Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / ALIEN JESUS: Cosmic Challenges to Earthly Religions
Transcript
- 0:00We understand life free the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a
- 0:08symbol, an idea. The population of atheist this country is going through the
- 0:13rule, rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell
- 0:19the truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my
- 0:23hand on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational
- 0:28world. Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth,
- 0:32beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing,
- 0:37question everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by
- 0:46Said Andrews. Is their alien life out there somewhere. We've all looked up
- 1:03at the stars and the planets and thought, m I wonder what are their
- 1:07intentions? How would this effect religious belief? When I was a religious person
- 1:14for decades? Wait a minute, what if it wasn't just about humans on
- 1:17this planet? Hand created by the creator of the cosmos. What if that
- 1:22creator had created something else elsewhere in the cosmos? What's that about? How
- 1:26would this effect religious belief when I was a religious person for decades? Wait
- 1:33a minute, what if it wasn't just about humans on this planet? Hand
- 1:36created by the creator of the cosmos, if that creator had created something else
- 1:42elsewhere in the cosmos, what's that about? These are fascinating discussions and my
- 1:47special guests are going to speak to that and a whole lot more. Jonathan
- 1:52M. S Piers is an author and philosopher from South Hampshire, UK.
- 1:56He co founded the Skeptic Ink Network and he's written a ton of stuff.
- 2:00He's written a lot of books, too many to list here, but a
- 2:04couple include Why I Am an Atheist and Not a Theist and Thirty Arguments Against
- 2:09the Existence of God. Doctor Aaron Adair He is a physicist and educator and
- 2:15a Bible scholar. He is currently a research affiliated MIT. He has done
- 2:22work that has included the European Organization for Nuclear Research or CERN and the Search
- 2:27for Extraterrestrial Intelligence SETTI. Ten years ago he wrote the book The Star of
- 2:34Bethlehem, A skeptical View, and these two gentlemen have now collaborated on something
- 2:40that I find fascinating, a book called Aliens and Religion, where two worlds
- 2:46collide, assessing the impact of discovering extraterrestrial intelligence on religion and theology. When
- 2:55I think of aliens, I think about the History Channel. And this is
- 3:00not a compliment. It used to be we called it the Hitler Channel because
- 3:04everything was the Second World War, right, Every show was acting, but
- 3:07there was some actual history going on as we would learn about the mid twentieth
- 3:12century blah blah blah, and all of a sudden, they just sort of
- 3:15left the rails and now it's angled aliens and the pyramids and all of these
- 3:20conspiracy theories. And I don't see any history on the History Channel, and
- 3:25so when I hear aliens, that's what I think about. This is that
- 3:30the case for you? I mean, does your brain ever go there?
- 3:32Well? I have to say that Aaron, my co author, one of
- 3:36his favorite channels is Issue Channel. He's a massive fan of ancient aliens.
- 3:39He does advocate for aliens building the pyramids. So that it was a quite
- 3:45difficult process writing this book because you know, I had to get over the
- 3:47fact that he had these completely nonsensical conclusions. Always good to establish credibility off
- 3:53the bat right here at the beginning, Aaron, you know, he felt
- 3:57the aliens built them. Now, come on, talk to me about ancient
- 3:59aliens in the History Channel airin What's your Day? Okay, so I think
- 4:02Jonathan's just a little bit confused because what he says aliens, he means anyone
- 4:05who's not British. And yes, it's true that not British people built the
- 4:10pyramids are called Egyptians. Yeah, so you're right that in the olden days
- 4:15it was the Hitler channel. But even back in the olden days they still
- 4:18attached occultism with Nazism and things like that right from the beginning, so they
- 4:23were never exactly pristine. But of course, yeah, nowadays the most historical
- 4:28stuff is ice road truckers or the things like that. The Ancient alien show
- 4:30is at best a bunch of hey, it's possible that, And so long
- 4:35as I can somehow say ten different competing hypotheses for the same artifact, all
- 4:42of them related to X kind of alien, it's enough to keep those speculations
- 4:46going. We found a man who has been studying this for thirty five years,
- 4:51right, that's how they frame it, and we're like, oh,
- 4:54impress it. They don't tell you that. You know, the guy thinks
- 4:58that Stargate was a documentary and that the aliens are going to come down,
- 5:02and the reason the pyramids exist is because they needed a place for the landing
- 5:05pad for the spaceship. Yeah, it sells him sitting in his sitting in
- 5:10his underwear in front of the Ancient Aliens TV show itself. That's some kind
- 5:15of big circle of Oh no, no, no, they're not wearing the
- 5:17underwear. They have a much better persona. They usually will dress up like
- 5:21Indiana Jones. That is the norm to give a credibility. If you look
- 5:27like nineteen eighties Indiana Jones, automatically think oh, you must be an actual
- 5:30archaeologist, not a cosplayer. It's almost like watching a homeopath on television where
- 5:34they wear the scrubs and they actually have this dethoscope. Somehow in the brain
- 5:40we're supposed to say, ah hah, yeah, scrubs and a stethoscope,
- 5:44you must be duct oral. How technical is the book? And this is
- 5:47a setup because I have the book, I know the answer, but I
- 5:51want you to talk about it because you two are big brains and your technical
- 5:56people. Most of us are not. So when you get into extra terrestrial
- 6:00life, the cosmos, life, the universe and everything, how hardcore are
- 6:03we talking here, gentlemen. Well, we have things that are scientific,
- 6:09mathematical, theological, philosophical, but I think we do a good job of
- 6:15making it so as many people as possible can read, understand, and participate
- 6:18in this conversation. We have sections of the book, especially in the appendices.
- 6:21That's just like pure math and computer simulations. Essentially, I made input
- 6:28the formula in the appendices. It's just that's not going in the main body
- 6:31of the book. I'm sorry, mate, it's not happening. So we
- 6:35reserved English for the main body of the book. No, all the books
- 6:40I've ever written, one of my kind of raison dtre in what I do
- 6:44is trying to communicate sometimes complex ideas or research. It's been written by so
- 6:49many different authors and trying to distill that into kind of layman's terms so that
- 6:56an intelligent, lame person can read my books. And this is, I
- 6:59think, another one of such books. And Aaron and I worked hard to
- 7:01make sure that that because he would he would actually submit stuff to me of
- 7:08a scientific nature, mathematical nature, and I'd say, look, we're going
- 7:12to break this down like for my benefit as much as a reader. So
- 7:15I think we've succeeded in doing that. I think it does a job of
- 7:18spreading itself across many different areas and topics that are relevant to this question,
- 7:24and it touches on maths, science, aliens, cosmology, philosophy, theology,
- 7:30psychology, hopefully in a way that people can understand. And I agree,
- 7:32I mean, I can validate that there's there's a lot of storytelling.
- 7:35I really feel like that if we're going to educate and change minds, even
- 7:39our own, I think storytelling is really one of the great ways to do
- 7:43it. It's like Sagan, right, Carl Sagan was a scientist. He
- 7:46was all about the data, but he was also great at telling the story
- 7:48of science and skepticism. Allow me here to quote none other than ken Ham
- 7:55of answers in Genesis, Young Earth, creationist, Bible literalist, and somewhat
- 8:01terrifying human being who has this on his website, and I quote, I
- 8:05do believe there can't be other intelligent beings in outer space because of the meaning
- 8:11of the Gospel. An understanding of the Gospel makes it clear that salvation through
- 8:16Christ is only for the Adomic race, human beings who are all descendants of
- 8:24Adam. I would just for the hell of it, like both of you
- 8:28do respond to ken Ham's declaration that we're it the center of all things because
- 8:35you know the Bible. Well, actually, I guess one of the questions
- 8:39we were seeking to answer with this book is is a discovery of intelligent alien
- 8:43life does that make the existence of only God more or less probable? It's
- 8:48a really simple question. Is God less probable if we discovered intelligent aliens?
- 8:52And the conclusion to the but the TLDR is, yeah, God is less
- 8:56probable. But it may be a problem that is great for that type of
- 9:01Christian, that kind of literalist conservative, for a doctrinally narrow Christian. So
- 9:07if you have just a general belief in God, there are a few of
- 9:09things that can go wrong. If you're belief in God it's got so many
- 9:13bolts on and so many constraints, then actually it leaves it open to being
- 9:16more easily invalidated. So the discovery of things like intelligent alien life is therefore
- 9:22going to be more of a problem for someone like ken Hand than for your
- 9:24average kind of liberal Christian who's like yeah and can find a way of adapting
- 9:30their belief system to that. And that's where kind of psychology comes into it
- 9:33a lot as well. Well, let me speak to the pill last of
- 9:35her in you you think much of that is about the ego. I mean,
- 9:37we are God's main point of focus. Therefore, come on, if
- 9:43something else existed that might minimize or marginalize us in some way, you think
- 9:48there's some ego would play. Well, actually, there's a huge element of
- 9:50that in what we talk about in the book. That's connected. I wouldn't
- 9:54say it's necessarily individual ego. Well, it might be a manifestation of that
- 9:58actually, which is Earth Chauvinism, This idea that in a way that we
- 10:01were geocentric in our understanding cosmology. Theologically we're kind of homocentric and anthropocentric,
- 10:09geocentric, and the idea is that we are the apex of creation. It's
- 10:13all about us, and if there are intelligent alien life forms out there,
- 10:18then that's going to play Mary havoc with that, and especially in Aaron can
- 10:22talk to this, especially when you introduce something called the Copernicum principle, which
- 10:26would state that actually we're fairly average. I don't know, Aaron, if
- 10:28you want to explain that. I think it also leads into when it comes
- 10:31to the history of interpreting Copernicus and our place in the universe that Kenahan would
- 10:37have found a company with other religionous in the Christian faith up to about sixteen
- 10:41hundred. In that one of the early Copernicans, Gerarnor Bruno, also posited
- 10:46that there is an infinity of worlds with people on them, and apparently this
- 10:52was one of the things that made the Inquisition go, Yeah, that ain't
- 10:54right, go to the burn at the stick. From what we could tell,
- 10:58one of the reasons Bruno was executed in sixteen hundred was for the belief
- 11:01in other worlds and people on them. So basically we know at least one
- 11:05person killed for religious reasons for believing in aliens. And yeah, part of
- 11:09the reason there was this fear of those ideas is that if God created this
- 11:15world, great, but if this world just pops around naturally just from Adams
- 11:18bumping into each other, while we're not special, we're not created. And
- 11:22also, yeah, how does the story of Jesus work? Does he only
- 11:26come to Earth? Does he have to go to many places? Again,
- 11:28historically, in connecting this to American history, one of the people to really
- 11:31push the idea and show how much silliness this might create if Jesus needs to
- 11:35somehow do his saving act on every single inhabited planet in the universe was the
- 11:41great Thomas pain in his book The Age of Reason, he basically points out,
- 11:43look, how silly it is that now we basically have to have Jesus
- 11:46incarnating, dying, rising and doing that over and over again for every single
- 11:50sun that happens to have inhabitants around it. It means there could be billions,
- 11:54if not trillions, of Jesus' I was listening you talk about those heretics
- 12:01of old who dared to say that, you know, we weren't the center
- 12:05of all things. Of course, Galileo is the easy one, right.
- 12:09The story of Galileo is definitely complicated. He did end the rest of his
- 12:13life in house arrest, and when he was being interrogated by the Inquisition in
- 12:18Rome, he was shown the instruments of torture. So basically you could say,
- 12:22you know, he was psychologically torture because he's going to show It's like,
- 12:26hey, you're going to you know, start talking the way we like,
- 12:28or all these instruments which we explained how they work. These things could
- 12:31happen to you, Yeah, it would be a moment of pause, Hey,
- 12:35we're going to tear you apart and set you on fire. Now,
- 12:39what's your opinion about geocentrism. I would be like, you know, wow,
- 12:43go figure, you know, I mean, yeah, in fact,
- 12:46if I could further connect it, the cardinal that basically did like the final
- 12:50prosecution of Bruno, Cardinal Bellarmine was also then the cardinal who basically started the
- 12:54case against Galileo. And I mean for hundreds even thousands of years, I've
- 13:00seen legitimate scientists, people doing groundbreaking work. It wasn't just this, you
- 13:03know, the primitive ancestors wandering in the dark. We knew quite a bit
- 13:09right. There were contemporaneous thinkers at the time who had an understanding, plausible
- 13:15understanding of how cosmology worked. So we're talking about there's a section on Biblical
- 13:20cosmology and how it just gets it completely wrong. The Bible gets the understanding
- 13:24of cosmology wrong. And why would God and what we call Omnigod and all
- 13:28loving, all knowing or powerful God use this you know, supposedly perfect or
- 13:33divinely inspired revelation to communicate with the world but get the basics so fundamentally wrong.
- 13:39And one of the arguments back to that iss, well, you know,
- 13:41people wouldn't have understood it at the time. It's kind of progressive revelation
- 13:46argument that you often see with slavery as well. Oh, they wouldn't have
- 13:48understood at the time that slavery is bad, so you know that's why they
- 13:52didn't say slavery is bad. It's like, really, you know, there
- 13:54were contemporaneous efforts to change and adapt the rules in other places concerning slavery.
- 14:00I'm not too sure, but Aaron, I'm sure I can tell you about
- 14:01how there were people at the time who had a much more enlightened understanding of
- 14:05how cosmology might have worked. And so therefore it doesn't work as an apologetic
- 14:11to say, yeah, they wouldn't have understood it if God had actually told
- 14:15the truth in the Bible. But you can't throw that out and without me
- 14:18grab an onto it. The Bible got so much wrong about cosmology. I
- 14:22mean, I want him to read the book. I want everybody to read
- 14:24the book. But give me some give me some of the highlights come on
- 14:26the stuff that makes your eye twitch when it comes to the Bible dealing with
- 14:31out there. So how about the pillars of the earth or the firmament being
- 14:37in the Hebrew Iraqia, this hammered out piece of metal that holds up the
- 14:41waters above to separate from the waters below, as if outer space is just
- 14:45a giant swimming pool and the stars are just these little lights plugged into that
- 14:48metal case around the Earth that is there just for signs and seasons, that
- 14:52somehow this guy is just an oversized calendar for us humans rather than Hey,
- 14:56those stars are just like our own son, with the own worlds, where
- 15:00people could be right now having similar or better conversations that we are having on
- 15:05Twitter. These are places to visit, but they're they're just little lights in
- 15:09the sky. When in Genesis it just says God he made the stars.
- 15:13Also, and I'm thinking our single galaxy alone has on the order of four
- 15:20hundred billion stars with a bee, and our galaxy is one of at least
- 15:24hundreds of billions with a bee galaxies in the observable universe, and observable that
- 15:31those are the limits of how far we can possibly see. We may have
- 15:33a universe of infinite size. So would you just dismiss that all too?
- 15:37He made the stars? Also, Oh my goodness, you are missing the
- 15:41big picture. I love it when Aaron gets excited. It's just brilliant.
- 15:46He's good. Yeah, he's good. Just a digression. I'm always interested
- 15:50in Genesis one, where God creates all the plants, trees, vegetation before
- 15:54the sun right on the so that I think service temperashuire would have been at
- 15:58least minus four hundred degrees fair in height. In the early Earth, there
- 16:03were lots of grobulbs that was going on. I mean, I love similar
- 16:08to that, I love the I mean. And we talk about this because
- 16:11we talk about whether if aliens exist, are they intelligent. If they're intelligent,
- 16:15are they moral? If they're moral, are they fallen? If they're
- 16:18fallen, that they need atonement? If they need atonement, does it need
- 16:21to be incarnation? So on and so forth. So we go to all
- 16:22these steps. But the idea of the Biblical accounts is that Adam and Eve,
- 16:26whether you believe they were historical and literal or symbolic, is kind of
- 16:30neither here nor there. But certainly in the literalistic understanding, Adam and Eve
- 16:34were told not to eat from the tree of knowledge of good and evil,
- 16:38So they had no knowledge of good and evil, and they eat from the
- 16:41tree, and then they get punished for eating from the tree, but they
- 16:45didn't have the knowledge of what's good and evil. So that is a really
- 16:48big issue in terms of the coherence of that very cool story. A friend
- 16:52of mine and fellow activist likes to freight it this way. He says,
- 16:56God created imperfect beginnings and then punished them for acting imperfectly. That's one of
- 17:03the big So that's sorry to derailed this with the previous book, But my
- 17:07book thirty Arguments against exist in a Gold, Heaven Held Satan and Divine Design
- 17:11looks at exactly those sort of arguments. That says, what is going on
- 17:15for this omnigod? Okay, I want to talk about biblical creation. God
- 17:22makes the planet and light and dark and man and woman and all that stuff,
- 17:26but he doesn't just do it once, and he doesn't just do it
- 17:30here. What would that even look like? And or imply, oh,
- 17:37we got to talk about that next job talking here with Jonathan MS. Pierce
- 17:48and Aaron A. Dare. They are co authors of the book Aliens and
- 17:53Religion, Where Two Worlds Collide, assessing the impact of discovering extra terrestrial intelligence
- 18:00on religion and theology, trying to decide if I'm going to say the sub
- 18:03bitle every time I talk about the book, but I might I had a
- 18:07friend who he wondered if there might have been an Adam and Eve on another
- 18:11planet. I mean, why would we have the only Adam and Eve?
- 18:15Right? I mean, if God designed the vast cosmos, he conjured it
- 18:18from nothing, why all the extra stuff? There? Is there a different
- 18:23Adam and Eve? And they would be aliens to us that means alien civilization
- 18:27that might sin and fall. And then does Jesus go and die for their
- 18:32sins? I mean, you know, does Jesus finish up here and go,
- 18:34ah, shit, Now I've got to go to City Alpha five verever
- 18:38you guys get into any of this sort of hypothetical stuff about one of the
- 18:44biggest areas that we get into. Actually, So we looked at a paper
- 18:47by to Christian theologians called mackintosh and McNabb, and they looked at six areas
- 18:52that they thought could potentially pose a problem for Christianity, for Christian belief,
- 18:56and we took we looked at those six areas. So they are the scriptures,
- 19:00the doctrine, the belief in theorism in general, narrative problem of evil
- 19:07and so on and so forth. So we looked at all these different areas,
- 19:08and one of them, the doctrine area, obviously has loads of your
- 19:11big chunky bits of theology and that we could get our teeth into. And
- 19:15one of the big arguments in that, and this exists amongst what are called
- 19:19astro theologians, who are theologians who deal with exactly what this book is about.
- 19:23This is a book about astro theology, amongst other things. And one
- 19:27of the big questions is does one Jesus work for everyone? Is that one
- 19:32Jesus to rule them all? Or do you need a billion Jesus to be
- 19:34incarnated in all these instances of intelligent alien life and then all the problems to
- 19:40go along with that with each of those because actually astro theologians they disagree on
- 19:45this point. And so we sit back and look at the criticisms that single
- 19:48Jesus advocates have about multiple Jesus. And then we look at the criticisms and
- 19:55multiple Jesus advocates have about single Jesus, and we just eat the popcorn and
- 19:57go, right, yep, you're right, it's all nonsense, and that
- 20:00the church wasn't splintered enough. Now we have people who believe in one Jesus,
- 20:04ten Jesus is a million Jesus is. I mean, come on,
- 20:07it's just crazy, Aaron. You want to jump in on this one.
- 20:11Yeah, So when it comes to the thoughts about are there worlds that don't
- 20:14actually even needed Jesus? In many ways, you know, there were some
- 20:17important thinkers who were ahead of us, like C. S. Lewis had
- 20:19a trilogy of books that basically imagine life on Mars, life on Venus,
- 20:23and it was untainted by sin of us pesky humans. In fact, when
- 20:27US humans accidentally showed up, the Martians were like, well, get them
- 20:30out of here. They're just going to mess everything up. They're the fallen
- 20:33people. Go away. Of course, if there are worlds that are unfallen,
- 20:36that's a bit of a theological problem because it's like, wait, God
- 20:38could have made us in such a way that we wouldn't screw up, then
- 20:42why are we like this. On the other hand, if one was to
- 20:45say no, no, all forms of intelligent life will fall and screwups,
- 20:49like wait, so God fails every single time? Well, there's a grand
- 20:52engineer for you. So one way or another, it seems like whether we
- 20:56are the only sinful people in the whole universe or we got lots of sinful
- 21:00cousins, it seems like that's a theological issue. And then yeah, if
- 21:03Jesus needs to basically just come to one world and do its magic, or
- 21:07if he needs to be like Scapacula and Quantum Leap and just keep regenerating at
- 21:11other bodies to you know, try to solve those sorts of problems is an
- 21:14interesting question and problem. There are loads of issues. Sorry, there are
- 21:21absolutely loads of issues to come with each of these. But the million billion,
- 21:25trillion infinite Jesus scenario has, of course, you know, countless issues
- 21:30in terms of well, actually, you would also need Jesus to not only
- 21:33be incarnated at all these different places and possibly different times, but also at
- 21:38the same time there will be civilizations out there who are existing at the same
- 21:42time as ours that would need to be kind of saved in the same way,
- 21:47and so therefore Jesus would need to exist simultaneously in perhaps billions of different
- 21:52galaxies. I'm going to get into This has got to be wild conjecture,
- 21:56but it'll be fun. I'm classic Greg Fan, I know Aaron Is because
- 22:02of his preking Zoom background. But you know, Roddenberry was looking for a
- 22:07way to economically create alien interactions in the show, and they came up with
- 22:12a CLASSM planets theory, which means, well, if they develop, if
- 22:15alien light develops, they're going to look a lot like us. So then
- 22:19you can bring in the oh, we need a female dancer alien while they
- 22:25bring in a female dancer and sprayer with green paint. Now she's an alien
- 22:29kind of thing. But we all sort of had that similarity alien life.
- 22:33I mean, can we even comprehend what that would even look like, how
- 22:36we would approach it if it could be communicated to using our method of language
- 22:41and perception. I mean, my mind explodes when I think about this stuff.
- 22:45What kind of life might be up there? Guys? Yeah, when
- 22:48it comes to you bring up Star Trek. In Next Generation, they had
- 22:53to create a conceit for explaining why are all these humanoids all over the galaxy
- 22:56and they had to credit it to some other advanced species billions of years in
- 23:02the past that then just seeded that kind of life everywhere, which, by
- 23:04the late contradicts evolution. So science fiction stop being scientific again. Oh no.
- 23:08Their more reality is that if aliens are out there and they're intelligent,
- 23:12we don't really have good prima foss reasons to think they're gonna look like us.
- 23:17But there could still be some similarities, Like if they're intelligent, they're
- 23:21going to indeed energy to perform any of their great tasks, So we can
- 23:26still like put civilizations on a scale of their energy production and control in a
- 23:30way so we can compare more and less advanced. If they are understanding the
- 23:37way the universe is, well, that's also something that we can put on
- 23:40a scale that we can have a common way of discussing things that we may
- 23:45have very different forms of bodies. The slug people of the southern side of
- 23:48Omicron Perci eight are certainly going to be looking different from us. But so
- 23:53long as we're inhabiting the same universe, we should find some ways of according
- 23:56to the same object and agreeing enough on a language to talk to each other.
- 24:00Not to say it's going to be easy, We're going to need quite
- 24:03the upgrade to Google Translate to make it happen. You guys, hear about
- 24:07the Google I guess has a new earpiece which acts like a Babelfish in real
- 24:11time. So if you have a smartphone app and you're speaking to someone who's
- 24:15I don't know, they have a foreign language, and you both have the
- 24:18app as you're speaking, it's translated in your ear in real time. And
- 24:23I thought, oh my god. I mean I never thought of Douglas Adams
- 24:26as a soothsayer, you know, as predicting the future, but he kind
- 24:30of was. It was amazing, Jonathan. You want to weigh in on
- 24:33what alien something got there? Well, well, okay, I was gonna
- 24:37weigh on something you just said, no, no, go ahead, go
- 24:38ahead and take the idea. The idea that science fiction is quite predictive is
- 24:45quite useful. So when we're looking at how will humans react to aliens turning
- 24:49up or us discovering aliens with the techno signature from far far away, so
- 24:53on and so forth, you're thinking, well, we don't have any experience
- 24:56of that, then how do you do we? So this science fiction?
- 25:00We look at science fiction and actually can tell us an awful lot about how
- 25:03we might react and about what aliens might be like, etc. Because it's
- 25:07a great area of where lots of writers and thinkers have done a lot of
- 25:11thinking and writing in terms of what might alien life be like and how might
- 25:15we react? And then we look at things like history. Just look at
- 25:18history and how did civilizations react like the Aztecs when the conquistal rules came over?
- 25:23How did what happen when Christopher Columbus founded a new new world or discovered
- 25:27the new world? And then what can we learn from that and how we
- 25:30might react in if we came into contact with alien life, so on and
- 25:34so forth. So there are analogies, there's history, there's science fiction,
- 25:37and that can all help us to understand how humanity might react in terms of
- 25:41discovery of intelligent alien life. But if I see, let's you know,
- 25:45let's say I can detect that it's a living organism, but it's some weird
- 25:49energy goo, I don't know what the hell or would even look or sound
- 25:52like like? Will we know even what to do with it? Do you
- 25:56communicate? Do you know if it's an intelligent but communicating on a pre quency
- 26:00that we could never save. I get overwhelmed by these types of questions.
- 26:04Well, we do try approaching very broadly something that's scientifically and philosophically very difficult.
- 26:11What is intelligence? Which is an all the more pressing question considering the
- 26:15advances in artificial intelligence that people wondering is that the intelligent or not? Or
- 26:19is it just an extremely good parrot. It's an open question in that community,
- 26:25and you know, we're not going to answer it today, even though
- 26:26obviously we have the correct answers. But when we try approaching how we would
- 26:32identify intelligence, we take a definition to basically say, does it show the
- 26:36signs of having agency? Does it show that it's actually moving towards certain goals
- 26:41and actioning on those changing to achieve those sorts of things like if there's some
- 26:45sort of goo on the ground and it's trying to go forward to some sort
- 26:48of source of food, and I put my hand in the way, and
- 26:49then I notice it goes around my hand to get there. I'm like,
- 26:52okay, this has some very basic agency to say the least. So even
- 26:56if I cannot comprehend it's biochemistry or its neural synaptic pathways or things like that,
- 27:02I can still make some observations say like, well, that's what I
- 27:04expect from an intelligence. So while I may not be able to communicate with
- 27:10the slug people, I'm hoping I can at least notice that they're intelligent,
- 27:14and all the more so if they decide to come here and with their superior
- 27:17intelligence, decide we need to do something for them. Compute aliens came here.
- 27:22There's a great cartoon and it shows these aliens that have arrived at the
- 27:26moment of christ crucifixion. And the first thing they see when they get off
- 27:30the saucer is they see some poor dude who's nailed to a cross. And
- 27:33one alien says the other, what do you think? And the alien says,
- 27:36I think we need to get the fuck out of here? Is what
- 27:38I If aliens appeared, do you think our predisposition to want gods? You
- 27:45think we'd see them as gods? They think religions would develop around aliens.
- 27:49Well, there's possibly something might be quite useful to think about it, which
- 27:53is off the sea Clark's third law, which says something along the lines of
- 27:57something of sufficient technology called advancement to you will appear like magic. So,
- 28:03for example, when you have the conquistadors with muskets sitting atop horses with metal
- 28:07armor, things that the Aztecs had never seen before, and they fired the
- 28:11muskets a flash mine off and then someone dropped dead at a distance. They're
- 28:14like, oh my goodness, that is magic. That is just insane,
- 28:18And to the conquistdals, that's pretty standard. Now, Aaron can talk to
- 28:22you about what would be required for aliens to actually come across galaxies to land
- 28:26at our planetary shores. But the technology that they would require to do that
- 28:33would seem divine to us. They would be able to do things that would
- 28:37seem pretty godly to us. So they could be situations and there are cargo
- 28:41cults we can look at and see what actually that kind of thing has happened
- 28:45before. There could be scenarios where humans would find alien life forms to be
- 28:49possibly godly, and it's worth building. We have UFOL cults right now.
- 28:55We have people who are effectively worshiping extraterrestrials, or or at least they're worshiping
- 29:00gods in an extraterrestrial form. I've had a few interactions more recently with people
- 29:06from the Raelian cult. Rayel was a Frenchman who said he encountered aliens from
- 29:11a landing flying saucerer back in the seventies and basically learned that the gods of
- 29:15the Old Testament, the angels and such the Elohim, those are actually aliens,
- 29:18Jesus, Buddha, Muhammad, all aliens. And oh and they're all
- 29:21coming back in twenty thirty five, so they're building the embassy to welcome them
- 29:25when they finally all come back. And while the cult might be small,
- 29:29it's still nonetheless, Hey, people are worshiping and practicing these sorts of New
- 29:33Age Utifo religions even without the aliens actually showing up. You can only imagine
- 29:37all the more so if they decide to land in front of the United Nations
- 29:41or anything like that. And yeah, we have several analogs of when group
- 29:45comes in with superior technology, leaving quite the impression. You know, Jonathan
- 29:51mentioned the Conquistadors, but even in the twentieth century we have some really good
- 29:53analogs with the so called cargo cults of Micronesia where they started creating the these
- 30:00new gods named John from short for John from America, also known as Russiffield.
- 30:06President Roosevelt became a god in these sorts of religions, and also a
- 30:10more British example, Prince Philip the Second also became a god in one of
- 30:14these religions that he was supposed to be a brother of one of these other
- 30:17gods from these cargo cults. So they were looking at all this you know,
- 30:19technology of just the twentieth century and thinking like, hey, we want
- 30:22that sort of you know, amazing technology, and so this religion forming around
- 30:26they saying, Yeah, our messianic Bidu will come in and he'll give us
- 30:30refrigerators and air conditioning and spam meat at a can and all these sorts of
- 30:34things that were absolutely amazing in the nineteen thirties and forties, let alone modern
- 30:38stuff. So I'm pretty sure that if the aliens did show up, there
- 30:42would be a significant contingent to people would be like, the gods are real,
- 30:45They've just landed, and start abandoning some of the other religious practices.
- 30:51At the very least, there's going to be a boom time for the UFOL
- 30:53cults. It's interesting if Jonathan and Aaron and I, let's say we were
- 30:59all label to go back in time and show people two hundred years ago a
- 31:03working cell phone, they might have considered us gods, right, I mean,
- 31:07we could have totally cashed in that ship. I've often thought about that,
- 31:11you know, you lie in a bad thinking about these different situations where
- 31:14if I went back in time with this, but if I could keep it,
- 31:15if it could hold its battery and I could, I could do things
- 31:18and show them stuff, and I just it would just be I'd seen like
- 31:22some magician. To them, it would be insane. But so I think
- 31:26you were. They might call it magic or a witchcraft. I mean,
- 31:30I think I said so people like to talk here. This is a political
- 31:33conversation about the Founding Fathers, and they're often treated like deities. They're very
- 31:38saintly in the eyes of a lot of American nationalists, and we always tried
- 31:44to remind them they did some amazing and visionary things, but they were also
- 31:48you know, they lived in a time where womens, Yeah, they weren't
- 31:52given position to power, and yeah, they owned slaves and I think Washington
- 31:57actually had slave teeth, and as deny and blah blah blah, you do
- 32:00all that stuff. And when the Second Amendment was written, it was written
- 32:04during a time when you know, they were ignorant about so much. They
- 32:07could have never imagined this or that. And so if we had gone back
- 32:09and they had seen Wi Fi, they might have thought it was witchcraft.
- 32:14You just never know it just so beyond, but they thought might have been
- 32:16possible. I'm that fascinating. Yeah, it is worth noting that in America,
- 32:21Washington technically is a god. If you go to the rotundra at the
- 32:23Capitol and look up, there's a painting of what is literally called the apotheosis
- 32:28of George Washington. So Washington has ascended to heaven to become a deity to
- 32:32watch over the land of liberty and bald eagles and super bowls and all those
- 32:36important things that we need to spread around the world. But I would also
- 32:39note we don't necessarily need superadvanced technology to convince people to worship us. There's
- 32:45this example that is in the first century a d that's in the writings of
- 32:50Josephus and shows up in the Book of Acts, where herod Agrippa basically comes
- 32:52out with a really shiny coat and people start worshiping him as a god.
- 32:57So all you really need is just a really fancy coat, and boom,
- 32:59you're a I was gonna say sorry, said you mentioned something earlier. I
- 33:02mean, both of you talked about slug people and the idea of aliens being
- 33:07so different to how we are. Actually, that is a problem that we
- 33:09deal with in the book with regard to the single Jesus advocates. So if
- 33:15they say, right, there's one Jesus to do all the job of atonement,
- 33:19and there's just this one story, how do all these intelligent alien life
- 33:22forms out there, these civilizations access that story then? Because I could be
- 33:28pretty certain that if we were kind of shown a story of some tentacled alien
- 33:32that was sacrificed and had you know, some tentacles chopped off or something,
- 33:37that we wouldn't feel that empathy that we do for other humans, right,
- 33:40because that's part of our psychology, you know, those mirror NEURONSI empathy and
- 33:45is biologically attuned to allow us to have sympathy for those who are more like
- 33:51us. Right. And so therefore, the particularity of the Jesus story being
- 33:55based paroicularly in our geography and time and on our Earth, possibly conveys a
- 34:01huge advantage to us that other alien life forms just won't be able to get
- 34:07out of that. They won't be able to have that empathy in the same
- 34:10way that we couldn't empathize with the Jesus who was potentacled now much thinking about
- 34:15it. I never hadn't considered it before. But if Jesus had to go
- 34:20and atone for the sins of the slug people, then that Jesus would have
- 34:25to be like a slug Jesus kind of a thing, and so instead of
- 34:30dying on the cross, they would just like somebody poured salt on him.
- 34:32Yeah, he assaulted for your sins. He wass saulted. Don't don't encourage
- 34:39him. I'm sorry about that. Jonathan ms Pierce and Aaron Adair, who
- 34:44are co authors of the book Aliens and Religion, Where Two Worlds Collide.
- 34:51Okay, is their life out there? I'm going to talk to a philosopher
- 34:57and a physicist my special guests after this. You want the show early and
- 35:07totally commercial free, and you want to support your humble hosts, become a
- 35:13patron at patreon dot com slash seth Andrews with my thanks, talking here with
- 35:21author and philosopher Jonathan ms Pierce and physicist and Bible scholar doctor Aaron Adair,
- 35:29co authors of the book Aliens and Religion, Where Two Worlds Collide. Many
- 35:37of our gods throughout history have been elemental God, Sun, God, moon,
- 35:39god astro theology, and we know that human beings haven't evolved kind of
- 35:45a gravitation, often toward beliefs, some of it rooted in infancy or even
- 35:51pre birth, and we'd seem to have a predisposition to associate the cosmos with
- 35:55the gods. Is that a scientific question a philosophical question? Have you tackled
- 36:00the question either one of you? Let me take this first from a math
- 36:05point of view, because one of the things I tried to do was compare
- 36:09how much energy it would take to actually get a spaceship from one planetary system
- 36:15to another if it came from another sun and came to our world. And
- 36:20I realized, if they launched something at us, that could reach a significant
- 36:23fraction in the speed of light, so that way the time wouldn't be so
- 36:27extraordinarily long. I realized, Wow, the amount of energy that they would
- 36:30need would mean that their civilization would be at least a million times more powerful
- 36:36than ours, and that would put them on energy levels equivalent to at a
- 36:40bare minimum forces of nature. So if aliens come here in their spaceships,
- 36:45they will have the energy resources of literal thunderstorms and earthquakes and things like that.
- 36:50So it's like, in a very real way, they would have the
- 36:52power level of the God's imagine before Thor would look up and say like,
- 36:57damn, I got nothing on these guys. It's also the idea that our
- 37:01cosmology, well our astronomy and our astrology is very much linked to our understanding
- 37:07of gods, and indeed God, so the Biblical God, there are elements
- 37:12that are particular to our understanding of the skies that have found their way into
- 37:17the Bible. Now, if this is like the story is the revelation,
- 37:22then that's quite problematic. If it's particular to just our understanding of what we
- 37:29see where we are Aaron, did you want to talk to that? Yeah?
- 37:32Yeah, let's talk about everyone's favorite character from the Bible. That's the
- 37:37bad boy the Bible, our friend Satan, his other name being Lucifer.
- 37:40But the name Lucifer comes from the Latin for the planet Venus when it's rising
- 37:45in the morning, So Lucifer literally means light bearer, and that's a way
- 37:50of referring to the morning star when it's rising up early just before sunrise.
- 37:53The thing is the only reason we have a morning star is an accident of
- 37:59our location of the planet, and just a little bit of geometry. The
- 38:01fact that the planet Venus is closer to the Sun than Earth is in our
- 38:06mostly circular orbits, means that you'll only ever see Venus basically on the horizons
- 38:13at sunrise and sunset. You can technically see Venus during the day, but
- 38:15you need to know exactly where to look, and it has to be really
- 38:17special conditions. I mean, you're trying to basically look at someone letting a
- 38:22match when there's a whole bunch of spotlights pointing at your eyes. It's a
- 38:23very difficult thing to do. But the fact of the matter is this idea
- 38:28of Satan being called Lucifer, is this idea that there even is a morning
- 38:32star, And that's just an accident of our astronomy. So if Earth were
- 38:37actually the closest planet to the Sun, if say Venus and Mercury weren't there,
- 38:42there would be no morning star. And so how can the prophet Isaiah
- 38:45refer to the Babylonian king as ou morning star are going to be thrown down?
- 38:49And it's like, well, there is no morning star. We don't
- 38:51know what you're talking about. And then they're going to name the devil after
- 38:53that. It's like, wow, that's really confusing, to put it mildly.
- 38:57So, whatever religion the aliens might have, unless they have identical planetary
- 39:01systems are as, they won't have the same astronomical visions and mythologies that we
- 39:07have developed by sheer accident. This is quite similar to something called the problem
- 39:13of particularity, which is connected to the scandal of particularity. So the scandal
- 39:17of particularity is this idea that the only way to access salvation is through Jesus.
- 39:22So what does that say if you're an alien from a different galaxy,
- 39:27like, the only way to access salvation is through Jesus. Again, it
- 39:30goes back to this or is that our Jesus does this? Jesus do it
- 39:32for you? How do you know about this Jesus? How can you access
- 39:35this story? And would it mean the senti so all of what we talked
- 39:37about before, or do you need your own Jesus? So on and so
- 39:40forth. And the problem of particularity is the idea that so much of the
- 39:45Jesus story. Again, if you if you are a theologian who advocates for
- 39:50the single Jesus idea. Then, so much of that story is based in
- 39:54a particular place in a particular time. It's very parochial. And there are
- 39:59six hundred thirteen mitzuhs. So these laws in the Bible that even now we
- 40:02have the problem of particularity is a problem irrespective of valiance, right. So
- 40:06it's it's someone in the AMAZONI of the rainforests, how do they understand the
- 40:09moral dictats of the Hebrew Bible that talks about you know, you can't have
- 40:14wool and linen together, you can't mix woo and linien, you can't eat
- 40:16shellfish, you have to get circumcised, all these kind of things. You're
- 40:20like, well, it really doesn't speak to me, doesn't speak to me
- 40:22as a modern person in the UK. Let loan someone from a bit here
- 40:25or someone from there, and then you're kind of expanding that issue out to
- 40:29other civilizations in other corners of the universe, and that problem is even more
- 40:34emphasized, I think. And just to highlight how that is, I imagine
- 40:38if we discover the planet of the Akidnas and they want to join Judaism,
- 40:44and then they tell them about circumcision, and they'll be like well one or
- 40:46or off four of the heads of our penises, because you know, we've
- 40:50got a bit of a different anatomy down there. Just one of the ardities
- 40:53that will happen if we try to explain and involve a grander community into these
- 41:00very parochial religions. Circumcising the slug people does provide a lot of logistical challenges.
- 41:07Now that it's a visual I now regret having in my brain. What
- 41:10do you want to what are you trying to accomplish with this book? That's
- 41:15a good question, I think Initially it's like, oh, what if?
- 41:19And answering to what if? And since the area of what we're interested in
- 41:22in different ways Aaron and myself, what's the probability of God existing? Is
- 41:27godlikely or not? And we look at in the book, we look at
- 41:30abductive arguments rather than deductive or inductive arguments. So abductive arguments are inferences to
- 41:36the best explanation to me, hopefully to Aaron as well. It's fairly obvious
- 41:40that when you look at all these areas and all these ramifications of the discovery
- 41:44of intelligent alien life, that actually, you know that kind of Omnigod that
- 41:47particularly, these narrower versions of God are just they're just less likely. There's
- 41:52just more problems if you introduce these other life forms. Well, let me
- 41:57stick with you for just a second. Do you speak at all to the
- 42:00idea of the watchmaker deistic? Something is out there kind of a god,
- 42:05you know, the spiritual that says, well, what if? I mean,
- 42:08do you address that at all? The thing about daism is that realistically
- 42:12there's no difference between daism and atheism. But if you've got a God that's
- 42:15created everything and then just sits back and doesn't interact at all, such that
- 42:20that God is effectively invisible, then it doesn't really matter whether that God exists
- 42:24or not. There's no meaningful difference between atheism and that kind of dayism.
- 42:29I don't think would you two agree, No, I'd agree. I mean,
- 42:31for all practical purposes. Plus, if we're talking about affecting positive change
- 42:36and moving people toward humanism on this planet, it's not the deists who are
- 42:40trying to change laws and brighten children with hell, etc. Right. I
- 42:45mean, though I'm not worried about the deists, in many ways, we
- 42:47kind of also do address the idea of deism because if the idea that the
- 42:52deist is also believing in some sort of all good God, the problem of
- 42:54evil rears its head again, and we actually do some computations the show if
- 43:00aliens merely exist, it makes the problem of evil worse. But to me,
- 43:04perhaps the most interesting thing that we did with the book is showing just
- 43:07what will change for humanity and especially for the religious traditions because they're going to
- 43:13have to change. We looked at some of the studies about cognitive dissonance that
- 43:16we're actually first done on a UFO called back in the nineteen fifties, the
- 43:21book by Leon Fassenger, when prophecy fails, prophecy that aliens are going to
- 43:23come and save all the good people, what everyone else was going to be
- 43:27destroyed. Well, as you can tell, the nineteen fifties came and went,
- 43:30and well the end of the world didn't quite happen, but that religious
- 43:32group still held on and believed even more fervidly. So we know, disproof
- 43:38or intellectual difficulties don't end religions. That just causes the message to change.
- 43:43So we're curiously how our religions going to have to adapt, which ones might
- 43:49pick up new followers based on the discovery of aliens, and also depending on
- 43:52are we discovering them that they just barely exist in another galaxy or are they
- 43:57hovering over the moon right now, that will make a big difference. And
- 44:00for me, perhaps one of the insights that became so poignant was when we
- 44:05were trying to project out, well, how many cosmic neighbors might we have
- 44:08in the Milky Way galaxy or the rest of the universe, and our suggestion
- 44:13is we probably do have neighbors somewhere, but they're probably not close, which
- 44:17means that it becomes absolutely amazing if we do discover aliens with our current means,
- 44:24because if we did discover them now, that means they have to be
- 44:28way more numerous than we might first estimate. And the only way that that
- 44:31can be true is that they are extremely long lived civilizations. And the beautiful
- 44:37thing is that observation, coupled with the Copernica principle that says, if we're
- 44:40just average and we find out the average lifespan of these civilizations is tens of
- 44:45thousands of years, we've got a huge beautiful future ahead of us just being
- 44:51the c students of the galaxy. So I find a beauty of what that
- 44:58discovery could hold for us. I really knowing we are not alone. So
- 45:01as we draw things down here, what I'm entering is you think there's something
- 45:07out that, you think there's life out there, the probabilities are too great.
- 45:10I think a lot of this depends on what you're understanding of the size
- 45:15of the universe is So it seems to me at any rate that the bigger
- 45:19the universe, and more likely it is that intelligent alien life exists out there.
- 45:22And if you advocate for an infinite universe, then there's going to be
- 45:28infinite instances of intelligent alien life. The issue is that I would say that
- 45:32they are quarantined by distance or we are quarantined by distance, is that the
- 45:37distances are so vast between these instances of alien life forms that there's no realistic
- 45:44hope of high fiving each other, let alone having technosignatures that reach each other.
- 45:49And if you've got an expanding universe that makes it difficult for light to
- 45:52reach certain areas, then this becomes even more difficult. So my conclusion would
- 45:57be, yes, there's almost certainly intelligent life out there. There's almost certainly
- 46:01loads of intelligent alien life out there, just it's quite a long way away.
- 46:07Yeah. We actually created a way of trying to run simulations based on
- 46:12our current scientific knowledge and ignorance and combined in an equation that's very famous known
- 46:17as the Drake equation, named after Frank Drake back in he created this back
- 46:21in the nineteen sixties, a way of estimating how many neighbors we might have
- 46:24right now in the Milky Way. There's a lot of those factors that are
- 46:28still unknown, but we have ways of dealing with that uncertainty, modeling our
- 46:34uncertainty in those results, and basically it's extremely unlikely that we are alone in
- 46:38the entire observable universe, and my estimates would put us the basically fifty fifty
- 46:43chance if we have galactic neighbors. Last thing, and you've been very generous
- 46:47with your time, and I will link the book in the description box,
- 46:51hoping everybody supports it and checks it out. But you know, as Aaron's
- 46:54a Trek fan and you're the philosopher I was always told and I think I
- 47:00may still buy this Truth is stranger than fiction. Oh, you've explored,
- 47:06You've looked out as best we can into the cosmos, and you've done the
- 47:09math literally and you've gotten into, you know, the human imagination and what
- 47:15can conjure in our minds. Someone Jerry, what do you think is truth
- 47:17stranger than fiction? I'll start, I think, Jonathan, well, I
- 47:22think truth is often predicted by fiction. When you look at where I was
- 47:25having this conversation the other day and someone's telling me, who knew a lot
- 47:29more about chat, GBT and AI and stuff than I do? And actually
- 47:34it's fairly scary because before you know, it's going to be Terminator and there
- 47:37are going to be drones, autonomous drones flying around having wards. And yes,
- 47:42science fiction predicts the future. I think. You know, you look
- 47:45at so many things that come to pass, and science fiction writers have predicted
- 47:49that already. So I think it's not that truth is stranger than fiction.
- 47:52I think is a fiction predicts truth quite often. There were some people,
- 47:57I think who dismiss my concerns about I'm reminded of that line by Ian Malcolm
- 48:01in Jurassic Park, right where scientists were so obsessed with whether they could they
- 48:07didn't stop to think if they should. I feel that way about AI in
- 48:10many regards. That's probably a whole other show. Well, I will remind
- 48:15you the other important statement by Ian Malcolm that can give us a little bit
- 48:19of a hope, because life finds a way. I don't know truth in
- 48:24fiction. You want to finish us off here, Aaron, I have seen
- 48:28some fictions that ain't going to be true. The human imagination can be amazingly
- 48:36diverse in what concepts can be in there. But on the other hand,
- 48:38it's also restricted. It's still lacking all the possible experiences that our brains could
- 48:45have. So what we might imagine now, I have a hard time believing
- 48:50it will be the same thing that we imagine a thousand years in the future,
- 48:53in the same way a thousand years pass. It was so hard to
- 48:55imagine all sorts of things. But again, the human imagination has been ahead
- 49:00of itself. Twenty five hundred years ago, you had people like Democratus already
- 49:02imagine Adams. You had Epicurus already taking that idea of Adams and imagining other
- 49:08world's end life on those other worlds. The idea of aliens is quite ancient.
- 49:14In some ways. Our scientists family caught up with that bit of imagination.
- 49:19Yeah, can I add to two things. First of all, just
- 49:22on the AI front, our book cover is actually the image of the book
- 49:27cover is designed by AI. It's Dally. So Aaron put in a couple
- 49:31of turns into that and it came up with a with a with an image.
- 49:36And now we've we've lost the designer a job. So that's that's good,
- 49:39isn't it. And the second thing is to what Aaron was talking about
- 49:44and what you said, set is that a thousand years ago and maybe the
- 49:46people didn't predict where we are at now. This is really interesting topic to
- 49:51discuss in terms of theology, biblical exegesis, prophecies. Right. One reason
- 49:55why I can categorically say that the prophecies of the Bible light of Bunkum is
- 50:00that at no point in the Hebrew Bible did they predict mobile phones like intercontinental
- 50:07ballistic missiles of the boards PlayStation five. You know, they're just like we
- 50:12predict a war between two factions and one of them wins. Well, whoop
- 50:17do you do? You know, brilliant great prophesy in there, Well,
- 50:21don't even go that far. Like the postle Paul couldn't even predict the existence
- 50:23of the twenty first century. This is a whole other show. You know,
- 50:30we'll have to hook up again when we're in the bunker and Skynet is
- 50:34flying its assassin ships overhead and we're looking for some time to kill. I
- 50:38think we should get together and talk again about AI and about the best and
- 50:43worst of technology, which I think is a hugely relevant topic. But it's
- 50:46an amazing book. Yes, I'm really impressed, and I really am impressed
- 50:51by how you've been able to ride it in a way that allows the rest
- 50:53of us to play along. Aliens and Religion, where two worlds collide,
- 50:59assessing the impact of discovering extra terrestrial intelligence on religion and theology. Jonathan MS.
- 51:07Pierce and Aaron Nadair, you're both very kind to join me. Thanks
- 51:10for coming, absolutely pleasure. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for
- 51:15a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring
- 51:21the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on
- 51:25upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist
- 51:31dot com.