Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Public Health Grand Rounds with Host Dora Ann Mills and Guest Brian Castrucci DrPH, MA
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Dora Ann Mills, Senior Advisor for Public Health at MaineHealth.
- 0:05Welcome to our Public Health Grand Rounds, where about every month we explore
- 0:10a relevant public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 0:15These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean
- 0:20and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 0:26Please note that guests' opinions are their own.
- 0:29Thank you. Welcome to MaineHealth Public Health Grand Rounds.
- 0:32I'm Dora Mills, the host, and great pleasure for me to introduce Dr.
- 0:38Brian Castrucci, whom we are very honored to host today. Thank you so much, Brian, for joining us.
- 0:46Brian is president and CEO of the de Beaumont Foundation, where he has helped
- 0:51make strengthening the public health workforce,
- 0:54building partnerships, and improving communication and trust central to the
- 0:59foundation's work, which of course could not be even more critical in the days post-pandemic.
- 1:06He brings the perspective of someone who has really done public health on the ground.
- 1:10I think he worked in WIC, I think, years ago. And before joining de Beaumont in
- 1:152012, he spent a decade as an applied epidemiologist and a leadership position
- 1:21in state and local health departments in Georgia,
- 1:24Texas, and Philadelphia, so very wide places.
- 1:28And the de Beaumont Foundation is based actually out of the D.C. area where he lives now.
- 1:33He holds a doctorate in public health leadership from UNC, the
- 1:36University of North Carolina, at Chapel Hill, and a master's degree in socio-medical
- 1:42sciences from Columbia.
- 1:43Many of us know his work through initiatives such as the Public Health Communications
- 1:48Collaborative and the Public Health Workforce Interests and Needs Survey, or PHWINS.
- 1:54He is also co-editor of Talking Health, A New Way to Communicate About Public
- 1:59Health, and Building Strategic Skills for Better Health.
- 2:02His work speaks directly to a challenge we all face.
- 2:07How do we help people understand what public health makes possible and earn
- 2:12their trust when evidence, uncertainty, and deeply held values meet.
- 2:19That question matters whether we're speaking with a patient,
- 2:21a community partner, or a policymaker.
- 2:24So we are delighted and so honored to have Brian help us think through these things today.
- 2:30Please join me in welcoming him in a biography, the book, I mean,
- 2:35so the book details. He's got his book in you.
- 2:39Ellen provide us the name of his book there and the link to buying it.
- 2:44We do have 25 copies. We'll be giving out to those from MaineHealth who are attending live.
- 2:50But also, he's written and co-authored a number of books. So thank you so much
- 2:56for joining us, Brian. I'm passing the baton over to you.
- 3:00Thank you so much. I started to sound like an academic here in my old age.
- 3:04I am a full-on practitioner, 10 years in different health departments.
- 3:09I led programs like family planning and WIC and MCH.
- 3:13And so today, we're going to talk a little about trust. Just from a philosophical
- 3:19standpoint, what I hope you take away from this are resources that you can use.
- 3:26Ultimately, I hope you go, oh my God, what a great guy, good looking, he was smart.
- 3:31But there's nothing I'm going to say today that's going to change a lot.
- 3:34But if folks can use some of these resources, I think that's where the rubber meets the road.
- 3:40I hope this is a first date and not a one-night stand, and so I hope to hear from you afterward.
- 3:47de Beaumont is here to help you, and so if there's ever a thing that we can do
- 3:51to make your life more easier in your practice, we want to hear from you.
- 3:56Let's really think about, you know, three things that we have to do to improve.
- 4:02Our public health practice. You know, first, We have to communicate better.
- 4:06We have to build deep relationships with all people, all, all people,
- 4:12not just the people who like us, right? It's like your kids.
- 4:15You have your kids, no matter if they like you or they don't like you,
- 4:18and on any given day, it can go either way, but you've got to build deep relationships,
- 4:22and ultimately, we have to upskill the workforce.
- 4:25So starting with communicating better, public health has some basic inherent
- 4:31problems with communication.
- 4:33First, we have no brand identity. When you see any, you don't even need the
- 4:38language on these cans to know what they are, right?
- 4:42White lettering on a red can, that's Coke. Black lettering on a red can,
- 4:46that's Coke Zero. You know, FedEx, Starbucks.
- 4:51These are things you see and you immediately know what they are.
- 4:54What is our brand in public health?
- 4:57This is something we have to struggle with and be more thoughtful.
- 5:02For, you know, I think back to my daughter when she was younger,
- 5:06she was asked by a friend, what is the difference between your dad and a pediatrician?
- 5:13And Chloe sat for a second and said, well, pediatrician helps one person at a time.
- 5:19My dad helps everybody all the time.
- 5:22What if that was what people thought when they heard public health,
- 5:26right? And not what they usually do, which is a public health. What is that?
- 5:31What do you mean? Shots for people who don't have money, right? That's what it is.
- 5:35So again, we don't have that brand identity. But I also cultivated that in my kids.
- 5:42When you think about the, like, Melissa and Doug, you know, dress-up doctor
- 5:46kit, you know, my father-in-law gave my kids that when they were younger.
- 5:52And I took the stethoscope away, gave
- 5:54them a notepad, and we did outbreak investigations amongst their dolls.
- 5:58But that helped them understand what public health was. But think about,
- 6:03you know, what did you play when you were a kid? You were a teacher, firefighter.
- 6:07You didn't play epidemiologist. You didn't play public health administrator.
- 6:11But that's how we start to actually understand what public health is.
- 6:15So we don't have this brand identity, and this is a huge challenge.
- 6:19We also don't have a common definition. So remember Pictionary?
- 6:24I used to love Pictionary.
- 6:25You know, you'd get a little card, and you would draw it. So this is,
- 6:28if I picked up a card, and it said hamburger, I would draw this.
- 6:32And y'all can look at that photo on the screen and be like, yeah,
- 6:36okay, that's a hamburger.
- 6:37I could get that. That's one point for us.
- 6:40And then if I pick up the next one, it's plane. And it's like,
- 6:43okay, I can draw a plane. This works. I get another point.
- 6:47But now think about, you know, all the people on this call, really smart people
- 6:52who've worked in health and public health.
- 6:54What if you pick up the card and it said public health? What would you draw?
- 6:58What would you even begin to draw? And if we can't draw it and we're public
- 7:05health experts, how do we expect lay people and legislators to understand what
- 7:10public health is when we can't easily define it.
- 7:14And the reason we can't define it is because we have really never built brain
- 7:17architecture with public health, okay?
- 7:22On the screen, you have all of these, like, you know, there are thousands of
- 7:28television shows that center physicians.
- 7:33We know what a physician is because we build the brain architecture for what a physician is.
- 7:38I mean, please, even Disney has a show about Doc McStuffins,
- 7:44and Doc McStuffins introduces physicians and what physicians do at a very early
- 7:49age to kids, even though I would argue most of what Doc McStuffins does is public
- 7:53health. We don't talk about it that way.
- 7:56So we have to figure out how are we building brain architecture for people to
- 8:02understand what public health is.
- 8:03And if we're going to continue this, you know, we're the silent presence that
- 8:07no one knows is there, always helping you, then no one's going to know what we are.
- 8:12Right. If you had elves in your house cleaning up every night,
- 8:15but you never knew they were there, you wouldn't value them.
- 8:18Kind of wake up every morning, go, oh, my house is clean. I guess I just go
- 8:21to bed and I wake up, my house is clean. That's a conclusion you would draw.
- 8:26You didn't know the elves were there because the elves never told you they were
- 8:29there. I fear that public health is sometimes working in that same way.
- 8:33Right. And when you look at these kind of shows on the screen here,
- 8:38you even have Quincy. I mean, Quincy was a medical examiner.
- 8:40We did a whole show about a medical examiner and people watched it.
- 8:45And so I can't believe that there's not something compelling about public health
- 8:49and our stories that we shouldn't be sharing with a broad number of people.
- 8:54Part of this challenge is, and you probably didn't think we'd have a Trump photo
- 8:58in our slides today, but we have too much complexity.
- 9:02Whether you like the president or you don't, you will always remember what he
- 9:06wanted to do to Hillary. He wanted to lock her up.
- 9:09You're going to remember what he's always, always remember what he wanted to
- 9:12do on the southern border. Build that wall.
- 9:14And if someone says to you, what's public health? Well, you need like three
- 9:18podcasts, five lectures, nine degrees, seven white papers. and then you'll understand
- 9:23a very small part of public health.
- 9:25When do you stop listening? After the podcasts or after the lectures? So what are we?
- 9:31Public health keeps people alive. Public health extends life expectancy. Public health what?
- 9:37I like to say that public health is about the safety, security,
- 9:41and economic prosperity of our nation.
- 9:43That public health helps every person in every corner of every county of this country.
- 9:49But I can't be saying those things alone. that's not brand identity that's a
- 9:53talking point so how do we start to agree on what we are.
- 9:59And we actually have people embrace this kind of idea of public health.
- 10:04And that idea of safety, security, and economic prosperity, that works for right,
- 10:10for left, for center, because you can find something in there.
- 10:13And it centers you, because you care about the safety of your family,
- 10:18security of your family, prosperity of your family. And so if public health
- 10:22can deliver on those things, I want to know what public health is.
- 10:26So when we think about building our communication skills and what we can do,
- 10:32we have two photos juxtaposed to each other on the slide.
- 10:36One is Dumbledore from the Harry Potter series, and one is Richard Simmons.
- 10:43So why are Dumbledore and Richard Simmons on this slide? Because there are no magic words.
- 10:50Unfortunately, we are not Dumbledore. I wish I was, right? I wish I had some
- 10:55incantation that would make everyone love public health.
- 10:59We don't. And so the question I get often is, what words do we use with Republicans
- 11:04to make them love public health?
- 11:06There are no words because I am not Dumbledore.
- 11:10I am Richard Simmons. Who knew that that's who I would become in my career?
- 11:17Because Richard Simmons was about doing the work, getting the training, putting in the hours.
- 11:23And that's what we have to do in our communications abilities in public health.
- 11:27It's a muscle and it's a muscle that we're going to have to work.
- 11:31And so just like if you're going to the gym for the first time in 50 years,
- 11:35the muscles aren't quite as strong as if you've been in that gym every day for the past 20 years.
- 11:41We have to embrace working with communications and communication skills in a
- 11:48much more aggressive way like it is a muscle,
- 11:52because that's how we're going to advance our own ability to communicate more effectively.
- 11:57We're going to have to show up, listen, act, and tell stories.
- 12:01I'm calling this slats, right? This is how you start to build trust and communicate
- 12:07more effectively. You show up.
- 12:11Think about your kids. Why do your kids trust you?
- 12:14Because you show up. If I've never gone to one of my kids' shows and I say,
- 12:20okay, I'm going to be at the show this Friday, they are not going to believe you.
- 12:25They are not going to trust that because they have a whole history of you not showing up.
- 12:31Are we listening or are we trying to correct everybody? Listening is what we want to do.
- 12:36I do fear sometimes that people think that they need to improve their communication
- 12:41skills to help prove other people that they're wrong more quickly.
- 12:46That's not communication, that's debate.
- 12:49So we need to be effective in listening, hearing what their problems are,
- 12:52hearing why they believe something, not just telling them they're wrong.
- 12:56We have to act. We have to do something. That's how trust is built, by actual actions.
- 13:03I was in Minnesota and had a county commissioner who owned an excavating company
- 13:07say, well, if I tell you I'm going to tear up your lawn on a Thursday, but I show up on Tuesday,
- 13:14all the trust campaigns in the world is not going to fix the fact that I showed
- 13:17up two days early and tore up your lawn.
- 13:20And then we have to tell stories, right? Data are really important, but stories stick.
- 13:26Okay. Remember there was this woman once and she had a pet. Her name was Mary.
- 13:32Anybody remember what Mary's pet was? Well, take a second to remember it was a little lamb.
- 13:37Now, when was the last time you actually thought about the nursery rhyme,
- 13:40but how do we remember that Mary had a little lamb, right?
- 13:43What was the disability that the mice had? Oh, they were blind.
- 13:47What was the last time you thought about that? Stories build brain architecture
- 13:52that we then recall, even when we aren't thinking about those actual stories,
- 13:57they're just there in our brain.
- 13:59And so when you think about how we talk in healthcare and in public health,
- 14:05I remember my daughter was bit by one of our cats because she closed the cat's
- 14:10tail in a door. So it was justified. It was justified biting.
- 14:15But we get to the ER and the physician said, you know, she seems a little diaphoretic.
- 14:19And I was raised by ER nurses. And so I have a twisted and dark sense of humor.
- 14:25And so Chloe says to me after the doc walked out, it was just me,
- 14:28her and the nurse. And she said, what's what's diaphoretic? And I said,
- 14:32oh, it means you're really, really sick. And of course, the ER nurse went right along with me.
- 14:38And we had a good time until we said to her, it just means you're sweating.
- 14:41And she said, then why don't we
- 14:42say that? And I said, yeah, that's a fair question. Why don't we say that?
- 14:48Read Paul Starr's Social Transformation of American Medicine to know why we
- 14:52don't say it. We don't say it because jargon is what professionals need to justify their profession.
- 14:58And so if we're talking about prevalence and incidents and data trends and are
- 15:03not and all the fancy things we can say in public health, We're not communicating well.
- 15:09I want you to think, remember when all the data were being pulled down off of
- 15:12federal websites and we said to everybody, data, these are important data sets.
- 15:18This is a horrible thing the administration is doing. But did we actually explain why?
- 15:23What we do with those data. Now, instead of just talking about the data over
- 15:27and over, what I might do is think about a cockpit, because I fly a lot.
- 15:33And inevitably, when people get on a plane, they always look into the cockpit.
- 15:38Now, I don't know what they're looking for.
- 15:40I guess they're trying to see if the pilot looks despondent or if everybody looks happy in there.
- 15:45But inevitably, people look into the cockpit. And so what if we described this
- 15:51kind of loss of federal data, like having half of that instrument panel blacked out.
- 15:58If you looked into a cockpit on a plane that you're getting on and half of the
- 16:03instrument panel was blacked out, what would you do?
- 16:07You would get off the plane.
- 16:09That's what's happening with our health when we are losing federal data. Okay, now I understand.
- 16:15You've given me some brain architecture. I now understand that.
- 16:19When I talk about social determinants of health, I almost never say social determinants
- 16:23of health. I talk about monopoly.
- 16:26I talk about playing with my kids. right? We played Monopoly and my son always
- 16:31lost. And then I said to him once, you know, you always play as the shoe.
- 16:35You should play as the boat.
- 16:37The next time he plays the boat and he's still lost.
- 16:40But he got so upset that his mother came over and she said, you know what?
- 16:44How about when you go around, go, you get 200, Brian, but Evan,
- 16:49my son, he's going to get 300.
- 16:51And when you land on a property, you're going to pay the full rent,
- 16:54but Evan's going to pay half the rent.
- 16:57And of course, anyone who enjoys privilege, I said that was unfair.
- 17:01But what my wife understood is that to change the outcome of a game,
- 17:05you have to change the rules.
- 17:07In our society, policies are those rules. If we want different outcomes,
- 17:12we have to change policy.
- 17:13I have people come up to me years later and say, I remember that.
- 17:16I think about your son, and I think about social determinants.
- 17:19And by the way, has he ever won at Monopoly? I'm like, no, not yet.
- 17:23But it's a story that they remember. Okay. We have all of these really important
- 17:28concepts and they will help people live healthy, healthier, happier lives.
- 17:33Our failing is not our knowledge. Our failing is our inability to communicate it.
- 17:38These are just an example of
- 17:40like how pictures can help really help people really understand a concept.
- 17:47Now, these were not done for thousands of dollars. These were all done by somebody
- 17:51on a very cool website called Fiverr.
- 17:54And there are people out there, they're freelancers. And I've pitched the idea
- 17:59on each of these and found an artist who would help make it come true.
- 18:03And again, have used these repeatedly to help us understand where we are,
- 18:10communicate very complex thoughts, but in a picture.
- 18:15And you will remember if you look at these pictures you put in your brain you tend to remember them.
- 18:20All right. Resources. This is so important. All of this talk is going to have
- 18:25a lot of these resources. And there's going to be a link to this whole presentation at the end.
- 18:31And so if you're not capturing the QR codes, there'll be a link for you to access.
- 18:36But what we have are some of the resources like communicating about public health,
- 18:40which is a toolkit that we put together at DeBeaumont, our Talking Health book, which also,
- 18:45if you follow the QR code with the city in it, is now an asynchronous training
- 18:52that is done. It is really, really good.
- 18:55We had exceptional instructional designers help us with it, and we had amazing video folk.
- 19:00It's well worth doing. It's worth doing as a cohort of people that you might
- 19:04all want to take that training and then talk about it at lunch on a Friday.
- 19:08What did you learn? What do you think about this?
- 19:10But this is the way that we build that muscle I was talking about.
- 19:13If you've never accessed the Public Health Communications
- 19:16Collaborative at publichealthcollaborative.org, please do so.
- 19:21This is an amazing resource of trainings, of webinars, of materials that you can access for free.
- 19:30The most popular resource at the moment is their plain language guide of how
- 19:36to use plain language when speaking to the public.
- 19:40What we didn't have during COVID was anyone giving us messaging.
- 19:44Fauci would talk in the morning, the state health official would talk at lunch,
- 19:47and then the poor local health official around three o'clock would have to give their talking point.
- 19:51No one gave us one set of talking points. They weren't vetted. They weren't tested.
- 19:56We were all kind of shooting from the hip, but there is not a political candidate
- 19:59who goes to a podium without knowing precisely what their talking points are.
- 20:04How those talking points need to be changed depend on the audience in front of them.
- 20:08And yeah, if we had hundreds of thousands of dollars in six months lead time,
- 20:12we could do of the same thing, but that's not how we're resourced.
- 20:16So Public Health Communications Collaborative is there to really help us as
- 20:21we think through building trust.
- 20:24Engaging our public and having the resources that we need.
- 20:27There are also some resources on PHCC's website, publichealthcollaborative.org,
- 20:33where you could just like slap your logo and send it out if you don't have the
- 20:37resources to develop those things for yourself and your own organization.
- 20:42So an amazingly good resource.
- 20:45Moving now to like building deep relationships with everyone.
- 20:50This right now is kind of public health dating profile.
- 20:54And I don't know how often y'all are on the dating apps. I am not.
- 20:57I've been married for 22 years.
- 20:59So I don't let my wife know that I'm on the dating apps. I mean,
- 21:02I'm not on the dating apps. But who's swiping right on this?
- 21:06Like nobody's swiping right on this. And then, you know, during the pandemic,
- 21:11we show up at the Chamber of Commerce to introduce ourselves for the first time,
- 21:16and to tell everybody that we're shutting down the economy, we're closing all
- 21:20the businesses. That's a bad first date.
- 21:23No one wants a second date after that.
- 21:26So how are we making relationships with people who don't just necessarily believe us and trust us?
- 21:32I want us to really think through, and this is a juxtaposition.
- 21:35I want you to take home and debate over dinner tonight.
- 21:39Is public health a science or is it a religion?
- 21:42And if it's a religion, we don't question it. We don't evolve.
- 21:47We don't test new ideas, right? You look at something like vaping.
- 21:51You know, if the data on vaping, we're doing a whole thing on clean indoor air
- 21:55and someone asked me, you have vaping in your clean indoor air policy.
- 22:00What data are there that shows vaping delivers the same clean indoor air hit that tobacco does.
- 22:08Remember, we did clean indoor air because we found in New York City that people
- 22:13who weren't smoking actually had cotinine levels in their blood.
- 22:17That showed that we had a secondhand smoke problem. Is it the same with vaping?
- 22:22Have we done the research? I don't know.
- 22:25But are we a religion or are we a science? If we're a science,
- 22:29we have to know. We have to answer.
- 22:32And this picture is from a hearing, a congressional hearing on abortion,
- 22:36where Josh Hawley asked this physician, can biological men give birth?
- 22:41And she didn't answer. She said, that's complicated.
- 22:44It's a question I can't answer. And I asked my daughter, I was like,
- 22:48Chloe, can biological men give birth? She goes, Dad, that's very complicated.
- 22:52It. And I was like, wow, how is that playing in rural Maine?
- 22:56How is that playing in rural America, more conservative America, right?
- 23:00Is that our science? The science, I think, says biological men cannot give birth.
- 23:05Now, that is not the complexity.
- 23:07There is nuance there.
- 23:09But biologically, that is the fact. And so we have to be able to deliver the
- 23:14nuance while not obfuscating the fact.
- 23:18Do we want to have, you know, do we want to be impactful? Or do we want to be idealistic?
- 23:23So one of my other questions that I often just, this is one of my thought questions
- 23:28I struggle with, during the George Floyd, following the George Floyd murder, you had in D.C.
- 23:34The mayor saying, okay, it is okay to protest the George Floyd murder.
- 23:41But the same week, it was not okay to attend outdoor church.
- 23:46Make it make sense. Make it make sense.
- 23:50Is that values or is that science? I imagine the virus didn't really care what
- 23:56you were actually talking about. It just did what it does, right?
- 24:00Viruses are going to virus.
- 24:02And so all of a sudden, because we wanted to protest the George Floyd murder,
- 24:07we could gather in groups and chant.
- 24:10But remember when we weren't allowed to do volleyball outside,
- 24:13we cleared off the beaches.
- 24:15Like, remember that? We like said, no, you can't go to the beach because of COVID.
- 24:19So when did it change? Why did it change?
- 24:24And if and if this makes you uncomfortable, I'm really glad because a thousand
- 24:29public health practitioners signed a letter that said it's totally OK to protest
- 24:34the George Floyd murder.
- 24:35I think the George Floyd murder was horrible and we should be protesting it.
- 24:39However, we had to weigh that against the guidance that we had been spending
- 24:45the last umpteenth months putting in place.
- 24:48You know, as maybe I'm someone who didn't care about the George Floyd murder
- 24:52and I wasn't going to protest, but now I'm angry because you told me I couldn't
- 24:56see my grandmother at Thanksgiving. Remember that?
- 25:00We said, if you go see your grandmother, then you could be a grandma killer.
- 25:06Do you remember when we said that? That was our messaging.
- 25:09But if grandma protests with you, I guess that's cool. Then you don't kill grandma.
- 25:14So, again, I'm asking us to be thoughtful about, are we a science? Are we a religion?
- 25:21Do we want impact or do we want idealism? You know, in a perfect world,
- 25:25impact and idealism are the same.
- 25:27We don't live in a perfect world. I wish we did. But this is what I need us
- 25:31thinking about, is we're trying to communicate with a broad swath of American people.
- 25:36And we don't want to be polarized, right?
- 25:39I think we spend an enormous amount of time in public health talking about declining
- 25:45trust. We've got to measure it. We debate it. We worry about it.
- 25:49But I think it's actually the wrong question.
- 25:52Instead of asking why people don't trust public health, we should be asking
- 25:58how people actually decide who they are going to trust in the first place.
- 26:02Now, we've been doing a bunch of work on this at the Beaumont Foundation,
- 26:05and we found that people generally move through about four steps.
- 26:11They discover information, they evaluate it, they try it, and then they have
- 26:16a positive experience and they begin to trust that source.
- 26:20This is how trust evolves.
- 26:24And there are several kind of important lessons within this process.
- 26:29First, people don't necessarily judge credibility by looking at one source.
- 26:35They look for agreement across multiple sources.
- 26:39They search Google. They compare websites. They talk to people they know.
- 26:43They look for information that reinforces what they've encountered elsewhere.
- 26:46Now, that has enormous implications for public health.
- 26:51Because we tend to think about communications as one organization at a time,
- 26:56our website, our social media, our press release.
- 27:01But the public doesn't experience information one organization at a time.
- 27:05They are experiencing an entire information ecosystem.
- 27:10And what that means is that our credibility can be reinforced or undermined,
- 27:16by what people encounter elsewhere.
- 27:19Second, people evaluate credibility differently than we might expect.
- 27:24We're going to look at degrees, institutional affiliations, scientific publications.
- 27:30People may value those things, but they also ask whether the information makes
- 27:35sense, whether it agrees with other sources, and whether it helps them.
- 27:42Thirdly, experience really does matter.
- 27:45When someone follows advice and believes it works, they are more likely to return
- 27:51to that source. That is really important.
- 27:53So once people trust a source, they become less likely to question what that source tells them next.
- 28:02Think about what that means.
- 28:05You could follow an influencer's advice about nutrition.
- 28:08You could lose weight. Now that influencer has earned credibility in the eyes of their followers.
- 28:15The next time the influencer talks about vaccines, supplements,
- 28:18or some other health issue, that person may be less inclined to verify the information independently.
- 28:25This is why engaging influencers is such a strong strategy because people show
- 28:32up for influencers because it's
- 28:34some trusting relationship that has been created by following this path.
- 28:39And so how we use influencers going forward is going to be really important.
- 28:43And this is our challenge, right? So once that influencer has earned someone's trust,
- 28:50and they have influence over their health decisions, then they are actually
- 28:55doing more of the heavy lifting than our decades of scientific experience.
- 29:01Just from that one experience of their experience with the influencer versus
- 29:06our literal decades of scientific work. And listen, I get it. I get annoyed, too.
- 29:13My kids will tell me something an influencer said to them, and I'm like,
- 29:17yeah, I only have 115 scientific publications. I've written eight books,
- 29:22and they're like, yeah, Dad, but Mr. Beast knows so much more than you. And I'm like, okay.
- 29:27Well, because we're really trading in kind of a different economy,
- 29:35right? My economy is one of scientific expertise.
- 29:38This many pubs, this many citations, this many books.
- 29:42They're dealing in a, I know them, I trust them, I did this thing they told
- 29:46me to do, and it worked out for me, and now I believe them.
- 29:50So also when we're thinking about trust and building trust, people just don't evaluate facts.
- 29:57They evaluate how information makes them feel. And interestingly,
- 30:02people really do think they have a great ability to do their own research.
- 30:08They believe that they can recognize misinformation. They believe that they
- 30:12can identify bias. They believe that they can tell when someone is trying to mislead them.
- 30:17I give them great credit because I actually saw something on Facebook recently.
- 30:23And it was a new movie that was coming out.
- 30:26And I went to my wife, oh, my God, they're making a sequel to this movie until
- 30:29I realized the main character, the actor who played them had died,
- 30:33even though they were on the poster. And I'm like, oh, this is not a real thing.
- 30:37You know, I don't know about you, but I spend a fair amount of time watching
- 30:40Marvel trailers on YouTube.
- 30:42And it's hard to tell sometimes between the real Marvel trailer and the fan-made
- 30:46Marvel trailer, right? It's just getting really hard to differentiate,
- 30:50but people believe that they can do it and that confidence matters.
- 30:55So if someone believes that they're actually capable of evaluating information,
- 31:00telling them that they're misinformed isn't a particularly effective way to earn their trust,
- 31:05because now it's not about correcting the information, it's about questioning
- 31:09their ability to discern between what is fact and what is fiction.
- 31:15And nobody wants to be lectured by someone who assumes they don't know what they're talking about.
- 31:20So research that we've done has identified five emotional influences that shape
- 31:26what people find appealing in our health information.
- 31:30And so we have to remember that people actually want to learn.
- 31:34They're worried about political bias. They're suspicious of financial motives.
- 31:39They're exhausted by negativity. I mean, come on, we're living through an election
- 31:43cycle. Aren't you all just kind of exhausted by negativity?
- 31:47And they're overwhelmed by the amount of information available.
- 31:51I mean, think about that, everybody. When I was a kid, I'm 52.
- 31:55When I was a kid, if I didn't agree with my doctor, what was my option?
- 31:59I'd either find another doctor or I would check myself to the library and I
- 32:03guess look in the Encyclopedia Britannica.
- 32:06How many of us remember doing little research papers in elementary school,
- 32:11looking at Encyclopedia Britannica? But now you can live check your provider with your phone.
- 32:19Right. So think about how all these emotions, you know, impact how we communicate
- 32:27in public health. You know, we we issue warnings. We publish guidance.
- 32:32We correct misinformation. We tell people what they should and shouldn't do.
- 32:37I mean, how often do you think, like, I understand why we don't invite public
- 32:42health people to a party because we're always telling people,
- 32:45no, no, no. Like, look, I will totally come clean that I am drinking a Diet Pepsi.
- 32:50And I often drink Diet Pepsi when I'm speaking.
- 32:54I've gotten notes from people. Oh, my God. What kind of public health person
- 32:57are you drinking a Diet Pepsi on a stage? I'm like, really?
- 33:03I don't eat a lot of red meat, I don't drink, I don't do drugs,
- 33:06I don't have promiscuous unprotected sex, and yet you're coming at me because I had a diet Pepsi?
- 33:11Again, how are we interacting with people?
- 33:14We're surprised when they turn to someone else when we are sometimes the no police.
- 33:20We have absolutely become exceptional at producing information.
- 33:27That doesn't mean that we've become good at communicating.
- 33:30People want to understand why something matters.
- 33:33They want to know what it means for their lives. They want information that
- 33:37respects their intelligence and helps them make decisions.
- 33:41They also want to feel that someone is listening to them. And this is where
- 33:45we need to rethink our approach. Let me give you a good example.
- 33:50Everyone is kind of worried about us losing measles back elimination status next month.
- 33:57Why are we worried about that?
- 34:00Like, why? I'll bet you the day after we lose elimination status,
- 34:05I will get up and I will have pancakes for breakfast.
- 34:08And I will go to work and I will watch my football games on Sunday.
- 34:15I am a New England Patriots fan. I grew up in Boston.
- 34:19How does it impact me? We have never communicated that to anybody.
- 34:25Didn't Canada already lose its elimination status? So how bad is it?
- 34:29I mean, I guess they lost it. And if we lost it, why is this important?
- 34:33Right. When you think about vaccination, instead of simply saying get vaccinated,
- 34:37explain how they work, what we know about the benefits and the risks and why
- 34:44our recommendations exist.
- 34:46Right. What were the risks?
- 34:48What has the science said? How do we because because if you really and I hope
- 34:53you do this, I hope you take some time to do a really deep dive on anti-vax YouTube. videos.
- 35:00Because they're not, they're never saying don't take a vaccine.
- 35:03They're never saying vaccines are evil. They're saying they're unsafe.
- 35:07They're saying they haven't done this research. And all we're asking is that they do this research.
- 35:12Because they are extending answers based on research they don't have.
- 35:18That's a much more compelling argument than don't do this.
- 35:22Right? So that's just something for us to think about. You know,
- 35:25we don't have to answer, you know, every questionable claim with another warning about misinformation.
- 35:33We have to help people understand how to evaluate competing ideologies.
- 35:41We have to stop treating the public like an audience that needs to be corrected
- 35:46and start treating people as partners who want to understand.
- 35:51That doesn't mean abandoning our scientific standards.
- 35:55It means making scientific expertise accessible, useful, and relevant. Say that again.
- 36:03Accessible, useful, and relevant.
- 36:06Which means, which Maha really does well, is they bring their findings into
- 36:12a way that people can understand them.
- 36:14Unfortunately, the entire academic model in the U.S. is about publishing and
- 36:18peer-reviewed papers, not impacting real people.
- 36:22Every, at DeBeaumont, every paper we do is accompanied with a blog or a video
- 36:26or an infographic because I'm not under the belief that anyone is really reading,
- 36:32my peer-reviewed paper.
- 36:34I have to somehow figure out how I translate that to legislators,
- 36:38to lay people, so that they can take the action that they need.
- 36:42Right? Effective communication isn't just about what we say.
- 36:46It's about how people experience what we say.
- 36:50The goal can't be simply to win an argument It's to earn a place among the sources
- 36:56people return to when they have questions Unfortunately, I think we're still
- 37:01trying to win an argument.
- 37:03We're trying to win a debate. So, you know, bringing these last two slides together,
- 37:09public health has spent decades building scientific expertise,
- 37:14and that expertise matters enormously.
- 37:17But we need to recognize something fundamental.
- 37:21Being right doesn't automatically mean being believed, and being believed doesn't
- 37:28automatically mean being right.
- 37:31And that is the challenge of the information environment that we're operating in.
- 37:36I went to my doctor recently because now you can do direct marketing of drugs,
- 37:41right? Because that was something we didn't do for a while. And now we do it.
- 37:44That's why kids know how to sing the Ozempic theme song, the O-O-O-O-Zempic.
- 37:49And there was this amazing drug that was shown on TV.
- 37:53And it was, you have better stamina, better mood, you lose weight.
- 37:59And I went to my doctor, I said, I want to take this drug. And he said,
- 38:01well, that's fine, but it's for menopause. I didn't care.
- 38:06I didn't care. He told me I could have better stamina. I could be, you know, lose weight.
- 38:10So again, we are interacting differently than we ever have with our healthcare system.
- 38:17And one thing I hope you remember from this talk, the monopoly that medical
- 38:22professionals had on health information has been broken and will never be restored.
- 38:29So my physician tells me something. I'm going to fact check that with the internet,
- 38:34Google, and my Aunt Mary.
- 38:36And the difference of today is Aunt Mary and Dr. So-and-so have equal standing in my brain.
- 38:44That's different than it used to be.
- 38:47I can bring up counter studies to what my doctor says on my phone.
- 38:51Are we ready to have that kind of relationship? Because how we answer is what builds trust.
- 38:59How we engage is what builds trust.
- 39:02And the minute we say, that's a stupid study and it's not peer-reviewed,
- 39:06so don't talk to me about that, we've lost the trust. It's over.
- 39:10So just a couple things to remember from this talk. One, we cannot credential
- 39:17our way into people's confidence.
- 39:21It's not going to happen. The
- 39:22public doesn't experience health information one organization at a time.
- 39:27They're experiencing an entire information ecosystem.
- 39:30Once people trust a source, they may become less likely to question what the source tells them next.
- 39:37Being right doesn't automatically mean being believed.
- 39:41Being believed doesn't automatically mean being right. And lastly,
- 39:45we have become very good at producing information, but we've not invested the
- 39:51time to become really good at communicating.
- 39:54If you take any one of those five things away from today's talk, this will be worth it.
- 39:59Okay, some really amazing resources, because I'm always going to give you resources.
- 40:04We have to engage the business community more effectively.
- 40:07Healthaction.org is the website for the Health Action Alliance.
- 40:11They have resources on workplace mental health. They did resources on MPOCs,
- 40:17on preparedness planning for your business.
- 40:19We spend more time at our workplace than we do with our families.
- 40:24For all that workplace wellness that happens at our work site,
- 40:2880% of health care costs come from children, retirees, and spouses.
- 40:35So community health is the new workplace wellness. HAA will help you with that
- 40:41messaging and how to engage businesses.
- 40:43You know, there needs to be a business council at every health department,
- 40:47at every hospital throughout the country. You got to engage the businesses.
- 40:52Communicating about public health. I shared this earlier, sharing it again.
- 40:55Engaging business leaders in public health partnerships.
- 40:59That is an amazing resource because if we don't engage the business community,
- 41:04we are missing a whole source of allies and advocates for health.
- 41:11People don't trust government. They don't trust the media. People do trust their employers.
- 41:17How many of you were in a position during COVID to have messaging that went
- 41:22to business leaders in your community that they then sent out to their employees?
- 41:27I'm sure you all could tell me the top three causes of mortality in Maine,
- 41:33but can you tell me the top three employers?
- 41:36And honestly, we have to be able to do both.
- 41:39And then this was something that we recently produced that I am extraordinarily proud of.
- 41:45And it's a report from the National Commission on Local Public Health Leadership.
- 41:50This is a toolkit written by elected leaders from both sides of the aisle.
- 41:58Governor Beshear from Kentucky, Governor Kasich from Ohio, county commissioners,
- 42:03health leaders, all of us work together on what do we have to do to engage local leadership.
- 42:09And I'm not talking about the president. I'm not talking about the Senate.
- 42:12I'm talking about your county commissioners.
- 42:14How many times has someone from your institution talked to a county commissioner,
- 42:18and not talked to them about, this is what I need from you, or this is the bill I want you to pass.
- 42:25Just talk to them about what do you need?
- 42:27What information can help you? What is important in your world?
- 42:31Well, the economy is important.
- 42:33Public health, health, health status is an economic indicator.
- 42:37Let me talk to you about that. When I was in Philly, I was able to link my birth
- 42:41record with Councilmatic District.
- 42:44I was able to give a city council person their infant mortality rate.
- 42:48Not the infant mortality rate in Philly. The infant mortality rate in Philly
- 42:51was very low, right? We were gentrifying city at the time. There was more money,
- 42:54more education coming into the city. The infant mortality was going down.
- 42:58That doesn't mean, though, that there weren't parts of Philadelphia with an
- 43:00infant mortality rate like the third world.
- 43:02But you've got to have the data. up, bring them something. This is a great toolkit.
- 43:06Really encourage you to take a look at it.
- 43:08Lastly, we have to upscale the workforce. This is a whole bunch of resources
- 43:13that I want to share with you.
- 43:14People who are new to public health, there is a residency program because I
- 43:18appreciate the training you might get in a school of public health,
- 43:22but only about 20% of the governmental public health workforce has an MPH.
- 43:27This helps you learn about public health more broadly and.
- 43:32Talked about PHCC earlier. This is something I really want you to think about.
- 43:37This is infodemiology and a link to the infodemiology training program, infodemiology.com.
- 43:43We know how to do surveillance for syphilis, but how do we do surveillance for information?
- 43:49Look at these examples, right? False claims that the U.S.—this is during Hurricane Milton in Florida.
- 43:56False claims that the U.S. government engineered Hurricane Milton to manipulate
- 44:00late Florida have spread widely on social media platforms days after similar
- 44:04claims about Hurricane Helene.
- 44:07Right. Conspiracy theories and falsehoods spread on platforms like X and TikTok,
- 44:11Reddit and Facebook, all suggesting the government can control the weather.
- 44:15This sounds outlandish, but I also watched during the measles outbreak in Lubbock,
- 44:21people saying online, I don't know why everyone's upset about measles.
- 44:24My mom used to hold measles parties.
- 44:27So your mom did not hold measles parties. But this is what there was no one
- 44:32correcting them because we weren't surveilling it.
- 44:34We weren't doing the infodemiology. In response to those rumors,
- 44:38FEMA said that this information harms vulnerable storm victims and may deter
- 44:44them from seeking assistance.
- 44:45The White House launched a Reddit page to combat these rumors.
- 44:49FEMA created a hurricane rumor response tab on its website.
- 44:54If you don't, listen, you ever wanted to think like, I wish I was in this room
- 44:59listening to these people and what they thought? That room exists now.
- 45:03It's on social media. You're not accessing it as a resource for you to drive
- 45:12your practice, to drive health care, to drive decision making.
- 45:15Infodemiology is what every health department needs in the future.
- 45:20If we are not looking at what people are saying online and reacting to it,
- 45:24we are leaving out a major source of information. We're flying blind.
- 45:28If you have ever wanted to get training in administration and management and
- 45:34budget, I found so many people in public health, they come to public health
- 45:39because they don't want to be salespeople. They don't want to do budgeting.
- 45:42They want to do the good work, help the people. But remember,
- 45:46without margin, there can be no mission.
- 45:50And so this is an asynchronous course offered by the University of Miami to
- 45:54help you learn budget, finance, Administration and Management.
- 45:58It's an exceptionally good course. I've had great reviews from people.
- 46:02This was written for public health practitioners by public health practitioners.
- 46:07And so, again, budget, finance, contracts, all that stuff that you never trained
- 46:12for, but you now have, you're spending a fair bit of your time doing,
- 46:17Beam can give you that training.
- 46:18This is the link to this whole presentation, canva.link slash main dash grand dash rounds.
- 46:26So if you want something in this, go get it, go find it, use the resources.
- 46:31This is lastly my LinkedIn, and I do a Forbes column, and I talk about everything from...
- 46:38Oh, the fact that Dexcom didn't let you change, made you share your data recently,
- 46:42or they wouldn't let you access your blood sugar. That was a problem.
- 46:47To a lot of articles on the pit and how the pit applies to day-to-day healthcare and public health.
- 46:54So connect with me on LinkedIn. Again, this is where I like to find people and
- 46:58we can continue conversations.
- 47:00This is my last QR code. This is the QR code that gets you to the DeBeaumont's newsletter.
- 47:08We send it monthly, full of resources, not a lot of fluff, strongly encourage
- 47:14you to sign up so that if we're doing grants or RFPs or just have a really good
- 47:20tool that can help you, you can find it.
- 47:22So that's my shtick. Hopefully this was helpful.
- 47:27And we got like nine minutes for questions if anyone has a question.
- 47:31That was fantastic. And I don't know where you've got your training as a comedian,
- 47:35but it's really I love the way you integrate. humor.
- 47:39I do think in public health, we don't integrate humor enough.
- 47:44I'm not naturally funny, but I just love it when people really have a.
- 47:49It seems like a knack for it. So thank you. And that's engaging in itself.
- 47:53So Renee does ask in the chat and please anybody, as you know,
- 47:56open up your mic. So please feel free to ask, raise your electronic hand and ask a question.
- 48:02Renee in the chat does ask about, well, do you get about, you know,
- 48:06the diet Pepsi, But what about role modeling?
- 48:09Like in public health, we'd be role modeling. So she's kind of being a devil's
- 48:13advocate, she says here.
- 48:14Like, you know, holding up a pack of cigarettes when you're talking about,
- 48:19you know, quitting smoking. So any particular?
- 48:23So, you know, this is the problem. Smoking was easy. And I'm just putting the,
- 48:29someone asked for the link.
- 48:31Tobacco is what a lot of us kind of grew up on. And tobacco,
- 48:37it's a binary. It's a zero, it's a one. Okay.
- 48:41I was eight years old when the HIV epidemic started. It wasn't a zero and a
- 48:45one. We didn't say everybody stop having sex immediately. That would have failed.
- 48:50We even said, if you're not going to use condoms, here are the other behaviors
- 48:55that you can do that are less risky.
- 48:58So we've done this before. When we get to soda, when we get to,
- 49:01you know, food, food's hard because there's no, I don't want to ever eat. It's can't be binary.
- 49:08You know, I can have a Coke.
- 49:10I can have dessert. I'm a diabetic. I'm a type two diabetic.
- 49:14Had a big fight with my endocrinologist because he was like,
- 49:16you can never have ice cream. You can never have sugar. I'm like,
- 49:18well, then just shoot me in the head. Like put me down.
- 49:22And I'm like, I'm not going to have have the big sundae. I'm not going to have
- 49:27it every day, but I'm sure as hell going to have a small ice cream.
- 49:31Right. And so again, where do we meet people? You know, tobacco is tough because,
- 49:35but again, even in tobacco use, you know, there are harm reduction.
- 49:39Like this is like Stephen's right here, harm reduction.
- 49:42We kind of like loss. Again, I'm, I'm doing a lot of thought stuff in vaping
- 49:47right now because it just hurts my brain.
- 49:51Because other countries are using vaping as a as a cessation device we've taken
- 49:57a very puritanical approach to it i don't want we all agree i don't want kids to vape we all agree,
- 50:04i don't want adults who don't use combustibles to vape we agree awesome,
- 50:11do i want adults who use combustibles to vape.
- 50:15That's a question yeah right that's a question so i again that the the we we're a you know we are,
- 50:24We are a group who are willing to allow safe injection sites.
- 50:30So what's our tolerance here? And when we're being binary, are we being religious
- 50:35or are we being scientific?
- 50:37Yeah. I saw a hand up.
- 50:40Yes. Who's got their hand up? I think, oh, Catherine, Kathy Burgoyne,
- 50:46who's a physician and recently obtained her MPH in the last couple of years. Hey, Kathy.
- 50:52And meanwhile i will just let people know that the canva,
- 50:57link for those who are listening only is now i'm trying to find it here but
- 51:02it's in the chat yeah it's in the chat but we have people do listen to it as
- 51:05a podcast so just trying to look it's canva c-a-n-v-a dot link l-i-n-k,
- 51:12backslash main hyphen grand hyphen rounds so canva dot link backslash main hyphen grand hyphen route.
- 51:22Catherine, are you able to talk at all? I can't, we still can't hear you.
- 51:26But Joe does have a question in the meantime. Any tips for dealing with youth
- 51:31as a group? Some say media is the most effective way.
- 51:35Youth, I mean, it's all the same tips, right? It's about listening to them,
- 51:42being empathetic listeners, not coming in and telling them.
- 51:46We do that a lot because we're experts, right? Experts tell.
- 51:51Well, so what, I mean, when you sit down with youth and you ask the first question
- 51:55of what do you, what are your pain points? What are the things you don't understand?
- 52:01You know, I talk to my kids all the time. It blows my mind, right?
- 52:04About what, what they're seeing, what they're hearing.
- 52:07For them, it's a lot of, you know, how do you navigate a world of marijuana versus fentanyl?
- 52:15How is one better than the other?
- 52:17You know, are we willing to say marijuana is okay?
- 52:20Like I grew up in a world where marijuana was illegal, right?
- 52:23It was a schedule for drug. Like we didn't have good research on it.
- 52:28So I want to say to them, look.
- 52:32I think marijuana is safe.
- 52:36It's available to you. What I'm worried about is, so it's my worry.
- 52:40What I'm worried about is I don't think we have really good data on the kinds
- 52:45of marijuana that are available now and what the kind of exposure we have to
- 52:49marijuana will do to you now.
- 52:51Because, you know, when it's illegal, it's really easy to, you know, it's harder to get a hit.
- 52:58But now I have a dispensary right down my street here. I pass it every day on my way to breakfast.
- 53:04So it's again, why do you want to communicate with youth?
- 53:09How do you want to engage them? But you have to engage them with plain language
- 53:13as an empathetic listener.
- 53:15And it's really, come on, if you have a partner, if you've ever dated somebody,
- 53:20you've put all of these communications tips to work.
- 53:23Again, married 22 years.
- 53:27I've learned how to communicate with my wife. If I'm going to ask my wife about
- 53:32something, you know, a new car, I'm going to lead with safety reports.
- 53:36I'm not going to lead with the fact that it's a cool Corvette.
- 53:40Because that's triggering for her. And Kathy, you are totally right that Dr.
- 53:44Shaw is an amazing communicator.
- 53:47I was not able to unmute myself, but now I can.
- 53:52I just wanted to say that I think my best example I can think of here in Maine is Dr. Shah.
- 54:00And he's still around. He's still teaching at Colby College,
- 54:02and I've seen him speak recently.
- 54:04And he's just, during the COVID crisis, he was on TV almost daily.
- 54:11He spoke slowly. He explained things very well. He used humor. He was available.
- 54:20You could email him. He was credible, consistent.
- 54:25And he just was such a great one. And I might add, he also held a Diet Coke every day.
- 54:33And Nirav is great. And the problem that we have is we have good communicators.
- 54:40You know, Lena Wendt's a good communicator.
- 54:42Caitlin Jettelina's a good communicator. They're there.
- 54:45It's how do we take this skill and make it ubiquitous throughout our workforce, right?
- 54:51I don't want to just like roll the dice on whether someone's a good communicator.
- 54:55I don't think anyone hired Nirav in Illinois thinking this man's a great communicator.
- 55:00I mean, he's kind of nerdy, right? He's a doc, he's kind of in the weeds.
- 55:04And then all of a sudden in Maine, he blows up and at CDC, he blows up as this amazing communicator.
- 55:12And so what is it that we learned from that when we are communicating,
- 55:16right? I had also, I think he did something I wish more health leaders would do.
- 55:21In public health, your job is really not to run the health department as the show.
- 55:27Your job is to be a politician, not a partisan politician, but you need to be
- 55:32at every Froyo opening, every Kiwanis Club talk, every meeting of the Chamber
- 55:37of Commerce so that people see you. Let your deputy run the health department.
- 55:42You have to be that political voice. So listen, I'm not saying that during COVID,
- 55:47I wanted businesses to be like, yay, you're closing us. I wanted them to say, this sucks.
- 55:54I hate that I have to do it. I'm doing it because I trust the state health official.
- 55:59I trust this local health official. I know them. And unfortunately,
- 56:03most people said, wait, who are you?
- 56:05Your door or what? Huh?
- 56:08Who elected you? Nobody. I was appointed. and you can shut down our whole economy? Yes. Yes, I can.
- 56:16That's scary. So Maine folks, love you guys.
- 56:21Please follow up on LinkedIn. If you have questions, go to the DeBeaumont website,
- 56:26follow the listserv and let's make the change we need together.
- 56:29So thank you all for coming today. Thank you so much. You've been wonderful. Thank you. Thank you.
- 56:35And don't forget November 10th, we have Monica Burrell, who's the lead for Google.
- 56:40She's the physician, former show, state health officer in Massachusetts,
- 56:46and is now the chief medical officer at Google. So she's going to talk to us
- 56:49about AI. So thank you so much, Brian. We'll see you next week at APHA.
- 56:55See you there. Bye-bye. Take care. Bye-bye.
- 56:58Thank you for listening. And we look forward to connecting with you again at
- 57:02MaineHealth's Public Health Grand Rounds, where we explore a timely public
- 57:07health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 57:10These grand rounds are posted to the Maine Health podcast channel on Podbean,
- 57:15and at mainehealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes. See you next time.