Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 85
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, true crime cases five four, three, two one one one
- 0:21one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. The dingo ate my baby. Literally many people have heard or used
- 0:46the humorous quip a dingo ate my baby. The origin of this phrase is
- 0:52rooted in a tragic series of events that happened near the base of Ayer's Rock
- 0:56in the center of the Australian Desert. The tale is a mystery to this
- 1:00day. It was around eight o'clock at night sometime in August nineteen eighty thirty
- 1:06two year old Alice Lynn Chamberlaine and her husband, thirty six year old Michael,
- 1:11were sitting around a campfire. Two of their three children, Reagan,
- 1:15four and Azaria, only nine weeks old, were already asleep inside the family
- 1:21tent. Meanwhile, their oldest child, Aiden, wanted something to eat before
- 1:26going to bed himself. This seemingly innocent request would change their family forever.
- 1:33Thinking her children were safe, Alice left the opening to the tent unzipped while
- 1:38she and the seven year old went to pick out a snack. While on
- 1:42the way back. It was Michael who asked his wife if the noises coming
- 1:45from the tent were Azaria crying. When she went to check on the baby,
- 1:49she cried out, my god, the dingoes got my baby. Hearing
- 1:55his wife's cry of panic, Michael rushed to the tent and found Azaria's blankets
- 2:00scattered about and his child missing. Within minutes, a group of nearly three
- 2:05hundred people were brought together to search the nearby area, even though it was
- 2:08pitch blackout. Alice had claimed to have seen the wild dog walking away from
- 2:14the tent. She said that it had been moving its head from side to
- 2:17side, but from the angle she had seen it, there was no way
- 2:21to tell if it had anything in its mouth. Despite the good intentions of
- 2:25those who participated in the search, they didn't find any trace of the child.
- 2:31By the time they returned empty handed, a group of women had begun
- 2:35a prayer circle, and Lindy was attempting to settle aident down who wouldn't stop
- 2:38crying, don't let the dingo eat our baby. By this time, a
- 2:44local police officer, Frank Morris, had arrived on the scene to help with
- 2:47the organization of the search, but even he believed the child to be dead.
- 2:53The story over night became a sensation, and television crews were showing up
- 2:57in hopes of speaking to the grieving family. For his part, Michael agreed
- 3:01to speak with them, though he might have been telling them only what his
- 3:05wife had told the police. By the end of the day, people were
- 3:07starting to question the validity of whether a dingo would steal into a tent and
- 3:13snatch a baby. Despite the media's suspicions, local police took the story at
- 3:17face value and started shooting all of the dingoes and other wild dogs in the
- 3:22area in hopes of finding the child's remains still in their stomachs. Even though
- 3:28they employed this extreme method, no evidence was found inside any of the animals.
- 3:34A few days later, the Chamberlains made their way back home to Mount
- 3:37Isa, Queensland. As members of the Seventh day Adventist Church, they found
- 3:43the strength to deal with her tragedy in their devoted faith. This also had
- 3:47people raising eyebrows, since they didn't believe the parents were appropriately disheartened by the
- 3:52loss of a child. Much of the absence of sympathy can be attributed to
- 3:57the family's religious beliefs. The family found themselves being looked at with what can
- 4:01only be described as an angry curiosity, given the only thing that most people
- 4:06knew about their faith was the modern disapproval of alcohol, gambling, jewelry,
- 4:12makeup movies, and television. Basically, they were looked at as odd rather
- 4:17than a family trying to go through the grieving process. It would be another
- 4:23eight days before any sign of baby Azaria was found. Another visitor to the
- 4:28site had been walking on the western side of Ayr's Rock when they came across
- 4:31some clothing. Upon closer examination, it was identified as a bloodstained stretch suit,
- 4:39bib, singlet and booties. The problem was there was nothing left of
- 4:44the baby. It could have been believed that the dingo had removed the child
- 4:47from its clothing and taken the would be meal back to its lair. This
- 4:53would have been believable except for the stretch suit had been found inside out.
- 4:58The idea that a wild dog had had been able to accomplish this feed was
- 5:01far fetched. Another possibility was that the baby had been dropped by the dingo,
- 5:06only to be found by a local dog who took the child's body back
- 5:11to its owners. When faced with a grizzly discovery, the owner, not
- 5:15wanting to explain why the body had been found by them, simply buried the
- 5:19child again, though this was hard to accept since it didn't make sense why
- 5:25the child wouldn't have been buried while still wearing her clothes. The most outlandish
- 5:30claim was the one where people suggested that the family had taken the baby to
- 5:33the top of Air's Rock and performed some sort of ritual sacrifice. If the
- 5:39family was to be implicated in the child's death, The most likely story was
- 5:44that of a rumor being spread around about Azaria having fallen from a cart in
- 5:47the supermarket and having suffered a seizure, after which Michael and Alice decided to
- 5:53kill her. As police gathered and tested forensic evidence, the Dingo story continued
- 5:59to fall apart. Around the Chamberlains, they took a stretch suit and dragged
- 6:03it from the campsite to the site where the bloody clothes were found. During
- 6:08this test, charcoal was smeared on the clothes that came from the brushfires that
- 6:12had recently occurred. When the bloody clothes had been examined, none of this
- 6:16substance had been detected. Police also put baby clothes on a dead goat and
- 6:23placed it in the dingo pen at the Adelaide Zoo. The body was torn
- 6:27apart and buried in various areas in their habitat. This test also showed authorities
- 6:32that the puncture marks found on the bloody clothes were not consistent with teeth marks.
- 6:38Blood patterns also seemed to indicate that the child had been sitting upright when
- 6:42the injury occurred. When journalists confronted Michael with this and question him whether he
- 6:47still believed a dingo took his child, he admitted that it was possible a
- 6:53person had walked off with the child, but they would have to be a
- 6:56maniac to have done so. By this time, the chamberlains were dealing with
- 7:00more than hostile curiosity, but outright rage. Some people so convinced of their
- 7:06guilt even levied death threats against them. Things went from bad to worse when
- 7:12a laboratory announced that the holes in the bloody clothing were made by what appeared
- 7:15to be scissors rather than the teeth of a small wild dog. Because of
- 7:21the widespread interest in the case, the coroner, a man by the name
- 7:26of Barrett was given permission to release the results of the investigation on television.
- 7:30Scores of people tuned into the broadcast expecting, or more likely hoping, for
- 7:36him to announce that the nine week old child had been murdered. They would
- 7:41be disappointed, however, when he stated in his professional opinion that the cause
- 7:45of death was due to a wild dog. Not everyone was on board with
- 7:49the findings, however, including a Supreme Court judge who ordered a new investigation.
- 7:56In November nineteen eighty one, Just before the new new inquest began,
- 8:01police received an anonymous letter from a couple that claimed to have seen a dingo
- 8:05with what they thought was a doll in its mouth. After they threw a
- 8:09rock at it, the dog ran off, leaving behind what they quickly discovered
- 8:13to be the body of a baby. In hopes of sparing the child's parents
- 8:18the pain of seeing their baby in such a state, they stripped off the
- 8:22clothes and buried her. Despite police trying to locate the source of the letter,
- 8:26the couple was never tracked down. The new inquest officially began on December
- 8:33fourteenth, nineteen eighty one. Under questioning, Michael confirmed he may have cleaned
- 8:39up some blood within his car, but assured police that it hadn't been a
- 8:43very large volume. Alice had also been asked why she had sent in a
- 8:48blood soaked tracksuit, the one she was wearing the night her child had vanished
- 8:52to the cleaners. A police officer also admitted to finding blood on the floor
- 8:56of the vehicle after removing the seats from the family car. If there was
- 9:01any doubt that the parents were in the crosshairs of police, all doubt was
- 9:05removed when a forensic biologist stated that she discovered blood on a pair of nail
- 9:09scissors and inside a yellow container inside the car. The most damning evidence seemed
- 9:16to come from Professor James Cameron, a British legal medical expert. In his
- 9:22professional opinion, he stated that the baby's throat had been cut and the resulting
- 9:28blood had flowed downward from the wound. He also entered into evidence that the
- 9:33holes in the clothes had been made with the scissors, and since there was
- 9:37no indication of teeth marks or the presence of animal saliva, a dingo could
- 9:41not be responsible for the injuries. He also claimed that under ultra violet light
- 9:48he found what could only be described as a handprint that was too small to
- 9:52belong to a man, but too large to be a child's. All of
- 9:56this evidence pointed to only one person, Chamberlain. Shortly after Christmas nineteen eighty
- 10:03one, Desmond Sturgis finally leveled the accusation everyone had long suspected was coming.
- 10:09Alice Chamberlain was arrested and charged with murdering her daughter, while Michael was charged
- 10:15as an accessory. After the fact, nine more months would pass before the
- 10:20trial would begin. On September thirteenth, nineteen eighty two. The prosecutor,
- 10:24Ian Barker, was attempting to prove that Azariah had been killed by her mother,
- 10:30after which her body was placed inside a camera bag before being disposed of
- 10:33somewhere in the Australian desert. The entire case, however, was based on
- 10:39forensic evidence. Despite their attempts to find a motive, nothing they discovered gave
- 10:43them a reason as to why Alice would have killed her own child. In
- 10:48her defense, Alice's lawyer brought forth a number of witnesses that disputed all of
- 10:54the prosecution claims and evidence, including the blood found under the seat, the
- 10:58cause of the holes in the bloody clothes, Chamberlain's own doctor who stated she
- 11:03wasn't suffering from postpartum depression, a mother who stated that a dingo tried to
- 11:07bite the arm of her twelve year old the night before Azaria disappeared, and
- 11:13their own blood expert that denied the blood stains on Alice's track suit were caused
- 11:16by an injury to the head or slitting of the throat. The expert also
- 11:22denied the existence of a bloody handprint on the clothing. The only thing that
- 11:26both sides seemed to agree on is the evidence being presented could not be universally
- 11:31proven scientifically. In the closing arguments, the defense stated that if Alice had
- 11:37in fact killed her child, she would surely have claimed to see the child
- 11:41in the dingo's mouth while it was walking away from her, but her story
- 11:46had never strayed from the one she'd given police Originally. Despite the trial lasting
- 11:52a total of seven weeks, the jury took less than seven hours to come
- 11:56back with a unanimous verdict. Both parties were guilty on all counts. When
- 12:01it came to sentencing, Justice Murehead didn't hold back looking at missus Chamberlain.
- 12:07He stated the following there is only one sentence I can pass upon you,
- 12:13hard labor for life. For Michael's sentence, he was given an eighteen month
- 12:18term in prison, but that time was suspended. An appeal to Alice's conviction
- 12:24was immediately filed, but not before she gave birth to another child A month
- 12:28after her incarceration. In April nineteen eighty three, the Federal Court rejected the
- 12:35claims of the defense. Most thought the tale was finally at an end,
- 12:39but that wouldn't be the case. All over the country. Support groups were
- 12:43being formed. Then in February nineteen eighty four, the highest court in Australia
- 12:48totally rejected Chamberlain's appeal. Not too long after this happened, though, a
- 12:54family came forward and described how a dingo had dragged their child from a car.
- 13:00In addition to this, Derrick Roff wrote to the National Times. In
- 13:05this letter, he stated that a dingo might attack a child given the situation
- 13:09and opportunity. In addition to this, thirty one scientists signed a letter that
- 13:13stated their disagreement with the conclusions that Kuhl had used as evidence. Even a
- 13:20psychologist who'd met with Alice while she was in prison came to the conclusion that
- 13:24he could find no reason for the criminal behavior and believed her to be innocent
- 13:28of the charges. All of these statements and pleas fell on deaf ears though,
- 13:35despite the large sentence that was handed out, Alice was released from custody
- 13:39on February seventh, nineteen eighty six, after serving just over two years of
- 13:43her life sentence. It was thought that she'd paid her debt to society.
- 13:50After her release, she and her husband continued to fight to clear their name.
- 13:54Part of this was in appearance with reporter Ray Martin. In the interview,
- 14:00she spoke openly about the charges and shared her beliefs on why so many
- 14:05may have thought her guilty. To her, it seemed normal that a mother
- 14:09who was accused of killing her own child based on rumour and speculation would react
- 14:13with anger rather than depression. During the same television program, one of the
- 14:18jurors stated that over time she had been convinced of Alice's innocence. She even
- 14:24went so far as to state that many of the other members of the jury
- 14:26had doubts themselves, but were convinced based on the forensic evidence. When reviewing
- 14:33the evidence of the case today, many people have trouble understanding how Alice Chamberlain
- 14:39was convicted, let alone suspected of the murder. No one ever questioned if
- 14:45they were a happy family or could come up with a credible reason why they
- 14:48would have killed Azaria. To this day, it is still considered one of
- 14:52the great breakdowns in the Australian justice system. In nineteen eighty seven, however,
- 14:58this miscarriage of justice was partially rectified when she was granted a full pardon.