Latest / SleepWise: Learn Softly, Sleep Deeply / What Is a Black Hole? A Calm Bedtime Story to Fall Asleep To | SleepWise
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening and welcome back to sleep.
- 0:03Wise to night. We drift towards some of the
- 0:07strangest and most quietly astonishing objects in the known
- 0:12universe, places where gravity has gathered itself so
- 0:17completely that even Light, the swiftest traveller we know,
- 0:22leans inward and stays, places The old imagination called
- 0:28impossible that early scientists doubted could ever be real, and
- 0:34that modern instruments have only recently begun to glimpse
- 0:39faintly against the glow of distant skies to night.
- 0:45We drift toward black holes. The phrase itself carries a
- 0:50certain weight for many people. It conjures images of cosmic
- 0:55monsters, of ravenous voids of danger lurking somewhere in the
- 1:00dark between stars. But the truth, as so often in
- 1:06nature, is gentler and more interesting than the legend.
- 1:11Black holes are not holes punched through the fabric of
- 1:15reality, nor drains, pulling the universe down into nothingness.
- 1:21They are, in the quiet language of physics, regions where the
- 1:26geometry of space and time has folded so deeply that no path
- 1:32leads back outward. They are not absences, They are
- 1:37extremes. They are what happens when one
- 1:42of the simplest forces in the universe, the patient pull of
- 1:46gravity, is allowed to follow its own logic to the very end.
- 1:52And so tonight, we will set aside the theatrics.
- 1:57We will not hurry through equations or cling to
- 2:01frightening images. Instead, we will move slowly,
- 2:07the way one moves through an unfamiliar room in the dark,
- 2:11letting the eyes adjust, letting the shapes reveal themselves at
- 2:17their own pace. There is no need to understand
- 2:21everything at once. There is no need to remember
- 2:25each name or number. The story will carry us, and the
- 2:31night will hold us as it does to approach a black hole gently.
- 2:38It helps to begin far from one. It helps to begin with the sky
- 2:44as humans once knew it, long before telescopes and equations,
- 2:50when the heavens were a quiet ceiling of light and the stars
- 2:55seemed pinned in place. From that older world, we will
- 3:00follow a patient thread through whispered ideas in the 18th
- 3:06century, through Einstein's reimagining of gravity, through
- 3:11decades of doubt and discovery, all the way to the first faint
- 3:17image of a shadow cast against distant fire.
- 3:22Along the way, we will meet event horizons and
- 3:26singularities, spinning geometries and silent giants at
- 3:32the centers of galaxies. We will think briefly about what
- 3:36happens to time near such places, and how light behaves
- 3:41when geometry itself begins to lean.
- 3:44And we will end, as all sleep Wise journeys do, somewhere
- 3:50closer to home, somewhere softer and more familiar than where we
- 3:57began. If these quiet stories help you
- 4:01rest, you can follow Sleep Wise and share it with someone who
- 4:06might enjoy drifting off while learning something new.
- 4:12And now, with the night around us and the stars patient
- 4:17overhead, let us begin. For most of human history, the
- 4:24sky was a place of quiet certainty.
- 4:28The sun rose and set with great regularity, the moon passed
- 4:34through its familiar phases, the stars wheeled overhead and
- 4:38patterns so dependable that travellers could find their way
- 4:43by them and farmers could measure the year by their slow
- 4:47procession. Whatever the heavens were, they
- 4:51seemed to be governed by a kind of patient order.
- 4:56In 1687, that order found a precise voice.
- 5:02In a long Latin work titled Philosophii Naturalis Principia
- 5:07Mathematica. Isaac Newton set down three laws
- 5:11of motion and a single sweeping law of gravitation.
- 5:17Everybody in the universe, he wrote, attracts every other body
- 5:21with a force proportional to the product of their masses and
- 5:26inversely proportional to the square of the distance between
- 5:30them. Double the distance and the pull
- 5:34becomes four times weaker. It was a simple rule written in
- 5:40the cool language of mathematics, and it described an
- 5:45astonishing range of things at once.
- 5:49The same rule that explained why an apple falls from a tree also
- 5:53explained why the moon does not. The moon is, in a sense, falling
- 6:00toward Earth all the time. It simply moves sideways quickly
- 6:05enough that it keeps missing. The same rule explained the
- 6:10tides, which rise and fall as the moon and sun pull gently on
- 6:15the oceans. It explained the slow, looping
- 6:19return of comets, including the one the astronomer Edmund Halley
- 6:26used Newton's equations to predict, correctly forecasting
- 6:30its return in 175816 years after his own death.
- 6:38Newton's framework rested on 2 quiet assumptions, so deeply
- 6:44held that they were rarely questioned.
- 6:48The first was that space existed as a kind of fixed and absolute
- 6:53container, the same for everyone, everywhere.
- 6:58The second was that time flowed evenly throughout the universe
- 7:03like a single great river. A second on Earth was a second
- 7:08on Mars, on the Moon, in the depths of empty space.
- 7:15Within this framework, gravity was strong where mass was great
- 7:21and where distance was small. Light was treated as something
- 7:26else entirely, a swift and luminous traveller whose nature
- 7:32was still being debated, but which was not generally thought
- 7:36to feel gravity in any noticeable way.
- 7:40Stars shone, planets moved, and the stage of space and time was
- 7:47assumed to remain perfectly still beneath them.
- 7:51Newton himself was uneasy about one part of his own picture.
- 7:55How could one body act upon another across vast empty
- 7:59distances with no visible thread between them?
- 8:04In his private writings he confessed that this puzzled him
- 8:08deeply. But the equations worked so
- 8:11well, predicting eclipses, orbits and tides to remarkable
- 8:17precision, that the deeper question was set aside.
- 8:22For nearly two centuries the universe seemed to behave like
- 8:27an exquisitely well made clock. And in such a universe, the idea
- 8:33of a star whose own light could not escape would have to wait
- 8:38for someone willing to follow Newton's logic into stranger
- 8:42territory. In the late 18th century, in a
- 8:47quiet rectory in the village of Thornhill in Yorkshire, an
- 8:51English clergyman and natural philosopher named John Michel
- 8:56sat down to think carefully about gravity and light.
- 9:01Michelle was unusual. He had been a professor of
- 9:07geology at Cambridge before settling into parish life, and
- 9:11he was the first person to suggest that earthquakes
- 9:16travelled as waves through the earth.
- 9:19He also designed the apparatus later used by Henry Cavendish to
- 9:23weigh the world. Michelle was, in short, a man
- 9:28comfortable with strange ideas. In November 1783, he sent a
- 9:34letter to the Royal Society in London, addressed to Cavendish
- 9:39himself, in which he asked a quietly daring question.
- 9:44Newton had taught that an object thrown upward from the Earth
- 9:49must reach a certain speed, the escape velocity, in order to
- 9:54leave the planet entirely. For Earth, that speed is about
- 9:5911 kilometers per second. For larger and denser bodies,
- 10:05the required speed is greater. Michelle wondered what would
- 10:10happen if a star was so massive that its escape velocity
- 10:15exceeded the speed of light itself.
- 10:18He worked the numbers using Newton's framework alone.
- 10:23He calculated that a body with the same average density as the
- 10:28Sun, but with a diameter 500 times larger, would have an
- 10:34escape velocity greater than the speed of light.
- 10:39Such a star, he reasoned, would still pull on its surroundings,
- 10:44but its own light would never quite leave its surface.
- 10:49From a great distance, it would appear entirely dark.
- 10:54Michelle called these hypothetical objects dark stars,
- 10:59and he even proposed how astronomers might detect them by
- 11:04watching how their gravity disturbed the motion of any
- 11:08visible companion stars in orbit around them.
- 11:12A few years later, in 1796, the French mathematician Pierre
- 11:19Simon Laplace arrived at a similar conclusion through his
- 11:24own calculations. Laplace was one of the great
- 11:29minds of his era, a careful and confident thinker who had
- 11:34reformulated much of celestial mechanics.
- 11:38He included the idea of an invisible gravitational body in
- 11:44the first two editions of his book Exposition de sistem de
- 11:49Monde, suggesting that the largest bodies in the universe
- 11:54might be dark for precisely this reason.
- 11:58By the 3rd edition, however, he quietly removed the passage,
- 12:03perhaps uncertain about how seriously to take such a strange
- 12:08suggestion in a work meant for a wide audience.
- 12:14For more than a century, the dark stars of Michelle and
- 12:17Laplace remained a curiosity, a footnote in the margins of
- 12:23natural philosophy. The instruments of the time
- 12:27could not test the idea. Light was not yet fully
- 12:32understood as a wave or a particle, and the very notion of
- 12:37a star whose light could not escape sat somewhere between
- 12:42mathematics and dream. But it had been spoken aloud,
- 12:48the thread had been laid down, and nature, as she so often
- 12:54does, was patient. She would wait until the
- 12:58language of gravity itself was rewritten before that thread was
- 13:03picked up again. A century passed before the dark
- 13:08stars of Michel and Laplace returned, transformed almost
- 13:13beyond recognition. The change came not from new
- 13:17telescopes, but from a new way of thinking about gravity.
- 13:22Altogether, in 19 O 7, while working as a patent clerk in
- 13:27Baron Albert Einstein had what he later called the happiest
- 13:33thought of his life. He realized that a person
- 13:37falling freely from a roof would not feel their own weight.
- 13:43Gravity, and the absence of gravity in that moment would be
- 13:48locally indistinguishable. From this small insight grew the
- 13:53equivalence principle, and from the equivalence principle, over
- 13:58the next eight years came general relativity.
- 14:03Einstein worked on the theory slowly and with great
- 14:07difficulty. He needed a mathematics.
- 14:10He had not yet learned the geometry of curved spaces
- 14:14developed in the 19th century by Bernhard Riemann.
- 14:19With help from the mathematician Marcel Grossman, he eventually
- 14:25found his way through In November 1915, he presented the
- 14:30field equations of general relativity to the Prussian
- 14:34Academy of Sciences in Berlin. They were 10 interlocking
- 14:39equations describing how matter and energy shape the geometry of
- 14:45space-time and how that geometry in turn guides the motion of
- 14:50matter and energy. The physicist John Wheeler later
- 14:56summarized the idea in a single sentence.
- 15:00Mass tells space-time how to curve, and curved space-time
- 15:06tells mass how to move. In Einstein's account, a massive
- 15:12body does not reach across empty space to tug on its neighbors.
- 15:19Instead, it gently shapes the geometry around it, and other
- 15:24objects follow the natural paths available within that shaped
- 15:29geometry. A planet orbiting the sun is not
- 15:34being pulled by an invisible string.
- 15:38It is following the straightest path it can find through the
- 15:42gentle valley the sun has carved into space-time.
- 15:47Even light obeys this geometry because there is no perfectly
- 15:53straight line for it to follow. Einstein's theory made
- 15:58predictions that could be tested.
- 16:02It explained a small drift in the orbit of Mercury that had
- 16:06puzzled astronomers since the 1850s.
- 16:11Mercury's elliptical path slowly rotated by about 43 arc seconds
- 16:17per century, more than Newton's equations could account for.
- 16:22Einstein's equations gave that exact extra amount naturally,
- 16:28with no adjustment. The theory also predicted that
- 16:31light passing close to the sun would be deflected by about 1.75
- 16:38arcseconds, twice what a simple Newtonian calculation suggested.
- 16:44In May 1919, an expedition led by the British astronomer Arthur
- 16:50Eddington travelled to the island of Principe, off the
- 16:55coast of West Africa, to photograph stars near the sun
- 17:01during a total solar eclipse. The measured deflection matched
- 17:06Einstein's prediction. The news made him famous
- 17:10overnight. And once gravity was understood
- 17:14as curvature, an old question could be asked again with new
- 17:19tools. What happens when curvature
- 17:23becomes severe? The answer would arrive sooner
- 17:27than anyone expected from the unlikeliest of places.
- 17:31Karl Schwarzschild was a German astronomer and physicist of
- 17:37remarkable gifts. By the time the First World War
- 17:42began, he had already directed an important observatory and
- 17:47contributed to several branches of his science.
- 17:51He was respected, productive, and deeply curious.
- 17:57When the war came, he could easily have remained at home,
- 18:01but he chose instead to join the German army, and by 1915 he was
- 18:07serving on the Eastern Front, where he calculated artillery
- 18:13trajectories and endured the cold and hardship of the field.
- 18:18It was there, in those difficult conditions, that Schwarzschild
- 18:23read Einstein's newly published equations of general relativity.
- 18:30They were dense and complex, and Einstein himself had not yet
- 18:35found exact solutions to them. Most physicists assume that
- 18:41exact solutions might be a long time coming.
- 18:46But Schwarzschild, working with paper and pencil between his
- 18:50military duties, found one. Within a few weeks of seeing
- 18:55Einstein's paper, he had solved the equations for the simplest
- 19:00possible case, the gravitational field outside a single perfectly
- 19:08spherical, non rotating mass. He sent his work to Einstein,
- 19:15who was startled and delighted. Einstein presented
- 19:20Schwarzschild's solution to the Prussian Academy of Sciences in
- 19:24early 1916. It was the very first exact
- 19:29solution to the field equations of general relativity, and it
- 19:34described the geometry of space-time around any spherical
- 19:38body, from a planet to a * for everyday distances and ordinary
- 19:45masses. It agreed beautifully with what
- 19:49was already known. It explained the motion of
- 19:53planets, the bending of light near the sun, and the small
- 19:57drift in Mercury's orbit that had puzzled astronomers for
- 20:03decades. But hidden inside
- 20:06Schwarzschild's solution was something else, something
- 20:10stranger. The mathematics contained a
- 20:14particular distance from the center of the mass, a radius at
- 20:18which the equations seemed to misbehave.
- 20:23At this radius, certain quantities grew without limit,
- 20:28as if the geometry itself were folding into something the
- 20:31formulas could not easily handle.
- 20:35We now call this the Schwarzschild radius, and the
- 20:40surface it defines is the event horizon of a black hole.
- 20:46For a body the size of the Sun, this radius would be only a few
- 20:50kilometers across. For Earth, it would be smaller
- 20:55than a marble. To reach it, ordinary matter
- 20:59would have to be compressed to almost unimaginable density.
- 21:05At the time, no one quite knew what to make of this strange
- 21:09feature. Schwarzschild himself did not
- 21:13live long enough to explore it fully.
- 21:16He fell I'll on the front and died in May 1916, only a few
- 21:23months after sending his solution to Einstein.
- 21:28He was 42. He left behind a quiet, lasting
- 21:34gift, a piece of mathematics that would decades later become
- 21:41the doorway through which physics finally walked into the
- 21:45country of black holes. When Schwarzschild's solution
- 21:49first appeared in 1916, most physicists treated the strange
- 21:55radius at its heart as a mathematical curiosity rather
- 22:00than a physical reality. The equations misbehaved there,
- 22:06but surely people thought, no actual object in the universe
- 22:12would ever be compressed tightly enough for it to matter.
- 22:17A star like the Sun would need to be squeezed inside a sphere
- 22:23only about 3 kilometers across for its Schwarzschild radius to
- 22:28reach its surface. The Earth would need to be
- 22:32crushed to the size of a peanut. Such densities seemed
- 22:38impossible, the kind of thing equations could describe but
- 22:43nature would never permit. Einstein himself shared this
- 22:49doubt. In 1939, more than two decades
- 22:54after Schwarzschild's work, he published a paper arguing that a
- 22:59true gravitational collapse to such a point could not actually
- 23:05occur in nature. He believed some other effect,
- 23:10some unknown physical process, would always intervene to
- 23:15prevent matter from crossing that threshold.
- 23:18He was, in this instance, mistaken, but his reluctance was
- 23:25understandable. Nothing.
- 23:28An ordinary experience prepared the human imagination for a
- 23:32region of space from which not even light could return, and
- 23:37Einstein was cautious about pushing his own theory past the
- 23:42point where its predictions could be tested.
- 23:47The mathematician and astronomer Arthur Eddington, who had
- 23:52confirmed Einstein's light bending prediction in 1919, was
- 23:57another skeptic. In 1935, he famously clashed
- 24:02with a young Indian physicist named Subramanyam Chandra
- 24:07Sarkar, who had calculated that sufficiently massive stars at
- 24:12the end of their lives could not hold themselves up against their
- 24:17own gravity and would collapse without limit.
- 24:21Eddington could not accept this. There should be, he insisted, a
- 24:27law of nature to prevent a star from behaving in so absurd A
- 24:31manner. The confrontation was painful
- 24:35for Chandrasekar, who was young and relatively unknown, and it
- 24:41delayed the full acceptance of his ideas by years.
- 24:46What seems strange now is how slowly the community moved
- 24:51toward what the mathematics had been quietly saying.
- 24:55The term black hole itself did not appear in common use until
- 25:01the late 1960s, when the American physicist John Wheeler
- 25:07popularized it during a lecture in New York in 1967.
- 25:12Before then, such objects were often called frozen stars or
- 25:18collapsed stars, or simply referred to by the unwieldy
- 25:23phrase Schwarzschild singularity.
- 25:27The new name was short, memorable, and a little
- 25:31haunting. It helped the idea settle into
- 25:34the public imagination. But acceptance was not merely a
- 25:39matter of language. It took decades of patient
- 25:43theoretical work and eventually observational evidence before
- 25:49most physicists agreed that the universe really did contain such
- 25:54objects. The resistance was not foolish.
- 25:59It was the careful hesitation of people who had been trained to
- 26:04trust their intuitions about what nature would and would not
- 26:09allow. The universe, as it turned out,
- 26:13was more daring than they were. To understand why some stars
- 26:18have no choice but to collapse, it helps to remember what a star
- 26:24actually is. A star is a vast sphere of hot
- 26:29gas, held together by its own gravity and prevented from
- 26:34collapsing by the pressure generated in its core, where
- 26:38hydrogen atoms fuse into helium and release enormous energy.
- 26:44For most of a star's life, these two forces remain in gentle
- 26:50balance. Gravity pulls inward.
- 26:54Pressure pushes outward. The star glows steady and
- 27:01patient, for millions or billions of years.
- 27:05But the fuel does not last forever.
- 27:08When the hydrogen in the core is spent, the star begins to burn
- 27:13heavier elements, each stage shorter and more frantic than
- 27:18the last. Eventually, even these sources
- 27:22run out. Without the heat of fusion, the
- 27:26outward pressure falters and gravity begins to win.
- 27:31What happens next depends on how much mass the star began with.
- 27:37In 1930, the young Indian physicist Subrahmanyan
- 27:42Chandrasakhar was travelling by ship from Madras to England on
- 27:48his way to study at Cambridge. During the long voyage, he
- 27:52worked out a calculation that would later carry his name.
- 27:58He showed that a white dwarf, the dense remnant left behind by
- 28:04a moderate star, cannot exceed a mass of about 1.4 times the mass
- 28:11of the Sun. Above that limit, the quantum
- 28:14pressure that normally holds a white dwarf up becomes
- 28:19insufficient and the star must collapse further.
- 28:24This boundary is now called the Chandra Sekhar limit, and it
- 28:29marks the first quiet line beyond which ordinary stellar
- 28:34endings become impossible. For a while, it was thought that
- 28:40collapsed beyond a white dwarf would simply produce a neutron *
- 28:47an even denser object in which electrons and protons have
- 28:52merged into neutrons, packed so tightly that a single teaspoon
- 28:58of the material would weigh billions of tons.
- 29:02Neutron stars are real, discovered in 1967 as pulsars by
- 29:08the young astronomer Jocelyn Bell Burnell.
- 29:13But neutron stars also have a limit somewhere between two and
- 29:19three solar masses, beyond which no known pressure can hold them
- 29:24up. In 1939, the American physicist
- 29:29J Robert Oppenheimer and his student Heartland Snyder
- 29:35followed the mathematics further.
- 29:37They published a paper titled On Continued Gravitational
- 29:42Contraction in which they showed that a sufficiently massive
- 29:47collapsing star must, according to general relativity, fall
- 29:52inward indefinitely. Nothing in the equations stopped
- 29:58the contraction. The outer layers of the star
- 30:02would pass through their own Schwarzschild radius, and to a
- 30:07distant observer the collapse would appear to slow and freeze
- 30:12at that boundary, while from the star's own point of view, the
- 30:17inward fall would continue toward a central region of
- 30:22unimaginable density. Oppenheimer's paper was
- 30:26published on the same day that Germany invaded Poland, and it
- 30:31received little attention at the time, but it had quietly
- 30:36answered Einstein's doubt. Collapse was not forbidden.
- 30:41It was, for the heaviest stars, inevitable.
- 30:46Of all the strange features of a black hole, the event horizon
- 30:51may be the most often misunderstood.
- 30:55It is not a wall. It is not a surface you could
- 30:59touch or lean against. There is no shimmer in the
- 31:03vacuum, no sudden boundary visible to the eye.
- 31:07If you were to approach one in a spaceship carefully and from a
- 31:13safe distance, you would see no obvious marker at the edge.
- 31:19The horizon is something subtler than that.
- 31:23It is a boundary defined not by anything material, but by the
- 31:29shape of the paths that light and matter are able to follow.
- 31:34The word horizon is well chosen. On Earth.
- 31:39The horizon is not a place, it is the line beyond which you
- 31:43cannot see, determined by the curvature of the planet and the
- 31:48position of the observer. Walk forward and the horizon
- 31:52walks with you. The event horizon of a black
- 31:57hole is similar in spirit. It is the boundary beyond which
- 32:01no signal, no particle and no beam of light can ever reach an
- 32:07outside observer. Events that happen inside it are
- 32:12forever hidden from the universe beyond.
- 32:16Hence the name for a non rotating black hole.
- 32:21The event horizon sits at exactly the Schwarzschild radius
- 32:26Karl Schwarzschild had calculated in 1916.
- 32:30The formula is unexpectedly simple.
- 32:34The radius is proportional to the mass.
- 32:38A black hole with the mass of the Sun has an event horizon
- 32:43about 3 kilometers in radius. A black hole with the mass of
- 32:48Earth would have a horizon about 9mm across, roughly the size of
- 32:55a marble. And a supermassive black hole
- 32:59with 4 million solar masses like the one at the center of our
- 33:03Galaxy has a horizon roughly 17 times the radius of the sun.
- 33:10Still small on cosmic scales, but enormous compared to
- 33:16anything close to home. What makes the horizon strange
- 33:21is not its size, but its nature. In ordinary physics, any
- 33:26boundary can be crossed in either direction.
- 33:30You walk into a room, you walk out of it.
- 33:33A photon enters a window, a photon leaves.
- 33:37But the geometry of space-time near a black hole is arranged in
- 33:43such a way that once you cross the horizon, every direction you
- 33:49could possibly move leads inward toward the center.
- 33:54The outward directions simply do not exist anymore, not because
- 33:59something is pushing you, but because the geometry itself has
- 34:05tilted. It is a little like walking into
- 34:08a valley, so deep that every step you take from a certain
- 34:12point onward in any direction is a step further down.
- 34:18You have not done anything wrong, You have not been
- 34:22captured, You are simply following the shape of the land.
- 34:28The universe does not punish you for crossing a horizon, it only
- 34:33quietly rearranges the options available to you.
- 34:37And from the outside, no news of you can ever come back, because
- 34:43no light can climb out. The event Horizon in this sense
- 34:49is not a door, it is a direction.
- 34:52Imagine very gently that a distant observer has sent a
- 34:58small probe toward a large, isolated black hole.
- 35:02The probe is equipped with a simple clock and a light that
- 35:07flashes once every second. For the purposes of this story,
- 35:13we will ignore the violent conditions near a realistic
- 35:17black hole and simply follow what relativity says would
- 35:22happen to the light of the probe as it approaches the horizon.
- 35:27At first, everything looks ordinary.
- 35:31The probe moves inward, the clock ticks, the light flashes
- 35:36once per second, and each flash travels back to the distant
- 35:40observer at the speed of light. But as the probe draws closer to
- 35:46the event horizon, something strange begins to unfold.
- 35:51The observer far away sees the flashes arriving slightly slower
- 35:58than once per second, then slower still.
- 36:02The time between flashes grows longer and longer, as though the
- 36:09probe's clock were winding down. This is not an illusion produced
- 36:14by distance. It is a real effect, a
- 36:18consequence of what Einstein's equations say about time.
- 36:23In a strong gravitational field, clocks closer to a massive body
- 36:29tick more slowly than clocks farther away.
- 36:33This is called gravitational time dilation, and it has been
- 36:37measured in laboratories and with atomic clocks flown on
- 36:42aircraft. Near a black hole, the effect
- 36:46becomes dramatic. As the probe approaches the
- 36:50horizon, the distant observer sees its clock slow toward a
- 36:56crawl. The flash is becoming more and
- 36:59more widely spaced, the light of each flash growing redder as it
- 37:04climbs out of the deepening gravitational well.
- 37:07From outside, it looks as though the probe is slowly freezing at
- 37:12the edge. It never quite reaches the
- 37:15horizon. The image of the probe lingers
- 37:19there, fainter and fainter, its final flashes stretched out
- 37:25across eternity. Older physicists sometimes
- 37:29called such objects frozen stars for exactly this reason.
- 37:35To a patient watcher far away, the last moments of the fall
- 37:40seem to last forever. But from the probe's own point
- 37:44of view, nothing so dramatic happens.
- 37:48The clock on board continues to tick at its usual rate.
- 37:53The lights continue to flash once per second.
- 37:57The probe does not feel itself slowing down.
- 38:01It simply falls inward, crosses the event horizon without any
- 38:07particular fanfare, and continues its descent toward the
- 38:11center. Relativity does not grant one of
- 38:14these two perspectives the final word.
- 38:18Both are real, both are consistent.
- 38:22The difference lies entirely in the geometry of space.
- 38:26Time which has arranged matters so that time itself is not
- 38:31universal. There is something quietly
- 38:34moving in that near a black hole.
- 38:37The universe keeps two different accounts of a single journey,
- 38:41and neither is wrong. The traveller falls, the distant
- 38:47observer watches a figure grow still, and in between them
- 38:54stretches the patient geometry of a world in which time near
- 38:58great gravity is not one river but many.
- 39:03The slowing of clocks near a black hole is not a trick of
- 39:08imagination or a feature of science fiction.
- 39:13It is the same effect that physicists must account for
- 39:17every day in ordinary technology.
- 39:21The satellites of the Global Positioning System carry atomic
- 39:26clocks in orbit about 20,000 kilometers above Earth's
- 39:31surface. Because they are farther from
- 39:35Earth's mass than clocks on the ground, gravity is weaker where
- 39:40they fly, and their clocks tick slightly faster than ours, by
- 39:45about 45 microseconds per day. Special relativity adds a
- 39:51smaller correction in the opposite direction.
- 39:54Because the satellites are also moving swiftly, engineers must
- 40:00subtract 1 effect from the other every day, or the navigation
- 40:06system would drift by kilometers within hours.
- 40:10A difference of 45 microseconds per day is almost nothing in
- 40:14daily life, but it shows that gravitational time dilation is
- 40:20real measurable. And woven into the ordinary
- 40:25workings of the modern world near the surface of Earth, the
- 40:30effect is gentle. Near a neutron star it becomes
- 40:35significant. Near a black hole it becomes
- 40:41extraordinary. Just outside the event horizon
- 40:46of a non rotating black hole with the mass of the Sun, a
- 40:50clock would tick at roughly half the rate of a clock far away.
- 40:55Closer still, the slowdown becomes steeper as the horizon
- 41:01is approached. The ratio grows without limit,
- 41:05so that a single second on the infalling clock corresponds to
- 41:09longer and longer intervals outside.
- 41:13This is why light emitted from near the horizon reaches distant
- 41:18observers not only delayed but shifted toward the red end of
- 41:24the spectrum. Its waves have been stretched by
- 41:29the steepening gradient of time, itself a phenomenon known as
- 41:35gravitational redshift. This redshift has been measured
- 41:39in more modest circumstances with great precision.
- 41:44In 1959, 2 physicists at Harvard, Robert Pound and Glenn
- 41:50Rebka, sent gamma rays upward through a 22 meter tower and
- 41:57measured the tiny shift in their frequency as they climbed out of
- 42:02Earth's gravitational well. The shift was extraordinaire at
- 42:08the very heart of a non rotating black hole.
- 42:12The mathematics of general relativity points to a place
- 42:17called the singularity. It is perhaps the strangest
- 42:22feature in all of modern physics, and one of the most
- 42:27honestly humbling. The equations say that matter
- 42:31falling through the event horizon continues inward, and
- 42:36that the inward journey cannot be stopped by any force we
- 42:41currently know. Everything converges toward a
- 42:45central region where density grows without limit and the
- 42:50curvature of space-time becomes infinite.
- 42:55The word singularity is used because the equations themselves
- 43:01at that point cease to give finite answers.
- 43:06They do not calmly describe something strange.
- 43:10They stopped describing at all. For a long time, physicists were
- 43:17unsure whether singularities were a real feature of nature or
- 43:22an artifact of particular perfectly symmetric
- 43:26calculations. Perhaps they thought the
- 43:30infinities appeared only because Schwarzschild had assumed a
- 43:35perfectly spherical collapse. In the real universe, stars are
- 43:41never perfectly spherical. Perhaps imperfections would save
- 43:47the mathematics. This hope was gently closed off
- 43:51in 1965 when the British mathematician Roger Penrose
- 43:58published a short but powerful paper showing that singularities
- 44:04are not merely the result of special symmetries.
- 44:08Using the methods of what came to be called global geometry,
- 44:13Penrose proved that under very general conditions, once
- 44:18gravitational collapse has proceeded past a certain stage,
- 44:23a singularity of some kind must form.
- 44:27It was a theorem, not a guess. Nature, or at least general
- 44:33relativity, does not seem to offer an escape.
- 44:39For this work, along with related contributions, Penrose
- 44:44shared the Nobel Prize in Physics in Tuan Tuani.
- 44:49Stephen Hawking, then a young graduate student at Cambridge,
- 44:54quickly extended Penrose's methods and applied them to the
- 44:58universe as a whole. Together they proved a series of
- 45:03singularity theorems which suggested that under general
- 45:09relativity, singularities are not a rare accident.
- 45:14They are woven into the theory. And yet most physicists do not
- 45:21believe that true infinities really exist inside black holes.
- 45:27The appearance of a singularity is more often read as a warning.
- 45:34It is a sign that general relativity, beautiful and well
- 45:40tested as it is, is not the final word.
- 45:44At such extreme densities, the effects of quantum mechanics
- 45:49must become important, and general relativity and quantum
- 45:53mechanics have never been fully reconciled.
- 45:58The singularity, in this view, is not a thing, It is a
- 46:02question. It is the place where our
- 46:06current description of reality softly admits that it is
- 46:11incomplete. There is a kind of dignity in
- 46:15that admission. Science is not obliged to know
- 46:20everything. It is obliged to be honest about
- 46:24where its knowledge ends. And at the center of every black
- 46:29hole, written into the geometry itself, is that quiet
- 46:35confession. Schwarzschild's original
- 46:38solution described the simplest kind of black hole imaginable,
- 46:44one that was perfectly spherical and did not rotate.
- 46:50But real stars spin. They rotate on their axes for
- 46:56the same reason skaters rotate when they pull in their arms.
- 47:01As a massive star collapses, its rotation speeds up, often
- 47:07dramatically. A slowly turning star can become
- 47:11a rapidly spinning neutron star, and a truly massive collapse can
- 47:18leave behind a black hole that carries most of that original
- 47:22rotation with it. For nearly fifty years after
- 47:27Schwarzschild, the mathematics of such a rotating black hole
- 47:32remained unsolved. Einstein's field equations, so
- 47:38elegant in simple cases, became fiercely difficult when rotation
- 47:44was added. The breakthrough came in 1963
- 47:49from a New Zealand mathematician named Roy Kerr.
- 47:55Kerr was working at the University of Texas at Austin,
- 48:00and he was trying to find exact solutions to Einstein's
- 48:04equations that would describe the space-time around a spinning
- 48:10mass. After months of careful work, he
- 48:14found one Its structure was far more intricate than
- 48:18Schwarzschild's. It contained not one but two
- 48:23relevant surfaces, and it described a geometry in which
- 48:29the rotation of the central mass actually dragged the surrounding
- 48:34space-time along with it, like a slow Whirlpool pulling water
- 48:39around a drain. This effect is called frame
- 48:43dragging near a rotating black hole.
- 48:47Space-time itself is set gently in motion by the spin of the
- 48:52mass. An observer close enough would
- 48:56find that they could not remain still even in principle.
- 49:02To stand perfectly motionless relative to distant stars, they
- 49:06would have to move against the flow of space-time faster than
- 49:10light, which is impossible. Instead, they would be carried
- 49:16along, swept quietly around the black hole by the geometry
- 49:21itself. Outside the event horizon of a
- 49:24curb black hole lies a region called the ergosphere, from the
- 49:29Greek word for work. Inside this region, an object
- 49:35must rotate along with the black hole, but it can still escape to
- 49:40Infinity if it chooses. The ergosphere is one of the
- 49:45most remarkable features in relativity.
- 49:48In 1969, Roger Penrose showed that it is in principle possible
- 49:56to extract energy from a spinning black hole by sending
- 50:00an object into the ergosphere and splitting it, letting one
- 50:05piece fall in while the other escapes with more energy than
- 50:10was brought in. This process, now called the
- 50:14Penrose process, does not violate conservation laws.
- 50:20The energy comes from the rotation of the black hole
- 50:24itself, which gradually slows as energy is removed.
- 50:29Real black holes in the universe are almost certainly CUR black
- 50:34holes rather than Schwarzschild ones.
- 50:39Rotation is the rule, not the exception.
- 50:43The silent giants of the cosmos are, in their own hidden way,
- 50:49turning, and the very fabric of space-time turned softly with
- 50:55them. Black holes come in a surprising
- 50:58range of sizes, and astronomers today recognize several broad
- 51:03categories. The smallest kind we know of for
- 51:08certain are called stellar mass black holes.
- 51:12They form when a single massive star, roughly 20 times the mass
- 51:18of the sun or more, reaches the end of its fuel and collapses.
- 51:24What remains is a black hole, typically between about 3 and
- 51:29several dozen solar masses, compressed into a region only a
- 51:35few 10s of kilometers across. The Milky Way alone is thought
- 51:40to contain hundreds of millions of such objects, most of them
- 51:46invisible, drifting quietly between the stars.
- 51:50At the other end of the scale lie the supermassive black
- 51:54holes. These are enormous beyond
- 51:58ordinary comparison, with masses ranging from hundreds of
- 52:03thousands to billions of times that of the Sun.
- 52:08They sit at the centers of nearly every large Galaxy that
- 52:13has been carefully studied, including our own.
- 52:17The very largest known examples exceed 10 billion solar masses.
- 52:24Their event horizons can be larger than the entire solar
- 52:27system. How such giants grew so massive
- 52:32so early in the history of the universe remains one of the most
- 52:37interesting open questions in astrophysics, and several
- 52:42theories compete to explain it. Between these two extremes lies
- 52:49a more elusive third category called intermediate mass black
- 52:56holes. These would have masses between
- 53:01roughly 100 and 100,000 times that of the sun, and for many
- 53:06years they were mostly theoretical.
- 53:10In recent decades, observations have begun to reveal candidates
- 53:16for such objects, including some detected through the
- 53:21gravitational waves they produce.
- 53:24When they collide and merge, they may turn out to be the
- 53:28missing link that explains how small black holes grow into
- 53:33giant ones over cosmic time. There is also a speculative 4th
- 53:39category that has never been confirmed.
- 53:43In the 1970s, Stephen Hawking proposed that very small black
- 53:49holes might have formed in the first fractions of a second
- 53:54after the birth of the universe, when pressures were so extreme
- 53:59that even modest concentrations of matter could have collapsed.
- 54:04These are called primordial black holes.
- 54:09Some might have the mass of a mountain compressed into a
- 54:13region smaller than an atom. Whether any exist, and whether
- 54:19they could account for some of the unseen mass in the universe
- 54:23is still an open question. What unites this whole family is
- 54:29simpler than it first sounds. In general relativity, a black
- 54:35hole is fully described by only a few numbers, its mass, its
- 54:40rotation, and its electric charge.
- 54:44Everything else about the matter that formed it is forgotten at
- 54:49the horizon. This is sometimes called the No
- 54:52Hair Theorem, a name given by John Wheeler in a moment of
- 54:57gentle wit. A black hole, in this sense is
- 55:02nature at its most austere. Almost everything is set aside
- 55:08and only the essentials remain. At the center of our own Galaxy,
- 55:13about 26,000 light years from Earth, sits a very dark and very
- 55:19quiet object known as Sagittarius, a star.
- 55:26It is the supermassive black hole at the heart of the Milky
- 55:30Way, and its existence was established not by seeing it,
- 55:34which for many years was impossible, but by watching what
- 55:40happened to the things nearby. Beginning in the early 1990s,
- 55:46two groups of astronomers, one led by Reinhard Genzel in
- 55:51Germany and the other by Andrea Gaez in the United States, began
- 55:57a patient, long term study of the central region of our
- 56:02Galaxy. Using infrared telescopes that
- 56:06could peer through the thick dust of the galactic disk, they
- 56:10tracked the positions of stars very close to the galactic
- 56:14center. Over years and then decades,
- 56:19they watched these stars move. What they saw was extraordinary.
- 56:25The stars were tracing tight, elliptical orbits around
- 56:29something they could not see. One of them, called S2, was
- 56:35eventually found to complete a full orbit in just 16 years,
- 56:42whipping past the central object at velocities of thousands of
- 56:47kilometers per second. From the shapes and speeds of
- 56:51these orbits, the mass of the unseen central object could be
- 56:57calculated with growing precision.
- 57:00The ants are settled near 4,000,000 times the mass of the
- 57:04Sun, all packed into a region no larger than the orbit of
- 57:10Mercury. Nothing known to physics could
- 57:14account for such a mass so tightly confined, except a
- 57:19supermassive black hole. In 2020, Genzel and Gez shared
- 57:27the Nobel Prize in Physics for this work, along with Roger
- 57:32Penrose. There is something tender about
- 57:35this discovery. For decades, astronomers watched
- 57:40the silent choreography of stars at the galactic centre and
- 57:45quietly inferred the shape of something darker.
- 57:49At its heart, the black hole did not announce itself.
- 57:54It left only a signature written in the paths of its neighbors.
- 58:02By reading that signature carefully, patient observers
- 58:07slowly pieced together a picture of an object that refused to be
- 58:14seen directly. Sagittarius, a star, is, by the
- 58:18standards of supermassive black holes, rather modest.
- 58:24Some galaxies host central black holes, 1000 times more massive.
- 58:30It is also relatively calm at the moment, consuming only small
- 58:35amounts of matter and emitting little light compared with the
- 58:40brilliant active nuclei of other galaxies.
- 58:44Our own galactic center is not a place of cosmic violence.
- 58:50It is a place of quiet gravity, where one of the most extreme
- 58:55objects in physics sits in the dark, holding its cord of stars.
- 59:02Every night when we look toward the constellation Sagittarius in
- 59:08a dark sky, we are looking, without quite realizing it,
- 59:14toward that hidden heart and toward the stars that have been
- 59:18teaching us for years what must live there.
- 59:23There is a quiet paradox in the study of black holes.
- 59:28The darkest objects in the universe are often found at the
- 59:32centers of the brightest things in the sky.
- 59:36This is not a contradiction, but a consequence of how matter
- 59:41behaves when it falls into a deep gravitational well.
- 59:46When gas, dust, or even the torn remains of a star drift too
- 59:51close to a black hole, they do not simply fall straight in.
- 59:58Almost always, the in falling material carries some sideways
- 1:00:02motion, and as gravity draws it inward, it begins to spiral.
- 1:00:09Over time, the material settles into a flattened rotating disk
- 1:00:15called an accretion disk, in which particles orbit the black
- 1:00:20hole at enormous speeds. Friction between layers of the
- 1:00:26disk transfers angular momentum outward, allowing matter to
- 1:00:31gradually drift inward toward the event horizon.
- 1:00:36As it does so, it is squeezed and heated to extraordinary
- 1:00:42temperatures. The temperatures reached in the
- 1:00:45innermost parts of an accretion disk can be millions of degrees.
- 1:00:51At such heat, the gas radiates fiercely, producing not only
- 1:00:56visible light but X-rays and ultraviolet radiation that can
- 1:01:03outshine the stars of an entire Galaxy.
- 1:01:07The first strong evidence for stellar mass black holes came
- 1:01:12from precisely this kind of glow.
- 1:01:16In 1964, astronomers detected a powerful X-ray source in the
- 1:01:22constellation Cygnus, which they named Cygnus X1.
- 1:01:30Careful observation showed it to be a binary system in which a
- 1:01:35normal supergiant star was apparently losing matter to an
- 1:01:40unseen companion about 15 times the mass of the Sun.
- 1:01:47The companion was too massive to be a neutron star and too
- 1:01:51compact to be anything else. It was almost certainly a black
- 1:01:56hole, and it became the first widely accepted observational
- 1:02:02case. At the largest scales,
- 1:02:06supermassive black holes at the centers of some galaxies devour
- 1:02:12matter so efficiently that their accretion disks become the most
- 1:02:18luminous sustained sources in the universe.
- 1:02:24These are called active galactic nuclei, and their brightest
- 1:02:29versions are known as quasars. A single quasar can shine with
- 1:02:34the light of a trillion Suns, yet its light comes from a
- 1:02:39region no larger than our solar system.
- 1:02:43For a long time, quasars seemed impossible.
- 1:02:48Now they are understood as the glow of matter falling into
- 1:02:53supermassive black holes in the distant, younger universe.
- 1:02:58In some cases, a black hole also launches narrow jets of matter
- 1:03:04and radiation, shooting outward at nearly the speed of light,
- 1:03:10stretching across 10s of thousands of light years.
- 1:03:15How exactly these jets are focused and accelerated is still
- 1:03:19being studied, but the outline of the story is now clear.
- 1:03:25Black holes are not simply dark. They are often surrounded by
- 1:03:30some of the brightest, hottest, most restless places in the
- 1:03:34cosmos. And much of that fire is the
- 1:03:38long, slow descent of matter reaching the final edge.
- 1:03:44For a long time, black holes seemed to be the most final
- 1:03:48objects in the universe. Matter and light could fall in.
- 1:03:53Nothing could ever come out. The event horizon was a one way
- 1:03:59boundary, absolute and uncompromising, and whatever
- 1:04:04crossed it was assumed to be lost to the rest of the cosmos
- 1:04:09forever. Then, in the early 1970s, a
- 1:04:14young physicist at Cambridge began to think more carefully
- 1:04:19about what happens very close to the horizon, and the picture
- 1:04:25gently shifted. Stephen Hawking had been working
- 1:04:29on problems in general relativity for years, including
- 1:04:33the singularity theorems he had developed with Roger Penrose.
- 1:04:37But in 1974 he published a short startling paper with the
- 1:04:44deceptively simple title Black Hole Explosions.
- 1:04:49In it, he argued that black holes are not perfectly black
- 1:04:53after all. When the rules of quantum
- 1:04:56mechanics are applied to the empty space just outside an
- 1:05:00event horizon, the result is that black holes should slowly
- 1:05:05emit A faint thermal glow of particles and radiation.
- 1:05:10The effect is now called Hawking radiation, and it came as a
- 1:05:15genuine surprise even to Hawking himself.
- 1:05:20The underlying idea is subtle. In quantum physics, the vacuum
- 1:05:27of empty space is not truly empty.
- 1:05:30Tiny fluctuations constantly produce pairs of particles that
- 1:05:35briefly appear and then annihilate one another.
- 1:05:39Near the horizon of a black hole, Hawking showed the
- 1:05:44geometry of space-time can separate such pairs before they
- 1:05:49have time to vanish. 1 member of the pair falls inward while the
- 1:05:55other escapes outward, carrying a small amount of energy with
- 1:05:59it. From far away, it looks as
- 1:06:03though the black hole is quietly radiating, and because that
- 1:06:09radiation carries energy, the black hole must slowly lose mass
- 1:06:15over time. The effect is extraordinarily
- 1:06:18small for any ordinary black hole.
- 1:06:22A stellar mass black hole emits Hawking radiation at a
- 1:06:27temperature of less than one millionth of a degree above
- 1:06:31absolute 0, far colder than the cosmic background radiation that
- 1:06:37already bathes it. In practice, such a black hole
- 1:06:43is not shrinking at all, it is steadily gaining mass from its
- 1:06:48surroundings. Only very small black holes
- 1:06:51would radiate quickly enough to evaporate within the age of the
- 1:06:55universe. For a primordial black hole of
- 1:06:59the right initial mass, the final stages of evaporation
- 1:07:04would release a bright burst of energy, a kind of quiet flash at
- 1:07:10the end of a very long life. Hawking's result has never been
- 1:07:15directly observed, since the glow is too faint to detect near
- 1:07:20any known black hole. But it is considered one of the
- 1:07:25most important theoretical discoveries in modern physics
- 1:07:30because it is one of the few places where general relativity
- 1:07:35and quantum mechanics clearly meet.
- 1:07:38Black holes, it seems, are not the final word after all.
- 1:07:44They too can very slowly give something back to the universe
- 1:07:50that made them. Einstein had predicted as early
- 1:07:54as 1916 that violent motions of massive objects should send
- 1:08:00ripples outward through the fabric of space-time itself.
- 1:08:05He called these gravitational waves.
- 1:08:10Unlike the ripples on a pond, they would not move through
- 1:08:14space. They would be ripples in space,
- 1:08:17gentle stretchings and compressions of distance
- 1:08:20travelling outward at the speed of light.
- 1:08:24For decades, even Einstein wondered whether they could ever
- 1:08:29be detected, or whether they were so faint as to remain
- 1:08:33forever beyond reach. The challenge is hard to
- 1:08:38overstate. A typical gravitational wave
- 1:08:42passing through Earth changes distances by an amount smaller
- 1:08:46than 110 thousandth the width of a proton.
- 1:08:50To measure something so small, scientists built extraordinarily
- 1:08:56sensitive instruments called laser interferometers.
- 1:09:01The Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory,
- 1:09:06known as LIGO, consists of two facilities, one in Louisiana and
- 1:09:13one in Washington state, each with two long perpendicular
- 1:09:18tunnels 4 kilometers in length. Laser beams are sent down each
- 1:09:23tunnel, reflected off mirrors at the far ends, and recombined.
- 1:09:30Any tiny change in the relative lengths of the tunnels caused by
- 1:09:34a passing gravitational wave would shift the recombined light
- 1:09:40in a measurable way. LIGO operated for years without
- 1:09:45detecting anything. The instruments were carefully
- 1:09:48upgraded, and in September 2015, just as the new advanced version
- 1:09:55began its first science run, a signal arrived.
- 1:09:59It lasted only about 1/5 of a second.
- 1:10:03It was a faint rising chirp, exactly the pattern theorists
- 1:10:09had predicted for two black holes spiraling inward and
- 1:10:14merging into one. Detailed analysis showed that
- 1:10:19the signal had come from 2 black holes, each about 30 times the
- 1:10:24mass of the sun, that had collided in a distant Galaxy
- 1:10:30roughly 1.3 billion years ago. In the final moments of their
- 1:10:36merger, they had converted about 3 solar masses of material
- 1:10:40entirely into the energy of gravitational waves.
- 1:10:44That energy had then travelled across the universe and reached
- 1:10:49Earth as a tiny tremor in the geometry of space itself.
- 1:10:55The discovery was announced in February 2016, and in 2000
- 1:11:01Tebahan, the Nobel Prize in Physics, was awarded to three of
- 1:11:06the leading figures behind Ligo Rayner Weiss, Barry Barish and
- 1:11:13Kip Thorne. Since then, dozens of additional
- 1:11:17detections have followed, including mergers of neutron
- 1:11:20stars and other black hole pairs.
- 1:11:23A new branch of astronomy has been born, one that listens
- 1:11:28rather than looks. There is something deeply sleep
- 1:11:32wise about that idea. 2 enormous invisible objects met in the
- 1:11:38dark long before the Earth had life or oceans, and the universe
- 1:11:44carried the news of their meeting outward in the form of a
- 1:11:48faint quiver. Patient instruments listened,
- 1:11:53and at last the universe was heard.
- 1:11:56For most of the history of physics, no one expected ever to
- 1:12:01see a black hole directly. By definition, the object itself
- 1:12:08emits no light. Even the matter falling toward
- 1:12:12it, however bright, was thought too small and too distant to be
- 1:12:18resolved against the glow of the rest of the cosmos.
- 1:12:22To picture a black hole, scientists relied on diagrams,
- 1:12:28simulations, and patient inference from the motion of
- 1:12:33nearby stars. The idea of an actual photograph
- 1:12:40belonged to a future no one could quite imagine.
- 1:12:44That future arrived in April 2019.
- 1:12:49After years of preparation, An international collaboration
- 1:12:53called the Event Horizon Telescope released the first
- 1:12:57image of a black hole, or rather of the glowing matter and shadow
- 1:13:03surrounding one. The target was the supermassive
- 1:13:08black hole at the center of the elliptical Galaxy known as
- 1:13:12Messier 87, or M87, about 55 million light years from Earth.
- 1:13:20It is one of the largest black holes known, with a mass of
- 1:13:25about 6.5 billion times that of the Sun and an event horizon
- 1:13:32larger than our entire solar system.
- 1:13:35From that great distance, it appears as a tiny dark speck
- 1:13:40against the sky. But the Event Horizon Telescope
- 1:13:44was built to resolve exactly such specks.
- 1:13:48The trick was simple in concept and astonishingly difficult in
- 1:13:53practice. 8 Radio telescopes scattered across the world, from
- 1:13:59Hawaii and Arizona to Mexico, Chile, Spain and Antarctica were
- 1:14:04linked together using precise atomic clocks and a technique
- 1:14:10called very long baseline interferometry.
- 1:14:14By combining the signals from all of them, the collaboration
- 1:14:19created what was in effect a single virtual telescope as wide
- 1:14:26as the Earth itself. Only such a telescope could
- 1:14:31possibly resolve a feature as small as a black hole's shadow
- 1:14:37at intergalactic distances. The resulting image showed a
- 1:14:42bright, asymmetric ring of glowing gas surrounding a
- 1:14:47central darkness. The asymmetry came from the
- 1:14:52rotation of the disk. Material moving toward us
- 1:14:56appeared brighter, while material moving away appeared
- 1:15:00dimmer, exactly as relativity predicted.
- 1:15:04The size of the dark central region matched the predicted
- 1:15:09shadow of a black hole of M87's measured mass.
- 1:15:16It was not a literal photograph of the black hole, but rather of
- 1:15:21the silhouette it cast against the light around it.
- 1:15:25In 2022, the same collaboration released a second image, this
- 1:15:31time of Sagittarius AR, the much smaller supermassive black hole
- 1:15:37at the center of our own Milky Way.
- 1:15:40Despite its smaller size, it sits much closer to us, so the
- 1:15:45apparent dimensions on the sky were comparable to those of M87.
- 1:15:51Once again, the predicted shadow appeared ringed by light.
- 1:15:57After a century of theoretical work, 2 of nature's quietest
- 1:16:02giants had finally allowed themselves to be seen in outline
- 1:16:09through the patient cooperation of telescopes across the world.
- 1:16:15After all this, it can be tempting to think of black holes
- 1:16:20as a strange corner of physics, a place where ordinary rules
- 1:16:27give way and reality grows alarming.
- 1:16:32But there is another way to see them.
- 1:16:35Black holes are not exceptions to the laws of nature.
- 1:16:40They are the laws of nature, followed all the way through to
- 1:16:46their natural conclusion. Take gravity seriously enough,
- 1:16:52allow it to gather and gather without interruption, and black
- 1:16:58holes are what you get. They are not intrusions on the
- 1:17:03universe, they are part of how the universe works.
- 1:17:09Almost every theme in this episode meets inside them.
- 1:17:14The patient pull of Newtonian gravity.
- 1:17:18The curvature of space-time introduced by Einstein.
- 1:17:23The slowing of clocks measured to within parts in a
- 1:17:27quadrillion. The bending of light first
- 1:17:31confirmed during a 1919 eclipse. The spin of stars carried into
- 1:17:38the curved solutions. The trimmer of merging black
- 1:17:43holes detected by LIGO in 2015. The silhouette imaged by the
- 1:17:51Event Horizon Telescope in 2019. Each of these threads leads
- 1:17:58sooner or later, to the same place.
- 1:18:02The black hole is where general relativity becomes most fully
- 1:18:08visible, where geometry becomes most fully geometry.
- 1:18:14There is a humility in studying them.
- 1:18:18The very center of every black hole reminds us that even our
- 1:18:23best theories have edges, places where they hand the question
- 1:18:29over to a deeper physics that has not yet been written.
- 1:18:36The strange marriage of general relativity and quantum
- 1:18:40mechanics, glimpsed in Hawking's calculation of black hole
- 1:18:45radiation remains one of the great unfinished projects of
- 1:18:51modern science. Black holes mark the
- 1:18:56Borderlands. They are where the map becomes
- 1:19:01uncertain and where future generations may find new
- 1:19:07continents. And yet, for all their
- 1:19:10strangeness, they have also become surprisingly familiar.
- 1:19:16Astronomers now find them by the dozens in stellar binary
- 1:19:21systems, by the hundreds in the centers of galaxies, by the
- 1:19:27dozens of merger events recorded in gravitational wave detectors
- 1:19:33each year. The universe is dotted with
- 1:19:37them, quietly, the way a forest is dotted with hidden hollows.
- 1:19:42Most of them do not threaten us. They sit in the dark, holding
- 1:19:50cord over their nearby stars, occasionally swallowing a stray
- 1:19:55cloud of gas, occasionally meeting another of their kind in
- 1:20:02a final spiral. That sends a faint ripple across
- 1:20:08the cosmos. When you see a picture of a
- 1:20:11black hole, the soft orange ring of 87 with a smaller glow of
- 1:20:18Sagittarius, a star, what you're really seeing is a story.
- 1:20:24A story that began with John Michelle's quiet Letter in 1783,
- 1:20:31passed through Einstein's reimagining of gravity, survived
- 1:20:36decades of doubt, and ended for now in patient images and
- 1:20:42patient signals received here on a small blue planet.
- 1:20:49Black holes are reminders that even the strangest things in the
- 1:20:54universe are still part of the universe and still, in the end,
- 1:21:01knowable. So now the journey can grow
- 1:21:06quiet. We began far from any black hole
- 1:21:11in an old sky that seemed steady and unquestioned.
- 1:21:16Newton had gathered the patient logic of gravity into a few
- 1:21:22elegant rules, and the heavens turned overhead, as they always
- 1:21:28had. From there, we followed a long
- 1:21:32thread. A country clergyman in 1783
- 1:21:37imagined dark stars. A French mathematician quietly
- 1:21:43reached the same conclusion a few years later, then withdrew
- 1:21:47the thought. A century passed.
- 1:21:51Einstein reimagined gravity as the curvature of space-time, and
- 1:21:58almost immediately a soldier on the Eastern Front named Karl
- 1:22:04Schwarzschild found a hidden radius inside the new equations.
- 1:22:11For decades, even the greatest physicists hesitated to believe
- 1:22:17such a thing could be real. Then Chandrasekhar, Oppenheimer,
- 1:22:24Penrose, Hawking, Wheeler, and many others followed the
- 1:22:28mathematics through, and the universe slowly revealed that
- 1:22:34the heaviest stars truly had nowhere else to go.
- 1:22:39The dark stars of imagination became the black holes of
- 1:22:44physics. Telescopes traced them by the
- 1:22:48orbits of nearby stars, gravitational wave detectors
- 1:22:53heard them collide, The Event Horizon Telescope photographed
- 1:22:59their shadows and 1 quiet object at the center of our own Galaxy,
- 1:23:064,000,000 times the mass of the Sun was finally given its name
- 1:23:13and its place. You do not need to remember any
- 1:23:17of this. The names will fade, the dates
- 1:23:21will soften, the technical details will drift away.
- 1:23:26By morning, what matters is the mood that remains.
- 1:23:32The universe is a place where gravity, given enough mass,
- 1:23:39becomes geometry, where time can slow near great weight, where
- 1:23:46light can be bent, swallowed, and sometimes returned in faint
- 1:23:53predicted ways. Where even the darkest objects
- 1:23:59leave signatures in the orbits of their neighbors, in the
- 1:24:03ripples of space-time, in the silhouettes they cast against
- 1:24:09distant fire outside the room, the Earth turns through
- 1:24:14space-time without your noticing.
- 1:24:18The Milky Way wheels slowly around its hidden center.
- 1:24:23Where Sagittarius, a star, sits in the dark with its court of
- 1:24:29stars far beyond it. In galaxies whose light has
- 1:24:35travelled millions of years to reach us, supermassive black
- 1:24:40holes glow at the centers of their own quiet kingdoms.
- 1:24:46And somewhere, perhaps tonight, 2 distant black holes are
- 1:24:53spiraling toward one another, sending a faint tremor outward
- 1:24:58through the geometry of the cosmos, a tremor that may pass
- 1:25:04through the earth long after this room has gone still.
- 1:25:10Yet here, in the small shelter of a night routine, gravity is
- 1:25:16gentle. The bed holds you.
- 1:25:20The lamp glows softly. The clock ticks at its own quiet
- 1:25:26rate. You do not need to solve the
- 1:25:30universe tonight. You only need to drift within
- 1:25:34it, held for a little while by a force that, in its most extreme
- 1:25:39form can fold the very fabric of space.
- 1:25:43But that here, now simply keeps you in place against the turning
- 1:25:49of the world. The world slows, and so do we.
- 1:25:55Good night.