Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / When DORs become LUAs: What you Need to Know About Letters of Understanding & NCUA
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:35This is Mark tranquil with another episode of with flying colors.
- 0:39I'm back here today with Steve far and Todd Miller of my team.
- 0:43How are you two doing this fine morning?
- 0:46Miller: It's a beautiful day.
- 0:48It's a beautiful day in Billings, Montana as well.
- 0:50Doing well.
- 0:51Treichel: Very good.
- 0:52Glad to hear it.
- 0:53We chatted recently about informal administrative actions, and
- 0:58today we're going to talk about some of the most materially used
- 1:02formal administrative actions.
- 1:04Before we do that, let's get a little bit of your background in case somebody's
- 1:08listening for the first time today.
- 1:10And Steve, you're going to go first.
- 1:12Farrar: Okay, yep, my 30 year plus career at NCU has really broke into 2 parts.
- 1:17The first 15 years I was out in the field, primarily as a problem case
- 1:22officer, where in regard to the day's topic, I was involved in, the
- 1:27working with credit unions on many.
- 1:30LUAs cease and desist, actually just a few of those, and conservatorships.
- 1:35Then the last half of my career, the other 15 years, I was in the central
- 1:39office and involved in such things as I wrote the enforcement manual for NCOA
- 1:44and was involved in assisting regions as they were considering enforcement
- 1:48actions against the credit unions.
- 1:51Good and Todd.
- 1:53Miller: I spent just a few months short of 35 years with NCUI.
- 1:57I can break my career out.
- 1:59Maybe 3 pieces.
- 2:01The 1st decade or so as an examiner problem case officer that 2nd decade or so
- 2:07as a regional capital market specialist.
- 2:10And that third decade or so as a Director of Special Actions, where
- 2:14I supervise problem case officers, capital market specialists.
- 2:19One of the things we're going to talk about today is conservatorships.
- 2:22I actually did one of those as a PCO and one as a DSA, where we returned
- 2:26the crediting to the members.
- 2:28Did a lot of them that didn't go back to the members as well, but I did return
- 2:32a couple creditings to the members as part of conservatorship actions.
- 2:36I counted those as wins.
- 2:39The ones that didn't go back to the members.
- 2:40I counted those as failures.
- 2:42So I didn't keep good track of how many of those there were.
- 2:45Treichel: I did a couple like that.
- 2:46I think Steve did as well.
- 2:47And it is nice when it ends with a rising from the phoenix like that, as
- 2:51opposed to a liquidation or a merger.
- 2:54Okay, very good guys.
- 2:55So let's 1st walk through.
- 2:57Letters of understanding and agreement and you know what they are, why
- 3:03they use them, when they use them, and we can maybe get into some a
- 3:07little bit finer details beyond that.
- 3:09But either, either of you prefer to chat first about the letters
- 3:13of understanding and agreement.
- 3:15Farrar: Go ahead,
- 3:15Miller: Todd.
- 3:17So a letter of understanding and agreement and we talked a little bit about this
- 3:20on our last podcast that can be informal or formal depending on whether NCUA
- 3:25publishes them or not, but at this point, the agency considers the Rob problem
- 3:31severe, you're probably going to be classified as a troubled credit union.
- 3:35Although there can be an LUA for compliance reasons where
- 3:38you might not have a code for.
- 3:41I would expect that to be very rare, though.
- 3:43In most cases, this is a troubled criterion.
- 3:45You've had some persistent problems.
- 3:48The NCUA wants a commitment from the Board of Directors to address
- 3:51these problems, and they want that commitment to be a formal commitment.
- 3:55In the case of a formal LUA, NCUA is probably going to publish it and
- 4:01there are certain state regulators.
- 4:03If there's your state charter, you're going to end up with a published
- 4:07letter of understanding and agreement.
- 4:10But these are usually generally cases where it's a severe number of problems.
- 4:15NCUA Once that commitment from the board of directors to a address this problem,
- 4:21and a published l UA is the first step in other more severe actions where it
- 4:26opens that door for them to take other administrative type of actions If the
- 4:31credit union is unable or unwilling to address the problems but by getting
- 4:36a board to sign, they're trying to ensure that this party unit at least
- 4:39is willing to address these issues.
- 4:43Treichel: Steve, anything relative Tolus that Todd said
- 4:47or anything you wanna add on?
- 4:48Letters of understanding and agreement?
- 4:51Farrar: Just that the, that the LUA and the way it's written up, the first part
- 4:55of it de describes the pro the problems that are supposed to be addressed in
- 5:02the corrective actions in the LUA.
- 5:04So those would, those should be those major issues of what you're dealing
- 5:10with, then when you get down to the actions that are being called for in
- 5:15that, it's real important that the credit union understand what they all
- 5:18mean, and that they understand the time frames that are put on those.
- 5:22Because.
- 5:23It's like when you're putting together a budget and in some
- 5:28years, you make it or not.
- 5:30And this 1 becomes, if you put together this budget, that's under
- 5:33an way, you're going to have to make all of the requirements in it.
- 5:36So there's that kind of big step up in difference versus
- 5:40a document or resolution.
- 5:42You should make all those timeframes.
- 5:44But then if you don't, as long as you have reasonable reason why you didn't,
- 5:47it it's, documented in the exam program.
- 5:50But with an LEA, not making the timeframes can be really troublesome.
- 5:54And it's so important that you understand those.
- 5:57Especially
- 5:58Miller: if this is
- 5:58Farrar: a
- 5:58Miller: public, a public one.
- 5:59Go ahead.
- 6:00I think there's another side to this, too, as well.
- 6:03Just the language used in LUAs that are published.
- 6:07It's very draconian and very one sided.
- 6:10MCUA reserves the right to remove officials.
- 6:13Assess civil money penalties, do some other things.
- 6:16And when you get to a point where NCUA is talking about publishing the
- 6:20LUA, it's probably best credit unions to actually seek some outside advice
- 6:25on this, whether it's an attorney or higher credit union exam solutions.
- 6:29We can take a look at it with you as well.
- 6:31These are pretty serious actions at this point.
- 6:34NCUA is exhausted what it considers its informal actions.
- 6:39These are fairly serious matters.
- 6:41And the boilerplate language in that is very draconian for the credit unions.
- 6:45It's intended to be serious.
- 6:47Credit union boards, if you get one of these, make sure you understand
- 6:51them and don't be scared to seek assistance from an attorney or from us.
- 6:56Excellent.
- 6:56Yeah,
- 6:57Farrar: your reputation risk, gets really high really quickly there
- 7:01because we talked about that, that they're the trades and stuff are
- 7:04looking for how NC way publishes those.
- 7:07And, that gives them, something to write about.
- 7:10Then they will.
- 7:12Treichel: Yeah, on publication.
- 7:13It's not like NC way.
- 7:15When they release their NCUA Express that says that they've conserved
- 7:20a credit union, or they release an NCUA Express that says we're having a
- 7:23training class, why don't you sign up?
- 7:25They don't use NCUA Express.
- 7:28As by recollection, when they publish an LUA, rather they are required to
- 7:32publish it to make it enforceable.
- 7:35And I don't want to say they bury it, but they don't announce, they don't scream
- 7:39it from the, from the mountaintops.
- 7:40That being said, people know it's there.
- 7:43Papers, the trades, without naming, which news organization
- 7:47might go look, they do go look.
- 7:49And then it becomes far more public.
- 7:51And that's where the reputation side of it can come into play.
- 7:55How about the word agreement?
- 7:56Letter of understanding and agreement.
- 7:59There are situations, I've said in calls with clients and on the podcast
- 8:05and actually it was a client from my first year that said, every time NCUA
- 8:10opens their mouth, I have to decide if I'm going to go along to get along.
- 8:15And I've turned that into, NCUA's got a really good idea.
- 8:19NCUA has a kind of good idea.
- 8:21Yeah.
- 8:21And it's, it has a bad idea and how far back do you, how do you push back
- 8:27or don't you push back, obviously on a good idea, you're not going to, but
- 8:30a mediocre idea, what will you do?
- 8:32And in a bad idea, what will you do?
- 8:34And all of a sudden, you have the arc of those types of things being
- 8:38thrown into a letter of understanding.
- 8:40An agreement you're when you sign it.
- 8:42You're saying you agree which makes in my mind It very important that a
- 8:46you can get it done and be that it's in the best interest of the credit
- 8:50union and the members any Wisdom you can share on agreeing to the lua.
- 8:57Miller: Hopefully by the time you get to this point your management team
- 9:00has had a chance to negotiate these items with Your PCO, our examiner.
- 9:06Most of the time if we're talking about a published LUA, you're
- 9:09probably dealing with a problem case officer as opposed to an examiner.
- 9:14But there should be some give and take on these agreed upon actions.
- 9:19Hopefully, they are going to be challenging and stretch goals.
- 9:24Like you said, sometimes it's best to, if the cost isn't significant, to
- 9:30go ahead and deal with these issues.
- 9:32Usually, by the time you get to a published LUA, though, they're
- 9:35pretty significant issues, and there's usually not cheap ones in
- 9:38there that are easy to accomplish.
- 9:41For the most part, usually these are big stretch goals that you're
- 9:44being asked to achieve by the time you get to a published LUA.
- 9:49It's a toughie, but appealing them in your actions, NCUA will take
- 9:54other actions if you don't agree to a published LUA, and the consequences
- 9:58to those might be just as severe.
- 10:01Farrar: Yeah, one of the items that we are hearing about is gradients are going
- 10:06through the process of, they've been informed that because of the nature of
- 10:10the problems and the extent of them, that they're going to pursue the LUA.
- 10:14And then you have, it goes with the exam report.
- 10:17Some gradients can feel pressure in terms of timeliness that occurs
- 10:22between when they're provided with maybe the first draft of the LEUA.
- 10:27And when the meeting is scheduled, when they would want it signed, I think, the
- 10:31credit union has every right to on that to request that timeframe be reasonable in
- 10:37terms of, the credit union has to address that they can make those items and they
- 10:42want to probably discuss that with their board prior to that meeting on signing.
- 10:47So I think it's important to have that communication that says.
- 10:50We understand that you got to do this action for us to really accept it.
- 10:53We need that reasonable amount of time to digest it.
- 10:57Make sure that the timelines are good and make sure our board understands.
- 11:02What we're getting into,
- 11:04Treichel: but, I had a conversation with the credit union board last week.
- 11:09And, the discussion was, this is a scenario where they may
- 11:14reserve the right to publish.
- 11:15They don't actually have the language yet, but they know they're getting 1.
- 11:18So they were trying to educate themselves.
- 11:20And there was.
- 11:23There were, I think, board members who are going to sign it and are comfortable
- 11:26with it, and there were board members who aren't comfortable signing it,
- 11:29there were board members that appeared weren't comfortable if it was going to
- 11:32be publishable and I pointed out to them if you abstain or if you vote no, and
- 11:37as a collective, the board agrees to, and let's say it's a publishable one,
- 11:42so let's say there's 15 board members, I'm going to give a big number because
- 11:45I don't want to, pick a number that 15 board members, let's say eight of them
- 11:50vote yes and seven of them vote no, and they sign it and it gets published.
- 11:55All 15 are subject to that LUA because it was a board decision.
- 11:58Even if you voted no, even if you abstained your organization voted
- 12:03and you have that corresponding fiduciary responsibility, et cetera,
- 12:08et cetera, as a board member.
- 12:09And, I saw some eyes open up wide relative to that.
- 12:12To, to that.
- 12:13So the board needs to know a lot of board governance discussions.
- 12:16And, board governance really hits home when you have them signing a
- 12:20letter of understanding and agreement.
- 12:22Miller: You made a good point there, Mark.
- 12:24Over my career, there's different times I've had board members who
- 12:27have refused to sign, even though the majority of the board did, thinking
- 12:31it shielded them in some way, shape, or form, but it really does not.
- 12:36Treichel: Yeah, they're conscientious objectors, essentially, because
- 12:39they're still on the hook.
- 12:41I know all three of us believe in the concept of an LUA should have the material
- 12:48items that are in a document of resolution and not necessarily all the items
- 12:53that are in a document of resolution.
- 12:55And it seems under merit, because merit, going down a little bit of a
- 12:59rabbit hole, because merit seems to, they now have the ability to track
- 13:03and say, okay, this door is done, this door is done, and this door is done.
- 13:06But they tend to maybe separate.
- 13:08Doors into something that might have been one door in the past might be three doors,
- 13:12and we're seeing a little bit and then you throw the economy like it is right now.
- 13:15You start seeing really long document resolutions.
- 13:19And as we've said here before, if everything's a priority, nothing's
- 13:22a priority in a perfect world.
- 13:24You agree with the concept that an should be skinnier than the door
- 13:30and should focus on the main thing.
- 13:34Miller: In concept, yes,
- 13:36Treichel: we're not necessarily seeing that in reality, but in concept.
- 13:41Yes, that's how you would do it.
- 13:42If you were still at N.
- 13:43C.
- 13:43U.
- 13:43A.
- 13:43Is that a fair statement?
- 13:45Yes.
- 13:46Farrar: That's how we always did it.
- 13:47The uas only addressed mainly the, what we would refer to as
- 13:52the root causes of the problem.
- 13:54The root causes of the problem.
- 13:56Treichel: Very good.
- 13:56And Steve, you trained NCUA staff and Todd, you did, you trained
- 13:59your staff to do it that way.
- 14:01And with with turnover.
- 14:02Not saying because we left, but with turnover they've got a lot of
- 14:06new people and, things change and then you can get a, you can get.
- 14:10You can get pockets of the country that do it different.
- 14:13You can get redirection from the top.
- 14:15As as you mentioned, we're seeing publishable potential LUAs, and
- 14:19we're seeing that a little bit.
- 14:21We're seeing LUAs more than recently, and we're seeing the publishable option
- 14:25more and I've said here before a dear friend who passed away, who used to
- 14:30be the general counsel at NCUA, when he consulted, and He would advise
- 14:33clients not to sign them and just send them a preliminary warning letter.
- 14:37And I really when he first started telling me that I really wasn't in that camp.
- 14:43I'm starting to move a little bit closer to that camp on a publishable
- 14:47one, especially if it's publishable in ad infinitum and it doesn't have
- 14:51any deadlines, et cetera, et cetera.
- 14:53If you find yourself with an LUA Feel free to reach out to discuss it and or reach
- 14:58out to a legal counsel to make sure you understand the ramifications of the LUA.
- 15:03Anything else
- 15:03Miller: on LUAs guys?
- 15:05Just something you mentioned dates there, other than new crediting,
- 15:10the new crediting can get an LUA that has a termination date.
- 15:13For the most part, LUAs, whether they're unpublished or published
- 15:17formal ones, they're not going to have termination dates.
- 15:20Those things are open ended.
- 15:21It's will you complete what you've agreed to do?
- 15:24And NCUA gets to decide, did the actions, were the actions completed and did they
- 15:29achieve the results intended as The way Steve used to phrase it when he
- 15:34was still teaching me how to do this.
- 15:36And that's how you determine is this LUA been satisfied?
- 15:39Did you do what you said you were going to do and did it
- 15:42achieve the results intended?
- 15:44And I think we're seeing these really long LUA's.
- 15:46It's a side effect.
- 15:47COVID a little bit.
- 15:48They missed things when they were off site.
- 15:50Things built up because credit unions had stuff off site.
- 15:53Then you have the bank failures.
- 15:55You have an inverted yield curve.
- 15:56You got delinquencies creeping up.
- 15:58Just to have them insure NCUA probably is a little bit stressed
- 16:04of what might occur in the future.
- 16:06And they're trying to get things resolved before they get costly.
- 16:12Treichel: Agreed, agreed.
- 16:12And you just triggered something in my mind that we had a situation
- 16:16where we had a client conversation where someone said, we messed up.
- 16:22We didn't give you an LUA last time.
- 16:24And we should have.
- 16:25And I believe the reality.
- 16:28Is that's not the case.
- 16:30The policy, I believe their current policy reads as if you're
- 16:36a four, you're going to get an L.
- 16:38U.
- 16:38A.
- 16:38Unless a higher levels level says you don't need to have an L.
- 16:42U.
- 16:42A.
- 16:42So somebody in that other situation said, We don't need the way.
- 16:46And then they came back and decided no, we do need it.
- 16:49And in an environment where you got the NCAA board talking about their concerns.
- 16:54You have staff going to be a little less likely to go out
- 16:57on a limb for credit union.
- 16:59And so I think the correlation between if you're a 4 troubled status, you are
- 17:04going to get an way people opting to go a different path, I think, is going to be
- 17:08Miller: Rare, very rare.
- 17:10It's always been rare.
- 17:11By definition at code four by their own policy, generally
- 17:15involved in LUA or a preliminary warning letter, one of the two.
- 17:19Treichel: Yes.
- 17:20It's always been rare, but I have recently seen where it wasn't done.
- 17:23But yeah, I think it's going to get, it has been rare.
- 17:27It's going to be rare and maybe even rarer.
- 17:29That's a wrap on letters of understanding and agreement with Todd and Steve.
- 17:33We also went on to record a discussion on cease and desist order
- 17:37is prohibitions conservatorships and a couple other topics.
- 17:41But I'm splitting those into separate topics for later release.
- 17:46Treichel: I want to thank you for listening.
- 17:47I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 17:49This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 17:58Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 18:02your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 18:06of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 18:11If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 18:14out our services at marktreichel.
- 18:16com.