Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 146 - Camera Man by Dana Stevens
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening, you've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hess here on jail Jbdia. Hello
- 0:22everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast of memories of yesteryear money,
- 0:26Miss Doug Kans and if you're tuning in Forgotten Hollywood for the first time,
- 0:30what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey back in
- 0:33time. We share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not
- 0:37known about. And in this episode, we have a very special guest with
- 0:41us today, Dana Stevens. And Dana is and has been with the Slates
- 0:48Film Critics since two thousand and six. She's also a co host of the
- 0:53magazine's long running culture podcast, Thus Slate Culture Gave Fast. But she's here
- 0:59today to talk about her book that just came out in paperback, and that
- 1:03is Cameraman Buster Keaton, The dawna Cinema and the Invention of the twentieth Century.
- 1:10Diana, Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you so much for having me,
- 1:14Ah, it's our pleasure. Thank you for coming on spend in a
- 1:15few minutes with us today. So we know what the book's about. It's
- 1:19about Buster Keaton. But how did this book come about what inspired you to
- 1:23write a book on Buster Keaton? Well, you know, they say,
- 1:27write the book you want to read. Right, That's a piece of advice
- 1:30you often hear to aspiring authors. And that really is where this book came
- 1:34from, is from a long, bubbling obsession with Keaton and silent film and
- 1:40the period of history that he came from, which is his lifespan was eighteen
- 1:44ninety five to nineteen sixty six. Right. And when people would ask about
- 1:48the book I was writing, when I was working on this, I said,
- 1:49it's not so much a biography of Keaton as a cultural history of Keaton's
- 1:53lifespan. You know, it's a cultural history of the United States between eighteen
- 1:57ninety five and nineteen sixty six, which, if you think about, you
- 2:00know, the technology and the entertainment and the cultural and social and political changes
- 2:04between those two dates. You know, even though he only lived seventy years,
- 2:07it's not an incredibly long life, but he really saw the whole world
- 2:10and the country change around him, and in many ways, I think his
- 2:14films told the story of that change, sometimes maybe even in ways he wasn't
- 2:17conscious of as a filmmaker. So, in addition to being just one of
- 2:22my favorite artists in any medium. You know, he's just a great,
- 2:24great filmmaker, comedian obviously, you know, slapstick comedian, and artist.
- 2:30I just felt like he was such an agent of or an agent is the
- 2:34wrong word, almost like a locus of change in the twentieth century. And
- 2:38that's what the subtitle of the book is about, right, the dawn of
- 2:40the twentieth the dawna cinema and the invention of the twentieth century. I'm kind
- 2:44of making a big argument own a way about him, and it's an argument
- 2:47that you know, if you look at his life, you will understand a
- 2:51lot of things, trends, forces, cultural changes that go way beyond just
- 2:54his life story. Yeah. So when it came to the research of this,
- 3:00it was it easy to obviously somebody like a Buster Keaton, there's a
- 3:05lot of material there, But was it hard to really focus and pare down
- 3:09things to put it in the books? And sometimes you will talk to us
- 3:13somebody and they see there's just so much and they have that trouble of trying
- 3:15to decide what to cut and what to put it in the book. Did
- 3:19you have that trouble? Oh? Yeah, I mean, anytime you're trying
- 3:22to tell someone's life story, right, even though this isn't a traditional classical
- 3:25biography, it still is going to involve reading lots and lots of biography and
- 3:30lots of film history and lots of American history, and you know, it
- 3:34could could easily spiral into an infinite project. So really what you're doing is
- 3:38deciding what not to put in right, And it is very daunting to realize,
- 3:43Hey, I think I'll write a book about this figure. I thought
- 3:45that I knew a lot about and I'd certainly read all the major biographies and
- 3:47things before I ever even started thinking about this book. But when you start
- 3:52to realize the amount of material there is, and also just the depth of
- 3:57his influence on other filmmakers, right, it's it really is kind of infinite.
- 4:01And I'm sure that many people reading this book will say, well,
- 4:03why didn't you talk about this? Why didn't you talk about that? Right,
- 4:06There's definitely other avenues I could have gone down that I didn't choose.
- 4:11But instead, what I chose to do is essentially moved through his life chronologically
- 4:15and in each era of his life try to find some outside force, some
- 4:19some some development or cultural trend outside of his story, but that intersected with
- 4:26it. So you know, for example, in talking about his childhood,
- 4:30he grew up as a vaudeville star on the stage with a traveling act with
- 4:33his family, the Three Keatons, and that's a really, really fascinating period
- 4:38to research. Of course, there's no recorded images of him and his family
- 4:42doing their things, so you have to just depend on descriptions of it from
- 4:45you know, people who saw it at the time, reconstructions kind of.
- 4:48And I decided to tie that in with the history of child labor laws,
- 4:53child abuse laws, you know, all the things that dogged him during his
- 4:56childhood, which was the act getting shut down again and again because it was
- 4:59considered too violent and kind of the question of what it meant to be a
- 5:02performing child at the turn of the century, and specifically a performing child in
- 5:06this act that was reputed to be the roughest act in the history of the
- 5:10vaudeville stage. Right, So that opens up all kinds of fascinating questions about
- 5:15the history of child labor laws and you know, working kids on stage and
- 5:18what did and didn't constitute child abuse in eighteen ninety five, and you know,
- 5:23the years the years after that. So yeah, that's one of the
- 5:26places where you know, I sort of chose something to go with his life,
- 5:30and it seemed to invite those questions. It really, this whole book
- 5:33honestly just sprung out of questions that I myself wanted to answer, like what
- 5:38was it like to be this person in this time period? You know?
- 5:41And what can I read or watch to help me understand that? Yeah?
- 5:44Well, and then, like you said, you're writing it in you know,
- 5:46the two and twenties, twenty twenty one, etc. But you're trying
- 5:50to put yourself in a mind set that was a much different than it is
- 5:55today. Yeah, more than a hundred years before, right, and you
- 5:58and you really realize how much changed in those those hundred years when you even
- 6:01look at photographs of his childhood in Vaudeville, and it's like for strong carriages,
- 6:05you know, and cars not around yet, traveling from by train from
- 6:10city to city, What was it like to ride the train, you know,
- 6:12at the turn of the century. All those questions kind of came up.
- 6:15And then you know, as as he changes and the world changes around
- 6:19him, he goes you know, he serves in the army during World War
- 6:21One, so there's a whole new era to write about. And then there's
- 6:27Hollywood, the beginning of you know, the film colony and film culture on
- 6:30the West coast. He was part of that because he started actually making movies
- 6:34when he was around twenty on the East Coast and was part of, you
- 6:38know, this group of people who realized, we'll wait a minute, there's
- 6:41this place with better weather, better light, you know, and a lot
- 6:45more space, and everything's cheap because this is just this city is just beginning.
- 6:48And so he was kind of part of that migration to to La and
- 6:51the early film culture well. And and he had touched every aspect of film,
- 6:58so he was involved all silent and then it went to the talkies and
- 7:01he was in all that. But not only was he also a player,
- 7:06meaning an actor, but he was a director, He was a writer,
- 7:10He did his own stunts, so he really captivated everything about the movies in
- 7:16one fascinating career. Yeah, I mean, I think it's not that unusual
- 7:20in the early early days of film that the person who is, you know,
- 7:24the main creative force in front of the camera is also behind the camera.
- 7:28That was the case with Charlie Chaplin. And it's the case with a
- 7:30bunch of filmmakers that I write about, you know, well, with Roscoe
- 7:32Arbuckle, you know, Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle, with whom Keaton got his start,
- 7:35and Mabel Norman, who gets the whole chapter in the book, who
- 7:39you know they called the female chaplain at the time, and h and who
- 7:42if not for essentially the you know this, this moment in the nineteen tens
- 7:46when women were kind of driven out of the creative end of the film industry
- 7:49probably would have would be in everyone's mind still as the you know, the
- 7:53female great slapstick comedian of that time. Anyway, all those figures, you
- 7:57know, both worked behind it in front of the but Keaton really took that
- 8:01further than almost anyone. I mean, he edited his own films, right,
- 8:03He did extraordinary stunts that he insisted on being the person who was doing
- 8:07them, never doubled himself. And I just to me, you know,
- 8:11you can make the case otherwise. And Chaplin is obviously an incredibly important figure
- 8:16and a great American artist as well or international artist. But but I feel
- 8:20like as a filmmaker, Keaton's stands above them all. You know, his
- 8:24sense of where to put the camera, his sense of when to cut.
- 8:26He you know, he edited his own films in the editing room like he
- 8:30was the guy cutting them. And it's just so so striking to me that
- 8:33somebody who had grown up on the stage and knew stagecraft so well just immediately
- 8:39and smoothly made the transition to film and started doing all these innovative things behind
- 8:43the camera. You know, He's just such a multi valent talent in that
- 8:46way. Yeah, and you're right, early on that seemed to be everybody's
- 8:50role. Compared today, if we fast forward to twenty twenty three, Yeah,
- 8:56somebody might Rye and or direct or. They made Rye in act,
- 9:00but they're not doing everything that some of the early pioneers were doing in film.
- 9:05And go ahead. Oh, I was going to say. When I
- 9:09was touring with the book last year, a question that I would often get
- 9:13was if Keaton were to be in a biopic, if there were to be
- 9:16a biopick, right, say, my book was adapted, what who would
- 9:22play him? And it's a really really hard question to answer, because I
- 9:26mean, not only is there absolutely no one who could do the physical stunts
- 9:28that he grew up doing, and there's not really even any way to train
- 9:31your way into it unless you get a child and start training to him at
- 9:35age four like he did. But that person would have to direct, you
- 9:39know, if you really wanted to recreate a Keaton, it wouldn't just be
- 9:43oh, this person is great in front of the camera. It would be
- 9:45oh, and they're conceptualized every everything behind the camera too, you know,
- 9:48and coming up with the ideas for the gags and where to place the camera
- 9:52and all of these things. So anything that you would create now, I
- 9:54mean, I would love to see a Keaton biopick if it was done right,
- 9:58but it would have to be just only showing a tiny fragment of what
- 10:01he actually accomplished. Yeah. Well, and the other thing that I've always
- 10:05said about this and past podcasts as well, because he did a little bit
- 10:11of everything, I think that made him even a much better director, actor,
- 10:16stunt man, because he was truly involved in every aspect of the process,
- 10:24right, which I think is lost on a lot of actors and actresses
- 10:31because they just didn't I don't want to say they didn't get it, because
- 10:35I think they did, but they didn't get it to his depth great.
- 10:39I mean something that I we just want to encourage your listeners if they're listening
- 10:41to all this and not really knowing his work that well. Is just like
- 10:46dive in, you know, start anywhere. Because almost all of this stuff
- 10:48is available streaming for free online. It might not be the greatest quality if
- 10:52you really want to see, you know, the most historically accurate one kind
- 10:56of you know, restorations. You can go to DVD and Blu ray and
- 11:01they have beautiful stuff. But it's really easy to find this stuff on archive
- 11:05dot org or YouTube for free and you can jump in anywhere. There's not
- 11:09any need to be a completist or start at the beginning. You don't really
- 11:11need any context. Like read the book if you want to, and hopefully
- 11:15that will give you a lot of historical context. But the stuff is still
- 11:18funny even if you know nothing about it. And I can vouch for having
- 11:20shown that to people all of last year, you know, when I was
- 11:24going doing book tour dates and so you know, I organized screenings for kids
- 11:28where I curated a program specifically you know, kid friendly Keaton, but really
- 11:33it's all friendly for all ages, you know, And I just really hope
- 11:35that some people listening to this will think beyond you know, the couple images
- 11:41that you might have of silent comedy, which are probably kind of blurring Chaplain
- 11:43and Keaton and Lloyd together. You know, I know I did that before
- 11:46I started reading about this stuff and watching it and just like, watch some
- 11:50because it holds up so incredibly well for one hundred year old humor. Oh
- 11:54absolutely. And the beauty that I really like is what you were talking about
- 12:00when you were short it to kids. You know, they see comedy today,
- 12:03but when you show this work from one hundred years ago, it's hard
- 12:09for the kids not to laugh and get it. I mean, it's really
- 12:13interesting to watch the reaction of the younger generation because, like you said,
- 12:18a hundred years later, it's still great stuff and people of all ages can
- 12:24relate to it. Yeah. I have yet to meet a kid who doesn't
- 12:26laugh at the short, especially the shorts. The shorts maybe because their cartoon
- 12:31length. You know, they're twenty minutes along, and so even a really
- 12:33little kid who might not be able to follow a longer story will just will
- 12:37absolutely get into it. And I met lots and lots of people who had
- 12:41discovered him as a child with their parents. You know, things would happen
- 12:43at a book signing or something where you know, two adults would come along
- 12:48and it was, you know, a kid and his dad, a man
- 12:50and his dad, and they had grown up watching this stuff together. So
- 12:52it really is a great legacy, and I'm really proud that the book has
- 12:56been sort of a part of that. You know, it wasn't something I
- 12:58had counted on that I would be part of introducing this work to new watchers,
- 13:03but it has turned out that way and that's been great. So in
- 13:05your research, what surprised you did anything stick out in your mind or surprised
- 13:11you doing your research of Blester Keaton. That's a good question. I think
- 13:16something that surprised me probably and that I think some readers have been surprised by
- 13:20two is that he had a lot more success in later life and was happier
- 13:26and more creative in later life than you probably think of because this sort of
- 13:28famous life story moment in Keaton's life, which is true, it's certainly true,
- 13:33is that he crashed really hard when sound came in, you know,
- 13:37in the silent to sound transition. He was not one of the actors a
- 13:41relatively few actors in Hollywood who survived that transition. Well, you know,
- 13:45so he signed this contract with MGM in nineteen twenty eight, which is when
- 13:50sound came in that he later called the worst professional mistake of his life,
- 13:56in which he went from being this creative force we were talking about somebody who's
- 14:00behind the camera in front of the camera, has his own production company,
- 14:01has his own crew, you know, carrying out his own kind of crazy
- 14:05visions, to just being a contract player at MGM, where he's just an
- 14:09actor and a comedian in front of the camera. And MGIM didn't understand him
- 14:13at all. They put him in terrible vehicles, you know. I mean,
- 14:16not to put all the blame on MGM. He also spiraled out at
- 14:18that time, started drinking too much, his marriage fell apart, and he
- 14:22really was a mess for most of the up to the mid thirties. Right,
- 14:28And because of that story and because he kind of you know, stopped
- 14:31being the main filmmaking force behind his movies after that, I think people tend
- 14:33to think, oh, Buster Keaton, this great genius of silent film who
- 14:37then became a drunk and went downhill and his life was over. But in
- 14:41fact, from about nineteen, the late thirties on let's say he started to
- 14:46get work again. He started to get work in front of the camera again
- 14:50by you know, the late forties, fifties, and then he had so
- 14:56much work he was turning it down, you know. I mean, it
- 14:58is true that he never had kind of power in the film world that he
- 15:01had before. But he was really excited by early television. For example.
- 15:05He was a real technophile and he always loved him kind of be on the
- 15:07cutting edge of technology, and he was everywhere on TV in the nineteen fifties.
- 15:11And that really surprised me. Once I started researching it. I knew
- 15:13that he'd done Twilight Zone, he'd done Candid Camera, you know. But
- 15:18he also, this is in the book a bit. He was one of
- 15:20the forces behind the I Love Lucy Show, even though he was never on
- 15:22it. He was good friends with Lucille Ball and he helped to coach her
- 15:26for the pilot and you know, kind of give her ideas for the show.
- 15:30You know, he just he was He'd performed in the circus in the
- 15:33nineteen forties and fifties in Europe at these very you know, high end European
- 15:37circuses where he was the star clown of the show. And so it's really
- 15:41if you love him the way you know I do, especially after having spent
- 15:45five years researching him. It's great to know that he also married very happily.
- 15:48In nineteen forty, after two miserable marriages, he married a woman,
- 15:52Eleanor Keaton, who was really a soul mate for him and a performing partner
- 15:56as well. And you know, so the last twenty five years of his
- 15:58life or so, I think he was both personally contented and professionally challenged and
- 16:06was not this sort of sad sack. And so the book has a happy
- 16:08ending in that way. You know, yeah, almost comes full circle in
- 16:11a way. You know, he grew up poor and had a career downfall,
- 16:18and then you have a nice happy endi uniting, right, And I
- 16:22say happy ending in relatively terms. You know, he didn't go out like
- 16:33he very well could have. You know, Sorry, we're worried about the
- 16:36world. You know, I got cheated because sound came in or anything like
- 16:41that. He basically, this is my words, but basically regrouped, collected
- 16:47himself and went out on top. Yeah, he wasn't bitter at all.
- 16:49In late interviews, he always said he was very satisfied with his life and
- 16:52his career. I do have one correction to something you just said, or
- 16:56just a reframing, which is that it's not quite true that he grew up
- 16:59poor or his parents were pretty poor when he was born and they were not
- 17:03quite making it on the vaudeville performing circuit. But this was another kind of
- 17:07surprising thing when I was researching him. Basically, the minute he joined their
- 17:11show at age five, they started to become a very successful vaudeville act.
- 17:15And by the time he was six, I mean, really the speed with
- 17:18which the act picked up steam and started to go on the top circuits is
- 17:22incredible. So he joined their act when he had just turned five, and
- 17:26if you look at newspaper clippings from the year after that, right when he's
- 17:30six years old, he's the star of the show. He's the one getting
- 17:33top billing, and instead of you know, begging for work, they're on
- 17:37the top vaudeville circuits, the Orpheum circuit and the Keith circuit and really,
- 17:41you know, kind of at the cream of the crop in the vaudeville world.
- 17:45So he was a successful performer from the minute he stepped onto a stage.
- 17:48That's I think part of what's astounding about his story. Sure, was
- 17:53you think his parents or he knew something was meant for him by the way
- 18:00he would get reactions from the crowd. I mean, was that something that
- 18:03obviously a lot of entertainers would feed off of. But did that drive him
- 18:07in any way? Oh? Yeah, I mean he loved I think he
- 18:11loved to perform, you know, even though he had the famous deadpan,
- 18:14you know, and always has the somber face and everything. Apparently behind the
- 18:18scenes, he didn't like to smile in front of a camera because that was
- 18:21part of his persona. So even in still pictures, he's rarely smiling,
- 18:23unless it's so candid he didn't know his photo was being taken. Sure,
- 18:26but he was somebody who loved to laugh and make people laugh, and I
- 18:30really think loved to be on a stage. And his father was somebody who
- 18:33was very aware of how important his son was to the act and was a
- 18:37great publicist, you know, sometimes to the extent that he would make up
- 18:41tall tales and you know, Joe Keaton, his father was a real embellisher,
- 18:45but he definitely knew how to exploit the value of having this prodigy,
- 18:48you know, slapstick prodigy son. Can't imagine somebody exaggerating the truth a little
- 18:55bit right to help the actor. Yeah, that was very much his dad's
- 18:59role. Yeah. Well, I know we're getting close here on time,
- 19:03and I want to thank you for coming on. But one last question before
- 19:07we go. I always like to ask, especially authors of a book,
- 19:11any favorite movie that you have a Buster Keaton one that just sticks out in
- 19:15your mind. Yeah, that's well, that's something that changes, I think
- 19:18whenever you really love an artist and you love all their work. Yes,
- 19:21sort of changes from it's a hard one time to the next thing you're asking.
- 19:25Yeah, but during the course of showing so many of his movies last
- 19:27year and talking about him so much with so many different people, I kind
- 19:30of developed official answers to that with the proviso that it might change in the
- 19:36future. I would say my favorite feature length Keaton film is Steamboat Bill Jr.
- 19:41Which was his last independently produced movie, the last movie he made with
- 19:44the Buster Keaton Studio. There's a whole chapter about it in the book,
- 19:47So if you want to hear why I loved it, read Cameraman. But
- 19:51that one I think was special in his life, and if you know a
- 19:53little about his life story, including his relationship with his dad that we were
- 19:56just talking about, I feel like Steamboat Build j is kind of working out
- 20:00some of the things about his father. It's it's a father's son story.
- 20:03It's about, you know, Keaton's character and his dad sort of working out
- 20:08their own problems together. It's very funny and it's just beautifully made. So
- 20:12I would say Steamboat Bill Junior is my favorite feature and my favorite shorts.
- 20:18I got to talk about the shorts too, because these are so they're they're
- 20:21so special in their own right. It's probably One Week, which also has
- 20:23its own chapter in the book, and which I kind of think of as
- 20:27like the first great romantic comedy you know, ever made as a film.
- 20:30It's just a perfect romantic comedy and a perfect slapstick movie at the same time.
- 20:36And I would actually say, if somebody out there is going to jump
- 20:37into Keaton and they're wondering what do I watch first, it doesn't really matter
- 20:41where you jump in, but you could do worse than starting with One Week.
- 20:44It's his first independently made movie, and it's absolutely wonderful. And I
- 20:48guarantee that you know, after you watch it, you're going to be curious
- 20:51to see more, and I want to be that under a little bit right.
- 20:56Well, David, thank you again for coming on and spending a few
- 20:59minutes with this today. I've really enjoyed the conversation, enjoyed your book audience.
- 21:03Please go out and get a copy of Dana's book, Cameraman, Bester
- 21:07Keaton, The Donna Cinema and the Invention of the twentieth Century. You're not
- 21:11going to be disappointed. It's now out in paperback. You can get hardback
- 21:15and get paperback now, Doug. If I can just add on to that,
- 21:17there's also an audiobook version of Cameraman. Maybe your podcast listener audience likes
- 21:22to listen to books. I know I'd like to listen to books sometimes,
- 21:25and I actually read the audiobook, which was a great pleasure. I asked
- 21:27the publisher if I could read it because I'm such an audiobook person, and
- 21:30I thought I always like to hear the author read their own book, you
- 21:33know, so it was the first time I'd ever done that. It was
- 21:34great fun. And if you're somebody who listens rather than reads, you can
- 21:38find that on Audible or any place you get audiobooks. Please go ahead and
- 21:41get a copy of Dana's book and read it. Like I said, you're
- 21:45not going to be disappointed again. Dana, thank you so much for coming
- 21:48on Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you done, all right? Thank you for listening
- 21:52to this episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Just search for Dogcast or Forgotten Hollywood.
- 21:56You can also find me on Twitter or Instagram at hes doug fourteen. If
- 22:00you listen to this podcast on iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe,
- 22:03rate, and review this episode. Tune in the next episode about Forgotten Hollywood.
- 22:07Thanks for listening and we'll see you then.