Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL X Sproule ERCE: Inside the global carbon storage challenge
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the first word
- 0:08in UK energy. I'm reporter Matt Perry, and
- 0:11today we're going to be talking about all things carbon capture
- 0:14and storage. The UK is investing big sums
- 0:17into a range of North Sea CCS projects, but it's not alone.
- 0:21There's a global push to start up this new industry.
- 0:24So let's dive into everything that's going on.
- 0:26I'm joined today on the podcast by Sproul ERCE, decarbonization
- 0:30lead and head geoscientist Ellen Mitchell, and CCS principal and
- 0:35reservoir engineer Andy Moore. Hello both.
- 0:37We're here in Aberdeen Live Today.
- 0:39And you know, that's where a lot of the action in the UK is
- 0:43happening in terms of carbon capture and storage projects.
- 0:45So I guess if you can give me a rundown on where are we at with
- 0:49developing a carbon capture and storage industry in the UK and
- 0:53what has brought us to this point in terms of of policy I.
- 0:56Guess I think it's a lot of it since the Paris Agreement.
- 0:58So it's really when countries are sort of focusing on
- 1:00committing money to reducing their emissions.
- 1:03And so that's mainly ramped up over the past few years perhaps.
- 1:06And I think previously it was lacking the government support
- 1:09and now that the government does seem to be more pro putting
- 1:13money behind renewables and decarbonization options and they
- 1:17have put that 22 billion behind the track one projects.
- 1:20I think in in addition to that, obviously it's well timed this
- 1:24podcast because yesterday we had the 7th UK carbon budget come
- 1:29out. So that's set every five years
- 1:32and that's now set a target of 87% reduction in GHG emissions
- 1:39by 2040 compared with 1990s levels.
- 1:43And that states that, you know, carbon capture and storage will
- 1:47play a large part in that. So it's a very vital technology
- 1:52and achieving those targets and the drive towards net zero.
- 1:57So that's I guess what drives our NDC's as outset by the Paris
- 2:01Agreement here in the UK. And where's the UK sit in terms
- 2:04of, I guess, the global picture of CC US?
- 2:07What are other countries doing and how does it compare to
- 2:09what's happening in the UK? The UK obviously is, you know,
- 2:14fast becoming a leader. I think if you look at the
- 2:16targets, so here in the UK, the UK government set a target of
- 2:21around 2030 million tons per annum by 20-30 and then leading
- 2:25up to 50 million tons per annum by 2035.
- 2:30And if you compare that to the European targets that were set
- 2:35last year and that is the whole of Europe, they have a target, I
- 2:38think it's around 50 million tons per annum by 2030.
- 2:43So UK is certainly out in front here.
- 2:47I think they're quite well placed because of the oil and
- 2:49gas industry. So CCS has a lot of overlap with
- 2:52those skills. There's a lot of people in the
- 2:54UK and with you could say the North Sea basin perhaps winding
- 2:57down a bit, it's well positioned to move into CCS.
- 3:01So other countries around the world, places like the US,
- 3:03Middle East, Australia and many others also have a lot of oil
- 3:07and gas. So they're kind of moving
- 3:08forward as well. And then you have some countries
- 3:10like Japan and South Korea that have a lot of emissions they're
- 3:13perhaps looking to store in other countries.
- 3:15So I think it's the skills that are driving it as.
- 3:17Well, you mentioned that connection to the oil and gas
- 3:18because a lot of the sometimes you see criticism of carbon
- 3:21capture and storage that it's an untested technology, it's
- 3:23untried. But but really we've seen, you
- 3:25know, Ecuador as had been using this kind of technology at this
- 3:28was sleep there and snowvit fields for a long.
- 3:31I was wondering if you'd give a bit of background on I guess how
- 3:34the oil and gas sector has developed this carbon capturing
- 3:37technology that we're now seeing pushed into these, you know,
- 3:41things like the Northern Endurance Partnership, East
- 3:43Coast cluster, hide it where, where is this sort of technology
- 3:45come from? Yeah, it's a lot of overlaps.
- 3:47I wouldn't say it's untested. You hear it's not tested at huge
- 3:50scales, just the the nuance. But the reason behind that is
- 3:54because there wasn't the money behind it or the reason to do
- 3:56so. It's less of a technology issue.
- 3:58What are some of the other I guess up and running?
- 4:00You mentioned Australia. I know there's a Gorgon project
- 4:02in Australia. We've got some other ones, I
- 4:04think in the US What are some of the operational up and running
- 4:07projects that we're seeing starting to get this technology
- 4:09going at scale? I think you've, you've mentioned
- 4:13a lot of them and I think that narrative before of, you know,
- 4:16CCS doesn't work. It's kind of untested.
- 4:19You know, there's certain aspects of some of those
- 4:22projects that have plagued the industry to a certain extent and
- 4:25not allowed it to progress in the way that it should.
- 4:28So obviously Gorgon's one of those.
- 4:30It's had delays, cost overruns and technical issues along the
- 4:34way. But you can look at that
- 4:36differently, I guess and say that we can learn from those
- 4:40early projects and make it successive the later ones.
- 4:42So for example, Moomba in Australia again, which came
- 4:47online in October last year into a depleted gas field.
- 4:52It's so far, you know, been a success and is managing to
- 4:59inject everything I said so far leading up to 1.7 million tons
- 5:04per annum. And how does that compare to the
- 5:05size of I guess of some of these UK project we mentioned, You
- 5:08know, we've seen funding committed in a license issued
- 5:11for the Northern Endurance Partnership.
- 5:13What kind of scale is that compared to some of these
- 5:15existing projects? In in terms of Mumbai, I guess
- 5:19it's slightly different in the sense that it's onshore, so a
- 5:24bit easier from that aspect. I think the volumes of 1.7 MTPA
- 5:29are slightly smaller than than what we're seeing, you know,
- 5:33endurance. I think the issues that Gorgon
- 5:36underwent actually were more around the, you know, water
- 5:39production and re injection. We touched on, I guess, the
- 5:43funding committed towards £22 billion is sort of the headline
- 5:46figure towards getting these cluster projects up and running.
- 5:49I guess how does that financial support help these projects?
- 5:54How is that sort of allocated into getting these projects up
- 5:57and running? It's very, I guess the UK
- 6:00business model is, you know, it's excellent in the sense that
- 6:04it is getting this industry up and running, but the business
- 6:09models themselves are quite complicated and they're very
- 6:12different to what to, you know, the project financing.
- 6:15We're used to an oil and gas. So one of the other areas of
- 6:19policy that's kind of really driving this and potentially
- 6:21will help I guess for the business model of these projects
- 6:24is obviously these policies to help or encourage firms in the
- 6:28Europe, in the EU to decarbonize one of the emissions trading
- 6:31schemes. I wonder if you go through how
- 6:32those policies are really kind of driving investment into the
- 6:36carbon capture and storage sector?
- 6:37Yeah, I think in very, very simple high level terms, you
- 6:42know, the EUETS is in place and benefits carbon capture and
- 6:46storage in the sense that ultimately it should be cheaper
- 6:51for industry to pay to store a ton of CO2.
- 6:55And it should be to to to buy allowances to admit their CO2.
- 7:00And over time at the amount of allowances they can purchase is
- 7:04reducing linearly. And that drives up the price of
- 7:07carbon in itself, making it again cheaper to to to carbon
- 7:12capture storage. I guess that's where the UK 22
- 7:15billion comes in because when there's no industry, you can't
- 7:18suddenly say, right, we're good to store our CO2 here because
- 7:21it's cheaper to do. So You sort of need the initial
- 7:23government support to set up the base industry to then allow the
- 7:26markets to take over. So that's where that kind of
- 7:30support initially for the capture and the transport and
- 7:32the storage allows that to start up.
- 7:34And then you suddenly get options where you can store your
- 7:37CO2. And I think the idea is then to
- 7:39pass it over just to more of a market based model with less
- 7:41government support. And the UK is really taking, I
- 7:44guess, a lot of focus on these sort of this cluster approach to
- 7:47decarbonize domestic industries. But we're seeing countries like
- 7:49Norway and Denmark, they're looking to, I guess, be an
- 7:54option for decarbonization for a lot of European countries,
- 7:57particularly like Germany with their industrial bases that
- 7:59don't have that access to, you know, the same geological
- 8:02resources that countries bordering in North Sea do.
- 8:05So how do things like, I guess the what, what policy measures
- 8:09is the EU taking to to I guess encourage investment in these
- 8:13carbon capture projects? And what are the kind of the
- 8:15considerations these developers have to take in terms of
- 8:19transporting CO2 across borders and those sort of inter country
- 8:22agreements? Yeah, there's some legal
- 8:23barriers like the London Protocol, but without being a
- 8:26legal expert, it sounds like that's quite easy to ratify.
- 8:30I think a lot of the Europe or the new region, at least a lot
- 8:32of that's come from the government region wealth fund,
- 8:35which is quite big. Yeah.
- 8:36I think the Danish government, you know, granted a lot of that
- 8:40money and then you've got the EU investment funds, etcetera that
- 8:45that supports a lot of those projects.
- 8:48But but, but interestingly, I guess from a storage
- 8:51perspective, as development forecast set, you know, 90% of
- 8:55storage will be in the kind of North Sea basin, which leaves a
- 8:58lot of these assets in kind of Southern and Eastern Europe
- 9:02quite stranded in terms of capture.
- 9:04Where do they store? So with that kind of 50 million
- 9:07tonne per annum targets by 20-30 in the EU, that also requires,
- 9:13you know, I think it's like 19,000 kilometers of pipelines
- 9:17in order to, to transport it to get to that storage site.
- 9:20So again, that requires significant investment from from
- 9:25that size. And it's just where things like
- 9:27the the Net 0 industry Act and the carbon border adjustment
- 9:30mechanism, I guess what role do those policies have in
- 9:33supporting the sector so? I think the Net 0 Industry Act,
- 9:35one of the angles that it took for the first time I think was
- 9:38to say if you're a country that's produced oil and gas,
- 9:41then you've now got an obligation to store X million
- 9:43tons per year the associated emissions.
- 9:46And so that's really put an emphasis on countries which are
- 9:49producers to invest in CCS from that angle.
- 9:52And so I think that sort of helps the EU.
- 9:55And then with the C Bam and the carbon border adjustment
- 9:58mechanism, you see countries that are needing to export into
- 10:01the EU certain products, they will be charged the equivalent
- 10:05of the ETS price unless they decide to reduce their own
- 10:09emissions on their side. So it's like a tax essentially
- 10:12on high emission products. So that's sort of allowing the
- 10:16EU to become or to stay competitive with heavy industry
- 10:20relative to the rest of the world with the ETS price and try
- 10:23and get the rest of the world to decarbonize almost.
- 10:25And are we seeing this, I guess pro, is that sort of clustered
- 10:28around certain industries? I know that the cement industry
- 10:30is one that's particularly interested in carbon capture and
- 10:32storage. It's because of the geological
- 10:34processes and manufacturing cement.
- 10:35There's not many other ways to decarbonize fuel switch away
- 10:37that problem. So is it, are these sort of
- 10:39clusters, are they mainly focused around cement?
- 10:41Is it around sort of gas fired power plants?
- 10:43Where are you sort of seeing these projects popping up around
- 10:46connected to to industry? It's a big variety of things.
- 10:48So cement is a good one because it's not connected to
- 10:51hydrocarbon. So it's sort of a hard to abate
- 10:53sector that there are few alternatives for steel's.
- 10:55Another big one is steel moving out of Europe, UK, there's a lot
- 10:59of uncertainty there. So gas powered stations,
- 11:02hydrogen production, waste energy is an interesting one as
- 11:06well. So when all the the waste gets
- 11:09burned and produced for energy, then capturing those emissions,
- 11:12injecting those underground, that's another higher to abate
- 11:15sector. Perhaps more at the personal
- 11:17level cuz actually your waste is getting burnt.
- 11:19So one that the public could support.
- 11:21I guess for the listeners of this podcast will be quite
- 11:23familiar with all of the UK projects that we've touched on,
- 11:26things like the Northern Endurance Partnership, High Net,
- 11:28Acorn Cluster, Viking, sort of those leading Track 1 and Track
- 11:322 projects. But you mentioned, you know, I
- 11:35guess a lot of focus on the North Sea, but what's happening
- 11:38kind of elsewhere in Europe, particularly around the
- 11:40Mediterranean. I understand that Italy and
- 11:42Greece are also looking at projects like this, kind of
- 11:44what's going on in in that part of Europe.
- 11:46Yes. So you've got a couple of big
- 11:47ones down there, the Ravena Project and Prenos.
- 11:50But as far as I'm aware, I think they're the only big two in the
- 11:53Southern part of Europe, I suppose so that you do hear from
- 11:56quite a lot of emitters that they would like to do CCS.
- 11:59But those two stores they think are already full up.
- 12:02So I think there's a lot of opportunity for other stores to
- 12:05open up. Even connecting to Egypt I think
- 12:07is one of the options. Yeah.
- 12:08And that that comes back to that point where the current
- 12:11development forecast just show all that storage is kind of
- 12:15within the North Sea basin just now, although you know there is
- 12:20there is enthusiasm from the emitter side over there.
- 12:24And there's a lot of onshore storage I think as well.
- 12:26So it's just sort of underexplored.
- 12:28So basins, onshore Europe, there's a lot of saline aquifers
- 12:32where you could store CO2 that's unrelated to depleted
- 12:35hydrocarbon fields. But yeah, not a lot of data, not
- 12:38a lot of wells. I guess is this why we're
- 12:40seeing, you know, so much focus on the offshore and and depleted
- 12:44hydrocarbon as well because as you say, there is so much
- 12:47knowledge about these regions geologically.
- 12:49There's already a lot of companies with those skills,
- 12:51with that ability and know how that can quickly turn around and
- 12:55pivot to that. Is that why we're seeing such a
- 12:56focus on these sort of projects? Yes, so unsure is cheaper and
- 13:00unsure where you've got no previous well bores that can
- 13:03leak. CO2 would be the best
- 13:05containment, but it is the issue that you don't have the data,
- 13:09you don't have the knowledge, you don't have the
- 13:10infrastructure set up. I think it's just a wealth of
- 13:12experience from data gathering and analysis over the years of
- 13:16all the well bores within the basin.
- 13:18And yeah, that means people have just studied it and understand
- 13:22it really well, understand if it's a valid store already,
- 13:26whereas onshore that lacks a bit more.
- 13:29And I guess maybe across the Atlantic to North America, we're
- 13:33also seeing a lot of focus on carbon capturing storage over
- 13:35there. What are some of the, I guess,
- 13:38policy considerations if you were looking to put together a
- 13:41carbon capture storage project in the US?
- 13:43How does it differ from, say, the the UK and Europe?
- 13:45It's obviously interesting topic just now and and it obviously
- 13:50works in a very different way in the sense that it works on the
- 13:5445 Q tax credits. And I think in 2022, Inflation
- 14:00Reduction Act increased the value of those tax credits to
- 14:04for carbon capture and storage to around $85.
- 14:07But obviously that's based on a financial incentive to do carbon
- 14:16capture and storage rather than, I guess, legally bound emissions
- 14:21reduction target based on an ETS price that that that kind of
- 14:25forces you down that path almost.
- 14:29But we've seen obviously recently that Trump has, I
- 14:32guess, paused all funding into those IRA mechanisms.
- 14:39And so it's a bit of vigor. So I'll wait and see at this
- 14:41page as to how that will flow on and impact the carbon capturing
- 14:44a storage sector. And I guess in Asia Pacific we
- 14:46touched on Japan and South Korea.
- 14:48Are they really driving alongside Australia the the
- 14:50developer of the carbon capture market in Asia Pacific?
- 14:53Yes, certainly on the emitter side, that's where a lot of the
- 14:56the capture points will be. So on the storage side, I think
- 14:59Japan and South Korea have less, some go to Malaysia and
- 15:02Indonesia, some Australia as well.
- 15:03So when you ship CO2, seen as it goes on a ship, it's then quite
- 15:07cheap to transport at long distances.
- 15:09That's what Northern Lights business model is.
- 15:11And that is what they're sort of looking to do in the future is
- 15:13potentially ship CO2 to nearby stores to keep in track with
- 15:17their NDC's as we discussed earlier.
- 15:19So it's really sort of emitters in Japan and South Korea looking
- 15:22to put it onto a boat, ship it over to other projects that are
- 15:25being developed. And then because they don't they
- 15:28is it that because they don't have the geological stores in
- 15:32those regions to to make use of domestically?
- 15:33Yes, exactly. So they, they do have some
- 15:35stores, but they don't have the volume of stores that they need
- 15:38relative to the volume of emissions.
- 15:39And these other countries have lots of stores and they're happy
- 15:42to take those emissions and the agreements, you know how you
- 15:45count that CO2 one country to another?
- 15:47I think that's the Article 6 are being worked out, but the other
- 15:51thing that's the business model at the moment is to ship it.
- 15:54And it kind of comes back to your point before about, you
- 15:58know, the, you know, the old oil and gas fields and all the
- 16:02wellbores etcetera. You know, Japan doesn't have a
- 16:04massive amount resources of oil and gas.
- 16:08So it's, you know, there's few wellbores, there's few data
- 16:12points to understand that from a geological storage perspective.
- 16:16They've got a bit of a different policies in different regions
- 16:20fueling different types of investments in these projects.
- 16:23Is there in terms of things like, you know, voluntary carbon
- 16:26markets and we've seen some things around I guess carbon
- 16:28accounting and things like that, COP 29 coming out, Are we
- 16:31starting to see more of like a global approach to these sorts
- 16:35of issues? Do we think we'll see maybe a
- 16:38more standardized approach across different regions or we
- 16:41kind of continue to see this variances and differences in
- 16:45approach between regions? So I guess, yeah, with the VCMS,
- 16:48you're mainly looking at carbon removals.
- 16:50So a lot of CCS is carbon avoidance.
- 16:52So you're attaching a capture point to an industry and then
- 16:55it's their emissions that are prevented from going into the
- 16:57atmosphere. So that's not a carbon
- 16:59reduction, that's just avoidance.
- 17:01So the real carbon reductions in the context of CCS or geological
- 17:05storage is decks and decks where you're reducing by burning
- 17:10biomass and capturing those emissions and storing them or
- 17:13extracting CO2 from the air and storing those.
- 17:16So those are sort of the real options that you might see in
- 17:19the voluntary carbon market. And decks in particular.
- 17:22You've seen people like Microsoft pay sort of $1000 per
- 17:24ton of CO2. That's removed because there are
- 17:28few other mechanisms to reduce carbon and store it so
- 17:31permanently. And DAX is like the direct air
- 17:34capture projects as well. So things like we see in ice and
- 17:36with the climax and their mammoth project and and things
- 17:39like that. So that's kind of, as you say, a
- 17:41different approach to permanently storing, I guess
- 17:44removables rather than as you say, abatement or reductions in
- 17:48from the industry. Well, whenever you're starting
- 17:50to move into, I guess the, the more geological side of things.
- 17:52So I guess coming up after the, the quick break, we'll be
- 17:55touching. Well, we're diving below the
- 17:56surface, you might say, into the, I guess the geological
- 17:59considerations of how you get a carbon capture project up and
- 18:03running and why or I guess where you would choose to to put one
- 18:09ahead. So stay tuned.
- 18:35And so now as I say, we're gonna be diving below the surface into
- 18:38some of the subsurface considerations for carbon
- 18:41capture and storage projects. So I guess take me through what
- 18:44we guess we'll start with, I guess your, your background,
- 18:46Ellen, Andy, how did you come to be involved in carbon capture
- 18:50and in storage? What's kind of led you to to
- 18:52getting involved in the industry?
- 18:54Yes, Sir. I've been at EOC 10 years and so
- 18:57initially started as a geoscientist and working in oil
- 18:59and gas projects and then moved over to CCS 4 four years ago I
- 19:04think. So I think CCS was always
- 19:06something I'd wanted to to do and get more on the climate side
- 19:09of things. And you can learn about all
- 19:10things greenhouse gas emissions, hydrogen, geothermal.
- 19:13Andy, you mentioned you, you're no stranger to Aberdeen either.
- 19:16You've, you've worked up here for the North Sea Transition
- 19:18Authority and then tells me what's sort of your, your
- 19:20background and how you kind of pivoted into the, the carbon
- 19:23capture and storage sector. Yeah, I think similar to Ellen,
- 19:26I guess I grew up in Arbroath, which is getting the service
- 19:30belt of the oil and gas industry.
- 19:32So it was no surprise that I ended up within this industry in
- 19:36this part of the world and start working offshore, after which I
- 19:40became a reservoir engineer working for various operators
- 19:44and as well as previously ERCE in the oil and gas division.
- 19:49I think it was that time I started to become more and more
- 19:51interested in carbon capture and storage and and that actually
- 19:55led me to do an online course in in that was free from Edinburgh
- 20:00University at the time. And conveniently, at the same
- 20:04time, a job came up with the NSTA, who's in this building
- 20:09actually. And yeah, I was one of the
- 20:11original members of the UK carbon transport and storage
- 20:15team over there. Meanwhile, ERC created ERC
- 20:20Evolution. And yeah, I've, I've ended up
- 20:23back in the private sector working on a wide range of very
- 20:27exciting projects, not just in CCS.
- 20:30So when you're looking to get a carbon capture and storage
- 20:33project up and running, I imagine obviously not all sites
- 20:36and not all fields are created equal.
- 20:37What are the perfect ingredients?
- 20:39I guess particularly you start in the North Sea for a carbon
- 20:42capture and storage field. Good question And I think it's a
- 20:46very difficult one to answer and there's a lot of variables
- 20:50involved and you can get so far down your kind of
- 20:53characterization side of things and find out that there's
- 20:57technical issues with your storage site.
- 21:00So what we've found I guess is that so far is that No2 storage
- 21:04sites are the same. And I think we work in the oil
- 21:08and we used to work in the world oil and gas whereby there was
- 21:12plenty of global analogs to compare things against to
- 21:15understand how things might work.
- 21:18Whereas obviously within CCS being a very new industry, there
- 21:23is a lack of global analogs. So there's this quite wide range
- 21:27of uncertainty that you work with, that is, yeah, I guess
- 21:31what makes it interesting at the same time.
- 21:33So like I said, the technical work the ERC is doing, what are
- 21:36some of the key areas that you're focused on at the moment?
- 21:39In terms of technical, so we have companies from sort of the
- 21:42high level and screening large regional areas to say this is
- 21:45where you should inject your CO2 in terms of looking at the
- 21:48geology as well as looking at topside considerations.
- 21:51So transport emitter cost side, sort of the full value chain.
- 21:55And when you get a bit further along, so once you've selected
- 21:58your storage site, we can then help companies progress that by
- 22:01building static and dynamic models.
- 22:03So that's simulating how the CO2 will move down hall, how it will
- 22:06flow away and making sure that it doesn't leak.
- 22:09Looking at old legacy wild boars to make sure that they're
- 22:12properly plugged based on abandonment records.
- 22:14So looking at the raw data and creating models and
- 22:18interpretation on that to then give that back to companies to
- 22:21either adopt themselves or use that as a reference case to
- 22:25support their own evaluation. And a lot of what we do as well
- 22:28as risk assessments. So we've been exposed to a lot
- 22:31of risk assessments for CCL sites from around the globe.
- 22:34So got a big internal list of all of the different risks that
- 22:37has been identified to date in terms of the capacity,
- 22:40containment, injectivity, seismicity and monitor ability
- 22:43of sites. So we can help companies put
- 22:45together risk assessments to then give to regulators or for
- 22:49their own internal use. And in the UK, have you been
- 22:51involved in any of the sort of track one, Track 2?
- 22:53I know we mentioned the Northern Endurance partnership involved
- 22:55in the Track 2 projects with Viking and CCSN and Acorn.
- 22:59And what work have you been doing there?
- 23:01Yes, I guess something we also provide as a service that you'll
- 23:05see is CPR. So that's a competent person's
- 23:08report and that's usually adheres to SRMS guidelines,
- 23:13which is the equivalent of PRMS on the petroleum side of things.
- 23:18And what a CPR is effectively a communication tool in the form
- 23:25of a report that allows you to communicate with various
- 23:27stakeholders and they can include people from the finance
- 23:31industry, it can include regulators and it can also
- 23:35include people like potential partners, business partners
- 23:40essentially that may want to invest in the operation.
- 23:43And interestingly, in terms of Viking, we RC delivered Europe's
- 23:49first public consent persons report to the SMS and.
- 23:54Where are some of the other regions where you're also doing
- 23:56these worker and competent persons reports?
- 23:58Yeah, it's as the CCS industry's grown over the last few years,
- 24:02we're seeing more and more requirements for CPRS.
- 24:06And so we've carried out CPRS in place like Australia, Malaysia,
- 24:11Europe and as you know, UK. So yeah, quite a wide variety.
- 24:16And what's interesting is it allows you to see how different
- 24:22areas of the world approach things and it also allows you to
- 24:27learn about different countries regulatory frameworks in order
- 24:31to deploy CCS. Because it's quite a new
- 24:35industry as well. I think each company has almost
- 24:37its own approach in terms of the technical modeling.
- 24:40So there's a large variety of software and approaches that
- 24:43different companies are using. And so we've seen sort of a wide
- 24:46variety from across the globe of different approaches that people
- 24:48have taken and the impacts that that has on how the the CO2 is
- 24:52predicted to to move in the subsurface.
- 24:54I imagine working with regulators around the world as
- 24:56well. There's sort of different
- 24:57reproaches, but also learnings from each other and and how
- 25:00different regions, different countries are doing things.
- 25:02Yeah, I guess the UK has probably the most amount of
- 25:07available guidance documents and the most developed public
- 25:11regulatory framework in that sense that the other countries
- 25:14can lean on and and learn from and and build the regulatory
- 25:18framework themselves. And so it's, I guess it's sort
- 25:21of a potentially an advantage for the UK and tenders that were
- 25:24being further along the line than some other regions that
- 25:27when they look to develop these industries and these technology,
- 25:29they'll be looking to the UK, they'll be looking to Scotland
- 25:32for that, for that expertise. Yeah, I think that's that's
- 25:35definitely a fair thing to say, yeah.
- 25:37Play at a high level. It's not just kind of going CO2
- 25:40into a hole in the ground, you're putting it into the rock,
- 25:42so into the pore space in between.
- 25:45Something like a sandstone or carbonate.
- 25:47So what you initially look for is a rock that you know has that
- 25:51porosity, that space to be able to fit the CO2 into.
- 25:54And you have all the data in the North Sea, so that's quite easy
- 25:56to identify. And then you also need sort of a
- 25:58seal above that. So that's a rock that has no
- 26:01pore space so that the CO2 can't move up under buoyancy and reach
- 26:05the seabed. And again, if you've had a basin
- 26:07like the North Sea that's trapped oil and gas, then you
- 26:09can be fairly certain that your seals are going to be able to
- 26:11trap CO2 and provided you don't put too much CO2 in there,
- 26:15because then the pressure would increase too much.
- 26:17But a bit different to sort of prospecting for oil and gas,
- 26:20where you sort of set your geoscientists off and looking at
- 26:22the rocks and sort of every minute detail is that you want
- 26:25to sort of progress things in an equal manner.
- 26:28So you want to get your well engineers in to check that your
- 26:31legacy wells are not going to allow CO2 to travel up the
- 26:34surface. There's quite a few different
- 26:35things than he was saying that comes into evaluation of a site.
- 26:39How does that different development approach, you say
- 26:41there's differences to how what what things do are firms
- 26:44considering when they look at these potential projects in
- 26:46terms, I guess like you know, the injection sites containment,
- 26:49what are what are some of the key factors that they're
- 26:51considering? So I guess in containment, the
- 26:52main issue that we've seen is legacy well containment, and
- 26:56that's an interesting one because legacy wells, there's
- 26:58always the option of going in and replugging them or be
- 27:00abandoning them. So it could just be an economic
- 27:03consideration. But because CCS isn't a high
- 27:05profit industry, then you don't want to be doing that.
- 27:08So yeah, one primary consideration is making sure
- 27:11that the wells are either there's not too many wells or
- 27:14they're new enough or have been abandoned recently enough under
- 27:19current decommissioning guidelines that they won't leak
- 27:21CO2. Fundamentally, yeah, there's,
- 27:23there's three key things that you look at and that is
- 27:27capacity, how much you can fit in containment, which is, is it
- 27:32going to stay there permanently after you've also finished
- 27:35injection. And then injectivity, which is
- 27:38the ray at which you can inject it into the store.
- 27:41And that is obviously has a direct impact on the economics
- 27:44of the project itself. And you've kind of got to ensure
- 27:49all three of these things through quite a stringent
- 27:53monitoring plan. So that's monitoring where the
- 27:56CO2 plume goes, how quickly it's going into the store and making
- 28:00sure it's not popping out anywhere essentially.
- 28:03And I guess when looking for stores as well, so it's not just
- 28:06looking for the biggest store, it's just a store that's big
- 28:09enough almost to store the volumes that are available.
- 28:13So it's very much tied to the emitter side of things.
- 28:15So that's a bit different with oil and gas.
- 28:17When you're planning sort of how much to recover from an oil and
- 28:20gas field, you want to get out as much as possible because it's
- 28:22profitable. Whereas with CCS, you might only
- 28:26be injecting the amount that's tied to the emitter relative to
- 28:29that store. So in that case, you might say,
- 28:32actually we're going to select a smaller store that's got less
- 28:35risk of leakage relative to a bigger store.
- 28:38So it's sort of balancing around the size, how fast you can
- 28:41inject the containment as Andy was saying, all these things
- 28:44depending on what your emitters is and what your business model
- 28:46is. Yeah.
- 28:49I think, you know we're used to in oil and gas and the same
- 28:52counts for CCS is that you there's large upfront CapEx
- 28:57involved. I think on the oil and gas side,
- 28:59you know you have plateau and production that is related to
- 29:05your deliverability or reservoir as well as your capacity
- 29:08constraints. And so you have a very fast
- 29:11payback period in it. As you come off plateau, you can
- 29:15continue to make money before you've got to abandon the field.
- 29:19Whereas in CCS you have a contractual obligation to have a
- 29:24be able to deliver a flat injection profile over the life
- 29:27of field. So there is no plateau.
- 29:30And So what you are assessing really is the ability to
- 29:34maintain that plateau over the life of field and therefore
- 29:38there is a longer cost profile and slower payback period
- 29:44related to that as a result. So some of the projects that
- 29:47we've got going in the UK at the moment, we've got the Northern
- 29:49Endurance Partnership, we've got High Net in the East Irish Sea
- 29:52and we've also the Track 2 projects, Viking and Acorn.
- 29:55Because what were some of the factors that led to those
- 29:58projects using the fields that they do?
- 29:59What was sort of attractive about those fields that led to
- 30:02them, you know, being the centre of these these projects?
- 30:05I guess we could speculate, but the SO endurance, the Bunter
- 30:10reservoir offshore North Sea is big, thick sandstone, huge
- 30:14connected aquifer. So it's very, very positive in
- 30:18terms of CO2 injection. I think there's been a lot of
- 30:21historical work hasn't been done that's within the public domain
- 30:25on the various fields within the UK offshore.
- 30:28And it's probably, you know, through that process that the
- 30:32front runners have come out that as we've said, you know when you
- 30:36weigh things up, have those three key variables in terms of
- 30:40capacity, containment and injectivity.
- 30:43I guess like with the high net project, those fields are just
- 30:46recently ceased production. They're timing the CCS with end
- 30:49of hydrocarbon production is quite key as well.
- 30:52So you can reuse some of the infrastructure and some of the
- 30:54platforms, some of the wells possibly.
- 30:57So again, the depleted field side is basically timing it with
- 31:00the end of field life. And how important is that in
- 31:02terms of, you know, the wells? Is it much easier to get a
- 31:05project going and and shift that to carbon capture and storage if
- 31:08the wells have only just very recently been abandoned or or
- 31:11have not abandoned? It depends.
- 31:14You can't usually just reuse a well for injection that's
- 31:17produced, so you need to have sort of higher chromium steel
- 31:21and change the tubing out. Anything that's going to be
- 31:24exposed to the CO2 I guess needs to to be a new component
- 31:29essentially. But it does mean you could.
- 31:31There's the option there to reduce your cost relative to
- 31:33drilling new wells. And if you don't reuse them,
- 31:36then you need to make sure that they're well plugged.
- 31:38Yeah. And I think that the other
- 31:39option is if you know as you approach COP and then you're
- 31:42going to reuse the field for CCS, it does give you that
- 31:45option to abandon what were the previous producing wells to a
- 31:50standard that is much more suitable I guess for CO2
- 31:54injection. You touched on the need to use
- 31:57of different levels of steel. Obviously it's a very different
- 31:59carbon dioxide to the natural gas and oil that's being
- 32:01produced. So what are some of the, I guess
- 32:03the different technical considerations between we talked
- 32:06about the fields, but in terms of the the technical side of
- 32:10things, what are some of the different considerations that
- 32:12firms have to look at when they're putting these carbon
- 32:14capture and storage projects together?
- 32:15A lot of the same things still apply from the oil and gas side
- 32:20of things. I think some aspects are much
- 32:23more pronounced and a lot of it depends on what type of store
- 32:27you're injecting into, whether it be a saline aquifer or
- 32:30depleted field and not just depends on the pressure of that
- 32:34field at the time. So in a saline aquifer,
- 32:38obviously you're starting at hydrostatic pressure after which
- 32:42you build that pressure up through injection.
- 32:45And the issues there from an injectivity side of things are
- 32:49that you can end up with salt precipitation in the near
- 32:52wellbore that can inhibit injectivity.
- 32:56Whereas on the depleted field side of things where you are
- 33:01pressure depleted, your concerns are more around the Jule
- 33:07Thompson effect and cold temperatures down whole, which
- 33:10can lead to things like hydrate formation and thermal
- 33:14fracturing. You need sort of materials that
- 33:17can withstand cold temperatures and cleated fields depending on
- 33:20whether you're injecting in gas or dense phase as well, and
- 33:23perhaps heating on the platform as well to heat your CO2 so it
- 33:26doesn't go too cold. And one of the, I guess some of
- 33:28the other key, I guess, you know, considerations for them in
- 33:31terms of those risks. And then also I just say keeping
- 33:34that injectivity consistent, what it was some of the key
- 33:38considerations for firms when they're putting together these
- 33:40projects in terms of mitigating those those risks and ensuring
- 33:43that they've got every element that they need to so.
- 33:47There's a large component of CCS evaluation that's risk
- 33:50assessment. So in the UK, the NSTA asks
- 33:53every licensee to undergo sort of an early risk assessment.
- 33:56So six months into getting the license, they need to list all
- 33:59of the risks associated with their carbon storage sites.
- 34:02That can be over hundreds different risks.
- 34:05The impacts of those, that's something that we've helped a
- 34:07few companies through as an independent assessor in terms of
- 34:11making sure that they captured all of those risks.
- 34:13There's a lot of Geo mechanics that goes into it, and that's
- 34:15something that's perhaps slightly new.
- 34:17There are different disciplines that have come through.
- 34:20So as the CCS industry grows, I think there'll be a a real need
- 34:26for Geo mechanics. As Ellen said, there is a gap in
- 34:29the market there as this industry takes off.
- 34:32Those people are very much in demand.
- 34:34Yeah. We've talked about, I guess,
- 34:35some of the parallels between in carbon capture storage and oil
- 34:38and gas. But I guess what are some of
- 34:39those transitional opportunities for people currently working in
- 34:42the oil and gas sector if they're looking to get into
- 34:45carbon capture storage as you both have Geo mechanics, what
- 34:48are some of the other, I guess, overlaps between the two
- 34:52industries that you expect to see a lot of growth in?
- 34:54Most of them I think what the the key difference is compared
- 34:58with oil and gas is as Ellen said already, there's a lot more
- 35:02focus on risks and in addition to that there's also a lot of
- 35:06focus on monitoring and technology there.
- 35:10And that's a really interesting and exciting be a part of.
- 35:13In addition to that, I think you know, we work a lot closer with
- 35:18regulations then we probably whatever used to in oil and gas.
- 35:22So it doesn't really just stop at the technical work, you know,
- 35:26it spreads out from there into other disciplines we're not used
- 35:30to. Yeah.
- 35:32I guess as geoscientist, I think a lot of the skills are very
- 35:35similar. So it's just understanding some
- 35:38extra elements that are more important in CCS relative to oil
- 35:41and gas. And once you know those, then
- 35:43things like building static models, predicting the geology,
- 35:47that's all pretty much identical.
- 35:49And then it's just accounting for extra elements such as, you
- 35:52know, the CO2 moving away, making sure that it's contained,
- 35:55understanding permeability pathways, heterogeneity, so
- 35:59making sure you've captured those elements in your model,
- 36:02the kind of key swings in terms of CO2 pressure dissipation and
- 36:06blue movement. And is the UK I guess, doing
- 36:08enough to make sure that it has those those skills for when it's
- 36:12industry grows, that there are people coming through the
- 36:14universities coming through in those pipelines of developing
- 36:16those geoscience skills? I think subsurface, well, I
- 36:20think university wide there has been a lack of people going
- 36:24through geoscience and perhaps subsurface engineering because
- 36:28of the association with the oil and gas industry.
- 36:30So you might see the skills shortage coming up in terms of
- 36:33new graduates. I think what I've heard kind of
- 36:35in the top sides, there's a lack of people available to build
- 36:39like pipelines and the actual infrastructure, but that's kind
- 36:41of hearsay. I suppose that might be where
- 36:44the critical pinch points are first.
- 36:46What I would say is the sales pitch, the CCS, because it's a
- 36:50new industry and I think I guess we would be straight out uni
- 36:54working in the oil and gas industry, which has been around
- 36:56for decades and it's built upon decades of years of experience
- 37:01and technological advancements. Whereas working in CCS,
- 37:05everyone's kind of learning along that journey.
- 37:07And so people are really open and honest in communication.
- 37:11It's a really exciting kind of new industry to work in.
- 37:17And yeah, it's been a really good journey so far.
- 37:21A a firm like ERCE, when you're going out and and working on
- 37:25some of these projects, what are the key considerations when
- 37:27you're looking at these projects in terms of things that we
- 37:29talked about the the risks and the what are some of the key
- 37:32considerations in the work that you do?
- 37:34So it depends on the purpose of the project.
- 37:36So we do a lot of, well I guess we do two types of projects.
- 37:40So independent assurance, so coming in as a third party
- 37:43verifier or auditor for these projects are also technical
- 37:47bottom up works of building the models.
- 37:49So we've recently been for subsurface lenders advisors for
- 37:52the NEP endurance project. And that's where you're working
- 37:55with the banks and needing to understand what they care about
- 37:59in terms of lending to this project.
- 38:01And banks are all about risks and uncertainty.
- 38:03So being able to communicate the risks that could impact them in
- 38:07terms of the flow rate of the CO2 or the CO2 were to escape.
- 38:12So that's the injectivity and the containment and then
- 38:15ultimately can they get all the CO2 in.
- 38:17So that's the capacity. So sort of all three of those
- 38:19things, I think. Yeah, exactly.
- 38:22I think that was a really interesting piece of work and
- 38:26exciting thing to be involved in given it's been granted the
- 38:29first storage permit here in the UK.
- 38:33And I think what was interesting about that piece of work from
- 38:36our perspective, doing the due diligence to secure, well help
- 38:42secure the project financing there was that we needed to
- 38:47communicate with a range of stakeholders that that didn't
- 38:52necessarily know anything about CCS given especially given how
- 38:56new an industry it is. So we had to communicate that
- 38:59from a very, you know, basic level down right into a very
- 39:04detailed level. And as Ellen said, the key thing
- 39:07for obviously the banks was understanding the risks
- 39:12involved. So, so I guess the probability
- 39:15and consequence of something happening and then the
- 39:18uncertainty associated with that.
- 39:20I guess some of the other projects we've done, so we do a
- 39:23lot to SRMS. So that's the CCS equivalent of the PRMS, so the
- 39:27storage resource management system.
- 39:30And so that's almost this guidance document that we can
- 39:32report to when we write competent persons reports for a
- 39:35variety of interested parties, though one of those could be an
- 39:39emitter, for example. So they might read our report
- 39:41and see that the store has good containment, has injectivity.
- 39:44They might be less interested in total capacity because say
- 39:47they've signed up first and they don't mind if they can't store
- 39:49the full amount. So it does just depend what the
- 39:53priorities of the stakeholders. Yeah.
- 39:56It depends on, I guess, what the client and then the stakeholders
- 39:58want from the project. Well, I think that's a perfect
- 40:01pivot because coming up after the break, we're gonna be
- 40:03talking about some of those exciting things on the horizon,
- 40:05some of the innovation we might be able to expect to see.
- 40:07So stay tuned. The help with GHG is a ERC
- 40:36e.energyorsproul.com Yeah, well, welcome back to Energy Voice Out
- 40:43Loud. So we've been discussing a bit
- 40:44about the, you know, the key considerations for the carbon
- 40:46capture and storage sector in the UK in terms of the geology.
- 40:50And we've sort of touched on a bit about the the different
- 40:52picture of what's happening around the world.
- 40:54But there are still some remaining hurdles.
- 40:56You know, there's a lot of projects going on, there's a lot
- 40:58of things moving ahead, but there are some barriers that
- 41:03still need to be overcome. So what are some, I guess of the
- 41:05some of the challenges still facing I guess the carbon
- 41:08capture and storage sector at the moment and, and how, what
- 41:11what works being done to overcome them at the moment?
- 41:13I guess the business models in the UK, they've just set up the
- 41:16the business model we discussed earlier, but that's just for the
- 41:19track one projects. So track 2 in the future.
- 41:22License fees are still uncertain about what those business models
- 41:25might look like. And similar with the EUI think
- 41:28you have specific business models for the projects that
- 41:30have reached FID so far, but a lot of them are aligned on an
- 41:34ETS price or perhaps C bam to make the economics of it work.
- 41:40But unless you sort of implement like a carbon contracts for
- 41:43difference or something like that to guarantee that minimum
- 41:46price, then investing the huge upfront cost that's associated
- 41:49with these projects is quite a lot of risk for majority of
- 41:52companies. And I guess coming back to that,
- 41:54the business model obviously for a lot of the UK projects is kind
- 41:57of this focus on keeping costs down for domestic.
- 42:00There's not too much cost for domestic industrial emitters so
- 42:02that they're not having to pay too much to, to decarbonize
- 42:06their operations. But I've heard particularly from
- 42:08from Harbor Energy in their their Viking project where they
- 42:10think one of the ways that they can be making money is kind of
- 42:13what we touched on, I guess when we're talking about Japan, South
- 42:15Korea is those shipments and there's imports of CO2.
- 42:18I guess how important is that kind of, I guess the side hustle
- 42:21almost in terms of importing CCS from from other countries, other
- 42:25jurisdictions to the feasibility or I guess the economics of
- 42:29these projects? Yeah, I guess, you know, I think
- 42:32the amount of storage sites there are licensed in the UK is
- 42:36probably over the amount of emissions that are available
- 42:40from UK domestic emissions. So therefore, you know, a lot of
- 42:45the projects you see do have a large contribution associated
- 42:49with them from EU emissions essentially.
- 42:53So, yeah, I think it's probably critical to the future of the
- 42:56industry that that cross-border transport and storage is part of
- 43:03it. And I guess the UK, the
- 43:06government isn't just investing this money to reduce their own
- 43:09emissions, but it's sort of the precursor to them setting up
- 43:12this business to then import CO2 from the EU and actually make
- 43:15money on that. So they do see it as sort of a
- 43:18money maker for the country, not just a pure money sink to try
- 43:21and reduce the country's emissions.
- 43:23So I think that is the future plan is to try and make it
- 43:25attractive for companies to deposit.
- 43:28There's 02 I suppose in the UK subsurface.
- 43:31Yeah, I think we hear this term a lot sort of sort of chicken
- 43:33and egg kind of investment situation at the moment.
- 43:36I guess could you delve into that a little bit?
- 43:37How does that kind of play out the carbon capture, what's kind
- 43:40of, you mentioned the, the Tract 2 projects, but what kind of
- 43:43other policy measures or or regulatory barriers need to be
- 43:48figured out to, to get companies to go?
- 43:50Yes, this is something that we we want to invest in.
- 43:53I think that the large benefit in the UK and to actually this
- 43:58time around obviously get the industry moving is that the
- 44:02track process and the business model obviously has paired
- 44:07emitter and storage operator together.
- 44:11So it's removed that chicken and egg piece in which, you know,
- 44:14there may be emitters willing to undertake the carbon capture
- 44:18side of things, but given the lack of certainty around
- 44:22storage, that's preventing them and investing in it.
- 44:25And on the flip side, that can be said from the storage side
- 44:28wanting to obviously build the infrastructure for storage
- 44:33without any line of sight of the emissions from the capture side
- 44:36of things. So I think in terms of a
- 44:39business model, the UK has done a done an excellent job from
- 44:43that perspective in the, you know, track 1 and 2 processes.
- 44:47I think going to conferences and speaking to some emitters, it's
- 44:51quite interesting. So you hear them say, you know,
- 44:53like cement plants in Spain. We'll say, oh, I'd like to do
- 44:55CCS, but there's no stores. And then potential stores will
- 44:58say, oh, you know, we could store CO2 here, but there's no
- 45:00emitters. And I think it's like lining
- 45:02those up and each one like having a guarantee that there
- 45:06will be a store or there will be an emitter for that store.
- 45:09That's sort of the crucial part. So do you think there's almost a
- 45:11piece there for the government to be, you know, going to these
- 45:14countries, say Spain, Germany, a lot of these European neighbors
- 45:18and, and saying you've got emissions, we've got storage.
- 45:21Let's work together on this. Yeah, absolutely.
- 45:23So I think the government should probably be doing that.
- 45:26I think the companies themselves that have these stores will also
- 45:29likely be doing that. I guess the issue is currently
- 45:32the transport, so the volume of ships actually transport that
- 45:35CO2. I think Northern Lights actually
- 45:37just got its first ships delivered last month.
- 45:40So, but I guess there'll be a bit of a dearth in the volume of
- 45:45those that are available. Yeah.
- 45:48And there's the, the other aspect is shipping as well
- 45:51compared with I guess pipeline is the purity of CO2 that's
- 45:56required within shipping is very high.
- 45:59It's up there at kind of 99 point something percent, which
- 46:04means there's, you know, additional energy requirements
- 46:08to capture that purity of CO2 compared with, you know, with a
- 46:12pipeline you're probably more looking or 95% purity.
- 46:17So there's, you know, the shipping can accelerate the
- 46:21industry in the 1st place, especially that cross-border
- 46:25piece. But really, you know, the future
- 46:27of it down the line is the pipeline transport side of
- 46:30things, so. If we can get these sort of
- 46:32barriers figured out, these kind of first track one, track 2
- 46:35projects of the line, what would a future kind of carbon capture
- 46:38and storage market or had an ecosystem look like in Europe?
- 46:41I know there are some companies like Franco and Neptune that are
- 46:44kind of more in the southern North Sea, and they've also got
- 46:47projects nearby. And through the dark, we see a
- 46:51huge, big, almost like a carbon and storage grid happening in
- 46:54the connecting emitters and these projects.
- 46:56What? I guess getting the crystal ball
- 46:59out, what could it look like in the future if we get everything
- 47:02right? Yeah, something like that.
- 47:06So I guess we've heard pipeline companies are looking at
- 47:08building these pipelines from EU to UK.
- 47:12I think the issue is trying to get the flexibility right.
- 47:15So that's where you might get some ships sort of alleviating
- 47:19small scale CO2 here and there, but the pipeline's transferring
- 47:22a lot of the volume. And if it's market driven, then
- 47:25stores that are cheapest to develop might be the ones that
- 47:28images would choose to go to because they can charge the
- 47:30lowest price. And then you've also got the
- 47:32issues of purity, as Andy was saying.
- 47:34So some stores would have higher requirements relative to others.
- 47:37So that would be again a cost issue or more attractive certain
- 47:40industries. You'd also need to get the EU
- 47:43and UK ETS all aligned and all the agreements sorted out.
- 47:46So assuming that can all get signed off.
- 47:49But yeah, I think ultimately I think all the governments are
- 47:51trying to drive towards a sort of market competition based
- 47:54model. So coming up on the horizon, you
- 47:56know, we've got obviously the Track one projects the high net
- 47:59and the East Coast cluster, Northern Direct Partnership.
- 48:01We've got Track 2, Acorn and Viking, but we've also got
- 48:04further projects down the line that the North Sea Transition
- 48:07Authority has done a carbon storage licensing round.
- 48:09So there's a lot of other projects in the works.
- 48:11What are some of the projects that ERC has been involved with
- 48:14and is working on at the moment? I guess we've been involved with
- 48:17quite a lot of the Track 2 and future licenses.
- 48:20So in the track two side, we've written competent persons
- 48:23reports for the Viking storage site for Harbor and the Acorn
- 48:27one as well. We've also been helping Parenko
- 48:30with their Poseidon project. So that's quite an interesting
- 48:33one to talk about right now is they're currently doing their
- 48:35injection test. So that will be the first CO2
- 48:37injected in the UK offshore. So a lot of companies are
- 48:41looking to the results of that. What were we, what are we
- 48:44expecting to come from these, from these injection tests?
- 48:47What are what are the companies interested to see in terms of
- 48:49these, these results? What are they looking for?
- 48:52I guess in in terms of how it applies to their their own
- 48:55operation. It's the different phases in
- 48:58which they're injecting into a depleted field.
- 49:00So in the gas phase, in the dense phase and seeing what
- 49:04happens down hole and in the near wellbore and how that
- 49:07impacts the injectivity side of things.
- 49:10Is is is really the interest here?
- 49:13So having sort of pressure monitors down hole to see
- 49:16exactly how the pressure responds temperature, what
- 49:19happens as you inject that CO2 in its different phases times
- 49:23they can build that into the. Model and looking ahead to as I
- 49:25say, it's quite an exciting industry to be working in.
- 49:27It's a lot like as saying the oil and gas had to where it's
- 49:29been around for decades. It is a newer technology.
- 49:33And so I guess what sort of innovation is being worked on?
- 49:36What kind of are you seeing firms doing in terms of the
- 49:41innovation side of things? I guess a lot on the, well, we
- 49:44don't actually work with the capture side, but there's a lot
- 49:46going on there that we don't know about.
- 49:48So I guess in terms of the subsurface, there isn't that
- 49:51much that needs to be innovative, I think.
- 49:53Yeah. I think the biggest difference
- 49:55is on the monitoring side as well in terms of technology.
- 49:59We're seeing, you know, a lot of technologies that are that are
- 50:04already used in oil and gas, but they're, you know, it's the
- 50:07combination of those technologies that will be used
- 50:10in the frequency in which they will be used and the rate of
- 50:14deployment of them that will be much different in carbon capture
- 50:17and storage. So there will be a lot more data
- 50:20to work with to ensure capacity containment and injectivity
- 50:25compared with what we're used to on the oil and gas site.
- 50:29It's plenty more work, you know. Yeah, it works in terms of the
- 50:34subsurface side of things. So you touched on a kind of
- 50:38different, what are the kind of different geological formations
- 50:42that are really conducive to these for the carbon capture and
- 50:44storage projects? Where do you see the most
- 50:46potential in terms of geology? Yeah, that's a very interesting
- 50:49question. So most of the projects we've
- 50:52seen are in sandstones. It's quite predictable in terms
- 50:55of the structures themselves. So four way dip closures, you
- 50:57know that it's quite robust. The CO2 travels up or up by
- 51:02buoyancy, so it's not going to leak out.
- 51:04So that is a lot of what we see in the UK and the early projects
- 51:08are targeting sort of robust closures.
- 51:11However, there's also the option of injecting in sort of a slab,
- 51:15like a dipping slab. And as long as you inject far
- 51:17enough down dip, then the CO2 will migrate up dip.
- 51:20But each time it travels through a pore, a little bit of it gets
- 51:23stuck in that pore. So that's called residual
- 51:25trapping. And it also interacts with the
- 51:27water into which you're injecting it.
- 51:29And some of that CO2 will dissolve and sink down.
- 51:31So if your slab is long enough, the CO2 will continue to move
- 51:35up, dip, but eventually it will just stop and it won't actually
- 51:38reach the top. So just generally large dipping
- 51:41aquifers can also be targeted, provided that you have enough
- 51:45information to be able to rely on your models that that CO2
- 51:48won't exploit a high permeability pathway.
- 51:50And then that's another option. You know, we see a lot of these
- 51:53carbon capture and storage projects happening in regions
- 51:56where there's already hydrocarbon sectors, you know,
- 51:58oil and gas production. But is that the only place you
- 52:01can do carbon capture and storage projects in the office
- 52:03sector? Are there other places where
- 52:04they may not have, you know, oil and gas reserves, but they can
- 52:06still do carbon encaption and storage effectively?
- 52:09Yes, yes. So anywhere where there's porous
- 52:13reservoir with a seal, you can do carbon capture and storage.
- 52:17So a lot of places around the world where they didn't have a
- 52:21hydrocarbon kitchen almost that will still have those types of
- 52:24rocks that you can eject CO2 into, but you just don't have
- 52:27the data and the knowledge about those reservoirs available.
- 52:30So you have to spend more money trying to find information about
- 52:33the reservoir areas where there's perhaps geothermal or
- 52:37water reservoirs exploited, you might have some information.
- 52:39So that could be perhaps a target, but they also do have to
- 52:42be deep enough. So you need to be generally
- 52:44below 800 meters below the surface in order for CO2 to be
- 52:48in its super critical state. So that's generally a cut off
- 52:51for sort of minimum depth that the CO2 needs to be.
- 52:56Yeah, I would. I think it's fair to say that
- 52:59all the saline aquifers we have seen today have previous wells
- 53:04in them and those wells have been looking for the
- 53:06hydrocarbons and didn't find hydrocarbons, but they found and
- 53:10for instead was of no interest. So the exploration wells are
- 53:13kind of abandoned and left as they are.
- 53:18And it's only that data then that's available that, you know,
- 53:23says, oh, we have a potential carbon storage site here.
- 53:27I think it's the, you know, battle between the just looking
- 53:31at the areas where you already have data or spending money
- 53:36exploring for carbon storage where there's currently no data
- 53:40and actually finding that that's not a viable store.
- 53:42Thanks Ellen and Andy for that really engaging discussion and
- 53:45deep dive into all things carbon capture and storage.
- 53:47And if you'd like to stay tuned on all things to do with the UK
- 53:51carbon capture and storage sector, you can head to the
- 53:53Energy Voice website or listen to Energy Voice out Loud on your
- 53:56podcast platform of choice.