Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E038: Dubai Debrief with Jackson Mikalic & Brian Cubellis
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:12having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. What you're telling me is that
- 1:25music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:28the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:33history of governors 1974198792972000.
- 1:40And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:42It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:44We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 1:49I say when we. Sell.
- 2:00What the hell did you gentlemen do over in the Middle East?
- 2:03You were missed. You know our friends at Coimena,
- 2:06they were asking about you. They were seeing if you can can
- 2:09make it and told them we'll get you out there soon enough.
- 2:12I had, I had prior engagements in Palm Beach.
- 2:14Great weekend in Palm Beach too. Maybe it was a little double
- 2:19action. You guys were in the Middle
- 2:20East, I was in South Florida, was getting getting everybody
- 2:23bowled up, pushing Bitcoin above $50,000, currently standing at
- 2:28$51,604.00 according to Bipo. We're, we're pumping.
- 2:34The quietest $51,000. It's beautiful.
- 2:38People keep saying that. Is it that quiet?
- 2:40It seems pretty loud. I don't know anybody talking
- 2:43about it outside of these five guys on this, yeah.
- 2:46I think we're just we're in the bubble, man.
- 2:48Like I think it it feels like people are talking about it, but
- 2:51most people are not thinking about this.
- 2:54I'm thinking about. It healthy.
- 2:55It's a healthy base, right? Now I'm waking up wife and I are
- 2:58dancing in the kitchen. It's a it's a good vibe.
- 3:03So we're back on the last trade and as I just mentioned we're
- 3:08here with the whole or a large majority of the on ramp team.
- 3:13Three of you, we're in Dubai last week at Bitcoin Oasis.
- 3:19The text message that were that were being sent as you were over
- 3:23there when you got back seems like things were pretty bullish.
- 3:26So I think what we're going to do with this episode is do a
- 3:28recap of what you guys saw over there, how the Middle East is
- 3:33thinking of Bitcoin compared to the United States.
- 3:37Obviously we had the conversation with the the Queen
- 3:42Mina team a couple weeks ago. You guys went and saw it in
- 3:46person. Michael, we'll start with you.
- 3:49Did it surpass your expectations?
- 3:51Definitely surpassed. But I want to put our buddy
- 3:54Jackson on the gun. I don't know if Jackson has been
- 3:56introduced to the the group. I know Cam was with us, but
- 4:00Cam's been on. So I thought Jackson would be a
- 4:01good person to talk about what we did.
- 4:04And also he had a lot of meetings.
- 4:06He was in the room just talking with folks from all over the
- 4:09region. So maybe Jackson, if you want to
- 4:11introduce yourself and then kind of give the heads on like the
- 4:14conversations. Let me do the intro.
- 4:15Jackson is a special place in my heart.
- 4:17We went to the same high school we met.
- 4:19Where was it? The Harvard Club or the PEN Club
- 4:21in New York City? Yeah, back in 2018.
- 4:24Yeah, we were the only two talking about Bitcoin at our
- 4:27alumni event and people thought I was crazy except for you.
- 4:31Yeah, to pick up the story from from there, it was.
- 4:34I was working in New York in 2018 and it was quite miserable.
- 4:38First job out of school and it was like all right I got to do
- 4:41anything to to advance my career here.
- 4:44And there's a Marty and I went to a private all guys Catholic
- 4:48school in Philadelphia. So there's a contingency in New
- 4:51York and we went up to or I went by myself to this networking
- 4:56event in 2018. Like I said, I was really at the
- 5:00time I was working at BNY Mellon, really just not thrilled
- 5:02about what I was doing. And I needed to figure out any
- 5:05way possible to get get, you know, by footing the door at a
- 5:09new firm and and meeting the right people.
- 5:11So I went to this networking event by myself and met Marty
- 5:15there. Like I said, I was by myself.
- 5:17Marty was having a good time with a couple of, I think, guys
- 5:20from his grade. But yeah, at the time I I owned
- 5:23a little bit of Bitcoin. It was maybe like a couple 100
- 5:26bucks. I was fresh out of school, so I
- 5:27didn't have a lot of money anyway.
- 5:29And Marty, I think you were just starting TFTC or the newsletter
- 5:35in the podcast. I'm not entirely sure where
- 5:36you're at with it at the time, but you pretty much set me
- 5:39straight. You're like, you know, stop
- 5:40focusing on the crypto and and shit coin stuff and you know,
- 5:44check out. I think it was maybe Vijay
- 5:46Boyapati's article at the time was one of the few pieces out
- 5:50there that was Bitcoin only and you know, really took a
- 5:53historical view on sound money in Bitcoin.
- 5:55And then, you know, piece by piece started following along
- 5:58there. I ended up going down the CFA
- 6:00route for a bit. So I passed the first part of
- 6:02that. It was kind of the the best way
- 6:05to advance my career in the Fiat world.
- 6:07So I ended up moving over to another firm.
- 6:09Stifel did alternative investment research there,
- 6:13covered hedge funds and private assets so private equity, credit
- 6:17and real estate. Did that for a bit and then
- 6:19actually joined a a smaller start up firm that was focused
- 6:22on agricultural investments in the US was really direct
- 6:26connecting accredited investors to investment opportunities in
- 6:30the USA. Lot of permanent crops that'd be
- 6:33like vineyards, nut trees, apple trees etcetera.
- 6:37It was really the first sales higher there, helped scale the
- 6:40firm quite a bit, raised a decent bit of money into our
- 6:44funds and and our private placements And then you know,
- 6:48really just been a bitcoiner all along.
- 6:50Like Marty said, we met back in 2018 and over time the
- 6:54conviction's grown quite a bit, 2020, it was very eye opening in
- 6:58many ways in terms of fiscal, monetary and just everything
- 7:01going on in the world. So starting to get more
- 7:03convicted. At that point it was like 2017,
- 7:0618/19. It was just kind of dabbling,
- 7:08trying to figure out what was going on.
- 7:09And then really the past three years have been really focused
- 7:12in on Bitcoin only and trying to figure out a way to break into
- 7:16the industry and couldn't have found a a better place to land
- 7:19at on ramps. Really excited about what we're
- 7:20doing here. Yeah, they put some special
- 7:25stuff in that that water down there Marty, you know concerning
- 7:28about Philadelphia and some of the the videos you see on
- 7:30Twitter. But then hearing about you know
- 7:33guys like both of you coming from there.
- 7:35But sometimes, you know we got to contain the Jackson has a
- 7:39little Jackson Jones in them and so we we got to we got to push
- 7:41it down real. The another Hey, Philadelphia
- 7:49gets a lot of Flack for good reason at times.
- 7:52But there's still a few of us among the city that believe the
- 7:56ideals that the country was founded on, which were written
- 8:00about in. In the city of Philadelphia, the
- 8:04revolutionary spirit of Philadelphia will re emerge.
- 8:07I think it will be because of people like Jackson and myself.
- 8:10I think it has to. It's like, you know going into
- 8:13the the UAE stuff now in Dubai is just incredible being there,
- 8:17right? It's, you know, I'm, I walk
- 8:19around the city of Philadelphia. It's crumbling in many ways.
- 8:24You know, there's obviously a lot of people here who still
- 8:28believe in the values of of the country and in the city and love
- 8:32the historical aspect of it. But I will say it's quite sad
- 8:35what's going on here and it's really eye opening to go
- 8:39somewhere like Dubai and just see really how prosperous the
- 8:42city is. And it is in many ways like
- 8:45something worth striving to in a city like Philadelphia or New
- 8:49York. It's it's pretty incredible.
- 8:51I mean and think the guys will chime in.
- 8:53But my experience being there for a week was was eye opening.
- 8:57It was you know kind of inspiring the amount of people
- 9:00who you know two weeks out just like wanted to take a take a
- 9:03meeting and the amount of meetings that we all had, you
- 9:07know, between the four of us that were there was quite
- 9:10surprising. I mean everyone wants to do
- 9:12business. They want to hear the story
- 9:13about Bitcoin. They want to know what we do
- 9:15specifically, how does it differ from crypto.
- 9:17And it's quite stark contrast compared to the attitude
- 9:22generally in the US, but maybe more so in in New York and
- 9:26Philadelphia, the Northeast, kind of like the Fiat hub of the
- 9:28world. Yeah, I think I got.
- 9:35Yeah, I was just going to echo some of that.
- 9:36I mean, it was, it was my first time in Dubai, been to Singapore
- 9:41in the past before. I would say there's some
- 9:42similarities there just in terms of like it's just a very
- 9:45impressive city, right? Sort of came up out of nowhere
- 9:48over the past like 10 to 20 years similar to to Singapore.
- 9:52And it's just you know America used to be thought of as as this
- 9:56melting pot. And to me it's like these are,
- 9:57these are the modern day melting pots, the the devise in the
- 10:00Singapore's of the world. And to Jackson's point, it's
- 10:03just that there was sort of a palpable difference in attitude
- 10:08and perspective about what we are doing at on ramp, but also
- 10:11just broadly in terms of like innovation and technology and
- 10:15people wanting to do business and be productive.
- 10:19So it was very refreshing in that sense just just to see the
- 10:23city that was just buzzing with with people wanting to
- 10:25collaborate and learn about what we were doing at on ramp.
- 10:28And you know even if even if there wasn't a direct way that
- 10:31they could work with us, they were you know, ready and willing
- 10:33to introduce us to people that that might be interested.
- 10:36And so just a super refreshing city to be in and really just
- 10:42met a lot of great people, potential strategic partners,
- 10:44potential clients. So overall super productive trip
- 10:49for us I think and just you know was very bullish in the sense
- 10:52that you know I think sometimes sitting here in the States, you
- 10:56know we can get lost in sort of the the Fiat bubble if you will
- 11:00or you know the US dollar bubble specifically.
- 11:02And I think there is an element of complacency with you know not
- 11:08only allocators here but regulators.
- 11:11And so the the differences there are just are are very apparent
- 11:14once you're over there that you know investors are open minded
- 11:19thinking about. You know there there is a lot of
- 11:21sort of digital asset in crypto talk in Dubai.
- 11:24But I think you know Bitcoin specifically does does resonate
- 11:27with people. There's you know interesting
- 11:30synergies between that region of the world and you know how
- 11:34they've generated their wealth over the centuries and you know
- 11:37hard assets, commodities, oil and gas.
- 11:39And so I think there's a natural tendency for them to appreciate
- 11:42something like Bitcoin, this you know digital hard asset, this
- 11:45digital commodity. So I think you know it's it was
- 11:48just interesting to see sort of that that dichotomy between you
- 11:52know what we're familiar with on a day-to-day basis and and you
- 11:54know going somewhere halfway across the world that just has a
- 11:58different outlook on things and and is just generally more open
- 12:01minded to to what we're trying to do here.
- 12:05Yeah, and. And make no mistake too that
- 12:08like yeah, as you said that Singapore and Dubai are really
- 12:11these two modern examples of like global capital havens that
- 12:18that are built on globalism in the extent like globalist
- 12:24financial markets markets at least.
- 12:27And and Bitcoin speaks to that because you know in the US if
- 12:30you have just AUS centric mindset and you think well we've
- 12:33got a good regulatory environment here and financial
- 12:36markets are strong here the dollar is strong.
- 12:39We don't really need a new currency.
- 12:41We don't really need a currency that shines going you know
- 12:44across borders in particular that is borderless.
- 12:48And you know, Dubai and Singapore in particular are all
- 12:52about borderless, you know, financial infrastructure and
- 12:59property rights and being a safe haven for capital in the way
- 13:01that Bitcoin is designed to be in, in in digital, in the
- 13:05digital landscape. So you know, of course it makes
- 13:08sense that that Dubai and Singapore would would lock down
- 13:11to, you know, the value proposition of Bitcoin above
- 13:14other financial hubs at at this point in time.
- 13:20Go ahead, Michael. Yeah, I think there was a few
- 13:24things. I think like taking a step back
- 13:26how we got involved was Laura and Lena from the Bitcoin UAE
- 13:31Association reached out based on there.
- 13:35I believe they lived in Dubai the past five to seven years.
- 13:38They recognized there needed to be a Bitcoin only advocacy group
- 13:42similar to what's going on in Texas with the Texas Blockchain
- 13:45Council. As far as helping the government
- 13:47understand, you know, why Bitcoin matters, advocating on,
- 13:51behalf of, you know, people bringing businesses to Texas,
- 13:55specifically the miners historically.
- 13:57But others in the future plan and they reached out looking at
- 14:01different partners and identified on ramp from, you
- 14:04know, from custody infrastructure asset management
- 14:08going and just being able to tell a very sophisticated story
- 14:10around the the asset. We had backgrounds in this
- 14:14obviously in Texas setting up a lot of the meetups and a lot of
- 14:16the conversation and cultivating that so that that was like the
- 14:18anchor point to go in there. And then we had partnerships
- 14:21with Quinmena and others going and so that was like the framing
- 14:24from a large part of the team and myself getting there
- 14:29initially. You look around and because we
- 14:32live in the States, it's like this place is pretty cool, but
- 14:35it looks very similar to the States.
- 14:36Obviously people wear different things, there's different
- 14:38customs. And so I thought that was like
- 14:41at surface level, that's what I was walking into.
- 14:44But then on the back half after all the conversations, I started
- 14:47to realize that it's just starting.
- 14:50Like it's we caught this in the upswing in the sense of I guess
- 14:551st to go back to Bitcoin and crypto.
- 14:58I realized like halfway through the trip that it was the most
- 15:01sophisticated crypto place on the planet earth, Earth.
- 15:04And what I mean by that is they had a lot of understanding of
- 15:07like infrastructure. They were an interesting quote,
- 15:09UN quote, interesting things around stable coins, crypto
- 15:13firms going there on. People understand you know all
- 15:17all this stuff related to crypto currencies and businesses going
- 15:20there from a geopolitical perspective for reason.
- 15:23But they were the most unsophisticated when it came to
- 15:26like Bitcoin. Why Bitcoin?
- 15:28Different forms of custody, the, the asset and basically how do
- 15:31you delineate or what's the difference between Bitcoin and
- 15:33crypto. And that was really eye opening
- 15:35because I think living in the West and as you start going East
- 15:38it's very different from like a market perspective on here in in
- 15:42the West. We at least have or specifically
- 15:44in the US, Bitcoin only firms that people recognize as Bitcoin
- 15:48only. So you can go there if you want
- 15:49to send somebody to learn about the asset.
- 15:51If you're looking to invest, if you're looking for multi sig
- 15:53custody, education, you know starting off on your journey,
- 15:58you send somebody to cash app or a river or wherever it might be,
- 16:01there's nothing like that there And it was.
- 16:03So it was very fascinating. But on the other side of it,
- 16:07it's literally the most ripe region as Brian referenced and
- 16:10everybody on, they're just like prime for it for so many
- 16:13reasons, whether it's culturally and religiously from a debt
- 16:16based or how they're against, you know, usury to understanding
- 16:20from a commodity base and also the energy aspect of it and just
- 16:23the sheer amount of capital that they're sitting on.
- 16:26And so it started to like navigate over the course of the
- 16:28week to say like Oh my God, like we're just getting started.
- 16:31Another example of this was they have a Ministry of AI where it
- 16:34was explained to me and I'll kind of butcher this, but I
- 16:36think the essence will come about in that about six years
- 16:40ago one of the partners we found there who's a family office that
- 16:44sits in Australia and then is moving to the UAE at least
- 16:48partial part time had went to like an AI convention and they
- 16:54had started about 5-6 years ago a list of about 200 projects
- 16:58that they identify that they want to implement across the
- 17:00city. And there was 200 projects that
- 17:02they put on a chart they were managing.
- 17:04And then it started to whittle down And I think the idea was to
- 17:06implement 20 of the top 200. And right now today February
- 17:112024, they're in the last five is from a strategic perspective
- 17:15and getting them implemented. And they were showing me these
- 17:17screenshots of like dashboards that look like the UI that you
- 17:20would get at a, you know Fang company here in the states that
- 17:23are governed by the the the government.
- 17:26And so when you start to look at that on the AI side, you start
- 17:29to really think about it again to what Jackson was referring
- 17:32to, the amount of interest and openness to talk about, you know
- 17:36a what we're doing or but just Bitcoin in general because it's
- 17:39a melting pot, the openness to have conversations and make
- 17:42introductions throughout the course of that week.
- 17:44We started to like loop back around to other people we were
- 17:47talking to that reference that we are had already been there or
- 17:49they knew of that individual. So it's still small enough where
- 17:52the same people are kind of working on similar things, but
- 17:56it's it's incredibly exciting. We'll talk about throughout this
- 17:58this podcast. But yeah, there's going to be a
- 18:00lot of opportunity. And anybody that's on the
- 18:02Bitcoin side, it's ever looking over there, there's it's just
- 18:04right for kind of like education and delivering services to a
- 18:08part of the world that's historically been a lot.
- 18:10As you go further E it's all crypto all the way to Singapore.
- 18:13Yeah. One thing I thought that was
- 18:15particularly interesting was kind of leading up to it, you
- 18:19know, doing prospecting and trying to find out who would be
- 18:22meeting with why. We're in the UAE and I noticed
- 18:25that a lot of people on LinkedIn use the term blockchain
- 18:29specifically, you know, rather than digital asset, digital
- 18:33assets, crypto or Bitcoin. So I what I thought was going to
- 18:38happen was spending a lot of time in these meetings trying to
- 18:42kind of start from Ground Zero and explain the Bitcoin only
- 18:46thesis. And you know, how does that
- 18:48differ from all the other crypto currencies and the blockchain
- 18:52space, right? But I found myself not really
- 18:55having to do that despite these people, a lot of people having
- 19:01blockchain in their profiles. It was almost like the maybe the
- 19:03industry term there, but it didn't necessarily signal that
- 19:06they were, you know, doing all sorts of things in the
- 19:08blockchain, right? So I went into these meetings
- 19:11thinking that it was going to be just spending a lot of time
- 19:14having to educate on Bitcoin. What is it?
- 19:16Why Bitcoin? But it was all intuitive for the
- 19:18most part. I would say 75% of my meetings,
- 19:22the conversation wasn't about Bitcoin at all.
- 19:24It was just about what we were doing specifically.
- 19:26And they already understood that Bitcoin was different from other
- 19:28crypto assets. So it was really encouraging in
- 19:30that sense too. It's just like you go in with a
- 19:33mindset or an expectation of how things are going to play out and
- 19:36it ends up being a little bit different than what I expected.
- 19:40In this case, it was, you know, really positive.
- 19:46Yeah, that's a key. That's a key insight.
- 19:48It's like the sophisticated individuals know there's a
- 19:50difference and that's where we kept finding it was the people
- 19:53on the ground that didn't know there was a difference.
- 19:55So like when you go to the meet ups and a lot of the things, the
- 19:57people shilling the stuff, it's all crypto.
- 19:59But once you go into a room with people with capital, they
- 20:02completely understand it. The problem is they don't really
- 20:04have an educational like custody.
- 20:06How do you like actually get delivery and like being able to
- 20:09allocate in size? And that that speaks to a
- 20:13problem I guess in the Bitcoin space is so many of these
- 20:18product services companies are US based, you know, in Bitcoin
- 20:22only land US based serving US customers especially if you're,
- 20:27you know, providing A hosted wallet or custodial service
- 20:31where you're taking custody of of of assets.
- 20:35And that means that, you know, a lot of these international
- 20:38places that are hungry for good Bitcoin products aren't able to
- 20:43be served by a lot of the Bitcoin only business models
- 20:47that exist in the US. And obviously you see you see
- 20:51clones of them, of of Bitcoin only companies popping up in,
- 20:55you know, specific countries, whether that's the UK or
- 20:58Australia or whatever. But it's kind of rare, I guess
- 21:03for for smaller countries like Dubai to have, you know,
- 21:08sufficient Bitcoin only startup serving what they need locally.
- 21:15And there's kind of a a shortage of the the ability for companies
- 21:20based in the US to serve the needs of of those all over the
- 21:25world. So it's kind of exciting to find
- 21:28opportunities where it is possible to serve some of those
- 21:32needs. With all this context in mind, I
- 21:37think the vibe that I've gotten is despite the fact that they
- 21:40may not be up the as far up the learning curve as we may have
- 21:45expected individuals in the Middle East to be.
- 21:48Do you think that they'll be quick to jump on this
- 21:51opportunity now that they've had the seed planted in their minds
- 21:55Like you're talking about custody very smartly?
- 21:58I think it seems like they get it intuitively now.
- 22:01Like how quickly do you think they get into this in size?
- 22:06So they're already kind of getting into it, which was
- 22:09crazy. Sorry Brian, just one thing.
- 22:12One thing popped into my mind is the Sovereign wealth fund is
- 22:17already seeding portfolio companies that do Bitcoin
- 22:20custody and Bitcoin mining. So it is already happening.
- 22:24I'm sure it's going to be accelerated into this next
- 22:26cycle, but I was just like blown away because it's almost like
- 22:30the draw parallel would be as if the Federal Reserve or the US
- 22:33Treasury is like ceding companies to be mining Bitcoin,
- 22:36you know, in Texas or you know working on custody
- 22:39infrastructure. So it's like pretty phenomenal
- 22:41just in terms of the government getting involved in the industry
- 22:44already. Yeah, yeah, that's it.
- 22:47I think it already is happening and I think it probably
- 22:49accelerates pretty rapidly And and just sort of touching on the
- 22:52point that that Michael made around, you know, being being
- 22:56some of the most sophisticated crypto or digital asset people
- 23:00is an interesting point. And I think it's like it's
- 23:02almost in my mind sort of a double edged sword of of being
- 23:06so forward thinking and innovative.
- 23:07It's like, you know, you want to go chase these shiny things that
- 23:11are purporting to do all these different things.
- 23:13And so I think naturally that kind of comes with it that
- 23:15they've they've sort of leaned into a lot of the things that
- 23:18surround Bitcoin. But in in some weird way, it's
- 23:21kind of a nice angle for us to come in there and just be very
- 23:25simple that it's like you just need to buy this asset, you need
- 23:27to hold it and here's how you should think about holding it
- 23:30because it has these unique custodial properties.
- 23:33So it's kind of a nice like differentiated angle for for a
- 23:36company like ours to come in and just say you know we're not,
- 23:38we're not really, you know, we're not snake oil salesman
- 23:42here. Like we just have a very simple
- 23:44philosophy and a simple product really.
- 23:47And so I think it was a nice, nice angle for us to be able to
- 23:51take given sort of the, the rest of you know, people's focus
- 23:56gets, you know, distracted to all these other things.
- 23:59Yeah and that's a key point like it really works knowing this
- 24:02playbook, Marty T the point of like we've done this previously
- 24:06when you talk about you know we we Lauren, Lana brought it up
- 24:09early and we're going over there about you know they have enough
- 24:12Cowboys dropping in in their jets and looking for $100
- 24:14million in a fly out. And I think you hear, I don't
- 24:17know if they still do it, but like where when the market
- 24:20tightened up with interest rates rising, how like Cal Canis and
- 24:23people were flying out there to source you know dollars for
- 24:25venture firms and this notion of you don't go there to do that.
- 24:29And when I when I remember her saying that and referencing this
- 24:32sounds, you know, a lot like Texas and how you would do
- 24:35business and you know, building relationships and education and
- 24:38shaking individuals hands. And so to Brian's point, that's
- 24:41effectively what the goal was to go out there and explain, you
- 24:44know, what we do, why it's different, it's Bitcoin versus
- 24:46crypto and why there's, you know, properties baked in the
- 24:49protocol that allow for different form of, you know,
- 24:51custody and governance around it.
- 24:53And that's really where things got fascinating to Jackson's
- 24:56point is everybody was a really open and interested in needing.
- 25:00I think like the custody format really speaks to something like
- 25:04innate because they look at it and they're like, oh, that's
- 25:05interesting, haven't seen it before with different
- 25:07institutions participating. They know Biko Biko's having,
- 25:11you know, growing presence there.
- 25:13But then the other part was the again, going back or kind of
- 25:16reminds me in a in a weird way, not apples to apples, but when
- 25:19Austin, when I first moved to Austin, TX, there was a lot of
- 25:22like boiling pot from a tech perspective where people are
- 25:25always happy to make introductions.
- 25:26They weren't from there, do business, do deals.
- 25:29And it was similar in that sense, minus all the homeless
- 25:32people on the streets. But and the the interest in like
- 25:37making introductions and saying like hey, like you know, you
- 25:40should talk to this individual or this, you know, sovereign
- 25:44fund that's tied to the central bank in this country because
- 25:47that would make the most sense for them to participate in this.
- 25:50Because part of our goal or going out there was you know,
- 25:52showing that we do have an interest in investing in that
- 25:55region and that's what they're looking for.
- 25:57There's really good podcasts out there what maybe drop them in
- 25:59the show notes or if anybody reaches out that really talks
- 26:02about they're looking there's like the two terms like
- 26:04Greenfield and brownfield, where like a brownfield will be like a
- 26:07multinational that goes to the country or the region and saying
- 26:10like, hey, we want to, you know, leverage infrastructure and
- 26:13we're going to, you know, expand our product there.
- 26:16And then there's Greenfield where you go in and invest in in
- 26:20the country and then build up your business from the ground
- 26:22up. And so a lot of that came about
- 26:25where there's a lot of interest from, you know, sovereigns to
- 26:28participate in these quorums. And in the last part and all
- 26:32that was you found out that like a week before SPF and FTX blew
- 26:37up, he was there trying to, you know, extract some capital to
- 26:40get himself out of whatever position they were in.
- 26:43And I think that's important to note because they do it in our.
- 26:47I'll speak for myself and the guys can chime in.
- 26:49But in my, in my experience there, it sounds like they want
- 26:54to do things the right way, like they want to work with the right
- 26:56partners. They vet people carefully before
- 26:58they give a lot of the licenses, whether it's in Abu Dhabi or
- 27:00Dubai. And so they're really looking
- 27:02for people looking to build long term sustainable businesses.
- 27:05And we know about this custody structure and what we know about
- 27:09the different ways you can get rugged.
- 27:11I feel like it's the most compelling story for them to
- 27:13participate to protect their, like individuals that live in
- 27:16these countries and the people that are looking at, you know,
- 27:19it's a, it's a clap, it's a top five capital market I believe in
- 27:21the world. So people are going to go there,
- 27:23they're looking for the advantages to be domicile there.
- 27:26Well then if you're going to be holding Bitcoin, it should be
- 27:28done in a way that is, you know, transparent and part of what we
- 27:31do. So that was another one of the
- 27:33last like pieces that were really positive.
- 27:35We're about to leave. Yeah.
- 27:39To to just make that even clearer if it isn't already, to
- 27:42people who are listening to this, because of the nature of
- 27:46our custody product, we can serve international Bitcoin
- 27:50holders and and and do that without, you know, having to be
- 27:56a custodial service because we don't take custody of your
- 28:00coins. We help you set up a custody
- 28:03solution where we participate, but we don't have control.
- 28:08And so that's that's essential for making it possible to serve
- 28:11Bitcoin holders all over the world regardless of jurisdiction
- 28:15because we're not a custodial solution.
- 28:18We we provide a custody solution which is a subtle distinction
- 28:23but important. And and to anyone out there
- 28:27who's who has been wondering if that if we do serve Bitcoin
- 28:32holders, you know, if you're not in the US, the answer is yes.
- 28:38And on the topic of the individuals that you spoke with,
- 28:43understanding the importance of this particular custody model,
- 28:46multi institution, multi sig, how much?
- 28:50Because I know we've talked about this a lot over the last
- 28:52two years and particularly on this podcast with the US
- 28:55freezing Russian treasury assets.
- 28:58Is that top of mind for any of the individuals that you spoke
- 29:02with? So it it didn't come out there
- 29:06explicitly people like call up on consultations and obviously
- 29:10from a commercial perspective we can't build products around ever
- 29:14around that. It's just not a commercial thing
- 29:17to to do. But I will say what has come up
- 29:22and I forget where this was an anecdote Marty, you'd love this.
- 29:25Like we had a lot of people that were prospective clients,
- 29:27clients partners from all over the world, meet us in Dubai,
- 29:30from India, from Australia to name two countries.
- 29:33And they see the vision of the model and want to take it to
- 29:37their their country or partner with us to do that.
- 29:40And one of the anecdotes that they brought up was as you start
- 29:43to go further E the ETF because becomes more and more untenable
- 29:47simply because of what you just referenced the Russian
- 29:49treasuries. And it just doesn't make sense
- 29:51to park significance amount of capital in Coinbase that's it's
- 29:54in San Francisco. And so that's really where
- 29:57another thing that ties into our offshore fun product to what we,
- 30:01you know, shared and that we're you know rolling out over the
- 30:05course of the next couple weeks and we partner with you know
- 30:07some of the pensions we're working with and other firms.
- 30:09That's a really nice product when it comes to being available
- 30:12to not have tax exposure to the United States if you sit outside
- 30:15of the US And then also from a custody perspective where those
- 30:19assets sit because again, individuals may have interest in
- 30:23having a key that sits in the UAE and maybe Singapore or
- 30:26another country like Switzerland.
- 30:29Yeah, it's a great point Marty, to your question and to
- 30:31Michael's point, the, the custody provider, infrastructure
- 30:36provider based in the UAE that's backed by the sovereign wealth
- 30:40fund. If you go on their website, you
- 30:42know one of the key words that sticks out is you know, a
- 30:47geopolitical risk, so hedging A geopolitical risk or an event
- 30:51like that. So they are a newer company
- 30:53maybe like 22 or 23. So I'm sure they were just
- 30:57thinking about this anyway in the context of global macro and
- 31:01geopolitics. But I'm sure that to Michael's
- 31:04point, a lot of people want to work with partners in their
- 31:06local market. So really for this to scale in
- 31:09the UAE, you know, part of the longer term vision here is to
- 31:12have a presence and have people you know based there and also
- 31:16having a key partner based there as well.
- 31:18Just because then it's a little bit more comforting to them and
- 31:21they can get, you know, they can maybe scale into the business,
- 31:25get more comfortable with the business if they know that one
- 31:27of the keys is held, you know, in their city or you know at
- 31:29least in their country. Yeah.
- 31:32I mean, on this point, we're going to talk about it towards
- 31:35the end. What's going on with the ETF
- 31:37inflows and how much of the daily supply they're eating up.
- 31:41It's far beyond the daily supply right now.
- 31:45But when these guys are ready to press GO, it seems like they've
- 31:49already pressed go. But when they really open up the
- 31:51floodgates, what type of impact do you guys think this will have
- 31:55on the market? I mean, you mentioned the
- 31:57further E you go, the less tenable the ETF becomes.
- 32:01So you have to imagine giving them an Ave. to access Bitcoin
- 32:07that isn't the ETF and that they're more comfortable with.
- 32:09Could have a similar, if not more pronounced effect on how
- 32:14much Bitcoin's getting gobbled up on the market every day.
- 32:18Yeah. I mean from just anecdotes on
- 32:22anecdotal conversations, right, like from the the market
- 32:25perspective outside of Binance, there's not like a crazy amount
- 32:28of like liquidity or like trading happening.
- 32:30So it's a lot of OTC and it's a very like clunky and hard and
- 32:33obviously like somebody has to send money for somebody has to
- 32:36send Bitcoin. But they were like sizable
- 32:39transitions that we're talking to different individuals about.
- 32:43Jackson had conversations and understanding that people are
- 32:46holding Bitcoin in very unsophisticated ways and vaults
- 32:50of very sophisticated individuals.
- 32:52And all that's to say like I think that the assumption is
- 32:57there needs to be the proper sophisticated kind of rails from
- 33:00execution all the way to custody where then you can really
- 33:03unlock, I think large amounts of capital are going to come in
- 33:06either way. It's just how comfortable our
- 33:08individuals can be and then really that maybe that flywheel
- 33:11expands. I think Marty, one thing that
- 33:14was really fascinating that kept coming up was that Saudi Arabia
- 33:17and Riyadh in particular are looking at Dubai and want to do
- 33:20exactly what they've done the past 10 years.
- 33:23But 100 X bigger and faster simply because they have the
- 33:26capital to do it and they everybody believes that it's
- 33:30going to happen. And so I think that's a more
- 33:33larger thing that me and Brian were were talking a lot about is
- 33:36like what happens when that part of the market, there was a tweet
- 33:39that came up when we're at dinner, but it was saying it's
- 33:42like not priced in that I think like Muslims globally or 2.1
- 33:45billion, if not a little more. And when you think about, like,
- 33:49it was a joke, but somebody asked about like Sharia
- 33:51compliant. And it was like, this is like
- 33:53our product is the most Sharia compliant thing that could exist
- 33:56in the sense of, like you literally just sit on the asset,
- 33:58you put it in cold storage and you don't touch it and it
- 34:00appreciates and purchasing power.
- 34:02And so this whole idea that when that part of the world starts to
- 34:04recognize like what this thing is and why it can't be
- 34:07weaponized against them in the sense of like what treasuries
- 34:09have been done, that that's not pricing at all.
- 34:13Yeah, totally agree. I think it's, it's hard to
- 34:15fathom just that that pool of capital that to your point, you
- 34:20know, may not be allocated to all the other asset buckets
- 34:23today because of Sharia compliance concerns.
- 34:26And so they, you know, historically haven't owned
- 34:29stocks, bonds, real estate, whatever it is.
- 34:32And so it's this massive, you know, fully untapped pool of
- 34:35capital that may now recognize Bitcoin as this thing that they
- 34:38can actually own. And so, yeah, that's part of it.
- 34:42I think the other part too, just going back to like the sort of
- 34:46innate appreciation for something like Bitcoin and its
- 34:49value prop in this region. I think it's, you know, partly
- 34:53has to do with, you know, really just proximity to areas where
- 34:58there has been more severe inflation or hyperinflation.
- 35:01I think that's that's certainly a component.
- 35:02It goes back to the idea of like you know we're in this Western
- 35:06Fiat U.S. dollar bubble and it's easier to ignore this thing
- 35:09called Bitcoin that protects you from from Fiat debasement.
- 35:12But I think people in this region and you know all the
- 35:15surrounding countries, it's just way more top of mind for them
- 35:19and and so part you know along with that is a greater
- 35:22recognition and understanding of counterparty risk.
- 35:24To your earlier point around, you know, probably not going to
- 35:27get comfortable with owning an ETF where the custodian is, is
- 35:30Coinbase and and they're you know sitting in San Fran.
- 35:34So I think it's it's this confluence of of all these
- 35:37different sort of elements that lead this region to just be very
- 35:42open minded and and really thinking critically about not
- 35:46only the the thesis on this asset, but how to actually own
- 35:49it the right way which is just incredibly bullish.
- 35:55Yeah, Sharia Sharia compliance is something that definitely is
- 35:59not priced in yet. And what were the conversations
- 36:03around mining, obviously very energy rich region.
- 36:07Our conversation with Talal, he highlighted there's obviously
- 36:10countries that are better suited to take advantage of the mining
- 36:13opportunity compared to others, but were there large
- 36:16conversations around mining specifically?
- 36:20I think that it goes back to the Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth fund
- 36:23that's investing in them. And I believe because of the way
- 36:25that a lot of the investments are structured, wouldn't go into
- 36:30the region you file applications.
- 36:32So it's not like I don't know. I mean I'm sure people are off
- 36:35grid mining like in the moonshine way that's done in the
- 36:39states that aren't like actually registered.
- 36:41But I I the way that it was described I feel like it's less
- 36:45simply because they're they're open to it.
- 36:47They're just in the there's obviously like a it's a better
- 36:50tax climate for something like that but it was referenced more
- 36:55Abu Dhabi because Dubai it's my understanding that they don't
- 36:58have any oil or very little and that's really where they kind of
- 37:02made their mark on the financial market side where Abu Dhabi's
- 37:05where the the oil sets I believe out of the seven kingdoms it's
- 37:08either the second or first most oil rich And so that's really
- 37:12where like I believe Marathon and other firms are.
- 37:14But yeah there's a large I think Oman and and one other country
- 37:20that's in the GCC was referenced I can't think of the other one
- 37:24obviously Saudi Arabia. The problem with Saudi Arabia I
- 37:26think is they don't have any publicly said mining yet.
- 37:33They're still like, I think like the innovation there and like
- 37:37what they're going to allow and what they're not.
- 37:41And I guess maybe we can dive into more topics if you guys
- 37:45want to about the week. But I I think the last thing
- 37:48that I want to touch on before we head to ETF news here in the
- 37:51States. Or should the US, should the
- 37:53West more broadly be worried about the competition that's
- 37:57coming? You know, it it is, it is sort
- 38:04of funny that we've in the US, in the West, we've sort of been
- 38:08lulled to sleep about like, oh, Bitcoin's this cool technology.
- 38:12You know, I think Brian did a great job of talking about how
- 38:14this is more top of mind, this is more relevant, salient to
- 38:17people outside of the US in particular where the dollar is
- 38:21strong. And so we, we have been lulled
- 38:25to sleep into thinking like oh it's this, this is great
- 38:27technology, it'll catch on eventually.
- 38:30And we in the US are frankly closer to tech innovation and
- 38:36hear about these things sooner. I think that's just the reality
- 38:40of of how tech works because of EU s s pole position in in terms
- 38:47of tech innovation, the tech, the innovation happens here and
- 38:51then it eventually, you know, percolates out to the rest of
- 38:54the world. But in percolating out to the
- 38:58rest of the world, Bitcoin finds hungry adoption.
- 39:03It, you know, it matters more sooner is more relevant to
- 39:07people outside of the US and and I don't think that that's like
- 39:11priced into how we think Bitcoin adoption is going to go.
- 39:15Like Bitcoin adoption for the first 15 years has really been
- 39:19like tech innovators in the US and in the West and in China
- 39:25seeing this, the potential of this thing way before it has
- 39:29real like traction and mainstream like applicability
- 39:36and speculating early that's that's been the entire history
- 39:39of of Bitcoin adoption to date. And now I think we're entering
- 39:43this era of like greater access to Bitcoin everywhere in the
- 39:48world. And the people who will most
- 39:53readily adopted are people in like Argentina or Turkey or in
- 39:59in regions where they're wary of foreign exchanges being seized,
- 40:04foreign exchange reserves being seized because of what happened
- 40:06to to Russia with being cut off the SWIFT and having their
- 40:10foreign exchange reserves seized by the G7 and so.
- 40:15That I think that's the next 15 years is we're going to be
- 40:18surprised us like complacent folks in the US who have thought
- 40:23that Bitcoin is is wonderful technology that'll eventually
- 40:26catch on by how it will be taken up now because of the you know
- 40:33imminent value proposition of it.
- 40:36In an era where where where the US can cut off people's foreign
- 40:42exchange reserves. We're going to see nation state
- 40:45adoption. Not in the US, not in the G7.
- 40:49It's going to be everywhere else 1st, and that happens in this
- 40:53next decade. Yeah, for Jesse, not being
- 40:58there, that was literally like the most elegant way to describe
- 41:02what's happening. Because if we know Bitcoin, it's
- 41:05all incentives and they've created infrastructure to bring
- 41:09people in there to not tax and kill them, like to provide
- 41:13resources for growth, to open up channels of commerce globally.
- 41:18Like they literally are setting themselves up and you're seeing
- 41:22talent go there. So you can start to see exactly
- 41:26how this forms into the point of you need the 1st 15 years where
- 41:29innovation quote, UN quote happens in the West.
- 41:32But then what's happening is now people are going for different
- 41:34reasons and I think about this stuff like water, it's why I've
- 41:37like so bullish on multi institution because I just think
- 41:40effectively like if you're going to be successful you have to go
- 41:42where the current is going and realistically like everything is
- 41:46not actually great there as well.
- 41:48It's the most surveilled country in the world.
- 41:49Like there's a lot of things that aren't positive.
- 41:51But the idea is if you're from a game theory perspective, you can
- 41:56set up shop there. You can do a lot of things.
- 41:58You can have them hold a key but they can't rug you and take all
- 42:01your Bitcoin and that's really where you know you start
- 42:04thinking about long standing. How do you build incentive
- 42:06models and infrastructure around ways that distribute risk where
- 42:10you don't have a single point of failure whether it's your
- 42:12personal life and being domiciled there or your assets
- 42:15being sitting at a single custodian.
- 42:17They're both one of the same things of like you're going
- 42:19where the puck's editing and you don't want me to place that's
- 42:21taxing you 40% looking to seize your funds hate you because
- 42:25you're doing something that like is deemed you know not ESG
- 42:28friendly. And all the things we know
- 42:29happening in various parts of the world frankly not just the
- 42:31US So that that is the key thing.
- 42:34They're setting themselves up to be welcoming.
- 42:36They're they're taking care of people and business that goes
- 42:38there and it's just like starting to accelerate And then
- 42:41Saudi Arabia's looking at them and they're like well why don't
- 42:43we do this like we're sitting here they've been, there's this
- 42:46been this macro tell in the past 10 to 20 years of
- 42:49diversification from you know oil for a number of reasons.
- 42:53And so they're like, well, why don't we bring in country or
- 42:56companies the Cole invest alongside them and then also get
- 43:00out into the market. So yeah, it's going to be a
- 43:02crazy next 15 years globally. Yeah, and to both of your
- 43:05points, Jesse and Michael, you know, the word that stuck out to
- 43:08me is complacency. And it's a very complacent
- 43:12attitude here in the US. But then from what I gathered in
- 43:16conversation in the UAE, it's an extremely competitive attitude.
- 43:20What ultimately keeps them kind of at the forefront of new
- 43:23technology? And Michael to your point you
- 43:25know skating where the puck is going.
- 43:27So the way it was described to me is if the UAE sees you know
- 43:31Singapore for example do something they want to do a 10X
- 43:35better. And that attitude is largely
- 43:37absent as a culture in the United States and it's
- 43:40ultimately why you know we're losing our foothold kind of you
- 43:45know at a global scale and you know kind of to that point is
- 43:48like skating skating where the puck is going.
- 43:50They see multi institution custody and they compare it to
- 43:54as Michael said earlier they're kind of a lot of unsophisticated
- 43:57ways of holding Bitcoin and they see this new model as a way to
- 44:01hedge out counterparty risk, geopolitical risk, eliminate
- 44:05single points of failure and they get it, it's it's really
- 44:08intuitive. So it's just been encouraging in
- 44:10that sense to, you know, to actually be in a jurisdiction
- 44:14that is not extremely complacent and you know, has an attitude of
- 44:18competitiveness and and really, you know, pushing its country
- 44:21and its people, you know, to be one step ahead of other
- 44:24countries. It's really refreshing.
- 44:28Yeah, and it goes back to the whole thing in Bitcoin about if
- 44:30you think it's a good idea, probably is.
- 44:32If it hasn't been done yet, you just got to do it because we're
- 44:34so early. It's like we had no business
- 44:36being out there. It's just nobody goes out there
- 44:38from the Bitcoin only side and part of the ten act better.
- 44:41It's like saying this stuff publicly is it's good for
- 44:44Bitcoin, but it's also good for us because we just like put out
- 44:47these ideas out in the market. It's a free market.
- 44:49Who's going to go there, go and provide services?
- 44:51And we all benefit from that as long as we continue to like,
- 44:53innovate and push, you know, this stuff forward.
- 44:56Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 44:58exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 45:01about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 45:05allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 45:09We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 45:12Yeah. And you have to imagine the fire
- 45:15under their ass is getting hotter.
- 45:17Looking at what's happening here in the United States with the
- 45:20ETF launching in, the amount of inflow that they're seeing,
- 45:24which is hitting, it's what seems like escape velocity.
- 45:29So I think we can transition to the ETF.
- 45:31So like when you pull up the article from earlier today that
- 45:35I put out, just want to shoot this out there, the guys at
- 45:38Bitmex Research and Thomas Fire from Apollo SAT's has been
- 45:43following the inflows. We've surpassed $51,775 today.
- 45:48We touched 52,000 for a bit there and a lot of people are
- 45:54surmising that it's because of these ETF inflows.
- 45:57And yesterday was the largest net inflow of more than 10,200
- 46:01Bitcoin. So it's all time high inflow in
- 46:05Bitcoin and dollar terms obviously since we're higher
- 46:09than what we were when we launched the ETFs.
- 46:12And what's happening here, Jesse, I mean this is the most
- 46:17successful ETF launch across the board.
- 46:21I think the Bitcoin I think black Rocks ETF surpassed GLD in
- 46:26trade volume yesterday and daily volume.
- 46:30Is this is it happening? Yeah, this is, this is a smash
- 46:35hit in terms of ETFs, unprecedented smash hit.
- 46:39I think it's already in my opinion it's already eclipsed
- 46:42what I expected by this point. You know I I was sort of
- 46:46cautioning people that like when the ETS launch they'll probably
- 46:51be like a small sell the news event where you know we'll we'll
- 46:54go down for a little bit and then the real sustained
- 46:58continuous inflow of of demand from the ETFs will matter over
- 47:04the next year plus and into the future.
- 47:07But that's already happening at a scale that I think is is
- 47:10certainly surprised me. I mean the last four days we've
- 47:154 trading days. We've been averaging 9000
- 47:19Bitcoin per day of demand, net net demand flowing into the
- 47:23ETFs, 9000 Bitcoin per day in an in an era where right now we're
- 47:29mining 900 Bitcoin per day. So there's 900 Bitcoin being
- 47:33issued every single day and 10 times that amount of demand
- 47:38coming in from just one demand source that's these ETFs.
- 47:42So that's not even accounting for SAT stackers or you know,
- 47:46people accumulating coins outside of ETFs. 910 X the the
- 47:52current supply issuance from just ETFs.
- 47:55And that is 2 months in advance of the halving when obviously
- 47:59the supply issuance gets cut in half.
- 48:02If we if we're sustaining this level of of daily, average daily
- 48:08net inflows to the ETFs of 9000 Bitcoin per day, that would mean
- 48:13that in two months we suddenly go to to 20X the demand from
- 48:19ETFs versus the amount that's being issued through Bitcoin
- 48:24mining every single day, which will be dropped to 450 Bitcoin
- 48:27per day. That's that's insane.
- 48:30I'm really what's happening here is that you know what when a
- 48:34halving occurs, typically the day before the halving, you all
- 48:40else equal have established supply demand price equilibrium
- 48:45where the amount of SAT stacking that's going on every day is
- 48:48equal to, you know, in in dollar terms, is equal to the amount of
- 48:52Bitcoin value being mined every day.
- 48:55So you know supply and demand are in balance.
- 48:58Then the day after the halving suddenly there's half as much
- 49:01supply being created, just as much demand all else equal.
- 49:05So now you have a situation where there's 2X the demand
- 49:09versus the supply that's now being created and that
- 49:13accumulates overtime that that shortage of supply accumulates
- 49:18as a supply shock over the ensuing 12 to 18 months.
- 49:22And causes are parabolic rallies as that eats through the
- 49:25available for for sale supply that sits on exchanges and
- 49:29suddenly there's no coins available to be had and the
- 49:32price starts to go up faster and faster as it as you know buyers
- 49:37have to bid for more coins and they have to raise their bids in
- 49:40order to find more supply. That's the supply shock that
- 49:43happens after every halving and that's because of it of a 2X,
- 49:47right. And right now we're seeing a 10X
- 49:51where the from just one demand source and that's the scale of
- 49:56what's going on right now. So it's pulling forward a bull
- 49:58market into the here and now. So long as these ETF demand,
- 50:02this ETF inflow continues at the rate that it's been achieving
- 50:07which has actually been picking up over the last couple weeks.
- 50:10So we might be entering just a period where because of the ETFs
- 50:16and the making it so much more accessible to put capital into
- 50:19Bitcoin, we're going to keep seeing hundreds of millions of
- 50:23dollars flowing into Bitcoin every day on average for who
- 50:26knows how long. And and that that could cause a
- 50:29hell of a bull market in a short space of time because it's so
- 50:32much greater than the typical supply shock that we see after
- 50:36it happened. Yeah, yeah, it's it's been, it's
- 50:40been insane just to. I mean, that was a great, great
- 50:42summary. But I I've found it funny just
- 50:45in sort of the first few weeks of these things being live like
- 50:49you did see like mainstream media articles saying like oh,
- 50:51this is a flop. It's like no, by by all
- 50:54measures, by all accounts these are the most successful ETFs
- 50:56ever launched. And to Jesse's point like the
- 50:59last four or five trading days have been absurd in particular.
- 51:04And if you know if this is sustained in any way, you're
- 51:07going to start seeing this have a material impact on the spot
- 51:10price. And obviously you know the in
- 51:12the first couple weeks of it being live you had various sort
- 51:15of factors at play like people rotating out of GBTC.
- 51:19And and you know there was also likely a you know a sort of
- 51:22preparation on the side of the issuers in terms of negotiating
- 51:26with OTC desks and and sort of having a lot of Bitcoin ready to
- 51:29be used to create new units of these things.
- 51:32And I think ultimately we know where this is all headed that
- 51:36you know that those OTCSOTC desks sooner or later run out of
- 51:39Bitcoin and they have to go source it in the open market and
- 51:41that's when you see a more, it's a wreck relationship between
- 51:44these flows and spot market Bitcoin price.
- 51:48And so I think it's it's been funny to see some of the
- 51:51narrative around like just people not grasping what's going
- 51:53on here. And also, yeah, to Jesse's other
- 51:58point around having, it's like it's right around the corner.
- 52:00This thing goes from 10X to 20X potentially in terms of demand
- 52:06versus versus supply each day. And yeah, we, we just had the
- 52:10Super Bowl last week. We've got Jesse's Super Bowl
- 52:12coming up in a couple months here.
- 52:15And it's like it's an in my mind, it's like it's more than
- 52:19just a Super Bowl, right. Because it's, you know I think
- 52:21what some people aren't grasping about this, this having in
- 52:24particular. And I think you know we know
- 52:27this internally and and sort of in Bitcoin circles, but it's
- 52:29like this one is even more important.
- 52:31It's it's kind of a special having in the sense that, you
- 52:35know, in terms of a Bitcoin stock to flow, it becomes more
- 52:39scarce than gold on an annual production basis.
- 52:41And I think that is you know, have has been in sort of a an
- 52:45internal Bitcoin narrative for for a long time.
- 52:47But I think once that hits sort of the mainstream narrative of
- 52:51like oh, this is actually the hardest asset on the planet,
- 52:54it's now officially more scarce than gold.
- 52:58I think that has a profound effect on on sort of you know
- 53:01whatever FOMO is going on around that time.
- 53:05And so, yeah, you combine that with these ETF flows if they can
- 53:07be sustained, might see some fireworks.
- 53:12Yeah, that that 3.125 and whatever the stock default gets
- 53:16updated just seems insanely small when you look when
- 53:19somebody's external looking. And like how much is this
- 53:21getting? How much is getting made daily?
- 53:24Yeah, to to Brian's point there, like I think, I think if the
- 53:28whole entire world understood Bitcoin, the price of Bitcoin,
- 53:32well the total value of Bitcoin would right now be or
- 53:36significantly larger than gold just based on the stock to flow
- 53:42comparison of it. If if Bitcoin didn't have
- 53:45greater functionality than gold does currently, currently its
- 53:50value should match. Oh this is great.
- 53:53Yeah Logan just pulled up. I saw this tweet today too of
- 53:58people are dumping gold ETFs and buying Bitcoin ETFs, largely
- 54:03meaning baby boomers with large stock portfolios are shifting
- 54:08allocation away from gold and towards Bitcoin which is exactly
- 54:11what you want to see. It also speaks to the narrative
- 54:13of of you know Bitcoin is fulfilling what the gold bugs
- 54:18have all always thought was possible or or should happen in
- 54:22terms of the sound money. They just had the wrong one
- 54:25because gold has its Achilles heel of of centralization and
- 54:29its vulnerability to paper gold manipulation in the in the
- 54:33markets and and Bitcoin is is come the hour come the asset of
- 54:41of Bitcoin for you know sound money in the digital era.
- 54:46Yeah it it's so you know I think that right now Bitcoin should be
- 54:51worth what gold is or higher which which is $500,000 per
- 54:56Bitcoin. It's just that only a tiny
- 55:00portion of the world has has learned what Bitcoin is, and so
- 55:05only a tiny portion of the world has appropriately valued Bitcoin
- 55:09in their portfolio. Which isn't to say that, you
- 55:12know, Bitcoin doesn't have that value, It's that it's just that
- 55:15the world hasn't caught on to what this thing is and how it
- 55:18fits into the global asset landscape.
- 55:21And and what's incredible about it too is that it doesn't stay
- 55:25where it's at, which right now 1.8% per year supply issuance
- 55:29for for Bitcoin gold has historically averaged 1.5 to 2%
- 55:34per year of new supply issuance from mining.
- 55:38And in two months it drops to 0.9% making it twice as twice as
- 55:43good as gold. And so then we enter an era
- 55:48where for the next four years the price of of the value, total
- 55:53value of Bitcoin from a stock to flow perspective, a store of
- 55:56value asset capacity perspective should be significantly greater
- 56:01than gold. We're not even, we're nowhere
- 56:03near that yet. And it's just because, you know,
- 56:070.1% of the world understands what Bitcoin is to date, and
- 56:11that's just a function of time. Yes.
- 56:14To be to be fair, like gold didn't stay stuck at a magnet at
- 56:1810 trillion and running gold is also moving.
- 56:22I just had a really great conversation with I'm down here
- 56:26in OH and lost it. Now you're here.
- 56:29Oh, gold ATMs are are coming around the world.
- 56:34I was meeting with the founder drew from down here, the oldest
- 56:38and largest Bitcoin ATM, Bitstop.
- 56:41And we were having this conversation yesterday around
- 56:43this narrative of like when Bitcoin goes up, especially if
- 56:46it's going up to anywhere near 10 trillion, then like there's
- 56:49narratives around sound money and all the things associated.
- 56:52And so I think we see a lot, It's a lot longer of a burn when
- 56:55the price goes. It's a 500,000 dollars, $10
- 56:57trillion market cap. Gold has gone up to 15 to $20
- 57:01million or whatever. But I think the point still
- 57:03stands. It's a better form of money.
- 57:06The other thing that it was a GB TC and FT XS last rugging of the
- 57:11ETF outflow. It was like a nice poetic like
- 57:15you know the the launch and you saw the like, you know whatever
- 57:18happened with Grayscale and then the FTXI guess it was a billing
- 57:20that needed to be sold. That was like the last kiss
- 57:24before kind of we we get to send it.
- 57:28Well, not yet. Apparently.
- 57:29Genesis is requesting that their bankruptcy.
- 57:35What's it called? Bankruptcy?
- 57:38Guardian. Not Guardian.
- 57:39What's it called? The estate?
- 57:41The bankruptcy estate and it allows them to dump $1.1 billion
- 57:46worth of GBTC shares. So there could be some more
- 57:50outflows from that type of activity due to Genesis.
- 57:54Which is funny because Genesis is a Digital Currency Group
- 57:58family company to to GBTC. But on top of that, like all
- 58:03this ETF talk, one thing that has been confirmed pulled up
- 58:06Logan that we surmised with Mark Connors is whether or not these
- 58:11ETF issuers would begin to use the Bitcoin ETFs that they have
- 58:15to put in other portfolios. And I think Fidelity was the
- 58:18first one to do that last week, adding a 1% allocation to its
- 58:22conservative all in one ETF in Canada.
- 58:26So now we're beginning to see these ETF issuers put the
- 58:31Bitcoin ETF in more of their diversified portfolios.
- 58:35That Bitcoin falls into the bucket of, in Fidelity's case,
- 58:39the conservative all in one ETF. So that's just another Ave. for
- 58:44demand and flows. Yeah.
- 58:46Not not only is that bullish for passive flows, but also on the
- 58:50active management side, going back to my Stifel days working
- 58:55with hedge fund managers, we'd have quarterly monitoring calls.
- 58:58So we'd work with a bunch of different fund managers, all
- 59:01sorts of strategies and the quarterly calls would just be to
- 59:05review the portfolio and see how they performed against the
- 59:09benchmark. So really in addition to these
- 59:12ETFs being launched where there's an allocation of Bitcoin
- 59:15and you know, passive money starts flowing into that,
- 59:18there's also the whole entire active side where you know,
- 59:20managers are benchmarking against a benchmark, right.
- 59:24And as those benchmarks start to incorporate Bitcoin into them,
- 59:27if managers are, if managers have negative attribution,
- 59:32meaning if they're like underweight Bitcoin relative to
- 59:35the benchmark and it's detracting from their
- 59:37performance or causing them to underperform the benchmark, then
- 59:40their investors, their LP's, are are going to have questions for
- 59:44them. So once Bitcoin starts making
- 59:46its way into more benchmarks, then active managers are almost
- 59:48going to have to be, you know, forced to start allocating the
- 59:51Bitcoin as well. Because, you know, we're all
- 59:55bullish enough to think that if you underweight Bitcoin relative
- 59:58to a benchmark, you're likely going to underperform.
- 1:00:01Yeah, that's that's the most fascinating part about this news
- 1:00:03to me. Jackson spelled it out
- 1:00:05perfectly. It's it's that, you know,
- 1:00:08assuming Bitcoin does what we all think it's going to do, that
- 1:00:12data point on your attribution report is going to stick out
- 1:00:15like a sore thumb. And it's going to be.
- 1:00:17And the reality is that you know, the vast, vast majority of
- 1:00:21active managers, whether you know, if you're managing an all,
- 1:00:24all world type portfolio where you're, you know, going across
- 1:00:28asset classes, the high, high likelihood is that you have 0
- 1:00:32exposure to Bitcoin. So that is going to stick out on
- 1:00:35your attribution report if Bitcoin does what we think it
- 1:00:37does this year as the main contributing factor to why you
- 1:00:42underperformed that benchmark. And so it's going to spark a
- 1:00:47conversation, you know, why isn't this in your portfolio?
- 1:00:50This is the main reason we're underperforming.
- 1:00:52You know, what's your thesis? Why?
- 1:00:54Why don't you own this thing? So that's going to be a really
- 1:00:56powerful sort of a slower burn, Obviously, like you need to see
- 1:01:01this play out as it as it's in these benchmarks for, you know,
- 1:01:05a few quarters, at least in my mind.
- 1:01:08But once that starts happening, yeah, it's like it, it forces
- 1:01:11the conversation and it becomes very apparent that this is the
- 1:01:14best performing asset of all time.
- 1:01:16And like, yeah, why? Why?
- 1:01:17If the benchmark has it, why don't you have it?
- 1:01:19You have to at least have an equal weight.
- 1:01:22Yeah, that's the mechanic for, you know, we talk about the, you
- 1:01:26know, the ETFs or a Trojan horse.
- 1:01:29You know it, it's Wall Street trying to make money off of a
- 1:01:32product. But in doing so, it becomes
- 1:01:35embedded into the norms of here's how portfolio
- 1:01:40construction should be done, here's the benchmark and then it
- 1:01:43it flips everything, right? It's like why are you excluding
- 1:01:46Bitcoin? It becomes the question rather
- 1:01:49than like why would you possibly include this crazy Internet
- 1:01:52money and and just with that like switch just a binary switch
- 1:01:57there you that's the seed for completely changing the broader
- 1:02:03societal stance on bitcoins place in a portfolio.
- 1:02:07It that trickles down into, you know, your wealth managers
- 1:02:11talking to families about here's what you should have in your
- 1:02:15portfolio, and then that trickles in.
- 1:02:18You know, that spreads into every conversation at every
- 1:02:21Country Club about, you know, how they're, how people's
- 1:02:24portfolios are doing in the current climate and how Bitcoin
- 1:02:27is outperforming and. And.
- 1:02:29And that, through this viral process of people talking to
- 1:02:33people, turns into Bitcoin being a standard, like a pillar of
- 1:02:37everyone's portfolio into the next 15 years.
- 1:02:44Marty, did you ever pinch yourself like starting?
- 1:02:46Are we saying super cycle? Are we saying super cycle here?
- 1:02:48Is that what's? Is this what is happening right
- 1:02:50now? I'll take, I'll take the
- 1:02:51opposite on that of like this just sets up the the exact
- 1:02:55mechanics for the next bubble. You know, bitcoins history,
- 1:02:59entire history is a series of bubbles where people get too
- 1:03:01excited, it goes too high, and then that the bubble pops and
- 1:03:06then people get too bearish at the bottom.
- 1:03:09In particular, people who are in their first cycle get shaken out
- 1:03:12at the bottom and sell at the exact wrong time.
- 1:03:15And we're going to see that just at, you know, the next level
- 1:03:18here. We're like maybe we go to 250
- 1:03:20and crash very painfully to 70,000.
- 1:03:23You know, like that might be what we're in for over the next
- 1:03:25four years. I think that's I think that's
- 1:03:28probably a little muted because of the passive inflows, but
- 1:03:31still the same. And then it goes back to like
- 1:03:34even though the having amount of Bitcoin issuance is less, you
- 1:03:37still end up with the same cycle because you're losing the amount
- 1:03:41of demand or supply versus the amount of demand and the dollar
- 1:03:44amounts. What's changing?
- 1:03:45I don't. I don't know, boys.
- 1:03:47Yeah, I mean I I think I think Jesse's right, but there is,
- 1:03:50there is a small part of me that and I and I haven't fully
- 1:03:54squared this in my mind, but it's like you know if if what we
- 1:03:57think to be true about a lot of this capital that it's now
- 1:04:00flowing in, they typically in all their other investment asset
- 1:04:04classes. Stickier capital.
- 1:04:05Right. Yeah.
- 1:04:06They have a longer term investment horizon on whatever
- 1:04:08they're doing. So if they have a fundamental
- 1:04:12understanding of what this thing is, they should have a longer
- 1:04:14than a two year view on it. So I think I just think some
- 1:04:19there's some amount of rebalancing that will that will
- 1:04:21happen. But I I just do think to Marty's
- 1:04:25point it's potentially stickier capital.
- 1:04:27So maybe it's it's more. And I think, and I think like
- 1:04:30this part of the conversations in a bit of a vacuum, completely
- 1:04:32neglecting the macro headwinds for the incoming economy and the
- 1:04:38financial markets, stock market, particularly in the tailwinds
- 1:04:42that provides for Bitcoin, where are people going to hide?
- 1:04:44Look at what's going on with credit card delinquency rates
- 1:04:47beginning to creep up at a faster pace than pre 2008.
- 1:04:51Inflation has not been solved as is evident by the fact that Joe
- 1:04:56Biden came out and tried to blame shrink inflation on greedy
- 1:04:59corporations. Seems like the feds going to
- 1:05:02have to keep rates higher for longer and despite the fact that
- 1:05:05people have been opining for years that Bitcoin has only
- 1:05:10appreciated in value due to the low interest rate environment in
- 1:05:12the last 16 months, 15 months has proven that not to be the
- 1:05:18case. And in terms of the ETF opening
- 1:05:21up these Ave. and what we discussed earlier with the
- 1:05:23Middle East, once that spigot gets open, think you have to
- 1:05:26imagine there's a lag there. It could take a year to 18
- 1:05:29months, which would line up with this Oracle peak of past bull
- 1:05:33markets and you have all these confluence of events happening
- 1:05:37that like maybe this time is different, I don't know.
- 1:05:40I I don't think people correlate all those things with Bitcoin
- 1:05:43though. Like that assumes the bubble
- 1:05:44we're talking about is widely known.
- 1:05:46Like when this stuff happens, Bitcoin doesn't become the like
- 1:05:49natural solution to all of it. So you and then to the other
- 1:05:52point that Brian was bringing up about the passive inflows, there
- 1:05:57will be sophisticated people that are holding for a long
- 1:05:59time, but the same thing happens on the other side of it.
- 1:06:02There will be exit liquidity that's come and larger size.
- 1:06:06I don't think. I don't think anything changes
- 1:06:08here other than the pool is like, I don't know the analogy,
- 1:06:11but it's like we had a small pool with like a little hose
- 1:06:13coming in and now the pool's gotten bigger and the hose has
- 1:06:16gotten bigger, but then the people jump in and still cause
- 1:06:18it to overflow. It's just more people until the
- 1:06:21whole, until we're just swimming in the whole thing and you know
- 1:06:23it gets to where we're going. But you see where I'm going with
- 1:06:26it, like nothing actually changes.
- 1:06:27Like more money comes in, the supply gets constrained every
- 1:06:30four years. It's the same thing whether it's
- 1:06:32Bitcoin at a dollar or Bitcoin at a billion dollars.
- 1:06:35I guess then we have two does. That make sense because I know
- 1:06:39that. I mean, I see what you're
- 1:06:40saying. I think analogies work for this
- 1:06:41though, like the pool analogy, like I get what you're going for
- 1:06:44there, but like I think this is a whole whole other game we're
- 1:06:50playing in this cycle cuz look and pull it up.
- 1:06:53The central banks are taking the mask off.
- 1:06:55This is from the central Bank of New Zealand yet earlier this
- 1:06:59week. Quick clip.
- 1:07:01The fiscal challenges et cetera that are there.
- 1:07:04So I'm very focused on being cost effective.
- 1:07:08We actually fund ourselves and then work out what dividend is
- 1:07:11needed to pay. So we kind of work but it's a
- 1:07:14great business to be in central banking money and people believe
- 1:07:18it and and and much wood and so. So it's it's a slightly
- 1:07:25different piece to. Wow, I just caught something
- 1:07:28here that I didn't catch yesterday.
- 1:07:29So we're central banking is a great business to be and we
- 1:07:32print people, we print money and people believe it.
- 1:07:35And then he said touch wood, he's like, hopefully they don't
- 1:07:37figure it out. I didn't catch touch wood till
- 1:07:39right now. The mask is off.
- 1:07:41People are waking up to this like a Social New Zealand, which
- 1:07:46was the first central bank to issue interest rate targeting
- 1:07:49policies in the world. Fun fact.
- 1:07:51So a lot of the reason that we're in this terrible
- 1:07:55situation. I'll be I'll be a little
- 1:07:57generous to to these guys. Like to me this speaks to
- 1:08:02they're just so deep in it. They truly believe it.
- 1:08:05Like, they truly believe that this, this is, this is how
- 1:08:08things should work, can work, and it's reasonable.
- 1:08:10And that's why he's like, he's like making a joke and not
- 1:08:15realizing how incendiary the underlying subject matter really
- 1:08:19is. He's touching wood.
- 1:08:21But again, I wrote this in the newsletter yesterday.
- 1:08:25It gets completely we'll pull up this clip, a little 2 minute
- 1:08:28clip. We got clips on clips on clips
- 1:08:30here, but it's completely analogous.
- 1:08:33Even though I just said that analogies are not apt, I think
- 1:08:37it is. How many?
- 1:08:38It really is that scene in The Big Short where they're down in
- 1:08:43Florida talking to The Mortgage brokers, asking them like what
- 1:08:46they're doing. And in the we'll watch the clip
- 1:08:50after this, but like in this clip, like you're talking like
- 1:08:53they're the central bankers in this.
- 1:08:55They're like, yeah, we don't care.
- 1:08:56Like we're exhibiting moral hazard because of the incentives
- 1:09:00put in front of us are to shovel these people into subprime
- 1:09:03mortgages. We get 10 KA pop.
- 1:09:04Similarly with the central banker, it's yeah, we're we are
- 1:09:11incentivized to engage in moral hazard because of the way the
- 1:09:16system works, the way we've erected it.
- 1:09:17So we're going to print money, we're going to make money from
- 1:09:19it and knock on wood, hopefully the people don't catch on to it.
- 1:09:23And post 2008, I think people really caught on to the systemic
- 1:09:27nature of the housing crisis. And I don't think that's been
- 1:09:31fixed, but I think what the central banks are doing is
- 1:09:34obviously a layer below everything that happened in 2008
- 1:09:38and people are really going to wake up to this.
- 1:09:40And as we know where debt is like they have to print more
- 1:09:45money and people. I think this is the point I'm
- 1:09:48trying to get at is I think we're approaching, I don't want
- 1:09:50to say it, it's not QA non related, but the great awakening
- 1:09:53where people basically understand like oh shit, these
- 1:09:57people are not good actors in the economy.
- 1:10:01Well, that's why he's knocking on wood, right?
- 1:10:03Yeah. Like that.
- 1:10:04That's that's the nefarious part of that clip is that he's
- 1:10:06knocking on wood. Which is demon summoning.
- 1:10:12Hey, so the the, the point in taking the other side, it's good
- 1:10:15to, it's good to have like talk this out.
- 1:10:18I don't think this is anywhere remotely the case.
- 1:10:21Simply because if we go back to the people that were crypto
- 1:10:24sophisticated, like talk to people setting up the CBDC or
- 1:10:27not CBDC, they might as well be. But like the stable coins in the
- 1:10:32UAE, like Bitcoin might as well be like dead tech.
- 1:10:36Like it, it's a dead rock. Like there's all this stuff
- 1:10:38happening. The point of just sharing that
- 1:10:40is like those are the people theoretically should be closest
- 1:10:43to what you're describing. I'm like thinking about like
- 1:10:46it's so far removed that the Fed, the central banks have lost
- 1:10:49control. Inflation's a thing.
- 1:10:50They don't believe it to be a problem.
- 1:10:52Well, they can people. They.
- 1:10:53Cannot believe it to be a problem, but it is a problem
- 1:10:56that is. Like, no, no, I agree.
- 1:10:58It's just that when it runs, they're not gonna be like
- 1:11:00Bitcoin's. The solution is the point.
- 1:11:03Yeah, this kind of. Goes background.
- 1:11:07For folks who haven't read it, When Money Dies is this
- 1:11:12incredible compilation of little anecdotes and vignettes really
- 1:11:18from what Weimar Germany and like, what happened and like
- 1:11:21what what unfolded when money died, when Fiat hyperinflation
- 1:11:27took hold there. And what is so heartbreaking
- 1:11:32about a lot of that, you know, a lot of those stories there is
- 1:11:35like that people just didn't wake up like it it it took like
- 1:11:42gold was there in front of them as as the, you know, the
- 1:11:46lifeboat. And for the most part people
- 1:11:49didn't realize like instead it actually went the other way of
- 1:11:52like people who put their money in stock markets saw great
- 1:11:57nominal returns like you know that and thought that they were
- 1:12:00getting rich. And so you he pour more money
- 1:12:03into the stock market rather than like realizing what's
- 1:12:05happening is it's a melt up because the the currency is
- 1:12:08becoming debase at a faster and faster rate and you really need
- 1:12:12to just get out of the system and put money into your value
- 1:12:15into sound money in gold at the time.
- 1:12:18And so there's all these examples of people like
- 1:12:20speculating even harder and then getting more wrecked eventually
- 1:12:24because of the volatility that that comes from, you know, that
- 1:12:29kind of debasement, you know, volatility up to the upside but
- 1:12:35also to the downside, wrecking people.
- 1:12:37So, you know, like in history, when this happens, people don't
- 1:12:42really wake up. It's really only in hindsight
- 1:12:44when when stability is found in the thing that emerges from the
- 1:12:48ashes. That's what I'm saying.
- 1:12:50The the hindsight may be on the other side of this cycle because
- 1:12:53are we in the melt up phase right now?
- 1:12:54Logan, pull it up. Look at this chart.
- 1:12:58Have you guys been paying attention to NVIDIA, like in a
- 1:13:02lot of these other tech stocks? I just saw the CEO.
- 1:13:05I think he referenced, like you know, proof of stake.
- 1:13:08Why waste that energy? Yeah.
- 1:13:11Yeah, the idiots are in control. Like, are we in the melt up
- 1:13:15phase right now? I it's.
- 1:13:17I think we are, yeah. To to both of your points that
- 1:13:20we are. And it's like I saw something on
- 1:13:22LinkedIn yesterday and it's someone who you know on paper is
- 1:13:26very intelligent and could be very, you know, well intelligent
- 1:13:29than everyone in this call right now.
- 1:13:30But it's like he shows a map of the United States and it shows
- 1:13:34property values and how they've increased since as the second or
- 1:13:37third quarter of 2020. And what was the money supply
- 1:13:40increase by? It's called 40% or so since then
- 1:13:44or in in the 18 months. And all of the state's property
- 1:13:47appreciation were just like right around 40%.
- 1:13:50And the post is about how, like real estate's a great
- 1:13:52investment. Look how these properties are
- 1:13:54appreciated. And it's like, I don't know how.
- 1:13:56Like how does it get more obvious than what, you know,
- 1:13:58what's currently going on. It's just it's frustrating.
- 1:14:01Hey, Marty, on that note, because we haven't had a chance
- 1:14:05to catch up is how great was Glenn and Sam because this goes
- 1:14:10again what we're saying indicated level like they
- 1:14:12understand this. I mean, obviously Glenn's second
- 1:14:17appearance, Kindred Spirit and getting Sam on as well was
- 1:14:23incredible. I mean, that's the thing I I do
- 1:14:26have this and I've disclaimer, I've had this feeling in my
- 1:14:30stomach since 2013, but it's more pronounced than ever right
- 1:14:33now that something like people are going to get caught
- 1:14:36offsides. Not only like not getting on the
- 1:14:39Bitcoin train, but really expecting the Fed and the
- 1:14:42federal government to be able to kick this can down the road
- 1:14:45further and further. I think the next time they kick
- 1:14:47it, it hits the wall and drops like 6 inches in front of them.
- 1:14:53Logan, pull up the chart I just put in in the chat of like I I I
- 1:14:58agree and I think we are in the melt up phase, but I think we're
- 1:15:01so early in it that it it fools us like so here's the chart of
- 1:15:06Weimar hyperinflation and it really took place between 1917
- 1:15:10and 1923 when it all fell apart. But it's it's obviously a
- 1:15:15parabolic advance, you know exponential acceleration of of
- 1:15:22of the exchange rate of of the mark to to gold.
- 1:15:27But if you look in the like 1917 you know 1918 range, you're
- 1:15:33you're seeing 100% year over year growth and that's still
- 1:15:41like the very beginning. And there's a lot of fall, 20%,
- 1:15:45one year, 220%. Oh, sorry, I was looking at the
- 1:15:50wrong axis. But you get the point of like
- 1:15:53very early on. There's, there's still already
- 1:15:55like uncomfortable levels of of of inflation.
- 1:16:01And you're still like 7 whipsaws away from it all falling apart.
- 1:16:09Marty, I think you're probably right in terms of US perspective
- 1:16:13in terms of going back to the the thoughts around complacency
- 1:16:17and and really just trusting that they can keep kicking the
- 1:16:20can down the road. But like Bitcoin is this global
- 1:16:23asset. I think you know if we're, if
- 1:16:25we're you know comparing this time around to Weimar Germany,
- 1:16:29it's like well the Internet exists now and Bitcoin is by far
- 1:16:35and away the best, most effective escape valve that
- 1:16:38we've ever had. So it is a totally different
- 1:16:41scenario to to, you know, 100 years ago in that sense, right?
- 1:16:45Like, it's much more feasible for people to get out in time
- 1:16:48than it ever has been. Thank you, Brian.
- 1:16:54Articulating, but I couldn't earlier.
- 1:16:56That's the other, yeah, again analogies.
- 1:16:58I think the historical context is good to understand and try to
- 1:17:03map to what we're going through now.
- 1:17:04But the context is completely different with the Internet,
- 1:17:07with Bitcoin, with the global nature of this asset.
- 1:17:13I have a question for you guys. I'm generally curious on with
- 1:17:17the ETF inflows, do you guys think people get like you know
- 1:17:20they go in at a 1% or whatever alternative asset asset
- 1:17:25allocation and then it appreciates the two 3%.
- 1:17:28Do you think that whether they increase their exposure or gets
- 1:17:32a 5 to 10%, do they go far enough to understand why if they
- 1:17:37need to take it off or why they would want, you know, different
- 1:17:39custody, all the things that you would go down when you naturally
- 1:17:42go down the rabbit hole? Or does this end up being like
- 1:17:44where people just like, you know, passively have large
- 1:17:48material exposure, not 1% point 5% but like 5 to 10% and they
- 1:17:53leave it on there? I think it's gonna be case by
- 1:17:58case. Like I think some people it, it
- 1:18:00will prompt them to learn more about it just from a pure
- 1:18:04curiosity and interest perspective.
- 1:18:05It's like oh this is by far and away the best performing asset
- 1:18:08in My Portfolio. Maybe I should understand it
- 1:18:10more deeply. And if they do that, then yeah,
- 1:18:12maybe they take it out of ETF, Sir.
- 1:18:14If not, maybe if they don't even go to that extent, it's like
- 1:18:17they're next by like their next allocation is something that's
- 1:18:21outside of ETF whether it's self custody or something like on
- 1:18:24ramp. So I but I do think it's just
- 1:18:27going to be case by case because it's like comes down to the the
- 1:18:30person or the investment committee, the allocator
- 1:18:32themselves looking themselves in the mirror and saying like
- 1:18:35should I understand the best performing asset in My Portfolio
- 1:18:38a little bit better. Well, to compare to equities,
- 1:18:41right? Like equities have been de facto
- 1:18:44savings vehicle for people in the US for several decades now.
- 1:18:48And I think it's still quite a minority of people who even
- 1:18:52think about why that is right. Why am I just funneling my
- 1:18:56retirement into the S&P 500, which is predominantly a handful
- 1:19:00of companies driving the performance?
- 1:19:02Why do I do that? And it's not like people are.
- 1:19:04A lot of people aren't thinking past that point in terms of, you
- 1:19:07know, the money is broken. And I'm using this as, you know,
- 1:19:11an alternative or a store of value.
- 1:19:13So I don't know, maybe it's a little pessimistic, but I think
- 1:19:17a lot of majority of people that buy the ETF are probably not
- 1:19:21going to go, you know, fully down the rabbit hole and
- 1:19:24understand the complexities of Bitcoin, the true nature of it,
- 1:19:27just because they haven't, Even a lot of people haven't even
- 1:19:30gone to the point of understanding why are they, you
- 1:19:33know, putting their four O 1K or you know, their brokerage
- 1:19:35account into the S&P 500 or another passive ETF.
- 1:19:42I'm a little more optimistic in the sense of the people that do
- 1:19:45understand it, of taking their dollars out of the equity
- 1:19:47markets, like the five people on this pod and that and that
- 1:19:52people that once they learn a little bit about or have
- 1:19:54material exposure because it's money, they have to like figure
- 1:19:57it out. It's just like if they don't,
- 1:19:59then they can lose it all. But we'll see.
- 1:20:04It's something I've just been thinking a lot about is like
- 1:20:06people get their exposure and then it's obviously going to
- 1:20:08increase or they're going to increase, you know, willingly,
- 1:20:10independent of price appreciation.
- 1:20:12And then what threshold does it get where you start to look at
- 1:20:14it more deeply than a number on a screen.
- 1:20:18And I think that I think it's naturally just because it's
- 1:20:22money. And it's very different than
- 1:20:23anything else. You have a like, intimate
- 1:20:25relationship with it. You start to look at like, what
- 1:20:27is this thing because it keeps increasing.
- 1:20:29And now you end up at this other side of it where you're, you
- 1:20:33know, going down the rabbit hole.
- 1:20:36Yeah. I mean look at the data, we're
- 1:20:37up 131% over the last year after over the last 12 months and 70%
- 1:20:43of the supply has not moved in over a year.
- 1:20:47Obviously probably not the institutions we're talking about
- 1:20:50in this context looking at their portfolio go up significantly
- 1:20:53and not rebalancing, but they are competing with these
- 1:20:56hardened holders as well, which that's a whole because the
- 1:21:00Bitcoin market, the holders that are in now I think really good
- 1:21:05as is evidenced by that huddle wave stat 70% holding for a year
- 1:21:10or longer. I think a lot of people that are
- 1:21:12already in are not giving up their sets anytime soon.
- 1:21:15Yeah, and we saw this previously with the GBTC holders.
- 1:21:19This part of like the impetus of on ramp on the Bitcoin Trust is
- 1:21:23like people realize they didn't like it to be in the trust and
- 1:21:26then to sell they had the taxable event and then they had
- 1:21:30to, they were that wasn't even the problem for a lot of people.
- 1:21:32It was getting out of the market for that two weeks because you
- 1:21:34have to sell, then you have to wait for the dollars to roll
- 1:21:37over to your bank account. Then you have to wait for the
- 1:21:38dollars to roll back over to to execute.
- 1:21:41And then that timing, especially in a bull run, really pisses
- 1:21:44people off because it could be the difference between having 10
- 1:21:46to 20% if not more or less Bitcoin.
- 1:21:49And so that's another like just data point on you get exposure,
- 1:21:52but then you wake up, you're like wait, this is a shitty
- 1:21:54product. So I think and again I don't
- 1:21:57know what the number is in percentage from all obviously
- 1:22:00it's probably not, it's definitely not ever.
- 1:22:02It's not a large percentage. But that was also more, I guess
- 1:22:05it wasn't a retail product, but there wasn't a lot of
- 1:22:07institutions. That was the only version, but
- 1:22:10there weren't a lot in in 2017, 2020 versus what's coming now.
- 1:22:17I'm bullish. We're bullish in all of you.
- 1:22:20Maybe not, Brian, but are you guessing Anything else we should
- 1:22:26touch on before we wrap up here? We'll be back in the desert
- 1:22:31soon. Jackson's going back.
- 1:22:34Jones. Jackson's going back in a couple
- 1:22:35weeks. We'll be back there in April.
- 1:22:36Hopefully we get Jesse along with us.
- 1:22:39Yeah, we got some big stuff planned in April.
- 1:22:42Can't name names, but big firms that we will be doing some
- 1:22:44events. We're going to take Bitcoin to
- 1:22:46the desert and they'll be maybe crypto things going on, but we
- 1:22:49will own the Bitcoin side of it. It's a very high signal stuff
- 1:22:53happening and. Thank you gentlemen.
- 1:22:56We need, we need the Bitcoin only message getting out there.
- 1:23:00You see, these societies have been built up over millennia.
- 1:23:05They don't deserve to get rugged by the disgusting people in
- 1:23:08crypto. You need to save them.
- 1:23:09You need to bring them in, show them the light.
- 1:23:14Yeah, that was actually a big learning Marty that I don't know
- 1:23:17if you've thought about deeply is like they kind of do a
- 1:23:20disservice when you offer crypto.
- 1:23:21Like in you're trying to like navigate to Bitcoin because at
- 1:23:24best you can just like it's a sprinkle of like casino versus
- 1:23:28just saying one thing and you go there and you explain why one's
- 1:23:31valuable, the other isn't. And then you can just give a
- 1:23:34whole, like, it's multidisciplinary, right.
- 1:23:35People come at it from different angles, so you can like help
- 1:23:38architect in their brain why this is an asset that's not 1%
- 1:23:41but 5 or 10%. It's just they're like doing
- 1:23:44themselves a disservice and they don't even realize it.
- 1:23:46It's something like it just started like being out there and
- 1:23:48realizing it's like they're trying to get like there's ETF
- 1:23:51providers that are out there showing everything and it's like
- 1:23:53guys, all your inflows, all your custody is Bitcoin.
- 1:23:56Why wouldn't you just focus on that?
- 1:23:57You're because at best you're just chilling you know crypto
- 1:24:01kernel. Yeah just trash cryptocurrency
- 1:24:03which because like the idea as an institutional investor if
- 1:24:05you're getting if you see all this on a website or what you're
- 1:24:08doing, then at best you're like well why would I take a
- 1:24:11meaningful position in Bitcoin because what about these other
- 1:24:13things like what if they're the next Bitcoin.
- 1:24:14So you're like rub yourself on an allocation side versus just
- 1:24:17like having a a stance And it's funny because it's the most all
- 1:24:21these people whether it's custody or liquidity is all
- 1:24:24Bitcoin didn't like majority is 80 to 90% And it's funny because
- 1:24:27every time we say we're Bitcoin only to very sophisticated
- 1:24:29people that are encrypted they're like oh that's real
- 1:24:31smart really. Yeah you'd be I I was on a call
- 1:24:37with an ETF provider I won't name who they basically said MI
- 1:24:39multi institutions bulletproof. Like it's just the reality of
- 1:24:43like you have to you know it's you got to get in strides like
- 1:24:47it's still early you know it was also that it would melt brains.
- 1:24:50So you know that kind of sends a signal of how early we are.
- 1:24:53But make no mistake like if if all this stuff works out which
- 1:24:56we all believe it will like multi institution will be the
- 1:24:59standard for how ETFs will be distributed globally.
- 1:25:02It's just from, again, flow of water.
- 1:25:05You can't have large amounts of Bitcoin sitting with a single
- 1:25:07entity. Yeah, it's common sense.
- 1:25:12Gentlemen, it's been a pleasure. Jesse, go yell at the people
- 1:25:15working on your house. I know you.
- 1:25:17I know you're looking to do that right now.
- 1:25:18I'm kidding. Jesse's a kind homeowner.
- 1:25:22It's good to his subcontractors. It's true.
- 1:25:28Brian Jackson, it's great to have you guys on.
- 1:25:31We'll be back next week.