Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Ruby Franke & Jodi Hildebrandt (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey deserve listeners. A lot of you have been asking me to talk about
- 0:04the Ruby Frankie abuse of her children and Jody Hildebrandt, I believe as the
- 0:09other individual's name, and I already talked about it with amberto in the Dugger
- 0:14Family Deep Dive recently. But there's a lot more to get into, and
- 0:18there's been new developments in the story. So I'm going to watch some news
- 0:23stories and talk about my clinical experience with child abuse. I obviously have treated
- 0:29as a therapist. I've treated a lot of clients who have been abused as
- 0:33children, or they were children themselves when I was treating them and they were
- 0:37abused by their previous caregivers or other people. But also I have treated perpetrators
- 0:43of domestic violence and of child abuse. For a time, I would actually
- 0:49be contracted by Child Protective Services CPS in Washington State and they would actually send
- 0:55me into the homes to work with families who are identified maybe been sometimes convicted
- 1:00of child abuse. They were identified as parents who were abusing their children,
- 1:06and so in the beginning of my career it was one of my specialties.
- 1:08So let's watch. My name is doctor Kirk Conda, I'm a therapist and
- 1:11a professor. Obviously there's a trigger warning heavily to this episode given the nature
- 1:17of these crimes. Let's watch well y'say one more time and then you're going
- 1:21to lose the privilege to eat dinner. This is Ruby Frankie, the mom
- 1:25of six behind the popular parenting YouTube channel eight passengers. On August thirtieth,
- 1:29Frankie and her business partner, Jody Hildebrandt were arrested after Frankie's twelve year old
- 1:33son and climbed out of a window of Hildebrant's home to ask neighbors for food
- 1:37and water. The neighbors immediately called authorities after seeing the malnursed boy at open
- 1:42wounds and duct tape around his wrists and ankles. So this is on the
- 1:46YouTube channel now this news, so you can check that out there. I'm
- 1:51just gonna watch a little bit of this too. I know all this,
- 1:53all these details, but maybe some of you don't, so it's good to
- 1:57review this. Utah police searched the Hildebrant and found Frankie's ten year old daughter
- 2:00in a similarly malnursed state. On September six, Frankie was formally charged with
- 2:06six counts of felony child abuse. So how did we get here? So
- 2:09if you didn't catch all that, Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt are colleagues and
- 2:15maybe friends who have a business or work with an organization called Connections. It
- 2:21is a parent education program. I believe from the marketing and from the news
- 2:27reporting. They work with parents to try to help them with their parenting.
- 2:30They recommend a very strict form of parenting, one might say abusive form of
- 2:37parenting. And Ruby Frankie had a YouTube channel with her husband and her kids,
- 2:44her six kids called eight Passengers. It was very popular. They are
- 2:46a Mormon family living in Utah. Now I've done a whole deep dive in
- 2:53the Duggar family chapters regarding using children in YouTube family vlog channel. Long story
- 3:00short, wouldn't surprise you that I don't think that these sorts of channels should
- 3:06be legal. I think that they should be illegal or heavily monitored, meaning
- 3:10that if you want to have a family channel like this, you have to
- 3:15be licensed to do so by the government, and you have to pay fees
- 3:20such that it can pay for infrastructure for monitoring and reporting. Because there's a
- 3:25lot of exploitation and harm happening to kids. Now in this instance, there
- 3:30are laws that regulate the mistreatment, the abuse and torture of children independent of
- 3:36a YouTube channel. Anyway. So you have Ruby Frankie who has this channel
- 3:39very famous, and then she is running into some controversy I think, regarding
- 3:44her parenting for years now, a lot of viewers are talking about how her
- 3:49practices are a problem, and even people in Ruby Frankie's family are starting to
- 3:54alert the authorities. Nothing is happening apparently. And then at some point,
- 3:59Ruby Frankie steps away from the channel for the most part, and she starts
- 4:02to work with this woman named Jody Hildebrant with this company called Connections, which
- 4:08is a parenting education group, a very firm, stern parenting education program.
- 4:15And then they start to do their own videos. Again, there's more controversy
- 4:18around that, and then a couple of weeks ago, there's a news report
- 4:23of a child that escaped from Jody Hildebrand's home, the colleague of Ruby Frankie.
- 4:29The child runs to a neighbor's house. The neighbor calls nine one one,
- 4:31the police arrive, they investigate. They find that the child was being
- 4:35duct taped. The child was emacias, one of Ruby Frankie's kids, and
- 4:40the child was emaciated, hungry, thirsty, and talking about how they were
- 4:46being tied up, and they escaped. The police investigate. They find another
- 4:50child in the home, a second child. An investigation ensues and the two
- 4:57individuals, Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt are arrested and taking into custody and charged
- 5:02I believe with child and dangerment or child abuse and torture of children or something
- 5:06like that. Maybe they'll report on that. Ruby Frankie had been regularly producing
- 5:11parenting blogs since twenty fifteen. The controversial channel garnered more than two million followers
- 5:16before it was taken down by YouTube following the recent abuse charges. But the
- 5:20signs were there all along. Yeah, this is a huge problem that one
- 5:26YouTube doesn't take these channels down quicker and I don't understand why. You know,
- 5:31they take channels down all the time. I mean I get threatened occasionally
- 5:36with disciplinary action by YouTube at times for merely showing too long of a clip
- 5:43of a reality TV show or something. I mean, they don't come after
- 5:46me right away, but you know there's an escalation of discipline that YouTube will
- 5:50enact, and of course that's probably all done by an algorithm and computer.
- 5:55You know, this taking a channel down requires human eyes. But still,
- 5:58you know, they're making billions upon billions of dollars, and you just think
- 6:01that YouTube would want to preserve their brand because the only reason why they'd keep
- 6:05a channel like this up is because they're making money from advertisements. Right the
- 6:10Ruby Frankie's making money and YouTube is making money from the ad from the ads.
- 6:15Given their revenue, I can imagine that YouTube doesn't need the revenue.
- 6:18And it's like this every time. There are channels that are you know,
- 6:23like with Daddio five that kind of thing, there are channels that are filming
- 6:28abuse of children or at least a questionable behavior. But no, I mean
- 6:32the Daddio five stuff, if you know about it, it was obvious,
- 6:35and with Ruby Frankie, I think it was a very similar thing, at
- 6:40the very least questionable and at worst obviously abusive to the children. And for
- 6:45YouTube to be alerted and to do nothing until it is a major news story,
- 6:49so you just got to think about all the other channels that are out
- 6:51there that are doing this sort of thing. And people are complaining and alerting
- 6:56YouTube, and YouTube is still doing nothing until it becomes international news. It's
- 7:01a crime. Now. YouTube is a capitalistic company. They are in it
- 7:05to make money for their shareholders, right, They're not in it for the
- 7:11public good necessarily. So that's why we need government agencies and regulations and laws.
- 7:17Are elected officials are here to protect us from the greed and the abuse
- 7:24of corporations like YouTube. That's why we need to extend the reach of organizations,
- 7:30agencies, government agencies like Child Protective Services to actually monitor this. And
- 7:33that requires money, which requires tax dollars, which requires legislation to advocate for
- 7:39that or allocate that money, or it means maybe even raising taxes. That's
- 7:44what it comes down to. Because workers at CPS are already overworked. When
- 7:48I did this sort of work before, I worked side by side with a
- 7:53lot of CPS workers, And there's a wide variety of folks who work at
- 7:57this agency. You know, some people I respect it a lot. The
- 8:01things that they would sacrifice in their own lives to protect children. You know,
- 8:05they'd work long hours and be stressed out all the time and get real
- 8:09close to situations that were very emotionally difficult. So I'd have people at that
- 8:13end, and then I'd have people at the other end that seemingly are just
- 8:15kind of phoning it in. You know, they probably did a good enough
- 8:18job, I suppose, And then I would hear outliers reports of CPS workers
- 8:22who were horrible human beings. So you know, I know that that happens.
- 8:26You have tens of thousands of workers, You're going to have a bell
- 8:28curve of individuals. But in my experience, they were all hard workers and
- 8:33got into it for the right reasons. But in my experience, they were
- 8:37overworked and underpaid, stressed out, underappreciated, and attacked by the public,
- 8:41which I didn't think was okay. It's like, if you have a problem
- 8:46with CPS, you know, individual stories of CPS, then sure, you
- 8:50know, bad apples or maybe we change the culture, but to just denigrate
- 8:52the entire agency for a few stories that rise to the news because you know,
- 8:58you don't here the news doesn't talk about the times when CPS does things
- 9:03well, which is happening every day, by the way, So you know,
- 9:07like for example, I was back in the day and am now I'm
- 9:11a I'm a private practicing therapist. They would call me and pay me a
- 9:18lot of money to go into the home because they cared about what was happening.
- 9:22They didn't just want to put a band aid. There was like,
- 9:24this family needs therapy, the parents need help, everyone needs help. We're
- 9:28going to pay for a therapist, not only a therapist, but we're going
- 9:31to pay them to go into the home and actually watch what's happening. And
- 9:35I was paid to be there like three hours a week, sometimes more than
- 9:37that, you know, pretty intensive therapy, and it worked, in my
- 9:43estimation frequently, not just my work, of course, but the team of
- 9:46therapists that I worked along with me. So anyway, it is a problem
- 9:52that needs to change, and there doesn't seem to be any movement in our
- 9:56society to advocate, to pressure our lawmakers to actually pass laws, or to
- 10:01allocate funds for this. We just have these stories happen over and over again,
- 10:05Daddy of five, all the others, and it just happens. We
- 10:09all go crazy, we all talk about all what a terrible person, and
- 10:13then we just move on with our day. This will happen again. It
- 10:16will, it's happening right now, But it's just not rising to the level
- 10:20of news and we are doing nothing as a society. It requires tax dollars,
- 10:26agencies, funding, training, monitoring, licensing, action, you know,
- 10:33an agency that has the power to take down a YouTube channel, for
- 10:37example. And when you when you have a capitalistic system, and you know,
- 10:41you socialize and brainwash everyone to be focused on money, and then you
- 10:46just dangle a million plus dollars in front of some of these parents, this
- 10:52is what you're going to get. And we have to do something about it
- 10:54because that that temptation and that system of money flowing to parents who are already
- 11:03possibly on the borderline of not being a tuned and not being nice as their
- 11:07children, not having compassion for their children, over emphasizing their own narcissistic needs.
- 11:13There's enough parents who are out there anyway who are not great as parents,
- 11:18and then we dangle millions of dollars in front of them, and this
- 11:20is what you're going to get until we do something about it. All along,
- 11:24my bedroom was taken away for seven months and when you give it back
- 11:28like a couple of weeks ago, unless you find it. Yeah, so
- 11:30I don't know if you caught that. But the older boy in the family
- 11:35was talking about how he was disciplined for something really minor. I can't remember
- 11:41what it was, but it was something that was like, I think he
- 11:46pranked one of his siblings saying like we're going to Disneyland or don't call me
- 11:50on that, and the younger kid was like yay, And then it turned
- 11:52out to be a prank by the older brother. And I think I wonder
- 11:56where that boy got the message that it's okay to exploit younger people. But
- 12:03anyway, he did something that me and my siblings did to each other all
- 12:07the time and probably just got like a reprimand. But what he got was
- 12:13he lost his bedroom. His entire bedroom was taken away from him, and
- 12:16he had to sleep in the living room on the floor for seven months.
- 12:20So he's reporting that on camera on a live stream or something on their YouTube
- 12:26channel, and he's sitting next to the mom who was the one who imposed
- 12:30the discipline, presumably, and she gets this big smile on her face.
- 12:35We don't know what that smile means, but given everything that we've seen,
- 12:37it's possible that she literally thinks it's hilarious. It's something that gives her pleasure.
- 12:43Maybe there are sadistic people who actually gain pleasure from harming others. Given
- 12:48the level of torture that is being alleged, it's possible. You know,
- 12:52the sort of people that you think who are sadistic psychopaths, or at least
- 12:58on that spectrum. Typically in movies, you know, they have like evil
- 13:01faces and blood dripping from fangs that are coming out of their mouth. And
- 13:07yeah, I guess maybe, but sadistic psychopaths can look like anybody anyway.
- 13:13So I don't know what that smile is. But another possibilities that she's smiling
- 13:18because she didn't expect it to be said I've seen that whole video for and
- 13:24he reports that and she's like, oh, we haven't told our audience this,
- 13:30so but it is. But let's rewatch that my bedroom was taken away
- 13:33for seven months and then you give it back quick. Okay. So look
- 13:35at that smile. Given everything, I don't know what's going on and that
- 13:43brain of hers, I can't know. It could mean a lot of things.
- 13:46It could be embarrassments. I don't know. But at the very least
- 13:52she knows that she has a YouTube channel. That is I'm assuming their entire
- 13:56job. I mean, when you have two million follow and especially family vlogs,
- 14:01because you might post several videos a day, You're getting a lot of
- 14:03revenue, right, so I'm getting all the products and the sponsors. He's
- 14:09I don't know, but she is posting these videos and she knows that her
- 14:16family. She's the one who's parading her family around in front of the world,
- 14:20and behind the scenes, she's disciplining her kids in this way. She
- 14:24has to know that that information is going to be out there. And that's
- 14:28another thing about this that is notable. She seemingly brags about this kind of
- 14:35torture and abuse of children. She thinks it's a badge of honor. And
- 14:39it's a political point of view as well, Like there are hints that she's
- 14:43conservative who believes that the Libs are taking over with their wokeness in their talk
- 14:50about, you know, babying their children. You know, we need to
- 14:52bring America back again with strong values and abusing our children like we did in
- 14:56the old days. I mean, look, you can be conservative, you
- 15:01can vote Republican, but you can't do that. The kinds of things that
- 15:05are lumped in together with conservatism is not the conservatives. I grew up.
- 15:09I grew up with conservatism in the seventies and eighties, and you know,
- 15:13god knows what everyone thought, but the way it was taught to me was
- 15:16it was just fiscally conservative, that's all it was. It was like,
- 15:18just careful about spending taxes, you know, trying to balance the budget.
- 15:22That's what conservative meant. It was conservative about and also conservative about traditional values
- 15:28to some extent, certainly not like this. Now. You could argue that
- 15:33in the seventies and eighties, conservatives didn't have to fight for this because it
- 15:37was just the mainstream. It was mainstream to be harsh to your children,
- 15:41much more than it is today. We've learned a lot as a society.
- 15:46We have a lot to learn. There are other countries that are doing a
- 15:50lot better than we are. You know, the United States is not the
- 15:52pinnacle of culture and of awareness in this area. So anyway, But that
- 15:58smile, that smile, So I just want to point out this possibility,
- 16:00there's a hypothesis in here. That smile is yes, I actually get tremendous
- 16:08pleasure the way that when a mother smiles like you know, when I see
- 16:12a smile like that, I think of a mother who is hearing her son
- 16:17talk about how much he loves his mom, how much he respects his mom,
- 16:22or how much he appreciated it when she let him go to the prom
- 16:26or whatever, just some kind of pleasure, right, that's a smile,
- 16:32potentially of pleasure. He's talking about being you know, I don't know what
- 16:37word to put to it, mistreated. He's talking about being mistreated. He's
- 16:42telling the world about having to sleep on the floor for seven months because he
- 16:47mildly pranked his younger sibling. And you know, these people exist. I've
- 16:53worked with these people. The vast majority of the perpetrators of child abuse that
- 16:57I have worked with are not are not socopaths, are not statistic. But
- 17:02I have come across them in a variety of different clinical contexts, not just
- 17:06in parenting, but just individual clients or court ordered people back in the day,
- 17:11and I get chills thinking about these individuals. It's these people. In
- 17:17the past, I've used the word monster to describe these people. They are
- 17:21monsters. It's not a clinical term, obviously, but meaning that these individuals
- 17:25probably need to be behind bars or at least heavily supervised for their entire lives,
- 17:30or else they are going to harm other people. They have a compulsion,
- 17:36they have an entitlement, they have a lack of empathy, they have
- 17:41a desire to harm other people, and they probably should be behind bars.
- 17:45The problem is that as a society we tend to think all people who commit
- 17:49these kinds of crimes are sadistic psychopaths, and that is statistically not the case,
- 17:55and clinicians who do these kinds of assessments also know that that is not
- 17:59the case. I've worked alongside with colleagues of mind psychologists who do assessments in
- 18:03prisons, and they will say, yeah, there's a good chunk of the
- 18:07prisoners who are people that should be behind bars forever. But there's a lot
- 18:11of people who absolutely could reform, especially if they have a life that is
- 18:15going well. They have a job, they have therapy, they have services
- 18:21very high likelihood that they're going to do a lot better moving forward. But
- 18:25there are some of those people that need to be sectioned off. I don't
- 18:27know. If I don't know if Ruby Frankie is one of those people.
- 18:30You can make your own judgment on that. I guess a couple of weeks
- 18:33ago. Unless you find a friend who's willing to share some of their food
- 18:37with you don't I don't think you're going to be able to eat. We're
- 18:38going to put a pillow and a blanket by the toilet and you could camp
- 18:45out in the bathroom, okay if you cut. Yeah. So they're showing
- 18:48a bunch of scenes that are evidence of the abuse to the children. Anyway.
- 18:55So there was a clip seemingly of Ruby Frankie exhibiting her policy about parenting
- 19:00that not only she did herself for many years, but also would recommend and
- 19:06teach to others that you can use deprivation of food as a discipline for children.
- 19:12She has a number of incidents where she exhibited that policy of making children
- 19:18go hungry or punishing that. Yeah, one more thing in my house.
- 19:27I'm going to take the scissors. Look at me, and I'm going to
- 19:30cut its head off. Well I haven't seen that clip before. Yeah,
- 19:37and it just I mean, can you imagine a kid, you know,
- 19:41a kid's face is blurred, which is good, but the kid looks like
- 19:44maybe four or five years old, six years old, And to threaten that
- 19:49you're gonna chop the head off of yeah, it'd be one thing and maybe
- 19:56possibly also very cruel and unusual to hunish a child by taking away their stuffed
- 20:00animals and putting them in the closet, for example. But it's a whole
- 20:06other level. And right now she's pantomiming how she would chop the head off
- 20:11of this stuffed animal in front of the child, and the child's crying and
- 20:18instead of you know, when you're parenting children, when you have children,
- 20:23or you're in charge of children, like you're a kindergarten teacher and you have
- 20:26to disappoint kids, it breaks your heart. It's it's it's hard. It's
- 20:32one of the especially you know, like when it's bedtime for them, you
- 20:34know, like everyone's over and everyone's having a good time, and you know
- 20:38that your kid does not function well the next day unless they get a good
- 20:42nine hours asleep, and it's like, oh, it's say thirty, it's
- 20:45time to go to bed, and the kids like, but I want to
- 20:48stay here and have fun, and you know, it just breaks your heart.
- 20:52Or you're at the store and they really want two stuffed animals instead of
- 20:57one, and you know, especially the younger kids, it just breaks your
- 21:03heart. And even when you're disciplining them for good reasons reasons that are helpful
- 21:08to them, and you're doing it in a compassionate, attuned manner, and
- 21:14they start to cry. It'll melt any parent, it just does. So
- 21:21who knows what's going on with three B Frankie, But it's a tick in
- 21:23the column of something characterologically off about her that she would one do this and
- 21:30to not alter her path as the child is starting to crumble and cry,
- 21:36you know, and then crying, you know, it's very different crying of
- 21:38children, Like the example gave earlier about a child that's crying about but I
- 21:41want two stuffed animals from the store. You can usually tell the difference when
- 21:45there's when the child is legit sad and disappointed and hurt and they're just angry
- 21:52at you and they're wanting maybe even to manipulate you. Children will do that,
- 21:56they're smart. This sort of crying is not the second This crying at
- 22:00least I can't see her face because it's blurred out, which is good.
- 22:03But the crying sounds like legit terror. Really, And that's another type of
- 22:08crying, right is is terror? Not just like I'm bummed out that I
- 22:12have to go to bed. It's like you're going to chop off the head.
- 22:18What No, my god, what are you doing? What are you
- 22:19doing? What? You know? Panic? Of course? You know children,
- 22:23we all. I have a stuffed animal behind me from my childhood when
- 22:29I was her age, Sam the dog. You know, there's not a
- 22:33big reason why it's on my shelf behind me. It should be in a
- 22:36box or I should give it away. But I've seen toy story three too
- 22:40many times and that's never gonna happen. It's right behind me, and he
- 22:44can always he has a view of the office. He can watch YouTube and
- 22:48I'm watching YouTube. He can watch me when I'm making these videos. So
- 22:52you know, we infuse personalities in these objects, particularly when we're young.
- 22:56They don't have personalities, but and you know, we evolved this sort of
- 23:02thing. And so for the mom to pantomime, she's gonna chop and the
- 23:07kids crying, and it's like it says something. I don't know exactly what
- 23:12it says, but it's it says something look at me, and I'm gonna
- 23:18cut its head off. And she's filming it. She's filming it and posting
- 23:26it on her channel. She's filming it and posting it and holding it up
- 23:37as an example, of how wonderful of a person and parent she is,
- 23:47and YouTube did nothing, and the government did nothing, the police did nothing.
- 23:56I am hoping and I'm pretty sure that in ten years, Like with
- 24:03revenge porn, it was not that long ago. It was eleven years ago
- 24:07when it was still legal to post pictures of your partners or even illegally obtained
- 24:15photographs I think potentially like hacking into someone's computer or their phone. Don't quote
- 24:21me on that one, but they're very least just posting nude or compromising photographs
- 24:26of you know, it was because we're a sexist society. It tended to
- 24:30be women who were being exploited this way. And also the response. You
- 24:34know, if there were a lot of revenge porn pictures of people of all
- 24:37genders, the women were the ones that were slut shamed and paid attention to
- 24:41and that sort of thing. But it was a mirror eleven years ago when
- 24:45that was still okay, at least in my memory. I did a whole
- 24:48deep dive on that whole story. There was that documentary that came out last
- 24:52year, and for many years that was happening. For many years, there
- 24:56was a lot of people who are being harmed. There was a lot of
- 25:00people raising their hand and saying, hey, we need laws. Hey,
- 25:03there's a problem here, and the government, the legislature, the powers that
- 25:07be just said, who cares about you? You shouldn't have taken those pictures
- 25:11anyway. What are you doing taking nude pictures of yourself? You sleut?
- 25:15There's something wrong with you. You don't deserve any sort of protections. And
- 25:19I think we have a similar although different problem with this and that. People
- 25:23hear about influencers or family vloggers and I'm like, well, they're all idiots.
- 25:29Who cares about that, They're just people influencers. You know, you
- 25:33say the word influencer among a certain group of people and it's like a bad
- 25:36word. It's like an insult to someone or you know. And I've experienced
- 25:41it among certain people I will talk about, particularly a few years ago.
- 25:45I think it's different, starting to be different, maybe just because I've told
- 25:48everyone about There were times when I would tell people. They would add friends
- 25:52would ask me like, so, how are things going with your job and
- 25:56stuff? And I'd be like, well, you know, I'm doing a
- 25:57lot of YouTube And they'd be like, ah, really, oh you're serious.
- 26:02Why what you know, there was this there's this this idea that you
- 26:07know, if you watch YouTube as much as I do, that it doesn't
- 26:08make sense to you because YouTube is it's just another media source. You know,
- 26:11it's it's got good stuff and bad stuff. It's got a lot of
- 26:15things. But to some people it's just like discountable in the same way that
- 26:18you know, ten fifteen years ago, a lot of people would just discount
- 26:22any sort of person who would take a nude picture of themselves and send it
- 26:27to their boyfriend. It's like, well, you asked for it, that
- 26:30kind of attitude, And I think there's a similar but different phenomenon happening here
- 26:34where bad things are happening and people just discount it because it's YouTube and it's
- 26:40the Internet and it's social media. Who cares? And that's a problem.
- 26:42But yeah, so wow, I have not seen this video before, but
- 26:47that this is wow disturbing. And you know, if you went through this,
- 26:55or you know someone that went through this, you know, you know
- 27:00this lasts forever. If you have them been through something like this, you
- 27:03can be like, well, you know, we all get disappointed when we're
- 27:06children, and we move on or we forget or we figure out some you
- 27:11know, when we when we move out of the house, we make our
- 27:15own life, and you know, you don't have to deal with your parents
- 27:18forever. But the emotional and psychological scars that are likely to occur for these
- 27:25children and all other children who are treated this way are severe. And I've
- 27:30worked with clients. I know of people who have worked in therapy for decades
- 27:36and they've only recovered from this kind of mistreatment about fifty percent of the way.
- 27:41In really good therapy, they're they're with the right therapists, they're working
- 27:45hard, and they still get triggered. They still have working models and schemas
- 27:49that plague them, voices in their head, not literal voices, but these
- 27:55notions that these automatic thoughts, these intrusive thoughts saying like you're a terrible human
- 27:59being, you don't deserve love, No one loves you, You're a piece
- 28:03of crap. Nothing is permanent, everything will be taken away from you.
- 28:07If anything good is happening to you, then it's just a matter of time
- 28:11before something horrible is happening to you. Because that's the way the world works,
- 28:14or that's because you deserve it, you might as well give up who
- 28:18cares about you? That's the conclusion that children will come to in situations like
- 28:22this, and that gets locked into your neurons. It's hard to correct for
- 28:26that. It's worth trying to correct for that. You know, the fifty
- 28:27percent that you can get down the road is worth it. But it lasts
- 28:32forever. I'm it cut its head off. You did not pack a lunch
- 28:38today. Hopefully nobody gives her food, and nobody steps in and gives her
- 28:42a lunch times. It hopped into the clip, right. I've seen that
- 28:45clip before as well, on the Philip Franco Show. It was a clip
- 28:51of her saying that her small child, I think eight years old, Ish
- 28:56who allegedly has ADHD, had forgotten to make her lunch for the day and
- 29:02had gone to school and the school found out she didn't have lunch. The
- 29:04school called the mom, and the mom again films herself posted on the internet
- 29:10proudly talking about how updating about the situation. The school didn't call YouTube or
- 29:17CPS. She's the one reporting this. So this is another thing to think
- 29:19about, is that she's loud and proud with this sort of thing. The
- 29:22entitlement the self assuredness, the brazenness of it. And that's a whole other
- 29:30level. And when I would work with perpetrators of various different crimes like this,
- 29:36whether it was intimate partner violence or child abuse, that was a special
- 29:38class of individual because more often than not, when I would arrive on the
- 29:45scene or I'd be assessing, or I'd be hearing a report from a client
- 29:48who was identified as a perpetrator, at the very least, they would try
- 29:52to obscure what they had done. They might believe that they're right, kind
- 29:56of on the inside for doing what they did, even though they weren't right,
- 29:59but they enough to not advertise it. They think, well, maybe
- 30:03I did cross the line a little bit, or I know other people think
- 30:06this is wrong. It's a whole But then I would meet other people that
- 30:10would just sit down and be like, yeah, I did it. What
- 30:11are you going to do about it? You're idiots? All y'all are idiots.
- 30:15You know that locked in mindset, that that entitlement, that self assuredness,
- 30:19that grandiosity, that foundation that whatever thoughts or emotions or impulses or urges
- 30:26that are generated from their twisted mind, you know, these are golden thoughts
- 30:30and motivations like no one can indict them, no one can refute the logic.
- 30:37It's it's particular and harder to treat, by the way, and much
- 30:41more concerning when you are a public official adjudicating these kinds of things, because
- 30:48again, it's one thing if like. One of the most often developments at
- 30:51the beginning of treating these individuals was I would sort of use my oversight as
- 30:56a bludgeoning tool to get them to stop temper rarely, because usually I knew
- 31:02that they wouldn't be on board with the notions, because you almost have to
- 31:06de brainwash them because they all get it from where they were growing up,
- 31:07by the way, and partially society, but often from when they were growing
- 31:11up. They were often treated this way or sought and it's ingrained in them,
- 31:15and it's hard to dislodge without a lot of work and a lot of
- 31:22being with them. You have to you have to gain their trust, you
- 31:23have to be with them, you have to have a good relationship with them,
- 31:26and you have to push back and slowly. It's like getting someone out
- 31:32of a cult. These perpetrators they're in a cult that they developed when they
- 31:36were younger. Anyway or they developed throughout their lives. But the first phase
- 31:41was well safety first, right, so I would not be hearing things that
- 31:45indicated that the perpetrator was changing very quickly, which is normal. But in
- 31:49lieu of that, at the very least, I could have them stop abusing,
- 31:53stop creating terror, stop creating harm, at least beyond a certain threshold.
- 32:00And so I would lay the ground rules. And I would, especially
- 32:04if I was working alongside the government. You know, I would say,
- 32:07well, if something happens, the government is going to do X, Y
- 32:10and Z. I don't work for the government. They're contracting me. I'm
- 32:14a private practitioner, but and I'm here to work with you. But the
- 32:16reality is you're being monitored by the government, and so they're going to be
- 32:21consequences, and you need to stop doing X, Y and Z. And
- 32:24for most people they would actually stop. I would hear from the victim alone
- 32:30saying, yep, they've stopped doing those things. They're still raging on the
- 32:35inside, but you know, yeah, they're not doing that stuff anymore.
- 32:37So they haven't changed yet, but they are changing their ways. So for
- 32:43one of these perpetrators to film themselves loud and proud people attacking them, and
- 32:49there are potentially government agencies even contacting them. I think there was that that
- 32:53happened at some point and to just loud and proud just state it like,
- 32:57yes, this is the right thing, I am right, I am righteous
- 33:02everything about Now. Another side to this is that when you're indoctrinated into a
- 33:07religion or a particular part or section of a religion that is similar along these
- 33:14lines, then you know that mindset is very easy to slip into where you
- 33:17just shut out the outside world. You get suspicious of the government, you
- 33:21start thinking, you know, adhering to conspiracy theories, and it makes you
- 33:23impervious to any sort of feedback or any kind of data that would refute it
- 33:29your terrible notions and gives her a lunch times. I have to Oh,
- 33:32so, what I was saying was the fact that you have an entire school
- 33:37body. You know, if you're a parent and you have kids in school,
- 33:39you know how this goes. Like if just imagine if it maybe it's
- 33:45happened to you where your kid goes to school and doesn't have a lunch of
- 33:49parents will fly into a terror of like, oh my god, what if
- 33:52the school thinks I'm a terrible parent. I have to really nail this,
- 33:57you know, run home, get food, drive. Yeah, oh my
- 34:00god, hey everyone, I absolutely do feed my kid every day, as
- 34:04everyone. This wasn't my fault, you know, and because that's what a
- 34:08good parent would do, because they are concerned about that, So that would
- 34:14be a normal impulse for a normal parent. But instead to film yourself saying
- 34:21I am not going to bring a lunch to my child because I want to
- 34:24teach that child a lesson. That child is in grade school. They also
- 34:30have a neurological condition of ADHD, but I don't care because I don't care
- 34:36about Because the whole Connections Parenting teaching program on their website, their mission statement
- 34:43basically said, I can't remember the wording, but they basically said, you
- 34:45know, psychotherapy is stupid and we have the real answers. So who knows,
- 34:52But she might have also been We could totally imagine Ruby Frankie and Jody
- 34:54Hilderrant throwing out psychiatry in general and saying a D is just an excuse.
- 35:00And there's a lot of people that believe that who aren't abusive. They believe
- 35:04that children get away with things and are labeled ADHD as a way of complying
- 35:09with the child's rebellion and like stupid and of course unscientific. But so the
- 35:20mom is filming herself saying, I'm not going to I told the school to
- 35:23not feed her. They said they do not feed her. I'm not bringing
- 35:28a lunch. I'm doing this to make a point to punish her, and
- 35:31you better not feed her. And she's filming this and saying and they better
- 35:36not. I hope they don't feed her because I want her to learn a
- 35:38lesson, like and you're filming it and you're posting it on the internet,
- 35:43and you think you're right, and you have followers that also think you're right.
- 35:46That's also the scary thing. If people didn't think she was right,
- 35:52then she wouldn't be big right. She would just be this weird person that
- 35:55you would hate watch on the internet. Sometimes she had millions of people that
- 35:59were following her. There's a lot of people who are indoctrinated into this mindset,
- 36:02maybe even you could say this cultish mindset that involves all the things that
- 36:08I've been talking about. So this is on the YouTube channel now this news
- 36:19is there food and nobody steps in and gives her a lunchtimes I have to
- 36:22neglect the kids, and my kids are literally starving. I told the kids,
- 36:25I said, I'm not even gonna let you eat breakfast until you get
- 36:29your choice. There's that laughter again. I don't know what it says.
- 36:34I know enough about psychological assessment that it takes a long time. There has
- 36:39to be a lot of tests, a lot of interviews, a lot of
- 36:43collateral interviews. And even then it's hard to tell exactly hours and hours of
- 36:47assessment. When I assess people for personality stories in particular, you know,
- 36:51it might take me months to feel confident in a consuptualization. And even then
- 36:57I'm just saying, well, it looks like this to me. And here's
- 36:59why I'm saying it. You know, these are constructs, are not hard
- 37:01scientific facts that someone is a psychopath or something. There there are constructs and
- 37:06labels that we apply to people for treatment purposes and research purposes. You know,
- 37:10it's very different than say geology, where you're studying the difference between diamonds
- 37:15and granit or something. There are discrete differences of molecules and properties that can
- 37:22be very easily determined, whereas with the difference between someone who has a personalized
- 37:25sort of versus someone who doesn't. There isn't that hard, scientific, numerical
- 37:30data that you can point to. You can't open up someone's brain and point
- 37:32to something and say that person is this, that person is that, But
- 37:36it does say something. Potentially, it would be a data point that you
- 37:39would pay attention to if you were assessing her that she laughs, let's rewatch
- 37:44them literally starving. I told the kids, I said, I'm not even
- 37:46going to let you eat breakfast. And the tone of it, it's hard
- 37:51to know, but the tone of the and again she's posting this to the
- 37:55world. This is her being proud of herself. This is her saying I
- 38:00am doing the right thing and y'all should be like me, and I don't
- 38:04care what anyone else says. And the tone of the laughter it cos I
- 38:08don't know how it comes across to you, but it comes across to me
- 38:12like the way a parent would talk about something that is much more mundane,
- 38:16you know, like, oh, well, you know, my kids sometimes
- 38:21they want to be playing video games all day and they don't want to do
- 38:24their homework, so you know, I told them that they need to stop
- 38:29playing PlayStation all day and they need to do their homework. It has that
- 38:31kind of tone to me, that kind of like we all understand, this
- 38:36is frustrating. We're in this together, like you know the deal. It
- 38:39has that kind of tone to me. Let's rewatch them. It gives her
- 38:43food, and nobody steps in and gives her a lunchtimes. I have to
- 38:45neglect the kids, and my kids are literally starving. I told the kids,
- 38:50I said, I'm not even gonna let you eat breakfast until you get
- 38:52your chores done. There's another possibility that she's laughing there because she actually knows
- 38:58that there's something wrong with it. It's like something kicks in for her that
- 39:02she's embarrassed or something. I don't know. There's a lot of possibilities irving.
- 39:06Like I told the kids, I said, I'm not even gonna let
- 39:07you eat breakfast until you get your chores done. This increasingly disturbing and controlling
- 39:13behavior was on display for years, causing backlash from concerned viewers. In twenty
- 39:17twenty, some even created a petition for Child Protective Services to investigate the Frankies.
- 39:22Yeah, as I said before, for years now, people have been
- 39:25trying to tell the authorities. People have been trying to tell YouTube, not
- 39:30only just people watching the YouTube channel, but people in Ruby Frankie's family,
- 39:34which we found out later her sisters, I believe, were they knew what
- 39:39was happening in the home or knew some of it, and they were actually
- 39:43calling CPS. Ruby Frankie's daughter, the oldest daughter who actually got out of
- 39:47the house, was also calling CPS and nothing was happening, and I don't
- 39:53know what is going on. Maybe we'll find out. I'm guessing we won't.
- 39:58On one end of the spectrum, you have situation potentially where CPS Child
- 40:01Protective Services are terrible human beings or lazy or some things. You know,
- 40:07they could have done something and they didn't because they're assholes or jerk faces,
- 40:13or maybe they're even in her sort of mind of thinking, I was like,
- 40:15yeah, but she should come down on those. You know, these
- 40:19are regular people, CPS workers, so who knows what their political points of
- 40:22view are. So you have that end of the spectrum. But then you
- 40:25have the other spectrum where you have CPS workers who absolutely knew about what was
- 40:30happening because they were getting reports that they wanted to do something but there wasn't
- 40:34enough there to actually do. You know, the public tends to think that
- 40:37CPS just has all this power. They do not have a lot of power.
- 40:42They have some power, but they don't they don't have the power that
- 40:45people think they do. There are other regulations on CPS, like judges can
- 40:49actually step in and I've actually been in court when this would happen. Judges
- 40:52can step in and say no, CPS, you can't do this. You
- 40:54can't infringe on the rights of this family or this child or this parent,
- 40:59And so I'm going to I don't know the technical legal language, but they
- 41:02would say no to that. They would prevent CPS from moving forward with that.
- 41:06The judge could even force CPS to do something. I could say,
- 41:08well you have to do this, you know, within reason. There were
- 41:12things that they could make them do, and so I would watch that.
- 41:15I wouldn't be a part of the government. I would just be there as
- 41:19an observer. I would kind of be on both teams. I would be
- 41:21on the team of the family and even the abuse of parent. I'm trying
- 41:24to get them to like him, trying to work with them. I'm trying
- 41:29to help them to feel safe with me, and so you know, I
- 41:30need to be there with them, and they're not for the majority, they're
- 41:35not horrible people. They were abused themselves and they want to parent in a
- 41:39way that is good. And they're struggling. They're getting triggered. They've been
- 41:44influenced. They had bad models, you know, bad parenting models growing up.
- 41:46And I've worked with a lot of people who and I'm not unique,
- 41:52a lot of specialists in this area have found success with perpetrators. So anyway,
- 41:57but I be on both teams anyway. The point is is that on
- 41:59the other end SECTRAM, it's possible that the CPS workers knew about it,
- 42:04they wanted to do something, but there wasn't enough there The allegations weren't such
- 42:07that they could actually do anything. There's that they also could have had a
- 42:13lack of funding because you know, the Ruby Frankie family is not the only
- 42:15family calling CPS during that week. They get hundreds of calls potentially from all
- 42:22sorts of sources, and they have to allocate funds and resources to the ones
- 42:28that need them the most. You know, there could have been That's the
- 42:30other thing is they could their caseload could have been a set that if you
- 42:34looked at their caseload, you'd be like, oh, yeah, those cases
- 42:37were much more important than the Ruby Frankie case. The Ruby Frankie case is
- 42:40awful, but those other ones, Oh my god. Yes, if you
- 42:44were going to do if you're going to do something with your time, you're
- 42:45very limited forty hours a week, then yes, you should be spending time
- 42:50with those families. That could have been a possibility. None other possibility is
- 42:52that CPS again wanted to do something but was prevented by politicians, or underfunded
- 42:58by politicians, or even police who were pushing back, or maybe someone in
- 43:01charge, some government official in charge of CPS was preventing, you know,
- 43:06protecting Mormons, or who knows, or saying YouTube is stupid, don't worry
- 43:09about that. Who knows? You know, there's there's there's a lot of
- 43:13possibilities, and as far as I know, we don't know as of today,
- 43:16I'm recording this on September fourteenth, what the situation was. It's easy
- 43:22to blame CPS, it's easy to have that scapegoat, but it's not always
- 43:25wise to do so. I've said this before in my experience with dozens of
- 43:30CPS workers that I've worked with. They do good work. They want to
- 43:35do good work. I mean, just think about it. What sort of
- 43:37person decides to get a job in CPS. What sort of person? Yet,
- 43:43because these people often have advanced degrees, or at the very least they
- 43:45have privilege to seek advanced degrees, you know, they could do a lot
- 43:50of things. They could. You know, the CPS workers that I worked
- 43:52with in the late nineties early oats, this was during the dot com boom
- 43:57of Seattle. They could have all these individuals had the capabilities of working at
- 44:00Microsoft and getting stock options and all that kind of stuff. But they chose
- 44:07to work for this agency that underpays them and overworks them, and under this
- 44:10public underappreciates them because they love children. They care about children. A lot
- 44:15of them were abused themselves as children. So to just write them off and
- 44:20scapegoat them isn't wise. Now, it's possible that they are the problem,
- 44:24but I don't know. Maybe we'll find out. Over the last four years,
- 44:29police made at least fifteen visits to the Frankie's home, but nothing was
- 44:32done to protect them. Okay, I didn't know that. I think I
- 44:35had heard that maybe some investigations, but fifteen visits fifteen I mean that still
- 44:40sort of fits within it elaborates on that spectrum I was talking about, you
- 44:46know, because on one hand, to be like, how do you visit
- 44:49fifteen times and not do anything? All the barriers that I talked about could
- 44:52have been present, not only the fact that the data just wasn't there,
- 44:58you know, there wasn't enough to grab on. Oh. I was going
- 45:00to say this earlier, that people tend to think that CPS has all this
- 45:02power and there are regulations around what they can do, and there's only so
- 45:07much money. I ran into situations clinically where I would have a kid who
- 45:12was obviously being abused by their parents, and in the beginning of my career,
- 45:15since I didn't know the full picture that CPS was dealing with on a
- 45:20daily basis, I was like, well, obviously CPS is going to do
- 45:23something that they're going to take the kid out of the home. They're going
- 45:25to protect this kid. They're going to place the kid in a foster home
- 45:29or some other place to get them away from the abuse of parents. And
- 45:32I learned early on that they didn't necessarily do that, even when it was
- 45:37obvious they should. And then I would ask a CPS work, I'd be
- 45:39like, why aren't you doing anything? And they'd be like, we literally
- 45:43don't have the beds, meaning we don't have the funds to pay for open
- 45:47homes to actually house these individuals. We literally have nowhere to send the kid.
- 45:52We could take the kid out of the home, but where they're going
- 45:54to go. I'm not going to bring the kid home to my house.
- 45:57And some of the CPS workers would actually contempt late then, and I think
- 46:00some of the CPS workers would actually do that because of their compassion for these
- 46:04children. Now, often CPS would be looking to other family members and so
- 46:07uncle's grandparents, church members, just anyone else that they could vet that,
- 46:12you know, obviously they would check to make sure this other household wasn't going
- 46:15to abuse them. But these were free options, right because family might take
- 46:19in the kid without charging anything. But if they don't have that, then
- 46:22they have to pay a foster home, they have to pay a group home,
- 46:25and these are expensive. And because our legislatures and the voters only ask
- 46:30the legislatures to allocate a certain amount of funds for that, there's only a
- 46:35certain amount of options that if you have what it range, it pours.
- 46:37You know, you get a lot of calls in from the public about allegations
- 46:40of abuse. You just have to pick the ten worst ones that you have
- 46:45identified and put them in a home, and the other ones you send me
- 46:49in because I'm cheaper. That's what they would do. They be a kirk.
- 46:52You got to go in there, But I'd be saying, I'm only
- 46:53there a few hours a week. What about those other hours? I mean,
- 46:57we can't know if the child isn't going to be abused, the abuse
- 47:00of parent isn't changing their ways necessarily, And I don't know them well enough
- 47:05to trust that they're not going to do this again. Safety first, right,
- 47:07and they'd be like, we don't have the funds, So it could
- 47:09have been that. Again. I want to say for the record, I'm
- 47:14very clear about this. I hope that it's possible that CPS workers were complete
- 47:19jerk faces. Now there's evidence that that probably isn't the case, because if
- 47:22you have fifteen visits, you probably have dozens of CPS workers that were working
- 47:28on this case, either on the front lines or at least knew about it,
- 47:31because there are staff meetings and collateral people you talk to. So the
- 47:36chance that you would have a whole group of CPS workers that would go,
- 47:42who cares about them? I'm a jerk face and I'm just going to be
- 47:45lazy. You know, that's not likely to have happened. Could you have
- 47:49one CPS worker or one and then their boss who are jerk faces at times?
- 47:54You know there are cases like that, But fifteen visits tell me that
- 47:58there are probably multiple people involved in It's not likely that they were all just
- 48:01complacent and didn't care about these children. I don't know that, but that
- 48:07is interesting. Fifteen times fifteen Well, so sometimes each one of those visits
- 48:13is part of one one larger visit, Like you get a bunch of calls
- 48:16and then you decide to investigate, and you visit, say seven times in
- 48:22one week, and you just say like, okay, we'll do the initial
- 48:25interview and then I have to talk because you know, there's eight people in
- 48:29this family, and usually you would want to talk to everyone individually, of
- 48:32course, because you can't talk to the kids while the parents are there.
- 48:35So maybe that's why there were so many visits. I don't know kids.
- 48:38After she was arrested, Frankie's older daughter, Sherry said in an Instagram story,
- 48:43We've been trying to tell the police, right, So I talked about
- 48:46this in the Dugger Deep Dive episode that the oldest daughter Sherry posted as soon
- 48:52as Ruby, Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt were arrested. As she says, Hi,
- 48:58all today, it's been a big day. Me and my they are
- 49:00so glad justice as being served. We've been trying to tell the police and
- 49:02CPS for years about this and so glad they finally decided to step up.
- 49:07Kids are safe now. But but there's a long road ahead and so on.
- 49:13So yeah, yeah, it's yeah. What I would hope that comes
- 49:21from this, which I'm guessing it won't, is that there are more funds,
- 49:27There are more tax dollars, there are maybe even more oversight to CPS,
- 49:31more attention given from the outside to CPS. It's sort of like with
- 49:37police officers, right. Not all police officers are criminals, but some are,
- 49:42and when there's no oversight, then those criminals can get away with their
- 49:45crimes. Is this Department of CPS one of those situations that needs a lot
- 49:52of oversight or needs an overhaul, or people need to be fired. Well,
- 49:55if so, especially if it starts the management level, then you need
- 50:00an outside group politicians or someone or the public having an outcry about a particular
- 50:06department. I don't know, but yeah, it is. I guess the
- 50:09silver lining that the kids are safe from now and finally getting but it's rough
- 50:15because and this is why taking kids out of the home is a double edged
- 50:20sword because on one hand, yes, get the kids away from Ruby Frankie
- 50:22and get them away from the abuse, but the attachment disruption is severe to
- 50:29these children. It's you're damned if you do, damned if you don't with
- 50:30this situation. Because you think, okay, the kids are now living with
- 50:35their grandparents, are on foster homes or I don't know where they're at,
- 50:37but some other place, and everything's good, the kids are safe, everything's
- 50:42fine, and the damage that they went through they need there before. But
- 50:45everything will be okay. There's this additional problem that I would see all the
- 50:49time, to some degree sometimes severe, that you unfortunately, when you're being
- 50:54abused by your parents, you are also attaching to them. You don't when
- 50:59you're two, when you're seven or even fifteen, you don't say, well,
- 51:01I live with a jerk face. I don't regard them. You need
- 51:05that part. We're we evolved to attach to these individuals. We evolved to
- 51:09look to them, to mimic them, to want their approval, to want
- 51:14them to be proud of us, to want them to love us, to
- 51:16seek them for a tunement of emotional connections. And we can't get away from
- 51:21that. And I know some of you lament that you had parents who were
- 51:24abusive, and you still are thinking about them. You're forty five years old,
- 51:30and you still wish that they were different. You still wish that they'd
- 51:32be proud of you, and you know, it's beating your head against the
- 51:37wall. And you might even have people or even therapists for that matter,
- 51:39unfortunately, telling you like, just move on, stop, you know,
- 51:43just give up on those parents. It's it's in our bones. It's hard.
- 51:46So for these kids, that also is a disruption. I'm not saying
- 51:52we should have kept them with the mom, but it's another abuse that happens,
- 51:57another disruption, maybe particularly for the younger kids. So let me talk
- 52:01about that that I would see for the older kids. There's a possible on
- 52:06everyone's different, but if the older kids experienced longer spans of abuse, then
- 52:10that has its own toll. Right, If you're fifteen and you had fifteen
- 52:14years of abuse, that's different than having five years of abuse, right.
- 52:17But on the other hand, to have an attachment disruption at the age of
- 52:21fifteen in general, is not as disruptive to your neurology and your scheme is
- 52:25and your personality as having an attachment disruption when you're five. So for the
- 52:30five year old to be taken out of the home as opposed to the fifteen
- 52:34year old, I don't know the exact ages, but I'm guessing there's somewhere
- 52:37in there for five year old to be taken out, you're saving them from
- 52:39ten years of abuse that the fifteen year old went through, which is good,
- 52:44but you're also causing a much deeper attachment wound for that child. So
- 52:50there's just no winning. And the answer is too, Well, what's the
- 52:54answer? Well, if we had a more a stronger CPEs government system,
- 53:01they I'm guessing could have intervened sooner, but that wouldn't have stopped the damage
- 53:07because by the time CPS gets called, there's a lot of damage that's already
- 53:09happened. So the bigger picture solution is that we break the chain. Because
- 53:17Ruby Frankie probably went through some difficulties growing up with her parents. Her parents
- 53:22probably went through similar difficulties when they were children, who knows of what sort.
- 53:28But this doesn't usually just come out of nowhere. This usually does have
- 53:30a transgenerational pattern. So we have to break the chain. How do we
- 53:35break the chain, Well, we have to raise awareness. We have to
- 53:37increase access to therapy and parenting support. You know, we often say like,
- 53:42well you need everyone needs to be in the therapist. Yeah, but
- 53:45there's a variety of mental health clinicians or relationship or parenting experts who can be
- 53:51hired and free available. But because the government, you know, the government
- 53:54pays for a lot of people. Government pays for a lot of things.
- 53:58So a lot of money in the government, and it's all a matter of
- 54:00what you prioritize. And I would say that this is a big priority right
- 54:05and CPS for years about this. The father, Kevin Frankie, claims he
- 54:08had no part in the abuse. You have something in the bag that you
- 54:12would like. So the father is a big question mark. At this point.
- 54:15There isn't a lot of reporting on him. So we don't know,
- 54:21but we just heard that his statement is he was no part of the abuse.
- 54:23It's possible, it doesn't seem likely. I'm sure most people wouldn't believe
- 54:28that. I mean, you're the other parent, you're there. Apparently the
- 54:31dad bout have moved out in recent history. I think I seem to remember.
- 54:35Don't call me on that. But is it possible that he was not
- 54:38a part of it at all? Not likely, especially given the videos that
- 54:44you see on YouTube. He's there. Might he have been really trying to
- 54:49fight with Ruby to stop doing X, Y and Z, and she was
- 54:52just doing it anyway. Yeah, some of you might have been through that.
- 54:55You might be living it right now. You might have a spouse that
- 54:58is at least border aligning on abuse of your children. You know, you
- 55:01have a spouse and you have kids together, whether you're divorced or not,
- 55:05and you have to live with the fact that your that your spouse or your
- 55:08ex spouse is abusing or mistreating your children, and there's not a lot you
- 55:13can do if it doesn't rise to the level of colleague, CPS or the
- 55:16police. If it's moderate to mild emotional abuse, which can be very destructive.
- 55:22CPS isn't likely to do anything about that. Sometimes they will. It
- 55:27is considered against the law or can be actionable by CPS, for sure,
- 55:31but you know, given funding and that sort of thing, it's it's unsure
- 55:36what they would do. But anyway, some of you might be dealing with
- 55:38that, and what do you do. You try to convince you, you
- 55:44say, you can't do that anymore. You try to make up for it
- 55:45with the kids as best you can, but you just have to live with
- 55:49it. Was the dad in that situation could be, but it also could
- 55:54be that he was at least somewhat a part of it or comple he sent
- 56:00about it, allowed an accomplice by the fact that he didn't step in and
- 56:04do anything about it, right, I don't know. There's also a possibility
- 56:07that he tried to get the kids away from her at times, and there
- 56:10were a lot. Who knows, There's just maybe that story will come out,
- 56:15but it certainly is. If it's true that he was at least moderately
- 56:19or absolutely involved in the abuses, it's a very convenient thing to say,
- 56:22is just like, yeah, I wasn't a part of the abuse. Like
- 56:30out you can pay cash for it, so you learn the value of your
- 56:37items, or you can do an equivalent value sure to get it back.
- 56:47And whatever isn't claimed by the end of the day, it goes in the
- 56:53carpet. Okay, So they're showing a clip of the dad going along with
- 56:59what the mom is doing. It's hard that clip is hard to interpret.
- 57:06Is that abusive in and of itself? The clip that we just saw,
- 57:09I mean, if you take it in the bigger picture, it probably was
- 57:14right, but it's hard to know. It's hard to know what was going
- 57:17on. The people that would know would be the kids. So why didn't
- 57:22CPS intervene sooner? It's possible that the family's wealth and race played a role.
- 57:28University of New Hampshire social work professor. Yeah. Absolutely, there's a
- 57:31lot of things in this category. There's a lot of research and it's not
- 57:36hard to imagine that if CPS in the same way that the police when they're
- 57:43called to a home that is stereotypically poor and low class, working class,
- 57:49or a family of color or an immigrant family, then there is a much
- 57:53higher likelihood because of the associations and the racism that is present, that they're
- 58:00going to take action against the family. But you know, the opposite think
- 58:01could happened as well, where if the family is underprivileged, the government agency
- 58:07CPS could just look the other way, similar to the way I guess they're
- 58:12being accused of here. But yeah, absolutely, And I'll just speak for
- 58:15myself. I've been there myself. So when I was starting out as a
- 58:20therapist, this was more of a thing for me because I in the beginning
- 58:24of my life as a therapist, I'm twenty six years old. I'm actually
- 58:29I can't even pay my bills because my salary as a therapist wasn't covering my
- 58:35student loan payment and my bills, and I lived like a college kid.
- 58:38I had a rent that was very small. I had a very old used
- 58:43car that had I'm not even joking, two fifty thousand miles on it.
- 58:47Eventually, by the time I had three hundred thousand miles on it. There
- 58:50was a hole in the floor of the passenger footwell. I could see the
- 58:54road, but I didn't have money. I'm a therapist at this point,
- 58:58I'm a salary therapist. I'm also a professor at this point. Just gives
- 59:01you an idea of how little we get paid. I mean, not as
- 59:04little as other people do, but still, and I was intimidated by people
- 59:08who had wealth and older people. And I would be sometimes in this contract
- 59:16or other kinds of gigs that I would have where I would work with rich,
- 59:21privileged white people, you know, very rich people, you know,
- 59:23think dot Com that kind of thing. You know, it's funny looking back,
- 59:27they probably weren't even that rich, but to me, they just seemed
- 59:30like mansion millionaire billionaire people. And I would notice, because I spent a
- 59:35lot of time being taught this and supervised around this and thinking about this,
- 59:38I would notice that I would be a little bit more nicer to those families
- 59:43and a little bit more deferential, a little more tentative, little more careful
- 59:47about confronting them that sort of thing. It wasn't always the case, but
- 59:50it was a factor. And I, you know, I can admit that
- 59:53because I have been brainwashed and socialized in this society, just like everybody else
- 59:58has the differences that in my profession, we spend or at least in my
- 1:00:01pocket other profession, we spend a lot of time analyzing that about ourselves and
- 1:00:06reason where it's about it. You know, if you have a student or
- 1:00:08a supervise that says, I treat everyone the same. I don't see color,
- 1:00:13or I don't care if someone's rich or poor. I treat everyone the
- 1:00:15same. You know, maybe, but probably not unless you grew up under
- 1:00:20a rock. You were socialized and brainwashed by our society. So something's going
- 1:00:23on there. I'm not going to accuse someone automatically of something, but you
- 1:00:28know, let's move past that and go a little deeper. Let's see what
- 1:00:30we find. And my university Antioch, Seattle, and also just the pocket
- 1:00:36of people around me, and also just my own upbringing. I'm half Japanese
- 1:00:38and you might think of me as just like this. You might even not
- 1:00:43know I'm Asian. I don't know, but when I grew up in the
- 1:00:45seventies and eighties, people definitely knew. In the nineties, even today,
- 1:00:49I mean, someone called me a chink the other day or not the other
- 1:00:52day, but not too long ago, they were trying to attack me and
- 1:00:58a young white woman called me a chink. And Seattle and Ballard Liberal Seattle.
- 1:01:02So there. But particularly when I was younger, I was definitely otherized
- 1:01:07and living in an all white community, and you know, just east of
- 1:01:12Seattle and some Amish, and so that also could have helped me in the
- 1:01:16beginning of my career to be skeptical because I saw racism and bias and other
- 1:01:22people and I had to wonder where my bias and racism was as well,
- 1:01:27sexism, all sorts of isms, if you will. So you know,
- 1:01:30maybe that helped. But the YouTube channel now this news is speculating maybe CPS
- 1:01:37was going easy on the Frankie family because of their white, blonde, blue
- 1:01:44eyed Mormon rich status. It could be, but I wouldn't assume that anecdotally.
- 1:01:51I would even see some CPS workers who had a bone to pick with
- 1:01:53privileged people, right, because the other thing to think about is CPS workers
- 1:01:59are not necessary all white people, right, So you can have people that
- 1:02:04absolutely are aware of bias and of white supremacy and white privilege and fight it
- 1:02:10every day, and when they show up at a house like the Frankie's family,
- 1:02:15Frankie family, they are like, there's no way that I'm going to
- 1:02:17treat this family better than the other families. You know, in fact,
- 1:02:21I might even go harder on them because of their privilege. So it's all
- 1:02:23speculation at this point. Possible that the family's wealth and race played a role.
- 1:02:28University of New Hampshire social work professor Vernon Brooks Carter looked at four hundred
- 1:02:31and eighteen substantiated cases of lack of supervision. Carter found that white kids were
- 1:02:37more likely to be inadequately supervised by their parents, but African American children under
- 1:02:40similar circumstances were more than three times as likely to be removed from their parents'
- 1:02:45care. Yeah. Wow, that's quite a difference three times. Other study
- 1:02:51from the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia revealed that between twenty ten and twenty fourteen,
- 1:02:55white children were hospitalized for abuse assessment for shorter periods of time than black children,
- 1:03:00even if their injuries were more significant. So did the system think?
- 1:03:05Right, That's an important caveat there, because it's possible that the pressures that
- 1:03:10you put on black families and the you know, not only from the criminal
- 1:03:15justice system, but from the economic system and all the others, you know,
- 1:03:20just the systemic racism in our society, that would cause these families to
- 1:03:23be stressed out a lot more, stretched thin, a lot more, and
- 1:03:27thus maybe when there is abuse it can be more severe. I'm not saying
- 1:03:30that's the case, but that could be the reason why you have more actions
- 1:03:35taken against black families as opposed to white families. But they pointed out that
- 1:03:39even when the abuses and the white families were more severe, the children were
- 1:03:45still not taken out of the home or there was still less action taken against
- 1:03:50the white families even though the abuses were more severe. So it's an important
- 1:03:53part of that study that needs that they highlighted. Which is good and in
- 1:03:58the end, each of us will account to God. And there it is
- 1:04:04just yeah, and some of you might be religious Christians, Mormons even and
- 1:04:13you look at Ruby Frankie and think that she's a monster. So it doesn't
- 1:04:15necessarily mean that everyone that believes in God, or every religious person or every
- 1:04:19Christian or every Mormon is like this. But when you have a brainwashing occurring
- 1:04:26within a religion or even just within a particular location of church, then you
- 1:04:30get some interesting things. There's so many things that can uphold someone's point of
- 1:04:36view that their parenting is okay. There's even passages in the Bible that literally
- 1:04:43support what she is doing. So there's that also if you feel like the
- 1:04:47secular world because you're just being told us all the time is falling apart,
- 1:04:53and their sinners and all their diseases and all their poverty and the homelessness and
- 1:04:57all you know, the wars. It's all because of the sins of the
- 1:05:00outside world. Then when the outside world comes into your house like CPS,
- 1:05:04it says, hey, something's going on here, you just regard them as
- 1:05:08the secular woke libs who you always all week long. You're they're the devil,
- 1:05:14They're the demon, sometimes literally, and you are fighting against them.
- 1:05:17And here they are coming in into your house trying to change things like the
- 1:05:20devil will try to do. And I'm going to be a good Christian,
- 1:05:23a good Mormon. I'm not I'm not going to let that happen. I'm
- 1:05:25not saying that that's what happened here. But we've heard stories of that before.
- 1:05:30And that's another factor. You know, after doing the Dugger Deep Dive,
- 1:05:32I always knew that there are evangelical movements and Christian cults that are here,
- 1:05:38and there are cult ish like things that are happening within Jehovah witness or
- 1:05:43Mormons or something. You know, you hear about these things. But doing
- 1:05:45the thirteen chapters of the Dugger deep dive and the months of looking into everything
- 1:05:51and all the interviews and all the documentaries and all the thinking about it.
- 1:05:56I now have a much deeper appreciation for the problem that we have in our
- 1:06:00society and really around the world. This is not just an American thing.
- 1:06:04You could even argue it's worse, much worse in other countries. If you've
- 1:06:09grown up in other countries that have problems like this, you know that at
- 1:06:13least in the United States there are there's pushback and freedom to push back to
- 1:06:17some extent. So but it's still a big problem in United States. And
- 1:06:20the amount of cloistering of people and the shutting out or the outside world,
- 1:06:27and the charismatic leaders, and you know, it's all cult. It's all
- 1:06:30just right down the middle cult behavior and cult indoctrination and brainwashing. And it's
- 1:06:34scary. You know, you have more than twenty percent of Americans believe in
- 1:06:39the tenets of Q and on that there is this cabal of rich lizard people
- 1:06:45drinking the blood of babies so that that they could stay. I mean,
- 1:06:49I knew about those people. You always, yeah, there's always going to
- 1:06:51be this fringe. But when you think one in four Americans believe this kind
- 1:06:57of nonsense. And it's not like it's one thing to believe in the Bible
- 1:07:01and to believe the literal word like, well, it says in the Bible
- 1:07:06you're supposed to if you spare the rod, you what do you you know,
- 1:07:09you screw up your kids or what. Can't remember the exact passage,
- 1:07:12but you know, that's a lot more mainstream. It's still as ridiculous,
- 1:07:15but at least it's it's more traditional. The QAnon stuff, it's someone just
- 1:07:19made that up in the last ten years. You know, there's just some
- 1:07:21some IDEO's trolling of the of the followers and it just took hold. So
- 1:07:29it taps into all those cultural things, because of course it taps into the
- 1:07:32Satanic panic and the worry of things that have been around for a long time.
- 1:07:38But but it's a brand new kind of flavor of it anyway. So
- 1:07:41that's another factor here that I don't know if a lot of people are talking
- 1:07:45about maybe people are about I don't hear it. That's another thing that we
- 1:07:48should be paying attention to. I don't know what to do about that exactly.
- 1:07:53Outreach to these communities that probably is part of it. Like, we
- 1:07:57see a culture war in our society, and I this hand gesture of just
- 1:08:00like there's there's a widening of these two distinct cultural groups with the United States
- 1:08:06the I don't know what label the liberals and the conservatives, if you will.
- 1:08:10And when you have that, there's a lot of systemic processes that take
- 1:08:13place that are really quite predictable and really quite known and happen in all sorts
- 1:08:17of systems. Where you can have a breakup between two people that will be
- 1:08:20a similar sort of thing, but the phenomena are the same. Where you
- 1:08:26dehumanize the outgroup, you heavily identify with in group. You look for infiltrators
- 1:08:32in your in group because of the fear that is you're being dedoctrinated into.
- 1:08:35You know, both sides are teaching fear of the other, fear of the
- 1:08:40apocalypse, fear of Nazis, and you know, just fear fear, fear
- 1:08:45Antifa or whatever. And the world is a scary place. And the Chrismatic
- 1:08:48leaders step in and say I can save you. I know what to do,
- 1:08:51And you have to figure out who in the in group is an infiltrator.
- 1:08:56We got to identify them, get rid of them, shame them particularly
- 1:08:59because they're a problem. They're in the inside, and we should really hang
- 1:09:03them out to dry, we should really burn them at the stake figuratively,
- 1:09:06then attack the outgroup. And then the outgroup receives those attacks, and they're
- 1:09:11hurt by them, and they're scared about them. They don't to do about
- 1:09:14them, And instead of being vulnerable and going to the other group and saying,
- 1:09:16hey, that kind of scares me and that hurts my feelings, they
- 1:09:18transfer that into anger and hostility and they attack too. It hurts the other
- 1:09:23side, and the why just gets bigger that anger gets It's the same in
- 1:09:26a divorce. When you start to have you get married, you fall in
- 1:09:30love, you're absolutely bonded, things are going well. There are conflicts that
- 1:09:33happen, attachment injuries and triggers, there are there's a widening gap between the
- 1:09:38two people and you instead of being vulnerable to the other person and saying,
- 1:09:43hey, let's go to therapy, or hey, that hurt my feelings,
- 1:09:45or hey i'm scared. I don't want to lose you. It's you're a
- 1:09:47jerk face, or I'm going to go to the bars and drink, and
- 1:09:50the gap just gets wider and whider and down the road five years, ten
- 1:09:54years. You think your former spouse is the adeble person, is like the
- 1:09:59worst person on the planet that you know, They're a true monster, and
- 1:10:02both people think that about each other when both people are not a monster.
- 1:10:05Now, maybe one of them is, maybe both of them are, but
- 1:10:08more often than not that's not the case. So well understood, it's systems
- 1:10:12thinking, it's systems theory. It's well taught and understood within the marriage of
- 1:10:16family therapy world, within the relational therapy world that I'm a part of.
- 1:10:20And it's not something that is easy to comprehend. It's much easier to scapegoat
- 1:10:25and to yell at the ruby Frankie's or yell at the other side of the
- 1:10:28political spectrum and say they're the problem, we need to get rid of them,
- 1:10:31instead of recognizing that we all play a part potentially in the problem.
- 1:10:36And so when we have this widening gap, you're going to have more of
- 1:10:41this kind of thing, because you have this siloing of thinking and philosophy and
- 1:10:46behavior that is by its nature completely impervious to outside groups. Because it has
- 1:10:53been identified that the outside groups are idiots or devil people or lost their way,
- 1:10:58or sinners or conservatives or you know, fascists. You know, it's
- 1:11:01just like, I can't everything they say is discountable and everything we say is
- 1:11:05golden and awesome. You know, it's it's not sustainable, and it wasn't
- 1:11:09always the case. In the seventies and eighties and nineties. It was bad,
- 1:11:13but it wasn't this bad, and we can all do something to change
- 1:11:15it. The problem is our chrismatic leaders are politicians. They benefit from that
- 1:11:19split because they get no scrutiny when they are identified as a chrismatic leader within
- 1:11:26the end group, because the more afraid we are, the more we latch
- 1:11:29onto a chrismatic leader, regardless of what they do. This I see as
- 1:11:32a symptom of that. I see her and possibly even the protections and the
- 1:11:38privilege around her. If CPS and the police didn't do anything, they could
- 1:11:42have felt like, well, Ruby Frankie's one of us, you know,
- 1:11:45she's one of the privilege, she's one of the conservatives, she's one of
- 1:11:47the religious people. So I'm not going to do anything. But I don't
- 1:11:50know. I kind of doubt that's the case for all the CPS workers.
- 1:11:55But but this at least a mindset of a parent that believes and then all
- 1:11:59the followers. You know, she is a monster that is partially created by
- 1:12:03herself and her parenting that she went through when she was a kid. But
- 1:12:06she is also, in my opinion, created by the millions of followers that
- 1:12:12praised her every day and told her she was great and gave her money by
- 1:12:16watching videos or donating or whatever. You know, it's a systemic problem.
- 1:12:20It's not just an individual that we need to change. All right, Well,
- 1:12:24it's a journe there. Tune in next time when I continue following this
- 1:12:27story, and everyone, please take care of yourself because you deserve what you
- 1:12:30really really do