Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep3: GRD003 - Should I Take the Pension Lump Sum or Annuity Income Stream?
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm ed slot and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement strategy
- 0:21or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to argue.
- 0:33And both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your Family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:01Ed Slott: Hi everybody.
- 1:02And welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:04I'm Ed Slott, along with Jeff Levine and Jeff, what are we debating today?
- 1:09Jeff Levine: All right.
- 1:10So up for today, ed, we're gonna be discussing or debating.
- 1:13I should say whether someone should take their lump sum from
- 1:18a pension or whether they should take it out as an annuity option.
- 1:21And for today's discussion, let's not focus on whether a joint annuity or a
- 1:26single annuity based on a single life.
- 1:28Let's just say, do you want a big pot of money or do you wanna
- 1:32take it out over your lifetime in guaranteed payments to last.
- 1:36Ed Slott: You mean like a pension?
- 1:37Like the company offers you a pension monthly's payments
- 1:41or a lump sum all at once.
- 1:42That's a big question, especially with lots of companies trying to de-risk
- 1:48and get rid of their, uh, pension obligations off their balance sheet.
- 1:52Jeff Levine: Well, hold on.
- 1:53Don't go.
- 1:53Don't go there yet.
- 1:56First we gotta flip.
- 1:57Maybe you don't wanna make that argument, Ed..
- 1:59Ed Slott: All right.
- 1:59All right.
- 1:59Oh, you did it already.
- 2:00I wanted the coin.
- 2:01I had an actual coin.
- 2:03All right.
- 2:04Jeff Levine: All right.
- 2:04You, you are the winner.
- 2:05So you get to pick, you wanna take the side of when you're given the option,
- 2:08you should take the lump sum or do you wanna take the, this, the option
- 2:12of when you're given that choice, you should try and take the pension.
- 2:16Ed Slott: And as we always say on these debates, this is for educational purposes
- 2:20to help you make the right decision.
- 2:21It doesn't necessarily mean we agree with the side we're taking.
- 2:26So I'll take the side of the lump sum.
- 2:29Jeff Levine: All right.
- 2:30I'm going with the side of, uh, then I'm going with the side of annuity.
- 2:33Perfect.
- 2:33All right.
- 2:34So ed, let, let, let's kick it off.
- 2:35I will defer to you.
- 2:37I will defer the coin toss if you will.
- 2:39Uh, and, and let you start, why would you say, take the lump sum?
- 2:43Ed Slott: Well, it's a bird in hand, you know, when I've spoken to clients
- 2:46and I've had this discussion with people, just like the people, uh,
- 2:49listening today, uh, they say, no, I like, like to have my cash in the hand.
- 2:54You know, sometimes they don't like their company, they don't trust their company or
- 2:58don't trust the viability of the company.
- 3:01And they like to have that cash in hand, even though, actuarily, it may be
- 3:06less, they have the full payment, they can roll it over to an IRA and they
- 3:11know it's in the bank, no matter what the future of the company might be.
- 3:16Jeff Levine: Well, that that's a fair point, ed, but, but what is the
- 3:19number one concern that most people have when it comes to retirement?
- 3:23Ed Slott: Living too long and running outta money.
- 3:26Jeff Levine: All right.
- 3:26Well, when you take your money, it's up to you to figure out and
- 3:30it's up to the markets to handle, and it's up to what stocks will do.
- 3:34It's up to what bonds will do.
- 3:36If you go through a, a number of tough years, especially close to retirement,
- 3:40where sequence of return risk can kick in that could completely derail
- 3:44an otherwise sound retirement plan.
- 3:46Whereas if I have the ability to take a, a pension that is a
- 3:51guaranteed stream of income that I have for the rest of my life.
- 3:55And if I'm married, I can choose to take that over a spouse's life
- 3:58or even over a younger beneficiary.
- 3:59Now that may reduce my payments, but I can create guaranteed income
- 4:03for the life of myself, as well as other individuals I care about.
- 4:07And I don't have to worry about what the markets will do.
- 4:10That's on the company.
- 4:11I don't have to worry about what, uh, bond rates are and what, you
- 4:15know, what interest rates do and how they impact my, my portfolio.
- 4:19I can leave that risk onto the company.
- 4:22And, and you even said, ed, like companies may want to get rid of
- 4:26this because they think it's too good of a deal for the employee.
- 4:29Well, usually if the company thinks it's too good of a deal for you, why
- 4:33would you give it back to the company?
- 4:35Ed Slott: Well, some people it's true people, uh, like the idea on the one hand
- 4:40of guaranteed income for life, the money never runs out, but then I've spoken to
- 4:44people and they say, well, I'm retiring.
- 4:46I'd like to take an extra 50,000 or a hundred thousand and do this or that,
- 4:51or get a retirement home and do things.
- 4:54That won't cut it on the monthly payment.
- 4:56Sometimes I need part of a lump sum.
- 4:58Maybe not all of it and the rest they can invest on their own and maybe do annuities
- 5:03with their own advisor and create some of that stream of income or do other
- 5:07planning, but they have more freedom.
- 5:09And that's what people like.
- 5:11Again, back to the bird in the hand, they can take the lump sum.
- 5:14It's true what you said they could run outta money if it's poorly invested,
- 5:18but that's where you, uh, work with hopefully a financial advisor that
- 5:22can get you where you wanna go and limit the risk in the investments.
- 5:26If that's what you're worried or having, knowing you have other
- 5:29funds, you talked about sequence of returns risk, which means withdrawing
- 5:33when a market is in decline.
- 5:35Hopefully, if you're making, if you're looking to make this decision, do I
- 5:39take the lump sum, and it's a very big decision now because lots of people
- 5:43are in transition, leaving companies.
- 5:45Do I take the lump sum or do I take monthly payments?
- 5:49You have to look at your own house and see if you have other funds that
- 5:53may carry you if the market goes down.
- 5:56Jeff Levine: That's all fair, but I, I look and I say, what happens when
- 6:00an individual wants to make sure that they don't run out of money?
- 6:04What's one of the best ways they can do that.
- 6:05And it is with a guaranteed stream of income, whether that's through a
- 6:09pension or even through a, a private, uh, insurer's annuity and not, you
- 6:15know, a true income style annuity, like a single premium immediate annuity or
- 6:19some other style of annuity where you make that payment and the insurance
- 6:24company now guarantees income for life.
- 6:26And I think it's important to understand, uh, you know, for, for listeners to
- 6:30understand that if, if that's the case, and you're looking at these two options,
- 6:35your pension plan is almost always the cheaper annuity, if you will, right?
- 6:40Like there isn't the need to spend dollars marketing for your pension plan.
- 6:45There aren't all the, the distribution costs, etc.
- 6:48So when we compare what you could get on the open market with $1 of
- 6:53retirement savings and how much income for life that would buy with the same.
- 6:58That you could take with $1 of your pension and see how much income for life
- 7:02that would buy, uh, most of the time, not always, but most of the time your pension
- 7:07will create a larger income stream.
- 7:09So you are, you're in a situation where you're already getting a really good
- 7:14deal on guaranteed income and let's face it, another argument here that is
- 7:18probably discounted in a lot of, in a lot of places is the simplicity of this.
- 7:24You know, we're talking about people who are going through retirement.
- 7:28And most of the time when we get to retirement, we need to simplify our lives.
- 7:33Uh, we are getting to the point in our lives where maybe cognitive
- 7:37ability begins to decline and, and we wanna spend our time doing
- 7:41things that are important to us.
- 7:43Not doing all these other things like figuring out how much stocks and bonds
- 7:48I should own and worrying about what the markets will do and not, it's not just
- 7:51the, the fact that the markets go down.
- 7:53It's not just the, what if, but even if things are good, there's so many more
- 7:57decisions now that you need to make.
- 7:59How much do you invest in different things?
- 8:01Which investments do you take?
- 8:03Do you have a Roth account or a traditional?
- 8:05All these decisions now piling on you at a time in your life when
- 8:09you're trying to simplify things.
- 8:11I mean, it just, it sounds almost daunting to me, whereas
- 8:13the pension is nice and easy.
- 8:15It's almost like when I worked, I just get my monthly check and I go do what
- 8:18I want with that money each month.
- 8:20And you know what it's even better than working.
- 8:23Cause I don't have to do anything to get it.
- 8:25Ed Slott: Okay.
- 8:25So somebody, uh, listening to this might sound, oh, that's
- 8:29daunting, but you know what?
- 8:30When I've had people sitting in front of me and I've told them the same
- 8:33things they say, I still want the money.
- 8:36I want the big check.
- 8:37And anyway, and I'm gonna throw you a softball here.
- 8:40Okay.
- 8:41Uh, anyway, what if I'm taking the payments and many people have that
- 8:45choice, you said joint or one life or two life, obviously the longer
- 8:49you want the payments to go on the pension or what you call an annuity.
- 8:53The guarenteed payment, the the lower they will be.
- 8:57But, uh, so many people that choose that tend to want the higher payment,
- 9:01which ends maybe at the first life, if you're a married couple, for example.
- 9:05And then people say, what if I die three years in?
- 9:08Jeff Levine: Well, that's good.
- 9:09I'll take your lay up here.
- 9:10Yes, I'll take your I'm gonna now slam dunk it.
- 9:12So if you have that, take the money and take a little
- 9:15extra and buy life insurance.
- 9:16Ed Slott: I knew you were gonna say that.
- 9:17That's why I said I threw you a softball.
- 9:19Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 9:20Well, I appreciate that.
- 9:21I I'll give you back one, ed.
- 9:22Uh, and, and that's, you know, one of the things that you've said is
- 9:26that you should consider what would happen if the company goes belly up.
- 9:30The good news there, if you will.
- 9:32I guess it's not really good news if your company goes belly up, but the, the nice
- 9:35part about that is the insurance that's provided by your pension actually has
- 9:40insurance behind it in many cases and notably the P B G C, the pension benefit
- 9:45guarantee corporation guarantees, uh, up to certain amounts of monthly income.
- 9:52Even if your plan goes belly up.
- 9:54So.
- 9:55It's fair.
- 9:56Ed Slott: Let me respond to that because that's the softball bad argument.
- 10:00Nobody, you just made your own argument against that.
- 10:03You don't want complexity.
- 10:04You want simplicity who wants to deal with a pension benefit guarantee, Corp that
- 10:08at best after years of problems, they'll give you a few cents on the dollar.
- 10:14If that happens.
- 10:15Again, I think a lot of people, even though actuarily they would do better
- 10:19with the monthly payments, given an average life expectancy, most people
- 10:24feel more comfortable taking control of their money, getting the lump sum, you
- 10:28know, getting that two, three, 400,000 out, putting it maybe in their IRA of
- 10:32the ability to convert it to a Roth IRA.
- 10:35And they feel they have control of their money and they don't have
- 10:38to worry about these other things, including the company going belly up.
- 10:42Imagine telling somebody, well, now you're gonna have to deal with
- 10:45a pension benefit guarantee Corp.
- 10:47They're a government Corp oop, they're short staffed.
- 10:48They'll get back to you in three years and pay you 5 cents on the dollar.
- 10:52Jeff Levine: Yeah, we could put a link to the, uh, PBGC in our notes.
- 10:55Uh, our show notes.
- 10:56It's worth noting that this year for 2022, uh, if you're taking basically
- 11:01a straight life annuity, right, and you're a 67 year old, just to give
- 11:04people a sense of, of what those maximums are this year to be about
- 11:08$7,500 per month, which is pretty good.
- 11:11Although there are definitely some people who have income and
- 11:14pensions that are in excess of that.
- 11:15And with that, you would be effectively on your own.
- 11:18And if you had.
- 11:19Uh, a joint 50% survivor annuity for, so for two individuals that age, it's
- 11:24closer to about 67, 6800 per month.
- 11:28So we'll put a link to the, the PBGC benefits maximums in the show notes, and
- 11:33people can go check that out and see,
- 11:34Ed Slott: and we'll hope nobody will ever have to go there.
- 11:36Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 11:37I, I, yes, that's a good point, ed.
- 11:38Hopefully that is useless information for everyone, uh, for the rest of their lives.
- 11:43No doubt about it.
- 11:45Ed, anything else that like sticks out to you as a strong argument to make
- 11:48here in favor of, of taking this lump sum while you have that opportunity?
- 11:54Ed Slott: Again, the control and you actually, I wasn't even thinking of it,
- 11:58but you actually made the better argument, which I said a few minutes ago about the
- 12:02ability to convert it to a Roth once you roll it over to your IRA and this way
- 12:07you could do some Roth conversions, too.
- 12:10Jeff Levine: That's fair.
- 12:10It's a good point that we didn't discuss.
- 12:12You do have not only more control over your investments, but over more
- 12:15control of when you pay those taxes...
- 12:17Ed Slott: and more control estate planning wise, even with the secure act and the 10
- 12:21year rule, at least, you know, something, if you don't spend it all, uh, you have
- 12:26some control over the beneficiaries that will get it for at least 10
- 12:29years under the current tax rules.
- 12:31Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 12:31Well, I'll throw them out one more here for, for, for people thinking about
- 12:35leaving money to the next generation.
- 12:37And then you mentioned the secure act, that's that law from 2019, that began
- 12:42to impact beneficiaries in 2020, where previously, you know, young individuals
- 12:47were able to, or anybody really, if you were named on a beneficiary form,
- 12:50could spread out the, the tax impact by spreading out the distributions from an
- 12:55inherited IRA or 401K or similar type of plan over the course of their lifetime.
- 13:01Whereas now many of those individuals have to, to lock those
- 13:04distributions into just 10 years.
- 13:08So you may be compressing a multi-decade distribution schedule into just 10 years.
- 13:12And of course, taking out more income in each of those years
- 13:15can mean pushing yourself into a higher bracket phasing yourself
- 13:18out of credits and exemptions, etc.
- 13:20Well, interestingly enough, uh, now we don't have final regulations
- 13:24ed, yet as we record here today.
- 13:26Um, but we do have proposed regulations.
- 13:27And if the final looks anything like the proposed that's one other argument,
- 13:32actually in favor of the defined benefit plan for those looking to provide a, a
- 13:36lifetime income stream and a legacy to, to children or even grandchildren in
- 13:41the sense that with the secure act, many of those beneficiaries would have to
- 13:45take out everything over just 10 years.
- 13:48Whereas the rules only apply those that 10 year rule only applies to define
- 13:53contribution plans, define benefit plans.
- 13:56Like a pension plan actually are exempt.
- 13:58So you can effectively replicate the stretch by taking the pension
- 14:02option and just choosing a younger beneficiary as the joint annuitant.
- 14:07In other words, the other individual with whom you take
- 14:09distributions out over a lifetime.
- 14:11So a lot of times people think like, well, I have to do it over myself and a spouse.
- 14:15It could be over you and a child or you and a grandchild.
- 14:18Yes.
- 14:18Payments will be much lower, but if you're endgame...
- 14:21Ed Slott: That's what I was just gonna say, that was my argument.
- 14:23To knock that down.
- 14:24The minute you add a beneficiary with all extended payout.
- 14:27There's no free lunch.
- 14:28The longer the annuity payments go out.
- 14:31The lower each monthly payment will be a monthly distribution to you will be.
- 14:36And again, when I speak to clients and consumers, most
- 14:40of them want the larger check.
- 14:42Jeff Levine: That's fair.
- 14:43That's fair.
- 14:44Many, many, you know, just because you want something
- 14:46doesn't mean it's good for you.
- 14:47That's part of why we're here.
- 14:49I guess I'll throw one more out to you.
- 14:51And that's simply that, uh, when we're looking at plans, a lot of times they're
- 14:55based, you know, they're based on actuarial tables and those actuarial
- 14:59tables may consider all individuals of the same age effectively as equivalent and
- 15:05the unfortunate reality is that, you know, your socioeconomic status in life also
- 15:11determines a little bit of your longevity.
- 15:12If we look at individuals with higher incomes and higher net worth.
- 15:16They tend to have better access to healthcare facilities, the ability to pay.
- 15:20They're not worried about going to the doctor and what the copay
- 15:23is, or, or able to afford whatever pills or treatment they may need.
- 15:27And so the, the life expectancy of someone with a, a higher income and
- 15:32higher net worth who is just by nature, more likely to have a pension is
- 15:36actually longer than the average life expectancy of the average person that age.
- 15:41So you're kind of getting a benefit, uh, in, in, in those types of pension and look
- 15:46clearly, ed, obviously, if, if you know, you're, you're someone who's not healthy
- 15:50taking a, a pension option over your lifetime probably is not a great idea, but
- 15:55to the, to the flip side of that, right?
- 15:57If there's an opportunity here to, to benefit from your higher net worth your
- 16:02higher income and that, um, actuarial push out of your life expectancy, the pension
- 16:09can be even that much more attractive.
- 16:11And that may be my, my final argument here on this one, ed.
- 16:14Ed Slott: All right.
- 16:14You know, so you're going back to the, actually the social security argument and
- 16:18social security is actually an annuity.
- 16:21It's a big bet on whether you should take it early or late.
- 16:24We we're going to do that on another one of these, uh, great retirement
- 16:28debates, but it's the same issue.
- 16:30But I wonder if people had the option of getting the lump sum from social
- 16:36security instead of the monthly checks.
- 16:38I think a lot of them would take the lump sum, a bird in the hand,
- 16:41they like the cash up front.
- 16:42That's my final word.
- 16:44Jeff Levine: All right.
- 16:45Fair enough.
- 16:45Well, let's.
- 16:46Let's just take a quick second, add to sum up some of the key points here
- 16:49that we talked about on, on both sides.
- 16:52So we said some of the key reasons to think about maybe taking your
- 16:56pension, uh, as a lump sum are that it gives you more control.
- 17:00So control over your investments, control over your tax planning control
- 17:04over how you leave those assets to your heirs, a lot more control.
- 17:08And you're also taking that away from the company, which could
- 17:12ultimately, you know, run out of money.
- 17:14The pension plan itself could run out of money.
- 17:17And while there is an insurance backing up, many of those plans, the PBGC, as
- 17:22we said, the pension benefit guarantee corporation there is that just adds
- 17:27to the, the mounds of complexity and could limit the amount that you're
- 17:31actually entitled to from the plan.
- 17:33Whereas we said kind of some of the main benefits of this lifetime income
- 17:38is just that it's guaranteed for life.
- 17:39As long as the plan can pay that out and you reduce your complexity,
- 17:44the investment decisions and all that are now on the company.
- 17:47And if you live a long lifetime, and that's what most people are concerned
- 17:50about is outliving their money, right.
- 17:52They don't wanna run out of money before they run out of life.
- 17:55They wanna make sure.
- 17:56That they have that income.
- 17:57That's one of the reasons that, that, you know, the primary reasons you might
- 18:00consider taking the annuity style or true pension option, monthly income
- 18:07or quarterly income, whatever that is, periodic payments over a lifetime.
- 18:11Ed Slott: All right.
- 18:12You know, one last thing I know, I said the last thing was the
- 18:14last thing, but since you said
- 18:16Jeff Levine: I will allow it, ed, go for it.
- 18:18Ed Slott: Since you said they like the lifetime, they want to, the
- 18:20income, they live a long time.
- 18:22They may get ill.
- 18:23I hear from people that say, you know, the opposite.
- 18:26The reason I want the lump sum is before I get too old and too ill, I
- 18:30may wanna take some of those chunks and enjoy it now, while I can,
- 18:34and that's the second last word.
- 18:36Jeff Levine: All right.
- 18:37Fair enough.
- 18:38Well, ed, as you know, there are two sides to every coin, but your life
- 18:42and retirement decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 18:46And that's why one thing that you and I always agree on is making sure
- 18:50that you're taking, talking through any big decision with a knowledgeable
- 18:53financial advisor or tax professional.
- 18:56So you can weigh the pros and the cons of those different decisions against
- 18:59your specific goals and objectives.
- 19:02And if you'd like to continue the discussion with ed and I we'd love to
- 19:04hear from you, you can reach out to ed on Twitter using the handle at the Slott
- 19:09with two Ts @TheSlottReport, you can reach out to me using the handle @CPAPlanner,
- 19:16wanna tell us what we missed or other arguments pro or con uh, particular side.
- 19:21You tend to agree with more than another, or you just have
- 19:24a topic for another debate.
- 19:26We'd love to hear from you.
- 19:27So until then, thanks so much, ed.
- 19:29It's been fun and I will see you next time for the great time debate.
- 19:33Outro: Jeffrey Levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham wealth partners.
- 19:37This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 19:40not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 19:43Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 19:46which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 19:49Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 19:52completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 19:54The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 19:57and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.