Latest / Q&A: Social Security Disability Today / Why do I have to start a new Disability claim?
Transcript
- 0:02Hey, everybody, this is Attorney Anthony Reeves and as always I'm going to
- 0:06give you my again my legal beat tip of the day. Here's a common
- 0:10question that people ask me, what do you mean I have to start over
- 0:14with my Social Security disability case? All right? Depending on what state you
- 0:19live in, you may have two steps in order to fully go through the
- 0:21disability process in terms of when they consider you to have to start over.
- 0:26First, if you're in a state that has one level of appeal, that
- 0:28means you file your application, you get denied once, and then you have
- 0:33to go before a judge. The second type of place is a place that
- 0:37has two levels of appeals. That means you actually file an application, you
- 0:42get denied once, you appeal that get denied twice, and then you actually
- 0:46have to file what's called a request for hearing before judge. Both instances,
- 0:50whether it's one level of appeal or two levels of appeal, is exactly the
- 0:53same. Once you go before a judge and a judge des sides that you
- 1:00are not disabled under the regulations, you technically have to start over again.
- 1:06I want you to listen carefully because I don't want people to think are you
- 1:08saying that I can't appeal a judge's decision. That's not what I mean.
- 1:12When a judge renders a decision, you typically have two options. You can
- 1:17either accept that decision, or you can appeal that decision. If you choose
- 1:21to appeal that decision for purposes of social security, the period of time from
- 1:26the date of that judge's decision going backwards has been decided upon. So let's
- 1:33say you decide to go and file a brand new application, which you're well
- 1:36within your rights to do so while that old one is pending. Well,
- 1:40what happens is that when they ask you if you're disabled, and you say
- 1:44when your disability began, even though you know your or you believe that your
- 1:48disability began long before the judge's decision, they can only look at the period
- 1:53from the day after the judge's decision. Okay, they can only look at
- 1:59that particular period time. So let's kind of follow me on this once again.
- 2:02Let's give me. Let me give you an example. Let's say,
- 2:06for instance, you get a decision from the court on January first of twenty
- 2:12ten, but you say that you were disabled back in two thousand and eight.
- 2:15Well, the judges already looked at all of your medical records from at
- 2:17least from the period of January first, twenty ten, going backwards. So
- 2:23you go and you file a new application, and you go on January second,
- 2:28you appeal January first to the judge decision one January second, you go
- 2:31and you file a brand new application. What a date can you indicate you
- 2:36became disabled? Well, you know that you became disabled back in two thousand
- 2:38and eight. Well, there's already been a decision on that. So if
- 2:44in theory, you can only go back from when January second, now somebody
- 2:47are going to be like, that sucks. I've been disabled the entire time.
- 2:51Why am I only limited to that date? Because in the eyes of
- 2:53the Social Security Administration, the date the judge renders a decision, it is
- 2:58typically treated as if from that date, going backwards, that that judge had
- 3:02the ability to review all of your medical records before then and could not determine
- 3:07that you were disabled at any point in time before that date. So what
- 3:12does that mean for you? Well, when you go and you file a
- 3:15new up application, in theory, they're going to treat chairships you started,
- 3:17You're starting from scratch. That's important to know because sometimes what you have is
- 3:22people who will say they want to rely on all the old records that the
- 3:27judge previously relied upon when they go to file a new application. Unfortunately,
- 3:30that's not how it works, because remember the way the regulation works. They
- 3:36look at it as if the judge has already looked at those records and said
- 3:38you're not disabled. You don't get the luxury of having to file again and
- 3:43get somebody else to look at those records again and say, oh, the
- 3:45judge got it wrong. Now here's a couple of other weird times that pop
- 3:50up where this whole notion of you starting over again kind of comes into play
- 3:54when you file an application and you get denied. I always tell people go
- 4:00through the process, but not everybody does it. What they end up doing
- 4:02is they get a denial, they'll go and they'll start all over again.
- 4:05Well, what happens is when you start all over again, if you do
- 4:09it within a year from that last denial, they're just gonna treat that as
- 4:14a new apple. They're gonna basically open up the old application and look at
- 4:16it going backwards again. Let me give you another example for those of you
- 4:19who may have gotten lost with what I said. Let's say you filed an
- 4:24application on June first, you got denied on September first, Well, you
- 4:30get the denial, so you figure, well, I'm just gonna start over
- 4:31again. Get you file a new application on October first. Does that mean
- 4:35they're gonna look primarily at October first going forward. No, they're gonna look
- 4:40at the fact that you applied again within a close proximity to your last denial
- 4:45the say within a year, and they're gonna treat this as if your application
- 4:48actually goes back to that June application. In other words, they're reopening it.
- 4:55Well, what happens and next seeing people do this where you're sitting here
- 4:57and you apply, you get denied, and then you wait a couple of
- 5:00years, and then you decide to go again. Then you want to say,
- 5:04well, I'm disabled now, but I was also disabled back when I
- 5:06filed that earlier application. You can ask for Social Security to reopen, but
- 5:11there's a catch if you do it within a year of that initial denial.
- 5:15And that's the the key trait, your initial denial, your first time you're
- 5:19ever to deny, they'll open it up for whatever reason. Meaning if you
- 5:24applied on June first, twenty ten, you get denied in August twenty ten,
- 5:29you reapplied September of twenty ten. As long as you applied, they're
- 5:32automatically reopened that June application. Hey, you could file again in May of
- 5:36twenty eleven and they'll give you back to June twenty ten. But let's say,
- 5:42for instance, you did it like I was showing you before, You
- 5:45waited two years, and then you decided to do it again. Maybe you
- 5:47get approved the second time around, and you're like, wait a minute,
- 5:49I was as bad now as I was back then. Why are you not
- 5:53considering that? Social Security is going to ask you one question, Do you
- 5:58have a good reason for why you did not continue appealing that earlier application,
- 6:02Because the only way you can go back and get the benefit of when you
- 6:05applied two years earlier is you have to ask for what they call good costs
- 6:11and people. Because you got tired, or you were bored, or you
- 6:15got frustrated, or you forgot those are not good reasons. Okay, it
- 6:20has to be something sufficient. Maybe you got denied and you didn't know,
- 6:26so you went and reapplied, because no one you never got a decision.
- 6:29That's a good cause. Okay, maybe you got you have a cognitive problem,
- 6:34you have memory loss, something like that, but you got to be
- 6:36able to demonstrate it. Just you're saying it alone is not going to be
- 6:40enough. So keep that in the back of your mind. Now, one
- 6:46other thing here, just kind of keeping you going forward so that you're aware
- 6:48of this. It's important to recognize that even when you're going through it and
- 6:54you start over again, it's not going to be the same timelines both time
- 6:58around. Meaning this you mean what, well, let's say you filed your
- 7:00first application and you went through the process real really really fast. Don't automatically
- 7:06assume that when you start over again that that's going to happen the exact same
- 7:11way. It may take longer, it may take quicker. Like I always
- 7:15tell people, these are a case by case basis. Keep that in the
- 7:18back of mine and you'll always understand how this process works. This is Anthony
- 7:23Reeves. This is your legal beat tip of the day, and if you
- 7:25have any questions call us at www dot dot www dot Reesfirm dot com,
- 7:30or you can always hit me up till free at eight eight eight nine sixty
- 7:33two zero zero zero seven. If you go to the res firm website,
- 7:36we have a chat function so you can actually speak to someone and I hope
- 7:40this helps you out. For more questions that you want to just see answered,
- 7:43go to Legalbett Anthony Reeves dot com and you have a wonderful day