Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Tylenol Murders | 44 Years Later, Who Was the Killer?
Transcript
- Nicholle: Content Warning. This episode discusses murder, poisoning, sudden deaths, grief, and the deaths of several people, including a child. We're going to talk about the victims respectfully and focus on what is documented about this case, the investigation, and what remains unanswered. Some material may be difficult to hear. Please take care while listening. Zalle: There's something about an ordinary object that makes certain crimes harder to understand. Because when you look at the object years later, nothing about it looks dangerous. It's just a bottle. It sits on a shelf. It belongs in a medicine cabinet. And in 1982, millions of Americans had one in their homes. But imagine being an investigator called into a house because something doesn't make sense. Three people are suddenly sick, then three people are dead, and you're standing in an otherwise ordinary home trying to figure out what could possibly have caused it. You look around, the food is fine. The house is fine, there is no obvious source, and then you notice something sitting there that almost everybody in America would have considered completely harmless a bottle of medicine. What happened next would turn a bottle of pain reliever into the center of one of the largest murder investigations in American history. Hey y'all, welcome back to Coughing Crime with Mom. I'm Zalle Nicholle: And I'm Nicholle but around here I'm Mom. Zalle: If you're new here, We tell true crime stories the way we'd actually talk about them over coffee. Detailed, conversational, and without skipping the parts that matter. Nicholle: And if you've been here before, thank you for coming back. Zalle: Before we get started, make sure you subscribe, follow us wherever you're listening or watching. And if you enjoy the episode, leave us a rating or review. Nicholle: Because those little things really do help people find the podcast. Zalle: All right. Today we're going back to nineteen eighty two. And this case starts with something so ordinary that it's almost difficult to understand how terrifying it became. Tylenol. Let's go back to the beginning. September twenty-ninth, nineteen eighty-two, it was a Wednesday, and nobody waking up that morning knew that by the end of the day, an ordinary over-the-counter medication would be connected to a series of deaths that would terrify an entire country. The first victim was a twelve-year-old girl named Mary Kellerman from Elk Grove Village, Illinois. Mary Wasn't waking up expecting anything unusual. She was sick with cold symptoms. Her parents gave her extra strength Tylenol, and sometime afterward, Mary collapsed. She was taken for medical treatment, but doctors couldn't save her. She died that morning. Nicholle: And at this point, there wasn't a murder investigation. There wasn't even a reason for anyone to think murder had happened. you've got a child who's sick, medication is given, and then she suddenly deteriorates. The medical explanation wasn't immediately obvious. Zalle: And then in Arlington Heights, another person became critically ill. His name was Adam Janice. Adam was twenty seven years old. He was a postal worker and lived with his family. Adam became severely ill and died that same day. And now you've got two completely separate households, two different communities, two people, and nobody yet knowing they're connected. Nicholle: And that's the part I think is so frightening When you look at the timeline, there wasn't some obvious crime scene. Nobody broke into a house and nobody was attacked. Nobody saw a suspicious person running away. People were simply getting sick. Zalle: Then the situation inside the Janice home became even more alarming. Adam's brother Stanley Janice, who was twenty five, and Stanley's wife Teresa, who was around twenty, were in the house. They took Tylenol from the same bottle and then they became critically ill too. Nicholle: Three people, one family, the same house. And now three people are suddenly collapsing. Zalle: They were taken to the hospital, and despite doctors' efforts, Stanley and Teresa died. So within hours, three young adults from one family had died. Nobody understood why. Nicholle: Imagine being the person walking into that house. You're not walking into a traditional murder scene. You're walking into a home where three people have suddenly become violently ill and nobody knows what happened. and that's where Helen Jensen comes into the story. Zalle: Helen Jensen was the public health nurse for Arlington Heights. She was called to the Janice home because officials were trying to figure out whether something in the house could have caused the sudden illnesses. And what she found was, by all accounts, an ordinary, tidy home. No obvious gas leak, no obvious environmental explanation, nothing immediately jumping out as the source of three sudden medical emergencies. Then Jensen found a bottle of Tylenol. Nicholle: Yeah, so you know, I'm guessing that I don't quite nothing if you even sort of stuff through certain lengths or the most then just out and put Zalle: And she found a receipt showing that the bottle had been purchased that day. And she Yep, and six were missing. Nicholle: down the list, join them on and she counted the capsules. Yeah, six and Zalle: Three people were dead. Nicholle: Six two printers. And this can be the connected by two things. See the I don't know the people in this question actually. Zalle: Two for each person. And Jensen immediately connected those two things. She believed the Tylenol was responsible, but people initially questioned that conclusion. Jensen later described being so frustrated by the skepticism that she initially insisted they look at the capsules again. She kept making the same point. Three people had died. Six capsules were missing. The bottle had been purchased that day. Nicholle: And I love this part because it's not some dramatic detective moment where somebody walks in and immediately knows everything. It's the public health nurse noticing a pattern that other people hadn't connected yet. She didn't have the entire answer, she had one observation, and she refused to let everybody move past it. Zalle: And then another piece of information came in. Nicholle: Keller. Zalle: A twelve year old girl named Mary Kellerman had died that same morning. She had also taken Tylenol. Now the connection was getting getting harder to dismiss. WTTW's reporting, including Jin Jensen's later interviews, documents this early sequence in her discovery of the six missing capsules. Nicholle: It's Zalle: Medical examiners began looking at the depths differently. The capsules were tested and investigators discovered something horrifying. They contained potassium cyanide. Nicholle: Medical 60 and with medical sixties. The capital contests and best conditions are the company horrified. They contain as a signal. So now we're not talking about a medical mystery anymore. We're talking about poison. And we're talking about poison that had somehow gotten into a common medication. Zalle: Yeah. And that changes the entire investigation. Because if the poison had somehow gotten into the medication during manufacturing, that would be one kind of catastrophe. But if someone had intentionally introduced it afterwards, that's a completely different situation. Authorities determined the contamination occurred after the product had left manufacturing rather than being a manufacturing defect, and suddenly investigators had a murder case on their hands. But the investigation wasn't finished because there were more victims. And the killer wasn't finished. The next victim was Mary Reiner, twenty seven from Winfield. Mary had recently given birth to her fourth child. She died after taking contaminated Tylenol. Nicholle: She had just had a baby. That's one of those details that changes how you hear the timeline. This wasn't somebody whose life was ending. She had just brought a new baby into the world. So sad. Zalle: Heartbreaking. And then Paula Prince, thirty-five Nicholle: And then followed her Zalle: of Chicago. Paula was a flight attendant. She had returned from Las Vegas to Chicago and went to a Walgreens on North Well Street. That purchase was captured on surveillance footage. That footage is one of the most haunting pieces of the case because it's so ordinary. You can see Paula going into the store, buying something that millions of people would have bought without thinking twice, and then she went home. She never made it to work as expected. Her sister became concerned, and Paula was eventually found dead in her apartment. A bottle of Tylenol was found nearby. Nicholle: Purses for the painting steps, and Paul was into the subject in her park. A bottle of Zalle: Then there was Mary McFarlane. Mary was thirty-one years old and lived in Elhurst, Illinois. She worked for Illinois Bell at a facility in nearby, Lombard. Nicholle: And it's not Illinois, it's Illinois. Illinois. There's no S. You don't Zalle: Illinois. What? Illinois. Whatever. She were it is. Right at the S. Nicholle: say the S. It's Illinois. Have you? Zalle: Illinois. Nicholle: Chicago, Illinois. Zalle: Whatever. She worked for Illinois Bell at a facility in nearby nearby Lombard. On September thirtieth, nineteen eighty two, Mary arrived at work complaining of a bad headache. She reached into her purse and took extra strengthenol and and shortly afterward she collapsed. Mary was taken to Good Samaritan Hospital in Downers Grove. She died there hours later, and testing was showed that cyanide was in her system. Investigators then examined the Tylenol capsules she had been carrying. Five of the ten capsules in her purse tested positive for cyanide. Nicholle: Mary left behind two young sons. Her brother Jack Ellison was also her coworker. He later recalled that Mary had gone into a break room at work to take the Tylenol before collapsing. Zalle: And that's one of the details that makes Mary's story so heartbreaking. She was at work, she had a simple headache, took something she believes would make her feel better, and within hours, her life was over. Nicholle: Mary McFarland was the fifth person to die in the Tylenol poisonings, and investigators were now dealing with a pattern that was becoming impossible to ignore. And then Paul Paula Prince, 35 of Chicago. Paula was a flight attendant. She had returned from Las Vegas to Chicago and went to a Walgreens on North Well Street. That purchase was captured on surveillance footage. Zalle: That footage is one of the most haunting pieces of the case because it's so ordinary. You can see Paula going into the store, buying something that millions of people would have bought without thinking twice, and then she went home. She never made it to work as expected. Her sister became concerned, and Paula was eventually found dead in her apartment. A bottle of Tylenol was found nearby. Nicholle: So you have seven victims now. But what's strange is that they aren't really connected to one another. They're not all friends. They're not all coworkers. They're not members of the same family. They aren't being selected because of who they are. They're connected by what they swallow. And that Zalle: And that is what made this case so terrifying. The victims were essentially strangers. The person responsible didn't have to know them, didn't have to follow them, didn't have to confront them. The weapon was sitting on a store shelf. Let's put the seven victims together. Mary Kellerman, twelve, Elk Grove Village, Adam Janice, twenty seven, Arlington Heights, Stanley Janice, twenty. 25, Teresa Janice around 20, Mary Reiner, 27, Winfield, Mary McFarland, 31, Lombard, and Paula Prince, 35, Chicago. seven families were dealing with something they could never have imagined. Nicholle: Seven and eight birthday with the Janice family, the loss was even more concentrated. Three members of one family died after taking Tylenol from that same bottle. They had started their lives together. Stanley and Teresa had actually been married only months before. This Zalle: That is so heartbreaking. Nicholle: it is. That poor family. Zalle: More than a thousand people attended their funeral at Saint Hyacinth. This is where I want to slow down for a second, because when we tell a case like this, it's easy to turn the victims into a number. Seven. But there wasn't a number walking into a hospital. There was Mary. There was Adam. There was Stanley. There was Teresa. There was Mary Reiner who Nicholle: But There wasn't a couple of box boxes. There was never. There was. There was never. There was no. What Zalle: Who had just become a mother again. There was Mary McFarland. There was Paula Prince, who had just come home from a trip. These were ordinary people having Nicholle: I did just hold on. There was an in. There wasn't. What I did something. These are four minutes. Zalle: ordinary days, and that's what the person responsible exploited. As investigators started tracing the contaminated capsules backward, another disturbing fact emerged. There wasn't just one contaminated bottle. Investigators ultimately identified eight contaminated bottles. Five were associated with the seven deaths. Three additional contaminated bottles were discovered or turned over to authorities, and the bottles were connected to multiple retail locations, Jewel, Walgreens, and other stores. Nicholle: Which means investigators couldn't simply say, okay, this bottle came from this store, so let's figure out who worked there. They had a much larger problem. Zalle: Exactly. Because now the question became how many bottles had been tampered with? Where had they gone? How many were still sitting on shelves? And how many people might take one before anybody realized what was happening? Yeah. Nicholle: Hmm. Zalle: Aye. Remember what year this was? Nineteen eighty two. There was no Facebook, no Instagram, No Twitter, no smartphones, no push notifications, no internet where somebody could post a warning and have millions of people see it within minutes. The warning had to travel through television, radio, newspapers. I know a lot of y'all don't y'all don't even know what a newspaper is. Police, hospitals, and word of mouth. Nicholle: And I just want to point out, I think I was six when this happened. And imagine Zalle: Way before my time. Nicholle: And imagine getting the warning from your television. Don't take the medicine that's sitting in your bathroom. Zalle: That sounds like all the recalls we got going on. Don't eat grapes. Don't breathe the air too deeply because then you get Nicholle: with the food. Yeah. Stay inside. Zalle: Police officers drove through neighborhoods using loudspeakers and bullhorns, warning people not to take Tylenol. Chicago mayor Jane Byrne ordered the medication removed from stores in the city. Johnson Johnson initiated a massive recall. Consumers were urged to stop taking the product. Millions of bottles were pulled or destroyed. Nicholle: And people were terrified because the threat wasn't somewhere far away. It wasn't something you could see. It could be in your own medicine cabinet. Zalle: That part. The thing that had always represented relief had suddenly become something people were afraid to touch. Authorities began testing huge numbers of capsules. The scale is different to comprehend. Investigators had described examining approximately eighty thousand individual capsules. Nicholle: Eighty thousand. my Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: god. Zalle: Capsule by capsule. The investigation became enormous. The FBI later described it as the largest product tampering investigation in law enforcement history. Nearly a hundred and twenty investigators from federal, state, and local agencies were involved. Nicholle: And that's before you even start talking about the tips. Because once the public knew somebody had intentionally poisoned medicine, everybody became suspicious of everything. Zalle: And investigators had another problem. They weren't just trying to find a murderer. They were trying to figure out how the contamination happened. Who had access, who had opportunity, who had knowledge, who had motive, And who might have said something that in hindsight suddenly sounded very different. One of the earliest major persons of interest was Roger Arnold. Arnold was forty eight years old and worked at a jewel warehouse. A bartender contacted authorities after saying Arnold had claimed to possess cyanide. Investigators searched Arnold's home. They found firearms, ammunition, chemistry equipment, and books related to explosives and poisons. They also found a white granular substance, but the substance wasn't cyanide. Nicholle: So this is where we have to be careful because when you hear man had cyanide, that sounds like a solved case, but that's not what the evidence showed. Zalle: Correct. The substance tested wasn't cyanide, and Arnold was never charged with the Tylenol murders, but investigators continued looking at him because there were other connections. He worked for Jewel. Some contaminated bottles were connected to Jewel. He frequented bars near the Walgreens where Paula Prince had purchased Tylenol, and he had worked with Mary Reiner's father. Nicholle: And then his story takes a completely separate and tragic turn. Zalle: It does. Arnold became convinced that a man named John Stanisha had reported him to police. He began looking for Stanisha, but Arnold had the wrong man. He killed him. Stanisha had nothing to do with the Tylenol investigation. Nicholle: So this man who had nothing to do with the Tylenol murders became a victim because somebody believed he had pointed the finger at him. Wow. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. When I was doing the research and heard that, I was like, I don't even remember. Obviously I wouldn't remember because you know I'm not that old. But anywho. I don't remember hearing that detail before. Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah. Zalle: Arnold was convicted of Stanisha's murder and sentenced to thirty years. However, he served about fifteen. He died in two thousand and eight, but he was never charged in the ty in the Tylenol murders. WTTW and SBC both document Arnold's investigation and the later killing of Stanisha. Then investigators looked at another man, Kevin Masterson, 35 of Lombard. Masterson reportedly had a longstanding grudge against Jewel. The background involved his former wife in an incident in which she had become accused of shoplifting and claimed she had been mistreated by store security. Masterson believed the incident contributed to the breakdown of his marriage. Nicholle: Masters and people break down the question. Investigators Zalle: Investigators learned that he had allegedly made statements suggesting he wanted revenge against Jewel and that other people Nicholle: learned we had allegedly stated people in the field of people. Zalle: could suffer. Nicholle: And again, there are details here that sound suspicious, but suspicion isn't the same thing as proving someone committed seven murders. Zalle: Right. Investigators searched his residence. They found writings they considered unusual in empty gelatin capsules. But the capsules weren't Tylenol capsules and weren't connected physically to the poisoned ones. Masterson eventually surrendered to the FBI in Los Angeles. He was retorn he was ret Nicholle: It was report. He was McCarron. He was with Jack. Zalle: He was returned to Illinois and and questioned, but authorities ultimately ruled him out. He was not charged with the Tylenol murders. This part of the investigation is worth including because it shows just how wide the net became. People who had suspicious circumstances surrounding them and still no murder charge. CBS and contemporaneous UPI Nicholle: contemporaneous Zalle: Reporting document Masterson's investigation, his jewel related grievance, his surrender to the FBI, and the fact that he was never charged in the poisonings. Then investigators got something they hadn't had before. Nicholle: Then investigators they had a Zalle: A communication from somebody claiming to be connected to the killings. Johnson and Johnson received a letter demanding one million dollars. The writer threatened additional deaths if the man if the manny if the money wasn't paid. Nicholle: communication. Johnson and Johnson were secret records nothing wrong with it. The writer threat they still have to make expanding Zalle: is wrong with my mouth. If the man in. Get at man and Marnie. Who? Nicholle: for the many. Get that man in Mary. That many Ooh, okay. And now you've got somebody essentially inserting themselves into the investigation. Zalle: Precisely. The letter became one of the most important pieces of the case. Investigators worked to trace it. Eventually, it led them to a man Nicholle: The letter we take one of those importance is space. If that's the data's important place, eventually it went to filming. Zalle: named James Lewis. Lewis was 37 years old and living in New York. He became a central suspect in the case. But there's an important distinction. Lewis was convicted of extortion connected to the letter. He was not convicted of murdering the seven victims, and he was never charged for those murders. Nicholle: So for decades people would hear his name and think that's the guy who did it. But legally that's not what happened. And that is horrible in these cases, what it Zalle: Right. Nicholle: can do to somebody's life. I mean, he clearly wasn't a good guy, but Yeah. James. Zalle: But that's what was on the books. James Lewis repeatedly denied that he poisoned the Tylenol, and the murder case never produced the physical evidence prosecutors needed to charge him. The FBI's historical account says no one could be charged with the murders because of insufficient evidence. while Lewis was prosecuted for the extortion attempt, the Lewis investigation became complicated. Because the extortion letter was real. The connection to Lewis was real. And then investigators began examining everything surrounding him. His statements, his movements, his background. His explanations for the letter and later his interactions with investigators. Lewis said the letter wasn't what authorities thought it was. He claimed it was intended to draw attention to another issue that he had been trying to make a point involving his wife and her former employer, but investigators weren't satisfied with his explanation, and over the years Lewis remained associated with the case. Years passed, the case remained open. The names changed in the headlines, the investigators changed, technology Nicholle: Here's past case we make the names change in the next slide. The investigators say technology. Zalle: changed. Nicholle: But the thing is the question is who puts my eyes in this house and out? Zalle: But the central question didn't Who put cyanide in those capsules? And how? Nicholle: And then technology gave investigators something they didn't have in nineteen eighty two. DNA tests. We love a good DNA test. Zalle: We love a good DNA testing. I love a good DNA testing. Yes, exactly, Nicholle: seven. Zalle: Gimme the Dana. In 2007, authorities took another serious look at the case. Old evidence was revisited. Old witnesses were interviewed again. And James Lewis was interviewed repeatedly. A lot. CBS CBS Chicago obtained records showing investigators met with Lewis or spoke with him at least 34 times between roughly 2007 and 2009. Those conversations were consensually recorded. Nicholle: Yeah, thirty four times is a lot of times. Yeah. Yeah. And here's what we're sending is substantial time on the competition. So we're going to have the line. We discussed a company for objects everywhere and didn't trade theory from the rest of the internet. I'm not sure what that is. Zalle: At least 34. Yeah. And here's where this case gets really strange. Lewis wasn't simply saying I didn't do it. He spent substantial time talking about how he believed the killer could have committed the crimes. He theorized. He drew diagrams. He discussed how somebody could have avoided leaving obvious evidence and he demonstrated his theories for investigators. Now I'm not sure what that man was thinking, but it wasn't thinking it through. Nicholle: It wasn't a clear. That's what I Zalle: That's what I know. Nicholle: at all. So I mean, I can understand why investigators would pay attention to that. Because if you're sitting across from somebody who is accused of something like this and they're giving you detailed theories about how it could have happened, you're gonna wanna know, why do you know so much? Zalle: Why are you telling me? Right? Like, okay. I don't get that. But knowing how a crime Nicholle: I don't understand what's happening here. I don't get that. But knowing how Zalle: might have happened isn't by itself proof that you committed it, though it does make you look a little suspicious. Nicholle: No, incredibly suspicious. I mean, I'm not Zalle: Just slightly spacious. Just a little rascal of special. Nicholle: an investigator, but if I was an investigator, you're my suspect. You're at the top of my list. But I But that's what it's invested. Zalle: Yep. Put eyes on him. Okay. But that's where this investigation becomes complicated. CBS documented Lewis discussing theories about how the killer could have handled the bottles and capsules, including demonstrations during recorded meetings. Yeah, he went like thorough into his theories, okay? Nicholle: Yes, he did. Zalle: It's very mind blowing. Investigators also took Lewis to the Walgreens where Paula Prince had purchased her bottle. According to retired FBI agent Roy Lane, Lewis appeared unusually animated and moved toward the area where Tylenol products had been stocked Nicholle: investigate all of the wall remains of all the friends and purchase her bottles. According to a fact of FCS, Roy Lane always appeared and moved toward the area. Zalle: in nineteen eighty two. Again, interesting. Absolutely. Proof? No, not necessarily. Though how specifically do you know where the Tylenol is? Because it takes me a minute to find anything at any Walgreens or C V S. investigators looked Nicholle: It investigates. Zalle: more closely at the timeline of Lewis's extortion letter. The letter was mailed october first, nineteen eighty two. Lewis had previously said he spent several days working on it. That raised an obvious question. What did he know Nicholle: The letter was possible. What did he know? Zalle: and when did he know it? Nicholle: Because if somebody's writing about the killings before the killings become public, that's potentially enormous. Zalle: Right, right. But the problem was that Lewis's memory about the timing changed. During later interviews, he acknowledged that his recollection on when he wrote the letter was uncertain. Investigators couldn't turn that inconsistency into a murder charge. And then there's another piece of evidence that has followed Lewis for years. In 2010, investigators found Lewis's fingerprints on a copy of a book titled Handbook of Poisonings. Nicholle: That sound That sounds awful. This is really an Zalle: It just really isn't looking good for Lewis. I'm just He's guilty, Your Honor. If this is the evidence, because I mean, it's not circumstantial. It's a fingerprint. You know, the circumstance is like the context of why you was reading this book. Nicholle: guilty or this is the evidence because I mean it's not circumstances. It's a fingerprint. The circumstance it's like the context of why he's reading this book. Yes, yes, yes. But I don't know if you I've heard that he's like so Zalle: But I don't know, because I've read things like confessions of a sociopath and shit like that. So do that make me crazy because I read crazy shit. Nicholle: so no, no, it's not that he read the book by itself. Right? It's that he had Zalle: All of the other stuff. And then the book. Right. Nicholle: All of them. Yeah, we just put all that together and it just it's like step by step it gets worse for good old Lewis. Zalle: Like he's slowly walking down the step. Yeah. Okay. But again, context matters. A fingerprint on a book about poison doesn't tell you when he touched the book or why he touched the book. It doesn't establish that he used the book to commit the murders, though they use cyanide, which is poison. In case somebody couldn't follow along with that. Okay. And it does not place him at a Tylenol bottle. Nicholle: It does. They decide that paper. Somebody don't follow the fact that it does not place him to of the problem. It's one certain and it's one. Zalle: It's one piece of circumstantial evidence. Nicholle: And that's really the story with Lewis. There are a lot of pieces that made investigators suspicious, but Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: there wasn't that one piece that closed the gap. Zalle: Right. They just never got that piece. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: because investigators eventually obtained DNA from some of the Tylenol bottles and the DNA did not match James Lewis. So Nicholle: So I mean that's huge. That's a big that's a big mark Zalle: It is. Nicholle: That's a big mark in his column. Zalle: Yes, it is, but it does not prove Lewis couldn't have committed the murders. It means investigators didn't have a DNA match tying him to the contaminated bottles. CBS reported that the DNA obtained from some of the bottles did not match Lewis, and that a later search of his home did not produce the hard physical evidence prosecutors needed. Just the extortion later and all of the horrible things that happened during the trial. Nicholle: Yes, that extortion letter, the theories he gave, all of his many interviews and that fingerprint, you have circumstantial evidence and then you have DNA that doesn't match. Zalle: Yeah. And that is why the case stayed open. Even though I'm sure those detectives was like, This nigga did it. I don't know Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: why I cannot find what I need to find, but I know he was he was involved in some way, shape, or matter. Maybe he was friends Nicholle: He did it. Wait, yeah, yeah. Zalle: with the person who actually did it. Like they went and talked about this over a beer and they was like, Yeah, we're just Nicholle: Yeah, Zalle: talking about it, blah, blah, blah. And his friend went through it. I don't know. But I would have been like, Yeah. Chief, Chief, we gotta figure out how to bring him in. Nicholle: Mm. But I wasn't like that. She she gotta figure out how to bring a thing. However, she was Zalle: However, James Lewis died in july twenty twenty three. He was seventy six. He died without ever being charged with the Tylenol murders, and his death didn't answer the central question. If anything, it closed one of the most frequently examined chapters of the investigation without providing a definite conclusion. Nicholle: Which means the case didn't end with Lewis. it just lost one of the people investigators has spent decades looking at. Zalle: I'm sure the cops were pissed. Yeah. But that's important because even before Lewis died, investigators had never publicly established that he was the killer. So obviously the case remained open. Nicholle: Yeah, this section everyone. Yeah. Yeah. Zalle: But while the murder case remained unsolved, the consequences were enormous. Before 1982, over-the-counter medicine medicine packaging didn't have the same tamper evident protections Americans are accustomed to today. Tylenol capsules weren't sealed shut. Boxes didn't have the modern temp tamper evident protections consumers now expect. I don't like that word. Nicholle: But while the murder team permitted solved, the consequences were enormous. Before in 1982, only the counter medicine medicine advocates didn't have the hamburger medicine protections. Americans are a question today. Highland on statues one school ship boxes didn't have one except amber medicine protections. But I mean that's crazy to think about today. If you opened a container of a box of Tylenol and opened that top, you'd be like you wouldn't even get to the top. You'd be like, Absolutely not. In fact the bottles now tell you don't take it if that's messed with. Zalle: I don't take it. Yeah. Nicholle: So after somebody exploited that vulnerability, the entire industry changed. Zalle: Yes, the FDA issued tamper-resistant packaging regulations in 1982, and the Federal Anti-Tampering Act followed in 1983, making tampering with packaged consumer products a federal crime. The FDA specifically identified the 1982 packaging regulations as a response to poisonings such as the Tylenol Deaths and notes, the 1983 Federal Anti-Tampering Act. Nicholle: And that's one of the weirdest legacies of this case. The murders were never solved. But almost every person who buys medicine today lives with the safety change that came out of what happened. Zalle: Yeah. The butterfly effect. Nicholle: Exactly. Zalle: So let's strip away everything we've heard over the years and look at what we actually know. We know seven people died after taking extra strength Tylenol capsules contaminated with cyanide. We know the victims lived in the Chicago area and that the deaths happened over a very short period. We know contaminated bottles were found at multiple locations. We know investigators identified eight contaminated bottles. And that approximately 80,000 capsules were examined during the massive response. We know the contamination was determined to have happened after manufacturing and the investigation involved federal, state, and local authorities on an enormous scale. We know James Lewis sent the extortion letter and was convicted for that crime, and that he denied killing the victims. He was never charged with the murders. Nicholle: everyone. We know their souls and make fortune first it's considered the bad question. And then he decided to take it in after sparkle. Zalle: We know DNA attained from some of the bottles Nicholle: We know the end of some homework. Zalle: did not match Lewis, and we know that for more than four decades nobody has been convicted of the seven murders. Nicholle: And then twenty twenty six happens. You know what I'm saying? Zalle: You know what I'm realizing? This year's the year of like we're finding a lot of shit out. You know, with whether it's like the Epstein Files or all of them coming back with new evidence, like the the yogurt shop killing and all of the Nicholle: the yoga thing. Zalle: extra stuff with the people coming back and getting caught nowadays for stuff that happened all so many years ago. Nicholle: Right, right. Inceptively best if you don't say that Zalle: In September twenty twenty six, investigators in Idaho announced a development that immediately sent people back to the Tylenol case. For more than four decades, an unidentified mm Nicholle: from more of the base. And that then effects and best would be Zalle: Fix your face immediately. Nicholle: I don't know. An unidentified man developed as a much more in December of nineteen eighty six man walked to take the temperature voice. Zalle: unidentified man had been known as the Unknown Wanderer. In December 1982, a man walked into Sacred Heart Catholic Church in Boise, Idaho. He died there after ingesting cyanide. He had no identification, he had a false name, he had cash, nearly 30 keys, and a story investigators couldn't solve. For decades, nobody knew who he was. Nicholle: He died after his death by men I did. He had a question. Nearly thirty and the story had pictures for decades, so what did it was Until now. Zalle: Until now. Ida County investigators identified him as Dr. Matthew Francis. Nicholle: Bitkowski. Zalle: Bedkowski. DNA work helped establish his identity through a surviving relative. and once investigators knew who he was, they started looking backward into his life. And that's where the Tylenol connection appeared. CBS Chicago and Boise State Police Radio both reported the set. Both reported the september two thousand twenty six identification and the possible connection to the Chicago case. Batkowski was a chemist. He had worked in chemistry-related positions, including at Lockheed's White Sands Test Facility in New Mexico. Before that, he had worked for a flavors and fragrances company in Jacksonville, Florida. And according to investigators, co-workers at different points in his career remembered him making comments about poison and cyanine. Nicholle: Bikkowski was a kid's he had worked in symmetry related positions, including the white sex proposition. Before that, he had worked with places, fragrances companies, back and forth. And according to investigators, co-worker at different points of his career under making functions about poison and sci-fi. And we're talking about comments that investigators didn't necessarily understand as connected to a murder at the time. Zalle: Correct, but investigators looking backwards decades later found these statements much more interesting. According to Ida County investigators, co-workers recalled Baikowski discussing the idea of a perfect crime involving poison. And while working at Lockheed, investigators say he made a comment about introducing poison into our over the counter capsules. Nicholle: Now that is an incredibly specific thing to hear after the fact. Zalle: But ain't it though? Ain't it? But we're still not at he did it. Because the most important question is where was he when the Tylenol murders happened? When investigators examined belongings connected to Bedkowski, they found a hand drawn map of Chicago. First of all. Nicholle: When the best teachers stand and belong connected to the house, they asked and on the process. First of all. Zalle: Sit with me people. Who the fuck hand drawing maps of a whole big ass city. This not one of the little small, like out in the country towns. Yeah. Chicago. Nicholle: that wouldn't be photographed the hand drawingness of a whole big ass city. It's not one of those little small, like I'm yeah. Chicago. They also found photographs and placed him in the Chicago area. Zalle: They also found photographs that placed him in the Chicago area. And Nicholle: And at first investigators said that some of those photographs could have been of late nineteen eighty sixty. Were they examinations reporting they were late for December nineteen eighty five? So Zalle: at first investigators believed that some of those photographs might have been from late nineteen eighty two. Further examination reportedly indicated they were more likely from December nineteen eighty one. So Nicholle: he had been in Chicago, but not necessarily when the murders happened. Right. And that's pretty investigators have not been able to have been Chicago very possibly. Zalle: Right, and that distinction is critical. Investigators have not been able to place Bedkowski in Chicago during the final week of September nineteen eighty two, when the Tylenol poisonings occurred. CBS reported that investigators found evidence placing him in the Chicago area in late nineteen eighty one, but could not establish that he was there during the critical September nineteen eighty two period. Then investigators found something else. A small bottle labeled as cyanide. Testing showed that it contained sodium cyanide, and investigators believed the material had been produced from peach and apricot pits. Nicholle: And investigative material to predict process. But the Tylenol murders involved potassium cyanide. is the same with substance that we can have soap. Zalle: Yes, yes. And that distinction needs to stay in this story. Okay. The substance connected to Bekowski was sodium cyanide. The poison found in the Tylenol capsules was potassium. Cyanide Those are different compounds. So the bottle does not provide a chemical fingerprint that simply says Nicholle: Those are different compounds, so of codelessness survived in several circumstances as the exact Zalle: That's the exact poison used in Chicago. It is evidence that investigators find relevant because of the broader circumstances. Nicholle: portion of intercoveries. It is evidence that investigators are relevant to the broader circumstances. Right. So you've got a chemist, a history of discussing poison, a connection to Chicago, a Chicago map he personally drew, a bottle containing cyanide, a death by cyanide three months after the Tylenol murders, but you don't have him physically in Chicago during the murder. Zalle: Yeah, exactly. And that's why authorities aren't calling him the Tylenol killer. There's another part of Bekkowski's history investigators are examining. In March 1982, he was fired from Lockheed after an incident involving a local pharmacy. Investigators say he had attempted to obtain pills or capsules for an experiment. Nicholle: investigators that we had a teacher protection for an experience. Zalle: Police became involved and investigators later found evidence that he had been conducting experiments Nicholle: Police became involved in investigating Richard California that we had been susceptible to any Zalle: at home. Nicholle: Which puts that several months before the Tylenol murders. And that's the part Zalle: Yeah. And that's the part of why investigators are looking closely at his timeline. But again, chronologically, isn't proof. A Nicholle: person that is a ministry fisherman that's in his family a person said the figure of the least per figure in the country. And then those strangers were the fact that has disappeared but this like a Mexico. Zalle: person having a history of chemistry experiments doesn't establish that person committed a particular murder or these particular murders. And then there's the strangest piece of the timeline. Batkowski disappeared from his life in New Mexico. He sold his car near the Mexico border Nicholle: He solved his property for like so worth Zalle: And eventually he turned up in Boise. Inside a Catholic church, he died from cyanide poisoning. He had taken steps to conceal his identity. He carried a false name, had cash, nearly thirty keys, and no one knew who Nicholle: And eventually he turned up into the inside of Catholic Church. He died by an action. He had taken steps because his idea he carried things. Zalle: he was. Nicholle: And three months earlier, seven people had died from cyanide poisoning in Chicago. This that is a question. Zalle: Yep. Yeah. And that is exactly why investigators revisited the possibility of a connection. But the FBI has also cautioned that repeated claims of connections to the Tylenol murders have remained unsubstantiated, and the Bureau says it remains involved in the investigation. This is probably the most important section of the entire update because headlines can move much faster than evidence. As of September 2026, investigators have identified Betkowski as the unknown wanderer. They have found evidence they believe warrants examining a possible connection between him and the Tylenol murders. They have shared that information with Chicago investigators. Chicago police and Arlington Heights police have acknowledged receiving and reviewing the material, but authorities have not. Nicholle: They have shared that information to Chicago and test space. Chicago foods arms and pieces acknowledged the student and root complex, but a those have not established that I can see Chicago and I'm not going to be they have not practiced any consciousness because Zalle: established that Bekowski was in Chicago during the poisonings and they have not charged him. I mean, obviously, because he died in nineteen eighty two. Nicholle: that's And there's another problem, even if investigators eventually established that he was in Chicago, that still wouldn't automatically prove he was the person who contaminated the Tylenol. Zalle: Yeah, it would it wouldn't automatically prove that. They would still need the evidence connecting him to the actual crime, like the bottles, the capsules, the store, the timing, or the contamination. Maybe even to the people who handled the products. So that's the missing bridge. Nicholle: And that's why I don't want us to say they finally solved the Tylenol murders because they haven't. Zalle: Correct. They have not. What they have is a new investigative lead. And honestly, after 44 years, that's significant enough without pretending it's something it isn't. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Mom, You know what keeps sticking with me about this case? It's not just that the killer hasn't been identified. It's how little the victims had to do with the person who killed them. Nicholle: You know what he gave me about the disease? It's not just that it's still a tax, it's how limited the difference has to be with the person who's building. Yes, and that's what gets to me too, because most people understand danger through relationships. You worry about somebody who has threatened you, somebody who's following you, somebody you know has a problem with you. There's usually a person attached to the danger. We understand that type of danger. Zalle: Yeah, but here you could walk into a store, pick up a bottle, take it home, and never know that something had been done to it at all. Nicholle: Yeah, and you wouldn't even know you were in danger. That is scary. So scary. Yeah. And that's it to help people thought about the basic because episode war that you think that we gained and something truly ordinary. Zalle: That is terrifying. Yeah. And that changed how people thought about everyday safety. Because after this, the question wasn't only who is dangerous. It became can something completely ordinary be dangerous? There are still major questions. Who physically contaminated the capsules? How many bottles were tampered with beyond the eight investigators identified? Were all the contaminated bottles placed by one person? Was there more than one person involved? Where exactly were the bottles altered? How did the person move through multiple stores without being identified? What was the motive? Nicholle: There are so many components. Who thinks it was the fan base exercise? How many bottles and thread exercises were all but stand-based by legislation by one person? Was there more than one person involved? Where exactly was the boxes of one person? How did the person lose the solid destroy the clean ID for? What was the modus? Zalle: Why those particular stores? Why those particular dates? Nicholle: Why those particular scores? Why those particular dates? You perhaps the biggest question. Why did the person die? Zalle: And perhaps the biggest question, why did the person stop? Nicholle: Yeah, because after seven people died, whoever did it just disappeared. No confession, no courtroom, no definitive murder weapon in somebody's possession. No confession explaining why. No final answer. And that is frustrating. Zalle: Yeah. And that's why every new lead gets examined so intensely, because the case has one of those rare combinations investigators hate. A clearly established crime, clearly established victims, a known poison, a known product, known contaminated bottle bottles, a massive investigation, and still no person conclusively connected to all of it. Nicholle: Yeah. To bring it back to the families, because 44 years can make a case sound ancient, but it isn't ancient to the people who lost somebody. For the Janice family, three people were gone from the same family. And for Mary Kellerman's parents, their daughter was gone. Mary Reiner's children grew up without their mother. Paula Prince's family lost her. Mary McFarlane's loved ones lost her. Adam Janice's family lost him. And Stanley and Teresa never got the life they had just. started building. And that is sad. That's all that and then something I don't want to be supposed to take. This isn't just the history. It's seven weeks never craft again. Zalle: And that's something that's so sad. And that's something I don't want lost underneath all the suspects and theories. This isn't just the mystery of who did it. It's seven people who never got another day. The physical world changed after the murders. Tamper resistant packaging became required. Federal law changed. Drug manufacturers changed how products were sealed. Consumers became accustomed to Nicholle: Visible world creating protective purpose. Never with this technique required by roll of things. Roger spectroscopes too. Consumers have been custom Do we safety? And the idea that those objects would be open to protect their cells without any formula became a part of the side. Zalle: Two safety seals, and the idea that a bottle could be opened and returned to a shelf without anyone knowing became much harder to imagine. The FDA's historical timeline specifically credits the nineteen eighty-two tamper resistant packaging regulations with responding to poisonings such as the Tylenods, followed by the Federal Anti-Tampering Act Nicholle: The FBA's closer pipeline specifically that nineteen ninety two anti-resistant activity regulation was responding to such an item, followed by the still acting. Zalle: in nineteen eighty-three. Nicholle: So every time somebody peels a seal off of a bottle of medicine and hears that little crackle. Zalle: There's history behind that. So where does that leave us in September 2026? The Tylenol murders remain unsolved. Seven people were killed. No one has been convicted of those murders. James Lewis is dead, but was never charged with the killings. Roger Arnold was investigated, but never charged with the Tylenol murders. Kevin Masterson was investigated and later ruled out, and now investigators have a new name to examine. Doctor Matthew Francis Bikowski, but he cannot currently be placed in Chicago during the September nineteen eighty two poisonings. Nicholle: The evidence Zalle: The evidence publicly described so far establishes a web of intriguing connections, not a completed evidentiary train chain. Nicholle: And that's where I think this case needs to stay. Not Bukowski did it. Not Lewis definitely did it. Not Arnold did it. Not somebody else must have. just this is what investigators know. This is what they don't know. And this is what they're still trying to connect. Zalle: Yeah, because after forty four years, the temptation is to grab the newest theory and make it the ending. But the truth is we don't have an ending yet. Think back to that bottle. That ordinary bottle sitting in a medicine cabinet. That's where the story began for so many people. Nobody knew. Nobody could look at the bottle and see what was inside. And that's what makes this case different from so many others. The person responsible didn't need to know the victims, didn't need to confront them, didn't need to enter their homes. He or she only needed to alter something ordinary and then leave it behind. Nicholle: And that's what this is different from social media. The person responsible didn't need to help vacuums. They will need to provide them to leave to their homes. He or she only needs a operating nearly problem. And forty-four years later, investigators are still trying to figure out who that person was. Zalle: so if anything changes in this case, you already know we're going to be watching Nicholle: so in any constituents you already know we're going to be Zalle: it. We want the whole story, the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the human beings behind the case. If you made it all the way through this episode, thank you for spending your time with us. Nicholle: And if you haven't already, follow us, subscribe, and leave us a review. Zalle: Tell us what you think about this episode. And if you're watching on YouTube, hit that like button. It really does help us keep growing. Nicholle: It really does. And please tell us, what do you think the investigators should be looking at next? Zalle: We'll see you next time. Nicholle: Bring your coffee. Zalle: We'll bring the crime. Bye. Nicholle: Bye.