Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / The Wars of the Roses: How England's Aristocracy Killed Itself in 30 Years
Transcript
- 0:00History tells us the War of the Roses was a chivalric struggle
- 0:03between 2 great houses, ending with Henry Tudor's victory at
- 0:07Bosworth and the dawn of Tudor age.
- 0:11That's the cover story. What actually happened across 30
- 0:15years between 1455 and 1487 was something much darker.
- 0:20Two cousin lineages of the same royal family, Lancaster and
- 0:23York, fought a sequence of battles that didn't just
- 0:26transfer the crown, they systematically destroyed the
- 0:29English aristocracy. In 1450, England had roughly 200
- 0:34noble houses with the wealth and military power to shape the
- 0:37Kingdom. By 1490, half of them were
- 0:40extinct. At Taunton on Palm Sunday in
- 0:431461, an estimated 28,000 men died in a single afternoon in a
- 0:47Blizzard, the bloodiest day in English military history before
- 0:51or since. Henry Tudor doesn't found the
- 0:53Tudor dynasty by defeating Richard the 3rd at Bosworth.
- 0:56He inherited a country where the class that could have stopped
- 0:59him from doing that had already killed itself.
- 1:02This is the pattern when an aristocracy turns its weapons on
- 1:05itself. It doesn't get replaced by
- 1:07reform or restoration, it gets replaced by something more
- 1:11centralized than what it tried to defend.
- 1:13Today I'm joined by the medieval scholar on X to walk through one
- 1:16of the most thorough acts of aristocratic self destruction in
- 1:20English history. Welcome back to Hidden Forces in
- 1:41History. I'm your host Jeremy Ryan, Slate
- 1:43CEO and Co founder of Command Your Brand.
- 1:46You can find us at commandyourbrand.com.
- 1:50Reminder, if you're brand new to this channel to like this video,
- 1:52leave us a comment and to hit that subscribe button if you
- 1:55want more Hidden Forces in history.
- 1:58So today we're talking about a subject that I have really
- 2:01nerded out about in the last couple years and that is the
- 2:03English War of the Roses. And it's something that
- 2:07historically, I don't think we quite get a lot of the
- 2:11viewpoints that really explain the situation and even who came
- 2:15out on top. So today we're actually joined
- 2:17by one of my favorite X accounts.
- 2:20If you haven't followed him yet, please go do that.
- 2:22He is at Medieval Scholar. So we have the Medieval Scholar
- 2:25with us today. Thanks for hanging out with me
- 2:26today man. Thank you for the invite, it's a
- 2:28pleasure to be here. Yeah.
- 2:30So for people that may not be aware of your work, just tell us
- 2:32a little bit about what you do and and you know what they can
- 2:36expect from you. So what I do is that I have a
- 2:40sub stack as well as AX slash Twitter page that's dedicated
- 2:44to. Telling.
- 2:46People and educating people about the insurance and outs of
- 2:49medieval history, whether that be culture, religion, trade,
- 2:53warfare, and even highlighting stories of great heroes of the
- 2:57age, especially for me when I was in American public school,
- 3:04this is just not something that we learned about.
- 3:07But growing up, you know, I, I remember watching Disney's like
- 3:10Sword in the Stone and I was like, this is really cool.
- 3:12I want to learn more about this. So I got into it.
- 3:15I created this page dedicate. I really just thought, you know,
- 3:19maybe 15 people, 20 people, they'll think that this is
- 3:22really cool and that and I'll be content with that.
- 3:26And Needless to say, it's been a it's been a wild ride to be
- 3:30where we are now. And I'm I'm very grateful to be
- 3:36able to talk with people like yourself and other people who
- 3:40are interested to know more about history.
- 3:42So I, I want to kind of start us out.
- 3:44So we kind of lay the groundwork correctly when we're, we're
- 3:46talking about the War of the Roses and I know we have an hour
- 3:49booked out. So I'm really hoping we can fit
- 3:51the War of the Roses into an hour, because it is.
- 3:54It's very it's. Very long ordeal.
- 3:56So, so we'll see how this goes. But can you walk us through the
- 3:59English political landscape in 1455, years before the wars
- 4:04began? Because I think that is
- 4:05important to have that. What kind of country is England
- 4:08at this time and what specifically was about to break?
- 4:13OK, so England in 1450, it was not a it wasn't a failed state
- 4:18and it was not on the verge of collapse or anything like that.
- 4:22It was still a very powerful, major and influential Kingdom in
- 4:27Europe. Monarchy and the people around
- 4:30it were still, in terms of recent memory, are still
- 4:34enjoying the events of what happened when Henry the Fifth
- 4:39was monarch of England and the conquest that he did in northern
- 4:43France and of course the Treaty of the Treaty of Trois that
- 4:49would make him the crown King of France after the death of
- 4:53Charles the 6th. Obviously Henry dies before that
- 4:57happens. Charles dies afterwards, and who
- 5:00becomes king is the very, very young boy, Henry the Sixth, who
- 5:05will become incredibly important in this story.
- 5:10So in 1450, a major event really starts to stoke the fire that
- 5:18people are having. It's called Jack Cade's
- 5:21Rebellion. It begins in 1450.
- 5:23It goes from the months of April to July and it's basically
- 5:28people who are voicing their grievances, their local
- 5:32grievances about corruption, abuse of power, taxes, and all
- 5:37things like this. Not to mention this is also
- 5:41stacking on top of the stress of the 100 years war which is
- 5:45essentially in its final hours. The 100 Years War only has about
- 5:50three years left, 2 1/2 depending on what time of 1450
- 5:54you want to gauge it. So England is not in trouble,
- 6:02but it's on its way there. So I guess we look at it, you
- 6:06mentioned Henry the 6th, there's a there's a succession crisis
- 6:10that is resolved around him. And what's the actual nature of
- 6:14his kingship and what made rule untenable?
- 6:18So much for the political class. So Henry the 6th is really
- 6:22interesting because when you're looking at the Wars of the Roses
- 6:26from an outsider's perspective, someone who may not know a lot
- 6:30about it, they hear about what happens usually when there's a
- 6:33civil war or a revolt like this. Usually eyes are drawn towards
- 6:37the reigning monarch. You know what's wrong with them?
- 6:40Like, is it like a Richard the Second?
- 6:42Like, are they a tyrant? Is it like a Henry the Eighth?
- 6:45You know what's going on. Henry the 6th is not actually a
- 6:50tyrant. He's very personally an
- 6:53admirable monarch, he's religious, he's charitable, and
- 6:57he's committed to peace for the Kingdom.
- 7:00The problem with Henry is that it didn't effectively make him a
- 7:07good king. It could make him a admirable
- 7:11person as a result, but it's not.
- 7:15It doesn't translate well into monarchy.
- 7:19You're you're expected to lead politically managed competing
- 7:22noble interests, reward supporters, punish opponents,
- 7:24things like that. You're supposed to project your
- 7:27authority as king, and Henry was not very good at this.
- 7:33So Fast forward a couple years to 1453 when the Battle of
- 7:40Casteon happens and England loses, and that's effectively
- 7:45the end of the 100 Years War and England has lost.
- 7:49Henry goes completely catatonic. He has a sort of mental health
- 7:56crisis, he goes completely catatonic and he's completely
- 8:01incapable of governing England for a considerable amount of
- 8:06time. And in that point is when
- 8:09Richard, Duke of York, is made defender of the realm.
- 8:13So when Henry is completely out of the picture for a while, the
- 8:19question of the nobles around him begin to raise up.
- 8:23And it goes something like, you know, what do we do?
- 8:27Our king is completely out of the picture.
- 8:29He's not able to rule the Kingdom in this state.
- 8:33So if the king can't rule, then who's ruling in his place?
- 8:38And he's a very interesting character too, from the
- 8:40perspective of cause I've read a lot of Dan Jones's work and, and
- 8:44a lot of other sources and even his, his marriage to, to
- 8:48Margaret of Anjou. Like she's a very interesting
- 8:50character in this story as well. Because it seems like in a lot
- 8:53of ways, and I could be taking some leaps here, but it seems
- 8:56like in a lot of ways, she's who Henry isn't, if that makes
- 8:59sense. I agree.
- 9:03Margaret von Jew is actually a very politically smart, cunning
- 9:09woman. She's very politically savvy and
- 9:13she's able to do the things that Henry is unable to do.
- 9:16Like you said, something that a lot of people tracing back to
- 9:21what I said earlier, a lot of people will typically put their
- 9:24eyes onto the king. You know, what did they do
- 9:27wrong? What did they, what did they do
- 9:29to cause all this problem? And I think that it's very
- 9:35important to analyze this conflict as something that isn't
- 9:41entirely Henry's fault. England already had structural
- 9:45problems within the realm, but his inability to manage those
- 9:50problems kind of exasperated the political situation into a
- 9:56constitutional crisis. Henry didn't create the tensions
- 10:01that led to the wars happening, but once they got going,
- 10:07considering the person that he was, he was unable to stop that
- 10:10train once it got moving. And as well, I'm kind of foggy
- 10:15on the details here, so I'm, I'm hoping you know them, but is it
- 10:18Henry the 5th or is it one of the rulers before him that
- 10:21actually changes? I'm not sure if it's divisions,
- 10:24but the way titles are done as well.
- 10:26And that also creates some of the underlying pressure as well.
- 10:28Am I correct to say that? I believe it's Henry the Fifth.
- 10:31OK, that changes how things go. So.
- 10:34So what? Exactly does he do?
- 10:38Things sort of it goes about actually earning and prestige of
- 10:46these titles and it's not totally getting rid of, you
- 10:53know, familial ancestral like inheritance of the power.
- 10:58You know, there's still going to be people who become Duke
- 11:01because their father dies and they take over the title.
- 11:07So everything is still centric on family.
- 11:10A lot of these families are very powerful.
- 11:12Obviously the two main character families of this conflict are
- 11:18Cadet houses of the legendary House of Plantagenet, but I
- 11:27think people began to see that nobles and aristocrats start to
- 11:35really gain a lot of power as the centuries go by.
- 11:40By the time you're in the late 15th century, people are like,
- 11:44Knights aren't what Knights were in the 1100s, You know, in the
- 11:481100s, Knights are simply just very elite ground soldiers.
- 11:53By the time you get to the late 15th century, Knights are not
- 11:56only that, but they're also extremely influential.
- 12:00They're land owners, they're leading armies, they are taking
- 12:07part in court affairs and how to manage governance.
- 12:12So it's a very it can be very messy for someone who is inside
- 12:17it and they don't know how to work it.
- 12:19So that's really interesting because I think to me, it makes
- 12:22me think of the whole thing of history doesn't repeat, but it
- 12:24does rhyme. Because if you even look at the,
- 12:27the mid to late Roman Republic, there's the, the, the class
- 12:32that's called the equitase. It's, it will be translated to
- 12:34Knights and earlier they had been cavalry officers in the in
- 12:38the Roman army, but it eventually just becomes a
- 12:40political class of people that actually don't serve in the army
- 12:43at all. So it's it's, it's kind of
- 12:44really interesting how history can pattern itself of each
- 12:48other. And I guess we look at the first
- 12:50battle, which is at Saint Albans in 1455.
- 12:53It's usually cited as. The start of the war.
- 12:56But how clean is that as a starting point?
- 12:59And was it always going to escalate past a dynastic war?
- 13:03Was there still kind of a way to to claw it back in it at this
- 13:05point in time? So if you ask a historian who
- 13:11has been studying the Wars of the Roses for pretty much their
- 13:15entire career, they will say that it's true.
- 13:18Say, Albans is traditionally the flashpoint that starts the
- 13:24entire. It begins as, you know,
- 13:27political back and forths. But this is when it really
- 13:30erupts into armed conflict. You know, the whole situation is
- 13:34already sort of like a powder keg, and the skirmish at Saint
- 13:38Albans is like the match that goes into the fire.
- 13:44So what happens is that Henry the 5th or Henry the fifth?
- 13:51Henry the 6th towards the end of the battle is captured and this
- 13:58is something that a lot of people are just shocked to see.
- 14:05So St. Albans happens on May 22nd of
- 14:081455. So this is just two years after
- 14:11the end of the 100 years war. Two years after Henry the Sixth
- 14:14goes catatonic for the first time and it was about it was
- 14:22generally small for the battles of the time.
- 14:26Saint Albans had about 3000 to 7000 Yorkist forces and they
- 14:32were clashing with about 2000 forces under the Lancastrian
- 14:36banner. So the Yorkists moved and moved
- 14:42from outside the village, moved outside the town, and slowly but
- 14:46surely they began to engage in urban warfare in the Middle
- 14:50Ages, which I think is a really cool sort of mix of.
- 14:54That's like the first time for me that when I was studying, I
- 14:57saw urban medieval combat, so I thought that was really cool.
- 15:01But one of your favorite figures, Richard Neville, the
- 15:06Earl of Warwick, is sort of the hero of the day.
- 15:11He flanks through the gardens of the Market Square and shatters
- 15:16the Lancastrian line that are defending the city.
- 15:20Only about 200 people die in the battle, which 200 people is a
- 15:26lot, but for the battles that are to come is a considerably
- 15:31low number. I think that looking at how
- 15:36people were reacting towards all the problems, especially people
- 15:41like Richard, the Duke of York, who was defender of the realm, I
- 15:48think armed conflict was inevitable.
- 15:50Would it be at Saint Albans? I don't know.
- 15:53But St. Albans obviously is sort of the
- 15:56flashpoint to when this becomes less of a feud and more of into
- 15:59an armed civil war. So the King Henry is captured
- 16:06and Richard, the Duke of York returns to London with the King
- 16:12in tow, and he is reinstated as protector by Parliament himself.
- 16:20So is it? Really interesting.
- 16:21I know we'll get back to, to Richard Neville the, the, the
- 16:24Duke, the the Earl of Warwick later the kingmaker.
- 16:28He's a, he's a very interesting character in this whole story
- 16:30because he's, he's very involved in, in much of it.
- 16:33He seems to be one of the shrewdest political operators in
- 16:36all of it too. So we'll, we'll get to him more
- 16:37in a bit, but we look at 1460 to 1461, the conflict moved from
- 16:43more of a a faction type dispute to to more of a full succession
- 16:47war. What are the events that lead us
- 16:50up to Tauten? So Tauten is really a event that
- 16:58is sort of marred by a very long and bloody path that just paints
- 17:05a swath of red through England and hits this sort of
- 17:13cataclysmic, violent crescendo at Touten itself.
- 17:18So you have St. Albans, the King is captured,
- 17:23the Duke of York is made defender again by Parliament.
- 17:28Eventually you have battles such as the Battle of Wakefield,
- 17:35which is in 1461, Richard, Duke of York and his Yorkist allied
- 17:42forces, They ride out of Sandal Castle to meet the Lancastrians,
- 17:48and it ends up being an ambush. Richard and his men are
- 17:51surrounded on all sides. Richard's knocked off his horse.
- 17:55The Yorkists are absolutely annihilated.
- 17:58They're crushed, Richard is killed, and it's a complete
- 18:04victory for the Lancastrians. And after Richard's death, his
- 18:10son Edward would take control of the Yorkist faction.
- 18:14And after this he would go on to the OR sorry, he would take
- 18:26control. And then while Richard of
- 18:29Warwick was defeated at the second Battle of Saint Albans,
- 18:32because there's two of them and Margaret of on Jews forces would
- 18:36recapture Henry the 6th after this.
- 18:40So Edward and Richard Neville unite together with their forces
- 18:47after this defeat. So Henry the 6th and Margaret
- 18:53they move N from London for the sake of obviously personal
- 18:59safety, but also because politically a lot of people
- 19:04don't really like them anymore. They move N after losing the
- 19:07support of many of the Lancastrian forces had committed
- 19:11atrocities in the area. So the local, even the local
- 19:16lesser parts of the, you know, sort of caste system, even the
- 19:22peasants and other people, they are looking at this as like,
- 19:25what is going on? You know, the King's forces are
- 19:28committing all these atrocities everywhere.
- 19:30How are we supposed to be expected to support him?
- 19:33So they flee. Edward takes this opportunity to
- 19:37go to London and declare himself king.
- 19:42So Edward becomes King Edward the 4th, and following himself
- 19:46being crowned, he takes his army.
- 19:49Now is King Edward the 4th, and he marches north, and this upon
- 19:57marching N, is when we get to Taunton itself.
- 20:02And Edward the 4th I find to be. And I don't know, maybe this is
- 20:05my own opinion on it. I really see him as the guy who
- 20:09could have been the hero of this story, right?
- 20:11To me, he just seems like he seems like the one who in the
- 20:15end should have come out on top, right?
- 20:17Like he seems like the one that that should have been king.
- 20:19You know, he had the the military prowess, he had the
- 20:22right political positioning. You know, maybe he didn't quite
- 20:25have the right lineage, but at the same time he had some
- 20:28lineage. But he really seems like, in my
- 20:30opinion, the one that should have been the hero of this whole
- 20:34thing. And what we'll find out a little
- 20:35bit later that he ends up really not being that hero to me.
- 20:39It's just he's, he's a very interesting character in that
- 20:41way. Edward's a really fascinating
- 20:44guy. Part of it, what makes him so
- 20:48interesting, is how much he stands out.
- 20:50Edward, according to historians, stands at about 6 foot 4 inches.
- 20:55So he's huge for that time. He's gigantic, yeah.
- 20:59And he's physically strong. He's highlighted numerous times
- 21:03for his capability in battle and his his tendency to lead from
- 21:08the front in the vanguard among his men.
- 21:10So just the sight of like a 64 king in his full suit of plate
- 21:17armor is first. The person on the other side of
- 21:21the field is not really something you want to see, but
- 21:24Touten is, for lack of a better word, is complete carnage if you
- 21:36want to go directly into Touten here.
- 21:38We'll, we'll get into, we'll get into Touten in just a second.
- 21:41And I don't want to get my, my, my Henry the fifth fans mad
- 21:45because I think I ultimately am my favorite British monarch is
- 21:48Henry the 5th. I know memory medieval and Ion X
- 21:50go back and forth that he likes Richard the Lionheart better.
- 21:53And I, I think Henry the 5th's better, but I, I really think
- 21:56that had Edward the 4th lived, he had the ability to be a Henry
- 22:02the fifth type character. But I guess looking at, at
- 22:04Tauten, it's, it's Palm Sunday in 146128 thousand are dead in a
- 22:10single day in a, in a total Blizzard.
- 22:12What's the modern scholarly assessment of those numbers and
- 22:16what's actually known about the battle and how it unfolded?
- 22:21So Tauten the numbers of dead can be disputed.
- 22:26They're still being disputed to this day, but feels.
- 22:29Like every historical battle is that way.
- 22:31Yeah, Towin is like, 'cause people don't want to be like,
- 22:36oh, there was 100,000 dead, It was the rivers ran red with
- 22:41blood. Well, it's like, it's like the
- 22:43the Greeks talking about the Persians.
- 22:44They were a million Persians, you know, there.
- 22:46There definitely weren't, but. OK, yeah, that makes it feel
- 22:49better. The chroniclers at the time
- 22:50really wanted to like hype up their side, but they definitely
- 22:56all agree that it was the largest and bloodiest battle on
- 23:00English soil. Regardless of what the final
- 23:03death tally was, it was complete carnage.
- 23:07So like you said, it takes place on Palm Sunday on March 29th,
- 23:111461 in North Yorkshire and. So this is basically in the the
- 23:18Yorkist homeland at this point in time.
- 23:23Yeah, this is, you know, what they're writing 'cause they had
- 23:27ridden N on Jew and Henry and Edward has declared himself king
- 23:33and he goes N to follow them. So he wants I, I, I would
- 23:39imagine from my point of view, if I was Edward, I'm looking at
- 23:44Touten as like, you know, whatever this next battle is
- 23:47that we have, I want it to end everything right here.
- 23:53And Edward is no slouch. Edward actually goes undefeated
- 23:58in his military career in his life, especially as king.
- 24:03If I remember correctly, Edward goes A&O in his, in his military
- 24:09career in the Wars of the Roses. Edward is a formidable warrior.
- 24:13He also has his, he also has his brother Richard by his side,
- 24:19which we'll see him rear his face later.
- 24:23And so you get to Touten and there's a snowstorm blowing.
- 24:30Lancastrian Archers look to begin the assault themselves.
- 24:36So they start firing volleys of arrows towards the Yorkist
- 24:39lines. But due to the winds that are
- 24:42happening during this snowstorm, the winds are proving the arrows
- 24:47to be ineffective. The arrows are actually landing
- 24:52short. They're not.
- 24:54They're not blowing back or anything.
- 24:55They're landing short of the Yorkist line.
- 24:58So what the Yorkist Archers are doing, since the wind is on
- 25:01their side, they're blow, they're shooting their arrows
- 25:04back, and then when they run out of arrows, they're walking
- 25:08forwards and taking the Lancastrian arrows out of the
- 25:10ground and firing them back. The Lancastrian soldiers realize
- 25:17what's happening. They go, OK, our Archers are not
- 25:20going to be able to do anything because of this.
- 25:21They're. Supplying the enemy.
- 25:23They're like, they're like, OK, we're going to have to just
- 25:26advance. We have to advance and we have
- 25:28to engage in melee. So they charge into their ranks
- 25:34in an absolutely brutal, bloody melee ensues.
- 25:38The orcas were outnumbered and they begin to get pushed back,
- 25:43and at that moment, as they're being pushed back,
- 25:46reinforcements from the Duke of Norfolk arrive and flank the
- 25:50Lancastrians on his and flank the Lancastrians and just
- 25:57completely route them, destroy them and crush them.
- 26:02But before Norfolk arrives, Edward is at the front with his
- 26:08men, and he sees where the places are beginning to really
- 26:13bend and break. And what Edward does, and This
- 26:16is why I love him so much as a warrior king.
- 26:18This is, you know, it encapsulates like you, what you
- 26:21were talking about, sort of like Edward or like Henry, where he
- 26:24sees his men are struggling. And Edward, this giant Titan who
- 26:30at contemporary accounts say that his armor was resplendent
- 26:34gold, but obviously golden armor is it was probably gorgeous, but
- 26:39it was not fully gold. But he he moves from where he is
- 26:45and he goes to that part that's struggling, and he engages in
- 26:49the brutal combat himself and rallies his men with his
- 26:55presence to follow him and continue to push the
- 26:59Lancastrians back. Norfolk arrives and completely
- 27:02routes them, and the Lancastrians begin to flee, and
- 27:09they eventually are. They're they're throwing off
- 27:13their armor. They're trying to just lighten
- 27:16themselves up even just a little bit so that they can continue to
- 27:21run away. But obviously it doesn't matter
- 27:25if you are naked or fully armored, you're not going to
- 27:28outrun a man on horseback. So these guys are promptly cut
- 27:35down, and the historians roughly estimate it's about 50,000
- 27:43people on each side. Some people say it's about
- 27:4750,000. It's a gigantic battle.
- 27:50Wow. I think people like when they
- 27:52think of the Middle Ages, it's like, you know, a couple
- 27:55thousand people on each side, you know, a couple, you know,
- 27:58maybe 2000 dead, you know, that's about it.
- 28:03But touting really is a massive outlier where the numbers are
- 28:11staggeringly high because this is sort of like this is sort of
- 28:17like, this is the battle of this whole conflict that could make
- 28:22or break the whole aspiration of either the Lancastrian side or
- 28:29the Yorkists. So what ends up happening is
- 28:38they're funneling more and more and they take off their helmets
- 28:45and armor and they attempt to flee, make them and they're
- 28:48completely easy kills for the pursuing Yorkists.
- 28:52They they're running and they flee into this area, which is
- 28:56now known as the Bloody Meadow, where Norfolk and his men
- 29:01completely cut down any Lancastrians that are in front
- 29:05of them. It's a complete wash.
- 29:10Both sides before the battle were told to be told to give no
- 29:14quarter. Gregory's chronicle states that
- 29:1842 Knights were killed after being taken prisoner and
- 29:22archaeological digs in the 20th century, they discovered mass
- 29:27graves of soldiers from the battle.
- 29:31One man, I had posted about him a couple times.
- 29:35He's only known as Tauten 25, and he's a skull.
- 29:40But what's terrible about him is that his skull from about, I
- 29:47would say the corner of his mouth, maybe right above it, the
- 29:51corner of his mouth, right where his upper canine is.
- 29:54All the way until it curves upwards into his.
- 29:58The top of his head is completely.
- 30:00Bisected by what was probably a pull axe or a battle axe or
- 30:06something like that just chopped right into his face.
- 30:10A lot of nobility were also slain in battle.
- 30:19Lancastrian nobility lost the Earl of Northumberland, Lord
- 30:23Wells, Molly and Dakar, and Sir Angie Andrew Trollope in battle.
- 30:30The Earls of Devon and Wiltshire were taken prisoner and then
- 30:33executed afterwards. After this battle's over, Henry
- 30:40flees to Scotland in exile after the defeat of his army and his
- 30:45wife and his son, and the battle was a complete, resounding
- 30:52victory for the Yorkists. And there's even a commemorative
- 30:55cross today at the battlefield. Something that really made my
- 30:59stomach churn when I was reading about the battle was that when
- 31:04Before the Bloody Meadow happens is that Norfolk and his cavalry
- 31:11men are chasing the Lancastrians and in their desperation they're
- 31:15running across a river and Norfolk and the other Dorkas men
- 31:20are completely slaughtering them to the point that the river does
- 31:24actually run red. For days afterwards of the
- 31:26battle there were so many corpses in the river that it
- 31:31said that the Yorkists didn't even get their boots wet because
- 31:35they were just using the bodies as a land bridge.
- 31:42So. We hear this and this is this is
- 31:451461. We hear this and we say, OK, so
- 31:48Edward the fourth wins this battle.
- 31:49It sounds like he absolutely pulverizes the Lancastrians
- 31:53here. He should have a rule and he
- 31:56should be king for the rest of his life, right?
- 31:57It's a it's a position to be in. But then something really
- 32:01strange and and in English history happens and it's called
- 32:04the reedaption. And that's who's involved with
- 32:08it is also kind of a head scratcher as well.
- 32:11We have Warwick the Kingmaker, the one that actually helps
- 32:16Edward the 4th to become king is now involved with helping the
- 32:21other side to put Henry back on the on the throne.
- 32:24So So what is the reedaption? Why does this change happen and
- 32:27and what happens to Edward? So Edward, from 1461 to 1470, he
- 32:34was stable. He was, but he was increasingly
- 32:38being strained by the constant factional politics of all the
- 32:43noble families that are taking part within this war.
- 32:46So the Earl of Warwick, who was completely instrumental to
- 32:53Edward currently, but also Edward on his rise from when he
- 32:58first took over when his father died to becoming king.
- 33:04They have a falling out. They have disagreements over
- 33:07foreign policy. They have disagreements with
- 33:10distribution of patronage. But the biggest one, the really
- 33:14big nail that goes into the coffin of this relationship is
- 33:20that Edward secretly marries Elizabeth Woodville.
- 33:24Yeah, Edward secretly marries Elizabeth Woodville, and Warwick
- 33:28is pissed. This is not who Warwick wanted
- 33:32him to marry. He doesn't, as far as I
- 33:37remember. I'm believe Warwick doesn't even
- 33:39like the Woodville's as a whole. And he's like, what are you
- 33:43doing? And he's like, I, you know, this
- 33:46is who I want to marry. So Warwick goes, forget this,
- 33:51I'm not doing this anymore. And Warwick begins to there's
- 33:59like there's a breakdown within the Yorkist coalition and
- 34:02Warwick begins his own little rebellion between 1469 and 1470.
- 34:11And so Warwick, the key, the key things to know about this whole
- 34:17scenario is that Warwick rebels against Edward.
- 34:21He allies with Edward's brother, the Duke of Clarence.
- 34:28He restores Henry the 6th in 1470 as king, which is the
- 34:34Reedeption and Edward the 4th returns in 1471.
- 34:42And this all leads up to the really it it's very interesting
- 34:47how poetic this conflict is. It leads up to the very poetic
- 34:52sort of climax of all of these previous social struggles in
- 35:00Tewksbury in 14. 71 So what happens at Tewksbury?
- 35:05You know what what we have? We have this situation where
- 35:08Edward now is king, but he isn't king.
- 35:11Henry wasn't king, but now he is king.
- 35:13And then when this leads us to Tewksbury, what happens at
- 35:15Tewksbury? So Tewksbury is really
- 35:20interesting. So the strength of each army is
- 35:24about 5 to 6000 soldiers on each side.
- 35:28Another another fairly large battle.
- 35:33Edward is leading the Yorkists and the leader of the House of
- 35:38Lancaster is Prince Edward of Westminster.
- 35:44He's Henry the 6th's only son. So this is a dramatic battle
- 35:51that is about to take place. The only the only son of the
- 35:55actual by blood king of England is on this battlefield against
- 36:02undefeated Edward the OR Edward the 4th.
- 36:05And it is it, I think it's Edmund is married to Cecily
- 36:08Neville at this point in time or who is he married to at this
- 36:10point in time? Edward the 4th.
- 36:14No isn't isn't Edmund married into the Neville family or am I
- 36:17confused? Believe so.
- 36:19OK, anyway, continue. So the battle ensues, and it's
- 36:29it's bloody. Edward of Westminster is killed
- 36:33in battle. Henry, the 6th's only son, is
- 36:35dead. So Henry now has no air, no
- 36:39direct air. At least the direct Lancastrian
- 36:43succession line is severed. With that death, the battle ends
- 36:50and not just is Edward of Westminster killed, but also
- 36:58many of the leading Lancastrian nobles are arrested and executed
- 37:03on the spot. One of which is Edmund Buford,
- 37:08the 4th Duke of Somerset, who is a very on the Lancastrian side,
- 37:13a very influential, very powerful leader.
- 37:18He's a military commander, he's seasoned, he's been around, he's
- 37:23constantly fighting in battles, and he has always been loyal to
- 37:26the Lancastrian cause. And at the end of this battle,
- 37:30he is taken to in chopping block and he has his he is beheaded by
- 37:34an axe on just literally right after the battle.
- 37:41Henry the 6th also dies shortly after this battle happens in the
- 37:47Tower of London. It's not provable beyond doubt,
- 37:52but a lot of people believe that Henry the Sixth was murdered.
- 37:56I think it's a very plausible thing to say that Henry the
- 37:58Sixth was likely murdered by someone in the Yorkist cause to
- 38:01just go, Oh my gosh, I just want this to be over already.
- 38:05Just get rid of this guy. Like this.
- 38:07I'm so tired of this. Just get rid of him.
- 38:11So this battle effectively destroys any possible credible
- 38:17Lancastrian line continuation in its primary form.
- 38:24So from here, the Yorkists are structurally secure.
- 38:31Edward the 4th is king. It's looking great from their
- 38:37perspective. You know, the Prince of Henry is
- 38:43dead, Henry himself is dead, and you guys just come off a very
- 38:47dramatic battle. This is fantastic for them.
- 38:53So then what? What happens next?
- 38:56Like like where do where do we go next from here?
- 38:58Because the the the man we end up on top.
- 39:01We talk about the laying Castrans not really having
- 39:04somebody. We could be seen as the next
- 39:06candidate to be king, but somehow we end up with Henry the
- 39:127th, the son of Margaret Beaufort, who isn't exactly
- 39:16somebody we think should be in line to be the next king.
- 39:23Oh, are you talking about Henry Tudor?
- 39:25Yeah. Oh, yeah.
- 39:26So, yeah, yeah, it's OK. So in the in, in the in between
- 39:32there. So Edward father's children, you
- 39:37know, the the famous Princess in the tower that many people know
- 39:40about, Edward dies eventually of illness, which is probably the
- 39:46biggest tragedy of this whole conflict.
- 39:48Because I think if Edward was to have survived, I think that this
- 39:53conflict goes completely differently.
- 39:56So Edward dies and it's now up to the his children Princess in
- 40:05the tower. However, they're too young.
- 40:10So who becomes Regent to to lead in their stead?
- 40:14Edward's brother Richard, Duke of Gloucester, who ends up
- 40:20becoming Richard the Third of England.
- 40:23Now, I don't think I've ever found someone who's like neutral
- 40:28on Richard the Third. They either really like him or
- 40:30they really hate him. I.
- 40:31I tend to think he, we, we've had Matt Lewis on the show to do
- 40:34an episode on, on Richard and also the the Princess and the
- 40:36Tower. I tend to think that Richard got
- 40:39a bad rap. And I think a lot of it goes
- 40:41from a lot of it comes from, you know, Shakespeare, which I think
- 40:45was a lot of propaganda. And, and I think at the same
- 40:47time, you look at Henry Tudor, a guy that that actually had no
- 40:50legitimacy needs, needs to look legitimate.
- 40:52And how else would you do that? By by, you know, killing a
- 40:54tyrant? Absolutely.
- 40:57I think from their perspective, I think in hindsight, they think
- 41:01they believe that painting Richard at, you know, this last
- 41:07surviving king of the Plantagenet dynasty as a tutor,
- 41:12you're thinking, oh, well, if we paint this guy as like a really
- 41:16terrible person, well, then it gives us probably more
- 41:21favorability amongst the public. They're not going to reminisce
- 41:25so fondly about, you know, this king of of ages gone by.
- 41:32So Richard becomes Regent, and what is believed to have
- 41:38happened, you know, the Princess are put into the tower, Richard
- 41:43becomes king, no longer Regent, and eventually at some point the
- 41:55Princess disappear. Did Richard do it?
- 42:01I don't believe he did. Some people are, some people
- 42:04really dedicate their whole lives to trying to figure out if
- 42:07Richard was the one that did it. I don't think he did.
- 42:12But so Richard becomes king and. Richard kind of gets.
- 42:18Overshadowed by all the people who are in this conflict,
- 42:22Richard has plenty of battle experience as well.
- 42:26He has fought alongside his brother Edward plenty of times
- 42:30on the battlefield. He's no slouch.
- 42:33That's not a pun because he has spine problems.
- 42:39He has he's. Got like a crippled hand as
- 42:42well, right? Yeah, he's got like a crippled
- 42:44hand and I think he has. I'm blanking on it.
- 42:47What's that? What's that spine condition
- 42:50called? Scoliosis.
- 42:51Scoliosis. So Richard's Richard's a little
- 42:54banged up, but like he's still an effective warrior.
- 42:58So it eventually leads us to what many people consider is the
- 43:07end point of the war with Bosworth after Richard had spent
- 43:14many a time, you know, defeating local rebellions, people that
- 43:19are rising up. Richard sort of takes an
- 43:23approach that's away from Edward the 4th and is more
- 43:26heavy-handed. You know, a lot of people are
- 43:35executed repeatedly, repeated executions, noble, some noble
- 43:41lines go extinct. Redistribution of land and
- 43:44titles happen. Instability and political
- 43:49instability is on the rise. So Henry the 7th that you
- 43:55previously mentioned, Henry Tudor, he makes an alliance with
- 43:59Margaret of Anjou and he sails from France to England and he
- 44:08with his army begin to March. And Richard hears about it, and
- 44:13he goes, well, I guess I'm just going to have to go stop it.
- 44:17If I stop this, if I stop this random upstart Henry Tudor, then
- 44:25this hopefully will finally be all over and the Plantagenet
- 44:30dynasty will continue to reign on the throne of England.
- 44:33And that leads us into the ultimate the ultimate climactic
- 44:37battle. Bosworth Field.
- 44:40So what? What happens at Bosworth?
- 44:43And you mentioned earlier that many people see Bosworth as the
- 44:48end, but then there's also, I believe it's at two years later.
- 44:51There's also a battle at Stoke Field too.
- 44:54So you know what happens at Bosworth and is this really the
- 44:57end or, or what can we think about it?
- 45:02It depends on who you're talking to.
- 45:08Most people will comfortably say that Bosworth is the I guess on
- 45:20paper the big event that ends the conflict there is Stoke that
- 45:25happens later on, which could sort of be the final nail in the
- 45:30coffin. But Bosworth is really like the
- 45:34end of it, that you could consider it because Stoke is
- 45:39more of a battle between small rebel forces, people that are
- 45:44still rising up in support of the Yorkist cause.
- 45:47But they have no royal, you know, that they're not led by
- 45:51Edward or by Richard or by people like this.
- 45:54So Bosworth happens on August 22nd in 1485.
- 46:02And one could consider that this is sort of like England's
- 46:06crossroads. You know what?
- 46:09The entirety of what we know England as hangs in the balance
- 46:15by what happens here. And by the time the battle
- 46:25actually starts, Richard has amassed a large group of people
- 46:31who are loyal to him. So deployed Richard and his army
- 46:38deployed near Bosworth on Ambien Hill with forces of about 7500
- 46:45to 12,000 soldiers. Norfolk commanded the right
- 46:51flank of the army and which was protecting The Archers as well
- 46:59as the artillery, and Richard's infantry held the center.
- 47:04The vanguard and then Northumberland's men who were
- 47:08on, who were mounted, guarded the left flank and they had a
- 47:15clearview of the battlefield from their vantage point.
- 47:22The big person that a lot of people like to direct their ire
- 47:27to is the Stanleys. A lot of people are very upset
- 47:32with the Stanleys. They look at them as sort of
- 47:34they have. They betrayed Richard, they
- 47:36betrayed the king. Stanley's the one that kind of
- 47:38like hangs out, sees who's winning or who's losing, and
- 47:40that decides where he's going to go.
- 47:41Is that correct? Yes, he's the one that stands
- 47:44back. And what leads to Richard making
- 47:49that sort of valiant final charge to try and kill Henry?
- 47:55Because the Stanleys are like, they're just hanging out.
- 47:59They're just waiting to see what happens.
- 48:02And Richard feels betrayed. So Henry had a smaller force,
- 48:08about 5000 to 8000 men. They have recruits from Wales
- 48:12and other border counties and even employed some deserters
- 48:17that came from Richard's army. They had 1800 French
- 48:22mercenaries. And as Henry's army began to
- 48:27advance, they were continuously harassed in the field by
- 48:32Richard's artillery cannons. Now Henry was lacking military
- 48:39experience on his own, and Oxford kept the was the one who
- 48:45kept the army in a tight formation so that they are
- 48:50avoiding being completely enveloped by Richard's larger
- 48:54forces. They don't want to happen what
- 48:56happened at Wakefield, where they are completely surrounded
- 48:59and just crushed. In one fell swoop, Norfolk's
- 49:04forces advance, held off by Oxford, and they lead several of
- 49:09Norfolk's troops to flee. Richard called in the battle for
- 49:17Northumberland's assistance, but his troops didn't move, likely
- 49:21due to difficulty of maneuvering, some people say on
- 49:25the narrow Ridge of the hill that they were sitting on.
- 49:29So Richard decides I'm going to just lead a direct charge and
- 49:36I'm going to see what happens here.
- 49:38So Richard spurs his horse. He leads a direct charge towards
- 49:44Henry, and Richard actually comes surprisingly close to
- 49:51killing Henry Tudor in this battle.
- 49:54Wow. Richard's Richard's cavalry
- 49:58charge was obviously it failed, but there was a moment where it
- 50:04looked like he could have really done it.
- 50:11So Richard's attack was absolutely fierce, but Henry's
- 50:17forces with the aid of Stanley's men.
- 50:23Oh, Stanley. Eventually surrounded and
- 50:26overwhelmed the King on the field, King Richard is now
- 50:31unhorsed and separated from his main contingent of forces, and
- 50:37he begins to fight bravely, refusing to retreat from the
- 50:41field regardless of the situation that he's in.
- 50:44He's ultimately killed in the thick of the battle.
- 50:49Historians believe that it was by a Welshman wielding a halberd
- 50:52that completely just clobbered him in the in the head.
- 50:57His death led to the complete disintegration of Yorkist
- 51:01forces, with Northumberland's men fleeing and Norfolk himself
- 51:04being killed in battle. Richard's demise on this field
- 51:10marked the end of the battle and the conclusion of his reign.
- 51:13Richard dying there is the last English king to die in battle.
- 51:20Wow. The Plantagenets are dead and
- 51:27the and Henry is has Henry has claimed the English crown by
- 51:35right of conquest, despite his distant lineage from anyone
- 51:40who's taking part in this in this war.
- 51:44So, Henry. He's like the illegitimate son
- 51:46of of Owen Tudor who was like a like AIII.
- 51:50Don't know the exact lineage but the guy wasn't close to being in
- 51:54the kingly. Line yeah, no, they were.
- 51:55He was distantly related, but he was like if things went on like
- 52:00legally there was no chance that he was going to become king.
- 52:04So by right of conquest, Henry Tudor claims the throne of
- 52:08England. He's crowned on the field as
- 52:11Henry the 7th and according to this, the legend, I don't know
- 52:20how true it is, but Richard the Third's crown is found on the
- 52:25field. After the battle is over,
- 52:29someone takes Richard the Third's crown into their hands
- 52:32and they place it on top of Henry Tudor's head and claims
- 52:36are and declares him to be Henry the 7th of England.
- 52:41So the Plantagenet dynasty has come to an end on this
- 52:44battlefield, and the Tudor dynasty that no one could have
- 52:49known would cause all the problems that it does has
- 52:53officially begun. So what is the consolidation of
- 53:00of Henry's rule look like? Because I think here's the
- 53:02interesting part, right? If you look at it, the
- 53:03aristocracy for the past thirtyish years has just been
- 53:07mercilessly killing each other. So I guess the question I would
- 53:10have is how many of them are left?
- 53:13And is this part of the reason that Henry's able to consolidate
- 53:17in in the way he does and and how does he consolidate?
- 53:20So under Henry the 7th, So the aristocracy of England remains
- 53:28very powerful, very wealthy, and very socially dominant.
- 53:32But there's a catch, and it's that noble power was more
- 53:36tightly dependent on royal favor.
- 53:39So unless you were really like, unless you were favored by the
- 53:45king, your power was more limited.
- 53:51If you had the favor, there were more things, more opportunities
- 53:55that were open to you. Private military retinues are
- 53:59restricted even more under Henry the 7th, and the Crown was more
- 54:05willing to intervene in noble disputes because they don't want
- 54:10obviously what just happened for the last 30 years to happen
- 54:14again. So aristocratic power in England
- 54:19doesn't really disappear, but it's more a shift away from its
- 54:23independence. It's now relying on how are we
- 54:28viewed by the monarch. Henry the 7th rules an
- 54:35aristocracy that's intact, but he rules it that he rules it in
- 54:40a way that's far more cautious and politically constrained
- 54:44because obviously he is making sure to not let what just
- 54:51happened happen again. So I guess in looking at that
- 54:56then, you know, Henry builds this new institutional
- 55:00architecture, which is the early Tudor state that the council
- 55:03learned in law, the first centralized fiscal apparatus,
- 55:07the suppression of noble retraining.
- 55:10So could he have built this without the prior 30 years
- 55:12having destroyed the noble class 1st?
- 55:14Or would he have faced real institutional opposition the way
- 55:18earlier monarchs did? Like like, how do we look at
- 55:20that? Probably not in the same form.
- 55:27I don't believe perfectly that Henry the 7th state would have
- 55:33emerged the same way without the wars.
- 55:39Because of the wars, it undermined the legitimacy of
- 55:44private noble warfare. That's why Henry the Seventh
- 55:48really starts to begin this whole like noble favor.
- 55:54It removed many of the most militarized aristocratic
- 55:58leaders. It created demand for stability
- 56:02and order because obviously noble houses are not the only
- 56:06people that suffer throughout this last 30 years or something
- 56:09in England, you know, farming villages and other lands are
- 56:13absolutely terrorized by what happens.
- 56:17England itself is completely torn apart.
- 56:20So people want stability and order and it is used to
- 56:28strengthen acceptance for strong goal or stronger royal
- 56:32authority. So how I look at it is.
- 56:37That Henry the 7th administrative and also monetary
- 56:47reforms they weren't automatic consequences of the war, but
- 56:54they're deliberate policy choices.
- 56:58So how I really would say it is that the Wars of the Roses for
- 57:03the last 30 years created the conditions for stronger
- 57:09monarchy. It put the IT put the
- 57:11opportunity in its place. But Henry the 7th built that
- 57:16monarchy through conscious institutional development.
- 57:22That's so interesting because I, I often like to say about the,
- 57:24the fall of the Roman Republic, the 100 years of civil war is
- 57:29actually what created Caesar. Had he lived in another era, we
- 57:32might likely have never seen a Caesar.
- 57:34So I think that that power vacuum is quite interesting and,
- 57:38and what it allows to come out of it.
- 57:39So we look at the War of the Roses like how should we view
- 57:42it? Should we view it as 2 noble
- 57:45houses basically fighting who's going to be the next king or,
- 57:48you know, the aristocracy destroying itself?
- 57:51Like how should we look at the? War of the Roses.
- 57:56So. From my perspective, the Wars of
- 58:05the Roses weren't simply just Lancaster and York slaughtering
- 58:12each other, but it was rather more so a a prolonged crisis of
- 58:18politics of the aristocracy or aristocracy which repeated elite
- 58:24conflict unintentionally and strengthened the monarchy.
- 58:29So the Wars of the Roses gets actually a lot of, there's a lot
- 58:39of misconceptions about the Wars of the Roses in general.
- 58:46And I think it's very helpful for people to understand the
- 58:51reality of what the conflict actually was.
- 58:53It's a very deep, it's very like it's impossible to talk.
- 58:57About it for just an hour and cover everything.
- 59:00There's so many battles that we left out, but like, if we were
- 59:03to leave them all in, this would be like a four hour episode.
- 59:08Well, I I said in the beginning that that would be a real
- 59:10challenge to fit this into an hour I.
- 59:12Think I think we've done a good job so far, but something that's
- 59:16very interesting about all of it with the misconceptions.
- 59:22So it wasn't 2 fixed factions that were fighting non-stop for
- 59:27like. 30 straight years people were shifting allegiances all
- 59:31the time based off of who would pay them more money or give.
- 59:35Them I think the Earl of Warwick.
- 59:37Warwick is a great example. Of that Warwick had some
- 59:41disagreements with Edward on top of the marriage that he hated
- 59:44very much and he's he didn't exactly switch sides like
- 59:51entirely, but he shifted away from Edward to the point that he
- 59:55would fight against them. So allegiance has shifted
- 59:58frequently based off of, you know, who would give me more
- 1:00:02money, who would give me more land, who would give me more
- 1:00:04influence and things like this. Noble shifted their allegiance
- 1:00:10all the time. Identities of things like
- 1:00:13Yorkist and Lancastrian were. Labels retrospectively and local
- 1:00:22familial and political interests, I believe.
- 1:00:25Mattered more to the average person than ideology would.
- 1:00:29What would benefit me? What would benefit my lands, my
- 1:00:34villages that are under my like, if I'm the Duke of this area,
- 1:00:38you know, how is this going to affect my people?
- 1:00:41So it's not a simple like binary civil war like how we look at
- 1:00:45like the American Civil War, but it's a consequence of just
- 1:00:49constant overlapping crises. That's why it's called the.
- 1:00:54Wars of the Roses because it's really a bunch of different
- 1:01:00conflicts melded into each other.
- 1:01:04Would you say that's the biggest misconception you often find
- 1:01:07yourself correcting in your work or or is there something bigger?
- 1:01:10I think some people typically think, some people typically
- 1:01:15think that it's a very like binary straightforward thing
- 1:01:18where people are Allegiant to one side in 1455 and they're on
- 1:01:22the same side non-stop for 30 years.
- 1:01:25That's certainly one I see often.
- 1:01:27Another one is is. Casualties.
- 1:01:33I think, and obviously as a someone who's into Rome, you
- 1:01:37probably have seen it a lot too, where people will maybe go on a
- 1:01:41Wikipedia page or something like.
- 1:01:42That they might see a number that is from A at the time, you
- 1:01:46know, a contemporary source. And oh, there were 500,000 of
- 1:01:51them. Where in reality, historians
- 1:01:54come to the conclusion that there's maybe, you know, 50,000
- 1:01:58and people tend to to no fault of their own.
- 1:02:02Will believe at face value those contemporary.
- 1:02:05Sources and a contemporary source at the time, even for the
- 1:02:09Middle Ages, they're very propagandized.
- 1:02:13They're made, you know, because obviously even the people who
- 1:02:16are chroniclers, they have their own people that they support.
- 1:02:19They want to make their guys look bigger.
- 1:02:21They want to make their guys look stronger, more badass.
- 1:02:23Dude did you see Edward the fourth with 900 guys?
- 1:02:27Just took out 400,000 Lancastrians.
- 1:02:30That's amazing, man. Like he was 7 foot tall picking
- 1:02:34guys up and literally just biting their heads off on the.
- 1:02:36Yeah, dude, he was the Mountain from Game of Thrones on the
- 1:02:40field of Tower, and that was badass.
- 1:02:42Like that's how that's how they talk about it.
- 1:02:45I think that's a really good point though, too, because I
- 1:02:47know even my other channel, the Roman pattern, we talked about
- 1:02:50civilizational collapse and people often talk about late
- 1:02:53Rome and they'll use the military as an example to show
- 1:02:55how well it's doing. And they'll say, oh, you know,
- 1:02:57there were so many lead more legions in late Rome than there
- 1:03:00were in early Rome. And it's like, well, yes, there
- 1:03:03were because they reduced them in size.
- 1:03:05They went from 5000 men to 2 or 3000 'cause they just didn't
- 1:03:08have enough guys. So I think once again it it
- 1:03:11really goes back to what actually happened and, and what
- 1:03:14do we actually know and, and many times though that
- 1:03:18information can be skewed, primary sources are still the
- 1:03:21best sources we have. Absolutely.
- 1:03:24I actually, when it comes to the question of like, you know, what
- 1:03:28were the Wars of the Roses really about?
- 1:03:30Like what you asked me earlier? Or if someone was to ask me
- 1:03:33that, you know, on the timeline, if someone was to just, you
- 1:03:37know, tag me and and ask me that I actually wrote down.
- 1:03:41A little statement of what I would say as an answer.
- 1:03:47So if asked that question, I would say the Wars of the Roses
- 1:03:52began as a dynastic and political crisis caused by weak
- 1:03:56royal government, evolved into a struggle among competing
- 1:04:01aristocratic factions, and ultimately transformed the
- 1:04:04balance of power in England by leaving the monarchy stronger
- 1:04:08and the nobility less. Able to challenge it.
- 1:04:13And that is how we get Henry Tudor to be Henry the 7th.
- 1:04:17And it's funny because Henry the Seventh really isn't that bad of
- 1:04:21a king, but Henry the eighth, Wow.
- 1:04:25It really. Is that that that's a podcast
- 1:04:26for another time. I will I will say and we we are
- 1:04:29taking Henry the eighth up on a future show.
- 1:04:31So. I'm excited.
- 1:04:33Well, I, I appreciate you doing this today for, for people that,
- 1:04:36that want to follow you or check out your work.
- 1:04:39How should they do that? As I said, there's a lot of ex
- 1:04:41accounts I follow, but yours is one of the ones I actually have
- 1:04:44notifications on because what you post is great, especially
- 1:04:47when you're posting that Holy Roman Empire empire flag.
- 1:04:50So. So where can people find you and
- 1:04:52what can they expect from you? So.
- 1:04:54If you want to see the content that I'm making, you can go on X
- 1:05:00or if you call it Twitter, it's at Medieval Scholar and I have
- 1:05:05my sub stack tagged in my profile, but it's also the same
- 1:05:09thing. It's Medieval Scholar on sub
- 1:05:11stack. I write frequently about on both
- 1:05:15platforms about anything related to the Middle Ages.
- 1:05:20My biggest fixation obviously is into France is into England, the
- 1:05:27Holy Roman Empire, and even the years going into outwards of the
- 1:05:34Middle Ages play, you know, Maximilian of Habsburg and the
- 1:05:39rise of the Habsburg dynasty. I like the Dukes of Burgundy and
- 1:05:43I write very frequently about the influence that all these
- 1:05:46things have as like sort of one big spider web as the growth of
- 1:05:52medieval Europe over the course of 1000 years.
- 1:05:55I also just recently went to a museum on a vacation, and I
- 1:05:59posted a bunch of really, really cool artifacts that were housed
- 1:06:03at the museum, including a authentic German salad.
- 1:06:07And I think people who are really into that stuff will find
- 1:06:12an absolute blast of it. Yeah.
- 1:06:15So that's where you can find me. If you want to find anything
- 1:06:20that interests you. I have a highlights section on
- 1:06:23my page and just scroll through it and there's a bunch of great
- 1:06:26stuff to read. Very cool.
- 1:06:28Well you guys should definitely go follow him.
- 1:06:29Definitely one of my favorite followers on X Medieval Scholar.
- 1:06:32Thanks for hanging out with me today man.
- 1:06:33It's an honor. Thank you for the invite.
- 1:06:35Here's where this leaves us the story we tell about the war of
- 1:06:38the roses is a story about heraldry, succession, and the
- 1:06:41eventual triumph of Henry Tudor that's the romance the actual
- 1:06:45story is mathematical. 200 normal houses in 1450, about 100
- 1:06:50of them extinct BY1490208000 men dead in a single Palm Sunday
- 1:06:55Blizzard at Touton. An aristocratic that destroyed
- 1:06:58itself across 30 years of dynastic war and produced a
- 1:07:01country where the institution that survived the destruction,
- 1:07:04the crown, could centralized power in a way no English
- 1:07:07monarch have been able to do for two centuries.
- 1:07:10Henry the 7th inherits a Kingdom where the class that could have
- 1:07:13resisted royal power has eliminated itself.
- 1:07:16He builds the council learned in law.
- 1:07:18He prosecutes the surviving nobility for retaining private
- 1:07:21armies. He revives forgotten feudal
- 1:07:23duels. He fills the treasury.
- 1:07:25His son, Henry the Eighth, breaks with Rome from a position
- 1:07:28no medieval king of England could have occupied, because
- 1:07:30there's no longer an aristocratic class strong enough
- 1:07:33to stop him. That's the pattern worth
- 1:07:35remembering. When an elite turns its weapons
- 1:07:37on itself, What fills the vacuum isn't reform, it's the
- 1:07:40institution underneath with the strongest hand.
- 1:07:43Many thanks to the Medieval Scholar for walking through this
- 1:07:45with me. Go follow his work on X.
- 1:07:48He is at Medieval Scholar. If this has changed how you see
- 1:07:51the War of the Roses, subscribe because the hidden forces don't
- 1:07:54stop at Bosworth. This has been Hidden Forces in
- 1:07:57History. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 1:07:58Be sure to like this video, leave us a comment, and smash
- 1:08:01the subscribe button if you want more hidden forces in history.