Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E039: Institutionalizing Bitcoin with KPMG
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35Custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation as we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class. We are having all annual
- 1:18maintenance fees for clients that secure their wealth before
- 1:21the next Bitcoin epoch. What you're telling me is that
- 1:25music is about to stop and we're going to be left holding the
- 1:29biggest bag. Of odorous excrement.
- 1:31Ever assembled in the history. Of.
- 1:34Doctors. 1970. 4. 198792972000 and.
- 1:41Whatever we want to call this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:43over and over. We can't.
- 1:44Help ourselves. I say when we sell, I say when
- 1:51we sell. And we're live.
- 1:56Gentlemen, San Juan Brian, welcome to the last straight.
- 2:01Thank you for joining us. Thanks for having us.
- 2:04Thank. You.
- 2:05Well, you guys are doing some pretty important things at KPMG
- 2:08that we're going to talk about. I think this is a really
- 2:10exciting episode for us because we operate in the world of
- 2:15Bitcoin predominantly thinking about what we can do to push the
- 2:19edges of the technology, leveraging things like multi sig
- 2:22to make sure people are custodying their Bitcoin the
- 2:25right way. And you guys are sort of a
- 2:27bridge between the world that we're in and the traditional
- 2:30world, particularly with auditing, consulting.
- 2:34And you guys have dove deep into Bitcoin, particularly writing a
- 2:38piece highlighting that Bitcoin is ESG A compliant.
- 2:44And if you are interested in pushing an ESG future into the
- 2:49world, you should be leaning into Bitcoin.
- 2:52Before we jump into that particular research report that
- 2:55KPMG put out, just learn a little bit about yourselves.
- 2:59How did you find Bitcoin and how did you find yourselves working
- 3:03on these particular teams within KPMG focus on this industry?
- 3:08Yes, I guess I'll go first in Quan.
- 3:09So Brian, consalvo, I'm a partner with KPMG.
- 3:12I'm in our technology risk practice.
- 3:15I think if I go back to when I first heard about Bitcoin and my
- 3:20my path was not unsimilar to others, I'd probably say it was
- 3:24pretty late in, you know, 2017 until I finally actually started
- 3:28to hear about it should obviously been around what,
- 3:31eight years or so by then, which is kind of hard to believe.
- 3:33But I I I was very, very quick to dismiss it when I first heard
- 3:37about it. It definitely seemed very scammy
- 3:41on the surface. I kind of equated it with, you
- 3:44know, gamers who were just trying to create this own
- 3:47currency, which is obviously not even true.
- 3:49So I mean, I fell victim to some of the misconceptions that
- 3:52people immediately have when they hear about cryptocurrencies
- 3:55in general. And then it wasn't until
- 3:57probably 2019 or so I was at a training and sitting with some
- 4:01guys that I work with and they were talking about it.
- 4:04And I kind of just revisit, I guess I just had a sort of a
- 4:07different lens. I looked at it from and I was
- 4:10like, OK, if this is still around like this is obviously
- 4:12maybe there's some substance here.
- 4:14And I think that's when I went down the rabbit hole.
- 4:16And, you know, I'd say the rest is history.
- 4:21Yeah. And I started my finance and
- 4:24accounting career 25 years ago, right, duringthe.com boom.
- 4:29And then after that downturn ended up in housing finance.
- 4:32And so it's got to experience the housing boom, the great
- 4:36financial crisis, the aftermath and the reactions to it.
- 4:39So during those experiences trying to learn and about what
- 4:42was going on and filling my gaps to my knowledge and what I was
- 4:45seeing day-to-day and the policies related to how to react
- 4:49to that got more interested in just broader monetary and fiscal
- 4:53policies out there and what would be a potential solution
- 4:56for this in the long term. And 1st R ving about Bitcoin, it
- 5:00first came out now at at the time it first came out pretty
- 5:04early as still we're still right in the aftermath of the great
- 5:07financial crisis. You know it seemed like a hobby
- 5:10thing on the side. It was interesting but never
- 5:12would have expected within 10 years to see so much growth in
- 5:16it didn't really get more involved until much later,
- 5:20especially after you know a lot of it was really difficult as
- 5:24you as you you guys know to buy and sell Bitcoin.
- 5:29It was really difficult to do that.
- 5:30The exchanges didn't really exist early on.
- 5:32You had to mine it, but lately last several years, especially
- 5:36in 2019-2020, got more interested in and see its
- 5:38potential for the topics that I was looking into during the
- 5:42great financial crisis. And I think considering the
- 5:48prowess that KPMG has an accounting might be good to
- 5:51touch on Bitcoin generally as an innovation in the realm of
- 5:57accounting. Is it?
- 5:58How do you guys see what the open Ledger brings to the world
- 6:03of accounting? Well, I think it's, I think it's
- 6:07difficult to make the, the correlation just from the
- 6:09standpoint of it being a distributed Ledger, right.
- 6:14But if I just think about the work that we do under the
- 6:16accounting lens when we're auditing companies financial
- 6:20statements, it does make it somewhat easier to audit
- 6:24something that's publicly available.
- 6:26So when you have these decentralized ledgers, things
- 6:28like Bitcoin, it's much easier to go out there and have
- 6:31assurances over that immutable Ledger versus a company systems
- 6:35that can be manipulated by individuals.
- 6:39But I think when we look at kind of where KPMG fits in thinking
- 6:42about some of the the core services that we have like
- 6:45audit, tax, advisory that sort of thing, you know we we
- 6:48actually audit some of the public companies in this space.
- 6:52You know one of the big things that we're going to be tasked
- 6:54with doing and we have been is actually verifying assets that
- 6:59are under custody. And I think that introduces some
- 7:02new complexities, number of things that the audit world has
- 7:05not, has not seen before. And it wasn't until probably,
- 7:10I'd say the last four or five years where some of these
- 7:13companies in the crypto ecosystem started to go public
- 7:16that they then started to undergo financial reporting,
- 7:20audits and things that have to adhere to something called
- 7:23SOCKS, which is basically a controls audit that public
- 7:28companies have to to undergo on an annual basis.
- 7:32Yeah, it's fascinating. I mean and at 10:31 we have a
- 7:35portfolio company Hoseki that is partnering with Bitwise to
- 7:41verify their on chain assets. And so there is the ability to
- 7:46verify that you actually own Bitcoin in particular wallets
- 7:48via signing a message that says you own the private key to that
- 7:52that public address. And it'll be really interesting
- 7:55to see how it plays out like do these third party solutions like
- 7:59Hoseki come to market that help these companies verify.
- 8:02Then the whole discussion. Jesse, I'm freaking jump in.
- 8:05Like what proof of reserves? Like how can you actually prove
- 8:07the reserves and not the liabilities?
- 8:10Yeah, just I I find it so interesting how, you know
- 8:15different cohorts of people come to Bitcoin faster or slower
- 8:20depending on like the subject matter that they're familiar
- 8:22with in their in their career. And and I've noticed it.
- 8:26So I have an accounting background.
- 8:29I got a masters in accounting never never went into you know
- 8:33BIG4 accounting after that. But I've noticed that
- 8:39accountants seem to get Bitcoin or or be interested in Bitcoin a
- 8:43little bit faster than than the average person.
- 8:46And I think for me it was, it was part of partly a fascination
- 8:49of like oh wow, you can. This thing is designed to have a
- 8:53a complete audit every 10 minutes automatically And like
- 8:57that's just you know you you spend spend all this time in
- 9:00accounting class learning about all the steps that are necessary
- 9:03to to try to get some precision around you know accounting
- 9:07numbers for for public or private companies.
- 9:11And here's this thing that can help so much by providing this
- 9:15this different structure that enforces an audit every 10
- 9:19minutes. And I think, I think that's you
- 9:21know there's Pierre Rashard, Robert Breedlove, Cedric
- 9:28Youngman, bunch of other accounting background
- 9:31bitcoiners. And I think that's part of I
- 9:34think accountants have a slight leg up in getting to in seeing
- 9:37the the potential of Bitcoin sooner than other folks because
- 9:42of what they deal with on a day-to-day basis.
- 9:45Yeah, I think a lot of people that I've interacted with at
- 9:49KPMG definitely get it right. Like they understand the
- 9:52technology, they understand how to audit it, they understand all
- 9:57of the nuances and complexities that come with it.
- 9:59Now where where it becomes a whole entirely different story
- 10:02is whether or not they believe in it as it actually solving A
- 10:06fundamental problem, which is why it was created in the first
- 10:08place. But I think just by being
- 10:11accounting experts, one of the things that you know anyone at
- 10:14any BIG4 is going to be responsible to do is actually
- 10:17understand these things. Because if their clients are
- 10:19going to be transacting with crypto, if they're going to be
- 10:23holding on their balance sheet, etcetera, they're going to need
- 10:25to know how to audit. It and I think the point about
- 10:29going more fundamental as you know like accounting one of the
- 10:33big innovations hundreds of years ago during the Renaissance
- 10:35of the double entry bookkeeping, you have two parties there and
- 10:39then the idea behind double entry bookkeeping is every
- 10:42transaction has a interaction with the balance sheet and
- 10:45income statement. So you can track who owns what
- 10:48right and that is it Equity is a debt, so that for every asset,
- 10:52right. And then I've heard the
- 10:54blockchain or Bitcoin specifically also described as
- 10:57triple entry bookkeeping and I'm like what I've never learned
- 11:00that in school what triple entry bookkeeping meant.
- 11:02But I think the the concept there is that you have two
- 11:05parties they do a transaction and you have this third party
- 11:09that in more traditional finance you have to hire to confirm that
- 11:13that transaction's legitimate right.
- 11:15But in with the blockchain or or Bitcoin you have these you could
- 11:18even be anonymous that other people are verifying that that
- 11:21transaction's legitimate. So you got a three party system
- 11:23already pre built and how it's designed and it it doesn't
- 11:27require that you hiring a third party that you trust and write a
- 11:30report to say this is a legitimate transaction.
- 11:32So I think that I think that's where they 2 interact and that's
- 11:36probably why you also hear some people say maybe the blockchain
- 11:39technology also has the long term legs that could impact
- 11:42finance and and banking and other industries.
- 11:46Perfect summary, well articulated that I agree that
- 11:50the triple entry bookkeeping phrase that you hear bandied
- 11:54around is a little bit hand WAVY, but at the at the core
- 11:58there is something you know that is the special sauce of like
- 12:01having a third party who's necessarily verifying the the
- 12:08double entry accounting that is going on.
- 12:14Yeah, working with alien technology.
- 12:19You guys are are learning how to deal with this too and
- 12:21incorporate. I guess that's another
- 12:23interesting topic we can talk about before we dive into
- 12:26bitcoins. Role in the ESG imperative is
- 12:30how do you see Bitcoin maybe not disrupting but being
- 12:35incorporated into what you guys do at KPMG?
- 12:40So if at all I yeah, no, it's a good question.
- 12:43I think a lot of that will be driven by how much adoption we
- 12:46see from from clients, right. Like at the end of the day, what
- 12:50our clients start to do and what they plan to do will drive where
- 12:54KPMG and other consulting like firms decide to upskill their
- 12:58own employees and where we see the opportunity.
- 13:02So I think it's really driven by the companies themselves in
- 13:04terms of where KPMG starts to play.
- 13:10And and on what Sung Kwan was saying about, yeah, the the
- 13:15double entry bookkeeping occurred in the in the
- 13:17Renaissance. And and I remember from
- 13:20accounting classes probably an accountant's indulgence of
- 13:24claiming that a good part of the economic boom of the Renaissance
- 13:28was fueled by this innovation in in accounting that enables
- 13:34business on a larger scale and a more like a more professional
- 13:42scale than than was previously possible.
- 13:45So you know, like accountants I think have a reasonable claim to
- 13:49say that that innovations in accounting enable a renaissance
- 13:55and we might be seeing some additional renaissance unfold as
- 14:00a result of the innovation that that comes from triple entry
- 14:04bookkeeping and what that enables for business globally.
- 14:09Yeah, I think to that point on historical aspect of the global
- 14:12adoption and how accounting helps with that, modern
- 14:16accounting could trace its roots back to the the railroad boom
- 14:191800s. The reason why is he had all
- 14:22these foreign investors like Europeans funding companies that
- 14:27were doing business in the United States which was a growth
- 14:29country at the time. Right there was the developing
- 14:31world that's considered developing world back then.
- 14:33And so you needed it to have accounting statements that
- 14:37accurately reflect balance sheets and income statements and
- 14:41cash flows as well to look into that.
- 14:44And so I I think with your point about Bitcoin and other
- 14:47technologies is how do you help with cross-border global type of
- 14:52trade transaction and investments and have trusted
- 14:55reports that you can rely on to make business decision,
- 14:59investment decision even to even know like if you're making a
- 15:02return or not because you can imagine even back then invest
- 15:05all this money into something, how do you know you're actually
- 15:07getting a return. So I think that's that's part of
- 15:11the long history of accounting and and and blockchain could be
- 15:15a big part of that future. Real quick before the the report
- 15:21Marty's question about getting involved in Brian, your response
- 15:24about the companies will dictate like I would imagine
- 15:27historically look like somebody looking at a Coinbase and
- 15:32diligence in consulting looking at like them as a counterparty
- 15:34is a big part of the business. But I'm actually curious on the
- 15:37other side of it, if you guys think about external parties or
- 15:41companies looking at firms to get best practices on like
- 15:45bringing custody in house rather than going external.
- 15:48If you have a sizable allocation it starts to be get become
- 15:51meaningful. It's like maybe I don't have a
- 15:52counterparty that sits I think about custody because it's
- 15:54technology and I can you know think about best practices or
- 15:57cross-border or other angles around this technology.
- 16:00Do you guys see any of that or how do you think about that and
- 16:03preparing for it? Because I would imagine that's
- 16:05where a large part of the market goes, where you know every
- 16:08company you know we talk about becomes a Bitcoin company in the
- 16:11sense you have to start to incorporate some of this
- 16:12technology just because it's a better form of technology for
- 16:15cross-border treasury, whatever it is.
- 16:18Do you see any of that or have any thoughts about like how you
- 16:19prepare for that? So I would say in terms of
- 16:23bringing custody in house or using third party custodians,
- 16:26I'd say that's somewhat of a nuanced kind of view at the
- 16:29moment. Again, I think if we start to
- 16:31see a significant amount of adoption going forward in terms
- 16:34of corporate splitting on the balance sheet, more companies
- 16:37starting to transact in crypto and then custody becoming an
- 16:40even bigger topic than it already is.
- 16:42And yeah, I mean that that certainly could be something
- 16:44that we start to take a position on and something that could be
- 16:47kind of incorporated into certain engagements that we
- 16:50deliver. I guess one area that I think
- 16:52about that that would become pretty relevant is some of the
- 16:57due diligence engagements that we do that could be something
- 17:01that we evaluate and I know we've we've even helped company
- 17:05evaluate certain custodians in in general.
- 17:09So kind of like a vendor assessment.
- 17:11So I think that's something that we could we could definitely do
- 17:14and maybe something to a degree that we're already doing.
- 17:17But in terms of that being like a core service, I think that's
- 17:19where you know, we would just have to wait and see.
- 17:24Yeah, yeah. It's valuable.
- 17:25It's valuable information, if you can advise correctly on
- 17:28that, because as we've seen throughout Bitcoin's history,
- 17:31there are some that do it right and some that that do.
- 17:33Not, yeah, I think. I think the big thing too.
- 17:36And and this is probably something we'll we'll get into
- 17:39at some point is I I still just think there's so many people out
- 17:42there and so many companies that if they were to get into crypto
- 17:46somehow, I just don't think there's a huge appetite for a
- 17:50lot of these people and a lot of these companies to to do self
- 17:53custody. Now my hope is that that changes
- 17:56over time. I do think that sort of the
- 17:58ethos of Bitcoin is that you are self sovereign, you're you're
- 18:01custodying the assets and you're removing any counterparty risk.
- 18:05But I think the way it's currently structured today, I
- 18:07mean I remember when I first took custody of my own assets,
- 18:11like it was kind of daunting. And I and I think about people
- 18:15right now that, you know, take my parents for example.
- 18:18Like I don't think, I can't even begin to think about trying to
- 18:20explain maintaining your seed phrase and and all that to them
- 18:25and have them feeling comfortable doing it.
- 18:27So I think hopefully, again that will evolve.
- 18:30I think it's going to be something where the next
- 18:32generation, maybe it becomes more inherent to them and
- 18:35something that is just second nature.
- 18:38But I think where we're at right now, I do think it's still so
- 18:41early that there's just people that when they finally take that
- 18:44leap and if they do start to buy any Bitcoin or any other cryptos
- 18:50that they're just going to feel much more comfortable keeping it
- 18:53on on exchange. And I think that's just the
- 18:55reality of of where we are right now.
- 18:58Yeah. And I I mainly bring it up
- 18:59because it's been in previous discussions like Bitcoin's
- 19:03obviously very emergent. So us as individuals are the 1st
- 19:05to take self custody and there's been a proliferation of
- 19:08collaborative custody partners where people can participate.
- 19:10But whether it's us as individuals running big
- 19:13companies or it becoming pretty obvious like and without naming
- 19:17the name, there's a company out there that holds a lot of
- 19:19Bitcoin. Yeah, who better who better to
- 19:21trust or at least participate in that trust than the entity
- 19:25that's holding that versus an external party solely?
- 19:29And so it just seems like a logical progression.
- 19:31As education grows, it would go in that direction.
- 19:35Yeah, I and I, I definitely think that we need more
- 19:39custodians out there, whether it's collaborative custody type
- 19:42solutions like you just mentioned, Mike, or even
- 19:44centralized custodians that we have today.
- 19:46Because you're right, there is one primary one out there and
- 19:51the more that grows the more centralization risk we start to,
- 19:55we start to see. So hopefully that will start to
- 19:57evolve over time. Nation states, I was just going
- 20:03to say nation states as well. We got Latin African kind of
- 20:05rolling Bitcoin sitting in North American or potentially North
- 20:08American just like a lot of cognitive dissonance on like
- 20:11where the asset sits versus their stance on that.
- 20:14So you I I would imagine you start seeing the entity
- 20:15participate more and more in the governance effectively in on
- 20:19chain, yeah. Yeah.
- 20:21It'll be interesting to see if this, how this pans out.
- 20:25The idea of self custody is just so difficult I think in the
- 20:28world of traditional finance because you take a company today
- 20:32even the cash on their balance sheet, they don't self custody
- 20:34that cash, they don't have piles of cash in a room.
- 20:37It's it's held at another entity, it's an obligation to
- 20:39the other entity of the securities that they have pretty
- 20:42much any financial asset, it's effectively being held by
- 20:46someone else on on their behalf And so it's an obligation,
- 20:49right. So the idea of getting into some
- 20:51custody that you actually own the asset and control it without
- 20:54the need of somebody custodying it for you is, is a foreign
- 20:57concept. So I think it's a very difficult
- 21:00leap to say hey, not only get exposure to Bitcoin, let's say
- 21:04as a treasury asset, but late you should self custody it as
- 21:06well. I think Brian's probably right
- 21:08that the more likely middle ground is that they'll rely on
- 21:11custodians. For them, it's a little bit
- 21:13closer to what they're familiar with today.
- 21:15When somebody holds cash on their behalf, for example, Yeah.
- 21:20And and obviously this is what we've been so focused on at on
- 21:23ramp the last 18 months of building out like another
- 21:28version, another model of you know multi institution custody
- 21:33where where where we believe that it it preserves some of the
- 21:37attractive benefits of self custody namely that the end user
- 21:42retains control without you know handing over coins to a third
- 21:48party custodian. But it fits in with the model
- 21:52that entities and most individuals frankly are used to
- 21:57of you know not having to take full responsibility for how
- 22:02they're setting up and maintaining their own custody
- 22:05set up and instead interfacing with with a portal to their
- 22:11coins that you know feels familiar.
- 22:14It's a it's a legal relationship with the business even though
- 22:19that business doesn't have you know unilateral control of their
- 22:22coins. It's you know and and that's the
- 22:25way that it retains some of the attractive benefits of self
- 22:28custody. So there's you know it's it's
- 22:30obviously still early days for for custody for this type of
- 22:35asset class and and it's very exciting to be a part of
- 22:39building out these solutions that are better tailored to
- 22:42where businesses are at in terms of what they're used to their
- 22:46their competences, their their capabilities.
- 22:50You know most businesses are just simply not ready to set up
- 22:54self custody because who's going to hold the keys and how you
- 22:56going to manage that. That's a that's a gigantic
- 22:59hurdle, a whole learning curve to to get up in order to take on
- 23:05self custody. But it's possible with this
- 23:07model, multi institution custody to preserve the benefits of
- 23:13custody without having to spin up.
- 23:15You know a giant organizational leap in terms of how you're
- 23:21approaching your own treasury and security around that.
- 23:24I guess the thought experiment really stems from like Google
- 23:27and Apple. If they decide they want a
- 23:28sizable position, why wouldn't they just get a couple engineers
- 23:31to figure it out? Like, I mean logical progression
- 23:34to figure it out themselves are the smartest people in the world
- 23:36versus sending it across, you know, through the Coinbase and
- 23:39like you guys figure out. It's like we probably have
- 23:40smarter people to do this. We already have an example of
- 23:42this with Tesla. They forked BTC pay server.
- 23:45Yeah. Exactly.
- 23:49Yeah, that's right. That's why I like I I also
- 23:52actually anchor to there will be first principles thinkers that
- 23:54will only actually take sizable positions in a format like this
- 23:58because they will take the position that I can't give up
- 24:00unilateral control. It's like, if you think about us
- 24:02as individuals, I think about my own journey and only being able
- 24:05to have a sizable material position if I could anchor the
- 24:07keys to the real world and know that they don't get up and walk
- 24:10away and plug themselves in. So that same concept starts to
- 24:13grow from like 1 to 2% to 10%. You have to start thinking about
- 24:16like actually how do I make sure that this doesn't end up, you
- 24:19know, in a landfill or, you know, hacked.
- 24:21And so that's how you start to get to these like concepts we're
- 24:23talking about that generally seem foreign at first.
- 24:26But over time, you start looking at this thing and realizing, OK,
- 24:29like this is a different asset. So now I have to treat it
- 24:31differently from a pure custody perspective.
- 24:36Yeah, it's fascinating because we just spent the 1st 20 minutes
- 24:38of this conversation highly focus on the custody aspect of
- 24:42Bitcoin. But there's it's multivariate,
- 24:45it's dynamic. We could spend 3 hours talking
- 24:48about custody alone, but then you have the other parts of the
- 24:51network and particularly what you guys focused on in your
- 24:54report, which is mining, which is where the physical world
- 24:59really connects with Bitcoin in the digital world that that it's
- 25:02providing us. It's very energy intensive.
- 25:06I I've been in the mining industry for six years now.
- 25:08It is one of the most masochistic industries on the
- 25:13planet. I believe it's highly
- 25:15competitive. It's cutthroat, but it is
- 25:18invigorating because you have this intersection of the Bitcoin
- 25:22mining industry in the energy sector happening right in front
- 25:24of you and it's just infinitely fascinating.
- 25:27And yet there are many misconceptions about how Bitcoin
- 25:31plays in the world of industry. And I think the report that you
- 25:35guys put out, Brian, that you co-authored was really important
- 25:39because we've been fighting this energy consumption debate as a
- 25:46Bitcoin mining industry by ourselves for for some time now.
- 25:50And I think the report that you guys put out, particularly
- 25:53stamping KPM GS name on it, is a very strong arrow in the quiver
- 25:59in the narrative battle that we find ourselves in.
- 26:01And so I think transitioning to the ESG report, why did you feel
- 26:07compelled to write this particular report?
- 26:10And what about the mining industry made you comfortable
- 26:14putting your neck out there and putting KPM, GS name on this,
- 26:18saying that, hey, Bitcoin mining is actually an imperative if you
- 26:21care about ESG. Yeah.
- 26:24So I lead one of our emerging tech Co ES at KPMG.
- 26:28And so one of the things that we focused on for the past few
- 26:30years is, is just crypto in general.
- 26:33So that's kind of how I got into this space a little bit at least
- 26:37as it relates to KPMG. And then if I Fast forward is
- 26:41probably early in 2023 that I came up with the idea that, you
- 26:45know, there's I think the criticisms about Bitcoin mining
- 26:48are obviously well documented. And I just thought, look,
- 26:51there's there's a whole other side to this coin that no one
- 26:54seems to really be talking about.
- 26:55Obviously the Bitcoin miners are saying it and they're pounding
- 27:00the table, but there's probably a lot of people who just aren't
- 27:03really willing to listen. They probably view it as a a
- 27:05conflict of interest or you know, something to that effect.
- 27:09But there just seem to be a a growing list of benefits that
- 27:14Bitcoin mining offered in terms of, hey, look, this isn't just a
- 27:19matter of Bitcoin uses a lot of energy, which I think even that
- 27:24can be somewhat debatable. I mean, yes, it's it's energy
- 27:27intensive, but I mean what's what's a lot of energy?
- 27:30I mean, if you think about it, I think Bitcoin by most estimates
- 27:33are somewhere like 1/4 of 1% of global energy use.
- 27:37I would say that's pretty minuscule.
- 27:40And so then for us to be focusing our climate efforts on
- 27:44that, it just seems to be, I don't know, I I don't see a lot
- 27:47of value there. I mean, even if you just wiped
- 27:50Bitcoin mining off face of the Earth, I mean, in theory you
- 27:55didn't really save a whole lot. Now the other side of that is
- 27:58you'd probably be doing a disservice because as we caught
- 28:02out in the report, there's just a number of ways that I think
- 28:04Bitcoin mining is actually assisting with this, this
- 28:10climate issue that we're faced with.
- 28:12We can go through them. But I mean I think one of the
- 28:15biggest things that I think people really just don't
- 28:18recognize is when you think about all this renewable energy
- 28:20that we have, which I think renewable energy is in the
- 28:24United States about 15 ish percent of of energy production,
- 28:28which is a relatively low number.
- 28:30But then the other thing I always call out there is Bitcoin
- 28:33mining as a whole. It's estimated to be somewhere
- 28:36in the 50 to 55% range for renewable energy.
- 28:41So that what's that? That's nearly three, four times
- 28:45more renewable energy than the average mix we even have to
- 28:48begin with. I think that's pretty important
- 28:50detail that a lot of people seem to forget.
- 28:54And then you get into things like demand response, you get
- 28:57into the ability to mine with flared gas and methane from
- 29:00landfills. Those are pretty amazing
- 29:04examples of how Bitcoin is actually reducing the amount of
- 29:07greenhouse gases that get emitted.
- 29:10If you look at just flared gas and mining with methane from
- 29:13landfills. And I know that's not something
- 29:15that's really being done at a huge scale just yet, but methane
- 29:19is like 80 times more potent than carbon dioxide over a 20
- 29:24year period. So I think if we're going to
- 29:26look at ways to solve climate issues, like I think many
- 29:30experts have signaled that methane reduction or mitigation
- 29:34is one of the most important ways to do that.
- 29:36And I think there just seems to be numerous examples of where
- 29:39Bitcoin mining can fit in and actually help solve some of
- 29:43those problems. And I think we tried to do kind
- 29:46of a layman's explanation of that in the paper, going through
- 29:49some of those examples where it's being done, it's being done
- 29:52quite a bit in the United States.
- 29:53I mean, one thing I always call out too is the vast majority of
- 29:59Bitcoin mining domestically in the US is being done in Texas.
- 30:03Well, coincidentally, Texas is where the most renewable energy
- 30:07production is located. I don't think that's a
- 30:10coincidence. And I think when we get into the
- 30:13supply demand mismatch of these, you know, solar wind energy
- 30:18sources being intermittent and the fact that if we don't have a
- 30:23buyer at a certain point in the day and then demand may peak at
- 30:26a certain point in the day, there's a lot of waste energy
- 30:29that you can't just turn off a solar panel, you can't just turn
- 30:32off when wind turbines. That's one of the benefits of
- 30:37fossil fuel burning plants is it can scale up and down.
- 30:39So if you're going to have a transition to using more, you
- 30:45know, solar wind sources, I think you need to be able to
- 30:49find ways to to monetize that. And I think that's what Bitcoin
- 30:52miners have been able to do. Yeah, look, pull up that last
- 30:55chart again. I mean, Pierre, Richard from
- 30:58Riot was tweeting about this yesterday.
- 31:01Perfect segue to these charts, Brian, because if we look at the
- 31:05pricing throughout ERCOT yesterday and went negative
- 31:08because wind and solar production was extremely high
- 31:12throughout the day. And so for anybody out there is
- 31:15unaware of how Bitcoin mining helps solve this problem, if you
- 31:17have negative pricing, you're essentially on the hook for
- 31:20that. You just turn on a bunch of
- 31:22Bitcoin miners and use that electricity to mine Bitcoin and
- 31:25produce revenue instead of having to eat the negative
- 31:27pricing throughout the day. So it really fits uniquely in
- 31:34this arena to solve this particular problem.
- 31:36And then another thing like I, I think the amount of wind and
- 31:40solar that's come on here on the grid here in Texas has been
- 31:44immense over the last few years and that's highlighted some
- 31:48problems when when you, when you're overly dependent on these
- 31:51two sources. That's the beauty of Bitcoin
- 31:55mining as well because when you have negative pricing there,
- 31:57it's negative for natural gas, nuclear as well.
- 32:01And so you can put large mining operations behind the meter
- 32:05during these negative pricing events and just direct the
- 32:07electricity to the mining operation to create revenue.
- 32:11And so it has become abundantly, it's been clear to me for six
- 32:15years now. That's part of the reason why I
- 32:17joined Great American Mining. We were doing flare gas mining
- 32:21in the Bakken. And it's just like this, all
- 32:24this energy is being wasted, whether it's on grid or off
- 32:26grid, and it should be monetized.
- 32:28We want to make. I think the narrative should be
- 32:30we need abundant energy sources if we want to continue
- 32:34flourishing as a society globally.
- 32:39And with that in mind, we should just be as efficient with the
- 32:42energy that we're producing, whether it's off grid or on
- 32:45grid. And Bitcoin mining is uniquely
- 32:47suited. There is no other application
- 32:51that can solve these problems due to the fact that bitcoin's a
- 32:54distributed network and you can have downtime that's not going
- 32:58to disrupt. The rest of the network, which
- 33:01is cannot be said for any other application.
- 33:04Yeah, I think that's sort of plays into the demand response,
- 33:07Marty, right. Like and that's something that
- 33:10the average person and I put myself in that category prior to
- 33:12writing the paper, like really didn't have a good understanding
- 33:15of. Like, that's the challenge with
- 33:17understanding how Bitcoin fits into this is when you start
- 33:20looking at energy markets and things like that, like they're
- 33:23very complex, They're, you know, most people probably couldn't
- 33:25even tell you how their electricity is generated, where
- 33:27it's actually coming from. They take for granted the fact
- 33:30that they walk in their room, they turn on the lights, they
- 33:31turn on their stove, whatever it is and they have, they have
- 33:34energy. But I think, you know, and that
- 33:37last graph you pulled up, I mean you can see a very obvious peak
- 33:42throughout the day and then sudden decline in the evening
- 33:46for solar. Well, where's the rest of that
- 33:49energy going? That's where I think Bitcoin
- 33:51mining can fit in. I think the fact that miners are
- 33:53able to Co locate, I think that's the other big
- 33:56characteristic that the average person doesn't recognize like
- 33:58you can't do this with other industries.
- 34:00You can't have a hospital that just shuts off power because
- 34:03demand seems to be increasing throughout the day or some sort
- 34:07of other industrial plant. So I think they play a very
- 34:10important role just given that they're a flexible user of that
- 34:12energy and the fact that they are very price sensitive.
- 34:16This was a big theme for us out in the UAE or in the MENA region
- 34:20in general in Saudi Arabia, it was estimated there's a guy from
- 34:23Saudi Aramco that's running a venture firm out there.
- 34:26And I'll butcher these numbers, but directionally I think he
- 34:28said over the next 30 years they're supposed to add like 100
- 34:31gigawatts and a large percentage of that is going to be in
- 34:34renewables. It's just like a natural kind of
- 34:37skate valve for like Bitcoin mining.
- 34:38And they're already looking at it.
- 34:39And we've seen this like in Oman and Abu Dhabi, but that's just
- 34:43like one region of the world that will be, you know, looking
- 34:47for that kind of demand. Yeah, it it feels like, you
- 34:52know, Brian, Brian, you hit on such a core part of this
- 34:57misunderstanding just generally in the public.
- 34:59It's like people assume that their electricity is just a
- 35:01commodity and that it flows you know without without problems
- 35:06from from a plant thousands of miles away all the way across
- 35:11the country without any loss you know to plug in to wherever it's
- 35:15needed and and that's just not how electricity works.
- 35:20The physics of it you know the electricity needs to be there.
- 35:24There's lumpiness it's not evenly distributed and you know
- 35:28you you touched on how the methane methane mining is is an
- 35:32example. I think to me it stands out as
- 35:35like the the single most exciting thing for with regard
- 35:40to Bitcoin and the environment of yes there's a lot of
- 35:45synergies with renewable energy installations and and
- 35:48incorporating Bitcoin mining into the business case for
- 35:51whether or not to put in those renewable energy installations.
- 35:56But when it comes to methane mining there's there's nothing
- 35:58out there that Marty talked about.
- 36:01There's there's no other use case that can be that flexible
- 36:05that nimble in terms of geography and Co location that
- 36:10makes it possible to justify capturing methane in landfills.
- 36:15There's there's just no point in capturing methane at a large
- 36:18scale from a landfill so that you can generate power on site
- 36:25except for Bitcoin mining. And so Bitcoin mining creates
- 36:28this use case where it makes sense to capture and use methane
- 36:32and and you know Brian to what you were talking about that's
- 36:35that's like the the low hanging fruit really in terms of Bitcoin
- 36:39in the environment. If people are concerned about
- 36:43reducing greenhouse gases. Here's this ready made
- 36:46application that that does something that no other
- 36:50application on the planet is capable of doing because of how
- 36:53nimble and it is in terms of its flexibility with time and also
- 36:59geographic location. I don't know if you want to dig
- 37:03in a little bit more to that, but to me that feels like you
- 37:06know when you were digging into this report, that probably stood
- 37:10out as as something that people aren't talking enough about.
- 37:14If if you care about the environment, if you care about
- 37:16reducing greenhouse gases, this should be a major topic.
- 37:19Well, Brian, before you you hop in, I mean we have a great
- 37:23example of this yesterday. Chris Alfano from 360 Mining is
- 37:26right out the door here. In the comments he tweeted out
- 37:29that he got a cold call from a natural gas producer, I believe
- 37:33in the Marcello Shale up in the Northeast.
- 37:35That was saying he's only making $0.30 per MC per MCF for his gas
- 37:39right now. And if you were to take that gas
- 37:41instead of set it down the pipeline, sell for $0.30 an MCF
- 37:44and divert it to a generator to produce electricity to mine
- 37:47Bitcoin, you can get like $10.00 an MCF right now.
- 37:50And so that's the beauty of this particular solution is that it
- 37:54provides a free market economic incentive to solve these
- 37:56problems. You don't really need
- 37:58intervention from the government or subsidies to solve it.
- 38:02It's just pure economic greed that can solve these emission
- 38:06problems. Yeah, I think that's a.
- 38:08Can you guys see this this chart?
- 38:11Yeah, Logan's going to try and pull it up right now.
- 38:14OK, so while he pulls that up, this is an excerpt from the
- 38:18report and it basically just gives a breakdown of, I guess,
- 38:22sectors in terms of the greenhouse gas emissions that
- 38:27they're responsible for. And as you can see, tourism by
- 38:32far is the biggest and you even have gas flaring here, which is
- 38:35pretty huge. That's an order of magnitude
- 38:38bigger than Bitcoin, just the the gas flaring in the landfills
- 38:42alone, which is substantial. I mean just think about if you
- 38:46were to really start to scale mining even more so than it is
- 38:51now and you can start to reduce the amount of methane that's
- 38:56being emitted into the environment.
- 38:58What I I like that you said, Marty, is this is all done
- 39:01through just basic incentive structures.
- 39:03There's no government subsidies, There's no handouts here to make
- 39:08it work. I mean, look at tourism.
- 39:11Tourism is massive. I don't think anyone on the
- 39:13planet is going to be willing to not go on their annual vacation
- 39:18to another country or flying across the United States,
- 39:21wherever it may be, in order to start reducing their own
- 39:25personal emissions. I mean, same with the fashion
- 39:27industry right here. I was actually very surprised at
- 39:29how big this number is. But the bottom line is people
- 39:32always want the, you know, newest set of shoes that come
- 39:36out. They want to constantly update
- 39:37their wardrobe, etcetera. Like these are things that have
- 39:40massive implications on climate. But what people I find really
- 39:44want to focus on is this tiny one down here, which is Bitcoin
- 39:47mining, As if that's going to have any sort of impact where I
- 39:51think anyone should be able to look at this chart and realize,
- 39:54OK, if we really want to make a dent and climate change like
- 39:58these big huge. Bubbles here are where we need
- 40:02to focus our time and energy, not the tiniest ones.
- 40:04Now obviously that doesn't mean that I'm suggesting that Bitcoin
- 40:09mining should just use whatever power it possibly can, but I
- 40:12think obviously is the paper alluded to and Marty you can
- 40:15probably speak to given your expertise, is the fact that it's
- 40:20Bitcoin miners are consistently seeking out the cheapest price
- 40:24power they possibly can. Obviously, the price of their
- 40:26electricity is the biggest input and what is ultimately going to
- 40:30drive their margins the most and where we've seen them start to
- 40:33do that is through primarily renewable energy sources.
- 40:38And where we have stranded and wasted energy, that often is a
- 40:42byproduct of renewable energy sources.
- 40:45Yeah, it's. I mean, when you run the numbers
- 40:48in bull markets, even when natural gas is in a bull market
- 40:53itself, like even when it was trading around like 10 to $12.00
- 40:57towards the end of 21, it was more economical to mine Bitcoin
- 41:01with natural gas toward the peak of the bull market last year,
- 41:05then send it to send it to the Bitstream.
- 41:08Obviously, Bitcoin mining didn't divert a material amount of
- 41:13natural gas, but that is a variable that's entered the
- 41:18equation that can be added to the tool chest.
- 41:21So these energy producers, they'll make them more
- 41:23efficient, make them more profitable and then give them
- 41:25more optionality to build more robust operational stacks
- 41:31incorporating Bitcoin. And I think that's why it's very
- 41:34important that you guys wrote this research piece and that
- 41:37we're having these conversations right now because obviously with
- 41:41Elizabeth Warren and the Department of Energy really
- 41:44focusing in the very small bubble that you highlighted on
- 41:47that last chart. Like we need to get this
- 41:49narrative out there because we are reaching a point of
- 41:52maturation in this particular off grid space.
- 41:55Companies like Upstream and Giga really stepping up their
- 41:58manufacturing prowess and building the data centers and
- 42:02the generators that will enable this market to flourish off
- 42:06grid. It would be a damn shame if the
- 42:10government were to step in and stamp it out right when it's
- 42:13about to take off. Yeah, I think one thing to note
- 42:19maybe maybe because we're so into it.
- 42:20So it's fundamental problem that we understand is that I think
- 42:24for the average person they may not realize how difficult it is
- 42:27to store the energy because everyone has batteries.
- 42:30So they might think that any energy that's produced can be
- 42:32stored and used later, right. But as you know that's not
- 42:36really the case even with battery technology, you can't
- 42:39store all the energy that can be produced.
- 42:41So the electric grid is designed to be, you have to build it to
- 42:45be to produce the peak and that creates an efficiency because if
- 42:49you're doing that and looking at the doing an investment, if
- 42:52you're all your profits are at the peak, but then you start
- 42:54losing money at the troughs. Well, where where is that extra
- 42:57demand going to come from to to make something look like it's a
- 43:01good investment like building a renewable energy source.
- 43:04And so I think that that's the other aspect to I think what
- 43:06I've been talking about here is that it helps with the
- 43:09investment decisions. If you want to invest in other
- 43:12sources, this helps make that look more appealing.
- 43:15And some of that energy that's that was produced with this is
- 43:19not necessarily wasted because a lot of this energy can't
- 43:22actually be efficiently stored. And maybe one day there will be
- 43:26some technologies that allow that to happen, like any amount
- 43:29of energy produced can be stored and used later.
- 43:31But that's not really the case that we're out today.
- 43:33No, it's it's insane like the efficiencies of Bitcoin mining.
- 43:38So on the economic side of thing like the time cost of capital
- 43:42when you're building out these generation assets is massive
- 43:44because you have to build out the asset, you have to build out
- 43:46the substation, this is on grid and then you have to build out
- 43:49the transmission lines and all all that takes a ton of capital
- 43:53and a ton of time and you're not making any revenue on that
- 43:57investment. But between the time you break
- 44:00around to build a generation asset, get the substation set up
- 44:04and get the transformer lines interconnected with the grid.
- 44:09Now with Bitcoin mining, build the generation asset, build a
- 44:13substation, and then put a Bitcoin mining operation behind
- 44:16the meter as you're building out the transmission lines, which
- 44:18can take 12 to 18 months, so you can begin making revenue 12 to
- 44:2218 months before you would you would have otherwise if you
- 44:25didn't have this option there. So the economics from a capital
- 44:30allocation and investment perspective make a ton of sense.
- 44:35Yeah. I think one of the things that I
- 44:37was exploring when I was doing the report is where do we have
- 44:42examples of Bitcoin miners being part of the capital raise for
- 44:45these renewable energy sources? And my understanding and the
- 44:49feedback that I got was the problem right now is that some
- 44:52of these miners just don't have the creditworthiness for
- 44:56investors to kind of use them in as part of some sort of power
- 45:00purchase agreement. So they're going to be the
- 45:01primary buyer of that electricity from day one is
- 45:06given the creditworthiness of those miners.
- 45:08So Marty, I don't know if you have any thoughts there, if
- 45:09that's something that is a a, a problem now that will start to
- 45:13resolve itself as these miners kind of start to build their
- 45:16credit over time. But I mean some of these these
- 45:20companies are are public U.S. companies.
- 45:22So I found that kind of hard to believe.
- 45:24Yeah. I think as more of these larger
- 45:27publicly traded miners begin owning more of their generation
- 45:30assets and the substations themself makes them more
- 45:33creditworthy because you can use those hard assets as collateral.
- 45:37And that makes a a much better case for a credit investor where
- 45:41they're like, all right, well, maybe we don't believe in
- 45:43Bitcoin, but if we have these generation assets as collateral,
- 45:47we feel comfortable writing the check.
- 45:50And then we, we have seen an example that's actually recorded
- 45:53with Jamie Mccavity, who's the CEO and founder of Corment.
- 45:57But it's on the opposite side of of the cycle that we're talking
- 46:01about. So he bought a wind farm in West
- 46:04Tech, West TX and their substation assets, but he bought
- 46:08it. This wind farm's 12 years old.
- 46:10So they ran out of their ability to leverage renewable energy
- 46:14credits there. They they took them for 12 years
- 46:17and they weren't able to take them anymore, which made it
- 46:19completely uneconomical. So he was able to come in and
- 46:22say hey let me, why don't you give me all your generation
- 46:26assets and your substations and we'll do that as an in kind
- 46:31equity inject injection into Corps Mint the company and then
- 46:34we'll come and bring our mining operations and and make this
- 46:37wind farm profitable. Yeah.
- 46:40That's really interesting, I think.
- 46:41I agree. I I that seems like an example
- 46:44of something we'll start to see more and more, especially with
- 46:47some of these existing energy projects that might fall by the
- 46:50wayside or just proved to not be economical and that's where
- 46:53miners can come in and provide they have the capital to do so.
- 46:58And I think we're we're correct me if I'm wrong here Marty, but
- 47:01I think we're sort of seeing that in like an isolated
- 47:04experiments stage in Africa with like gridless compute putting in
- 47:09micro hydro installations that are entirely based on like we're
- 47:13going to, we're going to invest this capital to create this
- 47:16hydro installation because we're going to be Bitcoin mining.
- 47:19And so if it works in that scale the the first principles of it,
- 47:24of it are sound and it it can and will work on a larger scale
- 47:28eventually. But I think that that is very
- 47:32exciting to me because it's sort of the tip of the spear, I
- 47:35think, in terms of of justifying energy installations because of
- 47:40power purchase agreements with Bitcoin miners.
- 47:44Oh, you guys are going to get me running.
- 47:46And if you think about the set scale, you know companies like
- 47:48Satoshi Energy and Sonoda out there that are really working on
- 47:52the accounting side, partnering with Bitcoin mining companies
- 47:56and utility companies that are their counterparties and trades.
- 47:59And you can envision a future in which instead of getting invoice
- 48:03for your power consumption at the end of each month and having
- 48:06an N 30 and 45 payback period, you can literally mine Bitcoin
- 48:11and use the lightning network to pay your energy bill as you're
- 48:14consuming it. Like we're we're not only
- 48:17talking about efficiencies at the physical layer, we're
- 48:19talking about capital efficiencies in terms of how you
- 48:22actually pay your energy bill and how you capitalize utilities
- 48:26companies. And this will open up a bunch of
- 48:28capital for these utilities to begin reinvesting in their
- 48:31operations more quickly to make the overall grid system more
- 48:35robust. Thanks for tuning in.
- 48:38If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 48:40further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 48:43a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 48:46our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 48:50you on your Bitcoin journey. I can learn out on this for for
- 48:54quite a while It's it's I I think this is the most bullish
- 48:58part of the Bitcoin ecosystem. Obviously 21 million scarce
- 49:02asset you can self custody your wealth and prevented from being
- 49:06debased is extremely exciting and an innovation that will
- 49:11probably not be repeated or there.
- 49:13There won't be an innovation as as great as Bitcoin for some
- 49:18time. But this particular intersection
- 49:20of the energy sector and Bitcoin mining, I think people are
- 49:23sleeping on it and I think it is going to drive an energy
- 49:26revolution that we'll look back on a century from now and be
- 49:30like, holy crap, I can't believe we were doing things the way we
- 49:32were before Bitcoin existed. Yeah.
- 49:34The programmatic streaming of value is very underpriced or
- 49:39understood right now. That's like 1 angle and energy.
- 49:41But that goes across like the world and like how general net
- 49:4430 or whatever settlement is generally been.
- 49:47And once that gets unlocked, like we haven't even like we
- 49:50squint, we know like you know interchange and that's like a
- 49:53kind of a consumer thing. It's us to change where we don't
- 49:55have full scale adoption. But there's a lot of other
- 49:57things that I think will play into it, whether it's like
- 49:59reinsurance or what you just referenced with Sonoda or other
- 50:04kind of like capital movement from countries that it's harder
- 50:08to get out for whatever reason. There's a lot of ways that, like
- 50:11streaming lightning will help from a friction perspective and
- 50:16capital movement. Because it unlocks a ton of
- 50:20capital. With these utilities companies,
- 50:22you have to put up massive deposits because they don't know
- 50:24if you're actually going to pay your bills.
- 50:26And if you have a Bitcoin mining operation and you can say, hey,
- 50:29here's how much hash rate we have, you can look at the
- 50:31network hash rate, the difficulty and basically
- 50:34calculate what are what are payouts going to be on a
- 50:36day-to-day basis and have some assurances that you're actually
- 50:39going to get paid. And we can set up the contract
- 50:41in a way where as we get paid, you get paid as well.
- 50:46Yeah. Night and day efficiencies in in
- 50:49capital markets and energy, you know which will be a tailwind,
- 50:52just an ongoing tailwind indefinitely for so long as as
- 50:56Bitcoin exists which is pretty exciting And and I I guess if
- 51:00you take it to the extreme that's where people get excited
- 51:02about like this is how we we build the Dyson sphere of you
- 51:06know like this is how we incentivize like unbelievable
- 51:10scale energy production and and and that's linked to societal
- 51:14progress to civilizational progress.
- 51:18And so it's to me that it's Bitcoin provides a ton of hope
- 51:25for individuals in in how they're saving their their
- 51:28money, but it also provides hope on a civilizational scale.
- 51:32And I think that the, I think Marty's right that the thing
- 51:34that we sleep on that we under appreciate is the extent to
- 51:38which this will fuel technological and civilizational
- 51:43advance because it incentivizes energy production by by by
- 51:51identifying all these areas where there's opportunity for
- 51:54greater efficiency or for turning waste energy into real
- 52:00energy into electricity and using it.
- 52:03I'm creating a market for it. And you know, so having KPMG and
- 52:08Brian having you dig into this and and and highlight the the
- 52:12fact that you know what there's there's a lot of really exciting
- 52:17substance here. And and this is not exactly what
- 52:22the a common narrative about Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining has
- 52:26been. I think is I think it's been a
- 52:29breath of fresh air for Bitcoin miners who've been kind of on an
- 52:33island trying to trying to set the record straight and have
- 52:37been unable to. And so I guess I'm curious,
- 52:41Brian, if if you want to share a little bit about like what the
- 52:45process was like for you as you were digging into this and
- 52:48trying to raise awareness internally at KPMG.
- 52:53Also just in general in in in the you know BIG4 kind of
- 52:59landscape of of thought leadership, what was that
- 53:03process like for you? Yeah, it was.
- 53:07It was pretty interesting, right?
- 53:08Like I had been part of some teams that have published things
- 53:12before, but nothing of this scale, nothing that I think
- 53:16maybe when it against some mainstream views, right, like
- 53:19some of the the stuff that we've historically done, it's it's
- 53:23pretty cut and dry. But I think this presented A
- 53:25viewpoint that, you know, maybe some people might disagree with.
- 53:29But I think one of the things I really tried to focus on when I
- 53:31was doing the paper is to not put anything in there that
- 53:37wasn't based in facts, right. So if I was going to go through
- 53:42the paper and give examples of where Bitcoin mining is is is
- 53:46providing value to the climate issues, then you you wouldn't
- 53:50really, I wanted to to structure so that you couldn't come back
- 53:53and disagree with me. It's not an opinion I was
- 53:55offering. You know, I I didn't want to
- 53:58have it be you know something where I'm promoting Bitcoin like
- 54:01go out and buy Bitcoin. Bitcoin's going to go up in
- 54:03price, nothing like that. So I really wanted to make it so
- 54:07that it was fact based and that if you were going to, you know,
- 54:11there was a, there was a couple scenarios where, you know, we
- 54:13might have softened the language, we might have used
- 54:15certain words that because this went through so many different
- 54:18reviews, especially 'cause it was a larger piece, you know,
- 54:22naturally you get that many cooks in the kitchen, everyone
- 54:25wants to to tweak this, tweak that.
- 54:28But I'd say by and large, I mean the, the, the firm was very
- 54:30receptive to it. And like I said, it was just
- 54:34there was nothing in there that you could disagree with.
- 54:37And I think that's, I think that's where I was able to get
- 54:41the powers that be comfortable with it.
- 54:43And so, you know, they asked some questions and we, you know
- 54:46go back and forth a little bit, but it was a relatively painless
- 54:48process I would say. And on the other side of that
- 54:53process, actually publishing and releasing the research report,
- 54:58what was some of the reception that you got?
- 55:00Did you change any minds that people who were previously
- 55:04skeptical say, all right, you're making a good point here.
- 55:07Yeah, that's a good question. So one of the thing there was
- 55:10obviously a ton of outreach once the paper was published.
- 55:13I think a lot of people really appreciate it.
- 55:15I mean, even people from within the firm were reaching out to me
- 55:17directly saying it's great that, you know, we were basically
- 55:21writing something along those lines.
- 55:23I think, I think for me though, I always told people like who
- 55:28I'd really like to hear from is who kind of went into that paper
- 55:32as a critic and came out sort of a proponent.
- 55:36And I haven't really heard many examples of that.
- 55:39And it it could just be because of the reach I have or don't
- 55:41have where I just don't have access to some of those people
- 55:45or I just haven't heard about, you know, somebody saying, hey,
- 55:48this changed my mind. But you know, I I've told people
- 55:51on a couple of the different podcasts I've done that those
- 55:54are the people I really want to hear from.
- 55:56Or even if people have a view that they disagree with, like
- 55:59let's let's have a dialogue about it, you know, if nothing
- 56:02else, that's what I sort of aim to do, was to to create more
- 56:06dialogue and not have it be such a polarizing topic because it
- 56:09really shouldn't be. So yeah, that's kind of, that's
- 56:12kind of been the way it's all played out over the past six or
- 56:16seven months. Well, I'll jump in.
- 56:19I'll say, I'll commend you. I think that report moved the
- 56:22industry forward. There's a lot of concepts that
- 56:24go discussed in in closed doors or behind the scenes and I think
- 56:30generally you know that this term and I think it plays into a
- 56:32lot of things in sales where you're always going to have
- 56:35somebody that's going to buy, you're always going to have
- 56:36somebody that's you know. Pro.
- 56:38Bitcoin or pro understanding the report and then you're always
- 56:41going to have somebody that will never buy or somebody that's
- 56:43always going to like be antagonistic to the report.
- 56:46But the reality is you're looking at the margins in that
- 56:48middle group and helping either them instinctually or
- 56:51intuitively what they thought. But putting it in a succinct way
- 56:55is what, in my opinion, that report did.
- 56:57And putting the name around it like a KPMG and having it well
- 57:01articulated you. There's a lot of individuals
- 57:04from the circles that I've run in and I'll let Jessica and
- 57:07Marty, you know, chime in that it added a lot of validity and I
- 57:11don't want to say confidence but credibility to what they already
- 57:15knew and had been hearing. But to put it in a succinct
- 57:18package like that. So yeah, it was.
- 57:21It was awesome to see and it was a big driver for us to be able
- 57:23to share and share some of the concepts that we've been talking
- 57:26about, but have it again put together in a very concise
- 57:29fashion. Yeah.
- 57:31And before, before this report, you know, kind of what was out
- 57:35there from a credible source was really the, the Cambridge report
- 57:40that that I'll say in my opinion was a biased bit of analysis
- 57:47that was rooted in falsehoods. That's my perspective and it was
- 57:53very, I think, I think now there's two credible things out
- 57:58there, which one is that Cambridge report, the other is
- 58:01this KPMG report, which is rooted in facts and paints a
- 58:06very different picture. And I think that that moves the
- 58:09needle right there and I think will be the start of a trend,
- 58:13hopefully of people, you know, from credible organizations
- 58:18taking an objective look at Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining.
- 58:23Yeah. And I think there's a reality of
- 58:24like we have to meet people where they're at, even if like
- 58:29the framing or where you kind of kind of want to go against the
- 58:31framing because we don't fully agree with it.
- 58:33At the end of the day, if you don't meet somebody where you're
- 58:35at, you can't actually get them to where you want them to be
- 58:37because they'll just never start.
- 58:39And so there's just like, it's like you got to like, it's
- 58:41almost like almost losing the battle personally to win the war
- 58:44long term. And so that's what I really
- 58:47loved about. It's like, I think a lot, even
- 58:48on this part. I'm going to talk about it here,
- 58:50But there's probably some concepts in the framing that
- 58:51maybe people wouldn't. Yeah, we didn't necessarily
- 58:55agree with. But I think it's very important
- 58:57to meet individuals where they're at and then let them
- 58:59kind of go down and pull on that string because we're never going
- 59:02to get them right off the bat. It's just enough for them to
- 59:04start looking down the rabbit hole and understanding how this
- 59:07really changes a lot of these dynamics, which I think that's
- 59:10what the report effectively did and maybe was part of your goal
- 59:13as well. Yeah, it's.
- 59:14About 100%. That's a very good point because
- 59:16once you see it, you cannot see it.
- 59:18It's like and you have to get people receptive to actually
- 59:21seeing it in the 1st place and meeting them in the middle is
- 59:23probably a good strategy as somebody who has employed the
- 59:27antagonistic strategy in the past.
- 59:31I love it means there's like the two.
- 59:32One that's been coming around, probably been around for a
- 59:34while, is Bitcoin doesn't waste energy.
- 59:36It utilizes wasted energy. And then our friend Griffin
- 59:39Habee, who basically said he had dawned on him, he was a land man
- 59:42in Texas and said it really was like instrumental or his mind
- 59:46chef mindset shifted when he realized there was no such thing
- 59:49as stranded energy after Bitcoin mine.
- 59:52Like these little concepts really like get somebody's mind
- 59:54thinking about, like, what are you talking about similar?
- 59:57Important I heard Alex Gladstein the other day on a podcast
- 1:00:03framed it as not not. Bitcoin mining is wasting
- 1:00:07energy. Like if you have this energy and
- 1:00:11you're not going to use it. Because there's no other use
- 1:00:14case for it, then you're wasting it.
- 1:00:16So you might as if you have otherwise wasted energy, you
- 1:00:20should be putting it to work, generating some revenue with
- 1:00:24Bitcoin mining. Yeah, that's a key theme of his
- 1:00:27recent article Stranded, which I thought was just so well
- 1:00:30written. And I think it's I posted about
- 1:00:32this on LinkedIn but if I don't know how anybody could read that
- 1:00:35article and it's it's a long form article but I don't know
- 1:00:38how anyone can read that and come away and still think yeah
- 1:00:42this Bitcoin thing is is a waste of energy.
- 1:00:45I mean it is literally helping 600 million people in in Africa
- 1:00:49that don't have electricity. And I just think that's just
- 1:00:53remarkable. And I don't think it's something
- 1:00:55that people have an appreciation for, especially some of us that,
- 1:00:59you know, live in developed countries that, like we said, we
- 1:01:02we sort of take for granted the fact that we just have energy at
- 1:01:06our fingertips whenever we want it.
- 1:01:09This is something I wanted to say earlier, but I think it's
- 1:01:11imperative that we begin putting like simple first principles,
- 1:01:16energy curriculums in schools like people shit like it is
- 1:01:19arguably Bitcoin and energy, Money and energy are two of the
- 1:01:23most important tools we utilize as humans on a day-to-day basis
- 1:01:26and most people don't understand either of them.
- 1:01:29This goes back to like a first principles education problem as
- 1:01:33well. I think you have a bunch of
- 1:01:34people who just take all this for granted.
- 1:01:35Their money, the fact that they can turn the lights on and they
- 1:01:38don't know how it works and it leads them to make bad decisions
- 1:01:43in the long run. Delivery.
- 1:01:47Yeah. And and on that the Africa
- 1:01:49point, like I, I, I, I come back to the 20 years ago, The
- 1:01:56Economist ran a big, you know, big addition about the dark
- 1:02:01continent and like why is it that Africa just isn't
- 1:02:04developing? Like what is going on?
- 1:02:06What It's such a shame. Like why, why, why is this
- 1:02:10happening? And of course, you know, didn't
- 1:02:13really address the like root causes of like the the colonial
- 1:02:18like frank system and how that's a a major impediment to
- 1:02:22development and progress. And you know, it just stands to
- 1:02:26me as like the system that has been in place, the
- 1:02:29establishment, the establishment and economic incentives have
- 1:02:33prevented Africa from developing at the same rate as other
- 1:02:40continents. And now here's this thing that
- 1:02:43is providing the you know the the base infrastructure layer
- 1:02:47necessary for economic development, abundant
- 1:02:50electricity and bringing that to to a continent that has been at
- 1:02:55the dark Continent in in the perspective of of the economist
- 1:02:59which is sort of the the flagship for the economic
- 1:03:02establishment. And that should be celebrated
- 1:03:05and and I think will be but it it's just not clear to people
- 1:03:08yet that the the incentives that are actually there are there and
- 1:03:14that Bitcoin helps achieve these these dreamed of goals that the
- 1:03:19status quo has not been able to offer.
- 1:03:23And Jesse? I believe we've talked about
- 1:03:24this book before, but Jesus de Soto think for like another part
- 1:03:28of this problem is private property rights.
- 1:03:29And the layer below all this mining infrastructure is the
- 1:03:32fact that these individuals can now hold Bitcoin, and Bitcoin
- 1:03:36will respect their private property rights.
- 1:03:39And from that foundational core, you can begin to build a more
- 1:03:44advanced society. And so with that in mind, I
- 1:03:51mean, we can keep talking about energy.
- 1:03:52We talked about custody, We talked about energy.
- 1:03:55What are you guys looking forward to in the next three
- 1:04:00years? Obviously, we have the ETF
- 1:04:01approvals earlier this year. It seems like we have a tailwind
- 1:04:05of adoption coming our way. How are you guys at KPMG
- 1:04:11positioning yourselves to stand out against the crowd of
- 1:04:15auditors and accountants and consultants that can actually
- 1:04:18advise companies of Bitcoin becomes more widely adopted?
- 1:04:23I think for me, one of the things I'm kind of really keep
- 1:04:26an eye on, it's just where some of this regulation goes and
- 1:04:29there's been a number of different bills that have been
- 1:04:31introduced, some that could be pretty problematic for the
- 1:04:36industry. There's been, I know we have
- 1:04:39like SAP 121 which I think could potentially be repealed just
- 1:04:45given the conclusion that the the GAO came to get given that
- 1:04:49it didn't follow the Administrative Procedures Act.
- 1:04:52I think. But those are two things that I
- 1:04:55I kind of point to because like even SAV 121 has made it very
- 1:04:59difficult for let's say banks for instance to transact with
- 1:05:03crypto because it just has huge implications on what it does to
- 1:05:07their balance sheet. Given that whatever customer
- 1:05:10liabilities they're going to be responsible for custody, there
- 1:05:14needs to be a corresponding asset that they have.
- 1:05:16So I think that just becomes very cost prohibitive.
- 1:05:18So if something like that were to be repealed, that could kind
- 1:05:23of be a boon for the industry. And then just like I said,
- 1:05:27seeing where some of these regulations go, what these bills
- 1:05:30look like if they ultimately become law, I think those are
- 1:05:33some things that I've personally seen with companies that I've
- 1:05:36been speaking with that are keeping them on the sidelines
- 1:05:39for the time being. I was going to say I saw the
- 1:05:44American Bankers Association and other group of consortium
- 1:05:48leaders basically banging on the door saying you need to let us
- 1:05:51get access to this. Yeah, that's what I was going to
- 1:05:54ask to the extent you're comfortable, if you can dig a
- 1:05:55little deeper lesson like SAB 121, but the American bankers
- 1:05:59and I saw cursory like, is it their interest in basically
- 1:06:04custody and getting some of those fees that they've been
- 1:06:06basically not allowed to participate in because of that
- 1:06:09rule. Was that like the notion that
- 1:06:12they want to participate in custody for some of these ETFs?
- 1:06:16I can't speak to it mainly just because it's just not regulation
- 1:06:21that I've, you know done a deep dive into like I kind of
- 1:06:23understand the cursory points of it.
- 1:06:25And also like the digital asset any money laundering Act, which
- 1:06:29I think was, I think what you might be also alluding to.
- 1:06:33Those are just ones that I know are in progress right now.
- 1:06:36I have no idea which way they're going to go in in some of those
- 1:06:39implications. I I just don't have the the
- 1:06:42wherewithal to go too deep into that might.
- 1:06:46Yeah, I think you know when you when you talk to certain members
- 1:06:49of the Bitcoin community, the ETFs could be a little
- 1:06:52controversial because it's not you know, not your keys, not
- 1:06:55your Bitcoin concept, but self custody and all that.
- 1:06:58But but another way to think about it is if the ETFs could
- 1:07:01lead into greater adoption and and people participating into
- 1:07:05it, the the more the industry can feel comfortable using it.
- 1:07:08Maybe, maybe that's a way to get into this space.
- 1:07:12You have more proponents for it then you have a more balanced
- 1:07:15view I think ultimately in the regulations.
- 1:07:17And so that's I could only think be helpful to helping out the
- 1:07:20debate, right. Because if you if you don't have
- 1:07:23like these vehicles like the ETFs and greater like
- 1:07:26institutional adoption of it or people wanting to be
- 1:07:29economically incentivized to maybe custody it for example,
- 1:07:33then then you just you really just it's it's easy to get
- 1:07:36somewhat run over, you know. So I think this helps with a
- 1:07:40more balanced discussion about the rule makers and the regulars
- 1:07:43and even Congress about where things are going.
- 1:07:45I think just more people into it to help with a healthy debate is
- 1:07:49is useful. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:07:53Yeah, 100% goes back to meeting people where where they're at,
- 1:07:56like that's how they consume financial products and now you
- 1:08:00have banks wanting to potentially custody it.
- 1:08:02Like, there you go. That's the right right.
- 1:08:05But I think the way what it seemed like where the bank
- 1:08:08started to back off was, I think it was January 2023, there was a
- 1:08:13a joint letter issued by Federal Reserve, FDIC and the OCC.
- 1:08:18And I think that was sort of a shot across the bow of basically
- 1:08:21saying, look, we'll allow you guys to do this.
- 1:08:24But if you read in lines, they're saying we really don't
- 1:08:27like you doing this. And I don't think the risk was
- 1:08:30worth the reward. This was also, you know, shortly
- 1:08:33after FTX it happened, I think this was several months after
- 1:08:36that, if that. So I think the industry as a
- 1:08:38whole just sort of had a huge black eye on it.
- 1:08:40And I think big banks will probably just think, you know
- 1:08:42what, the risk isn't worth the reward.
- 1:08:44But I think that's a little over a year now.
- 1:08:47I think a lot has changed. I think the the industry is kind
- 1:08:51of rebounded substantially. I mean the ETFs were a big part
- 1:08:54of that. So it'll be interesting to see
- 1:08:57how that plays out this year, especially being an election
- 1:09:00year or if anything really doesn't start to change until
- 1:09:03after the election. Yeah.
- 1:09:06And that's your point is all the finances risk and reward, right.
- 1:09:09And then with things like the ETF potentially they'll see more
- 1:09:12reward, you know the financial money managers, banks, lenders.
- 1:09:18So there's that. You know, if it was all risk and
- 1:09:21no reward, they would not touch the space at all of course,
- 1:09:24right. So I do think that these new
- 1:09:25products can help on the balance that equation more that get them
- 1:09:29interested in the space. As the affable Michael Goldstein
- 1:09:34once said, the only winning move is to play.
- 1:09:36And it seems like the banks are beginning to realize this like,
- 1:09:39hey, you got to let us play. It's it's important.
- 1:09:44But as you mentioned Ryan, like obviously a lot of the froth in
- 1:09:49our industry, particularly crypto not necessarily Bitcoin
- 1:09:54has scared a lot of big players from from entering the market
- 1:09:58because they look at what happened and many failures of of
- 1:10:02the last 15 years and they say holy crap like what is going on
- 1:10:05here, billions of dollars of shareholder equity washed out
- 1:10:10overnight in many instances. And so that has the industry's,
- 1:10:16the incumbent financial industries guard up like should
- 1:10:19we even play with this? It seems like they're losing a
- 1:10:21lot of money over there, which has certainly been the case.
- 1:10:23But as we know companies like on RAMP Unchained, other companies
- 1:10:28that are really exhibiting best practice in terms of custody and
- 1:10:32securing customer funds and acting as actual fiduciaries
- 1:10:36that care about securing their their customers funds.
- 1:10:40Like there is a right way to do it in a wrong way to do it.
- 1:10:43So based off the lessons we've learned over the last two years
- 1:10:48specifically, I think, how do you navigate the conversations
- 1:10:51with potential clients of, hey, here's what these companies did
- 1:10:55wrong and here's the right way to do it?
- 1:11:00Yep. Yeah, I agree.
- 1:11:03Yeah. I think to tie into what Marty
- 1:11:05was saying, I'd be curious like from institutional like
- 1:11:07allocations and volatility, just like how do out of those
- 1:11:09conversations or how have you seen them go for somebody coming
- 1:11:12in and saying digital assets, help us understand what's
- 1:11:17happening here because I feel like that's a big like concept
- 1:11:19just overarching whether it's a grand law or a large
- 1:11:22institution, company, corporate, treasury, it's like there's
- 1:11:25something here, it won't go away, but I can't see the forest
- 1:11:28through the trees. Like how do you do you guys
- 1:11:31engage in that conversation, you guys engage in like portfolio
- 1:11:34allocation, sharp ratio, like any of the studies that have
- 1:11:36been put out there on like how this can actually benefit from
- 1:11:39preservation of wealth? Well, I, I we're not financial
- 1:11:45advisors, neither is our firm. But we have clients who are.
- 1:11:49And I I think what you're alluding to, if you look at, I
- 1:11:53think it's an interesting discussion when you think about
- 1:11:55this more from a portfolio management allocation
- 1:11:57perspective, because if you're like let's say a true believer
- 1:11:59in Bitcoin, you have 100% of your net worth in it.
- 1:12:02You have, you have a different view, right?
- 1:12:04But what if you look at it more from you just want to view this
- 1:12:06as as an asset class and with efficient market hypothesis out
- 1:12:11there there's there's reasons why like passive investing and
- 1:12:14SP500 index has gotten popular. It's not like people are in
- 1:12:17individually looking at all the companies and assessing how much
- 1:12:20cash flow this generating. They're just buying the index
- 1:12:23and and in the past these indexes didn't exist like they
- 1:12:27weren't there weren't easy way to transact to buy an entire
- 1:12:30market weighted index And then ETF showed up about 20 years ago
- 1:12:34and and now it's become a very popular way to invest.
- 1:12:37And so from a market allocation perspective, you know, look at
- 1:12:41the S&P 500 popular index that people invest in is what about
- 1:12:4542 trillion I think roughly market cap and then bitcoins
- 1:12:49roughly around a trillion. So you know, do the math, that's
- 1:12:52like a little over 2%, so like 2.3% or so.
- 1:12:56And so just even from that angle, you know, there's should
- 1:12:59you have Bitcoin in a portfolio that's well diversified.
- 1:13:02But the efficient market hypothesis would tell you that
- 1:13:05it's very hard to pick individual assets or even time
- 1:13:08the market and consistently beat that over the long term.
- 1:13:12And so from from an allocation perspective, I think is now this
- 1:13:16is an easier way to transact in it through the ETF, although
- 1:13:19that's not exactly Bitcoin, it's at least a proxy for it and hold
- 1:13:22the Bitcoin then would people at least consider it as part of
- 1:13:27their allocation for portfolios? And I think I think the answer
- 1:13:31is is probably and I would like to caution though that somebody
- 1:13:36who's been investing for 25 years, I remember when the IT
- 1:13:39was really hard to buy gold and the gold ETF showed up and we
- 1:13:43generally you don't see gold in a lot of people's portfolios
- 1:13:46even though efficient market hypothesis would tell you
- 1:13:48probably should own some for diversification purposes, right.
- 1:13:51And so we'll we'll see that. I think gold and Bitcoin are
- 1:13:55very different though, right. And so maybe Bitcoin could
- 1:13:58become get more traction than gold did in in that context of
- 1:14:02like these broader portfolio allocations.
- 1:14:04And I think there are, there is one firm in Canada that started
- 1:14:07adding it into their general funds, total Rasa return funds,
- 1:14:11which is interesting to see because they, you know like if
- 1:14:13they have 6040 portfolio of stocks and bonds maybe add like
- 1:14:17a percent in Bitcoin and that's just part of the overall
- 1:14:19allocation. So people investing in those
- 1:14:21funds for example, may not even know they're buying Bitcoin, but
- 1:14:24they're just buying exposure to the overall market, right.
- 1:14:27So I think that will probably start, you see that more and
- 1:14:30that will drive greater adoption because you're not really just
- 1:14:32making an investment and hey, I'm going to put everything into
- 1:14:35Bitcoin. It's just again just part of an
- 1:14:37allocation. Your your other question about
- 1:14:40well could that impact treasury assets on companies that's
- 1:14:47that's an interesting one because you know companies are
- 1:14:49going to be a lot more depending who they are.
- 1:14:52They have shareholders that have boards to convince as well
- 1:14:54couldn't fit within the risk management policies.
- 1:14:58I think as you see more adoption that it can matures then it just
- 1:15:03becomes an asset that just feels like something they should at
- 1:15:05least consider and then that's where you know firms like us can
- 1:15:08help out about the regulations around that and how and the risk
- 1:15:12management processes around it. But I think it's going to be a
- 1:15:16process to get there. One thing to note, you also
- 1:15:19mentioned sharp ratios and you know that it'd be interesting to
- 1:15:24see too going forward because a lot of those analysis that are
- 1:15:27out there, they're like the last five years that show fairly good
- 1:15:31sharp ratios relative to other assets and somewhat low
- 1:15:34correlation to things like 6040 portfolio, the S&P 500.
- 1:15:39As these ETFs get bigger and they're held by investors that
- 1:15:44also own let's say bonds and stocks, will there be greater
- 1:15:48correlations and tightening in the sharp ratios as as they are
- 1:15:52owned by similar investors that own those other assets?
- 1:15:55Right. Most of the five year history of
- 1:15:58they're showing these Bitcoin studies that you didn't have
- 1:16:01that there as much. I know there's ETFs in other
- 1:16:03countries, but they weren't that large.
- 1:16:05And so it'll be interesting to see how this plays out.
- 1:16:08Where is Bitcoin will be continue to be a unique asset
- 1:16:11that you should incorporate into a portfolio to improve your
- 1:16:14sharp ratios and correlations or will they actually start
- 1:16:17converging? We'll we'll see.
- 1:16:20I think that's a big question. A piggyback on that, that I know
- 1:16:24Jesse's pretty interested in is like the FASB rules for
- 1:16:27accounting. Like do you see that changing in
- 1:16:29this upcoming year from like corporate treasuries and them
- 1:16:32adding to the balance sheet? Well, I I think there is already
- 1:16:35has been a a change. So about that around fair value
- 1:16:39accounting it used to be and this is actually a little bit
- 1:16:42outside of I know our firms has expertise in this is a little
- 1:16:46bit outside of what I typically do day for day.
- 1:16:48But I think the problem with the issue with the existing rules
- 1:16:51was the way it was treated in that you'd hold the the value at
- 1:16:55the the impaired value. So not just the the fair value
- 1:16:58but the lowest part of that fair value if it gets impaired.
- 1:17:01So the the value and when Bitcoin value going up so much
- 1:17:05it's just highly undervalued on your on your official US gap
- 1:17:09balance sheet. And so the the change that's
- 1:17:11coming up, I think there's a is a option to early adopt it, but
- 1:17:15the the change really I think probably later this year or next
- 1:17:18year. This year.
- 1:17:20Yeah. I think some kind of could early
- 1:17:22adopt, but I don't know who is going to do that.
- 1:17:24The option right now and then and then it's mandatory at the
- 1:17:28end of the year, yeah, it's going from intangible property
- 1:17:32which you only, you can only impair to to fair value, yeah.
- 1:17:37Right, right. So then the fair value for.
- 1:17:39Micro strategies quarterly earnings calls will will now
- 1:17:44start to have a bunch of you know, realized or unrealized
- 1:17:49gains from from Bitcoin appreciating which will flow
- 1:17:53through to their profits which will change the narrative around
- 1:17:56micro strategies Bitcoin strategy.
- 1:17:59Yeah. I think in general with the fair
- 1:18:00value accounting, there's two things to note, especially for
- 1:18:03an asset that's been, if you've held it for a while that's been
- 1:18:05impaired so much the, the, the additional date of adoption,
- 1:18:09that would be a pretty sizable increase in your balance sheet
- 1:18:11if you hold a lot of Bitcoin, right, because the fair value is
- 1:18:15just so much higher than your book value.
- 1:18:17And then to your point going forward with all the new
- 1:18:19quarterly reports that come out, the change in the value would go
- 1:18:23through the income statement. And so that can create a lot of
- 1:18:25volatility. I'm sure analysts would look at
- 1:18:27it as like here's core earnings without the impact of the fair
- 1:18:30value change at Bitcoin and this is what it looks like with it.
- 1:18:33So you you'll see this impact both on the balance sheet and
- 1:18:36income statement side. So I do, you know, there's a lot
- 1:18:38of companies that are pushing for that change, peers and the
- 1:18:40FASB agreed with it and so that that's coming up.
- 1:18:43So that's a big change. Exciting times.
- 1:18:50I think we're going to win, gentlemen.
- 1:18:53The the tailwinds are behind us right now.
- 1:18:57Heading into a halving. Mining economics heading into a
- 1:18:59halving are the best they've been throughout any cycle we've
- 1:19:03got. The ECB came out this morning
- 1:19:06trying to besmirch Bitcoin. They got ratioed and community
- 1:19:09noted out the gills. We've got a good technology
- 1:19:13here. It can, it can help us preserve
- 1:19:15our wealth, help us verify assets.
- 1:19:17It can help us become more energy efficient.
- 1:19:19You guys have anything we should wrap up with before we leave
- 1:19:22here? Yeah, I think we covered it.
- 1:19:24I feel like we could have gone another another hour or so, but
- 1:19:27I guess that's par for the course of these conversations.
- 1:19:29So thanks a lot for having us. We enjoyed it.
- 1:19:32Yeah, definitely. Thanks for having us to talk and
- 1:19:35want to let the Bitcoin community know that they're that
- 1:19:38we are doing services in this space.
- 1:19:41And I know that the maybe common knowledge.
- 1:19:43I I think you mentioned you have some relatives who used to work
- 1:19:45for the Big four and they're just shocked that some of the
- 1:19:48Big Four are into it. So I I think, hey, at the end of
- 1:19:51the day, we're going to help out our clients and if clients are
- 1:19:54into this space, that's what we're going to do.
- 1:19:57Yeah, we should. We should all get together at
- 1:20:00the The Bitcoin Takeover next month down here in Austin, if
- 1:20:03you guys can make it down. Yeah, I'd like to, Yeah.
- 1:20:07There's a number of conferences coming up that hopefully we can
- 1:20:10we can meet in person at. Yeah.
- 1:20:12Well, I look forward to shaking your hands in person instead of
- 1:20:17looking at you through a screen here.
- 1:20:19Yes, Likewise, keep crushing it, Michael.
- 1:20:22Jesse, we'll be back next week.