aggressive.
- 20:29So remind me of the scene when if he dies and
- 20:33I have a feeling that he has to die, right? In
- 20:35the end of this game, if I determine if he's
- 20:37a mother respecter or a mother, I'm kind of nervous
- 20:40because it seems like this that remind me that
- 20:43he's actually not that. Good of a good guy, you
- 20:47know what I mean? Is that they're still killing
- 20:49innocent people who are just doing their jobs.
- 20:52And so, again, kind of like Dutch, where I'm
- 20:55going back and forth on his character. It's moments
- 20:58like this that makes me go back and forth on
- 21:00Arthur. Yeah. And it's kind of like in Yakuza
- 21:04when we have this issue. We're like, relatively
- 21:06to being in the Yakuza, are they a good person
- 21:10or not? Yeah. We then find the bonds. And Dutch
- 21:15leaves Arthur to deal with the prisoners while
- 21:17the rest of the gang rides back to Coulter. At
- 21:19least the mission was successful. Nobody died.
- 21:24Okay, final scene. Arthur returns to camp and
- 21:27the first thing we hear is Grimshaw yelling at
- 21:29Marybeth for reading and not helping. The gang
- 21:32is packing up camp to head to Horseshoe Overlook
- 21:35on Hosea's suggestion. John's really not doing
- 21:38well as they load him up onto the cart. I feel
- 21:42like if I didn't know better, I would have thought
- 21:44he would have died. can we get this man a blanket
- 21:47while he's in this wagon? So they head out and
- 21:51eventually we're out of the snow and then we
- 21:54cross the river where we get the classic Arthur
- 21:57line of I broke the goddamn wheel. So he, Jose,
- 22:02and Charles stop to fix the wagon and they notice
- 22:05they're being watched from the cliff. Charles
- 22:07says if they wanted trouble we wouldn't have
- 22:09seen them. We get more of Charles' backstory
- 22:12which made me really sad but I thought that Maybe
- 22:16he knew how the Indians worked because he is
- 22:21part Indian. Yeah, for sure. But either way,
- 22:24I kind of like the scene to give the characters
- 22:27a bit more depth and backstory, which will make
- 22:32me even more curious when the time comes when
- 22:36something happens and then we see where Red Dead
- 22:40Redemption 1 happened. When the time comes. Yeah.
- 22:44You gotta run and don't look back. Okay. No,
- 22:48I agree. I mean, we get a lot in this scene.
- 22:50We get Charles's backstory and then Hosea explaining
- 22:52to Arthur how, as he puts it, the Indians in
- 22:55this park got sold a very raw deal. Charles kind
- 22:58of like gets offended a little bit or pushes
- 23:01back and Hosea finds a way to blame Arthur for
- 23:04offending Charles. I fear I was perhaps trying
- 23:07to simplify something more complicated for the
- 23:10benefit of our block -headed driver here. And
- 23:13that's when we learn Arthur says, don't forget
- 23:15Hosea is a con man born and bred. So that's kind
- 23:19of where we learn more Hosea's role in terms
- 23:22of criminal behavior. When we're closer to camp,
- 23:28they're talking about the ferry job and Hosea
- 23:30says, maybe it's me who changed and not him.
- 23:33But we kept telling him that ferry job didn't
- 23:35feel right. Speaking of Dutch, I find that interesting
- 23:38because I feel like we're already making excuses
- 23:40for Dutch. Like, oh, maybe I changed and he didn't.
- 23:43So would Jose get killed if he said that? Dutch
- 23:45has changed a lot. And knowing how loyal Arthur
- 23:48is to Dutch, it just might be Jose's way of staying
- 23:52smart and sparing himself from future kind of
- 23:55issues with Dutch. Exactly. Yeah. I think it's
- 23:58kind of like they're all loyal to him. But at
- 24:01what point do we question him? And I think Jose
- 24:03is already at that point and nobody else is.
- 24:06And I think we see that because they get to the
- 24:08new camp and Hosea immediately gets into it with
- 24:11Dutch about Blackwater, his and Arthur's lead,
- 24:13Micah pushing for the ferry job. Dutch basically
- 24:16just responds, I kept us together. And Hosea
- 24:19says, I guess I'm just worried. I want folks
- 24:21safe before I go. I guess by that he means die
- 24:24because he's kind of old. Dutch is again reacting
- 24:27very emotionally to having someone question his
- 24:31decisions. Dutch and Hosea then address the gang.
- 24:34Dutch says, get to work. And by comparison, Hosea
- 24:38says, get to work, but stay out of trouble. And
- 24:41then we learn that anything that the gang members
- 24:43bring in, the camp gets its slice. And then we
- 24:46end with Miss Grimshaw yelling at Tilly. Miss
- 24:50Jackson, I've seen shit with more common sense
- 24:53than you. And then chapter two, Horseshoe Overlook.
- 24:57I'm kind of nervous about Arthur's future. Because
- 25:01if this is going to be like a parallel to how
- 25:03John dies in the end. Right. to to complete the
- 25:08whole redemption arc is arthur gonna die too
- 25:10and maybe based on the trailer i'm like having
- 25:13all these questions that is maybe arthur gonna
- 25:16die to save john and that is his redemption yeah
- 25:20well it's i mean a question we've all we all
- 25:24had playing because it's like arthur's not in
- 25:26the first game and he seems like a pretty prominent
- 25:28member so like i'm kind of nervous and i'm with
- 25:31you guys on on that now watching this and knowing
- 25:34what i know We're one chapter down, six chapters
- 25:38to go, but the other chapters will not be one
- 25:41episode. So there's a lot of time left with this
- 25:44game. Any other summarizing thoughts for you?
- 25:47Should we move on to stats? Stats. Let's do it.
- 25:50Okay, I have two stats and I have a secret stat
- 25:53that I'm not going to reveal until the summary
- 25:55episode. I did not see a bouquet of flowers,
- 25:57so that carries over to episode two. Do you think
- 26:01you can guess my two stats? One of them, you
- 26:04got it. It's my favorite stat ever. You gotta
- 26:07guess it. Headshots. No. I have one close to
- 26:12that. I'll tell you this one because you haven't
- 26:14seen it yet. But number of times that Arthur's
- 26:17hat gets shot off his head is one of them. But
- 26:20you gotta guess my other one. It's my all -time
- 26:23favorite stat to track. How many? Is it driving
- 26:28related? No. You know? Come on. Don't overthink
- 26:33it. Number of animals you killed? No. It's a
- 26:40repeated one. I've done it before. I do it a
- 26:41lot. I'm blinking. The stress. Cigarettes. Cigars.
- 26:49Yeah. There you go. Cigarettes smoked. Cigarettes
- 26:54smoked. With the subcategories of cigar and et
- 26:57cetera. Yeah. So do you want to guess? Obviously,
- 27:00I revealed Arthur's hat did not get shot off
- 27:02in this episode, but it did get shoveled off
- 27:04his head. So there's that. Do you want to guess
- 27:06how many cigarettes were smoked in this? I feel
- 27:11like four, eight. They smoked a lot here. 25?
- 27:19No. 15? I'm just going to keep spewing out numbers.
- 27:23No. Seven cigarettes and one cigar. Seven? Yeah.
- 27:30I feel like there's a lot more than seven. Do
- 27:35you want me to guess the entire game now? Yeah.
- 27:38Do you want to do just the entire game? I feel
- 27:40like that's easier then. By chapter. Let's do
- 27:4442. That was my first guess. 42. Okay. 42. Total.
- 27:51Should I guess has shot off? Oh, yes. I don't
- 27:56know. Is 12 too low? Let's do 12. I don't know.
- 28:00I haven't tallied them. All right. 12. It only
- 28:02gets shot off when you're in a fight scene, right?
- 28:05And someone shoots at you. Mm -hmm. I feel like
- 28:08you'd be pretty good at dodging them. And this
- 28:10is my confidence in your skill set. So I want
- 28:13to just go with 12. Damn, you're dodging bullets
- 28:14now? Yeah, you're dodging bullets. All right.
- 28:19Well, sounds good. I'm excited to tally that
- 28:22up and see how close you are. Anything else you
- 28:26want to say for chapter one? No, but I'm very
- 28:30excited to be back into this routine and analyzing
- 28:34this game. And it's such a great game to analyze
- 28:37too. I'm excited. We've never done a season like
- 28:40this before, so we'll see how it plays out. But
- 28:44yeah, I'm excited. We'll be back next week with
- 28:48part one of chapter two. What happens? Do you
- 28:51count us off? I forget. Yeah, I think I do. Audacity
- 28:55on one, three, two, one. Thank you for listening.
- 28:58And don't forget to send in any questions, comments,
- 29:00or game suggestions. You can find all our contact
- 29:03info on our website, replayreviewspod .com, or
- 29:06contact us directly through our site. Did we
- 29:08completely miss something? Are we way off the
- 29:10mark? Or you just want us to take a deeper look
- 29:12at anything from the game? We'll tackle any topics
- 29:14you all want to hear in our season wrap -up episode.
- 29:17We also have a Reddit where we discuss anything
- 29:19we're curious about. Go take a look and let us
- 29:21know what you're thinking. Our theme music is
- 29:24Condemned by Eggie Toast. They'll play you out
- 29:26and we'll be back next week.