Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #60: Would More US House Representatives Fix Congress' Problems?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan analysis of political
- 0:05science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:09Today, we're going to talk about expanding the size of the US house of representatives.
- 0:15Could that fix Congress?
- 0:16One of the most common criticisms of the government, especially Congress, is a lack of
- 0:21responsiveness and representativeness.
- 0:24I think we all have felt that way at one time or another.
- 0:29Now there are many reasons people cite for that issue with responsiveness and
- 0:33representativeness.
- 0:35Sometimes it's the party in power if it's a party that's not the one that that voter
- 0:41supports.
- 0:42The percept perception of politicians in general.
- 0:45Excuse me.
- 0:46Do that again.
- 0:47The perception of politicians in general.
- 0:49Congressional staff being insufficient at responding to constituents.
- 0:54Lack of ability to contact members of congress and their staff and so on.
- 0:59And these things contribute to the abysmally low approval rating for congress.
- 1:05But there is one proposal that you might not be familiar with, though it has been gaining some
- 1:09traction in recent years, and that's expanding the size of the US House of Representatives.
- 1:16We have sat at 435 members, not counting the nonvoting members for Washington DC and The US
- 1:22territories for over a century now, and that 435 total was set in law by congress in 1929.
- 1:30Could revisiting that law and expanding US house membership be the solution that makes
- 1:35congress more responsive and representative of the people they are supposed to represent?
- 1:41Today, we explore that question, and included in that is a brief history of the size of the
- 1:46US house, why some activists believe a larger house will fix a lot of congress' woes, the
- 1:52arguments made in favor and opposition to expanding the US house membership, whether any
- 1:59political party benefits from an expanded US house, and the discussion about the ultimate
- 2:03goals for improving the US house regardless of whether we support more members there.
- 2:11Let's go.
- 2:12So the purpose of the US house.
- 2:15Obviously, we gotta go all the way back to the US constitution, what actually set in stone how
- 2:21the US house works.
- 2:23So the design of the legislative branch congress of the US government was one of the
- 2:28biggest sources of debate during the constitutional convention.
- 2:33You had smaller states that wanted equal representation across states so that they
- 2:37weren't dwarfed by larger states.
- 2:39That was what was called the New Jersey plan.
- 2:41And you had larger states that wanted proportionally based representation so that
- 2:46they were rewarded for being bigger.
- 2:48That was the Virginia plan.
- 2:50And eventually, long story short, the delegates decided on the Connecticut Compromise, also
- 2:56called the Great Compromise, which put together a lot of those ideas from both the New Jersey
- 3:03plan and Virginia plan, and it became a bicameral legislature, Congress.
- 3:10So there is a US Senate, which has equal representation for states.
- 3:14Each state gets two senators.
- 3:16And then the US house, which is based on the population of the states.
- 3:20And Alexander Hamilton and James Madison wrote extensively on the US House of Representatives
- 3:26in Federalist Papers '52 through '58.
- 3:29And in '55 in particular, James Madison defended the then current number of 65
- 3:35representatives, a far cry from what we have now, 435, by saying it would expand as the
- 3:41population increased, which would prevent individual legislators from gaining too much
- 3:47influence.
- 3:48And a number of representatives would ensure that they are in consistent contact with
- 3:52constituents because of the proportionality, they would be tied much more to their
- 3:58constituents.
- 3:59But, also, the US house wouldn't become so numerous that passion would overpower reason as
- 4:07to slightly paraphrase what James Madison wrote there.
- 4:10So the whole idea for the US house was to increase as the US house increased, but they
- 4:16didn't quite go so far as to say, well, this is what it's gonna be throughout the rest of US
- 4:23history.
- 4:24They didn't necessarily think all that far ahead.
- 4:26They for as prescient as they were, they couldn't obviously foresee everything that
- 4:31could possibly become But generally speaking, the US house was supposed to become bigger as
- 4:37the US house grew.
- 4:38So how has the US house changed over the years?
- 4:42Early on, we talked about how it was 65 members to start off in the US house, but that expanded
- 4:49considerably pretty quickly, and it changed frequently over time before it became set at
- 4:55435 people.
- 4:56The first congress, which was 1789 to 1791, was at 65 members.
- 5:01But then by the third congress, which was only 1793, 105 members.
- 5:07And then the eighth congress, which was in eighteen o three, 142 members.
- 5:12And it fluctuated from about 1833 to 1861, the start of the civil war, fluctuated between 220,
- 5:20240 ish members, so it grew pretty quickly and pretty considerably so.
- 5:29And, of course, when the South rebelled and seceded from the union, US house membership
- 5:37went down quite a bit when Southern states became readmitted into the union after the
- 5:44civil war.
- 5:45It went from 243 to 292 members close to the end of the Reconstruction era that followed the
- 5:51civil war.
- 5:52So it's 292 members in the forty third congress, which started in 1873.
- 5:57And then it climbed considerably over the decades until it was 435 members in 1913.
- 6:05But it wasn't officially capped at 435 until the permanent reapportionment act in 1929.
- 6:13Apportionment had increasingly become a major sticking point between the smaller rural states
- 6:19and larger urbanized states.
- 6:20A lot of that going back to that debates during the constitutional convention.
- 6:25Smaller states didn't wanna be overpowered by larger states, but larger states thought too
- 6:30much of their pie was getting cut into by the smaller states.
- 6:34And so this schism actually led to the US house failing to reapportion itself following the
- 6:401920 census, the first and only time that that has happened.
- 6:44And then in 1941, congress adopted the current formula for reapportionment, but the actual
- 6:51number of 435 wasn't set until or it wasn't officially set in in until 1929, but it had
- 7:00been 04/1935 since 1913.
- 7:04Now as for population per district, that is obviously considerably grown too even as the US
- 7:10house was growing.
- 7:11So in 1790, there were only about four 34,000 citizens per US house district, at least by the
- 7:19best numbers that we have.
- 7:21By 1860, so seventy years later, that had climbed up to a 122,000 people per district.
- 7:28Then in 1910, it was 211,000.
- 7:31Following the Reapportionment Act of 1929, the average was 280,000 in 1930, and then it went
- 7:38up to 470,000 in 1970.
- 7:41And then by 2020, it was 762,000.
- 7:46And it's projected to be 874,000 people per district by 2040.
- 7:50So these districts are becoming gargantuan, and that's one of the reasons that activists are
- 7:58pushing for a larger US house.
- 8:03Speaking of which, let's talk about this actual debate, and then we'll go over the actual
- 8:11trickiness of making The US house larger.
- 8:14So I'm gonna talk about six different arguments for supporting the expanded US house and for
- 8:23opposing The US house expansion.
- 8:26I'm not taking official sides one way or another, at least in this episode.
- 8:33And these are arguments I've heard previously, and then there is our potential arguments I've
- 8:37thought of that could be made.
- 8:39So you gotta, even if you do support one side or the other, if you're really trying to
- 8:44debate, you have to think about, well, what is something that somebody else can say that I
- 8:49would have to counteract?
- 8:50And you have to assume that the other side, even if you really think they're wrong, you
- 8:55have to assume that they're going to come up with really good arguments, so you have to be
- 8:58ready for them.
- 9:00But that being said, here are six of the biggest arguments that have been made or might
- 9:06be made by people who want a bigger US House.
- 9:11So number one, more members means more constituents can be directly served by the US
- 9:19house and their staff.
- 9:20We just talked about the 2020 census numbers that were about 762,000 people per district on
- 9:28average.
- 9:29That's a lot of people to represent.
- 9:31But if you add something like 50 more members, 100 more members, 150, 200, however many more
- 9:38you add, that average per district is going to go down.
- 9:42And so instead of having to serve 760,000 people per district, maybe you only have to
- 9:49serve 700,000 or 650 or 600,000 or 550,000.
- 9:55So the idea is that you can actually serve all of your constituents or at least close to all
- 10:02of constituents.
- 10:03Maybe they're still gonna be too big for you to actually directly get involved with every
- 10:09constituent, but it's gonna be a lot more feasible.
- 10:13And, also, the the founding fathers did intend for the US house to continue to grow with the
- 10:18population.
- 10:20The reapportionment act the permanent reapportionment act of 1929 that has been set
- 10:28for over a hundred years.
- 10:30Before then, we didn't go even remotely close to that long without expanding the US house.
- 10:37And then too many citizens per representative severely limits public access and makes
- 10:42citizens feel the government is unresponsive because, oh, I'm just one voice in over 700,000
- 10:48people or 600,000 people.
- 10:50They're not gonna listen to me.
- 10:51Or and they already feel like they're not being listened to even if the government does hear
- 10:56them, even if they're at town halls or they're contacting the member of congress's staff in
- 11:02their home district.
- 11:03They may still feel like they're not being heard.
- 11:07And so the idea is that if you get fewer or yeah.
- 11:13Fewer people per US house member, you're gonna get more direct responses by US house reps,
- 11:19which makes people feel like the government is more responsive, and that means more civically
- 11:23engaged citizens because they feel like their voice matters.
- 11:28And according to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, research that they cite said that
- 11:35voters that's from smaller districts are more likely to approve of their representative and
- 11:40feel like their congressperson is doing a good job in keeping in touch.
- 11:44So that's the first one of the first big arguments that you hear.
- 11:49Another argument made for expanding the US house membership is that not just fewer people
- 11:57per district, but the actual geographical boundaries of the district are gonna get
- 12:03smaller.
- 12:03So it makes it easier to travel within districts for things like town halls or direct
- 12:09service in the community or people going to these district offices to contact their local
- 12:18federal or local congressperson.
- 12:22Some districts are geographically quite large, especially rural ones because the rural areas
- 12:28are more sparsely populated, and so the average is about 600, 7,000 700,000 people, but it's
- 12:37going to be spread out over a much larger area.
- 12:39Urban areas are a lot more condensed because the population is a lot more packed into
- 12:45smaller areas.
- 12:47And so less travel within a district would further facilitate closer and deeper
- 12:51relationships with constituents, with advocacy groups, and between their congresspeople.
- 12:59Another argument that you hear for expanding US house membership is that the costs of each US
- 13:06house race would be lower, which would also allow a wider demographic array of candidates
- 13:11to compete and be more representative of the nation overall.
- 13:14So you've seen US house races, US senate races, of course, but even US house races are just
- 13:22getting some of them are just getting absurdly expensive.
- 13:26Millions, tens of millions, even couple times a hunt couple $100,000,000 depending on what the
- 13:34district is or and where it is.
- 13:37And these large districts favor incumbents and other well financed candidates because
- 13:42incumbents tend to be more well financed, and the well financed candidates are more able to
- 13:47reach the larger districts.
- 13:50They're and they're gonna be become more well known by a lot of people by default.
- 13:54So it makes it much harder for contenders and gets especially contenders that don't have a
- 14:01lot of money or at least relatively don't have a lot of money to be able to compete so it can
- 14:08make things more of a done deal from the get go.
- 14:12And then campaigns have to spend less money on outreach to voters because they have less or
- 14:16fewer voters to appeal to.
- 14:20And back in February, there was an article from the Population Reference Bureau.
- 14:24Rob Ritchie of what was then the Center for Voting and Democracy, it's now called FairVote,
- 14:31he cited research that said that demographically, women and minorities in
- 14:35particular would benefit from smaller districts.
- 14:40Women do better in elections for smaller districts according to his research, and there
- 14:46would be more opportunities for racial minorities to compete in elections without
- 14:49having to contort the lines.
- 14:52So more racial minorities that are actually in office.
- 14:58So the idea is that you would have a more demographically representative congress.
- 15:02A lot of times, congress gets lambasted whether fairly or not as a bunch of old white people.
- 15:09Another argument that is made in favor of expanded US house membership is that because
- 15:19more members means fewer voters per district, third parties and nonpartisan candidates would
- 15:25have a better chance at competing in these elections.
- 15:28It's been exceptionally rare, especially over the last thirty years for the US house to see a
- 15:33third party or nonparty candidate win a congressional race.
- 15:37There have been a couple times where they've come close, especially the last couple rounds,
- 15:42but they ultimately don't make it.
- 15:46And, usually, voters believe that voting for a third party or a nonparty candidate again,
- 15:52whether right or wrong or whether it's right in a particular case, some voters believe that
- 15:59it's a wasted vote to go outside the Democratic Republican dichotomy.
- 16:06Even if they absolutely hate both parties and they think both parties suck, a lot of people
- 16:10still believe in this, quote unquote, lesser of two evils idea.
- 16:16But if there's smaller constituencies, people theoretically at least might feel differently
- 16:23about these other candidates and say, okay.
- 16:25You know what?
- 16:25Maybe these guys do have a chance.
- 16:27Another argument made for expanding US house membership is that it would make more races
- 16:34more competitive.
- 16:36Fewer votes per election means fewer votes that candidates would have to win and persuade from
- 16:41another candidate.
- 16:42The margins of error would be a lot smaller.
- 16:47You have a lot of these districts.
- 16:48Over 80% of congressional districts, in fact, are considered safe for either the Republican
- 16:55Party or the Democratic Party.
- 16:57And what regardless of your political views, that's not healthy for democracy.
- 17:04You need competition.
- 17:06But the idea of more members would make more of those districts more competitive because those
- 17:12safe districts would be split up a lot more and make for more competition.
- 17:17So instead of 80% of districts being safe, maybe it's more something like 50% depending on
- 17:24the number of US house reps you you move to.
- 17:28Because there's gonna be some districts that no matter how much you cut it down, they're gonna
- 17:31be safe for one party or another.
- 17:33But the proportion of those races that are that way are going to be a lot fewer if you add more
- 17:40US house reps.
- 17:42And then the final argument that we'll cover for expanding US House membership is that it
- 17:49would reduce over representation of small states in presidential elections, and so it
- 17:54would give states more equal influence on the electoral college.
- 17:57So roughly speaking, the electoral college is pop population somewhat representative, but
- 18:07because states smaller states get three electoral college votes no matter what because
- 18:12they at least have one US house rep no matter what, and every state gets two senators, and so
- 18:18your electoral college votes are made up of the total number of congresspeople that you have
- 18:22for that state.
- 18:25But if you're adding more US house members, the larger states are getting more representatives.
- 18:34And the smaller states would get more representatives too, but not as much as the
- 18:39larger states.
- 18:39So the idea is that the electoral college would be more representative of the population in
- 18:47terms of proportion across states.
- 18:50And there's currently a large variance in population sizes for different districts,
- 18:54partly because these smaller states only have one US house district, whereas in these bigger
- 19:02states that have a lot higher of a population, the individual districts might have more
- 19:08people.
- 19:08And then, of course, it depends on how much these particular districts grow over the course
- 19:13of the decade before the census leads to reapportionment.
- 19:18So those are the arguments not the only arguments, but those are some of the most
- 19:23common arguments you hear in favor of expanding US house membership.
- 19:27But let's talk about arguments against an expanded US house.
- 19:34Again, these are arguments I've heard previously or potential arguments that could be
- 19:38made.
- 19:39So first one is that more representatives would mean more representatives and their subsequent
- 19:48staff that you would have to pay, which means there's more taxpayer dollars spent on them.
- 19:53The current salary for members of Congress is a 174,000 base pay, and then the leadership gets
- 19:59more.
- 20:00I believe the speaker of the house gets 230,000 or something like that.
- 20:05Then you have to have the funds to pay their specific staff members.
- 20:10And they have people that have sometimes specialized things that they do for their
- 20:18chosen representative that they're working for, but a lot of times they have roughly the same
- 20:23job.
- 20:24It depends on the representative.
- 20:26But then not only the staff for each specific member of Congress, then you might need even
- 20:31more people to staff the congressional committees because congressional committees
- 20:36also have staff.
- 20:37So they might need more people to staff those congressional committees to attend to more
- 20:42representatives of congress.
- 20:44And the overall US House has specific staff members.
- 20:49Then the political parties in the US House have staff members.
- 20:56And all of these people would be needed to attend to more US House reps, depending on how
- 21:00many that they add.
- 21:04That's adding a lot more taxpayer dollars that have to be spent on congressional and
- 21:11congressional staff compensation.
- 21:14And with a lot of these arguments about especially with looming shutdowns seemingly
- 21:20every other month for the government and the high deficits that we see each year, it adds to
- 21:29the debate about whether we should expand the US House because now it's adding more costs to
- 21:36the deficit that we already see.
- 21:39Another argument against expanded US House membership is that it would make it harder to
- 21:45reach majorities on contentious issues because you have to get more representatives in line.
- 21:50And you have for the majority and minority party, you have what are called whips.
- 21:57They whip people into shape, basically.
- 21:59Tell them, get in line.
- 22:00You have to vote this way on our bill.
- 22:04And so the idea is that republican whips try to get as many of their republicans fellow
- 22:09republicans in line.
- 22:10Democratic whips try to get as many of their fellow democrats in line.
- 22:13But also, if you could potentially get defectors, quote unquote, from the other party
- 22:19that might be willing to support that same stance on a given bill, those whips will
- 22:24contact them as well.
- 22:26And then that party's whips need to need to work extra hard just to make sure, hey, you
- 22:32cannot fall out of line.
- 22:33We need you to stick around for this.
- 22:37So these whips would have to get more people in line, so they'd have to spend more time with
- 22:44each individual representative to say, Hey, you need to stick with us, or, Hey, you need to go
- 22:48away from your side to work with us on this bill because X, Y, and Z reasons.
- 22:54So more time being spent whipping people into shape, into consensus, especially if you're
- 23:03adding a 100, a 150, 200 members to the US Congress or to the US House specifically.
- 23:11Another argument that people make against expanded US House membership is that special
- 23:16interest groups with larger budgets could influence even more representatives much more
- 23:22so than less resource groups because the special interest groups that have more money
- 23:27have a lot more resources to spread out across multiple people, whereas the less resource
- 23:33groups can't do so.
- 23:35They might still just have to pull all their resources toward a few representatives, and
- 23:41then there's even less competition for those bigger resource groups to influence certain
- 23:49other representatives.
- 23:51And these less resource groups already have trouble competing, but they do have somewhat
- 23:58better chances at influencing certain representatives because they can focus on fewer
- 24:03US house reps.
- 24:06And, also, you spend less time researching who you can potentially influence.
- 24:12Another argument against expanding US house representation is that you would need new
- 24:18infrastructure and more office space to accommodate the larger membership.
- 24:23So you're gonna have to build onto Capitol Hill to house more members and their staff, which
- 24:30costs more money, which means more taxpayer dollars, not just because you're compensating
- 24:36this extra congressional membership and this extra congressional staff, but to have to
- 24:42actually add onto the building of Capitol Hill.
- 24:45You need to spend more money.
- 24:47Now, obviously, that wouldn't be a perpetual thing where you're doing it every other year
- 24:52necessarily.
- 24:52But, I mean, if you have to upkeep the building, there's more of the building to
- 24:56upkeep.
- 24:57So then that's still costing more money.
- 24:58And then you got other little things too, like adding in furniture and paying the electric
- 25:05bill.
- 25:06So a bunch more costs added on even if it's not necessarily going to be the case for every year
- 25:13like a salary, you're still adding on a lot more cost.
- 25:18And you also have to devise where these new offices are going to be.
- 25:21So more deliberation on where you're gonna put these offices and how you're gonna design.
- 25:27And as ridiculous as it might sound, where offices are is a big deal to members of
- 25:35congress.
- 25:35They do some wheeling and dealing and bickering behind the scenes to get the, quote unquote,
- 25:41best offices.
- 25:43And when you are a good member of your party and that party takes power, they they give you
- 25:50the best office because you supported them.
- 25:53If you're a rank and file, you're a newbie, or you you you were there already, but you you
- 25:59weren't as supportive of the membership and they become the majority party, they'll
- 26:05probably remember that and give you some faraway office that's much harder to get to.
- 26:09It does happen.
- 26:10You think if there's anything in Capitol Hill that you don't think doesn't get political,
- 26:15well, you're mistaken.
- 26:17Even office spaces get political.
- 26:21Another argument that is made against extra US House membership is that it's harder for
- 26:28individual rank and file members to have a major impact now, of course, with 435 members
- 26:34not including the nonvoting members of US congress or for the US house that are for the
- 26:41for Washington DC and for the territories, it's already going to be difficult to make some
- 26:50noise.
- 26:51Now for better or for worse.
- 26:54Sometimes it's better that they don't make some noise, but at the same time, can't drown out
- 27:00their voices either because they are there on Capitol Hill.
- 27:04Unless they get out of line, then some people might say that their voice should be drowned
- 27:09out.
- 27:09What is exactly getting out of line?
- 27:13But even more individuals in The US House membership means each individual member might
- 27:20be less able to act on constituent interests.
- 27:23And I could actually pull more power into the hands of leadership because they are the ones
- 27:28who already have the attention and the prestige.
- 27:34And they can use that on more members of congress to get more of them in line, and it's
- 27:42a lot less likely that any single one of them might make a, quote, unquote, result happen.
- 27:50And then the last argument that we'll cover over people's arguments against US house
- 27:58membership expansion is that more members would lead to more bills being introduced and bogging
- 28:05down the process further.
- 28:06Not just bogging down the process in terms of whips having to reach out to more members to
- 28:11try to get them to vote on the bill, but bills have to be introduced on the floor.
- 28:15The very, very oversimplified process for a bill is it gets introduced on the floor, then
- 28:25it gets to the committee.
- 28:26Committee hammers out the details, goes to the full floor, the full floor, the full chamber of
- 28:32of congress supports it, then the other chamber of congress has to go through the whole
- 28:36rigmarole, the same thing.
- 28:38They have to agree on the exact same wording of the bill, so it might go back and forth between
- 28:42the chambers.
- 28:44That's the short version of the process for how a bill becomes law.
- 28:49But more bills then would have to be introduced on the floor, which means more time having to
- 28:54be spent on hearing the name of the bill and getting all every single one of those bills on
- 29:02the docket.
- 29:03Some some of those bills won't be heard because of some wheeling and dealing behind the scenes.
- 29:09And then those have to be sent to committees to be hammered out fully, but then those
- 29:13committees have to spend more time on more bills to hammer out more bills details and
- 29:20voted on before the full chamber to take it up.
- 29:22And then the full chamber will have potentially more bills to vote on.
- 29:27And so there's a lot more behind the scenes stuff that people can use to try to kill more
- 29:31bills, whether they just simply don't like somebody or somebody is the opposing party or
- 29:38some sort of esoteric procedural rule in the chamber of congress that we're talking about
- 29:46says, for some reason, oh, no.
- 29:48We can't hear that bill because whatever reason it might be.
- 29:53There's all sorts of procedural rules in congress that are just super esoteric even to
- 30:00people who are in congress.
- 30:02And every once in while, you hear about seldom used rules to try to make something happen.
- 30:09And so you're bogging down the process not just towards the end, but towards the beginning of
- 30:14it too for how a bill becomes law.
- 30:17And then the committees have to have more bills to deliberate on and refine, decide whether
- 30:21they're going to approve or not approve them, and send them out of committee.
- 30:25And then past committee stage, more bills are happy to be voted on.
- 30:31So it can take even longer for a bill that you might be interested in as a constituent to be
- 30:39heard, if it even gets heard.
- 30:42So, again, those are not the only arguments that are made for or against US house or
- 30:50expanding the US house membership, but those are some of the really common ones that you'll
- 30:54hear or potentially will hear, especially if this movement for a larger US house becomes
- 31:03greater, becomes gets a lot more traction.
- 31:07So regardless of whether the expansion of the US house is the proper way to address a lot of
- 31:15congress's woes with responsiveness and representativeness, Let's just say, for the
- 31:21sake of argument, we are going to try to expand the US house membership.
- 31:27Well, of course, like everything else in politics, it's quite tricky and a lot easier
- 31:34said than done.
- 31:36Now it would be easier than some things because certain changes might require a constitutional
- 31:45amendment, and constitutional amendments are extraordinarily difficult to achieve.
- 31:51You need two thirds of both chambers of congress to propose an amendment or the state
- 31:56legislatures, two thirds of them call for a constitutional convention.
- 31:59And then the full amendment has to be approved by three quarters of the state legislatures in
- 32:05order to actually be ratified.
- 32:07Enlarging the US house would not need a constitutional amendment because congress
- 32:12already did that through a statute.
- 32:13They capped seats at four thirty five in the reapportionment act of 1929.
- 32:19And if con if you're trying to reverse a bill by Congress, you don't need a constitutional
- 32:24amendment, you just need a regular bill.
- 32:30And so you just need to focus on getting a majority of the US house, but that is still
- 32:36quite tricky.
- 32:38One of the reasons why is actually deciding on the number of members of the US house.
- 32:46What exactly is the appropriate number?
- 32:47We're at 435 now, so should we expand it to 500, 600, 700, 800, a thousand, maybe more.
- 32:58It's there's not really an objective number per se.
- 33:02Now we can argue about which number is best, but it's hard to really come up with a truly
- 33:07objective.
- 33:07This is the best number to use, but we can maybe get close enough to try to say that
- 33:12something is objectively the best.
- 33:14But, of course, there's debate about that.
- 33:16But what if we're basing the instead of just raising the cap and still having a maximum
- 33:23number of representatives like that, maybe we're still pegging it to the average number of
- 33:29citizens per district.
- 33:30But then what is that number?
- 33:32We're at 760,000 plus citizens per district on average.
- 33:39So what's the appropriate number?
- 33:42Probably not gonna get to 40,000 or 60,000 because then just it becomes an absurdly
- 33:46unwieldy US house.
- 33:48And I don't think even people who are arguing for an expansion to US house membership would
- 33:54argue that we need that many members of congress.
- 33:58So what is the average that we're trying to look for?
- 34:02Is it 650,000, 600,000, 500,000, 400,000?
- 34:08Again, hard to come up with a if not impossible to come up with an objectively best number for
- 34:14that.
- 34:15There will still be a lot of wheeling and dealing.
- 34:17So even if you have five different people come together and agree, oh, yeah, we we do need to
- 34:23expand The US house membership.
- 34:26Well, all five of them might have a different idea of where that number should go.
- 34:33Some of them might support an maximum cap just higher than 435.
- 34:39Some of them might support making it based on average number of citizens.
- 34:45But the exact number of US citizens per district, maybe they still don't agree on that.
- 34:52So even if you come up with a specific number, so if you do get a bill through that says we're
- 35:02gonna base US house membership on x maximum number of representatives or this average
- 35:11number of US citizens.
- 35:13Okay.
- 35:13Let's say that there's a bill there that's that's up for a vote by the full US house.
- 35:22How do you get a majority of the US house to support it?
- 35:25They're politicians, so they typically need an incentive to support something, whether it's
- 35:31appealing to their party loyalty or ideological affiliation or they have a constituency group
- 35:39that is particularly powerful in their district and is trying to influence them one way or
- 35:45another on a bill.
- 35:48There needs to be some sort of every once in a while, you'll get sure.
- 35:53You'll get a truly altruistic vote on a bill, but a lot of times that doesn't really happen.
- 35:59And that's not to say that every vote is selfish in congress.
- 36:03I know it's very easy to dunk on politicians.
- 36:06I do it a lot too.
- 36:08But it's not necessarily because they're being selfish.
- 36:10It's they're they just have a lot of things to consider.
- 36:15Or there might be a little bit of selfishness to it, but it's not like they're purposely
- 36:19trying to screw over anybody.
- 36:21Not always, at least.
- 36:23But then even if you get past individual incentives, is the current majority party in
- 36:30congress going to support it?
- 36:31So whether it's a republican majority or a democratic majority in both the US house and
- 36:37the US senate, is the current majority party gonna support it?
- 36:41They might not because the current rules got them that majority.
- 36:45And the minority party might say, no.
- 36:47We do need more members and more US house membership in congress if they feel like that
- 36:53will get them a leg up.
- 36:54But then if they become the majority party, they might suddenly turn around and say, yeah.
- 36:59You know what?
- 36:59This actually isn't so bad because of reasons.
- 37:03A lot of times, parties and individuals change their tune on something when they suddenly get
- 37:12a lot more power and prestige and influence.
- 37:17But then what if the US house and the US senate are split between the parties?
- 37:22You need to get both chambers to agree on the same exact wording in the bill.
- 37:26So even if Republicans thought that we needed to expand the US house membership and Democrats
- 37:32didn't or Democrats did and Republicans didn't, well, then you are probably gonna be at an
- 37:39impasse because both chambers of congress are different parties.
- 37:43But even beyond that, even if you did get both chambers of congress to agree that house
- 37:50membership needed to be expanded, well, they would need to agree in the same exact wording.
- 37:56And, again, that gets back to the what's the appropriate number to base the US house
- 38:02membership on?
- 38:03A maximum number of representatives or average number of citizens per district?
- 38:09So a lot of things to consider, and also not even just by party, talking about geographic in
- 38:18terms of total population of states again.
- 38:21Talked about before the smaller state versus larger states schism, if you will.
- 38:28Smaller states might be harder to get on board because some would argue that a larger US house
- 38:35would reduce the power of small states in presidential elections.
- 38:39Smaller states having an outsized influence, whether that's whether it's right or wrong for
- 38:45smaller states to be able to have more influence than their population would suggest.
- 38:51I'm not gonna get into that.
- 38:53But them having an outsized influence, smaller states are probably not gonna give that up
- 38:58easily, and you might have enough of them even across party lines that would say, no.
- 39:04No.
- 39:05No.
- 39:05We we are not going to expand the membership of the US house if they feel like it's benefiting
- 39:13them the way they are.
- 39:14Because not just party incentives and group incentives.
- 39:17There's individual incentives, and sometimes those individual incentives can transcend party
- 39:22lines.
- 39:24It can happen to anybody.
- 39:25We all have certain things that influence us to feel a certain way, certain biases, certain
- 39:32benefits that we're not gonna wanna give up, and certainly, members of congress are no
- 39:36different in that regard.
- 39:37They can act on that considerably and have a lot more influence on the political system that
- 39:46way.
- 39:47Regardless of whether we support the expansion of the US house membership or not, regardless
- 39:53of how tricky it is.
- 39:54Ultimately, what is this about?
- 39:56Why do people want an expanded US house membership?
- 40:01Well, the idea is it's about making congress more responsive, accessible, accountable,
- 40:07representative, or some combination thereof or some other word that I didn't come up with.
- 40:14And all of those are admirable admirable goals that regardless of political views or whether
- 40:21the party we support is in power, we want that for congress.
- 40:25We should want a congress that is more representative, more accessible, more
- 40:30accountable, more representative, actually tries to help out constituencies, constituents
- 40:41across party lines, regardless of whether those people voted for that representative or not.
- 40:48And regardless of party, the vast majority of us often feel that Congress as a whole falls
- 40:53short of these goals.
- 40:56So if we keep those ultimate goals for expanded US house membership in sight, but if we can't
- 41:07get a bill passed to expand the US house, can we achieve those goals a different way?
- 41:12In other words, what are other ways that we can make congress more responsive, accessible,
- 41:18accountable, representative, or some combination of those words?
- 41:22When you're doing policy analysis, regardless of how deep you get into the weeds of it, Every
- 41:28policy has pros and cons to it.
- 41:30Now many supporters of a policy are going to work to convince you that it doesn't have any
- 41:35flaws because it doesn't really behoove them to tell you, well, there are some things we
- 41:39haven't worked out, but there are always trade offs.
- 41:42Some policies might have more trade offs, some policies might be subjectively or objectively
- 41:47worse or better.
- 41:49But there's always going be some sort of flaw because human beings are involved.
- 41:54And human beings are oftentimes very shortsighted or biased or self interested.
- 42:02Now policies aren't inherently at complete odds.
- 42:06They can be supplemental to each other, but that's not always the case.
- 42:11And there are always other ways to at least attempt to accomplish the goals that you're
- 42:15ultimately trying to accomplish with varying degrees of success even if one policy is the
- 42:20quote unquote best, but you might need to implement multiple policies.
- 42:25So some other ways that we can try to achieve those goals for congress that advocates of an
- 42:32expanded US house membership would argue for, Maybe you can include something, and these are
- 42:38just I haven't really thought super deep about these and how you would implement them, but
- 42:43just some things to really get the the gears turning in your minds.
- 42:47Maybe other ideas include town hall attendance requirements.
- 42:51Lately, some members of congress and really over the years, a lot of members of congress,
- 42:56maybe not a lot, but some members of congress get blasted even if it's by voters of the same
- 43:03party for not attending town halls because they are afraid of some sort of blowback or they
- 43:09just don't feel like making the trip or something else holds them up.
- 43:16Is there a way you can force them to attend a certain number of town halls?
- 43:21Probably not.
- 43:22But if you at least hold them accountable to say, if they if you don't go to this many town
- 43:29halls, we're going to make sure we punish you at the ballot box or in some other way,
- 43:35obviously, not anything violent, is that something you could do?
- 43:41Because if you make them go to more town halls, they're going to be more responsive, more
- 43:47accountable by default because they're having to hear more directly from a group of
- 43:52constituents that are very involved.
- 43:55What if you simply added more congressional staff to attend to constituent needs?
- 44:00So, yes, that's higher cost because you're adding more congressional staff members, but
- 44:08more of them can attend to more needs of the constituents because there are more staff
- 44:16members to take their calls and emails and physical letters in the mail.
- 44:23So they might feel like they're being heard, and so people feel that congress is being more
- 44:29responsive.
- 44:30Even if it's not that specific member of congress, it's still their staff, and that
- 44:33staff represents that representative.
- 44:37What about independent redistricting commissions?
- 44:39So instead of having how a lot of states do it where the legislatures, the state legislatures
- 44:46redraw the lines of those congressional districts and state legislative districts, If
- 44:54you have more independent members and how you would make sure they're independent, that can
- 44:59vary.
- 45:00But if you're taking politicians out of the equation of redistricting, can that make them
- 45:07more accountable, more responsive because they're not trying to draw the lines in a way
- 45:13that benefits them?
- 45:14They're not trying to gerrymander.
- 45:16A lot of times they gerrymandering has become more and more insidious.
- 45:21We've gotten better and better at detecting gerrymandering, but some people can be very
- 45:26sneaky about how they draw certain district lines.
- 45:30What about campaign finance reform?
- 45:33So we talk about the cost of elections earlier and how more membership in the US house would
- 45:40lead to less cost for races because there's more campaigns having to have money spent on
- 45:48them and your campaigns are having appeal to fewer voters.
- 45:54So is there a way we can do that through campaign finance reform?
- 46:00And that's a huge umbrella of potential reforms.
- 46:04You can't really get into that right now.
- 46:07But maybe one one day, we'll have a podcast episode about campaign finance reform.
- 46:11But it's not just about changing the behavior of congress.
- 46:16We can also change our own behaviors because a lot of times we contribute to the lack of
- 46:21responsiveness and accountability in congress as as well as the representativeness of
- 46:29congress or the accessibility of congress.
- 46:33We can also do better.
- 46:35We can't just put it all on our government officials.
- 46:38So we can change our behaviors as well, such as being willing to hold people across the
- 46:43political spectrum accountable no matter what their party is.
- 46:46Obviously, a lot easier said than done.
- 46:48But we do need a lot more accountability.
- 46:51If you're not holding your own side accountable, then you don't actually believe in
- 46:54accountability.
- 46:55Accountability does not exist in that scenario.
- 47:00Not boxing ourselves into echo chambers.
- 47:02Another thing that's a lot easier said than done.
- 47:04We have to be a lot more deliberate about not keeping ourselves just hearing the things that
- 47:12we wanna hear and patting us on the back for believing the same things that some talking
- 47:17head on the TV or the radio said because, oh, they said what I said, I've got everything
- 47:22figured out.
- 47:23So, of course, they're right.
- 47:25But in any case, need to seek out differing sources of information or not even necessarily
- 47:34ones that are on the other side of the aisle, but ones that are not just pandering to us.
- 47:39More neutral opinions, we need to really seek out as well.
- 47:45Being more civically engaged with politics beyond voting because the most active people in
- 47:52politics are the ones that are the most polarized.
- 47:56People who are not so engaged with the process tend to be less polarized.
- 48:01So we need to have people who are not so politically polarized to participate more in
- 48:08campaigns.
- 48:09So representatives feel like they have to respond to more people of a more eclectic
- 48:17variety of people from different parties and ideologies and issue stances.
- 48:24And then also putting more effort into researching candidates.
- 48:28A lot of times we wait until the last minute to research, hey, believe me, I've been guilty of
- 48:33it too.
- 48:33Now.
- 48:34I obviously am a lot more involved in politics.
- 48:37It's it's my, it's my career is in it.
- 48:40But sometimes I can procrastinate on researching candidates for a local level race,
- 48:46for example, as well.
- 48:48But we need to be a lot better in our research habits, but also teaching people how to
- 48:53research better as well because not everybody knows how to find this information if the
- 48:57information is even out there.
- 48:58Information is not always out there.
- 49:00Some candidates, you can't find anything on for one reason or another.
- 49:06So it's not just about changing how congress behaves, but how we behave.
- 49:11Changing that will also lead to changes in behavior by congress.
- 49:17So is expanding the US house membership the way to go?
- 49:22Is that what's gonna achieve all these things we wanna see in congress?
- 49:26Is that going to fix congress?
- 49:28Maybe it will.
- 49:29Maybe it won't.
- 49:31Politics is so complicated that it's probably not gonna be the only thing.
- 49:36Even if it is the right thing to do, it's probably not gonna solve everything.
- 49:40But it is, in any case, something we really need to consider.
- 49:45And even if we come to an agreement that we do need to expand The US house membership, we
- 49:51still need to talk about how exactly to do that as well.
- 49:57So some food for thought, and that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with
- 50:03Paul podcast.
- 50:04As always, thank you so much for listening, and please like, comment, subscribe, share.
- 50:10Links to the show notes, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my email, my website, mymedium.com
- 50:17profile, and the stuff I write on there.
- 50:20The five day educational email course I have that is free.
- 50:24That is about ways that we unintentionally inflame effective polarization, political
- 50:32polarization in general, why we make those mistakes and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 50:38And of course, come talk to me.
- 50:39I've got a lot of services to provide in research, analysis.
- 50:44I do webinars.
- 50:46I have I will can even make an educational email course for you if you are a civic and
- 50:51nonpartisan organization.
- 50:53So love to hear more from you and more from people who enjoy the show and any constructive
- 50:59criticism you have as well.
- 51:01So as always, thank you so much, and until next time.
- 51:06Take care.