Latest / Come Sit With Us: Friendship, Community & Real Conversations / Why Trauma Bonding Isn’t Real Friendship (And What To Do Instead) | Come Sit With Us
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from crying with someone who never stops to ask if you’re okay after the tears dry. It feels like intimacy, but it’s actually just a heavy, shared weight we’ve mistaken for connection. I want you to think about the last time you felt truly seen by a friend. For most of us, our first instinct is to reach for the moments where we broke down together. We remember the hospital waiting rooms, the breakup nights spent on kitchen floors, the funerals where we held each other up because we were the only two standing. We look back at those scenes and think, wow, we are bonded forever. We survived the worst things together, so we must be soulmates. But here is the quiet truth that I had to learn the hard way: shared trauma does not equal shared joy. And without joy, friendship becomes a memorial service rather than a living relationship. It’s a space where you go to mourn, to vent, to analyze, and to dissect pain, but rarely to laugh until your ribs hurt or to celebrate small, stupid wins. When I say this, I don’t mean to minimize the importance of having support during hard times. Of course we need people in our trenches. But when the trench is the only place you meet, you forget how to build a house anywhere else. Friendships built primarily on shared trauma often feel incredibly intense. They move fast. You share secrets that would scare away casual acquaintances within weeks. There is a rush of adrenaline, a sense of being chosen, of being trusted with the darkest parts of another person’s history. It feels profound. But over time, that intensity burns out the oxygen in the room. If every conversation revolves around what went wrong, who hurt you, or how unfair life has been, your nervous system stays in a state of low-grade alarm. You start to associate your friend with stress. You might even find yourself subconsciously avoiding good news because you don’t know how to shift the dynamic from crisis to calm. It creates a strange paradox where you feel closest to someone when you are both suffering. This isn’t love; it’s codependency wearing the mask of sisterhood. You aren’t connecting as whole individuals; you are connecting as wounded parts trying to soothe each other. And while that soothing feels nice in the moment, it doesn’t heal anything. It just keeps the wound open so there’s always something new to talk about. Let me tell you about Sarah. Or at least, let me tell you about a version of her. In my early twenties, I had a friend whose life was essentially a series of cascading disasters. Her ex-husband left her for her sister. Her job ended abruptly due to office politics. Her car broke down the same week she got sick. And I was there. I was always there. I brought soup. I listened for hours. I validated her rage. We were best friends. But do you know what we never talked about? Music. We never talked about what we were reading. We never talked about the silly thing our dog did or the recipe we wanted to try. Our entire bond was anchored in her misery and my sympathy. One day, I realized I didn’t know who she was outside of her victimhood. I didn’t know her hopes, her dreams, or what made her eyes light up. She didn’t know me either. She only knew me as the witness to her pain. That realization hit me with the force of a physical blow. I was lonely in the middle of one of my closest friendships because we had forgotten how to just be. We had traded curiosity for catastrophe. And once you stop being curious about each other’s lives, you stop seeing each other as people. You start seeing each other as roles. The sufferer and the savior. And neither of those roles is sustainable. Building a friendship on shared joy requires a different kind of courage. It requires vulnerability, yes, but a lighter one. It means showing up as you are right now, not just as you have been broken. It means talking about your fears, sure, but also talking about your ambitions, your weird hobbies, your favorite song, your plan for next summer. It means allowing space for happiness without guilt. Many of us, especially women who have been conditioned to carry the emotional labor of the world, feel guilty when we are happy. We feel like we’re betraying the struggle by enjoying ourselves. So when we’re with a trauma-bonded friend, we stay in the dark because the dark feels familiar and safe. Joy feels risky. What if we lose it? What if it makes us seem shallow? But joy is not shallow. Joy is resilient. Joy is proof that life continues despite the pain. A friendship rooted in joy says, 'I see your pain, and I honor it, but I also see your strength, your humor, and your capacity for delight.' It celebrates the whole human, not just the damaged parts. This doesn’t mean you ignore the hard stuff. It means you don’t make the hard stuff the only thing. So how do you change this if you’re already in one of these relationships? First, you have to notice it. Name it internally. Notice when you leave a conversation feeling drained instead of recharged. Notice when you feel relieved that the call is over because you’re tired of processing grief. Then, gently introduce the light. Bring up a topic that has nothing to do with pain. Ask a question about their interests. Share something silly. Watch how they react. Some friends will resist. They might pull back or redirect the conversation back to the problem. That’s a sign that the dynamic is deeply entrenched. But others will breathe a sigh of relief. They might admit they’re tired of talking about the trauma too. They might light up when you mention a movie or a memory of fun times. Be patient. These patterns took years to form. Shifting them takes time. You might need to set gentle boundaries around venting. 'I love supporting you, but I want to make sure we also have time to just hang out and not talk about work drama.' It sounds simple, but it’s revolutionary. You are teaching your friend that you can handle joy. You are teaching them that they don’t have to perform their pain to be loved by you. Ultimately, we have to ask ourselves what we’re looking for in our connections. Are we looking for a mirror for our suffering? Or are we looking for a companion for our life? Shared trauma can create a powerful initial hook, but it cannot sustain a lifelong bond. Life is mostly mundane. It’s mostly Tuesday nights and grocery runs and boring meetings and lazy Sundays. If your friendship can’t survive the mundane, it won’t survive the long haul. Shared joy builds resilience. It creates a reservoir of good memories that you can dip into when life gets hard again. Because life will get hard again. Everyone faces loss. Everyone faces failure. But if you have a foundation of laughter and shared interests, you have a safety net that isn’t made of tears. You have a place to land that feels like home, not just a shelter. I’m not saying to abandon friends who are grieving. Grief needs community. But I am saying to evaluate your overall balance. Does your friendship feel like a sanctuary? Or does it feel like a job? You deserve friends who celebrate your victories as enthusiastically as they hold your hand through your defeats. You deserve connections that lift you up, not just ones that hold you up when you’re falling. Let’s build friendships that are strong enough to handle the pain, but light enough to dance in the joy. Thank you for sitting with me today. I hope you take a moment to check in with your own heart tonight. Who brings you light? Who drains you? Trust that feeling. I’ll be here next time. Take care of yourselves.