Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Stocks Beat Indexes in Year One
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a persistent myth in tech circles that once you buy a stock on its IPO day, you are basically signing up for a roller coaster that ends somewhere below where you started. The data tells a different story. Luna: You are talking about the idea that IPOs are overpriced, that the pop is fake, and that the real return comes from waiting for the hangover. Lucas: Exactly. And look, there are plenty of IPOs that crater. We have seen that. But if you look at a basket of tech IPOs from the last, say, three years — companies that went public in 2024 and 2025 — the median one-year return from the close of the first day of trading is actually positive, and in many cases it beats the S&P 500 over the same period. Luna: That is counterintuitive. I think most people assume the first-day pop is the whole show, and then the stock drifts lower as insiders sell. Lucas: Right. And that does happen in some cases. But what I find interesting is the mechanics underneath. When a company goes public, the underwriting syndicate typically prices the deal at a discount to where they think the stock will trade — that's the pop. But after day one, the stock often grinds higher for months. Part of it is the float. Luna: The float — the number of shares actually available to trade — is usually tiny relative to the total shares outstanding. Lucas: Yes. A typical tech IPO might sell only ten to fifteen percent of the company. So you have this very tight supply of shares, and if demand from institutional buyers remains strong, the stock can climb steadily. Then, after a few months, the company reports its first earnings as a public company. And because the roadshow pitch deck is usually conservative — bankers hate missing estimates — the company often beats. Luna: So you get a double catalyst: low float plus earnings beats. That is a recipe for a steady climb. Lucas: Exactly. Reddit is a good example. It went public in March 2024 at $34, popped to around $50 on day one, and then over the next twelve months it traded in a range of $40 to $70. It never gave back all the gains. And it got added to the S&P 500 in late 2025, which brought in index fund buying. Luna: And Instacart — well, Maplebear, its parent — went public at $30 in September 2023, popped to $33, then drifted down to $25. That seemed like a bust. But then it recovered and by the one-year mark it was above $40. Lucas: That is the thing. The initial disappointment actually created a buying opportunity. The company had priced conservatively, and when it started delivering operating margins that beat expectations, the stock rerated. By the time the lockup expired in March 2024, the stock was already well above the IPO price, so the insider selling was absorbed relatively easily. Luna: But you mentioned lockup expirations. That is the big risk around month six or twelve. Suddenly the float can double or triple. Lucas: It is a real test. And some stocks do crack. But interestingly, the data shows that for tech IPOs that have beaten earnings consistently, the lockup expiration is often a non-event. The stock might dip a few percent, but it recovers within weeks. The selling is usually pre-arranged through trading plans, so it's not a surprise. Luna: What about the ones that fail? There have been some high-profile disasters — I am thinking of the SPAC cohort from 2021, but also traditional IPOs like Arm Holdings, which traded sideways for a year. Lucas: Arm is a special case because it had a massive float — SoftBank sold a big chunk — so the supply-demand dynamic was different. But you are right. The pattern I am describing works best for companies that have a small float, strong institutional demand, and a business model that can surprise to the upside. If the company is overhyped and then delivers mediocre results, the stock can fall hard. Just look at the 2021 cohort: Rivian, Robinhood, Coinbase — all of them were priced for perfection and then reality hit. Luna: And today, we are in a different environment. The market has been choppy. The S&P 500 is down a bit, and some big tech names like Microsoft have dropped nine and a half percent in the last five days. So the IPO aftermarket might be more challenging. Lucas: It is. But if anything, that makes the pattern more interesting. In a risk-off environment, the limited supply of shares in a small-float IPO can actually be a tailwind — there is less competition from other IPOs, and institutions are hunting for quality. The key is to be selective. Look for companies with high insider ownership, a clear path to profitability, and a valuation that doesn't assume perfection. Luna: So if you are listening and you want to play this, what is the practical takeaway? Do you buy on day one? Do you wait for the lockup expiration? Lucas: I would say: do not chase the first-day pop. If the stock doubles on day one — like some of the AI IPOs did — you are already paying for years of optimism. Instead, wait for the first earnings report. If the company beats and raises guidance, and the stock pulls back on that news — which it sometimes does because the market wanted even more — that is a better entry. Then you have six to nine months before the lockup expiration, and if the fundamentals hold, you should do well. Luna: That is a disciplined approach. And it relies on the company's ability to execute, not just on the IPO hype. Lucas: Exactly. And honestly, if today's conversation was worth a coffee to you, that is the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep the show ad-free and focused on the data. Luna: Yeah, it is a small way to support the kind of analysis we try to bring every episode. If it's useful to what you are building or running, that's great. Lucas: So back to the data. One more thing I want to highlight: the role of index inclusion. When a company like Reddit gets added to the S&P 500, it creates a structural bid. Index funds have to buy, and that buying is not price-sensitive. So if you own the stock before the inclusion, you get a nice bump. Luna: And inclusion usually happens around the one-year mark, which is also when the lockup expires. So you have these two forces — index buying and insider selling — that can offset each other. Lucas: Right. That is why the year-one anniversary is such a critical moment. If the stock holds its ground through that period, it often becomes a core holding for institutional investors. And then the narrative shifts from 'new IPO' to 'established growth stock.' Luna: It is a fascinating lifecycle. And it suggests that the first year after an IPO is actually a period of price discovery, not just volatility. Lucas: Exactly. The market is figuring out the right valuation, and the company is proving itself quarter by quarter. For patient investors, that can be a very rewarding window.