Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E008: Is Larry Fink A Friend Or Foe Of Bitcoin?
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972 thousand. Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 0:24Sell, hey, I say when we sell. Oh Logan, you're going to ninja
- 0:32launch on us. We are recording.
- 0:37We are meeting, as you can tell anybody who's who's watching
- 0:40this, there's only three of us. This week.
- 0:42I'm in Nashville, TN. I'm at the Lightning Summit
- 0:45being hosted by the Bitcoin Park here in Nashville, an incredible
- 0:50coworking space and Event Center for people building in Bitcoin.
- 0:53Wanting to learn more about Bitcoin, I wanted to pull one of
- 0:57the attendees. To this summit in to be our
- 1:00guest this week. And I got Rugged.
- 1:02I'm not gonna, I'm like gonna name who it was.
- 1:04I don't wanna put them on the spot publicly, but we got
- 1:08Rugged. So it's just the three of us.
- 1:09This week it's gonna be an intimate episode, a tight rip.
- 1:13Gentlemen, how are we doing? We're doing this new format and
- 1:19it's just the three of us this week.
- 1:20Are you OK? New format different time zones.
- 1:23I'm in Mountain Mountain time right now.
- 1:25Jesse on the West Coast and the the rugging will maybe we
- 1:28announce who who rugged when we have him on the pod because it
- 1:31was a great idea and good concepts that we do want to talk
- 1:34about so. And we will touch on that.
- 1:39But before touching on those big news of the day again, I do love
- 1:44these summits and these Bitcoin events that are like.
- 1:49Very busy and high signal and you're like forced to engage and
- 1:52actually pay attention. I haven't been on Twitter all
- 1:54week. I wasn't on Twitter this morning
- 1:57and I was only made aware of this video clip like 20 minutes
- 2:01ago. So Logan, let's pull it up.
- 2:02We got Larry Fink on CNBC saying some stuff.
- 2:12I can't talk about Bitcoin, but we have a filing with the SEC so
- 2:14I'm prohibited. I can talk about crypto in
- 2:18general and I can talk about what we have done.
- 2:22You know, we believe we have a responsibility to democratize
- 2:26investing and we've done a great job and and the role of ETS in
- 2:31the world is is transforming investing in it.
- 2:35I think we're only at the beginning of that.
- 2:38I mean we we, we believe. The fixed income market is going
- 2:42to become multiple trillion dollars in in in ETF.
- 2:45Equities will continue. More and more the market will be
- 2:50will be delivered through an ETF platform.
- 2:53If you think about what was done 1520, no 20 years ago now with
- 2:58the advent of a gold ETF, that really democratized gold.
- 3:05Investing it broadened out of the cost of transaction for
- 3:08gold. I mean, the cost of transacting
- 3:10physical gold is absurd. And now with crypto, the idea of
- 3:18democratizing that role, the cost right now, the transact,
- 3:23it's quite expensive. We're talking points, not
- 3:27decimal points. And so that's a big .2 over the
- 3:32last five years. More and more our global
- 3:36investors are asking us about the role of crypto.
- 3:40And as I said, I do believe a lot of crypto is is going to be
- 3:44it's an international asset, it's going, it is, it has a
- 3:50differentiating value versus other asset classes.
- 3:54But more importantly because it's so international, it's
- 3:57going to transcend any one currency and currency evaluation
- 4:00if you just look at the value of.
- 4:02Of our dollar and how a depreciate lasts 2, two months
- 4:07and how much it appreciated over the last five years.
- 4:09I mean a international crypto product can really transcend
- 4:16that and that's why we believe there's great opportunities and
- 4:21that's why we're seeing more and more interest and that interest
- 4:23is broad based worldwide. Before we jump jump in, can you
- 4:31guys help me understand what he meant by appreciate and
- 4:33depreciate? He said like in the past two
- 4:35months, it's appreciated and depreciated and I.
- 4:39Think he fumbled through that? It was.
- 4:41He was. Fumbling.
- 4:44What do we think he meant? Cuz that's just very confusing
- 4:46us, the whole story. Yeah, Dixie that the dollar
- 4:50index is down over the last couple months.
- 4:53It had a strong. Year or two before that, but
- 4:58it's down now and that's just a measure of how the dollar is
- 5:00performing versus other Fiat currencies, which is to say that
- 5:06for you know for a couple years there other Fiat currencies were
- 5:10printing more than the dollar. So they were debasing faster
- 5:12than the dollar. So the dollar was doing
- 5:14relatively better and now the that's kind of flipped like the
- 5:19Swiss franc right now is, is kicking butt versus the dollar.
- 5:24And so that's a trend that's been been playing out and I
- 5:28think he was just kind of extrapolating that.
- 5:30Yeah. Yeah, but probably it was.
- 5:34It felt like watching that. It was the third time I watched
- 5:37it in the last 10 minutes and it seems like it was like fed some
- 5:41talking points and yeah, and fumbled through it.
- 5:44Like, I don't think he really believed what he was saying,
- 5:47but. It it did feel like he hadn't
- 5:49really practiced them, at least. And yeah, there's.
- 5:54He he had a week ago he came out and said that Bitcoin is a
- 6:00product that BlackRock wants to get into.
- 6:02Because then he made this strange leap of the foundational
- 6:06value of BlackRock is about hope.
- 6:10Which of course is hope being this, this word that Michael
- 6:14Saylor has has linked to Bitcoin and made part of the Bitcoin
- 6:18ethos that Bitcoin is about hope.
- 6:20So. He, in a kind of fumbling way
- 6:24then, was trying to connect BlackRock with the Bitcoin
- 6:27ethos, as if a bitcoiner had been coaching him the same way
- 6:32that I think, like RFK and other politicians have been coached on
- 6:35Bitcoin recently. I think the whole thing's
- 6:39insane. I was listening to one note, the
- 6:41one notice, he said They're democratizing crypto vis a vis
- 6:45Bitcoin. It's like this week it's such a
- 6:47prescient or like. It just within 24 hours, at the
- 6:52same time, Mutiny Wallet announces you can, you know
- 6:55basically spin up a lightning note and a node accept a
- 6:57transaction in a browser. They're democratizing crypto in
- 7:00the same way that they democratize gold.
- 7:03He's touting as a good thing that they made paper gold and
- 7:06that you know good luck getting your gold if you need it.
- 7:09When when the time when at the time you need it.
- 7:11Imagine like good luck getting your Bitcoin at the time you
- 7:14need it. Like it's just it's completely
- 7:15nuts. Yeah, and I think.
- 7:18Again, he was leaning into the transaction cost when I really,
- 7:23if I think about rocking it correctly, is comparing the cost
- 7:26of getting exposure to Bitcoin via an ETF to buying Bitcoin
- 7:30directly on an exchange and the the different fee structures
- 7:34that exist between those two. And that's funny.
- 7:38He still believes that, like transacting in Bitcoin, just
- 7:41buying it and like holding it in the ETF or just holding it on an
- 7:44exchange and not rocking like the actual.
- 7:48Cost of sending an actual Bitcoin transaction at the
- 7:50protocol layer and viewing it as this bare instrument that people
- 7:55will actually use and spend and move around.
- 7:58And he's really stuck in this myopic view of, oh, Bitcoin is
- 8:02just gonna go sit in our fund at Coinbase.
- 8:05That's what people are gonna want.
- 8:07That's right. We got confused with Jesse what
- 8:09he mentioned on the two year cuz it the way I interpret it was
- 8:12that Bitcoin against the dollar you know has been against.
- 8:16That you know the price relative to dollar the past two years,
- 8:19but over five years, the past five years, and it seems like he
- 8:22had like 4 different or five different talking points he was
- 8:24trying to like string together and they all just got lost
- 8:26within him, just like, you know. Yeah, that, that, yeah, the time
- 8:31frame comparison thing was confusing.
- 8:33I'm not really sure what he was trying to trying to say there.
- 8:36And yeah, it does feel like for better and worse here, Larry
- 8:40Fink has wrapped his head around maybe.
- 8:45Bitcoin is digital gold, and he doesn't understand Bitcoin yet,
- 8:51but he sees, oh, gold is a product that BlackRock has,
- 8:55quote UN quote, democratized with an ETF that's been very
- 8:58successful. Maybe we can make money doing
- 9:00that for Bitcoin and and I think that might be as far as he's
- 9:04gotten, but that might be enough for him to suddenly be an
- 9:08advocate for like legitimizing in the in the mainstream
- 9:14finance. View Bitcoin as a product, as an
- 9:18investment asset, and that that's a good tailwind.
- 9:24Though. Michael's right that you know
- 9:26they want to ingest as much Bitcoin as they can and have it
- 9:29sitting in a single fund without actually enabling people to to
- 9:34use the underlying asset or even take self custody down the road.
- 9:37Because we know that the Bitcoin ETF that BlackRock has proposed.
- 9:42Doesn't allow an average Joe to take an income redemption out of
- 9:47it. You you're not allowed to do
- 9:49that unless you're a registered broker dealer and you're doing
- 9:52the whole Bitcoin rather than fractional.
- 9:56And that's not that's not going to happen all that often for
- 10:01for, you know, an average individual.
- 10:05But what? But what does give me hope here?
- 10:08Is that this seems to be a trend and this is where I'm going to
- 10:11get out. I'm going to get on a strange
- 10:12soapbox that I wasn't expecting to get on, you know, a week ago.
- 10:17But Larry thinks excitement about Bitcoin right now.
- 10:22There's there's just under the surface there's like a, you
- 10:26know, an affable grandpa's excitement and that might be why
- 10:31he's a killer because you think that he's, you know, a friendly
- 10:34grandpa but really he's he's stone cold, ruthless, but.
- 10:38At any rate, there is something about his language right now
- 10:41with Bitcoin of he's realizing the things that we've all
- 10:45realized in in our own journeys into Bitcoin that first of all,
- 10:51Bitcoin is not Monopoly money. It it has real substance to, it
- 10:56has real value. And then once you have that
- 10:59fundamental switch, you start to appreciate just how much value
- 11:03it it it brings to the world. And you know, at the end of the
- 11:08day, Bitcoin is American values. It's about personal freedoms,
- 11:15property rights, you know, self determination, not allowing
- 11:18anybody to steal your wealth over time, being able to save
- 11:21and build a brighter future for yourself and your family through
- 11:25saving that, that's that's fundamentally American now.
- 11:30Wall Street Titans, despite all of their.
- 11:37Sins. They love America.
- 11:40You know, if you're if you're a selfmade billionaire who has,
- 11:45who has made a long career in Wall Street and you're you're
- 11:48hanging out in the Hamptons in the summer and your lavish
- 11:51spread in the backyard watching your kids play in the pool and
- 11:54circled by grass, which is the Hamptons way, you're going to
- 11:59love the country that helped you.
- 12:03Live this life even if you were an absolute wolf in in getting
- 12:08there. You love the foundation of
- 12:11America. You love American values.
- 12:14And now here comes this thing that you are starting to
- 12:16recognize is American values more so than the US dollar. the
- 12:21US dollar is actually not American values.
- 12:24And so I think we've seen this with Paul Tudor Jones and Bill
- 12:28Miller and Stan Druckenmiller where when they.
- 12:32You know, dig a little under the surface.
- 12:34They realize that Bitcoin has merit and is actually something
- 12:38that aligns with their value system.
- 12:41And then they become advocates for it, as we've seen those
- 12:44three men do. And now every other Wall Street
- 12:48Titan is forced to reckon with Okay.
- 12:51I respect those three guys, and in fact, all of my friends who
- 12:57look into Bitcoin start to become advocates for it.
- 13:00So maybe there's something here. And then they do their research
- 13:03and come away discovering that Bitcoin is American values.
- 13:07And I feel like Larry Fink is at the beginning of that orange
- 13:12pill epiphany and for many reasons he will probably never
- 13:16get there fully. But I think he just went from
- 13:21vocally anti Bitcoin to, you know what?
- 13:24Bitcoin is good for the world. And that's a huge step.
- 13:29So few few things. I agree because because what I'm
- 13:33going to say after is going to be a very controversial.
- 13:36I agree that the game theory obviously aligns for everybody
- 13:40to adopt and hold Bitcoin and Bitcoin is the most American
- 13:43thing. At the same time are you telling
- 13:45me Black Rock the creator, the most anti American?
- 13:50You know basically ESG is now getting Bitcoin from American
- 13:54ethos is that what you're saying Jesse?
- 13:56I'm going to say that I'm going to bend over backwards here and
- 14:00try to make this argument that that the EFG thing was them
- 14:06falling for, you know, that that political narrative and wanting
- 14:11to do something good for the world and ham fisting it, That's
- 14:17my argument. Yeah.
- 14:19No, I mean, so because I'm curious, like, yeah, I said
- 14:24there's that. There's also like I was taking
- 14:27notes on this last time, again the third time like Marty in the
- 14:30past 20 minutes hearing it and he said a lot of key things like
- 14:34I think there were tales on BlackRock about like
- 14:36transcending the US like absorbing capital global
- 14:39investors. I I think what they ultimately
- 14:42got is they they recognize like 1.
- 14:45The asset is coming. It has like there's certain
- 14:49market structure of. We know inflation, what happens
- 14:52to gold and hard assets. Bitcoin will do its thing.
- 14:55There's an understanding what will happen.
- 14:57There's a having coming ETF has to come.
- 15:00You know they're having the SEC lawsuit with GBTC.
- 15:05They get the nod, get the ETF. But the idea is that there's so
- 15:09much liquidity like to be absorbed by whatever 1617
- 15:13million BTC that's out there. That there's two parts and then
- 15:18you know, pumping the bags that they will accumulate.
- 15:21Well, also he referenced like this ETF, this model that has
- 15:25started the past 15 years of centralization of assets.
- 15:29They kind of, he didn't say tokenization, but there's also
- 15:31this Wall Street thing happening right now where the next wave
- 15:35where we're starting to see it. And again, we did this in like
- 15:371718 and like St. O's at the time, whatever,
- 15:39they're going to refer to tokenizing bonds and ET F's.
- 15:43In this world. But there's just this play on
- 15:45it, at least in my view of centralizing assets and at a
- 15:50click of a button, being able to say these aren't yours anymore.
- 15:54Because that's effectively what he was communicating about the
- 15:56gold centralization of we made it cheap and costly to be able
- 16:02to or less costly to hold gold. Which sounds really good.
- 16:06It's like the great, you know, Turkey meme where it's good for
- 16:09364 days and on the 365th day, when you actually, you know,
- 16:14whatever needed, you need the gold.
- 16:15In this case, you're dead. It can't, it can't come to you
- 16:18in the same way Bitcoin. So yeah, this, the whole thing
- 16:22doesn't smell good at all. I think these guys are not
- 16:25working in Bitcoin's best interest, and I don't think
- 16:29that's a problem. It's just more of we should
- 16:31recognize it. And plan accordingly because
- 16:34anything otherwise specifically with this situation I think
- 16:37would be everybody. It's a disservice, agreed.
- 16:43Well, not only I'm gonna take it in a different direction, which
- 16:45is I don't think he understands PIC at all yet, but I do think
- 16:55the last line of that clip, particularly around Bitcoin and
- 17:01quote, UN quote crypto. Being able to transcend any
- 17:05individual sovereign nation currency is a nod towards like
- 17:11the black rocks of the world. Larry Finks of the world
- 17:13Understand the the geopolitical and economic landscape of the
- 17:18world is extremely fragile right now.
- 17:20And he's probably sent a bunch of analysts like, all right,
- 17:22what's going to be the next move or one of the next moves?
- 17:25And they've come back and they've said all right, Bitcoin
- 17:28and crypto is probably that. And he's sort of rushing.
- 17:31To market with this ETF and with this narrative that, again,
- 17:34obviously hasn't practiced enough.
- 17:37He was fumbling through that whole interview.
- 17:39And it's like, all right, just like I'm being told this is the
- 17:43right thing to do, like we're all in a Bitcoin.
- 17:45It transcends. Like he was given a few lines to
- 17:47try to remember he he did it pretty poorly and then ran with
- 17:50it. But to Michael's point, like it
- 17:52it is a bit alarming, the way they're framing it.
- 17:58Disingenuinely like again using is sort of equating the
- 18:04transaction cost of exposure to an ETF versus you run in the
- 18:10middle Bitcoin exchange like river or cash app, whatever it
- 18:14may be, and equating that with actual like Bitcoin transactions
- 18:18that people, individuals and businesses can make at the
- 18:21protocol layer or layers above it, be the lightning network.
- 18:26That's that's. Disingenuous #1 Very alarming
- 18:29#2. BlackRock and others that come
- 18:33after them were able to successfully lull the public
- 18:36into believing that getting exposure to Bitcoin via these
- 18:40products is going to enable them to leverage the the properties
- 18:46of Bitcoin, which it's not The BlackRock specifically.
- 18:49We know that unless you're a blessed participant, blessed
- 18:54broker, dealer, you're not going to be able to take that Bitcoin
- 18:56in kind and do. And things with Epiquit that you
- 18:59want. And another thing here too is if
- 19:02BlackRock gets this approved, which I think we all agree is
- 19:04probably very likely, then others follow suit.
- 19:08And it seems like I believe there's six filings out there
- 19:11right now and four of the six are using Queen Base as their
- 19:15custodian. I believe the two others using
- 19:17State Street and I believe State Street maybe Fidelity, but if we
- 19:22get to a situation where the ETF.
- 19:24It gets approved, it gets popularity because Larry Fink's
- 19:30of the world are successful in conning the public and believing
- 19:34this is the best way to get exposure to Bitcoin.
- 19:36Like we can have a situation like again this, the fact that
- 19:40he was comparing this to gold and what the ETF market did for
- 19:44gold. Like if the ETF, the Bitcoin ETF
- 19:48does does what? Like it's it's not going to be
- 19:54like, well, like all the supplies going to concentrate in
- 19:56coin base and then queen base just becomes this massive
- 19:59honeypot and this target for governments to be able to show
- 20:01up to and be like, hey, we see you have 3,000,000 Bitcoin
- 20:05there, we're gonna, we're gonna need you to to give that to us
- 20:08or to to not move it off your exchange and that could really
- 20:12hinder a large part of the market.
- 20:14Yeah, I think that's been the big the big unlock is what you
- 20:17said on the global it's the reflexivity that they recognize
- 20:20that. If you think about gold, what is
- 20:22the ultimate if in a world where Bitcoin does everything, we
- 20:25think, what's gold At a tryout like $10,000, that's 5X from
- 20:28here, the reflexivity and understanding a single Bitcoin
- 20:32from 30K could be 300 K, 3,000,000 based on supply demand
- 20:36that they can aggregate that. I think it ends up just being a
- 20:39simple equation of a if we, you know.
- 20:43Screen light, the ETF, we can accumulate trillions in assets
- 20:45and that's fees. And to your point what I think
- 20:48the 2nd is a call option that we potentially can control this and
- 20:52A is great and B is just extra gravy on it and I think that's
- 20:56as simple as what's happening here.
- 20:59Yeah. So I think I hear, I hear what
- 21:02you guys are saying. I think there's I I'm probably
- 21:05being a fool here because I think that there's an
- 21:09earnestness that. They'd think they have, because
- 21:15when people find out about Bitcoin, what what does
- 21:18everybody do? Everybody shows up and says, I'm
- 21:22here to fix Bitcoin, right? And and this is their version of
- 21:26that, right? Bitcoin's an asset that makes
- 21:29sense in a world where the US dollar hegemony is, is fading.
- 21:34The rise of the bricks is a threat to.
- 21:38The Western dominance of the international markets and you
- 21:44know, that's what Ray Dalio got wrong about the changing world
- 21:47order. He implies that, you know, since
- 21:50there's a 600 year track record of the global reserve currency.
- 21:58Rising and falling every hundred years and and it being a new
- 22:01nation every time, the ascendant superpower takes over as the
- 22:06global reserve currency because that's the currency that you can
- 22:09trust your value in that. That pattern led him to sort of
- 22:15suggest that China is going to be the next global reserve
- 22:18currency. But what he missed is the rise
- 22:20of the Internet. The Internet creates this super
- 22:24sovereign currency. That transcends international
- 22:28borders and it's Bitcoin and that super sovereign currency is
- 22:34greater than any trusting any individual nation.
- 22:39And so that, you know, that's what I think Larry Fink and and
- 22:43his team at BlackRock are better suited to understand right now
- 22:47is in the current global landscape there is a case for
- 22:51neutral reserve currencies, hard assets and that means.
- 22:56Gold, historically. But now Bitcoin in the digital
- 22:59age, and holy shit, this thing could be big because of that.
- 23:05And then then they come in with Okay.
- 23:07Great. So Bitcoin has value.
- 23:09Let's do what we do and try to quote, UN quote, democratize it
- 23:14by spinning up an ETF. Yes, yes, I just discovered
- 23:18Bitcoin and I'm here to fix it. And that's where you think right
- 23:21now. And so, you know, I think it's
- 23:24this combination of like earnest intent and the classic fallacy
- 23:29that everybody comes to Bitcoin with and Bitcoin humbles you.
- 23:33And when you have yet to come to Bitcoin on on its terms, you are
- 23:38setting yourself up for hard learnings because you will
- 23:42eventually be humbled. And then you will figure out,
- 23:44oh, this thing just wants to be held in cold storage on chain
- 23:49and and and outside of the Tradfi universe.
- 23:54That's coming for Wall Street 10 years from now, but right now
- 23:58they're they think Bitcoin is great and they're here to fix
- 24:01it. So the two, the two counters
- 24:03that is again we're, I'm not I won't say what I think they're
- 24:07doing, I'm just looking at their actions.
- 24:10We've all known. I think anybody paying attention
- 24:12like the government can't create a CBDC, they cannot create a
- 24:16digital unit that can be transferred and it would be a
- 24:18public private partnership BlackRock owns basically Circle.
- 24:23BlackRock has already signaled they're the the horse they're
- 24:26riding on international trade and settlements as the things
- 24:29are going. So I think like from a that
- 24:30perspective and the second part is like I go back to this Block
- 24:355 is the closest because we're still so early but block 5 come
- 24:38in to you know fix Bitcoin or do lending in the Bitcoin world.
- 24:42You know like to your point they got wrecked.
- 24:44It's the same thing like black or Block 5 BlackRock coming in
- 24:50and. Attempting to do what they're
- 24:52doing, but at an or, you know, 100 X to 1000 X broader
- 24:56exposure, being the largest asset manager.
- 24:58Like we know that when people come into Bitcoin, they whoever
- 25:02they come in through is going to be how their journey, it might
- 25:05dictate their whole journey. i.e. it goes to 0 or it may you
- 25:10know push them back on the curve of learning based on the
- 25:15education information. That's where we focus so much on
- 25:18it here. You know you guys kind of.
- 25:20Carry that torch longer than I have in the sense of like the
- 25:23content Marty you put out content Jesse you put out and
- 25:26people that have come in I used to say this that Unchained when
- 25:28they found Unchained like and it was a very bold statements that
- 25:31he found like the signal will help you walk through it will
- 25:34help you out of custody will help you how to lend against it
- 25:36if you decide to stay it's up to you but but it's up to your you
- 25:40know it's up to your kind of like risk you want to take
- 25:43because we know you know what happened with genesis block file
- 25:45that and so it's a very similar thing with with.
- 25:49BlackRock except for it's again orders of magnitude larger When
- 25:52you think about app that managers capital allocation
- 25:55they're going to go to BlackRock and they're going to say you
- 25:58understand this, you bless this tell me what to do.
- 26:01Govern me harder. Daddy do where do I put the
- 26:04bitcoins? Where do I send them to How much
- 26:07should I let you hold. So again it's just.
- 26:11You know even if they did, you know, in good faith think that
- 26:15this was American valleys and health it.
- 26:17Like if they don't fully understand it and they're still,
- 26:20they're going to cause so much pain and disruption for a bunch
- 26:22of people that yeah, it's just a hard thing to like rationalize
- 26:27how it's it's positive other than yeah.
- 26:31I I think you're right that the good intentions here don't
- 26:36amount to much in terms of the experience that BlackRock may
- 26:39be. Creating for its investors down
- 26:46the road here or or other Wall Street firms.
- 26:48I mean, last week I ranted about how Wall Street is going to get
- 26:53burned. Some Wall Street firms are going
- 26:55to go under in the next 10 years because they they engage with
- 27:00Bitcoin in the wrong way and they rehypothecate and they have
- 27:03a hole in their balance sheet when the tide goes out and and
- 27:06boom, it's bigger than the enterprise value of the firm.
- 27:09And poof, some venerable Wall Street institution of 150 years
- 27:13is is gone just because they underestimated Bitcoin.
- 27:18That's going to happen. It could happen to BlackRock.
- 27:21And so the the good intentions here don't create good outcomes
- 27:26necessarily for an in fact, what they do create is a giant new
- 27:30surface area for attack for 61O2 for a honey pot of of assets.
- 27:38That that government forces could leverage a wedge that that
- 27:43they could exploit in the future.
- 27:47But I guess I'm, I'm, I'm excited about the narrative
- 27:51shift that Bitcoin is good and I think it is very concerning the
- 27:58kind of the product that people will be herded into and the
- 28:04weaknesses of that product. Down the road, but but I I'll
- 28:09take the win. But I do think it's on
- 28:12bitcoiners. It's on us to raise the alarm
- 28:16about which vehicle you're trusting.
- 28:19I mean that was the the, the metaphor I was going with when I
- 28:23wrote my recent piece about digging into the the BlackRock
- 28:27S1, the filing laying out all the specifics about Blackrock's
- 28:32proposed ETF. And my take away was that it is
- 28:36a bicycle with one good normal wheel and one square wheel and
- 28:42the square wheel is BlackRock governance and custody and and
- 28:45how they're proposing to approach that using the old
- 28:48world way for Bitcoin and and that's a centralizing force and
- 28:53and a bit of a scary force in in several ways so.
- 28:59So I think that you know it's a bad vehicle.
- 29:02But I'll take the win in terms of, you know, Larry Fink saying
- 29:05that that Bitcoin is good for the world.
- 29:08Yeah, yeah. I'll take that win to take the
- 29:10wins where we can get them. They want to pump our bags,
- 29:13definitely do it. They're certainly trying to pump
- 29:15their own bags and. Michael won't take this the.
- 29:18Onus is on us to wait wait, I'm. Gonna get on something.
- 29:22You're gonna like don't worry, the the onus is on us to get
- 29:24people into the good products and then This is why Onramp
- 29:27exists and again there's either a.
- 29:32Mental blocker, blinder or just pure ignorance to the way
- 29:37Bitcoin works, particularly around the native properties,
- 29:41particularly multicig that enables very unique custody
- 29:44models which on ramp has built with the multi institution
- 29:50multicig where the Bitcoin sits within the trust like I think as
- 29:58educators and his people. Maybe even advising tratify
- 30:03companies getting into Bitcoin, providing Bitcoin products the
- 30:06the way we should be pitching this.
- 30:08Again, like bitcoins, distributed nature works at many
- 30:12different ways. You have the distribution of
- 30:14full nodes to make sure that's really hard to change the
- 30:17protocol and shut it down. You have the distribution of
- 30:20hash rate geographically and the the ownership breakdown.
- 30:25To make sure that the mining sufficiently distributed so that
- 30:28the network's secure and the blocks are being produced, you
- 30:31have the distribution of nodes and channel management at the
- 30:38lightning layer. And then again, private keys is
- 30:40probably the one that is least talked about, but arguably one
- 30:45of the most obviously one of the most important, just equally as
- 30:48important. As the rest of those those
- 30:51factors, if you want Bitcoin to be as robust and resilient as
- 30:55possible, and if it's as robust and resilient as possible, it
- 30:59will be extremely valuable. The more robust and resilient it
- 31:02is, the harder it is to shut down.
- 31:05The more valuable it is, the more people are like, oh, this
- 31:07is ironclad, I need Bitcoin, it is our money.
- 31:11And so I think an area that's been a lack of focus throughout
- 31:15Bitcoin's history has been the private key distribution, like
- 31:18distributing keys. In creating these quorums of
- 31:21multi institutions to make it extremely hard for governments
- 31:25or large investment firms like BlackRock to essentially take a
- 31:31large portion of the Bitcoin supply and either create a honey
- 31:34pot or control it unilaterally on behalf of millions of people.
- 31:39And so that's again Jesse to your point about educating
- 31:43people about these different structures I think when doing
- 31:46that. Aid to get people to understand
- 31:49it. It's like all right, you use
- 31:50this distributed multi institution, multi sig model
- 31:54because it makes the distribution of private keys
- 31:59more robust, which makes it harder to unilaterally control
- 32:02Bitcoin on behalf of governments or large institutions, which
- 32:08increases the value prop. It makes it more valuable as a
- 32:11result. So with that pitch.
- 32:14To people to help them understand this, I think you
- 32:17just add like the sprinkle on top and like, yeah, this is
- 32:19gonna make Bitcoin more valuable cuz it's much harder to
- 32:21unilaterally control large swaths of Bitcoin.
- 32:25Yeah, I mean, so there's a couple things.
- 32:27When Jesse was like all this, I empathize and.
- 32:31To get where the different takes or like our stances on it
- 32:35because it it makes sense. I think there's partially
- 32:37whether we met or not, like BlackRock coming in we like to
- 32:39go because it's going to pump our bags.
- 32:41Like this thing's going to get insane quickly.
- 32:43I think we all agree there but when Jesse was breaking down
- 32:46like how how this is going to play out and and BlackRock, all
- 32:53I could think of was the greatest trick that ever the
- 32:55devil ever pulled was convincing everyone he didn't exist and
- 32:58right when I thought that. Jesse mentioned the people
- 33:02getting herded into this product and I think that's exactly
- 33:06right. Like they get hurt into the
- 33:07product. As Marty mentioned, keys needed
- 33:11to be distributed, but keys needed to be distributed is not
- 33:14intuitive and it's not it doesn't make sense to majority
- 33:19of people like majority of people have not come into space.
- 33:21It's the same thing. Where yield doesn't make sense
- 33:25or the the fact that you shouldn't generate yield on
- 33:27Bitcoin didn't make sense and a bunch of people lost all their
- 33:30funds. And so I think of like you know
- 33:32Bitcoin just flips kind of how the products in the financial
- 33:35environment will be built similar to again blockvised
- 33:39loans. With rehypothecating you take a
- 33:41more and a pragmatic conservative approach.
- 33:44You get your Bitcoin, you can you know get U.S. dollars or you
- 33:47know lend lend against it if you need it, but you get your
- 33:49Bitcoin back. You know, high or low loaded
- 33:52LTV, similar with keys. Looking at it saying oh, I want
- 33:56a conservative approach. I want multiple people to hold
- 33:58these keys and have a governance in place.
- 34:01That sounds great. The reality is that's not how
- 34:03traditional finance works. It's everything.
- 34:06It goes against everything that they believe in.
- 34:09When it comes to centralization of assets, how do you, you know,
- 34:13financialize them which comes with risk generally you can
- 34:15print your way out of risk, you can't print more Bitcoin and so
- 34:18this whole thought of. Yes, I think we all agree here
- 34:22that we know the model for the future but at the same time I
- 34:25just can't like Champion or be excited about well this is how
- 34:29that it's we're just going to have another five years of just
- 34:31blowups and craziness and doing it the wrong way and and all of
- 34:35this just like I think it is what it is and money will flow
- 34:38in and and realities. We can't change any of it but we
- 34:41should we should be aware at least admit this probably is how
- 34:45it plays out. Versus oh, this is all like in
- 34:48good faith because it's just in the history of everything
- 34:51Blackrock's done has not shown any of that to be the case.
- 34:55And if this disintermediates all other assets, then this wouldn't
- 34:58even and they understand anything around what's
- 35:01happening, then they wouldn't be acting in good faith moving
- 35:02forward. So yeah, BlackRock.
- 35:08Larry thinks may may, you know, love American values and see
- 35:12them in Bitcoin. But the other things that
- 35:15BlackRock. Clearly love loves is they They
- 35:21love control and they love influence.
- 35:24And so you can you can like American values and that's good
- 35:27and that makes you a Bitcoin advocate.
- 35:30But. So how do we know they how do we
- 35:33how do we know they like American values.
- 35:34Like Marty knows way better than I do but Marty like just from an
- 35:38offshoring in the amount of energy production that's been
- 35:40halted. What that means from like just
- 35:42pure you know what what that means from low income
- 35:45individuals in America feel the access and flourish.
- 35:48Like how do we know like explain the logic behind they love
- 35:52American values. Yeah, it's speculative and it's.
- 35:59It's the odd exercise of, you know, these these guys who are
- 36:03The Who are Wall Street billionaires.
- 36:05They're really smart, very well read dudes all, all guys.
- 36:12Know how to play the political game.
- 36:13I think that's important factor here.
- 36:15That is like when it comes to ESG and all that stuff.
- 36:18I think a lot of that's driven politically.
- 36:21They're hyper competitive. And and as part of that, they're
- 36:25hyper social, So they're always, they're in the business of
- 36:28finding an edge and that means talking to each other constantly
- 36:32and they're constantly evaluating like Okay, who do I
- 36:35respect? Who's on to something, whose
- 36:38mind do I admire? And so that's the game they're
- 36:41in, that's the game they're playing and it's all a wealth
- 36:45accumulation game for them. But that game is only possible
- 36:50with with, you know, American rule of law.
- 36:54And the American culture of of like entrepreneurial endeavor to
- 36:58try to accumulate wealth and build wealth and create a
- 37:01brighter future for your family. Of course they, you know, have
- 37:05to engage in this by engaging in a political game.
- 37:07They're, you know, doing things that that are successful, that
- 37:14are not admirable. But I think that you know every
- 37:21all of these guys think that they're good guys.
- 37:24And that they are, you know, the pillars of their family.
- 37:28And that puts them at like an American patriarch identity at
- 37:33their core. And America has values that have
- 37:38enabled capitalism resonate with them.
- 37:42You know, like they they think of themselves as good guys.
- 37:45And what do they like? What are, what are their values?
- 37:48What are they embody? What are they champion?
- 37:51I think it's not a too much of A leap to think that the shared
- 37:56the common values that they have as a group Wall Street Titans is
- 38:00that they love capitalism, they love American rule of law and
- 38:05they love that culture of building a brighter future for
- 38:08your family. And ultimately that's America.
- 38:11So that's my that's my thought exercise.
- 38:14I do, yeah. So I do agree.
- 38:17And I think, what? This is this is a good.
- 38:21I'm glad you're having this conversation because as we're
- 38:23working through this and like it can almost see and curious you
- 38:25guys thoughts like where this ends up like everything's good
- 38:29for Bitcoin, right. So the price pumps, people come
- 38:31in, they have to hold it. So the people that weren't even
- 38:33wanting to hold it at 30 K want to hold it at 150 K through
- 38:36every K they can't hold it because of the liquidity
- 38:38profile. But then ultimately we see this
- 38:40fork from Black Rock that says oh you can't take your Bitcoin,
- 38:43you can take the green Bitcoin. And so everybody that got herded
- 38:47in basically through the BlackRock solution or orbit,
- 38:50right, Because it's going to go to Coinbase.
- 38:52Anything else associated, it's like, hey, this thing's crazy,
- 38:54like you could take it, but it's just not the actual Bitcoin.
- 38:59Yeah, I think that narrative shift of we just went from from
- 39:03BlackRock saying Bitcoin is bad because ESG to now Bitcoin is
- 39:08good because ESG. And that can never be undone.
- 39:14Like that narrative shift will will remain, but what can still
- 39:18happen, What I think will still happen is people will get
- 39:21burned. People who are being herded into
- 39:23Wall Street products will get burned.
- 39:26They they will learn a hard lesson.
- 39:29And so all this incoming demand is good for the price, but you
- 39:33better be sure that you're holding actual Bitcoin that you
- 39:36can count on. Otherwise that good for the
- 39:40price isn't good for you long term because you may end up with
- 39:44a 0. So.
- 39:46But even when that happens when you know when some Wall Street
- 39:49firms get burned and and their investors get burned.
- 39:54We don't go back to Bitcoin is bad.
- 39:57We go we go from from Bitcoin is good to oh Bitcoin is good and I
- 40:03better control it the right way. So what you can do is get ahead
- 40:06of that learning. By recognizing it now that there
- 40:11are some ways that that you know to have better custody and and
- 40:16promises assurances about you have actual Bitcoin and you
- 40:20control it versus learning the hard lesson with the herd that
- 40:24is currently being herded into Wall Street products so.
- 40:28We're going to get a what you're saying, what we're what we're I
- 40:30think saying is we're going to get a New York Agreement 2.0 in
- 40:34four years with Cocacola, Google.
- 40:36And everybody saying, Oh no, no. Like this is not the good
- 40:38Bitcoin. And they're gonna get, they're
- 40:40gonna get wrecked. I'll take yeah.
- 40:43I'll take a contrarian taker. I think yes, she is on its way
- 40:45out. I think it's dying.
- 40:46I think the public's fed up. I'm not gonna call peak clown
- 40:49world, but I do definitely think there is a shifting in sentiment
- 40:55of the broader public. I mean, you can see this in
- 41:00confidence polls whether it be presidents and.
- 41:05The federal government more broadly, the media like faith in
- 41:08institutions, is crumbling. BlackRock is an institution that
- 41:13people are going to be like, all right, what the hell are you
- 41:15doing? Why do you have 10% of all these
- 41:18companies? Why are you pushing ESG down our
- 41:20throats, which is that driving this world insane at a social
- 41:25level and really hindering the stability of our energy sector
- 41:28materially and. I like from when it comes to ESG
- 41:34and BlackRock, I do think the broader public is getting wiser
- 41:37to things that are going on with that particular initiative and I
- 41:41do think it is it will be ephemeral.
- 41:44I think we'll look back in retrospect and four or five
- 41:47years be like ah ESG that was that was pretty funny did.
- 41:51You hear that? Was.
- 41:53Did you hear the latest? I saw a quote.
- 41:56It was very recent of Larry Fang.
- 42:01Said that he's ashamed of of what ESG has become.
- 42:06Yeah, the. Politicized nature of it.
- 42:08He he does. He doesn't like what it is now
- 42:11and he doesn't. And he's not planning to focus
- 42:15on it. Or I forget what exactly is.
- 42:18Yeah. So people like, like on the
- 42:19social and like having like things forced down their throat
- 42:24from large investors like that sentiment's definitely changing.
- 42:26And on the other side is just like.
- 42:29Empirically, objectively not profitable.
- 42:31Like these ESG funds don't make any money like you're you're,
- 42:35you're not gonna return for your investors.
- 42:36And at the end of the day, that's what these guys really
- 42:39care about is like, how could they make money?
- 42:41You can only make money on fees via AUM and management fees for
- 42:46so long without providing actual returns for the end investor
- 42:51before it just doesn't work out. So I think you should.
- 42:53We should in many ways. You know, we didn't have a
- 42:57fourth guess or one rug dust. We should have just had Odell
- 42:59on. I feel like I need a counterpart
- 43:01to the, to the, to the, to the statism on this on this show.
- 43:05Because like, Marty with the like, yeah.
- 43:07Status. Well I mean it's it's kind of
- 43:10was like issues on its way out like issue was was by definition
- 43:13ephemeral. Like it had no definition like
- 43:15it was just this thing it just had this weird thing that it can
- 43:19be on its way out and you can just usher in something it
- 43:21something else that. You can use to craft a narrative
- 43:25of control. And then you mentioned like the
- 43:27centralization of assets are going away.
- 43:28It's like actually the opposite, like all the tokenization, the
- 43:31ETF's, everything is going back. You know, like tokenization is
- 43:35in my opinion like the best rugging because you're putting
- 43:37an asset on the blockchain and where does it sit and how many
- 43:40layers of counterparty risk exist?
- 43:42And you're basically sitting, you're going into a like for
- 43:46anybody. Listening out there, you can put
- 43:48a tomato on the blockchain. But if on en route your tomato
- 43:53from wherever it's was produced to to your plate.
- 43:57If in the middle of that route, I take that tomato and I eat it,
- 44:02you can have a claim to a token of a tomato on the blockchain
- 44:06all you want. But I ate the tomato.
- 44:08It's not yours. You get no pizza.
- 44:10You get no pizza, You get nothing.
- 44:11You get, you get nothing. You can't tokenize physical
- 44:14assets like. But what you can tokenize is
- 44:19information, and money is information.
- 44:22And that's really kind of the only thing of value that is
- 44:26information. It's a it's a Ledger.
- 44:29Money is a Ledger of who owns how much of something, and you
- 44:34can exchange that but and and. So that's the argument for why
- 44:37tokenization of real world assets is fundamentally limited,
- 44:41but money is really the only use case that it makes sense for.
- 44:45The beauty of what we're gonna get is we're gonna get tokenized
- 44:48Bitcoin. That's what everybody's That's
- 44:51what we're all talking about here.
- 44:52Like we're gonna get tokenized Bitcoin.
- 44:53They're gonna say they figured it out.
- 44:56We tokenize Bitcoin because that's effectively what an ETF
- 44:58is, right? It's just an ETF.
- 45:00And then they're gonna trade it on it.
- 45:01It's gonna be a token and you're gonna have a claim on it.
- 45:04And nobody's ever gonna get the bit.
- 45:06Nobody's ever gonna get the Bitcoin.
- 45:07Like, that's basically where this all goes.
- 45:09We said this like the second or third pod, It's like the trap
- 45:11has been set. And it's just yeah.
- 45:18You want direct UTXO exposure? Anybody listening out there?
- 45:24And yeah, and you sure as hell want to the ability, the right
- 45:27and ability to take that if you're not currently ready for
- 45:33it now, which is the whole point of on ramp.
- 45:36Yes, yes. We got a lot of work to do
- 45:39gentlemen, that's why. We do the show.
- 45:43That's why we're very passionate about educating people the right
- 45:46way and that's why On RAMP has really dedicated ongoing sort of
- 45:51advisory services as you're learning about Bitcoin.
- 45:54That's why outside of this show, I produce a newsletter and two
- 45:59other shows to to really try to get the message out there and
- 46:02educate people correctly. It's important and if you're out
- 46:07there and you. Can see that we may have a
- 46:13better understanding of this stuff than the black rocks of
- 46:16the world. And you have people that are
- 46:17exploring this like send them, send them our way, send them the
- 46:20content. Because again, if you, if you do
- 46:24believe, as I do, that this is, I mean may sound crazy and it's
- 46:31probably why people think we're a cult, but I do think it's a
- 46:33moral imperative to make sure that Bitcoin succeeds.
- 46:37In the digital age, and if you do too, I think it's very
- 46:39important that you point people in the right direction and get
- 46:42them access to the correct information.
- 46:49Yeah, we will never tokenize your Bitcoin.
- 46:57And and I I can't help but think about like this.
- 47:00This is why I've titled my writing series Once in A Species
- 47:04because the the scale of what's. Happening here is a once in a
- 47:09species event of going from analog value system to digital
- 47:15value system. That's a zero to 1 moment that
- 47:19only happens once, and we just happen to be living through it.
- 47:24Now the that's an incredible opportunity.
- 47:27It also creates a massive risk because if you fumble this
- 47:33transition, you set your. Dynasty back you you could, you
- 47:38could be wealthy now, and if you screw this up, your future
- 47:42generations are not wealthy because you didn't manage this
- 47:45right. Maybe you trust the wrong Wall
- 47:48Street firm. You get your Bitcoin allocation,
- 47:51it goes to the moon, and then you get rugged and you find out
- 47:55you have zero. So you got to manage this well.
- 48:00If this is as big of an event as we think it is, and the way to
- 48:04do that is. By getting smart, by seeking out
- 48:08more information, educating yourself, talking to people,
- 48:12talking to people who know about this stuff because they've been
- 48:15in it full time for, you know, a half dozen years like all of us
- 48:19have been, Marty, more so longer than that.
- 48:24And so you know this, the scale of the decisions you make right
- 48:30now with regard to how you approach Bitcoin.
- 48:34Could be the defining factor in whether or not your
- 48:37grandchildren live well or not, and it all comes down to how
- 48:43much education you get about Bitcoin now in order to make the
- 48:48right decisions in this zero to one once in a species event.
- 48:53Yeah, it's the most important thing.
- 48:55I think that's exactly right in in what we're going through
- 48:58right now actually. It aligns with everything else
- 49:01that's happening. Marty, our friend Tom, when I
- 49:03bring up we're in a bull market for for statism and you have the
- 49:07prescient or non prescient claim that we're in a clown world peak
- 49:11I think two years ago and it's just continued to get worse and
- 49:14I think it will. We think about like social
- 49:18networks, the news money, like they're all in the most like
- 49:21highest. Point of centralization.
- 49:24And we're gonna continue to go that way.
- 49:25In the same way we're gonna continue to go into government
- 49:27overreach until there's this like pushback.
- 49:30And then we go the opposite way. And I think of like gold and
- 49:33gold having free banking and the way that the notes were claimed.
- 49:36And then we went to the centralized point where we
- 49:38needed dollar claims and everything that's happening now.
- 49:42So I think like to this is just like a natural progression.
- 49:44BlackRock will own a bunch of Bitcoin and then we're all going
- 49:47to like hit this confluence of all this central points where
- 49:49the market recognizes this is actually not the natural and
- 49:52organic way that we should. You know basically systems
- 49:55should be created in long term sustainable like the high
- 49:59volatility at the end points where then it starts to go back
- 50:02out into the fringes. And one of the things is like we
- 50:04talked about the centralization of gold, but there's two
- 50:06products, one in Europe, I'm sorry.
- 50:09Canada and then one here in the US, they basically let you like
- 50:13have the claim on the gold but then take possession of it.
- 50:16And I think we'll see more and more of that where it's like you
- 50:18can have a claim on a unit but then there's a check and balance
- 50:21of it like knowing that you can take possession.
- 50:23Because that's what allows for the free market to determine if
- 50:25this is like an unsavory or savor actor.
- 50:28Instead of just waiting and pushing that volatility out
- 50:30until the very edges where there's trillions of dollars
- 50:32sitting somewhere and you can never touch them.
- 50:33And now you're holding a 0 or a paper claim on green bet coin.
- 50:37So anyway, I think it's a long winded way of just saying like,
- 50:40this is all part of it, but if you recognize what's happening,
- 50:43it's not just like crazy people telling you it's like, oh, this
- 50:45makes sense under the like rules of Bitcoin.
- 50:48Also the rules of what's happening just on a like
- 50:51societal level. And you can get ahead of it.
- 50:53And getting ahead of it allows for your family to have like the
- 50:56wealth to live the life you want, but also pass it, pass it
- 50:58down. And I think.
- 51:00The event going on here in Nashville this week is
- 51:03indicative of why you want to make sure that you're in
- 51:05exposure to Bitcoin the correct way like on RAMP.
- 51:09Maybe if you're you're not comfortable taking self custody
- 51:13of your Bitcoin right now, but in the future you may be and you
- 51:16may want to leverage some of the products and technologies that
- 51:19are being built out on 2nd layers on bitcoins.
- 51:21Right now Nashville, we're at the Lightning Summit and there's
- 51:25people from around the world that are building products on.
- 51:29The Lightning network to to make Bitcoin more useful and more
- 51:33accessible for individuals. And you're probably going to
- 51:37want to use these products at some point in the future.
- 51:41And if you do, you're probably going to need like to self
- 51:44custody Bitcoin to some extent and like by siloing yourself to
- 51:51Bitcoin exposure via something like a BlackRock ETF.
- 51:55You are essentially. Preventing yourself from being
- 51:58able to do that in the future, to be able to utilize the
- 52:01technologies that are being built.
- 52:05The best case scenario, you're going to have to sell that ETF
- 52:09exposure, pay the taxes, and then buy back Bitcoin properly
- 52:12via another vendor so you know when you're making this
- 52:15decision. Yes, you may think Bitcoin is
- 52:19only digital gold right now. It's just going to sit there
- 52:21forever. And that may be the case, may
- 52:23sit there for a while, but I'm pretty confident seeing
- 52:26everything that's being built like you're actually going to be
- 52:28using Bitcoin as a payments network, as a money, as a
- 52:32daytoday currency at some point over the next decade.
- 52:35And when that point comes for you individually, when you're
- 52:38ready to shift from using Bitcoin purely as a savings
- 52:41account to as to an Internet native currency that you're
- 52:45spending and using on a daytoday basis, you're going to really
- 52:48want to make sure that you have the correct exposure.
- 52:52Yeah, that's a good threat is like if you if you want Bitcoin,
- 52:55if you think it's going to appreciate in value, the
- 52:57extension of that is you will the people the things that you
- 53:00want people will demand Bitcoin for them and you can't just,
- 53:05yeah, I know you're jumped in. They're not going to take
- 53:08partial shares of the BlackRock ETF like you're not.
- 53:10No, they won't. Jesse, I'll I'll throw to you
- 53:13but but after that Marty would love to hear kind of your big
- 53:16takeaways, said we weren't able to make it down to Nashville.
- 53:19Would love to hear kind of like some of the talks yesterday or
- 53:22like some what are the announcements that are notable.
- 53:26Yeah, let's go to that. That's been a great event and I
- 53:30mean getting them in person at these events, whether it's the
- 53:33Nashville summits that they have here, the takeover events we
- 53:37have in Austin, many conferences around the world, it's great.
- 53:41Getting together, the Bitcoiners are actually heads down
- 53:43building. A lot of people believe that
- 53:46there's really nothing being built on Bitcoin, but once you
- 53:49come to these events, it's hard to to actually go out and say
- 53:54that earnestly because it's obvious that there's a ton of
- 53:57building going on. And so this Summit again is
- 53:59particularly focused on the Lightning Network.
- 54:01So it's a bunch of developers building wallet software,
- 54:03building products that that leverage Lightning, and I think
- 54:09for me. The big theme, I mean, I
- 54:12moderated the panel, so I'm a bit biased in terms of probably
- 54:16my favorite discussion. But I I did a panel on Lightning
- 54:20and AI with Paul Toy from Stack Work, OB from Fetty, and Jack
- 54:25Mowler's from Strike yesterday. And I think again, this is going
- 54:30back to the point I just made earlier, like you're going to
- 54:33need to actually use Bitcoin and spend Bitcoin I think over.
- 54:37The Lightning network, particularly at some point in
- 54:40the future and the convergence of Bitcoin in AI is happening in
- 54:45real time. And so that's actually one thing
- 54:48we really touched on the panel was last week Lightning Labs
- 54:53announced that they had an L402 implementation in Lang Chain,
- 55:00which is a very popular AI developer kit.
- 55:05And tool that is being used. And so we're basically at the
- 55:10beginning stages of the lightning that we're getting
- 55:13integrated with artificial intelligence companies and I
- 55:17think this is going to be massive Bitcoin particularly
- 55:19over the lightning network solves a massive problem or many
- 55:24massive problems that AI companies have #1 like like
- 55:30chargeback risk right now if you go to mid journey you go to
- 55:32ChatGPT. And you're you're paying a
- 55:36monthly fee for access to their models and to their to their AI
- 55:42agents, whatever it may be. And you pay monthly fee.
- 55:46A lot of people are paying with credit cards and a lot of people
- 55:49are charging back that. So there's massive chargeback
- 55:51risk that exists for these companies and it's particularly
- 55:55a big risk for them because on the back end, due to the energy
- 55:58intensity of the Gpu's, there's a lot of capital expense expense
- 56:02on that side of things. So they have to make sure.
- 56:04There's capital efficient as possible from business
- 56:06perspective and so like what Lightning Labs just released,
- 56:10makes it extremely easy for these artificial intelligence
- 56:14companies to create paywall gated API access using Bitcoin
- 56:18lightning network. So if an individual like myself,
- 56:20if I get a mid journey I want an image instead of paying a
- 56:23monthly fee with a credit card. Every time I want to produce an
- 56:27image using mid journeys models I get a I get a lightning
- 56:33invoice. Likely will automatically be
- 56:36paid. I'll probably set an allowance
- 56:38on mid journey like hey pay any invoice that gets sent to me up
- 56:41to this limit. And so like every time I ping
- 56:44their API to get an image, I'll pay them a little bit of
- 56:46Bitcoin. That's one way in which it'll be
- 56:49implemented in the AI world. The other way which stack work,
- 56:52which we're invested in at 1031. They've been at this for years,
- 56:56but it also helps AI companies actually build these large
- 56:59language models because it enables.
- 57:02Companies like Stackwork to pay global workforce to add data to
- 57:05their models because they can pay people in Southeast Asia and
- 57:10Latin America and Africa very small amounts of money using the
- 57:16lightning network in Bitcoin globally.
- 57:19Since it's international currency like Larry Fink seems
- 57:23to grok right now and since it's very low fee and since anybody
- 57:29can download a wallet on their. On their cell phone it's very
- 57:33easy to pay global distributed workforce to help you build your
- 57:37large language model. And so long winded way of saying
- 57:40yesterday, I think the Bitcoin in AI the lightning in AI panel
- 57:47is very high signal because it's very early on in this trend and
- 57:50I think when we talk about like Bitcoin usage the.
- 57:56The amount of usage that is just gonna be used from machine to
- 57:59machine, like these AI agents just going out with Bitcoin
- 58:02allowances, the complete task on the Internet.
- 58:05Like you can make a very easy argument that actually in the
- 58:08future the most transactions on the Lightning Network will be
- 58:12conducted by AI agents. And so, yeah, I think that's
- 58:16that's a trend that nobody seems like rock right now.
- 58:19Absolutely. And I think that tour tour to
- 58:22Mr. Just went on Preston's podcast and and made the case
- 58:25that. That right now is the 1995
- 58:29moment for Bitcoin, meaning that, you know, 1995 was kind of
- 58:33the the hockey stick moment for Internet adoption.
- 58:38And you know, if you zoom out just a little bit of the few
- 58:43things we've talked about here, AIAI using Bitcoin as its
- 58:48preferred currency because it's native to the Internet.
- 58:50That's Jack Dorsey's whole argument that's happening now.
- 58:56A couple other data points are are big at this moment in time
- 58:59for Bitcoin adoption, those being the rise of bricks.
- 59:06The BRICS countries just announced that they're going to
- 59:08have a gold backed currency and that's going to compete with the
- 59:12US dollar and that means the US dollar hegemony is eroding, hard
- 59:18assets are back on the International Monetary stage,
- 59:22that being gold with. Gold being held by China and
- 59:26you're trusting China and they're reporting and and
- 59:32honesty about what they're holding and and your ability to
- 59:35get it back. And of course that contrasts
- 59:40with Bitcoin where you don't have to trust a a nation state
- 59:46to hold your gold. With Bitcoin you can take self
- 59:48custody and control it yourself. So that's happening.
- 59:53And and then finally, Wall Street.
- 59:56BlackRock, the most important capital allocator in the world
- 1:00:00has gone from creating a narrative in you know in
- 1:00:05mainstream media. Pushing a narrative in
- 1:00:07mainstream media that Bitcoin is bad for the world, bad for the
- 1:00:10environment, bad for, you know, harboring and and enabling
- 1:00:14criminals. And now suddenly in the last
- 1:00:18month if you look through the. Headlines about Bitcoin in in
- 1:00:23Forbes It It's all positive. All of it is positive.
- 1:00:27Now it's all about how Bitcoin is good for the environment
- 1:00:30because it reduces emissions. What?
- 1:00:32Bitcoin is what people like Marty have been saying for
- 1:00:34years, and the mainstream media has been actively gaslighting
- 1:00:40the world about to convince them otherwise.
- 1:00:43But now BlackRock is aligning itself with Bitcoin and so now
- 1:00:47they're saying the same positive things.
- 1:00:52And that it's actually not a haven for criminals and in fact
- 1:00:54it empowers people in developing countries to have savings
- 1:00:58accounts who otherwise would be unbanked.
- 1:01:00Bitcoin is good for the world. So those three forces have are
- 1:01:03happening right now and they weren't happening last cycle a I
- 1:01:07and Bitcoin the the the changing monetary world order of the
- 1:01:14dollars on the way out is it going to are you going to trust
- 1:01:17your. Money in gold currency that's
- 1:01:21controlled by China or you going to trust a hard asset that lives
- 1:01:26on the Internet and you can take self custody of and now Wall
- 1:01:30Street's an ally for Bitcoin. This could be our 1995 moment
- 1:01:35for the Internet of value in the same way that we all saw how
- 1:01:38that played out for the Internet of information.
- 1:01:43You jump and I do want to make one more point about the
- 1:01:46Bitcoin, the lightning and a I convergence that Paul made on
- 1:01:49the panel last night that I really never thought of, is that
- 1:01:54you need privacy when calling on these large language models,
- 1:01:58especially if you're a corporation or a company.
- 1:02:00And if you are, you have an account with Open or chat GB T
- 1:02:06with open A I. And you put your credit card
- 1:02:08information there and like you're they know what you're
- 1:02:12what you're searching like they they can get some inside
- 1:02:15information of like how you're thinking about your business.
- 1:02:18And so these companies from A, from A, B to B perspective,
- 1:02:22companies that want to leverage A, I tools, they need a degree
- 1:02:25of privacy and the lightning network provides that for them.
- 1:02:27If you can just pay an invoice over the lightning network
- 1:02:31without having to put in any personal.
- 1:02:33Identifying information like that is actually a massive
- 1:02:36unlock for corporations being able to to have some sense of
- 1:02:39privacy when leveraging these AI tools to make their businesses
- 1:02:43better. Yeah, no, that it's fascinating.
- 1:02:47You know, we talk about it a lot, you know, inside
- 1:02:51conversations about just how exciting like Bitcoin and AI and
- 1:02:54where that's going or the world's going with like emerging
- 1:02:58technologies. Part of the goal for this show
- 1:03:00is in. We've started to do it, but it's
- 1:03:03like really bringing to light the overlap of Bitcoin with
- 1:03:08existing market structure technologies and then also
- 1:03:11innovative net new technologies that to just a point need a
- 1:03:15native currency. So I think that'll be a broader
- 1:03:19focus as we like. Week over week, find experts and
- 1:03:23be able to talk about like what does AI mean or Bitcoin and AI,
- 1:03:26whether it's like music, whether it's data search, Marty's Point
- 1:03:29privacy and like B to BI think there's going to be a lot of
- 1:03:33money to be made in these segments and they're going to
- 1:03:36look very different as we've talked about with the the market
- 1:03:39structure of like Bitcoin custody and how like financial
- 1:03:42services will look, just because it's so different than the
- 1:03:45traditional world being a lot of these.
- 1:03:47The new companies, the way they're formed will look very
- 1:03:51different. And so part of the goal for for
- 1:03:53us is to like kind of bring them to surface and have discussions
- 1:03:56around it. These, the landscape over the
- 1:04:00next decade is very exciting and there's a lot of opportunity
- 1:04:03outside of just like holding the spot underlying asset, but the
- 1:04:07infrastructure or for like individuals with businesses that
- 1:04:11are trying to get ahead of curves of where the market's
- 1:04:13changing things that are happening.
- 1:04:16Strikes working on it and others when it comes to interchange and
- 1:04:19remittances and what does that look like using lightning.
- 1:04:22But there's no shortage of different applications that'll
- 1:04:23be built out. And so we can kind of figure out
- 1:04:26a way in the format to really showcase that.
- 1:04:29I think there'll be a lot of like value for us to discuss,
- 1:04:31but then also from the external market to glean from it.
- 1:04:37Yeah. It's happening, It's happening
- 1:04:41gentlemen and anybody listening is just getting exposed to
- 1:04:45Bitcoin. Again, I do want to stress you
- 1:04:47may not want to use Bitcoin transactionally or like leverage
- 1:04:52it at the payments network. Quite.
- 1:04:54Yeah. You may view it solely as a
- 1:04:56savings vehicle And I I actually think that's probably likely the
- 1:05:01smartest move at this point of Bitcoin's monetization phase is
- 1:05:04to view it as a savings vehicle and sit on it as.
- 1:05:08It appreciates some value over time.
- 1:05:10However, the decisions you make today will determine whether or
- 1:05:15not you're able to leverage Bitcoin to its full extent in
- 1:05:18the future. So when you're trying to figure
- 1:05:21out how to get exposure, if you're not comfortable taking
- 1:05:25possession of Bitcoin now, buying an exchange, sending it
- 1:05:28to a wallet that you control, we're not comfortable with that
- 1:05:30now, and you're basing your decisions off of that.
- 1:05:33Make sure you make the right decision that allows you.
- 1:05:36To have that option in the future when you are going to
- 1:05:39want to leverage the utility that's being provided at the
- 1:05:42different layers of the stack. One thing is we were talking
- 1:05:45about I just mentioned innovative stuff, but also how
- 1:05:47things aren't innovative cuz it feels like a way.
- 1:05:50And whenever the cycle happens, it's gonna be crypto and AI and
- 1:05:53you're gonna have to rehash why you don't need a new token for
- 1:05:58AI for everything. And so I just think that's part
- 1:06:00of this as well as explaining that so people can share with
- 1:06:03their network and then go let the trap.
- 1:06:06I mean, I highly recommend Logan if you want to pull up that
- 1:06:09tweet from Lalu again, like go, we'll, we'll link to this in the
- 1:06:13show notes. Go read the the blog post from
- 1:06:17Lightning Labs, it's in the quote tweet that Lalu sent out.
- 1:06:20And I actually think Bitcoin's going to have an advantage to
- 1:06:23cycle, particularly around the Lightning and AI because of the
- 1:06:30dev tooling. And that's been built to date
- 1:06:33and the fact again, this is L 402, so this is compatible with
- 1:06:37the HTTP stack like it's HTTP 402 compatible what Lightning
- 1:06:43Labs has built. And so I think from a dev
- 1:06:46tooling perspective, what Lightning Labs has built has a
- 1:06:50massive advantage over any upstart crypto token that wants
- 1:06:55to claim they can do AI better like that this is literally
- 1:06:58native to the HTTP protocol. What Lightning labs that build,
- 1:07:02and it's gonna be much easier to plug this in, to plug the
- 1:07:05Lightning Network in to these applications opposed to like
- 1:07:09creating a token and trying to like, smash it on onto AI.
- 1:07:16Yep. Here's hoping this is 1995.
- 1:07:22Let's do it. Gentlemen.
- 1:07:23Sorry I was late today. I must apologize, but it was a
- 1:07:27tight rip. It was a good one.
- 1:07:30Yeah, it was fun. No problem at all.
- 1:07:32We'll we'll we'll give our absent guest a ribbon next time.
- 1:07:38We will and we will, we will be back next week.
- 1:07:44Michael anything, anything to ended on.
- 1:07:47I was just gonna say Logan's our our 4th guest.
- 1:07:50Oh yeah, Logan do you have any any alpha to provide the
- 1:07:53listeners out there so much but I'm.
- 1:07:56Gonna keep it all a secret. I'll get it out of.
- 1:08:01We'll get out of Logan one day. All right.
- 1:08:04We'll see you guys next week. Awesome.
- 1:08:07Thanks guys.