Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Caveat Litigator: Avoiding Landmines in California Real Estate Disputes
Transcript
- 0:02My name is Brianna Rucker. I am Diversity and
- 0:05Inclusion Committee Chair of the VHBA's Barrister's
- 0:08Section. And I'm super excited to introduce our
- 0:11speaker today. His name is David Kohher. David
- 0:14is a mediator and arbitrator at Kohher ADR with
- 0:18extensive experience in legal practice, corporate
- 0:21counsel, and legislative service. He has held
- 0:24key roles at Southern California Edison, Ervin
- 0:27Cohen, and Jessup. and as legislative counsel
- 0:31to a U .S. congressman. David also serves as
- 0:34an ADR panelist for the U .S. District Court,
- 0:38Central District of California, and has held
- 0:40numerous civic leadership positions, including
- 0:43chairing the Pasadena Board of Zoning Appeals.
- 0:46And now, without further ado, let's get started.
- 0:49All right, great. Thank you, Rhianna, for the
- 0:51introduction. Appreciate that. If we could go
- 0:54ahead and put the slides up, we can... Start
- 0:58with the presentation. All right. And let's go
- 1:06ahead and get started then. So as you all know,
- 1:10we're here to discuss real estate disputes and
- 1:13potential issues. First, a little bit about myself.
- 1:16So you heard some of my background earlier. Some
- 1:19relevant experience that I'll add to that is
- 1:23that I also am a past chair of the Planning Commission.
- 1:26here in the city of Pasadena, which is where
- 1:28I'm actually sitting at the moment. And from
- 1:33that experience in Pasadena, it's been helpful
- 1:36for informing some of the background that we're
- 1:38going to be talking about today. If we could
- 1:40jump to the next slide, please, that'd be great.
- 1:42All right. So let's talk about why we are here.
- 1:49California real estate disputes can often involve
- 1:52unanticipated legal complexities, issues such
- 1:56as historical easements, municipal zoning quirks,
- 2:01certainly familial emotional overlay, and disclosure
- 2:07pitfalls. So this is something, it's an area
- 2:11where even the seasoned litigator can inadvertently
- 2:15make a misstep through the patchwork of statutes
- 2:18and local ordinances that are unique to the area
- 2:21of real estate practice. I want to be clear,
- 2:25this isn't meant to be a primer in terms of an
- 2:27understanding of the whole of real estate law
- 2:30in California, but rather to highlight some of
- 2:34the areas that I have seen issues arise, also
- 2:38to provide perhaps some ideas for issues you
- 2:41may want to watch for in your cases. And really,
- 2:46it's just a focus on those critical pitfalls
- 2:48that can end up diverting a case, unfortunately.
- 2:53With that, let's go ahead and head to the next
- 2:55slide, please. And the first area we're going
- 2:59to talk about is zoning, CEQA, and political
- 3:03momentum. And for that, we're going to talk about
- 3:06the case of Save Tara versus the city of West
- 3:09Hollywood. If we could go to the next slide,
- 3:12please. we'll see some pictures here of Tara.
- 3:18Now Tara is a pretty unique property. This certainly
- 3:22was not a black acre or white acre type of nondescript
- 3:27property as you often hear of in real estate
- 3:30cases from law school. The story begins with
- 3:35a colonial revival mansion as you can see in
- 3:38the pictures located on North Laurel Avenue in
- 3:41West Hollywood. is originally built in 1914 and
- 3:45nicknamed Tara after the plantation in Gone with
- 3:49the Wind. It wasn't actually featured in the
- 3:53movie, mind you, it just was named after. In
- 3:56any case, is on beautifully landscaped grounds,
- 4:00is designated as a local cultural resource in
- 4:031994. In 1997, the then 98 -year -old owner,
- 4:11Elsie Weissman, donated the property to the city
- 4:14with a life tenancy provision for herself. She
- 4:19passed away in 2000 and the property then became
- 4:25the city's infee. So in 2003 is when our story
- 4:30really kicks off and that's when the city began
- 4:34to take action to try and transform Tara into
- 4:3735 units of affordable senior housing. to enable
- 4:42the financing of this construction project that
- 4:45is going to be a major remodel, it entered into
- 4:49an option and development agreement with a local
- 4:52nonprofit that offered to convey the property
- 4:55at a low cost and to contribute nearly two and
- 5:00a half million dollars in land value and loan
- 5:03assistance. This was all done before a CEQA review,
- 5:07however. The city issued public statements celebrating
- 5:11a federal grant and relocation planning assistance.
- 5:17Staff of the city began engaging tenants about
- 5:22eviction timelines. Obviously had to move out
- 5:24some of the folks who were in there in the units
- 5:28that already existed in Tara. And it was clear
- 5:33that the project had momentum, even though environmental
- 5:36review had not been initiated at all. There were
- 5:40press conferences and press releases and all
- 5:44of the like, as you can imagine. Well, neighbors
- 5:47who didn't want this project formed a group called
- 5:51Save Tara. It was a grassroots group opposing
- 5:54the project. They sued. seeking to avoid the
- 5:58agreements from the city and force secret compliance
- 6:02before the city can make any binding commitments.
- 6:06Now, at the time, the case law out there seemed
- 6:11to indicate that CEQA would only apply for the
- 6:15actual land use approval, which is why the city
- 6:18had moved forward in this manner. They thought
- 6:20they didn't have to engage in the CEQA process
- 6:23until there was an actual permit application
- 6:27or otherwise zoning change, something of that
- 6:32nature, some land use provision that was before
- 6:34them. But the trial court ruled against them,
- 6:38reasoning that the agreement explicitly conditioned
- 6:44conveyance and funding on the CEQA compliance.
- 6:52SAVETAR appealed and this went to the Court of
- 6:56Appeal and then the California Supreme Court
- 6:58who disagreed. The California Supreme Court adopted
- 7:02an intermediate rule. So even a conditional agreement
- 7:07such as what the city signed that had a provision
- 7:10in it that technically said, no this is valid
- 7:13until the CEQA approval and we go through the
- 7:16full CEQA process and then the land use approvals,
- 7:20even that mounted to a de facto approval if in
- 7:25context the lead agency's actions, in this case
- 7:29the city of West Hollywood was the lead agency
- 7:31for CEQA purposes, These, such as public statements,
- 7:37the financial commitments, the activities for
- 7:40tenant relocation, option agreements, clearly
- 7:45demonstrated a practical certainty about the
- 7:48project. And in such cases, the California Supreme
- 7:51Court ruled an environmental impact report must
- 7:55proceed the approval no matter how caveated the
- 7:59contract language might be. Today, Tara is still
- 8:04owned by the City of West Hollywood and it is
- 8:06home to some affordable housing units as a small
- 8:10artist community. However, the project that was
- 8:15envisioned in 2003 never materialized and largely
- 8:20because of this Supreme Court case ended up causing
- 8:24too much delay and then eventually the project
- 8:27died. If we could go to The next slide here we
- 8:33can talk a little bit about what does it all
- 8:35mean here. I think our key legal lessons to take
- 8:40away are that project momentum at a lead agency
- 8:44can trigger a CEQA requirements even with conditional
- 8:48terms. Now let me talk about what a lead agency
- 8:50is for those of you who may not be familiar.
- 8:53When you have a project, given the patchwork
- 8:56of local governments in California, especially
- 8:59in an urban area, you'll often have several different
- 9:04government agencies involved. That can mean both
- 9:08local and state jurisdictions, it could be special
- 9:10governments, so on and so forth. A lead agency
- 9:15is the one that is chosen by the uh that ends
- 9:21up taking the lead on the project, and they have
- 9:24control over it. And the reason for this setup
- 9:27is to avoid requiring multiple environmental
- 9:30impact reports, multiple CEQA approvals, etc.,
- 9:34etc. The court here prioritized the actions and
- 9:40the intent, rather than the legalese of the agreement,
- 9:45putting the substance over form. And the public
- 9:50narrative that was presented mattered more than
- 9:52the contract clauses. Remember, there are lots
- 9:56of statements and pronouncements and press, you
- 9:59know... various publicity around what was going
- 10:04to be done, how great it was, and the contract
- 10:07clauses were buried deep in the agreements as
- 10:10seen as a hook for technicalities. The California
- 10:14Supreme Court in this case saw through all of
- 10:17that and said, no, the city is taking an action.
- 10:19A public agency is taking an action. They have
- 10:23to treat it as a secret matter from the start
- 10:26of taking that action. What we can learn here
- 10:31is it really demonstrates how regulatory and
- 10:34political momentum can undermine those legal
- 10:37defenses when not anticipated early. In this
- 10:41particular case, the city of West Hollywood thought
- 10:43their legal defense was going to be that particular
- 10:46contract clause. And for mediation purposes,
- 10:50The case shows that early recognition of zoning
- 10:53and project dynamics, including the public statements,
- 10:57the municipal behavior, kind of what the community's
- 11:00involvement was here for the land use, is crucial
- 11:05to a realistic risk assessment. If we could go
- 11:09to the next slide. I apologize. I'm just going
- 11:13to try and fix my light here, if I may. All right.
- 11:16Thank you. Let's talk about some of the, I believe
- 11:25we talked about the key legal lessons. Now let's
- 11:28talk about the strategic mediation lessons here.
- 11:31So again, look for zoning dynamics early as I
- 11:33just mentioned. The municipal politics are important
- 11:37to the situation depending on the size and the
- 11:39scope of the project that it could be important.
- 11:43It also could be something that while the municipal
- 11:45politics do not initially play into consideration
- 11:48in your analysis of your client's project. depending
- 11:52on what else is going on in that jurisdiction,
- 11:55there could be other issues where it comes into
- 11:57scope. There could be other developments where
- 12:01it could ensnare your client's project. So you
- 12:04want to work with someone who has that localized...
- 12:08that local and specialized knowledge to be able
- 12:12to see those issues ahead of time. And on the
- 12:15flip side, the potential for using CEQA risk
- 12:19for managing a project that your clients may
- 12:22oppose. Conditional causes are not going to provide
- 12:26you with immunity. So that's not going to be
- 12:29a solution to the mediation in terms of the settlement
- 12:33that's reached. because those are going to be
- 12:38found to be invalid, so it's going to provide
- 12:40you with little leverage. And then consider the
- 12:43substance of what's going on for the legal and
- 12:47public procedural risk. So discuss that zoning
- 12:50strategy early, exploring who else is on the
- 12:55horizon that could step into the situation and
- 12:58create a risk. One thing that a mediator can
- 13:02do to help is to reframe that zoning conflict
- 13:05as risk management in the project. Especially
- 13:10because, let's be honest, the CEQA timing can
- 13:13be very ambiguous, right? It can be a lengthy
- 13:17process and time can be a problem if not kill
- 13:23many deals. Okay, with that, I think we've discussed
- 13:28that thoroughly. Let's go ahead and move to the
- 13:32next item here. We're going to talk about title
- 13:36and issues with a chain of title. And for this
- 13:39one, I want to talk about the city of Manhattan
- 13:42Beach. It's a case called the City of Manhattan
- 13:45Beach versus Superior Court. But it actually
- 13:48involves a particular jogging path in the city.
- 13:53And if we could go to the next. Slide, please.
- 13:57You can see a picture of that there. So this
- 14:01jogging path's over a forgotten railroad, all
- 14:04right? So let's talk about the early 1980s in
- 14:08Manhattan Beach, a coastal community built atop
- 14:12sand dunes and rail beds. I'm sure most who are
- 14:16listening here are familiar, have been, but buried
- 14:20beneath what had become a public jogging path
- 14:23and a greenway, was a legal enigma written in
- 14:29a 100 foot wide easement grant. Well, I guess
- 14:35that was actually the debate. Was it an easement
- 14:37grant or was it title and fee? And we'll get
- 14:39into that. The original grant came from 1888
- 14:44by the Redondo Land Company and was to the Redondo
- 14:48Beach Railway Company. which eventually, by the
- 14:51time of our litigation story, would become part
- 14:55of the Santa Fe Railroad. It was a grant for
- 14:59one dollar, and the deed, as it was entitled,
- 15:03described the grant in a limited fashion as a
- 15:06right of way for the construction, maintenance,
- 15:10and operation of a steam railroad. So that's
- 15:14language that sounds like an easement, right?
- 15:18and an easement for a limited purpose, for very
- 15:22narrow limited purpose, the construction maintenance
- 15:25and operation of this steam railroad. Yet the
- 15:30document also used traditional Ramize release
- 15:33and quit claim language akin to an offer of a
- 15:37full interest, such as if you were to sell land
- 15:42in a complete fee title. Well, Many years later,
- 15:49obviously steam railroads are not practical to
- 15:52be operating through Manhattan Beach today and
- 15:56in the 1980s the Santa Fe Railroad sold the land
- 16:00to the City of Manhattan Beach for park use.
- 16:05And obviously this transaction was conducted
- 16:07by both the Santa Fe Railroad and the City of
- 16:10Manhattan Beach with the assumption that it had
- 16:12full legal title. Heirs of the Redondo Land Company.
- 16:17Now remember, the Redondo Land Company was the
- 16:20owner of the property that then made the grant
- 16:23to the Redondo Railway, the Redondo Beach Railroad
- 16:27Company. The Redondo Land Company heirs surfaced
- 16:34and asserted that the railroad, for these purposes
- 16:38Santa Fe Railroad, only held an easement, not
- 16:41fee title. and that therefore the Santa Fe could
- 16:48not sell it to the city of Manhattan Beach and
- 16:51that they demanded compensation through claims
- 16:55for rejectment based on years of non -rail use
- 16:59or in the alternative inverse condemnation. Well,
- 17:04as you can imagine, the case made it to the California
- 17:07Supreme Court, which found the deed ambiguous.
- 17:11Okay, not a surprise there. So it looked beyond
- 17:14the text. They considered how the Redondo Land
- 17:16Company had behaved afterwards, how the land
- 17:19was treated over the decades, and how subsequent
- 17:23transfers had implied full ownership without
- 17:27objection from the Redondo Land Company or heirs.
- 17:32So the California Supreme Court concluded that
- 17:34Santa Fe had received a fee simple interest.
- 17:38or more precisely the Redondo Beach Railroad
- 17:43Company had received a fee simple interest, which
- 17:46then became the property eventually of the Santa
- 17:49Fe Railroad. And because of this, there was no
- 17:55compensation owed to the heirs. So in mediations,
- 18:01often disputes over title will hinge on similar
- 18:04ambiguities. uh and litigation can become this
- 18:09kind of generational tug of war so the the problem
- 18:14is that confidence is eroded when the parties
- 18:16realize that their assumed legal foundation here
- 18:20ownership by the santa fe railroad is shakier
- 18:24than believed and it's less a question of framing
- 18:28it as who's wrong but for mediation purposes
- 18:32and reaching a settlement it's really about questioning
- 18:35What is this really worth and what are the risks
- 18:37of continuation? In this particular case, now
- 18:41obviously I wasn't a part of the mediation of
- 18:44the case between the heirs to the Redondo Beach
- 18:48land company and the city of Manhattan Beach,
- 18:53but given the complete loss that occurred in
- 18:58this circumstance, it would be interesting to
- 19:02know what was offered by the City of Manhattan
- 19:05Beach and what the balance would have been for
- 19:10those errors between what they eventually got,
- 19:13which was a large legal bill, and what they could
- 19:17have gotten from the City of Manhattan Beach
- 19:19earlier on in the process. If we could go to
- 19:23the next slide, please. We can talk about some
- 19:26of the key legal lessons here. So this was a
- 19:30deed dating all the way back to 1888. Here, the
- 19:35prior use of the land at the time seemed relevant
- 19:38to the purchase. For some reason, there was a
- 19:42desire to put language in about the construction,
- 19:45maintenance, and operation of a steam railroad
- 19:48into that grant deed, rather than simply having
- 19:54it be fee -simple transfer. I suspect at the
- 19:59time, under knowing the history of the region,
- 20:02that was because the Redondo Beach Land Company
- 20:05wanted to ensure a railroad was being built on
- 20:09that land and not just more houses by the beach,
- 20:13because there was a transportation issue. There
- 20:15was a reason they were selling this piece of
- 20:18land for just $1. But that ended up causing unintended
- 20:22consequences down the road. think the lesson
- 20:28here is not just reviewing the title report,
- 20:32okay, because this would not necessarily have
- 20:34been caught by a title report. It is reviewing
- 20:38the history of the land, the use of the land,
- 20:41and to see if there might be some question in
- 20:44that document, okay, in any of those documents
- 20:47that are in that chain of title that would be
- 20:51relevant to what you're trying to do with the
- 20:55land. In this particular case, for example, even
- 20:59if it hadn't been the city of Manhattan Beach
- 21:02buying this land for the construction of this
- 21:06public greenway, let's say that there had been
- 21:08a different bidder, that Santa Fe Railroad had
- 21:12sold it to a home developer, more houses were
- 21:15built in the space, which certainly would have
- 21:18been an economically beneficial use of the land
- 21:22by the early 1980s. Nonetheless, you would have
- 21:27had the same issue and there is a question of
- 21:30how the court would have considered that balancing
- 21:33of the equities at that time with a different
- 21:37purpose for the land. Here the courts did look
- 21:42beyond the text to the behavior and For a similar
- 21:48situation your client may need to assemble evidence
- 21:52of land use of the transfers and of long -term
- 21:55control What was done with the land? during the
- 21:59period in question here is a period of nearly
- 22:03a hundred years Historians may be a good option
- 22:07for this if funds allow There can be local historians.
- 22:13Sometimes, local historians will be employed
- 22:16for getting a particular property to be declared
- 22:21for historical status, such as the Melrose tax
- 22:24exemption. Alternatively, there may be other
- 22:30historians who may be relevant to the discussion.
- 22:33That's something to look into and consider beyond
- 22:35just to get obtaining a title report and title
- 22:38insurance. And also understanding that the transactional
- 22:44horizons may not allow for a resolution in time
- 22:49for what the project is. Here, the project was
- 22:53used as a greenway by the community. There was
- 22:57not a time limit on it in the way that my hypothetical
- 23:02developer, who may have purchase that land from
- 23:06the Santa Fe to build homes on, they may not
- 23:10have been able to make that project pencil out
- 23:12given the time that would be required to take
- 23:16a deed from the 1880s all the way to the California
- 23:19Supreme Court. Okay, so that's something to think
- 23:22about too in terms of these issues that may crop
- 23:24up and that you may find as you're working on
- 23:27putting the case together. If I could have the
- 23:30next slide, please. Let's talk about some of
- 23:34the strategies for mediation here. So as we've
- 23:39talked about, title reports are not the whole
- 23:41story. I doubt that something like this would
- 23:46have been discovered and highlighted on the title
- 23:48report for a project, and certainly for a similar
- 23:53project. It's going to be a development of some
- 23:57type. These ambiguous deeds can mean uncertainty
- 24:02and leverage. So having a strong story to tell
- 24:06us that this as the dispute spanned over a century
- 24:10involving descendants who never saw the land
- 24:12and it turned on subtle wording differences beyond
- 24:17what Quite honestly, even most lawyers would
- 24:20understand to have been a problem. I think that's
- 24:22something where you'd have to be specialized
- 24:25and knowledgeable about real estate matters to
- 24:27understand the significance of the language that's
- 24:30in that deed that I quoted for you earlier. And
- 24:34again, not just have reviewed the preliminary
- 24:37report, but also have actually reviewed the document,
- 24:41the underlying deed document itself. which also
- 24:45can mean being able to read the underlying deed
- 24:47document. As those who have delved into these
- 24:50matters know, those documents can sometimes have
- 24:53legibility issues. That being said, the city
- 24:59had long acted like the true owner, maintaining
- 25:01the past, installing various improvements, et
- 25:05cetera. And so that also can... That ended up
- 25:11providing help here in the California Supreme
- 25:13Court's ultimate analysis and their decision.
- 25:16But in mediation, the lesson, one other lesson
- 25:20here, I should say, is shifting the conversation
- 25:23from the all or nothing discussion of the legal
- 25:27minutia to really getting into what's another
- 25:31year of litigation really worth, right? um now
- 25:35one member one benefit here that the city had
- 25:38going for it is that the longer it took for the
- 25:42litigation continued the longer these uh neighbors
- 25:46the members of the community had the beneficial
- 25:49use of the greenway right so time was not uh
- 25:55an issue of leverage for them okay then yet you
- 25:59want to take a look at that when you're examining
- 26:02something like this for uh clients all right
- 26:07let's go ahead i'm also gonna i'll just take
- 26:11a moment to note that um if uh before i jump
- 26:16into the the next section here um well that's
- 26:19fine you can move forward to the next slide um
- 26:22Regarding partition actions, but I just want
- 26:24to know if you have questions that come up Please
- 26:27enter them in the Q &A box. We have that feature
- 26:32here And I will be going through those later
- 26:36I I don't believe folks have access to the chat
- 26:39and I I don't have access to be replying in the
- 26:42chat But if you do have questions, feel free
- 26:45to use the Q &A so I can address them later Okay
- 26:50with that then let's go to the next slide so
- 26:54I can start talking about partition actions.
- 26:56And I've got two examples for you here. There
- 27:00we go. All right. So, now, in California, California
- 27:09law grants real property co -owners an absolute
- 27:13right to partition. It's Code of Civil Procedure
- 27:17872 .210. But every co -owner has a statutory
- 27:26right unless it is waived in writing. However,
- 27:31this can be difficult in practice. So let me
- 27:35share with you a story of family dynamics, legal
- 27:39rights, and the emotional attachments. all coming
- 27:43together and colliding in a partition case. This
- 27:47is the story of two brothers, Adam and James,
- 27:51who had recently inherited a modest but very
- 27:56well -located duplex in Los Angeles from their
- 28:00mother who had passed away. Adam was the younger
- 28:03of the two brothers. He lived in the upstairs
- 28:06unit for over a decade. uh after moving back
- 28:12uh when his mother's health began to their mother's
- 28:15health began to decline he stayed on in the home
- 28:18uh after her passing he was maintaining the home
- 28:22paying the utilities handling minor repairs Really,
- 28:27to Adam, it was more than a property. It was
- 28:30home. You know, the garden still had the mother's
- 28:34rose bushes. I remember him discussing, I mean,
- 28:38you know, the dining room was filled with Thanksgiving
- 28:40memories, right? I mean, all of the trappings.
- 28:44So his understanding was that there was an unwritten
- 28:48agreement that he had earned the right to stay
- 28:51in the property, okay? But... James was the older
- 28:58the older brother. He lived out of state He hadn't
- 29:01visited much the last few years He had run into
- 29:07trouble with a failed small business unfortunately
- 29:10and and a divorce He saw the duplex as a lifeline
- 29:17He needed his share of that equity He felt justified
- 29:23in pursuing it. He He thought there's nothing
- 29:25formal that specified what the rights were going
- 29:31to be in terms of the transfer. It was left to
- 29:34both of them. It passed on to both in equal shares.
- 29:41Okay, so unable to come to terms with Adam, they
- 29:48James sought out counsel filed a partition action
- 29:51and they were asking the court to Force a sale
- 29:55because of this Adam felt blindsided He really
- 30:01wasn't prepared to deal with the business matter
- 30:04at hand He, when it came to mediation, he was
- 30:09angry, defensive, he was holding on to the emotional
- 30:14and personal issues involving the home, and he
- 30:18really was holding firm that his brother was
- 30:20violating their mother's wishes, claimed that
- 30:24she had always said he could keep the house.
- 30:26Of course, there was nothing in writing as to
- 30:28this. At one point, he said, you know, it's not
- 30:34just a building to be bought, sold. And, you
- 30:40know, now, unfortunately, as lawyers, we know,
- 30:43well, that is kind of what it is. Obviously,
- 30:48I didn't say it to him in that way, but that's
- 30:51the reality of the matter, right? And there's
- 30:54a lot of emotion around that. And he felt it
- 30:57was all that he had left of his mother. James,
- 31:01on the other hand, had a very clear -eyed view.
- 31:05He came prepared. He understood. He came with
- 31:08counsel. They understood what their rights were.
- 31:12But this is a case where, obviously, there are
- 31:16clear legal rights involved. It was going to
- 31:20be messy to be able to—it was going to be time
- 31:24-consuming. to finish the process and it was
- 31:26going to be messy to then complete the sale after
- 31:31having won in court. So in this case the mediation
- 31:37wasn't just about the legal outcomes it was about
- 31:39the resolution. And what stood in the way here
- 31:43was not the Code of Civil Procedure statutes,
- 31:47it was the pride and the deep sense of personal
- 31:51injustice, of Adam having felt betrayed. James
- 31:55meanwhile, I've been talking about him being
- 31:59hard -nosed in this, but he also felt that he
- 32:01had been ignored in this, that his needs, as
- 32:05he had fallen on some hard times recently, as
- 32:08I mentioned, were being ignored by Adam, and
- 32:12that Adam was living in this largest duplex where
- 32:17he... You know, had all this empty space, he
- 32:21could easily take his half of the money, James
- 32:23felt, and Adam could live somewhere else. It
- 32:26wasn't like James was trying to put Adam out
- 32:28on the streets, so he thought Adam was overreacting
- 32:32to the situation and ignoring James's needs,
- 32:35especially his financial situation. There are
- 32:39a lot of practical and human concerns here. Now,
- 32:42eventually we were able to work out an arrangement.
- 32:47Part of this was getting Adam to get understanding
- 32:50that the court wasn't going to be able to enforce
- 32:54his sentimental claim. James also recognized
- 33:01that forcing a sale was going to have two negative
- 33:06impacts. First, from the business side, lower
- 33:08market value, his hair on the deal, so it's going
- 33:12to be troublesome. Beyond that, it also was going
- 33:17to have long -term impacts and really foreclose
- 33:20the option of repairing this relationship between
- 33:27the brothers. So with that, we were able to work
- 33:32out a situation where independent values were
- 33:37going to be obtained as to what the proper valuation
- 33:40is, how to how to for Adam to get financing to
- 33:46be able to pay James a lump sum so that James
- 33:52could be able to take care of his financial concerns
- 33:56while Adam was then able to operate the property,
- 34:01rent out the other unit, and make the payments
- 34:05on the loan that he had obtained. It wasn't a
- 34:09complicated real estate transaction here. It
- 34:12was, I mean there were some unique bits to it,
- 34:16but really at the end of the day it was about
- 34:18getting people in the right place to be able
- 34:20to understand this and to be able to consider
- 34:25these with a clear mind. If we could go to the
- 34:28next slide. We'll talk about the legal rights
- 34:31involved here, first off as an absolute right,
- 34:35as I discussed, to cut a civil procedure. And
- 34:37by the way, there's a citation slide at the end
- 34:40that's going to be in the written materials of
- 34:43this and all the other cases. But there also
- 34:46were problems nonetheless. James had to pursue
- 34:50the lawsuit. He had to spend some time and money
- 34:53on it. and risk the destruction of an otherwise
- 34:59positive familial relationship. Those are costs
- 35:05that the Code of Civil Procedure cannot reimburse
- 35:09you for, it can't protect you from. Let's talk
- 35:13more about the strategic mediation lessons to
- 35:16learn from this example. This is really the legal
- 35:21right. partition, meeting the emotional resistance,
- 35:24and that legal clarity does not necessarily equal
- 35:29win, right? The partition rights may be black
- 35:31and white, but those sibling dynamics are anything
- 35:35but. Reframing this helped bridge the financial
- 35:39needs on James's side regarding and the emotional
- 35:43value that Adam was finding in it. and that reframing
- 35:48it from rights to risks opened up new possibilities.
- 35:52Neither party left with everything they wanted,
- 35:55but they actually both felt that they gained
- 36:00more than they were expecting. So I thought that
- 36:03was a very positive resolution. And then finally,
- 36:08the structured buyout that we were able to organize
- 36:13meant that a business solution is able to be
- 36:18found to the legal issues, but there had to be
- 36:20the right contact set for the emotional win of
- 36:25the relationship being repaired or setting a
- 36:28foundation for the repair of that emotional relationship
- 36:31that also had to be built in. All right, let's
- 36:37move on to the next slide, please. And we're
- 36:41going to talk about a... Duck Pond up in Butte
- 36:46County. So this is a case of Butte Creek Island
- 36:54Ranch versus Creme. It's a 1982 case. It's out
- 37:00of the 3rd District and the parties were co -owners
- 37:04of a remote Butte County Duck Ranch. Duck Hunting
- 37:09Ranch, I should say. Okay. It was a secluded
- 37:15ranch in Butte County's famous Butte Sink. It's
- 37:19a vital seasonal habitat for migrating ducks.
- 37:23And the ranch was composed of two parcels. There
- 37:26was parcel A, a 40 acre parcel with a sleeping
- 37:31house, communal dining building. garage barn,
- 37:36really all the development. There's a small landing
- 37:39strip on that 40 -acre parcel, but everything
- 37:46was pretty spread out. Meanwhile, Parcel B was
- 37:51a 181 -acre marshland ringed by the Butte Creek
- 37:58and the Sanborn Slough. parcel a that had the
- 38:05support camp on it really supported parcel B
- 38:10which is where the duck hunting occurred is much
- 38:15more rustic but functional so crim was a man
- 38:20with generational ties to the land. He had visited
- 38:23the ranch annually since 1948. He inherited his
- 38:28half in 1971 and continued using the property
- 38:32heavily. Meanwhile, the Bute Creek Island Ranch
- 38:37Partnership bought the other half in 1978. When
- 38:42Crim refused the attempts to buy him out, they
- 38:45filed for a partition. and the case ended up
- 38:49centering on whether the property should be physically
- 38:51divided or simply sold outright. Well, a court
- 38:56-appointed referee came up with a solution, proposed
- 38:59a partition in kind where each cotent will receive
- 39:04a comparable hunting acreage on parcel B and
- 39:08half of parcel A with access via existing paths.
- 39:13And the approach seemed to preserve the value
- 39:15for both, avoided capital gains, tax consequences,
- 39:20and considered how rare comparable ranches were
- 39:23at the time. It was practical, equitable, a solution
- 39:29designed to keep both parties whole without the
- 39:33disruption of a forced sale. But then one partner
- 39:39in the partnership side, remember it's CRIM and
- 39:43then the partnership. Of that partnership, one
- 39:46partner decided he wanted the entire ranch. He
- 39:51planned a bid on Parcel B himself and so he wanted
- 39:58to force a sale. So the referees, the quarter
- 40:01point referees approach did not carry the day.
- 40:05Suddenly the partnership Was not willing to engage
- 40:10in this proposal proposed settlement and demanded
- 40:15a sale of the whole property instead and The
- 40:19trial court ended up granting that agreeing to
- 40:21divide parcel a in kind and sell parcel B Alright,
- 40:27so crim appealed because that was gonna mean
- 40:31that he was cut out of parcel B entirely when
- 40:35that one partner ended up buying it at the sale.
- 40:38The appellate court here, the third district,
- 40:41reversed the trial court and it did reaffirm
- 40:45California's statutory presumption of favoring
- 40:50a partition in kind unless the division would
- 40:53substantially reduce value or violate local subdivision
- 40:59or zoning laws. The forced sale, the court emphasized,
- 41:04must be strictly justified. And in this case,
- 41:08parcel B, a fertile migratory habitat, was without
- 41:12any comparable replacement property available
- 41:15on the market. Sale would most certainly diminish
- 41:19the value for CRIM, both of what he retained
- 41:24in parcel A. and the value he was gonna get from
- 41:28parcel B because who's gonna go and try and buy
- 41:31parcel B that doesn't have any value or any interest
- 41:35in parcel A, right? So you have a limited market
- 41:38and so Crim's gonna end up getting the shaft
- 41:41on the pricing for parcel B as well as the enjoyment
- 41:46of parcel A. So when co -tenants are stuck, not
- 41:52because the law is unclear, but because their
- 41:54needs diverge, the question is to ask what's
- 41:59going to align with the statutory default and
- 42:02the emotional reality in this situation. And
- 42:05I think Bute Creek reminds us of that balance.
- 42:08Let's go ahead and go to the next slide, please,
- 42:11and talk about the key legal lessons. So partitioning
- 42:14kind is preferred. Again, the appellate court
- 42:16affirmed the referee's recommendation. Statutory
- 42:21presumption favoring a partition in kind did
- 42:26carry the day, but here the division would substantially
- 42:29reduce the value. There was not an issue of that
- 42:35second prong test for the exception, which is
- 42:38if it would violate local subdivision or zoning
- 42:41laws. Also, A foresale must be strictly justified.
- 42:47Due to the finality of the result of a foresale,
- 42:50the court is going to look carefully. Here, they
- 42:53looked carefully. They saw that losing parcel
- 42:55B would be damaging to parcel A's owners, which
- 43:02would mean both the crim and the ranch. If left
- 43:07to only parcel A due to any other buyer making
- 43:10a successful bid on parcel B and, of course,
- 43:14the damages there. Let's uh jump to the next
- 43:18one uh if we could please here and um let's talk
- 43:25about the strategic mediation lessons to be had
- 43:30here all right so laws uh a law that favors in
- 43:36-kind division unless impractical it's about
- 43:39the uh complexity of applying the statute Anchored
- 43:44in real world stakes. Okay, we're dealing with
- 43:47a combined 221 acre duck club To one party the
- 43:52land was a legacy to the other. It was a business
- 43:57There there were business impacts even to crim
- 44:01for whom the part the land was a legacy That
- 44:06helped in the court's analysis of justifying
- 44:09why not to simply put Parcel B up for auction.
- 44:15Further, the emotions in this case aren't going
- 44:19to erase statutory rights, but sometimes they
- 44:24justify those rights. As here, the referee and
- 44:29the statute align with equitable division. The
- 44:32division plan thoughtfully addressed tax impacts,
- 44:35replacement, scarcity, and use. An approach much
- 44:39closer to mediation. problem -solving, right,
- 44:43than the statute that provided a very narrow
- 44:49resolution. Crimm had long years of memories.
- 44:54He had been there every year since 1948 at the
- 44:57time. He had continued use while the Bute Creek
- 45:05Ranch which was a partnership, it was a business,
- 45:08it had ambitions. Both perspectives and the party's
- 45:12leverage on both sides mattered here, but the
- 45:16fact that CRIM had a good story to tell about
- 45:21that use of parcel A as to why foreclosing access
- 45:26to parcel B would render parcel A of less value
- 45:32showed why it could not simply be replaced. His
- 45:38value in parcel A could not simply be replaced
- 45:41with a sale forced by the court of parcel B.
- 45:47And so here the mediators are going to have to
- 45:51balance the statutory defaults with the client
- 45:54realities and the legal principles are part of
- 45:58the storyline that can be told But I think that
- 46:04it's something where, again, it's a situation
- 46:07of looking at what is the total of the balance
- 46:11for the parties in the case. With that, I am
- 46:21going to ask for questions. If we have questions
- 46:26here, please enter them in the Q &A. Okay, all
- 46:34right We do have one question. Does the new Partition
- 46:38Act impact your views of partition? You know,
- 46:46it does some I'm gonna I'm gonna be honest This
- 46:49it hasn't been in my opinion Tested sufficiently
- 46:53for us to see what the stories are gonna be of
- 46:56what comes up When I look at it from a mediation
- 47:00perspective, it's not necessarily just at the
- 47:03legal rights that are involved, but also quite
- 47:07frankly on how it triggers the emotional rights.
- 47:11When you look at these two stories of partition,
- 47:14they both were involving emotional matters. If
- 47:18these were situations where they were two businesses
- 47:22or business -minded folks, Let's start with the
- 47:28Adam and James situation. If that were something
- 47:32where it was simply a matter of getting the best
- 47:36value, that would be an easier thing to figure
- 47:39out. Probably wouldn't have even required a lawsuit
- 47:43being filed. Unfortunately it did and I think
- 47:48more of that was about the emotions involved
- 47:52than necessarily about the legal rights. The
- 47:55legal rights obviously gave rise to, well let's
- 47:58just go with the lawsuit option. That was a case
- 48:02where honestly they could have worked it out
- 48:05at a mediation before the lawsuit was filed by
- 48:08virtue of the clarity of the rights. I think
- 48:11the clarity of partition rights in the new Partition
- 48:16Act is going to create leverage, similar leverage
- 48:21for future situations, but it wouldn't necessarily
- 48:25solve the problem either with Adam and James
- 48:29or the fact pattern here from Crim and the co
- 48:35-owners of the Butte Creek Ranch. Hopefully that's
- 48:40helpful as an answer there. I'm open to answering
- 48:44any other questions. We have a few minutes remaining.
- 48:48If anybody has any questions, please feel free
- 48:51to type them in. And if not, then I am happy
- 49:01to thank everyone for your time. If we could
- 49:04go to the next slide. Contact information is
- 49:08there. Please feel free to reach out whether
- 49:11you're attending this live or watching this later.
- 49:15If you have any, either questions about what
- 49:17we've talked about today or questions otherwise
- 49:21where I can be of help, we'd love to speak with
- 49:25you. And then finally, if we could go to the
- 49:28last slide, please, these are the citations.
- 49:31As I said, these are provided in the written
- 49:33material. But these are the cases and statute
- 49:39that we discussed here today. So seeing that
- 49:45there are no other questions posed yet. It looks
- 49:47like we actually have some questions through
- 49:50that we received through email. I'll go ahead
- 49:53and read them off. So what tools or resources
- 49:58beyond standard title reports would you say are
- 50:01most effective in covering hidden risks or claims?
- 50:06Well, it depends upon the particular risk that's
- 50:11involved here. In the case that we talked about
- 50:14for the city of Manhattan Beach, that's one where
- 50:17it would be beyond reviewing the title report
- 50:20and digging into the underlying documents, the
- 50:23deeds, any easements that may be involved. And
- 50:27also a visual inspection of the property and
- 50:31of the neighboring properties would be good for
- 50:34seeing if there are documents that should be
- 50:38there that are not, right? For example, there
- 50:42could be various utility easements. that are
- 50:48apparent when you're on property but are not
- 50:52contained or not documented in the title report
- 50:55then you have to try to figure out is it that
- 50:59there are no written easements and it's a prescriptive
- 51:03right that you're dealing with in that case what
- 51:07what are the limits of the prescriptive right
- 51:09and what is that going to do for the your clients
- 51:13plans with the property Another useful tool,
- 51:20as I mentioned, would be retaining a historian
- 51:23to get an understanding of the use of the property.
- 51:26Now, it may not require a full -blown historian.
- 51:30Depending on the community and where you're at,
- 51:32it might be something that a local historical
- 51:35society could be helpful in. This depends on
- 51:39the posture of where you're at. If it's something
- 51:42where the historical society has taken a position
- 51:44against the particular development, obviously
- 51:47that's going to be somewhat problematic to be
- 51:51able to get their help for a more affordable
- 51:54rate than necessarily hiring a full -blown historian.
- 51:58But if not or not yet, it's something where it
- 52:02could be helpful. They can be doing the footwork
- 52:05for you. They have the area knowledge and understanding.
- 52:08And also, it could be something where you get
- 52:11those folks on your side for the potential future
- 52:17discussion if it's going to require some type
- 52:20of action by the city or other political jurisdiction
- 52:24where the local historical society may have sway.
- 52:29So those would be where I would look to. And
- 52:33then beyond that, if there's a particular property
- 52:36or question or issue, I'm happy to go ahead and
- 52:39reach out. I'd be happy to see if I have other
- 52:42ideas. Do we have any questions? Yes, actually.
- 52:47So it looks like we have two more. Great. What
- 52:51strategies would you say are most effective for
- 52:54framing partition disputes and mediation so that
- 52:57clients can reach structured buyouts instead
- 52:59of prolonged court battles? Uh, I think the the
- 53:06key thing to bring to those mediations first
- 53:09and foremost is an understanding of the valuation
- 53:13and backup there's A lot of times folks will
- 53:18come into those discussions with an idea of what
- 53:21the property should be worth They'll come in
- 53:26with comps from the neighborhood that are not
- 53:31necessarily on point to the extent that you can
- 53:35have, I mean, even independent data sources,
- 53:40not that Zillow or anything like that is gonna
- 53:42be the end all be all, don't get me wrong, but
- 53:45those can be helpful data points. Honestly, what
- 53:48I find works best will be an area realtor who
- 53:53knows the market, who can... succinctly explain
- 53:58why certain comps are of value, and while certain
- 54:01comps are not of value, to be able to have that
- 54:04person available as an expert on call is ideal.
- 54:08But if not, and not only is it ideal, but also
- 54:13quite frankly, it's usually more cost effective
- 54:15because otherwise you're talking about getting
- 54:18a realtor to prepare a written report. I don't
- 54:21know that you need an appraiser per se. A situation
- 54:26may call for an appraiser as part of the settlement,
- 54:31right? But I don't know that you need to bring
- 54:34that to the mediation. What you do need to bring
- 54:36is as much as you can about the valuation and
- 54:39the why of the valuation. Because what is it
- 54:43that the other side is trying to do that you
- 54:44want to avoid? And telling that story. in mediation
- 54:48as to why it's going to be a diminution of value
- 54:53and how to be able to address that. I see a question
- 55:00in the Q &A, but was there another question that
- 55:02came in by email that we can address first? Sure,
- 55:06let's see. Would you say there are some reoccurring
- 55:10blind spots you see litigators overlook that
- 55:12create unnecessary exposure for their clients
- 55:15in these cases? Yeah, I would say that from what
- 55:20I've seen You know the partition actions are
- 55:24most interesting I think in terms of the emotions,
- 55:26but in terms of practicality it's not taking
- 55:30into consideration the impacts of Land use regulation
- 55:35and what that what that really means right a
- 55:37lot of folks who may not be familiar with the
- 55:39jurisdiction come in and they look at what the
- 55:45code says, they look at what the general plan
- 55:48or specific plan documents say, and they think
- 55:52that they've got a roadmap. And that's just not
- 55:55the case because, again, it depends on the project
- 55:58and the size of it, but if it has political implications
- 56:02in the jurisdiction, excuse me, it's going to
- 56:07be something where you have to plan for that.
- 56:10beyond just what's in the documents, right? And
- 56:16then the other main area of issues I see is around
- 56:20title and what exactly grants are, grants of
- 56:23easements, prescriptive rights, things of that
- 56:27nature. Those tend to crop up a lot, at least
- 56:32in my practice. Okay, let me take a look here.
- 56:37I'm gonna read the question off. I understand
- 56:40that real estate brokers representing a client
- 56:43don't bother reviewing title reports. No comment.
- 56:49But if a lawyer is involved in representing a
- 56:52buyer, I've always thought that reviewing the
- 56:53actual documents referenced in the report is
- 56:56part of the buyer's lawyer's job. unless somehow
- 57:00excused from it by a property -limited scope
- 57:05of representation. The city of Manhattan Beach
- 57:08had to know up front that there was an issue
- 57:10before they closed on the sale. Am I wrong? So
- 57:15I don't know that there's specific... I mean,
- 57:19I agree with you in practice. I think that that's
- 57:22absolutely the correct approach to be taking.
- 57:25I don't know... And I don't know at the time
- 57:28in the 1980s that there was a specific ethical
- 57:30obligation for the buyer's lawyer here, the City
- 57:34of Manhattan Beach's lawyer, to have reviewed
- 57:36all of the title documents. That being said,
- 57:41putting that aside, it's obviously best practice.
- 57:45I think that what may have happened here is it
- 57:50may have even been reviewed. and just not considered
- 57:53because remember the case did turn at the end
- 57:56on the quitclaim language that was in that document.
- 58:01So if you're the lawyer, if somebody's going
- 58:05back and saying to them, well, we had to go through
- 58:07all this litigation because you didn't review
- 58:09it, that lawyer could say, well, I reviewed it
- 58:11and I saw the quitclaim language and I thought
- 58:12that would carry the day, which it did. Technically
- 58:16correct. I wonder more, what I find more intriguing
- 58:21is on the plaintiff's side in that case, the
- 58:28heirs to the Redondo Beach Land Company and how
- 58:32exactly that came together, how they found out
- 58:34about this, how they ran this lawsuit, what their
- 58:41expectations were, who invested in this. in essence.
- 58:48That's the part I would love to learn more about,
- 58:51quite frankly. But no, I think, I think that
- 58:55you're right. So, okay. We are at, we're at time.
- 59:03So thank you for the questions. Appreciate those
- 59:07and appreciate everyone's attendance and time
- 59:11today. Have a wonderful rest of your afternoon
- 59:15if you're listening live, and if not, a wonderful
- 59:19rest of your day. Take care.