Latest / Before you say yes / Ep. 9 Why consent is also about money, bills and shared financial decisions: Angelique Wan uncut
Transcript
- 0:00What affirmative consent looks at is the fact that consent is given freely, it's given voluntarily, so an absence of pressure, threats or coercion, it's enthusiastic and it's ongoing.
- 0:14So I really want to talk about money and how you can apply consent to money.
- 0:20My view is that financial literacy programs just haven't worked in Australia.
- 0:26We have a really high rate of financial illiteracy, about 40% of Australians.
- 0:35And I have wondered about whether the consent conversation can be applied to the way you think about money and bills in a relationship –
- 0:45So, you know, what's mine?
- 0:47What's yours?
- 0:48What's ours?
- 0:49How does this work?
- 0:50What could it look like if you're having that conversation around money?
- 0:53I think consent and the concept of boundaries absolutely applies when it comes to, you know, issues around finance or money.
- 1:01Again, in any relationship, whether that's an intimate relationship or also with a friendship, but I think you're
- 1:07You're very right in saying, Catherine, that we don't really have conversations about this.
- 1:12And I think this is probably the piece that financial literacy programs have missed out on.
- 1:19I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 1:20I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 1:29This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 1:40So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:45I'm Anjali Kwan.
- 1:47I'm co-founder and CEO of Consent Labs.
- 1:49And what does Consent Labs do?
- 1:52So we're a not-for-profit working to end sexual violence in Australia, specifically how sexual violence is experienced by young people.
- 2:00We do that through the delivery of preventative education, focusing in on consent and respect for relationships education programs.
- 2:07We're really trying to actively change the current normalised culture around sexual violence and, you know,
- 2:14to be one where it's not experienced by people and particularly young people.
- 2:19So we deliver our education programs to communities of young people, their parents and carers and educators in settings like schools, universities and community organisations.
- 2:30I'm so glad that you've come on to talk to us about this today.
- 2:34As a mum of young adults now who learnt about consent at school, they were like some of the first kids who started having that in their curriculum and I was learning with them because we didn't learn about consent when we went to school.
- 2:48Me neither.
- 2:49Yeah, it's crazy.
- 2:50So how did you come to this work?
- 2:52I think like many people, it was a bit of a happy mistake.
- 2:55It's not at all where I thought my career path would be going.
- 2:59I actually set out on a career in banking.
- 3:02I studied business.
- 3:03I started my career in the banking industry.
- 3:05Yeah.
- 3:06But while I was at university studying, I lived on campus.
- 3:10And while that was an incredibly fun experience, I love the independence.
- 3:14I'm sure you can imagine, Catherine.
- 3:16It was also an incredibly eye-opening experience.
- 3:19And it was the first time where I really started to reckon with how normalised instances of sexual violence were.
- 3:26Yeah.
- 3:27At the time, I didn't have the language to call it as such.
- 3:30It was really feelings of, this doesn't feel quite right.
- 3:34And that sort of sentiment or that feeling was echoed by so many of my peers throughout the first year of living on campus.
- 3:44followed by the sentiment of, I don't know who to tell.
- 3:47I don't know how to seek support.
- 3:49And I probably don't want to because I don't want to make a big deal out of this.
- 3:52A real minimisation of their feelings.
- 3:55And so I really sought to, I suppose, educate myself because like we were just saying, we didn't receive consent education in school.
- 4:03And that was sort of the eye-opening moment for me that...
- 4:07there's language to put to these feelings being, you know, experiences of sexual harassment and sexual assault, and that actually these things can be prevented.
- 4:15At that time in Australia, this was around 2016, there was starting to be a bit of a swell of activity, particularly around violence against women, the prevalence in Australia.
- 4:27And,
- 4:29and how certain institutions were really enabling these cultures and with a particular focus on university campuses.
- 4:37And so I suppose with that sort of swirl of activity starting to happen, I wanted to be a part of that quite actively.
- 4:45To change the status quo for young people and particularly young women, I didn't really see anything happening in the Australian landscape that looked like consent education and particularly not education that was led by young people and built for young people.
- 5:01What I had experienced in high school, and I wonder what your experience was, Catherine,
- 5:06was an education curriculum that felt really out of touch or really out of date with the experiences that I was sort of navigating as a young person.
- 5:14And a lot of awkwardness and taboo and I suppose a feeling of shame really talking to issues around sex and consent and dating.
- 5:22And
- 5:23I really wanted education that was strengths-based, that was obviously age-appropriate, but that gave young people the ability to make informed choices.
- 5:33It gave them knowledge.
- 5:34And when I didn't see that in Australia, I sought out to create that with my co-founder, Joyce.
- 5:40And it's been a whirlwind.
- 5:42There's been so much amazing activism in the Australian landscape around Australia.
- 5:48the policy that supports the prevention of violence against women and broadly violence against women initiatives.
- 5:54And so I jumped into this full time in 2021 and it's been an amazing wild ride since.
- 6:00Yeah, it's fantastic.
- 6:02And what I love about
- 6:03What you have done is take your own lived experience and your expertise and what's happened to friends around you and turn that into something that is really meaningful and having such a massive impact.
- 6:18We were talking the other day, how many young people have you been able to educate people?
- 6:23We've educated 185,000 people across Australia in about five years.
- 6:28Amazing.
- 6:29Good on you.
- 6:29We're just getting started.
- 6:30Yeah, congratulations.
- 6:32That's really fantastic.
- 6:33Thank you.
- 6:33And also you talked about the people who care about young people too.
- 6:36So how are you reaching them?
- 6:38So we reach them through similar institutions where we reach young people.
- 6:42So the school community, I think, has such a powerful channel to make real impact in the world.
- 6:49And for us, it's really important that
- 6:51you know, the burden of this social change doesn't only fall on the shoulders of young people.
- 6:58It's also a recognition that young people are inherently, their views are shaped by the adult stakeholders that they look up to, most importantly, their parents and carers, but also, you know, the trusted adults that they see in the school environment and beyond that.
- 7:12And so...
- 7:13it's really incumbent on all of us as those role models to young people to be considering how we're role modelling respect for relationships, how we're talking about consent, how can we ask young people to do it any differently if we're not doing it differently ourselves.
- 7:29Yeah and if you haven't learned it, it's really hard to have those conversations and to model it.
- 7:34So can you tell me a little bit about when you're teaching consent?
- 7:38What are the concepts of consent?
- 7:42And how do you talk about that with young people?
- 7:45So we use a model called affirmative consent.
- 7:48Incredibly so, that's now reflected in a lot of our legislation in Australia as of the past couple of years, which is fantastic.
- 7:55And what affirmative consent looks at is the fact that consent is given freely, freely.
- 8:01It's given voluntarily, so an absence of pressure or threats or coercion.
- 8:06It's enthusiastic and it's ongoing.
- 8:09These are sort of some of the core tenets that we talk about when it comes to giving consent.
- 8:16It's essentially acknowledging that you're not a mind reader.
- 8:19No one is a mind reader.
- 8:20And that in order to understand what someone else is wanting or what someone else is open to, you have to ask a question and you have to check in.
- 8:28And I think when I was talking to my son actually about consent and they're aware of the work that I do around financial abuse, they'd come home, we were just having this chat and they were saying, you know, mum...
- 8:41When we're taught about consent, we're not being told that we're bad because you can't be a mind reader, but we're being told this is what it is.
- 8:48This is what it looks like.
- 8:49Here's how you ask for it.
- 8:51Here's how you give it.
- 8:52Here's how you check in.
- 8:53Is that the kind of language that you use?
- 8:55Consent goes hand in hand with boundaries.
- 8:58Boundaries are how we communicate what we are and what we're not comfortable with.
- 9:03Boundaries are a personal thing and they can relate to a range of different things.
- 9:08For example, you can have boundaries around money, which I know we're going to get to.
- 9:13You can have boundaries around your intimate relationships.
- 9:16You can have boundaries with your friends in terms of how you spend your time, your emotional investment.
- 9:22And the thing with boundaries is that they can change depending on
- 9:28your age, depending on the point in time you're doing an activity, depending on the context.
- 9:34So are you doing something in private?
- 9:36Are you doing something in public?
- 9:38And who are you doing it with?
- 9:39You know, there's a lot of different factors that can influence your boundaries.
- 9:42And it's really about, firstly, understanding for yourself personally, how you feel about doing something.
- 9:49Are you comfortable or are you not comfortable with doing something?
- 9:52And then communicating that to the person that you might be doing it with.
- 9:56So we always encourage the use of an I statement instead of a you statement.
- 10:02Boundaries are about expressing how you yourself feel about something.
- 10:07You're not trying to impose something on someone else or tell them how they should be feeling.
- 10:11And so starting a sentence with I don't feel comfortable about doing something because of X, Y, Z.
- 10:21Or you don't even have to provide a reason.
- 10:23A no is a no.
- 10:26is maybe a bit of a newer concept for people to understand.
- 10:29You don't always have to provide a justification for why you said no.
- 10:33But I think probably the biggest thing that I would recommend is asking open-ended questions.
- 10:39If you're trying to understand how someone else is feeling about doing something or about a subject, asking questions like, how do you feel about...
- 10:51going for a walk on the beach.
- 10:53How do you feel about opening a joint bank account?
- 10:57Can I ask, have you ever tried something like this before?
- 11:00Those types of open-ended questions are how we encourage a conversation that's not laden with, you know, judgment or shame.
- 11:09And if you have those two things, then it's hard to have a productive conversation.
- 11:13Yeah.
- 11:14How do you feel about going for a run?
- 11:17I don't like it.
- 11:18exactly full stop I feel the same way so that makes a lot of sense it's really practical why is it that it's so hard to have a conversation about sex and it feels taboo
- 11:29I think there's a lot of layers to it, but I wouldn't even say it's just isolated to sexual encounters or intimate relationships.
- 11:35I think, you know, innately as humans, we want to feel a sense of belonging.
- 11:39And so sometimes saying no feels like you're letting someone down.
- 11:43Then you layer on, for example, gendered expectations.
- 11:47A lot of girls and women are raised to be people pleasers, essentially.
- 11:51And so that's an added layer of making it feel hard to say no.
- 11:57And also the sense of rejection is hard to feel.
- 12:00Like sitting with that sense of perhaps shame or embarrassment is never nice.
- 12:05And it's been not really spoken about, I suppose, how to sit with that sense of rejection and be okay with it and move on.
- 12:13And that is something that we talk about in our curriculum.
- 12:15So that's why I think it feels hard to sometimes put yourself out there because you might fear that sense of rejection or failure.
- 12:23Or why it can feel hard to say no.
- 12:27in a sexual encounter or even in a platonic relationship.
- 12:30You know, we do a lot of our work in those high school settings, speaking from year seven upwards, and a lot of our education around those age groups is centred around friendships.
- 12:41And it's such a formative time for those young people.
- 12:44There's sometimes a lot of nerves coming into year seven and you're trying to figure out who your friendship groups are and, you know, elements of peer pressure are starting to be felt at that age.
- 12:53And so...
- 12:54You know, even having a conversation with a friend like, hey, can I borrow your water bottle?
- 13:00If you don't feel comfortable with someone, you know, maybe for a hygienic reason doing that, sometimes it can feel really scary to say no.
- 13:06So I think it's just normalising that experience for young people and for all of us really.
- 13:12These conversations can feel a little bit awkward now, but it's worth having it so it doesn't continue to feel awkward ongoing.
- 13:19Yeah, and it's a really good point because especially now, I guess even when you started doing the work, we probably didn't have the amount of time or the algorithm complexity that we have on social media.
- 13:33it's now pretty normal for parents of children to have tracking, GPS tracking of their children, and then that becomes pretty normal in a friendship group.
- 13:44But actually that can tip over into where it becomes unhealthy into stalking and surveillance behaviours.
- 13:53So how do you navigate those conversations?
- 13:56Because it might feel, well, you know, mum's been tracking me so that I know I'm going to school.
- 14:03Yeah, I think that's a great point, Catherine.
- 14:06And, you know, perhaps it can be a question that we start with asking parents and carers.
- 14:12When you, for example, ask your child to share their location with you, are you actually role modelling a conversation or is that an expectation that they don't have a say in?
- 14:24And sort of what are the parameters are you imposing on them when you do location share with them or ask them to share their location?
- 14:31So I think that's a real opportunity for parents to role model what a really productive conversation around location sharing might look like.
- 14:39Because, yeah, I think implicitly young people are picking up that location sharing is the norm in any relationship.
- 14:47And it's weird if you put a boundary to say, I actually don't feel comfortable sharing my location at all times with you.
- 14:55And it's interesting, like we have this specific conversation with young people in our module, which sort of focuses on consent as it relates to, you know, the online world.
- 15:04And what we're hearing from them is exactly that.
- 15:07Most of them, without a second thought, will share their location with people.
- 15:12their friends, with their partners.
- 15:14And it's seemed to be quite a normal activity that you know where your friends are at all times.
- 15:20And so I think, you know, for us, it's an opportunity to really prompt them or to encourage them to think about, are you comfortable with this?
- 15:27And if you're not, then how do you have that conversation with someone?
- 15:29Yeah, especially when everyone else is doing it.
- 15:33Yeah, that's really tricky.
- 15:35So I really want to talk about money and how you can apply consent to money because my view is that financial literacy programs just haven't worked in Australia.
- 15:45We have a really high rate of financial illiteracy.
- 15:50About 40% of Australians are not literate.
- 15:53What that means is that they don't understand concepts like compound interest, for example.
- 15:59And I have wondered about whether the consent conversation can be applied to the way you think about money and bills in a relationship and location sharing and all of those other things.
- 16:13So, you know, what's mine?
- 16:15What's yours?
- 16:16What's ours?
- 16:16How does this work?
- 16:18We've had a lot of conversations about this and I'm really interested in your expertise and your thoughts about how could you step into that discussion?
- 16:27So it's not just consent about intimate partner or even the use of technology.
- 16:33What could it look like if you're having that conversation around money?
- 16:36Yeah.
- 16:37I mean, I think consent and the concept of boundaries absolutely applies when it comes to, you know, issues around finance or money.
- 16:45Again, in any relationship, whether that's an intimate relationship or also with a friendship, we talk about this with young people, you know, in terms of
- 16:55How much is normal to spend for birthday presents?
- 16:58As an example, that can often go unacknowledged and can create a little bit of awkwardness when it's not discussed up front.
- 17:05So encouraging young people to have these conversations with their friends.
- 17:09Another one is how do you both feel about...
- 17:13you know, say for example, you go out for lunch or for dinner, do you split the bill 50-50?
- 17:18Do you get it this time?
- 17:18Your friend gets it the next time?
- 17:20How can we have these conversations up front to make sure that you're both on the same page?
- 17:24So it's using all of those sort of frameworks and tools that we just spoke about when it comes to setting boundaries, saying,
- 17:31hey, how do you feel if, you know, I get the bill for this lunch and then you get the bill for next time?
- 17:38How does that sit with you?
- 17:39And inviting that conversation, you're asking that open-ended question.
- 17:42And if the other person says, no, I'd actually, you know, prefer to split 50-50, it's just easier for me to keep track that way, saying, sure, that sounds good.
- 17:51But at least you've had that conversation up front.
- 17:53So absolutely consent and the concept of talking about
- 17:58your sense of boundaries and the other person's boundaries when it comes to money is absolutely important.
- 18:02But I think you're very right in saying, Catherine, that we don't really have conversations about this.
- 18:08And I think this is probably the piece that financial literacy programs have missed out on is communication around it.
- 18:15And also even just talking to young people saying, why did I learn trigonometry at school?
- 18:22When am I going to use that?
- 18:24Yeah, when I'd really like to know how do I save money to buy a house or to buy a car and how does this credit card actually work and all of those things?
- 18:32Because it's not a firm part of the curriculum.
- 18:35And probably, you know, there's a lot of adults who don't know how to do those and don't have those skills.
- 18:41No fault of anyone.
- 18:43But no one tells you.
- 18:45When you learn how to drive a car, it's this is where the indicator is.
- 18:49This is how you turn on the lights.
- 18:52If you have a manual, this is where the clutch is and how you change the gears.
- 18:55All of those things.
- 18:56Exactly.
- 18:56This is how you look at where you are between the lane.
- 18:59We're not taught about this is what this particular bank account does.
- 19:03Here is how a credit card works.
- 19:06When you sign up, you know, you move into a house and you've got your rental agreement or your energy or your water bill.
- 19:13This is what that means.
- 19:15It's just like we fall into and we're expected to learn about it.
- 19:18Yeah, I obviously feel very passionately about the role of education and giving people language, knowledge of their rights, etc.
- 19:27And I obviously also feel passionate about the role of our schooling education curriculum in setting us up for skills that are really practically important.
- 19:36And I think you're so correct that there has been a deficit or a gap in the curriculum around financial literacy to date.
- 19:43And as a result, people are just having to find their own way.
- 19:47Yeah.
- 19:47What are the other sort of money conversations young people are stepping into that they're trying to navigate?
- 19:54I mean, for example, getting their first job and all of the questions that come with that, you know, setting up your bank account, your tax file declaration, like that's confusing talking about superannuation perhaps.
- 20:08And then how do you actually think about saving and spending that money and sort of figuring out perhaps how to budget or where your comfortability around spending versus saving thresholds sort of sit?
- 20:19Yeah.
- 20:20So those are some of the conversations that we could be having, but also when it comes to, you know, young people getting into intimate relationships, really encouraging them to continue with that theme of communication and asking open questions to understand.
- 20:35What's their comfortability when it comes to, for example, joint savings accounts with their partner or who's contributing what percentage to certain bills or certain expenses that they might share?
- 20:48I think these are the types of conversations that we can be having with young people.
- 20:52Yeah.
- 20:52And how would they open that up?
- 20:55You mean in a, like a relationship?
- 20:57Yeah, like, okay, we've decided maybe we're going to move in together.
- 21:01Yeah, yeah.
- 21:02I mean, I think it can be done a couple of different ways.
- 21:05It...
- 21:06is sometimes helpful if there is a prompt, such as an event where, you know, you are moving in together.
- 21:11I think that's a nicer segue into starting a conversation.
- 21:17So, hey, this is a really exciting, you know, milestone for us in our relationship.
- 21:22Before we do this, like, I'd love to have a conversation about...
- 21:25XYZ, how we want to share the cost of our utilities, for an example, how we want to cover the cost of our rent, whose bank account is it going to come out of?
- 21:34Is it a joint account?
- 21:35I think, yeah, hinging that conversation off of an event or a milestone can feel like an easier way in.
- 21:42if you don't have an event like that, either using, you know, something that you might have seen on TV or on social media as an opportunity to start a conversation like, hey, in this TV show, these characters were just navigating this conversation and made me realise we've never actually had the chat about this.
- 22:01Or I was listening to this podcast and they were talking about, you know, money conversations and...
- 22:07I was wondering how we both felt about that.
- 22:09So I think sometimes, you know, using, yeah, something that you sort of seen around you as a spark for that conversation can feel like a bit of a more natural way to bring up a conversation if you are feeling a little bit uncomfortable because you've never talked about it before.
- 22:23Yeah, and it is one of those things you may never have talked about.
- 22:26You might have also grown up in a family where you're not talking about money.
- 22:30It does feel nerdy also to talk about money as well as feeling like I don't know how to step into it.
- 22:36It feels a bit awkward.
- 22:37Yeah, and I think the thing is it's okay for it to feel awkward.
- 22:41Like it doesn't have to be a super polished, sexy conversation.
- 22:45And I want to normalise that.
- 22:46You know, so many of the encounters that we have
- 22:50particularly when their encounters for the first time, are not going to look like they do in the movies.
- 22:55You know what I mean?
- 22:56We have this conversation a lot with young people, particularly when we're talking about relationships and dating and, you know, sex.
- 23:03Particularly if you are doing something for the first time, like, you've got to be able to figure it out together and, you know, maybe even have a laugh about it.
- 23:10Like, that's...
- 23:12When you have, hopefully you have a sense of, you know, trust in each other if you're in a healthy relationship where you can sort of fumble your way through it together.
- 23:23But as long as you're trying to have the conversation and you're both genuinely engaging in it, like that's the important first step and you can sort of build on it from there.
- 23:32It does bring me to a point that you said when we started the conversation about free and informed and enthusiastic and no pressure.
- 23:40What are those red flags look like?
- 23:42Yeah, we get asked the question a lot, what does a healthy relationship look like?
- 23:50Which kind of alarms me a little bit that that's not
- 23:53I guess young people don't have a good sense as to what they should be striving for.
- 23:58And, you know, we'll sort of have conversations around the fact that it's really healthy to have a level of independence, as an example.
- 24:06You know, perhaps to have your own friendship circle, to have your own stream of income.
- 24:12You can obviously have a lot of joint hobbies or interests and spend time together with your partner, but that it is unhealthy if...
- 24:20you know, they're incredibly possessive or they don't want you to have connections outside of your relationship.
- 24:27So that level of independence is, you know, one tenet of a healthy relationship for many people.
- 24:33Again, that sense of being able to have a conversation and open communication without feeling judged or immediately shut down is really important, particularly when, you know, it might feel a little bit awkward or hard to raise.
- 24:47That's sort of the second thing.
- 24:49And thirdly, it's that, you know, broadly a sense of happiness in the relationship.
- 24:53You can't be happy every single minute of every single day or every single relationship.
- 24:58But generally, there's that sense of I feel really content and respected.
- 25:03I think that it's really good to say this is what is a healthy relationship.
- 25:07And it's interesting that young people are asking, what does that look like?
- 25:12So the inverse of that is how might you be feeling or what are the things where you're going, actually, I'm a bit worried about this relationship?
- 25:23Yeah, I think when the other person isn't open to having a conversation or there's an immediate sense of a dismissal of your feelings or an invalidation of your feelings or an element of you feel like they might not be completely truthful.
- 25:39If there's also a sense of...
- 25:42them not respecting your independence.
- 25:43Particularly when it comes to money, you know, you have a right to understand how your money is being used.
- 25:49If you've got a joint bank account, for an example, you have a right to understand how, you know, those joint funds are being used and allocated and you should both have access to those accounts.
- 25:58And so if there's, you know, any questioning of or lack of information sharing about that, I would sort of consider that a red flag.
- 26:05If there's any sense of, you know, coercion,
- 26:08pressure or threats about how you should be spending your time or your money.
- 26:13That's another red flag.
- 26:15Could you tell me what that would look like and how you see that, say, in the programs you do now?
- 26:21What sort of examples would you give?
- 26:24It doesn't have to be about money, but just more broadly.
- 26:26Yeah.
- 26:27I mean, we talk a little bit with young people around gaslighting.
- 26:31So when someone's sense of reality is manipulated purposefully by someone's partner, say, for example, they really get them to question their sense of reality.
- 26:41truth and their memory as to whether something has happened.
- 26:45That would be an example.
- 26:47If someone's, you know, pressuring you to do a sexual act, one really common one that we see is I've just bought you a drink.
- 26:55Now you sort of owe me something, that sense of owing someone something.
- 26:59And I mean, I suppose you could say that in the context of money, I've brought in more income this month.
- 27:05And so you're not allowed to spend X, Y, Z, or you can't go out with your friends this month.
- 27:12So that sense of owing someone or that sense of like pressure because there's that power imbalance and someone's holding that over you is never a healthy sign.
- 27:23Yeah.
- 27:23And then what would you do about that if you were not feeling safe or feeling like actually there's something going wrong here?
- 27:32Yeah, it depends how safe you feel in that relationship.
- 27:36If you do feel safe enough to question it or to have a conversation with your partner, then that's the place that I would start.
- 27:43But that might not be the situation that you're in.
- 27:46I'd really encourage you to reach out to your support network if you do have them, you know, a trusted friend or family member to let them know how you're feeling.
- 27:56And just so you know that there's someone that you can lean on.
- 28:00If you don't have that, or even in addition to, you know, there would be a variety of support services that you could speak to in order to get help or to sense check with someone.
- 28:11What about if you care about somebody and you're taking a look and I mean, you can never know what's going on inside a relationship, but sometimes you get the spidey senses or you hear something that somebody has told you.
- 28:24Yeah.
- 28:25And you just think, well, maybe something's going on here I'd like to understand or do they know what's going on?
- 28:31How do you talk about that in your programs?
- 28:34Yeah, yeah.
- 28:35People just want to look out for the people they care about, right?
- 28:38They do.
- 28:39And I think that's a really beautiful quality and a really beautiful trait.
- 28:42The thing I would say is do it in private.
- 28:46Don't do it publicly.
- 28:47Obviously, don't do it in front of the partner that might be in question.
- 28:51And go really gently.
- 28:52Again, it's coming in with a sense of empathy and curiosity.
- 28:57And you never want to make someone feel...
- 29:01shamed or you never want to make that person feel isolated.
- 29:06You know I think the reality in instances of domestic violence which is a little bit different but can sometimes be related to economic abuse or financial abuse is that it can take someone you know up to seven tries to leave a partner and what you really don't want to see in that situation is that individual isolated from
- 29:26So I think it can be really helpful to have that conversation, but you ultimately want to make, you want that person to feel like they have agency to make their own decisions and that if they don't immediately agree with you or they don't immediately leave their partner, they know that your relationship is still intact and that you're still, you know, a trusted person that they can come to and speak to if they have any issues down the track.
- 29:54Yeah.
- 29:54Yeah, I think that's great advice because there are, and there's many people I have spoken to, many victim survivors, who've just said they knew that the person who invited them into the conversation was going to be there for them, even when they weren't ready to disclose or they might not have even seen what was going on.
- 30:15Exactly.
- 30:16And particularly when it comes to financial abuse, we know that so many people don't recognise they're in it.
- 30:22until many, many years later.
- 30:25And it's a bit of an awakening and can be an incredibly rude shock as well.
- 30:30And sometimes it can take your time to get your head around, right?
- 30:33Which is why I think it's really important to make sure that you both leave that conversation feeling like it's still a trusted space.
- 30:41We got very heavy just then.
- 30:43I think your work is incredible.
- 30:44I think you are bringing an incredible sense of optimism and practicality to equipping young people and the people that care about them with the tools to be able to do something that does change the way we think and approach healthy relationships.
- 30:59What gives you hope and why do you do it and maintain this optimism?
- 31:04I love stepping into a classroom and watching the way that young people engage with our team of educators.
- 31:13it just this sense of curiosity that young people have really fills me with hope.
- 31:18I think, you know, adults can often be really dismissive of young people as, you know, maybe they're not curious or put them all in one basket, but they're such a diverse group of people.
- 31:31And when we are able to cultivate a space where they feel like they can ask questions and they can be met with
- 31:40curiosity, a lack of shame and a lack of judgment, like that's really beautiful.
- 31:44But that's not often the spaces that they find themselves in.
- 31:49So I feel a lot of hope when I see young people engaging with our educators and asking questions that
- 31:58you know, it might feel really tricky or really vulnerable for them to ask.
- 32:02It's a challenging time that I think they find themselves navigating, you know, moving ideas around what, you know, gender looks like or what masculinity looks like can feel really tricky to navigate.
- 32:14But yeah, creating those spaces where they can ask questions that, you know, maybe make them feel really vulnerable to...
- 32:21is exactly what we're here to do.
- 32:23And that fills me with a lot of optimism.
- 32:25Yeah.
- 32:26Can we just dive into the masculinity topic?
- 32:29Because you did talk about how it can be a sense of shame if someone doesn't want to go where you want to go.
- 32:36And
- 32:38There is a big cultural obligation or sense of obligation, particularly for men to be the provider around money and to be the main breadwinner.
- 32:48And then if people can't necessarily fulfil that societal expectation or if they are feeling like, well, I can't look after you or my family or you as my partner, what's the navigating of that conversation around that sense of shame or loss?
- 33:07it's not real necessarily.
- 33:09I get it.
- 33:10I get that it's real for you personally.
- 33:12But the only person who puts that obligation on you is you too.
- 33:17So you have the power to change that.
- 33:19But I also think it's society that puts pressure on men and that's internalised.
- 33:23So we run this workshop in
- 33:25high schools and also in universities around the concept of masculinity.
- 33:29And we open it up with questions around what does society tells you makes a good man?
- 33:35And it has surprised me a little bit how tightly held some of those really stereotypical understandings of masculinity still are.
- 33:47So for example, that they have to be the breadwinner.
- 33:49young boys are still feeling like society is telling them that that's what they have to be.
- 33:53I don't know, in my little optimistic bubble that I live in, I would have thought that maybe the dial had started to shift on that, but they are still hearing loud and clear that they have to be the breadwinner.
- 34:03They have to be physically strong.
- 34:05They have to be emotionally strong.
- 34:07no vulnerability or emotions are allowed.
- 34:09Like those are the messages that society is telling them is what makes a good man.
- 34:14And so throughout, you know, the next hour or so of the workshop with them, it's sort of unpacking, well, what does being a man look like to you?
- 34:22And that's when we start to hear, you know, diverse expressions of masculinity.
- 34:27It's,
- 34:28being empathetic.
- 34:29It's looking after your friends.
- 34:31It's maybe not going to the gym.
- 34:33It's being allowed to ask my mate, how are you feeling?
- 34:37Are you okay?
- 34:38And so I suppose what we're really trying to do is broaden someone's
- 34:44sense of it's okay to be individual when it comes to your expression of masculinity.
- 34:51You can be physically strong, but you can also be caring.
- 34:55It doesn't have to be one or the other.
- 34:58So I think that work is hard because we grew up in a world where young boys are inundated from
- 35:07you know, as young as being a toddler about what it means to be a man.
- 35:10And so unwinding that and asking them to question that is hard and uncomfortable.
- 35:17But that's why it makes, you know, doing the work even more important because otherwise, yeah, then they do end up being men who feel the pressure of being a breadwinner and no one should have to feel the burden of that.
- 35:30Yeah, and so helping to unpick and then be clear on who I want to be so you can navigate the world.
- 35:37Yeah.
- 35:38Being confident.
- 35:39Regardless of societal expectations.
- 35:41Yeah, and then this is who I am.
- 35:42And there is a liberating thing that comes when you turn 50 and you go, yep, I've worked it out now and I don't give a fuck anymore.
- 35:50Excuse my friend.
- 35:51But you stop giving shits about it.
- 35:54And I don't mean that you then become ruthless and awful to people, but you just...
- 35:59Don't feel as confined or bound to what others, yeah.
- 36:02Yeah, you feel confident.
- 36:04I've actually made my way for a while and I know who I am.
- 36:08This is me.
- 36:09People can take it or leave it.
- 36:10I don't want to upset anybody but, you know, also if you don't like me, that's fine too.
- 36:14You want to be authentically yourself.
- 36:15Yeah, that's right.
- 36:17And the question is how can we all do that at a younger age?
- 36:20Yeah.
- 36:21And I think you're right and we are all on that journey of who am I, how can I authentically express myself?
- 36:29But I do also think it's a particularly confusing time for, you know, young boys who are, yeah, going through, you know, those teenage years are hard enough.
- 36:37And then media is telling them that they're the problem and they're bad people, but they're just trying to figure out who am I?
- 36:45Yeah.
- 36:46I had the privilege of sitting on a governance committee for one of Australia's universities for the last three years, looking at student safety and wellbeing.
- 36:55And on our committee, we had students, which was just fantastic.
- 36:59And I realise how much I love learning from young people, curiosity, being unafraid to ask questions and to see the world in a way that is new and fresh and really exciting.
- 37:11Yeah.
- 37:12So I'd encourage anyone to just get yourself around young people and talk to them about all of these issues.
- 37:19And because, as I said at the start, we didn't learn how to navigate some of these conversations.
- 37:25And if we can do it together as well and do it with that sense of curiosity, I think that's going to be really helpful.
- 37:32Thank you so much for making time for this conversation today.
- 37:36We are asking every single guest at the end of the podcast to complete the sentence, before you say yes, how would you complete that sentence?
- 37:48Before you say yes, ask yourself, what are my boundaries?
- 37:54And then communicate them.
- 37:55Thank you so much, Angie.
- 37:57I really appreciate your time.
- 37:58Thank you, Catherine.
- 37:59This has been such a joy.