Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 8)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the program. In
- 0:03this episode, we're getting right back to that brief by
- 0:06the United States Government. In response to glad Maxwell's attempt
- 0:11to appeal her sentence. Part C the discussion, Judge Nathan
- 0:16conducted a thorough inquiry and determined that Jur fifties inadvert
- 0:20errors on the jury questionnaire did not undermine Maxwell's right
- 0:24to a fair trial. Maxwell does not meaningfully engage with
- 0:27Judge Nathan's careful opinion, instead suggesting that juror fifties testimony
- 0:32at the hearing was patently absurd. These conclusiony arguments fall
- 0:37short of establishing that Judge Nathan abused her discretion in
- 0:41finding that this case does not present the extraordinary circumstances
- 0:45that justify overturning a jury's verdict based on an error
- 0:49during vordire. Maxwell's claims fail at the first step of
- 0:53McDonough because jur fifties errors were inadvertent. Jur fifty testified
- 0:58as much at hearing, providing a detailed narrative of why
- 1:02his errors were a failure of diligence as he rushed
- 1:05through the questionnaire while distracted. Judge Nathan credited this explanation
- 1:10in light of his demeanor, which she closely observed as
- 1:13he testified, including during his answers to questions he appeared
- 1:18not to expect. She explained that his answers were logical
- 1:22explanations and generally internally consistent. Given in a calm and
- 1:27straightforward manner. Juror fifties explanations were consistent with his sworn
- 1:31statements months earlier at oral wardire and his testimony that
- 1:36his sexual abuse history was not salient or affront of
- 1:39mind consideration. Judge Nathan also noted that Juror fifty's answers
- 1:45aligned with his incentives by testifying under a grant of immunity,
- 1:49he could not be prosecuted for his false answers on
- 1:52the questionnaire, but he could be prosecuted for false testimony
- 1:55at the hearing, and had he hidden his sexual abuse
- 1:58in order to get on the j he would not
- 2:01have immediately disclosed it to the media after trial. To
- 2:04the contrary, in one video interview with the media, Juror
- 2:07fifty appears genuinely and completely surprised to learn that the
- 2:11question er asked about his history of sexual abuse. Maxwell
- 2:15does not directly challenge Judge Nathan's factual findings on this
- 2:19point much less demonstrate that they are clearly erroneous. Instead
- 2:23relying on United States versus Langford, nine ninety f Dot
- 2:27two D sixty five sixty eight, Second Circuit, nineteen ninety three,
- 2:31Maxwell argues that McDonough's first step is satisfied by any falsehood,
- 2:36deliberate or otherwise. This argument misses Lamark. This prong requires
- 2:41a showing of deliberate dishonesty by the jur rather than
- 2:44mere honest mistake. This Court has explained that in McDonough,
- 2:48the Supreme Court found that the juror's good faith failure
- 2:51to respond, though mistaken, did not satisfy even the first
- 2:55prong of the test. United States versus Shall, forty one
- 2:59ft three d ps D eight eleven, eight fifteen, Second Circuit,
- 3:02nineteen ninety four. The defendant in chall also relied on
- 3:06Langford to contend that a new trial was appropriate even
- 3:09if he can't establish the jurors dishonesty. This Court rejected
- 3:13that argument, concluding that such a contorted reading of Langford
- 3:17is incorrect because it would eliminate the threshold requirement of
- 3:21the McDonagh's test. Jur dishonesty en. This court concluded that
- 3:26the defendant failed to satisfy the first prong of the
- 3:29test because defense counsel explicitly conceded the good faith of
- 3:33the jur id at eight sixteen c. United States versus McCoy,
- 3:38nine to ninety five Ft three D thirty two fifty one,
- 3:41Second Circuit twenty twenty one, holding that District Court properly
- 3:45recognized the initial question to be explored is whether the
- 3:49juror's non disclosure was deliberate or inadvertent. Maxwell's claim also
- 3:54fails that the second step of McDonogh. The hearing established
- 3:57that Juror fifty harbored nobias, approached his jury service with
- 4:00an open mind, and was committed to deciding the case
- 4:03based on the evidence and the District Court's legal instructions.
- 4:07As Judge Nathan found Juru fifty's credible responses two questions
- 4:11asked of all jurors who indicated prior personal experiences with
- 4:15sexual abuse under oath at the hearing established that he
- 4:19would not have been struck for cause if he had
- 4:21provided accurate responses to the questionnaire. Judge Nathan would have
- 4:26asked Dur fifty follow up questions during Vordire to determine
- 4:31if it would have granted a challenge for cause. Judge
- 4:34Nathan asked those questions at the hearing, and jur fifty
- 4:37sworn responses made clear that he was a fair and
- 4:40impartial jur who did not harbor any bias and who
- 4:44would not have been excused for cause. Nor was Juror
- 4:47fifty the subject of any bias actual, implied or inferred.
- 4:52After assessing Juror fifty's demeanor, Judge Nathan found that he
- 4:56repeatedly and credibly affirmed that his personal history of sexual
- 4:59abuse use would not affect his ability to serve as
- 5:02affair and impartial jur in any way, be lying any
- 5:07suggestion that he was actually biased against Maxwell. Judge Nathan
- 5:12also correctly rejected Maxwell's central argument that she should imply
- 5:17or infer bias based on the purported similarities between jur
- 5:21fifties personal history and the issues at trial. Judge Nathan
- 5:25explained that she need not imagine a wholly hypothetical universe
- 5:29to reach that conclusion. During vor Dyer, she asked every
- 5:32follow up question requested by the defendant with regard to
- 5:36a jur's personal experience with sexual assault, abuse, or harassment,
- 5:41although for a majority of these ajurs the defendant did
- 5:44not propose any follow up questions. One prospective jur described
- 5:49her own childhood sexual abuse at an age closer to
- 5:52the victims in this case. Another described a friend's recent
- 5:55coercive sexual abuse by a professor. Maxwell did not even
- 5:59bring a four clause challenge as to either. Similarly, for
- 6:03cause challenge against Juror fifty would not have prevailed on appeal.
- 6:07Maxwell contends that had jur fifty answered the questionnaire accurately,
- 6:12it clearly would have provided a basis for a four
- 6:15cause challenge. In particular, Maxwell challenges Judge Nathan's finding that
- 6:20Juror fifty was credible and unbiased, relying on a few
- 6:23isolated statements drawn from various parts of the hearings transcript
- 6:27and some from post vertic statements. As described above, Judge
- 6:31Nathan explained how Jurorf fifty's explanation for his erroneous answers
- 6:36was plausible and consistent, and she found them credible after
- 6:39assessing his demeanor through challenging questioning. She also properly disregarded
- 6:44his postvertic statements about the case explaining that a juror's
- 6:48view of a case and defendant would necessarily change after
- 6:52reviewing thirteen days of evidence that persuaded twelve jurors of
- 6:55the defendant's guilt. Actual and inferred bias are both committed
- 6:59to the province of the trial judge and Judge Nathan's
- 7:02findings that neither existed were not clearly erroneous. See Torres
- 7:07one twenty eight f. Dot three d at forty four.
- 7:11A finding of actual bias is based upon determinations of
- 7:14demeanor and credibility and are within a trial judge's providence
- 7:19United States versus Greer two eighty five F. Dot three
- 7:22D one fifty eight one seventy two, Second Circuit, two
- 7:25thousand and two. A finding of inferred bias is, by definition,
- 7:29within the discretion of the trial court. Maxwell also argues
- 7:33that Judge Nathan should have implied bias, highlighting some similarities
- 7:37between juror fifty sexual abuse and the sexual abuse discussed
- 7:41a trial that falls far short of requiring the district
- 7:45court to imply bias first. As Judge Nathan explained, the
- 7:48law is not that bias must be implied when a
- 7:52juror has a personal experience similar to the issues at trial. Rather,
- 7:56this Court has consistently refused to create a set of
- 7:59unreasonably constricting presumptions that jurors be excused for cause due
- 8:04to certain occupational or other special relationships which might bear
- 8:08directly or indirectly on the circumstances of a given case.
- 8:13This case is not within one of the rare extreme
- 8:15circumstances where a mandatory presumption of bias applies see Torres
- 8:20one twenty eight ft three d at forty five, Greer
- 8:24two eighty five ft three d at one seventy two second.
- 8:28Although there are some similarities between Juror fifty's childhood sexual abuse,
- 8:32there are also differences. Jur fifty was younger than the
- 8:35trial victims at the time of their abuse, he was
- 8:38abused by a family member, and he disclosed his abuse
- 8:41much earlier, and critically, Juror fifty credibly testified at the
- 8:46hearing that he was able to put aside his experience
- 8:48of sexual abuse and judge the evidence fairly. This is
- 8:52not the sort of extreme situation that calls for a
- 8:55mandatory removal. More generally, it's entirely a pro propriate for
- 9:00jurors to rely on their common sense and life experiences
- 9:04to a judge guilt. These very human elements constitute one
- 9:09of the strengths of our jury system, and we cannot
- 9:11and should not excommunicate them from jury deliberations. Quoting United
- 9:16States own verse McMahon four thirty five ft. Two d.
- 9:21Eight thirteen eight eighteen, Second Circuit, nineteen seventy on these facts,
- 9:26to imply or infer that Juror fifty was biased simply
- 9:29because he was himself a victim of sexual abuse and
- 9:32a trial related to sexual abuse and sex trafficking, and
- 9:35despite his own credible testimony under the penalty of perjury,
- 9:39establishing that he could be an even handed and impartial
- 9:43jur would be tantamount to concluding that an individual with
- 9:47a history of sexual abuse can never serve as affair
- 9:50and impartial jur in such a trial. That is not
- 9:53the law, nor should it be. Finally, Maxwell suggests that
- 9:57Judge Nathan abused her discretion by preclude voting defense counsel
- 10:01from questioning Juror fifty and precluding inquiry into jur of
- 10:04fifty statements to journalists as to the former. The manner
- 10:08in which the hearing proceeds is committed to a distret
- 10:11court sound discretion Moten five eighty two f Dot two
- 10:15d at six sixty six, including specifically the extent to
- 10:19which parties may participate in questioning the witnesses Ianello, eight
- 10:23sixty six f Dot two d at five forty four.
- 10:27Judge Nathan reasonably decided to lead the questioning herself, with
- 10:31repeated opportunities both before and during the hearing for Council
- 10:35to suggest questions, and Judge Nathan's decision is reinforced by
- 10:39Council's requests for vexatious, intrusive, unjustified subpoenas and for questions
- 10:45that swept well beyond Juror fifty's ability to be impartial
- 10:48dur and instead probe deeply into other aspects of his life.
- 10:53As to jur of fifty statements to journalists, it is
- 10:56not entirely clear which statements Maxwell thinks should have been
- 10:59part of the hearing. The hearing, of course, covered both
- 11:02the substance of his sexual abuse and the fact of
- 11:04his statements to journalists. See at two seventy five, asking
- 11:09whether jurf fifty understood from your interviews that the fact
- 11:12that you were abused would be a known fact in
- 11:15the world. It appears that, in Maxwell's view, Judge Nathan
- 11:18should have inquired into whether and how is sexual abuse
- 11:22affected the deliberations in the jury room br seventy one,
- 11:27suggesting that Jurd fifty operated as an unsworn expert on
- 11:30the subject of traumatic memory, acknowledging Rules six oh six
- 11:34b's prohibition an inquiry into jury's deliberations and mental process,
- 11:39Maxwell argues that the exception for extraneous prejudicial information that
- 11:44was improperly brought to the jury's attention that are evidence
- 11:47six six B two A applies here, but Maxwell expressly
- 11:52waives this argument in the district Court, explaining that she
- 11:55does not seek to impeach the verdict based on the
- 11:58content of deliberations and need not inquire into the content
- 12:01of deliberations to establish her jury bias claim, and in
- 12:06any event, the exception does not apply because the experiences
- 12:09that jurors are understood to bring with them to the
- 12:12jury room are internal matters that do not constitute extraneous information.
- 12:17Werger versus Shavers five seventy four US forty fifty one
- 12:21and fifty two twenty fourteen, Rejecting parties attempt to use
- 12:26the extraneous information exception to establish that a jur should
- 12:30have been excluded under McDonough based on his personal experiences.
- 12:34All right, we're going to wrap up this episode here,
- 12:36and then the next episode we're going to pick up
- 12:38with point number four. The District Court's response to a
- 12:41jury note did not constructively amend the indictment. All of
- 12:46the information that goes with this episode can be found
- 12:49in the description box.