Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 6. When love becomes a liability: Before you say yes to an insurance policy
Transcript
- 0:02Before you say yes, find out what happens when something goes wrong.
- 0:08I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick, former senior bank executive, now working with companies, governments and regulators around the world to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:18This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts and your digital life with someone you love.
- 0:29So before you say yes to an insurance policy, listen to this.
- 0:36Do you have insurance for your car or your house or your contents?
- 0:41Do you have compulsory third-party insurance?
- 0:45As boring as insurance sounds, it's one of the most important contracts you're going to sign.
- 0:51In 2025, general insurers in Australia wrote 86 million policies and paid out almost $50 billion in claims.
- 1:01It's big business.
- 1:02And it's one of the big decisions you need to make in a relationship, especially when you're signing on the dotted line with someone else.
- 1:09Andrew Hall is the CEO of the Insurance Council of Australia and admits he can bore a dinner party senseless talking about insurance.
- 1:18But when I spoke to him, I was anything but bored.
- 1:22Stick with me for 15 minutes and you'll walk away with a lot more confidence about what joint really means when it comes to insurance.
- 1:30And you might even wish Andrew was at your next dinner party.
- 1:35So insurance is one of those things that people sign up to and then they put in the drawer and they forget about it until they need it.
- 1:45Can you tell me what exactly is an insurance
- 1:52At its core, what insurance is, is the opportunity to take a risk off your side of the ledger and have somebody else carry it, pull that risk at a set cost per month or per year.
- 2:04And when you start accumulating assets and when you start doing things like setting up a business or whatever it is, buying a home, buying a car, taking a holiday, you've got to think about what the risks are in your life and how you're going to protect those if the worst happens.
- 2:19So when you're starting out, say in a relationship with someone, you're starting to think about, I'm going to share my money, share my bills.
- 2:29What are the risks people should be thinking about then?
- 2:32Well, from an insurance perspective, when you start sharing things, you are sharing that risk.
- 2:37You're sharing that liability that someone could steal that laptop or they could break into your home and take more things or that the home could catch fire and burn down.
- 2:47Your rental property could burn down around you and you lose all those contents you've bought.
- 2:51Everything you bought from Ikea the week beforehand goes because the lithium-ion battery caught fire in your property.
- 2:58I mean,
- 3:00I can bore a dinner party senseless these days with the risks that are in people's lives.
- 3:05And if you think about risk too much, you'd never do anything.
- 3:08And when you start owning things collectively, it brings in an added level of complication.
- 3:15Now, insurers will make that as easy as possible for you.
- 3:19If you own a home or a car or a boat or whatever it is in joint names, an insurance policy can be in both names.
- 3:27It's always important to understand, though, what does that mean when a policy is in both names?
- 3:32And importantly, what's it going to do if the worst happens?
- 3:36How important is it to understand whose name a policy is in, who is covered, who can make changes, who can cancel it?
- 3:46It's really important for insurance because insurance from a couple of perspectives, first of all, from an underwriting perspective, the insurer needs to understand who it is that they are covering and what rights or obligations they have because insurance does actually put obligations on consumers as well.
- 4:03You are obliged to drive safely.
- 4:04You are obliged to keep your home well maintained and good repair.
- 4:10So understanding who has those obligations is really important.
- 4:15The other interesting thing about insurance, where it differs enormously from a banking product, is that it is very easy to cancel an insurance policy.
- 4:26And there's a lot of safeguards built into insurance policy so that if somebody takes one out and then in a few days' time realise it's not quite what they needed, they're able to cancel it and they can get their premium back and the like.
- 4:38The downside with that is, again, unlike a banking product that has a lot of signatures on it, a lot of paperwork involved, if you try to change an account or redo a mortgage, for example,
- 4:53It is quite easy to cancel an insurance policy.
- 4:56And that's for a raft of good reasons that have come in over the years.
- 5:01It's designed to empower the consumer to take control of their own finances and determine if they can get a better deal.
- 5:06They can absolutely opt for it.
- 5:09An insurance policy at its most lasts for usually 12 months maximum.
- 5:14So it renews every year as well.
- 5:16So understanding how an insurance policy generally works is the first step, because if you understand how it works, you can then make sure that you're well protected within that process.
- 5:28So every year when the renewal comes in and we've been living through and it's a big problem at the moment with inflation every year while inflation has been sitting around three to four percent.
- 5:37In fact, in building, for example, it's sitting near 10 percent.
- 5:41So, again, if the house burns down, it's.
- 5:46It may have cost $500,000 to replace it in 2020, but in 2026, 2027, it's going to cost you more than likely close to a million dollars.
- 5:55So you have to adjust those sorts of elements of your insurance policy.
- 5:59And again, anyone can call up at any point and do that.
- 6:02It also means they could call up and adjust it down.
- 6:06So you wouldn't want a scenario where somebody calls up and makes the sum insured so low that it's never going to do the job it needs to do if the house was damaged.
- 6:16They're the sorts of things that you need to be very aware of and make sure that as the owner of that policy and the co-signature of that policy, that the communications are set up, that you are alerted and that you are fully across any of the changes to what's happening with those policies.
- 6:32Yeah.
- 6:33That example is one that has really stuck with me.
- 6:37A woman that participated in the research for my paper described how she'd been paying a house insurance policy for many years and didn't know that the policy had been cancelled by her ex-husband until after he'd threatened to burn the house down with her and the children in it.
- 6:59And the premium had also been repaid to him.
- 7:02So she was like, why didn't I know about this?
- 7:05Why wasn't I informed?
- 7:07And I know a number of insurers have now moved so that they can, they are saying to, if you are informed,
- 7:14are co-insured on the policy, they'll send an alert.
- 7:17So there's a good reason to do things, but there can be a flip side when there is a nefarious motive from somebody.
- 7:24So I think that that point about checking what it is, being aware of how it works is really critical.
- 7:30But it is a case when you're doing it jointly, for example, you've got to have a conversation around the kitchen table.
- 7:36You've got to talk to each other about what are the risks that we're prepared to carry and what aren't.
- 7:41Even when it comes to your excess, another boring element of insurance, and again, your eyes can glaze over.
- 7:48But if you set your excess at the highest possible level, some insurers offer it up to $10,000.
- 7:55What that effectively means is that if anything breaks in your home under $10,000, you need to find that that money won't be covered in your insurance policy.
- 8:03And it can be very hard to find $5,000 to replace the hot water system all of a sudden, $3,000 to replace a laptop that's broken or stolen.
- 8:13These are the sorts of things that both parties need to be aware of and get comfortable with.
- 8:17We're happy to carry that risk and pay a cheaper premium, or we'll pay a little bit more in our premiums to cover it.
- 8:24Yeah, so it's going in eyes open, eyes wide open and being very deliberate about the conversations you're having both in your home and with your insurer and being deliberate about the decisions you're making about what risk am I prepared to take.
- 8:44Most of what we've covered so far sits firmly in the plan for life's curveballs category, like illness, accident and even the hot water system.
- 8:54But insurance policies can also be relevant at the far end of a very different spectrum.
- 9:00In my design to disrupt research on the insurance sector, I found something that surprised even me, the malicious damage exclusion.
- 9:09That's a standard clause in most policies that's designed to prevent fraud.
- 9:14It means you can't just smash up the television and claim on your insurance policy because you want a new one.
- 9:21But it can, in certain circumstances, leave a victim of domestic abuse without a claim.
- 9:29In my research around the design to disrupt paper on insurance, one thing that survivors said is that they were unable to make a claim if their partner or ex-partner may be damaged or destroyed property because there's the malicious damage exclusion in an insurance policy.
- 9:53But what I thought was really promising was there's also a number of insurers who've said, actually, we still want to be able to have some flexibility to pay out those claims.
- 10:03Can you explain a little bit about that?
- 10:06In insurance contracts, as I've said before, they're legal contracts and they're built around and designed around providing cover where it's genuinely been an unanticipated risk.
- 10:19And so clauses have been drafted, exclusions have been put in place, and you can understand why those exclusions were there.
- 10:27If you choose to deliberately smash up your car with a sledgehammer and then claim an insurance claim, the insurer is going to ask the question, why are we paying this out?
- 10:39This wasn't an accident.
- 10:40It was deliberate accident.
- 10:41and malicious damage.
- 10:44It's driven a lot by what's happened in the past around fraud and still continues to happen.
- 10:50The way we can see insurance products defrauded, there's always a clever new way that people are coming up with to game a system and access money.
- 11:00And the problem is everybody pays for that through their premiums.
- 11:04But then there are these times when if you look at this through the lens of how someone can do this and weaponize the product against a partner and have very little regard for the financial outcome for themselves even in doing this.
- 11:19I think that's the moment where the industry has sat back and said, yes, there are times where the legal clause and the exclusion made a lot of sense.
- 11:29But there is mitigating evidence here that needs to be taken into account that this wasn't the fault of one of those parties.
- 11:35And that person has now been left without a home, without a car, without the asset that they jointly owned.
- 11:42And, you know, the perpetrator...
- 11:46has had some sort of victory in their minds.
- 11:48Of course, it's not a victory in any shape or form.
- 11:51In fact, it's a crime.
- 11:53But, you know, insurers do need to find that flexibility.
- 11:58And it's challenging, I think, in a sector where you rely very heavily on
- 12:03contractual enforcement to be able to manage insurance products and pay the right claims.
- 12:10But I think it's also important that insurers think with a human mind and look at circumstances.
- 12:15And I think this is where the work is leading them to think about the vulnerabilities that people have in those sort of circumstances and be able to take that into account.
- 12:25That's the extreme end.
- 12:27The industry is moving and the conduct of others clause now appearing in more policies is one of the most significant product design changes in Australian insurance in recent years.
- 12:39But for most of you, the practical question is simpler.
- 12:43What can you actually say to your insurer when your circumstances change?
- 12:48Have you got any practical tips for what someone might say to their insurer if they need that additional support or that extra care?
- 12:57On anything, I always say to people, pick up the phone and have a conversation with your insurer.
- 13:04There are other ways of doing it these days and a lot of them have chatbots, for example, that are staffed by humans and agents and will also detect that sort of wording.
- 13:14But
- 13:16If anything changes in your life, having a conversation, it's not the first thing you'd have a conversation with.
- 13:24There are other people in your world that you would talk to probably.
- 13:29But when you start thinking about your financial arrangements, just like you would around your banking and your accounts or anything like that,
- 13:35call your insurer and tell them, this person's no longer living with me.
- 13:39Does that change anything for my premium?
- 13:43I'm in a situation where I'm not sure what is happening with something.
- 13:47Can you please not email me or this is my preferred manner of contact?
- 13:53We have to respect that.
- 13:54If you don't want a phone call, you tell your insurer, please don't call me.
- 13:59Use this as a method for contacting me.
- 14:02Otherwise, large systems can make mistakes and can accidentally issue a notice or a renewal or something like that, which is going to fall into the wrong hands at that point in your life.
- 14:15So it's critically important to talk to them and don't feel afraid to raise it with your insurer that they are trained.
- 14:22And if the call center person you speak to, they will more than likely divert you off to somebody who is trained to be able to provide you with that support.
- 14:31I think it's really important to another risk.
- 14:34And obviously the reason that I do the work that I do and that I'm raising these conversations through this podcast is we also don't necessarily think about what's the risk in our relationship.
- 14:48What happens if something in the relationship goes horribly wrong?
- 14:52And it could be an illness.
- 14:54It could be someone losing their job.
- 14:56No one goes into a relationship thinking that's going to happen, but there is an opportunity as you start thinking about the other risks.
- 15:04What do I need to do to look after myself?
- 15:06How could I set myself up in case that happened as well?
- 15:10Two people on an insurance policy, who gets to operate it?
- 15:13Who gets to cancel it?
- 15:15And I think this is the issue that not just insurance, but across financial services, banking, superannuation, everywhere else.
- 15:26These are products that were designed back in the day without thinking about that human element of jealousy and revenge.
- 15:33And they're nasty elements that when weaponized can really wreak havoc on people's lives.
- 15:40And I think the more financial institutions like insurers can think about what are those risks that our products present, what are those risks that our products present?
- 15:48And how can we just build in the protections that people need or the processes to deal with it when and if that happens, then they're much stronger and they're better products.
- 16:00And people can have a lot more confidence in all of that.
- 16:02And I think that's what the industry is determined to do.
- 16:07My takeaway from Andrew?
- 16:08Invite him to your next dinner party.
- 16:11But seriously, insurance is a safety net, but only if you understand what you're covered for, what you've agreed to carry yourself and who has the power to change it.
- 16:21Most couples set up an insurance policy and never look at it again.
- 16:25The renewal arrives every year.
- 16:28That's your prompt.
- 16:29So before you say yes to an insurance policy, do this.
- 16:33Know who's on the policy and what that means.
- 16:37Both names on a joint insurance policy means both people have rights, including the right to cancel, to change the sum insured or to adjust what you're covered for.
- 16:48Make sure you're listed as a co-insured, not just mentioned.
- 16:52And make sure policy communications like renewals or changes or cancellations also come to you.
- 16:59Insurance is the one financial product that's really easy to cancel.
- 17:04And that's a vulnerability as well as a protection.
- 17:07Someone else on your policy has the same right to cancel it, or to change the cover, or to pocket the premium refund.
- 17:16Ask your insurer directly, can this policy be changed or cancelled without my knowledge?
- 17:21And set your own contact preferences so you're always in the loop.
- 17:25Have the excess conversation before you need it.
- 17:29The excess is the amount you agree to cover yourself before the insurer steps in.
- 17:34So for example, if it's set at $5,000 and your hot water system fails, that's $5,000 you need to find yourself.
- 17:42Both people on a joint policy need to know what the excess is and agree that they can actually cover it.
- 17:48Open the renewal notice every year.
- 17:52together.
- 17:54Insurance is the product most people set and forget, but your circumstances change, your assets change, and your rebuild costs change.
- 18:03Inflation's been running hot.
- 18:05What it would cost to replace your home today might be very different for what you insured for, and a renewal is a prompt to check.
- 18:15If your circumstances change, call your insurer.
- 18:18You don't need to disclose everything.
- 18:20You can simply say, this person's no longer living with me.
- 18:24Does that change anything?
- 18:26Or I'd like all the correspondents to come to me only by this method.
- 18:31Insurers are trained for sensitive circumstances.
- 18:35And if the person you reach first isn't the right one, ask for someone who specialises.
- 18:40You're entitled to that conversation.
- 18:43The renewal arrives every year.
- 18:45That's your moment to ask, do I still know what I've agreed to?
- 18:49Because love shouldn't cost your freedom.