Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Fragility of Electric Vehicle Infotainment Systems
Transcript
- 0:09You know, when you think about the car industry, you probably
- 0:11still think about, well, welding, metal building, power
- 0:14trains, that kind of thing. Exactly calculating torque.
- 0:16The complexity was all physical. But today, that is fundamentally
- 0:20completely shifted. A modern car isn't just a
- 0:22machine anymore. No, it's an intelligent,
- 0:25connected digital transortation hub.
- 0:28That's the new reality and. What does that mean in practice?
- 0:30It means we've gone from Ure mechanics to Ure computing.
- 0:36A modern connected car, or ACC, as the industry calls it, is run
- 0:40by hundreds of electronic control units, ECU's right, and
- 0:43it runs on well over 100 million lines of code A. 100 million.
- 0:48That puts your family sedan in the same league as like a
- 0:51military aircraft. It does, and the immediate
- 0:53consequence of all that digital complexity is, well, inevitable.
- 0:57Bugs. Bugs.
- 0:58A high likelihood of software bugs and when a safety critical
- 1:02issue pops up, the OEMs, the manufacturers have to recall
- 1:05entire fleets. And that's the old, painful
- 1:08process we all know. Registered mail, scheduling
- 1:12appointments. A huge headache.
- 1:14It's immensely costly for them and it absolutely crushes
- 1:17customer satisfaction and brand image.
- 1:20But the solution is here and it's called Over the Air updates
- 1:23OTA, right? It lets them patch software
- 1:26remotely over a wireless network, often while the car is
- 1:29just sitting in your driveway. And for the car companies, the
- 1:32savings are already known and they are massive.
- 1:35We're talking estimates of over $35 billion a year for the
- 1:39global industry. A staggering figure it is, but
- 1:42what was really missing, you know from the research, was the
- 1:45value for you, for the actual owner of the car.
- 1:49So not the corporate savings, but the consumers benefit.
- 1:52Exactly. We had all this data on OEM cost
- 1:55avoidance, but a huge gap in measuring the economic benefit
- 1:58to you, the consumer, especially when it comes to a safety
- 2:01recall. That's fascinating.
- 2:03So that's our mission for this deep dive.
- 2:04We're unpacking a study that actually modeled this experience
- 2:08to put a precise dollar value, or euro value in this case, on
- 2:11what that OTA convenience is worth to your wallet.
- 2:14OK, let's start with that traditional experience then, the
- 2:16one every car owner dreads and starts with that letter, right?
- 2:19That registered mail notice? Yeah, it tells you there's a
- 2:22defect and you have to physically bring your car to the
- 2:24workshop. That friction, that
- 2:25inconvenience, is exactly what this research set out to
- 2:29measure. And the model breaks it down
- 2:31into two possible journeys for a car owner without OTA.
- 2:36It does, and it all depends on one thing, how long the update
- 2:39takes. So walk us through those two
- 2:41cases. OK, so case 1 is the best case
- 2:44scenario really. If the service time is short,
- 2:47let's say under 2 hours, the owner just waits nearby.
- 2:50Annoying, but manageable. Exactly.
- 2:53Minimal friction, but case 2. That's the one we all dread.
- 2:56That's the one that ruins your day.
- 2:57Completely Case 2 happens when the service time is longer.
- 3:01Maybe the update is just really complex, but more often it's
- 3:04because of dealership bottlenecks.
- 3:06You know, huge queues during a mass recall.
- 3:08High friction scenario. That's it.
- 3:10So you have to drop the car off, find some other way to get home,
- 3:13and then travel all the way back to the dealership later to pick
- 3:16it up. Let's just focus on the
- 3:17logistics of that for a second, because that's where time really
- 3:20becomes money. You're talking about four
- 3:21separate trips. 4 Just for one software bug.
- 3:25So you drive the car to drop it off?
- 3:26That's one. Then you take a bus, a train, a
- 3:28taxi, whatever to get back home. That's 2.
- 3:31Then you have to repeat that journey to go back to the
- 3:33dealership 3. And finally, trip #4 is you
- 3:37driving your updated car home and the research model this
- 3:41exact sequence because it represents the highest possible
- 3:44cost of inconvenience. Which brings us right to
- 3:47quantifying that cost. How do you put a price on that?
- 3:50Well, the economic model calculates the total cost for
- 3:54you, the consumer, and it's made-up of two main parts, the
- 3:58cost related to a potential accident and the cost of the
- 4:01recall operation itself. OK.
- 4:03And what's fascinating is that even though this is a safety
- 4:05recall, the accident cost is surprisingly small.
- 4:09It's negligible actually. How can that be a safety recall?
- 4:13Sounds serious. The fault can be serious, but
- 4:16the model calculates the probability of an accident
- 4:18happening because of that specific fault before you can
- 4:21get the update as extremely low. So what kind of number are we
- 4:25talking about? In the scenarios they validated,
- 4:27it was just .01%. So the real financial hit, the
- 4:31real driver of the cost to you, isn't the risk of a crash.
- 4:35It's the hassle. It's the physical recall process
- 4:38and the loss of your time that's the real expense.
- 4:41So when we drill down into that recall operations cost, the
- 4:44researchers found the main expenses aren't even the obvious
- 4:47things like gas money or a bus ticket.
- 4:50That's the huge insight from the study.
- 4:51The biggest financial burdens are the value they assigned to
- 4:55your lost time. OK.
- 4:56So we're really looking at two things, the value of your time
- 4:59spent traveling and the value of your time spent just waiting.
- 5:03The actual service of course, is free.
- 5:05The OEM pays for that. It's the.
- 5:06Opportunity cost of your time. Precisely, let's define that
- 5:10this value of time. It sounds academic, but it's
- 5:12really a measure of your life being put on hold.
- 5:15It is so. First, you have the value of
- 5:17lost driving time. This is the money you lose or
- 5:19the leisure you miss because you're driving to the dealership
- 5:22instead of working or doing something else.
- 5:25And the second part. The waiting.
- 5:27That's the value of lost waiting time.
- 5:29It's calculated based on what your time is worth while you're
- 5:32sitting in the waiting room or just waiting for the call.
- 5:35How do they measure that? The model assumes that time is
- 5:37totally unproductive, so it's value is tied directly to the
- 5:41average net hourly salary in the area they studied, which in this
- 5:44case was Milan. It's literally the income you
- 5:47couldn't earn. And the findings on this are
- 5:50just stark in the real world scenarios.
- 5:54The biggest part of the entire recall cost was always that
- 5:58waiting time. It wasn't just the biggest part,
- 6:00it was completely dominant in the first scenario, that waiting
- 6:03time cost was 65% of the total. Yeah, 2/3 of the cost is just
- 6:07waiting. And in the second scenario, it
- 6:08was even higher. It accounted for 87% of your
- 6:12total financial loss. 87%, so the queue, the bottleneck at the
- 6:16dealership, that's where most of the money is lost.
- 6:18Absolutely. The system is set up so you're
- 6:20inconveniences measure and lost time, and that time has a very
- 6:24high monetary value. Now, what about the other part,
- 6:27the travel time? The variation there told a
- 6:30really interesting story about the OEM's infrastructure.
- 6:33It did, yes. In scenario one, they looked at
- 6:35a smaller OEM with a pretty sparse dealer network.
- 6:39The average customer had to travel almost 4 kilometers.
- 6:42And that cost? The resulting travel time cost
- 6:45made-up 32% of the consumers total cost.
- 6:48But for a bigger car company with more dealers?
- 6:51That was scenario 2A. Much larger OEM, a better
- 6:54network. The average travel distance
- 6:56dropped to just one kilometer. And the travel cost dropped with
- 7:00it. Dramatically, it was only 11% of
- 7:02the consumers loss in that case, which confirms, you know if you
- 7:05own a car from a brand with a less effective dealer network,
- 7:09the lack of a nearby shop significantly hikes up the price
- 7:12of your inconvenience. So let's tie this all back to
- 7:15OTA. What does this mean for you when
- 7:17you can just skip that whole process?
- 7:18It means you avoid that entire financial cost.
- 7:22The expected savings for you is equal to that full recall
- 7:25inconvenience cost we just discussed.
- 7:27OK, let's get to the numbers. What kind of savings are we
- 7:29talking about here? Well, the total inconvenience
- 7:32cost for a consumer without OTA is consistently over €100.
- 7:36For just one recall. For one recall event, yes.
- 7:39In the two scenarios tested, it was between about 103 and 147.
- 7:44OK. So let's say the OEM can fix, I
- 7:46don't know, 30% of these issues remotely, which the study used
- 7:50as a baseline. What's the tangible saving?
- 7:52The expected savings for you would be between about 30 and
- 7:56€44 per recall, but, and this is the key, if a recall is 100%
- 8:01fixable over the air. Then you save the whole.
- 8:04You save the full cost that's up to €240 for a single event.
- 8:08In that higher friction scenario, it's a clear,
- 8:10quantifiable return. And this is where it gets really
- 8:12important, especially when you think about massive recalls in a
- 8:15crisis situations. The research looked at the scale
- 8:18of the recall. Yes, a sensitivity analysis and
- 8:22the findings show the system just breaks down exponentially
- 8:25under stress. They found that as a number of
- 8:27recalled vehicles double, say from 10,000 to 20,000, the cost
- 8:32to each consumer and therefore your savings from OTA grows
- 8:36almost exponentially. How exponentially?
- 8:39With a growth rate close to 300%.
- 8:41Wait, hold on. So A 100% increase in recalled
- 8:44cars leads to a nearly 300% increase in my personal cost.
- 8:48That's the multiplier effect. This is maybe the most critical.
- 8:52Finding OTA becomes exponentially more valuable
- 8:55precisely when the traditional dealership system is totally
- 8:58overwhelmed. Because the lines get longer,
- 9:01the waiting time shoots up. And waiting time is the most
- 9:03expensive part of the whole process.
- 9:04It disproportionately inflates your cost.
- 9:07There was also a related finding on the actual update time
- 9:09itself, wasn't there? Yes.
- 9:11The model showed that as the software update duration
- 9:14increases the time the car is actually plugged in, the total
- 9:18cost to you also increases more than proportionally.
- 9:21So an OTA enabled car just becomes more and more convenient
- 9:24the bigger the software fixes. Exactly.
- 9:26The value of avoiding that physical process just keeps
- 9:30climbing. OK, so let's try and summarize
- 9:32the big take away here for you, the owner.
- 9:34This research really proves that OTA isn't just some cool tech or
- 9:38a way for car companies to save money.
- 9:40No, it has a clear, quantifiable monetary value for you.
- 9:45And that value, surprisingly, is not about saving on gas.
- 9:49It's about avoiding lost, unproductive time and the very
- 9:53high financial price tag that comes with that time during a
- 9:57safety recall. The inconvenience has been
- 9:59priced, and while these number, you know, savings of 100 up to
- 10:03240 euro make a powerful case, it's important to remember that
- 10:07the model doesn't even capture the full picture.
- 10:09What's missing? The qualitative benefit?
- 10:11The study acknowledges these are significant, but they're hard to
- 10:14quantify. Things like.
- 10:15Enhanced customer satisfaction. A drastically better end user
- 10:19experience. Maintaining brand loyalty.
- 10:22These are incredibly difficult to put a number on, but they're
- 10:24probably the most crucial things for an OEM in the long run.
- 10:27The cost of your inconvenience today hits their bottom line
- 10:30tomorrow. Precisely.
- 10:32This definitely gives us a lot to think about.
- 10:34I guess the final thought is this, given that the complexity
- 10:37of our cars, and therefore the frequency of software recalls is
- 10:41only going up, how will OEMs manage customer loyalty when
- 10:44convenience for the lack of it can now be measured down to the
- 10:48very last euro? Thank you for joining us for
- 10:52this deep dive into the true consumer cost of automotive
- 10:55inconvenience. If you found these insights
- 10:57useful and interesting, please be sure to follow the channel
- 10:59for more deep dives into the sources that shape our connected
- 11:02world.