Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - Configurizinator
Transcript
- 0:06AV Superfriends On Topic is an independent
- 0:08production wholly owned and operated by AV
- 0:10Superfriends, LLC.
- 0:12For the highest quality recording of all
- 0:13of our shows, visit AVSuperfriends.com.
- 0:20This is AV Superfriends On Topic,
- 0:22a thirty-minute monthly roundtable focused
- 0:24on a single topic.
- 0:25This discussion will be opinionated,
- 0:27to the point,
- 0:28and saturated with our well-known blend of
- 0:29painfully-won expertise and
- 0:31deeply-embraned immaturity.
- 0:39For some time in September,
- 0:40twenty twenty six,
- 0:41it's the best sounding and most forward
- 0:43thinking podcast in higher ed.
- 0:45This is the super friends on topic.
- 0:47Episode number seventy eight,
- 0:49which I realized the other day means over
- 0:51six years of this show.
- 0:53So not getting any money back.
- 0:56Broadcasting live across three time zones
- 0:58from the first line of code to the
- 0:59last logic block, compiling commands,
- 1:02triggering automations,
- 1:03and praying nobody updated any of the
- 1:05plug-ins on a Monday morning.
- 1:06I'm Chris Dector,
- 1:08your local host with the most syntax
- 1:09errors per minute,
- 1:10and you're tuned in for another Friday
- 1:12afternoon podcast adventure.
- 1:13And yes,
- 1:13I'm coming to you live from a storage
- 1:15room.
- 1:15Dungeon.
- 1:16It's a storage dungeon.
- 1:18You want some old projectors?
- 1:18They're back here.
- 1:21Whoa.
- 1:22Come on now.
- 1:22Wow.
- 1:22It's so dusty where you are,
- 1:24Justin Sneeze.
- 1:25That one snuck up on me.
- 1:26Sorry.
- 1:26Justin Sneeze.
- 1:26I didn't know where that came from.
- 1:31I feel better.
- 1:32Thanks for asking.
- 1:33Congratulations.
- 1:35Leave all that stuff in there.
- 1:37We're going to leave that in.
- 1:38Speaking of Justin Sneeze,
- 1:40let's say hello to today's panel of August
- 1:42A.V.
- 1:43Super Friends.
- 1:45Oops, where are we here?
- 1:47Our first panelist develops quote-unquote
- 1:49advanced programming entirely through
- 1:51browser-based drag-and-drop blocks,
- 1:53colorful arrows,
- 1:54and enough nested if statements to make
- 1:56actual programmers avert their eyes.
- 1:57He's a senior visual logic solutions
- 2:00architect from Kansas City.
- 2:01Say it a little, Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 2:03Hi there.
- 2:04Just like a light switch.
- 2:06On or off?
- 2:07I love drag-and-drops.
- 2:08They're spicy.
- 2:09On or off?
- 2:09That's a lot of light switches.
- 2:13Our next panelist ensures classrooms
- 2:14behave exactly the same way every time,
- 2:17except for the inexplicable eight percent
- 2:19of cases where the projector turns on,
- 2:20the shades goes down,
- 2:21and nothing else happens.
- 2:23He's a director of deterministic room
- 2:25behaviors from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 2:26Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolosinski.
- 2:29I cannot get any of these VLANs to
- 2:30communicate.
- 2:31Nothing's online, nothing works,
- 2:32but we're going to go ahead and do
- 2:33it anyway.
- 2:34What if you had more VLANs?
- 2:35Would that help?
- 2:35That'll solve it.
- 2:36Yeah.
- 2:37These ones don't work.
- 2:37We need new ones.
- 2:38These ones are all used up.
- 2:39Or we'll just go to Cisco's SDA and
- 2:41just have no VLANs and VLANs and things
- 2:44that communicate across VLANs.
- 2:45All right.
- 2:46Our next panelist builds self-monitoring,
- 2:49self-healing AV systems capable of
- 2:50detecting faults, opening tickets,
- 2:52sending alerts,
- 2:53and ultimately creating more work than
- 2:54simply answering an original support call
- 2:56in the first place.
- 2:57From Greensboro, North Carolina,
- 2:58say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 3:00If you don't answer the support call,
- 3:02you don't have any work.
- 3:05Ignore the problem.
- 3:05There's no problem there.
- 3:08And our final panelist provides executive
- 3:11leadership for turning every AV system
- 3:12into a sprawling,
- 3:14interconnected ecosystem where one button
- 3:16press can accidentally reboot an entire
- 3:18building.
- 3:19Ask me how I know how.
- 3:21He's a vice president of Overwrought
- 3:22Signal Automation from Bowling Green,
- 3:24Kentucky, Salem, Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 3:26You know,
- 3:26I had to look up what Overwrought means.
- 3:28And overly excited.
- 3:33I should have had Larry's title.
- 3:34It's more appropriate.
- 3:35I forgot to mention Larry's title.
- 3:37So I got Overwrought.
- 3:38I'm just a manager, though.
- 3:41Well, no,
- 3:41Larry's title almost sounds legit.
- 3:42Yeah, almost.
- 3:47As you may have guessed from our thematic
- 3:49intro there on today's show,
- 3:50we're going to discuss what modern AV
- 3:52programming looks like and what a modern
- 3:53AV programmer should be,
- 3:56at least on our teams.
- 3:57But first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 3:59If you are listening to this as a
- 4:00recorded MP three,
- 4:01just know that somewhere upstream,
- 4:02a horrifying collection of logic blocks,
- 4:03event handlers, lookup tables,
- 4:04conditional statements,
- 4:05and probably at least one forgotten global
- 4:07variable has determined that you are
- 4:08allowed to hear this episode.
- 4:09We do stream live on Fridays at about
- 4:11three fifteen Eastern twelve fifteen
- 4:12Pacific or whenever Larry finally
- 4:14satisfies the required interlock
- 4:15conditions and the show start flag
- 4:19evaluates to be true.
- 4:20You can join us for that live on.
- 4:24When he shows up,
- 4:24you can join us for that live on
- 4:25Twitter, LinkedIn, or YouTube.
- 4:27And if you can't join us live,
- 4:27you can connect us on the socials.
- 4:28You can follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 4:30YouTube, and blue sky.
- 4:31Uh,
- 4:31please don't forget to spread the word,
- 4:32share this podcast with your friends,
- 4:34colleagues, enemies, perfect strangers,
- 4:35programmers who insist everything should
- 4:36be written in C sharp programmers who
- 4:38insist nothing should ever be written in C
- 4:39sharp.
- 4:40And the guy who built the entire control
- 4:42system in Fortran, seven,
- 4:43seven using nested,
- 4:44forty-seven nested if statements and a
- 4:46sixteen column multivariable lookup table
- 4:48that no living person understands.
- 4:50If you want to support the show,
- 4:51please consider donating.
- 4:52Your contributions help us to keep
- 4:53bringing you the honest AV content you
- 4:55love or love to hate.
- 4:56Think of it as setting a bullion called
- 4:57Keep AVSF Running to True.
- 4:59You can find the donation link in the
- 5:00show notes or on our website.
- 5:03Finally,
- 5:03please leave us a review wherever you get
- 5:04your podcasts.
- 5:05Five stars is preferred,
- 5:06but if you insist on something more
- 5:07complicated,
- 5:08we can construct a weighted scoring
- 5:09algorithm incorporating episode quality,
- 5:11host attendance,
- 5:12microphone gain structure,
- 5:13marks punctuality, ambient temperature,
- 5:15lunar phase,
- 5:15and the current value of register three,
- 5:16two, seven, six, eight.
- 5:18We'll then dump that result into a lookup
- 5:20table,
- 5:20run it through three layers of legacy
- 5:21logic, translate into Lua,
- 5:22rewrite it in Python because somebody said
- 5:23Lua is stupid,
- 5:25rebuild the whole thing in a configurable
- 5:26no-code platform because Python is stupid,
- 5:28and ultimately discover that all we really
- 5:30needed was one button labeled listen to AV
- 5:32Superfriends.
- 5:34Thank you for your support.
- 5:35We could not do this show without you.
- 5:37Stupid.
- 5:39So I'm pretty sure I covered every higher
- 5:41level language in there.
- 5:44I'm right.
- 5:45I'm punch cards.
- 5:47I didn't get that far.
- 5:48So we need to go any.
- 5:50Did we need to progress much like the
- 5:51Scantron type stuff?
- 5:54I'm not sure why we had to get
- 5:56past just a button press and.
- 5:59Well, that is a good question.
- 6:01So to that point, Jamie, today's topic is,
- 6:03and I think we have generically described
- 6:05this as, what does modern, modern,
- 6:08twenty-twenty-six, and specifically,
- 6:10I want to set some rails around this,
- 6:11specifically on our teams,
- 6:13what does modern AV programming look like?
- 6:16What does a modern AV programmer look
- 6:18like?
- 6:20How are we treating this?
- 6:21Because there's a lot of kind of,
- 6:23let's just say,
- 6:24is it fair to say legacy?
- 6:25Historical weight that comes with some of
- 6:29this stuff?
- 6:30Ooh,
- 6:32there's a lot of streams that are crossing
- 6:33here.
- 6:34Quick poll.
- 6:35Who actually has a program?
- 6:37I want to start with this because I
- 6:38want to get it off my chest real
- 6:40quick.
- 6:43This is just a...
- 6:44Watching from afar here,
- 6:47a lot of folks like to aspire to
- 6:49that programmer title because it pays more
- 6:54and it's a lot of the stuff they're
- 6:54already doing.
- 6:56So I think that there's the pay scale
- 6:58of the title,
- 6:59and I want to make sure that this
- 7:00conversation is not like... Well,
- 7:02pay scale or not, there's the title.
- 7:03The title, exactly.
- 7:04I don't want to talk about like, oh,
- 7:06I want to get there because that's like
- 7:08the holy grail of AV.
- 7:10Why don't we start with that?
- 7:11Who has a position on their team with
- 7:14the word programmer or programming or
- 7:17whatever in the title?
- 7:20I still do.
- 7:21Yeah.
- 7:21There's one we do.
- 7:22And Justin, I think is raising his hand.
- 7:24Yeah, I do not mark.
- 7:26Mark Leary, you know, it started that way.
- 7:27It's not gonna change.
- 7:31We're not gonna know what title is.
- 7:33How about how about your previous?
- 7:35Nope.
- 7:36I know you're you're so this closest I
- 7:38got in the previous role was control
- 7:40systems engineer.
- 7:43But the word programmer or programming was
- 7:46not there.
- 7:49Yeah.
- 7:49I haven't had a title or a bespoke
- 7:52programmer in almost a decade.
- 7:53Yeah, I was going to say,
- 7:54Larry could back me up,
- 7:55nor was it the case at IU.
- 7:57But that's because every engineer had to
- 7:59know how to program.
- 8:02Also, everybody there was an engineer.
- 8:04That is a prerequisite anyway.
- 8:06They gave out the title like engineer like
- 8:07Halloween candy.
- 8:08Yeah, they did.
- 8:10Mark,
- 8:10I don't think we had programmers at OSU
- 8:12in that sense with that word in the
- 8:14title.
- 8:14Yeah, it's a little bit different,
- 8:15but it's very, very, very, very,
- 8:17very similar though.
- 8:17Is the word in the title?
- 8:18I think it is.
- 8:20Damn it.
- 8:21I'm trying to think how far back I
- 8:22can go.
- 8:22Here's the next question.
- 8:23Here's a follow-up question.
- 8:24If you have a...
- 8:27official programmer titled person on your
- 8:30campus working for you?
- 8:31Is there other people that actually
- 8:33program but and I think that's where
- 8:35Mark's going?
- 8:36Yes.
- 8:36Yeah, that answer is yes for me.
- 8:39Like,
- 8:40it's I'm not saying they're not doing good
- 8:43work.
- 8:43That's not what that's not what this is.
- 8:45I just feel like I want to check
- 8:47in where we are now.
- 8:48And I'm gonna look at the crystal ball
- 8:50and look forward a little bit.
- 8:53And so I'm not really too concerned with
- 8:56how we got here.
- 8:57Where's my harp?
- 8:58Because we know the story,
- 9:00and we know how this goes.
- 9:02I hear it,
- 9:02and I've seen it on a lot of
- 9:03message boards as well.
- 9:04Like, oh, I want to become a programmer.
- 9:08That's back in time, sorry.
- 9:09That's close enough.
- 9:11The future's going to look like the past.
- 9:13Hold on, I got this one.
- 9:15There it is.
- 9:16Here we are.
- 9:19Now that we're here...
- 9:21In the year twenty twenty seven six,
- 9:25wherever we're at right now,
- 9:27we have made it past the future.
- 9:30Do we still need these programs?
- 9:31We made it past the future.
- 9:33We passed it,
- 9:34which we are now in the past.
- 9:37Anyway, I don't know.
- 9:40Because, yes,
- 9:42there's a lot of programmatic style
- 9:44configurator stuff.
- 9:46Configurator.
- 9:47Configurator going on.
- 9:50Configurator.
- 9:51But I looked up,
- 9:52let's just start with the definition of
- 9:53programmer, as brought to us by Wiki.
- 9:56No.
- 9:57This is how we're going to do this.
- 9:58It's like a high school report.
- 10:00Webster defines programmer as...
- 10:03Computer programmer or coder is an author
- 10:05of computer source code or someone with
- 10:07the skill in computer programming.
- 10:10Professional titles, software developer,
- 10:12software engineer,
- 10:13may be used for jobs that require a
- 10:15programmer.
- 10:16Okay, that really solves nothing.
- 10:18back to where we were.
- 10:20You've made it worse.
- 10:21Yeah.
- 10:21And then it prattles on for a good
- 10:23ten pages of nonsense here of the history
- 10:26of where it comes from.
- 10:28And I'm just curious how much complex,
- 10:33bespoke, unique,
- 10:35actual no joke programming is still going
- 10:39on.
- 10:39Do we forecast moving forward?
- 10:41Do we see a lot of that still
- 10:42on the horizon?
- 10:46Um,
- 10:46and nobody wants to say no because they
- 10:48don't want to feel bad.
- 10:49I'll be the first to say, no,
- 10:50I don't.
- 10:51To parse that, right?
- 10:52I, I, yes, I do see, um,
- 10:55attempts at having bespoke programming,
- 10:58but not necessarily,
- 10:59necessarily from our internal teams of
- 11:02plate people.
- 11:03It's usually from outside.
- 11:05So integration or somewhere else where
- 11:08they want bespoke programming because
- 11:11Well, yeah, because they support the code,
- 11:13they support the modules,
- 11:14and you have to call them in order
- 11:15to support those codes and modules.
- 11:17If it's coming from outside the...
- 11:19It's coming outside the house.
- 11:21I don't like any of that.
- 11:22But inside...
- 11:24I'm not comfortable with that being the
- 11:25future at all.
- 11:27But I'm... Oh, I'm just...
- 11:28Who cares about the future?
- 11:29Oh, okay.
- 11:30Look, I'm focused on yesterday.
- 11:32I will put us back in the future
- 11:33so fast.
- 11:36But I do think that, like, internally,
- 11:38and like I said...
- 11:41In the good old days of AMX.
- 11:43Oh, I like that.
- 11:47But I think internally,
- 11:48like I saw this a while ago,
- 11:50and we kind of stopped having a bespoke
- 11:52programming because ninety-nine percent of
- 11:55any system,
- 11:55and we do some more complicated things,
- 11:58didn't need it.
- 11:59We just don't.
- 11:59And it's getting easier and easier by the
- 12:01day.
- 12:02And so having syntax, having semicolons,
- 12:05having, right, who cares?
- 12:09Use the drag and drops.
- 12:10Let's move forward.
- 12:11Let's go.
- 12:12Make it easy.
- 12:13Have every single technician ready to go.
- 12:17Have one or two that can handle it
- 12:19at a higher level and everybody can now
- 12:22support everything at all times and you
- 12:24just don't have the issues.
- 12:25Has the tide just lifted all the boats?
- 12:30Has all of that just become more just
- 12:31nascent?
- 12:32All this is just kind of taken for
- 12:34granted that we're all going to have some
- 12:36level of like
- 12:39micro coding slash can advanced configure
- 12:42rising like it's just native and then it's
- 12:45just in the base now, I think well,
- 12:48so you mentioned a couple things there,
- 12:50but most systems these days and again,
- 12:56I think our bread and there's always those
- 12:57unicorns and always got my multi-purpose
- 12:59athletics,
- 13:00you know voting booth space or whatever
- 13:02the heck it is also gas station.
- 13:04Those are very strange.
- 13:08Most spaces are entirely configurizable
- 13:11these days.
- 13:12So who's touching code?
- 13:14And in fact,
- 13:14we even see Crestron has come out with
- 13:17their, what's their newest one called?
- 13:20Potato seven.
- 13:21Hot garbage.
- 13:22The other one.
- 13:24Fire.
- 13:24Construct.
- 13:25construction, all that stuff.
- 13:26They're pushing hard into like the No, no,
- 13:28this,
- 13:28you just get it out of the box
- 13:29is configurable.
- 13:31Qsys,
- 13:32who kind of made their name on being
- 13:33Oh, it's it's block diagrams.
- 13:35And it's, you know,
- 13:36it's block logic and all the rest.
- 13:39Now, they even have a simpler version.
- 13:41Again,
- 13:42we see this every now and then AMX
- 13:44had their art, the rapid project manager,
- 13:47whatever it was for years,
- 13:48like a Crestron studio.
- 13:49So these things seem to come and go.
- 13:51But
- 13:52even the ones who are kind of like
- 13:53they they make their money on very large
- 13:57or the capability to do very large complex
- 13:59systems are now recognizing that well the
- 14:01audience has shifted we need something
- 14:03that's even simpler than our simple
- 14:04versions um and so we're seeing that to
- 14:08the point where you can now do entire
- 14:09systems and you've been able to for years
- 14:11i get it extron people yelling at me
- 14:12right now but
- 14:14You can do entire systems without touching
- 14:16a line of code anywhere,
- 14:17and there's nothing wrong with that.
- 14:19And Jamie, to your point,
- 14:20that casts a wider net,
- 14:22to use a mixed metaphor here,
- 14:24to include more people with the capability
- 14:26to be able to do that.
- 14:30Cool, we're out of here.
- 14:31Yeah.
- 14:32There's another layer to this.
- 14:33There's a lot of layers to this.
- 14:34What?
- 14:35Nope.
- 14:36There's no other layer.
- 14:38There's a lot of people out there that
- 14:39are like, oh,
- 14:39but my data says it needs to have
- 14:42this unique hook and blah, blah, blah.
- 14:44And you're not wrong.
- 14:46I'm not saying that your support system or
- 14:49whatever, like...
- 14:51You can need all that,
- 14:52but is that just an opportunity to rethink
- 14:54those other things?
- 14:55Are we pearl-clutching complexity that
- 15:00does not need to be the case anymore?
- 15:02I agree.
- 15:02I think that's it.
- 15:05get him get him what do you mean
- 15:08he's got to take my the opposite stance
- 15:10of me and he's trying to figure out
- 15:11no it's no it's it's further it's it's
- 15:14a little further than that and you know
- 15:15i don't want this to turn into a
- 15:18you know side discussion of ai but it's
- 15:21going to i'm just holding it i'm just
- 15:22waiting i'm gonna get justin if you're
- 15:24gonna go there right now put a pin
- 15:25in that for about five minutes yeah we're
- 15:27gonna come back to that yeah cam's he's
- 15:29on it he's he's
- 15:30I don't know anything about code and
- 15:35there's nothing I can't code.
- 15:37I'll just leave it at that.
- 15:38Yes.
- 15:40That's part of the evolution too.
- 15:43So I was going to make that whole
- 15:45argument.
- 15:45Then manufacturers are going to jump in on
- 15:47it,
- 15:47but I'm supposed to put a pin for
- 15:49five minutes.
- 15:49So I got my timer going.
- 15:52I was about to say the same thing
- 15:53when Jamie said they were outsourcing
- 15:55their bespoke stuff.
- 15:56No, no, no.
- 15:58I see when it's outsourced.
- 16:01They, the outsourced company,
- 16:04relies on bespoke code because it makes
- 16:06more service money for them.
- 16:09That's what I intended to say.
- 16:11There's a way around that now, too.
- 16:13But there's still very much an attitude
- 16:15of, look how cool this is.
- 16:18I'm running this entire facility in the
- 16:20town two counties over with this one
- 16:24program.
- 16:24I'll show you cool.
- 16:26I would almost rather hire somebody that
- 16:29had real user interface and graphic design
- 16:32chops
- 16:34Because we're getting into this world
- 16:36where being able to understand user
- 16:39interfaces and being able to understand
- 16:41backgrounds on our project, I mean,
- 16:44some of that graphic design, I mean,
- 16:46that eyeball, that artistic look at it,
- 16:49I would almost rather have that person
- 16:50than a bespoke syntax coder.
- 16:53Well, even more than just the look,
- 16:55the user interface,
- 16:57understanding how to present the material
- 16:59and also the accessibility.
- 17:01There's so many aspects there that I do
- 17:03think there is a need for that role.
- 17:06But I'm not sure it's in the hard
- 17:07coding anymore.
- 17:08It's more in solving.
- 17:11I think I'm going to go out on
- 17:11a limb and probably catch a lot of
- 17:13flack for this.
- 17:13Well,
- 17:14I think we hold on to a lot
- 17:16of legacy approaches to how room control
- 17:19needs to be to include the touch panels
- 17:22to make things complex for no reason other
- 17:24than that is our job.
- 17:25Well, and that's, I was going to say,
- 17:27look, I like,
- 17:28but user interface to me also goes outside
- 17:30of just the graphical, maybe to you,
- 17:34you guys know,
- 17:35I like using buttons and switches and
- 17:37yeah.
- 17:37something tactile what's a person just
- 17:40used to use and whether you have to
- 17:42touch something or not that's an argument
- 17:44that mark likes to make but but there
- 17:46are times where you just want to touch
- 17:48one button you literally you just want to
- 17:50touch a button and it lights up green
- 17:52and it turns on like your lights in
- 17:54your house well i mean jamie you got
- 17:56a point because you know there's a there's
- 18:00a science to user interfaces there's a
- 18:02reason why our kardashians are all the way
- 18:04they are now
- 18:05Wow, they're garbage now.
- 18:08Well... Get off my lawn.
- 18:09Because it's cheap,
- 18:11not because it's a good user interface.
- 18:12But you're right.
- 18:13I mean,
- 18:13there's going to be more value in laying
- 18:16out a touch panel correctly.
- 18:17If you can program a system and it
- 18:19works perfectly in programming,
- 18:20that doesn't mean that, you know,
- 18:22the layout... What the hell is that?
- 18:25It's a damn cat, dude.
- 18:27I'm not pushing buttons.
- 18:29I think the cat's having a seizure or
- 18:31something.
- 18:31Just ignore it.
- 18:32Should be fine.
- 18:35There's going to be more.
- 18:37There's going to be more.
- 18:40um yeah yeah yeah there's going to be
- 18:46more uh eyes on the dashboard and you
- 18:49know why is this button over here why
- 18:51do i have to flip four pages to
- 18:52get to this main function so there's a
- 18:54lot of science and a lot of thought
- 18:56that needs to be put in but you
- 18:57can pro like you lay out the dash
- 18:59you lay out your user interface first of
- 19:01them do programming and programming i
- 19:03don't want to have five minutes to begin
- 19:04with like that's the point i'm making like
- 19:07Yeah,
- 19:07and I know that's a different
- 19:09conversation.
- 19:09You don't want to lay it out?
- 19:11He's saying he doesn't want a touch panel
- 19:13on a GUI.
- 19:13I will say – Like,
- 19:14I think five percent of my rooms do
- 19:15not have touch panels anymore.
- 19:16I'm saying when you do is – Well,
- 19:17let's get past that.
- 19:20There is a place where – and, yes,
- 19:23we need to move on from the GUI
- 19:24touch panel or whatever thing.
- 19:25But there's a place where people say,
- 19:26look,
- 19:26if I'm paying thirty-five grand for this
- 19:28room, it better be that, like,
- 19:29executive look and I want a touch panel
- 19:30and all that stuff.
- 19:31So I get it.
- 19:32That was the point I was going to
- 19:33make.
- 19:33I think there's a lot of people screaming,
- 19:34like, oh,
- 19:35our brand management has got to be –
- 19:37fine whatever i don't care it's html i
- 19:41don't care if you're using something else
- 19:42it's html that's what it is at this
- 19:44point or is it are you now delivering
- 19:46a fully configurable mtr zoom room
- 19:50whatever experience you're not programming
- 19:51any of that crap going into the web
- 19:53interface and making three drop downs yeah
- 19:54and so there's that whole piece right i
- 19:57just to me the capabilities of our systems
- 20:00at this point are so much more
- 20:03possible i guess like that we don't need
- 20:05to be in the coal mine doing all
- 20:07these this hard programming it can do that
- 20:10it's still being done it's being automated
- 20:12for those that are dabbling in the ai
- 20:14thing and you're doing a lot of this
- 20:15work and you're doing the thing i make
- 20:18html's as if they are just disposable
- 20:19documents literally i will share a design
- 20:22quick interactive here's an html and it's
- 20:24just a disposable artifact that's used for
- 20:26that one time i guess that's gone
- 20:28That may seem wasteful,
- 20:29but I can communicate a lot really fast
- 20:32and have Claude or whatever just make an
- 20:33interactive design.
- 20:34Somebody just click through.
- 20:35Oh, cool.
- 20:35Yeah, I get all this information.
- 20:37So the ability to create these things on
- 20:40the fly has never been more possible than
- 20:43it is now.
- 20:44Am I a programmer for that?
- 20:45No, I'm not.
- 20:47Is it doing what it used to take
- 20:48a whole room of people to do over
- 20:50weeks on end?
- 20:51Probably.
- 20:52But it's immediate right now.
- 20:55I did full on TCP IP switch programming
- 20:59in ten minutes yesterday.
- 21:01Bang, done.
- 21:02Am I a programmer?
- 21:02No, I'm not.
- 21:03So I think we all collectively have much
- 21:06more ability that it's time to rethink
- 21:08that piece.
- 21:09Is there a place and should they be
- 21:10doing this?
- 21:10Yes, we do probably need it.
- 21:12But I don't think looking forward
- 21:14We need to have just this one person.
- 21:17I think it needs to be more of
- 21:18a distributed capability.
- 21:19I think you can argue that with multiple
- 21:22positions in IT.
- 21:23Absolutely.
- 21:24For example, network engineers.
- 21:25How many managed network switches have we
- 21:27set up recently?
- 21:28Are any of us network engineers?
- 21:29Right.
- 21:32No.
- 21:32Well, my friend Claude is.
- 21:35Claude, I'll do it.
- 21:35Here we go.
- 21:36Right.
- 21:37So, Mark,
- 21:37you mentioned something there I did want
- 21:39to touch on that you kind of,
- 21:40I thought you were going a different
- 21:41direction with it.
- 21:42Maybe I will.
- 21:44What's it?
- 21:45It's the Magic Three Letters API.
- 21:47Yeah, sure.
- 21:49So a lot of these,
- 21:51as let's say devices, ecosystems, systems,
- 21:54whatever you want to say,
- 21:54have matured and they have mostly
- 21:57documented,
- 21:58I was going to say fully documented,
- 21:59mostly documented, poorly documented,
- 22:02API and restful access to things.
- 22:06It's the sort of thing where...
- 22:08we can leverage that to do a lot
- 22:11of automation that wasn't possible
- 22:13previously and would ordinarily require a
- 22:18whole amount of bespoke and custom
- 22:22programming to get that far that can be
- 22:24done with things that are,
- 22:26because the libraries are there and we're
- 22:28leveraging capabilities built into it
- 22:30without it necessarily needing
- 22:33someone to sit there and hack through
- 22:35libraries of stuff,
- 22:36because that's the way they've always done
- 22:37it.
- 22:37So I think we've seen as things have
- 22:40matured,
- 22:41we've seen a lot of that capability,
- 22:42the necessity,
- 22:43the necessity of that capability get
- 22:44removed as well.
- 22:46I think that's that's kind of running in
- 22:47parallel with kind of your data multi
- 22:50direction being wrangled and pointed and
- 22:53traversed,
- 22:54things are happening because of it.
- 22:55Right.
- 22:56And
- 22:58it just brings a whole new level of
- 23:00capability that we just never had.
- 23:01It used to just take so much longer
- 23:03than it does now.
- 23:04I think that's the whole...
- 23:07know where does code generation sit in the
- 23:11labor pool at this point in time like
- 23:12where everywhere it's it's it's everybody
- 23:15absolutely justin it does it is everywhere
- 23:17it used to be something that was held
- 23:19kind of oh these three people are the
- 23:21ones who know right anymore in fact
- 23:23they've encrypted it and put it uh behind
- 23:25a paywall and now you can't get to
- 23:27it i'll crack that shit i don't care
- 23:30make a new paywall and put it inside
- 23:31that one and they can't get to it
- 23:32yeah putting on the ai super cape you
- 23:34can do anything but yeah but it i
- 23:37still don't want to say we don't need
- 23:38the program we obviously still need this
- 23:40level of knowledge it yeah it's the
- 23:43knowledge it's the expertise and it's the
- 23:44ability to leverage that based on user
- 23:46experience and user interface whatever
- 23:49that and by user interface i mean the
- 23:51what the user interface is with not
- 23:53necessarily the the graphical version of
- 23:55it having that knowledge is still
- 23:58absolutely
- 23:59you know,
- 24:00paramount to being able to be successfully
- 24:02or successfully deploy these systems.
- 24:04It's not something that is limited to,
- 24:07I don't, that's pushing it.
- 24:09No, I think it's paramount.
- 24:11Paramount's too strong of a word.
- 24:12Okay.
- 24:12It's tantamount to,
- 24:14are you better with that instead of
- 24:15paramount?
- 24:15It's, it,
- 24:18I didn't say Apogee.
- 24:19I didn't say Apex.
- 24:20How many words do you want for this?
- 24:22It's not needed.
- 24:24It is needed, though.
- 24:27I think there is utility of getting code
- 24:29somewhere as the quality of having code.
- 24:31For successful systems,
- 24:34you need to understand.
- 24:37I think there's a core level of
- 24:38understanding of you have to understand
- 24:40how it all works.
- 24:43Because you need to understand that there
- 24:44is a communication pathway.
- 24:45No, you don't.
- 24:46If we're going to go this far,
- 24:49You've all seen it.
- 24:50There's lots of systems out there where
- 24:51it's clear they don't understand, A,
- 24:52how it works, or B,
- 24:53how people interact with it.
- 24:54So to justify... Well, I'm just saying,
- 24:57you know,
- 24:58just because you're not a programmer,
- 25:00I don't think anybody here, well,
- 25:01Larry may consider himself one.
- 25:04Used to, maybe, not anymore.
- 25:06Larry spent twenty-seven years in the
- 25:07cold.
- 25:07But we kind of all have the understanding
- 25:09of, okay, so there is if-thens,
- 25:11there are tables, there are APIs,
- 25:14there are these things.
- 25:15It's like, help me write this thing.
- 25:16I need to communicate with that thing.
- 25:18How?
- 25:18Well,
- 25:18I'm going to do it over the next...
- 25:19So there are some principles at play here
- 25:22that you kind of have to understand.
- 25:23You don't have to understand all the
- 25:24nitty-gritties.
- 25:26Some folks...
- 25:28They don't really desire or they don't
- 25:32understand how any of that stuff works.
- 25:33Therefore,
- 25:34even just prompting a prompt to prompt out
- 25:37the final product makes it really
- 25:39difficult.
- 25:39I don't know.
- 25:42So your grandmother would be able to code
- 25:45what you needed to code.
- 25:46Mark,
- 25:46you have to read that for people who
- 25:47are listening only.
- 25:48Yeah, that's a lot of words.
- 25:50Mark's muted.
- 25:51And you're muted.
- 25:52And you're muted.
- 25:52Good job, Mr.
- 25:53Screen Share on an audio file.
- 25:58For those of you listening,
- 25:58Mark is sharing an entire line of slop
- 26:01code.
- 26:02Yeah, slopping away over here,
- 26:03but it works, right?
- 26:04This is the Python script running a small
- 26:07HDMI switcher that an agent just runs,
- 26:09and you can speak into it,
- 26:11and it just changes and goes away, right?
- 26:12And all this stuff here,
- 26:13do I know what all this stuff does?
- 26:15No.
- 26:15Does it work?
- 26:16Yes.
- 26:17But you're also leveraging the API that
- 26:19the manufacturer has now written.
- 26:20I don't know.
- 26:22The hell, man,
- 26:23because sometimes I get in there,
- 26:24I'm like, how do I control this thing?
- 26:26And they're like, well,
- 26:26you could do it this way, this way.
- 26:28It's got an API.
- 26:28It's like, I don't know.
- 26:29I don't care.
- 26:30It doesn't matter.
- 26:30Right.
- 26:30I'm just like, make it work.
- 26:32I don't give a shit if it's got
- 26:33an API or not.
- 26:33I'll find a way to control it.
- 26:35It said, okay, let me ping it.
- 26:36Let me see what's possible.
- 26:37Oh, it worked.
- 26:38Okay, so it grabbed it.
- 26:40It said, yep, it's working.
- 26:41It responded.
- 26:41Let's go.
- 26:42Okay, here's the string.
- 26:43It's this TCP IP command,
- 26:46and that's HDMI one.
- 26:46This is HDMI two output.
- 26:48Okay, we're done.
- 26:49I think what I would push back on
- 26:52is you didn't know how to code,
- 26:54but you knew what the end result needed
- 26:56to be for all your experience.
- 26:58And I think that's why the programming
- 27:00role is developing more into an
- 27:02engineering role where you can understand
- 27:05what the system is supposed to do.
- 27:09But for Justin, Justin just doesn't care.
- 27:11I think it's just going to morph.
- 27:12I think what we expect of a programmer
- 27:15in the future is the ability to
- 27:17orchestrate all of this stuff more
- 27:20rapidly.
- 27:21So see what I'm doing here?
- 27:24See that?
- 27:25No, because it's a podcast.
- 27:27He's zooming in and out of his camera.
- 27:30And then my camera can go up and
- 27:31down?
- 27:31Up and down, yes.
- 27:33Oh, very basic, right?
- 27:34So I didn't know how to control this
- 27:37camera that I'm controlling.
- 27:38I just said, hey,
- 27:39I want to control this camera.
- 27:40It's at IP.
- 27:40Go figure it out.
- 27:42Push the code.
- 27:43Done.
- 27:44That's it.
- 27:45Right.
- 27:46And so I think you have a lot
- 27:47more capability than you historically have
- 27:49had in a much faster timeline, right?
- 27:52And so we can exponentially be more
- 27:54productive for all the things that
- 27:55historically were programming work.
- 27:57We can do much more of that and
- 27:58cover a lot of ground faster.
- 28:00So I think the requirement still exists,
- 28:03but what does a programmer do
- 28:06future for us is it just this kind
- 28:08of work are they just doing a lot
- 28:09of this type of api work and all
- 28:11that or code by code writing the thing
- 28:15doing the stuff and sending it and i
- 28:17think programmers traditionally had pretty
- 28:19good way of laying things out at least
- 28:21ours does as far as user interfaces i
- 28:23would spend more time having that person
- 28:26do that job than actually coding because
- 28:28that's more important
- 28:30when you're customizing a user interface
- 28:32when you have that.
- 28:34I think for the most part,
- 28:35and what we've all basically said,
- 28:37is that no, the bespoke programmer,
- 28:39the coding,
- 28:40the actual syntax person is not really
- 28:43necessary in our way of life.
- 28:45Now, it is necessary in other places,
- 28:47but maybe not for us,
- 28:49not in our worlds,
- 28:50not in how we are deploying systems.
- 28:54you know we're not writing device level
- 28:56firmware with a sense of what we're doing
- 28:57that's different we can i know but that's
- 29:00my point is is that for our worlds
- 29:02it we don't need it we just don't
- 29:05need it and so having an engineering level
- 29:07doesn't work if you recall at the
- 29:09beginning i said i want to put rails
- 29:10around this this is on our team yes
- 29:13because there's people driving right now
- 29:14yelling at their car stereos that's fine
- 29:16mister you made a cruise ship work okay
- 29:19well
- 29:20And I don't understand why even with some
- 29:22of these tools available,
- 29:23we have some of our peers out there.
- 29:25They're like, well,
- 29:25we're going all scripting or we're going
- 29:27all this.
- 29:28We're like, why?
- 29:28Yeah.
- 29:29Why?
- 29:30Why would you lock yourself out of your
- 29:31stuff?
- 29:32Just use the configurator.
- 29:35To me,
- 29:35if I hear we're all scripting all the
- 29:37time, I'm like, great.
- 29:37I'll do that all day.
- 29:39Five minutes.
- 29:40Let's go.
- 29:40We're done.
- 29:41Yeah.
- 29:42Why are all your staff having to do
- 29:44this?
- 29:44Why are we reading through all that?
- 29:46Why are we doing that?
- 29:48Do you need it?
- 29:49None of you are doing anything more.
- 29:51We're all over in the same ballpark.
- 29:52None of us are doing anything crazy.
- 29:54Well,
- 29:55that's the thing is we shouldn't be doing
- 29:56anything crazy, but a lot of us,
- 29:59and I'll just say universities in general
- 30:02tend to do things that are
- 30:04nuts and crazy because they can not
- 30:06because it's necessary.
- 30:08I mean,
- 30:08I was I run in for the MPS
- 30:11is still live on your that's just you
- 30:13guys being economic or just saying I have
- 30:15I have seen full on classroom spaces in
- 30:17the past,
- 30:18where you go up and you hit a
- 30:19button and you get the splash screen and
- 30:21not splash screen,
- 30:22you get the info screen on the info
- 30:23screen.
- 30:24There's a drop-down menu.
- 30:25When you select the menu,
- 30:25little things appear.
- 30:27Why are we doing this?
- 30:28Why did you make this seventeen layers
- 30:29deep?
- 30:31How much do we need to have in
- 30:33there where it's like,
- 30:35that's just a web page now?
- 30:37If you're touching only the keyboard and
- 30:38mouse to get around it,
- 30:40you have too much shit going on.
- 30:41It should be less than three button
- 30:42presses away from your end result.
- 30:44Also known as a button panel.
- 30:46If not, none.
- 30:47I was going to say, why three?
- 30:49I just want one button.
- 30:53Is that all?
- 30:54Boom.
- 30:54Done.
- 30:55It doesn't even have anything to do with
- 30:56it.
- 30:56What's the button say?
- 30:58You press the button.
- 30:59It says, boom.
- 31:01Done.
- 31:01All it does, that's not even doing it.
- 31:03That just lets Jamie know there's somebody
- 31:04in the room.
- 31:07Well,
- 31:07that way all of the army of minions
- 31:10I have in the background can log in
- 31:11remotely and control everything.
- 31:14So, Jamie,
- 31:14you want some sort of interface that has
- 31:16one button.
- 31:16It could be a physical interface.
- 31:17It could be some sort of digital interface
- 31:19where there's a button that says the thing
- 31:21you want.
- 31:22Yep, and you press it,
- 31:23and then the secret eyeballs come in.
- 31:28We can actually do that.
- 31:30We can put that together for you.
- 31:34I don't know,
- 31:35but the future is going to be different
- 31:38but I don't see it including bespoke AV
- 31:42programmers very much longer.
- 31:44Can I throw an additional mention in this?
- 31:46Can we pause before that?
- 31:48Very much longer.
- 31:48I think there's going to be some pushback
- 31:51from manufacturers.
- 31:54on this we may be there will be
- 31:57manufacturers who will the markets kind of
- 31:59going to decide this to a degree i
- 32:01think it might take longer than we think
- 32:03but i mean i inherently agree with you
- 32:06it's just i and it's it's strange how
- 32:08some of those who have been uh pretty
- 32:09rock steady are now opening up these open
- 32:11modules be like well just copy and paste
- 32:13the thing out of there and put it
- 32:15in here and it works like what buy-in
- 32:17interesting that could possibly be one
- 32:20So yeah,
- 32:21buy was literally showing that off at
- 32:23infocomm.
- 32:23Like, hey,
- 32:24you don't like what this can do.
- 32:25Here is the entire code base for this.
- 32:27Open it up, drop it into Claude,
- 32:29add your modifications, dump it back in.
- 32:31That's where things are going.
- 32:32And let it recompile so it's now available
- 32:34for anybody else in the future.
- 32:36And that was one of the nice things
- 32:37about Q-SYS, too, is like,
- 32:38you didn't have to,
- 32:39but if you needed it for something,
- 32:41for some special event,
- 32:42you just drag in that little Lua box
- 32:45and you copy and paste and off you
- 32:47go.
- 32:49So I find a lot of value in
- 32:50that,
- 32:50and I've been even asking Extron for a
- 32:52while,
- 32:52like ever since they came out with the
- 32:54Python scripting,
- 32:55give me a little box so I can
- 32:57just copy and paste the little script that
- 32:59I need.
- 33:00Usually you only need a little one.
- 33:01It's just something dumb that I can copy
- 33:04and paste in there and it just runs
- 33:05in your GUI.
- 33:06Oh, we can't do that.
- 33:08Well then,
- 33:08I guess we're going to move on.
- 33:10It's just one of those things.
- 33:11Let me ask,
- 33:12I'm going to just blab it out here,
- 33:13and we'll transition out.
- 33:14Object-based things, is that programming?
- 33:18Here's a box you draw on the line
- 33:19between the two.
- 33:19How about object-oriented?
- 33:21Object-oriented?
- 33:22I'm not going to use the word,
- 33:23but is object-oriented programming?
- 33:27Loosely, yes,
- 33:28because you still have to work your way
- 33:30through it,
- 33:30even if it's a walk-by-walk stepway.
- 33:33I was on Steve Greenblatt's show,
- 33:35what is it, Ask the Programmer,
- 33:36and that was my stance.
- 33:37I'm like,
- 33:40it is the basic levels of programming.
- 33:42Logic flow.
- 33:44logic flow,
- 33:45walking through signal and logic.
- 33:46And so so I'm gonna say DSP is
- 33:50I'm not talking about the big processing
- 33:53running backward.
- 33:54Traditional open architecture,
- 33:56DSP object oriented flow is that
- 33:58programming?
- 33:59I don't first is then that has to
- 34:04be too.
- 34:05That's why I don't think either of them
- 34:07are there.
- 34:08I usually tend to go towards
- 34:09configuration.
- 34:10But I guess ultimately,
- 34:12it is program programming.
- 34:15But is it?
- 34:19It's interesting.
- 34:20I was thinking about,
- 34:20so as you asked that question,
- 34:22I was thinking about how I refer to
- 34:23things.
- 34:23I always refer to a DSP config,
- 34:29but I will refer to a control system
- 34:30program.
- 34:31So I don't know.
- 34:34We're just arguing words now.
- 34:35Let's get it done.
- 34:36That's all we ever do.
- 34:37Have we ever not done that?
- 34:40Things to ponder on.
- 34:41Justin, are you new to the show?
- 34:42Yeah, yeah.
- 34:44all just so easy now well that completely
- 34:47changed in the past year right we're in
- 34:50a different domain than we once were like
- 34:52our goals may be the same but our
- 34:53tooling has changed so let's let's take
- 34:55this conversation back to the original
- 34:57point about the title that somebody has if
- 35:00you're hiring a new person you're creating
- 35:01a new position whatever it is and you
- 35:04need someone to kind of own this
- 35:06capability
- 35:09what is that title?
- 35:10Is there a position that has that title?
- 35:12Or do you do do you cast that
- 35:15aside,
- 35:15it becomes part of everyone's
- 35:16responsibility?
- 35:17Or if you want someone who's like, No,
- 35:19this person is going to be the owner
- 35:20of this,
- 35:21but I want everyone else to be cross
- 35:22trained in it.
- 35:23How are we titling that sort of position?
- 35:26Cast?
- 35:27What if we could make it worse?
- 35:30No, let's answer this question first.
- 35:32Okay, right.
- 35:33So for me, for me,
- 35:35everybody has to do it.
- 35:37So everybody has to do as the
- 35:39configurations,
- 35:40everybody has to have understanding how it
- 35:41all works.
- 35:42And then the engineer,
- 35:43the design engineer, who has it,
- 35:46they're the ones helping putting things
- 35:47together.
- 35:48They're the ones usually responsible for
- 35:49interconnects and doesn't really talk to
- 35:52each other.
- 35:53They're usually that that
- 35:55owner expert of the config.
- 35:58But again,
- 35:58I haven't had a programmer in a decade.
- 36:00What's that title?
- 36:01I don't know if everyone designed design
- 36:03engineer design.
- 36:04So you have a design engineer now includes
- 36:06all your configure riser.
- 36:07Yeah,
- 36:08that's part of their job description.
- 36:10Yes,
- 36:10they're they're they're the owner of the
- 36:11tier five,
- 36:13tier four and five level of that.
- 36:14How many tiers do you have?
- 36:16At least?
- 36:16Take?
- 36:16Yeah.
- 36:17As many as it takes.
- 36:20I'm a nine support.
- 36:21I'm a tier.
- 36:23But the entire staff is expected to have
- 36:26that modicum of things.
- 36:27They shouldn't elevate very often.
- 36:28This might turn into a different show,
- 36:30but what do you define design as?
- 36:33Oh, boy.
- 36:35We had this conversation.
- 36:37No, we started to,
- 36:38and we never got there.
- 36:39Configurating and programming,
- 36:41then what are they actually designing?
- 36:44Because that's not design.
- 36:47There's separation from that.
- 36:49I'm a design engineer on our campus,
- 36:51and we have...
- 36:53Our engineers who do all configuration and
- 36:55programming,
- 36:55then we have our support people.
- 36:57Okay.
- 37:01So, Justin,
- 37:02I kind of agree with you there.
- 37:03I do not think the same person
- 37:05necessarily.
- 37:06I think there is a lot of crossover.
- 37:08I would not put it on the same
- 37:09person who is responsible for doing the
- 37:11design aspects of a system to necessarily
- 37:14be the person who is owning the system.
- 37:18the configuration risers.
- 37:20Right.
- 37:20Now I'm not saying there's not cross
- 37:22pollination there from time to time with
- 37:24redundancy, but primarily,
- 37:26and then looking at accountability and
- 37:28support mechanisms.
- 37:29Cause for example,
- 37:30like IU does it that way.
- 37:31They want everyone to all the engineers or
- 37:33designers and programmers and others.
- 37:34I don't like that system.
- 37:36Because some people may be great.
- 37:37That gets a little sketchy.
- 37:38Well,
- 37:38they may be great at the customer
- 37:40interaction and the design and the clever
- 37:41solutions and all the rest,
- 37:43and they may be terrible at programming.
- 37:44That's two different skill sets.
- 37:45Or vice versa.
- 37:45They may be a really fantastic programmer,
- 37:47but going out on the customer interaction
- 37:49that needs analysis and determining system
- 37:51designs and all the rest,
- 37:51they may be terrible at it.
- 37:53Exactly.
- 37:54I'm just saying, my experience.
- 37:57That design line.
- 37:57As somebody who's terrible at both of
- 37:58those things, that's my experience.
- 38:00Let me jump in.
- 38:02I'm...
- 38:03leaning kind of towards jamie's
- 38:05philosophical approach on this but as we
- 38:08started this show we jumped in right away
- 38:11around this ux and like experience piece
- 38:15that's more important now does is the
- 38:17future tying and moving the programmatic
- 38:21aspect closer to the commissioning side of
- 38:25what's going on is that commissioning
- 38:28programming like sign off is is that where
- 38:31it kind of sits
- 38:32I can more agree with that.
- 38:34That is interesting.
- 38:35I don't know.
- 38:36Our commissioner is usually the design
- 38:39engineer.
- 38:40Well,
- 38:40I was going to say something else when
- 38:41you jumped in there.
- 38:42That's the way it kind of should be.
- 38:44Commissioner, programmer,
- 38:45I see a lot of times there's a
- 38:46lot of overlap there between the
- 38:48programmer, configurizer,
- 38:50or whatever commissioning person because
- 38:54they're in there working on the devices
- 38:55right there,
- 38:56and if they need to make adjustments,
- 38:57changes, whatever.
- 38:58Yeah,
- 38:58but you need somebody behind them checking
- 39:00to make sure they're not screwing shit up.
- 39:03And so whoever designed it should be the
- 39:05one commissioning to make sure it meets
- 39:07all of the criteria that it was designed
- 39:09for.
- 39:10I think we've all agreed that we believe
- 39:12that programmatically that probably that
- 39:15skill belongs in a lot of different
- 39:17buckets now,
- 39:18and it may not be its own bespoke
- 39:20silo of work.
- 39:22Correct.
- 39:22I think the silo.
- 39:23It's a balance where I agree with Mark,
- 39:25but there also needs to be some
- 39:27accountability and ownership of that.
- 39:29Because when you have...
- 39:33I'll make it a giant puddle, man.
- 39:34When everyone's responsible for something,
- 39:37no one's responsible for something.
- 39:40I found this out a lot in the
- 39:42AV industry dealing with distribution and
- 39:45manufacturers are like oh just send an
- 39:47email to the group and then we'll get
- 39:49you a quote right over a lot of
- 39:50av is already nebulous but we got twelve
- 39:53people looking at this group email to
- 39:58other emails to figure out who's taking
- 40:01but why do we stop it why do
- 40:02we hold programming on some some special
- 40:04pedestal all right do we doesn't need
- 40:06to be.
- 40:08It sounds like the five of us vehemently
- 40:10agree that wherever it may sit,
- 40:13it's not a silo anymore and it's not
- 40:15on a pedestal.
- 40:16I don't think so.
- 40:18I don't think the accountability thing
- 40:19holds water.
- 40:20I don't think that's the argument that's
- 40:22valid.
- 40:22Do you have somebody who has a bespoke
- 40:24title responsible for hanging projectors
- 40:26onto mounts?
- 40:29Well, yeah, that's a little bit, maybe,
- 40:30depending on who they are.
- 40:32They're just the AV technicians.
- 40:34And so I think it is quickly encompassing
- 40:37all of this into that same realm.
- 40:39You guys are missing a big accountability
- 40:41part to this.
- 40:42Stop worrying about who to blame.
- 40:43It's not who to blame.
- 40:47then what is it?
- 40:48It's who's in the room doing the right
- 40:50job at the right time.
- 40:52So if you have a technician or a
- 40:54programmer or a designer that keeps
- 40:56screwing everything up,
- 40:57you have to have metrics to go,
- 40:59we need to talk about some corrective
- 41:01action here.
- 41:01That sounds like blame to me, sir.
- 41:03No, because you're working on a team.
- 41:06He's not blaming anybody, Mark.
- 41:08He's simply assigning responsibility for
- 41:09problems.
- 41:10Yeah,
- 41:10you can't just have everybody just doing
- 41:13everything.
- 41:13The future is a team of utility players,
- 41:16man.
- 41:17We're going to moneyball this thing
- 41:19together.
- 41:19Jamie,
- 41:19there is something to be said for that.
- 41:21The team is just utility players.
- 41:24If you have a team of eight people
- 41:26who have general skill sets and everything
- 41:28versus a team of specialists,
- 41:30who's more effective?
- 41:31I've seen it fall apart over and over
- 41:33and over again.
- 41:35Everybody's responsible for this.
- 41:36we're all a team we're all going to
- 41:38play that's that's the pm's problem now
- 41:40they didn't assign the task correctly okay
- 41:41well in the last three minutes where do
- 41:43you want to go with this because we
- 41:44are way over time and i think i
- 41:46think we agree i think we believe it's
- 41:48a distributed service programming i think
- 41:50it's the final sign off needs to be
- 41:52somebody i'm not sure what that job title
- 41:54is but i don't think it's that person
- 41:55working in a program we need to show
- 41:57on policing accountability and how you all
- 41:59deal with it because i would love to
- 42:01know how you just
- 42:02are like Sesame Street out there,
- 42:03and everything's unicorns and rainbows.
- 42:05Got a belt over there,
- 42:07and that's what's going on.
- 42:09I don't get it, man.
- 42:10How do you know who to hit?
- 42:12Oh,
- 42:12now we're back to assigning things to
- 42:14people.
- 42:15Yeah, anybody that I decide.
- 42:18Larry, this is your job today.
- 42:20We just got done with that conversation.
- 42:24All of them have the capability.
- 42:28All of them have the capability.
- 42:29So how many programmers do you have
- 42:31programming one system?
- 42:34Is it one for the team?
- 42:38There it is.
- 42:39I think you're arguing for us,
- 42:40not against us.
- 42:42I think we're all vehemently agreeing at
- 42:44this point.
- 42:45Yeah.
- 42:45No, I'm not.
- 42:46Until somebody has to be blamed,
- 42:47and then that person's ass is getting
- 42:48fired.
- 42:48Accountability is real.
- 42:52So Justin wants to ensure that if there's
- 42:53a problem,
- 42:54he knows who to blame because that's a—
- 42:56And how hard to blame him.
- 42:58If you have seven mistakes that are the
- 43:00same mistakes in a row,
- 43:02I kind of want to know who's doing
- 43:03it.
- 43:03That's fair enough.
- 43:04Yeah.
- 43:05So I can correct the action and let
- 43:07them learn.
- 43:08So here's what you need to do, Joe.
- 43:09So we don't have those seven mistakes over
- 43:10and over and over and over again.
- 43:12As you work through your Claude prompting
- 43:14program.
- 43:14It was my friend Jiminy.
- 43:15Jiminy screwed it up,
- 43:16but Claude A will fix it.
- 43:18Extron's big thing, and this was like,
- 43:19twenty years ago,
- 43:20their big thing was like,
- 43:20when you open a config,
- 43:21the first thing you do is put your
- 43:23name in there so we know who did
- 43:24it.
- 43:25So now that's what you need to put,
- 43:26you need to put that in Claw.
- 43:27You're going to programming jail, sir.
- 43:28That's why I put Justin's name in all
- 43:29of my programs.
- 43:30That's right.
- 43:30I put Justin Rexing in all of my
- 43:32programs.
- 43:33If you have twelve programmers,
- 43:35and you're programming fifty rooms,
- 43:37and programmer one programs ten of those
- 43:40rooms,
- 43:42And you're going to set up another hundred
- 43:44rooms to do.
- 43:44And you realize that all ten of those
- 43:46rooms are a problem.
- 43:47You don't know who did the ten rooms
- 43:49or the other twenty rooms.
- 43:50You don't know who did what.
- 43:52How are you going to fix the problem?
- 43:53You don't know how to fix the problem.
- 43:57How do you know?
- 43:58But I do, because that's labor deployment.
- 43:59This goes back to the projector hanger,
- 44:01my jiggy, your deer.
- 44:03But you said that you're going to assign
- 44:04the task to the team and let the
- 44:06team figure it out like a bunch of
- 44:07ants or something.
- 44:08Nope, never did.
- 44:08I don't think I ever said that.
- 44:11You said that.
- 44:12The rest of us didn't.
- 44:12I said all of them have the capabilities
- 44:14and all are able to do it.
- 44:16Justin, I do like that concept, though,
- 44:17of just putting a bunch of projects down
- 44:19on a table and just leaving and letting
- 44:20other people figure it out.
- 44:21Well, I just put them on a whiteboard.
- 44:22Check it off when you're done.
- 44:23That's right, yeah.
- 44:27I think right now there's still some bias
- 44:30towards programming is overly difficult to
- 44:32do what we're going to do.
- 44:33And there is still a lot of baked
- 44:34in fear of it not being done correctly.
- 44:36There is that.
- 44:37Absolutely, there is that.
- 44:38Moving forward,
- 44:39it will become more commodity tied to
- 44:41everything.
- 44:42It'll be a shared experience,
- 44:43just like the projector hang-em-a-jigger
- 44:45guy out there doing the thing.
- 44:48I think it gets encompassed in the general
- 44:51flow of work,
- 44:52and it's another task that's distributed
- 44:53amongst the engineers.
- 44:57But I'm willing to be wrong.
- 44:59All right.
- 44:59Any last thoughts?
- 45:00Because we got nowhere with this.
- 45:01Mark needs to be wrong.
- 45:02That's my last thought.
- 45:03I think we agreed that there is no
- 45:05more siloed,
- 45:06just doing only programming behind a
- 45:10locked door somewhere, not involved,
- 45:12never shows up on site,
- 45:13just sends it to a tech who loads
- 45:14the code,
- 45:14and then he somehow remotely
- 45:16troubleshoots.
- 45:16I'm feeling attacked.
- 45:19It's called go work for any integrator.
- 45:21Absolutely.
- 45:23I think we all agree on that model
- 45:24is kind of either dead passe or on
- 45:27its way out should be on its way.
- 45:29We don't.
- 45:30It's now part of a shared set of
- 45:31services and skills that people provide.
- 45:33But we don't really agree on who
- 45:35necessarily is providing that and how many
- 45:37people is it everybody or only certain,
- 45:39you know, folks on the team.
- 45:40So.
- 45:40All right.
- 45:42Things are changing.
- 45:43Things are changing.
- 45:45They're probably not going to go out and
- 45:46hire just the unique.
- 45:47programmer to do a thing.
- 45:51I'm changing all the titles.
- 45:53Or everybody's programmer.
- 45:55Well,
- 45:55now we'll do that for compensation
- 45:57purposes.
- 45:57Now you're on the trolley.
- 45:59There it is.
- 45:59Okay, we got there.
- 46:01I heard someone the other day say that
- 46:02they've done that a lot with the,
- 46:04what was it,
- 46:06they look at how the IT structure is,
- 46:08and they'll put the title interim in,
- 46:10because if you assign someone an interim
- 46:11role,
- 46:12you can do that almost instantaneously
- 46:13without having to go through HR,
- 46:14and
- 46:15And then they just let that sit long
- 46:16enough and the interim falls off.
- 46:19And there's a lot of little oddities like
- 46:21that in higher ed.
- 46:23can get you there well because I there's
- 46:27this concept of benchmarking against
- 46:28industry and from higher ed it's always a
- 46:30challenge because the salaries aren't
- 46:31there and so they it takes forever to
- 46:34get that stuff through so I understand why
- 46:36people come up with these little
- 46:37workarounds well all right roll out are we
- 46:40done we're done probably not sorry about
- 46:42that everybody interim overlord you get
- 46:46this you get this time back never sorry
- 46:48no refunds yeah
- 46:56putting up with yet another episode of av
- 46:58super friends on topic you can contact us
- 47:01with questions topic ideas or general
- 47:03complaints at avsuperfriends.com nice work
- 47:13everyone sharp broadcast really good
- 47:16everyone on the floor as well really a
- 47:18lot of hustle i liked it
- 47:20The opinions expressed by the AV
- 47:21Superfriends are solely those of the
- 47:23individuals and do not represent their
- 47:24respective institutions, organizations,
- 47:26companies, or clients.