Latest / Newcomer Pod / Blue Checks & Semi-Fascism (w/Tim Miller)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. So what kind of salad hey
- 0:13everybody Welcome to Dead cat Tom and Eric here no Katie this
- 0:16week she is off electing a new pope so we don't have her but
- 0:21this week we're talking politics we've got Tim Miller here
- 0:24political Insider GOP strategist author former Former GOP track
- 0:30strategists. I'm sorry, we're going to leave
- 0:32that all in, though. Author writer at large at the
- 0:35bulwark. I just added that one outspoken.
- 0:37Trump critic. I mostly pulling from your
- 0:39Wikipedia. But is there anything else I
- 0:41should have included there? I have a show on Snapchat called
- 0:43not my party. I have a I'm a Snapchat content
- 0:46creator now. Okay, you know, father, Oakland
- 0:50residents, Snapchat, Snapchat came to me, the dollars.it, is
- 0:54it is great. It is great.
- 0:56Actually, I'd love it. I know that, you know, it's not
- 0:58cool to be, you know. On Snapchat if you're 38 or
- 1:01whatever. And it doesn't feel like it's
- 1:03doing that great. But there are many daily active
- 1:06users who are teens and so if I get recognized on the street
- 1:11there's only two groups of people that will say hello to me
- 1:13like 58 year old women and Whole Foods.
- 1:17Tough to know me from MSNBC, right?
- 1:19Or Sara otte. Yeah or 16 year old model un
- 1:23boys who watch the Snapchat shit, I love those.
- 1:26Those are my two demos. Do you think you have more
- 1:29influence over? Her like who do you think you
- 1:30really? I think though I think the mom's
- 1:32I think I got more inputs over the moms.
- 1:34Yeah. But I would like to say that the
- 1:36answer was the 16 year old Bobby on boys, but they're all
- 1:39independent minded. I think it's the moms who I've
- 1:41got wrapped around my finger, they all want me to date their
- 1:44son or daughter. Uh-huh.
- 1:46That's the best Whole Foods conversation.
- 1:48Yeah, I want to say, quickly, it may not be cool to have a
- 1:50Snapchat, show a 38. It is very cool to write about
- 1:52Snapchat when you're 37 38. So really, I want to, I want to
- 1:55make that as a bunch of anchor like I concur with that.
- 1:58Yeah, there. Anyway, so This is supposed to
- 2:00be our politics episode, we got our midterms preview and the
- 2:04role that Tech in Tech money has played in the campaign.
- 2:07But let me, look, we're recording this episode on a
- 2:10Friday. And at 1900 hours last night,
- 2:14Zero Hour arrived and the walls of Twitter were permanently
- 2:17breached. The Barbarians of enter the
- 2:20gate. He's like he's firing people
- 2:22heads on Stakes right now, outside Twitter and Market
- 2:25Street, but, yeah, Ilan owns the company.
- 2:27Now, the prisons have been emptied, the scores.
- 2:29Have canceled miscreants are hooting, and hollering and
- 2:33shooting guns up in the air as they're all being let back onto
- 2:36the platform. So I guess we should just start
- 2:39right there. I mean, what do we have to say
- 2:40about an Elon own Twitter and the free for all that he has
- 2:43promised to unleash on the world?
- 2:46Yeah, I think that it's not going to be as fun as you think.
- 2:48It's going to be though. He seems to have fun and shitty
- 2:50situations a lot. So maybe he'll make the best of
- 2:53it but I wrote about. Do you guys are you guys
- 2:55familiar with the website? Get her very popular, social
- 2:58media site. Getter I spent all my time for
- 3:01far-right white nationalist. Yeah, I wrote an article last
- 3:04year headlined getter by the pussy.
- 3:06If you want to Google it that, that explored a very
- 3:10traumatizing, our that I spent on getter looking at all of the
- 3:13weird porn and like racial slurs.
- 3:16And the thing is that I content moderation is very unfun, and it
- 3:21is very challenging, and I think the decisions are not as it's
- 3:25much easier to complain about content, moderation and to
- 3:28moderate content. And so I think that Elon is in
- 3:31for a rocky or time than he expects on that front.
- 3:35A lot of these decisions are not that clear.
- 3:37Do you think he will like tear down the floodgates and deal
- 3:40with it? Or do you think he'll come to
- 3:42Jesus pretty fast? And be like, oh my God, this is
- 3:44gonna be a mess if I try really unleash.
- 3:46Well, he's already having to reckon with, you know, with
- 3:49advertisers and the fact that if you turn that place into a
- 3:51cesspool, it's incredibly unappealing to the people that
- 3:54keep the fucking lights on. So that's all really is.
- 3:57Always Craigslist, can an unmodified Did cite survive.
- 4:01I mean, I guess, Craigslist still survives.
- 4:03But do people use it anymore? Like, no, you know, because it
- 4:06becomes scam artists and white nationalist and porn, there's
- 4:09already plenty of porn on Twitter and so I, you know, I
- 4:13last time I tried to buy tickets for A Warrior's game on
- 4:15Craigslist. I got scammed.
- 4:17Okay, so people don't use this shit anymore and people stopped
- 4:19using Twitter and advertise will stop advertising on Twitter.
- 4:22So it does become a problem. He's gonna have to decide what
- 4:24to do about Donald Trump here. You know, I think that they'll
- 4:27probably do away with some of the stuff.
- 4:29That I didn't really think that was that valuable that Twitter
- 4:32tried to do to, you know, calm down critics.
- 4:35Like, you know, random Twitter fact checks of things, right?
- 4:40And like, I don't think any of that stuff.
- 4:41Was that useful in the first place?
- 4:43I'm sure we'll get rid of some of that and they'll be, you
- 4:45know, more of a free-for-all to say untrue things about
- 4:49vaccines. And do you think not as sort of
- 4:52a whisper of the right who can speed up to the left?
- 4:55Like, do you think he will win over right-leaning people?
- 4:59On Twitter. I mean like Trump has a
- 5:01competing you know, network with true social.
- 5:04I guess Trump will come back just for the audience but I
- 5:07mean, do you think he'll be able to sort of keep up the act of
- 5:11being on team right way? Yeah, I think so because it's
- 5:15super easy to keep up the act of being on team right-wing right
- 5:18now because it's just an oppositional nature towards
- 5:22Elites that trigger, right, trigger.
- 5:23And so yeah. So he can just kind of focus on
- 5:26complaining still about other left-wing Elites And that will
- 5:30keep him in the good. Graces of the maggot types.
- 5:33You know, he already has replied to cat turd today letting him
- 5:36know that he's looking into his shadow band sleep.
- 5:39Everybody like this is on the case he's looking into cat.
- 5:44Imagine being a mid-level executive at Twitter and getting
- 5:47an email today from Elan that's like hey could you please
- 5:49investigate the captured Shadow bam.
- 5:51It says something sir. At least you finally have an
- 5:54answer to the question of, what did you get done this week?
- 5:56It's like, well, I unbanned cat turd.
- 5:58Oh, we sure can't over Zach. Shadow band or did they just not
- 6:01have, you know, that engaging of content, right?
- 6:04The guy has like I think somebody was saying, as 800,000
- 6:06followers or something it was like just angry that he's not
- 6:09getting enough engagement. Well, that's the issue.
- 6:11I think I mean that, you know, like the Q&A on moment when
- 6:13Trump finally, you know, had to step down and Biden came in and
- 6:16you realize that the prophecy wasn't true.
- 6:18I wonder how much of the prophecy not being true with the
- 6:20shadow band people. They'll have to reckon with
- 6:22that, that units, like eels in charge, and I'm still not
- 6:24getting the engagement. I thought I should be getting,
- 6:26maybe this wasn't about like a giant left wing so it can Valley
- 6:30conspiracy. I think they'll find other
- 6:32things to, you know, feel aggrieved about.
- 6:35And I think that they probably will be a little bit more of a
- 6:37bump and engagement because some people, I don't know how many,
- 6:40but, you know, they always some meaningful number of people that
- 6:42come back from getter and truth and parlor and either do both or
- 6:47return to the site. You know, I'm sure that they'll
- 6:49do I like Tyler. I think has 25,000 right.
- 6:51Da. Yeah.
- 6:52But if you're talking about one of these people, if you're a
- 6:54conservative media Tweeter you know who like tweets complaining
- 6:58about the liberal, Idiots and like you are getting 12 retweets
- 7:02and now you're getting 18 like yo, I got right.
- 7:05You know my message is spreading now so I I think that they'll be
- 7:08so modest. Yeah, won't do anything for like
- 7:11the bottom line of Twitter. The number of people that come
- 7:14back right before the users, you know, to assuage them.
- 7:17You know, you already saying today, people feel very gleeful
- 7:20to like, you know, tweet racial slurs and like make fun of, you
- 7:24know, tell people to learn to code and all that sort of stuff.
- 7:27So like they will feel, they'll be as brief.
- 7:29Bump of endorphins. What do you make of the argument
- 7:32that moderates tend to like content?
- 7:35Moderation, more an Elan has positioned this as sort of
- 7:39simultaneously like a moderate Crusade and a sort of protect
- 7:44the right Crusade, how do you see those two things
- 7:48intersecting? Do you think he's going to end
- 7:50up serving the middle who doesn't want to see like the
- 7:53n-word in their thieves? Or he's going to know that his
- 7:56core constituency is sort of the troll crowd and he needs to keep
- 7:59Pretty close. Yeah, I actually don't know that
- 8:02there is as much distance as the question would make it seem
- 8:04because here's why there are two groups of moderates, right?
- 8:07There's my group right, which is the, you know, folks that left
- 8:11the Republican party over Trump. You know that have generally,
- 8:15you know, whatever classically liberal moderate Centrist views
- 8:18and like care about things like democracy and norms and such.
- 8:21We're not going to like the changes that Elon is making
- 8:24okay. But when Ilan uses the word
- 8:26moderate, that's on, who's talking about Elon is talking
- 8:29about About Joe Rogan moderates, right?
- 8:31Like people that were like are also for Bernie and kind of for
- 8:34trying, right? And line.
- 8:36Good hair. Use that coalesce around random
- 8:41candidates and like, whatever mood, I have it in me.
- 8:45That's honestly how most normal people are, maybe not most, but
- 8:48a lot of normal. People don't really align
- 8:50themselves to parties or candidates.
- 8:51They're just like, I believe in. I don't know gun rights and also
- 8:54that the, you know, we should be nicer to trans people.
- 8:57Yeah, exactly. So he just so he's like a real.
- 8:59Canary moderate, right? Which is like I'm questions
- 9:02about vaccines but I also, you know, I'm not a religious nut
- 9:06but I also, you know what I mean?
- 9:07And we can get into this in wear teal and all those other guys
- 9:10are. So I just I think that it is a
- 9:12different type of group that he's speaking to, which are
- 9:16people with like heterodox kind of radical heterodox views.
- 9:19They are also moderate the same way I am.
- 9:21But we disagree on everything right, but we're both moderate
- 9:24in the sense that we're not like in line with, whatever the
- 9:27generic view is from the Predominant political parties,
- 9:31but who is the enemy? Then for the right wing.
- 9:33Now we know at least on Twitter, I mean they had such a perfect
- 9:36foil when they could say, you know, these are the lives of
- 9:38Silicon Valley that are stopping me from reaching my, you know,
- 9:41god-given audience. But at this point with him and
- 9:44charge, I mean, they need something, right?
- 9:45I mean, that's the core of I've got great news for you, Tom.
- 9:48Yeah. Is it me you?
- 9:49Yeah. Yeah, you you're the enemy now.
- 9:51That's yeah. She's gonna be huge for my
- 9:53follower count because I'm the smallest of the three here, so
- 9:56I'd be glad to bring it on. That's fine.
- 9:58I don't know if you Particular, but meet the media, I mean,
- 10:01like, they'll always be people to be aggrieved about on Twitter
- 10:05that's just not. They will no longer be able to
- 10:07be aggrieved about the Twitter Executives, but that's just one
- 10:10category. Okay?
- 10:11I think that some people will be upset with you on but again
- 10:13eventually you kind of have to just realize who's on your side
- 10:16and join that side, right? And I think that there will
- 10:18probably be some decisions that he on makes it.
- 10:20They don't like. But the overwhelming majority of
- 10:23these people are not people that have like broadly defined like
- 10:27very specific policy views about exactly.
- 10:29Lee, what type of content moderation should be done on
- 10:32these big platforms? Like their views are just there,
- 10:35is this group of people that I hate?
- 10:37And so I'm going to focus on on that and that is what drives me
- 10:41and what motivates me and that group of people is not Ilan.
- 10:44I appreciate that. You're the ex conservative and
- 10:46your takeaways. Their reasoning is dumber than
- 10:49you think it is a little bit. Well, yeah, I mean I don't, I
- 10:53don't always have anything over the past seven years.
- 10:56The made you think that it was were validating what it's yours.
- 10:59From the others. There's at least of when he was
- 11:01once on the other. Dispel just one thing that I
- 11:04have to say, is that in this speech, he talked about the
- 11:07concern about the right, going into now Peter, chill smart.
- 11:11Not like the people that are complaining about twitter.com
- 11:14and he talked about nihilistic negation and that's just a fancy
- 11:17way of saying, like we just believe in nothing, we are
- 11:21oppositional to whatever the, you know, conventional wisdom,
- 11:26Elite narrative, status quo, whatever buzz word, you want to
- 11:28use is And like, Peter was right about that.
- 11:31It was like a self criticism of the right that he is trying to
- 11:34encourage them to have more, you know, Solutions oriented policy
- 11:38views. And so what he hasn't quite
- 11:39realized is that like the people that are supporting and
- 11:42following all of his like, various projects on this front,
- 11:45don't actually have that or care about it because he lives in a
- 11:48like a rich person's bubble on the coasts.
- 11:50But he identified the problem. I supposed to come up with it
- 11:53though. I felt like that speech.
- 11:55Yeah, it's like oh, 90% of it is like him shitting on California
- 11:59and him. A nihilist.
- 12:00And then the last like ten percent is like, oh, by the way,
- 12:03we should probably have like a positive policy View and it's
- 12:06like, aren't you? Isn't that what sort of the
- 12:08intellectual? Well, I mean looked I leave.
- 12:10It's him as you know, the X GOP political consultant isn't that
- 12:13standard structure for a speech? You know, you want to tear down
- 12:16the other side and the last two seconds be like and also we
- 12:19should do good things and that's your applause line.
- 12:21Know if that's the standard as a, certainly, a standard
- 12:24structure for a populist demagogue speech, I worked for
- 12:26moderate technocrats. I didn't write it kind of
- 12:28speeches like that. But yeah, I mean sure there's
- 12:32something to that but my point is that like he identified a
- 12:35real problem there at the end. Right?
- 12:37But like I think he either doesn't realize or just doesn't
- 12:40want to admit is that the underlying element of that is
- 12:44that the people that they're appealing to aren't looking for
- 12:48the solutions, right? Like that's not what they're
- 12:51interested in and if he started a, you know, and he has done
- 12:55some of the stuff like that, you know, teal non-profit for, you
- 12:58know, populist. He's studying Solutions like
- 13:01nobody's going to fucking tweet that shit.
- 13:03All right. Nobody wants to read the white
- 13:05paper about how they can find a different solution than
- 13:08California has to solving the housing crisis problem.
- 13:13The group of people who care about that finding Solutions,
- 13:15going back to our two different kinds of moderates, are my kind
- 13:18of moderates, right? Like the technocratic neoliberal
- 13:20moderates, who are like frustrated, you know who works
- 13:23briefly aligned with teal and sacks on getting rid of Chase
- 13:28and you know trying to Change. Some of the ways that some of
- 13:31the cities are being run. Like they're the ones that care
- 13:33about Solutions, like the reactionaries that are upset
- 13:36about Twitter and are said about content moderation.
- 13:38Like, those people are not interested in that, so you've
- 13:41given us your moderate sort of framework.
- 13:43Yep. What is your view of the
- 13:44Republican Elite right now? I mean I feel it used to be the
- 13:47case that it was like, okay, the Republican Elites willing to put
- 13:51up with you know the urbanist Republican an elite especially
- 13:54is willing to put up with some homophobia and racism in
- 13:56exchange for low taxes and a sense that That abortion is
- 14:00never going to make progress. And so like, who cares and that
- 14:03like anyone who's Savvy knows that this is all about low
- 14:06regulation and taxes. And if you're the type of person
- 14:10who's going to get so upset about, like a bunch of people,
- 14:12like, saying things that aren't even going to be implemented.
- 14:16Like, you're an idiot, that's sort of how I make sense of the
- 14:19old Republican Elite, which seems so much nicer now.
- 14:22I think at the time that I hated them but now I'm like man if
- 14:25only they were willing to sell out all their principles so they
- 14:28could pay low taxes at That would make sense.
- 14:31What is the Republican Elite right now watch?
- 14:34Because even Peter teal is trying to incite some of the
- 14:36populism. He's not just trying to do this
- 14:38just for low taxes, right? Yeah, well, it kind of depends
- 14:41on what you mean by Elite. Like, at this point, to me the
- 14:45Mitch McConnell's of the world are like yesterday's men and
- 14:49some of them realize that in some of them don't and like
- 14:51those are the people that you are describing who are still
- 14:54around and like, they were just willing to make greater
- 14:56sacrifices on the altar of native as Then you know, culture
- 15:01War. Then like those of us who bailed
- 15:03over Trump were right. He held the Republic together,
- 15:06you know. Yeah.
- 15:07They're all being displaced though.
- 15:08If you just look at the types of candidates that are running
- 15:11right now, you know TL coif like Masters your the JD Vance's like
- 15:16Herschel Walker's ridiculous. But like you know the folks that
- 15:18are winning primaries, these Republican states, their deal is
- 15:21different. They're not actually even that
- 15:23interested in low taxes or you know, smaller government.
- 15:27In fact, they Dislike capitalism to a lot of extent.
- 15:32We certainly dislike big corporations.
- 15:34I mean, that's the reflection of low capitalism though, right?
- 15:38I mean, that's a Tucker Carlson view that like these guys are
- 15:40all forcing us to use the pronouns, that we didn't feel.
- 15:43Yes. We had to discuss all that much
- 15:44before hand. Yeah, correct.
- 15:45And so you can see DeSantis trying to embody that even Marco
- 15:48Rubio, who is part of the older, you know, kind of way that you
- 15:51describe things Eric isn't it has not changed his rhetoric
- 15:54towards this. So now like the Primacy of their
- 15:57fight is the culture War. And this is I think what some
- 16:00people misunderstand what's happening on the right.
- 16:02Is a, there's this sense that like, okay, these are just, this
- 16:05is like the last gasp of these old Boomers, like a culture war.
- 16:09And like we had a little bit too much progress with a black
- 16:11president. And you know, as kids using
- 16:14different, pronouns and gay marriage, and all this stuff,
- 16:16and now there's a backlash to this, but that will go away.
- 16:19That's not it. The memes are the ideology.
- 16:22Yeah, there's the new group that is displacing the old group is
- 16:24actually centering the culture War even more, right?
- 16:27And like, that is the The motivating fight for people who
- 16:32are Republicans right now, it's something that I think that teal
- 16:35and his crowd get instinctually and maybe they don't like every
- 16:39element of it but like, they understand it, I think better
- 16:42than, you know, the old Republican guard does some of
- 16:45whom who are trying to catch up and I think that we're moving
- 16:48towards a Republican party, that looks more like what teal wants
- 16:51and looks more like what European conservative parties
- 16:54are which are culturally conservative on economic stuff,
- 16:58you know, maybe? More conservative than the
- 17:00Socialists but like certainly not you know, free-market
- 17:04thatcherism or anything like that.
- 17:05Like that's all gone. You know more government
- 17:08control, punishing, foes more isolationist.
- 17:11You know. So look at brexit look at or
- 17:14Bond. Look at Le Pen.
- 17:16Like that's where the Republican party is going.
- 17:19Like it's not going to look like the old classical liberal.
- 17:22You know, Reagan Thatcher at something and it's moving
- 17:24towards this. Other thing that jettisons
- 17:26really, the fiscal conservative element to it, And then
- 17:29obviously, the Global Leadership element.
- 17:31Do you think they do, like, you think they can really abandon
- 17:34low taxes, and you think they would Embrace unions?
- 17:38Probably not low taxes. They will probably won't
- 17:41abandon, but I certainly, will abandon like Pro business
- 17:45regulatory elements, right. And I think that low taxes will
- 17:50not be Central to it. I don't think that you'll see a
- 17:53ton of tax hiking except for tax hiking, that owns the libs.
- 17:58Like, you know, getting rid of The exemption well because
- 18:01they're also not the technocrats, so they don't
- 18:03actually have to balance the budget either, so it's so it's
- 18:06like, fuck that. What's the point of tax hiking
- 18:08and less you're just going to tax hike, like, getting rid of
- 18:10the state-based tax deduction, like to own the, you know, those
- 18:14of us who live in California and New York and stuff, you know,
- 18:17like, they'll be certain types of targeted tax hikes.
- 18:20That attack people. They don't like just any taxes
- 18:22that went towards funding urals. I imagine her in danger at this
- 18:25point. Yeah, that sounds like a top
- 18:26issue. You worked for McCain, right?
- 18:28Yeah, given. You're shitting on Republicans.
- 18:30Let's remind The Listener a little.
- 18:32You have some real Republican credentials here or how long
- 18:36were you on team elephant? Yeah.
- 18:38Sorry while I'm inside, I was a kid.
- 18:40I started working in politics in 98, Ron, a Governor's campaign.
- 18:43That's not age me to. That's not do kind of quick math
- 18:45on that that I worked for McCain and 08 in 2012.
- 18:49I worked for John Huntsman in the primary, who is the most
- 18:51moderate. Yeah, Rhino cock squish
- 18:53candidate. And that I think that was like
- 18:55the candidate, the best reflected, my world view, but
- 18:57also the one who endorsed Trump Early on in 2016.
- 19:01Yeah we had a we've had a falling out over that.
- 19:03He also endorsed Mike Lee in a primary this week and I had a
- 19:06lot of people message me. Like what's your boy doing?
- 19:08Was like about my boy man, I begged him to join the
- 19:10anti-trump after I was working on in 2016 refused to do it
- 19:14because he wanted to be Trump's ambassador to something.
- 19:17I don't, I don't know. He did, you got ambassador to
- 19:20Russia? Great job, brother, Donald
- 19:22Trump's and then I worked for Romney in the general after he
- 19:24beat us in the primary and then jab in 2016 and I worked on the
- 19:28GOP, autopsy. In 2012 that was like trying to
- 19:31tell the party to bring back compassionate, conservatism that
- 19:34didn't work out too well and I did a bunch of like, you know,
- 19:38lower smaller races in between all that but those are the
- 19:40presidential ones. I'm fascinated by the psychology
- 19:43of conservative. So we sort of we touched on the
- 19:45elite McConnell T little bit, I mean JD Vance is obviously
- 19:50running and is a key candidate in the tech Louvre.
- 19:54I assume you've read hillbilly eligibility.
- 19:58Thank you. Look or watch the excellent
- 20:01movie on Netflix, couldn't make it through the movie.
- 20:03Is there any connection from the book to his like View today?
- 20:07Or what do you make of the two people?
- 20:10There's some connection that I think speaks to where the party
- 20:14is going. And there's this old joke on the
- 20:16right at least to say to make fun of you commies which was
- 20:19like true Marxism has never been tried, you know like all these
- 20:23guys want to be marks it's still sad they're like you know just
- 20:26happens they all turned into genocides.
- 20:28Well it was just an Accident like real Marxism.
- 20:31We gonna try to exactly when you say, that's a joke.
- 20:33I mean I literally hear that from people on the left, I do,
- 20:35right? Yeah, I guess I guess.
- 20:37It's like you guys say it in a mocking enough way?
- 20:39Where it's like the same thing. Yeah, yeah.
- 20:46There you go. And so I feel the same way about
- 20:49conservative populism, which is that true conservative populism
- 20:53has never been tried and probably is not doable for this
- 20:55reason the JD Vance, embodies what I'm talking about which is
- 20:59that Ways, the JD van slyke went on the, you know, Davos tour,
- 21:04after he wrote that book, like sounded kind of a lot like Joe
- 21:07manchin, like, in a lot of ways you could almost imagine him
- 21:11running, it's like a conservative Democrat, right?
- 21:13He was like, gradually conservative.
- 21:15We have to care about rural people, you know, we shouldn't
- 21:17be dismissing them. Telling them that they need to
- 21:19learn how to code, like they also have responsibilities.
- 21:23They need to be able to pull themselves up from their
- 21:24bootstraps, but we need government, you know, level of
- 21:27government support that kind of free market.
- 21:29Republicans have been, you know, not willing to give in the past.
- 21:32I mean, the but to the extent I read it, it's like 95%, this is
- 21:35their fault culturally, but then to the extent, he has any
- 21:38solution. The last five percent is like
- 21:41maybe we could do some things with the government.
- 21:42It's so realizes that there has to be some government.
- 21:46Yeah. Right.
- 21:47That's what solution is. A little bit more of a
- 21:48government. Like the government can be more
- 21:51involved, right? I'm element of concert, you
- 21:53know, but the book definitely, maintained more personal
- 21:56responsibility stuff than he has now, right, okay.
- 21:58So, but What is the kernel of this pivot about where the party
- 22:03is going right? Which is that, like,
- 22:04laissez-faire capitalism is not popular?
- 22:07You know, does not work and we can appeal to working-class
- 22:11voters of all colors, but especially white voters, you
- 22:14know, by appealing to their grievance and saying government,
- 22:16Big Daddy, government can come help you too.
- 22:18And so, when JD started the campaign that is kind of the
- 22:21underlying element of it. It's like, I can be a more
- 22:24populist government. The government can play more of
- 22:26a constructive role kind of cultural conservative the Um is
- 22:30again going back to the Twitter thing, these people aren't
- 22:33looking for like policy, white papers about how we can move you
- 22:38know welfare to work, you know. And that's how we can make
- 22:41Medicaid more efficient or you know how we can add some tariffs
- 22:46to certain countries so that we can build more widgets in
- 22:49Mechanicsburg. Like they're like they don't
- 22:51care about any of that. What they care about is that
- 22:53they are mad at people that they feel like have, you know, agree.
- 22:59I have left them behind and so JD's campaign goes from like
- 23:04trying to address some of the legitimate Grievances, and come
- 23:07up with solutions to it, to just mirroring.
- 23:10They're illegitimate grievances about election fraud and covid
- 23:14and fucking laugh. You guys are fucked up and you
- 23:16need to fix your shit. He's like I hear you.
- 23:18They were like we're not all right.
- 23:21I did fuck you over the woman is the reason why your that your
- 23:27life isn't going as well as it should is because Somebody in
- 23:30Berkeley is saying that they have a day then pronouns, right?
- 23:33Like, I like that. You don't even want that help.
- 23:35So I, yeah. And I just think that that I
- 23:37think the JD vanch like Evolution, kind of shows, like,
- 23:40kind of where this is going. And as much as there might be
- 23:43some people who try to put some policy, white papers around,
- 23:46Maga conservatism like it really is just at its heart, you know,
- 23:50about you know kind of baby burning people's grievances back
- 23:53to him. Yeah.
- 23:54And the people that have tried to, you know, write the white
- 23:57papers and lend Have to Maga republicanism.
- 24:02Don't seem to have all that much power within the party, or
- 24:04they're just not very interesting people.
- 24:05You know, you have like fuck, what's his name?
- 24:08Josh, Holly was trying to do that for a while, right?
- 24:10I mean he had that whole convention around trying to
- 24:12build theological framework around trumpism and no one
- 24:17really cares about him and he's probably going to I don't he's
- 24:19gonna run and 24 either way, he's not going to make it very
- 24:22far because he has no purchase the tech policy, you guys know
- 24:26this better than me, but the technology is a great example of
- 24:28this, right? It's like, oh, we're mad at
- 24:31section 230 and we should punish the big tech companies.
- 24:34Right? But then it's like Elon takes
- 24:35over and he's like wait a minute.
- 24:36Now you know they say on that letter that was sent out.
- 24:38He's like I realized the importance of section 1030,
- 24:41right? It's like they don't have any
- 24:42actual. What they really want to do is a
- 24:44moat and say that I feel like the big red guys are being mean
- 24:48to us. Like they don't well have actual
- 24:50like, oh, I think we should reform text and X y&z ways and
- 24:54the people that do want that, you know, end up, you know, just
- 24:57being extremely minor players. What's so funny about it to me
- 25:00is I was just noticing and you know Google released their their
- 25:03cue and in it they put in a new risk factor of all the different
- 25:06regulatory legislation that could affect their business.
- 25:09They added list like all the different things that have
- 25:11passed in state houses, that could affect their business in,
- 25:14some way or another. And I noticed that one of the
- 25:16things in there was the DeSantis field that allows people to sue
- 25:19tech companies for D platforming them.
- 25:21I actually didn't even remember when that passed, it was
- 25:23sometime last year but you know, like, look, this is a thing out
- 25:26there, it could affect us. And I mean, there's no question
- 25:28in my mind. Like if someone actually did Sue
- 25:31under this law it would get appealed all the way up to the
- 25:33Supreme Court and someone would need to make a, you know, a
- 25:36judgment on whether or not. This is a violation of the First
- 25:39Amendment which in my mind there's no way that it's not a
- 25:41violation of the First Amendment.
- 25:43You know, being allowed to sue someone for D platforming.
- 25:45It's So absurd. But I don't know how fully they
- 25:48thought any of this through, right?
- 25:49It just felt really good at the time to sign a bill and tweet
- 25:52about it and anger a bunch of what they assume.
- 25:54You know, this idea of lives in Silicon Valley.
- 25:57Yeah, DeSantis has signed like a cup.
- 25:59Bills that are like this, that are certainly going to get
- 26:01overturned. And that's just one of them if
- 26:03you look at the examples of legal experts, but their PR
- 26:05releases as bills, and the other thing is just, the whole thing
- 26:08is preposterous and this is where I get even Crossways with
- 26:11the left-liberal criticism. I've plenty Christians have big
- 26:14Tech on the margins but the populist left criticism of like
- 26:18how we need to, you know, use antitrust against that all those
- 26:21things. It's just like, our on it.
- 26:23Yeah. It's like I'm sorry.
- 26:25We just have went through this huge test actually about whether
- 26:29the Big tech companies are monopolies that need to be
- 26:32broken up. And the answer is obviously, no,
- 26:34this is like the Golden Age of Nazi social media sites, like
- 26:40people who get, who given whatever D platform to have.
- 26:44I like, they started three competing for competing media
- 26:47companies that are all that all are doing bearings degrees of
- 26:52fine. As far as businesses, maybe they
- 26:53don't have, they are the size of whatever.
- 26:56But, there's certainly, some market capitalism.
- 26:59Arms are prolific. Yeah, therefore let Freddy.
- 27:02This is the Golden Age of them. I mean, are they doing really
- 27:04any worse than RC Cola is doing? Or like the smaller Niche Cola
- 27:08companies competing against Coke and Pepsi?
- 27:10I don't think so like they're doing fine.
- 27:11So as you know, anyway like this is like it's all just
- 27:14Preposterous but that's like they're not they don't run to
- 27:20Santa's doesn't care if it is. Right.
- 27:22If it you know if the law actually is upheld, do you think
- 27:26the Republican Elites are I want to be fascists at the moment.
- 27:31They know this mob is out of control, doesn't make any sense,
- 27:35but they want to ride this thing.
- 27:36You have already invoked or Bond.
- 27:39Like do you think this is semi fascism full fascism or
- 27:43obviously? Tyler Cowen wrote that piece
- 27:45sort of analyzing the new right recently where he sort of I
- 27:50thought he was almost he was too friendly.
- 27:52I mean he he sort of concludes that the new right is totally
- 27:55incoherent like we are but he's sort of like bed over backward
- 27:58to read. Sort of anti elitist argument
- 28:01through it that was meant to make sense.
- 28:04I think there's no one really thinks.
- 28:05It makes sense like anyway but it but do you think there are
- 28:08fascists? It depends like you know, we get
- 28:12into a semantic debate, right? It's like is Viktor Orban, a
- 28:15fascist. I mean, I guess kind of use a
- 28:18semi fascist. He's fat, he's fascistic in a
- 28:21way that he's not like Putin or she, you know, I mean like there
- 28:25aren't any Weger camps and Hungary, right?
- 28:28And like, you can still Bill, you're not getting arrested for
- 28:31tweeting. I don't like Viktor Orban in
- 28:33Hungary, you know, and there's definitely some corrupt ability
- 28:37of the courts and the media, right?
- 28:38And more government control. So Jonathan Chait of the New
- 28:41York Magazine went to the National conservative conference
- 28:44where t l spoke. And I think in wrote about this
- 28:46very smartly and he's like there's a lot of space between
- 28:49like Reagan and Putin. I forget what the fashion to
- 28:53Hitler maybe he is I forgot what the fastest example is like
- 28:55there's a lot of space inside my passions space.
- 28:57Right? And so yeah I think The
- 28:59Republican Elites want to move to something like that.
- 29:03I mean just finishing Disney. I get taken away Disney's tax
- 29:07breaks because they you know had a lesbian kiss in a movie like
- 29:11is that fascistic it's fresh its dick I guess it fascism.
- 29:15I don't you know do the Republicans actually want to put
- 29:17Lids in camps. Like I don't think so right.
- 29:19But do they want to use? We should have to live in this
- 29:21world where we're counting on like the goodness of their
- 29:25hearts. We're at the end of the day,
- 29:27they won't go too far. I mean I Feel like as soon as to
- 29:30their hearts and efficiency of their, like, operationalize
- 29:33them, right? It's like, I feel like they
- 29:35would want to get a lot of this stuff done, but they literally
- 29:37don't know how to motivate and like, operationalize.
- 29:40The troops to do anything beyond, you know, Yas and I
- 29:43don't mean to downplay that, right?
- 29:44Like I think that that or bonds hungry is horrible.
- 29:46Right. So I'm not trying to down but
- 29:48I'm just trying to say like when you're trying to give a fair
- 29:49assessment of what they want their goals are you know, it is
- 29:53it is a like a quasi minority rule, you know, I know the
- 29:57Republicans are not won a majority of popular.
- 29:59Since 2004. So it's a quasi, minority rule,
- 30:02it's controlled the courts. It's punishing enemies using
- 30:06kind of tax code and Regulatory stuff.
- 30:07It's demonizing marginalized groups, right?
- 30:10So I call that stuff is bad, you know what I mean?
- 30:13But I think that sometimes when people say oh they want fascism
- 30:16they're like no, I literally they want to be Putin and I'm
- 30:19like not sure. That's true.
- 30:20I think that there's certainly some people you know Steven
- 30:23Miller is pretty as prove out as fascistic as you can get the
- 30:27look into you know what do you want to do?
- 30:29With child separation and all that.
- 30:30So, you know, there are elements of it but I think that that what
- 30:33DeSantis is doing in Florida, is moving towards or bananas on as
- 30:38kind of what they see as the future.
- 30:40Yeah, we can have Paxton on next week to break down the anatomy
- 30:43of fascism and and you know what falls into what definition, what
- 30:47Robert Paxton, he wrote a kind of a seminal book about the
- 30:50anatomy of fascism and helping to define the term in the 20th
- 30:53century. It's a spin-off to look too
- 30:54smart for this show. Yeah, Berto Echo.
- 30:58Yeah, I read. You know, I Like a lot of books
- 31:00for like a month after 2016 and so I vaguely remember, authors
- 31:04and titles but that's a be kind of rely on all you rely on that
- 31:07one month to sound. Smart.
- 31:08Don't ya gasps. Yeah.
- 31:09And like, it's fading more and more as days go by.
- 31:11So don't ask me a single question about these books
- 31:13Paxton is like 89 years old too, he's not coming on.
- 31:16Okay, so we've already talked a lot about the candidates on the
- 31:19right specifically, JD Vance and, you know, I mean basically
- 31:22Trump picked him off of the scrap Heap in Ohio in or not the
- 31:26scrap Heap. But he basically like pushed him
- 31:27over the line in a way that He wasn't going to make it up to
- 31:30that point. So he's clearly, you know, at
- 31:32this point indebted to Trump and then the other obvious person in
- 31:35that list who's also a Peter teal, acolyte is Blake Masters,
- 31:39who we haven't talked that much about.
- 31:41I want to have it set on the podcast here because I've said
- 31:43it in group DM's and Eric is annoyed with me.
- 31:46I think he's going to win in Arizona.
- 31:48I know this is going against conventional wisdom and the
- 31:50polls but I just find that to be the most absurd outcome, midterm
- 31:54selection and making predictions.
- 31:55I feel like I don't do you think there's Lakes Masters could get
- 31:59A reservation at dorsia. I heard even get that reference.
- 32:02Now you've ever its American Psycho, right?
- 32:05Well, I'm very excited. Have you ever watched American
- 32:08Psycho? Tom?
- 32:09Yeah, let's just watch the movie.
- 32:12He it's very creepy. His parallels with Patrick
- 32:14Bateman the main character from American Psycho, just just
- 32:18physically, or just like everything.
- 32:20Just is actually the way he carries himself, not just yeah,
- 32:23I don't know that it lies on any murders but yeah, no, no
- 32:28emotions, the lack of Emotional. He's a Crazy Character to me
- 32:32because, you know, in the tech world we were all aware of him.
- 32:34We knew of him as the guy that I think he wrote 0 to 1.
- 32:37Right. And you know he was elected the
- 32:39notes for or whatever. Yeah.
- 32:41I mean he's basically a professional blogger and kind of
- 32:44I don't know what the word would be for Peter to what is your
- 32:46take on Blake Masters to me, he's an incredible case of just
- 32:50I mean he's an absolute zero you know no Charisma.
- 32:53You know if he wasn't really a figure and it is running against
- 32:55like an amazing candidate, right?
- 32:57Mark Kelly. We're closed.
- 32:59It's pretty good. He was an astronaut.
- 33:01I don't know if he's an amazing. Wasn't it has an astronaut I
- 33:03mean I haven't watched these debates but I would just think
- 33:06an astronaut that's your dream candidate.
- 33:08Yeah. I mean Mark Kelly isn't exactly
- 33:10mr. Charisma himself.
- 33:11He's okay. He's pretty fine, he's fine.
- 33:13But he's obviously has a much more accomplished and better
- 33:15life story than like Masters who took notes for Peter teal as
- 33:19best we can tell. But ya know, he has zero cause I
- 33:22went to see us doing the circus. It's show time show and we
- 33:25enough said in Arizona, and I went down there and watched
- 33:28Masters Arie Lake. And then Ted Cruz speak at
- 33:31events and like, at mean, Masters makes Ted Cruz.
- 33:36You know, look like one of the great orators of all time.
- 33:39Oh my God, Asters has like, has literally nothing going from a
- 33:43Christmas standpoint but Kari Lake is super talented and super
- 33:46fasci and I think that she could maybe carry him across the line
- 33:49a bit though. Just the crossover voting.
- 33:51These days is pretty small. So depends on how she wins by.
- 33:54So I've everything Masters could win, though.
- 33:56I don't know if I'd be ready to predict that I I think both
- 33:59those races are gonna be pretty close.
- 34:01And yeah, I find him interesting because he is, he's done a
- 34:05really good. You can tell that like Blake
- 34:08Masters is like a dude from California who like has probably
- 34:14like some like mainstream conservative views and like a
- 34:19few weird, you know, contrarian takes just like all these
- 34:22fucking Tech Pros do, right? But is trying to now fashioned
- 34:26himself into like what he thinks.
- 34:28I'm a God. Person should say right.
- 34:30And so, you know, this is how you seen him struggle on the
- 34:33abortion thing. You know, on the on the election
- 34:35fraud Cindy was old like blog posts is like, a young
- 34:39libertarian, right? Yeah.
- 34:41We had no in sort of direct contrast, I mean, yeah, he's
- 34:44like a monarchy and that right. Wasn't that is he dude, he was a
- 34:49contrarian, bro, posting on message boards like for CrossFit
- 34:53like that's all it was right, like he was probably just got
- 34:56through, they were CrossFit message ways.
- 34:59What's the reason for that? Like what it was the last
- 35:02Bastion of free speech? He was their social Community.
- 35:05Yeah, you feel you have a dog CrossFit but it's the most
- 35:08uplifting Community, you can imagine.
- 35:09No, he is searching for community.
- 35:11And there are a lot of P. The CrossFit to Fascism pipeline
- 35:14is actually pretty well-educated.
- 35:15Yeah, I got Taylor dream so I didn't green, is also CrossFit.
- 35:19That's true. That's yeah.
- 35:20And shit across the store anyway.
- 35:24Masters to me is like trying to figure out right?
- 35:26And so the did you see the humiliating video of Tom Calling
- 35:29him to tell him that he wasn't Tough Enough on the election
- 35:32fraud. I want to drop that audio into
- 35:34this podcast because it's really something.
- 35:36I mean basically you know, he has Trump on speakerphone and
- 35:39they're doing like a post debate recap and Trump.
- 35:41Who I don't even think watched it other than the fact that he
- 35:44said you know is like you weren't strong enough about
- 35:46saying the election was a fraud. Yeah.
- 35:48Yeah. How is your family?
- 36:00She says, the election was rigged installment, you'll lose
- 36:04if you got sake, Lose That Base, I'm not going soft.
- 36:08And you can just tell that Masters is like despite the fact
- 36:11that I can barely move Patrick Bateman, like, he's not a total
- 36:14sociopath like Trump. Right Ike, he knows that the
- 36:17election wasn't really stolen and you can just kind of see him
- 36:20in the photo, intellectual way, like, trying to, like stretch to
- 36:25find a way that you can say, the right thing without like totally
- 36:28embarrassing. Seeing himself and just being
- 36:30like, yes, I think that the Chinese bamboo ballots you know,
- 36:33were at to blame here in Arizona.
- 36:35Even though there have been five audits run by Republicans that
- 36:38have all said it was fine, right?
- 36:39Like like it's hard for him to get there and so he's struggling
- 36:42to navigate it. But I think that the key insight
- 36:45though for Masters is that he is at least not playing the game
- 36:50that Eric was talking about at the start or it's like I really
- 36:53care about tax cuts and and you know, all this other stuff is
- 36:57fake and support of that like Is that what he's doing?
- 37:00I key really cares about the the beasts that's best deal world
- 37:05and the PayPal Mafia have with the woke cultural Elite.
- 37:09And like, that's what he actually cares about.
- 37:11Can't do anything else is just in support of, they're not even
- 37:14going to like the legit Eric. Wemble, just like admitted that
- 37:17he, this is a total tangent, but like, he admitted that he was
- 37:20like afraid to criticize. The tomcod not bad.
- 37:23Like, I just feel like whatever fires, they have burning about
- 37:26cancel culture are like burning out right now.
- 37:29You say that. But at the same time, you know,
- 37:30Tucker Carlson label Taylor Lorenz, the ideological you
- 37:34know, chief of the Biden White House.
- 37:36Glenn Greenwald just tacked on Ryan Mac because Ryan Mac like
- 37:39laughed at him on Twitter. You know it's amazing that it's
- 37:42so proximate that it's just like Glenn Greenwald.
- 37:45Just has to yell at you and then all of a sudden is fucking on
- 37:47Tucker Carlson for the Hulk. I don't know what.
- 37:52Yeah, dude. What is your greatest strength
- 37:53of our own walls? Yeah.
- 37:54Like what? Something like nine tweets about
- 38:00me the other day because I appeared on Joy and read show
- 38:03and he said he felt like that showed grave hypocrisy.
- 38:06Why? Because Joy had said some
- 38:08homophobic tweets or something a long time ago and then I kind of
- 38:12did you think you could be making a lot more money?
- 38:14Now if you double down on them like stuck with the Trump thing,
- 38:17like sometimes I think I'm a sucker, I should just like go
- 38:19in. I could be crushing it and
- 38:21conservative world because it's such a low caliber of person.
- 38:25Like, you could be running circles around these people and
- 38:28yet, we Side to compete against other Democrats and it's like,
- 38:31oh my God like it's too much competition.
- 38:33I don't like I did you think about sticking it out?
- 38:36I never thought about sticking it out with Ides.
- 38:39I fucking hate down, I am like I have pulled Trump derangement
- 38:42syndrome, like I hate him. I hate all these two, all these.
- 38:44And I'm gonna be the old around the old man, and a senior
- 38:47citizens home pointing my bony finger at other person in the
- 38:51cafeteria being, like, that person was for Trump and I'm not
- 38:53sit with them in the cafeteria and 2082, but so I would not but
- 38:58that's And I just I preface this by saying I do not I do not want
- 39:03or require any sympathy, I'm doing just fine.
- 39:04I have a wonderful life in Oakland that the amount of money
- 39:08that it was left on the table, by bailing is like extremely
- 39:11substantial. And my friends who stuck around
- 39:14you know, they like literally one was just telling me that the
- 39:16day he was like dude you have no idea.
- 39:18He's like people that are idiots are millionaires.
- 39:20All right? That's because you know just the
- 39:23amount of money flowing through these campaigns.
- 39:25Also like the no competition thing is part of it.
- 39:29But the amount of money that's flowing through these campaigns,
- 39:31you know, both bottom up from Mega donors who are now spending
- 39:36way more on small dollars than they were for Mitt Romney.
- 39:38Like the amount of small dollar money coming into these
- 39:40campaigns are to figure out some parties.
- 39:43And yeah. And then and then top down from
- 39:45the billionaire class and I like contrarian billionaire class.
- 39:48So so you know they're doing they're doing well but that's
- 39:52just part of life. That's part of, you know, I'm
- 39:55supposed to be costly. I guess it's sort of.
- 39:57It's how you get to feel good about.
- 39:58That's ok, I'm going. Yoga and just kind of dealing
- 40:00with that. Yeah, things happen to bad
- 40:02people. That's you know, that's part of
- 40:04life. It's a good life lesson.
- 40:05Have you spent time with Peter to know?
- 40:08I get a lot of calls for everybody that wants to write
- 40:10Peter teal stories. They're just like you're gay.
- 40:12You were a republican are, didn't you ever get invited
- 40:14over? I don't know if I was Twinkie
- 40:16enough for Peter to get invited to the house.
- 40:18When I see pictures of the little crowd that surrounds him,
- 40:20they have more muscles and our blonder than me.
- 40:24So I just I don't know that I was ever picked out read a lot
- 40:27into that question everybody. Ori or fossil.
- 40:31He just knew that I was, I'm kind of the enemy.
- 40:33You have to understand for these people should have spent more
- 40:35time with Barry's Bootcamp. Apparently that's I should have
- 40:37spent more time berries for these folks like the teal crowd,
- 40:41like I'm really like the enemy like as much as the left is the
- 40:45enemy Like the quote unquote neocon kind of like
- 40:49establishment. Like I said we're both were
- 40:51moderate and I don't say Peters moderate but our views are
- 40:54different in opposite ways, right?
- 40:55Like I was drawn to Republican stuff by like the US should A
- 40:59Force for good in the world. You know, we should have less
- 41:02government in our lives, like Peter was drawn to it for like
- 41:05we should have culture War. The US should do less.
- 41:09We should punish our enemies, right?
- 41:11And so they looked at the like establishment Republican types
- 41:14as the real real enemies and so, no, I don't.
- 41:17We didn't have a leader like the bombings Parts.
- 41:21Yeah, the we are on opposite sides of all those primaries.
- 41:23That's rude. We're on opposite.
- 41:25Sides of all those primaries back in the day.
- 41:27Let's just play it forward by the The way this episode is
- 41:29coming up before the midterms, this might be our most topically
- 41:32relevant episode top. So proud of us for doing
- 41:35something ahead of something. I usually, it comes out like a
- 41:37week after the story is like a past winner.
- 41:39Anyway. So, you know, I assume that the
- 41:41Republicans will win the house. I guess the Senate is sort of a
- 41:44toss-up, you know, if they're in play, you know.
- 41:48And assuming they try to push some sort of legislation as far
- 41:51as Tech goes. I mean, what do you expect to
- 41:53see given the makeup of the, the current GOP?
- 41:57I think the Republicans will take the Senate to Just will
- 41:59allow in the production business but they're going to do nothing.
- 42:02They'll be some brinkmanship on the budget and they will
- 42:06investigate Hunter. Biden will probably try to
- 42:08impeach secretary mayorkas. If secretary mayorkas doesn't
- 42:11resign, what the Homeland Security, man.
- 42:15I don't even know some of this story lines they have going on.
- 42:18I don't need this stuff. Like what parlor man?
- 42:20Now, anyone who doesn't understand and this is good for
- 42:23everyone who has a friend who like, you know, it's kind of
- 42:26unhappy about inflation and thanks elon's funny.
- 42:29He isn't as dabbling in right. You know republicanism I signed
- 42:32everybody one hour of Steve, bannon's podcast.
- 42:34Oh my God. You just gotta listen to it for
- 42:36one hour and if you like what you're hearing, then go ahead
- 42:39and put on the hats, which teams.
- 42:41But that is to understand what's happening.
- 42:43You need one hour, Steve Banta. This part of the argument of why
- 42:46letting Trump back on, Twitter could be good for Democrats,
- 42:49where it's like, at least like get people's moderates back in
- 42:52touch with what Republicans they actually send out.
- 42:56I don't think I mean there's this thing called speak.
- 42:58This thing that's been And secret Congress, which like does
- 43:02things that are that are just going to not in the headlines,
- 43:05you know, and make incremental change to various things where
- 43:08things can get past and reproductive, right?
- 43:10That's yeah. So there could be some I'm a
- 43:12little bit out of tech policy for my days when I was doing
- 43:14that work. So I don't exactly know what
- 43:16could fit under that rubric but like the idea that there's three
- 43:19big sweeping you know change to you know section 230 or to
- 43:24addressing these like big controversial, you know issues
- 43:28around Just etcetera. Like, there's not, it's just
- 43:31not, it's just gonna die. There's not there.
- 43:32They're not gonna kind of do yeah, nobody's cutting a fucking
- 43:35deal on that over the next two years between.
- 43:38Yeah, the next Presidential. Yeah.
- 43:40So No One's Gonna Champion, one way or the other.
- 43:42The like, you know, carried interest loophole loophole, or
- 43:45anything that like would actually have.
- 43:47Yeah, actually matter to our audience are going back to sort
- 43:50of the did you know, the Neo cons and and the Republican are
- 43:54sort of the new right hating neo-cons the David Sachs and
- 43:57Peter teal, support the war in Iraq.
- 43:59Like, I feel like David Sachs is on Twitter.
- 44:01All the time being like, the war in Iraq, was such a mistake.
- 44:04Well, but like that guy definitely support had right and
- 44:07I can't I can't find. I'm like I've lazy find any
- 44:11evidence for this. How many just wasn't that?
- 44:13It wasn't much of a person? I can't find evidence.
- 44:15Either way, you know, they just become more famous black.
- 44:18People are prolific. I mean, they're like, fucking,
- 44:20you know, like I was in her hand.
- 44:21If anybody has evidence, the David Sachs supported the war in
- 44:24Iraq, sent it to me, charcoal, I guess, I guess you wouldn't see
- 44:27David Sachs on a CrossFit. Message board, but maybe check
- 44:30out some, I don't know message boards, the body milk eggs.
- 44:34Yeah, but see if he's Steve see where he's posting.
- 44:38I'd have to assume so that he had been.
- 44:41But again, I, as I was saying, these guys like that is, you
- 44:45know, sort of the cheat code for like, drawing the type of
- 44:49audience that they want, right? Which is that we are not part of
- 44:53the elite establishment and so in order to do that, you know,
- 44:57to go down this contrarian path. You just have to look at well.
- 45:00Okay. What were the things that the
- 45:01elites did that were wrong? Like the Iraq war is obviously
- 45:05example 1 and so, you know, all of them like criticize that now.
- 45:10But you know, there weren't a lot of people like the looks
- 45:12like David Sachs at the at the code pink protest and Crawford,
- 45:16right? Am I to my recollection.
- 45:17So the idea that these guys are not Elites, like the whole Elite
- 45:20conversation is the most inferior, like anybody just gets
- 45:23to call somebody else and we'll eat.
- 45:25And then I mean, with the whole Kanye situation in the rising
- 45:28like Anti-Semitism. It feels like even more coded
- 45:31when it's like you're a billionaire and yet you're
- 45:34calling other people. Elites.
- 45:37What is that? Watch.
- 45:38I think it's fairly straightforward.
- 45:39If you are influencing elections, then you are an
- 45:41elite. If you are influencing an
- 45:43election and also have a podcast with other people in which
- 45:45you're criticizing Elites, then you're not in the lead because
- 45:48you're criticizing them and you're aware of the hierarchy
- 45:51and being aware of the hierarchy removes you from that.
- 45:54Therefore you are clear to do that without being responsible
- 45:56for the system. I think, if you are a one
- 45:59Percent owner in the Golden State Warriors and get chastised
- 46:02for saying, rude, things about the uyghurs and saying nice
- 46:07things about the Chinese, then you are not an elite because the
- 46:11Real Lead is the majority owner of the Warriors, who has more of
- 46:15a stake in the basketball team, and can can wag his finger at
- 46:18you, right? Or the people that are on
- 46:20Twitter, you can use, you can find one person more Elite than
- 46:22you. Find about the elites, right?
- 46:25Yeah. Look to your left.
- 46:26Look to your right there. Not more Elite than you than
- 46:28you're in big trouble. Ville.
- 46:29Okay, the last section of the podcast here we have spent a lot
- 46:32of time talking about the types of people who are extremely
- 46:34critical of the mainstream media and I guess Eric and me and
- 46:38people that represent that. But you were also a central
- 46:40figure in the Facebook Stories from a couple of year.
- 46:43No central figure. You were a figure in the
- 46:46Facebook Stories from a couple years back and kind of, you
- 46:48know, in your time with definers and Advising that aren't so
- 46:52Cheryl specifically or just Facebook on, you know, policy
- 46:56and presentation and how to kind of work your way in through
- 46:58Washington and Yeah, they were kind of pointing to definers and
- 47:01maybe even use specifically, as I don't know, kind of a
- 47:04nefarious, part of running a corporation and pushing through,
- 47:09I don't know misleading, talking points and legislation and
- 47:11things like that, and then your time specifically, I mean,
- 47:14looking back at that whole period, which I think did, you
- 47:16know, affect you in certain ways.
- 47:18I mean, what's your take on that whole episode, and the way that
- 47:22the media can occasionally glom onto a narrative and, you know,
- 47:26see it through. I know this is going to be
- 47:28really A complicated answer. And so it's going to challenge
- 47:31people's priors and make people really you know uncomfortable
- 47:35but like the media can be not perfect and also right do their
- 47:41best to this. Try to get the story right and
- 47:44figure it out, I know. Wow.
- 47:45And this is really challenging, I mean, you know, I always say
- 47:48like some people on the right, get mad at me and they're like,
- 47:50why aren't you more mad at the left you were canceled?
- 47:52And I was like, I was, I'm doing okay, I've got more Twitter
- 47:55followers than Tom and I'm here on the spot.
- 47:59Cast right now. So I'm doing.
- 48:00Okay, I was criticized as criticized, the work we're doing
- 48:03for Facebook. I think some of the work we were
- 48:05criticized for was totally fair. You know, I write about this in
- 48:09not to do a book Vlog while I'm not doing bad things I did.
- 48:11But like, I write about this in the book where I look back.
- 48:14What's the title? Same title, it's got a why we
- 48:16did it. I look back in the choices that
- 48:18I made, even though I bailed on Trump and I think I made some
- 48:20bad choices. You're, when you're in this
- 48:22ecosystem of playing this political game or political
- 48:25adjacent game in the game of like public affairs, PR You
- 48:29know, there's a lot of incentives that push yourself
- 48:31to, you know, want to help to get clients when I hope to get
- 48:34good stories for your clients, want to help support your, you
- 48:36know, the people that are paying you like make you do some shit,
- 48:39not make you, but that leads you to do shit.
- 48:42That is in a gray area. Ethically speaking, and I think
- 48:46that in the bubble one of things I want to write about in the
- 48:48book I think is so important is in this bubble like the people
- 48:52who criticize you for that are bad.
- 48:55And those of us who are just trying to do our job, you know,
- 48:58running cover for the Companies are these politicians are like
- 49:02you know we're just part of the game.
- 49:03Like I don't like get off our back, right?
- 49:04Like this is just you know part of our job and like that culture
- 49:08I think is very creates problems, you know and I think
- 49:12creates bad incentives and I think that it allowed a lot of
- 49:16people to justify going to work for Trump because they've been
- 49:19doing work that right? They self Justified for a long
- 49:22time that they knew part of it was not real and of Ethics is
- 49:25that it might be inconvenient to you.
- 49:27The idea that it's just your job is.
- 49:29Is not an out like that. That's sort of exactly what the
- 49:32point of sort of more exact, that is exactly right.
- 49:34But I think my point is that, in this culture in, d.c.
- 49:37particularly on the right there, was this, your kind of buddy,
- 49:41you know, culture in which we don't have to deal with those
- 49:43ethical questions because like, you know, this is, this is just
- 49:47part of, you know, what we do, right?
- 49:48And so, anyway style, be Savvy like play that we're Sammy,
- 49:52right? We get it.
- 49:53We get it. These other fucking whiners on
- 49:55Twitter and their basement complaining about his, don't get
- 49:57it. So, anyway, that's that's a
- 49:59Enjoy the point of like the actual Facebook.
- 50:00So we're Consulting for Facebook.
- 50:02A lot of the work that definers was doing.
- 50:04I look back on and feel gross about the actual Facebook thing
- 50:07that the original story was about is like, not really one of
- 50:10them. I think the work that we're
- 50:12doing for Facebook was kind of just basic blocking and tackling
- 50:15do it, running PR, and I guess maybe working for Facebook and
- 50:18past like the actual thing that they picked on 28th like this.
- 50:22Yeah, it's like we put together backgrounders for all of the
- 50:25people that criticize them, right?
- 50:26It was just like here is why that person is Did a lot of
- 50:29times, you see people on the right, all these people we've
- 50:31been talking about, right? I'll do who had fake
- 50:33cancellations who said we were Shadow band, you know, diamond
- 50:36and silver testifying in front of Congress and I was putting
- 50:38together background or being like diamonds or not Shadow
- 50:40band. Actually, they're doing great on
- 50:42Facebook, maybe Facebook should be banning them more actually.
- 50:45And so, you know, we did similar for Lefty critics and the one
- 50:49example that the X keyed in on was the idea that like there was
- 50:52a background on who is funding? You know, some of the left-wing
- 50:54critics of Facebook and George Soros was one of the funders and
- 50:58so I sent them Times this background, I was like there's
- 51:00nothing here like we're just looking into who the various
- 51:03people are that are funding the anti-facebook work and then they
- 51:06sat on it for six months and the Tree of Life synagogue thing
- 51:09happens. Unlike the story runs four days
- 51:11later, which is like, Facebook has hired Republicans to like
- 51:14smeared, you know, to be like, you know, make up this fake
- 51:17thing about George Soros. And then, the next year, the
- 51:19times runs an op-ed from like Soros Foundation.
- 51:23That's like, we are looking into Facebook, it's all I guess is
- 51:26true. So anyway, I like music.
- 51:28Come out aggressively attacking Source itself.
- 51:31No, nobody had come out of dress.
- 51:32We do a background has come to an assessment that I think Soros
- 51:36is involved in it. Yeah, there was a list of all
- 51:39the different potential, liberal groups and organizations, and
- 51:42like sources, like the flashy name, because that's what people
- 51:44talk about. So I get it, you have to be
- 51:46sensitive around Soros, because there is a lot of anti-Semitism
- 51:49systematic attacks but like, literally this was what I did.
- 51:52All the time is a PR guy, which you have you don't do anymore,
- 51:54which is like, hey, we did some research.
- 51:56I send it to a bunch of reporters, probably not.
- 51:58Eric new, Omer. And it was like, hey, will you
- 52:00look into the see if this is true etcetera?
- 52:02The thing never went out like it never was published in every
- 52:06census, Rose things to reporters.
- 52:08Yeah. It was like a background Iran,
- 52:09like these funding, the left wing, Auntie Facebook stuff.
- 52:13So anyway in retrospect, I probably not great because of
- 52:16surahs like we probably should've been more sensitive
- 52:18even on the background or, but like nothing went public.
- 52:20I just think that the reaction to it was overwhelming, but
- 52:22because the reaction was so great and large part because the
- 52:25proximity of the Tree of Life thing, which was fucking
- 52:27horrible, and there was a ton of sores Misinformation was
- 52:29happening at the time about the Caravans and stuff, which I was
- 52:32criticizing. Like they looked into other
- 52:33shit. Definers did.
- 52:35And like, yeah. And we were all these people
- 52:36that were talking about right now the right-wing media types.
- 52:39Like I was feeding them shit, you know, to write stories
- 52:42about, you know, on behalf of clients.
- 52:45And like I Justified that because I was like, you know,
- 52:48whatever like the stuff, I'm sending them isn't racist,
- 52:50right? But you know it's going to live
- 52:52on these like Maga websites and and I like, I shouldn't been
- 52:57fucking playing footsies with those assholes.
- 52:59You know, I shouldn't even do like why till I get paid extra
- 53:02money but on by Qualcomm like all that stuff was you know,
- 53:05regrettable and some of it was listen if not even really real,
- 53:09right? But that's part of doing PR and
- 53:11I kind of wish I wasn't. I hadn't been doing that.
- 53:14Yeah, I mean what's interesting to me as a tech reporter during
- 53:17that period, is that it seemed like this was fast.
- 53:20Realization for a lot of tech reporters that the companies
- 53:23they have gotten had become very political in the way that they
- 53:25ran their PR operations. And I'm not saying the reporting
- 53:28was Or wrong or we shouldn't be critical of the fact that this
- 53:32was the new Norm in the way these companies were run.
- 53:34But it just seemed like there was a nun familiarity with, in a
- 53:36lot of tech reporters. When you see things that are
- 53:39standard within the DC world. Now, you could argue that it's
- 53:42not okay for it to be standard within the kind of the political
- 53:44world, but they're just seemed like it, you know, it felt like
- 53:47foreign territory for a lot of reporters and you see something,
- 53:50yeah, I feel like a, a challenge with reporting sometimes is
- 53:54sometimes you can have great reporting that comes in and says
- 53:57something that's like Obvious to every other reporter but the
- 54:01public doesn't understand and people will go while because the
- 54:06public know it, even though right.
- 54:08Right. Like it's like, this is my thing
- 54:10on the Facebook thing is like, it was crazy.
- 54:12Everybody's like now looking at like oh my God, this firm that
- 54:15has Republican guys is working for Facebook.
- 54:17This is shocking. I was like every report or knew
- 54:18we were right? I remember I we weren't doing
- 54:20like they tried to pay. They did paint it in a way and I
- 54:24don't really think this was intentional, but like, it made
- 54:26it seem like, oh man, like we're on.
- 54:28Covering the dark arts thing when like really like we were
- 54:31just like doing basic public affairs for Facebook.
- 54:35I like I said, we were doing some more so we were doing some
- 54:38dark arts up for some other companies, which is why maybe
- 54:40Facebook should've hired us and maybe we should never work for
- 54:42Facebook. I grant all that.
- 54:43But yeah, I I do think that there was there is sometimes a
- 54:46sense of kind of a babe in the woods tribe.
- 54:48Attitude, the New York Times uniquely is able to just be like
- 54:52both because they're good at Framing and writing and because
- 54:55they have such a huge audience and just like turning the whole
- 54:58world on to The issues they write about it, but to me that
- 55:01the framing was always with bothered me about a lot of those
- 55:03stories because you can criticize the tactic in general.
- 55:06And the fact that all these companies use these things.
- 55:08But I remember there was a, you know, a lot of stories saying
- 55:11Facebook had operatives that were going into Trump HQ and all
- 55:14their campaigns and giving them data and helping them, you know,
- 55:17work on Facebook a lot more. So that and it's just like,
- 55:20well, yeah, because they're spending a lot of money on
- 55:22Facebook and that's their job as a company that makes money is to
- 55:27make sure the people that are spending money.
- 55:28That there were a lot of stories written about that and in one
- 55:30sense, it's like, okay. Yeah, I mean that does sort of
- 55:33suck if you want to talk about any, you know, platform having
- 55:38some sort of relationship with any kind of client.
- 55:40I would love it. If these things were all just
- 55:42like, you know, software the people we just plug into and
- 55:44there wasn't as kind of hand-in-glove approach to
- 55:46things. But the fact is there is and
- 55:48it's constant specifically within politics.
- 55:50And I just think you need to have an awareness of that if you
- 55:52want to have a smart opinion on it rather than just feel like
- 55:55ooh that really smells bad to me and you can frame In that way
- 55:59and I don't know the story. Just didn't hold up in my
- 56:01opinion, you know, they were splashes at the moment and
- 56:04looking back at them, they just look really thin.
- 56:06Yeah, I so I think there are two elements, I think there was a
- 56:08Facebook moral panic at the moment it apart because like
- 56:12they thought that their Facebook's fault that Donald
- 56:13Trump won, you know, because we're on the Prussian, the
- 56:18platform and like none of that like has held up as being really
- 56:21true. Like the I got the Russia, the
- 56:23stuff that happened in the mainstream media.
- 56:25This is the other thing I'm mad. I did get mad at the Times about
- 56:28I was just Like you gotta fucking with like we're the ones
- 56:32to blame well that emails on the amount of Impressions that
- 56:53the New York Times got was significantly more than like the
- 56:56weird little Facebook groups that they said.
- 56:58To create like the amount of add money.
- 57:00They start was really small. So anyway, it doesn't mean it
- 57:02was good. There should have certainly been
- 57:04reporting about all that but like, there was this like more
- 57:07like everybody kind of got cozy being.
- 57:09Like, it's Facebook's fault that Donald Trump won, and like that.
- 57:12Like Facebook did you know stuff that in retrospect?
- 57:15They, you know, they should have cracked down on, but like there
- 57:18were a lot of actors or complicit in the Wikileaks stuff
- 57:21in particular and the Russian op on our elections in 2016.
- 57:24So that did bother me and I think that like had you know,
- 57:28you Early taken this exact same story about what we're doing for
- 57:31Facebook and like we had been doing it for Apple.
- 57:34Well, I could literally, wouldn't it would have been like
- 57:36a half a day story, right. Like people just wouldn't have
- 57:38cared like you laughter there. Was it that?
- 57:41Yeah, yeah, there was a lot of, you know, because people are
- 57:43doing that for Apple by the way, they're still doing it to this
- 57:45day and for Google and for whatever.
- 57:48And so I think that there was just this moment about that and
- 57:51I think that that some of that was obviously overblown and led
- 57:54you have a, my dr. Solis and it's okay, I would
- 57:57like to read it And the other, the other element though is I do
- 58:02think that the Trump thing woke people up and we were kind of
- 58:05some shrapnel to that a little bit.
- 58:07And there's an element of this that I do agree with.
- 58:09And I think that these challenges are hard for
- 58:11reporters for anybody, which is like things that were sop, you
- 58:15know, when Mark pain was doing her shit from Microsoft.
- 58:18Yeah, things that were standard operating procedure when Mark
- 58:20pain was doing the ship from Microsoft.
- 58:22Like is that really appropriate in the Trump era, right?
- 58:26Like, is it really appropriate after the Van, you know, like he
- 58:30proposes a Muslim ban to go do white glove service for them.
- 58:34I don't know the answer to that, I think that's worth looking at.
- 58:36Like, then on the other hand, like, should companies really be
- 58:39saying, well, we have random red lines of people that were
- 58:42willing to give, you know, we'll do it for Liz Cheney but we
- 58:45won't do it for for Donald Trump.
- 58:47Maybe that doesn't. Like, I do think that there's
- 58:49some there's some ethical questions associated with that,
- 58:51the just like the absurdity. And just extent of Trumps, you
- 58:57know, fucking corruption and Get tree.
- 58:59Like I made things that in a different time might have seemed
- 59:04like not that big of a deal and to feeling like a big deal for
- 59:06like some good reasons. So I think that that is also an
- 59:10element of this moving away from companies for a second like just
- 59:12like as a you know looking at the Democrats for a sec.
- 59:16The formula fucker. Yeah exactly.
- 59:19Like I feel like there's one view that like Democrats aren't
- 59:23cynical enough like your you got to Fight Fire with Fire.
- 59:26Like the Republicans are so good at like trying to win and we're
- 59:29all just like a bunch of like Earnest people running around be
- 59:32like, what, why do they do that? On the other hand, I feel like
- 59:36there's an argument that it's like, if you're going to play
- 59:38like moral piety, you should like Stan, you know, rise to the
- 59:42occasion. I don't know.
- 59:44Do you have a general like leaning one way?
- 59:46Whether the Democrats should be more, pragmatic, more ruthless,
- 59:49try to win against the Real Enemy or if you're going to be
- 59:52The Virtuous player, you got to be virtuous and like stick to
- 59:55that. I've I mean, I can They do both.
- 59:59I don't know. I may either going to be times
- 1:00:01of moral, where there are things are ethically gray, you know?
- 1:00:05I don't know. Like, I don't know.
- 1:00:06What's the answer to this? This is another scam.
- 1:00:07I was associate with Facebook stuff.
- 1:00:09But what and stuff we were doing when we were working for PR,
- 1:00:12like we would run these like, kind of not really news things,
- 1:00:16that kind of look like news, right in order to promote, you
- 1:00:19know, certain things. So it wasn't like fake in the
- 1:00:21sense that we made up the facts but it was fake in the sense,
- 1:00:23like, you made something look like news.
- 1:00:25It's actually a PR op that's just like, something that
- 1:00:28Millions. Ian grass tops.
- 1:00:29People have been doing ever since they were mailing fake
- 1:00:31newspapers, you know you'd have a website that will be like, oh
- 1:00:35yeah, the Lynchburg Gazette like tell you know, you know, reports
- 1:00:38this fact. And so like you sort of
- 1:00:40reframing article that was written by a, you know, credible
- 1:00:43Outlet like make it as inflammatory as possible and
- 1:00:46then do promote it adds to it that sort of thing, right?
- 1:00:48So, Democrats are doing this now.
- 1:00:50Republicans have been doing it. Democrats are doing it and it's
- 1:00:52like, should Democrats not be doing that because they should,
- 1:00:56you know, practice what they preach or should Democrat.
- 1:00:58Let's make sure to use every tool at their disposal to
- 1:01:01compete against the threat and that's why I'm asking you, you
- 1:01:04don't ya know, I don't know. I'm giving that as a confused.
- 1:01:06I'm giving that as an example that I think, is I really?
- 1:01:09I don't know. I'm not an ethicist and I don't
- 1:01:12think that if you read my book, Eat anyone would want me to be
- 1:01:14there at the session? So I'm doing the best I can.
- 1:01:17I think that's a confusing one and I think that they deserve to
- 1:01:19be criticized for it, but at the same time I get it.
- 1:01:22I think that the thing that bugs me more about the Democrats is I
- 1:01:26do think that one difference between the right and the The
- 1:01:28left in a way, that's nice and pure about the Democrats, but it
- 1:01:32is hurting them, is that the actual people that staff these
- 1:01:34campaigns like really Earnest, really, really.
- 1:01:38All right. And God love them.
- 1:01:39Like the people that run Republican campaigns are
- 1:01:41nihilists, and I think that this, like I said, we're paying
- 1:01:44with a broad brush obviously, but like the generally, there's
- 1:01:47something to this and I see Democrats like using messaging
- 1:01:51and things, because they think that it's the right thing to do
- 1:01:54and they don't want to hurt anybody's feelings on their team
- 1:01:57and stuff that Actually hurting campaigns, and if you look at
- 1:02:01their paid advertising, Democrats, paid advertising is
- 1:02:03like pretty good. Like if you look at Tim Ryan's
- 1:02:06paid advertising in Ohio, like you might think that he's a
- 1:02:08republican, like, it's pretty good.
- 1:02:10In the sense that I get is, I love it is.
- 1:02:12Yeah, with his wife, it's like, well, you don't have to agree on
- 1:02:15everything with your own wife. You don't, why would you have to
- 1:02:17agree with a politician? Like yeah.
- 1:02:19So, I mean some of the stuff that you used him with Tucker
- 1:02:22Carlson and so I think that like the paid, you know, but who's
- 1:02:25running paid advertising? It's like older, gray-haired
- 1:02:27like Democratic strategist. Like who's running the Twitter
- 1:02:29feed his right in the face with who's dealing with the candidate
- 1:02:31did today and I just I worry that Democrats are leaving stuff
- 1:02:35on the table and like losing Races they should be winning.
- 1:02:38I've written just this week with the Arizona Governor's race like
- 1:02:41which is a fight clusterfuck. I'll get fetterman.
- 1:02:45You know, I see this hole for the Federman discourse.
- 1:02:47It's like guys, it might be able list, it might hurt his
- 1:02:50feelings, you know, it might not be appropriate to criticize.
- 1:02:54But if we had a real talk realpolitik discussion about
- 1:02:57fetterman after his stroke, Like shouldn't they really have tried
- 1:03:00to find another candidate? Right?
- 1:03:02I give you wasn't going to be up for it.
- 1:03:03I'm like that's not ableist, it's just like re it's just
- 1:03:07reality, right? In saying that Federman can
- 1:03:09never run for anything again and he should be insulted or mock to
- 1:03:11the people that have Aphasia should be insulted or mocked
- 1:03:15your Doug. Hug you, what's?
- 1:03:17Yeah, but like what is the? But this person is can have a
- 1:03:20senate seat for six years and they're going to be a puppet for
- 1:03:22Donald Trump. Maybe we should like do what he
- 1:03:25can to win. So I like that.
- 1:03:26Is the part. I do think that Sometimes
- 1:03:29Democrats, pull punches because they're trying to do the right
- 1:03:31thing or feeling like don't want to do the right thing in ways
- 1:03:34that is harmful and that concerns me.
- 1:03:37All right? So we should, we should probably
- 1:03:38wrap it up there. But thank you for coming on.
- 1:03:40I hope you feel, you know, more morally pure in your, and your
- 1:03:44movement away from, you know, being in PR, and promoting other
- 1:03:47companies to being in media, promoting yourself, which is the
- 1:03:50light, which is the truth of the way.
- 1:03:53And well, the nice thing is about about it.
- 1:03:58That I am just promoting should I actually think is true, so
- 1:04:02that's a good step. It's not, it's a not morally
- 1:04:04pure but it is an important step in living a fulfilling life.
- 1:04:09And so I do recommend that and you know that I'm still, I'm
- 1:04:12still a fallen angel, you know, I'm trying to do my best so
- 1:04:15maybe eventually I'll move one step over from promoting myself
- 1:04:18to like, promote, oh, then you're immediately, good?
- 1:04:20Thanks, okay. Well, let me know.
- 1:04:24I don't think the priesthood is for me but maybe if you find
- 1:04:27something a little more pure, I'm He to take feedback.
- 1:04:29All right. Thanks Tim.
- 1:04:31Thanks for joining. Thanks a bunch.
- 1:04:32This is great sale. Cool.
- 1:04:35Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:46Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:47Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:49Goodbye. He to take feedback.
- 1:04:29All right. Thanks Tim.
- 1:04:31Thanks for joining. Thanks a bunch.
- 1:04:32This is great sale. Cool.
- 1:04:35Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:46Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:47Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:04:49Goodbye.