Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / S1 E20—Ruthless by Anne Stuart with Alice Murphy
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello everyone and welcome to First Encounter. My name is Andie James. I am a historical romance enthusiast and author. and today is one of our deep dives into an older or more classic kind of historical romance work. And I'm very excited. We are discussing a new to me author. This is the first time I have read Anne Stewart, and we're discussing her book, Ruthless. And I'm really excited. I'm fangirling a little bit because I am joined to discuss this book by Alice Murphy, who is the author of the fantastic book, A Showgirl's Rules for Falling in Love. Alice: Thank you. Andie James: the role being basically don't fall in love, you know, but that's okay. sorry if that was spoiler. I feel like that Alice: No, I think that's kind of the the the one rule of all romance novels. There's so many romance Andie James: Yeah. Alice: novels where the only rule is you can't fall in love and then inevitably, spoiler alert, I don't know if you've read a romance novel, they do. Andie James: Just don't fall in love. They do. Yeah, they break the rule. That's great. but Alice, I'm really excited to chat with you today and thank you so much for joining me. Alice: No, thank you. I am such a big fan of the podcast. I'm such a big fan of your work. So this is really a treat for Andie James: No, thank you. Alice: me. And to get to talk about this kind of bonkers old school romance is is very exciting to me. I didn't know this was your first Anne Stewart book. Andie James: It is. It is my first dance to it. Yeah. This is this is why the podcast is fun because it's forcing me to not forcing me, but I want to. But like there was all these older historical romances I'd not read because I mean I kinda came to the genre a little late. Like not I mean I'd read romance, but you know, I wasn't steeped in it like some people from a very early Alice: Mm. Andie James: age. And so there's all these books I haven't read because now, you know, now As an author in the genre, I have so many friends and other authors, and like I want to read their work and the new stuff that's coming out. And so I feel like I don't always have time to read all the backlist stuff I want to. And so this is so fun because I'm reading all these books and these new authors, and like it's so exciting to me. So thank you. Alice: No, absolutely. I this was a book that was recommended to me on Instagram, I think. And I had read some Anne Stewart before. I'm like you. Andie James: Okay. Okay. Alice: I wasn't, you know, I think there's like a a certain subsection of historical romance readers who were like reading their grandmother's, you know, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: zebra paperbacks like when their parents weren't looking. And that was not me. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: but I I did read a lot of like YA historical romance, which was kind of a thing when I was a teen. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah yeah. Alice: Like Meg Cabot wrote a couple of like Regency era romances, and there was Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: a book called To Capture a Pirate's Heart that I think was my first historical romance. I also went to like Andie James: I love it. Alice: a fundamentalist Christian school, and like the only I they literally like took my copy of Twilight and were like, you can't read this on campus. So they were like, you can read these books instead, and gave me like Christian historical romance. So I Andie James: Yeah. Right. Alice: read a lot of Christian historical romance growing up, some of which really holds up and some of it really doesn't. which I'm sure you can understand. and I came Andie James: Fair. Yeah, Yeah. Alice: to Anne Stewart like I guess two years ago. I was in a bookstore and there was a Lord of Danger is one of her books, and it has I Alice is a pen name. And so the heroine actually has my real life name. And I was like, what a fun like bingo card square to get is like read a book Andie James: Yang. Alice: with my weird real name. And then I was like, she has something I've never experienced before. Like it like it like activated something in my deep programming. And I was like, Andie James: Hehehehehe. Alice: now I'm now I'm an Anne Stewart fan for life. And like I've read her contemporaries, I've read her historical. She has like a bunch of kind of like spy thriller romances Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: that are weird and and Anne Stewart in the most Anne Stewart way. And I don't know, there's something about her that I I find very chewy and I like to to break apart the craft with people. So I'm excited to to dive in. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. I know. Well, I should say that I the reason I like approached you about doing this was because you I don't know, this was a while ago now. I mean I would say probably early on in this year, maybe like February ish. I don't know. Couldn't tell you what you'd written about, but you posted something on Instagram where you're talking about like multiple books, Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: I I don't know. Highlighting things you liked about these different books. And but you just said something about like you were you were mentioning this book and you said something about how like how you never wanted to shut up about this book and you wanted everyone to read it or something like that. And I was just like, well then she has to come on the podcast and talk about it. I feel that's Alice: My dirty secret about this book is I have recommended it to everybody who has asked me for a book rec, and I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: only gave it 3.5 stars, on my book journal. And every time I look back at that, I'm like, how did I give it a 3.5? And I'm sure that I had reasons, but for whatever reason, it's just really stuck with me. And and Andie James: But it stayed with you. Yeah. Alice: I think there's just so much to talk about in it. And even if you don't like walk away thinking, this is the greatest romance novel of all time. I do think there are so many elements of it that make for Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: good kind of romance craft and romance big big picture about the genre Andie James: Yeah. Alice: conversations that just like really tickle me as someone who loves to talk about this thing that we all love, romance. So I'm excited. Andie James: Yeah, it's great. Me too. Well, I mean, you kind of a little bit have now given us some context for kind of your background, maybe, in getting into reading reading all this. but obviously I think your book, although your book is different, it it it breaks some molds a little bit in a good way, I think. what made you be like, this is what I wanna write? I wanna write this book set in eighteen ninety-seven about this show girl and and we will clarify for everyone since I just did an episode about Taylor Swift. Alice is not Taylor Swift, even though it was very like I was very excited for you last summer because I don't think you'd like just announced your book, but it wasn't like super long since the cover had been revealed. Maybe not. Maybe, maybe. Alice: Yeah, I think it was it had been out so the book released in May and I think all this happened in the summer, later in the summer, when Taylor announced her new album. And Andie James: Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Alice: and yeah, some someone on TikTok had like a conspiracy theory that went kind of semi-viral and I was in Manchester, England, and I was like blissfully asleep and woke up and looked at my phone and my first thought was, What did I say or do that got me cancelled? I was like, I'm I'm the in I'm the internet's enemy, what did I do? 'Cause it was like Andie James: Why Alice: my whole phone was blowing up. And I was like, what did I do? What Andie James: is my why is happening? Yeah. Alice: did I say? Like I was just going through every comment, every line of the book I had written. I was like, what did I do? And it turned out that they just thought I was Taylor Swift. And then like of course my DMs Andie James: I yeah. Alice: were filled with like, you know I don't know if you're Taylor Swift, but I'm a teacher and and I this is my Amazon school wish list and I'm like, Well I want the babies to have crayons. yes, of course. So it's it was it eventually we had to clarify 'cause it was just you know, Taylor Swift was so many people's person and I Andie James: Yeah. Alice: didn't want to be like, I won't tell. You know, that didn't seem fair. So we had to but it was fun. It was a fun forty eight hours. Andie James: I know. I just it's so Yeah, well, I mean part of it obviously was the name, right? So Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: her album is The Life of a Showgirl and your book is A Showgirl's Rules for Falling in Love. So I mean it, you know. But it was also just like the artwork and the concept, like the colors. The colors, the green Alice: And the colours were the same and it was uncanny. Andie James: and the it was so I know. It was funny because after she revealed the album cover. I I just remember my thought was like, this is gonna be such a great marketing opportunity for Alice. I was just like, This is like it's perfect. I wish I had this kind of coincidence to coincide with Taylor Swift. But Alice: And you know what? It it it I I don't know that I would have gotten my second book deal if not for that that bump. So thank you, Taylor. If anybody reads my next book, then you have Taylor Swift to thank. or or blame if you don't like it. So Andie James: Well, there you go. There you go. Yeah. Well that's it. Yeah. That's a nice segue because you do next year in 2027 have another book coming out. I'm very excited for it. Alice: I do, I'm so excited. Andie James: So this is A Modern Girl's Guide to Love and Divorce, which hello, Alice: Yes. Andie James: just the name. Love it. and this one is a little more this is twentieth century. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Alice: Yes, so it's set in nineteen sixty-two and it's about two journalists who are kind of on opposite sides of the battle of the sexes. He's like, you know, a man about town, I'm a playboy, I, you know, I'm a cool guy who like goes to drink whiskey at two PM and write articles about the space race, and she's like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: a women's liberation journalist who's like Men are the worst. Why are we dealing with them? Women should be running the world. Which, obviously she's correct. And their editor forces them to get married, to report from the front lines of the modern American marriage. And, Andie James: my god, I love this. Alice: you know, he wants to make her fall in love with him because he wants to prove that he can, like, you know, tame any wild woman, you know, kind of taming of the shrew style. And she's like I'm gonna drive him to divorce. I'm gonna make this man hate me. And it's gonna be his fault. Andie James: Yeah. Alice: And everybody, you know, I'm gonna expose him for being kind of like a charlatan. And then again, don't know if you've ever read a romance novel before, but things do happen and he realizes like every horrible thing she does, he's like, no, but I'm kinda into that. I kinda like it when she's mean to me, and I kinda like it when she you know, and then she's like, Andie James: Yeah. yeah. Mm-hmm. Alice: but he has hidden depths and he has, you know, these things and He really grows and changes over the course of the book and has to own up to his mistakes and his issues. And I really I love a a hero growth journey. I think that like I you know, I love a cinnamon roll as much as the next girl. but I think there is really something to be said for a relationship that like makes somebody have to examine the person that they are and then grow and change. And I think that that's really fun. Andie James: Yeah. Which yeah, is what readers are telling us they want. I can't tell you how many posts I've seen lately. People are like, the men are so boring. And like I think Alice: Yeah. Andie James: because I think we kind of had a backlash to all the toxic stuff going on in our culture. And, you know, Alice: Alcohol yes. Fair enough. Andie James: yeah, it's like we just need like we want our fantasy to be like the good man, right? Not Alice: Mm. Andie James: the And so I but I think we've now swung maybe too far. And Alice: Mm. Andie James: so like I'm I've just seen a lot of commentary lately about people being like, okay, but like he needs to not be just totally perfect and she needs to figure that out, right? That and so I yeah, I appreciate a growth arc too. Which maybe is a good transition into talking about Ruthless because if we're gonna have Alice: if there is a man if there's a man who needed a growth arc, it is Rohan. Andie James: It is Rohan, yes. Our lovely Francis. So I I mean, you guys hopefully if you're listening know this by now, like we're gonna discuss this book. So spoilers ahead. So there you go. Spoilers abound, Alice: Spoilers abound, in fact. Andie James: yes. because we're gonna get into it. because this book, I I I really enjoyed it. And I will say, you know, as someone who I mean, just told me you've read some of my books, which is still mind blowing to me, so thank you. as someone who writes pr pretty cozy, you know, lower conflict, like internal conflict more than like whatever. I I, you know, I I tend to r like a really cozy book. And this is not a cozy book. but Alice: no. Andie James: I really enjoyed it. And I was honestly a little surprised when I looked it up and saw that it was first written in 2010 because it feels a little more old school to me than that. And I mean I Alice: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Andie James: know Anne Stewart's writing for a while, so Part of it is just maybe her style. but like when I think 2010, I don't know. It's like romance moves so quickly, right? In terms of like the phases and I I don't I'm not the right person to distinguish like different dates and stuff. But in my head, I think it's actually 2009 maybe, but 2009, 2010 is when Sarah McLean put out her first book. And so in my head, that's kind of like she's kind of part this newer generation. And this book to me I was like, twenty ten. That feels a little like more modern than I anticipated. But that's still sixteen years ago, which is insane to think. 'Cause Alice: Mm. Andie James: I don't know. and a lot has changed since then. So I think I don't know, it was interesting. It was this mix of like newer and older and Alice: Yeah. Yeah, I really do love it is it is kind of weird to look at it as like a 2010 artifact. But I think, you know, a part of it to your point does come from Anne writing a million books over so long. and I I think it I love to look at these kind of literary inflection points and see like what people are holding on to and p trying to pull into the present and what they're trying to leave behind. what Andie James: Yeah. Alice: are the elements that we are saying goodbye to and what are the ones we're saying hello to? And I think this book has a lot of those in that like, you know, Elinor, our heroine, is Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Alice: both like this kind of like shy and retiring virgin who doesn't really know a whole lot about the world and but she is also like oldest daughter to the extreme, an operator in her own right, is is she Andie James: To the extreme. Yeah. Alice: her the way her mind works is really interesting to me because she has been very n abused and neglected by her mother, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: who is a gambling addict and I think like an opium addict if I'm remembering. She's quite ill. Yeah. Yes. Andie James: She's very ill. She has some kinda S T D. We don't know what. But they just the French French pox or whatever they call it. Yeah. Yeah. Alice: And right. And and also thinking about like the time period, you know, like this Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: you know, typically now we see pretty much exclusively in in mainstream historical romances, like Harlequin historical's R.I.P. notwithstanding, like we pretty much only see Victorian romance and Regency. We sometimes get Gilded Age, which is what my book was. But this is a very Georgian like Andie James: Very Georgian. Alice: he wears high heels and tights. Like he has wigs. Like yes. And and Andie James: Mm. Yep. They talk about his high heels and his fancy big lace cuffs and yeah. Alice: here to l I w can we open our discussion? Do we need to like tell people what this book is about before I just dive into the craft stuff? I'm sorry. I'm apologies to all the readers. Let's let's recap. Andie James: We probably should a little bit. Sorry, we probably should. We should recap a little bit. Yeah, sorry. I do this. I go off. I just get invested and yeah. So I just finished this a couple days ago, so I feel like my brain is still processing a little bit. But So essentially Francis Rohan or Rohan's title, so I don't anyway, Francis Rohan either, is our hero. And he is he's been exiled from England. He we find out later that he fought in the war or the Battle of Culloden. and he was, you know, in favor of our Bonnie Prince Charlie, and so England's now like, you're a bit of a traitor. So he has been exiled from England. He's living in France. So this book takes place in France. So that and of itself is a little bit different, too. Not that there hasn't been several books that take place there over time. but again, for current, where it's very England focused or starting to be a little more America 20th century, which fingers crossed. we're in France. He is very I don't even know how to describe him. He's I I wanna say debauched, but that sounds judgy. He's very much a libertine, yes. Alice: He's a libertine. He's a libertine. He he he r I I always tell people I'm like he runs like the platonic ideal of a sex cult. Like, he he has Andie James: Yes, pretty much. Alice: this thing called the Heavenly Host and basically he opens Andie James: Uh-huh. Alice: up his big fancy castle and the select few are invited to partake in gambling and drugs and sex of all kinds and and he just loves it. But I I mean, he's so bored, Andie. The life of a libertine is so boring. Andie James: He is. He just yes. He's kind of colloquially known to the world as the King of Hell. obviously the Heavenly Host, it's very sacrilegious and very, you know. and so it's like he's just been this libertine. He has no qualms about any of this. He's not necessarily looking to reform. He has no feelings of guilt about any of this. But yes, he's bored. He's you know, we we find out he's like 39. He's like almost 40, and he just feels so old and tired of all of it, right? Yeah. And then yes. Alice: He's seen it all, he's done it all. And then a young woman appears demanding him to return her mother, who has been Andie James: Yes. Alice: gambling at his establishment. Andie James: Yes. Alice: And he's like, this poor pitiful thing. Her feet are wet and they're so hot. I gotta take her inside. I gotta get her out of the the bad stuff. He blindfolds Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: her and walks her through the castle and like tucks her away by a safe fireplace. Yeah, Andie James: Yes. Trying to protect her. Yeah. Alice: trying to protect her virtue. And and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: then kind of like becomes obsessed with her. Andie James: Yeah, it's just he's he's very I think she's not impressed with him Alice: No. Andie James: at all, and most people are. or he can charm any lady and he can, you know, whatever. And she's just over it. she just she's seen enough in her life. Like you said, she's kind of she's been mistreated by her family, her mother. we find out later in the book that her mother essentially likes sold her to a man because she she needed some debts paid. and he wanted a virgin, so there you go. and well, it's a little more sinister than that. He wanted her little sister. He's into young people. She's protecting her sister. It's a whole thing. Alice: It Yes. Andie James: Like you said, eldest daughtering to the extreme. Like her Alice: Yes. Andie James: driving Elinor's driving purpose in this entire book is protecting her sister. Her younger sister Lydia Alice: Yes. Andie James: is this like renowned beauty. And so Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: in Elinor's eyes, that's just danger, right? That's like these men are gonna be attracted to her. They're gonna take advantage of her. It's gonna be I have to protect her. And so Alice: And it's it's so I love that because it's so layered and it give it's not just like, I love my sister. It's Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: A, the sister is like a financial investment. We are never gonna get Andie James: Yes. Alice: out of this hole we're in unless she marries v well and very well. So there's that piece of it. I'm never gonna be safe and and healthy and happy unless Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: my sister marries well. And also, the trauma I went through to protect her is not going to be worth it. Andie James: Yes. It yeah. Alice: If she does not make it to the finish line. If she does not have her happily ever after, everything I suffered is for nothing. And so it's so rich and complex. And so Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: like the moments when she hates her sister, you feel it. And the moments when you Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Alice: she loves her sister and it's like, I would do anything for this, you believe it. And Andie James: Yeah. Alice: the moments when her sister makes just empty headed teen girl decisions. You're like, Andie James: Ha ha ha. Alice: I wanna wring your stupid neck, but also I get it 'cause Andie James: I know. Alice: I was a teen girl and I want to be free. it the the Andie James: I know. Yeah. Alice: there's a richness to this world that I find so compelling. And I think is just Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: one of the things that makes Anne Stewart really stand out to me. Because this is a very dark world and this is a very Andie James: It is. Mm-hmm. Alice: it's it's a world that's very hard to navigate emotionally and and even strategically Andie James: Mm. Alice: for Elinor. How do I get out of this? How do I get out of this this thing that my mother has put me into? 'Cause Andie James: Yeah. Alice: like they literally have one bed with one sheet and one chair. Like they live in squalor. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. I was gonna say we we we didn't full out say this, but I think it's implied in some of the things we said. But they are in a very precarious situation. So her mother was married to I don't fully understand. I I feel like my brain didn't comprehend exactly like if her father just kicked her mother out or like what was going on because he married another and so it's kind of unclear. Alice: Yeah. Andie James: I I don't know. Somehow they're married. Yeah. Alice: I'm trying to remember the details, but the mother the mu the marriage ends, the mother goes. Andie James: Yeah. But Elinor is the daughter of a English baron. so some connection there. So kind of similar to Francis in like there's ties to English nobility. We're kind of both living these lives of exile in France a little bit, although hers a little different from his. but they are in this state now, where they, I mean, deeply impoverished. and, you know, it's kind of I I've had people argue this when I'm explaining plots in my books too before where they're like, Well, why doesn't she just go get a job? And I'm like, not quite that Alice: Mm. Andie James: easy with the way that you've been raised and the skills that you have and the like all of that. But so trying to find a way out of this and mother wanders off to this someone takes her to one of the King of Hells parties and she's taken with her like literally the last cents that they have. To gamble with. And so she has to go after her mother because this is their last hope. And and then, you know, they meet each other and she just won't take any of his shit. She doesn't respond to him. She's standing up to him and he's like, Well, this is new. I'm so bored, and this is new. Like, I'm very intrigued by this woman. And then he can't stop thinking about her. And he becomes a little obsessed, as you said, and he wants to find ways to protect her while also desiring her, but he's not gonna force her to. Sleep with him, but he is also not not forceful and I don't know, it's this kind of I don't know. Yes. Alice: Look, dear, dear listener, I will just say this. There is a moment in this book where Anne Stewart fully had me believing that this man burned this woman's house down. And I was like, Yeah, good for him. Good for him. I'm so glad he did that. Like I was rooting Andie James: Yeah. Alice: for him to have burned her house down. Cause I was like, Yeah, and then she can move in with him. How fun. Like it's just the house does burn down in the middle. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. 'Cause their house does burn down in the middle. Alice: And there is a brief moment where you're meant to believe that he did it and you're kind of rooting for him. And like that's the level Andie James: and it yeah. I know. I know. It's crazy. Alice: of obsession that Anne Stewart convinces you he has, that you're like, I Andie James: Yeah. Alice: fully believe he would have burned the house down because she's too stubborn to accept the help. And he knows she needs the help. So he's like, Well, if I literally burn the ships, she has to come to shore. Right. And obviously he doesn't burn her house down, someone else does it, bad guys do it. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Let me just force your hand into this. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Well, and it's very so her mother is very ill now. Like we said, she has some kind of STD. I'm th they saying it's making her mad, so I'm inclined to think maybe like syphilis or something. you know, it's very clear that like she is at the end of her life now. Like we're talking weeks, maybe a month, right? and he's just so offhandedly like, well, she's suffering and life no good now. Like, do you want me just take care of her for you? And so it's kind of like Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: and so you believe 'cause she dies in this fire. The mother dies. and you kind of believe like, well maybe did he? And especially later, again, spoilers, like he does straight up kill some people for Elinor in the end. So it's like, yeah. Alice: Yeah, I love it. I don't know why. I'm just like, oh Rohan. Ugh. No. Andie James: I know. do I like people killing? No, but at the same time it's very good reason to. Alice: Yeah. Andie James: So anyways, so yeah, you kinda believe like maybe he did set this fire because to rid her of her burden and make her have to accept his his help and his cause she really has nothing and she needs to protect, Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: you know. But so she ends up at his home after all this. there's there's a lot more in between where, she's she's fighting his help, but then she finally is like, fine, he's gonna keep sending stuff, I might as well take advantage of it. And she is against her own will, attracted to him, right? She's never gonna let him know that. But sh there's there's some feelings there that she's fighting because her only experience thus far with sex has been very bad. Alice: Mm. Andie James: and so yeah, but she gets to the house and it's interesting because I I sent Alice some of my thoughts and my email is like, okay, here's the deal. I don't really read dark romance, so I don't know exactly what I'm saying. But I was like, this is like a non-dark dark romance. Like it feels to Alice: Yes. Andie James: me because he basically like finds he makes her sign a contract and like coerces almost like blackmails her into staying, and basically is like, cause he's about to have The big soiree of the year for the heavenly host at his place while she's there, kind of sheltering after the fire. And he kind of is essentially like, Well, I want you to stay with me, and you need to stay with me. Cause if you do, I'll send your sister away. She'll be protected. It'll be great. But if not, let's bring her back and see what happens. And it's kind of it's very dastardly. And you're like, Francis, what the hell? Like Alice: Yes. I love that you use the word dastardly because I think there's an element to this book Andie James: Yeah. Alice: that feels like when I was reading it, I felt like I was a girl in like 1816 reading this by candlelight. Like there is something about it that feels so like Andie James: E Alice: someone wrote this with a quill. Like Andie James: Yeah. Alice: everybody is the most of everything. there's Andie James: Yeah. Alice: something so theatrical about it. And that's kind of I think part of what makes it it's dark, but you don't feel like you're reading a dark romance. Or it's Andie James: No. Alice: the atmosphere and the mood is dark, but Andie James: Mm. Alice: it's not a dark romance. It feels like it feels like Count of Monte Cristo. It feels like like there's like a f Andie James: Yes, that's a great comparison. Alice: There's a flourish and a flair to it that makes it Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Alice: almost feel like inevitable. okay, well, it's Andie James: Yeah. Alice: it's fine because they're going to be all right in the end and I know that Andie James: Yeah. Alice: he actually cares about her. Having his point of view, I think, in the book makes it really Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Alice: important as well. I don't know, sorry, your thoughts. Andie James: No, well, it's just it's interesting because there's really this emphasis throughout the book. And I think part of this is what makes it maybe feel a little more old school than 2010. and I mean know that this was part of the times too that, you know, we're set in, but there's this real emphasis on like innocence and virtue, right? Alice: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Andie James: And you know, cause she's trying so hard to protect her sister, both because of the value and worth of that, but also because just to protect her sister, since she was not protected herself. And for so long Rohan thinks that she is an innocent, like Elinor herself. And he's like, Well, I can't I I don't debauch innocence. Like I can't, you know, there is I use that word again, debauch. I don't know, but or not yeah. Alice: And indeed, there's one of my favorite Elinor moments is when she feels like Rohan is getting too emotionally close to her. And Andie James: Mm, mm. Alice: in her head, she's like, Well, she thinks he is pursuing her because there's only power in virginity, and she must be a virgin. He must think she's a virgin. And so if I despoil that image, then then he won't want me. And so she Andie James: Right right. huh. Yes. Mm-hmm. Alice: comes up with this like ridiculous lie about I had a piano teacher and when my mother wasn't around I you know let myself be taken by this piano teacher Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: and Rohan's like I believe you that you are not an innocent I do not believe that story and one day Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: I hope I know what the truth is and then Andie James: Yes. Alice: when he does find out the truth he hates that he knows the truth and then he has to do something with the truth. Andie James: Yes. Alice: And there Andie James: Yes. Alice: I I love Rohan so much. It's like it's like the opposite of flames on the side of my face. I here's the thing. Okay, let's get into it. Let's talk about let's talk about Rohan. Andie James: Okay. Alice: so I I have some fatigue. I think I also write contemporary and I think I'm feeling a lot of that hero fatigue, cinnamon roll fatigue in contemporary, especially. And I'm feeling it in my own writing, I'm feeling it in the right in reading other books, like I have cinnamon roll hero fatigue. And one of the kinds of heroes, I think it's all to me. I look at a bookshelf right now and I'm seeing shadow daddies and I'm seeing cinnamon rolls. Andie James: Yes. Alice: And Rohan is neither of those things. Rohan is a third Andie James: Yeah. Alice: kind of hero that we really only see in sometimes mafia romance, but really typically in like older school historical romance. Andie James: Yes. Alice: So for example, the other Counterpoint I always give is Alessander in Alice Coldbreth's The Favorite. and I call it the operator hero. And it's Andie James: Okay. Alice: sometimes they're like typically they're dandies. You know, they're guys who like Andie James: Yes. Alice: really like fine things and really like nice wine and really like like they are kind of in some ways queer-coded, which I think is why a lot of contemporary writers don't like to touch that, because they're like, well, I don't want him to seem queer coded, I want him to be strong, Andie James: Interesting. Yeah. Alice: masculine, I'm a I'm a man's man and with Andie James: Yeah, because Rohan's leaning into the flamboyant Georgian all of it. Yeah. Alice: yes. He he is gonna have the best of everything, and Elinor to him is the best of everything. And like that is there's a kind of an allure to that. But the Operator Hero is so fascinating to me because they one of the things that I love about romance is that the ultimate currency in romance is like care and attention. It's you know, I This person is important enough to me that I will spend my time, money, brain power, effort, resources to do something for them that I know they need or want. And the operator hero is like, okay, I all I ever do is machinations. I do schemes. I do, you know, hijinks behind the scenes. Andie James: Yes. Alice: I I pull the puppet strings. I'm not the big strong alpha, but I pull the puppet strings of the big strong alpha. And the sh the guy who's like lurking in the shadows, moving the chess pieces. And Andie James: Yeah. Alice: watching that guy, who typically only does it for his own self-interest Andie James: Mm. Alice: and and self-preservation, like Rohan cannot go back to England because he will be killed as soon as his boots hit the sand. Like that's what he always says. Like, I can't go back because they'll kill me. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: And watching a man who has created for himself this whole new Persona, identity, life, fiefdom in France, then suddenly be like, no, every scheme I have ever schemed, I have to use all of that brain power now to make this one woman okay. There's a certain kind of compelling romantic element to that. Whether he is murdering someone who harmed her or bringing her clothes. Like, they're yes. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And he's like irritated about it. He's like Alice: He does not that's the other thing about the operator hero, Alessander in the Coldbreath book, is the same way, where it's like, I don't want to be doing this, and I wish I didn't feel compelled, but yet no one else is going to do it. So now it's my job. it's like I see something that needs doing, and now it is Andie James: She's become my responsibility. Alice: yes. But like, it's also not this ward was dropped in my lap and now I have to deal with her. It's like Andie James: Right, right. Alice: something in me has ch has said mine to this woman. And and there is an allure to that as a romance Andie James: Yes. Yes. Mm-hmm. Alice: reader that we don't see a ton in modern Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: romance, historical or contemporary or otherwise. Andie James: Yeah. Alice: And I kind of love it. I kind of dig it. It's sort of fearless in a way, Andie James: Yeah. Alice: 'cause it's it's a big swing, right? Like he's he's not a good guy. And and you could turn off and indeed do turn Andie James: Yeah. Alice: off a lot of readers. Rohan's not everybody's cup of tea. But for Andie James: Yeah. Alice: the people it works, it works. Andie James: Yeah. Well and it's interesting because for as much like What am I trying to say? Not inuendo inuendo but also there's no shying away from sex in this book as far as like what Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: he's engaged in, his what he's created with the Heavenly Host and all this. But for all that and all his talk, like they don't actually sleep together until 70, 75% through this book. Alice: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Andie James: and but that scene to me was so interesting because Like I was saying, he wa at first was convinced of her innocence and so he's kinda pushing her away. And then she as a defense is kind of like, no, I'm actually not and but then there's like the back and forth with the stories and whatever. But so then when she finally explains to him, gives him the truth, 'cause she's like planning to leave. So she's like it sh she's She's found some means of escape, which we'll go off on that whole s part of the story in a minute. But Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: she's found some means of escape and she's planning to leave, so she's like, What the hell? I'll just tell him he'll get the story, he'll move on, whatever. so she tells him about how she spent three months with this man and her mother and like set this all up and everything. And he is just like livid, and he finds out, like he convinces her to give him the name. And he realizes that it's one of the people who's currently in his home for this Bacchanal whatever. and so he promptly goes and challenges the man to a sword fighting duel and kills him. And so he comes back, he's very Alice: My first thought was the the Simpsons or I think it's either Simpsons or one of those shows where it's like and nothing of value was lost. He kills him and nothing of value was lost. Mm-mm. No. Andie James: Think about it. No, not really. We don't we don't miss this man. and but he come he's kind of in this like you know, because he just killed someone, right? Which presumably he's never done before. He's kind of like, you know, and he's kind of in this Alice: Well he he has a lot of trauma from Culloden in the war and hi his brother and but mm-hmm. Andie James: From Culloden. So he's killed people in the war. He's seen people, he's seen his family killed in front of him. And yeah. But so he's kind of in a mood and he comes back and she doesn't know what's happened. Obviously there's been some kind of fight because he's like got some blood and stuff. And but he kind of like cavemans a little bit and like carries her off to this secluded part of the castle and whatever. And she kind of resigns herself, like she's just I don't remember exactly how it all goes down here, but she resigns herself to like, this is happening. this is the moment and I I am attracted to him and I'm gonna kind of surrender to it. So she's kind of finally been like, okay, yes, I can I can get over my trauma. I can have sex with this man and try to enjoy whatever. but then so she's getting ready for it and she's like, okay, I'll just lie here in the bed and I'll be still and you can do what you need. And he realizes in that moment, shit, she actually isn't innocent. Like she's lost Alice: Mm. Mm-hmm. Andie James: her virtue. She's not a virgin anymore, but she is truly an innocent. Like this woman has no idea what's going on. She's never experienced this as anything but good. And then all of a sudden he's just like, I cannot do this. And he's Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: just like, so he backs off. And then she's like, What the hell? I was ready for you. I finally and so she like convinces him to come back and they finally do sleep together. And it's but I just thought like that twist where it's like he's just like, shit, like this is worse than I thought and I cannot do this. And that moment of conscience, not that he's never had it, like, Alice: Mm-hmm. No. Andie James: but I was just like, okay. Alice: Well there's he literally just murdered a man for making her feel that way. And Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Alice: then he he recognizes the monster in himself and he's like, Andie James: Mm. Yes. Alice: no no no no no no no Andie James: Yeah. Alice: no actually like I'm a pretend monster. I'm not a real monster. Andie James: Yes. Alice: I'm not a monster to you. And and it's like that that sort of Again, that's like a growth moment where he's like he has to to reckon with choices he's made, actions he's done to her, for Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Alice: her, and then decide, okay, well, what am I gonna do next? And then she has to kind of take on this, this isn't a game to him. It's not just Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: I'm not just a plaything that he is sort of Andie James: Yeah. Alice: like putting, you know, he I'm not a bird in a cage that he's sort of like fancying himself with for a while. He actually Andie James: Yeah. Alice: does care on some level about me or about this and then that allows her to fully open up to I'm not just a thing. I'm not just a body in a bed. I am a person that he's having this moment with. And Andie James: Mm. Alice: that like allows them both to kind of open up to something deeper and more real and physical intimacy, which is which is really great. I Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Alice: love it. I don't know. I I every time people are like, why do you like this book? And I'm like, you either get the TED talk or you get, I don't know. Andie James: feel that way too because like Alice: Hehehehe. Andie James: I like I said, this is it's not like I've not read stuff like this before, but like it's Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: not necessarily I would say my go to. Like it's a little darker than I but it's not like we said, like I don't know. I don't know how to explain it. but yeah, I'm like he's everything that like in real life I would absolutely hate. Which Alice: Yes. Andie James: is very true, I think, all the time of, you know, when we read Roman not all the time, but like, Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: one of my friends, Celine Oliver, she loves a f she freaking loves a himbo and she's like a real life god no, but you know, on the page, give me the himbo, like yeah. Yes. Alice: No. Celine Oliver also also excellent. Excellent. Everybody should be paying attention to what Celine's cooking up. Andie James: Her first book is coming out in February. And you guys, she's she's in my writing group. I've read part of it. It's amazing. It's it's called Where There's an Earl, There's a Way. So little little call out, but yeah, it's great. well and it's interesting because in a way this book felt similar-ish, I guess, to a book I did a couple months ago with Sri Savita, and that makes sen sense to me because Sri just recently started reading this series and she is currently obsessed with the third book in the series called Breathless. So now I'm like, well now I need to keep reading because I need to see like Alice: Yes. Okay. Here's the thing, now we gotta now we gotta have a three-headed podcast and have her on to talk about it because I am fascinated with this series because it does not do kind of the typical like book two is about the heroine's sister, book three is about the hero's cousin. Like it's not like that. It it's the house of Rohan, so it's about all of the descendants of this first couple. And book two suffers from what I call the rake's son disease. And it's like I have You can't it's hard, it's not you can't, but you it's harder to sell a rake whose father is a reformed rake from an earlier book. Because typically rakes are rakes because it's trauma, Andie James: This what what's the the Alice: something happened. And but I already Andie James: Yeah. Alice: saw this man get redeemed and he actually he's awesome and he's my best friend, so shut up by your dad that way. Like don't talk about him that way. That's Andie James: Yeah. Alice: my friend. And why are you acting this way? Your dad's cool, don't be a dick. Like it it Andie James: Yeah. All of a sudden I'm like blinking on his name, but St. Vincent's son, that book where with Pandora, everyone hates yeah. Sorry, going off on Kleypas again. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: Yes, same. Yes. It's it just it's just it it's harder to sell if I have all of the context. And so the the first, the third, and then like the fourth and fifth, I think, are are like I I would read and talk about again. The second one I'm always like Andie James: Mm. Alice: I don't know. It just didn't the the follow didn't work for me, I think. Maybe if there had been like Andie James: Yeah. Alice: a bigger gap between books or Something, but I was just like, don't talk about Francis that way. Andie James: Yeah. Alice: Francis, what you why's your kid acting like this? Get him straighten him out. Like, you know, it's just so funny to to watch like romance families like that because it just it Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: it affects how you internalize and understand like the child's the the main character's trauma because you know and are friends with and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: love their parents. So you're like hmm mm-hmm Andie James: It's so interesting. I have this concept that I would love to organize a collaborative series. And I want it to go across the I want it to like follow a family across the generation. So I want to get all my friends that write in different time periods, right? And so like Alice: Cool. Yeah. Andie James: I don't know. So I have this thought, but now I'm like, God, but that's true. Yeah. I'm like, but that's true. That like yeah. Alice: That's very much my thing. I love that. But I think I think if you're dealing with time periods that are far enough apart, you can kind of get away with that a little bit better. And especially Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: like the great thing about historicals is like there's always a war. Like you can it couldn't be like Andie James: There's always war. Alice: Their parents were great, but their great love died in the Lusitania, right? it can be it doesn't have to be parent trauma. It doesn't have to be daddy issues. Like it can be something else. Right. And Andie James: Right. Yeah. There's other things. Yes. There's Alice: maybe it is. Maybe it's like my mom died after they had this great love story, and I'm never gonna have a love story like them, and you know, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Alice: whatever. Like there there are ways to do it. It's just such a harder needle to thread, I think. but yeah, what Andie James: It is harder. Yeah. Yeah. Alice: a what a series. Anne Stewart just doing things that Andie James: Well, Marigo. Another thing about this book too is it's like you said, it's very expansive and it really creates this big world. you really feel the time period and it's just no one's writing that time period right now, I feel like. But well, my friend Musty Urban sometimes. But anyways, a little different. but yeah, like no one's writing Georgian anymore, no one's writing medieval anymore. Again, except for Harlequin, We Love You. But so there's like some side stories going on here, which I admire this because I write very focused like on my couple, and so I'm like, I don't know. But I really enjoy so we've mentioned the younger sister Lydia a lot. She gets a little side story, she falls in love with this beautifully scarred man. Anyways, but the other side thing going on, which maybe isn't quite a side because it's pretty integral to what happens and some some plot stuff. But from the very first, when we first meet Elinor, like she is just talk to a lawyer because they we find out that her father has died, distant cousin has inherited she something has been bequeathed to her. great. Great word. Sorry, title of one of my books , Bequeathed. she doesn't know what thank Alice: It's so good. Andie James: you. But she's trying to like get in touch with the cousin who's like out of town and figure out what's going on here. So cousin Marcus becomes kind of an integral part the story. from the beginning, there's something a little off. Nanny Maud, who tragically dies in the fire as well. Rest in peace, Nanny Maud. we love you. Alice: Pour one out. Andie James: But she's like, there's she's keying into something being wrong and but she pretty much figures it out right before she dies, but is not able to communicate that 'cause she dies. but we find out essentially, there's also like this random little scene in the middle where we change point of views and stuff where it's like this lawyer looking into I don't think it was the same lawyer Elinor was working with. But he's figured out there's something fishy going on and he has like forged whatever papers to say that he is Alice: Yeah. Andie James: the heir parent. and so Marcus just like kills the dude. You know. We're not we're not afraid of a little blood in this book, people. and so we're like, okay, so there's definitely something wrong with this guy now, but we don't know exactly what. Come to find out, I don't remember how we find out exactly. I mean Francis is looking into him because he's like. He just needs to make sure that Elinor's okay. So he's gotta look into this. No. No. He just, he just Yeah. Yeah. Make sure it's all in the up and up. Alice: Yeah, Francis does not trust this dude. Yeah, he's not jealous. Stop saying he's jealous. He's not jealous at all. Why would you even think that? It's not about that. He just wants to check that it's all okay. Yeah. Andie James: Cause it's like her only hope at this point, right? Is like some kind of money she will have coming to her. Or yeah. Alice: Right. De a sex machina, yes. Andie James: So but we find out that essentially he's actually her half brother. dad Alice: Mm. Andie James: had a dalliance with someone. so he is not actually able to inherit, right? He's not acknowledged, he's not whatever. And so because there's not a true heir, Elinor has actually inherited this estate. It's hers. Marcus knows this. Elinor has no idea. So he basically she still thinks this is her cousin. We find out later, he's the one who actually set the fire. and maybe trying to kill Elinor herself. there was also an incident kind of mid book where Rohan gets shot, like he's in a carriage Alice: Yeah. Andie James: and there's this stray sh bullet or not stray, but whatever. Alice: Basically a drive by shooting, essentially. Yeah. Andie James: Dreadby shooting, yeah. And it's very is someone trying to kill him? Is someone trying to kill Redding, reading, I dunno I don't know his friend who is in the carriage with him, who ends up marrying Lydia, our scarred beautiful man. like it's kind of unclear and then but then it's like, well, was maybe Elinor? Like, you know? Rohan has the suspicion because like maybe they thought she was in the carriage with him because they had just been together. And so it's all kind of like, what's going on? And so we basically find out that Marcus has been trying to kill Elinor so that there's no challenge to him being the cousin to inherit and whatever. and he's also the one who like provided her the means to try and escape from Rohan's castle. anyways At some point he finds her, he convinces her the best solution here is to marry me. Alice: Mm. Andie James: I you know, I'm your long distant cousin, it's fine, right? And then, you know, I can take care of you. You can go back to the house you grew up in, whatever. And she's like, Well, they don't really have another choice. So, sure. This maybe is the best solution. But something feels hanky about it, like it's a little off. And then find out later, like He has no qualms kissing her or maybe even sleeping with her, even though he's her half-brother. He knows this. She doesn't know this. He's fine with it, cause whatever. But then he tries to kill her again, obviously. cause then he would for sure, even if it's found out that he inherited, he was married to her, so it's like guaranteed to come to him, cause you know, everything that's the wife's now is the husband's, because you know, that's how it works. I'm going off now. But anyway, that whole thing was crazy to me. I'm like, let's just throw out a little incest, why not? Uhhuh. Alice: Yeah, but I but that's like I think one of the other things that makes it feel like not just old school, but a book Andie James: Yes. Alice: I would read by candlelight in the eighteen hundreds. that feels Andie James: Yes. Alice: like such a like Bronte sister third act twist. Like I Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Alice: it it's so gross and like no, like you no, you can't do that. Like and and Andie James: Yeah. Can't do that. Alice: it makes So Andie James: Yeah. Alice: I I put this forward as one of I think the best grand romantic gestures of all time. I love it so much. So Marcus, Andie James: Yes, let's get into it. Alice: the entire book, Rohan's like, I can't go back to England. I will be killed. I am a traitor. I'm in France for this reason. Like I have a great life here. I'm so cushy, it's boring and whatever, but like I live in a castle, it's great. And then Elinor gets whisked away by Marcus back to England. So they can be married and they can inherit this estate and then he can kill her. And Rohan's like, shit, now I have to go back to England and risk dying for this woman I love. And he's like so annoyed by it, but he has to. He can't not. And he has to. And Andie James: I have to go after her. He has to. Yeah. Alice: like he does. He does go back. And like Andie James: He does. Alice: the rescue moment is just so ugh. the I think one of the things to me that sells a grand romantic gesture, and this is like I I have a whole thesis about like the grand romantic gesture and the anti romantic gesture, grand anti romantic gesture. Because like the New Moon breakup scene in Twilight and like New Moon has so many anti grand gestures where it's like I love you so much that I'm going to hurt you and kill myself. because I love you so much, I have to protect you and I have to hurt both of us to protect you. Like that is an anti-grand romantic gesture or grand anti-romantic gesture. And a grand romantic gesture, they share the same DNA and it is sacrifice. It is like I am willing to risk something impossible, something like impossibly big. Because I love you and because it's you are worth it to me to do the one thing I always said I wouldn't do or couldn't do. and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alice: this is literally his life on the line, and he's done everything. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: And again, thinking about like that that family sacrifice. Elinor, everything has to work out because if it doesn't work out for her sister, then her sacrifice didn't matter. Rohan has something kind of similar with his past where it's like. I built this life here off of the backs of my dead brothers. Like, if I don't live, then them dying means nothing. And also, like, fuck that country, they sent me away. I hate England. And I don't want to go back just to die in England. Like, who wants to die in England? Right. And and so, like, Andie James: Right. Right. Yeah. To die for this false king and like, yeah. Alice: the fact that he goes anyway, Andie James: Yeah. Alice: it just like It gets me every time. I I'm a simple woman. I just wanna see a man do a hard thing. I don't know. Like that to me that's love to me sometimes. Andie James: And he's so yeah, and it's also like the it's so cliche but so delicious and cliche for a reason. Like she does manage to escape like right after they have been together because she overhears him saying something that he doesn't actually truly mean. He's Alice: Really mean. Andie James: just acting out and basically being like, Yeah, we just had this like whatever dalliance and yeah. And so she's like, nope, gotta get out of here. Runs into Marcus conveniently, and he's like, Yeah, let's get married and go back and whatever. So she goes off with him. All Rohan knows is that she is gone and she has left. He doesn't know she overheard things. She doesn't know he left with Marcus. He just knows she left. And so he thinks that to her it meant nothing. She thinks to him it meant nothing. And so he who was Mr. always in control, right? Like, because he is the one, as you said, pulling the strings. He is the one making everything happen. Like he is gonna participate in, you know, his little hedonist whatever. But he's like always still maintaining some level of something. side note, another way that it felt old school to me. because nowadays people are like, once you've met the one, you can't anything else. he full on sleeps with other people while he's dreaming of Elinor. he's just like, Yeah. Alice: Yeah, he does. A hundred percent. Yeah. Andie James: Anyways. side note, sorry. but yeah, but he like goes off on this drunken because he can't handle anymore. Like he thought they'd connected and she left and that's all he knows. And so he, you know, his friend Charles finds him. three days on and he's in this drunken stupor and whatever. And so then he's just so pissed at himself because he let three days go by, right? Before he can go and rescue her. And but he rides in just in time, of course. And he's like, Alice: Naturally. Andie James: Of course he's gonna, And in the meantime, Charles has now married Lydia. And so Elinor is now his responsibility too as a sister-in-law. And so he's like, No, no, no, you can't go back. Like you stay here. I'll go take care of this. Like, I'll get her. And then Rohan's like, hell no, you won't. You think I can not be the one to make sure she's okay? Like Yeah. Like Alice: Right. I'm not trusting this to an errand boy. this is my job. Come on. Andie James: I I have to do this. yeah. So I don't yeah, I really I really enjoyed it. And I I d I don't I mean obviously we just spent like close to an hour, maybe not an hour because we talked about other things, but we spent all this time talking about this, but I'm still like, I don't know. Like Alice: Right. It is it's I I think I described it to somebody as the ambergris of romance novels once. I Andie James: Mm. Alice: was like, it's gross great. Like and you're either Andie James: Yeah. Alice: gonna love it or you're it's not gonna be for you. But I think n even if Andie James: Well, it tells me Alice: I think no matter what, I hope people who read it come away with it thinking about Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: romance craft. You know, like Andie James: Yeah. Alice: this isn't just a book that you put down and you never think about again. Andie James: Right. Alice: And I think it it can stick in your brain and you can kinda walk around with it for Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alice: a little bit and and try and figure it out. Andie James: I think it goes to show how well written it is. Because as Alice: Mm-hmm. Andie James: you've pointed out, you know, like there's so many layers to these characters and why they feel and act the way that they do. Like Elinor's not just a protective older sister. Like there's there's a lot to that. There are times she loves her sister, there's times she hates her sister. We find out there isn't why like it's so complex and she pulls it off. And I think great writers do that. And like I'm gonna make A wildly crazy reference here. But when I was in high school, we had to read Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton. I don't know if you know this book. Alice: yeah, the one with the the sled. Andie James: Yes. And I remember just reading that book and being like, like he basically he has this miserable life, he has a terrible wife. Like he kind of falls in love with the wife's cousin, who's this lovely young woman who's there taking care of the wife because the wife's very sick and like whatever. And and in general, not really for adultery, not really for, these things, but you are rooting for him to cheat on his wife and find happiness and like Alice: Have some slice of happiness. Andie James: be with Maddie, this young girl and whatever. And then in the end, like it's all tragic and sorry, spoiler, but it's an old book. But like essentially they sled themselves into a tree on purpose, like essentially trying to kill themselves because they're both so miserable and they can't be together, which, a little over dramatic, right? But they don't die. They're just like injured and miserable still. Alice: Yeah. Andie James: And like saddest ending of the book, right? And like, you know, I was just like, well, this is a damn good written book because I find myself rooting for things that normally I'm against. Like, Alice: Yeah. Andie James: you know, and so I feel like this book is kind of that way. Like normally I would never find a character like him like anything good or redeemable, but now I'm like, Francis, like you did this thing and like and so it's just I don't I don't know if that comparison makes sense outside my brain. But like Alice: No, it a hundred percent makes sense. I I love a book where when I read it and I set it down and I Andie James: Mm. Alice: think about it, I'm like, in any other book, that character is the villain. And it it it happens with Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Alice: heroes and heroines sometimes, you know, where you read it and you're like, No, no, no. Like, if the book was from if if she was the third angle of this triangle, I would have thought she was a horrible, whatever, Andie James: Yeah. Alice: whatever, whatever. I think Rohan's a hundred percent like that. Rohan is the villain Andie James: Yeah. Alice: in like a thousand historical romance novels. Andie James: Yeah. Alice: But in this one this is like, you know, we think about this sort of ethos of romance that like there is someone for everyone. Like there there is your your person is out there, your red string is connected to somebody out there in the world. Like Rohan found the one person with whom he could have a love story. And I think that's what great romance craft does. Like that a really great writer in a romance context finds two people who on the surface should not be together and have no business being together. Andie James: Right. Yeah. Alice: But in fact, they are the only two people on earth who could make each other happy. And that's that's what Anne Stewart has done Andie James: Yeah. Alice: in this book. And and I just think there's so much to learn from it and take away from it. Andie James: Yeah, it's masterful. Yeah. Alice: And I could talk about it forever, even though it's it's got so many so many things to your point that just normally I'm like, No, I would never root for a guy to burn a girl's house down. That's not that's red flag behavior. That's not a hero, that's not hero material. But I kinda wanted him to do Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Alice: it, you know? Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. No, it's crazy. So cheers to Anne Stewart. I I yeah. Alice: Cheers to Anne Stewart and thank you for letting me talk about this for so long. Andie James: Course. Of course. No, this was great. I really do think I need maybe I can skip book two and just go to book three and I don't know. Because like I said, Sri's like I love it. And I don't know. We can we can do another little discussion at some point. But well, thank you for opening my eyes to Anne Stewart and Rohan and all his craziness and Alice: Lord of Danger next. Lord of Danger next. That's another Andie James: Okay. All right. I'm writing it down. Alice: very good older sister book. It has one of my favorite lines in all of romance literature canon. The this kind of evil warlock marries this woman and the the younger sister is the much prettier one. And the king of this is medieval and the king is like, you know, you can still divorce her and you know, you should marry the pretty sister and The warlock looks at him and says, My lord, I already have. And I'm just like, I just knocked over stuff on my desk. I was so excited. Like, my lord, I have. Andie James: I love it. I love it. Alice: He did marry the pretty sister. I'm like, So good. Anyway, Anne Stewart, Andie James: yeah, see this is Alice: she's she's cooking with recipes we have all forgotten, and we need to bring them back, is my point. Andie James: There we go. There we go. No, I love it. I love it. So well, thank you, Alice. Alice: Thank you so much for having me and thank you to all of your lovely listeners for for enduring me yapping about Anne Stewart. Andie James: No, it's great. It's great. I thank you so much for joining me. And I'm glad you were a game for this when I reached out and was hey, do you want to talk about this book that you said you just wanted to shout about? Like Alice: Hehehe Andie James: no, I love it. and everyone, if you have not yet read Alice's book, you should. I'll have links to info on Alice and her books and where to find info and all that stuff in the show notes. so it's A Showgirls Rules for Falling in Love and coming in twenty twenty seven. Very excited about this. The premise is like these journalists and I I'm I'm all for it. I'm all for it. So Modern Girls Guide to Love and Divorce coming in 2027 So keep your eyes peeled for that. I'm very excited for this. there's been this Alice: Thank you. Andie James: rise in 20th century that I'm so excited about. A lot of my my own friends are Alice: I am so glad it's happening. Andie James: writing it, like Hillary Bowen, Lindsay Barrett, Jane Hadley and like, yeah, everyone's Alice: Mm-hmm. They're both so great. Yes. I love that it's Andie James: yeah. Alice: happening. I I told someone once that my goal as a historical romance writer is to like basically have my own American girl collection, you know? Like I want to have Andie James: Love that. Alice: like a heroine for like a bunch of different time periods and like get to look at it and be like, how did love change over American history? Like I think that's such a cool project Andie James: Love it. Alice: as a romance writer. So I'm excited. Let I hope I hope the universe lets me do it. So now we have Gilded Age in in 1960s. We'll see what's after that. I'm hoping it's nineteen twenties or the Revolutionary War, but who knows. Andie James: It's great. Ooh. That sounds fun. I love it. I love it. All right. Well everyone, if you've not read Alice Murphy, you should. It's great. If you've not read Anne Stewart like me, you're in for a treat. I mean Alice: Yes. Andie James: I definitely need to read more now. The problem is the time. The time. But you know, it's okay. I know. Like there's Alice: Who can have the time? It's so much. Andie James: so many books I've read for the podcast now where I'm like, I want to keep reading this author, but I just, you know, I gotta go into the next book for the podcast and then, you know, who who knows? One of these days. But anyways, Alice, it has been an absolute pleasure. Thank you so much. and everyone who's listening, go try some Anne Stewart. So happy reading and listening and we'll talk to you all next time. All right, thanks. Bye.