Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Great Financial Services Debate
Transcript
- 0:00Everybody, welcome to your episode of Newcomer.
- 0:03Tom Doton here, joined by Madeline Renbarger and Eric
- 0:06Newcomer of Newcomer. We're all in San Francisco right
- 0:09now, but we are not all in the same place, actually.
- 0:12Madeline and I are holed up at our friend Volley's offices,
- 0:16which is as close to newcomer HQ in San Francisco as you can get.
- 0:20I would say this is the Newcomer Satellite office.
- 0:23Absolutely. You gotta come in.
- 0:24We can't all be in the same place for security reasons.
- 0:27We don't want all newcomer employees together.
- 0:29It was dangerous enough this week.
- 0:31Yeah, well, right. Good transition to the reason
- 0:34we're here, which is that we are fresh off the Breaking the Bank
- 0:37Summit, the Fintech Summit annual thing.
- 0:40Although what is it the second year you've done it?
- 0:42Well, the first year we called it the Newcomer Banking Summit,
- 0:45and we realized fintech was much more exciting than banking.
- 0:48So in some ways this was the first year and in some ways it
- 0:51was the second. You know, that was a little
- 0:53awkward on stage. It's like people are coming
- 0:55back, but this is the first time.
- 0:57But yeah, this was, yeah, our first pure Fintech summit with
- 1:00some returning faces. Right, there were some returning
- 1:04returning faces, like Jackie Reesus.
- 1:05Yeah, Matt Harris from Bain Capital Ventures came back for
- 1:08presentation round two. Big hit of both events I would
- 1:12say. All in all, it was a lot of
- 1:13people across the fintech world. It was fun kind of getting to
- 1:18talk to them in between sessions at the after party as well,
- 1:21which was exclusive. We try not to talk about the
- 1:25after party, but. Don't tell them I.
- 1:27You know I ran into like. The guy who'd gotten viral
- 1:29because he was trying to have people take out debt to make
- 1:33investment accounts, I don't know if you saw that the other
- 1:35day. I think it was like Basic
- 1:36Capital, who I had no idea was even going to be there there.
- 1:38So that's what I love about these events.
- 1:40You know, we try to get great founders there.
- 1:42And then I'm like, Oh yeah, I've I've heard of your company.
- 1:45So, yeah, it was a good crowd. And then excited about what we
- 1:47have to share about what happened on stage.
- 1:50Conversations ranged from a ton of different topics around
- 1:53fintech. I mean, the premise was, you
- 1:54know, fintech is back, baby. And then, you know, we had to go
- 1:57on stage and really ask, is it back?
- 1:59But stable coins certainly are back.
- 2:02The big resonating theme of the day was everyone is super pumped
- 2:06about stable coins. Probably.
- 2:07Talking about stable coins is back.
- 2:09Tripe a done, you know a billion dollar acquisition, billion plus
- 2:12dollar acquisition of Bridge. We had the Bridge CEO as the
- 2:15second person on stage. Jackie Reesus at Lead Bank is a
- 2:20bank that's really backed stable coin fintech companies.
- 2:23So we definitely open the day strong with people who are
- 2:26excited about. It, I mean, later in the day,
- 2:27too, we had, you know, Eric Gleiman from Ramp who has
- 2:30launched with Stripe and Bridge for a staple coin card.
- 2:34Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:35I mean, in the background of all this, you know, Tether is making
- 2:37more money than per employee that almost like any company in
- 2:40history off of stable coins. So everybody sees that there's
- 2:45like a ton of money to be made. And of course, Congress was
- 2:48passing legislation right as we were holding the event to make
- 2:52stable coins much more legal to do or clearly legal.
- 2:55So yeah, that I think that was theme A.
- 2:58We've decided the selects for this episode will be from Theme
- 3:02B, which I thought was equally interesting.
- 3:05Yeah, theme BI mean there was a big debate that I feel like is
- 3:08still kind of unsettled, which I find interesting.
- 3:10So we'll hear different perspectives on it later.
- 3:12But around, you know, the idea of AI enabling startup founders
- 3:17to go after service businesses, you know, like accounting, legal
- 3:20tech services, but you know, accounting, especially since
- 3:23this was a fintech summit and where the merits are around, you
- 3:26know, fully pitching your startup as a service business
- 3:30that can be fully enabled with AI, or rather, you know,
- 3:32sticking to software and you know, being the software
- 3:34provider for these businesses. Matt Harris at Bain Capital
- 3:37Ventures gave a presentation which I think captured some of
- 3:40the venture capitalists sentiment well, which is
- 3:43financial services businesses are enormous.
- 3:46You know, you think about accounting or broader services
- 3:50businesses like law. There are many, many, many
- 3:53billions of dollars of money to be made there.
- 3:56But of course, they're human intensive businesses, the kind
- 3:59that tech companies traditionally shy away from.
- 4:02But the argument is that now, thanks to large language models,
- 4:05start up founders should go after those categories.
- 4:08And Harris was arguing basically, definitely good for
- 4:11start up founders, maybe not as good for venture capitalists
- 4:15because they're still gonna be, you know, you might out operate
- 4:18a law firm, but you're not necessarily going to build, you
- 4:20know, a Facebook. So that was Harris's argument.
- 4:24And then as you're going to listen in these conversations, I
- 4:27put that question to Digit CEO Jeff Siebert and Rogo CEO
- 4:31Gabriel Stengel in our first conversation.
- 4:34And then I talked with Josh Reeves, the CEO of Gusso,
- 4:38probably one of the most experienced founders we had on
- 4:40stage and asked them, you know, do you really want to run a
- 4:44services business? Jeff at Digits had really stood
- 4:48up an accounting practice to build their QuickBooks
- 4:51competitor. And then Josh Augusto certainly
- 4:55has built some of these services businesses.
- 4:58But again, I think to sort of see if they can build software.
- 5:01So where did you guys net out in terms of the argument?
- 5:05Matt Harris, back to his presentation.
- 5:06He ended very strong in an interesting way by basically
- 5:09saying I'm tired of nibbling around the edges of fintech.
- 5:12You know, this is a $33 trillion opportunity, which I guess means
- 5:16all banking around the world. Well, it's also including
- 5:18accounting, it's including accounts receivable, it's
- 5:21including, you know, health insurance brokerages, as much
- 5:24money as possible that you know, any money industry I.
- 5:27Don't know if you guys heard this, but it elicited a woo.
- 5:29Yeah, from Jackie Reese's. I at least heard it.
- 5:32She was right in front of me while he was she also.
- 5:33Sent me an e-mail saying she loved that quote too.
- 5:35So yeah, she clearly agreed with that idea.
- 5:38Well, who wouldn't want to be part of a $33 trillion
- 5:40opportunity? But but I think that kind of
- 5:42speaks to the challenge that fintech has had, which is like,
- 5:45is this just some sort of, you know, skimming of, of businesses
- 5:48that the big banks and other financial institutions aren't
- 5:51already taking? Or is it like truly disruptive,
- 5:53right? Is fintech, Venmo transfers,
- 5:57weird loans, helping people, you know, finance their burritos?
- 6:01Or is it, you know, the core of the American economy that big
- 6:05services companies have been able to deliver?
- 6:07Or a bunch of small ones, Honestly, a lot of small
- 6:10businesses doing accounting and law and all these things that
- 6:13they want to tackle. Right.
- 6:15And like bringing it back to like large language models, like
- 6:17is this the entry point to this larger business, to this larger
- 6:21opportunity or you know, are we still going to be about these
- 6:24kind of marginal disruptive plays that can build real
- 6:28businesses like Klarna or a firm, but aren't, you know, I
- 6:32don't think are really necessarily taking 33 trillion
- 6:34as the opportunity there. I will say, I mean the success
- 6:38of Rogo so far, you know, they're basically building an AI
- 6:42agent that can automate the work of an investment making analyst,
- 6:45which is very specific, but has taken off, especially in an
- 6:49industry where, you know, unlike accounting, you can get most of
- 6:52the way there and the people will say, you know, this is good
- 6:55enough, we got this done. And so that is one place where I
- 6:59can see the service automation be very promising.
- 7:01But that being said, it is a pretty specific service that
- 7:04they're automating there. So we'll see how that expands
- 7:06accounting. Of course you know it's tricky
- 7:08'cause you don't want to mess that up.
- 7:10I, I think that's a key point, right, Gabe with Rogo is, you
- 7:15know, they're trying to replace like the Goldman Sachs analyst
- 7:17or even just, you know, give you a sort of cheap analyst that
- 7:20that has a rundown on companies you care about.
- 7:23You know, you imagine the bankers already like going on
- 7:25ChatGPT and be like quick before this client meeting.
- 7:27Tell me the download on this random like oil and gas company
- 7:30I've never heard of. And so there, it's like Rogo.
- 7:33Doesn't need to be 100% crack. They just need to be better than
- 7:36sort of the lazy version of this.
- 7:39And obviously they have, you know, aspirations to be much
- 7:42higher quality than that, but they don't need to be 100%
- 7:45correct. They need to help you get pretty
- 7:47broad coverage and be able to move quicker than you can right
- 7:50now. Whereas accounting, as Jeff was
- 7:52saying, you know, you need to get it right and you know, a lot
- 7:55of what they would need language models for is sort of the boring
- 7:59business of tagging all your expenses, which is somehow is
- 8:03still a task that's like cannot be fully solved by technology
- 8:08right now. And so he talks about how they
- 8:10use machine learning for a lot of the tagging because he finds
- 8:13it much more accurate. And then when they really can't
- 8:17figure it out, they sort of see if a language model can sort of
- 8:20crack it, but they're not really relying on it.
- 8:22So Madeline, I think exactly like you're saying, it really
- 8:26depends what business you're in, how much you trust language
- 8:29models that aren't totally consistent.
- 8:31You know, Jeff made the point like, well, ultimately you can't
- 8:35sue the AI. So if you mess up my accounting
- 8:37books, like, you'll sue the CPA. So there's a different stakes.
- 8:42You know, the last thing I'll point to before we throw it to
- 8:45you can listen to them. I did all that reporting on
- 8:48bench, the accounting firm in Canada that blew up where the
- 8:52founder basically said, oh, if you hadn't pushed me out, this
- 8:55would might have turned out differently.
- 8:57And you know, you can read those stories and it had a lot to do
- 9:00with the particular investors and executives.
- 9:04There was this real lesson that building a startup that hires a
- 9:07bunch of accountants is is a big headache.
- 9:09And so building a tech company where you're going to try and
- 9:13hire all the people and then slowly figure out how to do it
- 9:17better with software, it's hard to guarantee that you can bridge
- 9:20that gap. And then one day you may find
- 9:22yourself just operating a regular accounting firm and your
- 9:26investors want you to have, you know, the margin profile of a
- 9:30hot start up. And then you're in big trouble.
- 9:32Good recap of the event, guys, and I think now we should just
- 9:35kick it on over to two of the highlights of the event.
- 9:43Very excited about this panel. We're going to have a great
- 9:46discussion about what is possible with artificial
- 9:49intelligence in fintech. We have two of the very well
- 9:54financed cutting edge startups here.
- 9:56Both of you can certainly claim that.
- 9:58Gabe, you want to start with Rogo and just give the quick
- 10:01like what you guys are doing? Happy to.
- 10:03Thanks for having me. I'm Gabe.
- 10:05I'm the CEO and founder of Rogo. We're training an AI analyst for
- 10:08investment banks, private equity firms, and hedge funds.
- 10:11We're a Series B company backed by Khosla, Thrive, Eric Schmidt.
- 10:15A number of other folks deployed a, you know, a number of public
- 10:19investment banks, large alternative asset managers,
- 10:21large public equity investors. And you're, you're replacing the
- 10:24banking analyst, right? Not yet, not yet.
- 10:27Banking analyst right now, I mean, everything can be broken
- 10:31up into augmentation and automation and we're much more
- 10:34on the augmentation side still, even though, you know, I think
- 10:36we and a lot of folks see that changing quickly.
- 10:39And Jeff, the Digit story. Yeah.
- 10:42So two months ago, we launched the first feature complete
- 10:44replacement to QuickBooks in 20 years since 0 came out.
- 10:47It was a long build. We started the company in 2018
- 10:50and we're basically in R&D stealth mode ever since.
- 10:53And so our goal has been to basically automate and make
- 10:56small business finance real time intuitive, actually helpful to
- 10:58the business owner, not put them in a position where they're
- 11:01waiting two to three weeks to get a black and white PNL, which
- 11:03is sort of. You're coming for a QuickBooks.
- 11:05Space 100%, yeah. And there there are lots of
- 11:09problems with QuickBooks. Some of them have nothing to do
- 11:12with what a foundation model could produce, and some.
- 11:15So dude, how do you break down Yeah, how much of what's making
- 11:18digits different has to do with things foundation models can
- 11:21produce? So.
- 11:22It is pretty fundamental. I would broaden it to machine
- 11:25learning. So when I started the company in
- 11:262018, our premise was can we build the first GLA general
- 11:30Ledger for accounting that's ML native.
- 11:33We honestly got very lucky with this whole AI wave.
- 11:35Now it's AI native. Great.
- 11:37OK. But we primarily do traditional
- 11:40machine learning. If you look at accounting as a
- 11:42field, it is predictive, It is not generative.
- 11:45You do not want an LLM hallucinating your books.
- 11:48And so we custom train and run our own models in production.
- 11:51We do fall back to LLM Foundation models as sort of a
- 11:54worst case scenario. But our story to the industry is
- 11:57we are automating the bookkeeping.
- 11:59We automate 93% of it today. And what's unique about the
- 12:02accounting industry is they want that they are as a profession
- 12:06trying to up level the profession away from bookkeeping
- 12:08and into advisory and sort of client communication work.
- 12:12And so that's what they're going for, I mean.
- 12:14Basically, you use machine learning tag expenses, get it
- 12:17100% right, and then if you're tagging system doesn't work,
- 12:20you're like, all right, we'll try an LLM and see if it's sort
- 12:22of more free thinking style can tag it itself.
- 12:26That's the right way to think about it.
- 12:27So if a business has seen the transaction before, our
- 12:30predictive models are effectively 100% perfect.
- 12:32If the transaction is novel to the business, we then fall back
- 12:36to different tiers of models that ultimately result in an
- 12:39agent. Like what does your bookkeeper
- 12:41do? If you have something totally
- 12:42new? They Google it.
- 12:43What does the agent do? It Googles it.
- 12:47Gabe, that I don't know. I don't take that as the most
- 12:49optimistic view of what LLMS can do.
- 12:52It's sort of like, oh, we have our accurate ones and then we
- 12:54have our like guy who Googles things and like sometimes he's
- 12:57helpful. Like you're much more leaned
- 13:00into, like LLMS can deliver real value to bankers.
- 13:04What's possible right now? How accurate is your software?
- 13:07It's. Funny, Jeff and I were were just
- 13:09discussing it backstage because we have two very different
- 13:12products and very different users.
- 13:13If you get financials that are not 100% accurate and you are a
- 13:17small business and you don't know how to go in and audit
- 13:19those books yourself, that's a pain.
- 13:21If I give something that's, you know, good enough for an
- 13:23associate to check, you know, maybe as accurate as their first
- 13:26year analyst who's not perfectly, perfectly accurate,
- 13:28that's actually very value additive.
- 13:31Part of the, the benefit we had is that when we went in, folks
- 13:35were used to using products like Chacha, BT and a lot of our
- 13:38early users realized these tools can be very valuable without
- 13:41being 100% accurate. And so I mean, the last thing I
- 13:44would ever say when selling is that we are in 100% accurate
- 13:46tool. What I would say is you can get
- 13:48a lot more value than you think before they're 100% accurate.
- 13:50You need to be better than someone who's right out of
- 13:52college, and you need to be better than a lazy banker using
- 13:56chachi. Exactly.
- 13:57And as we learn, right, the way your intern learns to be an
- 14:00analyst, learns to be an associate, VP, director, when
- 14:02we're at director level, we're not going to get wooed by a
- 14:04better paycheck somewhere else and all the enterprise value
- 14:07isn't going to walk out the door and go to a competitive bank.
- 14:10And what I mean, what's the coolest thing you can do today?
- 14:12Like where do you think Rogo is really excelling?
- 14:15Like what is the sort of query I?
- 14:17Mean it does things why you should use.
- 14:19I was an investment banking analyst at at Lazard.
- 14:22I did buy Side M and A coverage for healthcare companies and I
- 14:25didn't know anything about healthcare companies and we
- 14:28would help large biopharma companies spend $5 billion to
- 14:32buy biotechs and it can do almost all the work I did in the
- 14:35analysis of those companies, right?
- 14:37Like looking at their R&D pipeline, thinking about the
- 14:39different you sort of oncology areas that might be additive for
- 14:42Johnson and Johnson or or someone similar and then
- 14:45preparing a presentation on why it would be additive to J and JS
- 14:48overall M and a strategy. I mean we can put together the
- 14:51materials diligence, the company, look through their
- 14:53financials, do a do a lot of what these folks are doing.
- 14:58Jeff, I mean, we saw sort of the presentation from Matt Harris
- 15:01earlier, which is like get into the services business.
- 15:04And I, I wrote last year a fair bit about like bench accounting,
- 15:08which tried to sort of do accounting plus the actual
- 15:11accountants. I mean, you're going after
- 15:14QuickBooks, right? You are not building an
- 15:15accountant team. You've, I think you've used some
- 15:17accounting firms to sort of understand your product, but why
- 15:21not go I guess whole hog and say we will be your accountant.
- 15:24We know how to use our software better than anybody.
- 15:27We'll take advantage of it and do the whole thing.
- 15:29This is such a good question. So and just to clarify, we
- 15:31actually do have an accounting team.
- 15:33We do have an accounting firm. Some of you may have seen our
- 15:35billboards. We do full service accounting
- 15:37for hundreds of top startups now, OK.
- 15:39That is not the business that we are not scaling that OK.
- 15:42Yeah, because. We are.
- 15:43I didn't think I was that wrong. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we do it, but
- 15:45we're not going to do it at scale.
- 15:46So we have. Capped the client, got it, got
- 15:48it. The reason we did that is we
- 15:49need to present a model firm to the industry, right?
- 15:52And so if you look at the accounting industry, they're of
- 15:54course traditionally relatively risk averse, relatively slow to
- 15:57adopt new tools. The cloud transition took them
- 15:5915 years. I'm not joking.
- 16:01And so we want to accelerate that a bit.
- 16:03And so we did build out a model firm to show you how you can run
- 16:07digits as a practice that is not the core business.
- 16:09And so I do think there's been a trap in the space.
- 16:12If you look at some of the well known sort of previous offerings
- 16:15that have tried to build a services business with some
- 16:18internal tech. And I mean you even see Atrium
- 16:20that failed at that in the legal space.
- 16:22I think it's incredibly hard to bring together a software
- 16:25business and a services business and actually scale it to high
- 16:28margin. And so we've been really
- 16:29disciplined on, we hire software engineers.
- 16:32It is a software product like there is no slippery slope of
- 16:35humans doing any of the work. Why?
- 16:37Why has QuickBooks been able to hold on so well?
- 16:40Yes, it's a marketplace product, believe it or not.
- 16:44And when QuickBooks came onto the scene in the early 90s, it
- 16:47also had taken them five years to build.
- 16:49They were sort of building on the backs of the personal
- 16:52computer revolution. For the first time, you could
- 16:53really do accounting for your own business, like in your own
- 16:56office. And the problem is you need both
- 16:58the business owner and the accountant to really buy in on.
- 17:02I'm going to use this software. And now 30 years later,
- 17:05accountants view it as a career choice.
- 17:06It's a religious preference. Like I'm a QuickBooks
- 17:08accountant, I'm a zero accountant, I'm a NetSuite
- 17:10accountant. And so that's the barrier to
- 17:12break down. Fortunately, there is a macro
- 17:15trend in our favour. So 33% of fewer people are
- 17:19pursuing Cpas. Gen.
- 17:21Z does not want to be an accountant, which you may or may
- 17:23not blame them. And 75% of Cpas are at
- 17:26retirement age. And so they're seeing this
- 17:28talent crisis as the sort of final motivation of, OK, we need
- 17:32to actually change software, We need to automate our role, We
- 17:34need to up level the profession. So I think that trend is very
- 17:37favorable. Gabe, you know, want to sort of
- 17:40give a guide book for other companies, you know, you're,
- 17:43you're, you're sort of at the cutting edge of using language
- 17:46models in your business. I'm curious how much you think
- 17:50what we've seen with ChatGPT is an endorsement of text based
- 17:54exchange interfaces. Like do you think the regular
- 17:58person or your banker customer wants to type inquiries and get
- 18:02great responses or do you think that's sort of an entry point
- 18:05over time? It's more and more like
- 18:06software. Look, I think we're lucky in
- 18:09that we, we have a lot of users who use the product we have
- 18:12today. I don't know if that means we
- 18:14have, you know, any predictive abilities about what that UX
- 18:17should be 5 years from now. For me, the abstraction is what
- 18:21is the easiest way for me to communicate with someone on my
- 18:23team. It's probably Slack, e-mail,
- 18:25text message, phone call. You know, if I ask for a
- 18:28deliverable, I get sent to PDFI review it.
- 18:30Occasionally I'll jump into the PowerPoint, the Excel backup
- 18:33myself. I think that's a very human way
- 18:35to work and there's a lot of throughput in that, you know,
- 18:37you can communicate, indicate a ton.
- 18:39I think at the limit, that's what you want these interfaces
- 18:41to look like. If you're building an assistant,
- 18:44if you're building, you know, an analyst replacement, if you're
- 18:47building Jeff's business, you know, I, I'd rather just have my
- 18:50books integrate directly into, you know, whatever systems those
- 18:52need to go into. I don't know anything about.
- 18:54No, this is actually, this is great because this is such a a
- 18:58product specific difference, right?
- 18:59Like as a startup founder, business owner, I don't want
- 19:02another person to manage. I don't want another thing to
- 19:04talk to, I just want the accounting done right and so we
- 19:07very explicitly have no chat UI in the product the data comes
- 19:11in. It is booked where?
- 19:12The output of Rogue, oh, I mean analysts would produce a report,
- 19:15so it's not that. Yeah, I got you, but.
- 19:17The way you would iterate might be, Hey, why'd you do this?
- 19:19Hey, add a page on this. Hey, Are you sure?
- 19:21You know, that was the post money valuation for the company
- 19:23and in the comp set. But I mean, it's, it's, you
- 19:25know, for, for Jeff, it's like, I don't want to hire an FPNA
- 19:28person, right? We're getting to the scale where
- 19:30it's like, you know, we need someone and I really don't want
- 19:32to do it. I'd rather just have those
- 19:34systems work and I don't want to talked about it with someone
- 19:36either. Right.
- 19:37Are you an evangelist when you talk to other fintech founders
- 19:41of like they should be applying foundation models to their
- 19:44business? Or are you more on the side of
- 19:46like, we picked the right area, it makes sense where we're doing
- 19:48it. And like, I don't know if it
- 19:50makes sense for your business. Yeah.
- 19:52I was I yesterday at Khosla Ventures is one of our big
- 19:55backers and, and they had a big summit yesterday and, and
- 19:58something that one of the speakers kept hammering was it's
- 20:00very hard for incumbents in a space to innovate, to brainstorm
- 20:04the sort of, you know, not just the incremental way to apply
- 20:06LLMS to your business, but the whole new business model that
- 20:09emerges. And part partly why digits is so
- 20:11fascinating is because it's innovating on the business model
- 20:14in addition to, you know, the actual technology.
- 20:16But I mean, I was, I was pushing Jeff in our we had lunch
- 20:19together to catch up before this.
- 20:20And I'm saying it sounds like you're not using.
- 20:22LLMS enough and he had a great retort and he obviously knows
- 20:26his business better than I do. But I mean, I think anyone who's
- 20:28not trying to use these tools in in kind of a step change way as
- 20:32opposed to an incrementalist way is is waiting for someone else
- 20:35to Jeff. You're an incrementalist.
- 20:39This is great. No, I mean to be clear, we do
- 20:41use LLMS, we do use agents. We've been running in in
- 20:43production for 18 months now. I'd say we are extremely
- 20:46disciplined on making sure we can guarantee the accuracy of
- 20:50the output. And so for an example like where
- 20:52we do use LLMS, we actively prevent them from doing math
- 20:56because yes, they've gotten better at math, but they can
- 20:58still slip up. Our team literally wrote an RPN
- 21:01calculator tool that we give to the LLMS and we tell them if you
- 21:04need to do math, do not try use this tool.
- 21:06And so there are a bunch of things you can do to put
- 21:08safeguards around it. What?
- 21:10Do you think about that? Well, you know, I, I think it's
- 21:13kind of the analogy I would use and it's going to be a really
- 21:16strained analogy, so bear with me.
- 21:18But the sort of Jeff Bezos thing of, you know, your margin is my
- 21:21opportunity, your accuracy threshold is someone else's
- 21:24opportunity because they're going to build something that's
- 21:25not going to work today or tomorrow.
- 21:27But all of a sudden the base models will be good enough where
- 21:29you could skip all these layers of complexity and structure to,
- 21:33you know, make up for that accuracy.
- 21:35And suddenly, you know, they will have some of that more
- 21:37human reasoning and be capable of so much more.
- 21:39I don't know if that's right in. Jeff on like the continued
- 21:43improvement of the models and if you spend too much time fixing
- 21:47the models today, you're missing out on the, I mean saving the
- 21:49problem is. How do you thread the needle?
- 21:51How do you get enough adoption and traction today to, you know,
- 21:54validate putting more in R&D for the future?
- 21:56And like, depending on how accurate you need to be, yeah,
- 21:59you might need to do some anachronistic things or like,
- 22:02you know, not use it, just throw LLMS at every problem, right?
- 22:04It's not, you know, you don't just want to use LLMS for
- 22:07everything. But I do think that like, you
- 22:10know, if if you aren't, if you aren't willing to, to accept
- 22:14some faultiness, some bugginess, some hallucination in parts of a
- 22:17product like someone else will. And then someone else will
- 22:21potentially figure out the new product paradigm or UX that's
- 22:23going to work when the models just get, you know, 10% more
- 22:26reliable. Jeff, we're in this moment
- 22:30where, you know, people are like, oh, we don't need software
- 22:32anymore. You're going to use like a
- 22:33coding agent to build it. Like I'm going to build my own
- 22:36custom model. Like why isn't the next digits
- 22:38just like a home brewed version of 0 instead of like your your
- 22:43company? Right now this, this is a really
- 22:46good question. And Can you imagine the models
- 22:47get so good that you don't need the accounting software at all,
- 22:50right? And like, could the model just
- 22:52you, you give it your data and it does your books?
- 22:54I, I don't think that is the future you want because
- 22:57ultimately this is still a workflow.
- 22:59It's a real business process that you need everyone involved
- 23:01with. You need user accounts,
- 23:03permissioning, notification sharing, like you need an actual
- 23:06experience. And so even to the extent we
- 23:09invest in the AII, do think it comes down to you also need to
- 23:12build better accounting software, right?
- 23:14And it's the same thing I would say with Figma, it's like, OK, I
- 23:17don't think Figma is disappearing.
- 23:19It can help you. It can automate a lot of the
- 23:20stuff, but you still ultimately want to canvas your team can
- 23:22collaborate around. And that's how we you finance.
- 23:25Like if you could picture a Figma for finance, what would it
- 23:28be? So we try to look at it as a
- 23:30broader product perspective where the AI is a core tool, but
- 23:34it's one piece of the entire vision.
- 23:36Just like if you were to build like, oh, Redis came out now, do
- 23:39you not need a whole other like class of products?
- 23:42You sort of still do like Redis is great technology, but you
- 23:44still need the actual experience around it.
- 23:46Do. You think we're close to you
- 23:48having the problem of someone gets an accountant who that
- 23:52accountant is using language models that are trying to
- 23:54interact with your software and then you're trying to figure out
- 23:57how much to serve them or have you started to see that or are
- 24:00we too early? We're we're a little too early.
- 24:02The accountants aren't that quite They're not only.
- 24:04Adopters. But we we think deeply about the
- 24:08collaborative flows like the accountant is in the picture.
- 24:10And this is actually an interesting point for folks as
- 24:13we talk with business owners. They do not want AI accounting,
- 24:18IE the the AI does 100%. They actually want the AI to do
- 24:21most of it. And they want their books
- 24:23blessed by a real CPA. Because you can't sue the AI,
- 24:28right? You need someone to I.
- 24:29Need a human I can blame? And so that is actually really,
- 24:33really important and that's why the industry is not going
- 24:35anywhere, right? They will up level and be able
- 24:37to serve more clients. But you still need that human to
- 24:40have blessed the books. Gabe, the rapper question, I
- 24:43mean, we sort of in the presentation earlier today, sort
- 24:45of, you know, we've, we've moved to a point where it's like, OK
- 24:48to be a rapper. We don't use that term because
- 24:49it's pejorative. Like where are I, I, you know, I
- 24:53love to use pejorative words positively.
- 24:55Like I've been on the case that it's like, no, you differentiate
- 24:58on the product and software, not necessarily like on the model.
- 25:01How would you calibrate that in terms of how much you need to
- 25:04have at some point, your own models, your own thinking, or
- 25:08we're going to be the best at directing chachi tea and
- 25:11anthropic and everybody towards our use case.
- 25:14Look, it kind of goes back to how Jeff answered the question,
- 25:17which is even if you have a profoundly intelligent model,
- 25:20you still need the tools to, you know, do the accounting workflow
- 25:22right. It's like even if you have a
- 25:24robot that can move the way human hand, they still need a
- 25:26drill to go, you know, install whatever they're installing for
- 25:30us. We're building the tools that
- 25:31some eventual agent intelligence either owned by us or someone
- 25:35else might use, Whether that's an Excel interface for an agent,
- 25:38whether that's a PowerPoint interface, whether that's
- 25:40structured financial data querying or unstructured
- 25:43financial data querying or integrations into the internal
- 25:46data systems of the banks and private equity firms we work
- 25:48with. That said, I think it's very
- 25:51clear that reinforcement learning is working and POST
- 25:54training is working on top of these Frontier models.
- 25:57And with very great specific evals you can actually
- 26:01outperform the Frontier. You with post training alone,
- 26:05you can find a lot of technological differentiation
- 26:07that that makes it more valuable.
- 26:09Yeah, I I mean, I think. I think that's what early
- 26:11results are showing. I don't know if there's, I mean,
- 26:13actually cognition had a great paper that they, I mean, not
- 26:16paper. It was a Twitter thread, but it
- 26:17but it was a great Twitter thread that.
- 26:19Sums up something in the current it was a.
- 26:20Great Twitter thread. Like maybe a week ago on they
- 26:24had, they had post trained a model with RFT for, you know,
- 26:27writing like CUDA kernels or something that that's quite
- 26:30difficult for O3. And they got a lot of
- 26:32outperformance with the types of technologies and and
- 26:36reinforcement techniques that are now diffusing through
- 26:37industry. And so I think we'll start to
- 26:39see a lot more of that. It reminds me of when folks used
- 26:41to overclock their CPUs and now CPUs are fast enough where no
- 26:45one really bothers as much. Yeah, No, no, that's, I mean,
- 26:47it's totally possible. I mean, I think the way the way
- 26:50that I think about RFT and post training is not necessarily that
- 26:53it's going to make the model smarter, but it's going to sort
- 26:56of prune the decision tree and make it better at using your
- 26:59tools, right. So like opening eyes never going
- 27:02to have your tool structure and it's training data unless you
- 27:04collaborate with that. And so the same way if you get a
- 27:06super smart human starting at your firm on Monday, they're
- 27:08going to need to learn how to use QuickBooks and zero and I
- 27:11hope digits, you know the model you want to teach it how to use
- 27:14those tools to Yep. Jeff, last question, last word.
- 27:18Would you tell a founder today to build a services business
- 27:22powered by you've done the sort of flirtation with having the
- 27:26accounting firm? Do you buy that investor
- 27:28narrative or do you think it's oversold?
- 27:30I think it's oversold and it's so tough because it is such a
- 27:33tempting narrative. It's build your services
- 27:35business, look at what's slow, automate that, move on, right?
- 27:37You can drive a high margin business.
- 27:39The change management, the actual people management is so
- 27:43challenging because it depends on which profession you're
- 27:46trying to automate. But there's so much built in
- 27:49just like native practices in that profession that in order to
- 27:52really automate everything and build the trust, it's a long
- 27:55journey to get to that margin versus.
- 27:57Just turns out people outside Silicon Valley, they know their
- 27:59businesses too. They're hard businesses.
- 28:01Exactly right. And again with accounting,
- 28:03accounting is complicated like. There is no way to simplify
- 28:06that. Great.
- 28:07Thank you very much. Thank you, Schuber say, about
- 28:13this conversation, two things. One, Gusto's the rare startup
- 28:18where I sort of have a rooting interest in that we are a small
- 28:21business, and every time Gusto solves a problem, I am relieved
- 28:25that you get to take it off my plate.
- 28:27The second thing is it's funny to be hanging out with you with
- 28:29shoes on, you know, do you guys still have you, have you gotten
- 28:32rid of your no shoes policy or are you still I?
- 28:35Feel like I have to give context to people here.
- 28:37So excited to be here. This is a fun space for me
- 28:39because we had a Gusto holiday party here in 2015, but our
- 28:43three first offices were only a block away and we were raised by
- 28:47our parents to take our shoes off at home.
- 28:49So for many years our offices were shoes off, walking around
- 28:52in slippers, socks. We passed them out to folks and
- 28:56then when the pandemic started, obviously people can do whatever
- 28:58they want at their home. Today, it's more of an optional
- 29:00policy. But I do describe it as a
- 29:02tradition that that felt right for gusto at the time.
- 29:05You know, yeah, in some ways it's like you've become this
- 29:08grown up company. Can you give, you know,
- 29:12obviously payroll is at the heart of it, but talk through
- 29:15just briefly what the pieces of Gusto's businesses are today in
- 29:18terms of the focus and where you're really strong?
- 29:22So something really important to know about Gusto is we obsess
- 29:25over a small business. So if we have any customers
- 29:27here, we're honored to serve you.
- 29:29And just know that there are more dentist offices in the US
- 29:33than tech startups. And so we really focus on
- 29:36mainstream small business of the six million ish employers in
- 29:40America, 2/3 or less than 5 employees.
- 29:43And so with that customer focus, payroll is our first product.
- 29:47I always like to say if you don't pay someone, they quit.
- 29:50So it's a pretty non optional product.
- 29:54So we're really happy we started there, but kind of broadening
- 29:57through the back office would be the way to describe it.
- 30:00We really obsess over customer pull versus company push, but
- 30:05benefits is a big investment area for us.
- 30:06There's many, many types of benefits, something I know we're
- 30:09excited to get into more. We have a pretty broad product
- 30:12group inside Gusto called Gusto Money that's focused on things
- 30:16related to cash flow management. For a lot of our customers,
- 30:18their biggest expense is payroll, paying their team.
- 30:22And one of the biggest points of stress is when APAR don't line
- 30:26up and they don't have the money in their bank account at the
- 30:28right moment to fund payroll. So we launched a bill payment
- 30:32not too long ago. Actually next Wednesday, we're
- 30:34going live with invoicing. So you'll see us do a lot more
- 30:37product investments, more in that B2B fintech part, but
- 30:40again, really, really focused on small business.
- 30:43And overall business sort of somewhere between 500 million
- 30:46and a billion in revenue. Can you?
- 30:48Describe it that way. We serve over 400,000 companies.
- 30:51I mean, one fun way we always grounded in customer we're you
- 30:56know, in the range of, you know, 8-9 percent now of all employers
- 30:59in America. And with the business model that
- 31:02leads to, you know, good revenue, we've been free cash
- 31:04flow positive for many years. We reinvest that money back into
- 31:07building new product to solve more pain for our customer.
- 31:11And I mean, you're an important sort of partner to other fintech
- 31:15companies. I know.
- 31:16I think the guidelines CEO was here at one point.
- 31:19What what do you see in terms of like the partnership strategy
- 31:22for Gusso? Yeah.
- 31:24So a big part of our approach to we're here to build a multi
- 31:27decade company, we're still early in the journey even though
- 31:30it's, you know, over 10 years. And that to me is a factual
- 31:33statement, right? We're only at about 89% of
- 31:35employers. You still have 30% of companies
- 31:37in the US doing even things like payroll by hand on pen and
- 31:40paper. So with the obsession on small
- 31:42business, a lot of what we're doing is replacing manual
- 31:45process, but there's just a lot of other pain points we want to
- 31:48help with. And if we're going to get there,
- 31:50it's not going to be entirely through first party products.
- 31:52So we've had a playbook, which we will continue to use of
- 31:55choosing product by product. Are we going to build?
- 31:58Are we going to partner? 4O1K is a good example of where
- 32:01we've partnered historically. And then there's also obviously
- 32:04acquisition. We've done that a few times.
- 32:06We'll do that more going forward for where we deem something that
- 32:09was third party becoming first party.
- 32:11But you know, we're not going to build it all ourselves, and
- 32:14we're excited to partner where it makes sense.
- 32:16Has artificial intelligence changed the pace of product
- 32:20development? I mean, you're, you're an
- 32:22interesting case in that on the one end, it's sort of the, you
- 32:26know, I don't know, Klarna's the world where they're like, well,
- 32:28we'll build everything internally.
- 32:29Like, you know, payroll could be imagined that way.
- 32:32On the other hand, it can accelerate your growth.
- 32:34Like how do you, how are you seeing sort of artificial
- 32:37intelligence, the ability to build faster impacting gusto
- 32:41today, I mean? I'm surprised it took this long
- 32:43to get to AI as a topic. I mean there's so many threads.
- 32:46I think a lot of folks here are technologists.
- 32:48I'll have to just choose like on productivity and how we build.
- 32:52We have 1000 person plus R&D team.
- 32:54I don't think we're that different than most software
- 32:56companies in that it's obviously driving pretty meaningful shift
- 33:00in how we build. You know, the iteration speed.
- 33:03I think we're going to talk later about, you know, there's
- 33:05the service as a software, software as a service, everyone
- 33:09gets SAS. A lot of what we do is taking
- 33:11stuff that involves compliance, involves manual filings and
- 33:16digitizing it into software. In the past I said we use
- 33:20paperless cloud mobile. Now obviously AI is a key
- 33:22ingredient to that, but that's on the more internal how we
- 33:25build side on the. Doesn't mean fewer engineers
- 33:28just to put a fine line on it. Yeah, doesn't mean fewer
- 33:31engineers. Given the scope of our ambition.
- 33:34It means like the amount of work we can do per gusty grows
- 33:38dramatically. But probably in the grand scheme
- 33:41of things, it means less hiring than if AI didn't exist.
- 33:45But we're also pretty ambitious, so we're doing a lot of hiring
- 33:48anyways. But it's because we want to go
- 33:50solve more pain point for our customers.
- 33:51And then on this sort of, do you feel the threat of customers
- 33:56building in house versions of Gus?
- 33:59Honestly, as a small business that's sort of incoherent,
- 34:01right? Because it's like I'm, I'm not
- 34:03going to build an AI team as a five person startup.
- 34:06It would matter more to your enterprise level competitors or
- 34:09how do you think about that challenge I.
- 34:11Mean, I don't think too many dentists want to go, right,
- 34:14build software. That said, the reality is most
- 34:17of what we're doing for a dentist office or other small
- 34:20businesses they haven't had access to in the past.
- 34:23They've been on their own. They've kind of had to do it
- 34:25manually or just not do it. And so for us, AI is enabling
- 34:29products to exist in a small business category that never
- 34:32existed. I think in mid market
- 34:34enterprise, you're navigating more of this complexity of
- 34:36displacing jobs. But our due N is to like grow
- 34:40the small business economy, right?
- 34:42And so we want to bring all of the things big companies have
- 34:45had historically to a small company.
- 34:48The only way we're going to do that right with a ratio that
- 34:51makes sense and with a scalability that makes sense is
- 34:54through leveraging technology. I.
- 34:55Mean, if I had to distill the angst of a small business, it's
- 34:58like I want to know that I'm in good standing and I don't know
- 35:01everything I'm supposed to do. And you guys are, but in the
- 35:04products, sometimes we like, you know, in New York, you're
- 35:06supposed to have sexual harassment training.
- 35:08OK, I'll pay you some money for that.
- 35:09Like, do you think AI is going to move us further along of just
- 35:12being able to give me an assessment?
- 35:14Like, have you done everything you're supposed to do?
- 35:17My combat fee, am I Good question.
- 35:19And like our customers, including you, do not want to be
- 35:24stressed or worrying about that. And it's our job to make sure
- 35:27you know fully if you're good or if there's something you need to
- 35:30do what that exact thing is. And if we can do it for you,
- 35:33even better. But yeah, compliance maps to
- 35:35most of our products, right? Payroll involves a lot of
- 35:37compliance time tracking, PTO involves a lot of compliance,
- 35:41local, state, federal rules. And so AI fits in there in terms
- 35:45of like ingesting. But at the end of the day, it's
- 35:49a compliance engine where accuracy needs to be to the
- 35:52like, you know, 6 Sigma. And that's always been true pre
- 35:56AI, post AI, that's been true since we started the company.
- 35:59How much do you think your customers want to talk to the
- 36:02product? Like, do you see a move to text
- 36:05interfaces now that they're more capable or you're like, we
- 36:09really need to flow whatever advances we have into actually
- 36:12the layout and design of the product?
- 36:15So we always start with like small businesses are busy and
- 36:17it's way too hard to run and build a small business.
- 36:20Still, you can attest to that. And so how can we help them?
- 36:23We can help them by saving time. We can help them by taking 5 or
- 36:2620 or 30 of the hats on their head off their head and doing it
- 36:30for them. Pre AI, I would say we did that
- 36:33through really clean, elegant, easy to use work flows primarily
- 36:37in a web app or a mobile app. That's gone us pretty far,
- 36:40right? Like that's what we're known
- 36:41for. Anyone can use Gusto with no
- 36:43training, no background in running a business.
- 36:46We have high NPS, high customer satisfaction.
- 36:48Our primary way of growing is word of mouth with AI.
- 36:52It's not about the technology, the interface.
- 36:54That's what we get excited about.
- 36:55A conversational interface for a lot of use cases that Gusto does
- 37:00is a more intuitive, more accessible way to use Gusto.
- 37:04You like it? You think it's?
- 37:05Promising. We think it's very promising.
- 37:07Our interface for that is called Gus, which people should
- 37:11hopefully get. I think it's somewhat like this.
- 37:12And then, yeah, well, Penny the pig is.
- 37:14Oh, that's a. Different logo OK, but.
- 37:16Then like you're like cracking Penny in half, but like Penny's
- 37:19being sacrificed for the sake of your conference.
- 37:21But yeah, conversational interface we don't think
- 37:24replaces web app, replaces mobile app.
- 37:26It's just a different surface area.
- 37:28But like we are taking 14 years of functionality and giving Gus
- 37:32those superpowers. So we have customers today,
- 37:35thousands of customers using Gus to go create shift schedules,
- 37:38right? You want to go change who's
- 37:40working with today? You know, take Sally off Friday,
- 37:43add 20 hours to gym. We go do that all for you.
- 37:46You can just tell us that in a conversational interface, or you
- 37:49can go through and navigate, but that saves time for a small
- 37:53business, which they really appreciate.
- 37:54I wanted to put one of the big themes of today to you.
- 37:58I mean, we saw Matt Harris give a presentation where he's making
- 38:02sort of a case that other investors have also made that
- 38:05it's like there's now, thanks to language models, this
- 38:08opportunity to go after services businesses and sort of be the
- 38:12services business while being a tech company.
- 38:15Then later I had Jeff, the CEO of Digits, who's building
- 38:19accounting software. He's, you know, hired
- 38:21accountants to figure it out and then software.
- 38:23And I think he was much more skeptical of that sort of, you
- 38:26can be a services tech business. Where where do you land?
- 38:30You've built a big business and you touch a lot of services.
- 38:34Like are you bullish on that argument?
- 38:37So I think we've had a kind of unique perspective to this
- 38:41because the first product we launched payroll mostly if you
- 38:46put aside like ADP paychecks, which are a minority of the
- 38:48market, the majority of companies in America did payroll
- 38:51by hand or with a local payroll service Bureau, which was
- 38:55basically a service manual localized business solution.
- 38:59So a lot of our journey has been taking and did it with health
- 39:03benefits, right? We are a broker.
- 39:04There are thousands of brokerage firms across the country that
- 39:07mostly do things by hand. So we take these complex
- 39:10compliance centric spaces and we do what we do best, which is we
- 39:15digitize the heck out of it because if we're going to go do
- 39:17it for 400,500 thousand, a million businesses, we cannot do
- 39:22it ourselves manually. So I don't think it's a zero a
- 39:25hundred, a hundred zero. Like we have operations teams at
- 39:29Gusto, but we have over 400,000 companies today.
- 39:32Our Gusty to employee or ratio is over 1 to 1000.
- 39:36That's only possible with the technology.
- 39:38Right. So you only want to do it if you
- 39:40can get to the point where it's fairly automated, not sort of
- 39:44for a long time, keep the humans sort of trying to figure it out
- 39:47or yeah, how long do you spend sort of like we'll do the human
- 39:50business to try and get to the point where we can automate it
- 39:53before saying, oh, I guess this is sort of, at least with the
- 39:55technology today, a perpetually human.
- 39:57Business, well, we were joking before, right?
- 39:59Like if a company is scaling a service offering to large, large
- 40:03volumes and it's staying service based, that's to me not a tech
- 40:07company, that's just a service business.
- 40:08Different multiple profile, different overhead costs,
- 40:11different operational complexity.
- 40:13We work backwards from what's best for the customer.
- 40:16For us to solve these pain points, it has to be technology,
- 40:18it has to be digital. It's just more accurate, right?
- 40:21We process several $100 billion a year of payroll taxes.
- 40:24If we were doing that manually, it would create human error
- 40:27potential. It would be too time consuming.
- 40:30So we digitize because it's a better experience.
- 40:33But when we're sub scale and trying out new products early,
- 40:35early on, I think it's totally fine to start more manual.
- 40:39It's about getting that feedback loop going, getting that
- 40:41learning going. But that's typically with less
- 40:43than 100 customers, right? If we're going to scale
- 40:46something, it better have good unit economics, good CAC, good
- 40:49gross margin and we should have confidence that it can scale in
- 40:52a, you know, technology enabled way.
- 40:54Otherwise, we're just going to build a huge operations team.
- 40:57Somehow in payroll, you're in like 1 of the wildest categories
- 41:02in Silicon Valley. You have, you know, like
- 41:04Rippling and Deal, you know, making huge accusations,
- 41:08obviously Ripley accusing Deal of spying on it.
- 41:11Have you done an internal check to see whether anyone's spying
- 41:15on you? And what do you make of sort of
- 41:17your high profile, sort of same, same category businesses having
- 41:24so much drama? We we just focus on the
- 41:28customer. Have you have you checked?
- 41:30Have you checked? We have a very, very like
- 41:35intense, like super, super expensive and worth IT security
- 41:39team. Yeah, but that's because we have
- 41:43like hundreds of billions of dollars of our customer money
- 41:46sitting in our accounts. And we, you know, do tax filings
- 41:49and tax payments and we hold Social Security numbers and a
- 41:52whole bunch of very sensitive data that we take that job very
- 41:55seriously. So I can tell you with
- 41:57confidence, we do not believe anyone is spying on Gusto, but
- 42:02that's because that's what our customers should demand of us,
- 42:04that we're obsessed with protecting them in every
- 42:06possible way. Do you see much competition or I
- 42:10mean, you're very focused on small businesses and I like that
- 42:13focus and it gives you a great mandate and sort of a mission to
- 42:17motivate the company. On the other hand, most
- 42:19businesses want to keep their customers.
- 42:21It's like it's much easier to keep the customer you have and
- 42:23grow with them than to find new ones.
- 42:25How do you think about sizing up with your customers?
- 42:29So we're both in a like very crowded space and a very
- 42:33fragmented space. And then yes, I think it's even
- 42:36very simplistic to say small business, medium sized business,
- 42:39large business, these are huge cuts.
- 42:42And even within small business, you have different industry
- 42:44types, different geographies. So, you know, hopefully everyone
- 42:48gets by now. We are obsessed with small
- 42:50business. We tend to see they're less of
- 42:53the kind of frothy Silicon Valley tech kind of drama,
- 42:58frankly. But there's still legitimate
- 43:00companies that have lots of good product in market.
- 43:03Intuit is a company we highly respect and we compete with
- 43:06multiple fronts. And you know, there's a bunch of
- 43:10other companies I used to say was only into IT folks that have
- 43:12built really incredible franchises and small business.
- 43:15You know, Shopify has a huge part of their company that's
- 43:18focused there, Square, Toast, HubSpot.
- 43:21So we feel like we're in good company and I always encourage
- 43:25more entrepreneurs to tackle the small business category.
- 43:28The playbook still is generally for SAS just to move up market
- 43:32and move to bigger enterprise. And in the past, I just meant
- 43:35small business was left. Do you?
- 43:36Want 100% business on Gusto? We have a lot of 100% business
- 43:40on Gusto. Most of them started on Gusto
- 43:43when they were one employee. So our focus is on small
- 43:46business. The vast majority will stay
- 43:48small if some grow bigger. We're honored and happy to serve
- 43:51them. There's probably a point at some
- 43:54point where they graduate. But I like to remind folks, you
- 43:57know, that's very rare, right? Like the number of companies
- 44:00that start at one or two and grow to 100 and our entire
- 44:02history is less than .1%. Is a, you know, we all at the
- 44:07end of the day, live or die by the economy in some ways, and
- 44:10you have a great sort of vantage into a part of it.
- 44:14Is small business in America strong right now?
- 44:16What's your read of the mood among your customers?
- 44:20Yeah. So we have economists on team.
- 44:22We publish a lot of content under Gustanomics and a lot of
- 44:25folks are interested in the data.
- 44:27I'd say high level two things we track a lot new employer starts
- 44:31and then net hiring across our customer base.
- 44:34I'd say on the second that is quite depressed.
- 44:37New hiring new. Hiring, net hiring.
- 44:39So just the propensity of our customers to add more to their
- 44:42team that's been depressed for a few years now on the new
- 44:46employer starts that really with the pandemic got dramatically
- 44:49elevated and it stayed fairly high.
- 44:52But yeah, it's more interesting to track given our size and
- 44:55scale. We feel like we're pretty
- 44:57diversified. It's more just net, net a bet on
- 45:00small business broadly and it tends to be pretty durable
- 45:02segment. Can you talk about the embedded
- 45:06payroll part of your business? And sort of, I mean there is
- 45:09this other trend of, you know, API based businesses right now
- 45:12where it's like, OK, you're helping other people interact
- 45:15with your service, but not necessarily building out the
- 45:17product yourself. How do you think about that as a
- 45:20piece of Gusto's business? Yes, we're always going to be
- 45:23driven by customer pull. So I'm very excited our direct
- 45:27business will keep growing past, you know half a million, a
- 45:30million businesses in the coming years.
- 45:33But a couple years ago we noticed and maybe some of you
- 45:36are part of this trend, but vertical SaaS in particular we
- 45:39got really excited about where you have companies tackling a
- 45:42very specific industry could be very esoteric, but if you obsess
- 45:46over that one category kind of build business in a box, you can
- 45:49actually create a viable tech company there.
- 45:52And every one of these folks kept coming to us and saying,
- 45:55you know, we don't want to build payroll.
- 45:57No one really wants to build payroll cuz it tends to be quite
- 46:00difficult. But we really want to provide
- 46:03payroll to our customer. And we don't want to just keep
- 46:04routing customers to you. We want to have it be native, a
- 46:07native product experience. And so we have some great
- 46:10reference points in embedded in Fintech, especially like Stripe
- 46:15as a good example. And so that was where the
- 46:17genesis of embedded payroll came about.
- 46:19That's what we call Gusto embedded payroll.
- 46:21And we're really excited there. We have a number of partners on
- 46:25the banking side. Chase payroll is powered by
- 46:27Gusto. We recently announced U.S. bank,
- 46:30we'll be rolling out payroll powered by Gusto.
- 46:32You know, 0 is another good example on the contact side.
- 46:36And so anyone that does want to launch or offer a payroll
- 46:39natively within your product but doesn't want to build in from
- 46:42scratch, please let us know. We're eager and excited to
- 46:45partner with you. That whole business is more of
- 46:47an infrastructure. Business, my last question, you
- 46:49know, we have a lot of founders here.
- 46:51You've been at this a while. Like what what?
- 46:54What's your main piece of advice to somebody starting a company
- 46:57today? Or what would you do differently
- 46:59if you were starting Gusto right now?
- 47:02So I'll answer both. My main advice I'm pretty
- 47:05consistent with, but I really believe it.
- 47:08It's imagine the 10 thousandth time you're describing what
- 47:10you're doing. Will you be as excited as the
- 47:12first time? Because at that point you can't
- 47:14fake it, It will show. And you have to have a deeper
- 47:19interest, passion, borderline obsession with the thing you're
- 47:23trying to fix, the problem you're trying to make better
- 47:26because that's what gets you through all the ups and downs of
- 47:28company building. And in our case, you know, I was
- 47:31with a team earlier today that's an incubation team launching a
- 47:34new product. And, you know, we went around
- 47:36the room and it was an easy first question.
- 47:39I didn't even have to ask it. Everyone just shared their
- 47:41favorite small business. And so in our case, you know,
- 47:44that obsession with small business comes through hopefully
- 47:46very clearly. It's a big part of our hiring
- 47:47filter. And as long as they're in pain,
- 47:49we feel like we have purpose and we have so much to do that we
- 47:52feel like we're really still early.
- 47:54There's a lot, lot more ahead. And if I reflect on learnings
- 47:57from prior chapters, I had a prior start up where that wasn't
- 48:00the case. And that's where, you know, you
- 48:03can, you can start a company or if you join a company, you feel
- 48:05like there's a miss there and wonder what's off right.
- 48:09And, and I would argue, you know, go back to like, what is
- 48:12the purpose? What is the reason why you
- 48:14exist? And it should not be about you.
- 48:16It should be about your customer.
- 48:18Great. Well, thank you very much.
- 48:19Thank you.