Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Paris Hilton Doc (2020 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. When the stories about Harvey Weinstein came out in full
- 0:04force, we as a society, justifiably so had a reaction to that story.
- 0:10And that's when the hashtag me too movement started, which was a great
- 0:15thing for our society. Well, a similar situation is happening right now.
- 0:21Paris Hilton came forward and told her story about being abused in a therapeutic boarding
- 0:26school, and she contributed to the hashtag breaking code Silence movement. This refers
- 0:34to a tactic used in some of these programs called code silence, in which
- 0:39the children were forced to be silent as a punishment for opposing the program.
- 0:45Many came out before Paris Hilton came out with her story, but with Paris
- 0:49Hilton's platform, the movement is getting a lot of attention since she raised a
- 0:55lot of awareness for it with her documentary called This is Paris and we should
- 0:59be a lot of attention to this. I only recently became aware of this
- 1:03movement when the Paris Hilton dot came out and many of you asked that I
- 1:07make a commentary or a reaction video to that documentary. I had no idea
- 1:12what it was going to be about, and the main point of the documentary
- 1:15is her talking about the trauma she endured at these therapeutic boarding schools. And
- 1:21in my reaction videos, I talked about my experience was with these therapeutic boarding
- 1:26schools earlier on in my career. They're called various different names, therapeutic boarding
- 1:30schools, therapeutic treatment centers, wilderness therapy, boot camps, academies, specialty
- 1:37schools, therapeut therapy camps, rehabilitation schools, religious schools, behavior modification programs,
- 1:45troubled teen industry, and so on. After I posted my reaction videos
- 1:49to YouTube, I received a lot of emails from people who had similar experiences.
- 1:55I was even contacted by some of the women who were in the documentary
- 1:59with Paris Hilton. So I thought I would do a follow up episode about
- 2:02this topic, this very important topic. This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast.
- 2:07I'm your host, doctor Kirkkonda. I'm a licensed therapist and a professor.
- 2:14In this episode, I'm going to start with an interview with one of
- 2:17Paris's classmates. In the interview, she refers to TTI and what she's referring
- 2:23to is the troubled teen industry and after we listen to the interview, which
- 2:30is I don't know, forty five minutes long or something, I'm going to
- 2:31read some emails from some other survivors, and I'm going to read an email
- 2:38from a therapist who used to work in one of these programs and provide some
- 2:43commentary on those emails. Let's get to the interview with Kate Smith. So,
- 2:47Kate, what would you like to share with the listeners regarding your story?
- 2:53My goal is to bring awareness to professionals in the mental health community of
- 2:59the drama that TTI survivors have. When a TTI survivor is looking for help,
- 3:06there's a lack of understanding. I've run into that when I've gone out
- 3:09and looked for help in a therapist or a psychiatrist or whatnot, tried to
- 3:14explain my story and they don't know what I'm talking about. They've never heard
- 3:17of it. I've actually been told by three different therapists that they can't even
- 3:22take me because they aren't qualified. So you, personally, as an adult,
- 3:25after having survived the Trouble Team industry experience that you went through, traumas
- 3:32that you went through, and you've sought out therapy from therapist individual therapy and
- 3:38you sit down on the couch and you start to tell your story about what
- 3:42happened to you as a teenager, and the therapists either say or give you
- 3:46the impression that they don't understand what you're talking about. Is that what you're
- 3:52saying? Almost it was just they didn't really acknowledge it. In our sessions,
- 3:54I would try to talk about it and just veer away from it,
- 3:59meaning that they thought, well, yeah, that's interesting, but it's not
- 4:01really the core issue is yes, and for you this was the core issue.
- 4:05Yeah, exactly. You can explain it better than I can. And
- 4:10then you come across my reaction video to well and then even going further back,
- 4:15Paris Hilton starts to come out and talk about what happened for her and
- 4:21I'm guessing she reached out to you or you found out about it. How
- 4:26did that process work? Some other survivors that I know who have been advocating
- 4:30for many years, we've all been working trying to bring awareness to the industry
- 4:35for many years. On and off. We were doing this campaign that my
- 4:43friend Jenna Bullis had decided to reactivate called Breaking Code Silence. We decided to
- 4:51take these pictures with our mouths covered with tape and holding up these signs saying
- 4:58which programs we went to and what happened to us or what issues these places
- 5:03gave us. You know, as everyone has seen now, they're flooded on
- 5:08the internet. You know, at the same time that we did that,
- 5:12I believe that's the same time that Paris was filming her documentary. Katie McNamara
- 5:17she was in contact with Paris. She was also in the documentary. She
- 5:24showed Paris, hey, these girls are doing this. There's a lot about
- 5:28other survivors out there doing a lot of different things to bring awareness, and
- 5:31she just happened to show her what we were doing, and Paris liked it.
- 5:35She thought it was cool. She thought it was great idea, and
- 5:39so she wanted to do it too. In the film, I think that's
- 5:43what you see is Katie mcnamaras showing Paris, Hey, this is what other
- 5:47survivors are doing, and that's how that came about. Then you watch my
- 5:51reaction video. Hmm, Well, you know, I thought, I wonder
- 5:56what this guy could do to bring awareness to to the mental health industry.
- 6:01You know, I know enough about these these camps and they're varied. The
- 6:04camps that I had worked, that i'd seen in operation with the clients that
- 6:11I worked with, ranged from a small little house in Texas with five kids
- 6:19and a pastor that runs it, ranging too large organizations in Utah that have
- 6:27dozens, if not I don't know, I don't know how many kids,
- 6:30but lots and lots of kids just revolving door like the Walmart of the trouble
- 6:34team industry or the you know, the these homes, and lots of different
- 6:41types of behaviors or lots of different reports as well. Some kids would come
- 6:46back and say, yeah, I kind of liked it, and other kids
- 6:47come back would say that they absolutely hated it and that they were traumatized by
- 6:51it. So what would you like for therapists to know? No matter what
- 6:57a child says, when they come out ten years later, they're going to
- 7:01have some type of trauma stemming from it, because there is nothing out of
- 7:08these places that's actual therapy. If a child comes out of there saying,
- 7:13oh, yeah, it was pretty great, I would say that they're brainwashed,
- 7:17and give them a few years and they'll come out of their fog at
- 7:20some point and realize that they have some issues there. They were trauma,
- 7:26they're traumatized at some point. Because that's not therapy, and anyone can tell
- 7:30you that's not therapy, right. Attack therapy isn't isn't good for you?
- 7:35Right. I mean, I'm not entirely sure what you're referring to when you
- 7:39say attack therapy, but I know what I've seen, which is that I
- 7:44would not call it therapy right, and too, It's essentially behavior modification.
- 7:49They're trying to alter behavior. And their tactics include essentially punishment and scare tactics
- 8:00to shape behavior. So if a child talks back a lot, for example,
- 8:05they will say, okay, we want to stop that behavior. And
- 8:07what we're going to do is we're going to intimidate the child. We're going
- 8:11to threaten the child with putting them in the hole like you saw in the
- 8:16documentary with the Parasilton documentary. We will take away food, will take away
- 8:22their bed and blanket, we will ridicule them, will literally beat them.
- 8:28And this is all an attempt to shape behavior. As I said in my
- 8:33reaction video, that that'll work, but at what cost it because eventually kids
- 8:41will give in, usually because they're so terrified and so traumatized that they'll give
- 8:45in. But the cost is that you're traumatizing the child. And also the
- 8:50child learns that they can't really trust anybody, but can't trust their parents for
- 8:56having put them in this thing. They can't trust the individual rules there.
- 9:00They can't trust clinicians because a lot of times there are clinicians who are employed
- 9:05in these facilities. So those kinds of techniques are sometimes employed. And we're
- 9:11talked about in the Parishilton documentary. Is that what you're talking about when you're
- 9:16talking about attack therapy? Yeah, exactly. And for instance, where I
- 9:20went at Tranquility Bay in Jamaica, attack therapy was the only type of therapy
- 9:26that we had a girl. She hadn't eating disorder and she was going through
- 9:30a period of time where she wouldn't wasn't eating. The therapist said, well,
- 9:33girls, what should we do. The group came up with, let's
- 9:37get some butcher paper and let's trace her naked body or not naked, but
- 9:43like you know, just with her underwear on. Make her fill it up
- 9:46with all the things that she hates about herself. And while everyone's screaming at
- 9:52her all of her issues that we knew, like, you know, your
- 9:56dad hates you and it's terrible. Yeah, I mean there's trauma. Yeah
- 10:01yeah, I mean it's the direct opposite of therapy. It's interesting that they
- 10:03called it therapy because it's not resembling any sort of therapy technique that I've ever
- 10:09heard of. It sounds like just flat out abuse, right, And that's
- 10:15why I feel like it's so hard for survivors to reach out and get help
- 10:20because we were told that that was what therapy was, and so we're scared
- 10:24of it. It just makes me really sad, and I said this in
- 10:28the reaction video that people while they are being traumatized, which is awful,
- 10:33that's just a terrible thing, But it's this double tragedy that they're also basically
- 10:37compelled to avoid the very thing that they need to recover. Just while we're
- 10:41on the topic of this is one. Yeah, a lot of people do
- 10:46not understand the trouble team industry and what it's actually like. It's a bit
- 10:52of a niche knowledge base that as a family therapist, I ran into a
- 10:58lot because I worked with a lot of quote unquote trouble teams. So in
- 11:03my early career and just by happenstance. Learned about these specialty schools just because
- 11:11parents were sending their kids to them and then, and that's the only way
- 11:15I learned about it. I never heard about this in graduate school. No
- 11:16supervisor of mine ever talked about it. It was just something that I just
- 11:20saw my first experience. Once I was picked up by the transporters who came
- 11:26into my room in the middle of the night and there was three of them
- 11:30took me away. We drove from Snahomish, Washington to Utah in twenty four
- 11:35hours. We went to Brightway Hospital first, they where I was for I
- 11:39think two weeks before I ended up in Jamaica. While I was there,
- 11:43there was another girl and she had taken the director's cell phone out of his
- 11:48office and she called her boyfriend or something. She was actually from Utah,
- 11:54and she hit it in the bathroom and she told me, hey, I
- 11:56hit I took his phone and I hit it in the bathroom if you want
- 11:58to use it, And so I was like sure, because you know,
- 12:01you're not allowed to talk to your family or call anybody or anything, you
- 12:05know, when you're there. So I went in the bathroom and I called
- 12:09my best friend's house anyway, she wasn't there. But when I put the
- 12:13phone back in the hiding spot and we got caught, well, I never
- 12:18saw her again. But my punishment was that I got all my clothes taken
- 12:22away and I had nothing but a hospital gown. Then I had to be
- 12:28put in Then I was put in isolation. I don't know, I don't
- 12:33know how long I was in there, a couple of days. I think
- 12:35I was given like a peanut butter sandwich once a day while I was in
- 12:37there, and I was made to sit in stress stress positions. And then
- 12:43when I was let out, I was I was told. When I was
- 12:48let out, I was like I was let out and got my clothes back
- 12:50and everything would be fine, like I was. My punishment was over.
- 12:52But the director he decided it was personal because it was his personal self own.
- 13:00So he came by and said, nope, she you can let her
- 13:03out, but she doesn't get her clothes back. She has to write a
- 13:07five thousand word essay now once she still has to stay in that hospital gown.
- 13:13So mind you, I'm in general population with other teenage boys as well,
- 13:18and I have nothing, like nothing, nothing else on but a hospital
- 13:22gown. I'm in another not the regular little classroom, but like another little
- 13:28room at a little desk with my hospital gown. I have to write this
- 13:33five thousand word essay about what I did with this young male. I don't
- 13:41he was. He couldn't have been much older than like eighteen. He had
- 13:46to have been like a graduate himself, screaming at me in my face the
- 13:52whole time, telling me like I was a horror slet this and that.
- 13:54All you know that was that was like my first taste of what the next
- 14:00year of my life was going to be like. So they have an employee
- 14:05who is hired to scream at particular students verbally abusive, aggressive things. Is
- 14:13that what you're saying, that's what he was doing to me. I guess
- 14:16he was. He was kind of my watchdog, so to say. He
- 14:20followed me around the whole time. So they have this guy that it's like,
- 14:24okay, we want you to watch her, and we want you and
- 14:28it's okay, or maybe even a directive to rate her, to punish her
- 14:33for you know, using the cell phone. Yeah, that is upsetting that
- 14:39moment. You know, those moments I think are when I started to realize
- 14:43that I was not going to be able to get through this unless I really,
- 14:48really, really dug deep. And I think that's when I started to
- 14:52disassociate from myself, yeah, which was hard to come back from. That's
- 15:00the fog you talk about, Yeah, yeah, I mean it's one of
- 15:03the effective ways that we have as humans to protect ourselves from an impossible situation
- 15:11which we're trapped with the abuser and the only way to escape is to back
- 15:16away from reality. Right. I want to tell my story. I don't
- 15:22want I don't want pity or anything like that, but I do want people
- 15:24to know what goes on in these places. I want a parent to hear
- 15:28this. I want a parent who's at their wits end to hear this and
- 15:31know, Okay, I'm at my wits end with my child, but that's
- 15:35not the direction I want to go. Yeah. Well, along those lines,
- 15:37what would you recommend parents do. I would recommend that they do family
- 15:41therapy with a certified therapist, someone who is well versed in trauma, probably
- 15:50because there's probably been trauma in the family that's gotten them to this point.
- 15:54I believe that there's a lot of things that come from trauma in the first
- 15:58place that get kids in these situations of bad behavior. And I don't know,
- 16:04I'm not the therapist. You can you might disagree with me, but
- 16:08I think that there's like a like I said, I think there's a lot
- 16:11of things that come from trauma that kind of get kids in this bad behavior
- 16:15cycle to begin with, and then the parents don't know what to do.
- 16:22Yeah, completely agree. And the parents often traumatize themselves as children and are
- 16:29sufferings as you're pointing out, and the reactivity from that trauma. You know,
- 16:37you for example, you have two parents who came from different sorts of
- 16:42trauma backgrounds and they're surviving and they're they're making the best of life, and
- 16:48they're they're trying their best, and there's lack of awareness in society, and
- 16:52even if they do have awareness as a lack of access to competent therapist to
- 16:56help them and so or they don't have the health insurance that actually allows her
- 17:00that. Whatever the case is, they're thirty five years old now and they're
- 17:03they're still surviving and they're still often triggered, but you know, they're doing
- 17:08well enough. They have kids, and as they're parenting their young children growing
- 17:15up they're as parents often checking out, maybe dissociating, maybe having trauma triggers,
- 17:22maybe gaining depressed, maybe getting anxious, maybe getting distorted in their point
- 17:26of view based on their traumas, and it affects the way they parent the
- 17:30kids, might affect the conflict between the parents. The kids might observe this
- 17:34whatever and now, and so the kid is also so that the chain of
- 17:41trauma is just being passed down generation and generation. The kid grows up in
- 17:45a similar traumatic mistreatment environment as the parents did. The kid is now fifteen
- 17:51years old and for the first time has the power or the personality to fight
- 17:56back and to say, I don't like this. I don't like the way
- 18:00I'm being treated. I don't like my life, I don't feel good about
- 18:03myself. Something is wrong. This family is not as good as everyone thinks
- 18:08it is. And and I'm I'm going to do something about it. Now.
- 18:14You know, there're still a child right there. They're not an adult
- 18:18there. There's still children. Their feelings are valid, but they don't know
- 18:22how to deal with it right, They don't know who to turn to.
- 18:26And so you're going to see acting out, You're going to see drug abuse,
- 18:32skipping school, maybe having a temper at school, getting you know,
- 18:36getting suspended, maybe expelled. Grades aren't going to be fantastic, maybe running
- 18:41away from home, maybe some petty crime, shoplifting, marijuana use, alcohol
- 18:48use, maybe some sexual activity. And the narrative in society often is,
- 18:55look at that bad kid. They just need to be told what to do
- 18:56that. You know, they need structure, they need someone to be consistent
- 19:02with the rules. And I always say that, sure, I mean,
- 19:07if that's what you want to do, I guess that could be part of
- 19:10the recipe. But the main ingredient and the recipe is, let's look at
- 19:15what got us here. Let's look at the long chain of traumas that have
- 19:19been passed down from generation to generation. And in the interim, as we
- 19:26do this, we're probably going to see a continuation of acting out by the
- 19:29team. You know that it's not like just explaining this to the teenagers going
- 19:33to cause the teenager to be like, oh, thank you, now,
- 19:37I'm going to be a perfect kid. You know, they're still angry,
- 19:40they're still upset, there's still suffering quite a bit. You know, I
- 19:45can remember sessions with some teenagers where I finally got them to trust me enough,
- 19:51and they would have a lot of you know, problematic behaviors. And
- 19:56I would realize through you know, repeat experience that some of these all of
- 20:00the kids really but only some of them open up and tell me about how
- 20:04much suffering they were experiencing on a minute by minute basis. You know,
- 20:10everyone understands that teenage life on a good day is suffering. Imagine if you're
- 20:17you've never had a safe relationship, you've never been able to just you know,
- 20:25relax relationally and trust other people and love yourself and and have that space,
- 20:32you know, yeah, and and and so you know you're you're gonna
- 20:37have some unbridled emotion and behaviors about that. And then because this cultural notion
- 20:45of like, well they just need structure, then these specialty programs, specially
- 20:51schools crop up to fill that market, you know, because there's a cultural
- 20:55understanding that creates a market. You know, similar to we tell women that
- 21:00they can't look a certain way, that they have to look a certain way.
- 21:03Well, when we do that to people, these terrible notions that we
- 21:07tell people, then a market will emerge to say, hey, you know,
- 21:11if you hate your body, I know how to fix your body,
- 21:14and you can you know, go under the knife and we'll fix you.
- 21:18You know. Markets will always crop up to meet any sort of need,
- 21:22whether it's misguided or not. And so that's where these specially schools come around,
- 21:29and they're they're doing exactly what the culture wants them to do, which
- 21:33is these kids need to be told what's up. These kids need to be
- 21:36put in their place. Yeah, these kids need to be um, you
- 21:40know, given consistent rules, and eventually they'll, like a horse, they'll
- 21:44be broken and they'll they'll be good after that. You know, they'll be
- 21:48good kids after that. And it's just a false, unscientific notion, and
- 21:52and and it's just perpetuating, piling on the abuse on an already abused person.
- 21:59You are so right not to mention. I don't know if you know
- 22:02a lot about the seminars and things that we went through. No, at
- 22:07the schools, the WASP schools specifically had these very intense, some you know,
- 22:14three day seminars that came through monthly. We had to graduate this set
- 22:21these sessions of seminars to be able to like move up in the program.
- 22:25And they were very they were shouted in secrecy and they were extremely psychologically just
- 22:33ft. I can't even like, there's no other way to explain it.
- 22:37Now now we know they were based on cult practices all the way back to
- 22:41Street Incorporated. Extremely extremely, extremely just messed up and you went you went
- 22:48through that. Yeah, So I'm guessing if it is like a cult,
- 22:52it is trying to strip the identity of the individuals. Was that involved in
- 22:56it? Yeah, and also trying to through influence through charisma, trying to
- 23:06get the followers to follow. Was that part of it, Yeah, pretty
- 23:10much. And then also just exhausting us, exhausting us, pushing us to
- 23:15our limits, and then once we all kind of break and explode, like
- 23:21then like love us and oh you know, like we're saving you, we're
- 23:26your saviors kind of like that, you know, right, Does that make
- 23:30sense? Oh? Yeah, I mean yeah, it's tried and true cult
- 23:33practice that is done by all sorts of organizations. It's you tear the military.
- 23:38We all understand boot camp. You tear the person down, you strip
- 23:41their identity, and then you redefine their identity for them. You tell them
- 23:49that this is who you are now. You are now a wonderful person as
- 23:56long as you're following me, and now the the pain will stop because you're
- 24:02now fully physically and mentally in the palm of my hand, which and if
- 24:08you don't do that, then there's going to be bad consequences. And look
- 24:14at everyone else. Everyone else is in the palm my hand, so you
- 24:17better be as well. Yeah, there was those were some pretty messed up
- 24:21things, and you had to you had to get through those seminars or you
- 24:26couldn't. You couldn't advance. So if you got kicked out of one,
- 24:30oh, there was hell to pay, and you didn't, it wasn't called
- 24:33kicked out. It would be called oh, you chose out. You chose
- 24:40out, So then it was all put back on you. Yeah, So,
- 24:42like you could stand up and say hi, my name is Kate,
- 24:47and the facilitator could just not like the way you said your name. She
- 24:52could say there was one actual one woman who was a facilitator. The rest
- 24:57woman she might say, I don't think you said your name with enough confidence.
- 25:03You're done that. I mean, like it was just there was no
- 25:07reasons ever, no good reasons ever. It was just whichever way the wind
- 25:11was blowing. Yeah, well, I mean that's how colts operate. You
- 25:14know, there's sort of a weird effect when you have arbitrary punishment and disapproval
- 25:21that puts everyone on edge and puts everyone in this constant state of like,
- 25:26I better please this person. You know, I have to really pay attention
- 25:30to how they feel about me. Otherwise very, very bad things are going
- 25:34to happen to me. And you do that for a sustained amount of time,
- 25:37and eventually you just learn subconsciously it's better to not think for yourself,
- 25:44because if you think for yourself, then bad things are going to happen.
- 25:45Yeah, it's pretty awful. Yeah, and I mean the bad things happened.
- 25:51I mean those places, those things, those seminars were terrible, terrible,
- 25:56terrible things. They would have girls re enact their traumas that they that
- 26:03had happened to them in their childhood, like re enact their rapes, their
- 26:08molestations. Oh, it was, it would be. It was awful.
- 26:11Girls would be forced to go around to the boys and and say, oh,
- 26:17you know, like yo, you know you want my body, I
- 26:19want to suck you off for drugs like things like that, Like because we
- 26:23were you know, they told all the girls we were all sluts and we
- 26:26all just wanted, um, just wanted to use boys for you know,
- 26:33whatever they could give us. My god, yeah, it was awful.
- 26:38It was I mean like it's it's hardcore. All right, let's take a
- 26:42break, and when we get back, let's continue the conversation. The reason
- 26:53why not every community has these sorts of schools is because most areas have laws
- 27:03that protect the rights of humans, including teenagers, but some areas do not.
- 27:10Utah. I don't know all the laws, but Utah must have relaxed
- 27:15laws about child rights because and I was eerie as I was watching the Paris
- 27:19documentary because early on, as I was reacting, I was like, oh,
- 27:23I wonder if she's talking about, you know, these sorts of schools
- 27:29that I worked with back in the day. And I started talking about Utah
- 27:33because and I always thought that Utah was just the closest state that had these
- 27:38sorts of schools. But then when I heard Paris, Hilton, being in
- 27:41New York was dragged to Utah's. Well, I was like, oh,
- 27:44maybe Utah's like one of the only places in the United States that has these
- 27:47kinds of relaxed laws. And then you have Mexico and then you mentioned Samoa
- 27:52and Jamaica. Right, so there, it's no, it's not like they
- 27:57want to have these schools in Jamaica and Samoa and Mexico. They just have
- 28:04to because if they operated within your local area, they would be breaking the
- 28:11law. And so we have laws for reasons. They're not bad laws.
- 28:18They're good laws that protect human rights. You can't imprison people, you can't
- 28:25use force to essentially in prison innocent human beings. You can't abuse them,
- 28:33you can't do you know, all these sorts of things that you're talking about
- 28:36that it's it's abuse, it's wrong. And when you operate in these other
- 28:41jurisdictions, then they're free to do whatever they want to you because the laws
- 28:45aren't you know, there, or the regulation isn't there, or the enforcement
- 28:48isn't there or whatever. And I remember hearing that too. I remember hearing
- 28:52about the schools in Utah, and you know, kids would come back and
- 28:56tell me what happened. But then the stuff I heard about the schools across
- 29:00the border, like in Mexico, we're usually a lot worse. And it's
- 29:07yeah, a lot of physical kinds of things, and I just thought,
- 29:12well, that can't be right, Like there's no how is this happening.
- 29:18And the other thing that I'll say is that the reason some people might be
- 29:22thinking, well, maybe it's not that bad, you know, because if
- 29:29it was that bad, we would have heard about it a long time ago.
- 29:30Well, there's a lot of reasons why you wouldn't have heard about it.
- 29:33One is that children. No one believes children anyway, So when when
- 29:38kids talk about things, people are like, wow, you know, that
- 29:42kid probably deserved it or something, or they're lying or something like that.
- 29:48So even on good scenarios, people don't listen to kids. The other thing
- 29:52is is that these are kids that are been designated as difficult kids. These
- 30:00are these are troubled teens. And most people don't like teenagers anyway, and
- 30:04the troubled teens, well, all bets are off. Like everything they're saying
- 30:08is completely suspect. Right, when our parents put us into these places.
- 30:14One of the first things that they tell our parents is if your child alleges
- 30:19any type of abuse or mistreatment, that is just them manipulating you. That
- 30:25is just them trying to come home. All the kids do it, just
- 30:29ignore it. They're gonna do it. Just know that they're gonna try.
- 30:33They're going to try, so just ignore it that it's just manipulation, it's
- 30:37all lies. You know your child lies, so just just know you know,
- 30:41of course, of course we're not abusing them. So that's one.
- 30:45So your parents are already being brainwashed themselves to believe that you're lying when you
- 30:52try to tell them you're being abused. Number two, if you do try
- 30:56to tell your parents and you get caught, you get punished. So that's
- 31:02there's your's it's like a lose lose situation there. And then by the time
- 31:07you're out, like the day you get out, you're so brainwashed by that
- 31:11point you just keep your mouth shut until you finally start to come out of
- 31:15the fog, which is you know, years later, right, and you're
- 31:19just so happy to be out, and and you also don't want to go
- 31:23back, and so you know that or you've been conditioned to believe that if
- 31:27you speak for yourself or even recognize who you are in your own feelings,
- 31:32then that leads to you being thrown in the hole with just a hoospital gain.
- 31:38And you know, it's a powerful thing. Cults are a powerful thing.
- 31:42Brainwashing is a powerful thing, and and they are they have market reasons
- 31:51to do that, you know it. They make money and their stockholders make
- 31:56money when they are very effective at brainwashing kids. Now, having said all
- 32:02that, which you know it was one hundred percent real and needs to be
- 32:07addressed, there are some people that I did work with who years later would
- 32:12say that it was a positive experience. Maybe not the WASP schools, you
- 32:16know, I don't, I don't know, but like I remember this one
- 32:20kid went to this like the one I described, It was like a small
- 32:25Texas boarding school, and there weren't any of those tactics from un understand and
- 32:35it was for him as a I think he was around seventeen. He just
- 32:39liked it because he was getting away from his family and from the chaos,
- 32:44and he you know, flourished in that in that space and came back fulfilled
- 32:51and kind of ready to start the next phase of his life. So an
- 32:55investigation needs to be done on all all the various different schools, you know,
- 33:00an objective outside investigation that because there might be something that we can learn
- 33:07from some of these programs. Maybe, you know, what are the programs
- 33:10that are working that aren't using brainwashing, that are helpful, that that do
- 33:19give the kid a choice on some level, what can be done there?
- 33:23And what are the schools that are obviously problematic and what do we need to
- 33:30do that. The other reason why you might not have heard about it people
- 33:34is that when people are abused, they don't want to talk about it because
- 33:37they're ashamed of themselves, because we stigmatize it. We stigmatize victims of all
- 33:43kinds, and so when people come out, they you know, they might
- 33:49have an inkling to talk about it, but they know that if they do
- 33:52speak out about it, someone's going to attack them. They're going to be
- 33:55like, Wow, it must have been your faults, or you must have
- 33:58asked for it, or you're confused or something like that. And that's why
- 34:04Kate and others are brave and doing a public service by stepping forward and incurring
- 34:10that stigma for the greater good. Oh yeah, it's it's scary. Is
- 34:17it is scary? But you know, I'm forty years old. No one
- 34:22can call me a troubled teen anymore. I have my own my own teens
- 34:25now, and I can tell you, I can tell you for sure I
- 34:30would never in a million years send them away, no matter what. Yeah,
- 34:36anything ever, happens, we are going to deal with it altogether.
- 34:40As a family. I will do anything anything I possibly can to fix,
- 34:47to help, to nurture, to support, to you know, push them
- 34:53along into adulthood. Never never, never, never them away, Never make
- 35:00them someone else's problem. Yeah. And as a family therapist that worked with
- 35:06a lot of troubled teams, so to speak for I don't know the first
- 35:10ten years of my career, I'll tell you that, you know, nine
- 35:15of the families I worked with couldn't afford to send kids to these schools,
- 35:21so we had to make do with doing things other than that, or they
- 35:25didn't want to send the kids to the school or whatever. But very expensive.
- 35:30Yeah, they were very I mean I talked about this in one of
- 35:34my reaction videos that I remember one mother she wasn't even particularly rich, but
- 35:38she took out a second mortgage because you know, it was something like eighty
- 35:43thousand dollars or something, and she didn't have that laying around in the bank,
- 35:46and so so, and that's an average school. That's not that's not
- 35:51like the premo specialty school. It's like just like the typical one of the
- 35:55cheaper ones actually, right, it's just like a typical school. And so
- 36:00because you're paying for a prison, you're paying for food and guards and buildings
- 36:07and you know, so called therapists and blah blah blah. Anyway, so
- 36:12the thing that I would do with families is we'd have to do everything else.
- 36:16We'd have to do the family therapy route. And it's very complex and
- 36:22it's case by case basis. But the theme that I found was always present
- 36:29was a reorientation of the focus by the family and the parents in particular.
- 36:37You know that we're taught as parents that we're responsible for our kids behavior,
- 36:43which is a good thing. You know, you don't want We don't want
- 36:45kids just running wild in the streets or doing terrible things. It's up to
- 36:51the parents to address it right. Well, for various reasons, you'll have,
- 36:57you know, kids that are traumatized or some other cause and their behavior
- 37:02has crossed a threshold, and the response and the recommendation from society is like,
- 37:08well, you just have to increase your discipline. You just have to
- 37:13become more intense, because you know, we all learned that as parents.
- 37:15You have a kid who takes a cookie from the cookie jar and you're like,
- 37:21okay, Johnny, don't do that. So you reprimand and then he
- 37:24takes another cookie out of the cookie jar the next day and you're like,
- 37:28okay, you don't get any more cookies for the rest of the week.
- 37:31And then the next day he takes another cookie out of the cookie jar and
- 37:36he was like, Okay, you're going to go to time out or you
- 37:37know, we escalate and we learn through experience that that usually works. You
- 37:42know, eventually the kid will be like, okay, I guess that you
- 37:45know my parents. Yeah, not all kids right, Not all kids right.
- 37:49Most kids or some kids will learn, well, she's using her stern
- 37:52voice, so I must really be in trouble, so I probably should stop
- 37:57now. For whatever reason, trauma or other wise, ADHD. There's various
- 38:00different things that can sort of throw a wrench in that system. You'll have
- 38:06some kids that just don't respond to an escalation and discipline, and by when
- 38:09they're ten years old, they're usually a lot easier to handle. When they
- 38:15turn thirteen, all bets are off. That's when the s hits the fan,
- 38:19right, and the kid now is just like, you know, you
- 38:24can't stop me, and I'm going to do all these sorts of things,
- 38:28not always, but this is the families I would be working with a lot
- 38:30of times. And the recommendation from sometimes from a lot of therapists is like,
- 38:37well, you just got to increase your discipline. You just got to,
- 38:39you know, take the door off of their room and take away all
- 38:44their things and ground them forever and never buy them another present for Christmas or
- 38:52you know these And I would watch this fail over and over and over again,
- 38:58and so I would work with the parents with Look, I'm on your
- 39:04side. I agree that your kid is exhibiting extremely problematic behavior. They're smoking
- 39:09pot in the middle of school. They're smoking pot. They stole three cars
- 39:15in a week. They are threatening to kill you in the middle of the
- 39:21night. Are these are bad behaviors? I'm one hundred percent have kind of
- 39:25validate your concern, your feelings. It's good that you're concerned. What do
- 39:31we do about it? Though? The question, because the key to all
- 39:37families and all child development is that the child believes that you love them,
- 39:45That the child believes and knows that they can trust you. You know,
- 39:50when all bets are off, the child knows, well, I know my
- 39:54mom and dad love me. And if you cannot establish that, then the
- 40:01kid will really go off the rails. That's when things really become problematic because
- 40:08kids, you know, they're gonna do kids stuff, but they want to
- 40:14know that they're lovable no matter what, that there's an unconditional love. And
- 40:19so as the parents will escalate their discipline and also just have normal emotional reactivity,
- 40:25their resentment would build up, their distance would build, and they would
- 40:30find after you know, a few years of this, that there's zero love,
- 40:35in fact, only contempt between parents and children. And so I would
- 40:40try to orient the family more towards the bond in spite of the bad behavior.
- 40:45It's like, you know, we need a baseline foundation of love and
- 40:49bond. And that was really hard for a lot of parents because they would
- 40:54say to me, well, what do you mean, I'm just supposed to
- 40:57like let it go. And I'd be like, no, we'll get to
- 41:00it later, you know, but we have to establish the foundation of a
- 41:04family, which is love, attachment, you know, goodwill, and then
- 41:08we can get to the other stuff. But that took a lot of convincing.
- 41:14I would spend months on parents because for them, they grew up in
- 41:19traumatized situations themselves and probably weren't loved enough by their parents, and so they
- 41:23didn't even know what that looked like. And they certainly didn't feel like their
- 41:27kid deserved it because they didn't get it when they were growing up. And
- 41:30so then we have to go into their histories and sort of help them heal
- 41:32from their traumas so that they can be more open to their own children.
- 41:37It was a lot of work and it was never easy, and it took
- 41:42me over time learning how to be essentially very convincing to people because I was
- 41:50essentially laying out an argument that was one hundred percent counter to what's being taught
- 41:57to them and potentially told to them by schools and are the therapists. And
- 42:02it was very hard, I'll tell you it was. I was not always
- 42:07successful, and because parents don't want to hear that they're the problem, right,
- 42:14or that they are part of the problem, right, or that they
- 42:16bred the problem. Yeah, but it's not that it's you know, and
- 42:21all of the survivors I've talked to over the years, hundreds and hundreds of
- 42:24survivors, that is a common theme that their their parents had trauma, Their
- 42:30parents parents had trauma, trauma breeds trauma. My mother had trauma. Her
- 42:37mother had trauma. And I'm we're talking, we are talking like like great
- 42:44a trauma stuffy that you you would just be like, oh wow, like
- 42:49that is deep, Like that is deep trauma, you know, and who
- 42:54you just you can't get away from it, no wonder, no wonder.
- 43:00I was out running around town, you know, every single day after school,
- 43:07not doing my homework, running around with boys or you know, running
- 43:12around with my girlfriends and smoking pot and whatever I was doing, you know.
- 43:15And I was from a nice family. My parents were very nice,
- 43:20well respected people. They both worked nice jobs. We had money, you
- 43:27know, nothing. I didn't want for anything, but man, I wanted
- 43:31for love and attention because they both had so much trauma in their own past
- 43:37that they just didn't have enough like love to give me, you know.
- 43:42So I think that was what made me go a little sideways as a teenager.
- 43:49And so you're you're right on the money. You are right on the
- 43:51money. These schools are not the answer. They are not the answer.
- 43:54Loving your kids more is the answer. Yeah, And to lay out the
- 44:00common thing that I would see with teens, because you look at the behavior
- 44:04and because you know, teens come across often like they don't care anyway,
- 44:07because they care so much that they're so scared of that vulnerability that they try
- 44:13to act like they don't care. But teenagers deeply, deeply care about their
- 44:17parents and their families and you know, being accepted. But they're so terrified
- 44:22of that, particularly if they've been traumatized, that they try to act like
- 44:24they're not. And so, you know, they're fifteen years old and terribly
- 44:29insecure but acting like they're not terribly dependent, trying to act like they're not,
- 44:32and they're at school and they feel terrible about themselves. They might have
- 44:42a history with a couple other kids in the class, they might have a
- 44:45history negatively with the teacher, and they don't know who to turn to,
- 44:51and they don't even know their own emotions because they were never giving a chance
- 44:53to think about it. They don't trust other human beings because no one's ever
- 44:57really been there for them, and so they're just a ball of suffering and
- 45:00distress sitting in class, whereas the kid right next to them doesn't have any
- 45:05of that distress. And so you're fifteen years old and you're just like you
- 45:09have nowhere to turn, you're you're in distress, and you don't trust other
- 45:15people, you don't even know what's going on with you. You're just looking
- 45:19for something to distract yourself. Well, there's a lot of things that are
- 45:22very distracting. Marijuana one will distract because the whole procedure of sort of scoring
- 45:28it and you know, figuring out a place to smoke it. But also
- 45:31the substance will sometimes numb feelings and make the distress go away. Sex will
- 45:38numb it, alcohol will numb it. Skipping school so that because you know
- 45:44to be distressed. You know, all of us understand this that if you're
- 45:46in a bad mood or you're sick, doing going to work or going to
- 45:52school is double problem. Right. It's like, not only do you feel
- 45:54miserable, but now you are in a place you don't want to be.
- 45:57You'd much rather if you're suffering physically or emotionally, you'd much rather be in
- 46:01sort of the best case scenario. Well, school is not best case scenario.
- 46:06Hanging out with your friends behind the dumpster is the best case scenarios.
- 46:09That's a relaxing, safe place, you know, So you're sitting there in
- 46:14class and you're suffering, and when you get caught and you're in trouble and
- 46:20you're pulled into the vice principal's office and your parents are called and they's like,
- 46:23why did you do that? You don't say, oh, well,
- 46:25I have trauma, and mom and dad you have trauma too, and so
- 46:30you know, I'm just looking for some way to get through my day,
- 46:32and I'm really sorry I did it. I just I just don't know what
- 46:36else to do because I'm a kid and I'm you know, kids don't say
- 46:39that, right, They say because I wanted to you asshole, That's what
- 46:43they say. Because you're a terrible parent, because this school is bullshit,
- 46:47that's what they say. But as a therapist, you have to be able
- 46:52to see through that and you have to be able to know that there's there's
- 46:57a reason for all that, and when you get called into these families,
- 47:02you have to help everyone understand that. And that was a lot of my
- 47:07job, honestly, was I would say, I don't know, a good
- 47:09five to ten percent of the work that I did with families was actually therapizing
- 47:14the schools. Was I would go to the schools and I'd be like,
- 47:16okay, so let me help you understand where that behavior is coming from,
- 47:21and they would appreciate it'd be like, oh, that makes a lot of
- 47:23sense, you know, because it's so tempting to just say this is a
- 47:29bad person, this child is a bad child. You know. It's very
- 47:35tempting to do that, and I get it because it's very frustrating. You
- 47:38feel like a failure as a parent or a teacher because you're trying and it's
- 47:44not working, and so it's terrifying to think, wait, is this my
- 47:49fault, is some sort of deficiency for me? Well, how about we
- 47:52all just decide this is a bad child, This is just a bad kid.
- 47:55You know that that'll relinquish us, you know, that'll save us saw
- 48:00and the kid will agree, yeah, I am a bad person, you
- 48:02know. And so that's what I would see. And it didn't make it
- 48:08easy to deal with as a therapists. It wasn't like I was not a
- 48:14victim of the child's abuse sometimes, but this was the perspective that when I
- 48:23did see success, this is what was the beginning of the success. It
- 48:29wasn't the full story because there were a lot of things you had to do
- 48:31after that, but that the attitude of understanding where it comes from, conceptualizing,
- 48:37believing, understanding that the child is suffering way more than the other kids
- 48:42are and they have no other way of dealing with it. Understanding that building
- 48:46the bond, just trying to just lower the distress for the child. That
- 48:53was the beginning of what would work for them. But there's so few people
- 48:59out that understand it, and frankly, you know, only a percentage of
- 49:04family therapists even understand that. Well, hopefully more start to understand that because
- 49:09hopefully a lot of these places get shut down. Is that your hope?
- 49:13Yeah? Is that going to happen right now? There's a petition on change
- 49:17dot org that you can sign to hopefully shut down the Provo Canyon School,
- 49:28the one that was in the documentary of this is Paris. That is a
- 49:31large that is one of the large that's one of the big players. Provo
- 49:35Canyon School one of the big players in the t TI. The belief is
- 49:40if we can get Provo shut down, it will start a domino effect.
- 49:45We can start getting some others, so, you know, shut down,
- 49:47you know, kind of just I would also say, and maybe y'all are
- 49:51thinking about this as well, is that the laws have to be changed.
- 49:53There's a lot of legislative work going on in the background as well. It's
- 50:00really difficult. It's been I mean years and year, twenty years it's been.
- 50:05We've been you know, survivors have been trying to get the laws changed.
- 50:08Um, you know, we get shut down quite a bit because it's
- 50:13a lot of good old boys playing the game as well. And well money
- 50:17is involved, right yeah, and multi billion dollar industry. Right. But
- 50:22given the awareness that is that Paris Hilton is helping with, maybe yeah,
- 50:30we'll get it done this time, I hope. So you know, never
- 50:34had a platform this big to shout from. So hopefully we're in it for
- 50:39the long game. So you know, we're not going to give up.
- 50:44And uh, you know, this isn't about me, This isn't about Paris,
- 50:47this, this isn't about um necessarily, you know, all the survivors
- 50:53that are out there plugging away at all of our little projects. But you
- 50:58know this, this is a about the kids that are in the schools right
- 51:04now that are suffering and being abused. When when I say that, I
- 51:08mean the petition to get the school shut down, because that's what's happening that
- 51:14you know, there's children in the school right now being abused. So yeah,
- 51:19go to change dot org and sign that petition shut down the abusive Provo
- 51:24Canyon School. Currently there's about eighty thousand that have signed, and they want
- 51:30to get to one hundred and fifty thousand people. So shut down the abusive
- 51:34Provo Canyon School at change dot org. All right, Kate, Well thanks
- 51:38for coming on the podcast. Yes, thank you for having me. Thanks
- 51:43for doing your part to raise awareness for this. It's definitely something that I
- 51:49have been thinking about for a long time. I you know, this documentary
- 51:54and you have, you know, increased my awareness because up until why the
- 52:00documentary and talking to you, I just had my own, my own anecdotes,
- 52:04my own experience with the kids and the families, which was limited,
- 52:09and I thought, well, maybe I just had a bad sort of batch
- 52:14there. But to hear all the stories, you're like, whoa, I
- 52:16was just seeing the tip of the iceberg with the kids that I was working
- 52:20with, and we definitely need to change this. It's it's on its face
- 52:28unethical to treat any human being this way, and it's obvious. And as
- 52:34an addition and that I would hope that people here is we don't want to
- 52:38take away a tool without providing a good tool, which is competent wraparound services
- 52:49with a competent family therapist. Right. I wanted to say that it's not
- 52:52just parents sending their kids to these facilities. Washington Stay actually sends foster youth
- 53:01and at risk youth out of state to unlicensed facilities under i EPs, Juvenile
- 53:07Justice alternatives and fostercare all paid for by taxpayers. Wow. Well, thanks
- 53:15for coming on the podcast, Kate. Let's take a break, and when
- 53:19we get back, I'm going to read some emails from listeners. All right,
- 53:30that's my interview with Kate Smith. She wanted me to tell everyone that
- 53:36if you want to reach out to her, you can find her on Instagram
- 53:38at Kate Smith dot p NW. That's Pacific Northwest or p NW Kate Smith
- 53:45dot p NW. All right, let's read some emails from other people.
- 53:51Charlotte from Georgia writes, thank you for covering Paris's documentary. I was wondering
- 53:58if you could cover other way program seminars. I just wondered what your perspective
- 54:04was, if it came from anything remotely good. All I know is it
- 54:08ripped me open psychologically and hurt many other people. And to this day,
- 54:13I still have to force myself to not just totally wall off from others.
- 54:16End of email. Yeah, so the WASP seminars referred to the Worldwide Association
- 54:23of Specialty Programs and Schools. Worldwide Association of Specialty program and Schools, this
- 54:30is the WASP program. And in the I don't know, I wasn't there,
- 54:35and I couldn't find any super reliable detailed descriptions of what was happening.
- 54:38But we heard Kate Smith actually describe some of that, and for Charlotte from
- 54:45Georgia, she's saying something similar that they would call this therapy, but it
- 54:51wasn't clinical. And in these schools they'll say, okay, we're going to
- 54:55do this form of quote unquote therapy. But as far as I know,
- 55:00and you know, maybe if they were here they could defend themselves, but
- 55:04as far as I can tell, these were just ways of breaking people down
- 55:09and abusing people into compliance, and then they just slapped the name therapy on
- 55:15it because then if anyone was auditing them, or if parents were looking into
- 55:21it, they could say, well, this is a therapy program instead of
- 55:23calling it what it is, which is an abusive program. I don't know.
- 55:29I'd have to see the research. I'd have to see it actually in
- 55:32action, but from what I can tell, what they would do is they
- 55:37had a pretty It's interesting because in a certain way, these programs were allowed
- 55:44to do whatever they wanted to for decades, and they were developing this way
- 55:51of controlling people's behavior that was away from what I can tell eyes of the
- 55:57academic community or the therapeutic community, and I think they were discovering some very
- 56:04interesting things. You know. It's sort of like how the Nazis were experimenting
- 56:08on their prisoners in a very unethical way, and we actually learned a lot
- 56:12from that. There's actually research from that that we learned from in this extremely
- 56:17unethical research. And because you know, if you want to research, okay,
- 56:22how do you control people's minds? You can't really do that ethically,
- 56:27right, So these programs have been essentially learning how to do that away from
- 56:31any kind of scrutiny, and from what I can tell, they developed,
- 56:37and this is only based on limited information, they developed essentially a program of
- 56:40cult brainwashing of people, a way of breaking people down and their identities you
- 56:45know, Kate actually talked a little bit about that as well, and now
- 56:50Charlotte is talking about it as well. How she's saying it ripped me open
- 56:53psychologically and to this day she has to force herself to not totally wall off
- 57:00from others. And you know, this is very concerning, right that we
- 57:06have these programs that could be using some of these tactics. Now, I
- 57:12suspect that many of these programs are not using these tactics, or are using
- 57:19good tactics if we will. But the fact is, from what I understand,
- 57:23we don't have enough eyes on the situation right because it's there's not enough
- 57:30awareness about what's going on over there. Anyway, Let's read another email here
- 57:36from Elizabeth and she was Elizabeth Martin in the film. This is another one
- 57:40of the women from the Paris Hilton documentary. I saw your reaction videos regarding
- 57:46Paris's documentary. Paris and I were in Provocanyon together. I was very sick
- 57:53with anorexia. Paris and I had the same therapist, so we had group
- 58:00two times a week for at least two hours together. Paris was an amazingly
- 58:04kind and authentic teenager. Paris was super smart, I can absolutely corroborate her
- 58:09allegations of abuse that happened at the school. I'm okay now, I have
- 58:15five fantastic kids, a career, and a husband who is amazing. I
- 58:19still struggle with PTSD, but I do pretty well. One thing that these
- 58:22facilities do is fail to address the family system that led to these issues and
- 58:29then often send girls right back to those situations. For me, when I
- 58:34disclosed sexual abuse at the school that i'd been through, the PhD therapist said,
- 58:39that's that's how the person showed love. So I just want to read
- 58:44that sentence again because it's just awful for me. When I disclosed the sexual
- 58:47abuse I had been through, the PhD therapist said, that's how that person
- 58:52showed love to you. These facilities also use seclusion and restraint punitively. The
- 59:00medical neglect that occurred cost me a lot of kidney function and lung function.
- 59:07A few of the really insidious after effects of these places like Provo, that
- 59:13are overlooked are the people. Often you know, the kids often develop a
- 59:17fear of therapy and psychiatrists, and the abusive practices in these schools leave us
- 59:22as easy pickings for abusive partners in the future. I used what happened to
- 59:28me as motivation to be successful. Being an attorney who specializes in child victim
- 59:34advocacy seems to be one way I could help prevent other kids from going through
- 59:38what we did while there. Paris was the mother hen to the younger kids.
- 59:45She truly is a great person. Paris has a lot of depth to
- 59:49depth to her. I'm really happy others will see that now. End of
- 59:52email. So yeah, I mean, I don't have much to say other
- 59:57than the words speak for themselves there, all right. Going on to another
- 1:00:00email here from Jillian, she writes, and by the way, I have
- 1:00:04permission to read all these emails. And I asked them explicitly if they wanted
- 1:00:07to remain anonymous, and none of them did. They just said, oh,
- 1:00:12I want my name to be out there because I want to stand proud
- 1:00:15and tall. Gillian says, Hi, doctor Kirk, I was watching your
- 1:00:19recent podcast on the Paris Hilton documentary where you talked about wilderness therapy and boarding
- 1:00:24schools. I went to both wilderness and therapeutic boarding schools as well. My
- 1:00:30older sister also went to residential treatment. Me and my sister had very different
- 1:00:36outcomes from these boarding schools. My experience in Wilderness was really good for me.
- 1:00:42My sister is bipolar and struggled with drug addition and abusive relationships, so
- 1:00:46I think her time and treatment mostly just kept her sober for a couple of
- 1:00:50years. When she came back, she pretty much went back to everything that
- 1:00:54had gotten her sent away, and eventually it was doing even worse than before.
- 1:00:59She finally resents our parents for sending her there. The Wilderness program that
- 1:01:04I went to claims a pretty high success rate. However, the people I
- 1:01:07graduated with have varied a lot in their experiences after graduation, so it's really
- 1:01:13hard for me to believe those claims and of email. All right, So
- 1:01:16for Gillian, she's saying for her sister it was similar, I guess to
- 1:01:21Paris and to Kate and Elizabeth and these other people about what they went through.
- 1:01:28But for Jillian, she's like, well, I went to one of
- 1:01:30these things, and you know, it's pretty good for me. I really,
- 1:01:32I really enjoyed it. It was an opportunity for me to get some
- 1:01:36therapy or out into the wilderness, met new people, change some perspectives,
- 1:01:40whatever, And yeah, I think that's important that's an important part of this
- 1:01:45is that it's really programmed dependent. And I in the reaction videos that I
- 1:01:53made, I talked about how I had a supervise who actually did this sort
- 1:01:59of work at a student, someone that I knew pretty well. He did
- 1:02:02this prior to become a therapist. In fact, I think he might have
- 1:02:06even became a therapist because he wanted to be a clinician at these at this
- 1:02:10wilderness school that he was in charge of. Actually it's a very small operation,
- 1:02:15and I think he might have been with one other person, but at
- 1:02:20any rate, he would take adults or teenagers, and so there's a teen
- 1:02:28version and then there was an adult version, and the people would hike out
- 1:02:31into the woods together and there'd be a few days where you'd camp out all
- 1:02:37together, and there would be activities and you'd talk about your feelings. And
- 1:02:42then for a number of days, each participant would be escorted to a part
- 1:02:49of the wilderness far away from the camp at the main camp, and the
- 1:02:52individuals were expected to stay in that place by themselves, without any one else,
- 1:03:00with no tent and no food, only water, and for several days
- 1:03:07they just sat there and thought, or you know, played with the fish
- 1:03:12or the frogs or whatever they did, you know, for number for the
- 1:03:15teen version, it was something like for a few days, and for the
- 1:03:16adult version, I think it was like for a full week or something.
- 1:03:21And it was voluntary, so the kids weren't forced into it, and obviously
- 1:03:25the adults weren't forced into it. And then you brought the kids back in
- 1:03:30or you brought the adults back in, and then you had sort of a
- 1:03:34wrap up set of days where there'd be more talks about your feelings and about
- 1:03:39what you experienced and bonding, and then you'd go home. And from my
- 1:03:45supervise's perspective, it was a wonderful thing, and the way he described it,
- 1:03:50it sounded really great. So these types of programs are extremely varied.
- 1:03:57You have that situation where the kids sign up for it they actually say,
- 1:04:01oh my god, that sounds amazing to get away from all the screens and
- 1:04:04the gadgets. And you know, my friend went through it and it sounded
- 1:04:08amazing, and I like the outdoors and you know, mom, Dad,
- 1:04:12sign me up. I want to go. So you have those kinds of
- 1:04:15schools or programs or whatever we want to call it, and then we have
- 1:04:19the sort that are presented in the Paris Hilton documentary, where it's essentially a
- 1:04:25prison that sends kids into jails to be abused. And I don't use those
- 1:04:33terms lightly. The kids are under lock and key, they are forced to
- 1:04:39take medications, they're they're forced to be in isolation, they are physically abused.
- 1:04:46And in the United States these exist and abroad, so you have schools
- 1:04:51in Mexico and Jamaica. Apparently I didn't know about that one in Guam.
- 1:04:56I hadn't heard about that one until Kate talked about it. So there's a
- 1:05:00wide variety. And that's part of the problem is that it to just blanketly
- 1:05:05say all these programs need to be shut down is ignorant of that variability.
- 1:05:12What needs to be happening is auditing. Is an outside auditor that looks into
- 1:05:17these programs and make sure that they follow certain ethical guidelines. There needs to
- 1:05:23be essentially an ethical code, especially in the United States. I mean,
- 1:05:27I guess you could say, well, you know, if these organizations exist
- 1:05:31in other countries, it's going to be hard to regulate that. But you
- 1:05:35also could pass legislation that could make it illegal for parents. The United states
- 1:05:40to send kids willingly to some of these programs. I mean, as I
- 1:05:44was saying in when I was talking with Kate, that we have laws about
- 1:05:47child welfare for a reason, and these programs arguably are you know, violently
- 1:05:56breaking these laws. So so anyway, for Jillian, she's like I had
- 1:06:01a great time and my sister had a terrible time. So as we move
- 1:06:08into this I and the hashtag code silence it is propagated, we need to
- 1:06:14we need to be nuanced in our approach because if we're not, I'm worried
- 1:06:19that some programs are going to come forward and say, like, we are
- 1:06:24not being abusive to our kids, and several people are going to come forward
- 1:06:27like Jillian and say I actually had a great time. And if we just
- 1:06:30say, well, they're lying or they don't really know the truth or something,
- 1:06:35then the movement is going to lose credibility. It would be like in
- 1:06:40the Me Too movement, saying that all movie producers are sexually assaulting people around
- 1:06:46them and using their power to abuse people, or any man in power is
- 1:06:50abusing people, that would invalidate the movement. So in the same way,
- 1:06:56we can't say that every single one of these schools is doing something horrible to
- 1:07:00kids. What we need to be saying is some of them are, and
- 1:07:05the way our system works, the kids have no power to speak out.
- 1:07:11And some of the kids, as Kate was pointing out, will report they
- 1:07:15did that the schools were going well for them, but they were, but
- 1:07:17they're actually dissociating or brainwashed or too afraid to tell the truth. So we
- 1:07:26just have to change how the system works, because some of these schools can
- 1:07:30absolutely exist for sure. All right, going on to another email here,
- 1:07:36This is from Katie. This is not to be confused with Kate. So
- 1:07:40we have a Katie and we have a Kate. So this is from Katie.
- 1:07:45I watched your video responding to Paris Hilton's experience and your review of wilderness
- 1:07:50camps. I am a practicing therapist who used to be a therapist at a
- 1:07:55therapeutic wilderness camp, and I just wanted to contribute a bit. While I
- 1:08:00agree that it is an extremely traumatic experience to be gooned as the kids call
- 1:08:05it chiming in here, the gooned meaning you know, goons actually grab the
- 1:08:10kids. It's interesting because I never heard of the term to be gooned,
- 1:08:15but that's the way I used to refer to it. I used to say,
- 1:08:18like, oh, so you're hiring two goons to come grab to grab
- 1:08:24your kids. So the email. While I agree, While I agree that
- 1:08:30it is an extremely traumatic experience to be gooned, as the kids call it,
- 1:08:33for most of the families we worked with, it was a very last
- 1:08:38resort for the parents. You recommended a good family therapist as a solution,
- 1:08:43but most parents couldn't even fathom having their teams cooperate with family therapy. The
- 1:08:47kid's behavior were usually too far gone. While I agree that trust and respect
- 1:08:54can be sure, that trust and respect can sure be broken because of the
- 1:09:00quote unquote imprisonment as you put it, I found that the most beneficial aspects
- 1:09:06of the camps is that it's a slap in the face and a removal from
- 1:09:11their dysfunctional patterns that they're so entrenched in. It's a chance to slow life
- 1:09:15down and realize that their patterns weren't working. I did end up leaving that
- 1:09:20position at the Wilderness Camp, and a big part of my decision was the
- 1:09:27ethical dilemma about forcing teens into therapy. I'd like to know more about what
- 1:09:32ideas you have for these situations where kids are running away, actively suicidal on
- 1:09:38drugs, severe oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder, etc. Where it feels
- 1:09:44far too late for the family relationships, for family therapy to even be possible.
- 1:09:50End of email. Right, So essentially Katie saying, I used to
- 1:09:55be a therapist at one of these camps, and I don't think you understand
- 1:10:00how horrible some of these kids behavior can be. You know, the kids
- 1:10:02are just completely out of control. And I find that, you know,
- 1:10:09it works because it's sort of like a slap in the face and you know,
- 1:10:12a sort of a wake up call, if you will, A removal
- 1:10:15from their pattern gives them a chance to sober up in that kind of thing.
- 1:10:18And that to you know, to suggest that these people should just use
- 1:10:23FAMI therapy as shortsighted because a lot of these kids will refuse to go to
- 1:10:28family therapy. Okay, yeah, one hundred percent. I mean my specialty,
- 1:10:32or you know, one of my specialties in my early career, I
- 1:10:35haven't worked with kids and teenagers and I don't know directly in probably ten years
- 1:10:41or something. But in the first ten I don't know, ten to thirteen
- 1:10:45years of my career, I a good well, especially the first five years.
- 1:10:51I would say first seven years. Let's just put it that way.
- 1:10:56I don't know why I being so micro about this, but so let's say
- 1:10:59the first seven years, about half my clients were these troubled teens. So
- 1:11:04think about that, like forty hours a week, and twenty of those hours,
- 1:11:10week in, week out, was spent working with families that had teenagers
- 1:11:15like this. So it was very much a part of my life. And
- 1:11:19a lot of people referred these people to me because one I became known for
- 1:11:25treating them, and too because I was a young man myself. I was
- 1:11:28in my late twenties and I looked really young, and a lot of teenagers
- 1:11:35felt like they could relate to me or something, and a lot of parents
- 1:11:39because a big concern for a lot of parents is, well, we don't
- 1:11:42want some old fuddy duddy therapists because our teenage client isn't going to bond with
- 1:11:47them what we want as a young therapist. And a lot of these clients
- 1:11:50were boys, so I and there aren't a lot of male therapists. So
- 1:11:57anyway, I got a lot of these clients, and a lot of them
- 1:11:59were Americans, too, by the way, because I'm Asian America and a
- 1:12:02lot of them were adopted, because there's a lot of adopted Asian American teenagers
- 1:12:08who are having issues with their behavior. But anyway, so yeah, absolutely
- 1:12:14I would see just completely out of control behavior and aggressive, hostile behavior towards
- 1:12:19me. So it wasn't like I didn't experience the problems. I mean,
- 1:12:27believe me, I was ground zero and I did in home therapy too,
- 1:12:31so I most of these kinds I'm talking about, I went to the home
- 1:12:35and I would go to court with them. I would visit them in detention,
- 1:12:42you know, because a lot of these kids would have at riscue petitions
- 1:12:44or chins petitions. I don't go into details on that, but they would
- 1:12:46be put in in detention for a couple of weeks, and I would actually
- 1:12:51go into the prison essentially, I don't know the technical term for it,
- 1:12:57but I would go in there and I would visit these kids. And there
- 1:12:59were various different of these lockdown prisons for kids. There was the main one
- 1:13:03which is on Capitol Hill, and there were other smaller ones. But anyway,
- 1:13:06I was intimate with the probation officers and the social workers and the parents
- 1:13:11and the judges and the lawyers, like you know, this was my bread
- 1:13:15and butter for a long time. And yeah, it's very very difficult.
- 1:13:20And to just say just send a family therapist in there, Yeah, if
- 1:13:27that's how I came across, that's definitely not what my message here is.
- 1:13:32What I want to say is just a little bit more detailed, which is
- 1:13:35that And as I was talking to Kate, I think you heard me talk
- 1:13:39about it, is that you need a family therapist that really knows what they're
- 1:13:43doing when it comes to these kinds of teenagers, and they're out there.
- 1:13:45There are a lot of family therapists, some of whom are colleagues of mine,
- 1:13:49are supervises of mine, friends of mine, who are very very good
- 1:13:54at this kind of work. Because it really takes a particular kind of family
- 1:13:58therapist to deal with this situation. You have to be a very charismatic therapist.
- 1:14:03In my view, the family therapist that I refer people to are very
- 1:14:11extroverted and they don't they don't sit back in the chair and listen all the
- 1:14:15time, like you got to lean in, You got to be with the
- 1:14:18families, You got to get involved, and it can get pretty chaotic sometimes,
- 1:14:25and you have to be interesting to the family because if you're boring,
- 1:14:29then the sessions just become kind of like venting sessions and family good family therapy
- 1:14:35for situations like this, you've got to get really involved and you've got to
- 1:14:40have a ton of compassion, but you also have it you also have to
- 1:14:43be a strong assertive therapist, you know, because if you don't, you're
- 1:14:46just gonna walked all over. Now I'm talking about the family therapist that I
- 1:14:50know. There's probably other kinds of approaches, but this is what I found
- 1:14:55to really work. And the thing that I found was and I talked about
- 1:15:01this a little bit with Kate in the interview, was that and it's very
- 1:15:06very complex, but the kinds of things that I found that I and I
- 1:15:11and I was never taught this. I just learned this trial by fire.
- 1:15:14Like you know, I went to graduate school for family therapy. There wasn't
- 1:15:17a single lecture or book that prepared me for these kinds of families. You
- 1:15:23know, systems theory and family therapy education only goes so far. And when
- 1:15:30I experienced these families, I was like, yeah, I mean some of
- 1:15:33the theories I learned apply kind of here, but there's so much confusion and
- 1:15:39detail here what has happened. So this is my developed sort of guideline that
- 1:15:45I that I used. And one is lowering expectations for the parents, because
- 1:15:51usually the parents still retained expectations that their kid was going to be the sort
- 1:15:59of kid that they could have a bumper sticker about. You know, my
- 1:16:01kid's an honor student, that kind of thing, and their adherence to that
- 1:16:05expectation was preventing them from realizing the reality. And a lot of that had
- 1:16:13to do with grief. A lot of parents, there's a lot of crying,
- 1:16:15you know, a lot of like just giving up on their dreams of
- 1:16:19having a kid that was the sort of kid they thought they were going to
- 1:16:24have when the kid was seven. You know, when the kid was seven,
- 1:16:27she was so sweet, and now she's like this holy terror. And
- 1:16:30so that was one thing. Another thing is to get the whole family to
- 1:16:33slow down, because there's such there's a temptation to dramatize every little detail.
- 1:16:42You know, her room is dirty, and they would just frantically try to
- 1:16:46address it right then and there, and I'd be like, Okay, let's
- 1:16:49slow down. It's not an emergency if there's no blood or no risk of
- 1:16:57blood. And I would literally have to tell people that it'd be like,
- 1:17:00you know, her cleaning her room, is that going to lead to someone
- 1:17:02bleeding out and dying? Because if that, if not, then let's slow
- 1:17:08down. It's not an emergency. And like we were saying in the interview,
- 1:17:13a lot of these parents have been traumatized themselves, and a lot of
- 1:17:15these parents were single parents. By the way, another thing that we worked
- 1:17:20on was trying to build a bond, trying to actually bring back some goodwill
- 1:17:26between the family members, sometimes again between the parents. Also choosing battles.
- 1:17:30I would often have to lay out for the parents, like if you if
- 1:17:36you go to war over every single expectation you have, you'll always be at
- 1:17:44war and your child will give up. Because if you fight about cleaning their
- 1:17:49room and getting good grades at school and making sure that they play a sport
- 1:17:58or that they get a job job, that they don't wear what you call
- 1:18:02slutty clothing, that they don't smoke pot occasionally, that they are not sneaking
- 1:18:10onto their phone at night, or you know, if you fight about every
- 1:18:14little thing, then there won't have, there won't be any room for any
- 1:18:18kind of positivity between the two of you. And when there's no positivity,
- 1:18:21your kid will give up. Because in order for your kid to be motivated
- 1:18:28and inspired to follow your rules, they have to love you, they have
- 1:18:31to like you, and if they don't like you for this kid, they
- 1:18:36will they'll really go off the edge. So let's try to prioritize here.
- 1:18:43And a lot of that for me was essentially as an expert telling these parents
- 1:18:48that they had permission to let go of certain things. There were two types
- 1:18:53of parents I found. One set of parents would be like, thankful that
- 1:18:58I was saying, you don't have to force your kid to clean their room.
- 1:19:01It's nice if their room is clean, of course, but let's be
- 1:19:05realistic here. Your kid is smoking pot every day and drinking on the weekends
- 1:19:12and stealing cars and isn't going to school. The fact that their room isn't
- 1:19:16clean is let's just say, that's further down the list of priorities. And
- 1:19:20so half the parents should be like, thank you, Kirk for telling me
- 1:19:26that that was okay, because I felt like I had to toll the line
- 1:19:29there because I felt like I was a bad parent. If I didn't,
- 1:19:32the other fifty percent of parents would look at me like that I was essentially
- 1:19:38just saying that I should. I should. I was telling them that they
- 1:19:43should let their kids do anything that I was saying that they shouldn't have any
- 1:19:46rules for the kid, and that was not what I was saying. And
- 1:19:49so I usually had to really prove to them that I absolutely supported their value
- 1:19:58of limitations to the child's behavior into you know, encouraging responsibility for the child
- 1:20:05and all that kind of thing. But for some kids, they were for
- 1:20:09some parents, they were just so rigid about these kinds of things, and
- 1:20:13it was it took a long time. And like I said, I couldn't
- 1:20:16just sit back in the chair and just try to convince him. I had
- 1:20:20to get I had to get into the thick of it with some of these
- 1:20:23parents. I'll never forget this one guy, very macho guy, and he
- 1:20:28was he was totally rigid about his kid and you know, picking on every
- 1:20:34little thing. And I was like, you know, saying, look,
- 1:20:40let's pick the top five things and let's really stick to that, but you
- 1:20:43know, six and beyond, let's let those things go for now, let's
- 1:20:45revisit those, but let's let those go for now. Let's pick our five
- 1:20:50most important things. You know, curfew, going to school, getting good
- 1:20:55grades, drug free, this kind of thing. And you know, well
- 1:21:00the fact that he has a mild attitude with you after school. Let's maybe
- 1:21:04let's put that lower on the list. I don't know, what do you
- 1:21:06think? Tell me your top five priors. This guy was just determined and
- 1:21:12so stubborn, and I I lost it. I'll never forget. This is
- 1:21:17again in home therapy, and I was actually at his place of work.
- 1:21:21Is a long time ago, but he was a construction worker, and I
- 1:21:25believe I was like he was like a foreman or a you know, a
- 1:21:29contractor or some kind of boss man. And so I was in in his
- 1:21:33sort of boss office, and I remember he was sitting behind his desk.
- 1:21:40I could have some of these details wrong, but I do remember this part
- 1:21:42of it is that I just started yelling at him. And I remember thinking,
- 1:21:46you know what, I'm done with this guy, Like I don't want
- 1:21:51to this is useless, as I was thinking in my head, and I
- 1:21:55was like, I'm just gonna tell it as it is and then he'll hate
- 1:22:00me and he'll fire me. As a therapist, and I'll never talk to
- 1:22:02him again, but at least I got my recommendations off my chest. I'm
- 1:22:08done tiptoeing around this guy, which is what I was doing. I was
- 1:22:11trying to I was trying to be very diplomatic, and I just was like,
- 1:22:15screw this, and so I just said, hey, dada, dada.
- 1:22:17You know, I really led into him, and then we started yelling
- 1:22:19at each other, and I think we might have even stood up and started,
- 1:22:24you know, really young. I don't know. I was probably exaggerating
- 1:22:27in my mind, but but we talked for a long time, and in
- 1:22:30my head it was hours because it just kept going on and on, and
- 1:22:35I started noticing that, wait, he hasn't kicked me out yet. We're
- 1:22:41still talking. And then at the end of the session, I said,
- 1:22:45I just wrapped it up, and I thought, well, you know,
- 1:22:47I let him have it, and I'm sure I'm never going to talk to
- 1:22:49Higain. And we were close enough to each other and then we just hugged,
- 1:22:56and I remember thinking, why are we hugging right now? This is
- 1:23:00weird. And then he hired me as a therapist ongoing, and I worked
- 1:23:08with him for years after that. And at in every single session we would
- 1:23:15touch on his relationship with his own father, and he would cry uncontrollably.
- 1:23:20And as he was crying, sometimes in front of his son, by the
- 1:23:25way, he would look at me and he says, he says, Kirk,
- 1:23:29every time you do this to me, you know, and I'm getting
- 1:23:30a little tier. You're just thinking about you know. He just every time,
- 1:23:33Kirk, you get to that soft spot and you know, you bring
- 1:23:38this out in me. And it was one of the most beautiful relationships I've
- 1:23:42ever had with a client. And the point is is that I couldn't just
- 1:23:45lean back, you know. That's why I said it takes a very special
- 1:23:48kind of therapist, family therapist. Now I'm not saying I'm special. I'm
- 1:23:53saying that there's a class of family therapists, maybe most family therapists that can
- 1:24:00do this kind of work where you have a good approach. You can remain
- 1:24:05differentiated, you can remain professional, but you're very much leaning in and you're
- 1:24:11not just always asking people how they feel about things. Other things is to
- 1:24:18as a family therapist is to help everyone recover from their trauma, whether that's
- 1:24:23in family therapy or individual therapy. Other things are is having family sessions where
- 1:24:30their parents express their vulnerability. Like I was saying with that one guy,
- 1:24:32he would cry in front of his son and this was a huge deal to
- 1:24:39the family as a whole. The son be his acting out decreased significantly as
- 1:24:45he saw his father crying in front of me. Now, that's not the
- 1:24:48only thing that needs to happen, but it definitely can. Depending on what
- 1:24:55the problem is in the family, it can definitely help. I mean,
- 1:25:00at the very least, it helps the kid go, oh, I guess
- 1:25:01my parents are suffering. I thought they were just out to get me,
- 1:25:05but I guess they're suffering a lot. And you know, it helps,
- 1:25:09and then you can bond and heal and you know, so being having parents
- 1:25:14be vulnerable and getting to their vulnerabilities is an important part of it, you
- 1:25:19know, and often that has to do with trauma recovery as well. Helping
- 1:25:23the child feel heard. A lot of these kids are walking around without anyone
- 1:25:29ever really listening to them, and when no one listens to you, you'll
- 1:25:33act out. Also helping the child with decision making. I did this a
- 1:25:38lot with teenagers. I'd be like, okay, so let's review your decision
- 1:25:43last weekend to run away from home for two days. And the kid would
- 1:25:47say, I didn't run away from home, and I'd be like, well,
- 1:25:50what do you call not coming home for seventy two hours? You know,
- 1:25:54like that's called running away, or at least you know, I don't
- 1:25:57know what you're going to call it. You didn't come home for seventy two
- 1:25:59hours. And I say, let's talk about the decision making there. What
- 1:26:03was going on in your mind leading up to that, And we'd break it
- 1:26:05down and it'd be like, well, I was getting sick and tired of
- 1:26:10my parents telling me what do and I just wanted freedom. And I was
- 1:26:15like, okay, what'd you do with your freedom? Well, I don't
- 1:26:17know, just played video games with my friends. Okay, so you got
- 1:26:21to play video games with your friends and that's great, and that's that's that's
- 1:26:27on the plus side of the column. It's in the pros column. Now
- 1:26:30it's like the cons of what you did. Now your parents are going to
- 1:26:35the police, they're going to the courts, and there's a chance that you
- 1:26:39could end up in detention from from an at risk youth petition because your parents
- 1:26:43are moving ahead with that now. Because they feel it's their responsibility to take
- 1:26:48action because you ran away from home, and if they don't do something about
- 1:26:53that, then they're being irresponsible unloving parents to just let kids, you know,
- 1:26:58thirteen year old just disappear from the face of the planet. Like not
- 1:27:02very many parents are going to say that they should just sit idly by with
- 1:27:06that. So, so, is there a different way that you could have
- 1:27:11got what you wanted? Maybe, like, well, I was grounded,
- 1:27:15I was like, okay, well, could you have withstood the grounding for
- 1:27:18a week and then and then hung out with your friends during the day and
- 1:27:24then got home between But you know before curfew, could could that have worked
- 1:27:28differently? Because you're shooting yourself in the foot. Now, for some kids
- 1:27:33this was not really the issue, but for some kids it was literally this.
- 1:27:36You know, some kids just have no mentoring. Essentially, they just
- 1:27:41have no one there to be like, hey, let's walk ourselves through this.
- 1:27:44You know, when I was a teenager, I had a you know,
- 1:27:48I had a rebellious sort of side to me, and I won't I
- 1:27:54won't go into the stories, but let's say police were involved at times,
- 1:27:58and I had people there that actually helped me to problem solve. I had
- 1:28:05my parents. I had coaches, you know, I was I played sports
- 1:28:10by football coaches were very dear to me. I had other people, and
- 1:28:16I would listen to them. I don't know if I thought I was listening
- 1:28:20to them at the time, but they were there to kind of just give
- 1:28:25me some advice and take interest in me. And that's a big function of
- 1:28:30being a teenager is having that kind of relationship with someone that's not an authority
- 1:28:34over you. You know, someone that you don't mind hanging out with,
- 1:28:39who isn't technically in control of your life, who can sort of objectively comment
- 1:28:45on what you're doing with yourself. Because this notion that like fourteen year olds
- 1:28:50have good decision making is just absurd, right. You know, they have
- 1:28:55a lot of needs and a lot of things pulling at them in various different
- 1:28:58directions, and it's not surprising that fourteen year olds sometimes to make mistakes,
- 1:29:02and so just punishing the kids doesn't help the kid understand how to make decisions.
- 1:29:10You know. One of the things I would talk with a lot of
- 1:29:12teenagers about was that I would say, I would tell them, this is
- 1:29:17the story. I'd tell them. In general, I'd be like, okay,
- 1:29:20kid. When I was your age, I didn't like rules either,
- 1:29:26and when I bumped up against rules, I would try to figure out a
- 1:29:30way to get around them. But I don't know what happened, but at
- 1:29:35some point in my teenage life, I figured out that if I just told
- 1:29:42my parents what they needed to hear and being honest to them, I thought
- 1:29:48maybe that would work. And so I sat my parents down one night and
- 1:29:51I actually did do this, and I told them that they didn't have to
- 1:29:57worry about me because I had a good value system, you know. I
- 1:30:03told them, like, if I'm out past curfew, you don't have to
- 1:30:06worry about me because I'm not going to do a I'm not going to do.
- 1:30:11I might be, I might do a little of C, but understand
- 1:30:14that, you know, in moderation. And I just kind of laid it
- 1:30:17all out and I said, you're just going to have to trust me on
- 1:30:20this, and I hope that you do. And my parents believed me because
- 1:30:27I was believable and I was telling them the truth. And so as a
- 1:30:31result, my parents let go of the reins and I had a great high
- 1:30:36school life because of that, and I didn't do terrible things because I didn't
- 1:30:42need to in order to have fun, and so that was me. It's
- 1:30:45not everyone, But I would tell that to kids, and I'd say,
- 1:30:48like, if you just gave your parents the benefit of the doubt and actually
- 1:30:53told them how you make decisions, then it might help, you know,
- 1:30:59I might ask, kid, I be like, so, if you know,
- 1:31:02if if someone buys a keg of beer, is it your mission to
- 1:31:08like get as drunk as you can and vomit? And they kild be like,
- 1:31:10no, I don't. You know, A lot of kids be like,
- 1:31:13you know, I don't even like drinking that much. You know,
- 1:31:15I just like to get a little high, And you know I don't.
- 1:31:17I don't like drinking a lot. I don't. I don't like that feeling.
- 1:31:20I'd be like, Okay, what if you told your parents what you
- 1:31:24just told me, Because if you told your parents what you just told me,
- 1:31:28your parents aren't going to be excited about the fact that you're getting high
- 1:31:30and that you're just having a couple of beers. But in the absence of
- 1:31:34any information, they think you're smoking pot and drinking all the time and that
- 1:31:39you have no ability to make a decision. So inspire your parents by telling
- 1:31:45them your decision making process because you're a smart kid and you know how to
- 1:31:49protect yourself. Now, of course not every kid was like that, but
- 1:31:53most of them were. Honestly, most of them, once they got out
- 1:31:56away from their parents' authority, they actually could decipher a good decision from a
- 1:32:01bad one. It didn't protect them from all bad decisions, but but it
- 1:32:05certainly was a guide that the parents were not really aware of anyway. Now,
- 1:32:13some of the kids were completely out of control for sure. So you
- 1:32:16know, I'm talking about a wide range of kids here. Other things are
- 1:32:20we would talk about natural consequences instead of creating conflict between parents and so,
- 1:32:27and this was this was a tough one. You know for a lot of
- 1:32:29parents. You know that when your kids don't do their homework, for example,
- 1:32:35the first thing you're going to do is you're gonna say, hey,
- 1:32:40how can you do your homework? Your teacher called and said that you didn't
- 1:32:44even turn in your assignment today. So that's so that's the first line of
- 1:32:47defense, right And for a lot of kids, that's all you need to
- 1:32:51do. You just need to be like, hey, your teacher called me,
- 1:32:54and you're in trouble. You didn't do your homework, and the kids
- 1:32:56like, oh crap, I'm in trouble, and then they get their behavior
- 1:33:00in line. Now there's a whole other group of kids where that doesn't work.
- 1:33:02Okay, So the second time happens, you you escalate your tone of
- 1:33:08voice. You're like, hey, we talked about this last week. Your
- 1:33:11teacher called again and said you didn't turn it in your homework. What's the
- 1:33:14deal? You know what's going on here, and you know some kids that'll
- 1:33:17work, but there's a percentage that even that second thing is not going to
- 1:33:20work for whatever reason. And so eventually this escalates into a constant level of
- 1:33:29monitoring and conflict between parents and kids. And then I would arrive and I'd
- 1:33:35be like, okay, let's evaluate this. What are you concerned about when
- 1:33:42it comes to homework? You know, what are you really worried about when
- 1:33:45it comes to homework? And the parents would be like, well, they're
- 1:33:47just supposed to do their homework, and I'll be like, okay, tell
- 1:33:49me more, like, well, homework teaches responsibility, and homework means that
- 1:33:54you're learning things. You got to learn things. You got to graduate from
- 1:33:57school and be like Okay, why do you want your kid to be responsible
- 1:34:00and graduate from school? And they'd be like, huh. You know a
- 1:34:03lot of parents they just never even thought this much through. They just sort
- 1:34:06of did what they think they're supposed to do without really thinking about why they're
- 1:34:11doing it. It's sort of like when you come to a stop sign in
- 1:34:15the middle of a desert and there isn't a car in sight, why do
- 1:34:17you stop? Right? I mean, people would just be like, well,
- 1:34:21because you're just supposed to, and I'd be like, no, why
- 1:34:25do you stop at any stop sign? You know? The real answer is
- 1:34:29because of safety. That should be the answer. I stop at stop signs
- 1:34:32because the stop sign is there to promote safety. If you just blow through,
- 1:34:38if everyone just blew through an intersection, there'd be accidents. So if
- 1:34:41you see a stop sign in the middle of a desert and there isn't a
- 1:34:44single car in sight for miles, you don't need to stop. Now it's
- 1:34:47against the law and you could get ticketed. But we have to understand the
- 1:34:51reasons why we shouldn't just follow rules and guidelines. Because the rules and guidelines,
- 1:34:58the rules of guidlines are there for a reason. So we need to
- 1:35:00know the reason and the reason why we are concerned about kids going to school
- 1:35:05and getting good grades and being responsible is because we want kids to be happy
- 1:35:10when they're older, and we don't want them to hurt other people. We
- 1:35:15don't want them to hurt others because that's not cool, and we want the
- 1:35:17kids to be happy. And when I got parents to sort of really sit
- 1:35:23with that. Okay, So when you're yelling at your kid and you're grounding
- 1:35:29them for three months because they are refusing to do their homework, you're trying
- 1:35:33to make them happy. You're you know, it's sort of like your husband
- 1:35:43gets bit by a rattlesnake and in the middle of the desert and you pile
- 1:35:48into the car and you're speeding to the hospital and you see a stop light
- 1:35:54ahead and you see no cars, you know, within miles of that intersection,
- 1:36:00and you stop at the stoplight. That's stupid, blow through the stoplight.
- 1:36:04Doesn't The stop light is there for safety because and this safety issue is
- 1:36:12you need to get your husband to the hospital. Run the red light.
- 1:36:15Think before you do shit like that. Okay, So when you're you're destroying
- 1:36:21your relationship with your child and you're driving your child's happiness, you know,
- 1:36:29into the ground because they're not doing their homework. You lost sight of the
- 1:36:33reason why you wanted your kid to do homework in the first place. And
- 1:36:39so, people listening right now, you hear the intensity of my voice,
- 1:36:43and this is the intensity I would talk to the parents because if I just
- 1:36:45sort of laid this out in a calm manner, they it wouldn't be compelling.
- 1:36:50I'd have to because it's a total paradigm shift. Now the parents would
- 1:36:56inevitably say, oh, so I'm just supposed to give up, Like,
- 1:37:00okay, good, I'm glad you said that. All parents say that,
- 1:37:02because they all did. And I'd be like, no, I'm not saying
- 1:37:05give up. I'm saying, let's have a holistic viewpoint when it comes to
- 1:37:12the child. You love your child, you want your child to be happy,
- 1:37:16and you are doing many things to help your child be happy. But
- 1:37:20some of the things you're doing are you've lost sight of why you're doing it.
- 1:37:28And research shows many children do not graduate from high school and are still
- 1:37:33happy. Many kids do not have high paying careers and don't go to college
- 1:37:41and are still happy. And many and this is what I'd always say to
- 1:37:45parents as well. I would say, and this is part of the paradigm
- 1:37:48shift. And I've said this before in the podcast. I'd say, would
- 1:37:51you rather have a successful surgeon who's an asshole and who's unhappy, or would
- 1:38:00you rather have your kid not graduate from high school and become a janitor and
- 1:38:04be happy? Which one would you rather have? And the parents would get
- 1:38:09tripped up on that. A lot of parents they'd be like, well,
- 1:38:15yeah, the answer is obvious, right, But because culture and pressure on
- 1:38:20parents is so pervasive, parents don't know how to sift through their own love
- 1:38:27for their child and what society is telling them what they're supposed to do as
- 1:38:30parents. Sometimes those things coincide, sometimes they don't. Society tells parents you're
- 1:38:36supposed to, especially middle class and upper class parents, you're supposed to raise
- 1:38:41kids who are rich and successful and dynamic, and they're beautiful and thin and
- 1:38:46have beautiful kids, and you know that have that take pictures awesome on Facebook.
- 1:38:53Like there's a whole lifestyle involved in this, and it's implicit, and
- 1:38:58no parent blicitly states this, but I would find it to be quite pervasive.
- 1:39:02And so when kids would not go to school. It would just create
- 1:39:09this vicious cycle where the parents would just lay into the kids. The kids
- 1:39:13would feel alienated and would passive aggressively not do their homework as a way of
- 1:39:17getting back at their parents. The parents would get more upset, and the
- 1:39:19thing would just go on and on and on, and then I'd step in.
- 1:39:23I'd say like, why are you doing this the parents while because we
- 1:39:27have to teach our kid to be responsible by it, like why do you
- 1:39:30want your kid to be responsible? And eventually we get to well, because
- 1:39:33I want my kid to be happy. If you know, if my kid
- 1:39:36is irresponsible, a lot of bad things are going to happen to them and
- 1:39:40they're not going to be happy. And I'd say, your kid is going
- 1:39:44to be a hundred times more unhappy if they don't feel love from you,
- 1:39:49if they don't feel that you accept them, then if they don't do their
- 1:39:54homework, take it from me. There are plenty of adults who did all
- 1:40:00their homework as kids and had no connection with their parents and grew up very
- 1:40:08unhappy people. And there are plenty of adults that I talked to who did
- 1:40:13terrible in school as a teenager but felt that foundation of love and attachment with
- 1:40:18their parents, and now as adults they're happy even though their careers aren't going
- 1:40:24fantastically. And so that took a long time, and with some parents,
- 1:40:29I literally would work on that paradigm shift for years, among other things.
- 1:40:33And so it's not easy and it doesn't necessarily fix the problem. The last
- 1:40:42thing here is oh, and getting back so to natural consequences. That's the
- 1:40:45whole point of what I'm saying here, is that we would try to get
- 1:40:48to a place where not all situations were like this. By the way,
- 1:40:54I would never just use what I'm saying, all the things I'm saying as
- 1:40:58sort of a panacea for all families. I definitely would have to adjust all
- 1:41:03this stuff depending on what the family was like and what was going on.
- 1:41:09Because of some of the families, particularly the Asian families. Not to be
- 1:41:13sort of stereotypical with my own Asian people, but a lot of the Asian
- 1:41:17kids who were acting out and doing a lot of concerning behaviors, their grades
- 1:41:23were still pretty good because of just the identity or something. I don't know.
- 1:41:27It's kind of a weird phenomenon, but I mean, certainly not all
- 1:41:30Asian Americans were doing awesome in school. But anyway, the point is is
- 1:41:35that I adjusted all this. I never just went into a family and just
- 1:41:39sort of bulldozed what I'm saying here without adjusting everything to the situation at hand.
- 1:41:44The last thing I'll say is parenting support. You know, parenting at
- 1:41:48a good day is stressful, and in these situations is like eternally stressful,
- 1:41:54and so one as a therapist, I would provide therapy, healing support for
- 1:42:00them, and I would also encourage them to talk to other parents. There
- 1:42:02were you know, there's a lot of parenting support groups around free that you
- 1:42:05can join, So there's that sort of thing. So I could go on
- 1:42:11and on for probably hours and hours and hours about what I did as a
- 1:42:15family therapist. And it wasn't just me that was involved. They were often
- 1:42:18probation officers, teachers, coaches, aunts and uncles, siblings, grandparents,
- 1:42:26you know, teachers, police officers, other people, other therapists. You
- 1:42:30know, sometimes they were multiple family therapists involved, wrap around services, these
- 1:42:35kinds of things, and I was a part of that team. And I
- 1:42:40would say that about a third of the time we succeeded by bringing the family
- 1:42:48closer together, healing the traumas for everybody to some extent, and reducing the
- 1:42:56problematic behavior in the child. Another third of the time, we got some
- 1:43:00headway with things, but the kid was still defying a lot of the rules.
- 1:43:06But the parents were less freaked out, they felt more supported, they
- 1:43:11felt like they had a good game plan. There was less conflict about the
- 1:43:16problematic behavior and the teenagers. The teenagers toned down their behavior a little bit,
- 1:43:20but it wasn't entirely gone, you know, they still would, you
- 1:43:24know, maybe disappear for twenty four hours, maybe some minor crimes, maybe
- 1:43:30ongoing pot use, this kind of thing. And then another third of the
- 1:43:34time, nothing good happened from my intervention. Like it, everything stayed the
- 1:43:39same. It was nothing I did worked either because of my faults, or
- 1:43:45the situation was just too off the rails, or no one really wanted me
- 1:43:50to help them, because a big part of this was I had to because
- 1:43:56when and it's a very stressful situation, and you family therapists out there,
- 1:44:00when these families arrive in my office, they would arrive in my office or
- 1:44:03I would be called to go to the home. No one wanted me there,
- 1:44:09so the teenager definitely didn't want to talk to me, and the parents
- 1:44:13didn't want to talk to me. The parents wanted me to talk to the
- 1:44:15teenager. The parents wanted me to therapize the teenager. The teenager didn't want
- 1:44:21to talk to me. The parents didn't want to talk about their problems.
- 1:44:25No one wanted to talk to me. So Step one was convincing everyone that
- 1:44:31they did want to talk to me. And for a lot of people,
- 1:44:35this was their first time in therapy, right, and that's a tough sell.
- 1:44:41None of them want to talk. None of them want to ask me
- 1:44:44for help. You know, everyone wants to blame everyone else, and job
- 1:44:49priority number one is getting everyone to admit that they have that they're contributing to
- 1:44:55the problem, which obviously is not easy for some of those families. I
- 1:45:00couldn't convince them that they should ask me for help, you know, and
- 1:45:06they just stayed in that space, and I just sat by and watched the
- 1:45:12train wreck, and you know, tried to get people to see how I
- 1:45:16might be able to help them with their part in it. You know,
- 1:45:19they would be complaining about the other person. I'd be like, well,
- 1:45:23that other person isn't here, right, now, but you're here, so
- 1:45:26maybe there's something you can do to change your you know, from your side,
- 1:45:30and they'd be like, no, it's not my fault, you know
- 1:45:31that kind of thing. So so there was a wide variety of what I
- 1:45:36saw, and like I said, only about a third of the time would
- 1:45:43things actually get better. So I am not claiming that there was some kind
- 1:45:48of high success rate. And any therapist who claims that when it comes to
- 1:45:56these kinds of kids is either delusional, lying, or extremely lucky with the
- 1:46:03five clients they've worked with so far or something. You know, it's a
- 1:46:08tough situation. The kid isn't mature enough to know what to do. Everyone
- 1:46:15has been traumatized in all likelihood or has some mental illness. The parents are
- 1:46:21doing everything they can, and they've got their own problems and their own shame,
- 1:46:28and they've made their own mistakes parenting and otherwise. And then I come
- 1:46:31in and I'm like trying to help people face themselves. It was a tough
- 1:46:36job to get people to be And the other thing, the other problem with
- 1:46:43this sort of therapy is like you got to be quick because this isn't long
- 1:46:45term therapy. You know, when adults come to me now. And you
- 1:46:49know my practice over the past fifteen years. Typically therapy goes on for years,
- 1:46:56so I got time to luxuriate. There's no rush. We can say,
- 1:47:01well, let's work on that over the next five years. What do
- 1:47:04you say? Okay? With these families, it was an emergency. Something's
- 1:47:09got to be done now. You know, this kid is presenting behaviors that
- 1:47:14need to be addressed now, and the family is falling apart now, and
- 1:47:18the kid could die now. And you know, sometimes I was actually a
- 1:47:23very huge concern. I had kids in gangs that were getting shot. There
- 1:47:29was a well I want to tell you the specifics because there might great confidentiality,
- 1:47:31but there was you know, a a news worthy shooting in Seattle and
- 1:47:36that one of my clients was involved in and and he almost died, and
- 1:47:41I in the hospital. It's like he's like, I, you know,
- 1:47:45Kirk, I now realized that being in a gang was wrong. You were
- 1:47:48you were right? Uh you know, it wasn't the right thing for me,
- 1:47:55you know, because I would I would tell gang members. Look,
- 1:47:57I get it. You have a group, you have a you have friends,
- 1:48:00you have a family. You feel like you can't really depend on your
- 1:48:04biological family. And so you've you've found a family. You've found people that
- 1:48:09are loyal, people that you can depend on, people that will notice you
- 1:48:14and hear you and be with you and have your back and really show that
- 1:48:19they won't abandon you. But at what cost, my friend, Like,
- 1:48:25they are asking you to throw your life away, maybe even die for this
- 1:48:32bond that you have, and is it worth it? You know, there
- 1:48:38are other ways of finding a family outside of your abusive situation that don't involve
- 1:48:44violence and death and you know, fifteen year prison sentences and you know,
- 1:48:51we would talk about that, and you know it didn't usually work. I
- 1:48:55mean, once a kid got into a gang, it's really hard to get
- 1:48:59him at because that that bond that they would build, and also the terror
- 1:49:04of retribution if they leave for some of them. But anyway, this kid
- 1:49:09is you know, he almost died and he is recovering and he's telling me,
- 1:49:14Kirky, we're right, and I'm and he was a real smart kid,
- 1:49:17and he was like, I'm not going back to those gangs, and
- 1:49:19there's you know, I'm just not going to do it. And we had
- 1:49:23some great sessions for a number of months and then one day boom back in
- 1:49:29the gang and I don't know, I'm from my memory, I don't think
- 1:49:33I ever talked to him again, because I don't think he ever showed up
- 1:49:35again. And as a therapist and new therapists out there, you know,
- 1:49:40this is just like so demoralizing to deal with that. You work so hard
- 1:49:45and then it's like one step forward, two steps back with some of these
- 1:49:50people. And the thing I'd always and this was a thing we would all
- 1:49:56tell each other as family therapist back in the day, is we'd say we're
- 1:50:00planting seeds, you know, meaning that we're planting seeds as therapists that will
- 1:50:05grow later once it's watered, maybe at twenty two or thirty two. The
- 1:50:13therapy we're doing now will grow into something beautiful then, but not now.
- 1:50:16We're planting seeds because we needed some hope that what all the hard work that
- 1:50:24we were doing as family therapists would amount to something, and it was never
- 1:50:29known. And that's one of the demoralizing things about being a therapist is that
- 1:50:32it's hard to Among some populations, it's hard to know anything you're doing is
- 1:50:38helping because you're you're standing you know, in front of a dam as the
- 1:50:45dam bursts and you're trying to hold back the water and you're you're putting everything
- 1:50:49that you got into the effort, and there's it's just overwhelming. There's there's
- 1:50:55too much trauma, there's too much going against you, too much going against
- 1:51:00the kid in the family, and and it's just it's heartbreaking. And so
- 1:51:05you just have to say, I'm planting seeds. I'm planting seeds. So
- 1:51:13that's a long winded response to you, Katie. I'm sure you can relate
- 1:51:16to it, as you worked with a lot of those kinds of people in
- 1:51:19these wilderness camps and with some of these kids, you know, a sort
- 1:51:26of lesser of two evils. You'd be like, as a parent, you're
- 1:51:29sitting there going, Okay, I don't want to imprison my child. I
- 1:51:32don't want goons to come and take my child away. That's heartbreaking to me.
- 1:51:38But if I don't do something, this kid is going to die because
- 1:51:41they're in a gang. Or this kid is using heroin. That's another thing.
- 1:51:45So y'all has a heroin problem. And there are a lot of there
- 1:51:46are a lot of teenagers using heroine that I would treat and they would just
- 1:51:53refuse to stop it. They would refuse to go to treatment, they would
- 1:51:55refuse sobriety. And what do you do as a parent? What do you
- 1:51:58do as a parent when you're sixteen year old is using heroin and everything that
- 1:52:01you're doing is not stopping them from using heroin? What do you do?
- 1:52:05Do you just you just let it happen? And because heroin kills and one
- 1:52:11of the clients that I had did die from heroin, because heroin is very
- 1:52:14easy to overdose. Opiates are very people know this. But but um,
- 1:52:19yeah, I had a client that died from from that. Very smart um
- 1:52:25you know, and a young woman. And I had so many sessions with
- 1:52:29her and she was tough to work with. She was she was, you
- 1:52:34know, hard to talk to. She hated being in therapy with me.
- 1:52:42We made it work, but um, but she died. And it's actually
- 1:52:47kind of hard for my brain to accept it. Actually, it's it's like,
- 1:52:49I don't you know, talking about it right now, It's like I
- 1:52:53don't think I I don't think my brain fully believes that she's gone. I
- 1:52:58mean, it was a client from a long time ago. But anyway,
- 1:53:00what are supposed to do as a parent, You've tried all the other things,
- 1:53:04and then someone comes along and says, look, if we can have
- 1:53:06goons come and take your kid to a wilderness camp. And by definition,
- 1:53:11they won't be using heroin. By definition, they won't be going and hanging
- 1:53:16out with gangs. They won't be on the corner selling drugs. Because they'll
- 1:53:20be there. It's sort of a prison, but it's also like a good
- 1:53:25time. We have activities and therapy, you know. And what do you
- 1:53:29do as a parent? Do you do nothing? Do you say, well,
- 1:53:32I don't want to spend the money, or well I don't want to
- 1:53:38I don't want to inconvenience my teenager, you know, because as a parent,
- 1:53:43you're sitting there going this is if I don't do something, my kid's
- 1:53:47going to die. And not only is that just going to be terrible,
- 1:53:51but that will be on me. That will be my fault that my child
- 1:53:56died. I If my child dies and I didn't do everything that I could
- 1:54:00have done, that's on me. So I better do something. And that's
- 1:54:04what a lot of these parents are doing. Now. Did Paris Hilton's parents
- 1:54:09were they really in that kind of scenario From the documentary didn't seem like it,
- 1:54:13honestly, But I don't know was Paris's behavior severe. It sounds like
- 1:54:19maybe, you know, she was a teenager going out at all nights to
- 1:54:23these clubs and with older people. You know, imagine your sixteen year old
- 1:54:30daughter is going to nightclubs in New York City every night and drinking, potentially
- 1:54:36using drugs, meeting older men, blah blah blah, Like you better do
- 1:54:42something about that, right. So it's just a very difficult situation. And
- 1:54:48the solution is not in breaking laws by imprisoning children. The solution is holistic
- 1:55:00care that is available to families with compelling, experienced, well paid professionals.
- 1:55:06Because part of the problem is that this sort of work is so stressful and
- 1:55:13you don't get paid that much this sort of you know, there's a reason
- 1:55:15why I only this in the beginning of my career is because I couldn't pay
- 1:55:19off my loans if that's all I did. It's it's you know, almost
- 1:55:24minimum wage to kind of pay that therapists will get when they do that kind
- 1:55:28of work, unless you you know, you're a family therapist for the stars
- 1:55:31and rich and famous, you know, like because insurance companies sometimes don't pay
- 1:55:38it doesn't pay for it. A lot of these families can't afford the kinds
- 1:55:42of services that are needed anyway. The point is is that we need tax
- 1:55:46dollars that are allocated by state and federal government that pays for a whole slew
- 1:55:55of clinicians to come in and potentially go into the home and help the family.
- 1:56:00Now, sometimes it's not going to work, but even if a third
- 1:56:04of the time it does, that's going to save a lot of lives and
- 1:56:08save a lot of pain and save a lot of trauma from a variety of
- 1:56:13sources. We also need to train better. We also need to focus on
- 1:56:21the things that I'm talking about and beyond rather than falling into it. Because
- 1:56:29some family therapists will fall into this trap of of well, I've just got
- 1:56:33to increase the discipline and the consistency around rules for this child. A lot
- 1:56:38of parents will, a lot of therapists will fall into this trap. And
- 1:56:40I've trained a lot of therapists who fall into this trap, and then I
- 1:56:44got to get them out. And it's very tempting as a family therapist,
- 1:56:47particularly if you have your own kids and you understand you sort of relate to
- 1:56:50the parents to just fall into this trap of like, well, these kids
- 1:56:56need structure, you know, there needs to be like discipline for this out
- 1:57:00because this child needs to know. But the difference between right and wrong.
- 1:57:05That kind of thinking, now it's complicated. There's nothing wrong with discipline,
- 1:57:09there's nothing wrong with structure, and there's nothing wrong with helping a kid understand
- 1:57:13the difference between right and wrong. Sometimes that is part of the equation for
- 1:57:16sure. But if that's all you do, it usually just perpetuates the problem
- 1:57:23in my experience, and there's so much more that family therapy can offer,
- 1:57:28you know, the kinds of things I was talking about, helping people to
- 1:57:30bond, helping people to build those attachments back, helping people to know their
- 1:57:34emotions, helping people to communicate their emotions, helping people recover from the resentments
- 1:57:41of the past between themselves and their families of origin for the parents. You
- 1:57:45know, there's so many things that therapists are very uniquely trained to give to
- 1:57:51people, and to just focus on rules and structure is really limiting your offerings
- 1:57:58to your clients. It'd be like going to a haircutter and all you do
- 1:58:02is like trim their nose hair or something. It's like, yeah, okay,
- 1:58:06that's good, but you know there's a lot of other hair in the
- 1:58:09person's head that you could help them out with. Well, you know,
- 1:58:15when I'm musing an analogy like that, I should probably end the episode.
- 1:58:17And that's what I will do. And let me know what you think.
- 1:58:20Go to psychology sat dot com, click on the contact page, let me
- 1:58:26know what you think. Also participate in the hashtag breaking Code Silence movement.
- 1:58:30If you haven't watched the Paris Hilton documentary on YouTube, that's instructional and everyone
- 1:58:38out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really
- 1:58:40really do.