Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CAMEL Codes Get Worse - AGAIN
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 3: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trico with another
- 0:37episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38It is June, we finally made it to June.
- 0:41I don't know about you, but this year seems to be flying by.
- 0:44It's going to be a short couple of topics I want to talk about.
- 0:47I've recently had a board presentation.
- 0:50I've got another board planning session I'm doing on Friday.
- 0:54And in preparation for that, I've been looking at some of the things
- 0:58that I look at quite frequently.
- 1:00One of which are the camel codes and the continued deterioration of camel
- 1:04codes, particularly code threes, which if you listen to the special podcast
- 1:11I did, which was the Audio of the NCWA board meeting where there were only
- 1:16two board members because chairman Harper is out for back surgery.
- 1:19Todd, if you're listening, I hope that all that recovery is going well.
- 1:23Back pain is no fun for anybody.
- 1:26And again, hope Godspeed and hope you'll get back on your feet soon, but I digress.
- 1:31The board meeting basically was just the share insurance fund
- 1:35briefing and they talked about camel codes, which again, deteriorated.
- 1:40Now there wasn't as much banter or language relative to what that
- 1:47might mean for the insurance fund, et cetera, et cetera, because
- 1:50Chairman Todd Harper is the one who usually drives those points home.
- 1:53And since he wasn't there, it was led by Vice Chair Kyle Hauptman and board member
- 1:59at large, Tanya Otska, and they agreed.
- 2:02Didn't go into the level of detail that Todd typically does, but the stats are the
- 2:08stats and the deterioration is as follows.
- 2:13It's in large credit unions, typically, basically, if you look at their charts,
- 2:18they show that the total number of credit unions that are in Code 3 and Code 4.
- 2:24In totality basically hasn't changed much, but it's the big credit
- 2:29unions that are getting downgraded and the code threes over 500
- 2:37million went up by 15 billion this.
- 2:42Last quarter.
- 2:43And I want to say that's about the ninth or 10th quarter in a row
- 2:47that the number has gotten worse.
- 2:49Another way that they splice and dice it.
- 2:51And again, the only place that they make public data available is in
- 2:56the aggregate and it is quarterly at these quarterly budget briefings.
- 3:01Now, last time they met, they talked about how camel code 3 of insured
- 3:07shares had tripled In 2023, that number went up again and is now at 8.
- 3:1461 percent of total shares are in code three credit unions and from the
- 3:21low point that they're showing from your end data, the low point was 2.
- 3:2633 percent in December of 2021, which is an increase of about what?
- 3:31I want to say 370%.
- 3:33The numbers keep going the wrong way.
- 3:35I believe they will continue to go the other direction based on my conversations
- 3:39I'm having with credit unions.
- 3:40NCOA is very aggressive.
- 3:43Now, earlier I said that the total number of credit unions is about the same.
- 3:49What I'm seeing is that small credit unions have been treated a little
- 3:53rougher on camel and defining small as basically anything under 500 million.
- 3:58There are more of those but that number has been constant through all this.
- 4:01What we're really seeing is that the larger credit unions NCOA is prescribing
- 4:06to the don't let any good crisis go to waste and they are finding some issues.
- 4:13Reacting over overreacting or one of those two things to what they're seeing
- 4:19in credit unions looking back and then looking forward on some of the books
- 4:22of business that they're running into.
- 4:24But they are being very aggressive on camel codes, very aggressive on
- 4:28document resolutions, very aggressive on examiner findings, and some letter
- 4:33of understandings that we've been seeing in our conversations that are broader
- 4:39than what they would normally be.
- 4:41I'll just put it at that.
- 4:42Usually and we're going to have some discussions on this.
- 4:44Usually letters of understandings are more of a rifle approach
- 4:49than a shotgun approach.
- 4:50But I think the massive turnover and staff at NCUA has led them to maybe
- 4:58lose their way a little bit on, on how.
- 5:02Credit unions pivot from documented resolutions to letter
- 5:05of understandings and agreement.
- 5:06But again, there'll be more coming out on that in detail down the road.
- 5:10But why do I think that this number will continue to get worse?
- 5:14So I went back and historically was looking at wanted to go back
- 5:19to the great recession, which again as a reminder was in 2008 and 2009.
- 5:25In 2008 and 2009, the shares that were in code threes were at 11,
- 5:32just over 11%, and close to 14%.
- 5:36So 2008, 11%, 2009, close to 14%.
- 5:41The recession was over in 2010, but it peaked there at 18.26%.
- 5:48In 2011 the first quarter, it went down from the 18 to six to the, to 18,
- 5:55even in January to just under 17 in February and to 17 and a half in March.
- 6:00So that's still double of where it's at right now.
- 6:03So that's the context of why I think it will continue to get worse.
- 6:09There are delinquency trends that show that I think losses will or lesser income
- 6:16will be out there during this period.
- 6:18And I think because of that, we're going to see throughout the remainder
- 6:21of this year and probably into 2025 and being aggressive on camel codes.
- 6:29And when they're aggressive on camel codes, that leads to
- 6:31longer reports that leads them to coming to see you twice a year.
- 6:34If you're a code 3 instead.
- 6:36Instead of once a year or less, if you're a code one or a code two.
- 6:40And again, they are reacting in some instances they are overreacting.
- 6:45That's just my opinion, but it's going to get worse before it gets better.
- 6:51And my prediction is this will continue it until let's just say
- 6:56another year, probably the rest of this year, maybe half of next year.
- 7:01And then of course, there's the election that comes up at the end of the year.
- 7:04And what that may mean for NCUA's board, which is probably nothing because of
- 7:09other than a change of chairman, if the president's changed, because the
- 7:12terms are pretty long right now for the two Democratic board members.
- 7:16So if Biden's reelected and its status quo, if Trump or somebody else is elected
- 7:22the the Republic wouldn't become a chair and they can control the agenda,
- 7:27but they still wouldn't have the votes, which was the position Todd Harper
- 7:30chairman, Todd Harper found himself in at the beginning of his chairmanship.
- 7:34So a couple other things vice chairman vice chairman Helpman spoke at the
- 7:39board meeting about share overdrafts and what he views as NCOAs overreach
- 7:44on the Data gathering and the fact that is going to negatively impact mergers,
- 7:50negatively impact small credit unions, negatively impact the underserved.
- 7:55Crystal clear that the board is divided on political political sides here with
- 8:00the Republicans thinking it's overreach and the Democrats full steam ahead on
- 8:05any fee is a junk fee, in my opinion.
- 8:07Now, as somebody pointed out to me.
- 8:10Chairman Todd Harper has not specifically used the words junk fee,
- 8:14although he's been very aggressive.
- 8:16And I've documented that in my past podcasts on measuring this data,
- 8:22pointing it out, following the lead of the Biden administration, following the
- 8:26lead of the CFPB and attacking fees to the point of calling a concentration
- 8:31of fee income, a concentration risk.
- 8:34So expect that Pressure to continue and it'll be interesting
- 8:38to see what happens in the budget later this year in that regard.
- 8:42Now, in regards to board meetings, so Chairman Todd Harper missed the last
- 8:49board meeting because of his back surgery and they've canceled June.
- 8:54So they canceled March.
- 8:55They canceled June.
- 8:57There's no meeting in August.
- 8:59They're going to be building up towards a budget.
- 9:01Todd's chairman Harper's first budget having a second democratic vote.
- 9:06So hopefully if all, if he heals up they'll have board meetings.
- 9:12In September, October, November, December, they'll have a budget briefing.
- 9:17They'll have a budget.
- 9:17They'll have an annual plan, perhaps a change to their strategic plan.
- 9:21Now that they've got the votes to Change that in the way that they would like.
- 9:26Although I predicted once before that I think NCUA will be going
- 9:31to a quarterly board meeting.
- 9:33And that's how FDIC does it.
- 9:35And the fact that they've canceled it twice this year, I think they're
- 9:39getting the public used to it.
- 9:41And they canceled March.
- 9:44They canceled June.
- 9:45That's the third and sixth month.
- 9:47If you'd roll that forward, that would be they wouldn't have
- 9:51one in September and December.
- 9:52I don't think that will work with that rhythm because of the
- 9:55challenges of getting the budget done at the end of the year.
- 9:58So I'm not exactly sure what they're year.
- 10:01Their timelines might be for if they were to go to a quarterly board
- 10:07meeting, but here's what I'll predict.
- 10:09If they do that, they'll have one in April, they'll have one in July where
- 10:12they can talk about where they're at budget wise at mid year, they'll
- 10:16have one in October where they'll have their budget briefing, and
- 10:19then they'll have one in December.
- 10:21So my prediction, 2025, NCUA goes to a quarterly board meeting,
- 10:26one in April, one in July, one in October, and one in December.
- 10:30All right that's all I've got for you today.
- 10:32I appreciate you listening.
- 10:33We've got a lot of exciting topics coming up that my team and I will be
- 10:37recording starting later this week on document resolutions, letter of
- 10:42understanding, cease and desist.
- 10:45Corporate governance, you name it.
- 10:47The hot topics that we're seeing in our conversations or hearing in our
- 10:51conversations with credit unions, we're going to be hitting them
- 10:54here over the remainder of 2024.
- 10:57As always, I want to thank you for listening.
- 10:59I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 11:01Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 11:09Speaker 2: Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors,
- 11:13subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 11:17experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 11:22If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 11:25out our services at marktreichel.
- 11:27com.