Latest / Wisdom of the Ages Library / 08 - A Confession - Leo Tolstory
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter eight of a confession by Leo Tolstoy. All these doubts, which I
- 0:04am now able to express more or less systematically, I could not have then
- 0:08expressed. I then only felt that, however logically inevitable were my conclusions concerning
- 0:13the vanity of life, confirmed as they were by the greatest thinkers, there
- 0:17was something not right about them. Whether it was the reasoning itself or in
- 0:20the statement of the question, I did not know. I only felt that
- 0:23the conclusion was rationally convincing, but that it was insufficient. All these conclusions
- 0:28could not so convince me as to make me do what followed for my reasoning,
- 0:32that is to say, kill myself. And I should have told an
- 0:35untruth had I, without killing myself, said that reason had brought me to
- 0:38the point that I had reached. Reason worked, But something else was also
- 0:42working, which I can only call a consciousness of life. A force was
- 0:45working which compelled me to turn my attention to this and not to that.
- 0:49And it was this force which extricated me from my desperate situation and turned my
- 0:53mind in quite another direction. This force compelled me to turn my attention to
- 0:57the fact that I and a few hundred similar people are not the whole of
- 1:00mankind, and that I did not yet know the life of mankind. Looking
- 1:03at the narrow circle of my equals, I saw only people who had not
- 1:07understood the question, or who had understood it and drowned it in life's intoxication,
- 1:12or had understood it and ended their lives, or had understood it and
- 1:15yet from weakness for living out their desperate life, and I saw no others.
- 1:19It seemed to me that the narrow circle of rich, learned and leisured
- 1:23people to which I belonged formed the whole of humanity, and that those millards
- 1:26of others who have lived in are living were cattle of some sort, not
- 1:30real people. Strange, incredibly incomprehensible, as it now seems to me that
- 1:34I could, while reasoning about life, overlook the whole life of mankind that
- 1:38surrounded me on all sides, that I could to such a degree blunder so
- 1:42absolutely as to think that my life and Solomon's and Schopenhauer's is the real normal
- 1:47life, and that the life of the millards is a circumstance undeserving of attention.
- 1:52Strange as this is now to me, I see that so it was
- 1:55in the delusion of my pride and of intellect. It seemed to me so
- 1:57indubitable that I in soil all men in Schopenhauer had stated the question so truly
- 2:02and exactly that nothing else was possible. So indubitable did it seem that all
- 2:07those millards consisted of men who had not yet arrived in an apprehension of all
- 2:10the profundity of the question, that I sought for the meaning of my life
- 2:15without at once occurring me to ask, but what meaning is and has been
- 2:17given to their lives by all the millards of common folk who live and have
- 2:22lived in the world. I long lived in this state of lunacy, which
- 2:25in fact, if not in words, is particularly characteristic of us very liberal
- 2:29and worded people. But thanks either to the strange physical affection I have for
- 2:34the real laboring people, which compelled me to understand them and to see that
- 2:37they are not so stupid as we suppose, or thanks to the sincerity of
- 2:40my conviction that I could know nothing beyond the fact that the best I could
- 2:44do was to hang myself. At any rate, I instinctively felt that if
- 2:47I wished to live and understand the meaning of life. I must seek this
- 2:51meaning not among those who have lost it and wish to kill themselves, but
- 2:53among those millards of the past and the present who make life, and who
- 2:58support the burden of their own lives and of oars. Also. And I
- 3:00considered the enormous masses of those simple, unlearned, and poor people who have
- 3:05lived in our living, and I saw something quite different. I saw that,
- 3:08with rare exceptions, all those millards who have lived in our living do
- 3:13not fit any of my divisions. That I could not class them as not
- 3:15understanding the question, for they themselves stated and replied to it with extraordinary clearness.
- 3:21Nor could I consider them epicureans, for their life consists of more privations
- 3:24and sufferings than of enjoyments. Still less could I consider them as irrationally dragging
- 3:29on a meaningless existence, For every act of their life, as well as
- 3:31death, is explained by them. To kill themselves they considered the greatest evil.
- 3:37It appeared that all mankind had a knowledge, unacknowledged and despised by me,
- 3:40of the meaning of life. It appeared that reasonable knowledge does not give
- 3:45the meaning of life, but excludes life. While the meaning attributed to life
- 3:49by millards of people. By all humanity rests on some despised pseudo knowledge.
- 3:53Rational knowledge presented by the learned and wise, denies the meaning of life.
- 3:58But the enormous masses of men, the whole, the whole of mankind,
- 4:00received that meaning and irrational knowledge. And that irrational knowledge is faith. That
- 4:05very thing which I cannot but reject. It is God one in three the
- 4:10creation in six days, the devils and angels, and all the rest that
- 4:13I cannot accept as long as I retain my reason. My position was terrible.
- 4:16I knew that I could find nothing among the path of reasonable knowledge except
- 4:20a denial of life. And there in faith was nothing but a denial of
- 4:25reason, which was yet more impossible for me than a denial of life.
- 4:29From rational knowledge, it appeared that life is an evil. People know this,
- 4:32and it is in their power to end life. Yet they lived and
- 4:34still live, and I myself live, though I have long known that life
- 4:39is senseless and and evil. By faith, it appears that in order to
- 4:42understand the meaning of life, I must renounce my reason, the very thing
- 4:46for which alone a meaning is required. End of Chapter eight