Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Lesson Planning & Instructional Design: How Teachers Plan Effective Lessons
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. I mean,
- 0:03usually when you talk about a medical diagnosis,
- 0:06there is a certain expectation of precision.
- 0:09Oh, absolutely. Like you break your arm, the
- 0:11x -ray shows a jagged white line and the doctor
- 0:13just points to it says, you know, there's the
- 0:15problem. Exactly. It's visible. It's categorized.
- 0:19And honestly, it is highly comforting to have
- 0:21that binary certainty, broken or not broken.
- 0:24Yeah, we gravitate toward that. It makes the
- 0:26world feel manageable because the problem and
- 0:28the solution are just, well, sitting right there
- 0:30in plain sight. But the moment you step into
- 0:32the world of a classroom, that X -ray machine
- 0:35just totally shatters. It really does. As a society,
- 0:39we tend to operate under this massive assumption
- 0:42that a teacher simply stands up, talks about
- 0:45a subject they know well, and learning just magically
- 0:49materializes in the brains of the students. We
- 0:51treat it like this organic passive occurrence.
- 0:54Which is perhaps the greatest misunderstanding
- 0:55of the educational profession. I mean, teaching
- 0:57is not simply standing up and talking. It is
- 0:59a highly - engineered. meticulously planned psychological
- 1:03process. It is the absolute definition of diagnostic
- 1:07muddy waters. You know, educators are constantly
- 1:11trying to figure out the exact mechanisms needed
- 1:13to turn a vague abstract idea into a concrete
- 1:16measurable learning moment. And that is exactly
- 1:18what we are decoding today. We are two undergrad
- 1:21psychology students geeking out on a deep dive
- 1:25into the source material for our educational
- 1:27psychology class. And you, our listener, are
- 1:30coming along as the third study buddy in the
- 1:32room. Yes. Our mission today is to trace the
- 1:35journey of an idea. We want to understand the
- 1:37psychological architecture of how a massive educational
- 1:40goal, something as broad as, say, understanding
- 1:44American history, gets distilled all the way
- 1:46down to exactly what a 10 -year -old student
- 1:48is doing at their desk on a Tuesday morning at
- 1:509 .15 a .m. To understand that architecture,
- 1:52we really have to look at the cognitive load
- 1:54placed on a teacher. Oh, the decision fatigue
- 1:56would be insane. Totally insane. If a teacher
- 1:59walked into a room on day one with a blank slate,
- 2:03the sheer volume of decisions required to design
- 2:05a year of learning would cause immediate burnout.
- 2:09So the educational system relies on a top -down
- 2:12hierarchy to narrow the focus. Starting at the
- 2:15absolute highest level, right? With national
- 2:18and state standards. Exactly. These standards
- 2:20are incredibly broad summaries. They basically
- 2:23dictate what a student should reasonably be expected
- 2:26to learn by the end of a specific grade. In our
- 2:29source notes, there is this fascinating look
- 2:32at Ohio's state standard for kindergarten through
- 2:35third grade language arts. What did it say again?
- 2:37The standard is literally just read accurately
- 2:39high frequency sight words. Which is a destination,
- 2:42but it severely lacks a route. I mean, a standard
- 2:45like that does not tell a teacher what to do
- 2:47on that Tuesday morning. No, not at all. To bridge
- 2:49that gap, educational psychologists and curriculum
- 2:52designers build curriculum frameworks. These
- 2:55documents take those massive standards and organize
- 2:57them into a scope and sequence. The scope and
- 3:00sequence. Yeah, they translate the abstract goals
- 3:02into specific observable skills. Right, right.
- 3:05Like, California's third grade English framework
- 3:07is a great illustration of this translation process.
- 3:10The overarching standard is about mastering English
- 3:13conventions. But the framework breaks that one
- 3:16standard down into nine highly specific skills.
- 3:19Oh, I'm nine. Yeah. So suddenly... The teacher
- 3:22isn't just looking at this vague idea of English
- 3:25conventions. They are looking at things like
- 3:27punctuating dates and titles or spelling one
- 3:30syllable words with blends. And that translation
- 3:32is crucial for a teacher's cognitive mapping.
- 3:35But we still aren't at the level of the student's
- 3:39desk yet. True. The final step in this top -down
- 3:41planning is the curriculum guide. These are the
- 3:44physical or graphic descriptions of the actual
- 3:47activities. They're the day -to -day stuff. Exactly.
- 3:49They outline the materials needed, the time requirements,
- 3:52and even the social grouping of the students.
- 3:54To help remember this hierarchy, I like the memory
- 3:56trick from our notes, SFG. SFG? Yeah. Some frogs
- 4:00growl. Standards, frameworks, guides. It moves
- 4:03from the broadest concept to the most specific
- 4:05daily plan. Some frogs growl. I like that. Okay,
- 4:08let's unpack this with a GPS analogy. The standard
- 4:12is the destination. Let's say New York City.
- 4:16The framework is the highway you take, like I
- 4:19-80, and the guide is the turn -by -turn directions.
- 4:22That makes perfect sense. There is a classic
- 4:24early childhood example in our notes involving
- 4:27an autumn leaves activity that fits this perfectly.
- 4:30Oh, the kindergarten one. Yeah. The guide gives
- 4:32the teacher a concrete task that hits multiple
- 4:35objectives simultaneously. The kids are tracing
- 4:38shapes to build fine motor skills, they are learning
- 4:41color categorization, and they're comparing sizes
- 4:44to build foundational math logic. So the psychological
- 4:47reality of the classroom is dictated by this
- 4:49top -down structure. Right. However, possessing
- 4:52turn -by -turn directions doesn't relieve the
- 4:54teacher from formulating a specific objective
- 4:56for that day's lesson. because they still have
- 4:58to decide how they will measure if the student
- 4:59actually acquired the new neural pathways. Exactly.
- 5:02And this requirement leads us directly into one
- 5:04of the most fundamental splits in psychology.
- 5:07The tension between evaluating the brain versus
- 5:09evaluating the behavior. Yes. The cognitive approach
- 5:13versus the behavioral approach. It is a debate
- 5:17that shapes every single lesson plan. Let's start
- 5:19with cognitive. If a teacher leans into the cognitive
- 5:22approach, they are working from the general down
- 5:24to the specific. Right. They begin with a broad
- 5:27internal goal. Like, the student will understand
- 5:30the nature and purpose of photosynthesis. But
- 5:33the inherent problem with understanding is that
- 5:35it is invisible. Totally invisible. You cannot
- 5:37peer into a student's prefrontal cortex to see
- 5:40if comprehension has actually occurred. So what
- 5:42do they do? Well, because cognitive psychology
- 5:45acknowledges this limitation, it requires the
- 5:48teacher to create a list of indicators. Indicators.
- 5:52Like sample behaviors that signify internal success.
- 5:55Exactly. An indicator for that photosynthesis
- 5:57lesson might be diagrams the steps in the chemical
- 6:01process or writes a plan to test leaf pigmentation.
- 6:04So the underlying philosophy here is that you
- 6:07aren't testing every single conceivable way a
- 6:10student could demonstrate their understanding
- 6:11of photosynthesis. Right. You were just taking
- 6:14a representative sample to infer that the internal
- 6:17cognitive shift happened. Okay, but then you
- 6:19have the behavioral approach, which was heavily
- 6:22influenced by mid -century psychologists and
- 6:24formalized for education by Robert Major. And
- 6:27Major rejected that kind of inference entirely.
- 6:29He argued that relying on samples of invisible
- 6:32understanding was just scientifically flimsy.
- 6:36So his method moves from the specific to the
- 6:38general? Yes. It demands that an objective dictate
- 6:42the exact concrete actions a student must perform,
- 6:46leaving zero room for interpretation. Major's
- 6:48framework is incredibly rigid. I was reading
- 6:51through the requirements, and an objective actually
- 6:53has to contain three distinct features to even
- 6:56qualify. What are the three? First, it must be
- 6:58an observable behavior. You cannot write, the
- 7:01student will appreciate the concept. You must
- 7:03write, the student will make a list. Makes sense
- 7:05for behaviorism. Second, you have to outline
- 7:07the conditions of performance. For example, given
- 7:10a blank map and a list of 50 cities. Okay, so
- 7:13very specific parameters. And third, it specifies
- 7:15a minimum level of acceptable performance, such
- 7:18as within 15 minutes with 90 % accuracy. The
- 7:22classic example used to illustrate major strictness
- 7:25involves learning a physical skill, like rollerblading.
- 7:28Oh yeah, I saw this in the notes. Under a behavioral
- 7:31framework, the objective for a beginner isn't
- 7:34you know, understand how to balance on skates.
- 7:36Because balance is too vague. Right. The objective
- 7:39is literally. Student skates 15 meters on level
- 7:42ground without falling. It forces the teacher
- 7:45to operationalize learning into raw data. OK,
- 7:48I see the utility for physical skills or procedural
- 7:52tasks like driving a car. But wait, isn't that
- 7:54a bit robotic? How so? Well, applying that rigidity
- 7:57universally feels incredibly limiting. How do
- 8:01you write a strict behavioral objective with
- 8:03a minimum level of acceptable performance for
- 8:05something beautiful, like understanding a Shakespeare
- 8:07play? That is the million -dollar question. Or
- 8:10even more complex, goals related to character
- 8:12or morality, like becoming a good citizen. You've
- 8:15isolated the exact vulnerability of strict behaviorism
- 8:18in education. It attempts to quantify the unquantifiable.
- 8:23I mean, you wouldn't want a minimum citizen,
- 8:24right? No. That sounds terrible. If you try to
- 8:27force complex moral development into majors'
- 8:30framework, you end up with absurd metrics like,
- 8:32the student will pick up three pieces of trash
- 8:34in a 10 -minute window without complaining. Which
- 8:37totally misses the point. That metric completely
- 8:40ignores the deeper psychological internalization
- 8:43of what it actually means to value your community.
- 8:46Exactly. Which is why modern lesson planning
- 8:49usually requires a compromise between the two
- 8:51philosophies. But no matter whether a teacher
- 8:54leans cognitive or behavioral, there is a universal
- 8:57golden rule in educational psychology. What's
- 9:00the rule? Focus on what the student does, not
- 9:03what the teacher does. A teacher should never
- 9:05write, I will summarize the plot of Macbeth for
- 9:07the class. Because learning is defined by the
- 9:09student's brain changing, not by the teacher's
- 9:11performance. Precisely. The objective must be...
- 9:14students will write a summary of Macbeth. Okay,
- 9:16so once you establish that the focus is on the
- 9:19student's output, the next psychological hurdle
- 9:22is determining the complexity of the thought
- 9:24process you are asking them to engage in. And
- 9:26in cognitive science, you cannot categorize thought
- 9:29without discussing Benjamin Bloom. Right. Bloom's
- 9:32taxonomy. It's the classic hierarchy of cognitive
- 9:35processes. Developed in the 1950s, it breaks
- 9:39thinking down into progressive levels, mapping
- 9:41how the brain moves from simple retrieval to
- 9:44highly complex judgment. And the progression
- 9:46relies heavily on schema theory. That's the idea
- 9:49that you have to build basic mental frameworks
- 9:52before you can manipulate them, right? Exactly.
- 9:55The architecture of Bloom's taxonomy is brilliant
- 9:57because it mirrors cognitive load. The foundational
- 10:01level is basic knowledge, which is just pure
- 10:04memory retrieval. Our source material illustrates
- 10:07this using the story of Goldilocks and the three
- 10:09bears. Right. So a knowledge level task is simply
- 10:11name three things Goldilocks did in the house.
- 10:14Just recall, once that baseline is established,
- 10:16you move up to comprehension, which requires
- 10:18the brain to process meaning. Like, explain why
- 10:21she preferred the little bear's chair. From there,
- 10:24the cognitive load increases with application.
- 10:27That's where the student takes the concept and
- 10:29maps it onto a novel situation. So predict what
- 10:32Goldilocks might have used if she entered your
- 10:34house. Yes. Then the brain is asked to perform
- 10:37analysis, which is deconstructing a concept into
- 10:40its component parts to understand its structure.
- 10:43Like select the part of the story where she felt
- 10:45most comfortable. And this is followed by synthesis,
- 10:48where those parts are combined into a new original
- 10:51whole. Tell how the story would be different
- 10:53if it had been three fishes instead of bears.
- 10:56That's a weird story, but okay. Finally, at the
- 10:59peak of the hierarchy is evaluation. This is
- 11:02where the brain weighs competing frameworks and
- 11:05makes a judgment based on criteria. For example,
- 11:08justify the statement that Goldilocks was a bad
- 11:10girl. It is fascinating to see how the brain
- 11:13has to hold the entire story, analyze societal
- 11:16norms, and then synthesize an argument just to
- 11:19answer that final prompt. It really is. Now,
- 11:21Bloom's original taxonomy was revolutionary,
- 11:24but researchers recently revised it to better
- 11:26reflect modern cognitive science. The revised
- 11:28Blooms, yeah. They transformed it into a two
- 11:30-dimensional matrix. Exactly. They separated
- 11:33the cognitive process. those verbs like remembering,
- 11:36analyzing, and creating from the actual type
- 11:38of knowledge being processed. Because knowledge
- 11:40isn't a monolith. It can be factual, conceptual,
- 11:44procedural, or metacognitive. Metacognitive being
- 11:47the brain's ability to think about its own thinking.
- 11:50So a teacher isn't just picking a level of thought.
- 11:53They are plotting a coordinate on a matrix. Yes,
- 11:56like evaluating procedural knowledge or applying
- 11:58conceptual knowledge. But the cognitive domain
- 12:01is only one piece of the psychological puzzle,
- 12:03isn't it? There are other domains of learning,
- 12:06like the psychomotor domain. Oh, definitely.
- 12:08The psychomotor domain maps the psychology of
- 12:10physical skills and muscle memory. Moving from
- 12:13basic imitation to naturalization. Right. It
- 12:16tracks how a learner moves from basic, clumsy
- 12:19imitation, like a kindergartner trying to copy
- 12:21a teacher's grip on a pencil through continuous
- 12:24practice until they reach that naturalization
- 12:26phase. Naturalization is when a physical sequence
- 12:29becomes entirely automatic, right? Like a gymnast
- 12:32executing a flawless 10 -minute routine without
- 12:35conscious thought about their individual muscle
- 12:37twitches. Exactly. But while the physical domain
- 12:40is interesting, the third domain, the effective
- 12:42domain, is where the psychology gets incredibly
- 12:45profound. Because it deals with feelings and
- 12:47emotions. Yes. It deals with the internalization
- 12:50of feelings, emotions, and values. It starts
- 12:53at a very baseline level called receiving. which
- 12:56is simply a learner's willingness to attend to
- 12:59a new experience or diverse viewpoint. What's
- 13:02fascinating here is how this links directly to
- 13:05moral development. It's the psychological foundation
- 13:07of moral education. A student might start by
- 13:10merely tolerating a concept they initially disagreed
- 13:13with, but as they move up the hierarchy through
- 13:16responding, valuing an organization, they begin
- 13:19to weigh that concept against their existing
- 13:21beliefs. And the pinnacle of this domain is characterization
- 13:25by a value complex. Right. Meaning the students
- 13:28has completely integrated this new value into
- 13:30a comprehensive hierarchy that dictates their
- 13:33behavior and worldview. It is a powerful reminder
- 13:36that education isn't just about transferring
- 13:38facts. It is actively shaping the ethical architecture
- 13:41of a human being. Which brings us to a critical
- 13:43pivot point in our discussion. Oh, the shift
- 13:45in control. Yes. Up until now, whether we are
- 13:48talking about standards, frameworks, or Bloom's
- 13:51taxonomy, the goals have been entirely dictated
- 13:54by adults. The psychological premise has been
- 13:57top -down authority. But what happens to student
- 14:01motivation when that hierarchy is inverted and
- 14:03the students are given the wheel? When you remove
- 14:05adult -driven mandates and allow the curriculum
- 14:08to be driven by the students themselves, it is
- 14:11called an emergent curriculum. From a psychological
- 14:13standpoint, this leverages intrinsic motivation.
- 14:17The brain learns far more efficiently when it
- 14:20is actively trying to solve a problem it genuinely
- 14:22cares about, rather than passively receiving
- 14:25information it was told to memorize. The classic
- 14:27example of this in the text involves a first
- 14:29grade teacher. She spent weeks planning a unit
- 14:32on Halloween bats and pumpkins. She reads a beautifully
- 14:35illustrated book to kick off the lesson, but
- 14:37the students completely ignore the Halloween
- 14:39elements. Typical first graders, what did they
- 14:41focus on? They become deeply fascinated by a
- 14:44drawing of the moon in the background. They start
- 14:46asking complex scientific questions about why
- 14:48the moon changes shape and how it stays in the
- 14:51sky. If that teacher is locked into a rigid,
- 14:54adult -driven framework, she shuts that curiosity
- 14:57down and forces them back to the bats. But in
- 15:00an emergent curriculum... She embraces the pivot.
- 15:03Using curriculum webbing, right? Exactly. She
- 15:05brainstorms connections in real time to map out
- 15:09a totally new path based on their intrinsic interest.
- 15:12Suddenly, they're building paper mache models
- 15:15and learning the physics of the solar system
- 15:16instead. Here's where it gets really interesting
- 15:18to me. It's essentially improv comedy. The teacher
- 15:21has to constantly adopt the yes -and mindset,
- 15:25taking whatever the students are curious about
- 15:27and building educational scaffolding underneath
- 15:29it. It requires immense cognitive flexibility
- 15:32from the educator. Totally. But giving students
- 15:35agency goes far beyond fun topics like astronomy.
- 15:38It is deeply tied to how students form their
- 15:40identities, which is the core of multicultural
- 15:43and anti -bias education. And this is a widely
- 15:45misunderstood concept. True multicultural education
- 15:49is not simply content integration. Like celebrating
- 15:52Kwanzaa alongside Christmas. Right. That's just
- 15:54surface level. From a psychological perspective,
- 15:57it requires an equity pedagogy. An equity pedagogy
- 16:00recognizes that different cultures have fundamentally
- 16:02different valid ways of processing and expressing
- 16:05knowledge. Yes. For instance, in many Western
- 16:07educational models, demonstrating knowledge is
- 16:10a highly individualized solo act. You stand at
- 16:14the front of the room alone. But in many other
- 16:16cultures, storytelling and knowledge construction
- 16:18are collaborative, dynamic group efforts. Exactly.
- 16:22And equity pedagogy structures the classroom
- 16:24so that multiple cultural styles of learning
- 16:26can flourish simultaneously. It allows different
- 16:29cultural styles of storytelling. It also demands
- 16:31a critical examination of the knowledge construction
- 16:34process itself. Students are taught to analyze
- 16:36how their own textbooks or media sources might
- 16:39frame historical events, or how media stereotypes,
- 16:43Hispanics, for example. The psychological goal
- 16:45here is prejudice reduction, actively rewiring
- 16:48the biases that students absorb from their surrounding
- 16:50culture. And connecting this anti bias education
- 16:53back to morality is crucial. Empowering the actual
- 16:56school structure so that a debate club or sports
- 16:59team isn't subtly dominated by one cultural group
- 17:02is a deeply ethical approach to shaping a student's
- 17:05worldview. It models a just society, giving students
- 17:08a lived experience of fairness. But implementing
- 17:12that level of equity in deep learning requires
- 17:14bridging the gap between the theoretical curriculum
- 17:17and the pre -existing architecture inside a student's
- 17:20mind. Right, a teacher has to connect abstract
- 17:22concepts to the real world. This can involve
- 17:25leveraging resources like a learning commons
- 17:27where students collaborate digitally using the
- 17:29internet or bringing in local experts like a
- 17:32city forester to discuss ecology or even field
- 17:35trips to the water treatment plant. Service learning
- 17:38is another incredibly effective bridge. But there
- 17:40is a crucial psychological distinction to make
- 17:42here. Picking up trash in a stream bed isn't
- 17:44just chores. Right. It's only service learning
- 17:47if they analyze and reflect on the ecology afterward.
- 17:51That reflection changes the cognitive paradigm
- 17:53from complying with adult chores to being an
- 17:56agent of positive change. But as teachers attempt
- 17:59to build these bridges, they inevitably crash
- 18:02into a major psychological roadblock. Preconceptions.
- 18:06Yes. Children do not arrive at school as blank
- 18:09slates. They might genuinely believe that heavy
- 18:12objects fall faster than light ones, or that
- 18:15humans lived with dinosaurs. Unspooling those
- 18:18misconceptions requires a deep understanding
- 18:20of cognitive dissonance. You cannot simply tell
- 18:23a student they are wrong. The brain will often
- 18:25reject facts that contradict a deeply held schema.
- 18:29And this gets incredibly complicated when a misconception
- 18:32is tender to a student's core identity or religious
- 18:35beliefs. Oh, for sure. The source material brings
- 18:38up the example of handling deep religious preconceptions
- 18:41impartially. Right. Consider a biology teacher
- 18:44instructing a unit on Charles Darwin's theory
- 18:47of evolution. A student might reject the scientific
- 18:50consensus entirely because they believe God played
- 18:52a more active, interventionist role. How does
- 18:54an educator handle that impartially? If you attack
- 18:56the student's core religious belief, their amygdala
- 18:59fires, they perceive a threat, and the prefrontal
- 19:02cortex effectively shuts down. The psychology
- 19:04of respect dictates that the teacher must respectfully
- 19:07acknowledge that belief without endorsing or
- 19:10invalidating it. They hold space for the belief
- 19:13impartially. Navigating that tension is perhaps
- 19:16the most delicate ethical tightrope an educator
- 19:19walks. To help remember how to build these bridges,
- 19:21there's a great memory trick. The APP method.
- 19:26Yeah. Activate prior knowledge, anticipate preconceptions,
- 19:29and practice. Ah, practice. And practice is heavily
- 19:33informed by Lev Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development,
- 19:36or ZPD. The ZPD is the psychological space between
- 19:39what a learner can do completely independently
- 19:42and what they can do with guidance. Right. A
- 19:44teacher operates in that zone using guided practice,
- 19:47which is the scaffolding phase. But eventually,
- 19:48the teacher has to step back and initiate independent
- 19:51practice. And the most heavily debated form of
- 19:53independent practice is homework. The psychology
- 19:55of homework is fascinating. Researchers Corno
- 19:58and Ju conducted studies showing kids view homework
- 20:00not as a fun game, but as the job of childhood.
- 20:03Just as adults have necessary labor, Children
- 20:06recognize homework as their societal obligation.
- 20:10If the workload is perceived as fair, they actually
- 20:13derive a profound sense of autonomy from completing
- 20:16their job well. It is a massive shift in perspective.
- 20:19Looking back at the ground we've covered today,
- 20:21it is staggering. We traveled from giant statewide
- 20:25standards, written behavioral and cognitive objectives,
- 20:28climbed Bloom's taxonomy, and figured out how
- 20:31to respect a student's prior beliefs and culture.
- 20:34It requires an astonishing amount of psychological
- 20:36calibration, but all this planning leads us to
- 20:39a massive cliffhanger for next time, when we
- 20:41shift from planning to assessing in Chapter 11.
- 20:44Oh, the story of Kim. Yes. Kim is an urban sixth
- 20:47grade teacher who shifted her assessments to
- 20:49focus on effort and validating her students'
- 20:52cultural heritage rather than traditional test
- 20:54prep. And her students' test scores doubled.
- 20:57But tragically, the school was still closed for
- 20:59poor average performance. It's a brutal cliffhanger
- 21:02showing how high stakes assessment impacts real
- 21:04lives. Which leaves you, our listener, with a
- 21:07final provocative thought to mull over. If our
- 21:10educational system is increasingly built on strict
- 21:12behavioral objectives and measurable state standards,
- 21:15what happens to the unmeasurable, effective goals
- 21:18of education? Are we designing schools to produce
- 21:21efficient test takers, or are we trying to produce
- 21:23good, moral human beings? Keep that in mind.
- 21:25Thanks for joining the Deep Dive today.